One of the most likable men in theater reviews the latest show by one of the most likable men in Hollywood. And with the assistance of his grandmother! Matt saw BILLY CRYSTAL 860 and discusses the trickiness of being intimate without being revealing, the balancing act of pain and humor, and how Ben Vereen stole Robert Morse’s Tony (according to some). Get a kick out of Sally! Important Links: * Broadway Breakdown Green Room: Patreon * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01have a pulse.
SPEAKER_03Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts, and we have our very first Matt Reviews for Broadway. We're doing things a little out of order on this series of reviews. Don't ask me why. I can't tell you. My brain is just a scattered mess these days, but We're choosing this one first because it's the most recent one we saw
SPEAKER_03and we have some fun intel for you. We are reviewing Billy Crystal's 860, or just Billy Crystal 860, however you want to read that. And it is a one-man show of Billy Crystal discussing with us The memories in his house, 860 is the house number that he lived at for almost 50 years, which unfortunately perished in the Palisades Fire in 2025. Which is, you know, a very heavy subject.
SPEAKER_03I was going to say heated, but that seemed inappropriate. And I got to go as a Drama Desk voter. Thank you. Woof. But I was able to take my grandmother to the show, which was very important to me. My grandmother has been taking me to theater for a long time. Most of my life. Both of my grandmothers have. Well, my grandmother is not really in a physical position anymore to see theater, so I can't really treat her to shows anymore. But this grandmother, who is 102, actually, at this point in time, she's closer to 103 than she is to 102.
SPEAKER_03She'll be 103. I'll let you know about some of that in just a second. And I really wanted to take her to something that I thought she would enjoy. Something that, you know, I could guarantee should be available for. And this seems like the proper opportunity. So before we get to my thoughts on Billy Crystal 860, I want you to know what Miss Sally Koplik had to say about Billy Crystal 860.
SPEAKER_00So without further ado, Miss Sally Koplik.
SPEAKER_02All right, so I am sitting here with one Miss Sally Koplik, theater connoisseur. You've seen many, many Broadway shows in your few years on this earth.
SPEAKER_01Indeed.
SPEAKER_02Yes, indeed. So we just saw 860, the Billy Crystal show. What is your association with Billy Crystal? Have you known much about him for his career?
SPEAKER_01Well, I remember when he started as a young man and I'm happy to see how successful he is. Unfortunately, he had a misfortune.
SPEAKER_02Yes, that is his house burning down, correct?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Yes, we're not referring to him being the voice in Monsters University. You did not know about that misfortune. But would you call yourself a fan of his? Yes. Okay. And so what were your thoughts on the show tonight? First thoughts immediately.
SPEAKER_01Well, I thought it was an autobiography. Yeah. From the time he moved into his Palisades home in 1979 to when it was destroyed by the fires.
SPEAKER_02Well, yes, that is what it is about. What were your feelings on the show? What was your impression of it?
SPEAKER_01I thought it was good, but not as good as I expected. But that's perhaps because it got so much publicity before it opened.
SPEAKER_02That's fair. There was a lot of hype for it that might have... Tremendous amount of PR. Yeah. Did you... Oh, there's some honking going outside your door. Did you find it humorous moving in any way? You were saying in the drive back... Sorry, I hope people don't mind the honking outside your window. You were saying in the drive back something about the production itself that kind of maybe affected your enjoyment of some of his material. Was that like the set design? Was it the projections?
SPEAKER_02Something bothering you? The projections? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And I found it difficult, but of course that's probably my age. What's wrong with your age? It's elderly.
SPEAKER_02Well... Very elderly. Some might just say you're in your cougar era.
SPEAKER_01I would say that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02You guys can't see this right now, but she's dressed very provocatively right now. A blazing red top.
SPEAKER_01Yes. With a scarf to match.
SPEAKER_02Well, you're not wearing the scarf right now, but that's because you're comfortably at home.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02Yes. And your wheelchair also matched your scarf and your shirt today.
SPEAKER_01Anyway, it was an entertaining evening, I will say.
SPEAKER_02What did you think of your seats?
SPEAKER_01Excellent. Thanks to my super-duper grandson.
SPEAKER_02Yes, and the super-duper podcast. You're welcome, babe. We were talking about this, actually, when we sat down. We were trying to remember the last thing you saw at the Imperial, which was probably August Osage County.
SPEAKER_01I saw that, yes.
SPEAKER_02You have no memory of this, but you did take me to see Hugh Jackman in The Boy From Oz.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02He played Peter Allen, who incidentally was a patient of...
SPEAKER_01My husband. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Grandpa had quite a few theater clients. True or false, Grandpa, his clients included Chita Rivera.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Bobby Morse.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Charles Nelson Reilly. Yes. Peter Allen and Liza Minnelli.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Who else? Bobby Goulet.
SPEAKER_01Yes. And Carol Lawrence.
SPEAKER_02Because they were married at the time.
SPEAKER_01And Michelle, Michelle, what was her name? Lee.
SPEAKER_02Michelle Lee. Oh, I didn't know that one. Herb Gardner, right? Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And Rita Gardner.
SPEAKER_02Right, because they were also married.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_02So things you might have seen at the Imperial Theater, you
SPEAKER_01saw
SPEAKER_02in Call Me Madam?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_02Annie Get Your Gun? Yes. Okay. So then I guess you also probably saw, did you see Dreamgirls when it was on Broadway, Jennifer Holliday back in the 80s? Yes. Okay. I did. I didn't know if that was your kind of show. Pippin?
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, I liked it and I like her.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, did you see Pippin? No. I never saw Pippin. Well, you know that Ben Vereen won the Tony Award that the Koplik family thinks belonged to Bobby.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Oh, you make me laugh.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's true. That's what your son always says, that Ben Vereen took Bobby's Tony.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's too bad.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. For anyone who's wondering, Robert Morrison's sugar, that's what we're referring to. But it's okay. Back to the show for a quick second, and then we'll wrap things up, my love. Any other takeaways this evening besides the fact that your fabulous grandson gave you fabulous seats and we had a fabulous meal and we got home before nine o'clock?
SPEAKER_01Unbelievable evening. Most wonderful.
SPEAKER_02But that's just because of your companion. Of course. I love him. Well, yeah, some people do. I guess you're one of the few. Who would you recommend this show to?
SPEAKER_01Elderly people or middle age, middle age and up.
SPEAKER_02Middle age and up, okay.
SPEAKER_01Not youngsters.
SPEAKER_02Because of why?
SPEAKER_01Because think it's an era, you know, not for teenagers particularly or even 20s above that. Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_02So if someone were to ask you, I'm thinking about going, anything you want to tell me about it to sort of get me in the right headspace for it, prepare myself?
SPEAKER_01Don't listen to all the hullabaloo. That's what I would say.
SPEAKER_02Don't get super hyped up. Just go and try to absorb it.
SPEAKER_01Enjoy it, but don't listen to all the public relations.
SPEAKER_02Can you remember something you saw on Broadway in the last couple of years that you really loved? You're pointing at me. Why are you pointing at me?
SPEAKER_01Because you know.
SPEAKER_02Say it to the people.
SPEAKER_01Jeremy. Strong.
SPEAKER_02Jeremy Strong.
SPEAKER_01Strong. In.
SPEAKER_02And then me.
SPEAKER_01Enemy of the People.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_01I loved it.
SPEAKER_02Yes, you did.
SPEAKER_01Best thing I've seen in a long time.
SPEAKER_02Yes, you really did love that. The acting was superb. I've taken you to quite a few good things, I've realized. Yes. I took you to that. I took you to Fun Home. Yes. Yes. And then a few things you were less enthused by. One of my favorite quotes from you. You won't remember this, but I want it on mic. Do you remember we saw a musical a few years ago? It was called The Prom. Sure. About Broadway actors who go to a small town. At intermission, you turned to me and you said, you were laughing a lot.
SPEAKER_02And I shouted back at you, it's funny. And you just shook your head.
SPEAKER_01I didn't see the humor.
SPEAKER_02Yes, I know. You looked at me very quizzically.
SPEAKER_01I didn't see the humor in that.
SPEAKER_02No. If it makes you feel any better, you're one of many people who don't see the humor in it. And some of those people are young people.
SPEAKER_01All right.
SPEAKER_02That's my grandma for you. She is an icon.
SPEAKER_01She is the moment and she will be outliving all
SPEAKER_02of us.
SPEAKER_03What's her secret? And, you know, she does whatever she wants. She really, I told her, Western science would like to put her in a closet because they don't want the world
SPEAKER_03to know that ignoring their advice could lead you to living 102 years old, soon to be 103. But anyway, that's Sally for you. So that's her thoughts on the show. My thoughts on the show. So as she said, you know, it's 95 minutes of Billy Crystal kind of bookending the show with the Palisade fires. You know, that's what opens the show. And then we go back to it towards the end. And in the middle, for the majority of the 95 minutes, I'd say maybe 80 minutes of the show, is Crystal kind of walking down memory lane.
SPEAKER_03More of his... Performing career than anything else. Because in this home, which he purchased in 1979 with his wife and his two very young daughters, which they were able to afford, A, because of house prices in 1979 in LA, plus that he was on a hit TV show called Soap. He was doing stand-up gigs. And, you know, they were just able to get a very good deal on this house, which, as it turns out, had a long history of being...
SPEAKER_03In the entertainment industry it was built and owned by entertainment people and then made its way back to Billy and his wife and he had an office with all of these wonderful mementos of his career in it and so the set is erupting And as he's going through his career, he, you know, the there's subtle lighting pinpointing different items in the set model
SPEAKER_03of his office that sort of not only are you going in linear order. But it kind of explains why we're discussing all these things, because ultimately in the end, these are the things that perished in the fire. And so Crystal talks about His big break into comedy of his standup routine, getting an agent, and then that getting him a job on a sitcom of playing Rob Reiner's best friend,
SPEAKER_03I believe on All in the Family, which then led to Soap. That led to a couple of comedy specials on HBO, which led to being a cast member on SNL. And that led to a movie career again with Rob Reiner with This is Spinal Tap, Princess Bride, When Harry Met Sally. Working on City Slickers, hosting the Oscars, his friendships with Rob Breiner and with Muhammad Ali and Robin Williams and Whoopi Goldberg. And, you know, Crystal is such a funny, gregarious guy.
SPEAKER_03He's such a warm, kind spirit. He's... He's sort of like if Tom Hanks did stand up, that's kind of Billy Crystal. You know, Tom Hanks has always has been called like America's father. And it's because he has this very warm, comforting presence. He's like a giant blanket in a sense, which is funny because you watch some Tom Hanks movies and he's played a couple of really caustic characters. One of the greatest magic tricks of You've Got Mail is that he plays a dick in that movie. And one of the greatest magic tricks of When Harry Met Sally is that Billy Crystal's character half the time is is a dick and 80% of the time is
SPEAKER_03a huge misogynist. I mean, he learns, he eventually learns, but like that's the, you don't really realize that when you're watching the movie because Billy is so likable. He's so sweet and that is just who he is as a person. You know, he doesn't, He's very smart. He's very funny. And obviously, you know, he wears his heart and his politics on his sleeve, but he doesn't talk down to you. There are definitely people in the world that he hates. One, Mr. Donald Trump, who gets like maybe two or three jabs in the show.
SPEAKER_03There was somebody in the audience who did not enjoy the second jab about him dodging the draft for Vietnam. But that was the one guy, as far as I could tell, everybody else was into it. But, you know, it's also why whenever he would do impressions of people or, you know, do like light negging of them, everyone just became his friend because it was always done with love and affection and he never really went over the line. If you watched the Martin Short documentary on Netflix, they sort of talk about this of how quick of a wit Martin Short is,
SPEAKER_03especially when he's doing something like Jiminy Glick. And Jiminy Glick is this character that Martin Short created of a There's an interviewer who doesn't do any prep, who's always insulting the guests, but the guests love it because Martin Short is just so good at making fun of them a way that they can enjoy it. And Billy Crystal's sort of the same way. You both feel like you are a welcomed friend while also a game participant without having really to be put on the spot.
SPEAKER_03That said, when we come back to the house fires at the end of the show and we see via projections that the house itself really kind of just, the whole thing perished. And a couple of items made it through and that's really lovely. But I had a friend who actually ended up being there the same night and he saw on Instagram that I was there. And we're talking about how we... Neither one of us were really moved by the end of it. I mean, listen, there were sniffles around me when I saw it, but we weren't really moved.
SPEAKER_03We enjoyed it. We had like a good time. But we weren't laughing uproariously. And when it came to the real-life tragedy of his house, we were like, I'm not crying. I don't really feel anything. And something that Crystal talks about in the show is early in his stand-up career, the manager he had who kind of really guided him and then gave him the advice that shifted his whole career trajectory. You know, Crystal would do stand-up and it would be, you know, punchline after punchline.
SPEAKER_03And the manager said to him, like, no, you're funny, kid. You're doing a good job. You're getting laughs, but you're not ready. You're not there. And he said, we don't know anything about you. You're not putting any of yourself into your comedy. Right now, you're just a one-line machine. You're not a storyteller. And I want you to be a storyteller and I want you to use stories that are unique to you. And at that point, Billy Crystal was a new father. So he was telling a lot of stories about his baby daughter and being married and all this stuff. And that was sort of the door that opened that really gave him a bunch
SPEAKER_03of new material and turned him into a storyteller. And The manager equated to saying, you know, like, you need to leave a tip.
SPEAKER_00You need to give us a little bit extra that's just a view for us that feels special.
SPEAKER_03And he says, you know, at the end of the show that he keeps that mentality with him. And in a way, this night is like another tip that's being left. And my friend Patrick and I were saying, like, I don't I didn't feel like we were kind of intimately involved. It really was more of a carousel of his greatest achievements. Now, great. Granted, he has amazing achievements and has had a very long, successful career. But.
SPEAKER_03The story of how the orgasm scene in When Harry Met Sally came to be, while a great anecdote, one that I already know, but while that's a great anecdote, it's not quite the same as hearing a story about what went down with him and his wife and their two daughters when there was a fight of some sort or there was a celebration of some sort. There are a couple of personal anecdotes, not many, one of which he and his brother got high right as soon as his wife had given birth to their first daughter. But that's one of very few personal anecdotes.
SPEAKER_03The most personal we get are, again, like his intimates with other celebrities of story or two about Robin Williams, which is really lovely, Muhammad Ali, which is really lovely, but also not even stories. Sometimes they're like kind of barely anecdotes. He's got a whole bunch of little ones about Muhammad Ali that are really nice, but they're not like a fully developed story. Story that it's always these like 30 second little quips, which are which gives you fun insights into all the people that he knew and so many people who you didn't know were great people.
SPEAKER_03But the point of all of this is to go through all the things that he had in his office that meant something to him in some way. And some things are. You know, souvenirs from movies and TV shows, other things are gifts he was given that are irreplaceable. He became friendly with Mickey Mantle, who gifted him one of the original seats of the original Yankee Stadium that famously was blue with a little green paint seeping through. And Mickey Mantle signed it on the back that perished in the fire.
SPEAKER_03And that is a, you know, one of a kind, never going to be found again kind of gift and is a true personal memory. It's also, this was a Patrick thing more than it was a me thing, but a lot of these things are very bougie items that are what makes Billy's life special, but it's hard to kind of Feel when a lot of the things he talks about the fire are that that bench,
SPEAKER_03Yankees World Series rings probably worth like tens of thousands of dollars, artwork that's probably worth somewhere in the six figures, things like that. And they talk about I mean, he's not fully unaware that he's very privileged and that he and his wife had insurance and they were able to rebuild and all this stuff. But again, he doesn't talk enough about the personal. You feel like you got a solid inside look into his career, but not necessarily into him.
SPEAKER_03Now, as I understand it, his other show, 700 Sundays, is a much more intimate look into his life, but also of his early life, not necessarily of his adult life. And I think that is ultimately, for me, is what is missing, is More of the intimacy of the day-to-days with his family, with his friends. And I think part of the reason why he doesn't do that is, A, the fire was a year and a half ago. It's still incredibly raw at this point.
SPEAKER_03And, for example, he talks about being best friends with Rob Reiner. The gift that he gave him in terms of his career in addition to just being a lovely human being. And as we get towards the end of the show and he says, 2025 was the worst year of our lives. We thought, how could it get any worse? We had the fires. And then he goes, and then December came. And December was when Rob Reiner was and his wife were tragically murdered. And he does not say those words. I don't think he even says Rob's name at the beginning.
SPEAKER_03He...
SPEAKER_00Talks a little bit about when Robin Williams passed, but he doesn't go into the details of that either. And it's more focused on the healing process and the belief in some kind of mystical afterlife. And he doesn't have to necessarily say Rob Reiner's name. Most of the audience knows what he's talking about. But Patrick did tell me that the person he was with... Didn't clock that that's what he was referring to. In fact, she thought that he was referring to his wife for a second that his wife had passed.
SPEAKER_00And so she was confused when there were videos of his wife at the end of the show. And she was like, is this a memoriam to her? And then Patrick had to be like, no, his wife's still alive. He's talking about Rob Reiner. And it's. And that happened less than a year ago.
SPEAKER_03So there's no way that Billy Crystal is going to be able to talk about it in a way that isn't still raw, but also then doesn't feel a little bit gross at the same time. I think...
SPEAKER_00Billy Crystal is such a class act in that he doesn't want to exploit the people in his life for profit. And at this point right now, because it's so soon after the events, it could feel a bit more like profit than art. Maybe with 700 Sundays, because the things he's talking about are so far in the past, there's enough distance that it can feel like fair game to really craft something out of it. And everything that he's talking about in this show is still a little bit too soon. And that's absolutely fair. But I think for me, that is what keeps it from being a really great night at the theater.
SPEAKER_00It's still fun because Billy is fun and he's... So funny, and he's so charming, and he can really hold the attention of a 1500-seat theater for 95 minutes. And, you know, unlike my grandmother, I thought design-wise it was good. You know, Imperial's not a small theater. It's not a barn. It's not the Broadway or the Gershwin. But, like, it's not a medium-sized house. I would say it's, like, a medium-plus house. It's on the more intimate side for spectacle. It's on the much larger side for smaller shows.
SPEAKER_00And... I found that the design filled the space enough that you didn't feel super cavernous on that stage. The projections were a really nice touch. And again, he is such a magnetic presence that you don't need a lot to do. To fill up the Imperial. And when everything goes away, the set sort of melts away and Billy's left alone on stage. And it's a really simple and solid effect. And it moves at a nice tight pace.
SPEAKER_0095 minutes, of course, is a solid amount of time. But yeah, I think because we all like him so much. And also, you know, the reviews were very strong for this. I was like, oh, I think this is going to be a really... Funny and moving, touching experience. And it was more nice than anything else. It was solid. It was okay. It was fine. It was a perfectly lovely 95 minutes at the theater. And the fact that my grandmother felt the same way, I think, should tell you something.
SPEAKER_00But yeah. That's it for Billy Crystal 860. I know this is a short one, but honestly, with all these reviews, they're going to be kind of like 20 to 30 minute nuggets over the next couple of weeks. But that's fine. Think of it less of long marathon episodes and more as little sprints throughout the next couple of weeks. And yeah, I'm trying to think of anything else I need to touch on with 860. I mean, I don't want to give too much away. He talks about As I said, he talks about the orgasm scene in When Harry Met Sally,
SPEAKER_00which I love that anecdote of how that scene came to be because I think it's a perfect example of what true collaboration is. He talks a little bit about the Princess Bride. He doesn't really talk about City Slickers. He just sort of name drops it. He talks about the Oscars, but again, there's no real backstage tea on that. He shows you a couple of highlights of his run as As an awards host, primarily his shtick of inserting himself into clips from the movies nominated
SPEAKER_00for Best Picture. He shows one from Titanic. Does not show the one from him in Mystic River because that's, you know, a very not-in-great-taste joke. He shows clips of his specials, him with Muhammad Ali. He shows a little clip of him on SNL. He sort of saves home videos and photos towards the end. Nothing terribly invasive. And I think he I mean, he talks about how when the fires happened, the way that news reports were going on about his home
SPEAKER_00and I'm sure other people's homes as well. But, you know, a news reporter going on national TV and standing on the grounds where his house used to stand and announcing on national television that his house burnt down and he and his daughter's Kind of living this nightmare that has always been their nightmare of the world knowing their intimate lives before they really do. And so I understand him being somewhat of a private person, but that's sort of the double-edged sword of when you're doing a show like this, of if you want...
SPEAKER_00If you want to do a show about you, you have to be willing to give up a little something of yourself that you've closed off to everyone else. At least just something. As his manager said, you got to leave a bit of a tip. And I think that Billy thinks that he's done that. I don't personally felt like he did. I felt like he gave us a very curated tip. And it was a perfectly enjoyable time, but it wasn't It just wasn't quite enough for me, you know?
SPEAKER_00But that's me with Billy Crystal 860. It's a lovely evening. It's a lovely evening to go. I'm sure if your parents want to take you or you want to take your parents or grandparents or whatever, There are worse ways to spend 95 minutes of your day than to spend it with Billy Crystal. And definitely don't let the tragedies of the end of the show dissuade you. There's a lot of humor to it. There's a lot to laugh at. And it's a very well done up production. It's not just him with the stool. There's some solid production value without feeling overproduced.
SPEAKER_00It's a very tasteful production. That's it with Billy Crystal. Our next review, I'm going to do... Okay, so in terms of Broadway, we've got 860, Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls Play, Other Desert Cities, and Paranormal Activity. So, okay, after this one, we're going to do Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls Play. Then we're going to do Paranormal Activity, then Other Desert Cities. And later this week, I will review The Imaginary Invalid. But that's going to be it for Billy Crystal.
SPEAKER_00I hope you enjoyed this. I hope you enjoyed Sally. Who should we close out with today? You know what? Because Sally... Hasn't been to the Imperial in about 18 years. And the performer she's probably seen most at the Imperial is Ethel Merman. We will close out with Miss Ethel Merman. So that's it for now. We will see you guys for Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls play in just a few days. Take it away, Ethel. [music]
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...