Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his Drama Desk endeavors. Take a peek! Important Links: * The Broadway Breakdown Green Room: Patreon * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Time Stamps: 0:00 Intro 2:40 New Apple review 4:00 I Became We 12:14 Copperfield the Musical 15:36 Aftermath 20:39 The Hairy Ape 28:14 Good Time, Charlie 32:52 We’ll See 38:25 Degenerates 46:06 Memoirs of Amorous Gentlemen 52:54 The Heart Listener Questions: * “What is the line between a play that’s pushing the envelope and just being tasteless?” * “Does stage drama have to always be dynamic to be compelling?” * “When have you watched a show and felt manipulated?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of And we've got another mother-tucking off-Broadway review roundup today. It's going to be going all over the gamut, shows that are still currently running to December or even the end of the year, shows that have recently closed, why I talk about shows that have closed.

SPEAKER_00Well, because I had to see them for Drama Desk and because you guys just had to make me a goddamn voter. And so I got to do my part. I got to see the show. I got to talk about the show because the whole reason I'm seeing these shows as a voter is being a podcaster. All of a sudden, why am I in a 1940s movie? Why am I now doing the Philadelphia story or the 1930s bringing a baby? It's all just Katherine Hepburn, isn't it? If you're watching this on YouTube, I apologize for my sweaty appearance. I also apologize for... The lighting. When I was living at my mom's, who actually will be making a cameo in a future review episode by the way,

SPEAKER_00I had a perfect setup. I was right in front of the office window. I had all this natural light. I looked like a goddamn angel. Now I'm in my own home and while that's wonderful, I don't have a window with all this nature light that I can set up in front there is my bedroom window But I'm not introducing all of you to my bedroom on YouTube. Not just yet, that shit's for OnlyFans. But I digress. I'm trying to stall because I've been putting this off and putting this off because it's just so many shows. I'm actually glad that I'm doing this now because now we're actually going

SPEAKER_00to be having a spectrum of shows that I really love, shows that I only kind of liked, shows that I didn't care for at all, and where the future may lay for some of these shows. If you can tell from the title of this, we are going to be talking about The Heart, which has recently opened off-Broadway at the Roundabout. We'll also be doing I Became We. I Became We is going to be the first thing we talk about. The Heart is going to be the last thing we talk about. I know that's a little bit of a bait and switch, but... That's just sort of how we're going about today. Before we get to actual reviews, though, we do have a new review of our own for the podcast.

SPEAKER_00And in true Broadway Breakdown fashion, we must give it the respect it deserves. So cue the light in the Piazza overture. Five stars, brilliantly insightful and entertaining. I moved away from New York City and largely fell out of touch with Broadway for many years. Matt and the podcast are helping make up for last. I think it's supposed to be lost time. For lost time. So insightful and so entertaining. Although I do kind of like the idea of saying for last time. It's you're helping make up for last time.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, Matt, this current episode is making up for the last one you did. Yeah, uncultured fuck. Thank you so much, Michael. What a wonderful review. We are at 399, 399 ratings and reviews on Apple Podcast. I want to get us to a nice clean 400. And then, of course, once you get to 400, then I'm going to be like, when are we getting to 500? But in the meanwhile, just seeing that 399, I'm like, God damn it, make this an even number. My brain is breaking. We did crack 180 on Spotify. We're at 181 on Spotify. That's amazing. Every time we post some new videos on YouTube,

SPEAKER_00despite the fact that I put very little effort into the quality of the camera or the lighting, we always go up about another 5 or 10 subscribers for every video, which I am very appreciative of. Clearly, that means the content is fantastic. So thank you, everybody, for appreciating my content. All right. Enough of my bullshit. Let's get into some actual talking of these shows because everything that we're discussing obviously is drama desk eligible. One or two may become Tony eligible down the line should things happen. But the first thing I want to talk about,

SPEAKER_00which I am positive won't be going to Broadway because I can't imagine commercial producers would be brave enough to take it on, but everyone should see it if they can. It is I Became We at the Atlantic Theater Company. Sorry, due to Blurriness with my camera. You can't see the playbill totally, but oh, there we go. It's a little bit better there. Yeah. I became we at the Atlantic Theater Company on the main stage of Linda Gross Theater. So I went in knowing very little about this piece. I actually didn't even know that the playwright was Mona Pirno,

SPEAKER_00who I last saw in I Love You So Much You Could Die at New York Theater Workshop. She's also the partner of Lucas Nath. And I Love You So Much I Could Die was an astoundingly beautiful and personal work done in a very creative way. And I bring it up because I want to tie it into I Became We as well as the show in between those two, which was I Assume You Know David Greenspan, another piece that Mona wrote that starred David Greenspan. What Mona Pirnault has been doing is creating these incredible Especially personal

SPEAKER_00autobiographical pieces and then taking herself out of them, keeping herself away from the spotlight and finding creatively theatrical ways to present these pieces. So like rather than just her coming on stage and going, let me tell you a story about me. She's finding other things. Elements that live theater can provide for her presentation. So for example, I Love You So Much It Could Die was a very harrowing tale about how she lost her sister to COVID.

SPEAKER_00And what Pirno did was she had her back to the audience and had a computer program recite all of her text. Sort of like AI, I guess, but like the point of the computer was that it was a very impersonal tone. It was very robotic, and there was a lot of humor to that. Piernau obviously wrote knowing certain things would sound funny coming out of this computer's voice. She had a name for the computer, but also the point of the computer program was when she couldn't cope

SPEAKER_00with her sister's suffering and then eventually the loss of her sister, She used this computer program as a way to hear her own thoughts out loud, a way that she could really process it all. And so she used it as a way for us to see how she went through all of this, how she kind of is able to grapple with all of it. And of course, there would be moments where she would sing a song she had written, but again, with her back to the audience. And again, super personal, very small canvas of dramatic storytelling.

SPEAKER_00But Incredibly powerful and incredibly creative. I assume you know David Greenspan is a one-man show. David Greenspan playing four different millennial playwrights, one of whom is Mona. And while the story itself is not true, the character that Mona writes for herself is true, especially her love of the actor-artist David Greenspan. Many of you saw him two seasons ago in Prince Faggot, of which he was absolutely the highlight. And so it's just that's another case of Mona putting herself into her work,

SPEAKER_00but not putting herself at the center of it. So this leads us to I Became We, which I want to. I won't go into too many spoilers, but what I will say is that it is ultimately the story of how Mona went from being a career oriented woman who loves her independence and being married to her husband and all this, but not wanting kids. And sort of priding herself on it and identifying herself from that lack of wanting kids. And going from that frame of mind to becoming someone who does want kids.

SPEAKER_00And again, on paper, that's sort of like a, okay, been there, done that. Isn't, you know, Diane Keaton baby boom, didn't we do this before? But that's where Mona has you go. Because what she does is she has worked with composer Jack D. Cohen, who also is the conductor of the piece, and they have created what could be a one-woman monologue into a 70-minute choral recital. It's 16 singers, all wonderfully classically trained,

SPEAKER_00a piano, singing Mona's text, a piano, And the best way I could sort of describe it is the ensemble of the Jerry Springer opera, if you ever listen to that, especially listen to the beginning and just sort of part of the humor of that is hearing, you know, everyday vernacular and swearing and mob mentality from a Jerry Springer show done in A beautiful choir cadence.

SPEAKER_00And that's the same thing here. Not necessarily that Mona is going for shock value, that she's going for filth. And the choir itself is not just a gimmick. It ends up being a really beautifully creative expression of feeling, of thought, of environment. And A lot of that is obviously Mona Piernau's acclaim, but also Jack Cohen's compositions are stunning.

SPEAKER_00And I'm not a huge... I'm an intellectual academic on classical music. My knowledge of classical music is kind of limited to everything that's in Amadeus and my 7th through 10th grade music education. But I do know a little bit about classical music and everything that I heard in this piece on a melodic level felt very much like paying homage to Schubert and Beethoven And Mozart and the whole gamut,

SPEAKER_00while never feeling like a warmed -over version. It still felt very new and felt very fresh. And there were so many facets to the compositions that Cohen came up with. And they scanned really well with Pirneau's text. Part of it is that Jack Cohen and Mona Pirneau collaborated on the text together so that the music could scan well with the lyrics. So certain moments could hit a punchline for humorous effect, for emotional effect. And it's not always just all 16 members of the chorus singing together.

SPEAKER_00There are solos. There are quartets. There is very specific dramaturgical reasoning behind all of the musical creative decisions done in this show, which is why the whole it being a choir singing Mona's story is not itself a gimmick. There is a reason behind it. There's thought behind it. And that is what separates it from a lot of other people who might just go, oh, that'd be a fun thing to do. Let me see how long I can run with this. It is... It is so funny. It is so heartwarming. It is so personal. It is so insightful and really ends on a lightly touching note.

SPEAKER_00And I just I can't recommend it enough. If there's any justice, our nominators at the Drama Desks will nominate for Best Music, among other things. Because at the moment, this is my favorite musical score of the season. Granted, I still have to see Wanted, and Galileo hasn't started performances yet. But as of right now, on this day of November 9th, 2026, this is absolutely my favorite score of the season. It's just, it's so... Tasteful and inventive and surprising and beautiful and impactful and epic

SPEAKER_00but also it's not trying too hard to be something it's not trying to be interesting and different it just naturally is this special piece and I can't recommend it enough. So immediately off the bat, I just want to start off with my rave for I Became We at the Atlantic Theater Company. Go now while you can. If you can, I know it's on TDF. So if budgets are an issue, go there or just, you know, go to the box office day of and see what they have for you, because I know it's selling well, but this is not like a Hamilton, Benjamin Button,

SPEAKER_00impossible to get a ticket kind of thing. Like you can you can find a way. And I highly recommend that you find a way. So that is I Became We. Back on the musical theater train, we have Copperfield, the musical at Duke on 42nd Street. This is, as you can suspect, a musical adaptation of the Charles Dickens novel, David Copperfield. It is written by Jeffrey Sharf. It is currently starring Bobby Conte as elder David Copperfield. The piece, the way that Bobby is the center of the show is ultimately

SPEAKER_00that the first act is presented as like more of a memory piece where he is the narrator. Weaving in and out of his memories as a child up until, you know, where he is at this present age and grappling with his mother and his stepfather and the abuse he had to endure as a child to get to become the man that he was. That is all that all sounds a lot more nuanced and interesting than the show actually does.

SPEAKER_00It is far more traditional musical theater take. There are a lot. It's sort of like because the actors all play instruments and it is ultimately done in a very. Period appropriate aesthetic, but also trying to have a bit of a style to it. And the actual musical theater adaptation of the piece, despite the fact that Bobby as Elder David Copperfield is like narrating it, it's not really a creative adaptation.

SPEAKER_00It is pretty straightforward. It is sort of the stage version of Oliver meets the orchestrations of Once with like, I don't know, the aesthetic of, oh God, I guess a Christmas carol? But sort of dimly lit, like the Michael Arden Christmas Carol, which that's not all bad stuff, but it just feels very passe, all of it. There's really not much I can say. The music is perfectly pleasant. It's fine.

SPEAKER_00The lyrics definitely are not up to snuff. It is not a, as I said, it's not a creative or thrilling adaptation. It is varied by the numbers to the point that When a character dies, someone comes on stage to say, they are gone, they are dead. There's no impactful dramatization of anything. It all just feels perfunctory, by the numbers, expository. Is it the worst thing I've ever seen? No, but it just feels like a musical from 65 years ago.

SPEAKER_00And even then it would have been considered a little choppy. So while I'm a fan of Bobby and I love his voice and I think he's got such a presence on stage, I do think this is rather a waste of him. Solid cast, a couple of weak singers if I'm being honest, but it's also a very elementary... The presentation of so many of the characters, like it almost feels a bit like a pantomime in the way that some characters are playing their roles of just of like uber villainy

SPEAKER_00or uber goodness. And just it's everyone is kind of playing it on the surface. And in their defense, a lot of the material as written is on the surface. So I can't really recommend it. But it does run till mid-December, early December. So if it does interest you, by all means, go see it. Just it did not do it for me. We also have Aftermath. Which was at ART New York Theatres, which is midtown like 54th Street, 53rd Street. This is a play by David Sachs. It stars Stephen Skybell, Danny Kornfield.

SPEAKER_00Danny Kornfield plays... Kornfield or Kornfeld? Sorry, Kornfeld. Danny Kornfeld, who most people remember from Harmony, he plays a young man living... With his parents on the outskirts of, it's not the outskirts, but like the suburbs of Washington, D.C. circa 2011. And his character, Josh, he's been raised Jewish, but he's... Been pursuing life as a journalist and has just come back from the Middle East where he was held in a hostage negotiation and ultimately has come back and he

SPEAKER_00but he wants to go back to the Middle East and his parents are absolutely forbidding him to do so. There is a whole will they won't they subplot with one of his fellow journalists, a woman who born and raised in London, but is a Middle Eastern descent and and There's a lot of the whole thing is very like kind of the living room kitchen sink drama, right? It's ultimately just about this family grappling with this one issue of the son who has all this artistic journalistic integrity.

SPEAKER_00He also has had his eyes open to the world and the suffering of the world and and is. Ashamed and embarrassed of his parents' wealth, but it's hard-earned wealth. His father was a political strategist and consultant and made a lot, a lot of money, worked very hard to make it. But what we find out, spoiler alert, is that... Danny Kornfeld's character Josh thought that he escaped his kidnappers and was able to make it back to America. No, no, no, no. We find out that his parents had actually paid a ransom for his kidnapping.

SPEAKER_00And that turns—that's not a major spoiler. It's said about like a third of the way into the show. And then it becomes Josh grappling with why would they do that, the money that they just gave my— Kidnappers is funding all of these attacks and these wars. But then again, another spoiler, what you find out is the reason that the kidnappers were able to contact his parents and were able to demand a very high fee, a ransom fee for him,

SPEAKER_00was that he had printed out and kept in his backpack while he was in the Middle East and Documents of his parents' finances in case he were ever to be kidnapped. And of course, he did get kidnapped and the kidnappers found these bank statements. And so they knew exactly how much money his parents had and they demanded all of it. So... He didn't bankrupt his parents. They still have money, but he took out, because of him, they lost all this money that they were going to use to retire comfortably.

SPEAKER_00And now it's sort of like, okay, now they're going to have to kind of scrape by after his father worked all of his life. And on top of this, all of the money that he's complaining, oh, this is what it's funding. It's like, well, Josh, you made that happen because your comfort was, and your need to have a safety net in your backpack was, Fucked everybody. And then as it turns out, there are other people who he was with who did not make it out alive because they did not print out their parents' bank statements in their backpack.

SPEAKER_00This is not a bad idea for play. It is a little Other Desert Cities Coded. We'll talk about Other Desert Cities in the next episode. It is a very traditional, like, again, four-person play, family drama, dealing with a major political worldwide issue that's not really onstage but always talked about from offstage. But ultimately, it just doesn't really gel for me. There was a lot of stuff that felt that could be cut. There was a lot of stuff that felt like it wasn't really developed enough. It wasn't really paced well. There was a lot of dead air in between scenes.

SPEAKER_00And... It also doesn't help that it wasn't as tight of an ensemble. Danny Kornfeld does his best with Josh, who starts off as just like an incredibly annoying character and then becomes just despicable. And I feel like there would have been something to the idea that he is an endearing character who actually has merit, only to find out that he did this very despicable thing. But Josh is just like the absolute worst the entire time. And so... The play turning on him does not feel like a genuine shock.

SPEAKER_00It just feels like, sure, yeah. So he sucks harder than I originally expected. Stephen Skybell is always a delight on stage, but he hasn't really given much to do. And then unfortunately, Jill Stern as his wife is just very much out of her element. That is aftermath. Can't keep up with Skybell or Kornfeld in their scenes. And so any potential dramatic dynamics you could have on stage just are not there for this. That is aftermath we're really starting to blow through some of these things next up also closed now but needing to be spoken about is Eugene O 'Neill's The Hairy Ape at Irish Rep.

SPEAKER_00This is an adaptation and condensed version of The Hairy Ape. The last time I was aware of The Hairy Ape being performed in New York City, it was at the Park Avenue Armory with Bobby Cannavale, and that was running anywhere from three to four hours. This adaptation was 90 minutes, no intermission. So this is, you know... It's really condensed. I took my friend Wyatt, who is far more well-versed in Eugene O'Neill than I am, and I asked him, like, did they do any major cuts?

SPEAKER_00Like, are there subplots that were taken away? Did they cut scenes? And he says, no, they actually, you know, it's every scene that's in the play. It's just like every scene that they show is about like half the length of the original scenes. The play follows a character named Yank here, played by John Beavers, and Yank works on a ship. He's a gruff, working-class man, and When we meet him, he's in his element, he's with his other co-workers,

SPEAKER_00all these men, and it should be said that this production of The Hairy Ape has a very, very attractive male cast, which, yes, it is me ogling a little bit, but the production, you know, director Akira and O'Reilly definitely wants us to know how hot these guys are. The show begins and they're all like... Sweaty with soot just perfectly accenting their muscles and they're all shirtless with overalls that are practically dripping off of them. So there's a lot of Homoerotic testosterone in this show already in this production.

SPEAKER_00And so the point is that character of Yank, he, you know, we see him in his element, he's drinking and driving and jonesing with all of his male coworkers. And then an heiress who's aboard the ship wants to see the working conditions of these men. And she sees Yank just being an absolute, This masculine menace, I guess is the best way I could say it. But she faints at the sight of him, of him being so gruff and calls him, you know,

SPEAKER_00big old hairy ape. And the rest of the play is basically Yank going into a mental spiral of not knowing what to do with this confrontation of someone so different from him saying without any kind of Consideration for his feelings or where he comes from of what they perceive him to be. And it begins with Yank first, you know, trying to find her going to the Upper East Side of Manhattan and trying to find her in the crowd, but can't because all of the rich people are are they all look

SPEAKER_00the same and they all sort of are in mass. And he ends up being arrested, but he's able to break out of prison by bending the bars because, again, he's just such an ape. He tries to join a workers union organization, but gets kicked out of that for running his mouth. He then finds that he doesn't really belong anywhere and ends up at the zoo where he sees an ape in a cage who he relates to. He sets the ape free. The ape then breaks his back, leaving him to die on stage as it runs off.

SPEAKER_00And that's the end of the play. Real fucking upper, right? I can't imagine how this play would work as the three and a half hour piece. Because at 90 minutes, it was feeling a little... Long for me because it's ultimately a very episodic piece. It's very rinse and repeat. Yank. Has a new load to go down to and starts in one way and always ends up worse by the end of it. And none of the scenes, none of the vignettes really felt tied together other than the fact that Yank is just always on this mission to prove that he is human,

SPEAKER_00that he is not this animalistic person. And blaming other people, blaming society, blaming femininity, blaming his own lack of fortune for who he is and how he's perceived. And he always just kind of makes it worse for himself every single time. And I think there's something to that, but it didn't really feel like a... Gripping, chaotic, downward spiral. It felt more like a methodical step down, step down, step down. And part of that is O'Neill, in my opinion, of just being this very poetic writer,

SPEAKER_00but also not necessarily being a writer who goes for the jugular in the way that we think of a Tennessee Williams, right? O'Neill is a lot more methodical and a lot more linguistic and For a piece like this, I feel like part of it might just be because this is earlier in O'Neill's career. He also made a name for himself writing all these one-act plays, and The Hairy Ape sort of feels like three one-act plays tied together rather than one cohesive piece that leads to a train wreck of a conclusion. There is a lot in this production that recommends itself.

SPEAKER_00It is a very strong Cast people really giving their all beavers as Yank really just throws his whole body into it. There are times where you kind of felt like your throat was getting sore by listening to him just sort of scream his way through this, but he really commits to it. I think part of me wonders if by having it be so short, if He's not able to pace himself throughout and really map out Yank's downward spiral in the way that maybe Bobby Cannavale was able to at the Park Avenue Armory. It's also, this is a much more avant-garde O'Neill.

SPEAKER_00This feels a bit like O'Neill meets Ionesco in a way. And this production leans into that. O'Reilly does a lot of abstract staging and design. There's a great deal of harsh blues and purples and greens. It's an unmiked production because it's a small space, but there is sometimes like ASMR sound effects that are brought in to really kind of add to the, not otherworldly, but just sort of something always being a little off kilter about it.

SPEAKER_00And when they're on the Upper East Side, everyone comes out with glittery masks on and makes you feel a bit sort of like you're in a I guess, how would I describe this? I described this earlier when I was talking about Imaginary Invalid when they begin and end the show in this way with the robes and their masks that are sort of feeling a bit like Eyes Wide Shut, that sex cult scene in Eyes Wide Shut. It's a little of that too meets some of the John Doyle aesthetic from The Visit of, you know, top hats and glittery masks and very presentational acting and movement.

SPEAKER_00Again, to sort of show how much of a different world this is from what Yank is used to, but that also applies to a lot of the production. It was a very stylized production, which I actually quite appreciated because I don't think a naturalistic production of The Hairy Ape would work. I don't think that's what O'Neill is going for. That said, because it is such a vignette piece, I don't know if this production needed more momentum or if it's just inherent in the text that it can't really move that way. If someone's ever seen like a traditional...

SPEAKER_00Performance of the hairy ape, uncut. Let me know if you've seen it done where it really feels like a steam train just going and going and going, because that might be an interesting discussion of a case of tightening a show actually being to its detriment. I don't know, just something for me to consider. But I'm glad I saw it. This is actually, fun fact, this is only the second time I've seen O'Neill on stage. My first was Long Day's Journey Into Night in 2015 with Jessica Lange at Roundabout. Next up, speaking of autobiographical, we have Good Time Charlie at The Public.

SPEAKER_00This is a play by Ryan J. Haddad. This is a piece where Ryan plays himself, but also has everyone else in the company play his immediate family, his mother, his father, his aunt, his grandparents, and most importantly, his uncle Charlie. And it is similar to Mona Piernault with I Became We, and I assume you know David Greenspan. It is autobiographical, but leaning into theatricality to present it. But rather than it being a specific idea that is fully crystallized,

SPEAKER_00the piece sort of feels more like an ode to theater lovers and theater conventions that But not quite tying together. I would be interested to see this show without Ryan playing himself to see sort of how a different kind of energy and a different kind of personality would be able to do his text. Because I think how he writes is so specific to how he performs, which is totally fair.

SPEAKER_00A lot of writers and performers are the same way. But it was just interesting to And it's, I mean, it's the kind of show where it has all of these details and references that are right up my alley. You know, it opens with a discussion and recreation in his backyard of the Brandy Cinderella. And there's a discussion of the 1950 Best Actress Oscar race and a character who just cannot stand Barbara Streisand as an actress and things like that. Not that I can stand Streisand as an actress, but these kind of conversations, these kind of references, having a Beth Malone joke with Fun Home and discussions

SPEAKER_00of Grey Gardens and It sort of feels like it's Ryan's love letter to his uncle, but then it also delves into his uncle's upbringing and the difficulties he had coming out as a gay man to his parents in the 1980s and finding a partner and finding love and being a mentor to Ryan as well as his friends being mentors to him and wanting him to have all the love and patience and acceptance that he wasn't granted while also... you know, dealing with the loss of friends as he's getting older and and the life

SPEAKER_00that he never really got to pursue because part of the thing of Charlie is he loves theater and absolutely passes it on to Ryan. But Ryan gets to go off and do theater And Charlie never got that chance. This is all really good stuff. The problem is that, for me, it lacks a consistent vocabulary in its theatricality of what is the world we're in and how cognizant are these characters of their presentation on stage. Because sometimes they will break the fourth wall and say, Ryan, I don't think that this is going to work.

SPEAKER_00We should do this scene a different way. Not as the actor, but as the character. And then the character of his uncle Charlie, pushing back, as well as other characters pushing back against Ryan, of why are you showing this scene? That's too much. That's Too Personal. Why would you do that? And yet it doesn't feel true or it doesn'T feel organic to me. It always felt a little bit like scenes would break because that's what we needed without actually doing the work to get us there.

SPEAKER_00And I say this as someone who also kind of writes in that way. I will write the scenes that I need, and then I'll work to get myself to those scenes, and I don't always succeed. And I feel like this is a piece that needed more time to really figure out the confines of The world it was in and the characters and what exactly the fluidity of fourth wall breaking we could have. I mean, there are good performances. The actor who plays Charlie, what is his name?

SPEAKER_00Jonathan Raviv. He's I thought he was really wonderful, really charismatic and and and and gripping. But ultimately, a show that has so much things that on paper I love quite a lot did not congeal into a really affecting whole for me. It's got a lot of heart and a lot of care. And for that, I think, you know, it's worthy of discussing and seeing, but it was not a successful piece.

SPEAKER_00It's one of those things where just because it has it doesn't make it Right. It's I'm glad that it's that these are the things that it's tackling, but it needs more than that. Something that on a much smaller canvas, far less What's he looking for? Far less adventurous and experimental in his presentation is We'll See, which is Richard Nelson's latest installation of the Apple Family Plays. If you don't know the Apple Family Plays, Richard Nelson has been writing these plays for a number of years now, and it is focusing on a group of siblings in the Apple Family,

SPEAKER_00and they're living in Rhinebeck, New York. And the play always takes place in real time. During the year that it's being performed, usually on some sort of election day. So the only other Apple family play I saw was Sorry, which I believe is during the 2014 midterms? I think something like that. And this one takes place on November 3rd, 2026. So our current midterims, which went very well by the way in case you haven't heard, it was quite a night still going on technically speaking there are still some votes that need to be counted but Like, we done good kids.

SPEAKER_00And the thing about The Apple Family Plays is that they are not really about plot. They are not about theatricality. Quite the opposite. Unlike, you know, Aftermath or, you know, unlike Aftermath, there is no major twist. Unlike The Hairy Ape or Good Time Charlie or I Became We, it's not about... The opportunities of stage and all the different ways you can tell a story. Like I Became We, it is a small canvas of human life,

SPEAKER_00but it is fly on the wall theater. It's about an hour and 50 minutes, and it's not as if the whole thing takes place over the course of an hour and 50, but it does take place over a single evening of the midterms, which is what's happening is the Apple siblings decide they're turning off their phones. They are not going to discuss, well, they are going to discuss politics. They won't say Trump's name. That's like the one rule they have. And we watch them as they set the table for dinner, and we watch them as they have dinner, and we watch as they have dessert, and Eventually, I'll leave the house to go home and sleep to see what the results

SPEAKER_00of the midterms were. And What you can always get from an Apple family play is, first of all, astonishing acting just across the board. And the actors who play these roles have been playing these roles for a while. Podcast fave Sally Murphy is one of the Apple siblings, although I believe she only started doing it like four or five years ago. But still, she's now been doing it for a while. But you have Sally Murphy, Layla Robbins, Marianne Plunkett, J.O. Sanders, and it's It is the kind of acting that isn't acting, right?

SPEAKER_00It's not hyperdramatic. It's not go for the throat, Medea or Oedipus or anything like that. It is almost documentary level, naturalistic, dropped in acting. The kind where you go, how are you doing this? How are you just able to be in the way that I imagine Lorette Taylor was in The Glass Menagerie, as they talk about in Broadway, The Golden Age? And it's not that necessarily anything that's being done on stage is itself thrilling. It's more that you are just living with these characters for an hour

SPEAKER_00and 50 minutes every two years and sort of seeing how they continue. And all of the major themes and messaging of the plays are always sort of standing at the periphery of the stage. They're never really dealt with head on. There's no moment where you go, well, this is what the play is about. Oh, this is what I'm supposed to take away. It is just about humans. It's in the microcosms, is maybe the words I want to say, the minutia of their dialogue with each other,

SPEAKER_00of their actions when sitting at a table or walking to the kitchen, the little microaggressions they have towards each other as siblings, the love they have for each other as siblings, the history of their family, of who they've lost, who they've gained, and people they talk about from offstage of partners or children. And It's not Tracy Lutz, August, Osage County, but there is something very compelling about it. It is also often very slow. The Apple family plays are not really my jam. I've only seen these two. So I wonder if I could commit myself to a marathon day if they ever were to do that again.

SPEAKER_00They did do it once in the public. I would like for them to do it again. But if I could commit myself to a marathon day and watch... Every play in succession and sort of see how everything ties together, how I would feel. Because at the moment, it's more of a tonic for me. It's a nice sort of breather of seeing something Quite different from everything else that I'm seeing with truly phenomenal acting, just like chef's kiss across the board, no notes. Everyone is astounding in it. And when you see performances like Marianne Plunkett giving in this

SPEAKER_00or Layla Robbins, Sally Murphy, J.O. Sanders, it's hard to go back from that and then see much more shallow performances and look at it as... Good acting or effective acting, or oh my god they were so believable. It's like once you've seen that shit, as we like to say, once you've tasted coffee, you can't go back to Sanka. And so while Will C is not the kind of drama that you go, that's coffee, it is the kind performing you go and go, that's fucking coffee. So in that respect, I recommend it.

SPEAKER_00But just know, The Apple family plays are definitely not for everyone. They're not really for me, but I can appreciate them. There are people who hate these plays because they are so light on story and drama and dynamics. The time can go by very slowly for a lot of people. So this is really also a test of your patience. How long are you willing to sort of sit with not much going on for the sake of human observation? That's the question I want to ask you about. We'll see. Speaking of human observation, but on a much more chaotic, dramatic scale,

SPEAKER_00we have degenerates at Playwrights Horizons. This piece is by Elsa West. And unlike We'll See, it is very theatrical. It is very dynamic. Unlike I Became We, it is very long. It is nearly three hours. The first act alone is two hours. And basically this centers around incels, incel culture, incel community, and does...

SPEAKER_00An interesting thing of going into the fiery pits of hell with it and then having a way of coming out the other end with a possible hope for the humanity of these people. It mostly centers around two friends who are part of a discord of incels chatting online. And they're very strict about who can come on and who can't. Women are the enemy, but also so is any kind of liberal culture.

SPEAKER_00So is any kind of femininity at all. So is being a man who wants to have sex with a woman. They find out that there's a man who has fathered kids and like, well, you can't be in the group anymore because you've had sex with a woman. You've put your penis in a vagina. And he's like, oh, well, you guys are you guys aren't. You know, warriors, you're fucking virgins, you're loser virgins, and they can't deal with things like that. Because they like to say, no, we speak the truth, we know who we are, we know what we're about, but they won't actually recognize the more broken pieces

SPEAKER_00of themselves. And only... When they start to do that, can there be any kind of healing? The main two are Zachary Desmond as Miller and Christopher Dylan White as Target. They have a very complicated friendship online because Miller will never on this Discord show his face. He'll speak into a microphone, but he'll never show his face, whereas Target will. Target is young. Target's about 18, 19 years. Very feminine and makes all of his money doing camera work, basically on OnlyFans,

SPEAKER_00dressing up in a feminine manner and making all of these pseudo straight, pseudo bi, pseudo gay men online question his sexuality, question his gender for lots and lots and lots of money. Eventually, Miller and Target meet, and that is the majority of Act 2, but that's also where things crash into chaos. Sorry, Act 1. End of Act 1 is Target and Miller's finally meeting at Target's apartment, and then Act 2 is this sort of chaotic crashing, falling out of everything that goes down between Miller and Target.

SPEAKER_00And what happens with Miller and Target is, like, there is this sort of infatuation that Target has with Miller. There is this sort of desperate need to be loved and connect that Miller has. But Miller also can't accept things about his own sexuality, about his own desire for contact because in a lot of ways he views that as weakness. And I think he also views it as weakness because he fears rejection so rather than be rejected by others he rejects them and he and Target fall into a very very messy connection

SPEAKER_00which Target It sees as a breakthrough of becoming more of a human being, Miller views it as a lapse in judgment. And again, without going too much into what happens in Act 2, all I'll say is Target goes further down the rabbit hole of gender, of questioning their own gender, of who they actually are, who they've always been. And there is a wonderful moment used with audio only.

SPEAKER_00Where you are not sure what exactly is going to happen with Target with the decision they intend to make and how someone in their life is going to respond to it. And it shows that for all of the toxic poison that we see in Acts 1, Wendt really kind of wants to hope for goodness. And I think we're all kind of feeling that right now after our midterms, but... It really shows you that so much of not just evil,

SPEAKER_00but like destruction comes from a kind of pain that people aren't willing to come to terms with. And only when Target is able to address the things about themselves that might be too painful otherwise to say, and is received with love and understanding, is there hope for Target. And By having that hope, Target then starts to project that same kindness to others, in particular someone who Target isn't even aware that they know from online.

SPEAKER_00And the show ends with sort of having it both ways, of Miller kind of going further into incel chaos and wanting to kind of become... You know, his own version of Musk, let's say, whereas Target and the people that Target chooses to surround themselves with find light. You could argue if there's a message to Degenerate, it's go fucking touch grass, you know, go outside and touch grass. But there is such a discomfort you have watching the show for a while, and there is

SPEAKER_00You might feel the need to want to leave an intermission. I almost did. Not that I was liking Act 1, but I was sort of like, what are we doing? I also was lied to about the length of the show. So when Act 1 was two hours long, I was like, Jesus fucking Christ. But Act 2 is a really bombing payoff for all of the... Discomfort that Wendt makes you go through. On a performance note, Desmond and White really just throw everything they have into this. It's the kind of egoless abandon that I find very refreshing to see

SPEAKER_00as an audience member and as somebody who used to be an actor. Just the kind of, it's go for broke, but not in a way that's indulgent. It's go for broke of this play's requiring a lot of both of them, both emotionally and physically, how they expose themselves. And they do it with no judgment of their characters, but just complete inhabitation of them. And if they did not work, this piece would be insufferable. But because they are so well cast and they are so finely tuned

SPEAKER_00to what these characters need, you understand what Wendt is doing with this piece. And it's not an easy one. Similar to We'll See, this can be a tough set. But unlike Wilsey, it's a tough set not because of the lack of action. There's actually a lot of action. It is stretched out a lot. It's not tight. It's two hours and 45 minutes, which is a bit long in my humble opinion. But it is a really insightful, And theatrical endeavor of, I think,

SPEAKER_00subject matter that none of us really would like to think about too often. But that is also why things like this are important for us to see. Important for our brains to really kind of keep them sharp and to avoid any kind of smooth brain This is why I feel like we all come to this podcast, right? I feel like I've been talking for a while, but I've also been plowing through a lot of stuff. Okay, we've got two things left. On to something that also kind of imagines itself as going into the depths of destruction and chaos and darkness and depravity, but isn't really doing so,

SPEAKER_00is Memoirs of Amorous Gentlemen. This is the last work of Duncan Sheik, or at least the last new work that I think we'll ever probably see of Duncan Sheik's on the theatrical stage. It is adapted by a manga graphic novel. It is co-written with Leah Nanako Winkler. It is directed and choreographed by Rob Ashford. It's starring Sophia N. Caruso. It follows a young girl named Colette who is working in a brothel in Paris. And Colette is tasked by a Japanese client to keep a diary of her time

SPEAKER_00in the brothel and discuss her clients, her work, her leisure with her friends in the brothel. She also talks about a boyfriend of hers, They ran away from home together to come to Paris to get married. He's a failing painter, so she does sex work to keep him afloat, but he takes the money that she makes and, unbeknownst to her, cheats on her with a high-class courtesan and buys this courtesan gifts and spends all of his money on her to spend time with her and hopes to run away with this courtesan and leave Colette in the dirt.

SPEAKER_00Not that Colette knows this at the time, but eventually she does find out. Other things ensue. This is another intermissionless piece done in the round. The whole environment is very Cabaret-esque meets maybe Grey Comet. There's a lot of... It takes place in the basement of the hotel that Sleep No More is at. They're calling it the Culture Club. Up in the attic is... And when you're down there, it is very like you're going to a members only VIP club. You have crystal chandeliers, velvet drapes,

SPEAKER_00you have mood lighting and marble floors and these sort of cabaret tables and this. Big in the round stage in the center. And so there is a lot of, I won't call it elegance, but there's a lot of style and a lot of sensuality to the aesthetic of the piece. The story itself is kind of whatever. There's not much to the literal story. What it tries to do is, I feel like it's trying to aim for stimulation while also being a satire of the sexuality it's presenting.

SPEAKER_00Of, again, the depravity of many of these male clients. And it doesn't really achieve either. Chic's music, as it always is, is very much a vibe rather than it being a dramatic compulsion. There's no, I've never found Chic's theatrical music to have a real heartbeat. It has a point of view and it has thoughts, but only Spring Awakening. And Spring Awakening for me is only in pieces. Is there really kind of a thumping pulse?

SPEAKER_00Often it's more of a leisurely vibe. You're always kind of floating on a placid cloud. And Part of that works in American Psycho because of the numbness of the culture of that show. But that also makes something like Amorous Gentleman, while trying to be sexy and thrilling and sensual, always feels cold and the sexiness feels tried and the depravity feels forced.

SPEAKER_00What it has going for it is on a music level, it's, you know, everyone sounds great. This is the best I've heard Sophia and Caruso sound. Of course, many of the numbers require her to then shriek to the high heavens by the end, which is, she does, and it does not sound shrieky, but by the third number, you can start to clock when they're going to have her go up the octave while she's being lifted up into the air. The... Costume designs of the show are trying to kind of go for a bit of a great comment of it's the essence of the period, but we're not going super historical.

SPEAKER_00We want it to kind of be modern edgy. There's a lot of Moulin Rouge in there as well of these amorous gentlemen in their, you know, coats and tails, but with maybe the shirts unbuttoned or there's no shirts. It is a very sexy cast. The men in the company are all very, very attractive and various different body types. And everyone provides a bold energy to each of their characters, so no one necessarily blends in with each other. But by trying to go for such an impressionable shock value half of the time,

SPEAKER_00it ultimately just leaves you, A, not feeling much, and when you are feeling anything, it's kind of bewilderment. It is not a successful piece in any respect. It's not a score that makes you think, oh, there's potential here. It's not a story that makes you go, well, I understand why they want to make this musical. It's Not A Production That Makes You Go, Well, At Least I'm Distracted By The Bells And Whistles And Smoke And Mirrors Of It All. Like the impression you get walking in is impressive of the environment of the space

SPEAKER_00And once you've done that, once you've taken it all in, there are no other surprises. It doesn't make exceptional use of the space. They try to do some environmental staging in the round stage, but even then it can't really do so. It wants to have that Chafkin comedy vibe of like, every place is really the stage, but it doesn't really do so. It's better off to just keep it to the center, but even then... It's still just so limited. And I can't really say more than that.

SPEAKER_00Try hard is the term that keeps coming back to my brain. It wants to be edgy. It wants to be sexy. But it also wants to kind of question what you think is sexy and why. But it's not interested in going deep on that. It's not interested in even... Celebrating the kinks, let alone questioning them. It kind of almost feels kink-shamey in a lot of ways, but the kinks that they do are kinks that are like so out there that it almost feels like, is this what you think the kinkiest of people kink?

SPEAKER_00Because I don't know if that's the case. I don't know if you've actually met a kinky person. I'm not sure. I went with my friend Brian. Brian Nash, who's a friend of the pod. You might remember him from the Hamilton episode. And also the Next to Normal episode. And we saw it together and we walked out and we're like, I mean, it's not hot garbage, which I hate to have that be the barometer of whether you recommend something or not. But for a show that wants you to feel something, the fact that you can't feel anything is really the ultimate failure of it.

SPEAKER_00You don't feel camp. You don't feel joy. You don't feel discomfort. You don't feel titillation. You just don't feel. It's a numbing piece. And that's Memoirs of Amorous Gentlemen. Finally, the one you've all been waiting for, The Heart, currently playing at Roundabout. This is a new musical that was making the rounds regionally and finally found its way to New York. The rumors of it moving to Broadway are very well founded. The word I have heard is that a show that has recently announced closing is

SPEAKER_00the theater that The Heart will be going into in the spring. We'll see what happens. I can't go any more than that. But it is written by Anne and Ian Eisendrath and Kate Kerrigan. Eisendrath did the score, Kerrigan did the book, and some of the lyrics. It is directed by Christopher Ashley. Ashley won his Tony Award for Come From Away. That's relevant because if I were to describe the heart in sort of a this meets this meets this, it's an episode of Grey's Anatomy meets the theatrical vocabulary of Come From Away with the music stylings of Here Lies Love.

SPEAKER_00It is EDM music, which is, you know, club techno music set to a story of a 19-year-old boy who gets into an accident and basically is found brain dead. And while he is not listed as an organ donor, he is healthy in every other respect. And the hospital would very much like to donate his organs to patients who really need it. So they have to speak with his parents. His parents have a bit of a confliction about it. But when I was watching it, I was like, oh,

SPEAKER_00I guess we're going to wait till the end to find out what their decision is. But no, we find out like at the halfway point of the musical that they say yes. This is a 90 minute intermissionless piece. And I would say like at the 40 minute mark is when the parents decide who the parents who are divorced at this point, by the way, decide yes. And then it's sort of what comes after that. I wasn't sure what to expect from this show. It is clear while watching it that they very much want you to feel. They want you to cry. This is like a notebook situation where they might as well be selling tissues in the lobby and being like, you're going to cry.

SPEAKER_00Come on, you're going to cry. And the woman behind me was indeed crying. I went with my friend Sophia and afterwards you both were like, I liked that, but I didn't cry. Why is that? And I think there are a couple of reasons. First of all, just, you know, if you look at reviews for this production, yes, it did get a critics pick on the New York Times from Elizabeth Finchentelli, which is her prerogative. She also gave a critics pick to Hell's Kitchen and Harmony when it was off-Broadway. I disagree with both of those critics picks. It also got eviscerated by Friend of the Pod Juan Ramirez.

SPEAKER_00So obviously there are opposite ends of the spectrum in terms of reactions to this show. I can't say I loved it. I did not hate it. Why did I not cry? Part of it is that when something is so obviously wanting you to feel a certain kind of way, you can start to feel manipulated. And musicals are manipulative. Theater is manipulative. But you don't want to feel manipulated. The magic trick is to take you along on the emotional journey. And then by the end, you accidentally find yourself sobbing. I tend to cry from very human moments, not the things that are epic,

SPEAKER_00the things that you can relate to, the things that you want almost for yourself. The things that make me cry are when Vice Principal Panch in Spelling Bee is Gives all of the $20 submission fee for the bee, but not telling her that it's from him, telling her, oh, this is the runner-up prize. You did it. Here you go. And all of not knowing what he's done, being very happy, that makes me cry. Matilda hugging Miss Honey because she's going to give her books, that makes me cry. Tina showing up for Louise on Bob's Burgers,

SPEAKER_00when Louise is going to do her poem at the library, makes me cry. I was about to cry just thinking about it right now. The hard for me has too many plates spinning on a storytelling level for me to get emotionally invested. And some of those plates are actually kind of not necessary. The cast for the most part is strong. I'll get to that in a second. There's one exception I have to that. But everyone in the show is playing multiple characters.

SPEAKER_00That is part of the comfort way of it all. And it is a lot of There's a lot of discussion of sort of not necessarily who the characters are, but what goes into the process of heart donations, organ donations, which is, you know, it's important for the audience to know the stakes of the situation and the protocols for how this all goes down, but it adds to a little bit of the clinical energy that I sometimes feel with shows like this, where even though they want a little bit at arm's length.

SPEAKER_00We don't know much about the young man who we lose, and by By the time that we move on to the organ donations The show has set up some details about him, but in my humble opinion, not enough to make it really matter. It wants us to be on the side of his parents, played by Wakina Kalakongo and Jason Tam. But again, because we have so many other characters we're dealing with, it's not just these parents. It's not going into the memories of this young man.

SPEAKER_00We also meet his girlfriend in memories of how they met. We learn more about the doctors of the hospital and the nurses and the hospital staff who deal with convincing people to have their parting loved ones become organ donors of the people who work in the computer system that help assign these organs to different patients in the hospital. These are a lot of moving components. And

SPEAKER_00For me, it's hard to feel affected when you're constantly shifting. And the aesthetic of the show also has a very sterile vibe of kind of almost the Curious Incident of the Dog in the Nighttime set of the computerized tiles and cubes, which is impressive and helps with the fluidity of the staging of the piece because we have to go from place to place in different moments in time.

SPEAKER_00Adds to impressiveness and not effectiveness for me. EDM is also not a kind of music that I particularly find thrilling. It can... Help with momentum, which I, what I give the heart a lot of credit for is that it keeps moving, which is helpful, but it doesn't, again, it doesn't make me feel. And certain components we can cut. As the girlfriend of our young man, so let me look up some of these character names here, actually. Um, the, okay, who is the young man who dies?

SPEAKER_00Is it, it's Thomas, right? Yeah, so that would be Lincoln Claus plays Thomas. Uh, No, it's Simon. What am I saying? It's Simon. Simon is the young man who dies and his girlfriend's name is... It's not... It's not Claire. Why can't I think of the girlfriend's name? I want to say it's like Ava or something. Marta? No, not Marta. Juliet. Yeah, it's Juliet.

SPEAKER_00Juliet is Simon's girlfriend. And she's brought into the story because when Simon's parents, again, played by Wakina and Jason, are arguing over whether Simon would have wanted to be an organ donor or not. They're like, well let's call his girlfriend Juliet because A she needs to know what has happened to Simon but also you know maybe this might give us some idea of what he might want and the truth is that Juliet is not a necessary component

SPEAKER_00to this show she doesn't She ultimately doesn't matter. There are things you could say on a thematic level. Oh, you know, she's the love that he felt before he died. You know, she was tied to his heart on a romantic way and in a way that his parents weren't. And she understood his heartbeat because she was a DJ at a club and that's how they met and all these other things. I'm like, all of that doesn't actually end up mattering. The main crux of the story is a young man has died and time is running out. And will his parents allow this to happen?

SPEAKER_00And if they do, whose lives get affected? That is the crux. So everything going on with Juliet is, I'm sorry, irrelevant. And it takes away time from the second half of the story, which is when we learn one of the people who gets Simon's organ, specifically who gets his heart. It is the character of Claire, played by Heidi Blickenstaff. Claire does not show up until the last third of the show. Once it's been decided that Simon's going to become an organ donor,

SPEAKER_00then there's the whole process of they have to retrieve the organs, they do a whole processional down the hallway to honor him for his service, and then Ren Rivera, one of the hospital administration staff, has to organize what organs go where. Once it's decided that Claire, played by Heidi, who is a woman about to hit 50, who's been on the waiting list for years and has finally decided that she's going to accept dying and live her final year of life drinking and eating and just having grand old time, that's when she gets the call.

SPEAKER_00She's gonna get the heart. I don't... A lot of issues that people have with the character of Claire, she gets the 11 o'clock number where she writes a letter to Simon or the parents of Simon to thank them and say, like, I don't know what to tell you other than this is who I am and this is what I'm going through. I actually quite enjoyed the song. I know a lot of people did not. They find the lyrics to be rather silly. I find them to be one of the more specific lyrics of the show. And for me, that's why I like it, because it's actual musical theater. It's not generalistic lyrics, which you find a lot in modern day musical theater.

SPEAKER_00But why it's not? Emotionally effective is because at that point, it's our second scene with Claire. We have her intro scene and then we have the scene where she comes to the hospital unsure how she's feeling about all of this and then writing this letter. And this is a piece of the puzzle where Claire needs to be brought in earlier. We don't have to do a lot of stage time, but we have to start having hints of her or other people whose lives are going to be affected by Simon's passing.

SPEAKER_00Rather than her coming in so late after giving different members of the hospital scenes and songs and getting intricacies of their lives, we have to remember what is this about. In the same way that, you know, Arthur Lawrence told the writers of Wicked, who, you know, they had all these subplots with politics and the animals, and he's like, what's the show about? It's about the two girls. It's about their friendship. When in doubt, always go back to that. And The Heart, for me, does not keep coming back to that. It's too involved with all the other elements of Logistics of the hospital,

SPEAKER_00of the parents, of the patients, of Simon's past. And for 90 minutes, that's a lot of thread to thread. And this makes it sound like I didn't like the show. I did like it, but this is ultimately why I wasn't moved. This is ultimately why I don't buy a lot of what they're selling me Emotionally speaking, I enjoy a lot of the music of it, but then again, you get these moments where Joaquina and Jason have to sing about who Simon was and how they felt about him.

SPEAKER_00And it's just, it's not enough time. It is the feeling of being moved by a song because of the sound of the music, because the beauty of the voices, but not actually being moved by it. And that's because for me, there's dramaturgical issues in this script and where the heart chooses to focus on and when. As I said, the cast overall is quite strong. Wakina can cry and sing like the best of them, and luckily the show does not ask her to rip her vocal cords out in the same way that Paradise Square did. I'm always happy to see Heidi Plicken stop on stage,

SPEAKER_00and she is just as talented and charming as she ever was. She's actually grown as an actress and has become even more nuanced in her delivery of a character like Claire, who could easily become too much of a caricature. Drew Gehling is probably my favorite of all the male performers in the show. The men don't have a ton to do in this, which is fine. It doesn't really matter. His work as the lead doctor of the heart transplant for Claire, I think that he finds a lot of small little idiosyncrasies

SPEAKER_00that make his character feel like an actual person. There's also Brie Jackson as Cordelia, who is one of the nurses working at the hospital. And while she understands Simon being brain dead, she still treats him with respect and care and consideration and like he's still alive, not because she wants to give the parents hope, but because she just thinks that what Simon deserves. And she does that without feeling sort of like the do-goodery nurse, just sort of like a decent human being.

SPEAKER_00The one person in the company who I found to be miscast was Jason Tam as Sean, Simon's father. Part of this is, from what we learn about Sean, of his demeanor of his past, of his former Rocky relationship with Wakina, I never bought that they had any kind of past chemistry. I never bought... And then

SPEAKER_00when things take a turn for the really intense and dramatic, Tam has always been someone who really goes for raw emotion. You can see that in his audition for A Chorus Line. And that works for someone like a Paul, who has to break through this wall of guardedness with this ocean of feelings. But with Sean, it's sort of zero to 100 really quickly, whereas Wakina knows when to hold it together so that way

SPEAKER_00when the floodgates open it feels earned. Tam's always going from zero to 100, which leads to a bit of a style of acting that could be considered melodrama. Melodrama... I think gets a lot of misunderstandings of what that actually is and how it goes about. For all of the shit I give my former teacher in college, one of the things he did say that I agree with and hold on to, and it's an easy way to express it, is melodrama is ultimately too much energy for the task, which is a phrase we have used before on this podcast.

SPEAKER_00So when someone is... giving hurt, but their hurt is an 11 out of 10 and it's immediate. And it's in a show, in a scene where everyone else is giving a 5 out of10, It stands out like a sore thumb. That's what makes it feel melodramatic. Whereas if you are giving an 11 out of 10 in a Greek tragedy where everyone else is also at an 11 out of 10. You're in that world. You're on that wavelength. It all makes sense. So for me, it's that Tam is, A,

SPEAKER_00just I find not a proper fit for his role in terms of energy, in terms of presentation. But then on top of that, the temperature of scenes, I always find he goes 30 degrees too hot and too quickly. And part of that is a directorial thing that is something that Ashley can do to rein him in. But I also think that that is something that not every actor has. Not a lot of musical theater actors have the ability to go so raw so quickly. That's a really amazing skill.

SPEAKER_00But you also need to have the antennae. The taste in your head to know a mismatch of performer and role. And it's not just me who felt this, by the way, so I'm not hating on him. I like Jason Tam as a performer. This was just not a role for me for him. Other things about the heart. The heart for me on a music level and a storytelling level has its spotty moments.

SPEAKER_00The song where Ren Rivera is going online and figuring out what organs go where becomes this very intense EDM song of like, and now I do this and now I do that and they only got five minutes and it becomes like a ticking time bomb, right? And in a lot of ways, like that is a lot of high pressure, but ultimately it's Ren Rivera at a computer for three minutes while the music is like, and now we're going to war. They're standing at a computer and that is musically too much energy for the task. There are moments in the heart where it's trying to go big.

SPEAKER_00It's trying to throw the spaghetti at the wall and you're just like, oh, but there wasn't a wall there and you're actually not even holding spaghetti. You're holding uncooked seaweed. So it's just crumpling on the floor. It's throwing an amazing pitch on the baseball mound only to find out that everyone's been playing tennis. There are other moments like that in the heart where you will just sometimes go, ah, I don't think that was it. And for all of the fluidity of the staging,

SPEAKER_00there are other moments where Ashley does not quite land the plane on a visual. Every time you go to Juliet at the club where she DJs, they try to do like a Michael Bennett It's a forced perspective thing of like, oh, we're behind the scenes. Everyone at the club is in the backstage corner while Juliet is up on a booth on a platform. And so we're seeing it from a different angle, but it just, it looks weird. It looks like misused space. Part of me wonders if a lot of the staging issues will be solved when it goes to Broadway and there are hydraulics. Entirely possible.

SPEAKER_00I think that could happen. I'm sure there are some lyric changes that will get tweaked between off-Broadway and Broadway, but the biggest issues for me, issues like space Paying too much attention on too many characters all the time and not zeroing in on our core characters and expanding upon their stories, that's not something that's going to happen. Bringing in Claire earlier into the show is not going to happen. The reason why Come From Away works is that Come From Away, while also dealing with multiple characters, the central conceit of Come From Away isn't the story of any one

SPEAKER_00of these characters. It's about the general idea of goodliness and being a good neighbor and a good human. And crafting a community out of terrible circumstances. It's not the story of four different people, of a Newfoundlander or these people from New York or that person from London. They are all pawns in the larger tapestry of the theme of Come From Away. That's not what The Heart is. The Heart is a specific story that wants to have different

SPEAKER_00Like a full season of The Pit even. The reason why I say Grey's Anatomy is because the whole procession down the aisle, down the hallway of the hospital is out of a Grey's Anatomy episode too. But I guess you could say it's more like an episode of The Pit or a season of The Pit. It's like five episodes of The Pit meets Come From Away with the music of Fear Lies Love. None of which are bad things, none of which necessarily couldn't tie together. But I do find that this show, for all of the heartstrings it's trying to pull, yes, I am, you know, an ice-cold asshole, but I did get teary after I became We.

SPEAKER_00I have cried at shows. I was overcome with joy during Schoolgirls. I have really loved things like Birthright and Heated Rivalry and Gary Starr. Obviously, my love can shine through. A musical can affect me, but in order for it to do so, it can't just rely on the subject matter. It can't just rely on the energy. There has to be a dramaturgical precision that then gets hidden by the smoke

SPEAKER_00and mirrors and bells and whistles of the musical theater of it all. As I said, you have to be a little bit of a sociopath because you are ultimately manipulating audiences to feel certain kinds of ways during a story. But if you're good at it, that manipulation is invisible. And then afterwards, you can just sort of admire them for doing their job as well as they did. That is the heart. If there's any other questions you have about it, you can join the Discord and ask me there, or you can join the Patreon and ask me on there. We will be having our next Matt Koplik exclusive Q&A at the end of November.

SPEAKER_00After this episode will be our review of other desert cities. Then it's going to be a Patreon preview of our fantasy draft of Tony snubs. As I said before, snubs are not really real. We're using the word snub more for attention, headline grabbiness, not because it's accurate. Although while we were recording it, the four of us realized in real time, some of our snubs were actually snubs. And after that will be my review of Here There Are Blueberries and then my review of A Few Good Men and Wanted and It's a Wonderful Life. It's it's all just constant, constant, constant.

SPEAKER_00And then Deep Dives will be coming. Honestly, Deep Dives will be starting in January, buying me some time to get the ball rolling on guests for that and research. Well, I also continue seeing all of these shows because we've also gotten our invites for Galileo and Much Ado About Nothing and a few other off-Broadway things like King's Critique and The Unbelievers. So like, yes, this is all really good stuff, but it's also be careful what you wish for because it is all the time, always think of all the shows we just talked about today. We talked about The Heart, Memoirs of Amorous Gentlemen, Degenerates, Will See,

SPEAKER_00Good Time Charlie, The Hairy Ape, Aftermath, Copperfield and I Became Wee so many off -Broadway shows in one episode And then I have to do separate episodes for the Broadway stuff. So like, yeah, it's a lot, guys. But overall, we're glad to do it. I'm hoping you guys enjoy it a lot. Keep your ears peeled for some news regarding the podcast and what might be happening with it quite soon. Some fun things have been happening behind the scenes. Some surprising things behind the scenes. We'll say that. Again, if there's any questions you have about The Heart or I Became We, Hairy Apes, Degenerates, The Broadway Breakdown Green Room,

SPEAKER_00otherwise known as our Broadway Breakdown Patreon, you will find the link in the description box or the Discord channel or the Substack, links there as well, or YouTube channel if you want to see my beautiful face and my baseball cap and my very dimly lit apartment right. That's all well and good. Again, five-star rating. You don't have to write a review if you're too nervous about writing something to be read on the podcast. You can just give us a nice five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. We're so close to 400. I'm now nervous that now that I'm asking guys to get us that 400,

SPEAKER_00five of you are going to submit, and then we're going to get over 400, and then I'm going to be like, well, now I want 500. But... We'll cross that bridge when we come to it. For today's episode, I would like to close out with Miss Heidi Plickenstaff. It's been a minute since we had her and we do love title of the show. This is a title of the show household. We love her dearly. So we will close out with Miss Heidi. And yeah, that'll be it. We'll see you guys for other desert cities after this one. So take it away, Miss Heidi. Bye. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: BILLY CRYSTAL 860 (w/ Grandma!)

    Oct 30, 202630 minAudio

    One of the most likable men in theater reviews the latest show by one of the most likable men in Hollywood. And with the assistance of his grandmother! Matt saw BILLY CRYSTAL 860 and discusses the trickiness of being...

    Credit the people on this episode