Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Tony Awards 2026: A Way Too Early Chat w/ Richie Grasso and Jeff Malone

Jan 22, 20261 hr 41 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

It’s never too early to argue about the Tonys. In this episode, Matt is joined by Broadway obsessives Richie Grasso and Jeff Malone (Half Hour, Half Hour with Jeff & Richie) to make wildly premature, deeply passionate predictions about the current season. Together, they size up contenders, clock narrative momentum, question voter behavior, and debate what actually wins awards versus what deserves to. Broadway Breakdown Links Broadway Breakdown Discord Broadway Breakdown Substack Timestamps00:00 - Welcome & ground rules for premature Tony takes05:10 - Best Musical: early frontrunners and dark horses15:40 - Best Revival: nostalgia vs. reinvention24:30 - Lead Actor & Actress races begin to form36:00 - Featured categories and scene-stealing performances45:20 - Director, score, and design categories55:10 - Critical buzz vs. box office reality1:03:30 - Industry narratives, snubs, and voter psychology1:12:00 - What could change everything before nominations1:20:00 - Final hot takes and disclaimers (because it’s January) Listener discussion questions Which category do you think is most unpredictable this year - and why?Do you prefer Tony voters reward innovation or execution?What early prediction do you think will age the worst by nomination day? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03Think of the prestige. Think of the respect. No, no, no. Think of the Tony. Tony, Tony, Tony, Tony.

SPEAKER_01Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL. And welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And with me today are friends of the pod. They've been gone for so long, but they've come home at last. You know them from their own podcast, Half Hour with Jeff and Richie. Please welcome back Richie Grasso and Jeff Malone. Hello, boys. Hello.

SPEAKER_00Hey, how are you? Happy New Year. I'm like, hey.

SPEAKER_01You guys just said that at the exact same time. Hey. So sweet. Happy New Year. How are you guys doing this New Year so far?

SPEAKER_00We're doing well. We're New Year. Reflecting on a lot of shows of 2025 and looking ahead to 2026, but all is well.

SPEAKER_01That is why we're here. It is our very first way too early Tony Predictions episode. We love to get this shit in January when it's still so wide open that anything is possible. Rather than do an official ballot for January, what I have decided to do for us gentlemen... is to look back on the season so far that we have seen and there are a couple of things that you're seeing in the next week uh after before this episode comes out but after we record so we'll we're all kind of feeling our way

through but we're looking back on the season so far and just kind of telling listeners based on what we've seen what we're telling everyone to maybe not forget about come may like

SPEAKER_01maybe you know be bold and put that on your predictions ballot because that just might happen from

SPEAKER_00our own personal insight i feel like and it's tough because i feel like unfortunately so many things from june to december are forgotten a lot of times in the tony awards not all of course but there's a lot of things that do we get not counted in because a million things open in march and april you know so it'll be interesting to see how that all pans out

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we definitely have a busy spring per usual, but it's not as busy as the last couple of years. Overall, it's fewer shows this season, especially on the musical front. So that'll be interesting to see what happens with nominations. I have some thoughts and I'm sure you do, too. So let's do it. Yeah, let's get let's get into it. You guys pick the first category and we'll go from there.

SPEAKER_00Okay, should we start big or should we go smaller? We have a whole breakdown here. I'm going to say we go, should we just go with a big one first?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, like Best Play.

SPEAKER_00Let's go Best Play. Let's go there.

SPEAKER_01Best Play, baby.

SPEAKER_00All right, what's eligible so far, right? We have Call Me Izzy, Punch, Little Bear Ridge Road, Liberation, Art, and Waiting for Gatto and Oedipus.

SPEAKER_01No, those are Rebibles.

SPEAKER_00No, those are Rebibles. Sorry, I read them all. I meant to read just the new play. Call Me Izzy, Punch, Little Bear Ridge Road, Liberation.

SPEAKER_01Yes. I think all out is also eligible. Like all in was eligible last year, but also let's be real. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02I don't think that's going.

SPEAKER_01Did you see it? No, I didn't see it. I saw All In last year, and that was enough for me. I'm not seeing All Out, which has a lineup of people I care less about. And apparently this year's stories from Simon Rich are even worse than last year's. So we're not seeing it.

SPEAKER_00I know. I think Lawrence being there playing is kind of cool. But other than that, I'm like, I don't need to spend all this money to go and see that. It seems like a placeholder. All right. Best play. What do you think? I mean, right now I'm putting my money on Liberation as best play from what we've seen.

SPEAKER_01Yes. I think Liberation is an absolute lock for a nomination. It is absolutely the front runner right now. We've got some British imports come in that are supposedly heavy hitters like Giant and every brilliant thing. But at this moment, it is Liberation. I also say Little Bear Ridge Road is probably a lock at this point. Punch and Call Me Izzy. Probably not. You had your moments. Yeah. Power to you. I think there's a world in which they get recognized in other spots.

SPEAKER_01We'll get to that in a second.

SPEAKER_00Part of me doesn't call me a Z. You'll be completely forgotten. I didn't really like it either. I mean, no.

SPEAKER_01It wasn't a good play. I think the only way that that play gets recognized down the line would be Gene Smart. And even that, I'm thinking probably – uh, uh, drama leak nomination performance. And that's where we're calling it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep. Yeah. Um, all right. Well, I guess we can go into revival since I already read them through. So what's the best survival art waiting for Gato and Oedipus so far? And we have a lot of revivals coming this spring, but that's what we got.

SPEAKER_01Well, so, uh, The question is what happens with Bug and Marjorie Prime, as this is technically their Broadway debuts, but they've both been around for a while. Marjorie Prime was a Pulitzer finalist 12 years ago. Bug has been around for over 20 years, has a movie version, and so does Marjorie Prime. I'm going to go ahead and say that they're going to be considered revivals. I think these are going to fall under the classics ruling. Yeah. Tony's going to Tony. Last year was weird because we had Eureka Day, which should have been considered original.

SPEAKER_01That fell into revival for some reason. And then many years ago, One Man, Two Governors, I know they tried to make that a revival. That ended up going in as original. So I do think Bug and Marjorie Prime, which are both over a decade old. Bug is like 20 years old and both had movie versions. I think they'll be under the classics rule. At the moment, I'm going to say Oedipus is a lock for Revival. Probably frontrunner to win, especially with Leslie Manville such a frontrunner at Actress, but we'll talk about that in a second. Yeah, and then I'm going to also put in a bid for Marjorie Prime for

Revival right now.

SPEAKER_01And that's where I'm going to leave that only because we also have – proof and joe turner's coming gone and fallen angels coming in the spring and i feel like there's another one death of a salesman right so i think at the moment we've got eight candidates for revival which means there are going to be four nominees right so with yeah so with that we would have becky shaw too would that be a revival Is that revival or original? I don't know. I was doing some research on it.

SPEAKER_01It also had an off-Broadway run, I believe. How long ago do we know that was? I don't know. I was trying to categorize what was like off-Broadway, like revival versus new, and it kept coming up that it was potentially going to be in revival.

SPEAKER_00It opened off-Broadway in 2008. yeah that's long enough that's yeah i don't know much about that show other than that's it also if if miss becky shaw miss shaw if you're nasty if she is deemed revival then yeah then i guess that would be nine and we would have five and that's a lot of revivals then that's why yeah

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that is absolutely the most stacked category of the season.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, I guess not stacked. The most packed. Stacked implies that they're all amazing revivals. We're packed with play revivals this year. So if we do have five, then I'm definitely calling Marjorie Prime. So Oedipus Marjorie Prime. I would even put in a bid for Bug. much as I found its production to be kind of just okay. I know the reception, the critical reception has been very strong. It's, it is a solid play and Carrie Coon is fantastic. We'll get to her in a second, but yeah, I will. We'll see what happens with proof and Joe Turner and fallen angels and,

SPEAKER_01and, and Brecker Shaw and death of a salesman. Even, Because if they're all great, then I think it'll be very easy for them to forget about Bug. I just think Bug is very divisive as a play and his production is not a super compelling case for it. What about you guys? Of what you've seen? Right now, we're probably going Oedipus too. Yeah, definitely. Because we've only seen Art Waiting for Godot and Oedipus. Yeah. I mean, listen... Art and Waiting for Godot, they made their money back.

SPEAKER_01Good for them. That is their award.

SPEAKER_00Right. I don't think there was anything to write home about for either of those. They're both good plays, obviously, but I don't think these productions needed to warrant any sort of big Tony buzzer thing. Yeah. these productions weren't even terrible i i waiting for gado i walked out going that was less painful than i expected but that wasn't great and then art i was like this wasn't terrible it was just insanely missable yeah right and money makers clearly right so yeah no they they made their money all right so that's the art for

SPEAKER_01the first time so oh yeah it was his first time so i was like yeah art Art is such a 90s play. It was this play that was such a huge deal for 1998. And it's one of those plays you see. And when you hear how popular it was, you go, that really was a pre 9-11 world, wasn't it?

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right, right, right. It's the kind of play that Big takes Carrie Bradshaw to in season one of Sex and the City. That is spot on. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And Carrie feels all cultured about it over brunch. All right. So we have play and play revival. I mean, musical revival is also weird right now because it's just ragtime and chess. And we've got – cat's jellicle ball and we've got rocky horror coming in the spring and mama mia is also eligible and there's another one right i guess beetlejuice could be eligible for it no beetlejuice isn't eligible they didn't they didn't invite tony people got

SPEAKER_00it got it got it

SPEAKER_01Mamma Mia is eligible. They invited Tony people, especially because they did an eligibility ruling recently that did not include Beetlejuice, but it did include Mamma Mia, which they just, they mentioned, what they said was the actress playing Donna is going to be considered lead, which implies that the show is eligible. I mean, I don't think anything on the design or production standpoint. So I think we're just looking at revival and actors. What do you feel if Titanic will be new or revival?

SPEAKER_00That's a big question we've had.

SPEAKER_01I think Titanic is going to be considered new.

SPEAKER_00Really? I do. I have a hard time understanding exactly what goes through the process with them because it just had such a long, successful off-roadway run very recently. So that's why I don't know how they... I think that not enough time has passed between it closing and it coming to

SPEAKER_01Broadway. I think that it hasn't been optioned for licensing yet. I'm almost positive it hasn't. And from what I understand, this production is going to be, if not a replica... a similar vibe of the off-Broadway production. As I understand it, it's the same creative team, so it'll be like a Here Lies Love situation, where it's everyone involved from off-Broadway is coming to Broadway and maybe expanding it, but it is the same DNA as off-Broadway. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think it's going to be considered new.

SPEAKER_01But I think that's it for revivals, right? It's chess, ragtime, Jellicle Ball, Rocky Horror. There's another one. No, there's another one in there.

SPEAKER_00Oh, and I'm on the other one.

SPEAKER_01Mamma Mia.

SPEAKER_00I think that's it. That's all we had down.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. So then we're looking at three nominees here.

SPEAKER_00Three. So, I mean, if I had to choose the three, I mean, if we took Mamma Mia out, let's just say, it could be Ragtime. I think Cats for sure. I think Ragtime for sure for nominee. I think those two. And then it'll be between Chess and Rocky Horror. I don't really know if Rocky Horror is going to be this big groundbreaking thing or is it just going to replicate parts of the movie and kind of be a moneymaker and go home. I don't know. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I'm going to go out on a limb. Unless Rocky Horror really shits the bed, like unless it's just really fucking bad, I'm going to go ahead and say that Rocky Horror will get in over chess.

SPEAKER_00Wow.

SPEAKER_01I do. I think that Roundabout has a really good relationship with the Tony Awards.

SPEAKER_00They do.

SPEAKER_01They don't always win, but they tend to get nominated.

SPEAKER_00Almost always get nominated.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Rocky Horror is an exciting property for sure. And similar to Art and Waiting for Gatto, Chess is making money and that's good enough for Tony people. They're like, oh, they don't need us. And I don't know how they'll all feel about it. Yeah. The word I've been getting from people, my own opinions aside, has been divided. Some people are like, chess was fun, but it was stupid. And people who are so, you know, balls deep in love with chess that saw the survival and were

mad because it took

SPEAKER_01the show so stupidly. But... Yeah. I don't think Chester's winning in. I think that they'll get a couple of outside nominations.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, maybe. I've heard that and we're seeing it soon. We've been waiting a while to see it, but I think it's just, I've heard everything from it's amazing to like, what is that? You know, because I feel like the music, most people leave and say, oh, I love that music. And there's a few really great songs, of course, in that score. That's why people love that show in that way. Yeah. Yeah, I think I'm just going with the bold statement that Katz is winning, but that's it.

SPEAKER_01He really thinks that's it. He really thinks that's it. Ooh. Ooh, we're talking about winning now. Winning. I know we're doing that part, but I'm like, hey, I just think that's winning, so good luck. Yeah. Do you want to have this chat now and then we can move on? It only has to be this category, but... It seems like it's between Ragtime and Katz to win.

SPEAKER_00That's what it seems like, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I – okay. I really don't want to – I need to word this carefully because I don't want to – there may or may not be also some people involved with this ragtime who are not super well liked in the community and some people are kind of looking for any reason to not vote for them. Yeah. I'm just going to leave it there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I hear you loud and clear.

SPEAKER_01I feel like you validate my bold statement. Absolutely. That's why when you said that, I was like, oh, I didn't know we were allowed to talk about this. And so I just so I'm trying to say it in as vague terms as possible again, because. These opinions that were given to me were not given under the guise of like, don't you tell anybody. But they also didn't say, say my name and say what I felt and why I'm feeling this way. I mentioned it in my review of Ragtime. You know, you look in the playbill and it says creative consultant Chris

Catelli. That is one of two people that were heavily involved in helping get Ragtime involved. opening night ready and every it's it's well known in the community that that's sort of what happened i mean i i feel like that's very like on the nose because i also think that there was so many missed opportunities with this ragtime production listen i think like a lot of people just like ragtime and they're happy that it's on broadway but like there was so many things that you could have done with a show oh yeah a lot of white people are happy to sit in that audience

and feel like

SPEAKER_01they're doing the work because they're at ragtime

SPEAKER_00This could be a whole other podcast conversation on the day, but scenery on Broadway and what's going on with scenic design on Broadway and when some shows want to throw scaffolding up and a band on the scaffolding call of the day and some shows want to put lavish scenery like Queen of Versailles and then some shows want to take the Vivian Beaumont theater and treat it like a concert hall. I just feel like that was the opportunity to put a really great set up. And did it work without a set? Sure. But my biggest thing with this Ragtime revival is this bare stage, bare stage, bare stage, put them center,

SPEAKER_00down center, down center, bare stage, and just put a different color on the psych behind them. It seems so concert-y to me. It didn't seem like that's what's really bothering me with this revival, mostly. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Put Casey Levy in a Tampax commercial and call it back to before. That's absolutely what that moment is. You couldn't have even just revealed the stage like Lincoln Center has done with all those Roger Hammerstein scores and showed us the orchestra for an on-track

SPEAKER_00moment. Even just give us something. There was nothing.

SPEAKER_01I didn't mean for this episode to be a shitting on Ragtime episode. Because I don't think this production is... bad no it's not and i've i've made my issues with me with the musical ragtime on its own made clear in my review i think ragtime is a very well made musical with a score that is like non-stop glorious but also i find that show a little hollow the revival did not do anything to uh fight me on that i'll just say that and like

every for every moment in this production that i thought was actually very well done it was then followed up by a moment where i was like well that was missed yeah

SPEAKER_03You're the top. You're an arrow collar. You're the top. You're a Coolidge dollar. You're the nimble tread of the feet.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I have a feeling this is going to freeze again just because it said the error thing, but fuck it. All right. All right. So that's enough talk about ragtime. I think that we should move on. But so revival. Yes. At the moment, ragtime is absolutely a lock. I am going to be a shitter and say chess is not getting in.

SPEAKER_02Okay.

SPEAKER_01But that's to say Best Musical, we've got six options this year. We only have two that have opened so far, Queen of Versailles and Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York. Which we did see. I'm going to – you did see. I'm going to go on a limb and say Two Strangers is in. It's probably the front runner right now. We'll see what happens with – the other four musicals in the spring. But that's sort of where we're at. I think Queen of Versailles actually will get some nominations, but musical will not be one of them.

SPEAKER_00I agree with that. And I will say that every other show coming this spring is wildly different. Some are dark, some are really comedic. Between Beaches, Titanic, Lost Boys, and Schmigadoon, those are four of the most completely random titles of shows, you know? When you said some are dark, some are comedic, I was going to reply with, and some are beaches.

SPEAKER_01Like, it's... Who the fuck knows what Beaches is going to be?

SPEAKER_00I don't know what to expect with that. I have a really low expectation bar. I know Wind Beneath My Wings will be a big hit. Jessica Vosk will be a big hit. I get that, but I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Let's see. No one seems pumped for it to be coming in. It doesn't even feel like the women in it are pumped that it's coming in.

SPEAKER_00In my head, I'm like, The Majestic? The Majestic? The Majestic. Kevin's not here. Kevin's not here. It's in my brain, the Majestic. I just can't picture that being in me. And St. James. These huge theaters these shows are going in. But I mean, maybe it'll work. The tea that I heard was that Beaches has the Majestic I think until September around that time.

SPEAKER_01Maybe a little longer than that. And they got it on a huge deal. They were already going out on this tour. And so they're getting a really good price for it. And also the Schubert's needed something until September because supposedly that's where Dreamgirls is going. I figured that. That was my guess.

SPEAKER_00They needed to fill the rent.

SPEAKER_01Yes, exactly. And I think something's going into the St. James after Titanic. Probably. Again, that was another thing where they were like, what can we have come in that is okay just being here until Labor Day? Which doesn't justify this Tony season because it feels like a Tony season.

SPEAKER_00COVID backlogs ended. We're in this middle ground. What do we want to do? Let's just kind of throw some paints on the wall, see if it sticks kind of thing. It just feels like that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I feel like this season is a lesson for everything that rushed their way to Broadway the last three years of maybe you should have taken that extra year to work on the show because, hey, look, you could have had a theater this year and you could have been a front runner.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. It's all about timing. We said that about Boop all the time. I mean, other things. I think Boop was in the wrong year.

SPEAKER_01Wrong year, wrong script.

SPEAKER_00Good, decent score though. I like some of that music.

SPEAKER_01I think Boop had three great songs and the rest needed work. Boop's score reminds me of Baker's Wife where I was like, you had three bangers and the rest could have had another draft.

SPEAKER_00I agree on that. Those same three songs I listen to frequently. I do love those three songs. I know which ones you're talking about.

SPEAKER_01But we digress. Let's now work our way back up. So we did the four biggies. Let's work our way down. Let's go down and work our way up. We have sound design of a play and musical. Here, I'll just say, I think that technical categories is where we might see Waiting for Gato in the spring. Especially that play with set lighting and sound design, I think is a really... solid option. I think that Oedipus will probably see for sound design as well. The fact that like,

SPEAKER_01A, everyone sounds so crystal clear, but also all the TV screens you sort of hear in the background and all that other minor stuff. I just think that's stuff that sound designers notice when they nominate. I think, yeah, Oedipus is my definitely shoe in there. There was a lot of things happening with the ear that we were both like, wow, yeah, there's definitely something.

SPEAKER_00Totally agree with that. And then I think—I mean, that's the one that just stands out to me, too. And then, I mean, looking at some of the—I'm switching over to my sound design musical. I mean, I guess the only thing—the three things we could talk about right now are Ragtime, Queen of Versailles, and Two Strangers. And I just put Two Strangers just because I actually—we actually had some slight sound issues with Ragtime. I personally—and we were in the orchestra, but I personally had some balance issue, not with literal design choices of— ambient music but i'm talking about like mics to orchestration balance blend at our performance and we were at a performance quite a few weeks

after opening it wasn't like we were at a preview so i thought that was a little jar i never heard that at lincoln center before but that was just maybe a bad sound performance for us but there was a few i actually looked over a couple times at the sound but are they

SPEAKER_00good like that was just i don't know if that was your experience i i The Beaumont is a really hard theater in general and there are pockets where it

SPEAKER_01just doesn't work. I don't know what it's about because I had heard such sound issues for Floyd Collins and then I go see Floyd Collins and I thought the sound design was impeccable when I went.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I liked that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, but that was something that people had complained about. Ragtime, I didn't have... overwhelmingly bad issues with the sound so much is that the imbalance I felt was like, I didn't actually think the orchestra sounded big enough. I actually, I actually felt, felt that it was so voice forward that it felt like the, it was similar to Sweeney Todd. I was like, the orchestra sounds large. It just sounds a little far away. And that was my issue with it. But I'm sure that that won't matter since Sweeney Todd won sound design three years ago and I'm still throwing my shoe about it.

yeah it's interesting like why do we just like yeah i think it was just a balance thing for me but i mean but that's why i put two strangers because yeah no two strangers i think is a solid choice i also i am going to throw chess out there i think that the sound design for chess while it is loud it is clear and you do hear everything great yeah yeah um i was like guys this is where mama mia comes into

SPEAKER_01play again I think the one to watch will be when Cats goes yeah it's I feel like Cats is gonna be like the sinners one battle after another where it's like once it comes in it's like well how many nominations can it rack up and that just sort of fucks around with everybody else but yeah I think in terms of what's open right now you guys will see chess soon enough but I think of what I've seen two strangers in chess would be the ones that I would

SPEAKER_01Put chips on for this category. Queen of Versailles. I actually think I felt the sound design was actually pretty solid for that show. But I think that that's such an easy category to skip out on that. It's not going to happen.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's also this conversation of which kind of leads into orchestrations. We could talk about that next if we want is like, do is it fair to say, oh, a show that has a six piece band is equal to sound designing a 23 piece orchestra? Is that fair? You know, that's a whole nother conversation because I've heard like we're talking about ragtime, this big full orchestra that doesn't seem well balanced. But then sometimes I hear these six or eight piece combo bands that sound amazing. So it's not about numbers per se. Always. You know, it's hard.

SPEAKER_01The assignment itself alters based on each production, but that's also kind of the game for nominations in general, right? Like, we're talking about ragtime versus chess for revival right now, and they're very different approaches to shows that have very different reputations. Yeah. The fact that I prefer ragtime over chess I think has a lot to do with, A, that I respect ragtime more as material, but I also, I guess I'll give chess props for making some bold swings,

SPEAKER_01whereas ragtime I do not think didn't make any really bolt swings outside of a turntable. And I guess a framing device with that, with, with Cole house's kid at the top of the show that never shows up again until the very, very end.

SPEAKER_00I said that, I know this is, we're going back on ragtime, but I say you have this awesome idea in the beginning. It's a cool directorial choice. Okay. That's cool. And then it's completely forgotten throughout the whole show. And no one realizes it because we're all like, look over there with the score, you know? So yeah, I think that he doesn't show up again because if you think about it too much,

SPEAKER_01it's actually weird how much of this story this child is hearing. In the Heights movie, when you find out that Usnavi is telling this whole thing to his daughter and her friends in the bodega, I'm like, oh, so they heard about Benny and Nina fucking. Yeah. How much of this story did you tell them and how much of it is us seeing it?

SPEAKER_00So that's sort of my thing. They cut to reminding us that this is a story told by a narrator in that way. My biggest pet peeve of a lot of directors are doing this lately on Broadway is you start with this cool idea or concept and then we completely forget about it at the end. And it's happened quite, I can name it quite a few times. And I'm like, just button it. We button numbers with lighting design choice. Why don't we button the story? Like, I don't know. To chest's credit, they remind you every three minutes that Bryce Pinkham is your

narrator.

SPEAKER_01They remind you every three minutes. To the point that you start to resent Bryce Pinkham.

SPEAKER_00We like Bryce, though, but I know.

SPEAKER_01We loved him, and he's doing his damn best.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so Sound Design, Oedipus, Two Strangers. I'm going to put in a bid for Chess. I'm going to put in a bid for Waiting for Gato. It's a Jamie Lloyd production, so ASMR is the headline here.

SPEAKER_00Yep, and then if we wanted to go over to orchestration, I think there was only two right now eligible, which would be Two Strangers of Queen and Versailles. I don't think Ragtime or Chess has new orchestrations, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Chess, I think, has new orchestrations or they're altered enough. Ragtime, I know they're using the original charts. I think it's a smaller orchestra than the original, but it's overall the same charts. I think Chess, it's a different size band. There are songs that are in different places. So I do think it's – I mean, I'm sure they're based off of OG stuff, but I believe it's new. Yeah, so I think – so if those are the three, then we'll have – I'm sure Rocky Horror is going to be eligible

for orchestrations. I have it on good authority that Jellicle Ball is doing some more stuff with the

SPEAKER_01music this time.

SPEAKER_00Cool, cool. And I thought that orchestration sounded great.

SPEAKER_01It did. Well, they didn't they didn't do a ton with the orchestrations off Broadway. It was they would put in a little bit of a club beat. But as I understand it now, Andrew Lloyd Webber has given them further permission to fuck around and find out with the music.

SPEAKER_00Cool. Go for it. I'll take it. It has this like, yeah, I just thought the music was really great in that.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. No, it's it's. I'll bring you guys back in like April and we'll see where we feel about stuff. Okay, I will say, you know, I didn't mind the orchestrations for Queen of Versailles.

SPEAKER_00I don't think all the songs are great in Queen of Versailles, but I mean, that's a pretty decent orchestra for a new Broadway show, I thought. For Stephen Schwartz, orchestrations of his shows aren't usually bad. I think Wicked orchestrations are good, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01It's a 90-piece orchestra. John Clancy is really good at what he does. There are certain pockets of his orchestrations that I think about a lot. You can listen to Caviar Dreams on YouTube still, and I think what he does with that song really helps a lot. Totally. We'll put a pin in that as we get to score, because my thoughts on a possible orchestration nomination for them kind of hinges on the fact that they are going to get a score nomination, and I think people are not willing to accept that yet uh no i get that i mean let's go

over to score now sure so at the moment our only two eligible scores are two strangers and queen of versailles not counting any plays with original music which i'm sure we've got a few that are going to happen i wonder what might happen with marjorie prime i wonder what's going to happen in the spring with with stuff but in terms of other

SPEAKER_01musicals it's beaches and lost boys and that's it, right?

SPEAKER_00Well, is Schmigadoon considered an original score? No, right? Because they were made for TV.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think Schmigadoon is going to fall in line with the same thing as Smash, where like, yes, it was written for this property, but in a different medium.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And so it's an adaptation of a previously written score.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00That'll be interesting. I mean, I'm seeing, I wonder if Stephen Schwartz will be nominated for Queen of the Star just because he's Stephen Schwartz and it was his first original show in 25 years, whatever. Like, I don't know. Maybe they might throw the bone to him on that.

SPEAKER_01I think it's the fact that it's Schwartz. I think it's the fact that it's one of the few genuine original scores. They are recording or they just recorded the cast album. So that'll be out around the time that nominators are starting to think about this. And there are worse scores than Queen of Versailles that got nominated in much more crowded fields.

SPEAKER_00Agreed. I really hope they did two cast recordings, one with Kristen and one with Sherry.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I doubt that, but that would be kind of cool.

SPEAKER_01That would be absolutely awesome. I mean, they won't do this. If anything, I wish that they would give us like two bonus tracks of Sherry.

SPEAKER_00I mean, they should. So they could see how many people actually listen to the Sherry recordings and see what they should have done. Do you know what they should do? This is going to be so niche, what I'm about to say, but I don't know. If you ever listen to the original, if you ever listen to Little Shop of Horrors or Annie, they have the bonus tracks at the end when it's Alan Menken sitting at the piano singing a cut song. They do that with, I think, Charles Strauss. They did it with Annie, and it's just some muffly recording of them in a studio. And I'm like, oh, that would be kind of cool if there was like, we're going to throw this bonus track. And it's like Sherry sitting with Stephen just singing casually

in the studio.

SPEAKER_00That would be kind of cool, maybe. yeah well grand hotel has that too if you if you ever listen to castor running for grand hotel because david carroll died before he could lay down his tracks so they have a bonus track of him singing love can't happen at some concert or cabaret yeah and it's really nice so yeah it would be great if they had a bonus track of like sherry's first listen i can send them the audio i have it of sherry's first performance singing that 11 o'clock number you know it's it's just so good

SPEAKER_01I also have audio of what was supposed to be her final show before.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yep, yep. Oh, now we lost the video. I hear you.

SPEAKER_01You guys are frozen again, but I can hear you.

SPEAKER_00We can hear you. Oh, we're good. We can hear you still, but our video. Oh, my God. This is a horror.

SPEAKER_01I spoke too soon when I was texting you saying, we never have a problem.

SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. Well, we're connected still. This is not an internet problem now. We can access your video. Check the cameras on and connect it and refresh.

SPEAKER_01Hello.

SPEAKER_00Okay, we're back. Yay.

SPEAKER_01Sometimes you just got to stick through it. Okay.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01So, uh, okay. So yeah, with score, I, I think that that's what's going to happen to queen of Versailles. I think that they are going to get that nomination from the recording from the shorts of it all. I also do think genuinely feel like there are songs in that show that work. And then there are other songs that obviously don't work, but I, I see a women on the verge trajectory where the show was trashed when it came out. I mean, in some ways, rightfully so. And then the recording comes out, everyone goes, Oh, like I don't, Away from the mess of it all, there is something here worth listening to.

SPEAKER_01And I think that also will help John Clancy's case for orchestrations. Whether he actually gets the nomination, who's to say? But I think that he has a better shot once they get that cast recording.

SPEAKER_00Totally.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But I mean, Two Strangers at the moment is at the forefront just of the new scores we have. Yeah. We'll see what happens with Lost Boys. I'm not even going to entertain the idea that Beaches is a true competitor here. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I haven't even heard a note of it. I don't recognize the composer's name on it. So I don't know if they're new to the scene or...

SPEAKER_01I just... Listen, we really don't like to have prejudice on things before they have a chance to prove themselves. But just everything that I have heard of this show from every incarnation out of town, everyone who's involved with it being like, we're not even sure why we're coming in. It's just... No one, even the people who are supposed to be vouching for this show are just sort of like, we'll see. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Yeah. And that's so exciting. I wonder if they're just relying on like the older generation who loves the 80s movie and Bette Midler to be showing up no matter what. Maybe there's that reliance, you know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, if you're sitting in the Majestic from far enough away in that wig, Vosk, you can pretend you should never.

SPEAKER_00Wait, I said this. I said, please, please change the wig. Please. If there's anything from those production photos we have to learn is that that original wig is not it.

SPEAKER_01No. Raggedy Ann in a Power Rangers jacket. Like, that's what it looks like. Even Jessica herself, thank God she's going to finally originate a leading role on Broadway.

SPEAKER_00Like, that's cool. Like, I've been waiting for this day for her. So that's it. You know, if it's this, then take it where you can get it, you know?

SPEAKER_01What can you do with this opportunity down the line? That's what we want to ask. But like, yeah, I saw that wig and I went, if ever there was an argument of why the Tonys need a best wig category it's to show everyone that this is not a nominee yep yep yep yes i would disagree with that for sure i guess i mean i guess i guess we could transition over to costumes if we want yeah let's do it costumes um we costumes of a musical i mean we have linda cho for ragtime christian cowan for queen of versailles and then

socha gilmore for two strangers those are really the three going going right except chess again we haven't seen but i don't know i haven't i know it's a lot of all

SPEAKER_00black right If Chess were to get a costume design nomination, that really would be like, we don't know.

SPEAKER_01It's... Listen, there's a lot about chess that I do not like, but if I'm going to give them their roses anywhere, it is not costume design, where Lea Michele is basically wearing a black jumpsuit the entire show.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, I will say I'm a big fan of Linda Cho's designs. I've always liked what she did for costumes, and I think that she's probably the frontrunner for Ragtime because I think one of the best parts of Ragtime is those costumes.

SPEAKER_01I think the costumes do a lot of heavy lifting. She is well-liked. I think she's won twice now.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Uh, and it's also a period show. The, yeah, I think that she has a good shot. My question is, is, is I hate to bring up, you know, uh, Jellicle ball again, cause who knows, but I have a deja vu of 2022 when six, one costume design over period shows like music, man in paradise square. Um,

SPEAKER_00We talk about this all the time. Yep.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Because obviously, you know, contemporary, more contemporary designs have a hard time getting in. Hell's Kitchen getting a nomination is sort of this random anomaly. But something like Six, which is its own world, but very hyper specific and really sells it. I wonder if something with Jellicle Ball, if that will help it.

SPEAKER_00I will also say, and I know this has nothing to do with it, but I will bring this up because there's a part of me that says, when you design six costumes for the musical six, plus four for the band, right? Because they had, so maybe it's like 10 or 12 costumes. But then that same year in the Music Man, you must have designed 100 costumes. over a hundred. I mean, so to me, it's not about the number. I totally understand that, but I have a hard time sitting here and saying like, don't you, I know, yes, they have associates and assistants that are helping them with all these designs when they have massive designs. I just think like, to me, it does come down to that a little bit.

SPEAKER_00Maybe you just actually, if I was a Tony voter, I would consider the number of costumes up there.

SPEAKER_01I would equate that Richie. I would, I would equate that Richie. with you fed a hundred students Kraft mac and cheese. They're fed, but it's Kraft mac and cheese. Meanwhile, these five students got filet mignon.

SPEAKER_00I know, but you can't tell me.

SPEAKER_01It's custom design.

SPEAKER_00I know. It's the design. But you can't tell me that those costumes in Music Man and those Pick a Little Lady hats and all that aren't gorgeous. You know what I mean? That's the way I look at it. You're saying that I can't tell you that? No, I'm saying... You won't hear it. I don't think that's Kraft Mac and Cheese, the Music Man costume.

SPEAKER_01That's what I'm saying. They look great, but in terms of design, I think Six was more invented in the design.

SPEAKER_00No, I get it. I get that. And that's why I'm like, when I look at Two Strangers, I'm like, I don't know if we're going to really... That's what I'm trying to say. But the one to watch is Jellicle Ball because you're taking ball culture and

SPEAKER_01marrying it with a feline cat look. That is designed really well. I'm also going to say keep an eye out for Rocky Horror. Let's see what they do with those Transylvanians.

SPEAKER_00Shmigadoon is a period piece. We'll see what happens with Shmigadoon. I was going to say,

SPEAKER_01I think Shmigadoon is a wild card in a lot of these categories, specifically costume and orchestrations and choreography.

SPEAKER_00Yes, choreography for sure.

SPEAKER_01But score, this all comes down to, no, we're on costumes now. Let's move into choreography now. Let's do that. At the moment, we've got chess, ragtime, and two strangers eligible. In the spring will be Rocky Horror, Schmigadoon, Lost Boys, Beaches Titanic, and Jellicle Ball. Again, I feel like I'm showing my hand a little bit. I'm just already calling out Jellicle Ball and Schmigadoon as nominees in this category. Totally. I'm also going to go out on a limb and say Lost Boys.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Having not seen a fucking frame of anything from that show, just the fact that there's aerial work in it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I'm like, I'm sorry. It's giving me Water for Elephants vibes. The fact that you can combine the two and if they do it even remotely well – It's getting in. I think that's nine contenders then because it's Queen of Versailles, Two Strangers, Chess, Ragtime, Beaches, Titanic, Schmigadoon. Yeah, it's going to be at least nine. So we'll have five contenders. So I'm looking at Schmigadoon. I'm looking at Lost Boys. I'm looking at Jellicle Ball. So then we got two more.

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think... I put ragtime as of now because out of Queen of Versailles and Two Strangers, ragtime has more choreo in terms of what I think Eleanor Scott did with the choreo in that. And there's not much choreo in ragtime, but there's movement. There is some dance breaks-ish a couple times.

SPEAKER_01They move around in those circles in the opening number. I was going to say, there's a lot of walking. There's a lot of walking on that donut.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I'm going to put Ragtime in there for now with the little asterisk of come find me in the spring and we'll talk and we'll see what happens. Because I also think Sam Pinkleton, I think, is such a really smart choreographer. And I don't know what he's going to do with Ragtime, but there's a possibility that can happen. For Rocky Horror. Yeah, for Rocky Horror. And then... I mean...

SPEAKER_00Titanic doesn't really have a lot of choreo, from what I remember.

SPEAKER_01It has a lot of movement in the same way that Ragtime does. I would call it more... There is choreography, but it's less showy and more just sort of how it fits with the direction. I actually think the staging and choreography for Titanic is very clever and works really well and well-integrated. Could happen. People always talk about... having most choreography, I talk about it a lot too. And I do think that that helps with winning most of the time, but I don't think that every show that has most choreography

gets in for a

SPEAKER_01nomination. There's usually one or two slightly more interesting nominees in there that never win, but like get in there. And that's where I feel like Titanic could possibly come. That's where if Rocky horror has enough movement that can go in. I am going to keep ragtime over chess.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Cause there's choreo in chess, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01There is choreography in chess, but how many Lauren Latoro shows have been ignored at this point? Yeah. I'm not entirely convinced that chess is going to break that trend for her.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Okay.

SPEAKER_01Your fave. Okay.

SPEAKER_00You made him speechless, Jeff. Wow. I can't believe it.

SPEAKER_01I'm very aware. I thought there was some cool bubble popping moments in Heart of Rock and Roll.

SPEAKER_00That was her too, right? That was kind of some cool.

SPEAKER_01She did do Heart of Rock and Roll. I liked the idea of that number. I did not like the execution of that number.

SPEAKER_00And I will say I did like the choreo in Tommy. I know Tommy was a little bit of everything. I didn't mind her choreo in that. I will say in some parts.

SPEAKER_01The people I know who are in Tommy loves doing that choreography. Okay, that's cool. And so I'm like, I'm like, happy you're happy. Yeah, yeah. My issue with her choreography in Tommy, it's my issue with her choreography in general of just like, she goes, for me, she goes too big too soon and there's nowhere for the numbers to go after that. Right. And so everything gets sloppy at like a minute in. Yeah. And Tommy, I remember watching just going like, from the jump, people were doing backflips. It's like, we're starting here? Yeah. Where can we go now? But that's also how I felt about Tommy in general as a production.

SPEAKER_01So in a lot of ways, she didn't match the energy Des wanted her to match. So she did her assignment. But like that whole 30 minutes into Tommy, I just plateaued. And I was like, oh, sorry. I plateaued. And I was like, I have I'm overwhelmed now. There's too much happening.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, there was a lot going on with that. But you'll see with Jess, I mean, Aaron Tveit does a line of coke off of a dancer's leg. it was also like so loud and i was not sitting up close i was like this is really loud like and i'm usually pretty okay with that for the most but that was so loud for the who's tommy yeah yeah same thing with jess with choose every every year there's a show or two that i've decided that i'm just gonna start saying their

SPEAKER_01names weirdly last year it was smoosh and this year it's choose

SPEAKER_00I love it. The one word titles too.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it's always, it seems to be the Imperial theater. Always a musical at the Imperial. That's one word. Choose.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. All right. Where are we bopping to next? We did.

SPEAKER_01Let's go back to some design categories. Let's look at. Oh, I mean, we haven't really done costume design of a play. That's a little harder right now, but let's, let's, let's combine costume design of a play with lightning design for both.

SPEAKER_00Lighting costume of a play.

SPEAKER_01So for plays, I think we can see liberation for costume design.

SPEAKER_00Totally put that as my, my number one. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, we'll see again, we'll see in the, in the spring what happens. I don't know what the design situation is like with giant, what's going to happen with fallen angels, but those are more period shows. Period shows tend to do well in general.

SPEAKER_00And liberation. I, again, here's a moment where I wish there was a wig nomination because those wigs and liberation were insanely good. Oh, my God. Yeah. Yeah. Like everyone. I was like, this is such impeccable design. I swore I was in the 70s with that. I think of everything that we've seen, probably Liberation is my only one to remember.

SPEAKER_01Not even Oedipus? I mean... For costumes? Oh, I thought Jeff was talking overall. No, no, no, for costumes. Oh, fantastic. Great. I was like, Jeff, I was like, how dare you leave Oedipus off your list of things that left an impression on you? Yeah, no, costumes. No, just for costumes. Out of all the plays that we've seen, I think we have so many coming that they're going to be the ones that are remembered. And Liberation might be the only one that I think would still be a contender. no I think agreed I think in the spring we have Joe's Turner's

come and gone to look forward to giant Death of a Salesman Fallen Angels we'll see what the situation is with Dog the Afternoon but that's another 70s piece so whole period stuff yeah it'll be very tight that category and then I guess bopping over to lighting of a play the same thing I think Oedipus lighting was amazing it's still in my brain the last last scene spoiler alert for y'all listening the last scene

SPEAKER_00No, after the moment. It was something about thinking that the play was over when it wasn't and doing that flashback and seeing that beautiful, angelic sunrise light. It sticks in my mind. I can still see it right now. I don't know what that just with him running towards her in the final moment before the blackout. That was incredible lighting to me. I just thought that was so well lit, that show. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Jeff, Oedipus was really good. I don't know why it's not on your list.

SPEAKER_00I always say Oedipus. Sometimes I say Oedipus. Well, we've all been saying Oedipus, and this is a production that's been calling it Oedipus. I know, I know.

SPEAKER_01I think that Oedipus is my one to remember here for lighting. I don't know if I would probably think any of the others are going to get remembered for lighting either. I think there's a chance for Waiting for Gato. I feel like Waiting for Gato could be the gray house of, you know, it was earlier in the season and it'll get two nominations, sound and lighting. Or set, who knows. But yeah, I think Oedipus I would consider pretty much a lock. I would also say Punch and Waiting for Gato possible nominations.

There's a world in which Punch gets completely forgotten in the spring and I would not.

SPEAKER_01Yes, there is. I would not begrudge the Tony nominators that I would understand why that is, but I don't want anyone to feel like that means that everything about punch was bad. There are things about punch that was, that were quite good. Yeah. Right. And I think the lighting helps a lot. I do think it will be forgotten though. When it comes to it. I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm, probably yeah maybe some of the lighting from liberation but i did have some issues sometimes with the back and forth between like when you're supposed to realize what part of the timing that they're in i didn't always think it

matched with what they were trying to show so that's why i would say yeah i think the lighting and liberation is probably the weakest thing for me that and all the cigarette smoke

SPEAKER_01but yeah yeah yeah On the musical front, it's chess, two strangers, ragtime, and queen of Versailles. Those are our contenders at the moment. I'm going to put a note in for two strangers and for ragtime.

SPEAKER_00Agreed.

SPEAKER_01So ragtime, I will say the lighting for me did so much heavy lifting. it held the whole show together i'm sorry other than the performances i mean yeah but because like the the set did was was a nothing burger and like i while i enjoyed the costumes they weren't as helpful in sort of with the storytelling for me as i said you know a lot of people were wearing the same costumes throughout so it's hard to get a sense of timeline of of what was going on and lighting i thought was so helpful in terms of just focus and also i think did a lot of heavy lifting with some of the staging like it's

numbers that were a park and park or were just people walking across the stage were so were elevated by the color and the mood and and and just helping you to see where everything went um and that was very impressive to me especially because as i as i mentioned before uh lighting had to go through a major overhaul during tech they they had to make a lot of changes really quickly and so the fact that they

SPEAKER_01were able to get it here by opening night i think is very impressive

SPEAKER_00Even the floor, not that the floor color matters always. Although, of course, for lighting designers, it was like a big black floor. You have to light these costumes on like a black surface as well. I mean, there's all these like, I mean, even the mesh that would come down and hang. And I said this in my episode too. Like the fact that we can see the seam lines in the mesh. I'm like, what are we? And now how does lighting designer hide that? Like I feel for the ragtime lighting designer.

SPEAKER_01Those hanging meshes that looked like they came straight from the bogs.

SPEAKER_00Really? I couldn't believe that. They even look wrinkled. I'm like, are we good? Are we good here at Vivian Beaumont?

SPEAKER_01Straight from the swamp.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01They just came in and I was thinking, a big, bright, beautiful world.

SPEAKER_00Very track, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, very track. I probably would put Ragtime in the middle of like it could get nominated, maybe not. And then I definitely think Two Strangers will probably get the nomination. Yeah. I think if there's a surprise here, it would be chess, which similar to Ragtime, because the set is such a nothing burger for me, the lighting has to do a lot. But I don't think that the lighting in chess is as intricate as with Ragtime. Like chess, it's more sort of like – Bold color over the entire stage, the entire time.

And then ragtime, I do think there's more detail-oriented lighting happening. If I had one major complaint about the lighting with ragtime is that it is often

SPEAKER_01quite dimly lit. But that's also, as Richie was saying, it's a black stage. And it's really hard to make everything light up on a black stage.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I get it. So it's tough. And I think I did get a little preview of what the scenic design is going to look

SPEAKER_01for Lost Boys. And I can only just imagine what the lighting is going to be like in that show. So that's probably my one that I'm most excited to see. Oh, yeah. Set and lighting for the spring, I'm... I'm not even going to entertain anything just because I have an idea of what could happen. At the moment, that way lies madness for me. While we have been pontificating on the future for some categories, lighting and set for musicals right now, I can't even entertain it right now. All of this is going out the window as soon as we see it all.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, exactly.

SPEAKER_01But I would say for set design, if there's one thing that I am absolutely staking my claim on, it's Queen of Versailles.

SPEAKER_00Yes.

SPEAKER_01That's going to get a scenic design nomination.

SPEAKER_00I really think so, because it was incredible. And Dane Laffrey is awesome in what they did with that. And I just thought it was just.

SPEAKER_01He brings you every Jellicle ball, Richie.

SPEAKER_00Well, and yeah, I also feel like the thing with Queen of Versailles, too, is I was seeing so many videos of the bows. So I knew what the set looked like at the end before I saw it. So that was kind of a spoiler for me. So when I saw the curtain rise at the beginning or that, you know, Victorian wall rise and I saw all this scaffolding, I was like, oh, the actual set's back there. And this crew has to, like, strike all that at some point to reveal. I just thought the set was very cool for that.

SPEAKER_01I also had seen the final product at a curtain call, but the fact that the reveal at the end was still made an impact for me, I think is testament to the design of that show. I also, I also will say with queen of Versailles in terms of costume design, we know that William Ivey long was like a ghost costume designer on that show. And I don't know how nominators are going to, feel about that so I that's something else where like I think it could happen especially because we I think people forget that show has a lot of period costumes in it right yeah in addition to very specific semi-modern

costumes for Jackie so it

SPEAKER_01still could happen but if it doesn't get nominated I think that there are nominators who are going to feel icky about putting one in for someone who is not officially William Ivey Long, but we all know is William Ivey Long.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And then also, I mean, if we really want to sit here and consider nominating the door frame for ragtime that comes out as a whole mansion, I mean, give me a break, right? Like, absolutely not.

SPEAKER_01And the swamp.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And that poofy thing behind Casey.

SPEAKER_01The Tampax commercial. It looks like she's in front of a giant maxi pad. Yeah, yeah. That was lit beautifully again. But then they let it red and you're like, now we're in fucking Carrie.

SPEAKER_00Plug it up. I don't know if she's technically on the beach in Atlantic City singing that song. I think technically she might be. that's usually where it's at yeah yeah so i'm like okay but you could have lit it like the ocean blues and then it went red and i'm like i don't know i just everything to me not not scenic design yeah i did like the scenic design of two strangers though i thought it was kind of cool and inventive of a different way of using the turntable bringing the things out of you know the luggage was kind of

SPEAKER_01cool so like yeah i don't know i wouldn't like write it off just yeah I think they have a really good shot at that. Again, I'm not entertaining spring options right now, but in terms of what we have in this moment, I think that Queen of Versailles and Two Strangers are absolute contenders for nominations. Queen of Versailles, just the massiveness of it that I also felt never went too much. For a show that was so big, and I know a lot of people thought it had not a lot of focus, I thought it didn't have a lot of focus. The design always made sense to me. And Two Strangers, I also think that that set design was very creative.

SPEAKER_01Maybe not the most attractive when you got into the theater, but then when you saw what it was doing throughout the performance, that was very well done for me. The fact that I'm such a slut for a turntable and I'm not here vouching for ragtime. I love turntables so much because I feel like you could literally put a turntable

SPEAKER_00into anything and somehow it works in some moment in some way. I love them. The number of shows where I just went, a turntable could be really useful here right now.

SPEAKER_01Waiting for Godot, turntable. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00I will also say, like, I wasn't around in the 80s when the original Les Mis, but our elders of the world would tell us that that was a really groundbreaking thing for that. To put a turntable in Les Mis was a big deal for people. I remember hearing people say that.

SPEAKER_01Because with Les Mis, it was a three-part turntable is the thing. It's like what Hamilton has is what Les Mis had.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And Les Mis, I mean, I think you can watch some of the original staging on YouTube.

SPEAKER_01Every bootleg alive of Les Mis is available somewhere. And I had seen the original production as a kid and then again when I was a teenager. And that staging remains one of the greatest stagings.

SPEAKER_00It's incredible. I think that staging is brilliant. But I think turntables, yeah, that's the saving grace of Ragtime. And it almost felt like we don't want to put any money into any scenery, but let's just put a turntable in. That's what it felt like those conversations were like. donut though because the center doesn't move it's just the outer rim and for every time that i thought that that donut was used well again it's like they would have one number one oh that was really good use of the donut and then the next number i was like oh that was that's not how the donut should be used here but agreed so

SPEAKER_01yeah but no the door frame for ragtime and get nominated yeah Not when we got Queen of Versailles in its massive set and we have two strangers that uses simplicity and a turntable really effectively.

SPEAKER_00And then,

SPEAKER_01you know, we've got stuff in the spring that's just really going to fuck with our brains.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. Yes. I was going to say scene design of a play. We can go there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Talk to me, boys.

SPEAKER_00All right. Let me go to that. Hold on. Turning the page. Oh, here. I put Oedipus for this, too. I think that there's some cool stuff going on with that in those huge doors that moved in the different entrances on different levels. And I just like the glass and the use of... You know, it was a very sterile environment at the same time, but I think that totally worked and it helped pop the costumes and the blood at the end and all that. I think there was just pop because of the sterileness of the space.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think Oedipus is definitely a contender there. Oh, yeah. No, Oedipus is absolutely a contender. Oh, I also meant to say, in terms of lighting, Little Bear Ridge Road, I would not be surprised if that got in. That had some really gorgeous lighting for what was a very sparse set.

SPEAKER_00Agreed. Yeah. You guys will see with Bug, I think Bug is going to get a set nomination.

SPEAKER_01There's a really big shift that is very impressive. And just because I don't know what the rest of the spring will look like. But yeah, for me, I'm going to say Oedipus and Bug for sure. I wouldn't even be surprised if something like Margaery Prime got in for set design, which is maybe not... elaborate but it's very detail oriented it's a very it's a home set and it's very detail oriented it does have a surprise in there towards the end and um i feel like with set design especially with plays they either go for really

bold concepts like a waiting for gado where you're like basically in the tree or they go for a super

SPEAKER_01highly detailed set like a marjorie prime you know

SPEAKER_00Totally.

SPEAKER_01I agree with that. I mean, I also think, like, you know, I'm looking at some other things from the season. Like, art was kind of cool, but it wasn't really, like, anything nomination-wide.

SPEAKER_00But at least we had some, like— Some were cool. Yeah. And Liberation, I know the lighting. I didn't mind that, like, side light wall. That was kind of cool to see in the basketball hoop and all—in the setting of this, like— The detail work in the gym and stuff was kind of cool, but I mean, I don't think.

SPEAKER_01We talked about a lot of the details that were in the set of Liberation.

SPEAKER_00The bleachers and all that. It was kind of cool. But also, it wasn't really a utilized set. It was just kind of like, it could have been a backdrop? Sure. Because they didn't really use much of it other than chairs downstage the whole time, you know?

SPEAKER_01I do see World War Liberation gets nominated for that set, again, because it's so highly detail-oriented. But if it doesn't, I'm not surprised. I'm not confident enough to put a chip down and say, hey, guys, remember this for the spring. But if I'm wrong about that... I'll be like, yeah, no, but I understand why I was wrong. Yeah, we're in a tough situation here. Eleven plays are coming. So I think like Oedipus is the strong one that I would say would still let's remember that for.

SPEAKER_01I mean, the balusters at Manhattan Theater Club in the spring, watch that be the most beautiful, elaborate design we've ever seen. And Renee Lee Scaldsberry is coming out in like a 17th century dress.

SPEAKER_00Right. Right. Exactly. Exactly. So you never know.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Uh, let's look at book of a musical. We only have three candidates right now. As of this winter, we have, uh, two strangers. We have queen of Versailles and we have shoes.

SPEAKER_00I'm just had a new book, right? Yes.

SPEAKER_01A brand new book by Danny strong. So that's eligible. And that has, we have had revivals with new books be nominated. We've had, uh, Douglas Carter being for Cinderella. David Henry Huang for Flower Drum Song. I think those are the only two of the last 40 years that that's happened. And then Hugh Wheeler, I know, won for his book for Candide. I'm going to go on a limb here and say that Danny Strong is not going to get nominated for Choose.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've heard mixed things about that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. The one thing I will say is that I, the book was never confusing to me.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01That said, every minute since I have seen chess, I have forgotten more and more what happened on the political end of that script.

SPEAKER_00I've,

SPEAKER_01But when I was in the theater, I wasn't confused. I just didn't care. And then since I've left, I've just forgotten most of it. Yeah. I just I just think that the arbiter narration sucks. But also, yeah, that is a very divided thing because I spoke to a voter who actually thought that the narration was good and funny and clever. And I was like, you liked the RFK brainworm joke.

SPEAKER_00Oh, God.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You like the jokes about Biden and Trump? And he was like, well, you know, and I went, OK, here we are.

SPEAKER_00Oh, God. Here we are. I mean, I feel and that's why I feel like I think two strangers could definitely get at this point anyway, could get something that's some clever writing. I think some of the jokes are really funny in that at times.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't dislike the book of Two Strangers. My two biggest issues with it, which I guess are rather fundamental, are I do think it's too long. I think the show is too long for the story it's trying to tell, and I don't buy the romance at the end.

SPEAKER_00I don't buy the romance at the end either. I agree with that. And everyone's like, so many people I know who saw it were like, but it's so cute. It's so cute. I'm like, that's great. It's cute. I don't also think that it's perfect. Like I have a problem, like the two things I have a problem with is, okay, I've said this on my podcast too. I feel like it's a light, loose plot of Elf. Like he comes to the city to look for his dad and he, and everyone does. And he's got this cheery, like, right. I mean, sorry. It feels so elf to me. And I'm like, he's like this bright eyed, bushy tailed kid who loves New York. And they're all like, all right, relax.

SPEAKER_00It's New York. He's looking for his dad.

SPEAKER_01And he grows up at the end. And yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I don't know if that's purposely done or not, but there was that. Also, I'm like so hung up on the cake and just like the whole like they're not carrying a cake across New York the whole time, like the title implies. And also, I've never seen a wedding cake in four boxes where one would fall off. I've never seen a cake transported like that in my life. So I don't know. I'm. I guess it's something – the way I viewed it was – and this was me doing heavy

SPEAKER_01lifting for a show that did not help itself. But I would imagine that it was – the situation was the tiers were separate and were going to be assembled on the day. But also, like, I've never heard of that before. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00A baker would maybe transport it like that. Also, if the dad's mega loaded with Amex cards galore and they're blowing all this money, they couldn't afford a cake to be put together and transported. I'm not understanding the legit, and I know that this is musical, right?

SPEAKER_01Okay, but yes, people are like, but it's cute. You know what's also cute? Paddington 2, and that is an hour and 40 and airtight and perfectly written.

SPEAKER_00I'm hearing that it's incredible.

SPEAKER_01Well, I'm not even talking about Paddington the musical. I'm talking about Paddington 2, the movie.

SPEAKER_00The movie, I see.

SPEAKER_01I'm looking forward. I can't speak on the musical yet. By the time this episode comes out, I will have seen it. My life will have changed for good. I think it will because every single person who I know has gone from all ends of

SPEAKER_00the earth have said that they've been changed by Paddington the musical.

SPEAKER_01I can't wait. I'm going to cry from start to finish.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, probably too.

SPEAKER_01This film, Richie, is a perfectly written screenplay, and it's an hour and 40 minutes, and it's just so fucking cute. Okay, it's on the list.

SPEAKER_00Putting it on the list. I'm watching it. I haven't even seen the first one, full disclosure.

SPEAKER_01The first one is delightful. The second one is perfect. I can't even explain it.

SPEAKER_00I love Paddington.

SPEAKER_01Two Strangers. Two Strangers for me is a perfect example of sort of how musicals kind of work, which is if something works for you, all of the flaws don't really matter because the overall impact is so strong. And if it doesn't work for you, all you see are the flaws.

SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah. And Two Strangers is a musical that I enjoyed mostly, but I had to work hard to get there.

SPEAKER_01And it overall did not... impact me in a way where i was able to let go of the issues and i think that the show just does have issues that's now exactly the thing that i can't begrudge the show is like the fandom of it is such that when you when you try like try to bring up this stuff the fandom is like no it's perfect it's it's it's brilliant and there's nothing wrong with it and i'm like okay well then we're done here and now i'm actually kind of hating the show because i agree

SPEAKER_00You're like taking the words right out of my mouth. That's what I said.

SPEAKER_01Like when we were talking about Two Strangers, I was saying this will become the cult musical of the season because it will create this cult fan base that just loves it no matter what. And like it's fine. But like if this was last season, the show would not be doing the same thing at all. The show would have closed by now if this were last season. Oh, yeah. And would not be remembered at the Tonys probably at all. And it's not that because the show is just so good. It's because, I mean, last season was a very dense season of musicals.

And the reason why Two Strangers is kind of keeping itself open right now is,

SPEAKER_01A, I know that it's relatively cheap to run, especially in the grand scheme of how expensive everything is right now. They... have figured out a budget that they're able to kind of keep going for a while. And because they're looking at the spring and, and unless lost boys or Titanic or Schmigadoon really kind of nails it, they have a really good shot at winning the big awards and they can run for a year and make their money back and call it a day. Right. But it's, yeah, I, it's really like piggybacking off of like the maybe happy ending as well.

SPEAKER_01So it's like right place, right time for the show. Yeah, no, they, they were very fortunate with their timing. The, But yeah, I think that they have book at the moment locked and loaded. I feel like Titanic is so stupid and I don't know if enough voters will sign off on the stupidity of it. But I don't see how the fans of shucked and the fans of and Juliet can see Titanic and then not fall in love with Titanic.

yeah so i i i'm i know we we're kind of being loose about how we're much we're talking about the spring right now but like i'm looking at titanic going i know i think that or even schmigadoon like could come in and eat up two strangers totally i think schmigadoon has a chance i thought there was some great dialogue in the script if they're going to take the apple tv script and just expand i know it just had an out of town in kennedy center too and maybe they're even doing more from

SPEAKER_00that um but i just feel like schmigadoon has a There's like a heart to Schmigadoon and there's like a message to be said about it. I think if they wanted to really expand on that more with some book writing, unless they just keep it really surfacy, like this is a silly spoof on Golden Age, I don't know what they're going to do.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I wonder if once we have more musicals playing in the spring, if the luster of Two Strangers being the only viable candidate of the winter will... dim a bit for people i wonder something to consider as of right now yeah like it's score book musical it's like locked in those nominations what happens later we'll see but that's where we're at for that um and i will say at this point though too that it it hasn't really got to the level of what maybe happy

ending was doing by

SPEAKER_01now Oh, no. That's the thing. People talk about maybe happy ending of, well, they were struggling up until the Tony Awards. I'm like, no, they were struggling all through previews and then like the first month of their run. But also you look at the grosses for maybe happy ending and it always kept going up. Maybe not by hundreds of thousands of dollars every week, but like every week it would go up enough that like there was momentum going. And so they were in a safe space by New Year's and Two Strangers really only has had two money making weeks since it opened.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, this week we'll be telling now that the holidays are over too.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And while they got decent reviews, they did not get the reviews that maybe Happy Ending got. Outside of their critics pick, no one really raved about the musical. Again, as you were saying, Richie, it was a lot of like, it's cute. It's cute.

SPEAKER_00And that's all I can keep saying. And I'm like, I don't know what else to say about it.

SPEAKER_01But that's, I mean, that's what I've been saying about it, but it's more in response from people go, it's so charming. I respond with no, it's cute.

SPEAKER_00Right. It's cute. It's like a Disney Pixar movie on steroids.

SPEAKER_01A little bit, a little bit. Okay. So let's look at direction, both play and musical.

SPEAKER_00Which one first?

SPEAKER_01Um, I'll say musical first just because I do think that Two Strangers will get nominated here as well. Agreed. I do think Ragtime and Director, at the moment I'm going to say a nomination, but it is so not locked and I really don't know how to tell people how not locked it is.

SPEAKER_00I can't remember if Lear was nominated for Into the Woods. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01She was. I feel like here's what I'm going to go out on the limb and say. I would like to see her not get nominated in this category because I feel like a lesson kind of needs to be made and say like, hey, you can be this great person at Lincoln Center, but hire directors.

SPEAKER_00Or not. I know what you're saying.

SPEAKER_01Hire directors for the shows.

SPEAKER_00And be artistic directors still.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I wonder, I wonder, I wonder how much word has gone out about the rehearsal and tech process for Ragtime. because if it has that does damage her chances because they are not they are not good stories about her not as a person or as a director yeah

i'm sure those stories

SPEAKER_01are out from what i've heard yeah yeah yeah um and and I really didn't want – I don't want this to be like a Lear bashing podcast.

SPEAKER_00No, no.

SPEAKER_01I've said this before. I think what Lear de Bessonet has in spades is I think she's got really great taste in material. She picks really good stuff.

SPEAKER_00She does pick good stuff. I think her first season at Lincoln Center Theater has proven to be a successful

SPEAKER_01one with Ragtime and Kyoto and Hamal and the Night Visitors. Like I think she picks good stuff. I don't think she is a director. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00And also saying, too, kind of going over to Mark Arden with Queen of Versailles, he's almost always been nominated, and he's won a few times now, a couple Tonys. And so this could be an opportunity where maybe he's nominated for Lost Boys and not Queen of Versailles. I don't envision him getting a nomination for Queen of Versailles. that's not happening yeah and i don't think that mayor is happening for chess either for juice i don't it's just that's just not happening i think that what's helping lear's case right now is that two strangers in ragtime are just really the only viable options of the winter it's possible like again we

can have like a gypsy situation where it gets the revival nomination but not the director nomination

SPEAKER_00right yeah right very true and then All right, well, let's see what director of a play holds up to here.

SPEAKER_01Also, I feel like we're saying this now and then they'll get all these nominations in the spring and we're going to be labeled as such haters.

SPEAKER_00And we're not. It's just so hard when the way the season falls because, again...

SPEAKER_01We'll always be labeled as haters. Yeah, but do you know what I mean? It's more sort of... I always want people to kind of be on their guard of just because something seems so obvious now, you don't know what's going to happen in the spring. And I... Yeah. If anything, I more kind of just want to emphasize the like... The stories that have come out about that process, that is really more than anything what I feel like will be a deterrent. But we move on from there. Okay. So we did choreography. We did book score.

SPEAKER_01I think now we just have the performances, right?

SPEAKER_00Well, we have director of a play still.

SPEAKER_01Oh, director of a play.

SPEAKER_00Yes. Yeah. So Call Me as the Art, Punch, Waiting for Gatto, Little Marriage Road, Liberation, Unipus.

SPEAKER_01Call me Izzy, right?

SPEAKER_00Please, don't even get me started on that. I did not. Jean Smart should be given a Nobel Peace Prize for the fucking Herculean effort she did.

SPEAKER_01At the moment, I'm going to say Liberation and Oedipus. Yeah. Those are my locks right now. I am wondering with Little Bear Ridge Road because Mantello's got Salesman in the spring and if Salesman works. If Salesman works. If Salesman works, that would be his nomination.

SPEAKER_00I think there's a high chance it works because of Nathan and Lori on it. I think there's a really high chance that it works, but I don't know.

SPEAKER_01It's in such a big theater.

SPEAKER_00It's in a big theater. I also just really kind of wish we were getting that Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?

SPEAKER_01Don't we all wish it was just that?

SPEAKER_00Jeff has yet to see the movie, and I still think the Liz Taylor performance in the movie, I know, is one of the greatest Hollywood movies. I know. I'm trying to get him to watch the movie, which is brilliant. And I wasn't one of the couple hundred people that saw one of the four previews of it before it closed and shipped out here with COVID. But I just love that script so much. I think that's a great play. I do think Oedipus and Liberation are probably two that are the big contenders there.

SPEAKER_01Do you think they're going to leave out Jamie Lloyd? No.

SPEAKER_02I'm just saying. They're going to leave him out.

SPEAKER_01I'm just saying. They're going to leave him out. Absolutely. They're leaving him out. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I also, I mean, like, you know, I don't, I don't really see like Scott Ellis for art getting nominated for there's nothing really much going on with that.

SPEAKER_01No, that ain't happening either. I think the only, so I, Oedipus and, and liberation. I think, yes, the only ones right now that I think we can entertain the idea of would be Marjorie prime and little bear Ridge road. Um, I'm not even going to say bug. I think that Cromer, while he's Super Bowl-like, this is not his best work. And again, in the spring, we've got Every Brilliant Thing, Giant, Dog Day Afternoon, Becky Shaw, Death of a Salesman, Prue, Fallen Angels, The Balusters,

SPEAKER_01Joe Turner's Come and Gone.

SPEAKER_00So much. So many things. I know. And I'm sure many of them are going to be perfectly mediocre, but, but we just need three.

SPEAKER_01Right. And like, so giant, I think we're giant, I think is happening because it's so well regarded from London. They love the British imports. It's Heitner. Nicholas Heitner is directing it. He's very well liked. If salesman works, I think that's where Mantello gets in proof. We'll see. Yeah. I don't have a lot of faith.

SPEAKER_00I mean, the only thing I can say is it's Tommy Kale directing. What gives me faith is that Proof is a good play and the casting is really strong.

SPEAKER_01Kale does not inspire a lot of confidence. I will say that him not being nominated for the direction of Sweeney Todd was a snub.

SPEAKER_00I thought that was a snub.

SPEAKER_01You thought it was a snub? That he didn't even get a nomination for the direction of Sweeney, personally. Why do you think that was a snub?

SPEAKER_00oh, we could go on and on about this.

SPEAKER_01Why did we just, why did we speak so much about Lear with Ragtime and yet Tommy and Cale gets a pass

SPEAKER_00between time?

SPEAKER_01That is sexism, Richie. I would argue those are two people in the same boat.

SPEAKER_00No, listen, and I know Tommy's on the coattails of Hamilton, right? Like being on this, like this is his big, big thing. I get that, right? I thought there were moments of Sweeney that were dark, that were cool. The jumping in and out of the floor was kind of cool. Like there was some moments that I was like, this is cool, but They come out of the floor in ragtime. I know.

SPEAKER_01I know. They do it a lot slower, but they come out of there.

SPEAKER_00I mean, we'll see what he does with... We'll see.

SPEAKER_01I'm mostly giving you shit, but also I've been very vocal on this podcast that I don't think Kale did a goddamn thing with Sweeney Todd other than the jump in and out of the floor. I called that no trigger Sweeney, no blood, no dirt, no danger. And I don't consider his lack of a nomination a snub. I consider his lack of a nomination appropriate. And if... If I just spent enough time talking about my issues with Lear's direction for Ragtime, I am going to be even keel here and say it's not sexism on my part because I will say the same goddamn thing about Tommy Campbell.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't think it's perfect. I think since Hamilton, I think it's been tough to kind of see. Yeah, we'll see what he does with it. Now he's going to do a play, you know, not a musical.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, his Anna Christie at St. Anne's got a critic's pick from the same woman who gave a critic's pick to Queen of Versailles. So take that as you will. we'll see what that's oh my god no not sexy listen i totally get it like right we should be no i no but i hear you no you enjoyed what he did with sweeney todd so you're standing by that opinion and you're allowed full disclosure don't have a ton of experience with sweeney so that was my first time seeing a sage production of it so i'm also yeah you're welcome that was that's a good intro to

sweeney todd

SPEAKER_01because they only gave you two fingers not the full fist

SPEAKER_00I will say that the – I don't think the movie is good at all. And so I had low expectations going in because I don't like the movie.

SPEAKER_01Oh, I love the movie. But the movie is a terrible representation of the show. The movie is its own entity.

SPEAKER_00It's its own thing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But we have like nine different recordings of the stage show on video. So I'm like let the movie be the weird stepsister. It's fine.

SPEAKER_00I need to go do some work on that.

SPEAKER_01Okay. But so yeah. I do not – unless – Proof is fantastic. I just don't think that Cale's getting in there. But I think that – like, Joe Turner's coming. Gone is a super huge option because that's such a fascinating Wilson play. The only thing is that it is directed by Debbie Allen, who does not have the world's best stage record. Yeah, yeah, yeah. As a director. But, you know – Things can happen.

SPEAKER_00We also have Kenny Leon's doing bolsters.

SPEAKER_01I was going to say, what's Kenny Leon directing this season?

SPEAKER_00What's Kenny Leon directing this season? He's working every season. Good for him because he's always working. Him and David Cromer is always working too. I don't know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, every season there's always something. I will say the fact that this is Leon's only show this season is a little more exciting to me. He could give a little more focus on something. Agreed. Give it some good focus.

SPEAKER_00Also, we have no Casey Nicholaw this season. Some names really every season I feel like we see, and I'm like, okay.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no Bart Sher the season either.

SPEAKER_00And also the director of Hell's Kitchen. I'm forgetting his name.

SPEAKER_01Oh, Michael Greif.

SPEAKER_00Michael Greif. I feel like we always see him on, but we don't see him. I do want to give a quick shout-out to Ann Kaufman from Marjorie Prime, who –

SPEAKER_01I don't think it will happen for her on this one, unfortunately. But she is well-liked. She has been nominated before. And her work on Marjorie Prime is so exquisite with the actors that if she does get in, it would be like a cost-of-living situation where the ensemble work is so good. And because she has such a strong reputation as an actor's director, that could happen. I think because there are so many options in the spring and Marjorie Prime will be closed, I think, by mid-February. So, yeah, we'll see. I think that Oedipus and Liberation right now are our two

winter warriors.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01Fighting the good fight.

SPEAKER_00All right, performances. Should we do play first?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, let's do play featured actor and actress.

SPEAKER_00OK, feature an actor and actress and supporting and leading. Let's see. Well, just a featured role. So best performance by an actress in a featured role in a play. I actually put Betsy Adem for Liberation. I really enjoyed her performance. I know Victoria Clark's up there, too, for Punch as a possibility. But Betsy for me over Victoria. I think this is where I have to tell everyone Vicki Clark is so lovely in punch and

SPEAKER_01she's not getting nominated and we have to accept it.

SPEAKER_00I think you're right. I think you're right. I love her.

SPEAKER_01I love her. But with the 9,000 women from liberation, not to mention, I don't know what's going to happen with Marjorie Prime if June Squibb and Cynthia Nixon will be considered both featured or one of them is going to be considered lead. You'll see for yourself, June Squibb is technically speaking the lead role, but she's not in it a lot. She makes up the first half a lot, and then Cynthia Nixon takes over the second half. And so I don't know if they'll be co-leads or co-featured. But whichever categories they're in, I hope they both get in because Nixon is –

SPEAKER_01Nixon is so phenomenal in Marjorie Prime.

SPEAKER_00I love her. I can't wait to see her.

SPEAKER_01That's great to know. Yeah, we don't have a lot for this category right now. Yeah, I think of Liberation, Betsy Item is probably the one who has the best shot of getting in. I would then maybe say... Here's the thing. Kayla, uh, Davion in liberation really only has the one big scene in act two. And it's a great scene.

SPEAKER_00I thought of that. I know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it's, it makes you wonder, is this going to be a performance where, because it has the one big showcase moment, that's enough, or is it not quite enough? You know what I mean? I feel like it's enough if we like go back to like sign and Sydney Bruce Dean's window. And like, that was enough for the supporting who won that.

SPEAKER_00Oh, that was... She won for the one scene, right? Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, no, she had more than that scene.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, but I mean, she was... Yeah. I mean, it's kind of like Anne Hathaway winning for the Academy Award, I mean, and for one song and one layman. I mean, it's like sometimes all it takes is one... Yeah, sometimes all it takes is the one. And I will say with Kayla Davion, like, it helps that her big thing is later on in the show.

SPEAKER_01Miriam Silverman is who won. Yes, yes, yes. But yeah, but Mavis in Sinan Cindy Brustein's window, again, like, she had... She has like she had three scenes and it's and she obviously won for like her big monologue telling all of them that they were like, you may be liberal, but you're awful. And and she just so ate that.

SPEAKER_00But yeah, that was amazing.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think so. I would say for me. Yeah, if it's outside of Betsy Adam, Kayla Davion is one that I just she's on my brain because of how that role is set up. And everyone in that show is wonderful. Wonderful. It's a phenomenal ensemble, but it is hard to figure out who to pick after that. I think what helps with Betsy is that she's a previous nominee. People know her. I also have it on good authority that Kayla Davion might be coming back next season. So maybe things will be floating around when nominations happen.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think they probably had the two like as the supporting roles in that show, the most interesting part later on in the show for them, like reenacting. So I think that's where it might separate them from like the rest of the cast because they are all kind of on the same level of like really great acting. Yeah. I also don't know what's going to happen with Laurie Metcalf with Death of a Salesman if the production will be such that it emphasizes Linda and she'll feel like a co-lead. Because up until the last production, Linda has always been in featured.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, always. I know. Yeah. The Sharon D. Clark production was the first one where Linda was considered a lead.

SPEAKER_01And I think there's enough of Linda that she can be a lead. Yeah. But it all is a matter of the angle of the production. So I don't know what they're going to do with this.

SPEAKER_00Totally.

SPEAKER_01But yeah, so Laurie Metcalf is just that. She's a little asterisk. I also, with Proof, Samira Wiley could absolutely get in for that. That's a great role. And who the fuck knows with the balusters? I also don't know what's going to happen with Giant. They've got some great women in that, but I don't know what those roles are. Yeah. And I'm assuming in Fallen Angels, those are both co-leads, Kelly and Rose Byrne, I'm assuming. Yeah, I would imagine that those are co-leads. Also, shout out to Anne Reed in Oedipus.

SPEAKER_01I know that June Squibb's 96, but Anne Reed is 90. And she also has a really phenomenal track where she comes in at the top and makes an impression and then comes back towards the end to make another great impression. So I wouldn't be surprised if we ended up seeing her as well. She's June Squibb and Kayla Davion combined. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Oh my God. There's a lot. I mean, it'll be anybody's game at this point.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think that, yeah. Featured actress in a play. It's so crowded that truly the nomination will be the award because there's, there's going to be a lot of women who will be unrecognized and we want to, yeah, we'll do, I'll do an episode for like the fallen who don't get nominated. Featured actor in a play. It's, it's a little more sparse. I think Danny bursting to Marjorie prime has a good shot here.

SPEAKER_00Um,

SPEAKER_01I hate to say it, I think James Corden art has a good shot here.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, sure, totally.

SPEAKER_01Do they fall in as featured, all three of them? Yeah, I think the original, they were all considered featured, and I would imagine it's going to be the same for this. Okay. So I think James Corden could definitely...

SPEAKER_00Yeah, for sure. I also thought Michael Patrick Thornton as Lucky and Waiting for Gatto was good, and I thought he could be considered maybe. There's Pozzo and Lucky. I thought Lucky was... I thought he has that really great monologue, and I just... Maybe, you know?

SPEAKER_01I mean, John Glover was nominated years ago for playing Lucky, and... For me, Brandon J. Dearden as Pozzo was really the standout performance, and I would probably nominate him. What do you think about that?

SPEAKER_00I thought he was okay. I just feel like... It was fine. That whole production to me was fine.

SPEAKER_01I didn't think he was fine. I didn't think he was perfect. I thought he was the best one in the show.

SPEAKER_00Well, maybe that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Because it's not going to be Keanu. I'm telling you that much.

SPEAKER_00No, no.

SPEAKER_01There's also John Carroll Lynch for Oedipus could also happen. But ultimately, actually, I could have sworn that art, they determined that they were all unfeatured. Am I making this up?

SPEAKER_00I have not heard, so I don't know.

SPEAKER_01I thought they were leading, but I... Let me look this up again, because I could have sworn they did an announcement. Didn't they do one announcement already? They did, but I don't... I don't know if that was considered in there or not.

SPEAKER_00That's hard on the play, you know?

SPEAKER_01I'm looking this up. I'm looking this up now. Will Harrison is considered lead for Punch. And then... Oh no, I guess they're all going to be considered lead because they're all above the title. Nevermind. I take that back everybody. Okay. Because I put them in our leading category. So maybe I did my research. I'm so sorry, everyone. I'm so sorry.

SPEAKER_00All right. Well, then we'll, I guess we'll see. I mean, I also,

SPEAKER_01I think that changes things up here too, because like, we still don't have a ton of the like featured actor.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think this is where Joe Turner's come and gone is going to dine out because there

SPEAKER_01are a lot of feature roles in that play. Yeah. And I don't know how they're going to balance it out in Dog Day Afternoon, if they're going to be co-leads, those two, or if one's more of a featured. Also, Death of a Salesman, we've got the two sons, Lucky and Biff. Those tend to do well.

SPEAKER_00Yes, they do.

SPEAKER_01And for things that we've seen right now, I would put Charlie Thurston in there for liberation just because he has a great

SPEAKER_00mustache.

SPEAKER_01Thurston Thurston.

SPEAKER_00I cannot. What?

SPEAKER_01He's a handsome man.

SPEAKER_00He is. Yes. He's only in one, two scenes. But yeah.

SPEAKER_01I'm saying for what we've seen, he would get nominated, right? Yeah. Yeah. I'm going to use the same thing I said in Natasha Pierre when we were talking about flooding the basement. Ain't no underground in Louisiana. There is only underwater. Flooded basement.

SPEAKER_00We go to lead actress and actor in a play. Let's go to female first. Actress in a leading role in a play. I mean, I'm I'm putting Leslie Manville here so far. I think that's probably the strongest contender. I mean, I definitely know you have Jean Smart and Laurie Metcalf in this category currently. as well um Susanna Flood as Lizzie in Liberation could also be considered leading I would assume yes she's considered lead yeah I think that as of right now Lori for Little Bear Ridge Road Susanna Flood for Liberation Carrie Coon for Bug and um who's the other one we're saying oh and Leslie Manville for

Oedipus those are those are all going to be fighting for it in the spring we'll see what happens with uh

SPEAKER_01Becky Shaw and Proof and Fallen Angels yeah yeah

SPEAKER_00I mean, I think Rose Byrne and Kelly O'Hara alone are going to be – if they're great and they're big names, I think that's going to be hard on that.

SPEAKER_01Also, it's going to help that Rose Byrne is going to be coming off of an Oscar nomination, possibly a win by that point. So there's going to be a lot of buzz with that. So, yeah, I don't – yeah, Taraji P. Henson and Joe Turner, she'll be considered featured. That's a featured role.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01We'll see what happens to Laurie Metcalf with Death of a Salesman. I think if they are smart, they will petition her as featured. So she can get two nominations in one year.

SPEAKER_00Right. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I mean, I also think, like, I do see a world where Gene Smart is completely snubbed out.

SPEAKER_01Gene's not getting in at this point. We have too many... strong contenders in better shows for gene smart to be in there uh i mean it was great as as good as carrie coon is in bug like there's a world in which she doesn't get in i mean because i i or even suzanna flood i really think that leslie manville right now is the only one that i'm just putting such money down of it's happening she's getting nominated she could possibly even win no matter what happens in the

SPEAKER_00spring she was amazing on that i totally agree And then actually that leads into actor in a leading role in a play because I do have Mark Strong up as a definite leading contender. 1,000%. I mean I know all the art guys are up there too.

SPEAKER_01All the art men, now that I know they're lead, they're all getting in. I mean I know they're all – They're not getting in.

SPEAKER_00I don't see – yeah, I mean I will also – I don't see Alex or Keanu for Waiting for Gatto really being up there either.

SPEAKER_01If I was giving it to one, it would be Alex.

SPEAKER_00Alex over Keanu, but yeah. I think that with the spring with Daniel Radcliffe and John Lithgow and the two Dog

SPEAKER_01Day Afternoon gentlemen and Nathan Lane for Death of a Salesman, I don't know how Cheadle's going to be considered for proof. I think he'll be considered featured, but I don't know.

SPEAKER_00That'll probably be featured, I think. Yeah, I think I think we're looking at Mark Strong and Mark Strong alone from the winter.

SPEAKER_01Maybe me. Maybe I'm having some ayahuasca right now. Like maybe we'll hear us Harrison for punch just because it's such a large central role. But I think that's a job. I think that would be punches only real chance.

SPEAKER_00I also still kind of go back to what you said earlier, that there's a chance that we just have punch completely forgotten overall, the whole production, unfortunately.

SPEAKER_01It's not a punch. It's a swing and a miss.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, right.

SPEAKER_01Not a punch. And then he would be leading.

SPEAKER_00Oh, Micah Stock for Little Bear Ridge Road. Would he be leading?

SPEAKER_01He would be lead. I don't see that happening, but I know people who really enjoyed that performance. I did not, but it's... I think he has a better chance than Will Harrison. I will, Harrison, I will say that. Yeah. But I just think that there are too many big, big dogs in the spring that I, I just think it's Mark Strong and that's the only one.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. If we go to musical. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Picture doctor and actress in a musical also kind of a little open. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, if we go featured actress in a musical so far, I mean, I think, I think Nichelle Lewis has a good chance of being nominated for Ragtime. Shayna Taub maybe too, but I think Nichelle maybe gets that nomination over her. Yeah, I think Nichelle's the only one in Ragtime in that category that I would put money down. I don't think it's going to happen, but I just want to put it in nominators' minds right now.

SPEAKER_01to consider Hannah Cruz for chess. Just do it.

SPEAKER_00Just do it. We love her. That's exciting. I'm excited to see what she's doing. She has a number in the show, right?

SPEAKER_01She's she only really has one. She has she has. I know I'm so well with with Leah, but she's playing Svetlana. She plays the wife. She shows up for act two. And as I said in my review, she's the only one in the show for me who is playing a character that I genuinely watch. I go, oh, you're a human being who's fucked before. Whereas I go, I don't know where what world you're coming from. But also I watched her in that show. I went, oh, you're the one who went. I'm in chess and I will be giving you chess.

SPEAKER_00Uh-huh. Okay, good. Okay. So that's great.

SPEAKER_01She shows up and I went, oh, we have a woman now. But yeah, I would like them to consider her. I do think Nichelle has a strong shot.

SPEAKER_00I wish Melody Butu's role in Queen of the First Eye was bigger. I don't see her getting nominated, but it would have been nice if they gave her a whole song or something. Yeah, she had that really nice monologue, but otherwise I think she'll probably get forgotten.

SPEAKER_01We'll see what happens with... Jellicle Ball and with Lost Boys and with Schmingadoon. From what I understand, Schmingadoon has a lot of featured actress chances.

SPEAKER_00Totally.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I also... I asked a friend of mine who's working on Lost Boys. I went, is Shoshana being a lead or is she a feature? Because Diane Weiss is really a supporting role in the movie. And they said that she, based on how the role is written for the musical, she could be considered lead. But she also, I think they're figuring out what her best option would be. And I think feature would be a better option for her. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it's kind of light right now.

SPEAKER_01We'll have Deborah Cox as feature.

SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. Oh, no, she would be.

SPEAKER_01We'll have Deborah Cox. We'll see what happens with Rose and Titanic, especially if the current rumor of who might be playing Rose on Broadway is true.

SPEAKER_00Oh, it was announced. Jim Parsons.

SPEAKER_01No, that's Ruth.

SPEAKER_00Oh, Ruth. Oh my God. I'm totally. Rose. Rose.

SPEAKER_01There's a rumor about who's going to be playing Rose.

SPEAKER_00Oh, there's a, that's right.

SPEAKER_01Can we hear the rumor? Let's just say she's known for being rather pitch perfect. Oh, and she's never every, she finishes every drink she has because she needs to play the cup.

SPEAKER_00I see. Interesting. You got it. That is the rumor. I got it. I got it. I got it. I got it.

SPEAKER_01You know what they say about rumors, though.

SPEAKER_00True. If we go to actor in a featured role... But there would definitely be a ton of features. For Titanic. And Schmigadoon.

SPEAKER_01Schmigadoon more than Titanic. Titanic, I think it's really just... Molly Brown that's a featured female role because there's actually a lot of options for featured actor in a musical there. Cal, Ruth, The Iceberg. I think those are all genuine featured roles. Definitely Schmigadoon. And if any of them like if Mackenzie Kurtz

SPEAKER_00Where is she going? Because she left Heather's pretty quickly.

SPEAKER_01She left Heather's. I think she left Heather's to do Sprungadoon. Don't call me on that. I might be wrong.

SPEAKER_00I'm sure she is. If that happens, I'll be very happy. Because she would be hilarious.

SPEAKER_01Because we're stans over here. And I heard she was great in DC. So that would be a nice option for her.

SPEAKER_00And then I don't know who's playing the Jane. I say it based on the Apple TV. I know Jane Krakowski had an awesome feature. But I don't know who's playing that.

SPEAKER_01But that was season two, wasn't it? No, she is in season one.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, she comes to the town and has this big number, but I don't know who's doing that on Broadway yet.

SPEAKER_01I don't know either. They've only announced that Alex Brightman and Sarah Chase are in it. They haven't announced anyone else yet. Featured actor. So from Chester is Bryce Pinkham and Bradley Dean. There's F. Murray Abraham from Queen of Versailles. Ragtime, there's Ben Levi Ross and Colin Donnell. Of all of these guys, I'm going to say Bryce Pinkham and Ben Levi Ross have the best shot. Similar to what I did before, with Jellicle Ball, with Rocky Horror, with Lost Boys, and with Schmigadoon, and even Titanic, I think those are going to come in and sort of flood the

options pretty soon. I had thought F. Murray for maybe leading, but I guess he would be supporting.

SPEAKER_01He isn't supporting. I think he's been deemed supporting.

SPEAKER_00Ben has more to do in Ragtime than Colin. I thought Colin was good, but Colin doesn't have a ton to do in that.

SPEAKER_01Father exists to be racist and for the audience to go, you're racist. Oh, shit. Sorry. Fuck, I have a phone call. One second, gentlemen.

SPEAKER_00You're good. You're good. Take your time.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Um, I have to, we have to, we have to wrap things up soon. Sorry. Um, to be racist. I don't think Colin's getting in. I think Ben has a better shot cause that's the better role. Um, but I, I think, so yeah, I would say right now, the only one that I would say to remember to keep tabs on is Ben, but I don't, I don't totally buy that. Uh, lead actress in a musical at the moment. We got Kristen, Casey, Leah, Christiana pits, Christine, Cheryl for mama Mia. I'm going to say Casey's.

and i think kristen is i don't i think she's on the bubble she's gonna be like idina from last season and be forgotten i think yeah i hate to say that but i think she's gonna and then also christiani maybe i'm sure leah's getting a nomination i haven't seen chess yet but i'm sure leah's getting a nomination like i mean i don't know if he is getting in really that's a bold statement it is very bold statement i

SPEAKER_01think sorry um i think with uh With Jessica Vosk and Marla Mindell and Sarah Chase and, and possibly Shoshana Bean. Like, I don't know. I think Leah has a shot, but I, I also, I just, I'm not sure Leah's getting it.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Well, we'll see. And Casey, I think, yeah, that's in for sure. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Actor in a musical. I think Joshua Henry, for sure.

SPEAKER_00I think for sure. I think actually I could go so far as to say, I think he could win it.

SPEAKER_01I think he's got a very good shot to win. I think Sam Toody for Two Strangers also is a short thing. And then everyone else we have, Nick Christopher, Aaron Tveit, and Brandon Uranowitz. I think they're all kind of swimming around of like, do we we'll we'll see we'll see maybe yep it'll be yeah especially with you know we'll see how successful luke evans is in rocky horror we'll see what happens with lost boys we'll see what happens with shamingadoon but um i also because i'll say with lead actress we can just say i think marlon mandel will be getting in for titanic it's just that's gonna happen um sure and then lead

actor and actress in

SPEAKER_01plays we do we do we did that already

SPEAKER_00Wait, so we're done? Yeah, we might be done.

SPEAKER_01That was the quick rapid fire at the end. Because I forgot I had a phone call.

SPEAKER_00Okay,

SPEAKER_01so what we have so far this winter, what would you say are the big shows that you want to make sure people keep on their possible ballots for nominations?

SPEAKER_03Ooh.

SPEAKER_00I think they kind of speak for themselves. I think two strangers in Ragtime are going to keep themselves in the race. They're just still running into the dead of winter right now. So I think those are things that people like are going to just have no choice but to keep on the back burner.

SPEAKER_01And then for plays, liberation, Oedipus probably.

SPEAKER_00We need to remember those even though they're closing soon. We have to remember those. And I want everyone to also remember Marjorie Prime, especially when it comes to acting.

SPEAKER_01I think that there's some good stuff that could happen there. Yeah, I agree with you guys. I think Liberation, Oedipus, definitely keep pins in that. I think Little Bear Ridge Road will have some stuff that will get remembered in the spring, but I don't think as much as people are expecting. I think of the two, Liberation is one that's going to carry on through. And then, yeah, for all the things we said about Ragtime, like Ragtime is going to do quite well on nomination morning.

SPEAKER_00Sure, of course. Oh, yeah, no doubt. Yeah, but I think what we've been saying is like, do not forget that Jellicle Ball is coming. Do not forget. Every category we've ended, and let's just not forget we have Jellicle Ball. I feel like that's going to really come out of nowhere, and then that's going to be the bright shiny toy that everyone looks at, and that's really going to happen.

SPEAKER_01Gentlemen, this has been so lovely. Thank you so much for joining me today.

SPEAKER_00Of course. Thank you so much for having us.

SPEAKER_01Where can people find you if you want them to find you?

SPEAKER_00Jeff?

SPEAKER_01On the podcast at Half Hour Podcast.

SPEAKER_00On Instagram.

SPEAKER_01With Jeff and Richie on Instagram. And we're on all the major platforms. Spotify, Apple Music, etc.

SPEAKER_00Take a listen.

SPEAKER_01Amazing. If you want to follow us, guys, I'm on Instagram at Matt Koplick, usual spelling. I believe we're going to be starting a TikTok soon. Don't quote me on that. You'll see us there. We're there too. TikTok scares me, babe. But you can also give this podcast a nice five-star rating or review. You can join our Substack or Discord, especially as we're now getting into Tony discourse. This is a great time to join the Discord channel or join the sub stack. Jeff, Richie, what diva do you want to close out with today? Oh, I chose last time. We should do a new Broadway diva manifesting Mackenzie Kurtz.

SPEAKER_00Ooh.

SPEAKER_01Okay. She's going to be a new Broadway diva. All right. We're going to do that. We're going to close out with Mackenzie Kurtz. All right. We will see you guys next week. Bye.

SPEAKER_02They've been out searching for a shrub. Out shopping for a bush. Well, they can kiss my tush. It seems to me they've really lost the clothes.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode