Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Matt’s London Trip (aka WE’RE BACK!)

Oct 10, 20262 hr 4 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Matt went to London and saw 8 shows. Also…we’re back!!!! Take a journey as Matt struggles to travel anywhere and wipes himself out seeing more shows than he had days in England. Important Links: * Broadway Breakdown Discord: Join Here * Broadway Breakdown Green Room (Patreon): Join Here * Broadway Breakdown Substack: Join Here * Broadway Breakdown Youtube: Join Here Time Stamps: 2:00 Voting for the next Deep Dives 5:30 Matt and London: A History 9:54 Midnight at the never Get 25:30 Avenue Q 35:33 Sinatra 52:42 How the Other Half Loves 1:06:21 Cats 1:15:13 Kimberly Akimbo 1:25:02 The Producers 1:35:48 Thelma and Louise 1:59:40 What’s Next This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_01bring a banana and Hello,

SPEAKER_00all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the deal, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the We have had exclusive episodes on the Green Room, but even so...

SPEAKER_00I'm sorry. Mostly off-Broadway at this point. We have our first slew of Broadway shows coming up soon and you will get reviews for all of it. You will get reviews for Paranormal Activity, Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls Play, Other Desert Cities, The Imaginary Invalid, 860, plus many, many more.

SPEAKER_00We'll also do some off-Broadway reviews of Slam Frank and Soon and a few other things I've seen since coming back from London. Delirium, Ectoplasm, Anon, things like that. Degenerates. And this is all important because this episode is actually about my famous London trip. We took another trip to London this calendar year. Usually we do about one, but now we did two. And this is our first solo trip to London. And we're going to get into all of the things that I saw there, what I thought of them.

SPEAKER_00Many people like to ask anything that we think could maybe come over to New York at any point. And so I'll discuss all of that with you as well. But final thing before we get to all of that, a little bit of housekeeping, I suppose. If you haven't noticed, we haven't done a deep dive in a while. We've wrapped up our last series of deep dives and it's been a minute since we did them. We will continue to do them as we start releasing reviews from the season and then we'll start doing some early Tony coverage. I'm going to bring on some new Drama Desk friends to talk about the Drama Desks and Deep Dives

SPEAKER_00And I was wondering what it should be that, you know, the theme is or how do I go about picking them? And the idea of doing another artist series is fun, but I couldn't really think of the artist that I wanted to do. We could do like a Jerry Herman, I suppose. We could do sort of a whole renewal of the Sondheim series, bring on new guests and do a whole new diving into all of those shows. Or we could, you know, make it a vote for the listeners. But I think that's going to be a deep dive series in the future.

SPEAKER_00But what I wanted to kind of harp on was another grab bag, another listener based voting system for the next series of deep dives. And so if you have been a company member of the Green Room, you already know this, you know, because the company members on the Green Room, a.k.a. the Broadway Breakdown Patreon, were able to submit their choices early for the deep dive selections. But if you're listening now on Main, first of all, welcome me back.

SPEAKER_00It's been a minute. But what you can do is if you don't want to join the green room and don't get any that exclusive content, but what you can still do is you can join the Discord channel with all the other Broadway Breakdown listeners. I think we have almost 400 on the Discord at this point, which isn't nearly the number of listeners we have for the podcast itself. That's just how many people have done the Discord. But You can go into the podcast channel on the Discord site. The link will be in the episode description here.

SPEAKER_00And you can put in your votes for the next Deep Dive series. Now you get up to five votes. I... You would probably want to do a minimum of three because there are three things you have to absolutely consider when submitting. One is you have to submit a movie that is adapted from a musical. You have to submit a musical that is adapted from a movie and you have to submit a play. Your final two can be anything you want. They can be two more plays, two musicals, two movie musicals.

SPEAKER_00There's been a surprising lack of Muppet movie musicals in the Green Room submission so far, but a lot of submissions for August Osage County and The Pillow Man and Women on the Verge of a Nervous Breakdown and Hairspray and the like. So if you want to submit again for Grab Bag, now is your chance. The link for the Discord is in the episode description here. You can click the link, you can join the Discord, and you can put in your... Five choices for Grab Back Indie Podcast channel while you're listening to this episode.

SPEAKER_00So again, that is one movie adapted from a musical, one musical adapted from a movie, and a play, and then two more at your discretion, whatever you want to do. Okay. All of that out of the way. Let's get to London. As I said, this was my first solo trip to London. I've always gone with a family member. I've gone with my father twice, my sister once, my mother three times. Actually, my mother and my sister. And then a family trip was my very first trip when I was nine years old or 10 years old. I can't remember. But famously, that was the first trip where I saw...

SPEAKER_00Starlight Express. And I saw Mamma Mia before I came to America. And I hated it when I was 10 because I didn't know who Appa was. I didn't get why the songs were famous. I didn't get why people were singing along. And I thought it was the worst audience behavior I had ever seen. Oh, how little I knew at that time. I have since changed my tune on Mamma Mia. I quite adore it. But so my trip to London was in September and I went mostly because Yeah.

SPEAKER_00So that's why we chose sort of the week that we chose. Getting to London already was a bit of a shitshow. The day that I was flying out, wouldn't you know it, was the day that Heathrow and most major airports in the UK were having a meltdown.

SPEAKER_00There was some sort of computer blip. I think like all of the systems were down for about an hour or two, which isn't the longest. But what happened was with that glitch, All of the flights that were going in and out of Heathrow had to get, you know, rearranged or pushed back. And so I think it was up to 2,000 flights that were either canceled or rerouted. And my flight was one of the flights that got canceled. And I didn't know what was happening. I just got a notification at,

SPEAKER_00I think, like 4 o'clock in the afternoon that my flight had been canceled. My flight was supposed to be for 10 o'clock. And I had been immediately rebooked for... Like Friday morning or something. And I didn't know what was happening. I was like, why am I missing two and a half days of my trip? Why can't I get an earlier flight? I ultimately was able to get everything rearranged. I flew out a day later. I was able to extend my trip by a day, which was actually it worked out quite nicely. And I did make it to London. Once I got to the airport, once I got on the plane, everything was hunky-dory.

SPEAKER_00There was no turbulence. There was no trouble getting into Heathrow. There was no trouble taking the tube from Heathrow to Kensington, which is where I was staying. The only two kind of bumps in the changing of everything was that my flight back from London because I pushed everything back a day. I wasn't able to have the airline just move my flight back a day because they're like, well, this wasn't our fault. This was Heathrow's fault, which is fair. That is fair. So I had to pay the difference for the new flight, which wasn't.

SPEAKER_00It was not a small fee. It was not the amount of a full month's rent, but it was more than a couple of fancy dinners at Le Cirque. We'll put it that way. And my hotel did not accommodate me for an extra day. They basically were like, you can get a different room, a much bigger, nicer room, but it's going to be three times what you were paying per night. And luckily, my friend Steve, who many of you know, if you are members of the green room, you listen to him on the podcast. Fantasy drafts for leading actress in a musical Tony winners. Or if you are listeners of the Golden Girls Deep Dive podcast with Jennifer Smart

SPEAKER_00and Patrick Hines, Steve has been on that many a time. He's referred to as Graham Cracker Crust. Steve was overlapping with me on my last two days in London. I think his first two or three days of a week-long trip. But I ended up staying with Steve on my last night. And so that's why you gotta have friends, as Bette Midler once sang. All of that drama aside, I'm sure many people are like, we're getting to the 10-minute mark, we haven't gone to a single goddamn show. I'm sorry, but I think this part of my travels is also incredibly fascinating.

SPEAKER_00The first show up was Midnight at the Never Get at the Menier Chocolate Factory. Those of you who listen to the podcast have heard me say Meniere many a time. I get to London, my friend Tom, who works at the National, was like, bitch, what you talking about? It's the Meniere, it's French. And then my other friend Steve, not Steve Tipton, but other friend who I saw Avenue Q with, we'll get to that. He also was like, yeah, what are you talking about? It's the Meniere, it's French. And so I went, okay, I guess I'm an uncultured fuck then, like my listeners. So Midnight at the Never Gap. Many at Chocolate Factory,

SPEAKER_00for those of you who might be unfamiliar or need a little refresher, you can see the little timeline of shows on the back of the program. If you're watching this on YouTube, you can see the little timeline here. We've had many a revival come to Broadway from the Meniere that have done extremely well here. The very first one was the Sunday in the Park with George that had the projections everywhere. That was really beautiful production. The revivals of A Little Night Music and La Caja Fall also came from the Meniere. The Cynthia Erivo Color Purple. And then most recently, the Jonathan Groff Merrily We Roll Along came from the Meniere.

SPEAKER_00They've had other revivals that transferred to the West End that we didn't get. Like they had a little shop of horrors that transferred. They had a sweet charity that transferred. The Meniere is a very well-respected theater. They also have the producers, which we will talk about in a second. But the thing about the Meniere is that it's technically off West End. I don't believe the theater itself is ever eligible for Olivier's. It's an incredibly intimate space. I think a little under 200 seats. A lot of the seatings is actually couches. Oh, and the baker's wife that we had with Ariana DeBose, that was technically speaking a transfer from the Meunier as well.

SPEAKER_00Again, very intimate. They're... Their specialty is sort of stripped down musicals. So a lot of shows that we have seen large productions of, like La Cage, like The Color Purple, like The Producers, they do sort of as intimate as possible. And sometimes it works really well, sometimes it doesn't. They also do plays. They've done Byron Seller and Dracula, Comedy of Terrors. And this is, I think, the first... I guess that's kind of a loaded statement because the Color Purple was

SPEAKER_00the very first time Color Purple was done in London when Menier did it, so... Okay, take everything back I said. I'm just an uncultured fuck. Point is, they do more intimate versions of musicals. And Midnight at the Never Get is a London debut for them.

SPEAKER_00We've had it in the States twice. The York Theatre Company did it in New York at one point, and then The Signature in Virginia did it. It is a piece by Mark Sonnenblick, Book, Music, and Lyrics. Mark is probably best known for being one of the co-writers of K-pop Demon Hunters. He co-wrote Golden, which he won an Oscar for. The show was conceived by Sonnenblatt, as well as Sam Bolin and Max Friedman. It is directed by David Cromer and starring Ben Platt. The premise. So also I cannot really talk about a lot of these shows without going into spoilers.

SPEAKER_00So if you really, really don't want any spoilers for any of these things, I'm sorry, but you might have to skip this episode. Otherwise, please continue to listen to the London Travels. The show follows Ben Platt, who plays a character named Trevor, and we are in the Never Get, which is a nightclub. And the design of the space is very environmental. So in addition to us peeing on these couches with little... Cabaret lamps sort of next to us.

SPEAKER_00There are also a bunch of nightclub tables on the floor and then Platt is on stage with the piano. There's a curtain and frosted mirrors that eventually reveal about an eight-piece band. A lot of moody, intimate lighting of yellows and blues and very smoky, very vintage aesthetic lighting. And what we learn is that In this moment, a man named Arthur, who we learn was a very, very famous composer... Wrote many hit songs, won Grammys and Oscars.

SPEAKER_00He has just died. And they're doing this really magnificent, opulent tribute for this composer Arthur Uptown, presumably Carnegie Hall. But here downtown at this rundown club that wasn't officially a gay club, but also wasn't wasn't a gay club called the Never Get is where Trevor is honoring Arthur in his own way and telling the story of how he knew Arthur. And what we learn is that Trevor and Arthur were lovers. Trevor was fresh off the bus in New York meets Arthur at a club

SPEAKER_00and their shared love of the American songbook and classic music because they came of age in the late 60s. A, when it was illegal to be gay, where many covert gay spots would be owned by the mafia, and the mafia and the police had sort of a deal where when the police needed to meet their quotas of arrests or raids, they would sort of schedule these raids and fine these men so that way their names wouldn't get down in the papers that they were raided and outed

SPEAKER_00as gay. But Trevor and Arthur meet at one of these spots, and because it's the late 60s of sort of the Burt Bacharach and the Beatles and rock music is coming on the scene, Arthur and Trevor do not like this. And so through their friendship and romantic relationship... Arthur is inspired by his love for Trevor to write all of these really beautiful songs in the style of the American Songbook. A little bit of Burt Bacharach in there as well. And Trevor performs them at the Never Get.

SPEAKER_00And what's important is that all of these songs are very obviously homosexual. It is Trevor singing about a man he loves. And while they are getting very popular for their pond, there is an opportunity for them to expand, to get bigger. But all of these record labels and big producers want them to change the pronouns. So that way they are not queer. They are Trevor will be singing about love for women and both Trevor and Arthur say no.

SPEAKER_00At some point, Arthur caves. And starts to pursue opportunities without Trevor. They start to go long distance as this is also happening. Stonewall happens. And while the country does not overwhelmingly turn positive on homosexuality, it definitely takes a major step forward. And over the years... Trevor and Arthur watch sort of from the sidelines as the country evolves with its perception of homosexuality. Trevor, who always remains open and who he is, but never quite as successful as Arthur.

SPEAKER_00Meanwhile, Arthur, the further away he gets from Trevor, eventually sort of cuts himself off from him. Starts to live a life of heterosexuality, marries women multiple times, and from what we understand from the little that Trevor has seen of Arthur over the years, which is like every 10 to 15 years, if at all, and always sort of in passing, Arthur just sort of looks older and more withered and as if the lie that he's living is starting to eat away at him.

SPEAKER_00And for all of the success he's having that Trevor is not, in some ways, Trevor is more successful than Arthur by living his truth. And this night, while both honoring the work that Arthur wrote with Trevor in the way that he always intended, it is also Trevor kind of... Grappling with all of the questions he has about Arthur that he never got answers to. Of why it was that Arthur truly left him. There is an actor by the name of Gregor Milne who plays the piano for Ben Platt but

SPEAKER_00then also stands in as Arthur when Trevor is reenacting certain moments with Arthur from their past. And... And he's also very aware of everything that Arthur is saying or that Gregor Milne, as Arthur is saying, is not always accurate. Sometimes it is he's acknowledging this is how I remember it, but I can't be sure if this was truly what happened. And then other times it is the Self-defeatist,

SPEAKER_00depressive side of Trevor's brain that is imagining what Arthur is saying to him. Very harsh, mean things that Arthur is saying to him that could have happened or could not have happened. And it's just a manifestation of that part of Trevor's brain, which I think many of us can relate to when, especially in matters of the heart, if somebody has broken your heart and sort of left you with all of these questions, you're sitting there going like, I don't You're trying to put the pieces together and you imagine every single situation that this other person might have been in

SPEAKER_00to leave you as such. And sometimes you want to imagine that person in a positive light that it really pained them to leave you this way. Other times you imagine that this person had no qualms about leaving you this way and they're very happy about it and they think very little of you. And so that is sort of where Trevor is kind of always at in this show as he's going through all of these memories of Arthur. And if you're wondering, well, when is this taking place and how old is this character supposed to be? Why is Ben Platt doing this? Now we get to a twist. There is a reveal where as we get towards the end of the show,

SPEAKER_00the lights go out for a moment and when they come back up like 15 seconds later, Platt is gone and an actor by the name of Barry James, who is... In his early 70s, stands exactly where Ben Platt had stood, in Ben Platt's clothing. And we realize this the entire time, as Trevor is performing, it's actually been Barry James, this much older man, singing. But because of the nature of this show, which is, I described it in the Green Room episode as sort of like, Hedwig and the Angry Inch meets Call Me By Your Name with...

SPEAKER_00The American songbook music thrown in there, like the Des Duran songs and maybe Happy Ending. And because of everything that he's reliving in this show, in a lot of ways, he is sort of... So, we learn that this is not...

SPEAKER_00A continuity error. This is a very intentional artistic choice. And then it gets a little Follies-esque where Platt and James sing together and do sort of like a duet of singing a song called It's My Song. It may not be pretty. The rhymes may not be great, but it is my song. And ultimately, it is the character of Trevor reclaiming his own place in the world and his own self rather than defining his whole life by the Romantic

SPEAKER_00and artistic partnership he had with a great artist and all of the questions and pain that he was left with and while remaining true to his self, never being able to shake himself free of the shadow of Arthur. I found this to be an incredibly beautiful and moving experience, which is all the more impressive considering I was going through jet lag like a motherfucker watching this show. This was the first show I saw.

SPEAKER_00After landing, I landed at like, I want to say 9 a.m. I slept an hour and a half on the plane, even though I tried to sleep more. I had been up since 5 a.m. so I could be tired for the airplane. Didn't really work. I didn't have a chance to take a nap. I got to my hotel. I showered. I went to Notting Hill and went through Portobello Road Market just to make sure that there was nothing there that I wanted. There never really is. That market's kind of a bit of a junkyard, if you're asking me. And I walked through Hyde Park and, you know, Tom and my friend Tom, who I went with, you know, we got dinner beforehand.

SPEAKER_00We had some wine. And the moment we sit down and Meniere does not in the past and not have terribly comfy couches, but they clearly have swapped them out in the last 16, 17 years, because while the couches are not exactly super plush and luxurious, they are far more comfortable. And sitting in those couches with this like low, moody cabaret lighting and then 100 minutes of like Mostly smooth jazz. I just, in the first five minutes, I was like, oh no, oh no, this is going to be so bad. And I told Tom, I was like, you need to check in on me.

SPEAKER_00And if you see me starting to fade, just like a little whoop, you need to pinch me hard anywhere, which he did from time to time, but not always. And so I would often pinch myself or during, when there was applause for a song, I would smack myself in the face because I was enjoying the show and But I was fading hard and fast. And I felt so bad for the person behind me because it must have looked like I was tweaking. And my head just constantly was like, go down and then back up. I never actually would fall asleep. But I would say maybe 40 to 50 different times when watching the show,

SPEAKER_00I just felt my body go ugh. And some catty bitch out there might say, well, isn't it because the show wasn't good? No, it's because I was exhausted. I really did love this show. It was probably my favorite thing I saw in London on this trip. Unfortunately, it was the very first thing that I saw. I know many people are not huge fans of Platt. Not everyone's a fan of his voice. There's nothing you can really do about that. His voice is his voice. I think he's got a beautiful voice. It maybe isn't the most versatile singing voice. I don't really think he's much of a pop singer.

SPEAKER_00Could this transfer? Absolutely. You know, it could absolutely be done again.

SPEAKER_00This wouldn't be a terribly expensive show to do. I personally think that they could just plot this right into where Justin Time currently is at the Circle in the Square and barely change the design of it and have it... Just show up with Ben Platt and do it for like a 12-week run. It would be great. I just think it's such a lovely show. And I think that Son and Blake has written a really marvelous score that is pastiche in the sense that it harkens back to a specific era, but it's not cheeky. It feels like a genuine songbook of...

SPEAKER_00Somebody who it's because it's this multi-layered of somebody who's not of the age of the American Songbook was written, but just right after it and is composing with that in mind. It's like somebody who is composing for. Let's say pop music now trying to write like the 80s or the 90s, even if they are like technically Gen Z. And so there's many layers to that. And I think that Sonnenblatt really nails it. And I look forward to seeing what else he writes because it was a very impressive piece for me.

SPEAKER_00That was Midnight at the Never Get at the Menye. The next day I saw a matinee of Avenue Q. I was supposed to see a Wednesday evening show about Hardy Har Har, Best Laid Plans. So I pushed my... Performance back to the Friday matinee, which is a weird thing in London. I'm seeing more and more of them. I don't know why we do Friday matinees, but that's their cross to bear. Saw with my friend Steve, again, not Steve Tipton, different Steve. And this is the first production of Avenue Q since the show opened in the West End in 2006.

SPEAKER_00I haven't caught up with all of the changes the show had gone through when it was at New World stages. I don't know what kind of update they were making at the time, so I can't speak to whether all of the updates in this version are brand spanking new for this production or if some of them are carried over from past updates, but There's always a concern with Avenue Q. And if you want more depth on the plot of Avenue Q and the history of Avenue Q, we do have a deep dive episode on Avenue Q with Sam Simak, who is actually incidentally in maybe Happy Ending on Broadway.

SPEAKER_00But There's always a concern of when you're doing a show from a different era and 20 years, 25 years, 20, yeah, 20, 23 years, I guess, is when Avenue Q opened on Broadway. That is a different era of America and musical theater. And this whole the whole point of the show was not only it being a comedy, but being an envelope pushing comedy and. There are always questions of, oh, is it taboo in a bad way now?

SPEAKER_00Is it on PC? How do we make this more streamlined for a contemporary audience? And I was nervous that a lot of the changes And I'm pleased to announce that the changes made to Avenue Q absolutely do not soften the show. It still absolutely goes there, which is fantastic. That's the whole point of the show. I found all of the updates to be intelligent and make sense. Most of the updates are just to keep the show current. So the character of Princeton, him temping at a suicide prevention hotline has been updated to him working at

SPEAKER_00a cannabis store. There are jokes about AI, there's jokes about Trump, and everything else is still pretty much intact. The best update they make, and again, I don't know if this is from pre-COVID or not, but I was wondering how they were going to do this, and then as I was watching, I was like, oh, they nailed it, which is the song Mixtape. And so what happened was they make it so that Princeton makes her

SPEAKER_00a personalized playlist on Spotify and then he goes to the bathroom and she sings a mixtape. It's like a mixtape. And there's a lyric where she's like, it's how folks used to flirt in olden days, which gets a huge laugh from the audience. I was like, brava team. That's a wonderful update. Um, this production mostly worked for me. I, what it really did was it reminded me just what a clever, well-crafted, tightly constructed piece Avenue Q is as a musical with a lot of intelligence and a lot of heart for a show that uses crass humor.

SPEAKER_00And some people could say that it's really a one gimmick show of, oh, you're using puppets in Sesame Street language to flip it on its head. I'm like, no, in a lot of ways, it's Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00You know, work and love and identity and all of the things that are just true to life. I find that it doesn't give concrete answers like, and here's how you get a job and here's how you hold on to your money. It's just sort of, you know, sometimes you get a job and sometimes you don't and sometimes you pursue a dream and sometimes you don't get it. And the song for now is just like such a really stunning finale of Accepting things passing through while also acknowledging that you can only do

SPEAKER_00so much. Accepting things as they are is not... You don't necessarily accept things as they are so much as you allow it to pass you by. Knowing that something better is going to come along and sometimes something worse is going to come along. And you can only just keep going and keep trying and keep working. And, you know... Everything that's good and everything that's bad is always only for now. You know, the line, each time you smile, it'll only be for a while.

SPEAKER_00It's something like that. I'm getting it wrong, but I'm trying to make it scam. But that lyric I always found to be very precious and moving because it's not just like, hey, all the bad stuff is just for now. All the good stuff is also just for now. And this production does not get in the way of Avenue Q. If I had any major issues with it, it's mostly that it's just in too big of a space. It's currently at the Shaftesbury Theater, which to give you context, it's about like a 1,200, 1,300 seat theater. And even though they're doing construction, and so the upper circle, which is the third balcony or second balcony for you Americans...

SPEAKER_00That's been closed off for construction. It's still a rather large stage. This is a theater that housed the premiere of Hairspray and Mrs. Doubtfire and Juliet. This is where the Who's Tommy was, Kiss of the Spider Woman, My Beloved Carousel transferred from The National to this theater. So it's... It's an intimate space for like big productions and it's kind of a cavernous space for small productions. This is by no means one of the larger theaters in London. London has some big ass fucking theaters like the London Palladium and the Colosseum

SPEAKER_00and the Dominion. But this is... You know, a relatively decently sized theater, but for Avenue Q, it's like putting Avenue Q in New York, like in the Schubert. While the Schubert is a perfectly lovely sized, you know, medium sized house, it's not the St. James, it's not the Majestic, you wouldn't put Avenue Q in there. You wouldn't put Operation Mincemeat or Benjamin Button in the Schubert. And so while this production makes use of the stage and, you know, They take the unit set that we're used to and they mobilize many of the buildings,

SPEAKER_00so there's a lot more to it. And they don't expand the cast, they keep it the core company. There's still a little bit of trying to fill out a lot of empty space that doesn't really work. And because it's such a large theater, there's a lot of stuff that doesn't fully go over the footlights into the audience. But overall, it's a really... It's a solid production of what has turned out to be a really beautiful, hilarious musical. I would say my biggest standout in the company was Emily Benjamin, who played Kate Monster and Lucy the Slut.

SPEAKER_00Her Kate Monster doesn't really... Reinvent the Wheel. She's very much in the Stephanie DeBruzzo mold, but she definitely has some takes on lines that were new to me that I really enjoyed. I remember, I can't exactly remember how she said it, but I just remember the way she said, if your teeth are the problem, I could knock out, I could always knock out a few of them for you. And just something about how her timing of it was so different from most Kate monsters that I just thought it was so funny and so special.

SPEAKER_00And the way she does Lucy the Slut, because they update Lucy the Slut to be like a major OnlyFans star and all this other stuff. And so she plays her as a very vocal fry-y modern girly. So it's sort of like, you're dating a monster. And I enjoyed that a lot. I think my only other issues, mostly in the cast, were... Amelia Mews, who played Christmas Eve, is good, but she's not quite as dry and deadpan as Anne Harada was.

SPEAKER_00She's a little more animated and a little more, like, sassy, which isn't a bad thing, but a lot of Christmas Eve's best lines come from just, like, deadpan, straight-on delivery, at least how I remember it with Anne Harada. And then Dionne Ward-Anderson, who plays Gary... Also kind of does a little, she kind of goes the opposite where she has a little bit of energy, but mostly goes for a deadpan. And it's sort of like, I think they need to sort of transfer attitudes.

SPEAKER_00Amelia's like kind of peppy, sarcastic. Christmas Eve, that energy needs to go to Dion's Gary. And Dion's deadpan Gary needs to transfer over to Amelia. But overall, this was a really, really fun time, and I was very impressed by it. I think the other major standoff for me was Charlie McCullough as Nicky and Trekkie Monster. Trucking Monster just has always been a crowd pleaser, remains a crowd pleaser today, and The Internet is for Porn was the biggest showstopper of the day,

SPEAKER_00as it should be, because that song is still relevant. Yeah, I mean... Guys, I hate to tell you this for all of you Wicked apologists out there, but between Wicked and Avenue Q, Avenue Q was the rightful winner that year of the Tony Awards. Now, was it the rightful winner over Carolina Change? That's a story for another day. That's another story. Never mind. Anyway, what I will also say is for a Friday matinee that was, you know, maybe half full, it was a very enthusiastic crowd of people who really loved being there. And that's because the show we're talking about is Sinatraa.

SPEAKER_00The tagline they have for this is the legend that almost wasn't. Actually, no, let me let me get this one accurate if I can, please, because it's important to express exactly why this. That is their tagline. Because ultimately, this bio jukebox musical of Frank Sinatra, which if you don't know who Frank Sinatra is, I really cannot help you. He is one of the most famous popular singers of all time, not just of the 20th century, but of the 21st century.

SPEAKER_00So many of his songs... And so many of his covers of songs have remained in the pop culture lexicon. They're used in movies and TV shows. There was a Twyla Tharp dance piece review that was all Frank Sinatra music. And as an image, as an entity, he has remained iconic. Yes, the legend that almost wasn't. That is the tagline. Watch Animaniacs,

SPEAKER_00they do jokes about this, or tiny tunes with, you know, tiny little decrepit Frank Sinatra singing and everybody swooning over him. Frankie! The most iconic version of the song New York, New York, even though we all do love Liza, the rest of the world knows it as a Frank Sinatra tune. Frank Sinatra has very famous covers of Don't Rain in My Parade, Gotta Live Till I Die, things like that. The... I went to go see this mostly because it has a majority American production team.

SPEAKER_00It's choreographed and directed by Kathleen Marshall. It's written by Joseph DiPietro, who you might know from Nice Work If You Can Get It, and Memphis, and of course, Diana. And it had been workshopped and done out of town with Matt Doyle, who has since been replaced by Joel Harper Jackson is the current Frank Sinatra. We also have... And from On Your Feet, we have Anna Villafanier. Is that how you say your last name? Anna Villafanier.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that's how you say her last name. Anna Villafanier. She plays Ava Gardner in this production. And then we also have a beloved British West End legend, Jenna Russell, as Frank Sinatra's mother. The reason why the tagline is the legend that almost wasn't is that unlike most bio jukebox musicals, Sinatra does focus mostly on a specific decade of Frank Sinatra's life, which is for somebody who came out swinging, who had immediate success as a popular singer and then went into the movies

SPEAKER_00and had immediate success there. He then followed that up with about eight or so years of just a complete flop era. His movies were making no money. He couldn't get a number one single to save his life. And things didn't really turn around for him until the mid-50s when he starred From Here to Eternity and then had a major career run of like the next 40-ish years. And Sinatra the musical focuses on that flop era. It opens when we're getting towards the end. He's just done this really huge show at the Paramount Theater.

SPEAKER_00He's married with a kid. We hear that all these girls are just storming the stage to touch him. And he goes straight from there to Hollywood where he makes a movie with Gene Kelly. That's huge. He does like two or three other movies that also do really huge. And then things start to spiral from there. He meets Ava Gardner and leaves his wife for Ava Gardner. He spirals from there because he becomes known as Ava Gardner's husband. And then eventually he makes From Here to Eternity and then goes on his run of success.

SPEAKER_00But of course, From Here to Eternity and his run of success is the last 10 to 15 minutes of the show. From the first 20 minutes of his success and the last 15 minutes of his success, that leaves us with two hours of Frank Sinatra flopping. I give the team a lot of credit for choosing to focus on a really hard period of Sinatra's life. And I also give them credit for the fact that they don't deny that he cheated on his first wife a lot,

SPEAKER_00and they don't deny that he wasn't around all the time as a father. But because Sinatra is being done with the Sinatra estate, aka his daughter Tina, there's only so much they can say and do. This is the problem when we have these bio-musicals and bio-pictures that have to work with the family estate because they need the life rights or they need the music in order to properly portray the You know,

SPEAKER_00the career and the talents of the people they're making these movies about, the families do not want any kind of negative connotations or any kind of negative perception of the person the movie's about. All you have to do is look at the movie Michael or even go on Broadway to see MJ. These are not deep dive investigations of very troubled people. It is a very much glamorized perception of who these artists actually were. And Sinatra was not a good person.

SPEAKER_00He wasn't the worst, but he was not good. He sucked pretty hard as a human being often. He had a violent temper. He was ragingly misogynistic. But he was charming and he was talented. And he ultimately had such a massive career that But that's not... You can't really get away with, well, he was such a great artist, you forgive him for everything. Because he never wrote songs. He was an interpreter of songs. He didn't write movies. He was a control freak as an actor, but he didn't write or direct these movies.

SPEAKER_00He was a talent. He wasn't necessarily a creative. And Sinatra the Musical has no point of view on him as a man. It has no point of view on his career. There are moments where there's a little bit of inventiveness. They... They do what I call the cheating medley. It's not even a medley, but they do come flying with me. And they do it as a number where Frank Sinatra is cheating on his wife with multiple starlets. First with Lana Turner, then with Judy Garland, and then with Marlena Dietrich.

SPEAKER_00And they do it in this giant bed where Lana Turner's in the bed first, and then she goes under the covers, and then Hedda Hopper, who's really kind of portrayed as the ultimate villain of this piece because she has it out for Franky. Everything she prints is a lie. But she says how, you know, oh, now he's sleeping with this actress who walked down the yellow brick road and wouldn't you know what Judy Garland pops up and then she goes into the covers and then Marlena Dietrich pops up. And that's pretty clever. It's not The actual execution could do with some work, but the idea is fun.

SPEAKER_00That's kind of as far as we go. Everything else is mostly exposition-heavy dialogue. We don't really get enough time to spend with any other character to investigate Their connection with Frank Sinatra, their relationship with him, their history with him, you know, his first wife is mostly just painted as a long-suffering saint, partly probably because that's Tina Sinatra's mother, and so there's no negative connotations that can be made about her mother. Ava Gardner is very much portrayed as, like,

SPEAKER_00a vixen who is a modern-day woman who Frank Sinatra couldn't keep up with, and, like, and Phoebe, uh, I don't want to say her last name. Panarettos? Phoebe Panarettos, who plays Nancy Sinatra, the first wife. She does a good job, but she's mostly just required to suffer through song all the time. And Anna as Ava Garner... Brings a lot of sex appeal and charm, but she doesn't have much beyond that. Again, she's sort of meant to be the polar opposite of Nancy. She's a modern woman, and she's hardened,

SPEAKER_00and she's got grit, and she's very upfront with Frank and doesn't let him get away with it. I mean, and even the whole philandering of Frank Sinatra...

SPEAKER_00They don't deny that he does it, but they don't really portray it in a light where it's like he has agency. He gets to Hollywood for the first time with his agent, who ultimately is like, spoiler alert, when the agent dies in Act 2, that's meant to be this really big, I'll cover you, Angel's funeral moment. And it just, not enough has been done to really make us feel that kind of way. But so Frank Sinatra gets to L.A., And he says to his agent, he's like, well, I've never cheated on my wife before. I would never do that. And then like kind of only gets convinced into doing it

SPEAKER_00because Lana Turner practically threatens him to fuck her. And I would imagine in real life it was the other way around. It was also Hollywood in the 40s and 50s where everyone was fucking everyone. You know, there's a documentary about that gas station where there were a lot of sex work going on with different Hollywood stars. And that's just a facet of the constant bed hopping that was going on in Hollywood in the 40s and 50s. I mean, all on the DL, but still.

SPEAKER_00Just the free idea that like Lana Turner basically is like, you will be having sex with me before the year is out. And if you don't, you better watch yourself. It's like, come on, come on. Let's give Lana Turner a little more credit than that. Let's give these women a little more. If we're going to give Let's not have it just be the agency of, hey Frank Sinatra, I'm a woman who chooses her fate and I choose to ride you into next year. That's like all that Ava Garner has to do, that's all Lana Turner has to do, or Hedda Hopper who's like, oh Frank Sinatra, I hate you and my agency is that I'm always going to spread rumors about you.

SPEAKER_00And then Jenna Russell as his mom just comes in every 20 minutes to go, I'm Italian and your mother eats some meatballs. It's not very well-rounded writing, let's just put it that way. On the upside, uh... Joel Harper Jackson does a very strong imitation of Frank Sinatra. The voice in particular does the, when he's singing, he does a very full-throated, harsh kind of sound that Frank was very known for. By harsh, I just mean like it's not polished.

SPEAKER_00It's not trained. It definitely feels like a God-given instrument. He, of course, is taller and more buff than Frank Sinatra ever was, so you have to kind of suspend your disbelief with that respect. But he's very committed to the piece, and he is a very magnetic center of it all. Design-wise, it's very projection-heavy. The projections do a lot of heavy work for the show, heavy lifting for the show. So whenever a lot of information needs to get passed over,

SPEAKER_00they do it through a 90-second film montage on the set. I think the biggest thing I have with this is, comparing this to something like Just in Time, which is not a show that I'm obsessed with, but I give it credit for having a point of view about Bobby Darin and having a theme about how they are going to present his story. Not just the, it's all in a nightclub, and oh, we have the book ends of, it's a performer putting on a show as Bobby Darin, which I'm still convinced was really just done because Jonathan Groff can't do

SPEAKER_00a Bobby Darin impression. Yeah. Everything he did, he had to do fast and he had to do right because he was going to live, live, live until he died. As it turns out, he lived a lot longer than he expected and lived long enough to become a bit of

SPEAKER_00a has-been. But until then, he worked very fast and very hard and got a lot done very quickly. And Just In Time gives you opportunities to see his talent as a musician. You see how he turns Mack the Knife from the Three Penny Opera into the pop hit that he made it. You don't ever see that with Sinatra. You don't see any influence he might have had musically. You don't see what drives him or what's keeping him from getting more success other than his temper, I suppose.

SPEAKER_00There are other things of, like, there are references to his mafia connections, which the show does in a very mocking tone. Like, they have people in Hollywood go, we would never hire you because of your mob connections. And I'm like, first of all, in the 1950s, you never actually said to the mob. You never said that out loud. And if you knew that Frank Sinatra was connected to the mafia, which a lot of people in Hollywood did, that actually would make you hire him more. There's a story in Godfather that is fully lifted from Frank Sinatra of a movie actor who wants a part. The studio won't give it to him.

SPEAKER_00Don Corleone, Marlon Brando, has his henchmen take the studio head's horse, cut off the horse's head, put it in the studio head's bed. And that's when the studio head's like, oh, I didn't realize who this movie actor was with, meaning the mob. And he's like, and now he has the part. And that's absolutely... Something that had happened or something like that had happened with Sinatra. So these movie studio heads being like, we've got morals in our own way. We would never deal with disgusting people like the mafia. It's like, okay, let's calm down and let's not lie about this shit.

SPEAKER_00And for two hours of watching Sinatra rinse and repeat with all of his struggles, we finally get to where he's succeeding. And he gets from here to eternity. And we go through the filming process of it in about three minutes. We go through the critical reception in 30 seconds. And we go through the Oscars where he wins in about 45 seconds. We spend more time with his daughter. Yeah, I think it's Tina that they have him with. Yeah. Or is it, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Who is it? Sorry, one second. I want to figure out exactly which kid we're using. Sorry, it's little Nancy. Little Nancy Sinatra. We spend more time with her talking to Frank about how she's nervous about going to the Oscars with him because they're going to be all these beautiful movie stars. To which she says, hey, don't you know, someday when I'm awfully low and sings all of The Way You Look Tonight with her, which is just So shoehorned in. And then we spend 20 seconds on the actual award and 30 seconds

SPEAKER_00on how he bounced back with his career. Everyone comes on stage and like, and then he made a collection of hit records and he created such a wonderful comeback. And half of you wouldn't be born if it weren't for Frank Sinatra, implying that your parents were fucking to his music. And that's the last 45 seconds of the show. Really disappointing conclusion. And if they want to bring this to Broadway, it cannot come in the state that it's in. It needs a better point of view. It needs to actually go there with some of his stuff because unlike a lot of Michael Jackson's fans,

SPEAKER_00the fans of Frank Sinatra know what a piece of shit he was. It's not that they don't care. It's just part of his lore. And so if you bring a whitewashed version of him to Broadway, it's not that his fans are going to revolt, but they're going to be like, ugh. No, they they want a Frank Sinatra biomusical that that gives you the music you want, as well as the gruff piece of shit that he was. There's a great story that John Mulaney tells of either I think it was his mom who told him this story or maybe a friend's mom.

SPEAKER_00Of Frank Sinatra was at a hotel and like John Mulaney's mom and her friends were there with a hundred other women waiting for him. And he finally comes out and they're screaming, Frankie, Frankie, sign this, sign this. And he's trying to get to his car and he just shouts out of the way, you fat pigs. And they're still screaming for him. And John Mulaney's like, that's just who Frank Sinatra was. And that was his power. He just says like, you fat pigs. And all of these women are like, oh my God, my clothes off still. That's the lore of Sinatra. He sucked. He was a shitty dude.

SPEAKER_00And yet, his fans knew this, and not only did they not care, it was just part of his lore. And so honestly, I'm like, don't fucking shy away from it. Put it out there. The people will pay tickets to see it. They will. They will indeed. So that's Sinatra. Okay. The very next day. Oh, and I think I said this already, but yeah, like... A theater about the same size as Avenue Q, twice the amount of people in attendance, and not even half as good of a response vocally from the audience as Avenue Q got.

SPEAKER_00There was disappointment from the woman next to me that they weren't singing New York, New York in the show, and I just sat there and I was like, honey, just wait, they're going to do it at the curtain call. And of course they did. Next up, at the Old Vic, a theater that I never had been to before. Fun fact, the Old Vic was the first home of the National Theater before they moved further down the bank. How the Other Half, did I say How the Other Half Lives? So the Old Vic, I saw How the Other Half Loves. Which is a play by Alan Eichborn, best known here probably for the Norman Conquests.

SPEAKER_00He also did Relatively Speaking. This is not Alan Eichborn's first play, but I think it's his second major hit. Relatively Speaking was his first real hit, and then this was his sophomore success, which solidified him as a major British playwright. Obviously, he was more successful in London than he was here. Tom Stoppard was probably the most prolific playwright on both sides of the ocean. Akebourne was a bit more of a Neil Simon-esque playwright. He did a lot of comedies,

SPEAKER_00but also being British, they were also commentary on class and the heterosexual marital state. But in a way that audiences could really enjoy. And as I said, this is my first time at the Old Vic. This production was done in the round for two reasons. One, this was how Alan Eichborn had always... The Old Vic is where...

SPEAKER_00They shot that so you can see a how gorgeously ornate it is. It's while also being a rather intimate space and like very old school. It's, you know, you've got your stalls, which in America we call the orchestra. And then I think two or three tiers of. So I was able to transfer my ticket to a Saturday matinee. They informed me this is a relaxed performance.

SPEAKER_00And we have relaxed performance in the States as well. I went to a relaxed performance of ragtime. Usually that just means that the house lights are at about 30% as opposed to being completely in the dark. And then any major explosions or lighting effects that could maybe cause a seizure or something are softened or done away with completely. But How the Other Half Loves doesn't really have any of that. The theater was just a 30% with the lights. But then also it allows people to come to see a show who maybe couldn't under normal circumstances or regular circumstances, I guess you can say.

SPEAKER_00No issue with any of that. The one issue I'll say I did have is there was a woman across the aisle from me who brought her baby to the show. How old the baby was, I couldn't tell you. That's never been my specialty, and I'm very happy for that. I would say that baby was anywhere between 10 and 14 or 15 months old, had hair on its head, was able to hold its neck up, wasn't saying sentences yet. I do not think this is a baby that could have walked on its own. This woman was carrying it in a baby Bjorn against her chest. Now, I do not know this woman's journey. I do not know if she was a member of the production team or if she was married

SPEAKER_00to somebody in the cast or whatever. But I was completely shocked that someone brought such a young baby to the theater that no one seemed to care. And then I was in the lobby. I saw signs for like, oh, here's where you can change your baby in the bathrooms. I went, oh, is this something that London Theater is doing at all, like all over? Or is this just an old Vic thing? Because I got to say, not a fan of it. I'm not a fan when people bring their newborns to Disney World. And I'm definitely not a fan when you bring your 12 month old to a West End play.

SPEAKER_00First of all, that child's not going to remember any of it. It's not going to absorb any of it. And was this baby well-behaved? Not really. It can't be. It's a fucking baby. You know, it wasn't screaming its head off in the first act, but it was making noise. And then eventually started to scream its head off in the second act, which is when the mother took the child out into the lobby, as she should have. But I mean, for any of my London listeners, is this normal? Is this something that y'all have been doing? Is this just an old Vic thing? Because I got to tell you, old Vic needs to change the policy on that. I don't, this is not where the bar should be at all.

SPEAKER_00This is also a two hour and 45 minute play. What child in the world has that kind of attention span? I digress. The play follows, technically speaking, three couples. The first couple is Fiona and Frank, which is, sorry, I need to look through my program here. The older couple, Fiona and Frank, are played by Roger Allum, who was the original Officer Javert in Les Maserables in the 80s, opposite Colm Wilkinson. And Dorothy Atkinson is his wife, Fiona.

SPEAKER_00Frank and Fiona are a very affluent couple. And Fiona was home late the night before, and we find out, not from Frank, but through our own watching as an audience, it's because Fiona was having an affair with one of Frank's co-workers. This moves us on to the second couple, Teresa Phillips and Bob Phillips. Bob and Teresa have a newborn baby. Teresa mentions, hey, Bob, you were out late last night. And Fiona and Bob both come up with different excuses of, oh, they saw Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And you see Frank and Fiona having their conversations while Teresa and Bob are having their conversations all in the same set, but obviously in different living rooms, like they're in their own homes. While this is all happening, Fiona is trying to call Bob, but Teresa keeps picking up.

SPEAKER_00Bob is trying to call Fiona, but Frank keeps picking up. Frank and Teresa have no idea what's going on. They don't realize what's going on. The affair that their spouses are having with each other, they both think that the constant phone calls and hanging up are some kind of perverts. But so Fiona and Bob tell Frank and Teresa, oh, I was helping Mary Featherstone, I was helping William Featherstone. Teresa then invites the Featherstones over for dinner. They can't come on this one night because that's the night that Mary Featherstone

SPEAKER_00and William Featherstone are having dinner with Frank and Fiona Foster. So the next act is the Featherstones having dinner with the Fosters as well as them having dinner with the Phillipses two nights in a row, but again, all happening on the same set at the same time. So eventually they're all sitting down at a table and you see William and Mary Featherstone Dealing with Frank and Fiona while also dealing with Teresa and Bob sort of flipping back and forth and back and forth. And there's a lot of fun staging that goes on with all of that. Frank and Fiona are a perfectly loving and attentive couple,

SPEAKER_00if a bit Dry and a little reserved. Part of that is they've been married for so long. They are the oldest couple in the bunch and definitely the poshest of the bunch. Teresa and Bob are a little more fiery. They argue more. They love each other, but they also have a lot of disdain for each other and frustration with each other. And then Mary and William are just such a wet blanket of a couple with William being a bit more mentally controlling of Mary. And Everything kind of comes to a giant head and a lot of misunderstandings

SPEAKER_00where eventually different people start to think the wrong affairs are happening. They start to think that Mary and Bob are having an affair or that Teresa and everyone starts thinking that they're like different affairs are happening and they're the wrong affairs. Everything kind of eventually gets cleared up in the end, and there's a bit more of an emotional climax between Frank and Fiona than you would have expected for such a, I won't call it a sex farce, but a bit of a marriage-y sex farce.

SPEAKER_00I won't go into any more specifics other than just to say it's a lot of sort of constant misunderstandings and characters talking about one thing while another character thinks they're talking about another thing. And you laugh at the double entendres and the way that lines can have double meanings. And... Ultimately, it's a fun play with actually a decent amount to say about the gender dynamics of heterosexual married couples, especially of different income tiers.

SPEAKER_00That said, it is of a certain era. It is around 1969, 1970, and it is, I would argue, about 25 minutes too long. I think that the number one MVP of this production was Roger Allum as the elder couple Frank Foster. He just has that gift that some older British actors have of being Being able to play someone ridiculous with completely straight face, but still have that little bit of the foot off the ground. If you listened to the Mamma Mia episode, the deep dive from years ago, we talked about this.

SPEAKER_00My friends who were in Mamma Mia on Broadway were always told, and every time Phyllida Lloyd came in to direct them, she would always say, remember, you have one foot on the ground and one foot in the air. Everything that's happening on stage is very real to your character. You, the actor, have to understand the levity of the world that you are performing in. And Roger Ellum is an actor who absolutely understands that with this play. I think another person who absolutely understands this is Laura Ellsworthy as Mary Featherstone, the lowest of the couples, the ones who come to dinner in both houses.

SPEAKER_00She does a bit of a British Annalee Ashford situation where she's constantly, she always has these vocal stimulants that And. . .

SPEAKER_00It also makes it gratifying when she eventually stands up to William towards the end of the show when she thinks that he owes her an apology, which he does. And when he can't fully verbalize it, but you can see from his body language he's trying to apologize, the joke is eventually she forgives him and says, yes, that'll do. That's enough of an apology. And... The way she does it is sort of she's holding on to her dignity while also acknowledging that the man she loves can only go so far. It was both very moving and very funny to me.

SPEAKER_00As I said, as a piece, I mostly went to go see it for historical purposes. I wanted to see more classical British comedies that I don't think I'd ever get to see in America. I wanted to see something at the Old Vic. And in many ways, it checked off all of those boxes. My biggest issue was just having a goddamn baby across the way from me. I'm sorry, but that was a loaf of bread with googly eyes. That's all that it was to me. That is How the Other Half Loves. That evening,

SPEAKER_00I will also say, because London had its hottest summer ever this past summer, just very long heat waves of very high degrees, and the weather was actually very beautiful when I was there. Because of the heat wave, a lot of the trees had browned leaves, so it very much looked like autumn, even though it wasn't really autumn yet. But I think the leaves plus it being on average like 65 degrees, it just went, ugh, fall. But the heat from the summer had done some damage to the infrastructure of

SPEAKER_00the London Underground, the tube, if you're local. And because of this, there was work that needed to be done on the tracks. Track maintenance needed to be done. And... Yeah. And, you know, it was always just so very clean.

SPEAKER_00And because they were constantly doing work on the tracks, there were many a times where the subway just absolutely fucked me left and right when I was in London, particularly when I was trying to get to the Old Vic. I had given myself about an hour and 15 to get there for what was supposed to be a 30-minute travel total. And wouldn't you know it, that wasn't happening. It got to be quarter to two, and my show was at 2.30, And I still had three more stops to go on one line of the two before I transferred

SPEAKER_00to a different line. And we were just sitting in the station for 10 minutes. And I was so nervous that we just were never going to move and I was never going to get there. I bolted out. I grabbed a cab, which I really didn't want to do. I don't like taking cabs, whether I'm in London or in New York. Got to the theater with 10 minutes to spare. So it was already a very stressful time getting there. But it was getting back was a lot easier. I'll just say that. But I got I went back because that evening I went to go see Cats at Regents Park Open Air Theater. Now, for those of you who wonder what that is,

SPEAKER_00Regents Park Open Air Theater is very similar to our Delacorte in Central Park. They, except it's not exclusively Shakespeare that they do, they always do a musical, they tend to do a play. I myself saw All My Sons there, I saw Little Shop of Horrors there, it remains my favorite production of Little Shop of Horrors that I have seen. More on that when we talk about the producers in a second. We had a transfer of a Regents Park production here. We had their production of Into the Woods that played in Central Park that I deeply hated. But also,

SPEAKER_00you know, the Jesus Christ Superstar that's currently playing in the West End, that is a transfer from what was at Regents Park. The production of Evita that we're getting on Broadway this season, which is a transfer from the West End, that West End production with Rachel Zegler was in a way a transfer from Regents Park, not Completely, but Jamie Lloyd had done Evita first at Regent's Park with a very similar set design and very similar staging idea that he then tweaked for The West End.

SPEAKER_00So this is to say, Regent's Park has done a lot of productions that are quite out there. Very bold, very bonkers. They did a production of Carousel where they fucked around with the ending so that way Billy wasn't actually redeemed. And they also moved it to like the 1930s, I think in Ireland, something like that. Like, they've often had very bold swings. You can look up photos of their productions of Ragtime and The Sound of Music just to sort of see the wildness with which they do shows. And after us having had Jellicle Ball in New York,

SPEAKER_00where I feel like it really kind of, for those of us who loved the show... Opened our eyes to the qualities that the musical Cats actually does have that we allowed ourselves to deny because the reputation of the musical, both with just it being such an odd show and then the awful movie version, we weren't allowing ourselves to acknowledge, like, actually, there's quite a bit of artistry here. The music is very good. I think the score is kind of wall-to-wall bops. And it's such an odd musical that it's actually kind of...

SPEAKER_00It's very admirable that it's succeeded as much as it has because it's just such an odd show with very little at its center. And you think, okay, this is Regent's Park. They're doing Cats. We just had a very wildly successful, artistically anyway, production that went very bold with it. What is Regent's Park going to do with Cats? Short answer, nothing. They don't do a damn thing with this. I went with my friend Natasha, who I had not seen in eight years. And we go in and the set was very stunning, I'll give it that.

SPEAKER_00It was basically like chrome and copper with a crescent moon and a couple of platforms towards the back, maybe one or two, but then mostly open space at the front. I went, okay, let's see what they do. And at the end of the overture, Cats are coming through the audience like they did in the original production, and they are wearing a version of the original costumes that John Napier had designed in the 1980s. The leotard with the rope around the abdomen that becomes a tail in the back with,

SPEAKER_00I don't think there are any leg warmers, but that's like the only thing that was missing. That and that, all of the cats' outfits were similar colors. They were all sort of brown and gray and white. And we get to the We get through the overture, we get to the opening, and already we're getting flashes of the movie where they're starting Jellicle songs for Jellicle cats. Are you blind when you're born? And they're singing it to the white cat, to the Victoria cat. And I'm like, oh no, this is just like the movie.

SPEAKER_00I'm not, I don't love this. And then the number's happening, and I do enjoy that opening number every time, but the staging is very Jillian Lynn-like of Going for actual feline movement of sort of constant modern ballet dancing. But there's no structure. There's no viewpoint. There's no attitude. And it's all this wide open space. There's no real levels to the set. The only levels are at the back for entrances and exits. And so we don't get any variety with the choreography or the staging.

SPEAKER_00And so it all becomes not chaos because there's an excitement to chaos. It all just becomes cluttered. And, and messy. And after the opening number, Natasha and I kind of just looked at each other and we went, oh no, I think this is, I don't, I think this was a mistake. And the show continues, and there are even more nods to the movie as we go through it. They do the original, original West End version of Mungo Jerry and Rumpel teaser,

SPEAKER_00not the one that we know from the Broadway production, from the pro shot. This is the one that Andrew Lloyd Webber had written in 1981, and And then Tom Hooper requested that they reinstate for the film. So instead of Mungo, Jerry and Rumpelteaser, it became Mungo, Jerry and Rumpelteaser. We're a notorious couple of cats. And correct me if I'm wrong, London friends, but I do believe after the Broadway production opened in the 80s, they put in the...

SPEAKER_00I believe the original West End production closed with the updated Mongo Jerry and Rumpelteaser. I'm almost positive. Correct me if I'm wrong. But that, as far as I'm aware, the updated one was the one that has been the one being done all over the world. So this change, I'm already going like, oh, God, we're again, I'm getting my Tom Hooper kicks here. And we have a female old Deuteronomy played by Melanie Laberi, who many will know from and Juliet. That's not a problem necessarily.

SPEAKER_00It's just another link to the film. And our Grizabella, I need to find her name again as well, because my question was, Rachel Wooding, who is a favorite of my friend Danny's. I remember from where we were sitting, I was like, why did they cast like a 27 year old to play Crisabella? The whole point is that she's older than everyone. She's a little more weathered. She is a whole point of memory is that she's proving her value and her worth, even if she isn't as spry as everyone else, even if she has been ostracized, like there is still merit to her being alive.

SPEAKER_00And then as I looked her up during intermission, I realized, oh, no, no, she's She's not 90, but she's not 28. Like, she's a bit older. It's just that the way that she's made up and the way that she sings, there's such a healthiness to her that you don't buy that this is a faded glamour cat. The set may or may not have more tricks up its sleeve. I also don't necessarily know if Rachel Wooding's second act memory brings full circle her performance, because the truth is that at the interval, Natasha and I chose to leave.

SPEAKER_00We weren't enjoying it. And ultimately, having not seen her for eight years, we were like, why don't we just go to a nearby pub and catch up and discuss all the things that we want to discuss? Which is what we did, which was perfectly agreeable to us. Ultimately, for me, it's after Jellicle Ball. There's a line in an episode in Orange is the New Black that goes, toast can't be bread anymore. Once bread becomes toast, it can't be bread ever again, or something like that.

SPEAKER_00And I feel with Cats, Cats can still become Jellicle Ball again, but Jellicle Ball can never be Cats again. Meaning, once you've seen Jellicle Ball, you can't go back to Cats. And I can't go back to Cats the way it was. I have... Come to re-appreciate my love for the music, my admiration for how bonkers of a show it is, but I can't go back to a traditional Cats ever again. I can only experience Cats, if not as Jellicle Ball, with the same bold creativity of Jellicle Ball.

SPEAKER_00And I was just so fascinated that with Cats at Regents Park Open Air, that this was the show they chose to do straight on. Like you did Little Shop as if it was in a cartoon. The set for All My Sons looked like it was a bombed out suburban house. You know, Into the Woods, you had the witch who looked like she was becoming a tree before our very eyes and added all these fairy tale characters that weren't in the original script, like a Hansel and Gretel that was eating their own costumes made of candy. And Cats is the show that you decide to be restrained and respectful on?

SPEAKER_00Makes no sense to me. Makes no sense. Somebody make it make sense to me. But that's Cats. So again, it's only a half for review. I apologize. But that's all I could really muster for the open air production. Next up, we have Kimberly Akimbo at the Hampstead Theater. Again, if you want more details on the plot of Kimberly Akimbo and the origins of Kimberly Akimbo, You can listen to my deep dive episode on it, actually with my father, fun facts. But ultimately, long story short, it follows a young girl, 16-year-old girl, Kimberly Lavaco, who has a rare condition where her body ages three to four times as fast as

SPEAKER_00the normal human being. So even though she's 16, she has the body of a woman in her late 60s, early 70s. It was done to critical acclaim on Broadway with Victoria Clark playing Kimberly. It is now having its London debut with Maria Friedman playing Kimberly Lavaco. This production is directed by Michael Longhurst. He did the Next to Normal in London that there's the pro shot of that we all love. He also did the Carolina Change that came to New York that I personally quite hated. And so I wasn't quite sure which Michael Longhurst was coming to the table.

SPEAKER_00But I was interested in seeing Maria Friedman on stage, and I was interested in seeing how the Brits did Kimberly Akimbo. And Hampstead Theater is... It's a little far up. It's a little further up than Regent's Park. It's a lovely theater and a very nice posh neighborhood, but it's not really in the hub of theatricality. Oh, I should also mention, by the way, that at Sinatra, we had a show stop in the middle of Act One right after Ava Gardner and Frank Sinatra meet.

SPEAKER_00They finished the number, the curtain came down, and they're like, we're in a hold. We'll come back in a second. They didn't tell us what it was, but... You know, the curtain comes out five or six minutes later and everything seems fine. Same thing happened with Kimberly Akimbo. After Father Time, they, Stage Vanisher comes out and like, we have to hold for a second. And then as it turns out, when they finish, they said, hey, so, and And in fact, one, there's a lot of ice skating that happens due to a technical issue. We cannot do the ice skating. So the cast will be doing the staging without ice skates. So just imagine they're on ice skates, which the audience really loved.

SPEAKER_00And then the cast had a lot of fun sort of improvising and ad libbing lines about the lack of ice skating. And the audience really enjoyed that. Kimberly Acumbo is a musical that I very much love. It's not like in my top 10 or anything, but I do think it was the best musical of the season it came out. Seeing this production has reinforced for me that it's a really good musical, mostly because I do not love this production. It's not a bad production, but it's sort of like death by a thousand cuts. There's always something that's a little off.

SPEAKER_00Part of it is the design. It's a very... I think it's a far too big set. It's on a giant turntable, which is a Michael Longhurst staple at this point. And the main set is basically one giant building that is meant to be the Lavaco household in one respect, but then also is the ice skating rink and the lockers at school and the library. And it just becomes a very cumbersome piece. The scene transitions go on for a little bit too long because the set has to constantly stay in motion. The Lavaco household we see as a three-tiered,

SPEAKER_00three-floored set, which just makes it all the more cool. And for a show that has trouble in the first 10 minutes getting the audience on its side because Kimberly's parents are not great and it hurts an audience to see her father be drunk and kind of just shit the bed as a father and see her mother just be too narcissistic and mean. To then have a distancing design and then have lighting that's just very harsh and cold to remind me a lot of the design of the lighting design in Groundhog Day,

SPEAKER_00where it was very dark with like reds and blues and like stark whites. It just doesn't do your show many favors. There are also things of the temperature and temperament of some of the performances. I was very happy to see Maria Friedman on stage. She sounded great. I would argue actually a little too healthy for Kimberly Lee. And so what

SPEAKER_00What I always found that Victoria Clark did was she had the attitude of a teenager and body language of a teenager, but her voice betrayed her youth. And it allowed us to be constantly reminded of all the limitations her body is enforcing on her, whereas Maria Friedman was a little too spry, a little too energetic. They dressed her very kind of punk rock, manic pixie, dream girl-esque. And Whereas Maria Friedman's voice was so robust and healthy, then her body language also was like almost too young.

SPEAKER_00It wasn't 16, it was more like 11 or 12. Very childlike, fidgety, and not really... Yeah. I think that, but which isn't, it's not that her performance was bad. It's just that it's those little things that keep it from being great and keep

SPEAKER_00the show from fully working. Same thing with someone like Alice Fearn, who played Aunt Debra. Who is probably the best one in the show, but still I had some issues with her performance. She sang the living shit out of it and she landed the comedy, but I'm so used to Bonnie Milligan's Aunt Debra being more subdued with her delivery because Aunt Debra is such a... And Bonnie Milgan got away with it because she would say it in such a dropped and demure kind of way.

SPEAKER_00And so you always sort of bought What she said and did because it just sounded so organic and so natural, just so free flowing. And Fearne definitely is playing it more bawdy and a little more pantomimey, which works in its own right. And I think is probably better for a production like this that needs some kind of energy and warmth to it. But it keeps her from being a bit more of a person.

SPEAKER_00And the thing about Kimberly Akimbo that I always enjoyed was that I always felt that the characters in it were Genuine people in a very heightened world for sure. It is David Lindsay a bear after all, but I still bought them at least in the original Broadway production. I bought them her, you know, Kimberly's parents as played on Broadway. You understood that her father is not a bad guy. He's just a constant loser. He loves his daughter, but he just keeps fucking up. You understand that her mom also loves her, but she also kind of keeps her at a distance because her mom can feel the pain

SPEAKER_00of knowing that her that she's going to outlive her daughter. And rather than actually grapple with that hurt, she just sort of puts it all at arm's length and focuses instead on herself. That's what makes the second to last scene with Kimberly and her parents so moving for me, is that Kimberly, when she says, like, let's confront the ghost, it's like, let's say the quiet part out loud, you know? And she And allows you to see the humanity in her parents

SPEAKER_00that has always been there, but has just been stunted from the fact that they had Kimberly so young and have always just sort of never grown out of this arrested development that they had. And the actress who play Kimberly's parents in London... More lean into the nastiness that is so easy to portray in these roles that I don't think is really meant to be there. They say bad stuff, but they don't mean it negatively. They don't understand the power of their words. They don't understand how it's coming off.

SPEAKER_00They are too self-involved and, again, just too stunted to know better. And it was a little more mean-spirited here, which I did not really appreciate. There's also a bit of an American... I was very happy to see this. I was happy to see a new interpretation. Again, it kind of reinforced for me that this is quite a good musical,

SPEAKER_00and I wish more people gave it the respect it deserves. I think the score is really lovely. I also got recognized by a listener in London. I did not get your name at the program stand, but the young gentleman who gave me my program for Kimberly Akimbo, just know that I remember you and I thank you. It was really lovely to see another listener in London. I always wonder if I actually have listeners over there, and then every trip I always run into at least one, and so that's really nice. I'm hoping that Londoners go see this musical,

SPEAKER_00and if they don't love it, that's fine, but just know that I love it. And I don't think this production is terrible. I just think that The opportunities that it misses, it misses by like just enough that it could get back on track with a little more fine tuning. It's not so far off base. It's just, it doesn't fully land. And that was rather frustrating for me, especially having seen it in New York, where I really do think that at least the cast was so locked in with the material that it just sold for me.

SPEAKER_00And again, also reinforced how much I loved Victoria Clark's performance and how hard this role is of not just vocally, but just... Physically and mentally, how you kind of have to get into this space of Making the audience believe that you are actually a 16-year-old in this old woman's body. And it's not, it ain't easy. If it were easy, everyone could do it. But I digress. I'm going to finish up with Salma and Louise, since that's the premiere here that most people are interested in.

SPEAKER_00So next up, I'll actually do The Producers, which was my last show of the trip. I saw this with my friend Mike, who did not know The Producers at all. And so it was interesting to hear his thoughts on it. This was a West End transfer from the Meniere. As directed by Patrick Marber, who is best known for writing the play Closer. He also directed Leopold Statt, which we saw in New York a few years ago. It's Stark's Andy Nyman as Max Bialystok. I best know Andy Nyman for the movie Death at a Funeral, the British version, not the Chris Rock version. And then I saw Mark Antolin, who played Leo Bloom.

SPEAKER_00I saw him in Little Shop of Horrors at Regent's Park about eight years ago. And I had heard a lot of really great things about this production. I heard it was a lot of fun. I had a few listeners see it and say really lovely things about it. And it's not a bad time. I did not enjoy myself at the show. I was happy to see the Garrick Theater. I'm always happy. I was trying to check off more theaters on my West End box. And it was interesting to hear Mike's take on the show. He fully clocked how act two was going to go by intermission, but he enjoyed it a lot.

SPEAKER_00He thought it was very funny, very clever. I remember he said the songs were like perfectly fine. I was like, yeah, no, it's the score works, but the score is not extraordinary. It reminded me once again that Full Monty should have won best score that year. But what people always ask with the producers in the same way that they ask with Avenue Q is could you still do it today with the way that the world is? Is it not woke enough or is it actually too scary because of the Hitler Nazi stuff? I think because the producers... I say this because this production, for me, is perfectly meh. It is very...

SPEAKER_00More than anything, it is messy. It is a sloppy production. It is not as tight as it should be. And granted, my memories of this show are the Broadway cast right after Nathan Lane and Matthew Broderick left. So it's like, I think it was still 85% of the original company. But, you know, 14, 15 months into the run, it was still a pretty hot ticket. And that cast was firing on all cylinders. You can also watch the entire original, original company on YouTube and just see how... Fast and hot that thing was playing at the time.

SPEAKER_00And just to see like really tightly wound musical theater comedy, just like a Swiss Army watch. Or Swiss Army? No, what am I saying? Not Swiss Army. It's getting late. Like a Swiss watch. But this production, everything that works about it kind of works in spite of what's going on on stage. Or... is due to credit from the original production. Like Lauren Letaro's choreography, the things she lifts from Susan Stroman are the things that work the best. Moments in Along Came Bialy, Moments in King of Broadway,

SPEAKER_00where she takes from Stroman, you're like, yes, that's where there's personality, that's where there's humor. But then also she can't help herself and she will throw in acrobatics or splits or major high kicks or modern movement in ways where you're like, why is this here? This is supposed to be the 1960s and it's supposed to be a love letter to the golden age of musical theater. Why are we doing like pop and locks right now? Yeah.

SPEAKER_00It was still outside the theater in Shubert Alley, and it was all of the stragglers after the show. So, you know, a homeless woman, a blind violinist, the ushers from the theater, people who had come from other shows, nuns who had just seen The Sound of Music or Walking By, things like that. A police officer. People of New York who were wandering around the street at that time, whereas this is just sort of, it was very, it was like an odd culmination of people with no specificity to it, which is, In this show, you need specificity with all of the dances and all of the characters.

SPEAKER_00A, it provides you more opportunities to think of creative ways to stage and choreograph and design, but then also that adds to the humor. A lot of things become funny because you know more about the character who's saying it. It's what makes things like Roger Debris and Carmen Ghia Not be offensive stereotypes because eventually you just come to know who they are and what they're like and how they would respond. And so when they do certain things that on paper could be seen as homophobic or a stereotype, you spend enough time with them to know, no, no, no, that's just who they are.

SPEAKER_00And this production doesn't really dive into that. It just kind of goes... Broad and over the top when in doubt. It also will go insanely fast when in doubt. Andy Nyman's Max Bialystok could take a breather, honestly. A joke will land and in the middle of the laughter he will continue on with the next phrase. I'm like, wait another two seconds because that next line is also very funny, but we don't get the punchline because we missed the beginning of it.

SPEAKER_00Now, granted, when it comes to comedy, I'd rather be faster than slow, but it's not a hard and fast rule. Like, it's got to be fast all the time. There's a tempo to these things, right? It's a very precise science musical comedy, and you have to really kind of feel it out and lock it in. And there are just times where it sort of felt like everyone was on different tempos, and that was really frustrating. Mark Antolin, as Bloom is good. He sounds good, but he's also a very tall,

SPEAKER_00handsome man, like rather kind of studly in my humble opinion. And this is the problem. You have very attractive people playing nerds. No matter where their origins are, maybe they were nerds growing up, but at some point they started to look hot and their way of living changed once they became hot. And similar to toast can't be bread anymore. It's very hard It's hard for hot people to go back to knowing what not being hot was and how people treated you when you were hot and what your body language was like

SPEAKER_00when you weren't hot. And so things like Leo Bloom's nebbishiness and his nervous tics are so put upon with Antolin that It doesn't ever feel like a genuine laugh coming with him. Whereas Say What You Will About Matthew Broderick, who I'm not the biggest fan of in general, what makes his bloom work so well in the original production is his sort of loseriness just didn't feel like an ill-fitting costume.

SPEAKER_00It felt just like him. And so he was able to say things quite simply and And the nebbishy, loser-y energy of Bloom just came off so naturally. And Anselin is kind of working a lot harder because he doesn't come off like a nebbishy nerd. You know, people were asking, oh, well, Josh Gad and Andrew Reynolds, could they do this show? Is that sort of the next Leo Bloom and Max Bialystok? And the short answer is yes, they could do it.

SPEAKER_00I think Gad is a bit more of a Bialystok than Reynolds is a Bloom. I really think that Reynolds is more of a Carmen Ghia than anything else. But... Even Rannells, who is a tall hunk of man, I don't, I, his bloom would be a bit more of a costume. And I would rather it be a Rob McClure. I would rather it be a, even a fucking Danny Burstein, who are, you know, wonderful actors and wonderful men, but have that more sort of insecurity locked in in their skin than some other people

SPEAKER_00that are trying to make this role happen. The question people ask is, is this going to be the production that comes to Broadway with Reynolds and Gad if they end up doing it? And the short answer is no. Because it was a Meniere production, the design is very sparse, which is fine for Meniere, but it was not dressed up at all for Broadway. They have not reconfigured the staging for the Garrick stage. There's so much comedy that is left on the table.

SPEAKER_00That isn't cashed in, but because the show itself is well written, because the cast is at least very game, and because it's not a disaster for production, just kind of a sloppy production, it's still an enjoyable time, but it is not this surefire hit of a production that just needs to come over and we can just plunk in whoever we want. Like, I think Broadway deserves to have the producers again. It's gotta be in a tighter, cleaner, crisper production than this one, is all I'll say. Um I guess highlights I I did enjoy the uh roger debris and the ula

SPEAKER_00although there are still issues I have with both of them um sorry let me find the castes for a second uh roger debris is played by trevor ashley he's very good if a little honestly uh too much like there's almost like an angry energy to him it's like If Larry Kramer were just given an endless supply of poppers, that's kind of how Trevor Ashley plays Roger Debris. Like, just Larry Kramer, high as a kite all the time. As opposed to, I don't know, like, A bit more of a Paul Lind energy, of just effervescent silliness and wit.

SPEAKER_00And then, yeah, Joanna Woodward was a perfectly good Ula. She's a little too in on the joke, and that's something that you don't ever really want to do as a comic actor in general. You don't want the audience to know that you, the actor, are smarter than your character. You need to play it straight. And I understand... Wanting to do more and be more in something like the producers that you could argue is misogynistic and homophobic and racist and anti-Semitic. And in a way, it is all of those things. And in a way, it's none of those things because it could be offensive to anyone.

SPEAKER_00It really doesn't need to be offensive for anyone at all. Except maybe Nazis because, oh boy, does it have fun with the swastika and with their main leader. It just... It throws that shit around like a rag doll and then covers it in glitter and bodily fluids until it's unrecognizable. And that is ultimately the biggest revenge that the show has on the Nazi party. Listen, if you want someone to not take anything seriously anymore, make it into a musical.

SPEAKER_00And the producers are like, what if we made Hitler a musical? No one would take him seriously. And that is the truth. Finally, we have Thelma and Louise at the Young Vic. This I saw with, again, friend of the pod, Steve Tipton. Hi, Steve. We had a lovely dinner at the Savoy and then walked over the bridge to the Young Vic to see Thelma and Louise. This was one of our first times at the Young Vic, which is just down the street from the Old Vic, wouldn't you believe it? The Young Vic is actually, it's the inverse of the Old Vic. The Young Vic is designed to be in the round and occasionally they'll do something

SPEAKER_00in a proscenium setting, which is what they did with Thelma and Louise. Uh, Thelma and Louise, this one I will give a brief rundown of the plot if you don't know. It is based off of the film with Geena Davis and Susan Sarandon. Uh, it is the story of two, uh, friends who live in the South, I think in Oklahoma, and they go for a weekend getaway. Uh, Louise, which is Susan Sarandon, Rachel Tucker here, and then Thelma, which is Geena Davis in the film, and Amy Lennox here. So Thelma is married to her high school sweetheart,

SPEAKER_00but the marriage has now gone sour and she feels very stifled. She's a housewife who never gets anything to do, doesn't tell her husband she's going away for a weekend trip with Louise. Louise is a waitress who has a long-term boyfriend who doesn't really commit to her. On their way to the cabin that they were going to stay at for their long weekend, they stop at a diet bar where Thelma flirts with a guy. Who's paying her a lot of attention because she doesn't get male attention much because of her husband. Thelma engages and she indulges in it a little bit, but she gets a little too drunk, gets a little too sick, goes outside where the man,

SPEAKER_00I guess trigger warning here, attempts to rape her, but Louise gets there just in time and then shoots him dead. They eventually go on the run. They pick up a drifter, JD, which is Brad Pitt in the movie. JD gives Thelma her first sexually pleasing experience, but then runs off with all of their money, which leaves them with very little chance of escape or anything to do. But luckily, before he left, JD taught Thelma his tricks on robbing banks and robbing convenience stores.

SPEAKER_00So Thelma does just that. Which puts Thelma and Louise in even bigger trouble. They run to the border, but the FBI and the police are on to them. There is one detective who is trying to find them, not because he wants to get them, he wants to help them. He's the only man in the entire story who wants to actually help them. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Not adhere to anyone else's rules. Thelma and Louise was a major success and a bit of a phenomenon when it came out, and it has remained a phenomenon and a shorthand for feminist cinema lit and just sisterhood and camaraderie. And I describe it as the first mainstream movie that I can think of that depicts women choosing the bear over the man. Which I do think is what has partly contributed to its success because that's

SPEAKER_00a phrase that people weren't saying in 1991, but people were feeling. Women felt that all the time, even if they didn't put it into those words. And to see two women choose themselves and choose What is ultimately a tragic ending, but their own personal choice over their choices being given to them by men was very liberating to a lot of women, and still is. And it's a wonderful movie. If you haven't seen the movie, please go see it.

SPEAKER_00It's just a fucking masterpiece. Susan Sarandon and Gina Davis are incredible in it. It's an amazing script. So the script for the movie is written by the same woman who wrote the Script for the musical, which is honestly a bit of a red flag if you're asking me. Callie Corey. Callie Corey has never written a musical as far as I'm concerned. She's written a few movies and TV shows, but Thelma Louise remains her magnum opus. The score is by Nico Case, who is not a musical theater writer.

SPEAKER_00She's more sort of like in the alternative indie pop mode, more of like an Anais Mitchell than anything else. Trip Coleman is the only person on the production team who has musical theater experience. There is no car. The car is a major component of the movie. Again, it's sort of where Thelma and Louise are just driving to the cabin to and then where they escape on and where they drive into the Grand Canyon. There is a car at the top of the show that is never used again. It's used to sort of reveal Thelma and Louise in the opening number,

SPEAKER_00and then every time they get in the car, it's portrayed by them standing in front of two microphones as headlights blare behind them. The set, for the most part, is a unit set of a dive bar. The ensemble plays multiple parts, and different spots in the dive bar play different locations, like a pool table becomes like a hotel bed and things like that. Act one of this musical started off to a really, really rough start.

SPEAKER_00The opening number happened and Steve and I both went, oh no. I'll just sort of lay it out flat. I found the first act to be kind of terrible from start to finish. I have a severe allergy to musicals where the opening number is literally the words, this is the story of. And that's sort of the opening number of Thelma and Louise of people going, this is a story about two girls who had their own way and they fought and they fled and they flew. And I just I'm like, can we not?

SPEAKER_00If it's Sweeney Todd, I'm OK with it. But Sweeney Todd uses it as both a motif and a storytelling device. And bookends the show that way, which Thelma and Louise does not. I like it a little less in Once on this Island and Hadestown, but I still like it in those shows. But again, those are bookends. The fact that this is a story being told becomes a through line of the show as well as becomes a bookend of the show. And the finale becomes a reason why this has been a story that's being told.

SPEAKER_00Once in the Silent literally has the finale, you know, this is why we tell the story, Hadestown, about, you know, yes, it's a sad song, but we're going to keep on singing it for X, Y, and Z. On the Green Room Q&A, somebody did ask, after I did my London blog for this, they were like, well, how do you feel about Aida? Where she literally sings, this is the story of a love that flourished in time of hate. Well, my answer to that is, if you listen to my deep dive on Aida with Will Van Dyke, we kind of talk about this, how the opening number is, while fun, kind of stupid, because every verse is just like,

SPEAKER_00every story, new or ancient, every story, short or long, every story. Every story, black or white. Every story, night or day. Every story, whether it's this story or that story or this story. Whether it was told to you by your grandma or your aunt. Whether it was told to you in a pool or on a plane. It's very Dr. Seuss. I do not like green eggs and ham. And it's basically saying like, every story is a love story. New or ancient. It's a love story. And that's fine if repetitive and a little dumb. And then it gets to the, boom. This is the story of a love that I flourish in a time of hate.

SPEAKER_00And I think we all can agree. When someone is being fierce, our critical brain goes out the window because we just start to, our little gay hearts, and no matter what your orientation is, we all have a little bit of a gay heart when it comes to our Broadway divas. And when Sherry Renee Scott starts belting opposite a guitar riff, it's like, yes, yes, queen, you do you. But even Aida bookends the show. Every story comes back around at the end, and we close out with the exact place that we had started,

SPEAKER_00which is this museum, and we see that Radames and Aida have found each other after all these centuries in reincarnation. Salma Louise is not that. Salma Louise ends with the way it ends in the movie of them flying off And choosing the bear over the men. There is no, and that was the story of these girls and how they drove and how they fled and how they flew. And this is why we are telling you this story. It does not become a complete arc from that opening number. It just becomes a, this is the story about women.

SPEAKER_00And they repeat it once in act two, but that's about it. And I am more about, why don't we just jump into the story then? So the next number is Thelma and Louise singing a song of like, and we're going off for the weekend. And here we go in the car. And it's not, The best number, but it is a better way to start. The truth is that Nico Case is not a musical theater writer. She writes about emotions and vibes. And so things like Thelma in Act 2 having a power ballad about her own And part of that is because songs like that live in the world of vibes and emotion.

SPEAKER_00And so that is, and it's not necessarily specific. And that is something that someone like Nico Case could probably write more for. There's this epidemic of everyone trying to find the Unique answer to musical theater writing. Ever since Burt Bacharach came onto the scene with Promises Promises,

SPEAKER_00it's been, well, what other pop writers are we sleeping on? What other indie alt writers are we sleeping on who could write a musical theater score? And for every Anais Mitchell or Sara Bareilles, we have the opposite of that. People think, oh... If they know how to write a bop, if they know their way around a cute, cunning lyric, they can write a musical theater score. It's a very different beast. And you see that with something like Thelma and Louise, especially with how Callie Corey, all of the best moments that she has in her script are the ones

SPEAKER_00from her original screenplay. Now, granted, it's an amazing screenplay, and I'm not mad about seeing those moments reflected on stage, but it shows you that she hasn't brought anything special or new to the piece. The only real thing she's brought is in the detective and his wife. The detective is played by Harvey Keitel in the movie. It's played by a man of color in the musical. And they reflect on this. They talk about how, oh, you know, you're a man of color and you're working as a police officer or with the police anyway in the South.

SPEAKER_00You need to have your badge on you all the time or they're going to shoot you and you need to do a good job because if you don't, then it's going to reflect it's going to Hurt the chances of men of color after you who are looking to go into your line of work. And it's like, yes, all of these things are indeed true. We don't have the time to give this the attention it deserves. And because we don't have that time, you're best to just not bring it up only because it's already, we're already thinking about it. But if you're bringing it up and then only doing lip service, to me, that's worse than not doing it at all.

SPEAKER_00The other thing they have is they, Callie Corey has expanded the role of the detective's wife and I'm not even sure she's in the movie, and if she is, she's got like two lines, but here she becomes a mouthpiece for the audience to basically properly express why this story has resonated with women for decades, which is every time he talks about Selma and Louise to her of like, oh, they did this. And she says, well, you know, they did shoot a man. Would you ever shoot somebody?

SPEAKER_00And she says, well, it's a miracle that I don't shoot someone every day. Do you know what it's like to be a woman? And it's not that it's unspeakable. True, but it is very on the nose and obvious. It is saying to the audience, we don't trust you to understand any nuance about what these characters are up to. We don't trust you to have your own feelings and opinions. We are going to tell you what it is. So that way, when you leave here, there's no debate. And this is something that has been happening with musical theater for a while now. So it's not a Thelma and Louise specific problem, but this is not something that I choose to lie down and accept

SPEAKER_00with musical theater writing. I think that musicals have the chance to be nuanced still. I think that you don't need to have a statement made to you in giant glittery letters so you can go off and be like, well, that's what it was about. And that's what they wanted me to take away from it. I think we can still have conversations about musicals in the way that we do about plays and film even. And the thing about Salma and Louise is that they are ultimately heroines at the end of the day. They are complicated for sure, but they're not anti-heroes. Yes, they do a couple of bad things, but the truth is that because we are invested in their story from the beginning,

SPEAKER_00we see who they are before they start doing things like Robbing a convenience store and sort of being on the run, we don't view them as villains or good women who have gone bad. We see them as women who are doing what they need to do to survive because the world around them refuses to let them win. And it's act two where the musical doesn't necessarily succeed, but improves because most people think of Thelma and Louise and they think of that second half. They think of,

SPEAKER_00first of all, the driving off into the Grand Canyon, but they think of Susan Sarandon and Geena Davis sort of dirt stained and wearing jeans and knee high boots and aviator sunglasses and like looking fly as fuck, having no shits to give, shooting up a truck because a trucker was being lewd to them and having the truck blow up. Getting their kicks and whatnot. And just being really independent badasses. And that is where the musical starts to... Again, I won't say succeed,

SPEAKER_00but starts to evolve and mature a little better because ultimately it feels to me and it felt to Steve that the writers were more interested in that part of the story than the first half. That was where they felt that the musical, their answer to why should this be a musical? Because you always want to ask yourself when adapting a story, what makes this a musical? I think there are things in Thelma and Louise that could be a musical. Thelma is a very closed off character who's got a lot Of water running beneath the surface and finally lets it all out as she pours her heart out to Thelma

SPEAKER_00about her assault in Texas and about all the regrets that she has been all the all the people who've disappointed her that stuff that is right for musical theater. There's so much in Act 1 that just does not meet that potential at all. There's a number that Thelma sings. After Louise has shot the attempted rapist and they're sort of on their own, they find a motel that And while Louise tries to get her wits together and get money together, she's like, Thelma, go off and sit by the pool and relax.

SPEAKER_00And Thelma sings this whole song about, well, isn't this a great vacation? And it's an up-tempo, slightly comedic number. And I'm sitting there going, you just got assaulted eight hours ago. Like, violently assaulted. And before he could do the ultimate... You know, active violence on you. It was when your best friend shot him dead. That is a very harrowing, traumatic moment. You are not then going into a comedy number eight hours later.

SPEAKER_00There is much more going on in that brain of yours. And the thing about Thelma that makes her an interesting character is who she is at the start is not necessarily a character that I think a lot of women would view as a hero. She's actually a woman who a lot of people might identify with of her Being trapped in this marriage, of her having her own arrested development, of being with this one man for many, many years. And part of the reason why she and Louise flee after shooting Thelma's assaulter is because Thelma's like, well, tell the authorities that he tried to rape me.

SPEAKER_00And Louise is like, everyone in the bar saw you drinking and dancing and flirting with him. And Thelma's like, that doesn't mean that this is what I wanted. And Louise is like, that doesn't matter to them. This is what they're going to see. Which then... Starts to ricochet in Thelma's own brain of, well, because a lot of the issues that they fall into of having to go on the run after shooting the rapist, of then them stealing money, comes from the fact that, you know, Thelma then trusts this drifter JD and fucks him and leaves him alone with their money, which he steals. So Thelma keeps fucking up for a long time

SPEAKER_00before she eventually starts coursing them on the path of badassery. And before she makes that turn, you see in the movie how much guilt Geena Davis' Thelma has because she ultimately is just too trusting of men and of the world and is still kind of in a high school, small town girl mentality. She realizes too fast and too depressingly how dark the world turns around her.

SPEAKER_00And not only is it affecting her, but it has brought down her friend with her. And part of her has a little break of like, is this my fault? Was I asking for it? Like, how much of this do I blame myself for? And the musical never really grapples with that. The musical doesn't grapple with that kind of tug of war of... Of just mind frames between her and Louise for most of Act 1. And even Act 2, once they get into the badassery of it all,

SPEAKER_00the thing is that what makes them so cool is ultimately what's going to lead to their demise. They are spiraling towards a tragic conclusion, an inevitable tragic conclusion, because everything that they do that is badass, of robbing a convenience store, of tying up a police officer and leaving him in the trunk of his car, these are all things that tie... The FBI to them and make them easier to find. For everything they do that makes them feel like Bonnie and Clyde,

SPEAKER_00It leaves larger, more obvious breadcrumbs right to them. Again, which leads to their inevitable tragic conclusion. So they don't become this spinning wheel of amazingness, but also chaos. It just becomes this slow burn of all the things they do that are awesome. You don't ever really get the fact that time is running out. You never really get the fact that everything they're doing is bringing the FBI closer to them. You don't get that kind of tension. As I said, the musical opportunities are better in the second act. It's a bit more evolved in the second act.

SPEAKER_00But there is one number that is just camp chaos, which is when the police are interviewing Thelma's husband as well as JD and going back and forth. And they don't go for country so much as they go for kind of like what Steve called Hamilton minus rap and like hip hop music. It's just it was. It was just very tonally off and very silly and a musical that takes itself very seriously as well. And I know this has been workshopped to death.

SPEAKER_00I know that people want this to come to Broadway. I know that Mickey Joe gave this four out of five stars. This is not a good musical. There are things in it. I think that Amy Lennox and Rachel Tucker do their damnedest. They have very good chemistry. And they really pour their hearts and souls into these performances and they sing their faces off. And I think they have come up with strong performances. And there's a fun aesthetic to the show. And not every song is a dud. As I said, I think that Rachel Tucker gets the best song on the show in the second act where she's singing about her former assault and the trauma and what that man took

SPEAKER_00from her. But ultimately... The whole thing amounts to a giant missed opportunity. There is something that they kept that I want to just acknowledge because it led to a really wonderful moment afterwards as we were heading into the Right before Selma and Louise drive off the cliff, they share a kiss and then they drive off. And that kiss has always been misinterpreted in my eyes. People taking that as a romantic gesture of that these are women who were in love with each other and finally they were able to express it because they realized

SPEAKER_00in this moment and then they drove off. And I don't, I've never interpreted it that way. And I say this because as we're in the show, they kept the kiss. And... Then they do their drive off. And as we're leaving the theater, there was a school group at the show as well. And we're walking out and we hear a couple of teenage boys together. And one teenage boy says, I didn't get why they decided to be gay at the end. That was so random. They had that whole LGBT thing at the end, but they kissed. And why were they queer at the end?

SPEAKER_00And the other boy goes, oh, that wasn't, I don't think that's what that was. I don't think that they were gay at the end. And the boy goes, well, but they kissed. They kissed at the end. And then the other boy says to him, well, I think that was just an expression of friendship. And Steve and I laughed because we were like, fuck yes, kid. That's what it is. To say that it is a romantic gesture, I think, is a gross oversimplification of what that moment means in both the movie and the show. The bond of friendship and sisterhood that Thelma and Louise have, not only of their love in friendship before the events of this story,

SPEAKER_00but then what they go through during the story and how they tie in even closer to each other. It becomes a bond that not many people can really claim because how many people can say that they have a friendship that is founded in Humor and happiness and solidified in trauma and pain. And then you have a cathartic release that ultimately results in the end of everything. Right? Not many of us. Count on one hand.

SPEAKER_00And that is what's going on with these two women of I love you. Like I loved you as a friend before any of this happened. I love you as a sister because of what has happened. And I... I'm at peace with us going out this way because I'm with you. And it's a kind of love that doesn't have to be romantic. Romantic love is not the only kind of love. It's not even the most powerful kind of love that you can have.

SPEAKER_00And I think Thelma and Louise is a story that proves that. As I said, when we begin the story, Thelma is married and Louise has a longtime boyfriend. Men keep letting them down. The world keeps letting them down. And in the end, they choose the bear. And in this respect, the bear is their bond, their death, and their choice. And that is something that I think is really important. And to the musical's credit, I do think that they explore it decently. But by the time we get to that ending, for me, it is too little too late.

SPEAKER_00The last 20 minutes of this musical proved to me that I spent an hour and 50 minutes thinking this shouldn't be a musical. They made a mistake. This should not be a musical. And in the last 20 minutes, I went, huh, maybe this could be a musical because this moment is getting fleshed out decently, not to its full potential, but more so than anything else in this production. And I hate to say this because I know they've been workshopping it to death, but I think we need to workshop it again, possibly with different writers. You know, Callie Corey wrote a wonderful film.

SPEAKER_00She's not a librettist. Nico Case is a wonderful songwriter. She's not a musical theater writer. I don't know. I don't know who I'd want to see write this. Who would you guys want to write this? Think about it. Who can give us some of that country twang but also give us that heat, you know? Because you need some heat and some dirt and some grit to this story. And then I don't know who I'd want to write the libretto. Maybe Paula Vogel? But I don't know how many musicals she's actually written, so maybe not that.

SPEAKER_00But somebody like that. Lisa Krohn. Maybe Lisa Krohn would do a good job with the libretto for Thelma and Louise. Yeah, let's see that. And then bring Janine Desori back in there. Have the Fun Home team come back again to do Thelma and Louise. Lisa Krohn and Janine Desori. That's it. That's the one. Okay, here we go. That's it. Woo! Alright, so guys, that was our London trip. I have such a headache right now as I'm recording this. Oh my god, I think that's why I'm spouting nonsense so much. But I hope you enjoyed this. I hope you enjoyed this a lot. After this episode on Main, you are going to get another preview of an exclusive episode from the Green Room.

SPEAKER_00And then after that, we are going to have some reviews, things like... A re-review of Slam Frank and Soon and some other off-Broadway stuff all sort of combined in one episode. Reviews of Paranormal Activity and Schoolgirls and Other Desert Cities. And then after that we will have deep dives getting sprinkled in throughout iTunes. I do have to go to Tampa at the end of the month to do rehearsals for a show for a cruise line that I've been creatively consulting on. In fact, another reason why we've been delayed on this episode is I had the last week doing

SPEAKER_00a workshop of this show in Washington Heights with the team. And while it's been going really well and really wonderful and very fulfilling, it is time consuming and very exhausting. So, you know, That won't interfere with episodes coming up in the future, but I'm just letting you know that I might say, oh, this episode's coming out next week, but then a different episode ends up coming out, and it's because my schedule has been going in flux lately, and so while I'm trying to make plans for all of this, things get in the way.

SPEAKER_00There's also a new change that's coming. I don't want to say anything just yet because nothing's been signed, but There's going to be a little change to the podcast soon, which might make it worthwhile to join the green room so you don't get ads when you listen to these episodes. But we'll come to that. We will come to that bridge. We will cross the bridge when we come to it. Okay? Yeah. See, it took me a while to get to the phrase, but I got to the phrase eventually. I cannot stress enough how much of a headache I have. If you want to submit your choices for the Deep Dive series,

SPEAKER_00you can do so, again, on the Discord channel. The link will be in the episode description. Remember, you get up to five... One movie based off of a musical, one musical based off of a movie, one play, and then the other two are yours to choose. You can do two plays, you can do two movie musicals, two more stage musicals. I would request that somebody put in a Muppet movie, whether Muppet Christmas Carol, Muppet Treasure Island, the Muppet movie, Muppets Take Manhattan. I would like to do one of those. I think it's really delightful, and I think I deserve a treat like that, don't you?

SPEAKER_00For this episode, let's see, I'm trying to think of what diva we should close out with. We've definitely closed out with Rachel Tucker before. We've closed out with Maria Friedman before. I think, you know what we're going to do? We're going to close out with... I'm going to look for some audio of Anna Villafonnier. I'll find audio of her and we'll do that. If not that, then I'll close out with audio of Jenna Russell.

SPEAKER_00Oh, so fun fact. While I was in London, I got to see The Odyssey, finally, in IMAX, 70mm, at the BFI IMAX in Waterloo. And it was really cool. The BFI IMAX, BFI means British Film Institute, in case you were wondering. It's in the middle of a roundabout and you can only enter it underground. So there's no street entrance. It's all underground, which is really, really, really, fucking cool. And I enjoyed the Odyssey. It was fine. 20 minutes too long, but I enjoyed it more than I expected.

SPEAKER_00And Samantha Moore And Anne Hathaway were the best performances in the movie. Samantha Morton and Anne Hathaway serving See You Next Tuesday. So that's all I got to say. So yeah, we're going to close out with Anna. So we're going to close out with Anna. And if I can't find any solid audio for her, we'll close out with Jenna Russell. But I will see you guys next week for the Green Room exclusive 20-25 minute preview. It's a jukebox that musical with... John Miscavige and Allie Gordon. And then after that, we're going to get some review episodes and then we're going to get some deep dives. And then before you know it, it's Tony time.

SPEAKER_00We're going to start doing some Tony episodes. So yeah, that's it. Take it away, diva. See you guys next week. Welcome back, bitches. Broadway Breakdown is back. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode