Matt is a fancy Drama Desk voter now, which means he has to see a LOT more shows! It’s quiet on Broadway right now, so Matt’s been seeing a whole bunch of Off-Broadway productions and he’s coming back early on the Breakdown to do a Summer Review Wrap Up! Followed up by a talk with Matt Rodin (@whoismattrodin) about his new site theater.games and how it’s combining fun and education for theater lovers everywhere!!! Broadway Breakdown Links: * The Broadway Breakdown Green Room (Patreon!) * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube 02:32 - A Walk on the Moon 08:40 -An American Daughter 14:36 - Giulia: The Poison Queen of Palermo 22:47 - The Winter’s Tale 26:58 - The Circuit 28:28 - The Pass 32:55 - Disruption 36:06 - Are You Mad at Me? 38:53 - The Maids 42:05- The Saviors 46:24 - Birthright 52:50 - Talk w/ Matt Rodin This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00I'm reviewing that situation. I must quickly look up everyone I know. Titled people with a station who can help me make a real impressive show.
SPEAKER_02Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous... Most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts, and welcome back after a bit of a hiatus. If you are indeed on the Patreon Broadway Breakdown Greenroom, it's been a little bit less of a hiatus than for some others, but still, it's been a stretch, and we're not So I'm kind of rusty.
SPEAKER_02We're doing a review episode today. We're doing a review roundup of all the things I saw this summer as a Drama Desk voter because, reminder... Back in July, I officially became a voter for the Drama Desk Awards, which is really cool, really fun. We're still kind of getting the hang of it. So I figured I would do a review roundup of all the off-Broadway things I saw this season.
SPEAKER_02This does include The Circuit, which I mentioned a little bit a while ago. And of course, this also includes Heated Rivalry, which I've now seen quite a few times. So I won't really talk about Heated Rivalry in depth because, again, I did a full episode of I'm going to do my best to discuss the basic premise of these things, and then my initial reactions, and then where I could see them heading in the awards circuit later this year.
SPEAKER_02If at all for some of them. So yeah, and then once this is over, you can stick around and you can listen to my interview with Matt Roden talking about his work as an actor as well as his recent endeavor with his theater games website. And we play a few theater games. So stick around for that after these reviews. So first up, we are talking about, I'm going to go actually kind of in ranking order from my least favorite to my most favorite that I've seen so far. So that should maybe help you figure out
SPEAKER_02So first up at the bottom of the list, unfortunately, is the musical A Walk on the Moon. This is based on the film by the same name that was written by Pamela Gray. Gray has written the book for this. She's also co-written lyrics with Anne-Marie Malasso, who wrote the music for this. It is directed by Cheryl Collar. Many of you would know Cheryl Collar for directing the plays Next Fall and Mothers and Sons. This was being titled Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And the play takes place in 1969. A Walk on the Moon ties into the man landing on the moon in 1969. But the story follows a woman named Pearl in this production played by Talia Seskauer. She is a young mother married to Max Ternan, who plays a man named Marty. They were teenagers who met, had sex. She got pregnant. They got married. Their daughter, Allison, who is played by Sophie Polano.
SPEAKER_02They eventually had a second kid and they're married and they're like relatively happy. But this summer of 1969, they go up to basically the Catskills to this Jewish Catskill resort. And Max Ternan comes every weekend because he has to work during the week. There's a running joke that all the husbands drive up every weekend and they all compete over who makes the best time upstate. But anyway, during the week, Pearl spends time with her daughter Allison, but Allison's also 15 and she's trying to break out. She wants,
SPEAKER_02it's 1969, she wants to get away from the squares that are her parents and her parents' friends. So she starts running off with this boy Ross, played by Oscar Williams. And while all this is going on, Pearl meets a man named Walker, played by Sam Gravitt, and he's just known as the Blouse Man. He sells blouses to all the women in the resort. And they start a flirtation, which eventually becomes a full-blown affair. And all gets revealed and all is discussed. And the idea of this musical, of this story, is that Pearl...
SPEAKER_02Is someone who never had a chance to really have a childhood to really find out who she was because at the prime age of 16, 17, she had to become a wife and mother a little too soon. And while she likes being a wife and mother, it was not a choice she had to make. It was a choice that was made for her. And so she misguidedly had herself a rambunctious period.
SPEAKER_01And the story, I can imagine, would work better as a film where it's this little slice of life. It happens over the course of a summer. There are only two real major incidents in the story. Everything else is just character study. When you have Diane Lane and Liev Schreiber and
SPEAKER_02Viggo Mortensen and Anna Paquin, a lot can be filled in the blanks with the performances. In this, Talia Saskauer does her best. She really tries to They find ways to make the narrative dots connect, but unfortunately the material does not help her. She has very good chemistry with Max Ternan, but ultimately their marriage just, you never really know where they are at. It sort of is, they are happily married when the story wants them to be happily married, they are not happily married when the story doesn't want them to be,
SPEAKER_02and there's no rhyme or reason for anything. It's just sort of whenever the writers want a specific person Walker, played by Sam Gravitt, is just, he's kind He exists solely to be her temptation and her opportunity for a youth. And he is handsome, he's charming, but that's kind of all he's asked to be. Unfortunately, Sophie Polona as Allison, Allison is just written to be so much of a brat.
SPEAKER_02And she's just sort of reactionary to everyone. And again, there's no... And she's constantly making jokes about her having these premonitions.
SPEAKER_02And it just doesn't, it's just, it's not funny. It made me very uncomfortable by how not funny it was. The lyrics are pretty awful. The best thing I'll say is like, there's some solid hooks in the music and it is of course extraordinarily well sung, but that's really kind of it. It doesn't. It has no style. It has no momentum. It has no energy. Every song feels shoved in. The best songs are the ones that actually make sense to the story, but they are not actually good songs. They are just placed in the right moments.
SPEAKER_02Thus, Talia Suskauer and Max Chernin Have something to actually play. It's not a lot, but it is something. And yeah, this is just, it's such a wash this show and really kind of, I hate to say this, but like one of the worst new musicals I've seen in quite a while. It's just a big fat no. And she...
SPEAKER_02Kind of succeeds, which is a testament to how talented and smart she is, because I cannot stress this enough. She is given almost nothing to work with. And they also, I mean, take a shot every time they remind you it's 1969. Take a shot every time they remind you that man is about to walk on the moon and the parallels between that breakthrough and what Pearl is going through. It's just it's so on the nose and it's just it's it's like laziest first draft. So that's it for Walk on the Moon. Moving on. Next up on the list is An American Daughter, which is having a revival via the La Femme theater productions currently being done
SPEAKER_02at the Signature Theater. It's not a Signature production. They are just renting the theater, similar to Walk on the Moon with Roundabout. I'm sorry. As I was doing research after the fact, this was considered a major disappointment in Wasserstein's career.
SPEAKER_02It was right after Sisters Rose and Swag, so she'd already had her Tony and Pulitzer for Heidi Chronicles and An American Daughter. Yeah. That's sort of the era of theater where a lot of writers are kind of writing for this optimistic end of history.
SPEAKER_02We have to kind of look back on history and realize how far we've come and congratulate ourselves for how far we've come. And all the problems of today is sort of of the modern upper middle class person. So this is today. An American daughter follows the story of a woman named Lissa. She is a doctor. Her father is a Republican senator. Her husband is a teacher at a university in Georgetown and Lissa is up for the nomination as Surgeon General. But then there is drama when it is revealed that she missed a jury summons
SPEAKER_02and now she's being hounded by the press. This is circa 1997 and this was considered a big deal at the time. Although as I was reading Ben Brantley's review for the original production, even he at the time was like, I don't know, this is a little suspect. But the jury summons is more sort of A smokescreen for the fact that she's a woman and an accomplished woman who up until this point has always been considered rather perfect. And now everyone's just going in on her. And Lissa is not much of a character. She exists to sort of just be reactionary. And it is, you know, it is well written.
SPEAKER_02Everything about it is on point, but it is very shoehorned in. It exists for an audience to applaud. And of course, they do applaud. This is not, even with all of the edits, it doesn't feel much like a play. I can't imagine that the original version by Wasserstein is much of a play. It is an idea, it is a point that is trying to be made, and every character is written.
SPEAKER_02Lissa is currently played by Gene Lichty, who is the... Producer, artistic director of La Femme Theater Productions. And let's get the elephant out of the room. She is not an actress. If she wants to produce works, that's amazing. She should not be producing works for her to be in. She needs to produce works for other people to be in.
SPEAKER_01When roles for women over a certain age are already hard to come by, The number of actresses
SPEAKER_02who maybe couldn't tear into this role because it's not much of a role, but at least could do something with it and have an opportunity to show themselves once again to a New York paying audience just And then Jean just kind of comes in and does this. It just really fucking pisses me off. If she wants to produce, fantastic. Good for her. Let other better actors get in there, especially because by being the center of this production, all the other actors have no one to play off of. The people who come off the best are Dakin Matthews, who plays her father, her Republican senator father, and Mary Beth Peel as Matthews' new wife.
SPEAKER_02Montego Glover plays Liz's best friend. Her name is Judith. She also calls her Jude. She is an African-American Jewish feminist physician, also a lesbian, but she also wants to have a child. And she's even flirting with having sex with a gay man who is their token Republican gay friend who's a political journalist. And again, everyone is just sort of a combination of Contrasting adjectives to make them seem interesting.
SPEAKER_02But no one is interesting. And there also is just a shallowness to every portrayal. For example, Robert Sean Leonard is this esteemed professor and he has this student, a female student whose name is Quincy Quince. And you can tell from the jump that Quincy is not a quote unquote girl's girl. And she's supposed to be this Gen X feminist who Wendy Wasserstein clearly has I'm sorry, I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_02But that's not really what Wasserstein is doing here. And if she is, then Sherna Lapine as the director is not really making that come through. It doesn't make me think that the play is good. It doesn't even make me really think that it was necessarily a better time. It was a more, I will argue, a more intellectual time about, you know, maybe... Next up on the rung is Julia, the new Jennifer Nettles musical that played at PAC this summer. Nettles wrote the score, the book, and starred as Julia, the Poison Queen,
SPEAKER_02I never got to see it live, but I have seen video clips of it. It is quite good, although I also think that no one can ever truly make Candide work. Julia tells the story of the allegedly true story, of a woman who ran an apothecary in Palermo in Italy who would poison
SPEAKER_02the toxic husbands of abused women. I did some research after the fact and my friend Patrick actually knows quite a bit about it. And he even said that there's even evidence to assume that it wasn't her who was doing it, that she was a front for someone else who was doing it. A lot of theories and conspiracies. But in the musical, you know, she's... She's a woman with a teenage daughter with a second marriage, and her husband is incredibly abusive, and to save her daughter,
SPEAKER_02she poisons her husband and then starts doing the same for other women in the town who come to her for help, and then it becomes... And she is being hounded by the church, the cardinal who is played by Quentin Earl Darrington, as well as a politician, a corrupt politician played by Christopher Ramirez. And in terms of plot, that's all kind of get into. Brie Jackson also plays a sort of omnipresent narrator who only really shows up the top of Act 1 and the top of Act 2. The things I'll say positively about this show is that Nettles has a really good ear
SPEAKER_02for music, and this is actually a very good idea for a musical. She has a really good ear for hooks. And it's a very clearly passionate project. And there's some nice design work. This set consists of stairs and then three doors that constantly open and shut to reveal new locales. Of course, the downside of this is that actors are constantly coming on stage to open and close the doors during scenes, in between scenes. It gets to be rather cumbersome. It's really cool for the first three or four transitions, and then it just becomes a nuisance.
SPEAKER_02The downside of Nettles' writing is that she is just not a musical theater writer. She has an ear for hooks, but her songs do not actually have any kind of structure. They don't have the builds. They are just sort of the hook on repeat. The lyrics also are rather kind of... Every now and then she'll have a good idea that she repeats over and over again. For example, the top of act two, omnipresent narrator Brie Jackson sings about sort of flashing forward to now Julia is doing this poisoning all the time. She was barely making a living, but now she's making a killing.
SPEAKER_02Cool. Cute joke. You get that once, maybe twice if you space it out enough, but no, no, no. It's actually the title of the song that opens act two and it's repeated over and over and over again. Zimmerman also doesn't actually quite have a flair for musical theater staging herself. She has a flair for stage pictures, but can't really connect the threads in any of that, and nor does she have a sense of pacing. A lot of the scene transitions are actually quite clunky. A lot of the choreography is quite clunky. The score also wants to sort of be a mishmash of Light in the Piazza and Hamilton.
SPEAKER_02There's definitely some... There's dissonant classical music in there and then pop and hip-hop, and they are not actually blended together. This is not a Dave Molloy tapestry of a score like in Great Comet or a Janine Desori Carolina change. This is a Jeff Richmond Mean Girls where every song is a very different flavor and it is very jarring. You don't even get a scoop of sorbet in between bites to cleanse the palate.
SPEAKER_02It's sort of like going from... Indian curry, right into sushi, right into pizza, right into an Oreo. And you're like, this needs to have a better blend. It needs to, everything needs to Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02He plays it so campy and so foppishly that often a lot of what he says and does is played for laughs. Or if it's not meant to be played for laughs, it actually gets laughs. And so again... He doesn't become anything that's really dangerous. And his songs become like Disney villain-esque. And Quentin Earl Darrington, as the Cardinal, has a whole song in the second act that is like full-blown R&B hip-hop
SPEAKER_02that just comes out of nowhere. And...
SPEAKER_01It's a show that has a lot of ideas, a lot of identities. It has no real direction, but it
SPEAKER_02has a lot of heart and has a lot of passion. And I think that's what's coming through to a lot of fans of this show. They feel the themes of it very deeply. It is kind of Suf's if Suf's wanted to, you know, draw some blood, but Whereas Sufts, I found, at least had a clear distinction of its tone, of its style, and knew what story it was tackling. My issue with Sufts was more there were times where I felt like it went a little too broad and eager for whoops and hollers and cheers rather
SPEAKER_02than actual investigation of stuff. Julia doesn't have that. Julia doesn't have a narrative direction. I think Nettles needs a book writer and she needs a lyricist. And she needs a stronger musical supervisor to help her expand these songs to really grow and have musical sequences and become more dramatically compelling rather than just wailing,
SPEAKER_02which is ultimately where it lives right now. And that's enough for some people, but it's just not enough for me. There are also just so many moments where I'm like, we don't need a song here or the song is taking up too much time. For example... The scene where Julia finally decides that she actually poisons her husband, it comes in a moment where her husband's home drunk and he gets violent and he starts to attack her daughter. And what happens is... He and the daughter start to fight in slow motion while Julia has an inner monologue and basically saying, this is not a time to think, this is a time to act, I gotta know what to do.
SPEAKER_02Now, that's fine, but the song itself that she's singing goes on for three minutes, and you could argue, well, it's meant to be only like five seconds in real time.
SPEAKER_01No, no, no, because Zimmerman and the choreographer have the second husband and daughter do what I can only describe as a domestic violence pas de deux. So while they're moving... You are thinking to yourself, how much time is actually passing because they are going all over this kitchen while Julia just keeps on singing?
SPEAKER_02That is something that a musical theater director has to be aware of. If it is just a fraction So that's where we are with Julia. I think it's a really good idea. There are nuggets of good hooks in there, but this is something that for my money needs a giant overhaul.
SPEAKER_01I would maybe nominate it for music and orchestrations as sort of an investment in Nettles as a writer. Moving on.
SPEAKER_02Next up is The Winter's Tale at the Public Theater at the Delacorte. If you listen to me on drama with Connor and Dylan, I do a very basic rundown of the plot of this show, which is really not one of Shakespeare's best. Basically, Raoul Esparza's King Leontes, I think that's how you say his name? No, it's Italian. And his wife, Lily Rape, is Queen Hermione. Long story short, he thinks that his pregnant wife, Hermione, who's pregnant with her second kid, is boning his friend, who's the king of another land called Bohemia.
SPEAKER_02He puts her in jail where she gets birth. He's going to kill them. So instead of killing the baby... They send it away. The baby is raised by Chuck Cooper and his son. Act two is 15 years later. The baby is grown up. She's a beautiful young woman. She's in love with the Prince of Bohemia, which is where she's now living. Again, this is the land that Rel Esparza's friend is the king of,
SPEAKER_02the friend who he thought was boning his wife. And that friend is not super into the fact that his son is in love with a shepherd's daughter, so he disapproves of the marriage. Chuck Cooper is like, hey, so fun fact, I actually found you when you were a baby. You had all this gold in your bassinet and a couple of things that implied you might be. It's not my favorite. It
SPEAKER_02This production runs three and a half hours long. It is very slow. There are things about it that are good. Lily Rabe is wonderful as Hermione. Marcia Stephanie Blake plays Paulina, a very faithful nurse to Lily Rabe, and is sort of the only one in the show who openly calls out Raul Esparza's king on his bullshit to the point that she got exit applause like two different times. They are really good. Raoul is such a wonderful actor. He is ultimately miscast in this. He is playing this far more subtle and inward like it's for TV or film and like it's
SPEAKER_02a more modern piece than it actually is. Lily Ray. And Marcia Stephanie Blake actually play the grand theatricality of Shakespeare that you kind of need for something like this. Because emotions run high, but also it's such an odd story. It's also such a fucking stretched out story that the fact that they're doing it uncut is stupid. This is a play that could easily be 90 minutes. And the fact that it is three and a half hours long, I think, is rather criminal. There's some beautiful design to it. The set I actually think is quite nice.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. That said, again, it just sort of plods along. And the second act, while a more colorful and exuberant act, actually has weaker acting. Part of it is because Lily Rabe and Ralph Esparza and Marcia Stephanie Blake are not there for the majority of it. Chuck Cooper is, as is Stephen Skybell. They are both very good. But it is not really... It's low-rung Shakespeare that is played a little too...
SPEAKER_02It's a little bit too much with curator gloves, you know, they just treated a little too much with prestige. And it's already you should always be having fun with Shakespeare in general. The best productions of Shakespeare I see are the ones where they get their hands dirty, where they really kind of get in the dirt with it. And for something that's not a Hamlet, that's not an Othello, that's not a Romeo and Juliet. It's like, come on. Fuck around with it and find out. But they don't. It's not the worst thing I've ever seen. It's just it was long. And I zoned out quite a few times. This needed to be tighter.
SPEAKER_02There needed to be some better performances. You can't just rely on Lily Rabe and Marcia Stephanie Blake, especially when they're barely in the second act. So that's The Winter's Tale. We have The Circuit, which I mentioned. Really, The Winter's Tale, the only thing I would nominate would be Lily Rabe and Marcia Stephanie Blake. I don't think that anything will come of it later in the year. But I mean, Marsha might, she really was a major highlight. With The Circuit, really what we have here is choreography and unique theatrical experience, maybe even lighting because it's very impressive what they're able to do outdoors
SPEAKER_02in various locations. But if you've ever listened to Hello Again, if you ever read or watched The Blue Room or you've even read La Ronde, it's a really fascinating play that was very scandalous for its time. But the idea that sexual violence Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But there's always going to be a weird disconnect to it. And that's sort of what it is with the circuit. And granted, them making it a silent disco adds to the idea that sex can be very impersonal and you can sort of be outside of your body while doing something that is very much of your body. But the double-edged sword of that is, while it's a really cool idea on paper, it does also truly keep you at a distance from everything and you can I think they could be up for unique theatrical experience.
SPEAKER_02I don't know if that'll happen, but it's possible. After this is The Pass, which is being done at La Mama. This is written by John Donnelly, which is an adaptation of his screenplay of the 2016 film by the same name that starred Russell Tovey. The story follows Jason, here played by Matisse Rochon-Neal, and Ade, played by Terry Bell. It begins with them as teenagers. The whole thing is focused on English characters and in various hotel rooms.
SPEAKER_02So the set is done with the audience on both sides and it starts in a hotel room and each scene is a hotel room years later that gets progressively nicer. So the first one is a basic hotel room in Romania. It's like kind of like a holiday inn plus. And Ade and Jason are teammates for an upcoming match of football, aka soccer, having spent years together at a football academy and a club for this football academy. They're basically doing tryouts to get in professional clubs in hopefully the UK,
SPEAKER_02but potentially around the world. And The long and short of it is that both of them turn out to be gay and they hook up at the end of this scene. But as the years go on, you realize that Jason chooses fame and success and thus goes into a closet. And you watch his life and his career through these exchanges with other people, eventually coming back around years later to him in a day as adults and seeing how it has affected him and what living openly has done for a day
SPEAKER_02as opposed to Jason. How Jason takes comfort and solace in his success, but also is aware that it is not fully fulfilling him, especially when years later he is divorced, he doesn't really see his kid, he's now divorced. He's retired from football and doing all these endorsement deals and has a lot of money, but no one really thinks highly of him anymore. He's famous, but he's not exactly well thought of.
SPEAKER_02And you see in the final scene with him in a day, he's trying to get back to his wild teenage years with him and sort of recapture that moment that they had years before, while also a day trying to confront Jason of why exactly he did it. This is higher up for a couple of reasons. The acting overall is very strong. Mattis Retron-Neil, I think that's how you say his name, as Jason is doing really exceptional work. I think that Terry Bell as the day is also doing really strong work. The design is also really fantastic. It was really,
SPEAKER_02the way in which the room would constantly shift in between scenes to become a nicer hotel room was really clever. And all the details to indicate the upgrade in each hotel room was really well done. It had a lot of style. Ultimately, I don't think it's really much of a play. I don't think it's really much of a story. This is a topic that, again, similar to Laurent, is not something that is not worth discussing, but it's something that's actually discussed quite a lot in various ways.
SPEAKER_02And it doesn't really do much to engage you outside of the titillation of the sensuality of the actors and of sort of the And I imagine this probably works better as a film. Again, you're more up close and personal with close-ups, and you can do multiple takes with actors to get the exact right balance that you want for each scene with all the dialogue. But as a play, it's just, it's a little bit of a nothing.
SPEAKER_02It's not awful, but it also does kind of drag on. Each scene is always about five to ten minutes longer than it needs to be. Yeah. There was a moment where I was like, oh God, whose phone is going off constantly? Like someone's music is playing or someone's having a conversation.
SPEAKER_02And I realized, no, no, no, it's the TV in the set that is playing. But the way that the sound design works, it doesn't sound like it's, it sounded far away enough and muffled enough that it was just really realistic. So I thought that was really impressive. So good for them on that. Next up is Disruption, which is currently being done at the Signature Theatre. It is not a Signature production, however, it is written by Andrew Stein. And it follows a group of friends, most of whom are married. Conrad Rickamora is married to Seanette Renee Wilson.
SPEAKER_02Elizabeth Stanley is married to Joe Tippett. And Jason Ralph is married to Irene Sofia Lucio. And Irene Sofia Lucio is sisters with Elizabeth Stanley. And their mutual friend, John David Washington, many of you know him as Denzel Washington's son. He was also in The Piano Lesson with Samuel L. Jackson a few years back. He is their very successful but very shady friend, and he's trying to talk them all into investing in a project that he's working on with a young, hungry up-and-comer in tech. And ultimately, it's AI.
SPEAKER_02They're working on an AI app, and the play is ultimately focused on this while playing a little fast and loose with theatrical devices of exactly how this app works and what John David Washington is doing. How he's communicating with his business partner while also fully manipulating his friends into investing by exposing all of the rot in their marriages for his gain. It's also not made clear exactly why he needs their money to do this.
SPEAKER_02If he already has all this money from other investors, if this is such a sure thing, why does he need his friends to do it? The stakes are not made relatively clear. Ultimately, what the play wants to be is a major warning about the dangers of AI. And the corruption of success because spoiler alert, they all they do end up investing in this and the app is incredibly successful and they all make a shit ton of money and they ultimately get what they want. But at the cost of a few things, the thing about this show is that it has a lot of wants to tackle.
SPEAKER_02It all feels about two years too late. It just feels incredibly passe now because AI has already progressed so much further than what this play is covering. It is pretty solid performances. The best scene of the show is when Elizabeth Stanley and Irene Sofia Lucio sit down and just sort of converse about their lives and their husbands and their sisterly relationship. And it's the only time where you really feel the play is about people. And It ultimately reminds you that no matter how many grand ideas a play might have
SPEAKER_02or a piece of theater might have, the thing you'll always connect to is the people. That's what's going to hook you emotionally and mentally. And if your humans on stage are not Well-rounded and locked in. All the other messages you want to get across will not succeed. And unfortunately, the rest of the play does not succeed. This one scene is quite strong. Similar to the past, though, it has really good design elements. Actually, moreover, But not so much that it tanks the whole quality of the company.
SPEAKER_02Next up is Are You Mad at Me?, a solo show by Brian Safi at Here Art Center. There's not much to say about this one. It's basically a 70-minute stand-up. It's Safi doing a lot of anecdotes about his life, both, you know, his younger self and his current. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And he has a lot of good jokes. It's just that it all kind of feels like rinse and repeat. After a while, the humor... So, for example...
SPEAKER_02He tells a story of seeing a woman at a grocery store that has a t-shirt and on the front says, I miss teaching kindergarten.
SPEAKER_01And on the back it says, oh wait, no I don't. And he thinks that that's sort of the perfect representation
SPEAKER_02of his personality. And It would be better if that were done towards the beginning and that was something we could keep coming back to. Instead, we are introduced to it about 20 minutes into the 70-minute show and we come back to it maybe two or three times and then we close out with it and it doesn't really feel fully baked. There's a lot of good stuff in here, but it's a little scattered and I would love it if Safi and his production team Could kind of come back to this and really work harder
SPEAKER_02on creating a fuller arc that might come at the expense of cutting some stuff and maybe adding some stuff. But I think that he is a gregarious enough presence that this could be enough for a lot of people, but this show could be even stronger with a more solid foundation.
SPEAKER_01As it stands, it's sort of a...
SPEAKER_02A free-for-all of bits rather than a show. And I know this is up for solo show. I think that there is probably, because it's August, I'm sure there are going to be more solo shows coming up. You know, we got Billy Crystal, Kat Cohen has her broad strokes happening right now at the Lortel. So it's going to be a crowded field. And in order to really make an impression, you have to do more than just throw new bits at the wall every 90 seconds. But it's not bad. It was a fun enough time. But for something that was 70 minutes, it actually felt quite a bit longer.
SPEAKER_02Next up on the list is The Maids. This just played at St. Anne's Warehouse after a transfer from the Donmar Warehouse. This is a modern adaptation of the play by Jean Genet as adapted by Kip Williams. You remember that he did the picture of Dorian Gray with Sarah Snook. And the maids, if you don't know, it's about a 90-year-old play at this point, almost 100. About two maids, Claire and Solange, who are sisters, who work for a woman only known as Madame.
SPEAKER_02And they both idolize Madame and hate Madame. When Madame is out of the house, they take turns play-acting as Madame and ways in which they could kill Madame. And they never actually figure out how to do it. And when Madame comes home, they start to... They tried to convene and find a way to actually kill her for real this time, especially now that their lives are on the line because Madame had a boyfriend that was doing some shady business deals. They exposed this to the police anonymously.
SPEAKER_02So the police arrested him, but then we find out he's getting released from prison. And so Solange and Claire are sort of like, it's now or never, but spoiler alert, they do not kill Madame. This version of the play is adapted to be modern times, most likely in France. Madame is played by Yaren Ha. You might know her from the most recent season of Bridgerton. She is the Cinderella Sophie of that season. Fia Saban plays Solange, one of the maids. She is best known for House of Dragon. And then Lydia Wilson is Claire.
SPEAKER_02I saw Lydia Wilson, I believe, in King Charles III on Broadway a few years back. I don't know what else we might know her from. The idea is that Madame is a... Millionaire heiress and social media influencer. So the set is her bedroom slash closet. So a lot of mirrors, a lot of white, a lot of flowers and a lot of very expensive but kind of gauche clothes. There's a lot of Instagram and projecting the Instagram and social media up on the mirrors.
SPEAKER_02Similar to Picture of Dorian Gray, but here it actually makes a lot more narrative sense to have it be done. And the thing about The Maids is that The Maids kind of has always existed to be a play for actresses to actress. It's not really as fulfilling a play as you want it to be. It especially kind of goes off the rails towards the end. But so to have actresses, actress is really the point of it. And it has a lot of style. It has a lot of flair. There's some good moments to it. But it is sort of a one note play for the first half and then changes notes. But then the second note becomes the only note for the second half of it.
SPEAKER_02And it just sort of ends. And so you're always appreciative that you saw it, but you're always wanting a little bit more. It's a solid adaptation. It's beautifully done. The acting is very good. I would personally recommend that Lydia Wilson be remembered At the end of the season for actress in a play, she's really fantastic in it and holds the thing together. But it's always something on paper that you're a little more excited to see. And then you see it and you're like, yeah, that was worth seeing. But it wasn't as life changing as I wanted it to be. It's higher up on this list because truly it's kind of a week.
SPEAKER_02But now we're getting to the stuff that I kind of recommend a little more fully because next up is The Saviors, which is at the Atlantic Theater Company. This is a new play by Bubba Weiler, who wrote Well, I'll Let You Go. It is about two teenage boys, Paul and Michael. Paul is played by Julius Rinzel. Michael is Ivan Howe. They are altar boys in their town church. And a lot of the play is then discussing the Bible, school, their friendship. And all of this is sort of put to the test when they encounter a drifter. Paul is more interested in this drifter than Michael is,
SPEAKER_02but also we find out later from Paul when he's talking to the drifter alone, this is because Michael might be a little more, have more complicated feelings about his friendship with Paul than Paul has about Michael. We learn that Michael might be confused about his sexuality and his Devotion as a friend to Paul. He might be more in love with Paul than just love Paul. But they're young and their hormones are changing and they also have their religion. So they're not quite sure what it is that they're feeling towards each other,
SPEAKER_02what their feeling towards their religion is. This is also put to the test because there is another adult character, a female character played by Crystal Finn. And we learn from Michael that Crystal Finn is this sort of And she's sort of this idealistic Christian woman in their church. She volunteers all the time. She does right by the Lord. And we find out, oh, her adult son is in Africa helping spread the word of the Bible. And about halfway through the play,
SPEAKER_02you start to realize that this drifter Julian from the Little hints he drops about his life. Oh, that's absolutely Crystal Finn's son. And now the question is, what is the story there? And lo and behold, yes, you find out that it is her son. He never was in Africa. He is a drug addict. And she and her husband were saying that to cover for him and to kind of evade shame and ridicule from the community. But her husband is now dead and her son has returned because he wants to get clean
SPEAKER_02and wants help. But She's not sure if that's something that she can do. And then Michael and Paul fight sort of about the drifter and about their friendship. And that's kind of the end of the play. This is similar to, well, I'll let you go in the sense that it feels very slice of lifey. It has a lot of humor to it. It has a lot of intimate, I think he wants to write a bit more of something like The Humans, but not something as weird, something a little more life-affirming.
SPEAKER_02I think that there are bumps in this play, primarily in dialogue. The scene between Crystal Finn's Judy and her son Julian is a little rough sauce for me just in terms of the actual composition of the dialogue. But I do like a lot of the dialogue between Michael and Paul. I think it's very realistic and I think it is incredibly insightful. The young boys who play those roles, you know, they're young. They are very good at sort of being within their own skin and not really... Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I think that Julius Renzel as Paul is probably a bit more effective for me than Ivan Howe's Michael, but both are good. I'm just not really one for child actors. I think that Crystal Finn as Judy is really kind of the standout performance for me in the show. I think she's really quite fantastic. I think this could be up for play at something like the Lortels or Off-Broadway play for Drama Desks. It's solid. It's a solid entry. I think I liked Well I'll Let You Go a
SPEAKER_01little more. The Saviors, for me, was a more
SPEAKER_02engaging first half. Whereas Well, I'll Let You Go took a long time for me to simmer. But once we got to the end of Well, I'll Let You Go, it really hit me. This one is solid. I think that it could be up for play. I think Crystal Finn could get remembered towards the end of the season. And the lighting also is very... We have Heated Rivalry next at number two. I won't say more about that other than you can listen to my review of it. I think it's a really, really, really strong parody musical and a strong musical overall. At number one, we have Birthright, which just ended its run at MCC.
SPEAKER_02Rumor is that it's coming to Broadway in the spring. This is by Jonathan Spector, who wrote Eureka Day. And it follows a group of friends who meet on a birthright trip to Israel circa 2006. It's three acts. Each act is about 10 years later. So act one is 2006. Act two is like September or October of 2016. And then the The third act is June of 2024. And yes, act three is very much dedicated to the state of Israel and the rise of anti-Semitism,
SPEAKER_02but also the conflicted feelings of progressive Jews living in America who maybe feel like Helpless, but also want to defend their Judaism, but also can't agree with what's going on in Israel, but also fight over whether the discuss of free Palestine is actually humane or if it's anti-Semitism that's disguised as progressiveness. That's the third act. The first two acts really are not about that at all. The first two acts, and I would argue the play as a whole,
SPEAKER_02is more focused on this friend group and
SPEAKER_01is interested in sort of Exploring what happens to friends over
SPEAKER_02time as the world shifts and as more technology comes into play. Obviously, one friend ends up moving to Israel in 2016 and they all kind of go across the country. And texting and emails and Facebook and Instagram can make you... Act 3 is a really smart and well-executed depiction of how smartphones have ruined the one-on-one.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Everyone starts the play thinking they know exactly what they want.
SPEAKER_02They're 23. The world is their oyster. And then 10 years later, they're a little wiser. They're a little more toughened. And they think now that they've been beaten up a bit, but also have had their own successes, that they really can go back into the world and do what they want. But also they are a lot wiser to their friends now and they're less idealized. And then the third act is sort of like, huh. We kind of are all battered beyond recognition, but also we do have this long bond and is our friendship now purely because we have
SPEAKER_02so much time with each other, the sunken cost of that, or do we really have This bond that is unshakable. Because without giving any spoilers, because again, this play might be coming in the spring and I want people to experience the story fresh. And, and, and, and,
SPEAKER_02It might make you more informed, but it only makes you more informed to a degree, and it makes you lose part of the person you once were or the person you could currently be with the person in front of you, because you would rather be right and you would rather be the most moral than actually be amongst people. And I think that this play deals with that in a very humane way, in a very humorous way. It's also incredibly funny. And this is Jonathan Spector who did Eureka Day, right?
SPEAKER_02He's not going to write a play that tells an audience this is how you should be feeling about Israel, about Gaza, about Judaism. Everyone has a mentality about it. That's not even just Gaza-specific, that is about anything in this world. Every time you think you have all the information, somebody comes along and drops a truth bomb on you, and vice versa. You want to always be open to learning and to being proven wrong for the sake of doing something right. In order to do right,
SPEAKER_02you have to acknowledge that you may not always be right, and if you want other people to pivot their frame of mind, you have to be open to it as well. And that's something that Spectre really specializes in with something like this and with Eureka Day. And I think he's actually better with it in this than with Eureka Day. Eureka Day is a more funny play. It's far more of a satire. But Birthright, I think, is a genuine piece in a way that Eureka Day for me was like two steps away from being a genuine play.
SPEAKER_02There's nothing in this that has like the same high as that Zoom call in Eureka Day. But I think that's because Birthright for me is just far more successful consistently in a way that Eureka Day was not. But that's Birthright. And that's sort of all I have to say about that. I think this is going to be up for play and director set, which is weird to say, but it's a really wonderful set. I think that Zoe Winters and Nate Mann will be considered as will... And I think this is like a shoe in front ensemble at Drama Desk.
SPEAKER_02It's just everyone is so connected to each other. So that's it with the review roundup. I hope that you all enjoyed it. As I said, I've been rather rusty. I have to edit this now and hopefully get it down to a nice tight two minutes. Joking, joking, joking. So we're going to take a little bit of a break and we come back. You can enjoy my talk with Matt Roden. So enjoy my talk with Matt Roden.
SPEAKER_00Please welcome for the first time to Broadway Breakdown, Matt Roden.
SPEAKER_03And then it feels like there should be applause. Like there should be some sort of like a track. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think if I'm going to be really shady, it's going to be like the kind of slow clap where half the audience knows who you are. And the other half is like, I thought this was Carolee Carmelo. What are we?
SPEAKER_03And that is the tea. That is the tea. I feel I constantly am assuming that nobody knows who I am, which somewhat is a better way to go through the world. Like to just have a baseline of like, oh, no, nobody knows me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I go that mentality as well. It has only bitten me in the ass once or twice, but I'm sure that's never happened to you.
SPEAKER_03No, I haven't had any negative experiences yet,
SPEAKER_01but I'm sure they'll come. So you're a professional actor, but anyone who knew you before
SPEAKER_02Company or All the Worlds of Stage or Bo, we all saw you on the red carpet doing theater games with Broadway actors. So most of us knew you as a personality theater fan, which I think even though your performing success has taken off, you still are that to your core.
SPEAKER_03Oh my gosh, totally. I mean, that's what it is at the end of the day is like, I'm a grown up theater kid, you know? I just was obsessed with all things theater growing up. All I ever wanted to do was to be a part of the community. And when I moved to New York, I went to school for musical theater in Boston at the Boston Conservatory. And when I moved to New York, I was determined to finagle my way in. I got an internship at 54 Below when I moved to the city and And yeah, it took a couple of years for me to like find my footing. But by the time I landed at Playbill,
SPEAKER_03which was before Broadway.com, I felt like, okay, there's something here. Those red carpets, which basically for anyone who doesn't know, I was doing mini games basically. It was like Billy on the Street. Before there were all these sort of man on the street series happening on TikTok, there was Billy on the Street. And then again, I saw a window of opportunity that most of these red carpets were doing these traditional interviews that You were getting 18 seconds with somebody you couldn't actually get a real conversation in. And so I felt like maybe there was something fun.
SPEAKER_03And these opening nights are supposed to be celebratory. And so I felt like this is a good way to introduce play and lightness and fun and give the people that are performing and the guests something to look forward to. And that's what started happening. I mean, I did it for four or five years and we did over like 150 of them. And it became... Yeah, something that people were excited about that when they saw me on the carpet, they were excited to get to do it. And my hope was always that I would be able to, for lack of a better phrase, like cross the rope that like there would I would get to be on the other side of
SPEAKER_03that, that I'd get to perform and be on stage and that people would go, oh, my God, I didn't know you did that, too. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think Moulin Rouge had shut down on like Tuesday or Wednesday. And then by Thursday, all the shows were done. And yeah, I'm so, so proud of what that is. And like, it's so nice to have that as like a calling card that like that was a thing that I got to do and accomplish. And in retrospect, especially like with where I am now and the theater games thing that I'm doing now, which we'll talk about, like you said, I'm The truth is, I was always making theater games. That was always part of my DNA.
SPEAKER_03That one happened on red carpets. This one is happening digitally now. But the game piece around theater has always been a part of me. I was an improv referee in high school. I was not playing the improv games. I was reffing the improv games. So I was always sort of a game organizer. And yeah, I'm like, I feel... And those games, the Red Carpet Challenge, were just an expression of love, you know what I mean, of this art form and...
SPEAKER_03And the community and the fact that I got to highlight people's personalities in a way that's different than like them just answering questions about like, what do you hope people take away from the show? Which is fine, but annoying after you asked that the fifth time. This was a way to like actually give people a little bit of a breather and give us as an audience a way of seeing someone in a different light, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it's because the listeners now really know who you are through how you speak about something else, not like what you're personally working on. Yes, so well said. Yeah, people learn more about Erica Henningsen because she tells you what character in Seussical she wants to be, not because of how she feels playing Sandra Dee in Just In Time.
SPEAKER_03That is exactly right. And so that's what the games were an expression of, you know, that like it was an opportunity to see someone with their guard down and a little bit sort of like thrown off their thrown off their their center a little bit in a good way.
SPEAKER_02Which is and I also want to not to kiss your ass too much, but I want to express how really hard that is to do with Broadway actors on red carpets because people are guarded in Hollywood for sure. But also there's this thing of. Once the movie is done, that actor has been paid. Whatever happens when the movie happens, they're on to another project already. There's a little bit of freedom of I can sort of be a little crazy. And with Broadway, like this is your current job and you're only getting paid as long as the show runs. And if you're out there being a fool or like spouting your mouth and being honest
SPEAKER_02about how you feel about maybe a troubled production, like that's not going to be great. And you'll get a black mark on you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no one has ever said that before. And I think that's really true. And I think that's true of people that weren't in the shows too, because again, we are a community that lives primarily in a scarcity mindset, especially actors. It's like, we're like waiting for the next thing to come. And so there's always a fear of how we're being perceived in a way that's a little more delicate than probably Hollywood is, because it just feels like that any job can come and go at any time. And so you're right that there are people that There is like a guard up in a new way, but I really appreciate you saying that.
SPEAKER_03And the thing is, once we started doing it more, people started to understand that it wasn't about having the right answers. It's about the personality and having fun. That's the thing that's actually going to make you look the best in these videos. It's going to make people like you even more. It's also...
SPEAKER_02I really love talking shop about this kind of stuff. I am also a theater freak. I love talking about a show for three hours and having crazy takes and making weird jokes. Because ultimately, that is why we all got into this community. Because... It's very rare to do Broadway and get rich unless you are the writer of a mega hit or you become like one of those over the title stars that can just be in something every season. That's right. This is not where you're going to get rich quick. And so a lot of it has to come from passion.
SPEAKER_02And. You don't have to be me. I always say this. Like, you don't have to be a straight dude in a musical theater and know who won the Tony for Best Actress in a Musical in 1972. That's a me thing. I understand you don't have to do that, Kyle Selleck. But, like, you know, know a couple of shows, know a couple of writers. It's why I always get a little miffed when theater actors, like, are asked stuff and they go, oh, I don't really know much about, like, the history. I just sort of do it. I'm like, ask a football player their favorite football player from the past. They won't say that. They won't give you that answer.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think most theater actors, even if they're not theater fans or theater kids, there is some affinity for the work that we do. There has to be in order to commit to something like this. Because like you said, it's not a fruitful endeavor most of the time. It's more for the game, if anything.
SPEAKER_01So what was it that made you fall in love with theater? Was it a specific show? Was it a gradual situation? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think, I mean, it started for me at about like four, three or four. There was that VHS of Mary Martin playing Peter Pan, and it just lived on loop in my house. And then my parents took me to see Joseph at the local high school, and that was it for me. I mean, the combination of those two things really sort of set me spinning, and I think a huge part of me loved the fact that I found something that got me praise. I found something that like... Got people's eyes on me and made me feel whole and powerful and strong.
SPEAKER_03And then as I started doing theater, I found the community and I found the people around me and I found that, you know, like any obsession that you have. Right. Like if you're obsessed with like murder documentaries, there's a giant community there. When you find people that you can talk like we talk about the things that we love, you feel less alone. And that was ultimately, I think, what sort of sealed the deal for me. Was that I felt I now I have found my people, you know what I mean? I know my people.
SPEAKER_03And the fact that I've gotten to stay a part of this thing for 30 years of my 34 years, I'm 34 years old, but probably 30 years I've been in feel like a Community member. It's incredible. And now, again, with the internet, we now have more access to that than we've ever had before. We are a larger and wider community than we've ever been. It's not so isolated. Now it's like global, it feels like.
SPEAKER_01And now there's no excuse for theater fans to not
SPEAKER_02be knowledgeable, in my humble opinion.
SPEAKER_03I guess that's true.
SPEAKER_02Sorry, I'm being a little more cynical about that take, but I agree with you. I will find sometimes... But what do you mean by knowledgeable? What does that mean to you?
SPEAKER_01So, I guess it also depends on what we mean by a theater fan.
SPEAKER_02There are people who enjoy going to the theater. They do it casually. They'll always see a few things. They'll know the name Sondheim, things like that. That's one thing. The people who... Claim to be theater fans who see multiple shows who try to stay up on top of Broadway and just like don't understand basic principles of how the industry works or like don't know shows beyond 1995. What I've learned with my time of one of the things that actually shaped this podcast was me listening to movie podcasts because I found
SPEAKER_02that a lot of theater podcasts either were people who And it's one of those things where theater fans...
SPEAKER_02What they choose to be knowledgeable about are much smaller things than most movie fans that I have found.
SPEAKER_01And maybe I'm exaggerating here, but every time I keep branching out to look at movie Reddits or Substacks or whatever,
SPEAKER_02it's these people who really get into the nitty-gritty of it all. And the only reason why it bugs me with theater people is when a show announces its closing... The conspiracy theories online from supposed theater fans, I'm like, you haven't been paying attention to the grosses of this show. You don't understand the financials of this show.
SPEAKER_03There's a bigger picture of play. I totally agree with that. I think, you know, this is the same reason why I say like. If you go to a coarse restaurant, the chef will come out and explain to you why they picked the ingredients that they did. And the dish is going to hypothetically taste better because you know where the ingredients came from and why the ingredients were chosen. Ignorance is not bliss. Like the more that you know... The more you can appreciate the thing. So, you know, I'm thankful because I have this marketing experience. I have all this PR experience.
SPEAKER_03I have this press experience. My husband is a talent agent. He was a casting director. I'm also an actor. I have many friends who are lead producers and co-producers of Broadway shows. My view of the industry, I really try to keep it 360. I really want to have a whole understanding because when something like that, like a show closing comes up, there's so many pieces and parts to it that... And I'm just such a fan of nuance.
SPEAKER_03You know what I mean? I love nuance so much. And maybe that's like me avoiding picking Elaine. But I tend to find that nothing really is black and white. Most things live in the gray. Yeah. I think that's partially what theater is about. It's that it's about showcasing the humanity of a person or a story or a moment or a thing and showing all the sides of it. I mean, the stupid example I can give you is that we've been listening to Hamilton. Over the last two days,
SPEAKER_03my husband and I, just because we were just like, oh, let's put on some show tunes and we put on Hamilton. And I've just been thinking a lot about the fact that like Hamilton is not a character that is made to be a hero. Like he is a flawed individual and he does some really shitty stuff in the context of the piece. Like they make all the characters flawed. Like nobody is perfect. And I think that. Sort of like just the nuanced view of a character. I think we can carry over into the industry as a whole and the way that we
SPEAKER_03as fans interact with the industry that I think we all have to like push ourselves to like look at the bigger picture and have a deeper understanding. Because again, like it makes the experience of going to the theater and seeing a show and watching a show go from a workshop all the way to a broad production. It makes the experience that richer because you understand what it takes to get there. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01I've said before, our morality has become binary. That's right. That's so well said. That's so well said, Matt. Thank you. Sometimes I write, Matt, just so you know. I'm not just a talker. But no, that's just
SPEAKER_02how it is. And the only time that people aren't binary about morality is when it comes to their own mistakes. So it's so judgmental and official with everyone else. But the moment you do something, not only is it a, well, no, treat me with respect. It's No, I acted how I thought I should and I did nothing wrong and I'm actually the victim here. And I'm like, okay, if you live in this world for as many years as you do and you are a person of this world, you are going to make a mistake and you are going to hurt somebody,
SPEAKER_02hopefully unintentionally, but you are going to do it and you need to learn from that. Mistakes are not evil as long as you learn from them and do better, but you have
SPEAKER_01to first acknowledge that you made the mistake. A mistake. Now, Matt, having said that, I want to ask you, what's your favorite musical?
SPEAKER_03Um, I, there's a couple that I think are really great. I'm a big rank guy. That, that show was a big moment for me. It was a, it was a huge game changer in my life. Um, and helped me come into my queerness. Uh, I think Guys and Dolls is an almost perfect musical, a musical comedy. Um, that one's really, really up there for me. I'm a big Les Mis guy, big, big, big Les Mis guy. Um, So that is a huge part of my heart.
SPEAKER_03And yeah, I love Hedwig too. I mean, I think Hedwig is a show that lives again outside of the binaries in all the ways. And that's sort of what I, again, like if I say I'm a fan of nuance, that's a show that again, like just lives in so much gray that, yeah, that to me is like a home, a landing place, you know?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we did a two-part deep dive on Hedwig, and we talk about how Hedwig is charismatic and a survivor, but Hedwig is not perfect. Hedwig is not this innocent victim. Hedwig has also perpetrated casualties in their trail.
SPEAKER_03And company, by the way. I mean, I know I'm biased there, but I think company also is like, in terms of book musicals, I think that is one of the greatest book musicals ever written. He wrote a... Yeah, the music is, I mean, the Sondheim of that all is wonderful, but the book, the scenes that George Firth wrote is truly some of the best scene writing in a musical I've ever, ever experienced.
SPEAKER_01So that's the thing is when we talk about favorite,
SPEAKER_02it doesn't necessarily mean like what you think is objectively the best. It's just the ones that mean the most to you. And I always then relate it to Sondheim where I'm like, okay, you can have a favorite Sondheim musical that maybe isn't necessarily what you think is his best musical or they can equal. I also think that there's a difference between what you think is the best Sondheim musical and the best Sondheim score or your favorite Sondheim score. Totally. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And also the production matters too, by the way. Are we talking about production or are we talking about the work? Because again, those things are different too.
SPEAKER_02If you had it in your power to mount a Sondheim musical and you got your choice of cast, you got a budget that you could do, what would you mount?
SPEAKER_03I mean, the truth is that now that I'm in bed, now that I'm so in bed with company and I spent a year on that show, I really think I... If a production is good of that show, I think it is so delicious. I also think Woods, I'm such an Into the Woods fan. That show has come back into my life in a really interesting way as an adult.
SPEAKER_03I didn't get to see the Follies revival. And again, that's just a show I don't know. I thought the Merrily revival was... Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I can't believe we spent a year with Company and I could do it again. I mean, I just love that piece so much. So, so much. Well, it helps if you got one of the best songs in the show. If not the best song on the show. I'm really proud of the fact that I only ever, those lyrics were, those lyrics are in my veins at this point. Like I could do that in my sleep after a year. I could do that in my sleep. And actually I did, I think because of the length of stuff, I think I did more performances of that than both Matt and John Bailey.
SPEAKER_03I think those runs were both shorter than we were on the road.
SPEAKER_01So I got to do that song a lot. So, okay. You have a new creation. It's out in the world right now. Let's talk about it. Okay, great. The website. Give us the elevator pitch. Basically, it is
SPEAKER_03daily puzzles, like world, like connections for the New York Times, but they're all for theater things. So it started with a game called Spike, which is guessing an answer based on five clues that are hidden behind five pieces of spike tape, and they're revealed one by one, and you guess each round, and You know, based on the clue, you pick a show or you guess the show. And if you get it right, you can solve that many clues and you share it. When it started, it was just this web version and it was just Spike.
SPEAKER_03And we started, me and this co-founder that I was working with, started to realize that like we had an opportunity to actually introduce more games. So that was in April. We launched in April and we now have five games on the site. So there's Spike, which is that clue, five clues, guess and answer. There's Curtain, which is a kind of like a Wheel of Fortune type game. You're going to guess an answer based on a clue, but you'll see the sort of like layout of the letters.
SPEAKER_03You'll see the layout of the words, kind of like Hangman-ish. Okay. Then there is Reblock, which is a logic puzzle game. And that is like you'll see a three by three sort of stage of different characters and you'll tap them to swap them and you try to reset. Re-stage, re-block the scene, as it were, as fast as you can. Then there's Program, which is a putting things in order game. So that's everything from Broadway opening nights to an actor's resume to what year
SPEAKER_03the show takes place, the songs from a soundtrack or an album, putting those in order. So that's an order puzzle game. And then the fifth game, which just came out last week, is a game called George, which is for George Surratt, which we didn't even talk about Sunday in the Park. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That fucking flop?
SPEAKER_03That fucking flop. And it's a picture reveal game. So you tap on a canvas to paint dots and then you guess the image or you guess what the subject of the painting is in as few dots as you possibly can. And yeah, these new puzzles come out at midnight Eastern every single day. All five games have a new puzzle every day. Yeah. And we have no signs of stopping. We've crossed half a million plays since April. And yeah, it's interesting because it's really exploded.
SPEAKER_03And we have, I think, something like 3,000, 4,000 people playing every single day. And we are just getting started. That's the thing. It's like we're at the very, very beginning of this thing. It's only been, you know, four or five months since we started. And the fact that it's already taken on the life of its own. We haven't done any marketing other than like a couple TikToks. It's all been my word of mouth, which is very theater people-y. Yeah. Yeah. I'm really like, I'm really proud and I'm really excited and I'm having
SPEAKER_03so much fun building these games. And yeah. Yeah, I think we did a Tony's Pool, too, so we had, like, the ability to, like, you know, bet on the Tony winners, and we'll do that again next year, but there's more stuff that's sort of, like, in the works that we're working on, because I think... Similar to sort of what I did with the red carpet challenge was I saw a gap in the marketplace. I saw that there wasn't anyone doing those games on the red carpets. Now, by the way, that's all anyone does is games on red carpets.
SPEAKER_03I have played in a lot of specialties. I've done email and I've done video and I've done photo content and I've worked with shows. But the thing that I didn't see was like daily puzzle games. There are, like you said, like there are movie podcasts. There are movie games. There are music games. There are sports games. There were no theater games. And so I thought, you know what? Let's make a little batch of theater games. And I'm really, really like touched and honored that it's taken on the life that it's taken on. And Yeah,
SPEAKER_03the daily puzzles are, it's a wild thing to have to, like, make sure that we have, you know, five games have a new puzzle every single day, but we're scheduled out, like, I'm scheduled out for, like, three or four months now, so I, frankly... I am terrible at the games. My theater history and my theater knowledge is not very good. If I wasn't making the puzzles, I would be completely failing them. But I think there's a couple pieces that have been really surprising. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And this is a way of expanding your knowledge in a way that's playful and fun, like Duolingo. And then the other piece is that because, first of all, it's free for everyone, so you don't have to pay. The archives, Spike has had something like 120 puzzles at this point. You can play every single puzzle. You don't have to. It's not just today. The entire archive is available. And what we're finding is that people are going back and they're binge playing. And like you were saying, we love our history and we love learning. Hopefully you're excited about learning and this is a good way
SPEAKER_03to expand your knowledge in a way that's like playful and fun. But I love it. I'm yeah, I'm very proud.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's also I just think that theater history is so interesting and so cool to like see how we keep how like how we got here, all the things that led to whatever. So, OK, I want to test out the game with you so the listeners can sort of get a vibe. Oh, my God.
SPEAKER_03No, this is going to be bad. What do you mean it's going to be bad? You're going to see how terrible my knowledge is. You're going to see how little I know.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Well, so I'm going to go into New Game George's Year. We're not going to do that one because that's a visual one. No, it's a visual game.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I'm going into the Spike Archives. Yeah, I would go into the Spike Archives and pick some random dates. That's the way I do it. Okay, so I just, I selected June 17th for Spiked. Okay. My first one is, it premiered at the Pasadena Playhouse in 2006 and played London Palladium in 2009 before Broadway. Guess the musical. Okay, I think I'm going to do it. Pasadena and then the London Palladium. Huh. I think I know what it is.
SPEAKER_01Did you get it right? I'm going to answer it now. Let's see. Yes, I got it right. God, come on. All right, so give me the second clue because I would not have gotten it. I don't know the answer. Okay, the second clue was it opened in April 2011 on Broadway at the Broadway Theater and ran for 561 regular performances. That's also a clue that would absolutely do it for me because I'm an asshole who knows that shit. Well, that's good.
SPEAKER_03I love that. So, okay, let me think about this. What color is the tape? Do you remember what color the tape was? Green.
SPEAKER_01The tape color was green. Is there a specific theme for each color?
SPEAKER_03Typically, this is a secret hint for your listeners. Typically, the tape color is a hint in and of itself. Interesting. Typically, the tape color is associated with the show in some way. Okay. All right, so let's think here. 2011... Mm-hmm. The Broadway Theater. I will say- The only ones I'm thinking of are like Sister Act at the Broadway Theater.
SPEAKER_03Catch Me If You Can was at the Broadway.
SPEAKER_01Catch Me If You Can was not at the Broadway, but it was that season. Where was Catch Me If You Can? The Neil Simon. And I just said that without reading a goddamn thing. I just know that. Is that true? Yeah. Sister Act was at the Broadway Theater for sure. Yes. Is that the right answer? That is the right answer. Sister Act. Nice. And the color was green? That can't be true.
SPEAKER_03The color was probably
SPEAKER_01pink or purple. It's green now that I have the... Oh, it's green
SPEAKER_03because you got it right. But I'm saying the tape color.
SPEAKER_01I don't remember. Okay, sorry. I forgot what the color was when I was doing the questions. I forgot. I was focusing on winning, Matt. Yes, I understand. Okay, great. Pretty good. I got it in two.
SPEAKER_03That's pretty good. I would have gotten that. That's great.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Give me a month. Pick May. Do May. May. Okay. I'm going to do May 27th because my birthday is March 27th. So is mine. Oh, wait. Your birthday is March 27th? Yes. Shut the fuck up. This is... And your name is Matt. And my name is Matt.
SPEAKER_03You're an Aries like me, girl. No wonder.
SPEAKER_01All right. So May 27th. What is the first clue? What's the color? Purple.
SPEAKER_03It's purple. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Before booking his first Broadway show, he was working as a bar mitzvah entertainer to pay the bills. Okay, but they said he, not she, because I know that fact about Idzina Menzel, but I don't know who else would do this. Okay, so we know it's
SPEAKER_03a he. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Who is comfortable around Jewish people? Not Jonathan Groff. I'm so dead. I think I know
SPEAKER_03who it is, but I think I know because I built the puzzle, but I don't know if I know. I want to hear you guess.
SPEAKER_01I genuinely have no idea. I'm trying to think of who are singers. What age bracket would you guess? I'm not giving you clues. That's the whole point of the game. God damn it. I helped you through the Broadway theater in 2011. That was also a clue. Whatever. Whatever.
SPEAKER_03All right, so read the second clue.
SPEAKER_02Oh, okay. So I don't know yet. I have to write, guess the creative.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it's a creative. Oh, it's a creative. I guess it doesn't say actor yet. It says creative. His first Broadway show, he was working as bar mitzvah entertainer. So maybe it's a writer then? Yeah, I guess it would be like a writer or a director, perhaps. I guess. I'm going to say... I'm going to say Mark Shaman just because I feel like that's a fun one. Nope, not him. Okay. Oh, I'm like, that could be right. Oh, okay. No, I know who it is.
SPEAKER_01His Broadway debut was in the original 1992 company of Crazy For You. Oh, I know who it is. Casey Nicholaw. That's right. Yeah. Yeah. Purple is for Aladdin. Oh, that would make sense. Yep. There we go. Okay. I got it in two. That's solid. Not bad.
SPEAKER_03Not bad.
SPEAKER_01Two is very good. Okay. So that's Spike. And then how I want to go. What's another one we can do before we log off?
SPEAKER_03Another one that's able to we're able to do out loud would probably be curtain is hard without the visual, but we could do program. You could do program.
SPEAKER_01Theater games. Put something in order. Yeah. Let's go for that. Okay. Okay. Program. Here we go. Put the things in the correct order. Okay. Songs from Into the Woods in cast recording order. Oh, okay. So this is like- That's today's, right? Okay. Yes. That's today's. Okay. That's good. This is good. We could do this. So Agony is Prologged at track seven. So I guess that's like, that's the constant and I have to work everything around that. That's right. So the songs we have are No One Is Alone, I Know Things Now, Hello Little Girl, Children Will Listen, Prologue Into the Woods, Stay With Me.
SPEAKER_01I don't think it's a spoiler to say that the prologue is the beginning. Even if you don't know Into the Woods, if you know English, prologue tends to be the first thing.
SPEAKER_03How nice to get a little giveaway. How nice. How nice. Thank you. On a Monday. Thank you, Steven. On a Monday. On a Monday.
SPEAKER_01On an ordinary Monday.
SPEAKER_03Well, I will say the puzzles scale. Most of the games, not all of them, but like program is a game that like it gets harder throughout the week. So like Monday, we're giving you that. We're giving you one in that whole thing. Like the agony you said is locked. Uh, yes. At least it looks, yeah, I think it's locked. It says track seven. Yeah, that's the one that's right. Yeah, it says, so it's locked. It's like the one, it's like a give to you. And the prologue is a give too. So do that first. Um, huh.
SPEAKER_03I mean, I know children will listen at the end.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Oh, so now I see what they're doing here.
SPEAKER_02Because it says agony track seven, but I don't think that means it has to be in seventh spot. It just means that I can't ever move agony. I can move things around agony, but not agony itself. Got it.
SPEAKER_01So I believe the order is prologue into the woods. Hello, little girl. I know things now because she's got to know things about the hello, little girl. Then I believe it's agony followed by stay with me. Uh, I'm almost positive. I think that's right. Yeah. Because stay with me.
SPEAKER_02This is where we have to get into the book of it all is because the witch learns about Rapunzel's prince, but when they sing agony, he's still in the honeymoon phase. He's pining for her.
SPEAKER_03Right, right, right.
SPEAKER_02Exactly. Right. Then no one is alone. Then children will listen.
SPEAKER_03I think that's it. How fun is this game? Look at, this is a game for you. This is a, see, do you see this is a game for the, the nerds.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01This whole site is for me, Matt. That's true. You basically made a whole site just for me. That's true. How'd you do? We nailed it, 100%. First print. First print. Nothing but green, baby. That's what I'm talking about. So good. I want to do one more, and then we will wrap things up. We'll wrap things up. Okay, July 23rd. Here we go. Program. Oh, 6th. Um, speaking of your March 2020 promo.
SPEAKER_03Is it another, is it another track list? It's another track list. Don't do, don't do that. Let's find one that's an opening night.
SPEAKER_01Find one that's like an opening or a performance count or something like that. Okay. Um, I didn't, okay. So, okay, here we go. Tony Awards won, uh, original production, uh, Okay, so this is by the number of Tonys, not like in order of when they won. Okay, so Will Rogers Follies is locked with six wins. I do know that The Producers holds the record with the most Tony wins. Yes.
SPEAKER_01The Band's Visit has 10. I will always remember that because it was such an insane number that year. Yep. I'm going to say Hairspray? Maybe? That sounds right. What else is there? So the options are The Producers, The Band's Visit, Hairspray, The Pajama Game, A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder, and Catch Me If You Can. Catch Me If You Can has one singular Tony win. So that's bottom. That's easy enough. Okay, so we know that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I feel like... I feel like Bands Visit won a bunch. It did. It won like 10, 9 or 10, because that was a very weird year where the Tony voters kind of were making a statement towards SpongeBob and Frozen and Mean Girls. Right, right, right, right, right. We reject you. And so Bands Visit ended up like overperforming that night. Right, yeah, right. I was going to say, I feel like there were a lot there. Yeah, they won.
SPEAKER_02I remember because I was I was at that Tony's and it was like the one time in years they had put best book on the telecast because they thought that Tina Fey was going to win and they won her speech on the air. Oh my God, that's so funny. And then Bands Visit won. It was. Yeah. And then everyone thought that Ethan Slater or Joshua Henry were going to win.
SPEAKER_01And then Tony Shalhoub won. So it was just like the hits just kept coming. Yeah. Right. OK. I'm going to. So I'm going to say 10. Hairspray. One, two, three, four. I think Hairspray won like. I don't know why I'm saying that. I think it's a little more than that. So they have three acting wins because Marissa beat Bernadette that year, which I'm always going to be bitter about. Did Mark and Scott win? They won. Did Harvey win? Yeah, they won score. Harvey won. The score won.
SPEAKER_01The book won. Sorry, the score won. The book won. Marissa, Harvey, Dick LaTessa, they all won, so that's five. Musical is six. And then I think Jack O'Brien won for director. So... And I think they also won costumes. So somewhere between six and eight. I'm going to say let's split the difference a seven because it's got to be either one above or one below Will Rogers Follies for there to be a list here. Right. Yeah. Like ties. There's no trickery with ties here. No, no, no, no, no.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So I'm going to say Hairspray by Will Rogers Follies. Then it's Pajama Game and Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder. I think Pajama Game won a bunch. No? I think it did, too. It's that weird thing, though, of the 50s where you're like, how many categories were there at the time, again? Right, yeah, right. Because, like, they don't have orchestrations, but they do have, like, technician. Right. 50s were a weird time. You could smoke while pregnant, and you gave Tonys to the technician. Okay. Okay.
SPEAKER_01I like your instinct. Let's do Pajama Game above Gentleman's Guide. Whether it's above Will Rogers Follies, I can't tell you. I don't know. We'll find out. We'll find out. Okay, this is the order I've chosen. Producers, Bands Visit, Hairspray, Will Rogers Follies, the Pajama Game. I'm confident about the top of that list. I feel very good about the top of that list. As do I. Pajama Game, Gentleman's Guide, Catch Me If You Can. If this is incorrect, then I'm going to swap Will Rogers and Pajama Game. Okay, let's see. It'll tell you what's wrong. Yeah. One, two, three.
SPEAKER_01Oh, no. Pajama Game and Gentleman's Guide were wrong. I needed to swap them. Gentleman's Guide. Okay. Then Pajama Game. Interesting. There we go. Now we're done. Pajama Game only had three wins? Wow. I'm going to Wikipedia for that bullshit. Oh, here. Now you're going to fact check me. Here we go. Not going to fact check you. I want to know why it is that Mandela affected them having like nine Tonys. Okay. Okay. So I almost got it right. Guys, I'm not perfect. I'm human. I make mistakes.
SPEAKER_03No, but you know what? Two prints, getting in two is pretty darn good, too. Thank you. Because that means that you got everything else right.
SPEAKER_01They only won three. They won musical, they won featured actress in a musical for Carol Haney, and they won choreography for Bob Fosse. How about that? How about that? Okay, that's it. I've learned. I've learned something today. And that is all
SPEAKER_03I want, is I'm just hoping to educate the masses and indoctrinate more theater fans,
SPEAKER_01if nothing else. And guys, if I can learn something from this site, you can learn something from this site. And there it is.
SPEAKER_03There it is. And by the way, you don't have to be a crazy nerd in order to play
SPEAKER_01the games because you can
SPEAKER_03learn.
SPEAKER_01That's the whole point. Even a crazy nerd like me can't always get it in one. Sometimes you got to make the mistake, make the error. You'll learn from it. And then I can slay it the next time around. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Mm hmm. Yep. I'll always remember that Pajama Game only won three Tonys that year. But you know what? That's okay. That's okay. But now you know. You know what I mean? Now you'll know forever. Exactly. Now you won't judge me the next time. And I really appreciate that. That's all it is about.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Matt, this has been so delightful. Thank you so much for sharing your passion and this website with us. It's a phenomenal tool, and I'm really excited for theater fans to
SPEAKER_03play with it. It's in the App Store, so you can actually download it on your phone as an app. It's not just the website. You can obviously go to theater.games, but there also is an iPhone app, so if you're wanting to play on the go, you can.
SPEAKER_01No, that's important to know. Yes, it's on the App Store, so go for the apps. And where can people find you if you want them to find you?
SPEAKER_03Ah, Google me. That's what I tell people. I'm like, just Google me. I'm like, you know, I'm all over the internet. I mean, I'm on Instagram, who is Matt Rodin. But yeah, if you search up Google or YouTube, you'll find some, I'm sure you'll find some gems somewhere.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Absolutely. Guys, if you want to follow me, I'm on Instagram, mattkoplik, usual spelling. If you like the podcast, nice five-star rating or review always helps with the algorithm. Make sure to join the Patreon, the Broadway Breakdown Green Room, become a company member for just $5 a month. That is a bagel with cream cheese. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Matt, we close out every episode with a nice Broadway diva that we put in post. What Broadway diva would you like to close out for your episode today? There's only one. There's only one. Bernadette Peters, Always and Forever. Always and Forever. Do you have a specific track you'd like to do or do you want to be surprised? I like being surprised. I like being surprised. Yeah. The best Bernadette Peters is the one that surprises you. It's true. All right. So that's it. Thank you so much, guys, for sticking around. I hope you enjoyed this bonus episode for August. You know, even though we're dark, I like to give you guys a little something something.
SPEAKER_01So, yeah, enjoy the rest of your summer, everyone. Thank you, Matt. And take it away, Bernie. Bye.
SPEAKER_00It's a grand night. The moon is flying high and somewhere a bird who is bound will be heard. There's throwing its heart at the sky. It's a grand night for singing.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...