Matt’s a Drama Desk Voter, have ya heard? Which means he sees SO much theatre. YAY! But also that means he doesn’t have as much time to record. BOO! Solution for now? A giant Review Round Up Episode covering over a dozen different performances!! What came out on top? What was forgettable? And what evening made Matt weep from start to finish? Also…how exactly does Elizabeth Holmes play into all of this?? Important Links: * Broadway Breakdown: THE GREEN ROOM (Patreon) * Broadway Breakdown: DISCORD * Broadway Breakdown: SUBSTACK * Broadway Breakdown: YOUTUBE Time Stamps: 0:00 Hello and a New Review 2:20 Shuffle Along Reunion Concert 7:54 Garry Starr Classic Penguins 11:57 Music City 12:52 Truly, Howard Hughes 14:02 In Honor of Jean-Michel Basquiat 15:44 Arias with a Twist 17:56 Delirium 22:00 Pre-Existing Condition 27:30 A Ghost in Your Ear 30:09 Anon 36:20 Soon 49:20 Slam Frank 1:02:50 Midnight Listener Questions: “Is being controversial synonymous with being important?” “Are there story ideas that are actually off-limits?” “Should we cater to shorter attention spans or do we need to challenge them?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_02Welcome to the pinchers from the stagehands, it's the only quiet thing they do.
SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all. And I hope not a ton of time.
SPEAKER_00I'm going through a whole bunch of things that most of which have now already closed, but I have to cover for Drama Desk purposes. For those of you who have forgotten, I am now an official Drama Desk voter, which is wonderful. I get to cover a lot of stuff for you guys. That also means I'm seeing a bunch of things all the time. I don't have a lot of time to record anymore. So it's a whole catch-22. Part of the reason I'm a voter is because of the podcast. And now that I'm a voter, I don't have as much time to record the podcast, especially once we start doing actual awards coverage and deep dives. First things first.
SPEAKER_00We have a new review, and we like to give our reviews the time of day, so if we can please cue the Light in the Piazza overture music. Five stars. Fabulous. Written by But We Sing It Anyway. Hadestown reference. Broadway Breakdown is fabulous. Matt has encyclopedic knowledge of Broadway and an acid wit. Most importantly, he's He actually loves theater. He's honest, but he's not trying to tear down productions for the fun of it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, but we sing it anyway. Remember that, guys, as we get into some reviews later in this episode. I am never trying to be a dick for the sake of being a dick. Sometimes my dickishness do come out, but I get provoked. I'm sort of like Elle Woods. I don't start the scratching, but if you do scratch me, I will scratch back. So I do want to kind of start on a very positive note here. This is not something that needed reviewing, but it's something I wanted to acknowledge. There was a reunion presentation of Shuffle Along or the making of
SPEAKER_00the musical sensation of 1921 and all that followed. If you know me, you know that I saw this production, its first frozen preview when critics were coming. I was there the same day as Ben Brantley. I thought that was very cool. And I adored this show so much. Was it perfect? No, perfection is overrated, especially when it comes to theater. But it was so intelligent and fascinating and creative. And I did find to be cohesive, even if it sometimes was fraying at the end. But like,
SPEAKER_00It still followed its own logical conclusion and had a point of view and was insightful about the questions that it asked and inventive about how it wanted to present itself and the passion it had for that era of Broadway and was designed to perfection. And I've always been harping on just how brilliant the show was and how it didn't get its fair shakes.
SPEAKER_00And I've been feeling a bit of a rut lately with theater and with some of my favorite artists of just, I feel like I've become a bit of a Debbie Downer and just sort of like finding all the ways in which something could have been better. An infamous case on this podcast was I was one of the earliest vocal critics out there of Audra McDonald in Gypsy, not just her, but the whole production. Got some backlash for it and then, you know... Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Like, but I love Audra and I love George Seawolf and I love Gypsy, right? Like why, maybe I am in the wrong here or maybe my cynicism has gotten the better of me. And then going to see this concert, which I didn't think I was going to get to see. And when I say concert, like it was a pretty much There were some cuts to the book. So George Seawolf's libretto, which was already a little scattered in 2016, has been reduced for this concert. So it's more focused, but it also certain things happen a lot quicker in scene work so we can get to
SPEAKER_00the songs. And I guess to sort of put it in perspective, it is a bio musical of the making of the musical Shuffle Along, which was a major breakthrough in Black artistry on Broadway, thus to say, commercial theater. And the thing about it that's so devastating is that it was this ginormous hit. And then so many people who were involved in bringing it to fruition sort of fell away into obscurity. And other shows that owe their debt to shuffle along became much better remembered.
SPEAKER_00And that is something that is talked about within the show. So it is indeed a... The first act is how this show came to be. Like Broadway Breakdown, it's sort of like, okay, let's figure out the context of what the show is. And George C. Wolfe and... Savion Glover really think outside of the box in terms of presenting certain moments and getting abstract and theatrical and metaphorical with certain parts. And then act two is the success and then the fallout of that success. And... This reunion was reunion of the entire original company,
SPEAKER_00sans Joshua Henry, who was replaced by Norm Lewis. And as I said, fully staged, all the original choreography, plenty of costumes, lighting, full band, a lot of people trying to be off book. Not everyone succeeding. Audra and Adrian Warren fully succeeded. They were sharp as a tack and off book the entire time. But when I tell you that I was kind of sobbing from beginning to end of this, what I mean is that it reminded me that, no, I do love musical theater.
SPEAKER_00I do love Audra McDonald. I do love George C. Wolfe. Honestly, I thought that Audra's performance in this blew what she did in Gypsy out of the water. She was funny. She was sexy. She was heartbreaking. She was in beautiful voice. She looked fantastic. As I said, she was off book and just like razor sharp all night long. Everyone was in fine form. Billy Porter, who I normally have a little hesitation towards, was in really strong form that night. Adrian Warren was incredible. And God, it just really ignited that flame in me again
SPEAKER_00of how much I love not just bold ideas, but bold ideas that go to the finish line and just challenge you and excite you at the same time. I think that musical theater that's trying to be deep or important, if it's going to challenge you, it also has to excite you simultaneously. You blend the two. That's what makes it musical theater, right? Taking music and storytelling and blending it in a way that straight plays cannot
SPEAKER_00and movies cannot. And I think that Shuffle Along is such a prime example of the 21st century of that kind of storytelling. It is not consistent with a lot of other musicals of the century. It's very unique in that respect. And I think because it's so unique in that respect, it turns some people off or confuses some people. But my God, I'm so happy that they filmed this concert and that it's going to be shared on PBS in 2027 because more people need to be exposed to it. It is just mind bogglingly sensational and brilliant.
SPEAKER_00My God was this. A healing night for me. Another thing that I saw that was sort of by accident, and I'm glad that I got to see it before it closed, was Gary Starr, Classic Penguins. This was a production that was started in Edinburgh, made its way to New York. It's going to go to London next. And then he had mentioned at the curtain call that after London, they're hoping to bring it back to New York. And I hope that they do. And it is 80 minutes A man going through the Penguin Publishing House's, you know, collection of literature.
SPEAKER_00Moby Dick, War of the Worlds, Grapes of Wrath, Of Mice and Men, Dracula, Frankenstein. And when I say that he's going through it, I mean like, sort of not really. And also, by the way, he's naked on stage the entire time. He has a top hat, he's got a coat, he's got little flippers to act as if he is indeed a literary penguin, but he's He has no pants. He has no underwear. He is showing dong. He is showing boot and hole. And when I tell you that that is ultimately a gimmick that then plays out into kind
SPEAKER_00of a really beautifully cathartic experiment, the show itself is ridiculously fun and silly and intelligent and inventive. You know, he goes through each book. There's a lot of audience interaction, which I normally hate, but somehow he was able to make it truly an audience collective where we all He pushes the boundaries of decorum.
SPEAKER_00And yet you're just so on board with all of it. Part of it is that he is so charismatic. He's so gregarious in that way. Part of it is that he has perfectly built how to let the audience in and move the goalposts of audience interaction. By being fully naked, he himself is putting himself out there totally exposed, nothing to lose. He is in some ways at the disadvantage because everyone can see what he looks like fully bare, but he is so... At ease with it. That we don't feel like we're voyeurs.
SPEAKER_00We feel like we're all just in it together. And when he goes through the catalog of literature, as I said, it's not... So when he does Dracula, he puts in fake fangs, opens up a trunk where you see a baby's head, like a baby doll's head, and he's like, I'm hungry for blood. And you go, oh, no, he's going to drink the baby's blood, which he kind of does. But what happens is he takes the baby doll out. Instead of it being a full doll, it's a bottle of V8 with a doll's head on top and legs and arms.
SPEAKER_00And he takes the doll's head off and he chugs the entire V8. And then he has himself a food baby, which then transitions into The Handmaid's Tale. Or he does Frankenstein, where he brings an audience member on stage where they have to be Dr. Frankenstein. And he's like, you have to, I'm going to be the creature. You got to dig out all of the body parts and sew it all together on me. And the audience member does it to the best of their abilities, you know, in a sort of yes and impersonation. And then he becomes the creature asking for Papa. And that's when the audience member runs off stage and back out into the audience.
