Matt Reviews: WICKED: FOR GOOD w/ Andrew Chappelle
1 hr 14 minAudio
Matt Reviews: Wicked: For Good with Andrew Chappelle Matt is joined by Broadway actor and podcast host Andrew Chappelle for a theater-nerdy breakdown of the hotly anticipated Wicked: For Good. Together, they dig into how Part Two stacks up against Part One, what the film gets right (and very right), and where it stumbles on its way down the Yellow Brick Road. From pacing to performances to the Wizard of Oz tie-ins, this episode explores why Wicked remains one of the most passionately debated properties in modern musical theater. Resources & Links Broadway Breakdown Discord Broadway Breakdown Substack Timestamps 00:00 - Welcome to Oz… Again Matt and Andrew introduce the episode and their shared history with the Wicked universe. 08:45 - Revisiting Part One & the Big Pacing Debate Matt’s qualms with Part One resurface and why movie musicals today struggle with airflow and pacing. Andrew counters with why he loves the “epic fantasy” pacing of the films. 10:40 - Comparing Film vs. Stage Energy Andrew describes seeing Wicked live again and realizing how fast the Broadway version moves - and how intentionally the films do not. 14:20 - No Good Deed Andrew declares No Good Deed the film’s peak - a visceral, intermission-style gut punch. Matt shares his own favorite moments, especially Ariana Grande’s performance. 22:40 - Can Art Be Too Safe? A conversation about modern creative fear, audience reactions, and why art that tries not to offend often loses its punch. 25:20 - The Wizard of Oz Problem (or Feature?) The backlash to Act Two’s deeper Wizard of Oz connections - and why fans remain divided. 56:50 - New Songs: Going for the Oscar Original songs in movie musicals: the pressure, the pitfalls, and why audiences scrutinize additions to iconic scores. Key People Mentioned Film Cast: Cynthia Erivo, Ariana Grande, Michelle Yeoh, Jeff Goldblum Creative Team: Stephen Schwartz, Winnie Holzman, Jon M. Chu Other Titles Referenced: Chicago, Dreamgirls, Hamilton, The Wizard of Oz, Suffs Listener Discussion Questions Did Wicked: For Good capture the emotional high of the stage version for you - or did the cinematic scope change it? How do you feel about the additional Wizard of Oz tie-ins? Did they enhance the story or distract from it? What makes a movie musical adaptation succeed - pacing, performance, fidelity to the stage show, or something else entirely? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
It seems to matter anymore Like a comet walk a moment As a passing as a sun Like a
SPEAKER_02stream that meets a colder Halfway through the water
SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL. Welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And this is a review episode of one and only Wicked for Good. And my guest today, you may know him from Hamilton, from Und Juliet. You might know him from his first Oh my gosh, insert applause here.
SPEAKER_00Cheers, standing ovation, my lord.
SPEAKER_01I love your intro. I think the idea of a DL Broadway stan is, it's very niche and I think has the seeds of a really great Law & Order SVU episode premise. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Law & Order SRO is what it's going to be called.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I could just see some really good lines coming, you know, from the studio about this DL person. We can't go down this rabbit hole too much because we've got we've got a full movie
SPEAKER_00to talk about. But I do kind of have take qualm with the quote unquote cool theater kid, like the person who's like, I do theater, but I'm a cool guy. I'm like, no, theater is not really cool. It's awesome. I love it so much. But like, it's inherently a very passionate thing to do. So when people like I'm too cool for school, I'm like, you're in Les Mis. You're not too cool for school. Just like be a nerd like me. It's fine. It's OK. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, you raise a really interesting point because when I was reading all of the paperwork you sent before this podcast, which, by the way, wow, you are very thorough. Yeah. Which a very theater kid of you. Yeah. You have an outline. Okay. But I was, like, thinking about my relationship to Wicked. And how when I discovered Wicked, I was a theater nerd.
SPEAKER_01Like, big time. Big time. Like, I remember... Like the first time I listened to the, I went to my friend's house and he was like talking about a chorus line and I'd never heard of a chorus line. And he was like, oh, you have to listen to it. And he gave me the CD and I put it in my Discman. Yes, that's the era that I'm in. And the sleepover was done. I was listening to the chorus line for the rest of the night. Mm-hmm. And that was the kind of kid I was, and that is about the same era that I found out about Wicked.
SPEAKER_01I remember one of my high school classmates had taken a trip to New York, and he saw Avenue Q, he saw Assassins, and he saw Wicked. And he was explaining to us the end of Act One. And he was like, she rises, she's flying, but her cape takes over the entire stage. And I was just like, I have to see this, I have to see this. um fast forward to me now i feel like i actually am a little bit more like that person that you just described the the i'm i'm a cool theater
i'm not like a regular i'm a cool mom you know i prefer you to drink inside of the house um i do i still do love performing in musicals but i can't say that i'm like coming home and
SPEAKER_01listening to dear evan hansen after i leave work Sure.
SPEAKER_00I think when you when it becomes your life for so long, it's when I talk about like the cool thing, it's not like, oh, you don't listen to musical theater on your days off. But when it's when it's sort of around you all the time. Yeah. Like you want to respite from it. You want to listen to other stuff. You want to watch other stuff. You can't make it your whole identity because there's so a there's so much in the world to expose yourself to and explore. But also sometimes you need a break from the stuff. I do this now. Full time. And I won't lie to you, like I get food poisoning from shows a lot.
SPEAKER_00And I come home when I'm like, I want brain rot. I'm going to watch British Bake Off and I'm going to listen to Sabrina Carpenter. And I'm not going to listen to a single vibrato for a week. And that is so I absolutely hear you on that. I will say, when did you finally see Wickhead on the stage? OK, so I didn't I did not get to see it in New York, although I'm jealous.
SPEAKER_01My boyfriend got to see the original cast.
SPEAKER_00So did I. And oh, did you really? This is guys. This is where we tell you I am Andrew Chiffel's boyfriend. Hard launch.
SPEAKER_01Oh, my God. You guys. I didn't get to see I didn't get to see Wicked until it came to L.A. And I got to see Stephanie J Block. That's a good one to see. I mean, I've been a Stephanie J. Block fan since Boy From Oz. I saw her as Liza Minnelli. And I just, I've always responded to like hefty voices. Yeah. You know, I just like love like a big, a thick voice.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And she's got that. And I mean, also to hear her whole story, her relationship to Wicked and how I believe she did the early workshops of Wicked when they were working in L.A., So it was like kind of a nice, it was nice to see her do the role. But I remember in college, I went to CCM for musical theater. And we were obsessed with Wicked. And when we were at school, Shoshana Bean was playing Elphaba. And so we, of course,
SPEAKER_01we know that was back when YouTube was like, I mean, I guess YouTube is huge now, but it felt even bigger to us then. And we would go to the dorm room and we would watch Eden Espinosa, Defying Gravity, Eden Espinosa, No Good Deed, Shoshana Bean, Wizard or Die, Shoshana Bean, No Good Deed. And we would just like memorize the riffs. And then we would take it one step further. And one of my classmates would call the stage door.
SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01And ask, is Shoshana Bean playing Elphaba tonight? And then we would like either hear yes or no. And we would be like, okay, great. She's playing tonight. This is good. She's on. That's how nerdy we were.
SPEAKER_00I fucking love that. Because you guys, it's not like you could even see the show. You're just like, we want to know. Is she working tonight?
SPEAKER_01She's working. Yeah, we just wanted to be informed about her attendance.
SPEAKER_00Thank you ever so much, sir, for your service. How lucky that audience was to get to see her and hear her. Absolutely. Absolutely. I saw Wicked the week before it opened with the entire original company. I then saw it that following August. And then I didn't see it again on stage until post-COVID, where I saw a very lovely, very talented replacement cast. But listeners of the podcast had asked me, oh, was it just as magical as the first time you saw it? And I said, no disrespect to the actors in that stage who are very talented,
working very hard.
