Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

BACKSTAGE PASS: Producing Marcel on the Train w/ Mitch Marois and Maxwell Beer

Mar 9, 202649 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Series SummaryWelcome to Backstage Pass, the brand-new mini-series from Broadway Breakdown. Whether it’s analyzing shows from yesteryear or documenting the process as it happens, we’re here to pull back the curtain and give you the inside scoop. First up: the Off-Broadway journey of Marcel on the Train. The GuestsMitch Marois and Maxwell Beer are the driving forces behind Marcel on the Train, shepherding the show from concept to Off-Broadway production. In this episode, they unpack the origins of the piece, the artistic vision guiding it, and what it actually takes to mount an intimate new musical in today’s downtown ecosystem. Fun Links: Mix and Match Productions Timestamps 00:00 - Introducing Backstage Pass 04:18 - The origins of Marcel on the Train12:07 - Developing a concept: tone, themes, and audience20:33 - Writing and shaping the piece for Off-Broadway30:00- Producing realities: budget, space, and scale40:00 - Hopes, fears, and what success looks like for this production47:00 - What’s coming in the next Backstage Pass episode This is just the beginning. In the next episode, we’ll continue tracking Marcel on the Train as it evolves - so consider this your all-access credential. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_02Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the deal, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown and the very first episode of Backstage Pass, our new miniseries giving you an insider's look at the goings-on of our fabulous, sometimes infuriating, but always complex industry. We'll be talking to the actors, directors, writers, producers, directors, designers, choreographers, and everyone else who helps create the magique. We are kicking things off with a look at Theatre of the Present,

SPEAKER_02Classic Stage Company's latest production, Marcel on the Train. Written by Ethan Slater and Marshall Paylette, the play tells the true story of Marcel Marceau before he became the world's most famous mime when he was a young man in Nazi-occupied France helping guide Jewish children to safety during World War II. The production began previews on February 5th and opened on February 22nd. Though it runs through March 22nd, it's already completely sold out. I know, I already tried. But even if we can't see it right now,

SPEAKER_02we can go backstage and learn what it took to make it happen. In this first episode, I am joined by producers Mitch Moroy and Maxwell Beer, who have been shepherding this project since 2022. They're the founders of Mix & Match Productions, which made its New York debut last year off-Broadway with the hit Celino V. Barnes, about the dramatic and very real relationship between the infamous lawyers Ross Celino and Steve Barnes. The show opened at the Asylum Theater in July of 2024 and extended multiple times

SPEAKER_02before it eventually closed in March of 2025. Oh god, I guess at this point it's almost two years ago. My math is terrible. Mitch and Max also won their first Tony Award last year as co-producers for Maybe Happy Ending. And in addition to running Mix and Match, they serve as managing and associate producers, respectively, for the Broadway producing team Handel Productions. So let's head backstage and get to my conversation with Mitch and Max.

SPEAKER_00Billy, I beg to differ with you. How do you mean? You're the top. Yeah. You're an arrow collar. You're the top. You're a cooler.

SPEAKER_02Max and Mitch, welcome to Broadway Breakdown. Hello. Hello. Hello. Good to see you. Good to see you, too. First, I want the listeners to get an idea of who you two are. How did you get into producing? How did that enter your chat?

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Well, Mitch and I are both started out as performers as well. So we came at theater from a public facing side, I would say. And through being in so many shows, we got a little peek behind the curtain. I was a child actor and I was doing a tour of Lost in Yonkers with one of our Marcel cast members, Alex Wise. Right. And during that tour, when I was in eighth grade, I would be looking at the seating charts and at the ticketing

for each performance

SPEAKER_01to see how many people were in the audience, which would then determine how much effort I would put into the performance, which if you're an actor... means you probably shouldn't be an actor if you're doing that. So that wasn't my path. But about five years earlier, I had fallen deeply in love with the musical Chitty Chitty Bang Bang. And my father had started to bring home Variety magazine because that had the grosses in it at the time. And so in about third grade,

I started following along the Broadway grosses and really just Chitty Chitty Bang

SPEAKER_01Bang. And I couldn't understand, you know, hundreds of thousands of dollars, but I could understand, oh, they had 70 percent of their seats filled this week. They had 80 percent of their seats filled last week. Why did that happen? And so now 20 years later, I've just like have developed the baseball cards of all the shows, all the stats, all the theaters, what works in what theaters. And that's what I fell in love with. And I thought, oh, I can do this with my life for a job. Like, how lucky would that be?

SPEAKER_01And that's how I got into producing full time. Fantastic. Mitch?

SPEAKER_02Um, I always thought I was going to be an actor, studied it in college. I went to Carnegie for musical theater. But even when I was there, I started thinking, okay, do I want to be a director instead? Do I want to choreograph instead? Is acting really the end all be all for me? And the answer was no. And at Carnegie, they do this thing called Playground where they shut down the School of Drama for a full week. And it's a festival of new works, plays, musicals, concerts, puppetry,

anything you can imagine. And like when I look back, that's the first taste of producing I ever got. Because you would be participating in like 10 shows and wear every hat or no hat or

SPEAKER_02one hat or three hats and get to experience all of it. And then when I graduated from college, I acted for a minute. I did some things and that was fun. But the kind of projects that I kept running towards were, you know, getting the opportunity to help found a company up in Vermont, were getting to put together shows, put together concerts and things. And then the kind of like trajectory from there and then working in nonprofit theater at various levels, whether it was a summer stock or whether here off Broadway in New York.

SPEAKER_02to then falling into commercial producing, because honestly, at the time I'd been working in nonprofit and at least here in commercial into the job that I was offered working with Ruth and Stephen Hendel, you know, paid the best and came with insurance. So I said, cool, I guess I'm working in commercial producing now. And that was about eight years ago. And then Max actually joined our office back in 2019 before in the before times as an intern. I was paid in Metro cards and lunches. I got the job via Playbill Jobs.

That gets into how Marcel fell into our laps because Max and I were really vibing in the office. We had great energy and we were saying, cool, we should find stuff to do together.

SPEAKER_02And kind of the North Star that I had was I wanted to find projects. I wanted something that made me feel like the movie Life is Beautiful. If you've seen that, that is finding... joy in terrifying circumstances? How can you find that kind of projects that make you feel like that?

SPEAKER_01And Max, because y'all go ahead. I don't know. Those kinds of those kinds of shows or films were at the end of it. You're crying and you're smiling and you're so happy and you're so sad and you just feel a little bit more alive than you did when you started that piece of art.

SPEAKER_02Ideally, there's hope, you know, that you're getting hope out of it. And Max was still working in another office on a new musical at the time that helped reopen theater after the pandemic called A Commercial Jingle for Regina Comet.

SPEAKER_01So I was working on that show as the writing assistant, the producing associate, the copyist and COVID safety, which meant I was a stagehand and was there eight shows a week as well. And, you know, that was at night. And so I was able to do this internship during the day. I started chatting with the director of the project, who was our favorite Marshall Palette. And Marshall and I just really got along. I saw a piece of theater that Marshall had made when I was a sophomore in high

SPEAKER_01school at Soho Playhouse called Triassic Park. And that was one of those instances where I left the theater going, oh, yeah. You can make fun theater. Like, that's the kind of stuff I want to make. So Marshall was always someone that I wanted to work with, and I was a little bit starstruck and intimidated at first. And then he starts sending me his plays. We start discussing them, and he sends me Marcel. I read it, and I go, holy crap, this is great.

SPEAKER_01Mitch, I think you got to read this.

SPEAKER_02And then I read it, and we were like, yep, this is the one. This is what we want to do. And then we actually, we sat, because it's written by Marshall and Ethan together, from a kind of a germ of an idea that Ethan had. And so we sat them both down, and we said, hey, we haven't produced... a show off broadway we haven't produced a broadway show we haven't done a commercial show on our own yet but we believe in you guys we believe in this project and we think we understand what this thing is uh both you know on the text side and the kind of production you want to build for it uh

would you guys trust us to take it on and they said heck yeah and uh i guess the rest is kind of history

SPEAKER_02now that was in 2022 was that Is that 22, 23? No, that was in 22, right? That was in 22.

SPEAKER_01That was like summer of 22. Yes. I got sent the script on June 6th, 2022. And we're going to have our first performance February 5th, 2026. So from June of 2022 to February of 2026, that is almost four years. From getting the scripts to this first performance, what...

SPEAKER_02Has this journey been? You come on as producers. What goes next? So this crazy thing of we were full steam ahead planning a 29 hour reading,

SPEAKER_01which is, you know, a week long industry standard reading that you kind of do to get some interest from investors or do some creative work. And this crazy thing happened where in August, our star and co-writer, Ethan, goes, hey, guys, we're going to need to put a pause on this for about a year because I just booked a wicked movie. And we were like, ooh. What? And, you know, so flip. We were so ecstatic, you know, you couldn't believe it.

SPEAKER_01And so we were like, amazing. You know, maybe we could do some work remotely. Maybe we do a remote reading. So we just, you know, we're like, you go, Ethan. We support you and we will do whatever work we can do in the meantime. Yeah. And so while Ethan was away, we managed to do a 29, we managed to do just a reading over Zoom, like a one day. And that was the spring of 23. April. And then from that, I felt motivated to apply for the Howl Prince Producing

Fellowship. which is this fellowship for young creative producers in our industry that gives

SPEAKER_01you access to mentorship, access to the classes in Columbia's MFA Producing and Theater Management program, as well as quite a bit of startup funds for a production. And you have to apply with a show. I've known who the Prince Fellow was since I was in middle school and have always wanted to apply, but knew I wanted to apply with the right project. And here it was like, I love the show. I believe in the show. And I think this is something that a creative producer, you know, can really use to sink their teeth into what is this business?

SPEAKER_01How do I take a nonconvent, maybe a slightly nonconventional piece of theater, a story about a mime in World War Two, you know, and bring that to a commercial audience? And so that started that path for the next year. And then we started doing a 29-hour reading. And I'll let you take that 29-hour in the fall, Mitch.

SPEAKER_02Sure, yeah. So, I mean, really, that 209 Hour was made possible because of the Prince Fellowship funding and, honestly, the mentorship that Max got out of it, getting advice from, you know, David Stone, from, who are the, Kristen Kasky,

SPEAKER_01Sue Frost. It was David Stone, yeah. David Stone, Kristen Kasky, Sue Frost, Tom Schumacher, Jeffrey Seller. Yeah, that's about as good as it gets.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah, so we got some great advice there. We did that first 29 hour in September. That was the first week of September 23, I want to say. Yeah, it was really successful. Our first time seeing it up there. coincided with rosh hashanah we did it on the air of rosh as it were yeah yeah yeah yeah so that was great yeah and from a from a development perspective we all walked away from that being like okay we know there is some there there you know we've now

finally seen it in with with actors in a room maybe just at music stands but you know there's there there uh there's work to be done on the piece itself uh so you

SPEAKER_02know while We were working with the writers and director Marshall on, okay, the work that, you know, as a team that the two of them plus the two of us thought, you know, should happen on it based off of both the feedback and the experience with the actors, you know, finally reading it out loud and hearing it out loud. We were counting the pavement. We were talking to nonprofits. We were reaching out. We were scheduling meetings. We were sending the script. We talked to some people in London. about hey is this a possibility and worth exploring there you

know we did all of that and then we got to a point where we were ready for another workshop and this was in 2024 now and this opportunity at williamstown uh presented itself to go essentially use it as a 29 hour to another 29 hour workshop to get it back up on

SPEAKER_02its feet essentially a whole year uh calendar year after the first one So with a new draft, with a lot of the original cast that we had, trying out some other people in it, though, because we tried some different things with the characters and such like that. It also coincided with the opening week of the first show that Max and I ever produced, Selina v. Barnes. So it was freaking chaos. But we made it work. And that reading to help kind of seal the deal. We had already been chatting with Jill Rafson at Classic Stage about the project

SPEAKER_02because Jill has been a supporter of Ethan's for a long time. And Classic Stage has from his relationship being there and Assassins. And he has his own musical that they've done a little bit of development there as well.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And Jill was at the reading that we did in 2023. So she's been very supportive of it, as well as Jill comes from Roundabout and was one of the heads of Roundabout Underground and really spearheaded that. So a lot of our favorite playwrights now of the David West Reads, Josh Harmon's like she was the one, you know, therapizing them, helping them, you know, helping structure as it were. And I thought, whoa, if we could have the person who helped those playwrights find

their voice in their

SPEAKER_01singular stories in that way, how lucky would we be if we had that brain working on our show? And, you know, you can't, the the theater industry is just a little the non-profit sector i should say is a little too fickle that you can't just say we want this one non-profit and if we don't go with that one non-profit you know that's it that's the ball game you have to it's kind of like dating and you have to talk to a lot of people you have to see who's interested as well you know are we able to provide for them what they would what they would need to have a successful production and like

the answer we were

SPEAKER_02lucky that classic stage was kind of always at the top of the list Classic stage, even from our first conversations, classic stage is at the top of the list in terms of the audience that it has, in terms of the space itself. The space itself is just so lived in and beautiful and wonderful for the story that we're telling here. And Jill, at the time when we did our first reading in 23, I think that was her... first full season as artistic director and she was really looking for ways to expand the mission uh you know it is they're reinterpreting and

reimagining the classics and the idea of reinterpreting and or reimagining a classic figure uh so that they could do things like a world premiere of a new play marcel classic figure this is a new play about this person that you think you know uh and if how it can

SPEAKER_02fit into the you know the classic stage ethos there

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Absolutely. And I mean, I think that what people don't realize is that every nonprofit in New York, as Mitch was sort of inferring here, has a different mission statement when it comes to producing. And of course, those mission statements change over time with new management. And so, you know, you can go to all of them and sort of see who's a fit, but it's also... a rejection from one is not a statement on the quality of the piece that you have. Like there could be a theater company that's like, we really grade. We don't do, we like fully don't do new works, hard stop.

And I think of it like, one of the gigs I used to have was as a college audition coach.

SPEAKER_02And I think of it as, you know, Like if you're a nonprofit, you're building a season and you are checking certain boxes with each show, kind of like a BFA class is checking certain boxes with, you know, they don't all need the same five foot two blue eyed, blonde haired mezzo. You know, like you're going to pick one. You're going to have, OK, this is the show that checks this box and this is the show that checks that box. And I don't have room for you in my season this year. And next year, I think we already have the one that's kind of like that. But check back in three seasons. Maybe then we'll have the room for you there. uh yeah that's also the game of the programming game and these

non-profits are so their lit departments are so overworked they have so many flipping submissions that come to them uh whether it's you know the cold call submissions that get sent in or the you know part of their writers groups submissions and the projects that they're internally starting to develop and excited to see go through or the commercial

SPEAKER_02people who come in and say hey We think we can bring in some enhancement investment to do a production here. They just have so much to review. There's so much in the pipeline. So to just get anybody to say, hey, let's at least take a meeting to talk about it isn't in itself a victory. Oh, yeah. You don't have to tell me, Mitch, about these lit departments and these nonprofits, about how overworked they are. I have a script that's at like five different nonprofits. They all have not read it in the last two years.

And I will honestly take that over them having read it and leaving me on read.

SPEAKER_01People wonder, like, what is the secret a lot to like either raising money or getting into a nonprofit? And like, it is just following up. So it is just sending more emails and following up and being relentless and being a little bit annoying and being OK with being annoying, but still being polite. And like that is the secret sauce. But it is really just sending emails.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's what we do.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it's so frustrating because whoever likes to write an email. OK, so to recap for the listeners, June of 2022 is when you get the script. By August of 2022 is when you were going to do the first 29 hour reading with Ethan. And then that gets delayed because of Wicked. So you do basically like a Skype one, a remote one. And so was the next one during the break when wicked was stopping showing from the sag strike or was that at one wicked okay so during the sag strike you guys

were able to yeah we did the full yeah the full reading was uh september of 23 that wasn't i don't remember if that was because of strike stuff but i don't think this i don't know that the strike allowed us to do it but regardless it was summer of 23 september of 23 was when we did the first full yeah i think i think the sag strike went from

SPEAKER_02july till mid-september maybe this is why i'm gay i remember that the sack strike started the week before barbie came out in theaters because the actors for oppenheimer and barbie were like on the red carpet they announced the sack strike and then they left the red carpet yep this is me showing my gayness but but that doesn't mean that the sack strike ended in december mitch that's just i know when wicked started refilming again um so it's entirely ethan can corroborate all of this when you chat with him yeah

SPEAKER_02But this is to say that Wicked finishes filming. You do the 29 hour workshop in Williamstown. OK. Did Classic Stage see that workshop or was that purely just from meetings and readings? They saw the video of the workshop. OK. They didn't come up to see it. No, they saw the video of it, though. Okay. That's another key point, everybody. Film your stuff. Film it, film it, film it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And it doesn't need to be, you know, like a $5,000 setup. It can be, you know, $300, you know, $250. And it can be a single angle, you know, one angle, no cutaways. People just want to go on the emotional ride of it. And sometimes when you add too much, it just takes away and becomes distracting. Yeah. We see, you know, people spend a lot of money on this thing that like spend money in other places, spend the money on marketing.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, you know, also sometimes if the material itself isn't good, it doesn't matter how many camera angles you have. You still have a dud on your hands. Sure. You know, that is definitely part of it. Sure. Everywhere you go. There you are. OK, so classic stage sees the video. They when did you guys get the green light that you were going to be part of this season? last December so December 24 I believe we had an inkling that like this seems to be going in a positive direction and then we had a coffee with

Jill Raffs and the artistic director and it was after that coffee that Mitch and I looked at each other and we were like I think we just got the winter slot at classic stage like

SPEAKER_01there was no like it's yours guys congratulations it was truly like I think this is happening. And then it was because nonprofits have their seasons to run, you know, and small staffs that we didn't hear from them again for a little bit because they were running their season. They're not concerned about the following, you know, the next season. And so for about four or five months there, I was like,

I think we're doing it, but also... And I was like, don't worry about it.

SPEAKER_02We're doing it. Yeah, I was like, Max, it's happening. We started budgeting it. We started talking about it. Like, it's happening. Don't worry about it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But, you know, that was up until, you know, last May, April even.

SPEAKER_02So, well, that was when we started like really formalizing the chats with Classic Stage about, OK, cool, because they were starting to now turn to looking at this 25, 26 season. So now it's talking about, OK, what are our dates? Okay, what, you know, when does it make sense to start performances? How long can the run be? What is Ethan's schedule going to be? When could we start rehearsals versus then start previews? You know, starting those loose conversations and starting to budget it out. Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_02All so that, you know, we could then get to the full enhancement agreement between us as the commercial team and then as the producing nonprofit theater. And all throughout in the middle of that, the official announcement came in June about the production. So like all of those conversations were still ongoing while, you know, production gets announced in the middle there. Okay, so this is a co-production. Can you speak a little bit more for the listeners about what that means? No, it's not a co-production. So I'm actually going to correct you there.

SPEAKER_02It's an enhanced production. An enhanced production. Okay, so words matter, labels matter, pronouns matter. Tell me exactly what this means. So in this instance, we as the commercial team, Mix and Match Productions, we optioned, we acquired the option for Marcel on the train from the writers, Marshall and Ethan. We have the option to produce a developmental production. This is qualifying as a developmental production because the commercial show, the commercial team here, we're not getting like ticket sales. off of this so we have the ability to do workshops you have the

ability to work with a non-profit etc now we found a non-profit that wants to work with us so we are essentially licensing our license we're sub-licensing to Classic Stage the ability to produce the show and it is Classic Stage's production of the show now

SPEAKER_02Classic Stage they say in order to do it you know this is what We can put into it as an organization. But, you know, as we've talked about the budget, this is what the budget looks like. And for those of you listening on podcast, my hand has gone significantly higher from that which Classic Stage is able to put in. So, you know, how are we going to bridge that gap? Hey, commercial producers, you're going to agree to enhance the production by that number so that it can be the full production that you want. um and in this instance classic stage they keep all the uh box office they keep the ticket sales it is their production of it we get a world

premiere of the show we get to we get to keep the sets and costumes and such after the fact and in terms of the cost of it yes we're raised we raised a lot of money for this uh to put it in to make the show happen but it's significantly cheaper than if we said okay we're

SPEAKER_02just doing a commercial off-broadway run with no non-profit help doing it on our own out there. That would have been about three times the extent of what doing it through the auspices of a nonprofit is right now. And is that what you tell investors when you're looking for the enhancement money of sort of what the purpose of this investment is? This is not necessarily about you're going to get your money back on this production, but this is what it's... You got it. Yeah, you got it very upfront. That's part of what makes it difficult to raise money at this stage, too. You've got to really believe in the project and in the product itself.

SPEAKER_02You've got to really be like a ride or die on a thing to say, cool, I'm going to write a check to you guys. And more likely than not, nothing will ever happen with this and it will die. Most shows die, you know. Maybe we'll be one of the lucky ones that the energy is right and the timing is right and the project itself is right for the zeitgeist and where it is and it will continue on. But, you know, I can't promise anything.

SPEAKER_01But as producers, we knew that a show, as I said, about a mime in the Holocaust riding a train was going to be a tough sell. What was the way that, you know, in the first eight weeks of introducing the show to the world, we could get audiences in? work with a theater that has a subscriber base or, you know, that has a built in audience that, you know, they're accustomed to buying the tickets already. We're not going to have to do that much education, which allows us to get folks in. Here's some word of mouth here like, oh, is it resonating?

SPEAKER_01Is it not? And then we're able to go away afterwards and say, do we need to do more work or can this move forward? Because the point of doing an enhanced production is that you eventually move it forward to a commercial venture so that those investors do get their money back. And, you know, this thing can be seen by more people and for a a little bit of that startup, a little bit of people going, you know, kind of like the play Job, which was off-Broadway, first at Soho Playhouse,

SPEAKER_01then the Connelly. Like, it needed Soho Playhouse for people to go, what is this thing? I've never heard of this. This new director, new writer, what's going on here? And then it could find its way to Broadway. And that's kind of what we needed. But with, you know, a show that's Six people has a star with understudies. That is a little bit of a higher cost than a two-person play, you know, in chairs. So we needed to partner with the nonprofit so that we could minimize our costs so that when we eventually do flip it to a commercial production

at some point down

SPEAKER_01the line, which is the intention, our development costs are that much smaller, making the commercial raise that much easier. Yeah. At the beginning of this,

SPEAKER_02when you erroneously and fallaciously said that we were, this was a co-production. Co-producers. Co-producers. I think that's actually interesting because like people go to a Broadway show, you know, and they look above the title. And on a Broadway show today, you'll see 5011 names up there. And, you know, if you look at the first like three names, those are, you know, on average, let's say those are the producers of the show. Those are the ones who are making all the decisions,

SPEAKER_02who sign the contract, sign the checks, approve the budgets, approve the marketing, do everything. Everybody else is a co-producer. They have been amazing. given, you know, certain privileges because they were induced to raise a lot of money, whether it's, you know, $150,000, $500,000, a million dollars sometimes even. And you get some back end, you know, kickbacks if the show, you know, god willing the creek don't rise makes profit someday and that is like the co-producing game so max and i were co-producers on maybe happy

ending we raised money for that one we didn't have any say in it we just really flippin believed in

SPEAKER_02it um and we're lucky that on marcel we've got a really lovely cohort of co-producers who were willing not just to like you know invest in the project but invest uh invest large sums of money and belief In the project itself, some based just off of, you know, reading the press release of it and hearing about the themes of the show and then reaching out and saying, oh, my God, what is this thing? I have to learn more. And then, you know, reading the script and watching a video of the Williamstown

production and saying,

SPEAKER_02great, I'm in. I believe in you guys and I believe in the project. Like that's it's a it's just a tiny miracle every time that happens. You know, if you look at kind of the trajectory of like work being done on the project, you know, oh, since 2022 when we got it, it's like, OK, cool, great. You know, a new script came in. Cool. Let's read that. Cool. OK, 29 hour. OK, there's a good amount of work there. OK, cool. Make that happen. Make that happen. Then you get to like May and it's just it's just like a hockey stick going all the way up.

SPEAKER_01And what I will say, the writers can attest to this as well. In the grand scheme of theater and timelines, this is incredibly fast. Most projects do not move at this speed. They probably take another three to four years or another two years.

SPEAKER_02Well, Matt, how long have you been writing your play? Why am I on trial right now?

SPEAKER_01Well,

SPEAKER_02just as context, I think it's, you know, for the listeners at home, I think it's good context because they know that your people know that you have a play. Well, so I started writing my play in December of 2022. The first draft was presented at a table read in January of 23. And then we did the stage reading last November. So yeah, I would say at this point, we're now at the three-year mark of when I put a script in front of people and said, read, bitch. But yes, that is where we're at right now.

SPEAKER_02The three-year mark. So, and we are, you know, Marshall and Ethan started writing this show in 2021. And then, you know, we read it in 2022. So from 2021, them, you know, having the idea and starting to put pen to paper to... You know, first world premiere in 2026, five years. And you can see, you know, there were multiple readings that we did through there. There's continued rewrites in there. There was a whole movie, multiple movies that were premiered that Ethan was in throughout this and TV shows

SPEAKER_02and like everybody's working. You know, Marshall has been doing he won awards down in D.C. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01His career has just fucking exploded. Exploded. Marshall's career, like, the scheduling puzzle of Marshall's career. Like, I'm so happy for him, and yet, like, oh, my guy. Have you noticed any shifts in the producing world post-COVID in the last, like, five years?

SPEAKER_02Have you seen... uh productions going in certain directions have you seen certain obstacles appearing more and more as you've been uh oh i've got one if i can yeah uh it's just i think it's i think it's really easy to say i want to have my show at a non-profit theater and do an enhance you know and do a run there because you know

SPEAKER_01it's cheaper oh it has the built-in audience The tricky thing, as we said before, is then you have no chance of making your money back. And we've seen a lot of shows, you know, go this nonprofit route. And then afterwards they go, what now? I don't know what comes next. I never planned for, you know, the next production.

SPEAKER_02If someone wanted to do an enhanced production as you were, as you guys sort of are approaching this one, how are you approaching it in terms of like the future of this play?

SPEAKER_01We believe that this is a Broadway play. Like, full stop. In our hearts, we believe that this is a play that deserves to be seen on Broadway. And so once that's your North Star, you start making decisions towards that North Star.

SPEAKER_02And not every show belongs on Broadway. That should not be the definition of success for everything. You know, when we're... talking to people for the first time about their projects and they're interested in hiring us as either general manager or executive producer or writers that are interested in maybe seeing if we want to option their show and produce their show. Those are some of the first questions we ask, like, OK, do you see this as, you know, a big Broadway musical a la The Book of Mormon? Or do you see this as a commercial hit that,

SPEAKER_02you know, is a sleeper hit that has a small production that builds a rabid fan base? Do you see

SPEAKER_01Little Shop of Horrors,

SPEAKER_02you know,

SPEAKER_01like off Broadway,

SPEAKER_02you know, these and we kind of get those things. Do you see this as a show that starts at a nonprofit in town here in town at like Playwrights and then goes into licensing and has a fruitful life there?

SPEAKER_01Here there are blueberries. Are you taking, you know, going nonprofit to start and then doing some commercial venture, but through a tour and around the country? You know, there's so many different paths. If you're not thinking of next steps and you're like, I want to do this as an off-Broadway show, my suggestion is to like go do the commercial off-Broadway production if you think off-Broadway is the end goal, which is an amazing place for a production to live. But you don't need to cannibalize your off-Broadway audience with a cheaper

SPEAKER_01off-Broadway production.

SPEAKER_02You know, so for like Marcel, it made sense to say, cool, we know that this we and our souls feel like this is a show that belongs on Broadway. How do we get there? Well, OK, having a pedigreed run at a important nonprofit here in town is going to help get a stamp of approval to it is going to be cheaper and is going to elevate the project and get us that audience and get all of these things that we know will also want to be the target audience for Broadway as well. I don't know if this is going to sound tricky or not. I mean this as a compliment, but it's almost like an enhanced proof of concept for people.

SPEAKER_02Because until now, you haven't really been able to do the show at a level to show what you think it can be. And so this is the most enhanced proof of concept to date.

SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah. We start rehearsals tomorrow and on February 5th will be the first time that Mitch and I are seeing a full production of the show with all the lights, all the set, all the actors, all the hope. God willing, February 5th will be the first time, along with the rest of New York or whoever's in that audience, that we are seeing that production, that show.

SPEAKER_02I mean. So Max, in a lot of ways, that's a great way for us to sign off, but I have like two more bullet points I want us to get through before we do that. So let's, I will make sure you repeat that in about five to 10 minutes. You'll have to remind me of exactly what I said, but please. Don't tell me how to do my job, okay? So Max, for both of you, you mentioned finances. I want to sort of ask you guys sort of, For listeners who are interested in this kind of stuff, and I also feel like for a lot of theater fans who have no idea how this works, financing for a show, but more importantly, the budgeting of a show.

SPEAKER_02So what goes into making that happen? What goes into making costs rise? And where does the money go for a budget on a show like Marcel? So for this one, it's less because there's two parts that like you asked what goes into making costs rise on this production. There was not so much that went into making the cost rise. This is people will come see. This is a I don't want to say minimalist. It is a bare bones doesn't feel right either because this is, you know, it's a gestural production. I think the design concept that Marshall has with this is very

intentional and it is. supposed to feel intimate and just by nature of, you know, the cost of lumber.

SPEAKER_02Everybody on this team is, you know, working pretty much at scale. It's not like Max and I are getting paid to do anything for this show either, you know? So we are all rolling up our sleeves and we're really lucky for that. And so the budget that we have here is... as low as humanly possible for, you know, six-person play off-Broadway at a nonprofit.

SPEAKER_01Tariffs are real. You know, all of those political issues do end up affecting us in a way that I had not quite experienced in a professional financial setting before. You know, it drove up our set costs by about half. Yeah. Really, it's significant. Like these are not things that we can just be like, oh, that crazy guy doing what he's like. It's a real like there's a real effect on people that are

trying to just put a

SPEAKER_01piece of art on a stage.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. But then when looking at sort of a just like a breakdown budget of what to spend money on, what would you say are the things that are crucial and yet possibly the most costly? Well, people are always the most. Well, but marketing, yes, but people. It's about the cast. It's about the designers. Like that is like the first priority, I think. You know, even before we get to marketing, it's like, OK, what are we paying the cast? What are we paying the designers? Will this is this? Can we do that?

SPEAKER_02What are the union rates? All of that. And usually that is that is a massive chunk of it. And then, yes, it's marketing. It is how you can have the best show in the world. But if no one knows that it's happening, what the hell's the point? And so with Classic Stage, I guess without giving away too much of the secret sauce, like you had a meeting with them about the parameters of how they go about putting up a production, how they go about marketing a show and had that conversation. It's as simple as like opening a Zoom screen sharing a Google

sheet and going down

SPEAKER_01line by line and saying, is this right? Is this too much? Is this too little? What do we need? And then we see the delta at the very end of it and we go, that's the enhancement.

SPEAKER_02We had many, many budget revision meetings of just going truly line by line and saying, OK, cool. And then, yeah. at the end of the day, that's what it is. This is what they can put in. Then we have to raise the rest. And what's interesting is that like, if we can't raise the money, then the show is not, then the show changes. Like there's a certain point where classic stage will do what they can do. And then it's entirely on our shoulders to raise the remainder of that, which in this instance, I think it's like... four times what classic stage is able to put in if not a little bit more and like that's fine that's the deal that we made it just is like if we

can't raise it if we can't find it then okay guys we got to figure out okay what's being cut how do what do we figure out now the bold lines within which we were working the sandbox we

SPEAKER_02were playing and just got smaller okay we got to figure it out yeah So, first of all, this episode won't be coming out the day before rehearsals begin, but we are recording this the day before rehearsals begin. So, first of all, how are we feeling?

SPEAKER_01So scared. I'm so scared. I'm so excited, but I genuinely feel... So scared because I love this show so much. Like it's just fear of not giving the show everything that it's worthy of.

SPEAKER_02You literally sound like every person the day before they get married. Well, we are. I mean, that's what it is. Like it's official now. Like we're there. I think tomorrow morning I will have a good cry at some point because it's just going to like hit me in the same way that when the show got announced back in June and the announcement went live, I was in the office early. shock of all shocks i think it was like you know 8 30 in the fucking morning something like that and we have some people that come and hang out at our office when they're doing you know remote jobs one of them jennifer

she was sitting on the couch and when the news when it like hit everywhere i just i lost it for a few seconds i just had a whole moment and jen just like she just like sat there with me

SPEAKER_02at God bless her. And I was like, okay, cool. We got it out of the system. Okay, this thing is real. Let's go. And got back to work. And I think that's what it's going to feel like tomorrow. It's going to be like, Max is better at this than me of like pausing me and putting his hand on my shoulder sometimes and being like, hi, let's take two seconds and just look around and say, this is really fucking cool. And then we put our heads back down and we'll do that a few times tomorrow, I'm sure.

SPEAKER_01The perks of meditation could not encourage meditation more. Meditation is amazing.

SPEAKER_02So then after tomorrow, you have until first performance in February. And then after first performance is obviously opening night. What are your mental trajectories as producers for those two stages? I think that's the thing that I'm most anxious or scared about is that I don't know

SPEAKER_01what our days or nights will look like. You know, we haven't started the rehearsal process yet, so I don't know. Oh, is this going to be a team that, you know, needs to hang around after six o'clock, you know, and really talk through the day? Is this a team that's just going home?

SPEAKER_02It's also not our production. It's classic stages production. So, you know, we are lucky that we don't, you know, we're not running payroll. We're not. doing company management we're not doing any of that so how can we be helpful but not in the way I think that like in the short term from now until when we start that preview so that's rehearsals plus tech our energy is just towards get the damn thing up like what needs to happen and what can we do to help Is there something that needs to happen? Is there somebody needs to press go on a soundbar for the next

day and a half?

SPEAKER_02Cool. We'll figure it out. You know, how can we help make that work? And then once it starts previews, it's okay. How can we make sure that the audience experience is what the whole team has intended? What we as the producers and what the creative team has intended? And are we, you know, delivering on the promises and on the, you know, contract that you set forth with an audience when they walk into that space? And then opening night happens and we're able to take a step back and take in the bigger picture and start to calibrate a strategy after that.

yeah yeah yeah because you know uh it's the world premiere no one has seen it before if the reviews are crap then we've got a lot of figuring out to do we got a lot of thinking to do if the industry isn't digging it then okay what do we do next if the industry is loving it okay what do we do next both possibilities are very real and then somewhere in the middle of you know maybe we show up and don't make

SPEAKER_02any splash at all uh All of the above is a possibility. And then it's like, OK, we have investors. OK, we have the creatives. What can we as the kind of team leaders then do to honor everybody's effort and move it to insert next step here? Like, what do you do?

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Well, we're going to find out in about four episodes, because that's where our listeners are going to come back to you guys at the end of this series. We're going to figure it out. It's really crazy to be recording this so early, knowing that by the time it comes out, we will be close to recording the end of the series as well. Time is funny that way. But any other things you want the listeners to know about either one of you or about this process before we wrap things up?

SPEAKER_01The only thing I'll say, like, I say this all the time, and, like, this is just my philosophy as a producer, and I just want to put it out there into the world. If the show that you're producing is an amazing email, don't produce it. If the show that you're producing is a terrible email, if it's a terrible pitch, it's probably worth seeing on a stage. The things that are the best emails, you'll pay 10 cents to see them, but they typically don't make for the most satisfying evening of theater. Then if you go for the shows that are the toughest pitches,

SPEAKER_01you know, the maybe happy endings of the world, the thing that you go, I don't know how to describe it. You just have to go see it. Those are the things that are typically worth seeing the most.

SPEAKER_02So I think that like what we talk about is like we'll get an email in. from producers or creatives on a project and it has you know it's this uh intellectual property being adapted by this person from a movie and then who wrote this movie and this person who's from this pop band and then starring these people who are film actors and wow that's really that's really cool uh and that sounds great in an email uh A lot of the times, though, that doesn't necessarily make for the most compelling art.

SPEAKER_02And then and then after that, the most like a commercially satisfying project, a project that actually does anything versus these projects that you get the email and you're like, what the fuck is this? Like the email, the pitch for maybe happy ending to robots who are being decommissioned and breaking down somehow fall in love in the future. the fuck like that you know and it's jazz and somewhere in our fireflies don't worry exactly yeah and don't worry about it yeah and then there's this like figment of one of them's imagination that's a jazz singer that runs around what the fuck like you know that is a terrible email and then you know we say

you have to experience it and then it changes your life you're making me feel a lot better about myself because i've been having so much trouble max and mitch pitching my own

SPEAKER_02play to people they say what is it i'm like well it's torch song trilogy meets the scream franchise but it's a romance and they go i don't know what that means i'm like honestly me neither you want to just come see it and yeah that's the only way yeah yeah that's what it's about it's about experiencing it you know and that's a we'll start getting ready for tomorrow tomorrow so i've taken up enough of both of your gentlemen's time so I want to thank you both for starting off this wonderful series

on your I expect to

SPEAKER_02be wonderful show. I will see it soon enough. I look forward to it. And yeah. So, guys, make sure to check out Marcel on the Train at Classic Stage Company. We're going to have more inside looks in future episodes. I don't want to give too much away right now. Just know that you should be coming back to this podcast to be getting some more insight soon enough. Thank you, guys. You know what? Normally I ask the guests to close this out with a nice little Broadway diva, but this is a special classy episode. So I'm going to have, and we're talking about France.

SPEAKER_02So I'm going to have us close out with Edith Piaf. I'm just making the call right here, right now. Love it. Love it. Take it away, Edith. Bye. All right, that's going to do it for this episode of Backstage Pass. We will see those two again when we wrap things up at the end of this series. I want to thank Max and Mitch for their insight. I want to thank all of you for your time today. And I want to thank Paula for getting me this Backstage Pass today. She's a good friend. Tune in next episode because I got a backstage pass from my friend Fred.

SPEAKER_02You don't know him. He's very shy. But Fred's pass got us a talk with the producing artistic director of Classic Stage Company, Miss Jill Rafson. So stay tuned for all of that goodness soon. Thanks, guys.

SPEAKER_00With my souvenirs.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode