Matt dives into The Lost Boys, the musical adaptation of the cult-favorite film. Matt unpacks its dark, teen-vampire energy and how (or if) it succeeds on stage. He explores the show’s tonal balancing act - camp vs. sincerity, nostalgia vs. reinvention - and whether the material sustains itself as a full-fledged musical. Along the way, Matt highlights standout performances and considers where the show fits into the current Tony Awards conversation. Important Links * Broadway Breakdown Live!: Green Room 42 Tix * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Timestamps * 0:00 - Intro + episode setup * 6:00 - Plot setup (no spoilers): world, characters, and central conflict * 19:00 - Performances: standout cast members and character dynamics * 28:00 - Book issues: structure, pacing, and emotional stakes * 35:30 - Design elements: sets, costumes, and atmosphere * 41:30 - Tony Awards chances: nominations vs. long-term impact Listener discussion questions * What makes a cult film like The Lost Boys ripe (or not) for musical adaptation? * How important is tonal consistency when blending camp, horror, and sincerity onstage? * In a crowded Broadway season, do nostalgic adaptations have an advantage - or are audiences craving something more original? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Thank you very much. That's all. But we have a great dramatic finish. Oh, I'm sure you do, but Mr. Granson... Ah!
SPEAKER_01Hit it! Broadway, Broadway, we've missed it so. We're leaving soon and taking June to star her in a show. Well hello all you theater lovers both out and proud and on the deal and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American
SPEAKER_00theater's most exclusive address Broadway. I am your host Matt Koplik the least famous So first up, if we will cue the Light in the Piazza overture...
5 stars great podcast from Broadway lover 17 started listening during the cabaret series and since then I've been hooked what a great podcast thank you for sharing your knowledge and passion with us thank you next up essential listening for any theater lover by Alex podcast duchess 413 5 stars Matt is part dramaturg slash historian part critic part fan part educator and yet somehow this show isn't
SPEAKER_00intimidating or stuffy remember that Rather, it feels like having the most intellectually stimulating chat with your funniest and most brilliant friend. Who's this friend? In a world when apathy for the arts seems to abound, it's life-affirming to hear Matt's passion and incredible depth of knowledge. Never stop this pod! Thank you very much! First of all, don't you tell me what to do. I mean... Unless you're paying my bills, in which case I will pay you some mind. But thank you. That's very kind of of you. I really appreciate it. Y'all are really doing a lovely job with these reviews and
giving me some words
SPEAKER_00that I myself have never used in my day to day. So, um, show me up with your knowledge and your wisdom and your intelligence. Um, okay. Let's get into it. I know it's the reason why we're all here. The Lost Boys.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Look at her. The Lost Boys is based off of the 1987 film that was directed by Joel Schumacher. It has had a long cult following and I had always known it to be a major film in the queer cinema canon. I had never actually saw the movie. It always just kind of looked rather silly to me and I just it was one of those things where because people were so vocal about it not like a huge majority but like enough people were vocal about it
and it's that thing where like when people get annoying about something you admire their passion but it also it starts to bug you it's why certain fandoms in Broadway shows have turned off people from seeing said shows because they're just so intense about it and we love the passion but sometimes it can be a double-edged sword but this is to say I only knew the basic premise of the movie I knew the cast and I
SPEAKER_00knew that there was allegedly a lot of homoeroticism and the hope was that that was going to get carried over into the musicale and I didn't really know the premise beyond you know family goes to a new town and there are teenage vampires that was all I really knew so I went into this with a pretty open slate I saw it about a week before they froze it and I wanted to wait to review it until I could see it again in its frozen state and review that so I this is pretty fresh I will say I
will give my hot opinion in one second I but I will also say when thinking about the two performances about 10 days apart maybe even a week apart I can't rightfully
SPEAKER_00say or no two weeks apart there were two weeks apart I can't rightfully say that I could spot major changes between my two performances. It was somehow about five minutes shorter, but that's really it. So there was no huge structural changes. No new songs were added between my performance and this performance. I had already seen it when Shoshana Bean's new Act One song was put in. It's possible that like some finessing was done in Act Two with pacing and the finale and whatnot. Act One seems pretty untouched.
it was also about the same length as two weeks prior so it I think I could have gotten away with seeing it unfrozen but I'm glad that I did so I could have my journalistic ethics in place for this up front I will say I actually quite enjoyed a lot of The Lost Boys I did not fully love it it's not a 10 out of 10 for me it's
SPEAKER_00not Really an 8 out of 10. I would probably give it a 7 out of 10. A lot of that has to do with the second act, and I will get to that in a minute. But that's just for the people who want to avoid spoilers and want to kind of just get my upfront opinion on this. Now we'll get into the nitty gritty so the show covers the life of one michael emerson who's 16 17 years old teenage boy played by LJ bennett
he moves from phoenix arizona with his mother lucy and his younger brother sam played by shoshana
SPEAKER_00bean and benjamin pajak pajak pajak respectively they are moving to Santa Carla California to move into his mother Lucy sorry his grandfather his recently deceased grandfather's home that has been inherited by Lucy and they're also moving because their father has left them their father it's implied in the beginning of the show was rather abusive and As the show continues and we learn little nuggets about their home life we learn just how abusive their father was he was an alcoholic
physically violent verbally
SPEAKER_00abusive and they so they are he abandoned them but also when Lucy and her childhood home from her father this was deemed a fresh start and so they moved back to Lucy's hometown now of course in between Lucy last living there and then moving away raising a family coming back Santa Carla has become what is known as the murder capital of the world by Alan and Edgar Frog the Frog brothers who are self-identified cartoon enthusiasts comic book enthusiasts and vampire hunters
SPEAKER_00There are a lot of missing signs all over the boardwalk, and while no one in the main cast, Michael, Lucy, or Sam, can really figure out what's going on, the Frog Brothers informed Sam it is absolutely due to vampires. And wouldn't you know it, Michael falls in with said vampire gang. The leader is David, as played by Ali Louis Borski. I never know how to say his name. And if you listen to our upcoming Tony's episode, Juan Ramirez says his name perfectly like seven times, and it just some reason hasn't sunk in yet. I will learn it by the time we get to the Tony Awards, I promise, because I am an ally for talented people.
who will most likely be nominated for Tony Awards Michael gets involved with this gang through a young woman that he has fallen for her name is Star Star sings in David and his friend's band Michael falls in with Star he falls for her Star gets
SPEAKER_00him involved with David's gang and it's revealed that The gang is a group of vampires they have slowly turning star and michael into vampires by the end of act one they're both half vampires and they both decide in act two that they are going to turn their backs on the vampire gang and The head vampire is a man named
Max who owns the local video store who hires Lucy at the beginning of act one beginning to middle of act one and starts to get involved with her a little bit and he reveals himself at the end of the show to be the head vampire he is killed and Lucy Michael and Sam start to heal and bond and move on as a family and they can
SPEAKER_00get through the night end of show Vampire musicals notoriously have done very, very terribly on stage. The only vampire show I can recall that has done well on Broadway is Dracula with Frank Langella. Musicals like Dance of the Vampires and De La Stat and Dracula have never done well. And part of the reason for that is vampire stories... in their essence are a very earnest and horny genre of storytelling horniness is something that musicals have not really been able to harness on
Broadway I've
SPEAKER_00argued I think the last truly horny musical is the Party but that's a very toxic kind of horniness there's a difference between sexiness and horniness you know like Moulin Rouge is kitschy little sexiness it's not really horny Lost Boys is hormonal and violent but it's not really horny West Side Story you could argue is horny but you need a production to bring that out of it Lost Boys is not really a horny musical and as somebody who was promised yearning homoerotic vampires I will say up
front I did not get that from this homoeroticism I'm sorry she's nowhere to be
SPEAKER_00found in this musical what we get is the younger brother Sam who I've been told in the movie played by Corey Haim is definitely queer coded he's not expressed as gay in the movie but it's sort of like there are traits that you could apply to queerdom and in the musical they make That he has an eye for shoe wear and he has an obsession with Rob Lowe and it's treated rather innocently at first but then he starts to kind of think that maybe
his quote unquote queerness that his mother refers to in the carousel kind of way
SPEAKER_00you're a queer one Julie Jordan no you like you're odd Sam takes on that word and it's more homosexual meaning in act two and this and comes into his own as a as a pansy so to speak and has this big I could be a superhero and I could be a queer superhero and I'll talk about that in a second but yeah like it's not really I would not call it queerness I would call it a blip it is not explored it is not really a storyline it's a moment
there's a bit of a non-binary undertone to the character of uh I think it's Alan of Alan Frog yeah played by Jennifer Duca in the movie the Frog brothers are cisgender male brothers and in the musical they turned it into um a male presenting and female presenting
SPEAKER_00character unclear how they'd It's a running joke that Alan Frog's full name is Alana goes by Alan or something like that and when they refer to themselves as the Frog Brothers and people question that they always go did I stutter and it's fine it's not the funniest bit nor is it like the most empowering bit it's a sort of there you know it's that kind of lip service that it's harmless but it's
not exactly the moment that sometimes people think it is at least in Broadway theater that's really
SPEAKER_00kind of all the queerness David is played by Ali. He is absolutely a heteronormative alpha male of his group but he's got that sort of glam punk rock Bowie-esque aesthetic which in a lot of ways you could argue has a queer
sensibility Bowie
SPEAKER_00absolutely had that about himself but that's also just kind of how it is in the 80s you know there's there's a certain effeminate quality to a lot of the pretty boys of the 80s the Rob Lowe's of and the heartthrobs like that of the 80s you look at you know the super super short shorts that men would wear in the summer films in that decade and it's sort of yeah there's there was a lot of fashion and a lot of That we would now equate with queerness or femininity that
straight-thinking men
SPEAKER_00just had and had no problem with. And so I don't view David as any kind of stand-in for queertum, nor do I really view the vampires as such. a friend of mine was talking about sort of this sense of belonging that the character of Michael has you know that's it's a very early want of his you know he wants to belong somewhere he feels restless he feels abandoned he's being forced to grow up faster than he would like now that they have left their father he's becoming the man of the house and he doesn't and he sort of resents that he doesn't want to be responsible he wants to enjoy himself he's he thinks
you know that's his
SPEAKER_00right as a kid and I get that and I think that sense of wanting to belong is something that is not necessarily specifically queer I mean it's definitely a trait that we apply to queer coded journeys a character who doesn't fit in in their surroundings who then wants to belong to a different surrounding but also I think wanting to belong is something that everyone can join in on it's less that I find it less of a queer journey because I find queer journeys like say Ariel and the Little Mermaid
wanting to belong somewhere else is a very specific situation of her environment does not understand or accept her and she wants to go where she thinks she will be accepted Michael's situation is a little different because he is understood and accepted in his
SPEAKER_00current status current environment his mom loves David's gang sees himself in them he sees star and he wants and he gravitates towards star it's
a which is a very heteronormative no homo element to that storyline he incidentally finds himself belonging with David's gang for all of 10 minutes towards the end of act one but it's not really uh I do not I personally do not subscribe to the
SPEAKER_00narrative that the Michael David storyline has homo undertones to it maybe it's because I was promised something a lot that I and I that was a lot more queer that I did not get so that was a little disappointing to me I'll go back now to the things that I do really like about this because I just went on a lot about the queer stuff but I will say what I really do like about this musical is kind of how much of a lot that it is we made jokes with Sam Ekman a while back about best most and ultimately
I would say the Lost Boys would win that category of best most it's when I first saw it my first thought during intermission was like this is a lot of musicals
SPEAKER_00And I meant that both positively and a little shadily. And I still believe that. I do think in the two weeks between when I first saw it and when it froze, I do believe that they shaved off a couple of minutes and helped tighten it a bit, which helps because Act One definitely was dragging the first time. and it feels a little bit less act one feels a little less everything but the kitchen sink so much is just like constant movement constant colors constant earnestness there are there's definitely a 1980s mega musical
vibe about the lost boys in the sense that everyone feels very deeply and very passionately which is what you want for a vampire musical the stakes are high it's life after death it's
SPEAKER_00for eternity It's killing in order to live. No, there's a lot of stakes to that, including stakes. And so you do kind of need epic scale to all of that. And I do think that the music reflects a lot of that. It is Yeah.
I mean the opening number I think while I wouldn't call it necessarily a banger it does have a lot of energy to it it takes us from Phoenix all the way to Santa Carla there's the No More Monsters it's it's it's I think it establishes our main characters perhaps the lyrics are a little on the nose and simplistic but that's also kind of a trait of the mega musical of it all the show itself is a bit of a soap opera and I would argue that the simplistic lyrics on a second listen are allow the soap opera elements of the story to unfold and not
feel totally cheesy right you want to maintain a tone for your narrative that the audience can follow and stay on board with because if you have jarring tones then it confuses your audience of what they're supposed to think of certain moments this is something we
SPEAKER_00talked about a bit with like Queen of Versailles right The F. Marie Abraham song of the Timeshare King is a campy number. It's meant to be comedic. They don't do it earnestly. But the show always had a mishandling of what kind of comedy it was going for. If it was going for social satire, if it was going for full-blown musical theater camp. And so when something like that number happens... Audiences looked at it like it was springtime for Hitler and I'm watching going no I know that they're trying to be funny here it's just that we
did not establish that this is where we were willing to go for the first 30 minutes of this show so by doing this number it feels a bit like a betrayal and Lost Boys for it to its credit has none of that betrayal for the first act I would argue when act two
SPEAKER_00begins that's the first betrayal at the end of act one is when Michael gets to his halfway point of turning into a vampire and he breaks through the window of Sam's bedroom and that's when Sam kind of realizes that something is up with Michael and act two begins and Sam realizes I think my brother is a vampire and The show goes into extraordinarily cheeky territory, which we had never done before. In Act 1, it was mostly earnest with a little bit of tongue-in-cheek
humor sprinkled throughout. and I found it quite effective having humor sprinkled throughout act one allowed the audience chances to breathe chances to relax it kept you from sort of rolling your eyes of a show taking itself far too seriously and then act two just goes into this weird silly land that is both not quite funny enough and also is just so inconsistent from everything we had it's like eating a cupcake after you've had a
SPEAKER_00steak and or like or even like halfway through your steak eating a cupcake and it's like why I had all of this succulent flavor and now I'm tasting pure sugar like what what is this and the show doesn't stick with that tone for the rest of act two but it pops up again about two more times and again it's for me it's just like such a tonal whiplash that it's kind of surprising to me that they wouldn't address it or they thought that this was an okay
way to go I mean the super power song that Sam sings in act two is such an easy cut that I can't believe they never did it my brother is a I would maybe tweak and get rid of you know the
SPEAKER_00sliding vampires and the Elvira's coming out of the shower it's just so It's just a little too like Titanic disaster the musical you know we never went in that direction before and now we're doing that and it's a little baffling and some people are going to take it like some people took the timeshare king I understand it's meant to be funny it's it's just such a throw thrown moment both of them The other issue that Act 2 has is a finale that I just simply don't buy.
One is the final showdown with Michael and Sam and the Frog Brothers and Star and
SPEAKER_00then Max revealing himself to be the head vampire. Sam, Michael, and the Frog Brothers all you know they kill the final vampires before Max shows up pretty quickly it's a it's pretty underwhelming in terms of fight choreo in terms of just how quickly everybody gets defeated it's sort of a whole setup of we have to defeat them it all gets done sort of one two three they do allow Paul Alexander Nolan another moment to really kind of revel in his charisma and power of his voice and allow him to relish in
being going from being sweet and dorky to fully evil for about a minute but it still feels for me a little bit underbaked for a show that took its sweet time getting Michael to the point of slowly turning into a vampire the defeat of everybody happens incredibly quickly and then after that there's a finale it's called If We Make It Through The Night
SPEAKER_00and it's this kind of finale that It's Les Mis kind of started this finale and it kept going with shows like Ragtime and with shows like The Color Purple where the entire cast comes on stage sings a nine part harmony faces out and sings about how they found love light and God one of the three or all three and and the hope of tomorrow you know and usually characters come back from the dead like in Ragtime or in Les Mis to join the company for the full tableau Lost Boys
does the exact same thing including bringing the vampires back and the song itself
SPEAKER_00is good I like the song it's pretty I like the metaphor of make it through the night you know make it to the day whatever that's all fine next normal also kind of does this now that I'm realizing it but I will say I did not find emotionally it to be quite earned maybe that part of that is because there's all this all these logistics about who's the head vampire and how we're going to kill everybody and then killing max as quickly as we do it doesn't feel like like we've totally reached this conclusion another part of this
is because with act one of an issue I have is by spending so much time focusing on Michael's story the show has trouble for the first half weaving back in Sam and Lucy as characters and their narratives and how they tie into Michael it's long stretches in act one until we get back to them and act two by being shorter in nature just allows their
SPEAKER_00character arcs to kind of get a lot more is more rushed through and how they interweave with each other is more rushed through. And I just don't feel like the table setting was fully done in Act One. There are points where it happens. You see the moments where the book writers and Michael Arden try to remind us of where everyone's at in their lives and how they're connected to each other and what's wrong with everything. But again, it's just sort of a little bit of We spend extremely long times with Michael Michael with Star Michael with David and
then oh yeah by the way Lucy's here and here's her song oh and act two okay here's Sam again and so the coming of them together as a family at the end of the show is not fully locked in for me and then the vampires coming back is not for me the
SPEAKER_00moment that I feel like they think it is it's not moving because For the entire show, they've been straight up murderers and manipulative and evil. They've been the full on villains. So them coming back in the finale to join us and getting through the night, I do not understand the emotional potency that the creatives think is there. So someone can explain that to me. I would really appreciate it. Physically, the show is also...
pretty unbeatable it's an extraordinary set by Dane Laffrey the lighting design is done by both Jen Shriver and Michael Arden I think the lighting and the set are pretty stellar and work beautifully together the effects are mostly strong there is a good deal of fly choreography the flying choreography for act one is pretty
SPEAKER_00impeccable it's There's a little bit tease at the beginning in a big sort of jump scare prelude and then the real flight happens when it's a scene that's allegedly famous in the film where Michael goes out with the brother of vampires after having drunk wine with blood in it which is sort of the initiation to half turn him into a vampire They all jump from a bridge into sort of the mist and Michael does the same and rather than fall to the ground he sort of falls into
nothingness before he eventually lands in his bed and it's a really beautiful effect where once LJ
SPEAKER_00Bennett lets go he he's sort of floating in blackness and by having very stark lighting and you know well placed wires it from if you're at enough of a distance it looks very impressive and the rest of the Empire Gang in that scene the way that they float also is very ethereal and beautiful where the flying starts to become a little more static is in act two when there's a bit more of a trickery to it when there's a bit more
of a fighting
SPEAKER_00complex to it it becomes a little You start to realize the limitations of the wires in Act 2 whereas in Act 1 because it's done very simply and quickly it is far more effective Act 2 when they try to kind of stretch their wings a bit more so to speak you see the limitations of it all and so it doesn't impress quite as much as it does in the first act The design still does Arden has a lot of really fluid staging a lot of beautiful stage pictures I think that the first like 25 minutes of the show are fucking rock
solid whether you like the sound of the music whether you can get on board with the lyrics is your own journey but in terms of musical theater storytelling it is very efficient it gets us through the opening number where we understand the three main characters their relationship to each other their history where they're off to what everybody wants we get Michael out of the house pretty quickly to the pier so we
SPEAKER_00can see the you know new environment that they're in we meet David and Star pretty quickly after that everything kind of happens in a very fluid almost cinematic way while still remaining entirely theatrical and it's really really I do think on a storytelling level it writes a check that I don't think the rest of the show quite cashes at least in terms of energy you know as I said it's a very high energy first 20 to 30 minutes and then it starts taking its time and there are thrilling beautiful moments but it doesn't have that kind of
steam train energy
SPEAKER_00that I find really interesting impactful from some of the best musicals it's not necessarily that you're going fast but you but you can always sort of feel like you're moving sometimes it's going at a steady pace of like 30 miles per hour before it accelerates to 50 then for a really crazy moment it goes to 70 then 80 then 90 and then it goes back to 30 so no matter what you always feel like you are going towards a destination narratively musically aesthetically and there are a couple of moments in Lost Boys
SPEAKER_00for me where it kind of slows down and will halt from time to time it does pick itself back up I do think that there are strong moments in act two it's not all bad I think it's kind of a mess tone wise the story remains relatively clear there's some things about the lore of vampires and how Max is able to sort of get away with being undetected for so long that get said very quickly and swept under the rug and definitely left me with some questions it left a few people
with some questions about it but that is also sort of at that moment in the show when Lost Boys puts its foot on the accelerator and it's like stop asking questions we're going we're going we're going which is maybe the smartest thing that they could do so even
SPEAKER_00though I'm like those final fight sequences are kind of Any other things I want to say about it? I think the number one song in act two is called wild it's a duet between Lucy and Max on their first unofficial date where they end up in sort of an abandoned playground where Lucy used to hang out with her friends when
she was younger and talking about how she would love to get back to a time when she was wild and sort
SPEAKER_00of reclaim that youthful energy she has as she goes forward and you know she and Max kind of lock in emotionally and mentally in that song and it's more importantly a time for Shoshana Bean and Paula Alexander Nolan to fucking wail and just be alone on stage have no one else with them and just go to town Vocally and you sit there and you go oh right this is what grown-ups do to quote Natalie Portman in May December this is what grown-ups do I am we know how I feel about Mr. Nolan I think he is our one of our greatest singing actors
around right now he's such a special talent he's such a smart unique actor with an incredible voice a grounded presence he's able to apply himself to all different genres of musical
SPEAKER_00theater and straight plays He's now played a villain three times in a row. Four times overall, three times in a row. Four with Dr. Zhivago. Five if we count Jesus Christ Superstar, which kind of counts because it's from the perspective of Judas. I mean, he does his job very well. The job he has is kindness. of a mid job he is not the role that people walk away thinking about not just because he's the villain but because he just doesn't have that much to do he spends most of act one being dorky not doing much vocally act two he gets the big duet
SPEAKER_00with Shoshana and then a nice sort of high note before he dies and that's sort of it in terms of the rest of the performances Shoshana I think everyone does a really strong job I don't think there's anybody who's bad I think that Benjamin Pajak as Sam you know we all saw him as Winthrop in Music Man or some of us saw him in Oliver at Encores he's a very talented young guy I think he's got a great career ahead of him he's sort of in this weird part in his teens where his
SPEAKER_00voice is changing and so he's not able to wail in the way that everyone else can because he's literally going through it physically going through it but he's got stage presence he's got charm the role is sort of written rather annoyingly and he sort of leans into that which I wish that he would kind of maybe pull back on that a little bit it's an earnest nerdy vibe and I think he can let up on some of the comical mugging that he's doing it would allow Sam to still be annoying but in a way that's
you know genial and and and charismatic LJ Bennett is you know he's super cute he's got a great voice he and Ali both have these like thick vocal folds so they sing with this sort of heavy masculine sound that we haven't really heard since the 90s and I'm obsessed with it it's why I fucking loved how Lea Michele sang in Funny Girl I was like oh my god not since Alice Ripley and Emily Skinner in Sideshow have
SPEAKER_00we heard such thick singing and so I'm really Thrilled that that kind of singing is back in Lost Boys LJ also really commits himself to Michael's sort of emo nobody understands me vibe the problem with that is I find that Michael's often for act one kind of insufferable of a character it's intentional because he has to learn that the community that he's always been looking for has been there all along where he's wanting to belong has always been there it's also again why I don't necessarily find Lost Boys and Michael's journey to be a queer narrative because
they wanting to belong somewhere and then finding a group to belong with only for that group to turn on you and then going back home is sort of not really the narrative that a lot
SPEAKER_00of queer people have found in their lives but he He plays his arc well. It's not his fault that I find Michael kind of a wet blanket and insufferable in Act 1. That's how he's written and he's doing the job. You kind of wish that there were a bit more shades to him in Act 1. He's got like a charismatic cheekiness with Star, but I'm sort of over the leading man turning on the charisma only when there's a girl he likes in front of him. You want him to have some other interests. You want him to have... a couple of like save the cat moments and not literally saving
a damsel in distress or anything like that but just like moments where you go oh this is why I'm going to follow your journey other than the fact that I have to because you're written as
SPEAKER_00our lead why do I want to watch you just because you're going through Shoshana once again is doing a musical where she's making breakfast lunch and dinner in the kitchen all the time and i think she's prepared like two different meals in this show and I'm like okay so that's a tenth of the times you're preparing meals in Hell's Kitchen but still that's two Broadway musicals in a row where
you're cooking on
SPEAKER_00stage for your kids that's um Let's find another show where she's not in the kitchen shall we and then waitress she was bacon let's get Shoshana Bean out of the kitchen out of the kitchen and center stage please but she does a really lovely job what Shoshana Bean has sort of started making a post-covid career out of is being the grounded center of like kind of wild musicals where there's a lot of personality around her and she's sort of a holding force the glue of it all and she does a really nice job with without being sort of a downer or fading into the background which it's easy
to do in a show like
SPEAKER_00this because everything is going on all the time always in terms of Tony nominations I mean I think it's pretty obvious it is a lock for nominations for musical score and book it's just It is. It's a big, big musical. There's no way in which Beaches or Queen of Versailles is getting in over it. There's no way that, you know, like three straight plays with music are going to get in over Lost Boys for score. This is a genuine original score. I think the music is very effective. It's a lot of music. It's big music. Some songs definitely are cuttable.
SPEAKER_00I think that Sam's Act 2 song is cuttable. I think his opening of Act 2 song could be tweaked a little bit. Star has a song called War that I... I am forlorn Manic Pixie Dream Girl
Distinct Shades but they're also one shade nonetheless which adds again into the sort of the earnest 80s mega musical of it all everyone's playing a bit of a trope and going to the back of the wall with it so it's the assignment that she's given and she does it well uh but her you know her big song act too while she sounds amazing I'm just sort of like I really don't think we need it it's it's a one
SPEAKER_00statement song I would rather that it I would like it if the song was integrated into maybe some story if there was a decision that Star makes into the song she doesn't really make any decision it's sort of like here's where I am in this moment it's sort of like how in One Day More One Day More isn't a story song the only thing that happens in that song is Marius decides he's going to fight with his friends in the revolution rather than follow Cosette that's one thing in a four minute song everything else is just everybody stating where they are at in that moment before the curtain comes down
and it's that's sort of what Star is doing in this moment it's like the Eponine track in One Day More for three and a half minutes and it's just Eponine's track nobody else but yeah in terms of score that's sort of how I feel it's getting nominated I don't see it winning if it wins it's just because it's so big and epic and that might work for
SPEAKER_00some people I also don't know if it's gonna work for everybody I do think Michael Arden's getting in for direction he does a really strong job I mean just if we're talking the physical job of aesthetic and staging and sort of uniting a company and helming a new musical on Broadway with no out of town and not a lot of time to make changes he got what started as like a three-hour musical at the beginning of previews to two and a half hours with like three-ish weeks three and a half weeks really of previews that's quite impressive and I think and it's a nice bounce back
from Queen of Versailles so I do think he's getting in I think there's a world in which it could get in for choreography there's not a lot of movement it's pretty seamless with art and staging you could argue that plus the fly choreography will be eligible in which case I think that they have a shot at a nomination for choreography I think they're going to go up and down the line with design with nominations set costumes
SPEAKER_00lighting sound design I could see orchestrations happening as well In terms of performances, I really think the only two locks we have are Ali as David and Shoshana as Lucy in Featured. Everything else is pretty up for grabs. LJ does a really good job, but I think now that Andrew Durand is eligible in Leading Actor, which oh, By the way disregard some of my takes yesterday because as soon as I finished recording the Tony Awards released their final ruling of eligibility so we have Stephanie Hsu and Andrew Durand eligible in leading
performances in a musical that
SPEAKER_00was a flip We had Schmingadoon eligible for Best Score. That was a flip. Laurie Metcalf in Featured for Death of a Salesman. We knew that. Alden in Featured for Becky Shaw. So that answered my question with that. But yeah, now that Andrew is eligible for Leading Actor, we have nine candidates, which means we have five slots for Leading Actor in a Musical. And that means, in my humble opinion, we have Joshua Henry, Brandon Uranowitz, Luke Evans, Sam Tootie, and Nicholas Christopher. all kind of locked in in that category if LJ gets in I think it
is at the removal of either Brandon or of Nick the reason why I think Brandon is vulnerable is because he's already a winner whereas there's a narrative of Josh of like it's time it's also how many acting nominations do we think nominators are going to be
SPEAKER_00willing to give ragtime it's you know are we really going to give it I think Hamilton had seven one two three four five six yeah Hamilton had seven and so it's like is Ragtime really gonna go for six or seven I don't think so and so there are especially when there are other people who could get in there and are worthy I think that makes Brandon a little bit more vulnerable and I think Nick is vulnerable just because I don't see Chess getting nominated for revival and if it's not getting in for revival there might be less of an incentive to nominate Nicholas
SPEAKER_00whereas LJ will be part of a Best Musical nominee he is the he's at the forefront of this musical whereas Nicholas is a co-lead with Leah and with Aaron so that's where I think LJ has an edge over Nicholas and over Brandon but I still think that those two are getting in over LJ just saying I don't really see any of the other featured actors in the show getting in you know we love ourselves some Nolan I just don't think the role is there Benjamin does a solid job I don't really think the role is there so yeah I think we're looking at musical score in terms of nominations musical score book
orchestrations set lighting costume sound direction so that's nine already possibly choreography that would be 10 Shoshana and David's that would bring them up to 11 I think Lost Boys
SPEAKER_00were looking at maximum 12 minimum nine that's yeah 12 okay you know I'm gonna say minimum minimum seven maximum twelve that's where we're putting Lost Boys in terms of nominations that's really all I can say right now on Lost Boys I hope that covered a lot for you guys I hope that seemed like a worthy review I know a lot of you were really kind of like waiting for this one both because it's the last show of the season I know that the show has a major fan base already I don't want to decry that but I also had a lot of friends who
saw this show in previews and texted me and were like oh my god I want you to rip it to shreds I hated it so much I do not I guess I understand the hatred because Lost Boys is so big and it's so earnest and it's very loud and it's very much setting a specific vibe which is not going to be for everyone like if you are somebody who's waiting for the next Frank Lester musical if you're somebody who went to go see Beaches and
SPEAKER_00you're like I really appreciated the tone of beaches I don't think Lost Boys is for you but you also have to give credit to a team that wanted to make something in a very specific way and I would say for like the first 60% of the show they really kind of do it the last 40% a little bit less so which is unfortunate but listen I've seen far worse shows get nominated for best musical I think there are a few worse musicals that have won in the past whoopsie daisy for me it's not something that I hate it's not something that I'm obsessed with I
think after now having seen it the second time I think I'm good I don't think I'll be seeing it again for a long time unless I'm invited back for some reason which I don't see happening that's sort of where we leave Lost Boys it is I think a
SPEAKER_00formidable It's a big big show in a big big theater
but like listen at the very least I think it's making it to the end of the calendar year and possibly beyond we'll see how it does with Tony's but I think that it's building up quite a strong fan base and good for them we we don't begrudge any show that can fill the palace theater for over a year it's a huge theater beautiful theater I love the new renovation but big big theater hard to fill that's it with
SPEAKER_00Lost Boys I want to thank you guys for listening to this episode again if you like us please give us a nice five star rating or review follow us on discord or onSubstack join all the Tony discussion on the discord there's a whole lot of stuff being talked about there also if you have questions about the podcast This coming Sunday is our next live show reviewing the 2025
26 season at Green Room 42 with Ragtime's Nicholas Barone and Mamma Mia's Chelsea Williams.
SPEAKER_00Also friend of the pod, Chelsea Williams. If you can't make it to the May 3rd show, we have Monday, June 1st coming up after that. which is the slightly early Tony Awards show also Green Room 42 link for both will be in the description for this episode we have one last pre-nomination episode coming up it's going to be a doozy we've got interviews with Broadway Breakdown friends and fam Casey Balsham from its Broadway bitch theater lease theater critic Juan Ramirez we have dramas Connor and Dylan McDowell and we
also have our gold derby friend Sam Eckman on my opinion the only expert at gold derby to listen to when it comes to theater all coming on to give us some of their final hot takes before the nominations come out that'll be this weekend before the live show and
SPEAKER_00then we are doing our response to the as soon as possible with spoiler alert the theater lovers Rachel and Will Anderson so uh get ready for that and that's it uh who should we close out with today we've closed out with Shoshana a lot I feel like it's a little silly to give her like a third or fourth close out but um hmm I don't know. Maybe we close out with her and Paul doing Wild. I feel like there's a video of them doing it somewhere on like Broadway.com or something.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, let's close out with them singing Wild. That'll be nice. We've never actually had Nolan out here as a closer. So that's it. Yeah, we'll see you guys for the next episode. Take it away, you two. Bye. Wild. Wild.
SPEAKER_01Wild. Wild. Wild. I wanna be wild again Wild again
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...