SPEAKER_00And all alone, as the creature from Frankenstein, he sings Billie Eilish's What Was I Made For from Barbie. That's the kind of ridiculous brilliance we're talking about. And it was the exact... Yeah. Not in a cult manner, but more just sort of in a like,
SPEAKER_00yeah, I'm here and I'm alive and I want an experience. And that's sort of what this was. And it was really for something as stupid as this premise is and as gimmicky as him being naked on stage sounds like it was very affirming to see something so creative and intelligent and ridiculous and effective. I really enjoyed that. Couple other of rapid fire things. We saw the return of the musical Music City, a new musical, which was an environmental musical being done at St.
SPEAKER_00Luke's that is basically about like the Nashville music scene and ins and outs of a brother duo band and what happens when they bring a girl on board. And it was solid. It's a two act with two and a half hour length. Honestly, could be about an hour and 50. It's really like kind of the premise of a 2008, 2009 movie. But it's a strong cast. And again, another show that does a really good job of...
SPEAKER_00The Aviator. This is pretty much how you would expect a buy-in musical of Howard Hughes by
SPEAKER_00the York Theatre Company to go. York Theatre Company is, they gravitate towards an older school sound, more kind of golden age, Rodgers and Hart kind of music, and that's very much what Truly Howard Hughes presents. It was a very impressive production, very well designed. It ultimately falls prey to all of the pitfalls of a buy-in musical of Howard This happened, then this happened, then this happened, then this happened. Without any clear theme or through line or point of view, Howard Hughes as a character ends up becoming the least interesting person on stage
SPEAKER_00because he becomes a cipher for everything around him rather than a genuine protagonist. His I Want song was literally called, I'm going to find it here because I remember thinking like, I Will Find a Way is the name of Howard Hughes' I Want Song. That's all you need to know about sort of the specificity we're talking about here with this kind of musical. We had the one-man show at New York Theatre Workshop in honor of Jean-Michel Basquiat, which was created and performed by Roger Smith. Roger was a friend of Jean-Michel Basquiat, the queer Black artist who was primarily known for his friendship,
SPEAKER_00collaboration, and inspiration with Andy Warhol. There was a play on Broadway, I believe, called The Collaboration, which was, I think, Jeremy Pope. And God, I can't remember his name, but he played Vision and he's married to Jennifer Connelly. Somebody remind me, Paul Bettany. I believe it was Paul Bettany and Jeremy Pope in The Collaboration. And if you're watching this on YouTube, you watch my brain literally try to close itself up and be like, figure it out, figure it out. And then I think I did. This is, again, a hundred-minute, intermissionless, one-man show.
SPEAKER_00Sort of Smith's recollections of Basquiat and their personal friendship. It was very slow and abstract. And I can't rightfully say that I, or my friend Josh, the one who I took to shuffle along, that we were necessarily taken in by it. It clearly means a lot to Smith and for that the piece deserves to exist because part of the inspiration for art comes from a passion to get something inside
SPEAKER_00of you out there but then once you put it onto a stage in front of people and you And this was something that just did not feel inclusive in that respect. Not that I need to be handheld or spoon-fed things. We all know that is absolutely not who I am. I just felt very much at a distance, at a remove from this kind of show. Something that threw me off my guard and didn't put me at a distance was
SPEAKER_00the show Arias with a Twist. This is a collaboration between the drag performance artist Joey Arias and the master puppeteer designer Basil Twist. This show has been around for a while now, I have found out, I think about 20-ish years. Joey Arias has been around since the 1980s. And it's hard to describe exactly what this is. It doesn't have much of a plot. It's mostly a collection of songs. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Running through various simulations almost as like a Godzilla 10,000 foot woman throughout the Manhattan skyline. Things like this. It sounds very odd. It is very odd. But it's also incredibly funny and incredibly just inventive. It's bizarre, but not in a way that makes you feel like you are being pushed away. In a way where you're just kind of getting more and more curious as the evening goes on. I can't rightfully say... This, you know...
SPEAKER_00I can't fully describe it. All I can tell you is the memories I have of it, the impression I was left with. In a way, it is sort of like a painting in that respect or like an acid trip. And I am not angry about either one of those things. It is different from everything else I've seen and it is memorable in that respect. And I will... Remember it probably come to the end of this season, if not far longer. Something else that I found to be kind of odd, not necessarily in a super memorable way, but in a way that I'm glad that I did for my own expansion
SPEAKER_00of my theatrical brain is Delirium, which was being done at the space at Irondale in Brooklyn. This is based off of the play Frenzy for Two by Eugene Ionesco. It is about a couple of That is squabbling in their apartment while outside is a war. Which war is unclear because I believe the play came out in the 1950s or 60s, but it could very possibly be World War II. It could be World War I.
SPEAKER_00It is up to you to decide. It could be a World War III sometime in the future. It could be a civil war. But this couple, for the entire run of the play, again, I think we're talking about a hundred minute intermission list, I can't quite remember, they squabble over their history together. We find out that they had left their spouses for each other and now they've come to regret it, but also they do still love each other, but they also... You know, opine about the past and their childhoods,
SPEAKER_00and they keep coming back to certain petty arguments, but while this is happening, the danger from outside keeps growing and growing. You start to hear gunshots, you start to hear explosions. The set, which is basically scaffolding representing an apartment, continues to fall apart as the evening goes on, and by the end of the What we've come to realize is that our couple, what looks to be an avant-garde
SPEAKER_00Ending of them putting on spacesuits and finally escaping and going out into space is actually their final fantasy because in truth they do not survive the war outside. They become one of many bodies that get tied up and hung by the rafters as an example to those who are still surviving the war. Ian Esco is not a playwright that I am incredibly familiar with. He does have a revival of his play, Rhinoceros, Coming to Broadway.
SPEAKER_00It is Replacing the Full Monty, which we discussed in the Green Room Q&A. I want to say back in September. I can't remember. Maybe August. But I had heard rumors. I think it was September. I had heard rumors that Full Monty was getting postponed and that Rhinoceros was coming in. And then that got confirmed this past week. And so he definitely deals with... Very large themes of societal danger and complacency in a, I won't say comic tone, but a bit of a comic tone, like definitely a clownish tone.
SPEAKER_00It's taking clownish buffoonery to represent the dark underbelly of
SPEAKER_01societal rot.
SPEAKER_00You know, the way that Delirium was performed was kind of how I wish more Waiting for Gado's were performed, of a bit more silliness. So that to not hide the pain that is at the heart of Waiting for Gado, but to engage the audience and keep the play going. So when the despair of the repetitiveness of the days that go on and on in the cycle of Waiting for Gado truly reveals itself... We can feel a bit more of a gut punch rather than sort of a lethargic,
SPEAKER_00okay, now when is this play actually going to be over? Delirium is not a show that's necessarily for me. It's not necessarily for my sensibilities as I have always known them. But it was an important thing for me to see. And I think shows like that and Arias with a Twist are important for you guys to see. Because if you only... Another play, Pre-Existing Condition, which is currently being done at the Barrow Group. This is by Maren Ireland, directed by Maria Dizia.
SPEAKER_00This is, I believe, the second production of this play that's been done in New York City. I got to see it with Lupita Nyong'o in the lead. I believe Philippa Su is now doing it. This, again, is like a 90-minute, two-hour, intermission-less piece that is ultimately focused on the healing process post-sexual assault. The main character's name is A. Again, when I saw it, it was Lupita Nyong'o. If you go to see it now, it's Philippa Su. And A... Has just gotten out of a very toxic relationship that turned violent towards the end.
SPEAKER_00And she is doing what she can to remove herself and heal herself from all of that. Part of that is going to group therapy. Part of that is dealing with people in her life who are still connected to her past partner. And Having to grapple with their own shaming of her and them trying to play devil's advocate, which is not even that they truly blame her for anything, but because they still want to be friends with her partner. And the only way they can do that is if they dilute the impact of what her partner did to her or dilute the fact that he instigated by saying that,
SPEAKER_00oh no, there are two sides to every story. And also of A's being able to trust men again, putting herself out into the world again. This was a piece of which I admired greatly and I mostly enjoyed. I still have a little bit of issues with Lupita Nyong'o on stage. This is my second time seeing her on stage. I saw her in Eclipsed. I did not get to see her in Twelfth Night. But Lupita Nyong'o is someone who I find to be such a searing presence on film.
SPEAKER_00And I know that she went to Yale Drama, so I know she studied acting for the stage, but I still find physically she... She can get at sea with what to do when trying to express herself to a larger lens, if that makes sense. Because the instincts are all correct, the emotions are there, and she doesn't over-emote or go too small. It's just a simple technical element of hands and arms.
SPEAKER_00And you can say, well, isn't that part of her characterization? Yeah. It also is, I don't think it helps that because the show is so fragmented and jumps around in timelines and doesn't, again, doesn't really go towards a specific situation.
SPEAKER_00Because the goal is not really the point of it. It's more about the journey rather than the destination. It can sometimes feel, and this is where passion and curation have to meet, it sometimes felt a little meandering. Some scenes felt a little repetitive. Some scenes felt a bit less impactful because they were coming after a long stretch of indecisive storytelling. The passion behind this piece is ultimately what carries it through.
SPEAKER_00And the, I think, intelligence behind the nuance of how each character is portrayed in the show helps a great deal. And the frustration and the confusion of A... Allows us to not view, not to feel like we were being hit over the head by what the play is attempting. And again, the strength of the ensemble of Dizia's direction really also helps it continue. I think I was expecting more to be really devastated by this or like really...
SPEAKER_00Extraordinarily moved. And I felt more like while it was an important subject, I had felt that other pieces had done it a little bit better, which is a very bougie problem to have. But that is my personal experience with the granite. You know, my history with Assault is very specific and my process through it was very different from A, so it's not like I could see myself in her, but I've also been very vocal of you don't have to necessarily see yourself exactly
SPEAKER_00in a character to empathize with a character. And I empathized with A. It was more the construction of the piece itself that did not always take me in. But again, there's a strong cast. Sarah Steele, Greg Keller, both really fantastic. And I thought that there's a really great story. I think I just wanted a little more of things like that with a bit more of a through line, which it's a little bit of a sociopathic way to think about, but that's kind of how you have to think of theater, right? A little bit of sociopathy.
SPEAKER_00That probably said that incorrectly, but oh well. Something else that is much lighter, but also I thought a little better constructed was A Ghost in Your Ear, which is at Audible Theater at Manetta Lane. This is, technically speaking, a two-person show. I will not give away the twist at the end, but the basic premise is an out-of-work actor is asked by his friend to do an audio reading of a ghost story for an
SPEAKER_00Undisclosed Client. The friend is behind his own wall in a sound booth, but you do see him as the story continues. The lighting gets darker and you feel more alone with the actor in the space.
SPEAKER_00He's given a very special mic that is basically a gray head that he can speak into at different angles. So you hear a voice in one ear or another ear or in the back of your head, things like that. And on an audio level, sound design wise, it's exceptional. Would you do it? Mostly, it's just a fun time.
SPEAKER_00There aren't a lot of jump scares. I don't think you need a lot of jump scares in a play like this. It's mostly an experiment intention. My only critique of this show, I think it's very well performed. I think it's beautifully designed. And I actually had a really fun time with the story itself. My only issue is I found the last five minutes to go a bit more campy cheeky. Which is fine, it can go there, but it tries to have something to say towards the end and have a little bit more emotional heft as the twist of what is actually happening the studio is revealed. But then...
SPEAKER_00It does like the final sort of jump scare that I thought was a little silly. But otherwise, I found it to be a very effective time. I really enjoyed myself. Again, it's not nonstop scares. I have not seen Paranormal Activity yet. That episode is coming up soon. But as I understand it, that is a lot more like jump scares. This is a lot more tension. Boom. Tension. Boom. And for me, I like that a lot.
SPEAKER_00Right around the 2024 election. And Crystal Finn, who some of you might remember from The Saviors at The Atlantic earlier this year, is a woman who is trying to be like a momfluencer on TikTok. She apparently had all of these followers on Twitter before Twitter became X, but then she got blocked and Elon Musk still has not unblocked her account. So she's trying to start over on TikTok and it's not going well. And she is ultimately a QAnon conspiracy theorist. And it's revealed that Not slowly, but not immediately. Like when we first see her, she seems relatively normal.
SPEAKER_00You know, she loves her daughter. She seems to love her husband. She, you know, is able to function like a human being out in the world. But more and more of what she talks about both online and then slowly to her daughter and to her husband reveals like that she is fully brainwashed by QAnon conspiracy theories. And all of this conflicts with across the way is their new neighbors who is a gay couple. And they are watching her on her TikTok as they see her kind of slowly start to spiral. But then they also instigate more spiraling from afar.
SPEAKER_00And as this is happening, Crystal Finn's daughter is reading King Lear in class. And so then the play tries to have a mirroring effect with King Lear. Uh... I enjoyed this play to a degree. Acting-wise across the board, I think it's really strong. Crystal Finn in particular is doing an incredible job as the character of Jeannie. And the first act I thought was really strong. It was setting up all of these plot points and exposing all of these threads that I thought were going to tie together. And when the gay couple are in their home sort of talking about Jeannie
SPEAKER_00and how crazy they think she might be... That's when Jeannie's husband shows up and they freak out because they don't know what to expect. But then he's asking them if they can give him any of their moving boxes because they've just moved to the neighborhood. He's like, hey, you know, if you could give me like whatever empty boxes you haven't gotten rid of yet, I'd really appreciate it. I'll come by at an undisclosed time. You know, I can grab them whenever in the middle of the night. And it's very clear that there's an implication of that he's looking into leaving Jeannie. There's also stuff going on with Jeannie's inner life,
SPEAKER_00with her daughter's inner life, the gay couple and what's going on with them. Jeremy Shameless's character starts to spiral his own self. He buys a gun. All these things start to happen. We're like, okay, we're going to culminate into a lot of conflict and a lot of drama in a second act. And also Washburn doesn't totally make Jeannie a certifiable nut. She's a nut when she's talking and raving on TikTok. But when she's with her daughter, you see that she's actually quite smart in a lot of ways. She had a literature degree. She's a good writer. But the whole play supposedly takes place over just a couple of days.
SPEAKER_00When Act 2 begins, Jeannie has fully flipped in a matter of like 24 hours and has totally snapped. But Shamos and his husband and Crystal Finn's genie never actually meet. The inclusion of the gun is never brought to any satisfying conclusion. Genie's husband going to them asking for boxes is never brought to any kind of conclusion. More and more of King Lear is brought into the text so that when it ends, Genie does her own kind of soliloquy to the audience as she sort of snaps in the rain and tears down their pride flag without actually, again, having met them, does a whole soliloquy to the audience and then says,
SPEAKER_00and now it's all over and the play is over. And you're like, ugh. The first act, I thought, did a really good job of setting up this house of cards. And then rather than watching it all collapse in the second act, it's almost as if the play put that house of cards behind a wall, brought out a different house of cards that we were not introduced to. And it's like, no, this is what we've been building to all along. Now watch this collapse. And it's very unsatisfying because you feel like everything that was getting led up to by intermission is just... Just completely abandoned for a whole new idea and I thought for a
SPEAKER_00while it was really fascinating to be inside the mind of someone who online you view as this crazy monster or so out of touch and to see how she is day to day is not quite how you would expect her to be online. You also wonder how much of her daughter starts to turn on her because her daughter does turn on her in the second act because Jeannie goes down such a deep end but again it's It's almost as if there was this whole second act that got cut and that what we ended up watching was a third act and they just tied the two together. And it's frustrating because act one really worked for me and then act two really did not.
SPEAKER_00The play does do a good job with how it presents the digital world, texting, videos, research online, things like that. A lot of really good projection work on that end, a pretty fluid set. But ultimately, the bad taste I have in my mouth of the second act really undercuts all of the goodwill that the first act gave me. I like challenging works like this that really kind of push your empathy, push your perception of reality. I want to talk more about this when I come back from the break with not only our next three shows,
SPEAKER_00but I will be including a little discussion of the new documentary on Elizabeth Holmes by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim called You Can See Everything, which was three hours and just bonkers and brilliant and... Cause so many questions with me and my mom and everyone else I know who's seen it. And I think that this is something important to tie into with our next three shows, which again, we'll talk about after the break, which is Midnight, Soon, and Slam Frank. I'll probably do Soon first. Then Slam Frank, then Midnight. I think that's how it's all going to tie in together.
SPEAKER_00This is not a gotcha moment. I have in the episode description the timestamps for everything of when everything happens. But I wanted to do the rapid fire out of the way first because now I got to take a break. I got to go see Copperfield. Then I'll be back and I'll either record those reviews tonight or first thing tomorrow. But you guys will get it literally in five seconds. So let's take a quick break. [music]
SPEAKER_00And we are back. The meat of the episode, the section that everyone's been waiting for. And yes, I am teasing all this out because that is what good content creators do. I'm also just constantly putting off my own thoughts as I keep, um, I should also say this as we continue. Spoilers abound for all of these. There's really no way for me to discuss these shows without going into the details. So if you really want no spoilers, I'm so sorry to say this, but you should probably skip this episode.
SPEAKER_00And if you don't mind spoilers, if you're okay with sort of the discussion of them, then let's barrel forward. Soon follows the story of a young woman named Charlotte. The whole thing takes place in her apartment, which she shares with her roommate, played by Mike Millen. Charlotte is known as Charlie. She's played by Ava Delaney. Her roommate, Stephen, is played by Mike Millen. And... This is being performed at the loft above St. Luke's Theater. So if you're on 46th Street, which is Restaurant Row,
SPEAKER_00rather than go through the main entrance of St. Luke's, you actually go through a side entrance by a church, go up two flights, and you end up in a big sort of loft space. There's a band on one side of the room. The audiences are on opposite sides of the floor. So again, we are in Charlie and Stephen's apartment. And Blum has done a really good job of sort of Keeping everything moving, everything flowing, making good use of such a limited amount of space, finding design surprises with projections and with lighting.
SPEAKER_00Sound design also is very well balanced considering that it was all happening in a very small room together. The show follows Charlie who has basically hold herself up in her apartment every day. Her roommate Stephen is gay. They've known each other since college and Stephen is more vivacious. And so he kind of keeps Charlie, I suppose, like Lively, but Charlie still refuses to go out. Charlie falls in love with a boy named Jonah who she meets by him delivering her groceries at the top of the show. Charlie has a strange relationship with her mother played by Melinda Hall.
SPEAKER_00And again, everything happens within the apartment and everyone goes in and out, but Charlie always stays. Charlie is glued to the TV, always watching the news. She's obsessed with Wolf Blitzer. And what we're learning is all of the things that Charlie is watching are maybe not necessarily true. They are Charlie's mental interpretation of them all. At the top of the show, Charlie is singing about how what's the point of sort of going out into the world when you're going to die soon. And Blamire tries to have it as a sort of a twist there of her talking about all of
SPEAKER_00the atrocities of the world, of Global warming and corrupt government and all these things. But you can tell from the jump that there's something off with Charlie. And spoiler alert, what you find out is that she had been diagnosed with hepatitis, incurable hepatitis, because she got checked out too late. And she's been told that she only has so long to live and she's decided to live out the rest of her days on the couch, not showing up to work. Charlie was an aspirational baker, got a job in a bakery, but then just stopped showing up to work.
SPEAKER_00So she only bakes at home. And Jonah tries to get her out of her shell and tries to get her out of the apartment, join him in Vermont, because as we find out, Jonah is actually incredibly loaded. His family owns like the grocery store chain that he was delivering from, which he does just sort of for poops and giggles. And so he's like offering to bring Charlie back out to their place in Vermont to go to a clinic to maybe get treated. Charlie won't do it. Charlie has a mental breakdown. But then Charlie does end up leaving the apartment and that's the end of the show.
SPEAKER_00Now... Some positives on this side. I think Nick Glemire is a very talented musician. He's got a good ear for not just melody, but genre. He's very flexible in that way. The performers do a really strong job of trying to infuse humanity into these roles and making these characters feel real. And as I said, Will Blum as director makes really good use of the space. The design is very effective. That is kind of where my pluses end with this show. It is not Terrible, but it's...
SPEAKER_00This is going to sound like a dig, but bear with me for a second. It reminds me of mid-aught, like, off-Broadway or YouTube musicals. If you were a musical theater kid between, like, 2004 and 2012... There was an era of the Kerrigan and Loudermilks, Paskin Pauls, Ryan Scott Olivers, where there would be these songs that would kind of go viral on YouTube
SPEAKER_00that would be done in a concert or like clips from a production. And you would think to yourself, oh my God, why are we not putting these shows directly to Broadway? These songs are incredible. And the truth was like, because these songs, while good on their own, when put in context of a show... Just did not work. Often because the script was underdeveloped or songs that you loved just don't fit in that show. I'll give you an example. There was a musical called Darling, which was a twist on Peter Pan. And you can watch a bunch of videos of it at Joe's Pub and all these other places.
SPEAKER_00And Alex Brightman was always the lead singer on all of the concerts and workshops of it. And there was one song called When Lily Came. And it's a fun song. It always pleases the crowded concerts. But I did a workshop of Darling my senior year of college. And when Lily came, though a crowd pleaser in concert, just killed the momentum of the show completely. It had no purpose being there. And... They just would never cut the song because it had too many fans on YouTube.
SPEAKER_00And Soon For Me reminds me of those musicals, both in terms of how the songs and the scenes don't really blend together, but then also the mid-aughts of like Garden State of these certain quirks that are written into characters to make them seem multifaceted, but it actually just makes them more Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And her main issue with the show was the character of Charlie, which I do agree with, but her specific lived experience was that she said, I have never met anyone who has been given a terminal diagnosis and has opted to just not fight or not even live, to just go into your home and just choose to rot slowly. Which, listen, the world is very vast. There are billions of people here. I'm sure someone out there had that exact response. But I understand what Emma means.
SPEAKER_00And it actually is antithetical? No, that's not the right word I want to say. It goes against what you need for a compelling musical and a compelling lead. If your lead is someone who is motivated to be inactive, what What can we do with that? Where can it go? It just becomes a series of scenes of people trying to help her and her refusing. And on top of that, it actually then makes you untrusting of the characters around her.
SPEAKER_00The character of Jonah, who, you know, the actor who plays him, Oliver Richman, he seems like someone who's genuine. But the very first scene we have of him is he's delivering groceries to Charlie and Bursts his way into the apartment and kind of just like through sheer gumption, gives her his number and convinces her to date him or as she can date since she's only in the apartment. And then as, which already kind of puts me off because it's sort of the inverse of the manic pixie dream girl. Jonah becomes like the well-meaning pixie dream boy,
SPEAKER_00which just in this day and age, it's hard to see that and not think of ulterior motives, no matter who the actor is who's playing him. Because Charlie gives Jonah nothing, not in their intro scene together, not in their scenes continuing. Every time he's trying to bring her out of her shell, convince her to maybe do something, and she says no, you're sort of going, and then he sort of comes out of the blue and says, I love you. You're like, but I don't buy this. There's nothing here to make me believe this. Charlie is not providing anything. And so now I don't trust Jonah for having the kind of judgment to just sort
SPEAKER_00of like keep applying himself to her. It's There's a book out right now called Fruit Fly. I won't give away too much right now. It's a fun book. It's not a masterpiece. But there is a character who you just kind of keep going like, why is this person constantly with this mess of a partner? Why do they keep cleaning up their messes? You don't understand. And then you realize, oh, it's because they actually get off on being the savior in this relationship. They actually are more toxic than the person who's constantly messing up.
SPEAKER_00And someone like Jonah, if this were a darker musical, it would maybe take all of these things that Jonah's doing with Charlie and show a more cynical undercurrent to those actions. But because this is a very earnest, very, I won't say optimistic, but, you know, hard on sleeve musical, we're meant to believe that Jonah's just genuinely a good guy and he and Charlie are genuinely in love with I don't see how.
SPEAKER_00You don't see Charlie being there for Steven when he needs it. You don't see how they support each other, how they lift each other up. It's just sort of... It feels as if the concept of setting a musical in one location, so you can put it up kind of anywhere, was the parameters with which Blemire wrote it and then came up with this concept. But the whole concept for me is just, it's on non-existent foundations, is all. And then, this is nothing to say of Melinda Hull,
SPEAKER_00who does a lovely job, but her role as Charlie's mom, you could cut her part completely. It is... It is so inconsequential to the story other than so Charlie can have someone to yell at when she gets her diagnosis. That's it. There's nothing in Charlie's character arc. There's nothing in the themes that make the mom all that important. There's also a song that they sang for their goldfish. You'll see it in the posters for this show. There is a photo of a goldfish in a goldfish bowl. The show begins. He's in a And so later on in the show...
SPEAKER_00Jonah and Steven throw a bar mitzvah for the goldfish and they sing a song for a bar mitzvah for the goldfish. It's not quite pain to a dead lizard, but it isn't not at the same time. I did kind of go, say fucking what now? This is not the worst thing I've ever seen. It's not the worst thing I've seen this year. It's far from that, but it is... I got such flashbacks to my later high school, early college days were things that I found charming at the time in characters
SPEAKER_00and storylines that I have since come to disregard because I find that they are unfounded. It's, you know, characters like, let's put it into movie perspective, the manic pixie dream girl, right? Like Natalie Portman in Garden State, Kirsten Dunst in Elizabethtown. These characters who kind of just, while they have their own lives technically, the majority of their time in the story is at the benefit of the lead character who gives them nothing in return. And that is the inverse here.
SPEAKER_00Charlie gives no one anything in return for their attention, their kindness, their humor. And so not only do we not buy those relationships, we then, as I said, It is well performed. It sounds beautiful. As I said, I think that Blandmeyer has a really good ear for music. The arrangements, the orchestrations are fantastic. I give Ava Delaney a lot of credit. She's pretty much in the room all the time, always. Sounds lovely. It has to go to really... I won't go too deep into Slam Frank because I do have a review.
SPEAKER_00Slam Frank. They have, first of all, turned it into a musical and they have diversified it and they have basically overhauled the entire premise of the story and have turned it into Slam Frank.
SPEAKER_00The show begins with the artistic director, who is also a performer in the show, giving a speech, you know, a pre-show, a pre-curtain speech. And opens with a land acknowledgement, but he doesn't know the name of the tribe that they are on the land of. And so it's already meant to show you that this is a spoof the overly performative wokeism of modern theater and the emptiness with
SPEAKER_00which people create musicals now in this sort of New York liberal vacuum. Which we have talked about on this podcast before. It's not that the ethics of it are what we are against. It is the emptiness with which they are written and presented. And how little it takes for a lot of audiences to be pleased with the simple lip service of a lot of these musicals. And also something that the show is trying to get into, because this is based off of, it was inspired by a tweet from like 2022 that said
SPEAKER_00that like Anna Frank had white privilege and Andrew Fox, the composer and lyricist of the show, had the idea for the musical from that tweet. One of the things that the show also kind of talks about is the erasure of Jewish identities. So yes, you could better believe that Palestine comes into play with this musical. Again, we're going to spoil our territory. When I saw this at the asylum, I was a little underwhelmed because I was under the impression that this was going to be a really, really cutting, biting satire of the modern musical theater scene.
SPEAKER_00And it is absolutely aware of how ridiculous so much of modern musical theater is and modern progressive theater is in general. But I remember thinking like for this almost two hour show, the first 90 minutes were like, Yeah.
SPEAKER_00There is a lot of trimming that could be done to help this, a lot of streamlining that could be done to help this. The biggest issues I have with it now that it's at the Orpheum are that by being now in a commercial space with larger production value, the conundrum that is this show's existence and its reason to exist are in a constant battle for me. You, I'm sure, have seen online, via social media, anyone who's involved with this show,
SPEAKER_00posting about not only how important this show is, but how against the grain this show is. It's important because it's against the grain. It's not like other musicals. It is a real musical, but we're telling the truth. We're going against the man. We're going against the structure. We're going against the whole establishment of commercial musical theater. And yet, it is now a part of commercial musical theater and doing all the things that commercial musical theater does in order to find financial success
SPEAKER_00of promoting every single celebrity who comes to see the show, no matter how messy or tainted they might be. Any person with a following gets a repost. And the glow up that the production value has had is Has also emphasized to me the double-edged sword of Fox's score, which is that I actually think Andrew Fox has written too good of a score for this show. If Lemire is talented with his versatility with music, Fox is like a fucking virtuoso.
SPEAKER_00He has a great ear for modern musical sounds, for the Hamilton of it all, for the Sufts of it all, for the Sixes of it all. And is able to pay homage to them in a way that you know what he's channeling without it sounding like a ripoff. And as a lyricist, he is also incredibly precise and incredibly cutting. And also very silly. Where I talk about the double-edged sword of it is that there are numbers where the point is, again,
SPEAKER_00how ridiculous creatives will go to prove their allyship and Without actually doing any introspection on themselves or the characters that they are writing to make their characters even interesting. Their characters just become interesting because of the checkbox of diversity that they fulfill. Not because they are interesting human beings to watch have drama. I have a clip on It's Broadway Bitch that makes the rounds on TikTok every now and again where I talk about how like we become our own liberal MAGA in
SPEAKER_00a Broadway theater when a character sings a song and That are all of the ideals we agree with in a take me to church vocally kind of way. And we applaud because we have a chemical reaction to the amazing vocals of the moment, but also like, yes, I'm doing the work by hearing this right now. And it's like, but you already knew this going in. So it's not challenging you. It's not informing you. It is. Re-emphasizing what you already felt. How does that make this important? How does that make this special?
SPEAKER_00And Fox has both mimicked and also mirrored this in almost too good of a way that the message gets lost by the medium. Both times I've seen Slam Frank, numbers that are very much a parody have not been, do not register with the audience as a parody. They understand that the show is meant to be a spoof, and yet these songs happen, and you'll hear audiences go, yeah, that's right, woo. Yeah, women do have souls and hoes.
SPEAKER_00And you're just like, do you not get that we are the butt of the joke of all this? That the fact that we... Find this to be challenging and important makes us as simplistic as our foes. And I don't know if that is a problem that Slam Frank itself can fix with any kind of tweaks, or if it's just the fact that its existence now in this space has become a new problem, right? By having such a larger, impressive set, by having more production value...
SPEAKER_00It starts to look too much like the thing it is spoofing and just starts to become the thing that it's spoofing. It becomes like a smart-assy version of the musicals that it's making fun of. You also have to ask yourself, like, what is it that the artistic director of the show... That this is taking place in. What is it that he would do? Because another joke is how like he's a straight white man, a straight cisgender white man. And by understanding that he is the villain, he is going overboard in trying to not be the villain and actually has now crossed
SPEAKER_00over into terrible taste the entire time. And there's a lot of fun to be had there and the show sometimes lands it with that but you but that becomes it's all like snake eating its own tail of overthinking of exactly what is it that this person would do in the confines of this show that he is creating so that the audience can. This is why I'm bringing up a little bit of You Can See Everything, which is the documentary about Elizabeth Holmes right before she goes to prison
SPEAKER_00that is made by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. If you haven't seen it, first of all, go fucking see it. It's three hours long. I know that's terrible, but you don't feel it for a second. And it is a fascinating portrait of not just a One of the most controversial figures of the 21st century. But also just the very idea of making a documentary and our own perceptions of reality and communication. And for every time that you think that you might be sympathizing with Holmes because she has...
SPEAKER_00Perpetrate a lot of crimes. She also is a mother now. And you watch as she's having to leave her children behind. You watch as she's having to grapple with being incarcerated. And part of you goes, I do understand how a mother would feel leaving her children. But then also you go, but am I being manipulated by being shown this? Is she knowing that she's manipulating us by putting her children on camera for this? The whole documentary came from Holmes and her partner, Billy Evans. It was their idea. And Fielder and Oppenheim are aware of all of these levels of perception and reality.
SPEAKER_00And not only that, their own role of how objective they actually can be by trying to treat the subject of their documentary fairly. And also wondering... If being overly humane is ultimately becoming a doormat for the person who's now taking advantage of you and looking back on moments that you can't understand and reinterpreting them much later in a way that can give you a sense of closure.
SPEAKER_00And these are all fascinating ideas that I'm telling you. None of these musicals are grappling with. Not just like the, it has to literally be all the things that you can see everything is talking about, but just the very fact of like questioning oneself just because someone is the protagonist of the show doesn't mean that they are innocent. Just because someone, you know, challenges the dark figure of a story doesn't mean that that challenger is perfect.
SPEAKER_00Perceptions can absolutely cloud your judgment. And something about Slam Frank is that like ultimately it comes from such a smart but smarter than you attitude that it's I do feel like there's a pressure to laugh, even if you don't always understand what it is that's being made fun of, or if it's just, oh, I recognize the reference and they're making fun of it, I'm going to laugh to kind of go along with it. There's a major twist in the final 20-ish minutes of Slam Frank where...
SPEAKER_00As there becomes word that Germany might be liberated from the Nazis soon, everyone's singing about what they might do once they're free, and Frank's sister Margot, who's been silent this entire time, sings of wanting to move to Palestine, where then they will kill everyone who's in their way, and Frank decides in order to Stop themselves from becoming the genociders that have been going after them this whole time. She reveals to the Nazis that they're in the attic. The Nazis kill them all. The actress playing Margot leaves the stage in protest of the musical.
SPEAKER_00And then... Hitler comes out in a robe and announces that they're trans because their art has saved his soul. And then everyone comes to the front of the stage and sings about how soon the whole world will think just like them and it'll be inclusive and wonderful and everyone will think progressively and then everyone will be just like them. It'll be just us, just us, just us. And as they sing this, their faces get more demonic and footage of October 7th starts flying all over
SPEAKER_00the walls. It's very clear where the team's views on all of this lie because ultimately you are reminded this is a musical within a musical. Ultimately being open-minded is its own hall of mirrors and that is something that they're kind of acknowledging at the end of the show as well as the fact that once again their belief that by being open-minded Pro-free Palestine, you are a shade away from Nazism.
SPEAKER_00So that is sort of where I wish there was a little more nuance and razor-sharp bite with the statements of Slam Frank in the last 20 minutes of the show. It feels a little bit more like a constantly antagonistic perspective without actually... I say this because one of our listeners...
SPEAKER_00Jillian, hi, had asked me about both Slam Frank and Midnight and said that she had read a statement by someone that said Slam Frank and Midnight were the two most important new musicals of right now, to which I said that proves to me that either neither show achieves their goals or that this person fully could not comprehend what the shows were doing because the truth is that Slam Frank is making fun of musicals like Midnight. Okay, and now we shall get into Midnight. If you really, really, really, really,
SPEAKER_00really want to hear my thoughts without any kind of spoilers, I will say this. And remember, I had a review that says that I don't gleefully try to tear down shows. And I'm not trying to tear down Midnight, but we have to kind of talk about this in two separate forms. One is the show itself, what we feel about the craft and artistry of it, followed by... Everything else, because there's a whole conversation happening online with Midnight. It started with passionate endorsements by often white influencers who got to see
SPEAKER_00the show for free. And then as more audiences were coming to see it, more diverse audiences, there became a louder contingency of black voices who have been very anti this musical. So immediate thought without giving too much away. Whatever things Todrick Hall is as a human being, the objective truth is that he is an insanely talented individual. Speaking of Blamire and Andrew Fox, he has an amazing ear for music, for arrangements in particular.
SPEAKER_00He really should just like work as a music producer. He has written the music, lyrics, and book of Midnight as well as directed and choreographed it and is starring in it. That is a very large accomplishment. That is a George M. Cohan level of accomplishment. And for that, he should be applauded just for the fact that this thing does not burst into flames every night. It is also a testament to a lack of collaboration, which is a red flag for me because what makes theater such a strong medium is
SPEAKER_00the fact that it requires collaboration to be great, especially musical theater. One person could technically do it all. We saw it here. That doesn't mean that they should. The product that Todrick has put forward has been called innovative. It's been called offensive. It's been called many things. I would not call it innovative. My immediate quote is, if Hamilton, Paradise Square, Diana the Musical... Cinderella and Song of the South all did three lines of cocaine together
SPEAKER_00while watching Freaky Friday, you would have midnight. That is not meant to be 100% a burn. But it is absolutely my immediate impact from this show. There's a reason why I chose each one of those items. Why Hamilton? Mostly because the show gets so much of its aesthetic from Hamilton, to the point that it's often ripped off. The set is framed. Very Hamilton-esque. There are a lot of stage pictures that are directly out of Hamilton.
SPEAKER_00There are a lot of staging moments that are directly out of Hamilton. Hodrick even tries to do his own version of Satisfied in the second act. Paradise Square because of the trying to be important and dramatic without actually doing its due diligence on History, dramaturgically, while also spinning so many plotline plates that none of them come to a satisfying end. And in fact, leads to so many campy moments of self-seriousness.
SPEAKER_00Diana, because like Diana, every song in Midnight is musically very engaging. That doesn't mean that every song works perfectly. The reason I say the three lines of cocaine is because Hamilton, Paradise Square, Diana live in their own levels of energy and taste. And Midnight takes all of that and just ramps it up by 20. If every song in Les Mis were the last 30 seconds of One Day More, if every set song in Hamilton was the last 20 seconds of My Shot and 20 seconds
SPEAKER_00of Skylar Sisters, that is kind of every song in Midnight over and over and over again. There are moments of peace. Usually the beginning of a song, there are a couple of songs in Act 1 and Act 2 that will start quieter, softer, but you better believe that it's going to build to a moment of wailing epic proportions. We're talking like maybe the first verse and a half of On My Own, which then turns into Let It Go. That is the kind of dichotomy we're talking about here. Cinderella, because the...
SPEAKER_00This Cinderella story is a major structure in the show, part of it being why it's called Midnight, and certain allusions to the Cinderella storyline, and Song of the South because of, honestly, the callousness with which it goes about portraying slavery and certain Black characters. Freaky Friday because of the twist in Act 2. Now, if you don't want to go any further with spoilers, by all means, stop here, stop now, because I'm going to be fucking talking about this now as I talk about the plot of this show. This is an audacious musical.
SPEAKER_00It is wildly inventive. It is wildly earnest. It is also relentless and exhausting. I went with my friend and at intermission, we were like, this is not bad. It's too much, but it's not bad. There are things you could cut. There are things you could rearrange and you would need breathing room. Every song cannot be the most because you eventually hit a plateau. This is a musical for the TikTok brain of have to be engaged all the time.
SPEAKER_00Bright colors over there. Turning table over there. High kicks over here. Wailing belt over there. Just move it. Never stop moving. Never stop shouting. Never stop singing high. And I don't think that having a shorter attention span is something that we should be bragging about. And it's not something we should be having our art cater to. We need to be better about strengthening our attention span. If I can't trust you to do the work to try to pay attention for longer than three minutes,
SPEAKER_00how can I trust you to do the work on yourself on something as big as racial bias, gender bias, sexuality bias? It's like, why should I trust that you're doing the work on that? You won't read a book for five minutes. You can't be trusted to pay attention to a dog food commercial. That is another flaw I have with this show is that it is by doing so much, it is catering to the lowest common denominator of our brain of always having to have stimulation always.
SPEAKER_00And you can't always be challenged when you're stimulated. You have to sit with your discomfort sometimes, right? That pressure is what turns a piece of coal into a diamond. So as I said, the plot of this show, Todrick is a slave named Rail, separated from his parents at birth. He is mostly raised by, one second, sorry, again, there's so many goddamn characters. Ethel? Yes, by a woman named Ethel, who is played by Ayanna George, who is actually, for my money, the best performer in the show.
SPEAKER_00I think her performance is the most well-rounded. And their master has a sister played by Autumn Hurlburt and Autumn's character Charlotte has two daughters, Violet and Scarlet. Scarlet is played by Kennedy Coggle and Violet is played by Bella Coppola and they are looking to marry themselves. The daughter's off to rich men. Kennedy Coggle is ultimately paired off with a young man named Richard who has a brother who is a war veteran, and they are wealthy, but Richard does not own slaves, apparently.
SPEAKER_00And at a ball that is sort of meant to tie Richard and Scarlet together, Richard and Rail meet. Richard hires Rail to work on a house that he's building, although he's paying him, which is fine, but there's, again, there's a lot of historical... Continuity errors here. We'll talk about this in a second. Towards the end of working on the house, Richard teaches Rail how to read and then the two kiss and start a secret relationship where they meet every night at midnight. And then through an unfortunate circumstance, they have a missed connection that leads Rail to be beaten up by some
SPEAKER_00of Richard's white contemporaries. And when Richard goes to help Rail, Rail shouts, I wish that all of you knew what it was like to be in our shoes. And act one ends by telling us that's exactly what's going to happen. And Act 2 is the next 24 hours with the roles reversed. Everyone who is a white character is now playing a slave, and everyone who is a slave is now playing a slave owner. But also, it appears that no one but Todrick Hall's Rail is aware that this has happened, possibly because Rail is the one who made the wish.
SPEAKER_00But Rail's also not necessarily confused by any of it. He's self-aware that a switch has happened, but he's still acting as Richard in his place in society. And a lot of messy things happen. Oh my god, just trying to cover all these characters and what happens with them is giving me a migraine. Before Rail and Richard have their connection during Act 1, Rail has fallen in love with a other slave named Lily Rose.
SPEAKER_00Lily Rose gets pregnant, and by the time he gets to the end of Act 1, she's like 9,000 months pregnant, and... When they all switch, Kennedy Coggle now plays Lily Rose and is now pregnant, and she and Richard, who's taking the place of Rail, they give birth to the baby, and when the baby has to be given up to a slave master, that leads Kennedy Coggle to take her own life. Again, all this is happening within the 24 hours that Act 2 is supposed to be taking place in. Bella Coppola's Violet takes the place of Lily Rose's best friend, Happy,
SPEAKER_00and Autumn Hurlburt's Charlotte takes the place of Ayanna George's Ethel and vice versa. The... Act 1. It is all on display. Everyone in the show is so phenomenally gifted, vocally singing to the high heavens.
SPEAKER_00But that has sort of become, for me, the new, the lighting was really neat. I might have said this in part one. I can't remember. I'm recording these two days apart. You know, on like 30 Rock, when Liz Lemon says to Jenna, the lighting was really neat. The truth is like, yeah, like lighting often is very neat. It's a really cool element of theater. And I feel like it's such an empty compliment now because to be able to create a vibe, an aesthetic, a mood via lighting is always just something that's going to be really neat.
SPEAKER_009.5 times out of 10 when I see a musical, the cast is incredibly talented and working their fucking butts off. So saying like the cast is talented has become for me the new the lighting was really neat. But the truth is everyone in the cast is very talented and trying their hardest to... Make characters that ultimately don't make a ton of sense. Lily Rose and Happy come out early in the show and Lily Rose has a connection with Rail, but then Happy is just there to kind of be Lily Rose's sidekick. She doesn't really have a personality of her own, but then Lily Rose spends a ton of time offstage because then Rail has to go off
SPEAKER_00and work at the ball that Scarlet and Richard meet at. And then he and Richard have their own like working relationship, which then becomes a That genuine relationship and Lily Rose is off on the sidelines and then sort of comes back and happy is not really all that important. Scarlett's sister Violet isn't all that important other than just sort of be like the less attractive sister according to their mother Charlotte. But Scarlett and Violet are like very close friends and both awkward when we first see them. They have a song where they're like we can only talk to people if we finish each other's sentences otherwise we have all these hiccups. It's supposed to be like giggly and adorable.
SPEAKER_00But then the moment they get to the ball... Scarlet has no problem being a bitchy mean girl and maintains a bitchy mean girl status for the rest of Act 1 and into Act 2 when everybody switches. Richard is portrayed to be like the good white person who doesn't have slaves, which, again, I don't think that that's a possibility at this time, to be a white, wealthy man in the South in the mid-1800s. I'm sorry, like... But I think 100% of the time that guy would own slaves.
SPEAKER_00Especially if it's inherited wealth. Because Richard isn't a self-made wealthy man. He comes from a wealthy family. We find out that he grew up with slaves on his father's plantation. He was raised by a black nanny. That is ultimately where his lack of racial bias comes from. Hold on to that because that's going to be a plot point in Act 2 during the race reversal. Is all this sounding confusing to you? Because it should. Because it's a lot. Because it's too much to really deal with. The thing that gets put by the wayside because we're spinning
SPEAKER_00so many plates is ultimately, for me, the queer romance that's supposed to be the central anchor of this show. Ultimately, it is not given any kind of juice for motivation or momentum. When Rail and Richard meet at the ball, they don't have a Tony and Maria at the dance moment where they have some sort of instant connection. They give us a brief bit of staging where a light shines on the goblet that Richard saves for Rail, but they don't have a...
SPEAKER_00They don't have a chemistry in that immediate moment that confuses and scares them. It's just sort of business as always. And Rail doesn't give Richard a second thought. And then when Rail is working on Richard's house, he's giving him the silent treatment until he thinks that Richard has deserved his words. You know, Richard has to constantly prove that he is a good white person. And then Rail starts to warm up to him, which is fine. Except once again, you're like, but then why is Richard keeping on going back to try to impress Rail? If Rael's giving him nothing,
SPEAKER_00and if they have no ultimate chemistry here, and they don't melt into each other, which then makes the romance more believable. And on top of all of this, the fact that they are gay in the South at this time, honestly gay in the South now, and then it's an interracial relationship as well between a master and a slave— The sense of danger, of taboo about it is never really in the room with them whenever they talk. You don't get a sense of just how much they're risking by even talking
SPEAKER_00to each other, let alone having midnight rendezvous. Because the other thing of this show, and part of the reason why I do think there's been a lot of backlash about the theme of slavery in the story of this, is ultimately that Padraig does not really do his due diligence by portraying the monstrousness of slavery in By also kind of talking about how mundane it is on
SPEAKER_00a day-to-day basis for someone like a slave at that time or a slave owner. If any of you saw Zone of Interest, what made that movie so powerful and hard to watch was just how boring a life so many of these Nazis and their wives and their families lived right outside of the camps as they were Running these concentration camps. And that is a new side to that kind of evil that people didn't really think about up until recently.
SPEAKER_00And it's something that should be thought about with Midnight. It's not that all of the other white characters who aren't Richard have an intense hatred for Black people. It's that they didn't view them as people. They viewed them as property. Which is also why there are two plot points, one in act one, one in act two. We eventually find out that Rail's parents both were killed, Autumn Holbert's brother. He shoots Rail's father during the prologue and then ends up shooting Rail's mother
SPEAKER_00in the second act in a flashback. And that is not something that you would see. And I beg you not to think about this for too long because it's a terrible way to think about human life. But the brother of Autumn Hurlburt in the show, the one who takes Todrick Hall's rail away from his parents at the top of the show and ultimately is his master, he would not kill two healthy Black individuals when he viewed them as his property.
SPEAKER_00What he would do is he would most likely torture or maim them. Not bad enough that they couldn't work, but bad enough that they understood when they stepped out of line. Again, please don't think about it too much longer than that, but that is a real danger to consider with these characters. You could get shot for running away, maybe not necessarily by your owner, but by a bounty hunter, by a neighboring white person, but you wouldn't necessarily get killed by your owner.
SPEAKER_00I hate that word. I do not ask people to watch 12 Years a Slave because it's a feel-good time, but it is a very accurate representation of that time. The way that Michael Fassbender or Sarah Paulson treat many of their slaves is exactly the kind of monstrosity that isn't really being portrayed here. Here, the The consequences only really exist in certain moments when the show needs them
SPEAKER_00to exist. They are never a constant underlying threat. For example, at this ball that is being thrown, there is a song called White People that the slaves sang. Sort of in the kitchen and, you know, behind the ballroom, whatever, as the white characters are about to sit down for the meal at this ball. And as a prank, the slaves put a rat on one of the pies in front of the guests. That would not happen. And when it does happen, there is no immediate...
SPEAKER_00Tension or danger, it is just pinpointing one slave and just deciding that that's who it is to blame, but not even with the threat of intimidating violence and with yelling a racial slur. That is not the kind of danger that you need in order to effectively discuss this time of history. It actually needs to go harder than that.
SPEAKER_00And I say this because it is not out of the realm to have a story in this time period. I don't think that's beyond a measure of taste. I think that's I don't believe in policing ideas for stories. But in a time when slavery is not being taught in a great many schools, if you're going to portray it, it is your job to accurately reflect it as much as you possibly can and not at
SPEAKER_00the needs of what your story... Not at the needs of your story or at the needs of your... There is... Something to be said about the first act of,
SPEAKER_00ultimately by the bloat, by cutting down, sharpening, and finding a focus, you might be able to have something. There are also too many times in Act 1 when Todrick gets in his own way and undercuts what could be a very powerful moment with either humor or overly lavish vocals. For example, when Richard and Rail kiss for the first time, and by that I mean Richard kisses Rail. Hmm. The immediate song is rail singing of like, wow, white people are weird. They just kiss you.
SPEAKER_00To which I say, if you want me to buy this romance, first of all, you need to show me that there is something between these two other than the fact that Richard just clearly has a crush and is using his position to do whatever he wants to rail. You can tell me that there's no malice in it, and that's fine. But in the same way that, like, I don't totally buy Jonah walking into Charlie's apartment and Charlie giving him nothing and him being like, but I'm one of the good guys and I want to go on a date with you. You cannot tell me that Richard is just one of the good guys based on how everything is going in this storyline.
SPEAKER_00Have the song, After They Kiss, be one of genuine confusion. The What About Love and Color Purple between Celie and Suge is a beautiful song of absolute joy but confusion. This is not something that Rail, as far as we know, has ever entertained. We don't even know if Richard has entertained this. Does this mean that the feelings they thought they had for other women don't matter? What of Lily Rose? What of Scarlet? Are the feelings they have just for this one individual or for other men?
SPEAKER_00Is this a passing fancy? What if somebody saw them? There needs to be all of these things happening, but instead it is a lighthearted riff on the silliness of the opposite race.
SPEAKER_01And that, I think, representative of so many issues that the show has.
SPEAKER_00It goes for emotion. But it doesn't go deep, and it doesn't really take into consideration the larger world beyond these characters. It rails against the unfairness, but not in a way that is true to the time or what these characters would have gone through. It rails against the unfairness in a way that we sitting here in 2026 can go, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. The racial twist in Act 2,
SPEAKER_00unfortunately, unlike Act 1, is something that I think needs to be burned down to the ground completely and just start from scratch. Now, on paper, do I hate this idea already? Yes. Is it possible that someone could make this work? Maybe. You never know. I had spoken to somebody who really, really loved Act 1, understood that it was a bit bloated, but really overall loved it, and then really disliked Act 2, and had said to me, here's the thing though, Matt, I am not interested in the George C. Wolfe version of Midnight, to which I argued,
SPEAKER_00except that you need the George C. Wolfe version of Act 2 of Midnight. What George C. Wolfe Part of the reason why Shuffle Along is so fantastic is that Shuffle Along is both a love letter to the theater as well as a bitter, impassioned war cry against how...
SPEAKER_00Stacked the odds are against Black artists no matter how well they do. It is also both a pain and an obituary to the accomplishment of these people who made such a groundbreaking show for their time. And Acknowledges that part of it is the mistakes of the characters, part of it is the injustice of the time, part of it is the odds of the business,
SPEAKER_00and that is what makes it such a fascinatingly messy and compelling piece. Midnight is a very clear-cut who's right, who's wrong, and gives you very, in my opinion, bland and grandiose messages that That, sure, in the moment can sound nice, put them on a pillow, but when you think about them a little more, come up empty. The reason for the racial switch in Act 2, according to Todrick in the writing,
SPEAKER_00is when everyone goes back, and again, remember, no one has known that they've switched places except for Todrick. They all come out of their clothes. They're wearing their ensemble blacks. Think the high school drama sketches in SNL. And everybody sings, you have changed me. I've been changed. You have changed me. I've been changed. And then they all come forward and start speaking about the power of the number 12, 12 hours in a day, 12 months in a year. The 13th Amendment abolishing slavery comes right after 12. And then they talk about the Supreme Court and gay marriage and all these things.
SPEAKER_00And then they go right back to the story where Todrick is nobly carted off And by that I mean it's not noble to cart somebody off to either their death or to torture, but that Hodrick walks off in a noble manner, leaving a shoe behind for Richard to hold on to. And so the first thing is that, A, no one has been changed because no one knows that they have switched bodies and nothing has changed in the story because the injustices are still the same. But then the other thing that Todrick writes in the score is you can walk
SPEAKER_00a million miles in your own shoes, but you need to walk a mile in somebody else's in order to, you know, know what they're going through. It's basically a plea for empathy. And I'm all here for empathy. I think that we as a society need far more of it. Just always we could have it in abundance. That is a message, though, for the white characters and the white audience because, yes, it would be good for the white characters to understand the torment that they put the black characters through. But I ask you, what lesson did the black characters in Midnight need to learn
SPEAKER_00that they could only learn by spending a day in the shoes of their oppressors and then going back to being slaves at the end of it? What lesson did they need to learn? Why is it that they needed to walk a mile in their oppressor's shoes? The truth is that they didn't. It is a lesson that only the white characters needed to learn, and thus the quandary of the black characters while getting a chance to have the actors show a different side to their talents,
SPEAKER_00they remain pawns in a chess game of Modern audience liberal guilt, which is ultimately another reason why I think that a lot of Black voices have had issues with this show. Because yes, there is Black excellence on the stage. There is amazing talent. And by doing the role reversals, the other thing that Todrick does musically is that he has the white character sing in a more fluttery, soprano-y register. The women, anyway. Because I remember at intermission, I was like,
SPEAKER_00you've got Kennedy Coggle and Bella Coppola and Autumn Hulbert, and you're not having them belt? What a waste. And my companion was like... I think Todrick's going to have them belt when they turn black, which is exactly what happened. And their black actress counterparts then flipped into a more fluttery, soprano-y range for Act 2, which again, really lovely to see that side of their talent. But then you also run the risk of watching Autumn Hilbert having to start doing a slight mammy impression in Act 2, which...
SPEAKER_00That's a discomfort I have of not like, oh, I need to be challenged, but like, no, we shouldn't do this. This is like the downside of this idea. And again, you ask yourself, are we celebrating Black talent or are we exploiting Black talent so that way white audiences with money can come, feel like they've done some work, and then leave? And I only bring this up because one of the things that Midnight is holding himself up to is its importance,
SPEAKER_00what it's doing for the conversation. And you know that it thinks that it's important because when you go see the show now, there is a pre-show announcement by Whoopi Goldberg, who goes out of her way to say that this is an original musical with original characters written by a Black queer artist. And that is what you are supporting tonight. And yes, all those things are true. And it's great to support new works. You don't need to remind me, I know. When you emphasize it that way, Whoopi, what you were doing, what you and I both know you're doing, because this is an Emily Gilmore tactic from Gilmore Girls,
SPEAKER_00Young Lady, you are intimidating me into liking the show and saying if I don't like it, it's my fault and that I'm not being supportive. It is like when Emily Gilmore manipulates you and then you call her out on the manipulation and she goes, what are you talking about? I just invited you to dinner. I didn't say anything.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm, mm-hmm, mm-hmm. Where does this leave us with Midnight? I don't know. There is something here,
SPEAKER_00at least in Act
SPEAKER_011.
SPEAKER_00The music is very creative and very powerful. As a lyricist, Todrick's not the worst, he's not the best. Every now and then he's got a good one here and there, but also he has a hard time scanning information in a lyric so that way the entire audience can hear it and absorb it and move on. There is so many moments that are, again, that were visually stunning and then other moments that were just sloppy and other moments that were just insane. When Rail, as a baby, is taken away from his parents,
SPEAKER_00his mother is trying to keep him and the slave owner is trying to take him and they end up doing a tug of war with the baby where the mom is pulling and a black sheet comes out on one side and the master is pulling and a white sheet comes out on the other side. That for me was not a powerful image. That was a what the fuck image. When Kennedy Coggle, you know, in Acts 2 has to be Lily Rose, 9,000 months pregnant, she and Richard have a duet together where they are dancing on the turntable. And Todrick has it choreographed in a way where Kennedy has to like crunk and twirl.
SPEAKER_00And my friend Charlie said to me, well, that baby's dead now. There are moments, again, as I said, straight from Hamilton, where, you know, they try to do their own Ariana DeBose with a bullet, with Richard and Rail writing letters to each other, and people are coming out, like, on point, floating papers around, flying around in the air, and it's quite insane. Oh, sorry, the satisfied moment I was going to tell you. So... What makes Satisfied so fantastic with that rewind is you go through all of Helpless
SPEAKER_00and you have a narrative and it's a lovely story. It's a lovely, you know, beginning, middle and end. And then we do a whole rewind where we see everything that happened in Helpless, but from the perspective of Angelica and everything is exactly how we saw it, but now we have a new perspective on it. And it doesn't make us dislike Angelica. It doesn't make us dislike Eliza. It just gives us more context and gives us more depth to that moment. In Act 2, when the races have reversed.
SPEAKER_00God, I was talking about the show the other day at a table read for my play, and I was like, yeah, you know, when they do the race swap, and everyone was like, that's not a phrase you ever want to have come out of your mouth, Matt. I'm like, I know, but it's here. It's happened. They did it. During the race swap in Act 2, Todrick as Richard. Speaks more on his black nanny who raised him until he was about 12. And we find out in a flashback that that nanny was Rael's mother. And she tells Richard, I have a son.
SPEAKER_00He would be about your age now. And so Richard goes to his father and says, Daddy, can Rael come and play? To which Richard's father then shoots Rael's mother dead. Now, 12-year-old Richard did not know that his father was going to act in such a way. And yet, There is absolutely no guilt crushing on his conscience that him having some damn loose lips killed this woman. We flash forward many years, we go to the ball where Richard and Scarlett are meeting
SPEAKER_00and possibly courting each other and where Richard... To me, this is not a satisfied situation because this is... First of all, this is information that Rail never finds out about. And second of all, this now changes everything about Richard's motivation for being with Rail.
SPEAKER_00He's holding on to all this information that Rail does not have, so the playing field is uneven. And it doesn't become this like, oh, I am enticed by you. It's, oh, no, no, I know who you are. I knew who your mother was. And I just want to get to know you now. Why? Why? To clear your conscience? We don't know. What is it about Rail that makes you think that he'll want to talk to you? This is not a gotcha moment. This actually makes me think even less of Richard. Even before, when Act 1, I was like,
SPEAKER_00I don't trust you for doing all of this for a guy who isn't giving you the time of day. And then you find out this new thing in Act 2, and I'm like, that doesn't give you any tragic backstory. This makes you actually kind of creepier to me.
SPEAKER_01Hmm.
SPEAKER_00A lot of things that happen in Act 2, a lot of people find out about what happens with Richard and Rail. There's a whole about-to-be-lynching sequence, which gets cut off, and Richard is the one who ends up having to whip Rail to get him out of being lynched, except the truth is that I think both of them probably just would have been killed if it had been found out that they were Gay lovers in a biracial relationship, I think that they both just would have been fucking killed.
SPEAKER_00I do. Honestly, of the two of them, Riel might be the one who wouldn't have been just, again, because of the whole property thing mentality that a lot of these characters would have. But I don't know. I don't know. This is why the Song of the South of it all is in my description because I can't buy a lot of what goes down in this show because the true horrors of slavery are so wibbly wobbly in how it's portrayed in the show that I can't take it seriously. I just can't.
SPEAKER_00And the message it has at the end is one that is not a new one. And the social experiment that it does is one that only benefits morally one side of the chessboard. And the side that should have benefits is just being used as players in a morality tale for a white crowd. I have nothing left to say, I don't think. I'm trying to think of any other moments that have really stuck with me or things
SPEAKER_00that I think could really go for this. I do not, I understand why there are people who are really into this. It is so much musical, all the time, always. It is throwing hordes of dance at you and bombastic singing at you. And it is a racial story, which is Again, the thing that Slam Frank kind of makes fun of, just that byline is enough for a lot of audiences to watch
SPEAKER_00and feel like they have done the work. But the show itself doesn't do the work. The show itself doesn't have any introspection on the fucking power dynamic between Richard, who maybe he is not Rail's slave master owner, but he is still a privileged, wealthy white man who is going to marry the niece of Rail's owner. Like, it does not grapple with any of this. And it's the...
SPEAKER_00Now, One thing I will say, somebody was asking me about, you know, is this like a Paradise Square thing?
SPEAKER_00I'm like, no, because Paradise Square was an inept piece of shit that at least felt like it was written by adults. Adults who made something bad, but adults. Midnight is sort of like the collection of creative rantings from a very brilliant, you know, teenager. That ultimately does not amount to much, but you see pockets of brilliance, you see flashes of brilliance every now and then.
SPEAKER_00And it doesn't move any of us to deny that Todrick doesn't have that talent just seeping out of him. But this is why you need collaborators, because you can't get perspective on all of this. Todrick, on a scale of 1 to 10, with talent is a 10. Kraft, 8. Like, musically, just absolutely fantastic. Lyric-wise, could be better, could be worse. Book writing absolutely needs a new book writer. Directing, you know, while he does steal a lot from Hamilton, he steals a lot of great stuff from Hamilton, but then there are things he steals from Hamilton that do not translate, like the letters flying around with the different dancers.
SPEAKER_00Choreography-wise, you know, there's a lot of movement. I can't rightfully say that it all... The one thing they do that's anachronistic is It's an act two, again, during the racial reversal. And there's a big, I think it's the wedding between Richard and Scarlett. And they have the black ensemble come out in black and white garb
SPEAKER_00that is very much not period appropriate, which is fine. It doesn't necessarily have to be, but it's the only time in the show that we do this where they put on like fashion week-esque clothes. Material. They're wearing avant-garde Alexander McQueen-esque black and white outfits. It's straight out of Jellicle Ball runway fashion. And I got applause from the audience, but it doesn't make sense because no other costumes in the show look like that.
SPEAKER_00So what is this? Is it just because we're now in a fantasy version, but how can we have any kind of sense of real danger or gravity if I don't know. These are questions for all of you guys. You can see everything. Join us in the Broadway Breakdown Greenroom, which is our Patreon. You can become a company member for just $5 a month. At the end of this month, we have our Q&A with me, which you'll only listen to on the Greenroom.
SPEAKER_00You won't get that on the main feed. So if you have specific questions about midnight, you can ask me in the comments there. I will not respond to any more comments about midnight via Instagram. I have not really responded to any of it on the Discord. Same thing with Slam Frank. I'm kind of done with it now. I'll probably have to talk about them again later on this season as I do my rankings in December and then again in May. But that's kind of it for now. If you do like the podcast, make sure to subscribe. Give us a nice five-star rating or review, either on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
SPEAKER_00I will have links for the Discord channel, the Substack, the YouTube channel, as well as the Broadway Breakdown Greenroom Patreon. If you disagree with anything I said here today, that's absolutely fine. That's what this is all for. But I do beg you to really think about some of this stuff, especially with Slam Frank and Midnight. Because controversy is not a bad thing necessarily. But to say that by being controversial, you are therefore good is another thing. I don't really have much else to say.
SPEAKER_00I've been rambling on for hours and hours and hours now. I don't know who I want to close this out with yet, so I will decide that in post, and you guys will find out as you're listening to this now. Coming up will be separate reviews of Paranormal Activity, Schoolgirls or the African Mean Girls Play, Other Desert Cities. 860 Imaginary Invalid. And then soon after that will be some more off-Broadway review roundups, including The Heart at Roundabout. So stay tuned for all of that. I have to get some more work done on all this because then I go to Tampa for a job
SPEAKER_00with a cruise line that I am considering. Beauty won't matter and brains won't matter when the world falls apart one cold and starving night. [music]
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...