SPEAKER_00But no, it's not the same. Because when I first saw it, 1800 people never heard Defying Gravity before. You cannot replicate that. Now, 1800 people, if you're lucky, 500 people in that theater have never heard Defying Gravity, but usually you're talking about 80 to 90% know it. And especially now with these movies, everyone's like going and being like, okay, let's see how this girl flies today. So you just can't replicate that. But what I loved about the first movie was Defying Gravity was able to capture that energy again for me. I remember when...
Cynthia Erivo sang that anymore and you heard bum bum bum bum bum I started to get choked up and my mom was like are you okay and I said yes it's just it's the song and I had no other way to describe it other than that where did you see wicked part
SPEAKER_00one when it came out
SPEAKER_01I was with my boyfriend in Houston for Thanksgiving. And so we went with his dad and saw it downtown Houston. And then I saw it again, like the next, like I think three days later with Jasmine Cephas Jones in L.A. Get a better theater because the sound in Houston at the Houston theater was not giving. And I was just like, I need the sound to really hit for me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, it needs to enter you. What did your boyfriend's dad think of the movie otherwise? Joe, did your dad like Wicked? His dad was lukewarm on it. That's okay. He's allowed to be. We did do a review episode of the first part a year ago. And much as I enjoyed it, I did have some qualms with it. So I do understand where people can be a little tepid on it. You had qualms with part one. I did. I did. Nothing that was bad. More that I thought things...
My big thing with movie musicals right now is I feel like pacing is an issue. I had just I've just done an episode on Chicago for the podcast and rewatching Chicago.
SPEAKER_00I'm reminded of how fucking airtight that movie is. And that show is airtight. It is. But the thing about the movie of Chicago that they do that I'm surprised more movie musicals don't do now is when a number ends in Chicago, the the button of it is a sound cue for the next scene. So there's no room for applause. You just go right into the next thing. And I really like that it keeps the momentum going. And there are times in Wicked and Wicked for Good where I really wanted that to happen just to kind of keep the momentum going because it's for
me Wicked part one there was nothing that I would cut but there was just air that I would like to sort
SPEAKER_00of suck out. I felt like I like the air in things like the Dancing Through Life when they dance together. That moment, I'm like, let her breathe. But other moments, I'm like, I wanted us to get to Wizard of Night a little bit faster. I wanted us to get to One Short Day a little bit faster.
SPEAKER_01See, the thing... Okay, so this is what I really enjoyed about the format of these two movies was that... And this only became clear to me when I went to go see Lincia in Wicked when she had her debut as Elphaba. Yeah. I had, you know, seen Wicked Part 1 twice or three times at this point, but I hadn't seen the stage show since, like, 2019, maybe? Oh, no, not true. 2022, 2023. Anyway.
SPEAKER_01And it occurred to me how fast-paced the Broadway show is. Like, I mean, that thing is going, boom, boom, we're here, we're here, we're here, the lights are up here, the lights are up here. And... In that moment, I was just like, oh, I actually feel like they were so smart to put the pauses into the movie. Because when I think about Wicked Part 1 and Part 2, while it is a musical, I feel like they formatted it more like an epic, like a Harry Potter or a Lord of the Rings style film.
SPEAKER_01Where, like, when you sit down to watch Harry Potter, like, you know you're going to be sitting there for over two hours. Like, get yourself ready. To, like, go into another land. And so what I really enjoyed about part one in particular, and we'll get to part two, of course, was, like... Just going to your point about how, like, if you go to see Wicked now, most of the people have heard these songs before. These movies have given us a gift by showing us things, us Wicked fans for 20-something years,
SPEAKER_01showing us new scenes, going into new characters, new places. Because it's like, if they just mounted what we've seen on Broadway forever, which I think is, like, closer to what Chicago does, even though they did the whole, like, you know... It's all in her mind. In her mind thing. And that music is conceptual anyway. Yeah. Like, if they did just kind of like a direct transfer, I think it wouldn't have been as big of a smash because there's just so much to
SPEAKER_01chew on in this world from the book and from, you know, there's just so much. Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00I think what the movies get right first and foremost is... making sure the music is well taken care of. Every song sounds fantastic. Period. Period. Yeah, exactly. And there's one thing about Wicked that, like, you know, there are... The show has its bumps, as does Wicked for Good. But the one thing that keeps it all together, that keeps it iconic, is that that music, you can be... an esoteric fuck all you want like that music hits in a way that is chemical and so
when you're doing the movie you have to make sure that those songs are treated well and i think most of those songs have been treated extraordinarily well and that is important to me um it returned to me during uh uh thank goodness and she i was her date we went to the premiere together what what is time i don't even know when that was here in new york and she turns to me during thinking goodness she goes that
SPEAKER_01sounds like hundreds of people singing And I think it probably was like maybe like 75 people singing, but then their vocals doubled. Yeah. Like, like it's just, it sounded tremendous.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. The sound. Yeah. Very, very full. And I, I appreciate it greatly. I love the lush old school. This is a movie element of, of that. Um, yeah. I did not get to go to the premiere of Wicked for Good. They kept begging me to go. Oh, you know, when I was there, they were asking, like, where is Matt? Yeah, I was I was I was busy that day. I am. Yeah, I was I was I was busy. No, but yes, I. You were missed.
SPEAKER_01I mean, many, many. I heard a lot of people asking where Matt was. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Cynthia Erivo didn't have laryngitis. She wasn't speaking out of protest that I wasn't there. Correct. Yeah. Yeah. She said if that voice.
SPEAKER_01They said enough is enough.
SPEAKER_00That's not here. I will not do an interview. What would you say was your biggest highlight for good? Scene, music, whatever. You know, I think you're talking about the material, not my experience seeing the film. Yeah, not what happened in the theater, but in the movie itself. What was the highlight for you? Well, I think that there are no notes to be given for the way that they presented no good deed.
SPEAKER_01Period. I mean, No Good Deed had me feeling the way I felt the first time I saw Wicked and Defying Gravity ended. And then the lights go down and then they come up and it's intermission and everyone's like, that's the way I felt after No Good Deed. So I would say the highlight for me in the movie was No Good Deed. Wonderful. What was yours?
SPEAKER_00Well, I'm trying. I don't know if it's a specific number or moment. I do feel I have absolutely no notes for Miss Ariana Grande and her performance. I thought that she was pretty exquisite in this. I thought she was equally heartbreaking and funny and sounded beautiful. I think my biggest highlight actually was because it was a new moment. I wasn't I did not find all of the inclusions of Dorothy worked for me. There's that one shot when the monkeys grab her from the troop and it's like a POV shot of her flying in the air and you see her feet dangling in the frame.
SPEAKER_00I wasn't a very big fan of that shot. It reminded me of like those simulation rides at Disney World where you're like on the Avatar rides. But when Glinda's with Morrible and the wizard's leaving in the balloon and you see Dorothy in the distance be like, wait for me, wait, don't go away in the balloon. Yeah. And Ariana Grande just goes, ugh, it's always something with that girl. And I just thought that that was very, very funny. And so that was a big moment for me. I would say No Good Deed and For Good were probably my two
biggest musical highlights.
SPEAKER_00I loved how Thank Goodness sounded. I thought Ariana sounded great. I wanted a bit more movement from the ensemble in it. I didn't like how stationary they were. Because the only movement came from those women in pink who were like... I don't know what you would call their dancing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, those like bubble ball girls.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Interpretive dancing with the balls. I wanted, because what I love in this stage show is sort of like the constant twirling that the ensemble does.
SPEAKER_01The coats, the coats. Everybody's slipping discs in their backs because the asymmetrical coat is there. They're dancing on a rake and going like this. Exactly. Everyone is now in wheelchairs. Yeah. But not NASA.
SPEAKER_00No, wait, no, no, not NASA. NASA's no longer in the wheelchair. I guess... I don't want this to be an overly negative episode because I did have a lot of qualms with this film, but I also had things that I liked. I did. I wasn't, I did not enjoy Wicked Witch of the East in this film. I just did not like the. Yeah. And again, but I can, I'm, I'm, I can talk about why, because I, my big thing is you cannot like something,
SPEAKER_00but you have to talk about it. It can't just be, she was bad. End of story. Because I don't think that's. conducive to conversation. What stuck out for you? Well, so again, I always that scene has always been fun for me on stage because Nessa, as little stage time as she has, I always found to be a very fascinating character in the musical of a young woman who could have so much in life because she's beautiful, she's well-liked, she's well-connected, but because she is a wheelchair user,
SPEAKER_00she defines herself by this part of her body, and she projects that everyone else pities her because of it, which is, I think, a very human thing to do when we all... when we all have things about ourselves that we're insecure about, we put in our head that it's all everyone else sees. We're all trapped in our own mind. Yes, exactly. And of course there's been conversation about an ableist narrative with Nessa with that. And I think maybe in the film, I would have liked the opportunity to keep that element of Nessa's character. Cause it's a very human flaw that we all have,
not of to define ourselves by the things that we can't do and that everyone else
SPEAKER_00thinks less of us for, but maybe, but having the, that not be the case for other characters like Bach doesn't not love Nessa because she's in a wheelchair he does he doesn't love Nessa because he's in love with Glinda and that is the hard fact and so I always appreciated in Wicked Witch of the East when she's able to walk now she still doesn't get what she wants, which is Bach. And we watch how she turns because she and Elphaba both get the label Wicked Witch. But Nessa actually earns her label because she's entrapping the
Munchkins in Munchkinland.
SPEAKER_00She's becoming- Into the travel ban. She invented the travel ban. She invented the travel ban. But she did also invent the black chic simple look. I mean, Michelle Federer with that tight ass bun. I'm like, she may be evil, but she looks fierce. I mean, she looks like Fosca. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01She's a young Fosca. Nothing is original. Everything is recycled. She looks like Donna Murphy. She was sitting behind me, by the way, at the premiere.
SPEAKER_00I was so gagged. Donna Murphy. I would love to see what her morrible would look like. But yeah, Donna Murphy would eat. The way she would do that Wicked Witch speech. My Lord. Go to text. She would paint it. Go to text. Go to text. But again, Nessa is Fosca with the glow up. But what I remembered about Michelle Federer, because she had this sort of This ingenue-esque timber to her voice that made you really want the best for her. And so when she takes that hard turn in Wicked Witch of the East,
SPEAKER_00I'll never forget her sobbing when Christopher Fitzgerald was like, I need to go see Glinda. And she goes to the desk and I remember she put her head down in her hands. And then he said, I lost my heart to her. You know that. And then I just remember Michelle's face going, boom. And then he's going, and I was like, oh shit, what's she going to do? And I didn't get that in this, in the movie. I didn't, it felt like they didn't want to let Nessa go full blown bitch because they didn't want a backlash about that. And I'm sort of like, she's more interesting if she goes that route,
especially because like she needs to earn the title Wicked Witch of the East
SPEAKER_00because she, she also gets that. So if, In this film, if she's dying two hours later from that cyclone, her evil legacy is the travel ban, which at that point is like four days old. And that's, for me, that's not quite enough.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think, you know... Yeah, I think that the actual part of Nessa Rose is just, it's a tough part. It is. Because it's one of those parts where you have to, as the person who is playing the part, really figure out your through line because you don't have a ton of stage time. Yeah. And, like, you figure out, like, where you sit. I think what I'm hearing from you is this classic issue that we
have now with
SPEAKER_01Beyonce's internet, which is, like, everyone's worried about getting canceled. Everyone's worried about how is this going to play? Who's going to come after us? What's the hashtag going to be? And I'm not super tuned in to all of the minutiae about why she didn't walk. I do remember hearing something about, like, If they make her walk, this is going to be, you know, people are going to be really upset about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And look, if people are going to be upset, then they are allowed to be upset. I mean, that's the world. You get upset by something every day. That's being alive. Yeah, I'm upset right now. Yeah, you're regretting being on this podcast every second. My God. But...
SPEAKER_01There is that weird thing that happens when you make art, when you are a little too tuned into the possibilities of somebody else's opinion, and then you have someone walk away from the movie like you did being like, I feel like maybe that could have been a little bit more intense. So, you know, you kind of end up losing both battles because it's like those people weren't offended, but they're also like maybe not even the core audience. And then you have people who are the core audience who are like...
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00A little gypped. And I think that's sort of the problem. As you were saying, when you're trying to make art that doesn't offend anyone, like you don't want to get canceled, you're out of fear, right? It's hard to make something that packs a punch. The things that... You do you have to do with your full chest and it's going to rub someone the wrong way because there are seven billion people in the world and everyone has a different walk of life, a different experience. Someone's going to get offended by it. Someone's going to accept get upset by it. That's their that's their journey. For example,
SPEAKER_00I'm sure there's someone listening to this right now who's like, I'm sorry, I thought Wicked, which of the East ate in the movie. And that is fabulous for you. Thank you. Love that for them. But that is sort of that is what we're doing here is we talk about things that have come out in the world. And once a piece of art, whether it's film or theater, once it is released, it belongs to the people now who are absorbing it. And every take is going to be a little bit different. And that's why we have a podcast like this, Andrew, where we have conversations.
SPEAKER_01You know, this reminds me of when we were doing Hamilton, downtown, and then in previews, uptown. Tommy, the director, was really good about insulating us from all of the chatter, which, like, I think was... Really helpful to us as we were all putting it together because we weren't really thinking about what other people were saying for the most part. It also did this weird thing to us where like a lot of us
didn't realize really the magnitude of the show until the Tony Awards this year at the 10th anniversary when
SPEAKER_01we were like standing on stage and people were like, like Oprah Winfrey was like crying and we were like crying. oh, like, you guys really liked this. Wow! You know, like, and so... Now he learns. Yeah, we live and we learn, for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but... And the thing about Wicked is... When the show came out, it was not well received and audiences kind of went with their guts of what they enjoyed. People like us went, I don't know. I read Ben Branly's review, but I got to say something about this really hit for me, even with stuff that doesn't maybe objectively work. When you're watching it and you get wrapped up in it, something hits a chemical part of your body, which is, I think, a magic of musicals.
SPEAKER_01And it's also playing on one of the most famous movies ever made. Yeah. That everyone is like the cult following of just The Wizard of Oz alone is enough to intrigue you as to what this movie is about.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Story is about. Yeah. But I think that's also kind of one of the points of contention for a lot of people about act two and with this movie, with the tie ins to Wizard of Oz, because this is by that.
SPEAKER_01They really were bothered about how much Wizard of Oz was tied in.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, and that's something that I guess. Okay.
SPEAKER_01You're one of those people, aren't you?
SPEAKER_00No, I'm not. I'm not. I'm not. I like Dorothy, but I don't know. I don't know. I don't know. What I will say is I had an epiphany watching the second movie because I But act two has all the same issues that that the movie has that people are complaining about. And for me, act two on stage works a little bit better, I think, because it's so quick, as you were saying before, like the stage show keeps moving. And when you don't allow yourself enough that much time to like sit and stew with
SPEAKER_00something, you don't have enough time to really think things over. You're just you're along for the ride. It's something I talk about this a lot with. phantom of the opera the original production famously has like two applause breaks the rest of the show moves like a movie and i do think it's because hal prince went if this audience stops to think about the plot for five seconds they are going to jump off this train immediately we have it was also it was the 80s everybody was doing coke and drinking chardonnay you know what i mean like cats was a big big
SPEAKER_01deal are we not doing that anymore Well, no, now I'm just drinking Chardonnay. And that's a big part, I think, with Act 2, like Wicked has, right? Listen, there's no art that's perfect. There's always going to be something here or there that people can be like, oh, well, what happened here? Like, this doesn't make sense. All right, well, babe, then you write it. But I do think... Like, going off of what you just said,
SPEAKER_01when you go to see Wicked on stage, you are just completely aghast at the end of Act One. You're catching your breath. Even if you've seen it before, you're like... Wow, that's a beast, right? And then you have 15 minutes to go to the bathroom and get a Chardonnay and get back to your seat. So the adrenaline is like pumping it like, okay, I've got things to do. And especially if you're a seasoned theater goer like you and I, you know how you're getting all that done. And so your body, your like spirit rhythm hasn't had time to like rest.
SPEAKER_01You're still moving forward. Absolutely. So that when act two starts, you're like, okay. And then there's nothing like a good downbeat to like hook you back into the story. But what I felt like they did really good about with this second installment of the movie was they basically gave us the opening of a Superman film. Yeah. Like, I was sitting there, and the first image started with those animals, and I said, now, what is this, honey? You know, and while at first I did not understand it,
I did like that it was unfamiliar.
SPEAKER_01It made me pay attention. because if it had just started the way it starts on stage, I'd have been like, okay, guys, here we go. This time I was like, what is happening? And then I saw they were building the brick road, and I turned to Pippa, I said, what are these animals? And then she has this, like, hybrid Batman-Superman opening because it was, I think, so smart to kind of frame her like a superhero in that way. She's got this, like, amazing, like...
SPEAKER_01magical villain backstory that we know isn't villainous, but she's misunderstood, and now she's, you know, righting the wrongs of this, you know, tyrannical person, which I feel like we need it. I think that was what I'm—the chatter I'm hearing on the internet, some of the things that people are saying they didn't love about this movie. I'm like, you know— If you're going to do act two of Wicked and you've got like millions and millions of dollars and Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo are there and
like the set is built.
SPEAKER_01you might as well give us as much as you can. You know, like, they filled in, listen, to their credit, they filled in a lot of blanks in this part,
SPEAKER_00too. I like this image you have of John M. Chu on set being like, well, we already built a set, so might as well.
SPEAKER_01We've got the tulips. So, like, we've got to do something else in this tulip field. We have the tulips. We had these people in Amsterdam planting these tulips for a year. Yeah. When there was when there was that close up of the tulips towards the end, I think it was after the melting scene around the time when when Glinda was coming
SPEAKER_00back to the Emerald City, there was that close up of the tulips. I was like, oh, they made sure to get that shot in. They're like, we planted a million tulips and my God, we will show them again. And now everybody knows they're real, real tulips. So like now they can really like revisit the tulips. Absolutely. I liked the beginning. I, I, I, that was another, that whole first section for me pre thank goodness was another moment where I was like, I like everything we're doing. I just like, if I were in the editing room, I would have gone into like shave off a second here, shave off a second there. Cause it was a full 10 minutes before we got to thank goodness.
SPEAKER_00So I liked it. It incorporated what Elphaba has been up to. I did like that. The movie showed more of Elphaba's efforts to try to, you know, help, uh, liberate the animals. I thought that was a nice touch because in the stage show, because there's not a lot of time, she kind of forgets about it after a while.
SPEAKER_01They really drill down on her with these animals in the second part. She really loved them animals. She goes full Snow White in that forest scene. And those animals say, honey, forget about you. You can sing at us all we want. That lion told us what you did to him. You took him out his cage. And I said... Why is this lion? This lion is over here complaining. The lion is one of those people that's always complaining about something. Like in a musical theater program, they're like, it's hot in here. And then you turn the cool air.
SPEAKER_01I'm like, it's cold. My hamstring is tight. And you're like, girl, then go outside.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think I have nodes. It's like, yeah, it's always something you do.
SPEAKER_01And still you need to sing on them.
SPEAKER_00We all have nodes.
SPEAKER_01Everybody get get with the program. And it was so funny because all those animals, they weren't in cages. And then they were just like, well, I can't believe you did that to that that lion. I said, this lion is in the woods with you. He would have still been in a cage. Spoiler alert. in the wizard's sex dungeon if she hadn't released him. Is that not a back room?
SPEAKER_00I say, just call it Sondheim's sex dungeon.
SPEAKER_01He had all those animals, honey, chained up. I said, that wizard is coming in here and doing all kind of nasty shit to these animals.
SPEAKER_00Yep. They look so scared. They look so hungry. I was going to say, I wish I had seen an eagle in there because then I would have been like, oh, that's a hat on a hat. Oh. The eagle, yeah. There are a lot of chestnuts in this movie. Yes, there are Easter eggs that people don't even realize are eggs. The... What was I going to say? Oh, the thing with the lion, that's always been something that people have kind of come for as like, but why is he mad? And I understand, I think I understand what they were going for of the sort of no good deed goes unpunished, right? Of like, she tries to do a good thing, but...
SPEAKER_00It doesn't matter. The propaganda against her has gotten so out of control that even the people she's tried to help think the worst of her. But I don't think they ever really were able to land the plane with that narrative for the lion because it's so quick. And because people like us go, I remember where you were at. Don't try to gaslight me. I saw I saw what had happened in that moment. And she did know evil. But it's it's I under I think I that is what they're trying to do. I will say. Oh, go ahead. I had an issue with the two new songs both being ballads because act two was so
SPEAKER_00ballad heavy already. And I wanted there to be a moment for some kind of.
SPEAKER_01I agree with you on this. I wanted there to be some like uptempo moments, but I think that they had to give them ballads because everyone's trying to go for these statues.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01A statue on the wall.
SPEAKER_00I know, but there have been some bops that have won in the past, and it's looking like Golden from K-pop Demon Hunters. That's probably going to take the statue this year, and that is a full-blown high-belted bop. I mean, not since Pippa, who I don't know, but I call her Pippa myself. Not since Pippa's high note and no one else have I heard such a high note in musical theater. Have you heard Golden from K-pop Demon Hunters? Maybe.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. My podcast co-host, Cody Rigsby, is obsessed with K-pop Demon Hunters. And I have tried to watch K-pop Demon Hunters now three times, and I just can't get through it. And it's one of those moments where I'm like, oh, I wish I could get through this. And at the same time, I'm like, do I? Does it say more about me just like as an adult that I'm like, I can't get through this?
SPEAKER_00You don't owe anybody anything to watch a movie. You know what I mean? I haven't actually watched it myself, but I have heard it. I have I have a couple friend with an 11 year old kid. Hi, Steve. Hi, Patrick. Hi, Daisy. Daisy loves K-pop Demon Hunters. And I have gone over there on numerous times where she has been playing the movie. And so I've heard Golden a few times. And I will say she she is a bop. you're an arrow collar you're the top you're a coolidge dollar
you're the nimble tread of the The top of the movie when when Elphaba is singing her reprise of Wizard and I,
SPEAKER_00you know, when I when I expose the wizard and everyone knows he's a fraud, you know, which is new, which is new. Yes. I like that. I did, too. I thought that, though, could have been a good inspiration for a new song for Elphaba of showing us all the time she's trying to almost like a precursor to No Good Deed of like her making this effort constantly of trying to liberate, trying to expose the wizard and not going well. But like, I will still try. I will still do it. And then it. another i want song exactly i want song a second i want song for for part two that
then kind of has an a response to like it's the call to and the response is no good deed of like i like that yeah and i yeah it would have given us a nice energetic
SPEAKER_00moment for girl in the bubble I my issue with that is I thought March of the Witch Hunters was such an energetic slay in this movie. Like I really was feeling the pulsation of that of that moment. And also like Ethan Slater just eating breakfast, lunch and dinner with his solo. And then when it kind of stopped for Girl in the Bubble, I was a little frustrated. And what I wanted instead was I wanted March of the Witch Hunters to reach this fever pitch that Glinda runs to Madame Morrible and is like, we have to stop this.
SPEAKER_00And Morrible's like, absolutely not. And in that chaotic moment, that's when Glinda's like, God, what do I do? Does Girl in the Bubble and have that actually also reach to a belted fever pitch that launches her onto the horse to go see Elphaba. So like it can still be a valid, but it reaches a nice, like exciting conclusion. Yeah. Because you're such a musical theater gang. You just want the girls to belt.
SPEAKER_01You need a giant belt. You want to do the split like Sutton Foster and Drowsy Chaperone. Yeah. You're like, you know, in Girl in the Bubble, it would have been great if she could have figured out a way to do a cartwheel into a split while belting a G.
SPEAKER_00No, that's what I wanted from Nessa Rose. I wanted Nessa Rose out of that chair and going into a split. Okay, well,
SPEAKER_01this is good that you bring about Nessa Rose because, like, I, you know, I don't want people, you know, to be offended by, you know, something like this, right? But why was she—she just was levitating. Like, you know what I mean? Okay, like, fine. You don't want her to walk? Fine. But they just kind of, like, lifted her up, and she was just kind of, like— hovering there like the ghost of Christmas past. And I'm like, Elphaba, let her twirl around the room. Let her, like, feel what it feels like to fly a little bit.
SPEAKER_01She was just kind of like...
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm not sure what the magic was supposed to be or what it was supposed to mean for her. She talked about, like, I want to go back to the moment when Bach said I was beautiful at the dance. And we as audience members are watching it going, but that moment was false. He wasn't in love with you. Exactly. Yeah, he was acting like I know that moment. Like all men, like all men. He was acting. Yes. Lying, lying about everything. What I was going to say about the Wizard of Oz stuff, though, was the more I think about it, the more I realize that Wicked, both on stage and in the film, doesn't really want you to remember the Wizard of Oz,
SPEAKER_00the book or the movie itself. intricately like they want you to remember like the basics of it because when you think about the actual intricacies of the movie and the wonderful wizard of oz novel a lot of it doesn't necessarily line up it's more sort of like a clever tie-in in theory but then when you like give it another minute there's that there's that video that goes around every couple of weeks ever since the first movie came out of judy garland as dorothy in the dungeon being like i'm fine and yeah my friend like genuine tears in her eyes and the caption is like imagining for good being sung like a floor above her as this is happening
it's true like she she throws Dorothy in the dungeon and five minutes later they're singing for good and it's your brain just is thinking of like Judy Garland sobbing on the floor while this is happening I mean that's the fun of it but that's also like I think that's where people who maybe didn't know the stage show watch this movie and they know Wizard of Oz so well that they like to them they're going that does that's not a real like tie-in that's a retcon and I say no and so I've always
SPEAKER_00viewed it as like you just kind of have to like Just go with it, hun.
SPEAKER_01It's a movie about witches and magic.
SPEAKER_00It's going to be okay. It's all fine. It's just a movie. It won't hurt you. But because the stage show kind of keeps moving, like the reveal of Bach being the Tin Men and all that stuff, it happens so quickly. It doesn't give you enough time to stop and ponder and think, wait a second, in Wizard of Oz, what does happen in that moment? It's like, nope, you can't think about that. We're already at the engagement scene for Fierro and Glinda. I did like that they incorporated Glinda in Wonderful. I thought that was a really nice tie-in.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was important.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think it helped with the almost seduction of bringing Elphaba to that side of the conversation. Yeah, yeah. And also I thought Cynthia did a really good job of like building that out.
SPEAKER_01Like she did really consider it. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, because I always viewed it as at that point, Elphaba is just so exhausted of what of fighting what is clearly a losing battle. And part of her is like, it would be easier to just do this. And maybe like Glinda's saying that she's trying to work the good from the inside. Maybe I can, too. And then seeing like, oh, no, there is no good on the inside. Like Glinda's just complicit in all of this as well. And and how that wants her friend there. She was like, come on, it's not so bad. Yeah. Yeah, be my girlfriend again. Let us be full on lesbians this time. We can do it for real now.
SPEAKER_00I did like the glowing of the tower as well. And then I did like sort of the upping the stakes of it. They're not just engaged anymore. Like they're about to get married. Yes, honey, left at the altar.
SPEAKER_01It was given a stampede in the Pride Lands. It was crazy rich Asians wedding. Yes. Truly. Meets Mufasa's death. No, yeah. Meets Mufasa's death. Ending with Cinderella with the shoe into the woods. 1000%. I think Ariana also did like the famous like Gen Z thing where like when she cried, she was like... Was that a Gen Z thing covering your mouth when you cry? A Gen Z thing? Yeah, you said the Gen Z thing of the...
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like I feel like Gen Z, like you guys are always like... Like, I feel like you guys are always covering your mouths. Like, when you laugh, when you cry, when something's awkward or embarrassing, you guys are like... Yeah.
SPEAKER_00They either say it's cringe or they cover their mouths. Yeah, I wonder what that's about. Do they want to bottle up their emotions? Are they afraid to let it all out? Ask your people.
SPEAKER_01Or are we... You're not Gen Z. You're millennial. You're Gen Z. Do you think I was Gen Z? Yeah, I thought you were Gen Z. No, I'm millennial. I was born in 1990. Oh, that makes sense. Yeah, I mean, if you have a podcast, you're a millennial. Yeah. First of all, wow. What Gen Z people have podcasts?
SPEAKER_00I feel like they're like, that's too cool. I'm just putting on baggy jeans. You truly are a man because you were giving me such a compliment and then you backslap me so hard. And I don't know how you feel about me anymore. You also know I'm a man because I have a podcast.
SPEAKER_01Yes, you do have. Yes. Listen, if you're a millennial and a man, you definitely have a podcast.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but good luck to the rest of the world because there are just so many of us saying our opinions on mic.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, whether you want to hear them or not. And like and full disclosure, I'm doing this wicked episode. Our wicked episode for our podcast comes out the same day. So if you enjoyed this conversation, you can get a double dose and listen to Tackle Pettiness right after this.
SPEAKER_00But listen to this one first. This is the out of town tryout. So Andrew can get his much clearer Instagram worthy opinions out for his own podcast. Well, no, see, this is a more theater, this is a more theater, dramaturgical-based discussion.
SPEAKER_01Cody and I are going to, we're a pop culture podcast, so the takes on that are going to be very different.
SPEAKER_00Okay, well then, pop culture for a moment. What character in Wicked for Good do you think is most likely to have a podcast? The Wizard. That's what I thought, but then I wondered, would he want, would that spoil the, like, elusive illusion of him? Or would he not care?
SPEAKER_01Oh, no, no. And I don't even think he would have guests on the podcast. I think he would just be like just him, like like Heather McMahon, like just like talking at his laptop. This is what I did today. Yeah, and it's a great way to get propaganda out. There's also probably no one else that has podcasting equipment in Oz. This is true. It would be the biggest podcast in all the land.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it would be the Wizard of Pods, I guess is what it would be called. Although I wonder, would I want a wizard podcast or do I just want morning musings from Jeff Goldblum? I want to know what that man thinks first hour of every day. Oh, I know. He's so kooky, right? He is. I really like his casting in this movie because I feel like the wizard is so hard to get right because he does have to have a sinister edge to him, but he also kind of has to have a warming first approach.
SPEAKER_00Totally. Yeah. And sometimes people cast him too cuddly or they cast him too sinister. And Goldblum has that like, oh, my God, you're just like my weird uncle. But are you my weird uncle? Like it's that. Yeah. Like how how SVU are we about to go here?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, when everybody's talking about all of these other people that auditioned for Elphaba and Glenda, I want to know the other men that were in for The Wizard. Because that list, I mean, even just like the list of men who played it on Broadway, like a lot of those guys are big enough that they could have done it in the movie.
SPEAKER_00They absolutely could have.
SPEAKER_01So I'm just like, so who else was it? Or was there no one else? Maybe it was always Jeff. Yeah, there is a Wicked podcast out right now that's hosted by Chris Murphy.
SPEAKER_00I listened to a little bit of it. They talked about the casting process a bit. They would not say who was coming in for a lot of the roles, but they did say that there were a lot of Elphabas and Glindas. I don't think there were really many wizards, or if there were, it was very few. From what I understand, there was no other Morrible approach other than Michelle Yeoh. Jon M. Chu specifically wanted her. We are very well versed in that particular plot point in the casting process with Wicked.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and they've really said that to us. She did not want to do the movie. They had to beg her multiple times to the point where they had to get on a Zoom with the two lead actresses to continue to beg her. In which she finally said, well, okay...
SPEAKER_00I'll tell you anything. It was like the president of the Academy got on the zoom as well and was like, I'm just saying your movie is eligible for Oscars this year. And, uh, do you want to get nominated or not? Maybe do this movie, babe. But I, I, I do ponder who other morables could have been because I like Michelle a lot, but this is not my movie for her. I don't think it's a match for this character. That's all I will say. And I watched her and I was like, you know, who would eat at this? Like, Glenn Close and then someone else texted me and said Emma
Thompson and I was thinking Emma Thompson and Cruella I'm like oh Emma Thompson would have annihilated telling Ariana Grande to shut up like it just you imagine you're like who could give drag queen without being too much well you know who I saw as as Madame
SPEAKER_01Morrible who uh I also was on Moesha with was Shirley Ralph um Shirley Ralph, that's a Matamorable. That is a Matamorable. That's like she's not giving full drag, but she's like she's right on the line there.
SPEAKER_00Oh, Miss Dina Jones absolutely knows how to toe the line for you. The woman who survived Michael Bennett knows how to give the gays what they want. Truly. And I mean, listen, when it comes to Matamorable, the limit does not exist.
SPEAKER_01There are so many women who can play that role. um and listen we can dig up names till we are blue in the face but those are not the names that did the role so we we we have what we have and we have to just accept this and and there are other there are other joys in this movie and there
SPEAKER_00are other michelle yo joys that is that is the fact
SPEAKER_01Well, absolutely. I mean, I, of course, like I'm chronically online, so I've seen all of the takes about her in the movie. And I think it's just like, and I guess I can be like this too. People have to be upset about something. They have to like scream into the void about something. But I just don't have the, I guess I don't have the energy. Yeah. I'm like, you know, okay, like, whatever.
SPEAKER_00You're very old. You're grandpa millennial. I am baby millennial. But I think for me, I guess I get angry if I can see potential and I feel like it's not realized. So it's less me being like, fuck you, I'm offended so much as I'm like, can we do another take? I really would love another take of this. But that's neither here nor there. It looks on you. That was the other take. That was... God damn it. I have tea about Carol Shelley's interpretation of Madame Morrible,
SPEAKER_00and I won't say who told me this, but it was somebody who worked with Miss Shelley on the role. And this was not something that was openly expressed, but how Carol Shelley interpreted the role and she worked with the wig and costume department on this to create this narrative is that Madame Morrible herself is is part animal and in fact has animal tendencies that she is suppressing as the show continues. So when you first see her with her wig, she's got the Mrs. Lovett buns that are hiding her hooves or her horns,
SPEAKER_00which she is shaving as the show continues. And you realize... Her wigs are getting smaller. So by the end of the show, she is just in the airtight.
SPEAKER_01Ramen noodle.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And by the end of the show, they've been shaved down. But also in early scenes, every now and then she would have like a slip up. She would like do a snort or she would do like a thing. But it's one of the things where you are not catching it. It's not obvious. But when she tells you what she's doing and you go back and watch, you're like, oh, I see it. It's very... Like Usual Suspects, Sizer Kose, where you don't see it at all when you're watching it. And then you look back and you go, oh, there are the clues. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_01This is what I have really enjoyed about having these movies come out is, like, all of the deep dives. You know, there was a video I saw of they, you know... do that moment in Wizard and I when she goes a celebration throughout Oz it's all to do with me and there's like the projection on the wizard's statue and it's like oh it is the celebration but it's that she's dead and you're like oh my god that's crazy and you know I enjoy that everyone is like
SPEAKER_01Having fun with it. I think really and truly, if you think about the spirit of this property and you think about the spirit of movies that come out at this time of year... it's all about community. It's about feeling good. It's about kind of just rediscovering something you love. And I think that was kind of the spirit I went into watching Wicked for Good Part 2, you know, retrospective.
It was just like, you know, let's just disassociate for two and a half hours and, like,
SPEAKER_01be taken away into another world. Because, my goodness, do I want to be taken away into another world most days.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that is most days indeed. I will say, I was very... There is an expectation that you can have over the years when you're being told like, oh, one of your favorite shows is going to get a movie version. You start imagining how it can go in your head. And truly the best moments are when it doesn't go how you expect, but it works even better. And that is how it goes. I felt that way a lot about part one where there were scenes where I was like, oh, I didn't imagine that. But I really like how they did that. And I knew part one,
I was in good hands at the very beginning when it didn't immediately open with a
SPEAKER_00boom, boom, boom, boom, boom. But it started with the voiceovers that then went into the monkeys crashing through the wall. And I was like, oh... OK, we're good. We're good. And I was very excited to see sort of how that translated into this. And there were moments where I was like, oh, that's really different than how I planned it. But I like how that went. And other moments where I was like, can I get in there? I would like to like the top of as long as long as you're mine. I do not enjoy them being on opposite ends of Elphaba's book. bird's nest when she's singing when she's like kiss me too
fiercely hold me too tight i'm like well he's outside he can't do that yet um oh see i thought that that was like her my my understanding was that that was her inner monologue wanting like
SPEAKER_01letting us in on her yearning that she wanted him to do that but like
SPEAKER_00You know, that's entirely possible. I might just be dumb. And when I like very horny watching, you're like, sing it to him. Yeah. I'm like, why are you not writing him already? He's here. He's with you. Like, get him like that broomstick. OK, girl, hop on. He has a face for sitting. Get on that face, girl.
SPEAKER_01Like, well, not when it was the burlap, Hattie. Don't sit on that. You get an allergic reaction. Oh, yeah. You're going to get scratches all up.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's the that's the true crime in all of this is that she only got to have sex
SPEAKER_01with him once when he was hot. It's true. And now she has to be with the burlap man, although he was still turning his burlap.
SPEAKER_00I mean, it's hard to make him look not cute. People were saying, oh, I didn't know Ryan Reynolds was in this movie when he became Scarecrow. Because when you look at the screenshots, he is giving a bit Ryan Reynolds.
SPEAKER_01It's true. Can we have a moment for the sex shawl? The sex cardigan?
SPEAKER_00Yes. The sex cardigan. That is what the internet is calling it, her sex cardigan.
SPEAKER_01The sex cardigan had me tackling in that movie theater. It is so auntie. It is so auntie. It's like, yes, I've got the Anita Baker on. I lit a candle. But I'm not giving him too much because I'm a lady.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I say normalize not being fully naked during sex. Normalize covering up the parts you want covered with a cardigan.
SPEAKER_01Well, because also she didn't know she had him in the bag yet. So she was like, I got to just give him a little of this. You know, she was like, I'm a marathon runner. I'm going to give him a little bit of the shoulder. I'm going to give him some clavicle. But I'm going to keep some other things covered, even though body T, Cynthia Erivo, honey. She wasn't covering up to hide. She was covering up for seduction. Let's get that straight point, period. But I think there's also something to be said for like, well, I'm not going to show you all of the goodies.
SPEAKER_02No.
SPEAKER_01My goodies. My goodies. Like, I'm not going to give it all to you up front. And then it's like after, you know, the throes of passion, you do need to have a little something, you know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Pillow talk afterwards. We were animals just then. I need you to remember that I am a person now, even though you treated me like the animal I was. Now you need to talk to me like the lady I am.
SPEAKER_01Also, something that's always been so devastating for me about the book of this musical is like, baby, I will I'm ready to end it all. If somebody says you're so beautiful and you're like, no. And it's like, well, no, you are. I'm just looking at it in a different way than everyone else who thinks you're hideous. You're like, oh, thank you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's that's a Winnie Holtzman. I need to tell you that line is not the come on you think it is. I always I didn't like it in the show. I don't like it in the movie. By the way,
SPEAKER_01deep, deep, deep, deep, deep cut, I went to drama school with Winnie Holtzman's daughter, Savannah. No way!
SPEAKER_00We went to high school together. That's amazing. Final takeaways from Wicked for Good. I know we're trying to keep it positive, but if there was one thing you would want to kind of go in and twist, is there anything in the movie that you would like to kind of get a redo on? You're allowed to pass, but I want to offer.
SPEAKER_01I did, I mean... You know, okay, so in Girl in the Bubble, I know everyone's really obsessed with Girl in the Bubble. And I liked it for what it was. You know, the camera moves in that song were so cool, but they did kind of take me out a little bit. I was just like, wait, are we in the mirror? Are we on the other side? I was like, where are we going? And it did kind of feel like an REM makeup ad. Mm-hmm. A little bit to me, like, you know, the palette and everything.
And listen, like, a lot of that is just, like, Ariana Grande's branding as flawless.
SPEAKER_01So, like, of course, like, the song where she's playing, like, a fairy princess dressed in pink in a pink and white salon with beautiful fashions. Yeah. With flawless skin. Like, of course, it all works. But it was just, like... I was like, maybe there could just be a little something, maybe something more here. But then again, even as I say that sentence, I want to slap myself in the face. Like, what do we want? Like, I feel like this when we watch RuPaul's Drag Race and people
are like, I don't know.
SPEAKER_01And you're like, that person was in makeup for hours, wrote this comedy, did the thing, put the wig on. Like, you know, we as consumers of art are just like, at some point, just like so unpleasable and gross as an audience. Because we can look at something like Girl in the Bubble and be like,
SPEAKER_00well, I didn't really like it. But I hear what you're saying. And I thought that that number was shot really well. And I liked the sort of... trick photography of constantly going in and out of reflections. And I thought that was sort of a good metaphor, I guess, for the point of the song. I think for me, all of the set dressing and the camera work was for not because the song itself didn't do anything for me. And so for me, there felt like a disconnect, beautiful as it looked. As you were saying, you know, you maybe wanted a little more from it.
I think it was the disconnect of the beautiful visuals from the song that I wasn't
SPEAKER_00feeling anything towards. It just it didn't blend in a way that I would have liked. But that's not to say that the number wasn't shot beautifully. But I also do find sometimes with John M. Chu with I felt this way a little bit in the Heights sometimes of like, this is a great music video. I'm not sure if this fits narratively. Like, it's really cool to look at, but I don't know what I'm getting from it storytelling wise. And that's something that I feel, but that's not necessarily a thing that everyone feels. But yeah, I think.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think we're kind of dancing around. I mean, listen, I think that like the best movie musicals are in recent years are Pago, Dreamgirls and Wicked Part One. And like, you know, Dreamgirls gave us that extra song and three extra songs.
SPEAKER_00What, what? It gave us three extra songs. We have Listen, we have Love You I Do, and Patience.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. I remember that medley at the Oscars. Yes. Oh, my God, Patience. Patience was a little too on the nose for me, but sure. On the nose in Dreamgirls, Andrew? Really? I feel like Listen is what you wanted. You wanted Cynthia Erivo to have a song like that. You wanted her to have that moment. So I understand this... You're not the first person to say this about these two original songs.
But there's also a trap when you put original songs because people are extra
SPEAKER_01hyper-focused in on the original song. I even told Pippa on the red carpet because it hit me because the music team took pictures before we took pictures. And so we were talking to some of them and whatnot. And I turned to her after they went to the red carpet. I said... Pippa, we get two original songs this evening. And she goes, we get two original songs this evening. You know, like there's something like, wow, we get to hear two new Stephen Schwartz songs.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's like it's honestly it's like a really ambitious undertaking to put two or
SPEAKER_01two new songs in a musical that every song is iconic at this point. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I'll be honest, the first time I heard Listen from Dreamgirls, I was not obsessed.
SPEAKER_01But over time, and like, you know, you kind of sit with something, you watch the movie again, you hear it on the radio. So I wonder if these songs will grow on us. It's possible. I... often wonder if things that are new uh or or changed are good or they're bad or if like we just get more used to them and and and thus be embrace them it's hard to tell it's always hard to tell i i don't want to listen for alphabet i that's not what i i'm not sitting here being like belt for me cynthia revo
i demand it but i
SPEAKER_00think more the idea i had was um did you see suffs on on the bridgeway No, I missed it. Okay. It's early in the show, Shayna Taub's song, when she meets Jen Colella, and she's like, I want women to vote. And Jen Colella is like, me too, but be more of a woman about it. And then Shayna Taub has this I Want song where she's... It's like getting the band together. She's like, I'm going to have this woman help me, and this woman help me, and the constant... And it's like, there's a motor underneath it. So no one's belting, but there's a drive to it. It's the... How will we find a way when there isn't one?
And that was the energy I kind of wanted from Alphaba's song of this storytelling
SPEAKER_00forward, like motor running song. That's not necessarily another no good deed, but had some energy to it. Ariana must be belting at all times. That is what I've decided because I am a gay man and I'm a misogynist that way. No, I was actually surprised how much Ariana sounded like her pop self in Girl in the Bubble. Like that was the least Glinda she sounded. And that's not a criticism so much as she sang. I was like, oh, right. This is the voice she sings like problem. And we can't be friends with. Yeah. So it was it was an interesting it was an interesting moment for sure.
SPEAKER_01Really only she really only let her her voice out like out out in. Thank goodness. It's like just the belt crossing across. Like that was like she actually like let her voice like live in that musical theater scene. it for like two seconds and it was thrilling um it's true i mean i want to say though uh and i know we gotta wrap things up but people always come for the bridges you didn't you didn't know you crossed until you crossed line and they're like oh that's the worst lyric in wicked the worst lyric in wicked is
in wicked witch of the east which is you're going to lose your heart to me i tell you if i have to i
SPEAKER_00have to magic spell you and And this is coming from someone who loves- When you say it, when you do it like Craig Cornelia would ask you in a masterclass to do it as a
SPEAKER_01monologue, that is tough.
SPEAKER_00It is. She is too. But I will say, in the movie, for all the cutting they did on that number, I watched that moment. I was like, John M. Chu, I'm not telling you how to do your job. Lord knows you're a better film director than I am. But I watched this moment. I was like, that's something you actually- This is my moment that I would have fixed, which is- If you're going to have that moment where Nessa sings, you're going to lose your heart to me, I tell you. If I have to, I have to. Have her look. Cut to the grimmery. Don't say magic spell you. Have her just see that and then book to the grimmery. But they did that and she still said magic spell you.
SPEAKER_00I was like, no. No. get it out of there get it out of there i felt like sigourney weaver and aliens get away from her you bitch like get that get that lyric out of there um so that was my big like if i could make one change it would be that because i think that was a way to have the lyric but not have the lyric got it yeah but i agree with you i think ariana sounded amazing on thank goodness and i appreciated that the camera was mostly on her for that solo uh in fact i think there was one take that lasted for like half of the half of the solos it was very nice
SPEAKER_00The camera loves that girl. I mean, she's stunning.
SPEAKER_01Wow. I mean, there was just something. I went and saw Leslie in Hamilton last week or the week before. I can't remember. But I was sitting there. Of course, I've seen Hamilton 7,000 times and been in it more. And I was just sitting there marveling at how lovely it is to watch people at the top of their game dance. Do what they do best. And I was thinking about that in terms of the dancers and just like the lighting. I was just like, wow.
SPEAKER_01I mean, it just like that show still really hits for me. But then I was also thinking about that when I was watching Ariana and Cynthia. And I was just like, wow, we are getting to see this. these two women at the top of their game with eating the best food, flying first class or private, like drinking alkaline water, going to bed early, massage in the morning, yoga ready, showing up to set 17 hours before they even have to shoot.
SPEAKER_01We are getting to see the best version of these talents now. Yeah. So that was something that I really enjoyed, just, like, marveling in that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think that these movies are a wonderful showcase for both of their talents, as well as them being just so tuned into what this story requires from them, which I appreciate.
SPEAKER_01They were fans. They were theater kid fans. I mean, it's all come out. Not to bring it all back and tie it in a bow, but, like— These girls have been campaigning to play these roles for like 20 years.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's true. And but that but that is why you don't have to try to pretend to be cool, because being passionate isn't cool. Cool is aloof. Cool is sort of the austere quality that Michelle Yeoh is trying to give to Madame Morrible. And it's OK to say you want something. It's OK to say that you love something. And that when you do, you get women like Ariana and Cynthia who make no mistake. These are women. They say, I'm not that girl. I'm like, that's right, because you are that woman. But these women who cared so deeply and love it so much and
gave us these really
SPEAKER_00wonderful performances, that's the outcome. That's what you get from just openly being like, yeah, I'm a theater fan and I love it. And it's not super cool, but watch me give you a gift anyway. And I think that that's a beautiful payoff. I also will say I did enjoy... That infamous shot that everyone now loves of them with the door, with their foreheads against the door crying because life is about to tear them apart. Also, people were asking, how did Elphaba know about the plan with Fierro as the scarecrow? People forget that one moment before For Good happens,
SPEAKER_00Chistery gives her that little patch of cloth with a note in it. That patch of cloth is from Fierro. The note in this from Fierro being like, here's what's going to happen. That's why she goes and she starts pumping out the water. Yeah. Like, that's the one thing that people are like, plot hole ding, where I'm like, eh, it's there. You just, they're just not, Jon M. Chu is not showing you what's in the note, but you're, you clearly watch her read something and then go into action. So for me, that wasn't a plot hole.
SPEAKER_01And then, you know, they, they gave us the ultimate gift at the end where they recreate the fan art. Oh, are you being Glendalby Alphaba?
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01They're, There it is. There it is. Because, you know, they kind of allude to this, like, whatever day that was where they, like, all went to have a picnic under the tree. You know, we saw it in Act 1. And we were like, what? Like, even when, like, I saw that footage in Act 1, I was like, what is this, like, magical day where they all went to this field and Elphaba has this hat on? Yeah. And they're just like, ooh, we're sitting. And then it's like to see, you know, what it was. It was a very inside baseball moment, you know? Like, I feel like
SPEAKER_01You know, my boyfriend's dad wouldn't get it.
SPEAKER_00But like, you know, we all got it. I think what I appreciate about that, because, yeah, they do sort of hint at that flashback in part one. And you're like, oh, what was so special about that day? And then in part two, it's sort of that moment aside. What I liked about it was, oh, there was nothing special about that day. And that's what made it special. It was it was a day where they were all just together and everything was fine and they were happy and they were friends and it was good. Like that was the happy memory that seemed inconsequential at the time. But it means so much now. It's I call it it's part of that montage that you see in romcoms,
SPEAKER_00the falling in love with each other montage where. You watch Diane Keaton and Jack Nicholson over the course of a day and something's got to give, just like have a picnic and walk on the beach and laugh. And it's all stupid little things. There's no grand gesture. But at the end of that montage, you're like, oh, they're falling for each other. Those little moments are the moments that are real. And that's what that ended up being, which I appreciated. I'm trying to think of anything else. Oh, the Grimery opens up for Galinda and implies that possibly she might be able to do magic in the future. So I guess part three be happening.
SPEAKER_00Wicked, Galinda's magical now. I honestly I don't think that that these these women can can do a third movie like no I know they're so tired like the amount of press and outfits even if just like I'm sorry even just me having to put a t-shirt and this on today I was just like who like imagine how many times Cynthia and Ariana change clothes in a day Absolutely. Andrew, I am not wearing pants for this interview, and I am exhausted.
SPEAKER_00They have to wear full body outfits. And you just look at them, and I know that they're so happy to have had this experience. It means so much to them. But also, this is three years of their lives. It almost ate them alive, really, when you think about it. So no, I don't actually think there will be a Glinda third movie. But they have said that they are toying with the idea of a third movie in some respect. Yeah. But I think Schwartz said, though, that it's not going to be a continuation of their stories. It's not. It's not. It's going to be other characters. And I feel like he put that in the press to be like, Ariana, we're not calling you up. Cynthia, we're not calling you up. You're okay. You can breathe. You can sleep.
SPEAKER_00But if it's not, why would we want to who? It's going to be the many it's going to be the many adventures of Dulce Bear. Dulce Bear is liberated now and she's going to get her. It's how Dulce Bear got her groove back. That is Wicked 3.
SPEAKER_01Oh, my gosh. And you know what? After after being in servitude for so many years, raising all these bad kids, she deserves to get her groove back.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It's the nanny diaries meets sex in the city. That's what it's going to be. Yeah, meets Jungle Book. Yeah. Oh, honey. The Jungle Book. She's going to get all those animals. She's going to get dicked down all over Oz. And we are going to live for it. Read her sex diary. I love it. Can't wait to see it. Animal style. Yeah. She's going to get Dulce Bear backed. Are you kidding me? Oh, you went there. This podcast goes there. What can I say?
SPEAKER_00This is the real journalism right here, right now. I see. This has been delightful. I know you have to get going soon, so I'm going to let you go. Where can people find you if you want them to find you?
SPEAKER_01Oh, my gosh. Well, you can find me at A-C-H-A-P-P-H-A-W-K. That spells A-Chap Hawk. That has been my Instagram handle. since i started on instagram and if you want to listen to my podcast it's act at tactful pettiness and on instagram and i think on tiktok too even though i'm not a big tiktoker but we do have our we do have our producer ren who who runs our tiktok which is great perfect Yes, that's where you can find me.
If you want to find me, guys, I'm on Instagram only at Matt Koplick, usual spelling. You can join the Discord channel if you want to talk to the other listeners about
SPEAKER_00the podcast or things going on on Broadway. There is a chat for the Wicked Movie on the Discord channel. So if you want to get more thoughts out, you can do that there. You can also join the Substack to read. more of my articles or get exclusive content that we'll be releasing at the end of the year via the podcast, including footage from our live musical episode that we did at Green Room 42 just a week ago. Oh, yes, it went. All right. Yes, that's yes. We will be having more shows there in the new year. It's a very exciting development on this front because I'm not just a hard hitting
SPEAKER_00journalist, Andrew. I also happen to be a decent writer and sing like a damn angel that would make even Philippa Sue weep. Wait, wait, wait.
SPEAKER_01No, this is great because I was on your Instagram. My friend Gabby McClinton was in one of your things.
SPEAKER_00She did the reading of my play. Yes, yes, yes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, she's like my sister. We grew up together. I've known her since 2006. So when this is over, I'm going to I'm going to group text you and Gabby and talk about this.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Gabby did the live stream reading of my play. She's a professional and she has a lot of time because she's not on social media. That is why she is better than the rest of us. Yeah, exactly. But yes, I do write. I do perform. I do sing. But this is my baby, is this podcast. So people should just keep listening to the podcast. Although I will be releasing some content from the concert soon enough. So people stay tuned for that. Andrew, oh, I didn't warn you this. We close out every episode with the diva, usually Broadway.
SPEAKER_00I will put her in post so you won't hear her right now. But when you listen to the episode, you will hear her play you out. What diva would you like to close out your episode?
SPEAKER_02Patty, come here. Come here, Patty. Come here. Come, come, come.
SPEAKER_01Some people probably aren't going to like this answer.
SPEAKER_02Come here. Come here.
SPEAKER_01My dog's name is Patty Lubone. I had never heard of that before. That's amazing. Lin-Manuel Miranda named her. Oh, so she's royalty. I was just going to name her Patti LuPone. And he was like, you can't just name your dog Patti LuPone. And so he said, it's Patti LuBone. I love that. Right before I walked out, I was playing Thomas Jefferson. I walked out. I was about to walk out in a room where it happens.
SPEAKER_01And he comes up to me and goes, Chappelle, it's LuBone. And I was like, great. Alexander. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Excuse me while I do my job, Lynn. Thank you so much. I love that. Okay, that's perfect. So yeah, we'll close out with Patty. We've closed out with Patty before people deal with it. In fact, Patty is the sound cue for when we cut to commercial. It's Patty and Anything Goes going, Billy, I beg to do it with you every time we take a break, which I'm sure will happen in this because of the technical issue we had earlier. That'll just be a Patty transition. But yeah, we'll go with her. Do you have any specific Patty moment you want or do you want me to pick for you?
SPEAKER_00I love that. We'll do that. Patty LePont coked out of her mind doing a new Argentina. That's what we're going to do, baby. All right. Thank you so much, Andrew. We will see you guys next week. Take it away, Patty. Bye-bye. Bye.
SPEAKER_03The Descamisadas are those he is marching with now. He supports you, for he loves you, understands you, is one of you. If not, how could he love me? I know.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...