Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Matt Reviews: GIANT, DOG DAY AFTERNOON & DEATH OF A SALESMAN

Apr 19, 20261 hr 1 minAudio

Matt dives into three very different theatrical experiences: the provocative West End transfer Giant, the uneven stage adaptation of Dog Day Afternoon, and a bold new revival of Death of a Salesman. From thorny questions of artistic responsibility and antisemitism to misjudged tonal shifts and a reinvigorated American classic, this episode explores what works, what doesn’t, and how each show may factor into the Tony Awards race. Important Links * Ticket Link: Revue-ing the 2025/2026 Season at Green Room 42 * Broadway Breakdown Discord * Broadway Breakdown Substack Timestamps * 0:00 - Intro + listener review + housekeeping * 3:00 - Giant setup: origins, creative team, and premise * 7:00 - Roald Dahl controversy + central dramatic conflict * 13:00 - Themes: antisemitism, accountability, and rhetoric * 19:00 - Performances (John Lithgow, Aya Cash) * 23:30 - Critiques: pacing, depth, and dramatic resolution * 27:00 - Tony Awards outlook for Giant * 29:30 - Dog Day Afternoon setup: true story → film → stage * 33:00 - Tonal misfire: comedy vs. drama * 38:00 - Character breakdown: Sonny, Leon, and adaptation choices * 43:00 - Direction, design, and staging issues * 47:30 - Performances (Jon Bernthal, Ebon Moss-Bachrach) * 50:30 - Tony Awards outlook for Dog Day Afternoon * 52:30 - Death of a Salesman setup: revival context * 55:00 - Direction and staging (Joe Mantello) * 57:30 - Performances (Nathan Lane, Laurie Metcalf, Christopher Abbott) * 59:00 - Tony Awards outlook + final thoughts Listener discussion questions * When a play tackles controversial real-life figures (like Roald Dahl in Giant), how much responsibility does it have to provide emotional clarity versus simply raising questions? * Can radically reinterpreting tone - like turning Dog Day Afternoon into a broad comedy - ever justify itself, or does it inherently risk undermining the story? * With Death of a Salesman revived so frequently, what makes a new production feel essential rather than redundant to you? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01That's all. But we have a great dramatic finish. Oh, I'm sure you do, but Mr. Granson... Ah! Hit it!

SPEAKER_02Broadway, Broadway, we've missed it so. We're leaving soon and taking June to star her in a show.

SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, and you guessed it, this is another review episode. Oh yes, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. We have three reviews we're covering today, three plays we were covering today. martha miller's death of a salesman uh giant as well as dog day afternoon although i think the order we're going to do is giant salesman sorry

we're going to do giant dog day and then salesman now let's do salesman no yeah let's do let's do giant dog day salesman sorry about all that a little a little all over the place today before

SPEAKER_00we get to all of that i think i think i read this at one point i can't recall i don't have a memory of this so if i did i apologize everybody but um i was as i said in a previous episode because of the way um apple podcast works i don't see reviews that are written outside of the country so i have to find through back channels how to find uh those outside reviews so if um I did read this. I apologize for repeating myself, but I just wanted to be sure because I don't think I did. And I want to give this person their due.

SPEAKER_00So please cue the light in the Piazza overture. Five stars, a man in chair with better hair. I've been listening to Broadway Breakdown for years now, but I was especially grateful to the pod this past weekend. I was playing auditions for Legally Blonde and had to sight read several songs from Mean Girls and Heathers. I have a broad knowledge of Broadway rep, but these shows only, quote unquote, Thank you. That's a Mean Girls reference for those of you who do not know.

SPEAKER_00Thank you so much for that. And once again, guys, make sure to rate, review, and subscribe and give us a nice five-star review if you can. Or join the Discord channel or the Substack. I'll be doing all of these calls to action at the end of the episode.

SPEAKER_03Oh, and also, by the way, make sure you buy tickets for the May 3rd live show covering the 2025-2026 theater

SPEAKER_00season, including the shows we're talking about today. we're gonna start off with the british import giant this is a new play written by mark rosenblatt directed by our beloved nicholas heitner starring john lithgow who is um a great actor and has said some things in the press lately that uh have not been fantastic i would say sometimes people try to um do the both sides argument

SPEAKER_03and it's not always great let's leave it at that uh Giant came from the West End where it won the Olivier for Best Play as well as Best

SPEAKER_00Actor in a Play. I believe also Best Featured Actor in a Play for Elliot Levy, I believe is how you pronounce his name. And it's a pretty timely piece, I will say. The basic premise, for those of you who don't know, I guess we should say that spoilers abound for all of these reviews, right? We try not to give away too much of the ghost, but... you gotta talk about this shit in depth a little bit. So Giant is about the children's book author Roald Dahl. Now, I would imagine anyone listening to this podcast knows who Roald Dahl is,

SPEAKER_00but if the name doesn't sound super familiar, you are absolutely familiar with his works. He penned such classics as Matilda, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, The Witches, The BFG, The Twits, Fantastic Mr. Fox. He, you know, possibly the greatest uh children's book writer of all time the play takes place it's about it's based off a very real event uh it takes place right before doll is about to publish his latest work which is the witches this is

circa 1983 and right

SPEAKER_00before the publication of the witches doll has uh written independently written a book review for a new book that is extraordinarily anti-israel because at this point in time uh israel had uh been invading and bombing beirut this is uh after beirut themselves had uh bombed and infiltrated israel so it Things happen with Israel all the time, it seems.

SPEAKER_00Again, I told you, it was relevant to today's world. So this book, it was mostly covering the intricacies of this war with Israel and Beirut. That definitely leans towards anti-Israel. And Dahl wrote an independent book review that was a rave for the book and goes on to talk about the state of Israel and his compassion for the Palestinian people. So based off of his time there when he was a soldier in World War Two.

But part of the review then goes on to talk about not just his disdain for the

SPEAKER_00actions of the state of Israel, but then his disdain for the Jewish people as a whole and how he feels that they have turned the tide on their narrative from being the world's number one victims of abuse during World War II. And homicide and genocide to being perpetrators of genocide in his eyes. And of course, this review causes major backlash and is really the first brick to lay the

SPEAKER_00foundation of the reputation of Dahl of being an anti-Semite. So the play is right after this has happened, and his publishing house, who he's new to because his old publishing house has rejected him. He claims that he left, but it's a difference of opinion. But his new publishing house has sent their director of sales, who's American, an American woman named Jessie Stone, as played by Aya Cash, They send her over to his country home,

SPEAKER_00which he's doing construction on, in order to coax him into crafting an apology, whether that's a written statement or having an interview with a reporter, because they do not want this impacting the sales of books, because there are all these... independent bookstores in america that have jewish owners and they are threatening to boycott selling the book and so of course his publishing house is like we got to get this done and at the house is doll iacash as jesse stone uh doll's

SPEAKER_00and allegedly close friend, Tom, as well as his fiancée, soon-to-be wife, Lissy, Felicity, and their housekeeper, Hallie. And... For the first half hour or so, the play kind of is skirting around the issue. Everyone's being pleasant. Jessie shows up and she's a big fan of Dahl because he is objectively a very good children's book author.

SPEAKER_00And eventually we get to the heat of the issue. And throughout the piece, it becomes a bit of a... antagonistic protagonist in the character of Roald Dahl. He pokes at everyone around him, Because he is so confident that he is right and he is so disillusioned with how everyone else is dumber than he is and more hypocritical than he is and won't stand

SPEAKER_00for their convictions. But he claims that he's not an anti-Semite. He's anti-Israel. And under the guise of, can't you see these atrocities happening? Why can't you stand for your convictions? And of course, what complicates the matters further is through his own overstepping of boundaries, investigating Aya Cash's character, he discovers that she is Jewish. He talks about how his agent and alleged friend Tom is also Jewish, while he still makes remarks about Jewish people in an umbrella

term that is

SPEAKER_00ultimately anti-Semitic, in the same way that when... A white Karen talks about the African-American community and says those people. Right. When she's referring to an incident with one in particular person or, you know, any any ethnicity, any race you can think of when people do an overarching generalization. Right. That is ultimately an aggression that is ultimately prejudice. That is ultimately racism. And the plague goes back and forth of who's in the right,

who's in the wrong. People are trying to have measured arguments with Dahl about what's going on with

SPEAKER_00Israel right now, what's going on with the Jewish population in general, the rise of anti-Semitism, how words have meaning. And you can have your convictions, but you also have to acknowledge when you've done something poorly or in poor taste. Or if you've you know, misworded something. There's a lot of wanting to give Dahl the benefit of the doubt. And he he keeps digging his heels in harder and harder and harder about refusing to do an apology. And of course, then it's revealed that Jesse Stone,

SPEAKER_00who is an American, they the publishing house have told Dahl that it was so important to them that she meet with him that they flew her over from new york uh directly in order to talk with him turns out she actually had been in london for a while that's why they had sent her over uh she's spoken about her son who had a brain tuber and is in a coma and she reads to him and doll had a daughter who had died tragically young from i believe a brain aneurysm and When he realizes that Jesse Stone has been in London actually

for a while,

SPEAKER_00he questions even if she has a son and if she does, if he's even in a coma. And he gets aggressively more anti-Semitic by shouting at her. And then that goes under the guise of, well, no, he didn't mean it. He was in the heat of the moment. And then, spoiler alert, we get to the final scene. Where everyone's cleared out and Dahl says, I will make a statement. I will do an apology. Let's call up, you know, this reporter that, you know, is asking for clarification and I will speak with him.

SPEAKER_00And everyone's pleased. Oh, he's going to get it because he might get a knighthood and they will have to revoke it if he's still in hot water. And the play ends with him on the phone with the reporter and his Australian housemaid Hallie is there listening to him. And she goes from curious to cautious to ice cold by the end of the scene before she eventually leaves the room and allegedly supposedly leaves the house.

Because in this interview, as Dahl explains himself to the reporter, he gets the veil gets slowly drawn and the words he says go from being anti-israel being anti-genocide to pure and simple anti-semitism it's not even about israel anymore it's just about the jewish people and their and their history and their reputation and the um racism against them and the prejudice against them the uh stereotypes

SPEAKER_00against them and supposedly the words in this final scene to this interviewer are word for word what doll said in his quote-unquote apology or his clarification and the play ends with that happening and i was with my friend who uh you know had heard wonderful things and he enjoyed it um as did i but he had said to me it makes you kind of wonder what's the point because he you know

SPEAKER_00He gets away with it all, and he got his knighthood. And I said, yeah, and The Witches was a major bestseller and was made into a movie and was remade into a movie. And The Witches has calendar its own scrutiny of anti-Semitism, and they talk about it in the play of sort of his comments in his book review about this book. that's anti-Israel, can draw a parallel to his writings of the witches, of the way he describes them. I mean, everyone take a shot for every time a British author has written the phrase hooked nose, you know? You have Dahl,

SPEAKER_00you have J.K. Rowling, you have fucking Charles Dickens, who, if you ever read Oliver Twist, the other characters refer to Fagan as Fagan, but Dickens refers to him as the Jew. Anti-Semitism... is a tale as old as time. It runs deep in many, many countries. What England does not like to admit to is that they are extraordinarily anti-Semitic and have been for almost as long as anyone can remember.

And this play does reckon with that a little bit, or rather to say it acknowledges that.

SPEAKER_00Giant is not interested in answers. It is interested in poking the bear. It is interested in questions, it is interested in conversations, which is ultimately what you want plays to do. I think if there's a major... critique i would have about it i have two critiques one is that it takes a while to really start cooking it's about 20 to 30 minutes before the play really kind of starts to heat up it's a lot of table setting that can make your mind wander and you start to think oh god is this going to be a really stuffy british play but no

it's definitely heats up it's it things start to pick up when ayakash enters but they don't really pick up until lithko's doll asks her if she's jewish and then

SPEAKER_00that's when the stove turns on But that's the first critique. The second critique is ultimately for all of the big topics that this show is approaching. It doesn't really tackle it. It intellectually tackles it, but I wouldn't say that it super emotionally tackles it, nor does it go beyond, I would say, like an inch deep. It's very eloquent, it's very intelligent, and it definitely is trying to parse as many different sides as possible,

SPEAKER_00which is, again, what you want. You don't want to be lectured at. But I do think that it maybe could be, it can get a bit bumpy and a bit sloppy with that journey. What saves it ultimately is it is extraordinarily well acted. You know, Lithgow is a phenomenal actor. Most, I would argue, most effective on stage. TV, he's done very well.

SPEAKER_00I mean, anyone who's watched Dexter or Third Rock from the Sun. And he's had some great film roles, World According to Garb, Terms of Endearment. But I think that he works best on stage because he's such a big presence. The name giant obviously refers to various meanings here. Dahl was also a very tall man like Lithgow is. He was a massive presence in English culture in the literature world. He's also the opposite. of what he wrote. He is not a BFG.

SPEAKER_00He's not a big, friendly giant. He's an antagonistic bully. Aya Cash's Jesse Stone even says to him towards the end, as the dust starts to settle from all the chaos, she says, you're not a man. You're a boy. Today has been the tirades of a little child. It's what ultimately makes you so brilliant at what you do as an artist, as a writer, but it's what makes you flawed and doomed to be flawed forever as a man. you know you this is something that will always be a problem with you and you should really work on it and it's great to see iacash's jesse

stone go toe-to-toe

SPEAKER_00with doll especially because no one else really will uh Mostly because they all have their own hangups. Tom is Dahl's friend and agent, but also while he does have affection for him, also a lot of his income depends on him, and he really can't afford to lose the relationship. And so when his feet are put to the coals by Dahl, Tom kind of skirts around the issue a lot and tries to say a

lot without saying too

SPEAKER_00much, and he gets called out on it. And Felicity, Dahl's fiancé, she's a little underwritten, I would argue. She acknowledges the ways in which Dahl won't reflect inward on his own failings, on his own moral failings, and applies them to their history together, but not in a way where he has anything to lose. And I think the reason why that's the case is because in real life, he lost nothing. And I think that the playwright...

Rosenblatt has a really hard time grappling with what he wants to investigate and

SPEAKER_00what actually happened. Like, Dahl either needs to lose something or needs to be proven something, not because we need an overly moral story, but the play ends in a way that's not even dramatically... It's not dramatically satisfying, nor is it dramatically... eerie, like eerily unsatisfying. As my friend said, it sort of just kind of ends and makes you go, OK, well, then why?

And I know a few people who have seen it and have hated it because they found it

SPEAKER_00incredibly anti-Semitic. I am not entirely sure I agree with that. If anyone saw the play and felt that way, please reach out to me on the Discord, on Substack, or even on Instagram and tell me your thoughts because I can understand the depiction of blatant anti-Semitism on stage to be disconcerting, to be uncomfortable. As we had said in our Thoroughly Modern Millie episode, and whether you think it applies to Millie or not,

SPEAKER_00To show racism is not being racist. To show anti-Semitism is not being anti-Semitic. To show sexism is not being sexist. There are people who are like this. There are people who say these things and think these things. If you are a good writer and good actors, you throw that person as a tempest in a teapot and you watch the combustion happen. And when the debris falls away, you ask, okay, what can we rummage from the ruins? I'm not sure if everyone's going to rummage anything from the ruins.

I think what some people had said to me was that they felt like anti-Semites would

SPEAKER_00watch this play and feel justified. I don't know how they, well, I know how they can because anyone can feel justified with how they think because we've grown to become a quite stubborn, boxed in and tunnel visiony world now, which ultimately is a mirror in the way that Dahl is reflected in this play. We all think we're the smartest. We all think we're the most correct. We all think we've got nothing left to learn. The moment you think you have nothing left to learn is the moment that you're dead, in my opinion.

SPEAKER_00Also, I think truly intelligent people, like the most evolved intelligent people, never think that they're done learning. There's always more that they could learn. which is how a lot of characters in this play feel. Anyone but doll, that is. And I think the play is at its best when Aya Cash's Jesse Stone really comes head-to-head with Lithgow's doll, and they really kind of go at it. That is when it's at its most compelling. And part of that is because Aya Cash, I think, is a wonderful actress. I've loved her on TV. I saw her in You're the Worst.

SPEAKER_00She played Neil Simon's first wife in Fosse Verdon, which she was a little underused in, but whatever. She's... she's such a wonderful actress and i love her and i'm so glad she's on stage right now and i would love to see her uh be recognized for this so i guess this is to say where do we see this sitting in the tony race it did get mostly good reviews a couple of raves it don't the The overwhelming consensus was positive plus.

SPEAKER_00This was not the runaway critical smash that it was in London, but it is doing well at the box office. It is a conversation starter, and it does have a Tony Ward's pedigree to its name. Lithgow is a two-time winner. Nick Heitner is a two-time winner. I think that this is definitely a lock for best play. I don't know if I see it winning. We'll talk more about the balusters in a few days. but i think that if any play is an opponent to liberation it would be the balusters but again more on that in another episode but i do think it's a

lock for nomination i think heitner is if not a lock i think he's a very strong possibility i see uh Lithgow I do think is a lock for Best Actor and I think is a very strong chance to win. Aya Cash I think is a formidable contender for Featured Actress in a play.

SPEAKER_00Again, I don't know if she's a lock necessarily. There are far too many options this season, but I would love to see her recognized. I do think she has a shot. Definitely has a shot. Elliot Levy I also think has a shot for Featured Actor in a play. Probably nothing in the tech categories. Crowley is a wonderful set designer. He does his job here, but the set is not... One that I think really strikes you. There's a bit of forced perspective. There's a color to it all. It's very well laid out. I mean, it could be nominated. We don't have a ton of really impressive options.

SPEAKER_00I feel like we've got two or three locks for set, and then it becomes sort of, okay, how are we going to fill this out? And it's a detailed house set, which, you know, the Tonys do love for their plays. But I do think play, actor, and director are the most likely, and then featured actress and actor are very strong possibilities as well. Possibly both, most likely one or the other. And yeah, that's Giant for us. So thank you, Giant. Next up, we're going to talk about Dog Day Afternoon. Oh boy. This is the stage adaptation of

SPEAKER_00The film Dog Day Afternoon, which in turn was adapted from an article, The Boys in the Bank, which was based off of a true story of a man who held up a Chase Bank in Brooklyn in the 1970s so he could collect money for his partner's gender reassignment surgery and made national news. He held up the bank and held everyone inside hostage for not not a full 24 hours i don't think maybe more like 15 16 and

what made it different beyond just the his reasons for doing it were the fact that he was such a charming gregarious person and that he had managed to turn a lot of the crowd outside the bank on his side and against the cops who were trying to negotiate the

SPEAKER_00hostage situation he had connected with many people in the bank who he was holding hostage. And this is also reflected in the film Dog Day Afternoon, starring Al Pacino. Dog Day Afternoon is a classic film. It unfortunately was one of my blind spots before seeing this play. And I actually thought about watching it before I went to go see... the stage play and I ultimately decided that I would hold off I would see the play and then I would watch the movie afterwards and do some more research afterwards so I could judge the play on its own merits uh the play is adapted

by Stephen Adley uh Gurgis who he wrote I think she wrote Between Riverside and Crazy am I wrong about that that's I'm pretty sure that's uh that was his right yeah he's the Pulitzer winner for Between Riverside and Crazy it's directed by Rupert Gould who uh did

SPEAKER_00Tammy Faye and Patriots, Inc., American Psycho, King Charles, Enron, the works. I'm sort of split on Rupert Gould. I enjoyed Inc. a lot. King Charles was a good one as well. American Psycho, you can listen more to my opinions on the musical in that episode, that deep dive we did. but i mean gould is for me visually very arresting but i don't always feel like he's got a sense of tone i don't always feel like he is in

control of his actors and i don't ever really feel much from his shows he's more smart than he is feeling and ultimately this production continued to prove that for me the play stars john

SPEAKER_00bernthal in the al pacino role and uh uh Abon Moss Bacharach as the Joan Cazale role, Al Pacino's accomplice in the holdup. And while the movie takes a mixed genre approach to the story, the play takes a full-on comedy approach, which is, for lack of a better term, incorrect. The movie is not a full drama. It's not a full comedy.

SPEAKER_00It's not a full suspense thriller. It is all three of those things. It is... a drama in the sense that it is a very serious thing that happens it's suspenseful because it's a hold up the moment you put a gun on screen it becomes suspenseful and it's a comedy because ultimately the character of sunny which is al pacino john bernthal doesn't know what he's doing he decides to do this robbery

SPEAKER_00At the very last second. Like that morning. And he involves two of his friends. And one of them leaves like immediately into the holdup. So it's just him and his friend Sal. And they don't know what they're doing. And they're flying by the seat of their pants, but they also, the robbery itself is representative of their frustration with the system and with the police and with everything that is built to work against them and the people

SPEAKER_00that they love, the injustice of it all. The famous scene in the film is, which is recreated here, is Sonny going outside of the bank to talk with the cops. and being fed up with their manipulations and the injustice of it all, and starts pointing to the recent Attica travesty and scandal, which Attica was a prison that was overcrowded,

SPEAKER_00underfunded, and there was a resistance within the prison from the prisoners, from the inmates, against the guards and the management there because they were being underfed. They were basically sleeping on top of each other. And there was a revolt to have change. And prisoners were killed because of it not because they were being violent they were they were systematically killing people a to reduce um the population but

also to uh send a message to the rest of the prisoners that that was what was going to happen if they continue to revolt against management and this came out and was a very big scandal uh unfortunately did not lead to any kind of prison reform but this was a major

SPEAKER_00story and so Sonny in the film points to this and starts shouting Attica and everyone in the street starts shouting Attica along with him as a way of uniting and turning against the police. And that, of course, is the act one closer of Dog Day Afternoon on stage. Having not watched the film after seeing the show, it is relatively faithful. Certain phone calls that are happening off screen in the movie that are just voiceovers are done on stage now, such as Sonny talking to his first wife.

SPEAKER_00That is the twist, I guess you could say, of the piece. And it's a twist in the movie, a twist on stage, is that Sonny keeps saying while he's in the bank, he keeps talking to the police. And one of his demands is, I want to talk to my wife. And they get his wife on the phone, but it's his first wife, his legal wife. And he says, that's not who I'm talking about. Get me my wife. And they come to realize that Sonny's referring to a person named Leon.

SPEAKER_00Leon and Sonny met in the village, and Leon was a sex worker. And they had a very tumultuous, very violent, very toxic relationship, both in real life and in the film and in the play. The play doesn't really go into all that. The movie acknowledges it a bit more. But Leon, at this time, was in a psychiatric ward for having tains and pills. And in the play,

it's more inferred that Leon did this because they were unhappy with their life and

SPEAKER_00with them... feeling like a woman trapped in a man's body and not getting the support that they needed it is revealed in the movie that that wasn't really the case the case was that much as they loved sunny their relationship was so um combustible that he that lee sorry that leon could not handle it and they ultimately tried to take their own life to get away from it and uh when they survived they were sent to a

find security and protection from sunny and sunny goes uh sunny went to visit leon they speak about um ultimately what leon really needs which is this gender reassignment surgery which propels sunny to do this robbery and sunny and leon have a phone call that is sort of their final goodbye before everything goes to shit at

SPEAKER_00the end of the play The phone call in the play, like the rest of the play, is played very much for comedy. And Leon in particular is played very much for comedy. Sort of like a mixture between Nathan Lane in the birdcage and Hank Azaria in the birdcage. Whereas in the film, played by Chris Sarandon, yes, there are affectations to Leon that I think some people might view as a stereotype or a little over the top. But first of all, show me any person in the queer community who's not a little bit over the top or doesn't have some trait about them that you would tie to a stereotype.

SPEAKER_00We all we all have them in some way or shape or form. Leon is no different because Leon is one of our community. And that is just the case. The way Chris Sarandon kind of plays Leon is a bit like Linda Belcher from Bob's Burgers, which is they play Leon like a Brooklyn mother. You know, it's just very my nerves, my nerves, my nerves, my nerves. And yeah, it's a little it's a little much. But also who's to say that Leon isn't a bit much? Leon can be a woman and still be a bit much.

SPEAKER_00Women can be much. That's equality, baby. We're all a little much sometimes. Right. But in this production, it is so over the top that there's no humanity to the character. There's no humanity to anybody. Right. Jon Bernthal as Sonny tries to get there, mostly in the second act when everything's falling apart. And God bless him, he works really hard to get there. But he ultimately can't because he is unsupported by the production.

SPEAKER_00Gould has given this the most literal design and staging possible. It's a very impressive design. It's a literal bank set that keeps flipping back and forth in and outside of the bank. But because of this, the transitions from outside to inside, from across the street to on the phone, are these very long, almost cumbersome scene transitions that kill momentum, that kill flow, that kill suspense. And by leaning into the comedic side of the play...

SPEAKER_00All of the heart is just gone. The only person who brings a bit of suspense to the piece is Eban Mosk, Bacharach as Sal, who doesn't have a lot of dialogue, but there's a lot of presence. He tends to just be there a lot, and his presence gives some edge to a show that ultimately does not give much edge. I could go on, but ultimately, this is just... This production is a wash. You're better off just watching the movie. It's far more...

well done and it's far more humanely presented and any issues you have with the 1970s film i urge you to remember this is 1975 think of where we were at that time think of where we are now and how people if this is where we're at now when we're treating the story for to be treated better in 1975 tells you a lot about the intention of that production of that film compared to this one in terms of tony

SPEAKER_00race stuff obviously play is out the window there was talk of this i feel like in our very first super early tony predictions back in february when no one really knew what this was going to be it was this big wild card because the movie's so good oh the playwright is a pulitzer winner rupert gold is directing this could possibly work and it just it absolutely does not uh I think what it has working for it best is technical categories. I think it is a lock for set design. Could potentially win. Again, it's an impressive set design.

I ultimately think that the set design doesn't work because it's so cumbersome,

SPEAKER_00but it is objectively impressive on a scale level. It could get in for lighting and for costumes. It's period 70s costumes. And that's really all I see for it. There was talk early in previews of Jessica Hecht. She plays sort of the head bank teller. She's in charge of all of the women in the bank. There was talk of her being nominated. She does a good job, but ultimately she doesn't have anything to go with. But of course, the same was true when she did Summer 1976 at Manhattan Theater Club,

SPEAKER_00and she got nominated for that. So anything's possible. We do, of course, love Miss Jessica Hecht, and we would love to see her win one day, but this is absolutely not her win. It's probably not her nomination. Not when there's so many other potential... nominees out there i mean i just spoke of aya cash and giant she absolutely should be getting in there over jessica hecht for this play uh ebon is going to be deemed featured he's above the title for this but he's going to be deemed featured for this play i don't see it happening john bernthal has a chance

as a leading actor in

SPEAKER_00a play especially um with fear Fear of 13 kind of flopping with critics. I have my review coming out in a few days, so you'll hear my thoughts on that. But the reception of Fear of 13 has been such that I think Adrian Brody's Tony chances have severely diminished, which actually pushes Jon Bernthal up quite a bit. But also we'll see what happens with Alden Emmerich for Becky Shaw. The review for that will be coming out in a few days as well. Although I guess I'll say this, and I'll repeat myself in the actual review. Having now seen Becky Shaw, I...

SPEAKER_00don't see how Alden can be deemed featured. He is the lead of that show. He just objectively is the lead. In the same way that Anikinani Rose, for me, is objectively the lead of the Balusters. They are ensemble pieces, but their stories are the main drive of the show, and they are who we start with, and they are who we end with. Same thing with Jon Bernthal. We start with him, we end with him. It is ultimately his story that drives the production. And he's doing his best. He is such a talented actor. He's also hot as fuck,

but he's undermined left and right by the show he's in.

SPEAKER_00And it's a shame because I think with a better intended production, he could be really great in this. He might still get a nomination, but I don't see it happening. So that's Dog Day Afternoon. Last up on the list is Arthur Miller's Death of a Salesman. Sorry, if you're watching this on YouTube, the sun is shining brightly, and so there's a bit of a glare, but you can see it right there.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. Death of a Salesman, baby. Death of a Salesman.

SPEAKER_00This is our second revival of it post-COVID, let alone our third revival of it this century and our fourth revival of it in the last 30 years. So that tells you a little bit about something about Death of a Salesman. It is... While Angels of America is my favorite play and definitely my favorite American play, death of a salesman is objectively the greatest american play the um strength of it

the its endurance to last over decades it's in if it's relevant no matter the time

SPEAKER_00that it's being performed in the depth of human tragedy within all of its characters that is just a three-course meal for actors makes this a piece that will always be done and makes everyone salivate to get their hands on to do which also can make it super overexposed as was the narrative when they announced this revival we just had one

SPEAKER_00do we really need it again? Who needs to see Death of a Salesman again? And plus they're in the Winter Garden Theater, which much as I love that theater, that is not really a theater for plays. Good Night and Good Luck died in there while I really enjoyed Wolf Hall. No one went to go see it. And Death of a Salesman is ultimately an intimate show. It's a kitchen sink drama, but also a memory piece. It's like Half a view from the bridge, half the glass menagerie. Because if you don't know the piece, it focuses on Willie Loman. He is the salesman in question who is on the mental and moral decline.

SPEAKER_00He worked hard all of his life. was never exceptional and never really made the right choices but not out of villainous reasons out of trying to do his best and ultimately kind of being unlucky over and over and over again and he's not perfect he was stubborn he was definitely egotistical and

unwilling to face facts about himself about his family but he wasn't a terrible man and he did not deserve to be discarded in the way that the world was discarding him

SPEAKER_00this is um The famous speech that his wife, Linda, played by Laurie Metcalf here, says to their sons, Biff and Happy, in the kitchen towards the end of Act One, that attention must be paid. You are to, you know, your father is a good man, he's a hardworking man, and what's happening to him is a tragedy, and attention must be paid. You especially hear how Nathan Lane is playing Willie Loman, and no one really associates Nathan Lane with a role like this.

SPEAKER_00This is a role that Brian Dennehy has played, a role that Philip Seymour Hoffman has played, Dustin Hoffman, George C. Scott. And Nathan Lane doesn't really fit into any of those kinds of men. But I will say, for me, this production very much earns its right to exist. which is a weird thing to say. But considering how this is our second production post-COVID and a play that tends to be rather overexposed,

SPEAKER_00it's easy for all of us to go, oh God, we don't need to see this. But it absolutely justifies happening, even if Scott Rudin is producing it. I don't think it's perfect. I do have my bumps with it. And I would like to see it again to see how certain things have gelled since the last time I saw it. Oh, also, by the way, while I was there after the show, I got spotted by two listeners. I didn't catch your guys' names, but two gentlemen... who came up to me and my father and my grandmother after the show and said, oh, we listened to the podcast.

SPEAKER_00And I just want to say thank you. Thank you so much for listening. It was a highlight of the evening for my father. Much as he enjoyed the play, he loved the fact that I got spotted. I guess I'm not the least famous podcaster anymore. Maybe just the second least famous. Who knows? I'll always be behind Mickey Joe, though, let's be honest. But... I'll start with my positives on this first, of what makes this worth seeing. This might be the most directory that Joe Mantello has been in a long time, probably since Assassins.

This is a production that reminds you, oh, Joe Mantello directed Love, Valor, Compassion. Because Joe Mantello has had a reputation for the last 20 or so years as being an

SPEAKER_00actor's director. He's not flashy. He's not show-offy. He's text first. He's actor first. And it's about getting performances that are so in sync with the text and so in sync with each other that everything just feels organic and easy and lived in. And... he's often lost best director of the Tonys for flashier stagings. Ironically, uh, his, his like real,

like sort of shot out of a cannon on Broadway.

SPEAKER_00Uh, Tony debut as a director, love all our compassion was like extremely stagey and he lost for that, uh, for that production, but he won for take me out and he won for assassins, which were far more stagey shows. This is the most stagey he's been since then. Um, This production takes place in what I can only describe as sort of like a post-apocalyptic garage. And the opening image is the garage door opening and Nathan Lane is Willie Loman driving onto the stage in a full car,

SPEAKER_00the car that we're supposed to have in Ragtime during Wheels of a Dream. She's currently on stage at the Winter Garden in Death of a Salesman, everybody. But that car remains on stage for the entire show until the very end when, spoiler alert, the title of the show happens. The title number happens, much like Oedipus. The title song happens when the car goes off stage. And what Mantello does with the script that I thought was so fascinating is for being such a memory piece, I think often productions forget how much of a memory piece it is and how much of

SPEAKER_00the mental decline of Willie we are watching on stage. And Mantello really takes that to heart. There's the line in Grey Gardens. It's very hard to distinguish the line between the past and the present. And that is absolutely something that Mantello grabs a hold of and never lets go. The way that he uses the car as both a metaphor as well as a gateway to Willie's present, back to his past, and Nathan Lane being unable to distinguish which is which.

SPEAKER_00This is also a production where Biff and Happy, for the first time, have actors playing their younger counterparts in traditional shows, traditional productions of this play. The actors double as their younger selves. And in the last production that starred Wendell Pierce and Sharon Clark, the actors, I felt, had a very hard time being convincing as the younger selves. And so the director's alternative was to have them be so performative that the whole thing felt almost like a vaudeville, which I felt was a very British way of approaching such an

American piece because

SPEAKER_00it was a British director.

SPEAKER_02But Mantello,

SPEAKER_00by having the role split, while it's less of a showcase for the actress playing Biff and Happy, it reminds you just how far away we are from what was and how much time has passed since Opportunity was at the lowman's door. And it allows Mantello... physical opportunities to stage of the ghosts of who biff and happy were and who willie still sees when he talks to his sons today as well as um

you know their neighbor eugene and everyone in their lives right the thing about the play that always has been kind of tricky and the last revival's answer to this was casting entre de shields was willie has an older brother ben a much older brother ben who

SPEAKER_00uh went off into the jungle, famously went off into the jungle and came out rich and only saw Willie once in Willie's adult life, came to visit and meet Biff and Happy and Linda and offered Willie an opportunity to go out to Alaska and be a part of a new company that he was developing. And Willie ended up saying no to it and the company did well and Willie would have done well and he would have had a good life

SPEAKER_00without having the tumultuous career of being a traveling salesman, having to go out all the time on the road and sell things to people that they don't need or do not want. And it's a major regret of his. And the role of Ben is a falsehood memory because Ben exists and him coming happened. But how it happened and how Ben actually was is up for debate.

SPEAKER_02We know that he came.

SPEAKER_00We know that he offered the job. We know that Willie didn't take it. We don't really know how Ben really was. We just see how Billy sees Ben, how Willie sees Ben. And in the last production, they had Andre de Shields basically play him like Hermes in Hadestown, straight out of a dream, coming out of Puffs of Smoke. And Jonathan Kent plays Ben in this production. And not Jonathan Kent, Jonathan, sorry. Jonathan Cake. I apologize, everybody. But you know what I mean. Jonathan Cake plays Ben in this production.

And the way that he and Mantello sort of approach it is his Ben is very real,

SPEAKER_00but he's also very austere. And there's a glow... of the odd about him. And you definitely get the sense that you're watching a person who existed through a filter. So what we're seeing is almost like an AI projection simulation of a reality. And that gives it the creepy factor that I think the role has always meant to have that hasn't always been successfully done in past productions.

SPEAKER_00And part of that is also the abstract Desolation of the design of the show and the way that Mantello uses the car, the office door at the back of the stage for entrances and exits, the way that they use lighting and sound to really kind of create this fluidity in the stage. staging in the way that memory is fluid, right? Say what you will about rolling. The one thing I do appreciate about Harry Potter is the pensive element of the idea of your memories coming out of your head,

SPEAKER_00and they are a liquid that then go into a bowl. Because memory is never solid. It's a liquid. It's a gas. They're all flowing in and out of each other. It's why you can't totally trust your memory exactly. It's why we ask other people to corroborate with us what happened. It's why people also have diaries, because you want to write it down immediately after it happened so you can remember it exactly as it happened. And that is something that I think this production has a great deal of fun with. There's a bunch of wonderful acting happening with some caveats.

And again, this is why I want to go back at some point to see sort of how things gel.

SPEAKER_00At the tippity-toppity of all this, we have Nathan Lane, who on one hand does all the things you need your Willy Loman to do. He checks all of the boxes acting-wise. And yet I still did not totally buy his performance because ultimately I do think it's a role that doesn't fit him. Again, I would like to go back and see with more time if possibly it has fit him more. But at my performance, I definitely felt that there were things about Lane that he can't really change. Not like his stature,

SPEAKER_00but his speaking voice and the way that when he combusts as an actor, it goes into a slightly campy territory, which works in someone like Roy Cohn, who was campy while also you know, incredibly scary. Willie is more of a devastating character. He's far more tragic and there's less of the camp of him. It's more of the human grounded earth bound to him. And I, I got the exhaustion. I got the, the fear and I got the,

SPEAKER_00um, arrested development of Willie and his stubbornness and his unwillingness to see how he had failed his sons, how his sons had failed themselves and the, um, lack of potential that was there anymore if there ever really was potential there you see all of this and yet there's always for me there was always like one dial was slightly off so it's not a bad performance it's a very good performance and all the right intentions and yet sometimes it's one of those things where you can't really break out of things that don't fit you

SPEAKER_00I would like to go back and see how that's a little bit different. In a similar and yet different way, Laurie Metcalf as Linda, Linda has always been known as a very warm and very sad presence. Those are things that Laurie Metcalf does not do. Laurie Metcalf cannot do doormat. Laurie Metcalf cannot do quiet, struggling-in-silence wife. to a man. She's incapable of doing that. Laurie Metcalf is a strong, bold, fierce presence. And she brings that to Linda. Her Linda has no time for the bullshit of her two sons.

SPEAKER_00But she ultimately, and you see how this woman who is so powerful and so strong and so smart, but you also see the love and care she has for her husband. And you see how those two blend. And it's very well done. It's a really fascinating portrayal of the role in a way that I don't think anyone's ever done before. Where it kind of bumps up for me against the wall is in act two when things take a turn for the Greek tragedy of it all. And granted, we are on a large stage at a large scale for a large house. I did not think that Metcalf had fully figured out how to take

that to a scale that

SPEAKER_00didn't seem overly shouty, you know? And again, this is something where... you want to go back and, and see how things keep progressing because I'm sure, I'm sure like by the end of the run of this, she and Lane will be absolutely zoned in and it will be impeccable. But at the time that I saw it, these were things that were kind of still being figured out between the two of them. Uh, of the two sons, we have Ben, uh, Ayers. Is that how you say his last name? Clock Twink from, uh,

ben alers from gilded age speaking of clock twink i do think that he i have i have a theory that he does not like that term because the first hour of the show he is shirtless and very much buffing himself up and i'm like oh he wants to kill clock twink and long live the clock twink long live the clock twunk i suppose um he and

SPEAKER_00christopher abbott as biff What Mantello also does is he moves the setting from the 1940s to unclear if it's the 1960s, 70s, if it's present day. I personally was getting more of a present day vibe when I saw it, but it's been more confirmed that it's now taking place in the mid to late 60s. And because of this, certain aesthetics and certain attitudes of characters change with it. Most importantly, Biff and Happy. The way that Abbott and Allers have been... directed in the way that they're approaching it themselves is

sort of like brooklyn bros so chains around the neck muscle tees which means there's a bit more of a mush mouth masculinity about their performances which they land but in the case of

SPEAKER_00abbott's biff for me made him a very distanced and cold and just uncareable character alers is happy is able to contrast that with a bit more of a comedic edge which the production desperately needs and it's a welcome presence but abbott's biff biff is supposed to be um a bleeding heart in this piece and because of the way that biff and happy are approached in this production that

SPEAKER_00doesn't allow abbott to get there at least not for act one and by the time everything comes to a head at the end of the show and abbott's biff pleads his emotional case to willie at the end abbott gives it everything and yet i didn't buy it because i did not find that the production led up to that now it worked for other people many people have spoken to how they'll never forget that the final scene with Abbott, and that's going to be what wins him the Tony for this show. And maybe it's true, and maybe that is something that got figured out ever since I

saw it.

SPEAKER_00But when I did see it, I found those two moments disconnected. And by those two moments, I mean the first. first 80 percent of the play and then the last 20 percent um it was sort of it was just a switch rather than a build-up and and i did not see any of that happening with him earlier in the show i found him to be rather stiff and part of that is just the attitude that this production has on these two characters that said The rest of the supporting company is fantastic. Tens, tens, tens across the board.

SPEAKER_00We have K. Todd Freeman, who once again brings it to every ball. The role is not the largest of roles, but he is absolutely fantastic in it. Michael Benjamin Washington, also a little underutilized, but has won two really great scenes in the piece. John Drea does really well in this. It's just, it's a really, really, strong company overall, even with my reservations on Abbott in the first half, with my reservations on Metcalf in the second half, and my slight ding on Lane throughout.

SPEAKER_00It is overall so intelligently and emotionally done for the most part, and such a different production of Salesman that you've seen that it really compels you to tell people to go see it. Because not only is Salesman, you know, it is a very strong production and it reminds you how phenomenal of a play this is and is sort of like exhibit A to anyone who doubts you. And so you want to send people to the Winter Garden who say,

SPEAKER_00oh, Salesman, that's a creaky old 1940s Miller play. It's like, no, no, no, go fucking see it. And if this production does not make you appreciate how fantastic this play is, then we kind of have nothing else to discuss when it comes to To drama, if you will. But the question you're all asking is, Tonys, what's going to happen with the Tonys? I think this has usurped Oedipus as the frontrunner for Revival. I really do. Partly because it's still running. If Oedipus were running right now, I think it would be more of a battle.

SPEAKER_00But at the moment, I think this is the frontrunner, especially because I now think that Joe Mantello has... jump straight up as the front runner for director of a play. And as I said with Jellicle Ball, it's really difficult to vote for a director for a revival and then not vote for the revival itself. It's really difficult. So I think those two are hand in hand. I think Lane and Metcalf are absolute lock for nominations. Christopher Abbott probably is going to get nominated.

SPEAKER_00Biff tends to get nominated. Featured actor in a play this year is a pretty, it's both a wide open field and a crowded category. And so any combination of actors could get in there. i think uh i i found ben allers as as happy to be the more successful of the performances i would nominate him over abbott but abbott tends to has the better role and has the final moments that really make you uh walk away with thinking about him for most people i would say i guess the other thing i'll say is i i found that metcalf wasn't able to fully land the final monologue of

linda the i can't cry

SPEAKER_00monologue but Listen, I'm sure that at this point she fully has it locked in. It just wasn't there when I saw it. But I do think that she and Lane are locked for nominations. Metcalf could win. Probably will, I would imagine. But I think she could win. Abbott could get nominated. Allers could get nominated. Revival and director locks. Favorites to win. I think that they also have... I think there are locks for nominations for sound and lighting. Probably favorites to win in those categories too.

SPEAKER_00I could imagine them getting in for set design too. It's not... It's a big set design, but it's a big and sparse set design. So it's not like it's as elaborate as, say, Dog Day Afternoon, but because of how it's designed, it is so supportive of the production, its housing, that that is what gives it the edge over something like a Dog Day Afternoon, especially if we're talking about for a win. So that would be... my thoughts on salesman for tony chances um so yeah once again that is us for giant

that is us for dog day afternoon and that is us for death of a salesman i will reveal more about where they rank in my overall rankings of the season in a few

SPEAKER_00episodes but yeah um That's it for this episode, guys. Make sure that you have your tickets for May 3rd, Broadway Breakdown, reviewing the 2025-2026 season. And then you've joined the Discord so you can talk more about your feelings about these reviews or where things are heading with the Tonys with other listeners of the podcast. You can also join the sub-stock. We're going to start having more written content soon enough. You can follow me on Instagram at MacCoplicUsualSpelling. You can do a nice five-star rating or review. And yeah, I'm trying to think who I want us to close out with today.

SPEAKER_00You know what? John Lithgow, his last Broadway musical was Dirty Round Scoundrels. And now we've done Sherry Renee Scott, but it's been a while since we've done Joanna Gleason, if ever. So we're going to close out today with Joanna Gleason. Okay, that's it. I will see you guys shortly for the next review. Yeah, have a good one. I hope you guys enjoyed this. Take it away, Joanna. Bye. Only three more tries and we'll have our prize When the end's in sight you'll

SPEAKER_03realize If the end is right it justifies the peace

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode