Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Matt Ranks (almost) Every Show of the 2025/2026 Season

May 14, 20262 hr 34 minAudio

After a full Broadway season of transfers, star vehicles, ambitious new musicals, baffling misfires, and surprise favorites, Matt finally attempts the impossible: ranking (almost) every show from the 2025/2026 season. From major Tony contenders to chaotic curiosities, he revisits what worked, what didn’t, and which productions lingered long after curtain call. Along the way, the episode becomes less a definitive “best to worst” list and more a snapshot of a season defined by big swings, divided reactions, and wildly different ideas of what Broadway should be right now. Important Links * Broadway Breakdown Live: Green Room 42 Tix! * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Time Stamps * 0:00 - Intro + ranking criteria explanation * 4:27 - #50 * 6:05 - #49 * 9:05 - #48 * 12:57 - #47 * 16:27 - #46 * 18:40 - #45 * 21:51 - #44 * 24:58 - #43 * 27:36 - #42 * 29:37 - #41 * 32:50 - #40 * 36:57 - #39 * 39:33 - #38 * 43:12 - #37 * 44:55 - #36 * 47:06 - #35 * 48:27 - #34 * 50:49 - #33 * 54:36 - #32 * 57:21 - #31 * 58:58 - #30 * 1:00:52 - #29 * 1:03:13 - #28 * 1:05:52 - #27 * 1:09:50 - #26 * 1:11:45 - #25 * 1:13:10 - #24 * 1:16:02 - #23 * 1:22:17 - #22 * 1:27:07 - #21 * 1:29:52 - #20 * 1:32:07 - #19 * 1:35:35 - #18 * 1:41:15 - #17 * 1:42:55 - #16 * 1:48:23 - #15 * 1:50:11 - #14 * 1:52:38 - #13 * 1:56:45 - #12 * 1:59:17 - #11 * 2:02:14 - #10 * 2:04:43 - #9 * 2:07:52 - #8 * 2:10:32 - #7 * 2:14:17 - #6 * 2:16:44 - #5 * 2:19:17 - #4 * 2:22:25 - #3 * 2:25:51 - #2 * 2:27:35 - #1 + final reflections on the season Listener discussion questions * “What was your personal favorite show of the 2025/2026 Broadway season - and did critical consensus line up with your own ranking?” * “Which production do you think will age the best over time, regardless of awards success?” * “Are there shows this season you admired more than you actually enjoyed - and how do you separate those two reactions?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Hello all you theater lovers both out and proud and on the DL and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address Broadway I am your host Matt Koplik the least

SPEAKER_00famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts and it has come that point in the season where we've seen if not everything nearly everything off Broadway Broadway a few things on the West End sorry in the West End And it's time to do a little bit of a final final rankings, if we should say. Yeah, you know, sort of get our heads around where what we felt about this season, what really stood out for us, what maybe felt by the wayside,

SPEAKER_00things that we loved that nobody else did, things that a lot of people loved that we didn't. It happens. It happens every year without fail. And I'm sure as we go through this ranking, people will be rankled by some of the choices that we have, but that's how this thing goes. Remember, this ranking is my personal feelings on things, and it's a combination of how I feel about the piece itself, how I feel about its presentation, the experience of the theater that evening or that afternoon, sort of my memory of the

of the joy or the heartbreak or the confusion and whatnot we are going to limit it to New York so nothing from the West End no Paddington no Starlight Express so sorry about that and as I said I have not seen absolutely everything so we haven't seen 25th annual Putnam County Spelling Bee so that won't be included we didn't see Mamma Mia when it was playing in New York for this season but I've seen Mamma Mia

SPEAKER_00five or six different times so No, I'm not really missing much outside of a few singular performances. I even have seen this iteration of Mamma Mia with the touring set and staging because I've seen it on tour. Did not see Jeff Ross with The Banana Show and I did not see All Out. but other than that we saw everything so it's a pretty comprehensive list I should say before we begin if you haven't yet we have our next and at this moment final Broadway Breakdown live show happening at Green Room 42 on June

1st the slightly early Tony Awards show it is a 75 minute musical live episode covering some of our favorite Tony winners moments in Tony history the history of the Tonys in general those of you who have been to Broadway Breakdown live shows know that they are

SPEAKER_00If you do come Just come guarded with some of your Tony Awards knowledge, some fun trivia that you have locked and loaded because we will be asking the audience for trivia answers and there may or may not be a few prizes involved. So keep your eyes out for that.

SPEAKER_00Matt Koplik Usual Spelling are in my storage unit and I did not have the time to go grab them so just know that when I say I saw it but I don't have the playbill in my

hand I'm not uh I'm not I'm not joshing you it's I did see it they're just they're in a storage unit on

SPEAKER_0061st street oh also because I was at the beta run of Masquerade, which is ultimately their dress rehearsal. I will not be including Masquerade on this ranking. That's very unfair to them to rank them based off of their first run through with an audience. But here is my mask as proof that I was there. You can even see the little phantom mask on top of there. But yeah, OK, now let's go get into it. All right. We have 50 entries. Again, this is a combination of Broadway and Off-Broadway. At number 50, we have House of McQueen,

SPEAKER_00the bioplay by Dara Cloud that premiered at the mansion at Hudson Yards. It was starring Luke Newton of Bridgerton fame. It was co-starring Emily Skinner. Y'all, this show was so bad that I memory blocked it and forgot to include it in my earlier rankings back in December slash January. that's how bad this thing was very much interested in jumping around in timelines this is a play that was about the fashion designer Alexander McQueen his childhood his break into fashion his success his failures ultimately

ending with his death by

SPEAKER_00suicide at the end of the show I remember it was a two act and at intermission you could go into the lobby and look at sort of this small walking tour of McQueen's history and legacy as a fashion designer including some of his actual pieces that were on display and you could see what a bold visionary he was and also how troubled he was and also how much craft and curation went into his work the detail of it all And none of that really translated. The best thing I'll say is that it's always wonderful to see Emily Skinner on

SPEAKER_00stage, although she wasn't really given much. And Luke Newton, God bless him, was incredibly game and really committed himself to the piece. And I would love to see him in another stage show in the future. Actually, it's your Royal Highness.

Tartuffe yet another show that I had memory blocked because I disliked it so much that I forgot to include it in the rankings earlier this year this is a adaptation by Lucas Nath of the Moliere play Tartuffe is ultimately a drawing room French comedy about the ultimate leech the aristocrat in this production played by David Cross Tartuffe played by Matthew Broderick the aristocrat's name is Orgon Orgon

thinks Tartuffe is awesome and smart and insightful he basically hires Tartuffe as like his personal life coach and like best friend and Tartuffe just sort of goes around his home and you know eats all of his food and drinks all of his wine and spends his money and tries to hit on Oregon's wife here played by Amber Gray everyone's always trying to tell Oregon Tartuffe is the worst and the maid is the

SPEAKER_00one who's trying the most to convince Oregon and come up with schemes to get Tartuf out of the house and ultimately it works out that Tartuf is vanquished but it's a very long journey to get there in Lucas Nath's adaptation he goes for rhyming couplets almost the entire time a lot of them rather forced and the humor is meant to derive from all of the random ways in which Nath is able to find rhymes in the text and It is infrequent that you laugh from said rhymes.

It is also infrequent that you laugh from the goings on of the production. This was done at New York Theatre Workshop and there was a lot of backlash about

SPEAKER_00this because it was not a new work. Tartuffe is a classic although New York Theatre Workshop of course has done their own revivals. It had major major talent involved. Tony winners Tony nominees Emmy winners Emmy nominees this was clearly not meant to be a gamble this was meant to be a surefire financial hit that if it worked would go to Broadway now it totally sold out it made them some money but it has not gone to Broadway because it was

bad the truth is that Matthew Broderick and David Cross actually were miscast and should have switched roles Matthew Broderick should have played Oregon and David Cross should have played Tartuffe everyone talented that they are were all in very different productions the one who was giving me the most um modern era Moliere was

SPEAKER_00actually Bianca Del Rio as um David Cross's mother who only shows up for the beginning and the very end of the show and she is the only character other than Oregon who is into Tartuffe who thinks that Tartuffe is amazing and then when Oregon finally breaks back into reality his mother Bianca still doesn't really believe anybody Amateurs and non-equity first!

Beaches I can go further into this if you desire but the truth is that we already did a very in-depth review of Beaches a few episodes back this is a musical adaptation of Rainer Dart's novel not on the 1988 Bette Midler Barbara Hershey movie and don't you forget it the only two things tying it to the movie are Jessica Vosk's wig design and that they include window beneath my wings at the very end of

SPEAKER_00the show Beatrice tells the story of two lifelong friends Bertie and Cece they meet when Cece is a performer on the boardwalk in Atlantic City and Bertie's very upper crust Pennsylvania family is vacationing there they exchange letters over the years as pen pals they grow up they reunite and they spend their adult years off and on as friends in and out of each other's lives and The show actually is less friendship focused than you'd think they have a big row at the end of the first act and spend half of act two not

really speaking to each other the show is more concerned about their relationships with the men in their

SPEAKER_00lives Those relationships of course fall apart and they come back together as Cece helps Birdie raise her child but the moment that Cece gets job opportunity she ditches Birdie but then Birdie gets sick five seconds later and Cece comes back and then Birdie dies and that is the end of the show Beaches is bad It's bad. There's no other way to say it. Beaches wants to be both a rousing crowd pleaser and a too hanky cry fest. And for me it is neither.

SPEAKER_00It is a design that is sparse and cheap and tacky. Not to mention once again projections that seem like they came straight out of AI or at best you know iMovie. At our Central Performances, we have Jessica Vosk as Cece, we have Kelly Barrett as Birdie, and they are both extremely talented musical theater actresses. If anything, Beaches proves that Jessica Vosk is capable of leading a show, of handling more dramatic material than just Wicked or concert

material or Hell's

SPEAKER_00Kitchen. She has the ability to create a fully formed character. Beaches does not allow her to do that because Beaches is just so amateurish on a writing level, on a design level, on a staging level. Vosk cannot succeed nor can Barrett because the show cuts them off at the knees at every given turn. They sound great, they have good chemistry, and you see them trying to find ways to

create more depth in a show that won't let them but that's it's an a for effort on both of their parts I won't say it's an a in execution not their faults just not how the show allows them to go the score best case I'll say the best thing I'll say about the score is that the music is not untuneful it has its moments it ultimately

SPEAKER_00sounds like a modern attempt at being frank lesser and and it just doesn't work not in a show like this not in an era like this the lyrics by Rainer Dart are just oh boy are they are they basic birdie has like an i won't be that girl anymore song to her mother in act one that is just like the most generic song that of course leads with kelly barrett having to belt her tits off on top of a ladder and it's just it could be applied into any show for any reason it's not

memorable enough or catchy enough um or boppy enough to get by on the fact that it is so basic feels

SPEAKER_00like it was inserted into chat chat gbt and you know put in onto a Broadway stage yeah um beaches may not be a train wreck because ultimately it's not interesting enough but it is not good it is extremely extraordinarily not good uh and that is beaches at 48 at number 47 Christine Day could sing it sir Dog Day Afternoon Dog Day Afternoon is actually kind of fascinating because uh After our bottom three here 50 49 48 we are now in the

territory that I would say

SPEAKER_00is not good but not good in a more of a numbing way not in a uh disaster-y kind of way and there are things to find positives about in the next couple of entries we have in the rankings of sort of not good uh with Dog Day Afternoon the good things I'll say is that we have in our lead performance John Bernthal as Sonny made famous in the film that the play is adapted from uh by Al Pacino Bernthal clearly is a talented committed actor Similar to Jessica Vosk in Beaches, he proves that he's comfortable on stage,

SPEAKER_00that he can carry a show, that he can drive home an emotional arc. Ultimately, it's for nothing because the adaptation by Stephen Adley Gurgis is not only extraordinarily faithful to the movie in terms of text, but also does not do anything for stage. It's not an inventive adaptation. He doesn't find a way to make it live on stage the way that it thrives on film and

Rupert Gould the director

SPEAKER_00who's very British and very esoteric and very cold Decides to present the entire thing like a straight up farce which the movie has comedy in it because ultimately it's about a bank robbery that goes wrong from the word go but there's a lot of tension to it in the movie there's a lot of emotion to it because you find out that the reason why Sonny is robbing this bank is because his partner is in need of money for a gender reassignment surgery and Sonny decides

SPEAKER_00to rob the bank to obtain that money and it's you know it's it's ultimately someone doing an act of insanity and boldness for somebody that they love they're they're at the end of the rope they're desperate and they can't think of what to do and so they do this and Bernthal you see that desperation you see that passion you see that love in his sonny but it can't go anywhere because the production that surrounds him is doesn't reciprocate everything that he's giving the only other

person on stage who's kind of as locked in as Bernthal is is Jessica Hecht as one of the head

SPEAKER_00tellers of the bank but it's ultimately a production an adaptation that does not understand what makes its source material work so well and does not understand the heart that is beating within this story it relies solely on Bernthal who I'm convinced is what he's doing is at the Opposition of the production team because no one else is doing what Bernthal is doing he sticks out both in a positive way and a negative way

because what he's doing is correct but what he's doing is so at odds with everyone else that I do

SPEAKER_00feel like he went rogue in like 10 Peck or during previews and was like, fuck all this. I'm going to I'm going to do what I think is correct. Gould as a director has been very missed for me for a while now. He did Tammy Faye last season. He did Patriots the season before that. And it's become very clear that pieces about American life are really not for Gould to do. And this is just another nail in the coffin of that for me. But yeah, that's Dog Day Afternoon at number 47. All right. At number 46.

Call Me Izzy the first play of the Broadway season starring Jean Smart written by Jamie Wax it is a one woman show where Jean Smart plays a woman who is an aspiring

SPEAKER_00poet in an abusive marriage in a trailer park and it's mostly I believe I saw Call Me Izzy in June Yeah I saw Call Me Izzy in June of 2025 because I went straight

from a Tony party it was like a gathering I think for AKA maybe I think that was the press team that was doing their like early Tony party it was like a Wednesday or Thursday and I

SPEAKER_00went straight from there to Call Me Izzy And it was just like going from a really lovely high of meeting new people and making new friends and sort of talking about the season to then seeing this 85-minute one-woman show where Jean Smart just goes on and on about the poems she writes and the professor she has an affair with because she's so unhappy in her marriage and just this really inert play that has good intentions and wants to tackle you

know difficult subject matter with a character that we really should want to root for and ultimately the only reason to have seen it was Jean Smart who remains that bitch remains a phenomenally gifted actress both depth of comedy and drama is so charismatic she can hold an audience in the palm of her hand but similar to Jon Bernthal in Dog Day

SPEAKER_00Afternoon similar to Jessica Vosk in Beech's Oh my! Letter from heaven! The Seat of Our Pants at Public Theater uh written by Ethan

Lipton this is a musical adaptation of Thornton Wilder's The Skin of Our Teeth it had Ruthie Ann Miles it had Shuler Hensley um it had Michaela Diamond I was really interested in seeing what this piece was going to be I like the cast um Lee Silverman was the

SPEAKER_00director uh I'm not the biggest fan of The Skin of Our Teeth as a play. I think it's a really intelligent, fascinating piece, but ultimately all the things that made it groundbreaking and mind-blowing in the 1940s we have done since then, and I would argue we have done better since then. Not every show that does it first does it the best. Some shows do, by accident. But Skin of Our Teeth, I think, is one of those... fourth wall breaking time fucking theatrical distorting pieces

that Wilder must

SPEAKER_00have written while he was like on LSD or something. Wilder in general loved Breaking the Fourth Wall, Skin of Our Teeth, Our Town, The Matchmaker. And Skin of Our Teeth is probably the most esoteric and the most um adventurous of all of his pieces but it's never really stuck with me especially in the last production at lincoln center theater but there were moments in the lincoln center theater production with gabby beans that did resonate with me and seat of our pants ultimately both over musicalizes and under

musicalizes the original play the best thing i'll say about it as a musical is that ethan lipton as

SPEAKER_00a writer has a really fascinating ear for music. He, similar to like Alacusa or Tesori, he can really fuck with many different genres and adapt to each genre but he doesn't always really know where the melody should go and how it should land and what the lyrics should scan with those songs also similar to a lot of musical theater writers now not every moment that he musicalizes feels

correct there are songs in Seat of Our Pants where you go I don't know why there's a song here other

SPEAKER_00than the fact that we're writing a musical this this moment doesn't call for it it feels super shoehorned in and that's unfortunate because then there are moments where songs do feel like they belong but they don't feel like the song the moment that is being musicalized feels correct but then the song that's been written does not feel like the correct song it's it's always been kind of a a mindfuck in that respect and seat of our pants tries to adhere to that while also not clarifying but calling out how skin of our teeth is really

mind trippy but it doesn't go further with that so it's more sort of like a reddit thread comment that gets punctuated a lot as actors rebel against the author and don't really know where to take the story next and I could see potential if not necessarily that

SPEAKER_00potential realized by that seat of our pants at 45 okay Next up at number 44 Christine Day could sing it sir Waiting for Gato starring Keanu Reeves and Alex Winter directed by Jamie Lloyd uh we have a Tony nominee in this company Brandon J. Dearden who we spoke very highly of in our review uh also in our final big Tony swings friend of the pod Juan Ramirez also spoke very highly of Brandon J.

SPEAKER_00Dearden uh This is another one where it's a classic play that has never really landed for me granted I've only seen it twice now both with Keanu and Alex as well as with Bill Irwin and Nathan Lane I probably preferred it with Lane and Irwin just because I felt that The company as a whole in that production was stronger I expected to really detest this production because I don't like the play much and because the idea of Jamie Lloyd directing it just felt like torture I'm not a fan of Keanu Reeves I feel like

movie buffs have been trying to gaslight us for years that he's a good actor he's

SPEAKER_00not but that's okay it was not painful uh and that's kind of the highest praise I can give it Alex Winter um actually gave a surprisingly strong performance in this and Brandon J. Dearden also very memorable it was a very striking simplistic set uh Those of you who are maybe unfamiliar with Waiting for Godot, and if you aren't familiar, you know, you don't need to get that familiar. I don't think you're going to see it in your local theater for a while,

SPEAKER_00other than the fact that it's cheap to do. It's four people and no set. But Keanu Reeves plays a character named Estragon, known as Gogo, and Alex Winter plays Vladimir named Didi. They are two friends who are waiting for a man named Godot. They're not entirely sure why they're waiting for him They're not entirely sure how they met Godot They're not entirely sure what he looks like They don't know what he does And Didi is more aware of the endless loop that they are in the endless cycle of waiting and

everything each day changes just a little bit and yet stays the same and then at the end of the day a young boy comes out and gives a message to Didi that Godot has been detained but he will surely arrive the next day and in this production Didi

SPEAKER_00seems to understand that Gado will never come but also there's nothing to do but to wait for him and it's a very sad fate that he's resigned himself to and there's been so many discussions of who Gado is what Gado represents ultimately you know it's not a it's not a play I find moving it's not a play I find enticing it's not a play I find very funny although part of that might be because

I've yet to see a production that has cast true clowns in the role like the original Broadway production did I would love to see what someone like Burt Lahr did with this show but I've yet to experience that in the meantime we have this production which was not the worst thing I've ever seen not terribly exciting but

SPEAKER_00you know just sort of This is the first Broadway production of art since its premiere in the late 90s. This production stars Bobby Cannavale, Neil Patrick Harris, James Corden. It's about a group of friends that start to tear apart at the seams when one of them, here played by Neil Patrick Harris, buys a painting from for $300,000 and the painting is simply white paint on a white

canvas and at first the discussion becomes what is art how does one define what makes good art and then

SPEAKER_00it starts This play took the theater scene by storm back in the 90s and Watching it now in 2025 slash 2026,

all I can say is that this is like very much a 90s upper middle class New York

SPEAKER_00elitist play. It wants to be a mocking satire slash mild farce about the hyper intelligentsia. And all that it really does is that it kind of ends up languishing in that hyperintelligentsia. Like the whole thing feels like it was sponsored by a thesaurus because there is such a masturbatory use of just language. that it goes beyond poetry it goes beyond satire and just becomes a flex the best

part of the show unfortunately is James Corden is the third and least successful and most buffoonish of the friends and it's frustrating that he's as good as he was in this show because I like Bobby Cannavale more as an actor but he is miscast in

SPEAKER_00this piece he understands How to make a character work for him but he does not live well in the world of the play Neil Patrick Harris works very well in the world of the play but he is not able to make his character adapt to him Corden is able to do both It's a pretty by the numbers production as directed by Scott Ellis There's no real zip to it no zaniness no energy no fire Ellis does a better job with that in a later show this season we'll get to that further up in the list again this was not bad this was just insanely missable that's

art at 43 at 42

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your royal highness. The Fear of Thirteen, adapted from the documentary of the same name by Lindsay Farentino.

SPEAKER_00Remember that name in a second. Starring Adrian Brody as Nick Yaris, a man who is wrongfully convicted of a sexual assault and murder. This production follows Brody as well as Tessa Thompson as a reporter who is writing a piece on the... inmates of the prison and she ends up finding a connection with Brody and is wary of the stories that he tells she's not sure how truthful he is she doesn't know whether she can trust him this ultimately goes nowhere because everything he says is truthful she does trust him they actually start to sort of

fall in love with each other but then she moves on with her life as he keeps on trying and failing to

SPEAKER_00have a judge or a jury Hear him out on new evidence that is proving of his innocence. Only when he's finally giving up after 22 years does a judge do an immediate order for the DNA evidence that ultimately releases him from prison. Fear of 13 is a piece that did very well in London at the Donmar Warehouse it's now playing at the James Earl Jones Theater which is about three times the size of the Donmar Warehouse and this is a piece that I would imagine does

a lot better with intimacy and there's moments of humanity in Fear of 13 it wants to kind of find the

SPEAKER_00humanity in the small moments but nothing can ever really fully connect here I called this trauma tourism and it does sort of feel like Brody is doing poverty cosplaying Tessa Thompson who's a very strong film actress is one of those film actors for me it feels like who just cannot translate The Queen of Versailles with Kristen Chenoweth

Obviously the show has been the punching bag of the Broadway season and I'm actually splitting this show in this ranking twice once with Kristen Chenoweth and once with her standby Sherry Renee Scott more on that later Queen of Versailles also Lindsay Farantino adapted from the documentary of the same name about Jackie Siegel who is the wife of the billionaire timeshare tycoon and their aim to build the largest home in America in Orlando Florida and all the things that go wrong and

SPEAKER_00all the things that Jackie loses along the way Queen of Versailles kind of wants to be gypsy meets the real housewives of Florida. Similar to how people felt about beaches or dog day afternoon and then walking out and going that wasn't as bad as people said it was. I went into Queen of Versailles obviously after all the reviews came out and the word of mouth was pretty atrocious and of course Kristen did not help matters with her online activity. I saw it the night that they announced their closing and I

walked out and I went huh that wasn't as bad as people said it was but it also was not good I can't say that I enjoyed it and it wasn't this is a case where while my expectations were low in terms of what to expect because my expectations for Broadway in general are high I did not walk out of Queen of Versailles going that was a better show than people give a credit for there is something to the idea of Queen of Versailles but I

SPEAKER_00didn't I did not see what that something was until I saw it with Sherry which is why we'll get to her in a second when I saw it with Kristen all I could see was a star vehicle where Kristen Chenoweth worked her tiny tiny little butt off but ultimately to no avail um and a role that proved that did not really fit her we applaud her on an artistic level for branching out and going beyond the Glinda, Lily and uh on the 20th century bubble of just like pure comedy. There was something that she was trying to go for with playing

a likable antagonist

SPEAKER_00or an unlikable protagonist, however you see it, and delving into a more morally murky area with a character. At the end of the day, Chenoweth's desire to be likable on stage and going for cutesiness overrode any chance she had of creating a distinguishable character. That said, there are things to recommend about Queen of Versailles. I do think that the design of the show is incredibly impressive.

The double-edged sword of that is that it's a show about the building of a house

SPEAKER_00that's under constant construction. So in order to be true to that, a lot of the design was very chaotic and people didn't always feel like they knew where to look. That's sometimes a problem with Michael Arden Productions in general. I do think that Stephen Schwartz's score had nuggets where you went, okay, there's something there I've said before. I think that the I Want song, Caviar Dreams, is a good song. I don't know if I think it actually applies to Jackie Siegel, but that is... again sort of the conundrum of the show for everything that you thought was objectively a well-crafted moment you then ask yourself but is

that a moment that applies well to the story we're telling that's Queen of Versailles at number 41 at

SPEAKER_03number 40 oh my letter from heaven Joe Turner's Come and Gone August Wilson's Joe Turner's Come and Gone this is a production that unfortunately I have to caveat with it was the worst theatrical experience I had this season with an audience because it was just non-stop of people showing up late well into an hour into the show people talking the entire time eating food the entire time over a dozen cell phones going off in act one

SPEAKER_00alone I was able to focus on Joe Turner's Come and Gone

bring an audience in with the emotional reality of the scenes while also keeping them on board with when things start to go in the mystical magical areas and the same is true of Piano Lesson which I thought was a production that actually leaned too far into the mystical this production I think leans too far into the reality even though the set was very abstract Debbie Allen as a director kept everything

SPEAKER_00very uh Highlights of this it is overall a good company Some performers land a little bit better than others. Cedric the Entertainer and Taraji P. Henson both acquit themselves well.

SPEAKER_00They have good chemistry with each other. They're, you know, very lived in their performances. Their Act 1s are ultimately stronger than their Act 2s. Not that their Act 2s are weak, but their Act 2s don't build upon their Act 1s. So while they write a very strong check in Act 1, it's not that that check is unable to be cleared in Act 2. They just actually never cash the check. Someone who is honed is Ruben Santiago Hudson as Bynum Walker No surprise there Ruben Santiago Hudson is our living interpreter of August

Wilson and thus is the

SPEAKER_00standout performer he's the lone acting Tony nominee for this production We also have the actress playing Martha Loomis, Harold Loomis' wife. It's a very late in the show entry into the company, but she really brings a great deal of passion that is lacking an act to for this show. Show. Design-wise, it feels very cluttered and unfocused. Granted, I have very strong memories of the last production that was directed by Bartlett Sher, who is not a person of color but is a good director of actors,

is a director who trusts text while also giving it enough visual flair that

SPEAKER_00everything sort of just congeals. Debbie Allen is a person who should be directing a show like Joe Turner's Come and Gone, but ultimately, at least at this point of her career, is not able to pull it all together with a unified vision and a sense of urgency and tempo which you think she would because she comes from the world of dance but I just I've never felt as a director that Debbie Allen has that in her but yes that's

us for Joe Turner's Come and Gone again there's more in-depth information on that

SPEAKER_00in our separate review but that's Joe Turner at number 40 at number 39 Punch written by James Graham direct transfer from London where it recently won the Olivier Award it was at Manhattan Theatre Club tells a very true story of a young gentleman who while out drinking one night after a football Match Punches a another young man at a bar the young man goes down this is Jacob Dunn by the way the young man's name is Jacob Dunn and he punches a young gentleman

by the name of James Hodgkinson James goes down goes into a coma and ends up passing away and Dunn is convicted of his murder goes to prison for a number of

SPEAKER_00years is rehabilitated through counseling and you know therapy he is able to build himself back up again and grapple with his toxic masculinity and his inner anger that has allowed him to has taken over enough of himself that he allows James Graham

has a knack for taking real world events and turning them into artistic works

SPEAKER_00whether on stage or on screen I ultimately feel like Graham is a better screenwriter than playwright he likes to write his plays like they are screenplays and while that can be an exciting thing it probably works best in Dear England the truth is that the best scene in the show is in act two when Dunn and Hodgkinson's parents sit down with Jacob's therapist or counselor however you want to describe her and for 20-25 minutes they all sit down together and just slowly

heal through questions that Hodgkinson's parents want to ask him about his life what would happen in that moment what he was thinking what he's up to now what he

SPEAKER_00plans to do and it's It is a true scene from a play where all four actors are able to sit and relish with each other and connect and have chemistry with each other and not worry about what part they're playing now, what the next scene transition is, what stage picture they have to make. It is just living in the moment and it's very beautiful. The rest of it I find very distancing, which is a shame because the story itself is quite good. But that's Punch at 39.

SPEAKER_00At 38,

SPEAKER_02Amateurs and non-equity first!

SPEAKER_00Chef. Choose, one might say. The first Broadway revival since the original with my beloved Judy Kuhn bombed in 1988. It has a new book by Danny Strong and is starring Lea Michele, Aaron DeVate, Nicholas Christopher. But Nick Christopher got in Hannah Cruz got in Bryce Pinkham got in

SPEAKER_00You know, chess had always been a blind spot for me. I had only really heard the score for the first time a few months prior in full. And the score is incredibly wild, fun, exciting, but also bonkers and clearly written by cocaine. I don't think it was even written by people. I just think it was written by cocaine itself. And a story that has never truly made perfect narrative sense to people. Also a story that not everyone has cared much about. The Revival tries to go for a campy tone Danny Strong's book is

actually more political than past productions but also by making Bryce Pinkham as the arbiter the narrator he becomes not just a commentator to clear up what's happening in each

SPEAKER_00scene but becomes an ain't I a stinker Gen Z coded jokester including RFK brainworm jokes and Joe Biden jokes and Donald Trump jokes and it's just for me the jokes are cringe and the plot while he does explain what's happening in each scene God help You If You Remember Everything That Happened In Chess A Few Days Later Unless You Want To Go See It Again To Clear Things Up What This Production Has Going For It Is Its Vocals Everyone In This Production Is An Incredible Singer

And They Sound Fantastic If I Were To Give Like A Ding To Anyone It Would Little It Would Be Aaron Tevate A Little Bit As Freddy Just Because We Are Used To Freddy Having More Of A Rock Tinge Sound Aaron Tevate Is Not That Aaron Tevate Is An Incredibly Healthy

SPEAKER_00Pure Sounding Voice But He Hits truly every note in a very healthy way so you're not worried about what's going to come out there's less danger to his singing which you could argue is important to Freddy as he's sort of the wild card character but in the end it it works for the performance that Taved is giving as Freddy which is um less you know destructively evil and more uh borderline personality disorder and and whatnot acting in general in this

production for me is sort of waiting for God or where I'm sort of waiting for it to happen not much Hannah Cruz is giving my favorite performance in the show because she's the only one in the show who feels like a person who like wants and needs and has even had sex which is important because sex is a major component of the survival and yet I feel like it's nowhere to be found except for Hannah Cruz but

SPEAKER_00A lot of moments that went viral on the internet, Nick Christopher's super long note, Lea Michele's nobody's side, Aaron Tveit's snorting coke off a dancer's leg in One Night in Bangkok. I don't consider this a fully formed revival. I don't consider it as smart as it thinks it is or as funny as it thinks it is or as sexy as it thinks it is. I was hopeful. I wanted it to be better than it was because I do enjoy a lot of the music. I think that everyone in the company is actually properly suited for their roles and yet... it just never happened and that's all we'll say about chess uh moving on at number 37 Christine Day could sing it sir The Baker's Wife I don't

know if you can see this on YouTube but The Baker's Wife at Classic Stage Company uh yet another troubled show this once again by Stephen Schwartz that had its first New York production in decades this time a classic stage company starring Ariana DeBose and

SPEAKER_00Scott Bakula you know it's about a woman who marries a baker and she's all content but then she sees a hot stud from the outsiders and she sings a song about a bird and she flees but then she goes you know what in order to bake bread I do need warmth so she goes back to Scott Bakula and there's talk about a cat that's Beautifully designed

pretty strong ensemble best thing about it Judy Kuhn opening and closing the show and also being funny as fuck people have never let Kuhnsey be funny before but she got to be funny here and we love that and she has a scene in act two with Sally Murphy who once again plays a troubled wife in a bad marriage not a bad production it made me realize why Baker's Wife doesn't work why it will never work and it's

SPEAKER_00actually a score that I don't like as much as people like Thought I Would. Similar to Chess, this has always been a blind spot for me in musical theater. Certain songs that I've always known, always knew Where is the Warmth and Proud Lady and Meadowlark, but didn't really know the rest of it. And watching Baker's Wife, I'm like, huh, the rest of the score is not great. It's not bad, but it's not great. I'm glad that Cunzi got her flowers. Beautiful set design, and we love Cunzi. That's The Baker's Wife at number 37. At number 36.

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your royal highness.

SPEAKER_00Heathers. Again, I don't have a playbill for this one and I won't go too in depth because I did a review of it, a solo review of it. But as we know, I love the movie of Heathers. It's very important to me. And I've always felt that the musical is not a great adaptation. I don't they go very hard in on a comedic I don't know

I wish that it were because they would be more interesting that way there are objectively good songs in Heathers some of which I actually think fit the moment I do like Dead Girl Walking I think Beautiful is a really good opening number on a musical theater level I don't love the journey it gives us for Veronica I don't

SPEAKER_00like it just undercuts a lot of the Mixed Emotions Of Veronica And Heather Chandler's Relationship Especially After Heather Chandler's Death Whereas In The Movie She Has A History With Heather Chandler She Has Memories It Was A Give And Take Of It's My Best Friend And I Hate Her But, you know,

still good music this was a pretty solid cast uh Casey likes his JD I thought was really good the best performance overall was Mackenzie Kurtz as Heather Chandler I thought this production also was a stronger production than the original had a better sense of tone and style uh and just overall felt more fully realized and I appreciated what Heather's does as a musical more this time around even if it still

SPEAKER_00doesn't completely work for me which leads us to number 35 Ginger Twinsies written and directed by friend of the pod Kevin Zach it is a 90 minute retelling with a queer bent on the Lindsay Lohan remake of The Parent Trap if that sounds incredibly specific it's because it is and there's not much else to say about it I laughed I definitely laughed at it it's more uh referential humor that's very much Kevin's brand of

comedy and that's not going to be for everyone uh it is a good company of actors what Ginger Twinsies actually really showed me was that how good of a director Kevin is I think Kevin especially for comedy really understands pacing and energy and uh surprise and uh

SPEAKER_00with something like Ginger Twinsies because And so so I was really impressed by what Kevin was able to do on a director front and it was a good company I'm always down to see Russell Daniels on stage literally every time but we do have a written review of Ginger Twinsies on the Substack if you want a bit more in-depth talk about that next up at number 34

Christine Day could sing

SPEAKER_03it sir High Spirits at Encores the musical adaptation of Noel Coward's White Spirit uh this for me has always been infamous for not only being a best musical nominee in the 1960s I think it's 1963 or 64 it also has a best score nomination at the loss of She Loves Me that's right perfect no skip score She Loves Me did not get a best

SPEAKER_00score nomination at the Tony Awards High Spirits did um And the only song I really know from a high spirit or can even sing for you now is You Better Love Me, a song by Katrina Lenk. Charles, played by Stephen Pasquale, is married to Ruth, here played by Philippa Su, and his first wife, Elvira, played by Katrina Lenk here, ends up getting summoned via a seance. It's a silly little play. It's a silly little show. What I appreciated about this encore's staging was that it had

no designs to be a

SPEAKER_00Broadway transfer. Yeah. with a full orchestra and a full company. We're gonna give you a little bit of set, a little bit of costume, but a lot of it has to be left to your imagination. And it's just about enjoying the fact that it's this nice little thing for two weeks. Let the nice little thing for two weeks be the nice little thing for two weeks.

SPEAKER_00Not everything from Encores needs to transfer. and so that was nice but it did also ultimately reveal to me weaknesses of the material itself not every performance in this production landed for me Andrea Martin god bless her was in over her head on this show she does much better on another show this season we'll get to that in a second but it was in my opinion the best use of Philippa Soo probably since Great Comet I felt the same way when Jane Atkinson played the role in 2009 in Blythe Spirit it was fun to

see Katrina Lenk I still feel like she's kind of finding her singing voice again after Company but this was a better vocal fit for her in general she also looked stunning she had a beautiful wig at least I thought so not everyone thought so but yeah you know it's high spirits classic encores the nice thing for two weeks was

SPEAKER_00the nice thing for two weeks right so that's high spirits at 34 next up at 33

SPEAKER_03Oh my! Letter from Heaven!

SPEAKER_00Slam Frank! Musical by Andrew Fox and Joel Sineski. It ultimately is a show within a show about a theater company putting on The Diary of Anne Frank and woke-ifying it. I've had friends a part of this show for a while throughout most of its development and I know sort of how it was for a while leading up to the production that I saw at the asylum and it... Allegedly the original arc of the show was a little bit more

like a noises off where you watched the production process as they were putting up Diary of Anne Frank and then wanting to give it a Hamilton spin at making it more racially inclusive rewriting elements that maybe people felt were cringy or problematic now addressing uh more of the historical context of Anne Frank in 21st century language addressing Palestine and and wanting to include music to excite younger audiences ultimately leading to a show that bears no resemblance to the

diary of Anne Frank nor to the actual person Anne Frank as it currently stands still Anne Frank is simply is the presentation of the show itself there's a little bit of a preamble by

SPEAKER_00the director of the theater company but then we go right into the show It is definitely a show that's going for shock humor and some of it landed for me some of it didn't there is a pivot in the third act of the show when as it's looking like World War II might be coming to an end within the next year or so the Franks sing about what they might do with their freedom and Anne's sister who has been mute this entire time then goes on a diatribe about Palestine and Anne Frank in order to prevent this Middle Eastern conflict

informs the Nazis that they are in the attic so they can go to Auschwitz be killed and then not have to be at war with the Palestinians and then the actress playing Anne Frank's sister quits on stage this is representative of the way in which Slam

SPEAKER_00Frank is not always sure What is rehearsed and what is improvised it's not always a sure where reality is it's not always sure what is the show within the show and what is just slam frank itself It has a lot of ideas, it has a lot of intelligence, it has a lot of creativity. It's actually a pretty solid score. Again, I think it appropriately mocks the Lin-Manuel Miranda faux hip-hop faux rap style with very precise lyrics.

SPEAKER_00And a company that... you know is very game and all within the same page of each other and it's a show that overly mocks how overly progressive we can be as a theater community we're all so performative with wanting to be the biggest and most informed ally that we stop being people and we stop listening and we just keep talking I say as somebody who's literally just been talking for over an hour I would like to see

SPEAKER_00at 33 at 32 actually it's your royal highness Batboy at city center uh

Batboy is where it's at on this list at 32 for a couple of reasons one we have two amazing performances one by Carrie Butler one by Taylor Trench we also have a show that is near and dear to my heart but also has gone through a massive overhaul in this production half of

SPEAKER_00the score has been changed act one is only semi-recognizable to Batboy fans it's also a production that is done in over 2000 seat theater where Batboy should not be living Batboy needs to be living in a less than 800 seat theater although if anyone's going to make it fit in an over 2000 seat theater it is indeed Alex Timbers who I think does some of his best work here probably since Peter and the Starcatcher Batboy is much more on Alex Timbers property than a lot of his other shows because it is campy it is silly and it doesn't really go for emotion and I

find that Timbers is

SPEAKER_00not an emotional director and so I appreciate all of that and it is overall a good company there are people like Andrew Durand in here we have Alex Newell in here Marissa Jarrett Winokur Chris Sieber and it was a fun enough time I went on a Sunday night when a lot of Broadway performers were there because they didn't have a Sunday show so the energy was really fantastic and there were things I really enjoyed you know we're now in the part of the rankings where I would say we're not even like okay minus we're like we're in the okay plus section of things

SPEAKER_00that I liked things that I liked of maybe not as much as other things um it was an enjoyable time and while I am uh happy that we're going to have a cast recording of the of this company and of the changes ultimately I've always felt that for all the things about the original Batboy that maybe are bumpy it works better in its original incarnation uh all of the changes for this new version at best are lateral moves and then at worst actually remove some of the off-Broadway weirdness of it that makes it so special but again

in our central performances we have Carrie Butler and we have Taylor Trench who I mean I think that between this and Floyd Collins Taylor is sort of proving himself to be a formidable force in musical theater he's not his voice is not such that he can play

SPEAKER_00any role but his acting is such that he's game for any role and so I am happy to sort of see what he does next I'm happy we were able to give Carrie Butler a goddamn leading role again on a big-ass stage if this were you know a show if that boy had actually transferred to Broadway this season like had been rumored I do think that Carrie Butler would have given Casey Levy a run for her money in ragtime she could have even won uh But it was still a fun time If not amazing,

fun That's Batboy at 32 At 31 Caroline written by friend of the pod Preston Max Allen at MCC theater it starred Chloe Grace Moretz as Maddie a young woman with a troubled past who is who's gotten

SPEAKER_00clean has a child who goes by the name Caroline and due to unfortunate circumstances with her most recent romantic partner she and Caroline are forced to flee their current home and go on the run and she returns to her childhood home where she basically has to beg her estranged mother for money to help her start a new life with Caroline beautifully acted by all three performers Preston has definitely done their most

mature work with Caroline I would say it grapples with you know family and relationships and similar to Punch not defining yourself by your past and also dealing with gender Caroline

SPEAKER_00is a transgender girl The problem I had with it was ultimately in the third act when all of the building blocks that I felt that Preston had so wonderfully and maturely built all kind of got tossed away for a late in show hook that didn't feel earned to me. Oh my! Letter from Heaven!

the Broadway production at Manhattan Theater Club of Tracy Letts' play starring Carrie Coon you can listen to a more in-depth review of that in a past episode the highest point of Bug is Carrie Coon who is just such a phenomenally gifted actress

SPEAKER_00Bug ultimately tells the story of her character who um is sort of at the bottom rung of their life. Her estranged husband is getting out of prison and she's been living in a motel room. Her child many years prior was kidnapped and they never found her son. And that has been a weight of trauma on her shoulders all this time and she gets involved with the man played by Namir Smallwood who slowly but surely envelops her in his PTSD and they both start hallucinating and spiraling into a QAnon

mentality of government conspiracies of government surveillance and it all eventually blows itself up in their motel room together and it's a very odd play it's a play that really works best as a pressure cooker where the tension has to

SPEAKER_00build a steadily throughout and this is a production directed by David Cromer similar to Caroline and Fear of Thirteen where I did not feel that the tension properly built it was mostly steadily placid throughout all of the first acts with the exception of Kuhn's performance and then act two finally was able to start to build on that and in the last 20 minutes I found incredibly impressive and memorable but it was disjointed from the rest of the production part of that for me was Cromer's tone

part of that was Smallwood's performance but at the center of it is Carrie Coon who really holds the whole thing together and is appropriately nominated for best actress that is Bug at

SPEAKER_02number 30 and number 29 amateurs and non-equity first A Christmas Carol which was at PAC NYC this winter as directed by Matthew Warchus it's an adaptation by Jack Thorne this adaptation of A Christmas Carol originated in London I believe at the Old Vic yeah the Old Vic and then was done actually

SPEAKER_00right before COVID in the winter of 2019 into January of 2020 at the Lyceum Theater and I'd heard lovely things about it and it ends up sweeping the 2020 Tonys in all of its categories in design in score and I got to see this production with Michael Service playing Ebenezer Scrooge and the negatives are Thorne as a playwright is so hopped up on the psychology of Ebenezer Scrooge that he basically retcons a whole backstory for Scrooge that isn't canon about abuse and

about his career Thorne does a lot of retconning for his own dramatic purposes and there's you know

SPEAKER_00something to it but ultimately It turns A Christmas Carol and Ebenezer Scrooge into this like couch therapy session and what saves it from being insufferable is Warchus' production which is not only stunningly designed but stunningly staged and creates a sense of old school theatrical magic around you and is a show that loves to make something out of nothing you know it's that thing of like three suitcases come together and it's a

SPEAKER_00train it really loves to do that and it's I think part of the reason why I enjoyed it as much as I did was after a very disappointing fall, it was really lovely to see a production where I went, oh, this is what a director with vision and creativity can do. Even if the adaptation itself is sort of only just okay, what Warchus does with it is pretty exceptional. So this is... the imbalance of power I have with this show the give and take of we have a text that I'm sort of mid on but a production that I was enamored

with so it's because of the text I can't put it higher I can't put it like in the teens and because the staging is so good I can't put it lower but we are now in the section of things

SPEAKER_00that I like with caveats so that's A Christmas Carol at 29 at number 28

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your royal highness.

SPEAKER_00Proof. The Pulitzer winning, Tony winning play by David Auburn starring Ayo Etta Beery and Don Cheadle. I won't go into it too much. I did a full review of this as well. The bullet points here are it is a good play. It is a play that grapples with family trauma and resentment and fear of inheriting of mental sickness. it plays around with what's real what isn't who to trust who not to what family

responsibility looks like how that can lead to resentment and that can sort of morph into a toxic shield for some people Catherine definitely uses humor as a defense mechanism she uses aloofness as a defense mechanism so it this production

SPEAKER_00is was proof that proof is a good play and it's not a bad production it's not a terribly exciting one Thomas Kale hasn't really been exciting for me as a director since Hamilton it's a rather by the numbers production it's a design that I think is on her way to a really successful performance.

SPEAKER_00She has a lot of the pieces there. There's a taste level and a just an experience level with straight plays that I think she needs to keep getting her feet wet with before she can really kind of thrive in material like this. I'm glad that she's doing I describe this as sort of like a really strong college production which sounds like a dig and it kind of is because this is Broadway.

But that also should be reminded that that doesn't mean I think this production is bad.

SPEAKER_00This production is fine. I think what saves it is the material itself, Kara Young's performance. Everything else is sort of just fine. A couple of things are not very good. Don Cheadle, I think, is objectively not good in it. but yeah like this is not the worst thing of the season uh it did get totally shut out of the Tonys but ultimately that's because a lot of much better things got in more on that later all right oh 27 Jesus I'm not even at the halfway point I'm almost at the halfway point 27 we have Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York I know some of you

are going to get very mad at me about this this is a perfectly sweet perfectly cute show my biggest gripes for this are ultimately it is about 210 as a two actor with an intermission and I think it needs to be 90 with no intermission I ultimately find that there's

SPEAKER_00not enough story to justify the length of this show uh I don't find that there's enough tension in the story or between the characters I don't think that there's enough payoff in act two for all of the questions that act one wants you to have with certain characters like with Christiana Pitts of uh with her Robin of like why is she at odds with her sister why is she doing all these favors for her sister why hasn't she been to visit her grandmother in years all of these things Some of these things get answered,

SPEAKER_00some of them don't, none of them to an extent where it makes a ton of sense or leads to more dramatic potency in the second act. What this show has going for it is a few things. As I said, it's cute. There's some humor to it. Sam Tutti as Dougal, I think, is giving an astonishingly good performance. I find that of all of the best actor in a musical nominees, I actually think he has the weakest material.

which is not to say that the material itself is weak it's just sort of okay and Dougal I think on paper is such a golden retriever annoying character that the fact that Tutty does what he does with it is rather astonishing Christiani Pitts has I

SPEAKER_00think the better character in terms of The chemistry they have is very much cell and Louise for me it is pure friendship it is pure somebody I can you know hang out with it's not a romantic chemistry there has been a great debate online both on the

SPEAKER_00message boards and on our discord about whether two strangers carry a cake across New York is even a romantic story can't you argue that it's a story about two people finding a connection with someone who maybe isn't their romantic partner but it's just someone who gets them who they like who they like being around and like I mean in a way that's also romance but I would say I feel that based on the way that the show ends the way that they stage their sort of realization about each other in the second act I do find that the show wants us to

buy a romance that is late blooming but ultimately deserved I don't think that the

SPEAKER_00show earns it I think that Tootie and Pitts do their best I think that the staging wants you to feel this swell of romantic emotions that I just don't buy. The design though I will say Sutra Gilmore's set design of various suitcases on an ever revolving turntable is a design that when you walk in you're not sure if you're fully on board with but the way that it reveals itself with all these surprises of different locations becoming a hotel room becoming a cafe becoming the

SPEAKER_00subway. Matt Koplik Prince Fogote by Jordan Tannehill

SPEAKER_00Matt Koplik I enjoyed this this is a show that I thought was blessed with a really strong company of actors I was really happy to see John McRae on stage again I really loved him in Everybody's Talking About Jamie this was actually my introduction to David Greenspan and I loved him I thought he was so fantastic

and I will go see him

SPEAKER_00in everything he does now very happy to see K. Todd Freeman in this he isn't given as much to do as I would like but that's okay because what he does have he handles very nicely um I don't think that the play itself when it gets to the actual narrative of the prince and his boyfriend I don't find that as engaging as I did the um fourth wall breaks where actors talk about their history with sexuality and art and sexuality

which I was nervous when going in and hearing about it I was like oh god is this

SPEAKER_00gonna be reminiscent of my play did I if my play ever gets produced God willing like are people gonna tie it to Prince Fogote and the truth is that I don't think you can because in Prince Fogote the fourth wall breaks are not the characters talking about the themes of the show it's the actors playing those characters talking about the themes of the show and their own personal histories with with it Prince Fogote is a bit more impressive in terms of its bolt swings and it's an actual execution I would say I was not

SPEAKER_00Christine Day could sing it, sir Little Bear Ridge Road our fourth nominee for best play by Samuel D. Hunter my lowest ranking of the four best play nominees biggest takeaways Laurie Metcalf fantastic best performance in the show there is the actor John Drea who I

SPEAKER_00had not heard of before for who came over with this production from Chicago I'm pretty sure and is also currently in death of a salesman he's great big surprise for me I really loved what he did very much kind of slice of life I have learned that this is sort of Samuel D Hunter's vibe very Sofia Coppola of like I feel a lot but in a very austere kind of way in a very isolated frame and I liked it fine I think I have this only two slots higher than two strangers carry a cake as well I maybe enjoyed two strangers more I did think

that Little Bear Ridge Road had a little more something to it on a on a subject matter level and ultimately the performance of Laurie Metcalf and John Drea were such that it really impressed me Micah Stock as the other lead I found to be quite weak so that's sort

SPEAKER_00of the trade-off between Little Bearridge Road and Two Strangers whereas Two Strangers I thought both performers were quite locked in but the material was sort of not quite there Little Bearridge Road I thought the material was a little farther along even if one of the leads was weaker so that's Little Bearridge Road at 25 at 24

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your Royal Highness.

SPEAKER_00The Rocky Horror Show. Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show. Again, we have another review of this one, so I won't go too far in depth about it. But what I will say is that I am very happy with the nominations that this production got. On a design level, I think that it very much carries over in a really charming way the kitschy community theater aesthetic that Sam Pinkleton clearly was going for for Rocky Horror. There is a inner turmoil that theater audiences have with this piece of

wanting a Broadway show while also acknowledging that Rocky Horror's charm comes from its bare bones

SPEAKER_00thrift shop, you know, survivor mentality. Its cult status comes from its scrappy underdog energy. but at the end of the day it is still a Broadway show in a 900 seat theater and so you have to find a balance between the two and this production doesn't really do that it also is not fully engaging with audience participation the performer who deals with it the most is Rachel Dratch as the narrator who I also said I know that

she was having trouble during previews at the performance I saw which was their

SPEAKER_00second to last preview I thought she fully had it locked in and I think her Tony nomination reflects that because Pinkleton does not have a full grasp on his company and balancing the Broadway with the community kitschy aesthetic I think that ultimately is what kept him from a best director Tony but What his design team is able to do is really helpful. What the majority of his cast is able to do is very helpful. I think that Josh Rivera as Rocky is fine. I think he would be better suited for Brad, although Andrew Durant is very good as Brad,

SPEAKER_00but ultimately I think Andrew Durant is very good as Brad. should be playing riffraff even though ambergray is also very good as riffraff but i also think ambergray should be playing magenta uh rachel drach stephanie shu as janet and luke evans as frankenfurter are the three who i think are perfectly cast in their roles and nail it absolutely uh you absolutely have to let go of the 2000 cast recording at least i had to because it's not going to give you that kind of um vocal power

SPEAKER_00Again, Pinkleton is trying to go back to grassroots Rocky, and that's not going to be for everyone. But there is a fun time to be had. It's just you have to know that all the things that seem sloppy and amateurish about it are 1000% on purpose. It's that that was their vision. You don't have to like it, but that was their vision. And I always applaud a show that, you know, is willing to take a swing with its vision. All right. So that's Rocky Horror Show at 24. At 23, we have a new entry. Christine Day could sing it sir well I'll Let You Go uh the

play by Bubba Weiler which is currently playing at Studio Seaview it had a production earlier this season that I didn't catch uh it tells the story of a woman played by Quincy Tyler Bernstein Bernstein Bernstein who is mourning the recent loss of her husband and a

SPEAKER_00different person from her life stops by her home to pay their condolences while also kind of having ulterior motives and that's not a thriller situation just in the way that everyone does right of how each person deals with loss how each person deals with having to be a support for someone going through loss how everyone's uh Unanswered Questions

is sort of our town meets rabbit hole it has a very our town vibe of not only the narrator but of you know bare bones set of imagine that this is a dining room imagine that there's a piano there and then similar to David Cromer's production of

SPEAKER_00our town there is a set reveal towards the end um it's a very beautifully acted piece my only real gripe with it why it's at 23 and maybe not at like 10 although again we're now in the area of things that I liked with Well I'll Let You Go ultimately in the first 30 minutes it was hard for me to get into it I was kind of fading in and out and it wasn't really until yeah I guess yeah I'm trying to think of who there was a certain person

where when they showed

SPEAKER_00up I was like okay now we're Now we're getting into it. It was before Emily Davis when the pieces were connecting and I was able to really lock in with the play and the production. And then once I did, I was really on board. But again, it was about 30 minutes so that I could let that happen. The different stages of grief and of mourning and of grappling with past mistakes and looking back on the past with both fondness and regret...

it deals with all of it in a really humane and relatable way and I would say that it's pretty much across the board fantastic acting I would definitely highlight Quincy Tyler Bernstein who I really enjoyed in Doubt two seasons ago and in The Next Room a long time ago as the central performance her character is a little

SPEAKER_00harder to understand at the beginning just because you're not sure like how in shock she is you're not sure how self-removed from everything she is if she's kind of going through a mental distress that's making her act in a very odd way or if it's just her way of processing her grief but at the end it all it ends up becoming a really beautiful arc that makes sense but for the again for like the first 30 minutes it feels a little okay what's

SPEAKER_00Where are we at right now? What is happening with this character? It's a piece that I do ultimately recommend. It's maybe not start to finish gripping. but it's a play that sneaks up on you and by the end you find yourself to have really been won over by its heart and its nuance and I really want to applaud them for that and there's a scene with Emily Davis and Quincy Tyler

Bernstein that I

SPEAKER_00found to be in my opinion probably the best acted scene in the whole piece I mean Emily Davis I'm a fan of while she wasn't put to good use in Tartuffe she was exceptional in Is This a Room which was at the Lyceum in I think 2021 maybe early 2022 just a really gifted actress who I could not be more obsessed with there's also Cricket Brown who plays her daughter Cricket has the final scene and has a really beautiful heart to

heart with Quincy Tyler Bernstein that really just those two scenes back to back well I guess they're not back to back there's a small one in between them but those two scenes towards the end really landed the plane of well I'll let you go for me also this is a random thing but now that the comeback is over I've found myself saying certain

SPEAKER_00titles like Valerie Cherish so I for, well, I'll let you go. Well, I'll let you go. Well, I'll let you go Well, I'll let you go Well, I'll let you go You find yourself saying things like Valerie Cherish sometimes Same thing with Rose Byrne as Oscar nominated in If I had legs, I'd kick you If I had legs, I'd kick you You know, you find yourself saying shit like that Okay, we're gonna do one more and then I gotta take a break because I

gotta go check out

SPEAKER_00an apartment in a little bit So, to recap At number 50 we have House of McQueen At number 49 we have Tartuffe At 48 we have Beaches 47 Dog Day Afternoon 46 Call Me Izzy 45 The Seat of Our Pants 44 Waiting for Godot 43 Art The Fear of 13 41 The Queen of Versailles with Kristen Chenoweth At number 40 Joe Turner's Come and Gone 39 Punch 38 Chess 37 The Baker's Wife 36 Heathers 35 Ginger Twinsies 34 High Spirits 33 Slam Frank 32 Bat Boy 31 Caroline 30 Bug

29 A Christmas Carol 28 Proof 27 Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York 26

SPEAKER_00Prince Fogote 25 Little Barrage Road 24 The Rocky Horror Show 23 Well, I'll Let You Go And at number 22 Amateurs and Non-Equity First Ken Rex Starring Jack Holden Co-written by Jack Holden How do you say his last name? sorry uh Ed Stamboulian Stamboulian let's say Ed Stamboulian who also directs the piece this is a transfer from the West End currently playing at the Lucille Lortel

Theater described as a true crime thriller it is a basically a one-man show uh John Patrick Elliott provides some music and sound effects as well for the piece but it's uh 98% Jack Holden uh and it is a true crime thriller about a true story about

SPEAKER_00uh Ken Rex McElroy who was mysteriously murdered in his hometown and uh there is no proper evidence or eyewitness testimony as to what happened uh spoiler alert it's basically a murder on the Orient Express situation where it's like a whole bunch of people who did it because Ken Rex McElroy you find out over the course of this play was a constant nuisance for the town that he lived in he was not a good man he uh

Destroyed a lot of properties he incited a lot of violence he groomed a in the play 14 year old girl I believe in real life she was 12 impregnated her and then married her and basically threatened her parents into letting her get married to him and then gaslit her into being his the Bonnie to his Clyde for the rest of their

SPEAKER_00marriage together just really awful awful man and uh the show centers first around a crime he commits that he is put on trial for and the town trying to figure out how to get him um I'm

for any people who are not a part of it to determine who actually set off the killing shot and the show sort of goes through all of this in flashback via a prosecutor against Ken Rex McElroy and the FBI who are investigating his murder and

SPEAKER_00the whole thing weaves in and out of different mediums there's recorded audio there's video projection and then there's Holden's performance itself as a performance piece Kendra X is pretty astounding as a piece of playwriting it's The

SPEAKER_00Play could definitely stand some trimming. At the moment, the things that it really relies on are Holden's performance and its imaginative style. and there's and there's also solid music by John Patrick Elliott I heard a lot of really strong things about Ken Rex I have friends in London who recommended it to me so when it announced a production here I bought a ticket and you know Holden won the Olivier which is you know massive achievement and honestly

a very well deserved

SPEAKER_00Olivier it's a really phenomenal performance and worth seeing that performance my slight mixed feelings on the play itself are not enough that it should put Ken Rex lower because it's ultimately well done it's just feels a little bloated in terms of pacing and timing which is an easy fix step step and maybe it's all of our I think it succeeds

like 80% of the time as I said it's a little too slow and moments to fully be engaging all the time but luckily Holden is so good that it doesn't ultimately really matter alright so that is Ken Rex at number 22 so next up at number 21 oh my letter from heaven Gotta Dance in its original incarnation when it was at theater

SPEAKER_00at St. Jean's for the York theater produced by American Dance Machine this is a review and you can see it currently at I think it's stage 42 is the name of the theater yeah it used to be called the Little Schubert back in the day that's how old I am it is a review of Broadway dance some film dance as well mostly Broadway and it's you know enacting what the company has always done which is American Dance Machine does a lot of recreations of iconic

choreography from iconic

SPEAKER_00choreographers and as taught and directed by the dancers who tended to originate them so they preserve the works of Michael Bennett Bob Fosse Jerome Robbins Susan Stroman Twyla Tharp so on and so forth this show ultimately there's nothing to it other than just a big old review of Wonderful Wonderful Dance and what it reminded me as it should remind everyone is how phenomenal musical theater dance can be when it is

genuinely crafted around

SPEAKER_00story and character and attitude, not just about overly wowing an audience. What the So You Think You Can Dance era of television has done to Broadway choreography is Really disheartening because it is often about impressive feats of strength and agility, usually right off the bat. So there's nowhere for choreography to go. And it's about applauding what the dancers can do, not what the choreography is.

SPEAKER_00When people say, oh, I love the choreography. It was so impressive. That's not what you want to be told. It's not about it being impressive, it's about it being exciting, it's about it being surprising, it's about how well integrated it is into the story, right? Some of the most amazing numbers from some of our most iconic choreographers have almost very little dance at all look at big spender from sweet charity it's not just about simplicity but it is about knowing how to make a number build

knowing how to make

SPEAKER_00it feel organic and knowing how to excite an audience and how to make Make it feel seamless with the rest of the material. Otherwise, it's just a dance recital. Otherwise, it's just gymnastics. And Gotta Dance is a wonderful reminder of what it can be and what it should be. So I highly recommend if anyone's around while it's running at stage 42 to go see it there. I know a few numbers have changed, but I think it's like 85% what it was at the York. All right. So at number 20.

Fallen Angels this is starring Kelly O'Hara and Rose Byrne this is a revival of the Noel Coward play there's been some updates to it some additional material added by Claudia Shear some trimming down it went from a two act to a 90 minute one act that is for the better because ultimately if you listen to my review of Fallen Angels which is the same episode as my Beaches review I describe this play as a lovely

SPEAKER_00little nothing it's not really about anything I mean obviously there are circumstances and there are characters but there's not a lot of conflict there's not a lot of story and you don't necessarily need challenging material in an old coward piece that's not what you go for but it is sort of an excuse to watch Kelly O'Hara and Rose Byrne sort of fuck around and find out you're not watching it because you're interested to know what happens next It's about each little bunt of a quip that one of them might say.

SPEAKER_00It's about the physical comedy that they might do. And the good news is that Rose Byrne and Kelly O'Hara are absolutely game and they fucking annihilate. the production is absolutely built around them it's designed to make them look amazing until they're meant to not look amazing it's luxurious it's beautiful it's period appropriate but also a little kitschy and fun the rest of the cast is strong they're not really given as much to do the one who has the most to do outside of Byrne and O'Hara is Tracy Shimo as the maid the name dropping maid there was a lot of talk early on in previews that she might get a

supporting nomination because a lot of people felt she stole the show she is very good she's a great actress her role is not quite enough for her to do that Ellis does a better job

SPEAKER_00with this than he does with art better sense of style better sense of tone better sense of pacing and just more opportunities for physical comedy with his actors than he had with art the physical bits are a little more scattered than I would like them to be but it is a very fun nice time at the theater and I do actually recommend it and it's really fun to see Kelly O'Hara be saucy and messy again alright so that is number 20 at number 19

SPEAKER_03Christine Day could sing it sir The Queen of Versailles Sherry's Version Miss Sherry Renee Scott if you're Nast Hay Here's the thing Queen of Versailles is not a good musical Sherry Renee Scott as Christian Chenoweth Standby did not suddenly turn it into a great musical however

SPEAKER_00this is a case where the experience of her first night will forever be tattooed onto what she brought to the show with Sherry Renee Scott in the lead role as Jackie Siegel already with her physical presence her comedic tone and her voice already is a more natural fit for someone like Jackie Siegel than Kristen Chenoweth who is small who is a little more tightly wound physically and also just has a squeaky speaking voice and a classical singing voice

Sherry is a little more earthy grounded voluptuous den mother that can easily pivot to slightly trashy Florida unaware of her comedic tendencies so that already fits

SPEAKER_00better for the role on top of that Sherry by being willing to go to a More morally gray area allows you as an audience with this show to see what the central conceit might have been, even if it got lost in execution, where the show started from and what it could be and what it might be one day, you know, with a lot, a lot, a lot of surgery. But the idea of a woman who had all this potential and squanders it because ultimately her values do not line up with her capabilities and

in the end is it all worth it who's to say and who's to say what exactly she has learned from all of the things she's done all of the things she's lost the people she's lost like her daughter and it was really fascinating to see all these things that I had seen with Kristen 24 hours earlier make a lot more sense with Sherry

SPEAKER_00again not fully successful but working which is like night and day and on top of that an audience that is at this moment of my life at the age of 36 after having seen nearly 500 different Broadway productions this is one of the closest nights I can think of that felt like what it must have felt like to see Judy Garland at Carnegie Hall of 1500 people who were there solely to see Sherry Renee Scott it was her first time

back on a Broadway stage in 10 years her first time in a Broadway musical in 15 and we were so there to support her and make her understand how much we missed seeing her do this and her entrance got I shit you not a full minute of applause I have

SPEAKER_00the audio I've timed it it's a full minute It was the most respectful, enthusiastic crowd because people weren't shouting at the stage. People weren't going, we love you, Sherry. Nobody was making it about them. We were all making it clear it was about her and it was raucous but respectful. And I can't think of the last time I had that. Maybe closing night of Grey Gardens. Maybe. Maybe. Or maybe closing night of Title of the Show. Maybe. Phenomenal evening. It is this low because ultimately Queen of Versailles still

SPEAKER_00Number Eighteen

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your Royal Highness.

SPEAKER_00The people called it Ragtime. This is going to be controversial for some of y'all, but I've spoken about this plenty on the podcast. I also have a review episode of this show as well. I've said this before, and you can fully disagree. I understand people have spoken to me about their thoughts on the show, and it has not changed my mind in any way. Ragtime is a musical where I listen to the score and I cry. I watch the show and I don't cry. Aarons and Flaherty have written an incredible score one of the

best scores of the 90s for sure maybe best score of the 90s unclear I still have to figure that out for myself it is also a show that was written in an era of musical theater and in an era of America where there was a great naivete of optimism mostly if you were

SPEAKER_00white and by putting blinders on you could think that we had reached the end of history it was post Gulf War pre 9-11 and Ragtag

who had it in his mind that he was going to create the greatest American musical since Showboat and that is Garth Trubinsky who literally saw himself as a modern

SPEAKER_00day Florence Ziegfeld even building a theater like Ziegfeld did that Showboat could play at that Ragtime could play at what we now call the Lyric Theater used to be the Ford Center of Performing Arts and it was converging the Apollo and Lyric Theater together to make one giant 1900 seat barn it is now I believe 1600 seats for Harry Potter but at the time it was 1900 seats and it was to house this massive massive all-American great American musical Ragtime and you can hear in my opinion that aura of self-importance in the show

and for me that is part of the reason why Ragtime doesn't age super well as a musical it's a perfectly fine musical it's not like a disaster of a book or anything like that McNally is a good writer but there are concessions that are made for the sake that this has to be an under three hour musical of a book that is like 400 pages covering 10 years of story but the book also that it's based off of is a cynical tale about how the American dream is only real if you're white or can assimilate to whiteness and the musical takes all of the events of the book and then gives it a Clinton administration optimistic white

spin and as I said when I listen to it I cry and when I watch the show I don't believe a word of it it's not bad I just I'm not moved and this production doesn't do anything to change my mind the good things about this production are the music is handled with great care it's a big orchestra it's a cast of phenomenal voices everyone in it is a strong

SPEAKER_00smart actor doing a lot of work to make up for the fact that this production also doesn't really have a sense of vision uh it is of and I'm not even I'm not even talking staging which is perfectly perfunctory half of the time and satisfactory the other half that's whatever you know sure like Do characters enter from the volumes of the thrust of the Beaumont and then exit offstage left to going in a diagonal as they say two lines because you know we got

to make use of the space sure is there any reason behind it no is it an ugly looking production 1000% is the choreography acceptable yes but what I mean is that there's so much in this production that I watch and dramaturgy aside of like We build the Model T Ford and then we don't even use it for Wheels of a Dream.

SPEAKER_00What's that about Lear? But just the very fact of there's so much in this show that relies on having an imagination as a director, having a vision, having a tone to be able to set and keep going. And the one thing I will say for this production is that it does keep going, but it doesn't really have a set tone outside of just everyone's just playing it. There's no imagination to it. There is no vision to it. It is simply, hey,

SPEAKER_00ragtime be good, we think anyway, and there are some bumps to it that we would like to acknowledge, sort of. We're going to have, you know, two people have a bump in in the opening number and we're going to take a breath before the final dream at the finale. That's the extent of a vision we have here. But because the

Everyone I know who adores this show and saw the original production still speaks

SPEAKER_00about that original production. This should be a few bits higher for me. But what's really dragging it back is all the ways in which this production is kind of just basic. And again, a lot of people will disagree. I know a few people who've seen it a few times and have cried their eyes out. God bless. Doesn't do it for me. But that's ragtime at number 18. Okay, at number 17, we have... The Lost Boys They're boys and they're very lost Here's the thing about The Lost Boys The Lost Boys is probably a worse musical on paper than

Racktime In fact I would say it objectively is But I do appreciate such a bold maximalist swing That

SPEAKER_00is able to hit the ball I would argue more often than not and I think part of the reason why there's a lot of hate towards this show is because of how overly earnest and maximalist it is I mean people hate the mega musicals of the 80s people hate Les Mis and Cats and Phantom and lord knows I have my thoughts on Phantom and I have my thoughts on Cats but like I'll fucking say it I am an esoteric asshole I love Les Mis it is one of my favorite musicals I will die on that hill but Les Mis is a big big show with broad broad

strokes and Lost

SPEAKER_00Boys is kind of the same so you have to Meet it at that level and then decide if it nails that assignment I think it achieves the assignment frequently It doesn't always, but frequently But I mean, I enjoyed it I don't think I'll be seeing it again anytime soon But I was happy that it wasn't a complete flop Oh my! Letter from Heaven!

Shmigadoon the Cinco Paul Extravaganza and I say Cinco Paul in quotation marks because there was a whole writing team for the TV show that are not credited here Cinco Paul editing down a whole season's worth of episodes into a two and a half

SPEAKER_00hour musical Everyone here knows what Schmingadoon is couple from the real world find themselves in the land of a musicale he's not into it she is and by the end of it they find love again there bing bang boom and you know other things happen but none of it's really important that's kind of my big qualm with Schmingadoon which is also my qualm with Fallen Angels is like most of it doesn't matter everything that happens doesn't end up mattering and I think that's what would actually push Megadoon to the next level of musical theater comedy is if a lot of the moments in the show

ultimately mattered most of them just don't but that's okay I also wish that it was a little smarter about its

SPEAKER_00musical theater knowledge and its satire of it Kind of Betty Kind of he knows his golden age musical theater movie stuff and listen I know that I'm a freak but also like half of our listeners are freaks right we all are persnickety about this shit and it's one of those things where I would love

nothing more than for this show to be able to turn off my brain for me and let me enjoy the ride and there are times when I really did and other times where unfortunately my brain had

SPEAKER_00to turn right back on and go I don't think so I don't think so honey but actually no a couple more caveats and then I'll go back to the positives caveat uh score is decent I didn't find it terribly harmable or memorable which is not a big gripe but for a show that's Golden Age coded it kind of would be nice to have a couple of songs you're like oh my god yeah that was a beautiful ballad or like oh my god that was such a rousing

dance number uh but you know the music sort of it's just fine it's fine it's fine it's fine and you know there were a couple moments where I laughed but I didn't laugh as often as I wanted to not because I thought it wasn't funny but it just didn't get me like there were moments when you watch something you go that was a

SPEAKER_00funny joke even though you don't laugh That was me like half the time with Schmigadoon But some things also did genuinely get me Positives It is a strong cast I think the women sell it a little bit better than the men But I also think they have the better material Enjoyed Mackenzie Kurtz As we all know I'm a huge fan of Isabel Michaela I thought she did great Anne Harada also very good always happy to see her on stage on a gas tire very good I felt a little she was a little underutilized Sarah Chase holds the glue together quite nicely in this show I think Alex Brightman also does a

good job by her side

SPEAKER_00he has the harder role of the wet blanket douche but Alex Brightman is so likable when he plays assholes that it's actually quite good casting design wise I think it looks pretty fantastic there are some people who are not happy with the set or the costumes I'm not entirely sure why I think they're very appropriate to golden age design aesthetics while also giving it a sprig of modern musical theater and Chris Catelli knows how to choreograph you know I love seeing him outside of the Newsies mold and just doing a good old fashioned number

that like can genuinely build I think he's one of our better choreographers working right now hot take

SPEAKER_00I still think he has a bit of a way to go as a director. I think he's good at sort of honing in on material and shaping it so it's nice and tight and makes sense. I think he's good at having his cast be all on the same page. I think he can stand to be a little more adventurous as a stager as a director and also be a little more mindful of the dead air in between scenes during scene transitions and just like certain pockets of jokes being able to face front and really land certain moments that are

meant to be funny or meant to give us an idea of what's happening in the story were a little muddled when there were more than like three people on stage so you know like we're again we're in the era of things that I like but not necessarily things that I love but that is Schwingadoon at 16 so to recap we have at number 50 House

SPEAKER_00of McQueen 49 Tertuffe 48 Beaches 47 Dog Day Afternoon 46 Call Me Izzy 45 The Seat of Our Pants 44 Waiting for Godot 43 Art 42 The Fear of 13 41 The Queen of The Baker's Wife Heathers Ginger Twins 34 High Spirits 33 Slam Frank 32 Bat Boy 31 Caroline

30 Bug 29 A Christmas Carol 28 Proof 27 Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York 26 Prince Faggot 25 Little Bay of Ridge Road 24 Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horse Show 23 Well I'll Let You Go 22 Ken Rex 21 Gotta Dance 20 Fallen Angels 19 The Queen of Versailles Sherry's Version 18 Rug Time 17 The Lost Boys 16 Schmigadoon

and at 15 we have Christine Day could sing it sir Daniel Radcliffe in Every

SPEAKER_00Brilliant Thing Duncan McMillan and Johnny Donohue a piece that I think is a wonderful community building exercise a phenomenal showcase for Daniel Radcliffe's talent and charisma a good example of giving you hope for humanity in terms of how 900 strangers can collectively come together and create a unique memorable night of theater where everyone's paying attention everyone is in it with each other and not for themselves

But also not necessarily much of a play Similar to Sherry in Queen of Versailles The memory of the experience is what brings it so high for me The material itself is kind of just fine A show about a young man whose mother suffers from mental

SPEAKER_00illness Tries to take her own life on more than one occasion and in order to help her in his young innocent mind he starts making a list of things that are brilliant about life that make it worth living and the list goes in and out of fashion as he gets older and more distracted but he comes back to the list major life events happen and he comes back to the list eventually he also becomes depressed and the list doesn't help his marriage but it does help him and

SPEAKER_00you know it's a Actually, it's your royal highness... I mean, but the

Roald Dahl who he plays Roald Dahl phenomenal children's book author who also was a raging anti-Semite we all knew this for the better part of 40 years but we were okay with it anyway it became part of the lore of him every time we would talk

SPEAKER_00about his books or movies of his books Oh yeah Roald Dahl amazing children's book writer raging anti-Semite and we would say that and then we would read his books and listen I have a signed copy of Matilda I have Charlie and the Chocolate Factory I watch Fantastic Mr. Fox I love the musical version of Matilda I am not exempt from this kind of hypocritical attitude But the play of Giant does kind of want to grapple with that as well As well as the

conversations around Judaism Israel and the Middle East In the case of Giant it's about Israel and Beirut Not Israel and Palestine And also having a conversation of when is something a genuine concern And when is it actually coded in anti-Semitism Giant makes it very clear by the end of the play that for all of the hoopla that Dahl talks about for being progressive it's ultimately an anti-semitic person that he is it's a little bumpy sometimes as a play but I think that

what it attacks it attacks really gracefully and I think that it's an incredible group of actors

SPEAKER_00wonderfully and directed with nuance by Nicholas Heitner good set by Bob Crowley always not always but like 95% of the time it's going to be a good set by Bob Crowley Lithgow is a force in this piece I was also incredibly taken with Aya Cash an actress who I've already had a wonderful um respect for but was happy to see her on stage and just absolutely crushing it goes toe-to-toe with Lithgow got Tony nominated for it and more importantly her hair her

shoes and her dress do not clash or go matchy matchy they are just perfect and they're on fleek yes uh yeah you can hear more about my review of giant in my

SPEAKER_00review of giant next up at number 13 Meet the Cartosians by Talene Monaghan. This is a piece about, uh, it's two acts. The first act, Fairy Great Gardens. Act one takes place in the early 1900s, around like 1923, 24, and it's an Armenian-American family that is urging the government to pass a law that allows Armenians to be considered white, a, um, Sort of a demand for visibility and equality.

And you're watching their journey with their Irish lawyer as they sort of discuss

SPEAKER_00the history of their family, what it took for them to come to this country, what they deal with every day, and their demand to be treated equally. And that is Act I. Act II is about 100 years later, and the Cartosians have now become an incredibly famous... family via reality TV and social media it's very Kardashian coded and they are doing an episode of the reality show to discuss their Armenian heritage but of course only in reality show fashion and the main Cartosian

who's Kim Kardashian

SPEAKER_00coded is not there yet so while they're waiting the they have Armenian Americans from California there to discuss their Armenian heritage with this Kim Kardashian person but she's not there yet so they're kind of sitting there waiting and they all sort of know each other and they start blowing up about a demand from Armenian Americans for the next census for them to be labeled in their own category not as white so the irony of a hundred years later the thing that

their ancestors fought

SPEAKER_00for and achieved they are now fighting to undo and it's a really good Will Brill Tony winner Will Brill also amazing

But it also has this conversation of identity and who gets to say your what and when do you get to define your what and what does that identity mean for you?

SPEAKER_00When does it become its own form of privilege? When are you using oppression as privilege? Because that is actually a conversation that needs to be had. And then there becomes the double talk of, well, now are you just bemoaning that your privilege is getting taken away from you because someone is calling out their oppression and now getting ahead? But that also applies to everyone, not just any specific ethnicity. And Meet the Cartosians grapples with that in a way that is engaging and entertaining and never condescending, but always leading to a conversation,

SPEAKER_00never an answer. And those are the best kind of plays. It's a little lower on the list for me simply because it has a hard time ending as a play. And I do think that the second act goes a little into giant territory where it becomes very long monologues of historical exposition and analysis that becomes less dramatic and more preachy

but before it can go on for too long in that respect it comes right back around and

SPEAKER_00goes back to being a very engaging play uh a really strong one in uh a really strong entry in the canon in my humble opinion i believe they even got a Pulitzer finalist yeah i think that i think they were finalists for the Pulitzer this past year but uh yeah just really strong a strong play and a strong cast and uh i believe this was also another cromer yeah Did Kromer have Yeah, David Kromer Kromer had three shows this season Fear of 13,

SPEAKER_00Bug, and Meet the Cartosians Man is booked and blessed, good for him Okay, so that's Meet the Cartosians at 13 At number 12 we have Oh my letter from heaven Bo the off-broad we hit from uh out of the box productions that then had a second run at where was it the st luke's theater on 46th street starring matt rodent written by uh douglas lyons i didn't know what to expect from the show i had a lot of gay friends tell me i had to see it telling me that it made them cry that's always a uh

Red Flag for me because it's rare that I see queer stories and I so thoroughly bond

SPEAKER_00with them I appreciate them but you know when you're starting to go into subcategories of characters that are closer to who you are when they are not super close to your life you appreciate them but it's harder to cry along with them right You have to kind of be moved by their story and the way it's told and ultimately bow is a fun time that has a lot of heart about it has a lot of imagination really fantastic music an amazing central performance from that road and this is my second time seeing him on stage after last year with all the world's a

stage and I think

SPEAKER_00he's very very special and definitely one to watch I Hope that we see him on a larger stage soon enough because i think he's better than some of our more constantly working broadway actors no tea no shade no pink lemonade but that's just my thought there there are moments in bow that definitely uh go towards the obvious when it comes to queer stories the bully who's secretly queer and and things like that um and then the central relationship between matt rodent and the character of bow nice as it is it doesn't quite develop

The show doesn't spend enough time on the developing relationship that they have

SPEAKER_00for the final moments of the show to really resonate with me, which is also where I think a lot of my friends who really gravitated towards it had some kind of situation in their life that mirrored Bo and thus were able to let go of the things that maybe were a little underdeveloped or underbaked because they just resonated with a good chunk of it which is fair I mean ultimately when we talk about critiques of shows right the bottom line is the show and

when you're critiquing a show it's because the show does not work for you and so all of the

SPEAKER_00Speaking of which at number 11 we have

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your royal highness. The Wild Party at Encores, which is maybe a bit higher than I would have thought originally.

SPEAKER_00This is a musical that is flawed. It kind of just ends. It doesn't really have a dramatic motor to it. And it is a show that fully needs time and expense to create an imaginatively designed and staged production. Encores does not allow for that. It's not enough time, not enough money, not enough stage space. I would have liked a bit more of an abstract design and staging than we got here. It was a little bit literal of a production for me.

SPEAKER_00But overall, the chance to hear this amazing score, top five of the 21st century, bar none, to hear it live for the first time and going twice actually to hear it live was incredibly important to me. and when this production worked it worked in a way that really took me out of my seat Jasmine Amy Rogers as Queenie just completely understanding the assignment and giving me all that I needed Adrian Warren as Kate uh Megan Murphy as Madeline uh I

was a little I was a little hard I was quite hard on um Jordan Donega's Burrs but

SPEAKER_00the root of what Burrs should B was already there so actors in this production who I maybe had notes for it some of them it wasn't like you're wrong you're bad it was you have the right idea now if we gave you another 10 days of rehearsal and I were in the room with you can we like finesse this and Donica was one of those people uh same thing with like Claiborne Elder as Jackie like there was a lot of good already happening and by the time we got to the second to last show which is when I went again a lot of things had really started to melt into the production that allowed it to just pop more you

know spoiler alert the more time you have to work on something the better you can be with it and the show is tighter and more focused and performances were getting more developed and

SPEAKER_00it was really Just a really exciting opportunity to experience a show that I have a great deal of love for while understanding all of its flaws while also understanding that I may not see it at that level of professionalism ever again. I would love to see it at that level of professionalism again. I would love a chance to even direct it myself one day. Should I ever get back into directing? Which is kind of like me saying, should I ever get back into heterosexuality? But, you know, never say never.

but i'm also really glad that a lot of new york got to see this show and experience what makes it so unique and to hear like what a really stanky jazz score this is because it's god it's just one of the best that's the wild party at 11 at number 10

SPEAKER_03christine day could sing it sir Becky Shaw at second stage the Broadway premiere of Gina Gianfrido's Pulitzer finalist play this is sort of a I'm not even gonna call it a rom-com this is like a

SPEAKER_00situation comedy about terrible people You're watching people manipulate one another from every angle. You're watching people do everything in their power in their mental gymnastics to justify everything that they say and do because they don't want to be perceived as a bad person even those

who say I don't care if you think I'm a bad person they care everybody cares it is someone asked me like oh what's Becky Shaw about and I said well it's about us and everybody we know it is a phenomenally tight ensemble Alden Ehrenreich is giving

SPEAKER_00the one of the best stage debuts i've seen in years granted he's already a wonderful actor but as we learned with you know atrian brody in the fear of 13 not every good movie actor can translate to stage but alden absolutely does but everyone in this production is wonderful madeline brewer as the titular becky shaw is fantastic you watch her manipulate without understanding she's manipulating you watch Lauren Patton be so

self-righteous and be the social justice warrior but also being the biggest hypocrite you see Linda Eamond just serving Lucille Bluth meets Tiny Tim Realness as I said on Instagram and you're seeing Patrick Ball be this like not like other men men which is all we know like the nice guy trope of oh you're so full of shit you do this to feel better about yourself or to get women and the whole play takes

SPEAKER_00all of these people and fucks around with them if I had one major qualm with Becky Shaw ultimately is that similar to Lost Boys it takes a while going where it needs to get to even if there's some air in it it's maybe the one of the closest I found about people of the 21st century in the millennial Gen X uh Titanic Listen I could be biased Probably am

Titanic Off-Broadway was one of my favorite things I've seen in the last 10 years.

SPEAKER_00It was my happy place. I saw it like seven times at the Daryl Roth Theater and once at the Under the Christides. And I was extraordinarily hesitant about its being successful on Broadway. I thought the St. James was too big I didn't like everyone who they were putting into the new company I thought that all of what made it successful in a 200 seat theater was going to die in a 1700 seat theater even if they closed off the balcony and made it you know 14 to 1500 seats and not everything works in the St.

James let's be clear there's a reason why this is a number nine not number one

SPEAKER_00because if this were off-Broadway fuck this would be a number one Jim Parsons is perfectly fine as Ruth's he's not amazing he's not as good as Russell Daniels or Nathan Lee Graham but he's good he doesn't shit the bed Melissa Barrera is a very solid Rose in fact there are certain lines she got laughs on that Rose's downtown didn't and that was really impressive to see Deborah Cox sings the mother loving shit out of Molly Brown but no girlfriend ain't funny it's okay that's fine whatever

and everyone else does a really strong job Leighton Williams amazing as the iceberg bitch Tony nominated as the iceberg bitch just fully stopping the show cold with River Deep Mountain High lip sync for your lifeboats the design even actually kind

SPEAKER_00of fills out the space decently it's sort of like trashy cruise ship aesthetic and that's very much the point the expanded orchestration sound good they don't overdo with more cast members they really try to keep it as a homegrown bunch of gays and their allies putting on a show in front of you But not going so amateurish that it feels insulting How you feel about the comedy of the show is up to you Similar to Ginger Twinsies, it's a lot of referential humor But because it's all trapped within the arc of the

SPEAKER_00story of Titanic There is still a narrative drive we have to get to Marla Mendel hilarious as always as Celine Dion and unlike Rocky Horror Show I think is able to take the amateur hour community theater energy and spin it into Broadway presentation something that Rocky Horror is struggling with in my opinion and it's just a blast it's just a blast my other only real note other than like you know

it doesn't always fit in the space not every cast member is equal footing there are a couple of changes that have been made to the Broadway production a little bit of extra material added mostly for Jim Parsons I don't think they really do much it just sort of bloats up the running time off Broadway it was a pretty tight 100 minutes now it's about an hour and 50 and 10 minutes can be a lot if most of it doesn't work and most of the new stuff doesn't work but all the stuff that worked

SPEAKER_00downtown still works here it works beautifully and that's great really gives you full of energy and life and joy at number eight is oh my letter from heaven mexodes mexodes is a two-person musicale extravaganza it's written and performed by brian quixota and nigel d robinson directed by david mendizabal uh choreography by tony thomas this tells of a true story sort of it it

SPEAKER_00Basically the fact that the Underground Railroad did not just move north, it also moved south to Mexico, which was emancipated. And this tells the story of a slave named Henry who has just killed his master in Texas and flees and ends up in Rio Grande and ends up on the farm of Carlos, a former medic who is now running this farm, and the two bond as Henry helps Carlos on the farm. What this is, more than just the story, it's about the

SPEAKER_00The way it's told and the looping machine will then loop that and then they'll sing a little something and then start looping that and it becomes the background music for the

song as they start to perform and there are pedals all over the stage that stop and start different loopings so it's already a technical marvel it's a writing marvel and then it's a feat of performance that the two of them give the performances that they give while also accompanying each other and themselves via these looping

SPEAKER_00machines and yet All of that technical stuff aside, it is still a very engaging two-person play about a very specific experience at a very specific period of time. What it says about history, about race, what this country teaches us in class, what it doesn't. Without being preachy, without being exposition dumpy, and without overly relying on the gimmick of the looping machines, Mexodus is able to be a genuinely thrilling original piece of

musical theater

SPEAKER_00writing. and if it had transferred to Broadway somehow this season if they had found like oh no an eligible hole in the wall to perform in before the Tony cut off they would be nominated for musical for score for book they would win score for sure they would win sound design for sure and I think Brian and Nigel would be in the best actor in a musical conversation and I think Nigel in particular would really give Joshua Henry a run for his money just saying okay that's Mexodus at number eight at number seven we have

SPEAKER_00Practice at Playwrights Horizons by Nazareth Hassan. We talked about this a bit in the rankings earlier this year. Practice follows a MacArthur Genius Grant, Asa, played by Ronald Peet, who is assembling a company in New York for a theatrical project that he's been commissioned to do that will be performing in Germany and then in London. And what starts off as theatrical exercises what starts off as

community building becomes manipulation and gaslighting and clearly cult building with this company of actors and the people who are working for him and it is a slow study in tension it is a slow study in manipulation and it is a very very accurate if you know Slightly heightened portrayal of how the fine line between cults and theater

SPEAKER_00degrees is very thin. As somebody who went to a BFA program, as somebody who has taken many a class, who's sort of had to be in these environments before You want to be better you want to be good and you want to be successful and you're willing to listen to anybody who you think will help you get there and that becomes an over reliance on another person who's just a person in this world with an opinion who somehow found their way in your path and lucked into receiving money

SPEAKER_00and time and attention from you. Now sometimes they will give you stuff that is absolutely worthwhile and other times they will manipulate you so that you are overly reliant on what they think and practice is all of that for act one act two becomes the actual presentation of the piece in which if you've ever seen the shape of things with Rachel Weisz and Paul Rudd the big twist is that Rachel Weisz has been manipulating Paul Rudd the entire time in a for the purpose of an artistic piece that she's doing.

SPEAKER_00And you find out that Asa, Ronald Pete's Asa, has been doing this entire project for the sole purpose of creating a cult-like mentality with his company. He absolutely knew what he was doing. And the actors in the company have to perform all of this together for you. And it is Very wild but then the final moments are after everything has happened in the performance you go oh my god how can they ever do this again they've been so betrayed are they all brainwashed and then you flash forward to

them in London they're like four weeks into their London run after having done it in Berlin for

SPEAKER_00you know a month and you see two of the performers kind of just you know wandering around the set one's listening to music and warming up one's grabbing a water and it's becomes what started off as a need to work as a need to find success artistically and then a need to be accepted and then and then a need to be successful into the piece becomes a job eventually all of this trauma just becomes a job the trauma becomes art the art becomes a job that is sort of

the timeline of practice it's a little disappointing on my end that all of the cult stuff became so overt and revealed to be the point I liked it when it's a little more implication but overall the way that it ends is enough to justify the reveal of Asa's real pursuits but yes that's that's practice at number seven at number six we have actually it's your royal highness Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman currently

playing at the Winter Garden Theater starring Nathan Lane and Laurie Metcalfe I struggled with if I wanted to put this production as high as I did because I still had thoughts on it when I saw it but I did see it early in previews and I imagine a lot of my qualms with it early in previews were resolved by the time it

SPEAKER_00opened especially now it's been about How can a production be different this production is different What Joe Mantello has done is nothing short of extraordinary and even the qualms they have on certain performances like with Nathan Lane I said I think he does everything right for Willie Loman I ultimately don't think that

the character just fits him properly I would like to see him again now that it's been two months Laurie Metcalf was still figuring out how to do what she was doing in such a large

SPEAKER_00space I believe that's the largest theater she's ever performed in so she definitely was figuring out how big she goes and uh she did she did I think she likes I I'd like to think that she did figure it out Christopher Abbott I was not really up on his act one I liked his act two better but by that point he had kind of lost me um and then Ben Ehlers as happy I thought was just phenomenal from start to finish and a wonderful supporting company uh all of these things are things that get fine-tuned all throughout performances and similar to Wild Party

SPEAKER_00Sony performances had deepened within a week I imagine that all of these performances have deepened even more because what worked so well I'm sure is working just as well if not better and as I said it's so much of it has stuck with me it's really wonderful to see Joe Mantello be like directory again you look at Love, Valor, Compassion you look at Assassins that's Take Me Out that man is back with Death of a Salesman and we could not be more thrilled there is the Scott Rudin of it all but listen if y'all are accepting

Lea Michele's renaissance and her redemption then you have to be a little more optimistic for Rudin you don't have to fully accept it but if you're accepting her ask yourself why you're not accepting him is it because you want to believe that Lea Michele's

SPEAKER_00best friend wouldn't be best friends of the monster I do do a review of this as well I had hoped I would really like this show I was

SPEAKER_02really happy with the subject matter and the story behind it I always get wary when a lot of theater people like oh my god so important must see must see must see because I don't trust people but what I really appreciated about liberation was how messy best wall was really was willing to go

with it in terms of the characters in terms of the chronological order of events in terms of breaking

SPEAKER_00the fourth wall she has Susanna flood playing both her and her mother and The show is not just about women's liberation it's also about mother and daughter relationships it's about the questions you never asked it's about the confusion and the frustration that you have today it's about how things are better how things are not better how things are the same it's about how everyone has a different mentality of what it means to be better of what change should be of how to get said change of who should

be at the center of a story and that is a lot to do and it's a lot of plates to spin and they spin most of them and some things sometimes feel a bit like wall is trying to address subject matter before someone can come in and you know critique her troll her online but

SPEAKER_00they are still important things to to cover liberation I feel like covers more bases than something like, say, Sufts does and is willing to not provide answers and not necessarily willing to be galvanizing for the sake of investigation. And I really appreciate plays like that. And I appreciate that a play like this can ignite so many theater people because theater people tend to not like that shit they say they do but they don't they want the plays

that make them feel good they want the plays that make them feel like they've done the work by being there and liberation doesn't do that liberation isn't saying here's take give me your hand let me hold it as we do the work together liberation is hey here's a bunch of people who did the work at one point and what was it for you tell me what work can you do now you're not you're not doing the work by being here this is to

SPEAKER_00inspire you to go do the work once you leave and I like that I like that a lot I think liberation would be a very worthy best play winner would it be my vote unclear unclear but I think it would be a good winner either way all right that's liberation at number five and number four oh my

SPEAKER_03letter from heaven Cats the Jellicle Ball I'm not going to say much more about this I did a review y'all know how I feel this is a true blue revival this is breaking down a show that has been both a phenomenon and a joke at the same time for over 40 years giving it new life giving it new energy giving it new style making it both still the cats that people know musically it is still the cats that you know there are some

SPEAKER_00clubbies to it there's been some rearrangements but like Those of you who know how Monko Jerry and Rumpelteaser sounds, you're getting that here. Those of you who know how the Jellicle Ball sounds, you're getting that here. But it is expanding who can be a part of that Jellicle Ball and what that Jellicle Ball can mean. Something like Cats has always been up for interpretation because it's ultimately about so very little. And If you like a show like Cats, you have to be okay with big swings for it.

This is not a show that has a hardened text that you have to think about in terms

SPEAKER_00of the era in which it takes place. Cats is about Jellicle Cats and who's the Jellicle choice and who goes to the heavy side layer. That's it. You have to allow directors to come in and make it about more. And these directors have done that. Bill Roach, Shailen Levinson, they have made it about so much more and have also expanded the outreach of black and queer culture to Broadway audiences this is a true celebration of BIPOC artistry and lives and legacies in a way that some shows claim

to be but I disagree the difference between what Jalen has done with Cats and what say like the team of

SPEAKER_00Ragtime has done with Ragtime is Ragtime for me has always felt like a show for white people to go oh yes racism important important important black people important important important while we then watch them you know suffer and then die sing a big song then die what I love what Jalen has done with Jellicle Ball is saying black voices don't have to suffer for you to hear them They're always going to suffer suffering is that's just the way that this country works they will always suffer but they've learned how to rise

above that and soar and should you want to hear them when they're at their highest you want to hear them when they're at their most fabulous don't listen to them when all is lost don't listen to them when the when things are bad or rather don't just listen to them when things are bad celebrate them when they want to be celebrated too and it

SPEAKER_00is a celebration it's a beautiful celebration that's me if I'm trying to also get political about this it's also just a fabulously fun time took my friend Patrick and he had seen it downtown and he wasn't a fan of it downtown but he loved it on Broadway it's a smaller space on Broadway and that intimacy allows for the energy to just bounce off the walls and feel like the greatest and grandest of parties and I loved it I love every second of it I could watch it till we're all dead that's Jellicle Ball at number four and number three is

SPEAKER_01Actually, it's your Royal Highness.

SPEAKER_00David Lindsay Abares, The Balusters at Manhattan Theatre Club. This probably would be my vote for Best Play. We have a review of it as well if you want more details on it about the Homeowners Association and all of the intricacies that goes on with that. Similar to Liberation, There's a lot of sitting around and talking There's a lot of no clear answers Similar to things like Giant There is a lot of the worst person you can think of Just made a really good point And the person who you consider a friend That just said something really stupid Similar to Meet the Cartosians

There is a lot of question about identity And who gets the right to say what Who gets the right to speak for who When are you standing up for somebody And when are you speaking for someone And what is the difference there And when is it bad And how can you tell

SPEAKER_00the difference for yourself right all that said it's david lindsey a bear and so it's also very quotable very funny similar to becky shaw unlike becky shaw there's no dead air in the balusters it goes where it needs to get to quickly and efficiently uh you know if you were to make a Gripe against it. I guess you could say it is a pretty traditional living room show for Manhattan Theater Club. You could also say that it is a show that definitely glorifies

the idea of working class are the wise ones and the truth seekers and the truth tellers and that anyone

SPEAKER_00with an ounce of privilege clearly is corrupt. Now, history has shown us that plenty of privileged people are not just corrupt, but also just blind. A lot of people blind to their own privilege. so I don't think that it's a gripe that you should take to heart too much but it is like one of those tropes that a lot of writers like to do with with things right um but I what I love about the balusters is that it's so it's first of all very engaging it's very funny it's very tightly um constructed Kenny

Leon has done a

SPEAKER_00really phenomenal job with his company here without you know overly pushing anything and it's also by the way Anika Noni Rose back on Broadway in a role that actually fits her for once not Wonderful Town not Uncle Vanya Mary Louise Burke back on Broadway in a Tony nominated performance thank goodness Richard Thomas we love Margaret Cullen we love it's It's just a really, it's the kind of conversations that you can get from Liberation, that you can get from Meet the Cartosians,

SPEAKER_00that you can get from Giant, while also having the entertainment factor of a Becky Shaw, of a Jellicle Ball even, even though it's not like glittery, fan-slapping, beautiful, like Jellicle Ball, you know? It's the perfect intersection of art and entertainment. and that may seem like overpraise for a show like The Balusters but ultimately I don't think it is I think that this is a genuinely fantastic play as I said would

probably be my vote it's less messy than Liberation Liberation goes for a more

SPEAKER_00grand goal of a bigger brassier ring and nails it 90% of the time for me Ballister's maybe goes like one level below Liberation in terms of its reach, but it reaches it pretty perfectly for me. So that's up to you in terms of what your metrics for rankings are. But that's the Ballister's at number three.

SPEAKER_03And number two, Christine Day could sing it, sir.

SPEAKER_00Marjorie Prime, Jordan Harrison's Marjorie Prime. Oh guys not much else to say about this perfectly acted show should have been nominated for revival Cynthia Nixon should have been nominated because she was giving one of the greatest performances she's ever given if not the greatest performance she's ever given her scene with June Squibb in the second half of the play devastating perfect you could hear a pin drop the night I went but ultimately you know Love, Loss, and What I Wore, the Becky Shaw story. Not Becky Shaw, the Marjorie Prime story.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, what it says about grief, what it says about loss, what it says about over-reliance of technology. How much can technology really help us? Can it supplant human connection? I think Marjorie Prime makes the case that it can't. But maybe one day more technology can learn enough about all of us in our history that it can understand and appreciate love and flaws. And it's not just about being useful, it's about just being there.

SPEAKER_00Because ultimately, for all of the primes that show up in each scene, while they are there physically, while they are there to support, they're not really the same thing as the person that they're replacing. you're getting regurgitated AI answers from a machine and it's sort of like having a therapy cactus it's nice to have something there but it's not the same thing and

I think Marjorie Prime does that in a incredibly humane way with once again just phenomenal phenomenal performances across the board best acting of the season bar

SPEAKER_00none and then at number one we have oh my letter from heaven oedipus leslie manville mark strong need i say more a incredibly stylized and inventive creative adaptation it is up for revival this year which has been very controversial for people because in a lot of ways you could say it this is a brand new play that's inspired by uh oedipus indeed you could say that um but i don't care just

from start to finish fucking loved it airtight production airtight text airtight performances I loved everyone in it I loved everything about it uh I know a few people who said oh I didn't believe a word of it well I didn't believe a word of ragtime so here we are we're at a we're at a crossroads we're at an impasse what do you want me to do about it I just loved it I loved every second of it uh any

SPEAKER_00justice in the world Leslie Manville will win actress in a play uh I found it so not just engaging but I found it so gripping I was almost on my edge of the seat of my seat the entire time and I went with my friend Len and afterwards we got a drink and some garlic knots and we

just like we went to like go catch up and sort of ask you know how we were both doing but we ended up talking about Oedipus for like the better part of an hour and then we went okay so

SPEAKER_00what's new with you and that's the mark of fantastic theater Weird as this season has been, I'm looking through like the top 20, 22 shows of this 50 show ranking and I'm going, you know what, there's been some good stuff. I'd even argue there's been some great stuff. And definitely some stuff that's maybe sort of in between but has been worthwhile for me. So that's it Final Final rankings We'll do it all the way backwards And then go all the way up again At number 50 House of McQueen Number 49

Tartuffe 48 Beaches 47 Dog Day Afternoon 46 Call Me Izzy 45 Seat of Our Pants 44 Waiting for Godot 43 Art 42 The Fear of 13 41 Queen of Versailles Kristen's Version 40 August Wilson's Joe Turner's Come and Gone 39 Punch 38 Juice 37 The Baker's Wife 36 Heather's 35

SPEAKER_00Ginger Twinsies 34 High Spirits 33 Slam Frank 32 Bat Boy 31 Caroline 30 Bug 29 A Christmas Carol 28 Proof 27 Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York 20 Since Why am I botching words today? 26 Prince Fagote 25 Little Bear Ridge Road 24 Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show 23 Well I'll Let You Go

22 Ken Rex 21 Gotta Dance 20 Fallen Angels 19 Queen of Versailles Sherry's Version

SPEAKER_0018 Ragtime 17 The Lost Boys 16 Schmigadoon 15 Everybody Brilliant Thing 14 Giant 13 Meet the Cartosians 12 Bow 11 The Wild Party 10 Becky Shaw 9 Titanique 8 Mexodus 7 Practice 6 Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman 5 Liberation 4 Cats The Jellicle Ball 3 The Balusters 2 Marjorie Prime and 1 Oedipus

SPEAKER_00Leslie Manville and Mark Strong doing the title song, Edipus. That is it for this ranking of this season, everybody. I'm assuming this has gone on for five hours. If not, God bless me and my being diligent today. I know these episodes can get long, but my God, we did 50 shows. so think about that average of how often I spoke for each show you know that's it for this one join us next week as we go back into Tony discussions it's not very long until the Tonys happen so we're going to do a discussion of sort of like how

the season shapes up during May before this ceremony we're going to talk about I think some Tony trivia and what we can learn from it as we look at future winners and we're gonna do a final predictions with our friends Jeff and Richie and then we're gonna do a recap of the Tony ceremony and then we've got another backstage past miniseries coming up we're gonna start recording that very soon I think you'll like this it's not gonna be five episodes it's gonna be four episodes and it's on a past show that a lot of us really like maybe not all of us but a lot of us

SPEAKER_00definitely me definitely me I like but that's it okay so for this episode Who should we close out with Hmm I already did all the call to actions At the beginning of this episode So you all know the diff Substack YouTube Discord Instagram Rate, review, subscribe Tickets for the June 1st show Our last show until probably September or October So if you like seeing them Now's the time Um Hmm I think we're gonna close out with I'm looking through all of these

playbills right now my god who do we close out with um no because we've done we did Anika pretty recently we did uh you know what I don't think we've done Kelly O'Hara recently should we do

SPEAKER_00Kelly or should we do Mackenzie Isabel Michaela Sarah Chase um No, you know what? We're going to do Casey Levy. That's what we'll do. We'll do Casey Levy. I know we've done her before. I don't care. We'll do her again. Yeah, so that's it. We'll see you guys next week. Take it away, Casey. Bye. Especially people who care about strangers Who say they care

about social injustice

SPEAKER_03Do you only care about the bleeding crowd

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode