Full Episode Here: The Broadway Breakdown Green Room INTRODUCING! The debut of the Broadway Breakdown FANTASY DRAFT! It’s like Fantasy Football. Except without the pesky football. And without a cash prize. Just all of your opinions on what we picked. Breakdown regulars Adam Elsberry (@adamels), Margaret Hall (@itsmargarethall), Rob W. Schneider (@robwschneider) and newcomer Steve Tipton (@stevetiptonnyc) all stop by the Green Room for a new Round Table. Drafting the Tony winners for Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Musical!!! Who gets Patti in Gypsy? Did someone choose Mary Martin in South Pacific? And what of Diahann Carroll in No Strings or Barbara Harris in The Apple Tree? FIND OUT!!!. Let us know YOUR Fantasy Draft Picks as well! Categories: One and Done (One nomination/One win. Nothing else) Second Wins (Second win in THIS category, not overall) Singularly Anointed (Only actress out of many to win for this role) Contentious Untouched/Iconic Soap Box Final Girl (The performance you just can’t NOT pick) This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to the Broadway Breakdown Green Room. All you wonderful company members have a seat in the green room with us. I am joined by our largest group yet. You know him. You love him. Gunkle of the pod, Adam Elsberry. Hi, Adam. Hi. We have longtime friend of the pod, Maggie Hall. Hi, Maggie.
SPEAKER_03Hi, Matt.
SPEAKER_01Sorry, Margaret Hall, for those of you who know her professionally. We then, of course, have the ultimate man of my life, Mr. Robert W. Schneider.
SPEAKER_00Hello, Matthew.
SPEAKER_01Yes, he usually necks me, but not right now. And then new to the pod, a new friend. Please welcome Steve Tipton. Hi, Steve. Hey, Steve. What is that? Can I talk? Hey, hi. I would hope you talk because you have to talk after this. Okay, so do you want to do a redo, babe? Hi. You're already working with a deficit because all the people know of you so far the choice from the last Green Room Roundtable.
SPEAKER_00You know, I'm hoping to make even hotter takes tonight. So here we go. You'll do great. Wait, I'm sorry. What happened, Steve? I missed the last one. What happened?
SPEAKER_01So the last Green Room Roundtable. So this is another Green Room Roundtable. Welcome, everybody. Our very first one, our inaugural one was the top 50 opening numbers in musical theater. You all know you're on the group text. And as we had a few opportunities. I texted each of you separately. I was like, hey, you get to make one pick. You remember Rob, you remember Adam. And Steve picked some people from Gypsy because that's what I had on the board. And we talked about it.
SPEAKER_01And Robbie and Rachel and Will all were like, I'm sorry, that's not the opening number to Gypsy. And a bunch of the Patreon members were like, that's not the opening number to Gypsy. My hot take is that I personally think that it is. Everyone says, well, may we entertain you? Thanks for updating me.
SPEAKER_01I stand by it too, Steve. Today, though, we are doing our very first fantasy draft category, leading actress in a musical Tony winners. So the way that this works, dear company members, is we have... Six official categories and then a seventh wild one that I will reveal at the end of the episode. And everyone in the roundtable will get to make a pick for each category. The categories currently are one and done.
SPEAKER_01Tony winners that had one nomination. They won for that one nomination and never had another ever since. Not even a win, not just a no win, but no nomination since then or before then, just the one. Our second category, of course, is Second Wins. These are Tony winning Best Actress in a Musical for the second time. This does not include people like Bebe Neuwirth, who won her second Tony, but she won her first for Featured Actress, and so on and so forth. Our third category is Singular Anointment. These are women who are the only ones to win a Tony Award for playing this role.
SPEAKER_01This means the role has to have been eligible for a Tony Award in other Broadway productions, and though women might have been nominated, they never have won. The fourth one is Untouched, Iconic Wins. This is up to Interpretations. So, you know, everyone will see what we do here. Number five is contentious wins that we have a gripe about and we want to debate on. And then the sixth official one is soapbox where we get on our soapbox and we say this win is not valued enough and I need to make a claim for it.
SPEAKER_01And then, of course, we have our final girls, but we cannot do final girls until the end of the episode. Okay. So we're going to start in alphabetical order. Each round, the next person who comes alphabetically will get to go first. And it's a free for all in terms of category choices. Everyone can pick whatever category they want. First up, Gunkel, you ready?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think so. This is mildly intimidating. Okay. All right. I want to do one and done. Okay. Okay. My God. Okay. I just want to show you. I made a list full of alts. People can't, the chat can't see, but I have like a list full of alts because I was so afraid that everyone is going to pick everything that I chose. Okay. Same. I'm going with my number one, which is my one and done, Joanna Gleason, Into the Woods. No, you can't do that because she's
SPEAKER_01been nominated before. Really? All right. Fine. She was nominated for Dirty Around Scoundrels and she was nominated, I think, for- It's any Tony. Really? That's what I mean by one and done. You have wrenched the system.
SPEAKER_03Oh, my pre-writes are messed up then. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay. This is how we make drama, everybody. I was talking a one and done. Did you not look at the Excel spreadsheet? I put a whole Excel spreadsheet. He did.
SPEAKER_00And I'm still confused.
SPEAKER_02There was a column on that spreadsheet. All right, fine. I'll do my second one and done. Thank God for alts. My second one and done is Glynis Johns in A Little Night Music. Great. Explain yourself, bitch. I mean, I will say one thing off the top. This was really hard in a lot of cases because many of these shows happened 30 plus years before I was born. So this is all Based on cast recordings and maybe some Ed Sullivan performances
SPEAKER_02and also just like Wish I Could Have Been There vibes. Absolutely. But Night Music, I think, number one, is a near-perfect musical. And I think that there are a couple of videos of Glynis Johns performing Sin and the Clowns. And I think I also came across at one point a clip of the scene... Like, leading into that. It was, like, two seconds of footage. But I just, I don't know. There's something about her and that character that just makes so much sense to me.
SPEAKER_02And the fact that she won a Tony for it in a pretty, like, reasonably stacked season, like, up against some other decent hitters. I don't know. I just, I think it's a role that deserves awards. Yeah. But not, but depending on who performs in it. And that's all I'll say for the time being, given other categories that we have going on.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I do. I love this win. I love Glynnis Johns. She's up against Debbie Reynolds for Irene. That was probably a really big contender. Marsha Rod for Shelter. Yeah. Mr. Schneider, didn't we cover Shelter in your 19... No, no, we didn't do that. I was thinking the 1975 thing. That's something else. What is Shelter? Do we know?
SPEAKER_00I have never heard of this. Yeah, I think it was Austin Pendleton in it. And I think it was Gretchen... Is it Nancy Cryer and Gretchen Ford? Oh.
SPEAKER_01I only know it as a song call out in title of show.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's Joanna Merlin. Oh, no. Yeah, famous casting director, Joanna Merlin, Terry Kaiser, Susan Browning. Oh, he's Bernie from
SPEAKER_00Weekend at Bernie's. Oh, nice. Susan Browning was in company.
SPEAKER_01And then Susan Browning from company, yeah. And then Tony Wells. I don't know what the hell that is. I know nothing about this musical. It is written by Gretchen Krier.
SPEAKER_02That is correct. Okay. And Glynis was also up against Leland Palmer, who, let's be real, Fastrata is not a lead actress role, but I'm sure she was incredible, but that is a weird nomination.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. People talking about Annie Hathaway being category fraud in The Odyssey, I'm like, let me introduce you to Leland Palmer and Pippen.
SPEAKER_03Let me introduce you to the Tony Awards before 1989. Correct.
SPEAKER_01It was the Wild West. My hot take is Glynnis Johns remains my favorite version of Send in the Clowns. You need to be an actress who can sing, but not a singer. Oversinging Send in the Clowns is not in my opinion.
SPEAKER_00Because the role was tailored to Glynnis Johns. Exactly. You know, not even that song, but also the other things like, you know, are you correcting the child? Don't. You know, all of that stuff. They're so perfect for her.
SPEAKER_02And I think she somewhat famously or infamously was sick when they recorded or at least was like worn out because that was back when they were recording like right after opening night. So like... I kind of love that her voice is a little baked. I like that there's that rasp to it. There's just there's something about and, you know, I mean, obviously, Mrs. Banks for life, like Sister Suffragette. Hello. I love I just love her. She's somebody who I wish we got more of as a as an actress in like mainstream stuff
SPEAKER_02that everybody knew. But yeah, she's my one and done because I just I think she's awesome.
SPEAKER_01And her in that red dress diva.
SPEAKER_02Florence Klotz working it out for everybody.
SPEAKER_01Margaret Hall, what do we have for you, please?
SPEAKER_03I am going to stick with one and done and put forward Miss Heather Headley in Aida.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_03Aida was going to hurt you.
SPEAKER_01That hurt me a little deeply, but okay.
SPEAKER_03Talk to me. Easy as life. Simple, said, done. I think it's the best singular moment Disney Theatricals has ever had on Broadway is her performance of that song. It's crazy. I miss her deeply. I understand why she has made the decision she has made to prioritize her family and stay out in Chicago and do all those good things. But for the love of God, please stop doing kind of bad TV shows on Netflix and come back.
SPEAKER_03Please! The American musical needs you, Heather!
SPEAKER_00She's just a star. She's just a star.
SPEAKER_01A performance so good that even though she's only done one other Broadway musical since then, we still consider her one of ours. 1.5. 1.5, Color Purple and Into the Woods. 1.75, because then also the Dreamgirls concert.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yes, yes. Give her a 0.25.
SPEAKER_011.75 since Aida, and yet we're still one of our great musical theater leading ladies.
SPEAKER_03Literally.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Oh, my God. She's everything. She's everything. The way-
SPEAKER_02Lion King. Sorry. Oh, my God. No, but since Aida is what I'm saying. Oh, since Aida. Sure, sure, sure, sure, sure. Okay.
SPEAKER_03Okay. God, she's so good. She chews on that part like it's King Lear. And when people talk about wanting Aida to be revived, I would love to see an Aida revival. I think the reason it has not happened yet is because Disney has yet to find the next Heather Headley. You cannot do Aida with someone that does not have that caliber of you are holding your breath watching them do what they're doing. It's not just a good voice. It's not just a good actor. It's not just statuesque.
SPEAKER_03It's this like ephemeral thing. And Heather has it.
SPEAKER_01I used to say you don't announce you're doing Funny Girl and then find a Fanny Bryce. You find someone who has to play Fanny Bryce and then do Funny Girl for them. I think Aida is the exact same way. Yeah. Schneider, what do you have to say about Heather Headley?
SPEAKER_00I love Heather Headley. Oh, my God. When I saw her in Color Purple, I was literally, I was like, the show is now called Suge Avery and Her Friend Who Sells Pants. Because I was like, all I'm watching is Heather Headley. Like, it was incredible. Incredible. I love her. That's all I've got to say. Yeah, Aida, I don't listen to it frequently, but the trio with the three of them, Sherry, Adam, and Heather, it is musical theater bliss.
SPEAKER_00You know, it's just great.
SPEAKER_01How many of us here saw Heather and Aida? I did. Not live. Not live. I mean, if you watch it at the library, it's a pretty great recording.
SPEAKER_03It's a really good recording.
SPEAKER_01God. Well, that's my favorite leading actress in a musical lineup. And Heather winning is kind of... Wow. Because it's Heather, it's Audra, it's Toni Collette for Wild Party, it's Maren for Kiss Me Kate, and then Rebecca Luger for Music Family. Everyone's a different flavor. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think it really came down to... Yeah. Yeah. And I feel like that was like the 1% that tipped Heather that year
SPEAKER_03because it was such a good year. But she also was just so transcendent.
SPEAKER_01She was. All right. Mr. Rob Schneider, you're next. What category would you like to do?
SPEAKER_00Can I go to one that I relate with? It's called Untouched. And that's where I would like to go next. Now, once again, would you do me a favor? Iconic wins that are undisputed. No one can come back and go, she didn't deserve it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, this is your choice. We can debate you, but it's your choice.
SPEAKER_00Great. I am submitting the great Dorothy Loudon for Annie. That is my submission.
SPEAKER_01Something about the tone of your voice. I was, I just, I could feel it in my bones.
SPEAKER_00I want her. It's untouched. It's undisputed. No, that role was tailor-made for her. I've never seen anybody do it since anywhere near as good as she did it. I love her. Done and done.
SPEAKER_02I had her under singularly anointed and a different category, but I won't contend with the untouched. It's so similar. Thank you, Senator Elbury. Have we all watched her
SPEAKER_00Tony win speech?
SPEAKER_03It's incredible.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. Yes. Because that also goes into it. That's also for me untouched. It's the whole package. It's a Tony moment. It's the speech. It's the performance. It's the history of flops leading up to this moment. It's just everything for me. And while her performance is untouched, I think it's also because she's a little bit touched, you know, like it's a little off kilter, you know, like who's going to take this role and be like, come to it sideways, you know.
SPEAKER_03No one has delivered some women are dripping with diamonds better.
SPEAKER_00Correct.
SPEAKER_02It just, it feels, it just,
SPEAKER_02It just sort of turns the focus too much onto the kids and it makes it feel too much like a kid's musical.
SPEAKER_01My thing is, I feel like the trick to Hannigan... It's the same trick to the Lady of the Lake in Spamalot, which is the way that Sarah Soto-Ramirez played the Lady of the Lake was that she was furious that she was in a Monty Python show. She's a Juilliard-trained actress. And I feel like Hannigan is furious that she's in a kid's show. She wants to be in a sex show. She's like, I want to get pounded. What are all these kids doing around me?
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_01And I think that that like absolute frustration needs to be seeping out of her body at all times. And with Dorothy Loudon, it came out with like a bump and grind and a growl. It's so good.
SPEAKER_02And she was just she was so horny. Like so horny. So horny.
SPEAKER_03It's the category for horniest Tony Wynn.
SPEAKER_01Um, you know.
SPEAKER_00We do on time. If we have enough time, we'll add a corniest Tony win.
SPEAKER_03Legitimately, it's a kid's show, but it's so sexual what she's doing up there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, God, I love it. All right, Steve, Steve, what do you have for us? All right, well, true form, I'm going to start off with contentious wins. Just come in with a hot take. However... This is a contentious win that is also iconic, but in a way that's like it should have won a different year. So these two people could both win. I'm glad that this one won, but someone else should have won. It's kind of like when Nicole Kidman won for the hours, even though it should have been Renee Zellweger for Chicago.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. So I have in my contentious Idina Menzel for Wicked. I have that too. Talk to me. So, of course, it's the legendary. Obviously, it should have been Stephanie DiBruzzo for Avenue Q. Steve. Steve chose violence today, everybody. But we have Kristen Chenoweth, we have Idina, we have Donna Murphy, and we have Tanya Pinkins and Stephanie DiBruzzo. And in my opinion, I would have won.
SPEAKER_00I absolutely want Tanya Pinkins to win for Carolina Change. So I love Idina winning for Wicked. But can we hold that till next season so we can get Carolina changed for Tanya? So there's my contentious one.
SPEAKER_01I'm not mad about that. I've been on the record to say I think that Adina is still the best Alphaba, even if maybe there have been better singers in the role. I just think what she did with that role... Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, such a such a crazy year with all those people. You know, honestly, many of them would have been OK choices. I would have gone with Tanya. I'm happy for Adina. But, you know, it's just a matter of time.
SPEAKER_01That's all. I love that for you. OK, I'm going to. Hmm. Part of me wants to also do contentious because I have a really I think. This might be a little semi-controversial as well, but also, I don't know, part of me also wants to do like singular anointment or soapbox. I'm going to ask the group, do you want me to do my controversial contentious or like do a new category? Do a new category.
SPEAKER_00Oh, you feel like a soapbox kind of guy, Matt.
SPEAKER_01Oh. Soapbox, controversial. What'd you say, Adam? I said do a new category. Maggie?
SPEAKER_03Let's hear your soapbox.
SPEAKER_01Okay, soapbox. My soapbox, speaking of Tony's speeches and audience reactions, my soapbox is Tyne, Daly, and Gypsy.
SPEAKER_03Yes! I hoped someone would say it.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I have been on record that even with her sick as a dog on the cast recording of Gypsy, I adore that recording. Part of it is that Eric Stern conducts that orchestra like it's on fire and I'm obsessed. But the singular focus that she has, it is controlled, but it is not studied. It is... Every other Mama Rose, I would argue, after Merman, there's always a little something that keeps her from being,
SPEAKER_01I guess, the ultimate, I suppose. And with Daly, for people, it was The Voice. You watch bootlegs of her. She's in far better voice than she is on the cast recording. And once that hurdle is cleared, you're like, well, she's the best. Because it's just the... The drive she has is incredible. And she's sexy and funny and terrifying. I love what she does with Rose's Turn. I love what she does in Everything's Coming Up, Rose's. You can tell back in the old Tonys when it was in a Broadway theater and it was just the community. It wasn't like 3,000 fans of Radio City can buy a ticket.
SPEAKER_01You understood from the shouts in the balcony where the community was supporting behind. And Dorothy Lauderdale winning for Annie, where it's like a full 30 seconds before she can speak because everyone's just so thrilled for her. And Daley winning the entire mezzanine of the La Fontaine is just filled with gays. And they are ecstatic for her. And that is how you know that she ruled. She's also the only Mama Rose to lead a Tony winning revival of Gypsy. No other revival of Gypsy has ever won. Just heard.
SPEAKER_03I legitimately think she's better than Merman. And I know that's sacrilege and I will go to hell for it. I don't care.
SPEAKER_01Well, keep that in mind for later.
SPEAKER_03I know.
SPEAKER_00I know. Well, I think Merman set the template and we have her to thank for how the role is structured and set and on her and what she did. And then other people came along and added to it. And maybe you think that the others are better. Look at me steering away from the controversy now. You said a match to the house, Steve, and now you're working way taintily. There are other people who create a role and, like, they own it. I think Merman has the role and other people can come in and, you know, that's why we've had a million revivals of it because other people can come
SPEAKER_00and do it too.
SPEAKER_03And I also think Merman would probably one of the first to tell you that she didn't think of herself as a capital A actor.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03She was Ethel Merman and she played Ethel Merman and he wrote for Ethel Merman.
SPEAKER_01It was the most acting anyone ever saw her do. But it's yes, better actresses played it since her. But the thing about Merman and Gypsy and like owning the role, what's interesting is that in a way she still does kind of own it, but not in the way of like Streisand and Funny Girl where it's just like this huge shadow. There's actually there's because so many great women have played the role. And the show is so good. There's leniency. There's leeway. So like there's still people can have their favorites, but there is like they're always that little Merman mark on it forever, even if it's not like a death grip, which I like.
SPEAKER_03There's just something so captivating about Tyne putting on Merman's coat. Like her performance in Call Me Madam for Encores is transcendently good. It's my favorite Irving Berlin cast album of all time. If that had transferred to Broadway, I would have single handedly championed her to a Tony win. She was so good in Call Me Madam. And it's another Merman role that time just redefined for me.
SPEAKER_01She's so good. People don't give her enough cred. I have only had the privilege of seeing her live on stage once in Mothers and Sons.
SPEAKER_03You didn't go to Shut Up and You?
SPEAKER_01I did not go see It Should Have Been You. I don't like gay stuff, Maggie. Makes me uncomfortable. Spoiler you. Especially when they're happy. Yeah, spoiler for the second act of that show.
SPEAKER_02Billy, I beg to differ with you. How do you mean? You're the top. You're an arrow collar.
SPEAKER_00You're the top. You're a Coolidge dollar.
SPEAKER_01All right, guys, that's going to do it for this preview of the latest Broadway Breakdown Green Room Roundtable. It's quite a mouthful there. To listen to the full thing, you can click the link to the Patreon in the description box. There are already some other wonderful exclusives, including full video footage of this episode. It's going to be a minute till we come back in the full swing of Broadway Breakdown, so I hope that this was a nice little amuse-bouche for you. The next episode, we're going to come back in about two weeks, and there will be a full review episode
SPEAKER_01of my London trip covering seven West End shows, the Sinatra musical, Kimberly Akimbo, Avenue Q, Cats in Regents Park, Midnight at the Never Get, the Thelma and Louise musical, and How the Other Half Loves. If you haven't joined the Patreon Green Room yet, you will get a lot of that material early. You will also get exclusive audio vlogs or blogs. What would you call it? Audio plug, like a podcast blog, something like that.
SPEAKER_01Well, in real time while I'm in London. So that'll be sort of a nice immediate Broadway Breakdown fix for anyone who wants that. But if you are okay and you don't really necessarily want travel plugs while I'm there, you don't have to subscribe. You can wait for the full episode in about two weeks. And then after that, we're going to really get back into the swing of things. We're going to have more reviews coming. Our first Broadway review is going to be Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls Play at Manhattan Theater Club. Some of the off-Broadway stuff that's been coming up, such as Midnight and in honor of Jean Basquit from New York Theater Workshop,
SPEAKER_01Truly Howard Hughes, things like that. And then we will announce the official selections for Broadway Breakdown deep dives. Your guess is as good as mine in this exact moment what those selections are, but they will be announced in the next three to four weeks. And yeah, that's when we're going to really kind of go back and hit the ground running. There will be deep dives, there will be reviews, there will be Tony Awards coverage, there will be some more interviews. And again, if you haven't joined the green room and you're like,
SPEAKER_01well, Matt, why would I care about getting episodes early and ad free? You don't have ads right now. Yes, not right now, but soon enough, there will be ads. I can't say any more in this exact moment, but stay tuned towards the end of September, early October, and you will get a nice little announcement of some of the Reasons why there were going to be ads again on the podcast. I'm sure I'm going on for far too long for this PostScript, but you guys know that I'm a long-winded asshole, so here we are. All right, that's it for the preview. Again, if you want to listen to the full two hours and hear everybody's selections for all
SPEAKER_01the categories, and if you want to also access the Excel file, the spreadsheet, so you can make your own selections, Click the link for the green room in the description box. And that is going to be it for today. I'm off to London in two days. So see you guys when I get back. Cheerio, pip pip.
SPEAKER_03I'm as corny as Kansas in August High as a flag on the 4th of July If you'll excuse an expression I use I'm in love, I'm in love, I'm in love, I'm in love I'm in love with a wonderful guy
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...