Matt was gonna take a week off but Michael Paulson decided to write an article. Matt goes into the latest NY Times “Doom and Gloom” piece about the state of Broadway musicals and what it gets right…and what it leaves out. Is the Broadway musical doomed? Or is this a turning point? Matt looks at this past season, the seasons before it, and last week’s grosses to figure out where we go from here. Tune in :) Important Links: Broadway Breakdown: Discord Broadway Breakdown: Substack Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Listener Questions: “Is this the end of the Broadway musical? Or is this a turning point?” “When was the last time a Broadway musical was the center of culture?” “What kind of lessons can Broadway take from the new wave of Hollywood hits?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. This episode actually was going to not exist. I was going to have just a blank episode this week because, due to scheduling reasons, nothing was really lining up to have an episode released. We have two more deep dives that we are doing
SPEAKER_01and scheduling wise it just hasn't really synced up yet for us to release the episodes and then we were doing a conversation with a listener of the podcast who also happens to work in the industry to talk about this past season and what we can learn from it and looking at next season and what we can sort of expect and that episode is still happening but again due to scheduling reasons we couldn't get it done in time for this week so I was like you know what we'll just let this one slide And then there was an article that came out in the New York Times in the last 24 hours that I thought was interesting and I wanted to address
SPEAKER_01because it actually kind of includes a whole bunch of Broadway news. And we haven't really done an episode about Broadway grosses in a while. I thought that we could sort of include that in this subject matter which is to say that Michael Paulson of the New York Times had an article come out and it is called what happened to Broadway's new musicals this year they vanished and it's highlighting how Hollywood actors in big plays and investors who are nervous and landlords who are kind of being keeping things close to the vest have created a shortened pipeline of new musicals on Broadway now
SPEAKER_01First things first if you know Michael Paulson if you know his work in the New York Times you know that he isn't necessarily lying he's also not necessarily a sensationalist but he is very much a Debbie Downer and that's not to say that he's someone who provides facts you don't want to hear it's that he provides facts and his interpretation is always a bit doom and gloom and There are things that he doesn't really consider in his article that I would like us to consider as we sort of scan through it and talk about next season.
SPEAKER_01So at the top of the article, right at the start, he says how coming out of the pandemic, we had a whole bunch of new musicals. for every season. There were 14 new musicals in the 2024 to 2025 season. That was the maybe happy ending death becomes her season. And then there were 15 the year before that. That was the Illinois' Outsiders' Suf's year. And he says now almost all of them were flops. The industry took note because this past season we only had six new musicals, two of which were Beej's and Queen of Versailles, and they were
SPEAKER_01Notorious Disasters and then the other one is Galileo which has been sort of kicking around most recently at Berkeley Rep and that one is going into the Schubert wanted going into the James Earl Jones and he's also saying
SPEAKER_01that it doesn't necessarily have to be this way because there are musicals that are wanting to come to Broadway but there are many things that are keeping them from doing so so Right off the top. Yes, we did have 14 new musicals last season. And we had 15 the year before that. That is not normal. That is not how Broadway has been even before the pandemic. If you look at seasons prior to 2020, we average about 10 new musicals a season,
SPEAKER_01which is, you know, a healthy number, but that is not 15. In 2019, we had 11. Also, some of these are technicalities because I was going through Wikipedia trying to you know discern how many new musicals there were every season and Wikipedia would include things like you know all about me the Dave Edna concert one woman show sort of thing and so my assumption is that that was considered eligible by the Tony committee but like that's not really a new musical but even so with that said uh 2019 we had 11
SPEAKER_01uh we had seven in 2018 just seven so that's only one more than this past year uh 2017 was the most we've had in about 30 years 2017 the most new musicals we've had in a single year in 30 years which was 13 uh sorry I should say sorry not 30 years because we had post-pandemic shows but um you know what I mean from 1996 to 2019 2017 had the most new musicals with 13 and 2016 had 11 then back to 10 12 in 2014 and then prior to 2014 we're flop flopping from 8 to 10 to 11 7 from 2002 to 2004 it was sorry from 2001
SPEAKER_01to 2004 we had seven new musicals every year um and and On those years, we would have two, sometimes three new musicals recouping. Worst case scenario, one. 1999, we had eight. None of those shows recouped.
SPEAKER_011998, we had eight or nine new musicals, depending on your litmus test of that. And only one of those recouped, which was The Lion King. 1997, we had seven new musicals. None of them recouped. 1996, seven new musicals. Two recouped. So let's start with that, which is to say that new musicals recouping on Broadway has always been rare. It is high risk, high reward. It is not normal to have 15 new musicals in a season. Honestly, probably not since the 1940s or 50s.
SPEAKER_01And to see how this is nothing new, all you have to do is read William Goldman's The Season to learn how doom and gloom on Broadway has always been the case. As Al Hirschfeld said in Broadway The Golden Age, I've been hearing about the death of Broadway since I was wearing short pants. And Same is true here Michael Paulson is not wrong The numbers don't lie We did have 14 last year 15 the year before That is not normal So why did we have so many? when prior to the pandemic we you know would max out at 13 over the course of 24
SPEAKER_01or five years well one thing that Paulson does talk about is how there was a backup of new musicals that kind of came in a flurry when Broadway reopened after a year and a half of being closed and a lot of shows did not come back so all these open theaters so that's one thing there was available real estate another thing was there was a major uh tax incentive with new works on Broadway action with all Broadway shows that allowed shows to have a better chance of recoupment because even if you only like recoup 90% of your investment once you got your tax incentive at
SPEAKER_01the end of your run that kind of pushed you into the black that was something that happened with the revival of Parade as I understand it Parade almost fully recouped in its Broadway run. I believe it lost money on the road, but due to its tax write-off, it ended up recouping overall at the end of when all was said and done. So there was a lot of incentive to bring shows to Broadway. There was money there, and then there was also money to be gained from the tax write-off. So that was one thing. So a lot of shows came to Broadway because the money was there,
SPEAKER_01the theater was ready, and that's that. Why did a lot of these shows flop? Well, first things first, we had 15 shows in a season. That is an insane amount of supply and not that much demand. Not when we were still having issues with tourism, people were afraid to fly, people were afraid to fly. Tickets are very
SPEAKER_01I mean I also don't think harmony was terribly good but that's my own opinion but that kind of leans into another thing which is a lot of these shows came to Broadway whether they were ready or not it was just that the money was there the theater was available and if you look at a lot of these shows in the last season
SPEAKER_01or the season before or the season before that look at the critical reception that they got and the audience reception that they got yes you know all of these shows every single one of these shows has their fans but there is still a narrative that persists that many of these shows just were not fully cooked yet or they were a bad idea sometimes shows are a bad idea a show like Heart of Rock and Roll fun as it was really needed a second look to get really streamlined to be the tightest version of itself when it came to Broadway it was sort of like
SPEAKER_01a third draft of a show that needed a fourth draft Something like Boop comes to Broadway and it has an out of town tryout but if you read the reviews from out of town all the critics say while this is very fun and Jasmine Amy Rogers is a star and This book needs a giant facelift and gave bullet points of all the things that needed to get changed and Boop, I think, adhered to like 20% of those changes. So when it didn't do well on Broadway, people can be upset, but you cannot be surprised. We've had Broadway musicals recoup that have opened post-COVID.
SPEAKER_01We've had jukebox musicals like And Juliet and MJ, as I said, Kimberly Akimbo, and I believe Some Like It Hot also recouped on the road. Shucked did very well on the road and recouped. I believe Suffs recouped on the road. The Outsiders has actually recouped on Broadway during its Broadway run. It is possible. People have been able to do it. And to say nothing of, you know, very expensive revivals like Sweeney Todd and Merrily We Roll Along that have recouped into the woods. Not expensive, but recouped. Just investing on Broadway in general has always been a gamble. It's a bigger gamble now because there's more money at stake
SPEAKER_01and things are more expensive to keep running. But ultimately, when you have a surplus of shows waiting in the wings, and then all of a sudden there's an opportunity rather than stop and think huh are we ready to go and you just sort of go there is a butterfly effect to that so boob coming to Broadway and not fixing all of its problems Lempicka coming to Broadway and not fixing all of its problems Redwood coming to Broadway at all all of that impacts the shows after that right that that is something that everyone in the industry has
SPEAKER_01to consider no one wants to make a bad show that's never anyone's intention But in order to make a good show you have to be incredibly shrewd and you also have to be ruthless you have to be willing to kill your own darlings if it is what's best for the show you also need to check your ego and understand that sometimes the best idea is not going to be your idea if you want to be a good collaborator you have to acknowledge when someone on your team has the correct idea even if it overshadows your contribution right
SPEAKER_01and you often hear stories of songs that are kept in shows because it's the songwriter's favorite and they really fought for it or a moment that you know the star performer really demanded to keep in there even though it ultimately kills the vibe of the show also You hear these stories of songs getting rousing standing ovations or songs going viral on TikTok and Instagram. But then the song in the show is actually kind of detrimental to the show itself. Think about a funny thing happened on the way to the forum. the infamous story of the opening number of that show where you know
SPEAKER_01the script is kind of locked and loaded it's it's it is set and Sondheim basically has to write songs around it and so the trick is to find songs in moments of the show where the audience needs a breeder and the opening number was a tough nut originally to crack Sondheim wrote a song that told the audience straight up front this is a Greek show but it's not about tragedy or war this is a comedy and the director George Abbott said I cannot hum this we cannot set the show on the foot of you know atonal music give me a song I can hum so Sondheim writes
SPEAKER_01a little soft shoe called love is in the air which is you know kind of accurate to what the vibe of forum was in terms of the themes but they go out of town with the show and it's just dying everywhere it's going it's dying and they don't know what to do and Jerome Robbins comes in and he sees the show and he goes the opening number is wrong what you have is a big brassy farce and you open the show with a very soft lovey-dovey soft shoe everyone thinks they're about to see a Noel Coward show and then you give them borscht belt So you need to tell them that that's what this is and Sondheim gets all grumpy
SPEAKER_01and he goes well I did that but George Abbott said he couldn't hum it and Jerome Robbins says okay Steve do another one that he can hum and Sondheim to his credit was like you know what fair let me let me do the same mentality of the first song give it the hummability of the second song and give it the energy that will set the tone of the show and that's what gave us comedy tonight and that's what made the show work so rather than digging in his heels and going no I did my job you you should look to George Abbott to make it work they all figured out what to do how to make it all work and there are other songs
SPEAKER_01that in other shows that are beautiful songs that get cut because we just need to get to a plot point faster think of um Come Down from the Tree from Once on this Island beautiful Aronson Flaherty song you should listen to it on I think it's in the Lost in Boston series Lilius White sings it and it's gorgeous Audra McDonald also sings it I believe and it's a wonderful wonderful song sung to T-Moon right after the opening number but ultimately it was decided that we needed to get to adult T-Moon faster because we needed to get to the inciting incident of the show which is T-Moon and Daniel and that love story
SPEAKER_01so we we did not have three and a half minutes to spare to sit and watch you know child T-Moon come down from the tree even though it does tie into the end of the show and ultimately that is for the best we don't get stories like that really anymore with new Broadway musicals you don't hear stories of a song that was great that people loved but ultimately it wasn't healthy enough for the show getting cut okay so Michael Paulson says what happened how did the new musical long uh long Broadway's fundamental building block become so scarce that the new drama critics circle opted to forego an award this year
SPEAKER_01for best musical and two of the five nominations for best score went to music composed for plays well they didn't have to go to plays they could have gone to Queen of Versailles and beaches but the Tony nominators were being bitches this year listen I do not begrudge them beaches that show is a show I do begrudge them Queen of Versailles it's not a great score but worst scores have been nominated this leads us to the three bullet points that Paulson talks about of what ultimately is leading us to this what he calls dearth of new musicals we already started to talk about
SPEAKER_01the art portion he says art money and real estate art aka a script and for musicals a score that are both more or less ready to go we already kind of talked about this but that is a major component to why a lot of these shows have not found success on Broadway is there are ideas there there are things that work but there are a lot of either super large chunks that are muddled for me that was something like Boop where I thought that the script was just so confused and I thought that there were two or three banger songs and then like a bunch of songs
SPEAKER_01that were just sort of there and second point money mounting a play or musical cost millions of dollars this is also true there is a new uh tax incentive for New York State with Broadway theater I'm not sure how it uh relates to the previous one I'm not sure uh if it's quite as um enticing as it once was but there is that has been implemented still and thus uh investors could have more reason to invest in some of these shows
SPEAKER_01but it is costing more money these days one is inflation she's a bitch to everybody second is I hate to say this but unions union negotiations over the years have created higher price tags for everybody involved some of those are absolutely warranted landlords are also asking for I don't know
SPEAKER_01where a listener who is an aspiring associate producer, won't say their name, but they showed me the breakdown of the running costs for this revival that they were asked to be an associate on. And they said no, even though it was very enticing, it was going to have a lot of clout to it. and did but he said showing me this breakdown he was like there's absolutely no way that they're going to recoup or even like recoup half of their investment
SPEAKER_01on this he's like the running cost is insane he's like and look at this and he showed me that there was a section where there were producer fees for the top producers of this revival now producer fees are not totally out of the ordinary but ultimately Most producers take a small fee just you know so they can keep their offices running so they can you know do their business day to day and ultimately they're doing their job which is keeping the show running but they do not get a giant chunk unless the show is making a lot
SPEAKER_01of money again it's sort of you know they need incentive for the show to do well so they will do their hardest to make it work because if they do their hardest and it succeeds then they make a lot of money from how from what the show makes but you see more of these fees getting into the five digit quadrant which which when the these salaries pile up that's adding another like 100k to a lot of these shows running costs there are some musical revivals in the last like two or three years that could have run for like 150k less but I digress and then
SPEAKER_01the third point that Paulson says is real estate Broadway has 41 theaters operated by a small coterie of landlords they are indeed one of the bigger villains of Broadway right now I will say and new musicals must compete with starry play productions as well as revivals to land a home there was a time when theater owners actually would invest in these shows that ran in their theaters if you read Gerald Schoenfeld's book I think it's called Mr. Broadway he talks about that the Schubert's when he and Bernie Jacobs took over
SPEAKER_01the Schubert's again to kind of give them an incentive to You know, They also would invest money in shows like Chess which did not work out or Big Deal
SPEAKER_01which also didn't work out but they it was their prerogative then to make these shows have the best chance of success as they could so when the show didn't work they couldn't blame anyone but everyone in the room with them right themselves their collaborators it was like you know it didn't work what can we learn so we can make the next one work right it's very it's very rare when a show works when it's like really just fan-fucking-tastic where every element is right and it still flops it happens it's rarer
SPEAKER_01than you would think even the shows that I love that I think are fantastic and did not work that did not land with audiences I can understand why I think Carolina Change is one of the greatest musicals of the 21st century and that original production was fucking poetry I fully understand why it did not land with people it is a tough cookie to you know munch on it is music that is not for everybody and it is a leading character who is a tough set and it's and it's racial politics
SPEAKER_01that do not make liberal white audiences comfortable because it does not uh what's it looking for it does not placate to what they want to hear right Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01But this is to say I'm sorry I went off a whole tangent me tangents you see these theater owners you see that now they are very few of them are actually investing money into any
SPEAKER_01of these shows if at all uh the rent that they are charging for so many of these shows is astronomical uh friend of the pod lucas mcmahon who is a producer on six and has been a producer on mrs doubtfire and oh mary He was on the podcast many many years ago back in like the 1.0 version and he talked about how theater fees theater rental fees are the number one cost for any Broadway show it's the it's the biggest financial burden
SPEAKER_01of any show's budget And always will be. Some shows have gotten lucky in the last couple of years due to theater sitting empty and landlords desperately wanting the theater to be filled. I know for a fact that part of the reason why Beaches and Titanic were able to go to Broadway was that the Schubert's and ATG respectively gave them extraordinarily good deals on their rent. just so that way the theater could be filled. These theater owners want shows that make money for them. And while a Broadway musical could be successful, more likely is not going to be.
SPEAKER_01They need the theater to be full. They need people to be buying refreshments and merchandise. And even if, say, something like, you know, Hell's Kitchen is technically running, but it's running at half capacity for six months. that's you know 750 people a night who are not buying concessions as opposed to art at the music box which is fully selling out 1100 you know seats a night
SPEAKER_01That's a lot of people buying wine and soda and popcorn and what and what have you. So, yeah, there's definitely a lot of gatekeeping going on there. And I think many of these landlords need to have their feet held to the coals so they can feel a little more pressure about all of this. The rest of the article goes on to talk about a lot of the expenses. As I mentioned, there's inflation. There is union pricing. There is also a lot of issues with, you know, our current administration and trading goods tariffs, if you will, that has definitely sped up the inflation
SPEAKER_01The other thing is that because the price is so high on a lot of these shows, the price tag on tickets is also incredibly high. It's been high for a very long time and it just keeps getting higher and the price of tickets are not matching where people are at financially. And so people are less likely to take a risk on a new musical if it got mediocre reviews or it has tepid word of mouth. People always say, oh, don't listen to critics. They don't matter. The New York Times doesn't have the clout that people think it does.
SPEAKER_01And that's true. The New York Times itself cannot kill a show. Reviewers alone cannot kill a show. But think of it like Grubhub or Yelp. If you're looking for a place to go for a date, let's say, or you're looking to order in for a Friday night, and you're looking at the ratings that all these restaurants or these bars have, you are more likely to go for a place that has four and a half stars from 3,000 reviews than a place that has three stars from 1,000 reviews.
SPEAKER_01Now, it's possible that... The Place with Three Stars has just been very unlucky and has had like 900 Karens take to the internet to fully sync their rating by a full star and it actually could be this amazing hole in the wall hidden secret that you would love but you're not going to take that risk and the same is true of Broadway if you are coming in from out of town or if you're just a New Yorker in general and you're interested to see what the season has to offer and you read
SPEAKER_01The New York Times for a new musical and the review was kind of tepid and you go I don't know well let me see what Variety had to say Variety is also kind of tepid then you read The Hollywood Reporter that one's positive but then you read Entertainment Weekly if you're reading Entertainment Weekly and that one's negative you're reading Vulture that That one's negative Then you're reading Charles Isherwood Wherever the fuck he's writing now And that one's positive You don't know where to go And then you're starting to ask around You're looking on show score You're going on Instagram And ultimately the vibe is just not selling And thus you don't put your money there You put your money towards something else
SPEAKER_01That has much greater confirmation for you It's something that ticket pricing is something between producers and landlords. Again, we're talking about these very frustrating landlords. There's this expectation that because the tickets are scarce, you're only getting a couple hundred seats a night for what should be this big event that you should want to see. The pricing comes in way too high and people get turned off
SPEAKER_01and they do not buy their tickets and then the prices get lowered eventually because nobody's buying the tickets and that then puts a stink on your show rather than starting at a reasonable place where people will be willing to shelve out say 75 bucks for you know a real orchestra seat to see something they've never seen before take a chance on it then if they love it they'll tell people they might even go again if this if the tickets are still reasonable and that's something to think about but that's not something that a lot of Broadway is doing you're slowly starting to see it for example Paulson talks
SPEAKER_01about Wanted and Galileo and Wanted announced their Broadway run rather early a few months ago and so they have a very long trailway before their Broadway opening and they are being very smart by offering very reasonably priced tickets early in the run in previews and right after opening this is something we saw also with Shocked this is something we saw with many new musicals that either didn't have an out-of-town tryout or their out-of-town tryout was so long ago that they need to build up buzz again so they need to fill the theater even if you look at Paddington
SPEAKER_01which also has announced it's probably run officially at the Hirschfeld we talked about this before you're welcome Paddington's pricing for all of its you know three weeks of previews is pretty you know decent for what is a big ticket musical for a show that you know is coming directly from London where it's sold out until September that has won seven Olivier's is critically acclaimed it's IP that is very recognizable it's going into a theater with 1400 seats which is a very nicely sized theater but considering people thought it might go into the St. James which has another 300 seats
SPEAKER_01They could really be doing dynamic pricing up the ass and fuck themselves. And for the first three or four weeks, it's actually pretty okay. It gets pricier after opening night, but not by like a huge margin. Those are definitely prices that they will hike up if the demand calls for it. It's a very tricky game to figure out, right? He quotes the head of Broadway banking at City National Bank, Eric
SPEAKER_01Peacock? Pycook? Pycook? Who says that Broadway itself is an optimistic industry. Nothing makes sense. None of it pencils out. But despite that, you still see bank accounts open up for shows that could be six months down the line, five years down the line. There's a pipeline of shows that are being developed, and this is true. Many shows are waiting. There's also new roads that come to Broadway that everyone is trying to reconfigure. Out-of-town tryouts are... very helpful they are also the most expensive way to see
SPEAKER_01if your show works more often more often now we are seeing shows doing workshops and then opening directly on Broadway things like the Lost Boys that is very scary because if there are bumps in the show you don't know until it's in front of an audience and the minute you do your first preview you It's out on the internet and people start finding out about songs that are terrible that need to get cut and maybe you do cut the song but you still have to waft off that stink for about three or four weeks and that those three or four weeks are money that you could be losing right now you want to
SPEAKER_01whether you like it or not as a Broadway producer or Broadway creative the moment your show starts performances in New York City it's basically open as far as the internet is concerned it's unfair because but it's the truth and so you have to think about just how ready your thing is how fully baked your thing is and if it's not fully baked be prepared and be ready to make changes quickly because the only way to ward off the sense of doom for your show
SPEAKER_01if something isn't working is to change things immediately and get those people who wrote you off early to come back and see the progress you've made which has happened it's absolutely happened But out-of-town tryouts themselves are still the best road to Broadway What an out-of-town tryout looks like now is a little different It used to be that you raised your capital You found a theater in Chicago or Boston, D.C. If you really wanted to get out of the way, Seattle or San Francisco And you would do about four to six weeks You would put your show up in front of
SPEAKER_01the audience You would get reviewed by the critics If it was working, word of mouth would come to Broadway you would tool it up and you would be coming in knowing what you had with what you think is the best version of it and people getting buzzed you hear success stories about this all the time like Hairspray uh trying out in Seattle I would love to do a deep dive episode on Hairspray and really talk about the uh out of town process with that because the thing about Hairspray that was so exciting was it was a movie that it was IP that was known
SPEAKER_01but it was not like they were adapting Jurassic Park this was not a billion dollar movie that the world knew this was a cult film that was the most successful film of John Waters who was the king of cult films and so it had a fan base it made a star of Ricky Lake but it wasn't a super known property and so it was more that there were you know a couple hundred thousand people who had their eye on it all of them in New York and when it goes to Seattle the reviews are such that everyone in New York takes notice and so when it comes
SPEAKER_01to New York that very first preview it's like 98% the Hairspray that we know and love and it goes off like fucking gangbusters and when I tell you that New York exploded from that first preview and that show became a sellout hit right after that preview That is the benefit of taking the time to really develop your show, going out of town with your show, and really experimenting with what you have and what the audience is responding to and how that can benefit New York ticket buyers. As I said, that is expensive.
SPEAKER_01So now out-of-town tryouts are more looking like going to a regional house like La Jolla, Old Globe, the ART in Massachusetts, and offsetting some of your costs with the regional theater. You're not officially an out-of-town tryout. You are a regional premier. But if all things go well, you can invite commercial producers to the production, see what you got, explain how much money you need to go to Broadway and what that money would be going for, or going to, and do your best to get that thing straight to Broadway as fast as possible
SPEAKER_01the hardship of that is by being a regional premiere you do not already have a theater locked and loaded in New York sometimes there's like back-end deals where you can sort of where producers kind of figure that out up front but a lot of times you see and we're seeing this right now these shows that do well regionally and then try to raise their funds to go to Broadway but they don't have that Broadway theater locked in yet so it actually ends up being two three sometimes four years before it finally comes to Broadway where as opposed to something like a hairspray uh or producers
SPEAKER_01or more recently you know uh god bless them like a queen of Versailles or last year death becomes her they did their out-of-town tryout with a theater in mind already so they didn't have that much long to wait between out-of-town tryout and Broadway they could come in Ready to go
SPEAKER_01that shows will do when it's not an out of town tryout when it's not a regional premiere when it's not a workshop is they will do off Broadway which is something that Paulson also sort of talks about we have this season we have The Heart which is going off Broadway at the roundabout it also had a regional production I think at La Jolla and then we also have The Curious Case of Benjamin Button which I saw in London and reviewed in a past London episode if you want to hear about that which is having its off-Broadway premiere at The Public I actually think that's a very good idea for both of these shows because and he talks about it
SPEAKER_01in this article that these are musicals that have a lot of credibility to them they got good reviews strong audience responses but ultimately they are still not fully sellable to investors for a Broadway run they need one last step of convincing and the heart and Benjamin Button are shows that are small enough that they can get done off-Broadway at the public or roundabout and it's not quite
SPEAKER_01the financial burden for these non-profit companies in their off-Broadway houses I think uh according to Paulson the heart has commercial producers attached uh same producers who are attached to come from away uh so there my assumption is that those producers are talking to landlords and saying this is what we're looking for if the show works we want to go directly to Broadway that season we do not want to wait because if you wait then you end up being a dead outlaw where you have a full year where you lose all of your buzz right same thing with Benjamin Button I would imagine that
SPEAKER_01the producers that are attached to that show are making it known to uh investors and landlords that this is a show that works it's been proven to work in London they are trying it here in a lower stakes environment just to really kind of guarantee what they got and if it and if it if that check clears they plan to go that happens more often now um not every show makes that work for them for every Kimberly Akimbo or Days of Wine
SPEAKER_01and Roses or pre-pandemic we have um Bands Visit or Spring Awakening or Grey Gardens right now and uh Paulson Cranston The Bedwetter
SPEAKER_01Matt Koplik Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
SPEAKER_01Matt Koplik How's the budget looking? All of these shows you have to ask yourself what is the budget? What is the capitalization? A lot of these budgets seem higher than they probably are because workshops
SPEAKER_01and developmental readings are all get rolled into capitalization for a Broadway show you saw this happen with Natasha Peer and the Great Comet of 1812 part of their price tag came from uh the ART production and I think even the off-Broadway casino production so they while they only returned like 30 percent of their investment it could have been 50 if they hadn't rolled in the price tag from off-Broadway and Boston uh you also have shows that had regional premieres in uh
SPEAKER_01Old Globe like Regency Girls which had a very strong reception and has a commercial producer Rodman Goodman attached Goodman explains in Paulson's article that their problem is just raising money now from what I understand about Regency Girls which they describe as Bridesmaids beats Bridgerton uh I understand that Regency Girls is very good it is subject matter that is very particular in fact I would say it's sort of like Bridesmeans meets Bridgerton meets Sufts if Sufts were willing to go harder
SPEAKER_01because it's a comedy but it's a comedy about birth control as from what I understand I think is an amazing concept and gonna be hard to sell that to a lot of people and they're kind of sticking to their guns of not having a major name attached they have been flirting with the idea of getting some like big names into Regency Girls ultimately I don't think they can really find anybody with true name recognition who's right for any of the roles so now they're trying to look at like big Broadway names but big Broadway names don't
SPEAKER_01really sell they will sell with tried and true properties like Kelly O'Hara in a revival of like I don't know if we were to do Music Man again I know it's soon but like let's say sure to do Music Man again that would sell more than Kelly O'Hara in Days of Wine and Roses look at Kelly O'Hara in Fallen Angels right with uh Rose Byrne Rose Byrne already a bigger name than Kelly but the two of them together in a non-profit where there is a subscriber base in a 700 seat theater of a property that is by Noel Coward that's a lot of uh those are
SPEAKER_01a lot of names that thrown together lead to ticket sales as opposed to Kelly O'Hara and Brian Darcy James in a musical version of a movie that a lot of people don't know and once you hear the plot it's very depressing right names very rarely alone sell tickets because then Paulson talks about how a lot of theaters instead want to go for plays primarily plays starring movie stars or TV stars because those are more short bets sometimes they are Sometimes They've proven to be A good investment For Robert Downey Jr
SPEAKER_01For Denzel Washington For George Clooney Less so for Adrian Brody Less so for John Bernthal Dog Day Afternoon is a property That a lot of people know Those two men are very well known For their TV work A little bit for their film work and Dog Day Afternoon started with very high ticket sales it is now on TDF for every performance whereas they were easily clearing a million dollars a week like 1.1 1.2 million dollars a week during previews and soon after opening reviews and word of mouth and lack of Tony's have absolutely killed its buzz and now it is averaging way lower we will talk about
SPEAKER_01that in a second when we get to grosses but the same thing for the fear of 13 which has cut its run short starring Adrian Brody pretty soon after his second Oscar win and you know feel how you feel about Brody he is a name and was a bit of a draw for fear of 13 again at the beginning of previews him and Tessa Thompson together in this technically speaking transfer from London where it got Olivier nominated no ticket sales started strong and then it's taken a nosedive word of mouth is a major killer so even no named actors are not necessarily a done deal there has
SPEAKER_01to be something beyond that there has to be it has to resonate with the demographic that you're trying to reach that's buying these tickets you see I talked about this kind of recently I mentioned the movie Obsession and if any of you are movie people or even box office people you'll know that Obsession is having a historic box office run right now a movie that cost less than a million dollars to make it was purchased by Focus Features for 15 million dollars it opens at 17 about six weeks ago
SPEAKER_01and in the last six and a half weeks the movie has now grossed 220 million dollars that is more than 12 times its opening weekend 12 time multiplier of its opening weekend kind of like that is unheard of in the 21st century we haven't seen a run like this in literal decades and in fact Obsession is famously made more money on its second weekend than its first weekend and then made more money on its third weekend than its second weekend. And that has only happened in the last 40 years to movies that have opened at Christmas time.
SPEAKER_01Anything else does not do that. The last movie to do what Obsession did that wasn't a holiday movie was E.T. in 1982. So why is it that Obsession is doing so well? Well, first of all, it is a good movie. It's a good concept that is told well. It's got very good acting. Excellent acting if you're an Indian ever-eddy. But it's also striking a chord with a particular audience. The Gen Z moviegoers see this movie and they see themselves on screen and they see themselves being portrayed well and interestingly
SPEAKER_01and thought-provokingly. And it's a movie that is touching on a feeling that a lot of people have or a lot of people don't understand. The idea of autonomy, toxic relationships, the difference between romance and obsession, between love and romance. of intimacy of communication of loneliness of isolation of how the nice guy can actually become a predator all of these things are in this you know 100 minute horror film and I question to you what's
SPEAKER_01the last Broadway musical you can think of that was able to touch on something a nerve like that in a way that became a conversation let's like exclude nationally because obviously Broadway is exclusive you can only see a Broadway show on Broadway and if you're lucky it's 1800 people a night usually it's about 1000 1100 people a night so you're not getting you know half a million people across the country every day seeing your film or seeing your Broadway show But what was the last Broadway musical you can think of that really started
SPEAKER_01a cultural conversation in New York? I can't really think of one post-COVID. I really can't. Best one I can think of is probably Dear Evan Hansen. Probably. And then that started its own conversation when it went viral on Love It or Leave It. But even the musicals that have done well on Broadway... they aren't really creating a conversation they're doing well within the subsect of Broadway theater goers but it's not branching out and before you say
SPEAKER_01to me well Matt how far can Broadway really reach I would argue that there are Broadway players Right? Right?
SPEAKER_01We have had quite a few plays. People knew about Appropriate. Yes, Sarah Paulson was the star, but Sarah Paulson is not Meryl Streep. She is not this internationally renowned movie star. She's not leading billion dollar franchises. She is one of the leading ladies of the camp cult gay demographic. The Ryan Murphy fandom, if you will. and so her being on Broadway inappropriate yes was big but also it was that appropriate as a play became a talking point for a lot
SPEAKER_01of theater goers it became a hot ticket because of its quality and because of its subject matter and because of its excellence and that is something that I don't see a lot of Broadway musicals happening and that is something that Paulson isn't really talking about in his article he does talk about the financials he does talk about the theater owners he does talk about how There were an influx of new musicals that came and sort of went, but he doesn't really talk about how none of them lived up to their reputation of being the American musical.
SPEAKER_01In the article, people are being interviewed and they're saying like, we're going to stick with it because this is what we do. Broadway does musical theater better than anyone. not always not always many of these musicals have blown many for many of them the reason why they did not succeed was because they blew now he does talk about lack of theater availability and a lot of these shows looking for the right theater so with that in mind let us take a quick look at last week's grosses and see where we are at in terms of theater availability. Keep in mind that this past weekend was Father's Day as well as Juneteenth.
SPEAKER_01I'm not sure how many people are going to see a Broadway show to celebrate Juneteenth, but, you know, maybe more than I expect. I don't know. When it comes to Pride, I tend to just sort of stay on my couch and watch Sense and Sensibility. Other people like to go out and party. Maybe other people want to go and see, you know, Death Becomes Her. That is their right. But so looking at the grosses from this past week, we've had quite a few shows go up in their grosses, a few go down, some by a large amount, some incrementally.
SPEAKER_01Right at the top we have N. Juliet, which grossed just over $600,000 at 72% capacity. and you take out credit card fees that's about half a million dollars for a show that costs about 750 to run maybe eight at this point now Chrissy Metz is in the show I believe this gross reflects her first weekend in the show so we'll see if she sells plenty of tickets during her run however I have been seeing Angelia on TDF quite a lot still and she while she's in the show so I can't imagine that
SPEAKER_01that's going to help much but also I'll be honest and Juliet's kind of been a life support for about a year now and if they aren't calling it quits by the end of the summer I don't know when they are but the Sondheim is you know a medium-sized theater it's a little over a thousand seats it is kind of in a shitty location and it's not a great looking theater but One of Vista Social Club
SPEAKER_01Continuously filled the theater not always to huge profits but it has it has tended to fill the theater above 80 or 85 percent capacity every week sometimes 95 to 100 percent capacity and they've had more money making weeks than money losing weeks. So I think one of us is social club is probably safe until the end of the year at the very least Cats the Jellicle Ball is currently only selling tickets to the end of the year at the Broadhurst and I think that is where they are going to keep it because while they did do well the Tonys they won three they did not win the big one
SPEAKER_01which was revival and even though I thought they had the best performance of the night and they've you know definitely gone viral on the internet with their Tony performance and they just did Skimble Shanks on Jimmy Fallon it's not really translating to ticket sales they have maintained over $900,000 a week sometimes a little over a million dollars a week but it's not quite breaking the box office like it should so I would imagine depending on how the rest of the summer goes they will keep it to January they might Close it up earlier than that but I would imagine they'd like to take advantage of
SPEAKER_01the holidays especially I imagine Halloween is going to be insane for that show Celebrity Autobiography Sayonara closing out the shoebird leaving us room for Galileo Chess just closed at the Imperial went out on a high 1.7 million not their highest gross but not their lowest either uh Chess started out strong like most revivals tend to do part of it is the name recognition a lot of people love Chess a lot of people were curious to see how this revival was going to go Lea Michele sells tickets love her or hate her she sells those tickets Aaron Tveit love him or hate him he also has
SPEAKER_01a fan base clearly not as big as Michelle's but he does sell tickets and Nick Christopher after the show has had has gotten a very sizable fan base and I'll be interested to see what he does next ultimately the reviews for Chess were Middling at best uh they had a couple of strong reviews Sarah Holdren at Vulture fully claims that the show is camp in the best way uh I would love to sit down with her and ask her what she thinks camp is uh but also word of mouth on the show was very divisive there were people who insisted that it was a phenomenal time uh some of people like me disagreed that did ultimately
SPEAKER_01hurt Chess it also doesn't help that Chess was running for so long but you see this happen with a lot of revivals they start to lose steam after the three month mark sometimes after the two month mark and Chess was losing steam once we hit 2026 and it was very easy to get tickets even when Leah was in the show whether it was TKTS or TDF Chicago at the Ambassador currently welcomed Mateo Lane and Krista Rodriguez it grossed $470,000 this week up from $438,000 that is not money making for Chicago but they also did make extraordinary bank
SPEAKER_01when Whitney Leavitt was in the show and I would imagine they're looking for ways to get her back into the show so they can make that money again Chicago whoever knows when that thing's going to actually close and of all the midsize theaters the ambassador is the one that nobody really wants it's got terrible wing space it's in desperate need of a renovation it's a weird staging layout I'd imagine that the Schubert's are trying to hold off on a So Chicago is not going anywhere anytime soon. Death Becomes Her is closing this month at the La Fontaine. It has gone up.
SPEAKER_01It went up over $123,000. It still hasn't quite cracked $900K, which I'm hoping it does this upcoming. Matt Koplik Matt Koplik I'll see you next time.
SPEAKER_01Starring Rachel Zegler The August Wilson is Dog Day Afternoon went up by $31,000. It grossed a full $585,000 at 75% capacity.
SPEAKER_01That is not a terrible gross for a straight play in general, but at the August Wilson, where they have about 1,100 seats and where they have two TV stars and the show was grossing over a million dollars early in the run, as I said word of mouth has fully killed that thing but we do have paranormal paranormal activity going into the August Wilson this summer they just moved up their opening date word on the street is that the Dolly Parton musical will be going in after that but TBD I believe paranormal activity closes at the end of 2026 leaving
SPEAKER_01the theater open in the spring we'll see if Dolly comes in in the spring or if they want to keep working on it But that theater will be open in the spring of 2027. The Hudson, Every Brilliant Thing, that theater is spoken for after Every Brilliant Thing closes when we get other desert cities with Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Ed Harris, and Allison Janney. But in the meanwhile, Every Brilliant Thing continues to just absolutely print money. Not to the extent of when Daniel Radcliffe was in the show, but Mariska Hargitay is holding her own with almost 1.2 million dollars. Can't fucking complain about that Giant recouped one of the few shows this season
SPEAKER_01that announced recoupment at the Music Box almost 1.5 million dollars almost a complete sellout this week Music Box is spoken for with Rosamund Pike's one woman show coming right after and in the spring it'll be empty and ready for something to come in there I imagine it'll be a play but who knows if the heart or Benjamin Button is looking for a theater in the spring music box is open for them I think the Walter Kerr is safe for a while Hadestown continues to chug along there was a time when we thought it was kind of ready to call it quits
SPEAKER_01but they pulled through and they've managed to have some pretty awesome casting coups and they've kept audiences and fans excited and engaged by having some really fun replacements so that is something that Hadestown always has going for it Hamilton what can I say 2.2 mil 100% capacity not going anywhere Harry Potter the Cursed Child 1.5 mil as long as Tom Felton is in that show it will be selling tickets so Tom Felton how long do you want to stay in it Joe Turner's come and gone at the Ethel Barrymore went back to over
SPEAKER_01a million dollars this week very exciting although it had been kind of going down in the grosses for a while not that any of this really matters the show is a limited run anyway and nothing is claiming the Barrymore after them so it's not like they're cutting this run short there I don't think that they're going to fully recoup but they will not have lost their entire investment so that is saying something just in time that is a show that did recoup it has not sold in the way that it did when Jonathan Groff was in the show but But it is selling.
SPEAKER_01This week, it's gone down to its lowest gross in a while, under $600K, 84% capacity. Part of that is because Jeremy Jordan has been on vacation. Jeremy Jordan has been able to surprisingly keep that show afloat. Again, a few $100K. Okay shy of when Groff was in the show but as I said the show has recouped they made their money and it actually has a pretty low running cost so I would imagine that even at over $700,000 in grosses like they were last week that is probably a slight profit for them maybe Happy Ending had a pretty low gross last week with $633,000 going up
SPEAKER_01to $710,000 this week at the Belasco Matt Koplik they may extend past Jeremy's contract I don't know who they have in mind to go into the show but Circle in the Square is a desirable theater for a lot of people it's not a lot of seats so you can do a lot
SPEAKER_01of dynamic pricing there they've had a lot of success with things like Enemy of the People and Romeo and Juliet and of course with Just in Time there was a moment where Baker's Wife really wanted that theater but I think Baker's Wife that transfer is dead TBD Belasco also not like the most desirable theater it has had its successes we saw this happen with you know Goodnight Oscar and Network and you know maybe Happy Ending has done way better than people expected but we'll see what happens I would imagine if things don't turn around soon
SPEAKER_01for maybe Happy Ending we might see this close up shop after New Year's but still that's an over two year run for the show and that's great MJ at the Neil Simon not going anywhere with 1.6 mil Moulin Rouge as we know is closing up at the Al Hirschfeld hasn't cracked 800,000 this weekend I expect ticket sales to pick up towards the end of the summer as it goes to its closing weeks but right now there doesn't seem to be a huge incentive for fans to go see the show again Oh Mary with Maya Rudolph at the Lyceum
SPEAKER_01I think that no one should really think of the Lyceum as an option for anything for a while not until we get word that they've run out of Mary's because at the moment oh Mary seems to be just fucking killing the game when it comes to replacements and they get really interesting awesome people to play Mary and that gets people constantly at the Lyceum and that's amazing operation mincemeat at the golden uh like O'Meary they do not say that they're open-ended they just keep announcing extensions which is tricky and uh you know dishonest but good for them it's it's it's keep it keeps them in
SPEAKER_01the press every time they say we're extending and mincemeat has been on a profitability streak lately it's not Matt Koplik definitely until january maybe until uh next march i'm sure there are plays
SPEAKER_01that are desperately wanting the golden so that's just a matter of how badly the schubert's want whatever's looking for the golden um proof at the booth it's a limited run uh but that's another show that started out very strong and reviews and word of mouth and lack of tony nominations absolutely killed its momentum you can get tickets for it on tdf all the time uh $730,000 this week you know solid capacity 92% but again considering where it started it's not great Ragtime doing great
SPEAKER_01for Lincoln Center Theater oh also nothing's really cleared for the booth right now but as of this moment I don't think anything's going in there once Proof has closed so any plays play revivals musicals could go in there again maybe even Benjamin Button could go into the booth if they really wanted an intimate theater the Beaumont is spoken for once Ragtime closes in August which I think is a good thing once Ragtime went past its first extension I believe everyone had to move off of their Lord contract and go on to a full Broadway contract
SPEAKER_01so Ragtime became exponentially more expensive to run and so while it is doing very well for them it's not making any heaps of money for them and so closing rack time when they are is probably for the best especially since they won't be able to keep the majority of their cast past August and that is a major selling point and one of the main reasons why this production is successful so them doing a few good men in the fall and Sound of Music with Jasmine Amy Rogers in the spring is a good move
SPEAKER_01Schmigadoon at the Nederlander is running until January uh it just had its highest grossing week yet of 1.18 mil and almost full capacity that's great for them uh considering they just won best musical four Tonys including best musical uh did a hope that they would be an SRO at this point that might be building we'll see what happens in July and August but I mean this is a show that I think will continue to sell decently until the end of its run in January I don't expect them to go past that I expect them to take it on tour
SPEAKER_01and make bank with that which will leave the niederlander open into the spring as i understand it that might be where damn yankees is heading which has been announced but has not confirmed its dates or theater uh there were rumors of it going into the La Fontaine but i think that's i think it's going to the niederlander six the musical at the lena horn uh went down one of the few shows to go down and it's gross this week uh six has been on life support for months now genuine months what was printing money for the first three years
SPEAKER_01of its run it is now I mean that show must cost pennies to run because they are at $553,000 this week in their grosses $453,000 if you take away the credit card expenses and there's no way that that's a profitable week I can't imagine that it is if it is they've met they've created some amazing deal with the writers and the designers and the actors where with all the coverage that they have and whatnot that they've been able to keep this running at 400k a week that'd be that would be fantastic for them but I don't think that's true I would imagine
SPEAKER_01the Lena Horne to be available for any shows that want it if not the fall then definitely in the new year Stranger Things the first shadow at the marquee they've already announced that they're closing they did get to go up in grosses almost 900k this week nothing has been announced for the marquee I doubt any show really wants it that theater is ugly it is a decent location and the Marriott has done some nice stuff to its marquee and to its entryway so people have a better idea how to get into the theater
SPEAKER_01but it's just not a desirable theater for most people Ballister's just closed up at the Freedmen Book of Mormon at the Eugene O'Neill isn't a cause to ring the alarms that was a very special 15th anniversary thing that they were doing Mormon Mystery Week where they had a bunch of original cast members plus Trey Parker Matt Stone and Robert Lopez come into
SPEAKER_01the show at any given point and do random pieces from the show alongside the current cast of Book of Mormon and because of that they had their highest grossing week ever I believe with 2.2 mil and so now they're at a more normal 850k Which is fine. I believe that is still, if not making money, breaking even for them. That said, Book of Mormon has been on a downward streak for the last year. And so I would imagine that they have another year in them.
SPEAKER_00I don't think the Eugene O'Neill will be available in January.
SPEAKER_01I imagine it'll be available about a year from now. If not a year from now, a year and a half from now. So it's not on Death Watch, but... She's coming uh fear of 13 of the James Earl Jones did go up slightly but again 500k 71% capacity as I said Hollywood stars are not a guarantee they just are not now of course if Denzel did fear of 13 or George Clooney did fear of 13 no one would care they would just go see it but Adrian Brody is not that caliber of Hollywood actor he is not
SPEAKER_01that top echelon he's respected he's a great actor but he's not truly a movie star but also if this show were better if it were better received I think we would be seeing healthier grosses right now but even so the James Earl Jones is spoken for in the fall Great Gatsby at the Broadway it did go up in grosses but only up to $775,000 this is a show that was clearing over a million dollars a week for over a year proving all of us wrong proving me wrong a show that I do not care for a show
SPEAKER_01that I do not have respect for but I do respect its hustle and I do respect how long they have lasted at this point that said they are definitely losing money they've been losing money for a few weeks now and they will continue to lose money they don't have anyone in the show right now that is clearly selling tickets uh even Oblazada is back in the show with Reeve Carney and they both have their fan bases but I think this is Eva's third time in the show at this point clearly the demand to see her has gone away and once she and Reeve leave her and Reeve leave that's
SPEAKER_01a nice rhyme uh the demand will be even less so we'll see what happens and then of course when summer ends and and tourism will fade and kids go back to school i imagine the grosses will be even lower but that said i don't know of any shows that are super hungry for the broadway in the same way that there aren't many shows that are super hungry for the majestic dream girls reportedly has the majestic but now i'm hearing that dream girls might push to next season Purple Rain the Prince musical uh was also going to go into the Majestic
SPEAKER_01but now they are taking time to retool so if they have figured their shit out by the spring and Dreamgirls is waiting for a full year maybe Purple Rain will take the Majestic or if Dreamgirls ends up coming in in the winter and Purple Rain is ready maybe Purple Rain can go into the Broadway that would be a nice that would be a nice thing uh Lion King and the Midskoff not going anywhere almost two million dollars and it's been running for almost 30 years it's the obsession of Broadway and by that i mean literally the movie obsession in terms of its run lost boys the palace had its highest grossing week yet 1.4 mil uh that is a nice healthy gross
SPEAKER_01for it that is a money-making week they need a lot more of those in order to return their investment but this is an encouraging sign I don't think we're going to see Lost Boys go away just yet too soon to tell how long this might last I don't know if this is a minor boon or if this is a steady stream that we'll see for a few months now or even a year or two but at the moment we don't have anything to worry about Outsiders went back to being over a million dollars this week at the Jacobs I don't think Outsiders is going away at least for another year but
SPEAKER_01the Jacobs is prime property it's a medium sized theater that a lot of people would love to have but in the meanwhile I think Outsiders is safe Rocky Horror Show at Studio 54 Roundabout has not announced any shows for Studio 54 I'm pretty sure once Rocky Horror closes I believe they want to do some renovations on the theater but Rocky Horror is making the money 1.1 mil this past week and I don't think that's slowing down anytime soon they have a lot of cast members leaving in July so I've as I understand it they have some really fun people coming in they already have Sherry Renee Scott so they got my money so we'll see
SPEAKER_01the word I hear is that Rocky Horror is unofficially going to run for a year dependent on ticket sales with new cast members Titanic at the St. James it's a limited run until September We'll see if it lasts that long because at the moment while it did go up it only went up to $763,000 Word on the street is that there's a revival of 42nd Street being produced by our beloved Scott Rudin that wants the St. James in the spring and if that's the case then ATG has no reason to kick Titanic out before their due date Two Strangers Carry a Cake
SPEAKER_01Across New York did go up at the Long Acre $20,000 to $670,000 gross that is technically speaking treading water for them again you take you want to take away about $100,000 for all of these grosses with credit card fees when you want to look at actual profitability and two strangers I do know has a very tight budget they have kept a tight leash on that show to maintain to make sure that it maintains and this is not I'm gonna argue that this will close up after Labor Day.
SPEAKER_01Most likely. Again, the Long Acre is a theater that I think a lot of shows will want. I think you'll see something like the heart or maybe even midnight in the garden of good and evil there's talk in the Michael Paulson article of goddess wanting a Broadway theater but of course everybody wants a Broadway theater I goddess to not have a good reception at the public I do not expect it to go
SPEAKER_01to Broadway immediately I don't think that there's a lot of trust It's also made Billions of dollars and the movies have kept it relevant so I think Wicked is safe for another couple of years so that said I think we can look at options
SPEAKER_01for anything that's looking for a theater next season we can look at the Jacobs we can look at the we can look at the Marquis we can look at the Lena Horne we can look at the Nederlander the Booth I think the Golden is an option but I'm not going to say it's a strong option uh Belasco Circle in the Square Ethel Barrymore is fully open we know uh Music Box we know is open Wilson we know is open uh Imperial we know is open and I think we can honestly I hate to say this but I think we can look at the Broadhurst and the Stephen Sondheim
SPEAKER_01as well for uh next spring for options for shows so let's think about that in terms of what might be vying for a theater we know that uh Damn Yankees is coming in there are a couple of other revivals that have been circling there's been talk again of how next to normal is actually happening but it might not be happening with Casey Levy which would be a damn shame because she was so phenomenal in it but more on that in our deep dive for next to normal and yeah think about that think about all these things about what makes Broadway musicals successful what makes them maintain what makes
SPEAKER_01them come to Broadway what makes them click with audiences with critics what makes them profitable in the end do not let Michael Paulson's article fool you 15 new musicals a season is not the norm We should be looking for eight to ten a year. And at the moment, we've got four new musicals confirmed. We have Wanted, Galileo, Paddington, and Warriors. They have announced, they have their theaters, tickets are on sale. and that's just we're still in June as I'm recording this so that there's more to come and if the heart works at roundabout and that transfers and
SPEAKER_01if uh Benjamin Button works and that transfers now we have six we we don't need 15 musicals we just need eight to ten and we need like five or six of them to be good and then it becomes a robust season right like um if I may We look at the 2005 year, which had 11 new musicals, only two of which actually recouped, but our four Best Musical nominees, Lighting the Piazza, Spelling Bee, Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, and Spamalot. It's a really strong lineup. I think we talk about this a lot of how that's kind of the last really great Best Musical lineup.
SPEAKER_01I think the next one after that is probably 2017 with Dear Evan Hansen, Grey Comet, Come From Way, and Groundhog Day. But of course, with all of these musicals, people have their opinions of quality. So we don't need 15. We already have four. We're definitely going to get at least seven. This coming season is already shaping up to be better than last season, but we'll talk more about that next week with our special guest. In the meantime, if you like this podcast, please give us a nice five-star rating or review. You can subscribe to the Discord channel and talk more about everything we talked about today.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure this article was already shared on the Discord channel so you can read it there you can subscribe to the YouTube channel you can subscribe to the Substack the next couple of episodes we have this talk with Sean Nyberg I believe next week after that will be our deep dive online at the piazza I'm going to try to get the deep dive on next to normal after that then I'm closing things out with a recap of this past season Broadway Breakdown and specifically some very important announcements of what we plan to do
SPEAKER_01with this podcast going forward and how all of you can help so Keep in mind with that. Then we're going to take a quick hiatus, give or take a review here and there. And then we will have our Backstage Pass four episode miniseries on Seussical going from Inception to Broadway. premiere to its post-Broadway legacy and we have interviews with original cast members Kevin Chamberlain Janine Lamanna Michelle Pac we have David Halstenberg the original music director we have Joyce Chittick we have staff
SPEAKER_01the resident director and I have a couple more interviews coming up I don't want to announce them in case anything falls through but it should be a good series I'm excited to work on it for you guys and that's it so for this episode what Broadway diva do we want to close out with you know what because she's coming back to Broadway again in a rocky horror show fuck it we're going to close out with Ms. Sherry Renee Scott because I really want to so yeah we will see you guys next week thank you for this amuse-bouche episode take it away Sherry bye
SPEAKER_00Troubles Come on Get happy Chase your cares away Shout hallelujah Come on Get happy Get ready
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...