Matt Reviews: THE ROCKY HORROR SHOW & THE FEAR OF 13
54 minAudio
Matt dives into two wildly different theatrical experiences: The Rocky Horror Show and The Fear of 13. One leans into camp and audience participation, the other a stark, psychological portrait rooted in real-life events. Matt explores how each production navigates tone, performance demands, and audience engagement - plus whether either has a meaningful path in this year’s Tony Awards race. Important Links * Broadway Breakdown Live!: Green Room 42 Tix * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Timestamps * 2:30 - Early awards season check-in: Outer Critics Circle Awards * 6:30 - Drama League Awards + impact on the Tony race The Rocky Horror Show * 10:14 - Context + legacy * 24:30 - Performances + standout casting choices * 35:54 - Tony Awards outlook The Fear of 13 * 37:43 - Premise + real-life inspiration * 48:51 - Tony Awards outlook + comparison Listener discussion questions * What makes a revival like The Rocky Horror Show feel fresh rather than purely nostalgic? * Re: The Fear of 13 - how does a commercial Broadway venture steer clear of “Trauma Tourism:? * Which type of theatrical experience resonates more with you right now: communal, participatory fun or intimate, psychologically driven storytelling? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01But we have a great dramatic finish. Oh, I'm sure you do, but Mr. Gramps... Ah! Hit it!
SPEAKER_02Broadway, Broadway, we've missed it so. We're leaving soon and taking June to star her in a show.
SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And wouldn't you know it, it's another review episode today. We got a couple more reviews coming up before we finally dive right back into all of our full Tony Awards coverage. Luckily, all of the shows have been open now.
SPEAKER_00So we're in the final grind of getting it all together. We have a couple of the housekeeping we need to do. We have a new review for the podcast. Thank you very much. And I also want to talk a bit briefly about a couple of awards. bodies that have released their nominations and what that means for Tonys and for your predictions and blah, blah, blah, blah. And then we'll get into our actual reviews. So first up, let's do the review for the podcast on Apple Podcasts. Cue the light and the piazza overture. Five stars. The King of Versailles.
SPEAKER_00This is the best theater podcast ever. No competition whatsoever. That kind of rhymes. Matt's theater knowledge is priceless, but he generously shares it among his people. His eloquence is unique and makes us all jealous. I will say I've been dinged a bit about my eloquence. I've said words incorrectly on this podcast, for sure, and will continue to do so. Moving on. I am desperately waiting for every single new episode. Dear Matt, don't you dare take... And that's where it ends. I'm assuming the final sentence is supposed to be, don't you dare take too long or your sweet time with stuff.
SPEAKER_00I'm not taking my time with these episodes. I do have to take a breather. I also have stuff going down. In the middle of rehearsals, we're in the final week before the next Broadway Breakdown live show at Green Room 42, reviewing the 2025-2026 season. Once again, get those tickets now. Or do the live stream if you can. And then we have more scheduling of episodes to do. I have a couple of projects I'm working on outside of the podcast. So scheduling is always just really hard. And getting time to record these and editing them and all that
is always tricky.
SPEAKER_00So I don't take my time. Don't ever think that I... I'm doing that. I do drag my feet a little bit because I am lazy. I'm very, very lazy. So after that, next up, we have some... that have released their nominations. We have the Drama League and we have the Outer Critics Circle Awards. Drama League and Outer Critics Circle do... Drama League does very basic awards. They have production of a musical play, revival of a musical, revival of a play,
SPEAKER_00direction of a musical, direction of a play, and then distinguished performance. And the thing that you need to know about the Drama Leagues, similar to the Outer Critics Circle, they combine Broadway and Off-Broadway... Otter's Critic Circle does separate when it comes to performances, but for production, they are blended. And the other thing you should know about the Drama League is it is a pay-to-play voting body. Anyone in the theater industry can join the Drama League. You do have to pay an initiation fee, and I believe there are dues,
SPEAKER_00and that is ultimately what gets you on the voting committee. There's no criteria outside of that. Also, I believe that production do have to pay to get Drama League members to see them. The voting body of the Drama League and the nominating body of the Drama League is very big, and some of them do overlap with the Tonys, so that helps. But I don't believe that productions make it a point to offer press seats to every single voting member of the Drama League. If they did, they would be out of business.
SPEAKER_00So, Drama League members don't always see every show. They also have a vested interest in certain shows. So, In a lot of ways, many productions get nominated. If you look at the best musical lineup and the best play lineup, it is like at least a dozen each distinguished performances. It's supposed to be a maximum of two performers per show. Sometimes there's a slip up, sometimes there's a blip, and sometimes there's just plain old corruption. Corruption is such a harsh word for something like this. The stakes are so low, but you know what I mean.
SPEAKER_00It's not always with the most honest of intentions, which is why something like Ragtime actually has three distinguished performance nominations as opposed to the cap of what is supposed to be two. Also, distinguished performance mixes not only Broadway and off-Broadway, but musical and play. So while it is a very, very long list, there are a lot of egregious quote-unquote snubs that you'll find in there. I believe Sam Tutti for Two Strangers was left off of the list for Drama League, which doesn't mean that he is now off the list for the Tony Awards. It's just that's how these things go. Autocritic Circle also is a very odd body.
SPEAKER_00They always have been. You just have to look at some of the musicals and plays that have done very well with Autocritic Circle awards with nominations. to see how they are not a direct reflection of the Tony Awards. So, long story short, how do the Autocratic Circle nominations and the Drama League nominations affect the Tony Awards race? They don't. Nearly at all. The best thing you can say about either, and this is true of the Drama Desks, which will be coming up soon as well, Drama Desks are a little more indicative. Drama Desks is a much smaller nominating body. I think it's like a tenth the size of the nominating committee
for the Tony Awards.
SPEAKER_00And I don't and there's no overlap whatsoever in terms of people. Drama desks also have a nominating body that serves much longer terms than the Tony Awards. Tony nominating members only get three years. They do not have to be three years in succession, but they total of three years. So no year with nominators is exactly the same. So it's hard to necessarily say what a nominating body's taste would be for the Tonys. It's easier to predict for something like the Autocritic Circle and the Drama Desks because there are a lot of members who nominate every,
SPEAKER_00every, every year. So once again, it doesn't really affect. The best thing you could say is it sometimes puts certain performances and shows on the radar that nominators might not have fully thought about. pursuing before but it's the same thing with the reviews critical reviews for shows don't necessarily dictate how the nominations are going to go what they might do is a show that is considered on the more flippant side like a titanic or schmigadoon if they get solid reviews nominators can feel a bit more like
they are allowed to
SPEAKER_00show them a lot of love Which is weird. You want to feel like no one's going to be influenced by anything. They should just go with their own personal taste. But it's true. We're all influenced by everything that happens around us. So it doesn't necessarily mean that nominators go, oh. oh, well, Schmigadoon got a critic's pick, but Titanic did not. Therefore, I shall give Schmigadoon 12 nominations and Titanic 4. That's not it. It's just more that when people are sort of on the fence with how hard they're willing to gun for a show,
SPEAKER_00sometimes a critical reception can help give them that extra push of, for lack of a better word, bravery to really go to the mat for the shows that they believe in. But also, it doesn't... That's a more an overall critical reception, not necessarily The New York Times. There is a very semi-true, I guess, logic that if The Times likes a show, that means that show has the advantage for nominations and to win. Not always the case. We remember in 2024, The Outsiders and Suffs were the only two Best Musical nominees
that year that did
SPEAKER_00not have critics picks, and yet they probably walked away the best at the Tony Awards that year, Suffs winning score in Book, The Outsiders winning musical, Hell's Kitchen. came in with, I think, the most, or at least they tied with the Outsiders for the most nominations. And Hell's Kitchen just walked away with actress and featured actress. Water for Elephants also had a critics pick. It walked away empty handed. Illinois had a critics pick. It walked away with choreography. Last year, Gypsy v. Sunset, Gypsy arguably had the better reviews overall.
SPEAKER_00It definitely had the better New York Times review. It had the critics pick. Plus, as the Tony season was ramping up, Ben Brantley decided to put it upon himself to write an opinion piece on why Audra was giving the best performance of the season. gypsy ended up blanking at the 20 awards and sunset one actress and revival these things happen you know the year of thoroughly modern millie that uh did not have a very good new york times review in fact i would argue they got pretty much a straight up pan and yet they did win musical and actress and featured actress you could and a slew of others you could argue the 9 11 of it all
SPEAKER_00As opposed to Millie versus You're in Town, that absolutely plays a factor, but that is more in line with why Millie would win musical, not necessarily why it would win all the other awards that it won opposite its competition. The Year of Jersey Boys, Jersey Boys got kind of a middling review from the New York Times. And yet that won Best Musical. The New York Times is not the deciding factor ever. It can help. It can help with a narrative. It can help with momentum. It is not the deciding factor. In fact, while Ben Bradley, I think, did give Kinky Boots a critics pick, he absolutely was more in love with Matilda.
And Matilda did not do nearly as well at the Tony Awards as Kinky Boots did or at
SPEAKER_00the box office. So there you go. These are lures that don't always hold up. Enough of all of that Tony speak. We'll talk more about that in a few days as we do a kind of final big swing nomination episode with all of you guys and a few friends at the pod. We won't do like an actual podcast. final predictions list so much as big swings that everybody's throwing out there to see if they catch on in the actual real realistic narrative but let's move on we've got two reviews today due today we have the rocky horror show
at roundabout theater company and we have the fear of 13 currently playing at the james earl jones theater uh technically speaking a british import from the donmar warehouse although this is a totally different production different director in david cromer on whole
SPEAKER_00new design team whole new cast except for its lead two-time Oscar winner, Adrian Brody. We'll do Fear of 13 last, so we'll open up with the Rocky Horror Show. Bam, bam, bam. The first Broadway revival since the 2000 production, which starred Tom Hewitt and Alice Ripley, Jared Emek, Raul Esparza, Daphne Rubin-Vega, Joan Jett, Leia DeLaria. The list goes on. Dick Cavett, my God. Not to mention people who were phantoms in that show, like Kevin Cahoon, Tony nominee Kevin Cahoon, Tony nominee Matthew Morrison, Deidre Goodwin.
SPEAKER_00Love, Deidre. For those of you who are unfamiliar with The Rocky Horror Show, it is the basis of the cult classic film, The Rocky Horror Picture Show, written by Richard O'Brien. In fact, it is listed outside the theater and in most marketing as Richard O'Brien's The Rocky Horror Show. That's become a theme this season. Arthur Miller's death of a salesman. August Wilson's Joe Turner's come and gone. At this point, it should be like Marla Mendel's Titanic. We're putting the author's name over everything, and I'm not entirely sure if that's an estate situation or what, but I've been noticing a lot more this season than in past seasons.
SPEAKER_00The Rocky Horror Show is about 53 years old at this point, I want to say, and it is infamous for being an incredibly transgressive and boldly proud character queer, fluid musical in the vein of a campy B-horror movie. And it was this giant phenomenon when it premiered in London. It was like an underground London musical that just kind of kept on getting bigger and bigger with its success, running, I think, for like six years or something like that.
SPEAKER_00Coming to America, being very successful in Los Angeles, which if you know Los Angeles, being a successful theater production is almost impossible. Not totally, but almost. Then infamously bombs on Broadway at the same time that the film comes out and the film also bombs. But the film, as we now know, has become a late midnight showing classic, having now run in movie theaters for over 50 years and becoming one of the highest grossing movie musicals of all time, even when adjusted for inflation due to the constant repeat
viewership of Rocky
SPEAKER_00Horror fans. This has now given the show a major legacy and reputation. And it has always been a bit of a tug of war when Rocky Horror has come back to Broadway because there is a Broadway expectation of production caliber. There is an expectation of what Rocky Horror is as a property. And there's an expectation that people have of how the two should meet. 2000 revival which has a great number of fans myself included i adore that cast recording that production was dinged at the time by critics for
actually being too
SPEAKER_00broadway for being too heavy on spectacle and vocal flair and treating the piece with a lack of grunge and this revival has now kind of had the opposite problem where people who either have a deep connection with the 2000s revival or have their own love of rocky horror either whether it's the picture show or it's their own productions they've done at Bucks County Playhouse or their own regional theaters. People having a specific expectation of sheen and polish and Broadway-isms that this production for some audience members has not met.
There's also the talk of the callbacks that are very typical in Rocky Horror.
SPEAKER_00Callbacks being that in the movie... What helped make Rocky Horror Picture Show become such a cult classic was the audience interaction. There would, first of all, be actors who would perform sort of in pantomime in front of the screen, but also audiences would come in with props and they would have specific moments associated. in the movie where they would call back at the screen. Famous ones would be two of our main characters, Brad Majors and Janet Weiss. When they would hear the full name, Brad Majors, audiences would shout asshole. And when they would hear Janet Weiss, they would shout slut.
SPEAKER_00Other things in addition to that, That I see you shiver with anticipation. That has helped add to the lore of Rocky Horror and this production during previews. People were very frustrated because they felt like the callouts were not being honored and maybe still are not being honored. What did I think? Well, I'll start off by saying I mostly enjoyed this revival. I have my caveats and I'll get to those. But... Overall, I found this a very pleasant experience. Not quite Helen Shaw's critics pick level of love,
but considering I had a few friends who were also at my performance who were
SPEAKER_00texting me afterwards about how they actually hated the production, which I don't. I'm not surprised by, but I'm sort of somewhere in the middle. I had things about it that I wish were improved, but also there's a charm about this production that I don't think can be denied. And I also think a lot of the kinks that people had issues with at the beginning of previews, a lot of them have resolved during the preview process. So good on Sam Pangleton and his whole company. Now we'll get a little bit more into the nitty-gritty, so if you want to skip, you can skip. If you don't know the basic plot, it follows Brad Majors, Janet Weiss,
asshole, slut.
SPEAKER_00They get engaged after a friend's wedding, and they decide to go visit their former college professor, Dr. Scott, whose class they met in, to announce their engagement. Their car breaks down in the middle of a rainstorm. They go to a nearby castle, as one does, to... To borrow a phone so they can call for, you know, an auto repair shop to pick up their car and take them to the nearest gas station. But once they get there, they find themselves in what Brad would probably call, I think he calls it like a hunting den for rich weirdos.
SPEAKER_00Of course, to us, we see these transgressive aliens who are odd and sexual and celebratory and a little incestuous. And they meet the infamous Dr. Frankenfurter, who brings Brad and Janet to his laboratorium to introduce them to his creation, Rocky, a stunning male figure who is basically there to relieve all of Frankenfurter's tension. Other shenanigans ensue. One of Frankenfurter's old lovers bursts back out of a frozen
captivity, only to be murdered. as it so happens eddie's uncle is the same dr scott that brad and janet tried to visit dr scott shows up in search of eddie and reveals that frankenfurter and his cohorts are all aliens and frankenfurter's servants semi-servants end up uh killing him and rocky and heading back to their planet of transylvania and brad and janet and dr scott escape and that's the end of the show the whole thing is as i said
SPEAKER_00framed like a pulpy B-horror film. What I think this production gets right that is going to be divisive for people is it leans back into the old aesthetic of rocky horror of the film and of its original uh you know off west end origins the whole theater uh the set design is by dots is very like party city plus intentionally so it's not that it is it's a very it's not a sparse design at least not around
the theater there's
SPEAKER_00plenty of stuff decorating the theater but none of it is particularly uh grand or expensive looking or streamlined it all looks kind of slapdash thrown together at the very last second it honestly feels like a community theater production of rocky horror you know with a budget of twenty dollars and a whole bunch of ingenuity and i think that there's a reason for that which is ultimately as i said bringing the show back to its roots there is a
um a broadcast from the west end i want to say like 2015 2016 of rocky horror show that was you know like a two-week run limited two-week run in the west end that was broadcast uh across the country for charity and that production is a similar vibe
SPEAKER_00of you know semi-amateur level production value and staging and a very pedestrian level of of performance intentionally so and it feels like pinkleton kind of got his inspiration from that production more than from the 2000s production and part of that is also evident in his staging there are cute little tricks that pinkleton does with puppets and with sort of garish costume design the choreography is intentionally very manic and sloppy
and there are moments of i guess you could say like classic english pantomime of presentational simplistic and yet like sort of milking the joke for the audience as long as humanly possible these things that the whole thing is for the audience but also like on this sort of steam train that kind of has to keep going because the
SPEAKER_00whole show has to kind of stay under two hours Where I think that this production is trying to have its cake and eat it too and can't really do it is musically speaking. Overall, it is not an unfortunate sounding Rocky Horror. This is where perhaps my prejudice with the 2000 revival comes into play. The 2000 revival, if you get a chance to listen to it and find footage from it, like, yes, it was a very much more grand looking production than this one. It also was done in Circle in the Square Theater where audience
interaction made a
SPEAKER_00lot more sense and it leaned into the callback vibe of the show. I believe in that production they provided props for the audience to use. They had a cheat sheet for callbacks that helps people who maybe were new to Rocky Horror virgins, as we call them. And they sort of had a foot in both worlds by... You know, the communal element of the piece while also providing a bit of more Broadway sheen and Broadway vocalization. This production kind of wants to stay in the amateur world for
the most part.
SPEAKER_00And that is a problem sometimes musically. i'll get more in sort of detail about that in a second when i sort of go down the list with with the cast but certain songs that i know can really just annihilate musically songs like the floor show don't fully land because they it's this whole production is again going back to basics same thing with i would say not uh yeah eddie's teddy and with a touch a touch a touch me science fiction picture show double
feature yeah sorry science fiction double feature i always i always get that title uh fucked up
SPEAKER_00But there are other things that are totally okay. I mean, we have actual good voices in this show. We have Andrew Durand as Brad, who does a really wonderful job with Once in a While. Stephanie Hsu is a strong singer. She's not Alice Ripley in her prime, which is a high bar to clear, but she is a strong singer. Luke Evans is a very good singer. We always knew this from Beauty and the Beast and his days on the West End, right? Now, as he's gotten a bit older and I don't think he's done stage work in a long time, there's a bit more of a raspiness to his voice,
SPEAKER_00which doesn't make it unpleasant. He still hits all of his notes and really kind of relishes in it. But it does add a bit more grit, which I appreciate. Yeah. In terms of the call-outs, I can't speak for every performance. I can only speak for mine. And my performance, it felt like the call-outs were figured out most of the time. The way that this production now tries to kind of handle it is Rachel Dratch is the narrator. deals with the brunt of it. And it's up to her to decide when she's acknowledging it,
SPEAKER_00when she's going to pause for it or not. But she does pause and she allows for call-outs. And she does, with her SNL magnificence, find ways to respond to the ones that she finds more interesting. The way that she kind of keeps it from going off the rails is with call-outs. Again, so there's the classic ones, like slut, asshole, say it, patient. And yet... Because Rocky Horror Picture Show has been around for decades now, and so many cities and countries have their own versions of the
call-outs, you can't ever do the show and have everyone do the call-outs they want to do.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes it's the whole audience is in on it. Sometimes it's like one random person says something really crazy. And when those unique ones happen, what Dratch tends to do is she finds a way to kind of acknowledge it with a bit of condescension. Not in a way of like, you're an idiot, what's wrong with you, you asshole, but more sort of like, that was a weird one, or like, never heard that one before. And it kind of keeps people, at least in my performance, it kept people in line where it wasn't about... their own personal experience with rocky horror anymore it was
about finding the common ground with enough people so that when there was a call out it was a special one of course you know there are still ones where someone would do something random and drach would acknowledge it but it wasn't a huge problem at least not at my performance there are other things that the cast absolutely relishes in luke evans
SPEAKER_00does uh lean into the sweet transvestite call outs but then there are other times where he makes it a point to kind of silence them not because he doesn't like them or the or the cast is trying to ignore them so much as again you can't have every call out be acknowledged you have to kind of keep going with it and it makes the ones that are acknowledged all the more special the brad and janet asshole sluts are always acknowledged And they're always acknowledged in different ways. The way that Stephanie Hsu and Andrew Durand kind of portray it is like,
SPEAKER_00if you've ever watched Archer, the character is Cheryl, who's voiced by Judy Greer. There's an episode where they're all on a plane to get to a submarine. Long story. But there's a whole subplot happening with Cheryl and her brother and her brother's girlfriend. Whenever there's sort of like suspense music playing, Cheryl's sort of looking around and going, what the fuck's happening with Cheryl? And then you realize Cheryl can hear the music. And she even says to herself, It's OK. It's non-diegetic. And it's a crazy joke. And it gets it pays off even fuller later where the music plays again.
SPEAKER_00And she's like, God damn it. Enough with the music. And everyone's like, the fuck is she talking about? Because no one can hear the music. You know, that's how it is. is in TV and film, right? Like the whole idea is if you're watching like an action sequence and you hear a 300-piece orchestra playing intense music, like Batman can't hear that music. We hear that music. And yet in Archerland, Cheryl can hear the music. And in Rocky Horror... Brad and Janet can always hear the sluts assholes, but they're not sure where it's coming from. And as I understand it, there are now performances where Luke Evans will sort of play
upon this and he'll
SPEAKER_00say things like, oh, it's the plumbing, which is hilarious. But yeah, it's always sort of like they're in this haunted castle and at any given moment they'll just hear like in the echoes somewhere asshole or slut and they're like wait what and it's it's a lot of fun to watch as i said not every call out is is done not every call out is acknowledged but when it is i think it's really worthwhile and i can't speak for every performance but at mine it did feel like they sort of found the balance there i will now get into performances and then sort of final thoughts on rocky horror in terms of cast we are
SPEAKER_00Sort of in a mixed bag here. We have some people who absolutely nailed the assignment. Some people who I think are strong, but maybe in the wrong role. And then two people who I do find to be just not right, not only for their roles, but for the show. At the top of my list here of my correct for their roles, nailed the assignment are... Luke Evans as Frank Inferter, Stephanie Hsu as Janet, and Rachel Dratch as the narrator. I understand Dratch had gotten sort of an unwary territory, sorry, had gotten into wary territory in the beginning of previews,
but I do think she's absolutely found her groove and really sticks out in a
SPEAKER_00fantastic way. And I just find her so funny in this in a way that I thought she was funny in POTUS, but sort of underused in what I found to be not terribly funny play or terribly funny funnily directed in this i think she is in her element and holds the whole thing together and deals with the call-outs really well and and just has a really strong ominous vibe but in a comical way that continues the b horror film aesthetic that i don't think
everyone else in the
SPEAKER_00company is able to do or isn't even allowed to do So she's just really wonderful glue in this show, but also glue that sticks out in a great way. Stephanie as Janet, I think, is such a wonderful piece of casting. And when she was announced, I was really excited to see what she was going to bring to it because I think she is such a phenomenal actress. You just watch her in everything, everywhere, all at once to see the depths of her talent. And I always felt that she was terribly underused in be more chill i liked her a lot in spongebob and then to see her be more chill and a show where i think the female roles are written terribly
and used terribly it kind of hurt my heart to see her play such a doormat of a role
SPEAKER_00that that had no follow through and in this she plays again an intentionally one-dimensional role but she has so much fun with the melodrama of it all it's hard for an audience to know how good the janet is up front because when brad and janet enter they are supposed to be kind of silly wet blankets literally they're out in the rain but as the show continues and brad and janet uh you know sort of devolve into um More just sort of, what's the word looking for? Salacious activities.
SPEAKER_00You really see how Shu can be just so game. Duran too, but I'll get to that in a second. Particularly the scene where Frank Inferter seduces Janet and Brad separately when he seduces Shu. You watch her character be devastated, but also still incredibly horny and into it. And the way that Shu goes about that, it's fantastic. She's slip and sliding all over the bed. She does legography that I can't really describe, but just you know it when you see it. And... letting her freak flag fly all throughout i think the best ways to cast rocky horror is you ultimately want weirdos to play even the more
straight laced parts
SPEAKER_00but I have nothing else to say. I just think she really nails it. And Janet had such a hard role. Again, she doesn't necessarily have the vocal prowess of Alice Ripley circa 2000, few do, but she does still sing it really well. And she had some vocalizations that I was really impressed by. Luke Evans as Frankenfurter. Again, you know, Frankenfurter is the role. You really don't have to do much to sell it. You just have to be confident and sly with a little bit of a wink.
SPEAKER_00And Evans doesn't really do a winking Frankenfurter. His Frankenfurter is a bit more of a diva and a bit more of a... lumbering presence in a fun way. You know, he doesn't have the Tim Curry, Tom Hewitt slash Terrence Mann vibe of a grand dame in pumps in a corset. In fact, when he does Sweet Transvestite, I was like, oh, I'm kind of getting the vibe that you're like a bratty teenager, which is also totally legitimate because in a lot of ways,
SPEAKER_00Frank Conferter is a horny, bratty teenager. Everything that Frank Conferter does is for the sole purpose of their sexual release or just their things that they like. They're not doing anything for any greater purpose other than their own enjoyment. And so there is a brattiness to Evans' Frankenfurter that I really appreciated. Would I have liked maybe a bit more of a winking tone to him? Sure, but I don't think that that's really the tone of this production. The tone of this production is more leaning into the melodrama rather than the fun of the silliness
well everyone is having fun but you know you know what i mean like there's there's a difference between having fun on stage by being bold and dramatic and then there's having fun
SPEAKER_00on stage by being fun All you have to do is sort of watch David Bedella's performance as Frank Inferno on YouTube to know what I'm talking about. Like, Bedella is doing more of a Tim Curry meets, like, I don't know, John Marco, the stand-up. I don't know how to say his last name, but you know what I'm talking about. The not-gay, straight, musical theater boy stand-up comedian who has never found a stool that he can't sit on. That is sort of where Bedella is at. And Evans is a bit more in the, like, head of gobbler in a horror movie.
vibe and it's fun he's living his best life and it absolutely works in our more like middle plus ground we have andrew durand as brad and we have ambergray as riffraff one of the cohorts for frankenfurter both do really good jobs they are appropriately cast they sound good they're having fun durand is very very game
SPEAKER_00again in the frankenfurter seducing brad scene duran is doing some great physical comedy and skip ahead 30 seconds if you don't want the spoiler when it is revealed to janet that brad is with frankenfurter in bed scene that they show is frankenfurter fully eating brad's ass like full-on white lotus season one just tossing that salad and it's a wonderful wonderful visual and we adore andrew duran for going for it on stage because the truth is not every actor would be willing to do that the thing is When I talk about people being freaks and needing to still be
able to play Brad and
SPEAKER_00Janet, that is true of Durand. But I also watched the show and I felt like while Durand is a really solid Brad, he could be used better elsewhere. And that's also probably because some people are not right for their roles. And so some switching would need to be done to make it work better. Same thing goes for Ambergray. Sounds good. Is in the pocket. Really leaning into the cappiness of the piece. Again, I think she can be used better elsewhere. Get to that in a second. Harvey Gwian as Eddie slash Dr. Scott.
SPEAKER_00Whole bunch of fun. Solid singer and really, you know, has a good ear for comedic beats, which sounds like such a low hanging fruit compliment. But you don't really know how much of a gift that is until you see people who do sort of by the numbers comedy jobs and shows. And then someone like Harvey in this show. having a lot of fun with turning phrases on their heads to get a new laugh out of it. After that, we have Josh Rivera as Rocky.
SPEAKER_00He's fine. He looks very good half-naked, although I still think that they have this Rocky a little too covered up. We're used to the golden shorts and nothing else. Rivera is in a bit more of like a harness-y situation and not a great wig, I'll say. And then at the bottom of our list, unfortunately, is Juliette Lewis as Magenta and Michaela J. Rodriguez as Columbia. Juliette Lewis, God bless her, is just not a very good singer. She has a voice. She's on pitch, but it's not a strong voice and not a strong musicality.
She also has sort of a lugubrious energy as Magenta and as the usherette that opens
SPEAKER_00and closes the show. And that's a huge ding against this production because it opens and closes with Lewis singing. And she is by far the weakest singer in the show. She's not as comfortable on stage as everybody else. So whatever good energy you had... from this production, it kind of gets lost at the end. Or not fully, but you lose a bit of it at the end because of the book ending numbers with Lewis. And Michaela is actually a good singer, but they do something weird with Columbia here and have Michaela singing in a falsetto and doing a weird kind of
voice that just a makes you lose the lyrics and b does not make her sound as rock starry as she can be because everyone needs to be able to rock out on this and Columbia you know has
SPEAKER_00time warp and also has the floor show and you need them to sell it. And because of the keys that they put Michaela in, because of the placement of her voice, it just doesn't do that. And that's a shame. Ultimately, there are people in this show who are either miscast or solid, but maybe not the best fit. I think in my personal humble opinion, I would put Josh Rivera in as Brad, put Andrew Durant in as Riff Raff, and then Amber Gray as Magenta. That is ultimately how I think it should go. Because Rivera as Rocky is not
terribly funny he's very committed but he doesn't really know how to sell rocky's dumbness and naivete there are more opportunities for him to do so as brad because brad is not as over the top in pain as rocky is brad is just oblivious and i think rivera can do that earnestness better as brad i also be interested to see him get his ass eaten although it's wonderful to see durand do that and then durand is just
SPEAKER_00you know He's luxury casting as Brad, and because we need him more as Riff Raff, because we need Amber Gray as Magenta, that is sort of how I would put everything there. In terms of Tony nominations, I do think this is a lock for Revival. I think it's the third final slot. As I said before, Roundabout really needed to shit the bed to get this production not nominated, and I don't think that they do. I wish that there was a bit more of a sheen to it. I understand the vibe they're going for, and I'm totally on board with it, but you want it to kind of kick up to a broadway caliber by like 15 you want
like just a little bit better singing from some people you want the staging to be you you're we're okay
SPEAKER_00with chaotic staging but you want it to be a little more mindful and have a little more of an eye for build and and stage pictures and you want you just want a little bit more ingenuity in book scenes as well as opposed to just stage numbers because something like over at the frankenstein place i think is actually staged incredibly well i think damage and it is staged really well i also think once in a while is staged well but then there are things like the floor show which is kind of sloppy time warp is kind of sloppy It's fun. It's energetic. They bring audience members on stage, but it's it's sloppy.
SPEAKER_00But I do think revival is locked. I do think Luke Evans is a lock. I think Stephanie Hsu has a really, really good shot at featured actress. We've yet to determine whether she's going to be in lead or featured. I think everyone but Evans is going to be in featured. And I think she's got a really strong shot at getting in there, which would be great. I would love to see Rachel Trach get in there as well, but I'm not as positive about that. I think Durand could get in. He's well-liked. He does a good job. It's not quite enough of a role to... stand out especially when featured actor is both crowded and
open at the same time so who's to say pingleton could get in it would not be my number one choice but crazier things have happened and i think that the the fun vibe he puts out is enough for some people and it is there is a vision here as opposed to other shows that maybe are a little smoother sailing but a little more mellow and bland in
SPEAKER_00terms of their vision So we give him props for swings and, and having some of it land. And I do think revival and Evans are locks. I could see a world in where costumes and set get in. And that's kind of it. I don't see it happening for choreography lighting perhaps, but the lighting is more sort of like always a shade of green, always a shade of red, always a shade of purple. Uh, that's sort of where we see rocky horror happening any more questions you can ask me in the discord or on Substack last but not least we have the fear of 13 by lindsey farantino based off of the documentary of the same name
the fear of 13 so up front in case you don't any spoilers i had seen this about two weeks ago and i really didn't care for it and i before i made my review somebody involved in the
SPEAKER_00production asked me where i was sitting and i said oh i was i was in the front of the balcony and they're like, we're going to get you a ticket closer to the stage. We want you to feel the intimacy of the show a bit more before you review it, like review it however you want. But will you do us this favor and see it again at a closer seat and then tell us what you think? I said, sure. So I went back. And so I will say upfront being being close to the stage did help. But my feelings on the show still are kind of the same, which is ultimately that I did not care for it.
SPEAKER_00There are things to admire in it. And it's absolutely done with the most well meaning of intentions. But ultimately, I do not think that this show works. Lindsay Farentino kind of 0 for 2 this season, both with pieces based off of documentaries. Those of you who don't know, the play in the documentary focused on inmate Nick Yarris, who was arrested, I believe, in the early 80s for a trigger warning rape and a murder of a young woman. He was found guilty due to circumstantial evidence,
but no actual forensic evidence because forensic evidence was in its infancy. And he was in jail for 20 years and eventually was released because DNA evidence
SPEAKER_00was analyzed and revealed that Yanis was not the culprit. None of his DNA was on any of the evidence. Someone else's DNA was. So after being in captivity for over 20 years, he is eventually released. The documentary is done sort of in the style of a one-man show. And the thing about Yaris that really made him a compelling figure was his desire for knowledge and his desire to fight for himself when it became clear that the system wasn't going to help him, that people who were assigned to his case were not going to help him.
SPEAKER_00Yaris started reading in prison he would read like a book a day novels law books whatever he could get his hands on and wanted to expand his vocabulary and better himself and in the play he also develops a relationship with a reporter named jackie miles here played by tessa thompson the rest of the company plays a very variety of roles eddie cooper's in the show he plays a variety of roles evram sykes plays a variety of roles ben thompson and And the show mostly follows Jackie Miles' interactions with Yaris,
SPEAKER_00her interactions with other inmates, the progression of her relationship with Yaris, how they sort of fall for each other and do sort of a faux wedding. And then she continues to fight for his case, even though it becomes more and more disparaging over the years as it gets thrown out or it gets delayed or he gets denied. And then eventually... yaris when he's on the brink of collapse is told that his case has finally been looked through and the dna has been looked at and he has been acquitted and he goes
back out into the real world the show also plays around with timelines so there's thompson and and brody's actual like in real time relationship and then brody
SPEAKER_00talking about his upbringing and his own trauma and the story of how he got into prison because he was arrested at first for a different crime and then while he was in prison he sorry while he was in jail he was made aware of a different crime the rape and murder of this young woman and he figured that he could pin it on someone he knew who was um a gang member but was also conveniently dead so he was going to tell the police in exchange for his
freedom and and considered innocent of his current charges, he would give them information on this other crime.
SPEAKER_00He does. They then find that the person that Brody thought was dead actually isn't dead. He's alive, has an alibi, which means that Brody is now a suspect in this other crime. And so while he is found innocent of his original charges, he's then found guilty of his of these new charges, which is what puts him in prison. And the play goes around all over with that and with other inmates and sort of the injustice of the prison complex and how flawed the justice system is. And the play does have a bit of humor in it. Part of the fun is how Yaris always goes against your
expectations of him.
SPEAKER_00He reads, he has insights, he has a sense of humor. There's also a bit of musicality. There are songs that are sung acapella in the show, which adds a nice little bit of gravitas towards it. There is a style to it, this production. The set design by Arnolfo Maldonado is basically, it looks like a unit set of a prison with floors of cells and dark brick all over. But then there are surprises. Things pop out of the set that reveal a room or a store or an apartment.
SPEAKER_00And there's a fluidity to David Comer's staging and the lighting by Heather Gilbert is very shadowy, but then also will provide some blues and purples during flashback sequences. Sarah Lux, who's friend of the pod from Backstage Pass, does the costumes. They're all very appropriate to the story. Being closer definitely gave me a better sense of Thompson and Brody's performances, which is to say that Tessa Thompson and Adrian Brody are magnificent film actors. They have great instincts. They're very dropped in. They have
a good insight into the characters that they play they have an open honest and natural way of tapping into their darker emotions but similar to other film and tv actors they haven't really figured out how to project that onto a larger space on a stage in an 1100 seat theater how to take what they're doing and magnify it
SPEAKER_00In the balcony, I could not feel it at all. It died somewhere in the orchestra. Being much closer, being in, I think, like the fourth row at this point, I definitely could see the seeds of where the performances were. They still didn't affect me partly because they were performances that one put on stage just did not land. I could see the nuances of them due to how small they are as performers, you know, being film actors. But still, there was something that just wasn't translating on stage for
them.
SPEAKER_00And it does give me a little bit more leeway with them, but it still doesn't make their performances totally successful. Brody, in particular, is kind of going for... typical inner city gang member with a heart of gold which is really not the yaris vibe if you even watch a couple of clips of the documentary or the documentary's trailer there's more to him than that and in fact he's he's really not that kind of stereotype at all
and his story is powerful all on its own but it's even more interesting when you sort of take into account how much he just like up front does not present how many people would unjustly think of an inmate the title of the piece always confused me and i wasn't quite sure why and then luckily um i think helen shaw in the times said why the title was the title and it's because in the documentary yaris talks
SPEAKER_00about you know learning all these new words and trying to expand his vocabulary, and he learned the word triskaidekaphobia, which is the fear of the number 13, hence the title of the documentary. But they cut that reference in the play. They talk about Yaris learning new words, and Brody says a few of the new words, but he never says triskaidekaphobia. So you wonder, why cut that and keep the title because now the title doesn't really mean anything unclear i guess my issue with the piece and and with brody and with thompson is fear of 13
SPEAKER_00while it has well-meaning intentions it ultimately can't help but be what i call trauma tourism which is when a piece is about a oppressed either group of people or person someone who is dealing with an unjust system someone who has heaps of trauma or or or what what have you happen upon them and an audience watches and feels empathy but ultimately walks out of the theater feeling like a better
person for having spent
SPEAKER_00two hours with someone who was in a worse situation than they were, even if the piece itself doesn't go any farther than that. That's always been one of my issues with, you know, musicals about racism or homophobia or sexism that don't really delve into the minutia of it and doesn't really try to challenge audiences to hold their own selves accountable. but rather just wants audiences to pat themselves on the back and say, you know, I did the work by being here today, which is just not true. It's ultimately the least you could do.
SPEAKER_00And Fear of Thirteen definitely wants you to live within this prison, literally and figuratively, while also... having enough of a distance that you are, as an audience, never culpable in any of it and never invested in it other than your emotions, other than your empathy. Again, it's traumatourism. You're simply passing through, taking a few pictures, patting yourself on the back, and moving on to the next better destination. In fairness to Fear of 13, that's pretty much true of any Broadway show that tries to do
something like this. And it is ultimately on the piece and the production team to overcome that.
SPEAKER_00And some have. We'll talk about that a bit more with August Wilson in the next episode. But I would argue the majority of them do not. It's a little easier to get away with it in a film. It's more realistic. It's up close and personal, especially with the documentary. But with a play, and especially with a Broadway play, it's such a high ticket price. Seeing the show, seeing the movie star is ultimately the selling factor and not necessarily the
SPEAKER_00subject matter itself or what one can do about said subject matter. It's not activism, it's tourism. And I don't have a solution. Not for this or for shows like it. Other than you kind of know when it works when you witness it. And that doesn't help anyone involved in this production, unfortunately. So I don't want anyone to hear this and be like, Matthew, that's not helpful. I know it's not helpful. I'm simply talking about it.
SPEAKER_00But that is something to think about. When you are doing a piece like Fear of 13, the first thing you have to say to yourself is, How do we keep this from being trauma tourism? And everything needs to be in aid of that. And while I don't think that this production succeeds, many others don't as well. So it's not, pardon the phrase, but it's not necessarily a crime that it doesn't succeed at this. But succeeded it, it still does not. In terms of Tony nominations, I do think that play is out of the cards for this show. I think Tessa Thompson is out of the cards. Brody could still get in because leading actor is a weird race.
SPEAKER_00If you are on the Discord, there's definitely a debate right now of who's a lock in leading actor in a play at the moment. I maintain that the three absolute locks are Nathan Lane in Salesman, John Lithgow for Giant, and Mark Strong for Oedipus. I would then argue Daniel Radcliffe for Every Brilliant Thing is next with a fifth open slot. Could be Will Harrison for Punch. There are a few members who think it's going to be Jon Bernthal for Dog Day Afternoon. It's certainly possible. Adrian Brody for Fear of 13 is also possible. We'll see what happens with Alden with Becky Shaw.
SPEAKER_00I maintain he is absolutely the lead of that show, but I am also a realist and understand that he will probably put in featured. But that means that there's a shot for Brody here. I could see this getting in on the design front for set and lighting in particular. It is a very efficient effective design and scenic design for a play is a little sparse right now similar to after it's like we got two or three locks and then the final two are sort of like let's see how people feel i do think cromer is out of the running there are simply too many candidates for that category for director of a play again i think our locks right now are robert ick for oedipus joe mantello for
death of a salesman
SPEAKER_00and whitney white for liberation after that Oh, there's Trip Coleman for Becky Shaw. There's Ann Kaufman for Marjorie Prime. Debbie Allen for Joe Turner's Come and Gone. God, who else would there be? Scott Ellis for Fallen Angels, I guess, but I don't really buy that. Kenny Leon for The Balusters. I think those are all legitimate nominees. Cromer, much as I enjoy him, I think he was going to get nominated for anything this season. It would be Bug, not this. But I don't even think he's getting in for Bug. So yeah, I think for Fear of 13, we can expect,
SPEAKER_00we should be prepared for up to three, maybe four nominations. None of them for play or director. But I think it's possible. It also could blank. That is also possible. But I don't, I don't ultimately think that it will. It's not, so bad that it deserves nothing like there is craft there it's ultimately just it can't overcome the tourism of it all but yeah so that's fear of 13 for you guys if you have any other questions please ask me on Substack ask me on discord you
can ask me on instagram at mac hoplick usual spelling if you are liking the podcast please give us a nice five star rating or review either on apple podcast five stars on spotify uh we're currently at i think 378 uh ratings on apple podcast let me double check if that's yeah it's still 378 we're at 170 on spotify i would love to get that up
SPEAKER_00to 200 but uh You know, we can't force it, and that's a very large number to get in not a lot of time. You can also check out the video of this on YouTube. As I said, the numbers keep climbing for that. We're not at Mickey Joe numbers. We literally just started doing this a few months ago, but the numbers are climbing, so... Thank you guys for your help and support. And the more traffic that we get on the YouTube, the more effort we're going to put into making better videos on there. So we'll invest more money in cameras and lighting and maybe some editing to make this more of like a super fun video to watch.
Unless you want to just sort of play it on YouTube while you do the dishes or
SPEAKER_00vacuum, in which case highly recommend. And besides, don't you want to see this beautiful, comfy sweatshirt I'm wearing given to me by friend of the pod, Brian Nash, who did our Hamilton episode back in the day? Fun fact, that Hamilton episode remains the hardest episode I ever had to record because where I was emotionally that day was awful. Isn't that a fun little behind the scenes note for you guys? Remember that I'm a real person with real feelings. Remember that when people write terrible things to you on YouTube or Spotify or in your Instagram comments or on Apple podcast ratings. It happens.
SPEAKER_00It happens sometimes. So we have two more review episodes coming up. We have the Ballisters and Joe Turner's come and gone next. And after that will be the Lost Boys. And then we're going to do one final Tony Awards prediction sort of episode. And then we will have our reaction to the legitimate Tony Awards. Tony nominations maybe we'll do a bonus episode on the final eligibility rulings when that comes out later this week probably Thursday TBD and then yeah if you haven't if you plan on coming to our next live show May 3rd Sunday May 3rd at 7 o'clock at Green Room 42 please do so if you can't make it to
that we have one on June 1st I'll be promoting that one as well that one is legitimately a Tony Awards
SPEAKER_00live show uh that is going to be on june 1st which is a monday at 7 at green room 42 it's going to be hilariously fun and that's it uh who should we close out with today let's close out with you know what fuck it we'll close out with miss shu with miss stephanie shu from rocky horror show i'll find something to close us out with for her and yeah we'll see you guys for the next one take it away stephanie bye That you'd never be into Into a guy That you'd kinda be into
From a guy That I'd
SPEAKER_03never be into Into a guy That I'd kinda be into Is he worth it? Jeremy
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...