Matt is joined by longtime theater podcaster Alan Seales for a wide-ranging conversation attempting to make sense of one of the messiest and most unpredictable Tony seasons in recent memory. Together, they unpack how narratives form, why certain shows over-perform while others stall, and what this year’s nominations reveal about the current state of Broadway. From voter psychology to industry hype cycles to the emotional chaos of awards season itself, the episode balances sharp analysis with genuine love for theater and the people who obsess over it. Guest InformationAlan Seales is the creator and host of The Theatre Podcast with Alan Seales, one of the leading interview podcasts focused on Broadway artists and creatives. Known for thoughtful, actor-centered conversations and deep industry insight, Alan has become a trusted voice within the theater community through years of interviewing performers, writers, directors, and behind-the-scenes creatives across stage and screen. Important Links * Broadway DropShop * Broadway Breakdown Live: The (Slightly Early) Tony Awards Show Tix! * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown Youtube Listener discussion questions * Do Tony Awards narratives shape the industry too heavily, or are they simply part of what makes Broadway exciting? * Which nominated show or performance do you think audiences and voters are responding to for completely different reasons? * In an increasingly crowded entertainment landscape, what should the Tony Awards prioritize most: artistry, commercial viability, innovation, or cultural impact? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_03Why not? Think of the prestige. No. Think of the respect. No, no, no. Think of the Tony. Tumble, Tumble, Tumble, Tumble, Tumble. Hello all you theater lovers both out and proud and on the DL and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address Broadway I am your host Matt Koplik the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts and with us today is
SPEAKER_01one of the daddies of the Broadway podcast network You know him from his own podcast, The Theater Podcast. Very apropos name with Alan Seals. It is Alan Seals. Hello, Alan. Oh, hello. So happy to have you here.
SPEAKER_00The domain was available, so I bought it and that became my podcast name. That's the story. Someone had to get it and you were just the smart one who got it first. I got ER and RE.
SPEAKER_01I got both. Listen, Jeff Bezos over here of the theater scene is like taking over all of it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I do have my robot stepping in to interview for me now. So if I start to glitch out during this interview, then you know that's what's going on.
SPEAKER_01That's no way to speak at the Survival Jobs podcast, Alan. They're more than just robots and you know it.
SPEAKER_00Alan, where are we catching you today? I am home in the Brooklands and yeah, I just came inside from a rousing hot game of playing basketball with my boys in the backyard with soccer balls and a soccer goal. So yeah, you know, we're creative. Yeah, sounds like a great day for you.
SPEAKER_01You know, like straight guy stuff, I guess. I don't know. I've heard of them in the past. Alan I don't know if you know this we're in the middle of awards season for for for Broadway I've never heard of Broadway no you've never seen a single show or spoken to a single person about it no no but yeah we're we are we're not even knee-deep anymore we are chest deep we are really in the thick of it all of the quote-unquote preliminary awards have happened so we just have another two to three weeks until the Tony's but um they're they're a coming
They are coming fast and I think there's gonna be probably be a few upsets I'm predicting but we'll get we'll get into that but yeah I guess where do you want to start with the upsets with the snubs with the well first I want to ask you sort of what's been your experience this year with with the awards stuff have you been at
SPEAKER_01any of the ceremonies have you been sort of in the mix with any of them Interestingly enough personally this past spring I was one of the lead producers on When Playwrights Kill which had its out of town run in Boston at the Huntington
SPEAKER_00Theater and I was just kind of like Steve McLaughlin and do you know get back to to ground myself for a second so I've purposely kind of just been letting it all happen around me this season while still seeing as much as
I can but personally from a podcast perspective not getting on I don't I don't need the luncheons and the junkets and the meet and greets and like I don't I don't know I don't know it seems to have lost its a little bit of its shininess for me I think
SPEAKER_01that happens when you start doing some I was at something the other day where somebody was like, oh, so what are you up to tomorrow? I was like, I'm going to the Drama Desk Awards for a second time and I realized like if this were five years ago I would have been like can you believe it I'm going and for some reason this year it's all kind of exhausting me uh so I'm only
human I can I can only be wide-eyed wide-eyed and optimistic for so long I've become uh small-eyed
SPEAKER_01and cynical and You were already cynical in the past, now you're just a little bit more small-eyed. Yeah, now that I've seen a little bit more behind the curtain, I'm even more so. I don't smoke, but I want to have a cigarette in my hand to just constantly be like,
SPEAKER_03ugh,
SPEAKER_01the bullshit.
SPEAKER_03Ugh, the bullshit. Yes no I get that I do get that it's it's a game I mean this is an industry of smoke and mirrors in so many ways on a literal level and on a metaphorical meta level just ultimately of like you want everyone to believe in your project no
SPEAKER_00matter what it takes and And you have to build on on that and and and You know I've talked about this in my podcast ad nauseum you're only kind of as good as your last job in a lot of cases just because that's the perception you have
of you as a performer or even a producer a creative yeah I find that I think for me what it is is I do enjoy the awards I don't do the sports like you do so this is like the closest I have to March Madness and you know fantasy football and shit
SPEAKER_01like that Breaking as we are recording beaches just announced closing oh okay it finally happened uh yes let's see beaches Broadway my my texts are blowing up so let's see beaches new musical scheduled to play its final performance on September 6th 2026 that's actually longer than I thought it was gonna last that's September 6th is it is the uh when they were supposed to close but now oh
SPEAKER_00Oh, now it's this Sunday.
SPEAKER_01Yes, they are closing on Sunday, May 24th. They were due to close on September 6th. Wow, didn't even get a week. No well they could have gone two weeks if they had you know announced it when they probably should have but everyone knows that dream girls wants the majestic but also like dream girls was going to get the majestic anyway because beaches was going to close in september anyway so when people were like saying oh is is why isn't beaches announced closing yet i'm like if the producers want to keep spending money and give the actors their health weeks let them go for it
no one's taking
SPEAKER_01that theater till december anyway like it's fine it's fine you know
SPEAKER_00No. And it's going to be fine. And I think, you know, yeah, Dreamgirls, maybe they'll get a little bit of extra time. Who knows? But, I mean, again, being on, like, the creative side of all this now, it's all just, like, what room you're in with what person at what time. And, again, it is being in the room where it happens, which is a lot of luck sometimes. And it's a very similar industry that... I don't have a correct way of ending this statement. It's the people that you know that get you where you want to be.
SPEAKER_01Right. Well, something you had said earlier that I gravitate towards is sort of, you know, you're only as good as your last job, but that's also kind of why no one will ever really know what the truth is about a show's situation until that body is cold and it's been a year or two maybe even a little bit longer and the people who tend to tell the truth about maybe unhappy productions are the people who either have given up on the end of this on the industry or people who've gotten more successful since said show like part of the reason why Laura Benanti is able to be a
truth teller about her time on Broadway is because girl has so much TV money now yeah like she's moved
SPEAKER_01on beyond that Yeah, she's like, oh, I'll tell you about, you know, how awful that show was. But everyone else is sort of like, yeah, no, you have you're doing a job and you don't know if you're going to get hired again. It doesn't behoove you to shit on, I don't know, let's say your director while you're in a show accepting awards.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah, absolutely. And because ultimately the casting director works for the director and the production and the producers and the producers. I was at the drama desks on Sunday no yeah Sunday and I had a friend who was at the drama league that Friday and they were texting me
while I was at the drama desk and then I was sort of confirming with them in the drama league which is essentially that there were certain winners that the room felt very odd about and it was one of those things where if you go on social media
SPEAKER_01if you go in interviews or whatever like you would never believe that you know anybody would have any kind of um anything less than a stellar reception in the room and they would win an award and yet there were certain winners where we both were like is it my imagination or like was there was their applause kind of muted and no I thought I thought the same thing so it's just it's one of those things where like maybe nobody says it but how how a thousand strangers in the theater react when you win an award is kind of should give you an inclination of how people actually feel about you
Which I guess tell me your opinion on the voters versus the general audience I mean that's sort of the conundrum of as a voter you're supposed to kind of be a voter because your insight and your knowledge is supposed to be of such that like you're kind of a tastemaker for theater like you're supposed to be the final voice on it
SPEAKER_01and yet I will say some awards bodies don't always do that you see this happening with the Oscars a lot like the Oscars have made it a very have made it their mission to diversify their voting body have more women included more younger voters included have people of color included and you see that reflecting in the winners in the last couple of years and especially in the nominees and the Tonys have diversified a bit not as much as
they should but a bit what hasn't diversified is the quote unquote precursors the drama desks theater critic circles the drama leagues which is why you often see such a pivot in nominations and in voting for shows at the Tony Awards I talk about this on the pod a lot the Tony Awards are not the Oscars in a sense that the Tonys don't have genuine precursors I've said this a lot guys so if I'm if you know what I'm talking
SPEAKER_01about deal with it The Oscars Mm-hmm
SPEAKER_01Yeah. But it's so fascinating when people are voting on all of these and people go, oh, well, clearly that's now what's going to happen. And yeah, sometimes it does because some things are undeniable.
SPEAKER_01Hamilton winning Best Musical is undeniable. It's not like the Drama Leagues predicted that. It's not like Outer Critics Circle predicted maybe Happy Ending was going to win last year. It's like, no, everyone knew maybe Happy Ending was going to win. It was just objectively the runaway musical. The algorithm feeds you back what you want to hear so people can... Create narratives for their fandom and believe that what they want to win or will be in your own echo chamber. That's literally how the social media algorithms are engineered
to work is to give you what you already what it knows you already like to keep you on their platform
SPEAKER_00longer and therefore earn more ad dollars off of you.
SPEAKER_01One could say the same of Broadway, Alan. What? No way. No. Capitalism hasn't found its way into Broadway. No. It doesn't tell you what you want to hear in four-part harmony and then have you come back and support it again and again and again. But, you know, enough... Enough about Cephs That's a cheap shot I didn't even really mean that Water for Elephants doesn't have the same The same punchline to it Outsiders?
No Not the same punchline either There's absolutely nothing political about outsiders It's simply just testosterone Wet testosterone Which I could watch over
SPEAKER_00and over again And I'm straight Tell us again,
SPEAKER_01Alan, how straight you are
SPEAKER_00Tell us more about basketball, Alan. Basket, shooty, hoopsie, soccer, ball, eagles.
SPEAKER_01I shot the ball somewhere. But we digress. So this is all to say we're now in this heat of the season. But as somebody who hasn't really been in the thick of the pre-awards and you're kind of getting back into the conversations of it all, what have you been hearing about um the awards this year I am surprised at the people who walked away hating on
SPEAKER_00Schmigadoon um uh I it was it was good It was good. I don't think it's worth hating. And there's good and bad with everything. The little curl in your mouth says that you hated it too. No. No. This is how everyone knows you're not a listener because you didn't listen to my
SPEAKER_01rankings episode where I ranked all the shows this season. No, I haven't yet. I liked it. I liked it fine. But also, I have also spoken to a few voters who, like, I wanted to go in not liking Lost Boys too because I'm not a fan of
like a adapted IP anymore because I want original stuff I want them maybe happy endings I want something that's standing on its own and can and can last on its own and uh something like you know Titanic Two Strangers uh great Lost Boys and Schmigadoo and I was like oh this is all adapted and then I was blown away blown
SPEAKER_00away by Lost Boys I am one of the lovers of that show What's Two Strangers adapted from? No, it's not. It's not. That's what I mean.
SPEAKER_01Oh, sorry, sorry.
SPEAKER_00Like Two Strangers and Titanic are the two that are not.
SPEAKER_01Well, no, no. Titanic is adapted from Titanic, Alan.
SPEAKER_00Well, kind of famously so. Okay, fine.
SPEAKER_01But it's not a straightforward adaptation for sure. Like they basically go, okay, how do we make Titanic as a movie... 40 minutes long then throw in Celine Dion songs and then add another 30 minutes of our crazy so did you like Titanic I love Titanic good okay we can still be friends absolutely you didn't have a choice in that babe that was always going to happen with us the of the four Titanic is my personal favorite I think that what I'm surprised by is when two
strangers opened because there was such a narrative of like oh this is going to be the front runner and like they just have to hold on till spring like the chatter around right now is like not
SPEAKER_01really big on two strangers it's really more When the nominations came out, I thought it was going to be like a three-way race among Two Strangers, Lost Boys, and Schmigadoon. And it now really kind of feels like a two-way race between Schmigadoon and Lost Boys with Schmigadoon kind of coming out ahead. Really? From what I've been hearing.
SPEAKER_00Really? I've talked to more people who thought Schmigadoon was just mid- And then, I guess, well, maybe I'm answering my own flabbergastation. That's a word from Wicked that I just made up. I'm flabbergastibated in that more people thought Spaghetti was mid, and then there's more extremes for Lost Boys and Titanic. And so, go ahead.
SPEAKER_01If there's extremes for Titanic, I will be thrilled. I would love that no I haven't met anybody who didn't like it but the people that I have met said they've heard from people who didn't like it but I mean I'm I'm sad
SPEAKER_00for them being in the St. James because they have to close the third the second balcony the third level because it's just too big of a house so it can't last as long as it's going to need to to build up a lot of audience base a lot of momentum just because they had to they took the house that was available to them I think You know it's a it's a business move you move in you get the Tony noms you say so then when you go touring they've already announced the tour that was announced this morning to national tour of Titanic they're like also now it's a Tony nominated tour whereas before it was just a very successful off-Broadway tour right like yeah
SPEAKER_01it holds more cachet I mean that's part of the reason why they did go to Broadway like when they announced the tour today everyone was going and in news that no one needed to hear not because we didn't want it but because we all know like we know girl it's that I think you should leave sketch where it's like someone drove a hot dog car in the middle of the window and what's his face comes out of the hot dog outfit he's like guys who could have done that no I definitely have heard from people who really enjoy Titanic I don't think any of them are
going to take it seriously enough to give it best musical my hunch is that if it if it leads to anything it could lead to a Leighton Williams win because I know that that's a performance that a lot of people have been really raving about I don't I'm not holding out hope for it I'm not like putting money down but I am saying like of all the Titanic options to win that's the one that I think could happen um I think I do still think two strangers has a good shot it's just that I feel like people are talking about it less and less and and whether you like or
didn't like Schmigadoon that is ultimately eating up more of the conversation than people's thoughts on two strangers that's true and I hear people talking specifically more about Christiani Pitts than Sarah Chase if we're talking about those two shows
SPEAKER_00specifically too
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm.
SPEAKER_00Right. So I hear people talking about Marla Mendel, Christiani Pitts and and occasionally Stephanie Hsu. But I don't I don't know. I don't. Yeah, I think I think the best leading actress in a musical is I think that's going to be a race between Christiani and Casey, do you want to say too? I think Casey's winning.
SPEAKER_01I do. I guess so I guess we can talk about the ragtime of it all because that is sort of what I was alluding to earlier which is it's it's no secret on this podcast that I'm mid on ragtime kind of in general I love the score I've never really bought the musical itself this production doesn't make me like it less it doesn't make me like it more I think this production is just sort of whatever what sells it is the performances um What doesn't sell it for me is pretty much everything else.
SPEAKER_01Now, Ragtime and Lear have been winning all of the pre-Tony awards. She and Ragtime won at the Outer Critics Circle, which a lot of people online were like, what the fuck is that? I kind of sat here going, I mean... I think she was always going to win that and same thing with the drama desk because like they rarely give it to the director of an off Broadway musical and Jellicle Ball wasn't eligible in either of those awards so like it was always kind of going to be her where people kind of lost their shit was when she and Ragtime wanted the drama leagues over Jellicle Ball because that was like the one award that they were
SPEAKER_01that they could have won and I again I maintain like I'm not I don't look at that as like Jellicle Ball being over again 95% of the voters of the Drama League do not vote at the Tonys and but the room at the Drama League is filled with members and members of the community because all of these shows that are nominated a lot of their cast and their creative get to go and the same thing was true at the Drama Desks and at the Drama Desks what had happened was they announced the nominees for director of a musical
and they announced Lear first and she gets kind of like tepid applause and then they announced the director of Spelling Bee who got massive applause and the director of Mexodus who got massive applause and I think Lear was the only director of a Broadway musical in that category I don't think that Catelli or Michael Arden were nominated but anyway they announced that Lear was the winner Room again was
SPEAKER_01very tepid to her win it was very like and they were listen they were effusive when Josh Henry won and Casey Levy won they they it was a nice round of applause when Ragtime won as a revival but like her applause was tepid and so then a friend who was at the drama league was like that was the same response that she got when she won there and then she proceeded to give a speech about like the importance of her show while standing like right in front of Jalen Livingston for Jellicle Ball which is like just the ultimate American fiction when uh the white people on on the board tell Jeffrey Wright I just
think we should award this book that you don't like because we need to like listen to black voices
SPEAKER_01while you could call me a hater all you want I was at town hall when she won and the audience was not thrilled so how does okay okay but that's that's what I'm saying like half of that audience in like the Tony conversation knew the story or like or we're not thrilled with her when in general but like yeah I and I'm I'm swearing to you I'm not biased
I was in my row and everyone was talking about it like that wasn't that wasn't really the effusive applause of a winner and then a producer friend of mine at drama leagues was like yeah no that's it was the same thing there too and so what it is is like clearly like she has the people who enjoy her work the voters of these bodies but like those people are not the ones in the rooms talking to these people as well yeah and then I ran into a drama desk voter and they brought up
SPEAKER_01weird to me and how they were like Should have been the Mexidus guy. That's who I voted for. I was like, oh, well, you know, you're one. And he goes, yeah, because people don't do their research. And I went, oh, it's like we're just saying that out in the lobby. I mean, I just repeated it on mic, but I didn't say who it was.
SPEAKER_00Hmm. Well, OK, OK, OK. So then from an ethical standpoint, are you are you voting for the person or the person's work? That's the thing. I would objectively objectively wasn't good direction. I thought not that's the other thing like here Bob Fosse only choreographed half a pajama game Jerome Robbins choreographed the other half that's very well known now so it's not like this is unheard of there is the story that Martin Charnin lost director of a musical for Annie because everyone just assumed
that Mike Nichols
SPEAKER_01directed it for him now they claim that's not the case Matt Koplik Sometimes you get broken clocks always try it right twice a day you know whatever that is I think people would be a little less upset about that all of that turmoil and and even those who don't know about the Bart share stuff there's definitely a stank on seeing Chris Catelli's name in the playbill as a
creative consultant where it's like everyone who works in this industry is like I know what the fuck that means I think they would care less about that if they thought the production itself
SPEAKER_01were strong enough
SPEAKER_00It's interesting to me, I guess, I mean, yeah, the Tony voters I do know, and the Drama Desk voters and everybody, like, they do, like, I've had some people, like, offhand just say, like, I don't like that person, I can't vote for them, or the way they treat their cast, or the way they treat so-and-so. Like, there's a lot of stuff that just, you know, like I said, it's a while ago, like I said a while ago, it's one of these things where you need to present publicly that everything's put together and rock hard solid and has no problems when like something as great as maybe happy
ending barely made it to opening because ticket sales were so bad until word of mouth got out exactly like this you want people to believe in your project no matter what's going on you have to that's the business I mean the narrative that's the narrative people have about why Leah wasn't nominated for chess was like oh well people still don't like her like we'll be a lot of them probably still don't and don't buy her redemption
SPEAKER_01arc but also you know it ties into uh the work itself but there I mean there are some people who weren't nominated this year who have yet to be nominated for Tony's and wonder why I'm like they don't have the best reputation as a person yeah well yeah that's true I mean and talk about like snubs and stuff is that why you think Lea Michele didn't get a nomination I mean I just don't think she was very good in chess but um like I don't I the best actress lineup we have is the one I would pick
SPEAKER_01I think every woman in that category is rightfully there but I think that the nominators clearly didn't hate chess they nominated it in quite a few places they ultimately did not nominate it for revival or director or book of a musical of which they were eligible so clearly it wasn't an overwhelming like it's more like we like pieces not the not most of the main pieces but pieces so I think that in addition to maybe a few people still not buying Leah's Redemption
SPEAKER_01I'm rewarding Laurie Metcalf and Nathan Lane Fair. Yeah. Actually, wait, that was something that was interesting in the drama desk too. They won revival and that was one of the very first awards of the night. And so Nathan Lane went up and accepted it,
SPEAKER_01which I thought was very smart of Scott Rudin for him to do. and Nathan accepts the award and he mentions Scott Rudin of like it was his idea to make this revival happen and there were a few boos and hisses from the audience and Nathan goes oh I see Scott Rudin's families in the audience tonight and made a joke and then said basically like listen you know feel what you want about him but but he was the one who wanted this revival to happen he's the reason why we all got together he goes and it's Joe Mantello that made it amazing so like if you like the revival Joe Mantello is the reason why it's amazing and
SPEAKER_01It exists because of Scott Rudin.
SPEAKER_00Fair. Okay. Which, yeah, he knows how to parse it. He does. He does. And producer's going to produce, I guess. I mean... You ought to know. Yeah. It's really interesting because it's like depending on... ultimately like who bring brings in who and who talks to who first and it's it's oh it's so territorial to bring in to to produce and to be like no this you know because if you want the credit if you want to be credited with a certain stature in
the program which which equates to a certain amount of residuals or box office cut or whatever the case is all of this is is it's like everyone's against each other
SPEAKER_00and it's so flippin frustrating to to be able to just like put it aside and and say like let's just make good work but you know just I guess like again going back again this is a business and there's going to be people you don't like in every business and you got to figure out a way to work with them and work through them and with them and then but going back to Scott Rudin too like dude probably can put I think that he is a bit more directly involved with that stuff than you would imply.
yes I agree with you but I'm saying there is a world where that happens oh sure but yeah I would think very quietly he's been pulling a lot of strings he basically he was still producing music man just his name wasn't on it you know it was I talk about this all the time like Broadway is not innocent about this stuff there are people who maybe were honored or mentioned at the drama desks on Monday who like their names would have been in that New York Times Me Too article that got killed
SPEAKER_01but And also everyone knows it So it's just one of those things of like Everyone needs to work Everyone wants to work Everyone wants to do a good job And I'm not here to like expose everybody But it is interesting how these things happen and I get really frustrated when like I'm sort of like you can either be an asshole and do amazing work or you can be a really kind person and kind of like underwhelm me on stage like you can't be an asshole and do underwhelming work and there are a few of those
people right now and I'm just like you either need to get nicer or get better which one are you going to
SPEAKER_01do Get nicer or get better yeah that is that's true right yeah I mean I guess that's why a lot of people keep throwing money at people who are dicks because they do good work yeah they're like they unfortunately they bring it to every ball I mean some of our greatest theater artists were absolute assholes Jerome Robbins Bob Fosse Michael Bennett but they did give us history which brings us back to the Tonys because ultimately awards don't matter in terms of it doesn't actually tell you whether what you did was unworthy or not it's just that
it's a marketing tool but also it I think on a larger scale it's a really nice context for us to discuss art because it's subjective and so rather than say like you know in years from now you can look back on this year and go okay well like how did that win over this when 30 years later this is seems like such the clear winner or what was going on in voters heads at the time and it happens all the time you know people always talk about the follies versus two gentlemen of Verona how could that have happened or
I don't know there's there's other plays that were such sensations when they opened and no one does them anymore have you done Tea House of the August Moon Alan Seale every night in my shower I don't even have an answer to that but you know but yeah yeah so like on that on that front what are things you are hearing sort of like overwhelming buzz for that you're like kind of confident about making predictions um yeah I mean like Joshua Henry no that is the overwhelming
100% gonna take it home like that that in and of itself he's he's the only one that without a doubt I would be very happy to put money on um there are plenty of people from Ragtime I would be happy to win he's the only one where I definitely would be like I'll put down 200 bucks because I know I'm getting it back yes yes I mean it's looking at
SPEAKER_00the nomination like best play um I I want liberation to win because it was very enlightening and pushed so many boundaries in a very good way and you liked the top of act two I don't know what you're talking about no I liked liberation a lot the balusters is probably the play I preferred
SPEAKER_01more but Liberation I think would be a phenomenal winner and I'm not upset about it yeah plus it it's gonna win the Pulitzer Prize you know they've announced that like it's it's got some pre some precursors as you were saying yeah and also I also should say I do think Liberation is winning whether I whether I would vote for Ballisters or not it is Liberation with without a doubt just like speaking of Drama Desk's Best Wall and Whitney White came out to present and when I tell you the whole room was like
yeah mm-hmm it's you two we like you two yeah yeah because they're they're they're just nice people people like them and they do good work I say it's that's a combo they're good people who do good work and we really like it when that happens yes we do uh looking at best musical let's see Lost Boy Schmingadoon Titanic and Two Strangers I I don't know I would I would be surprised if Titanic wins mm-hmm like I think it's the underdog yeah I currently have it as the
fourth likeliest to win fourth out of fourth yes out of four you sold last yes yeah it's my number one choice but it's what I think is the least likely for sure um yeah but but again I I say that because I just I have a hard time imagining enough of those voters taking
SPEAKER_01that show seriously on a just on a level of There's an uplifter um yeah like we have to we have to laugh and and that's why maybe that's why Schmigadoon is such a strong contender too I mean I guess yeah
Schmigadoon is more for the every theater goer where Titanic is more for the the queer culture uh queer
SPEAKER_01appreciators queer appreciated yeah um Yeah like you're right I guess it is a bit more specialized um but it still works it works for me like I said yes I want Titanic to win number one um I think it will probably go to I think it'll I don't know probably go to Schmigadoon and I will be surprised but not surprised if that makes sense like I think that's more it it
SPEAKER_00checks more of the boxes universally
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's what these early awards can do. As I said, they're not precursors in the sense that there's no real overlap, but they can help build momentum and they can build a narrative and some excitement. And Shubunga Dune, you know, winning at the Drama Desks, winning at the Autocratic Circle, and winning a bunch of Cheetah Rivera Awards. It gives a momentum to it of sort of, oh, people like it. It has been confirmed that this is a show that enough people like.
SPEAKER_01So if you saw it, and you liked it voter and you're on the fence about whether it's a worthwhile vote just know other people liked it too and I think that that is where it really helps and then people giving speeches and reminding people in the room hey you like me I give I give good speech that's sort of I think the power of what Queen Jean did at the drama desk was all of us going oh we've We didn't forget everyone jumped to their feet when she won but then she spoke and we're like yep we also really love Jellicle Ball and we all and
we agree with you Queen Jean that it's wonderful and important to lift up black queer joy right now
SPEAKER_00and artistry and not just the trauma yeah no I I get it and I think we're We're fighting ourselves as an industry between pushing forward underrepresented groups in seeing that seeing that type of thing on stage versus going with the the Garrett I'll put in quotes guaranteed Guaranteed Highbrow Musical I mean because we've got Jellicle Ball versus um kind
of I mean Lost Boys Lost Boys is mostly most a lot of white people uh Smrigadoon is a lot of white people um but you have Jellicle Ball you have uh Titanic's got a bit of diversity in it I don't know I mean half the cast of two strangers is diverse
SPEAKER_0050% you're not wrong there Good job, good job. But, uh, but I'm Ching. Um, but yeah, I, Not knowing the demographics of the voters, too, I can't say if that plays a part in it either, but I think historically it has. And like we were talking about earlier, again, like the drama leagues, the drama desks, all the precursor awards, like they are becoming more diverse. But I don't know that the Tony nominations, nominators slash voters,
SPEAKER_00which are two separate groups, by the way, if they are as diverse as they need to be.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the nominators do get to vote, but they are, we're talking like 60 to 70 people as opposed to 830 in the voting body. I mean, listen, we can always do more. We can always do better. We can always, you know, get more eclectic in our representation, which I would love. Eventually, you start just like having every single person from a different walk of life with such a I think what I like about that is that it I feel like this year in so many ways there are so few guarantees which makes me nervous because then
I'm going oh is it
SPEAKER_01my gut instinct all along but you have to ask voters like The question is, how do you like it in the moment, but then also, how do you think this is going to age in the future, you know? Well, would that be part of your voting criteria? It would in the sense that...
SPEAKER_00If you were allegedly a voter, allegedly? That word doesn't apply here. Hypothetically There we go There we go Hypothetically Alan Hypothetically If I were
SPEAKER_01a voter Yeah I think Less of sort of Um of like what is my legacy as a voter and more sort of I can't just go with how I feel in the moment I have to actually overanalyze after the fact and and think like okay yes I got swept up in the show but now that I'm sitting with it was that good or was that just a moment in the woods and I do like to think about you know is this show going to feel as good 10 years from now as it does
in this moment and some I do like I think Liberation is going to age like fine wine I think I actually think the balusters is going to age like fine wine Giants probably not going to age super well it's a bit bumpy of a play although they announced recoupment good for them I do think Aya Cash is going to age like fine wine with that hair and that
SPEAKER_01dress and those shoes I think you also kind of want to ask yourself as a voter like where do I want theater to head to do I want it to be stay exciting and be new or do I want it to go to the lowest common denominator there are certain shows that get nominated and I'm like I think they don't like I think a lot of jukebox musicals don't win because voters look at them as the lowest common denominator and like we don't want this to be what theater ultimately becomes I mean think about like Moulin Rouge doesn't count because that
was a COVID year but like the last genuine jukebox musical to win best musical was Jersey Boys 20 years
SPEAKER_01ago and that was one of the first Definitely one of the best ones too like it was but it was also such a phenomenon that they couldn't not vote for it it was it it by that point had been running for almost a year and it was such a sensation right yeah well it's one of those things that that came in tried something new and worked and then everybody's been trying to copy it since because financially it's easier to adapt existing songs than to write completely new ones and make those work if you're taking existing hits and
Adapting them to the stage great that you've already got a built in hit so I think where the difference though is no one involved with Jersey Boys expected it
SPEAKER_01to become what it was so the Four Seasons were incredibly honest in their interviews for the script and so all four of them on stage don't come off super great but it makes it exciting drama and then it became a billion dollar musical and then after that all the other jukebox musicals were like so in order to get the songs from the artist we need to paint them in the rosiest of pictures and they have no flaws and here are all their songs
SPEAKER_00What do you think? Do you think there are going to be any upsets?
SPEAKER_01I think there are opportunities for it, yeah. I think there are certain categories where there's a perceived frontrunner and then I think that there's a world in which that frontrunner could be upset. I don't think that Josh is getting upset. I don't think that Casey is getting upset at this point. I thought for maybe a minute Marla or even Christiani could possibly win but I think that's pretty locked and loaded I think Ben Levi Ross is at this moment the front runner for featured actor in a musical
but I do think that both Leighton Williams and Andre De Shields are sort of potential upsetters there Leighton because that's a that's a nomination that voters can vote for Titanic if they liked it a lot but can't bring themselves to vote for it for musical or book
SPEAKER_01and Andre because of his legacy he's 80 and still doing the damn thing it's a chance to award sort of like the whole cast of cats which I know many people go that's not logical that's not how math works I'm like no but that's how voters sometimes work yeah well just showing up sometimes is enough to to win something I totally get that yeah and then who who's the rest there it's oh Ali for Lost Boys um I think Ali could win if Lost Boys won musical but ultimately I
think if Lost Boys wins musical that just guarantees Shoshana Bean winning more than anything else I think I don't think anyone has any clue what's happening in Featured Actress in a Musical Featured Actress in a Musical let's see so let me pull this up I just can't get a consensus on it I've everyone is all over the place Featured Actress Actress in a Future Broke Let's Play in a Musical Okay so we
got That's Actor Show Bean Hannah Cruz Rachel Dratch Anna Gasteyer Nichelle Lewis I Again I love these two individuals I don't think Anna and Rachel Rachel and Dratch I don't think I
SPEAKER_00don't think Anna and Dratch are on the same competitive performance level as the rest of the is the other three I think with their roles yeah I think Anna has a chance because if Schmookadoon ends up being best musical that helps her case I don't the truth is Rachel is probably my vote in this category but I also think similar to Titanic Rachel I
SPEAKER_01think is the fifth likeliest winner in this category Why is she in your vote though? Are you just a Rocky Horror fan? No I just thought I thought that she nailed her assignment and I know that she had had a lot of trouble in previews kind of figuring out how to handle the callbacks and whatnot but by the time I saw her I thought she was locked in and really kind of kept the Trane going without it seeming like they were ignoring the audience like she she handled it all really well I thought that she had the right arch B level campy tone about her I've been very vocal about thinking Hannah Cruz is
the best performance in chess and I she probably would be like my second vote yeah and then Shoshana I
SPEAKER_01think Shoshana just, like, has built a career post-COVID of being the grounded presence in a chaotic show. This, Hell's Kitchen, Mr. Saturday Night, just, like, all of these personalities. And Shoshana's the one who just sort of, like, holds calm and holds center. And always in the kitchen, too. But... And, like, and I think she's lovely in it. I think the biggest problem in her way with Lost Boy, similar to Anna, is, like, so much of Act 1 isn't about her. But I think a lot of...
Featured roles that win tend to be a little more like sprinkled out throughout the entire evening you know you look at um last year Jack Malone and uh Natalie they were sprinkled out throughout the evening the year before that um who was that that was Daniel Radcliffe and uh Keisha Lewis again sprinkled throughout the evening
SPEAKER_01like Keisha Lewis they kill her off halfway through act two but she still gets to come back for the finale so you know it's it's a nice spreading out Anna has really nothing to do in act one but then like act two does kind of belong to her so yeah everyone sort of everyone has the same problem in opposite directions you know what I mean mm-hmm
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, no, and the fact that they're even nominated too, I mean, it shows that they're making the most, they're bringing their best selves, which are incredible performers, they're bringing their best selves to these roles that by no fault of their own are not in the whole show. They're featured, they're literally, yeah, they're featured.
SPEAKER_01They're genuine featured performances, yeah, but that's sort of, what I mean is just like you look at the last 10-ish years of featured performances and they aren't really like Specialty spots they're they're more like large ensemble pieces the the days of Marilyn Cooper getting eight minutes in the second act of woman of the year and winning are kind of gone fair that's very fair yeah I I want Hannah's my vote for this for this one it's a great vote
I also thought that was a wig she was wearing in chess I think it's her actual hair is it really I think so I think so if it is her actual hair no no because she went blonde yeah I thought I thought I thought it was a wig but then on Instagram I was looking the other day because I don't follow any of these people but I saw her like it was a candid photo and it looked like the same hair she had on stage and I went
SPEAKER_01did she genuinely dye her hair blonde for this I actually don't know if that is her real hair or not I don't know I saw someone I talked to someone the other day who had just seen Titanic it was like oh Melissa Barrera if you had not told me she had dark hair I'd think she was a redhead because that would look so good on her the wigs in Titanic are quite exceptional and I would nominate Chess for a wig Tony for Hannah Cruz's hair alone if it's actually a wig
SPEAKER_01But I also think that Leah's bobs are bad. So I don't know. That's why she didn't get nominated. She's a bad wig. Bad wigs. It can kill you. Believe me. I mean, I think that's what cost Vosk the nomination. Those awful, awful Bette Midler wigs. why did they choose to make those characters look like Bette Midler you don't need to do that you don't need to do that but also like why do they keep putting Betty I was about to call her Betty Gilbert why do they keep putting Kelly Barrett in like
SPEAKER_00helmet heads wigs like she's such a pretty girl let her look pretty I don't know but I I wanted this I wanted Beaches to be so good for for Kelly uh among everybody because like Kelly is such one of the most talented people I've seen on stage and she she deserves her due she deserves a hit and and yeah it's just the luck of the draw so far I know she's she's got a girl's got bad luck when it comes to original musicals and it's awful because you're right no she she deserves better I remember seeing her in Chivago and just
thinking this musical
SPEAKER_01does not deserve you yeah yeah ultimately take yourself out for a pitcher of margaritas because you are doing the lord's work you and paul alexander nolan they need an award for like characters that should have been cut and given it to the both men in beaches yeah oh my god both beaches is just like what are men we don't care ultimately yeah I don't know I don't know there are things that I don't get I mean and this is not unpopular opinion of like things like Queen of
Versailles you know didn't show up anywhere in the nominations but like I don't ever think I think that had a lot of potential had they listened and incorporated the feedback from the out of town but they just didn't like who what the egos behind some of this go back to
SPEAKER_00the producing side the creative side yeah that's the thing is I I did not see it out of town I had I know people who did see it out of town and then saw it on Broadway and they're like they found a way to cut 30 minutes but no like actual changes have happened uh like no major song changes have happened or anything like that and so I yeah I don't know what that was about because seeing Queen of Versailles I talked about this on the podcast as well I saw it with Chenoweth and I was like I don't know why this musical exists and then I saw with Sherry and I went oh I think I know what the idea was but why do you think you guys
SPEAKER_01found the way to tell it like because you didn't I think I know what story you want to tell and it's a good idea but this is not how you tell it although I maintain Caviar Dreams is a good song and I actually probably would have still given them a score nomination but you know ultimately the Tony nominator said Joe Turner's Come and Gone has more score that we like what did you think about Lost Boys like the rescues writing that album like what did I think of their work
or the Lost Boys of the music itself because I'd left Lost Boys and immediately looked up the rescues and listened to their music on the way home I liked the music a lot I think musically it's lovely I think where that score kind of falters is I don't love a lot of the lyrics not in a super cringy way but more sort of in a oh this is your first time writing musical theater lyrics like they're it's a little on the nose
SPEAKER_01it's a little um like overly earnest and then reading by Michael Arden how the vibe they were going for was 80s mega musicals and I went oh okay then in that sense yeah they probably did the assignment well but I would like to hear their second score because I do think I think they're I think they've got a good idea of emotion in a musical theater landscape I would like to see them continue that in a more specific less
extravagant setting to see
SPEAKER_01what kind of lyrics they write for that because I'm not sure like how Sondheimian you can be with teenage vampires in the 1980s you know i don't think you can write an everybody loves louis in that situation right right well that's again that's part of why like i like the outsiders i i do like lost boys i'm i'm in i'm in thumbs up camp for lost boys um for a couple different reasons but uh
SPEAKER_00And that was part of, I mean, I've always just kind of liked the non-Webers, the non-Sondheims, the less traditional path taken for musical theater because Rent was originally what got me into loving musical theater when I was late high school, early college, dating myself there. But yeah, like that was like, remember senior year of high school, driving around with the T-tops out in my Firebird, blasting the cast album of Rent, you know, like that was me. I was applying for social security when I got my rent album you
know like a day over 102 thank you it's the Vaseline it's the Vaseline I put on my armpits prevents the chafing I mean the truth is like of the three musicals nominated for score I actually probably would vote for Lost Boys I think that Two Strangers has the best
SPEAKER_01lyrics out of all three I think that Schmigadoon getting nominated for score is kind of ridiculous because ultimately it's majority what was written for the TV show they claim oh he we wrote a bunch of new songs it's songs that existed that have some new lyrics that's what it is fun fact I heard today from straight from the horse's mouth who's known as Mackenzie Kurtz that she auditioned for the TV show and they said no thank you they
SPEAKER_00said no thank you and then look where she is now
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they said we want somebody who has been on the Disney Channel.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Well, I mean, look at the problem we've got. Again, going back to capitalism and the fact that Giant Recouped, not because it's a great play, but I mean, it's a good play, but it's got John Lithgow in it. You're going to go see John and get a good play out of it. the performance is phenomenal well I think that I think giant is a situation of it's a small company not extravagant it's a British import so it comes with buzz and Olivier wins John Lithgow is a name the role doll of it all is you know it's
subject matter that people can understand it's a play that absolutely caters to the Upper West Upper East Side theater goers like you don't need a million people to
SPEAKER_01pay $150 to see your show you just need 90,000 to pay $200 and there are 90,000 Manhattan people and some in New Jersey and some in Connecticut who will pay that to see it right yeah I I guess I mean I thinking of things that like yeah people pay money for I guess I'm going back to
SPEAKER_00like uh the cost for um the cost of Broadway for uh uh uh Denzel Washington Jake Gyllenhaal Othello like famously what thousand dollar front row seats something like that something like that but um oh other other great performances too Oedipus I loved Alan you have to say its name correctly Oedipus there we go Oedipus Oedipus Oedipus Oedipus Oedipus
you know the ending everyone should everyone should know the ending and the fact that I was on the edge of my seat being like how are they going to do this how are they going to do this when's the shoe going to drop when's the other shoe going to drop I thought it was executed brilliantly and then across the board phenomenal performances no notes Leslie Manville is one of the other categories that I am locked in on that I'm just that's happening she's winning actress in a play yeah I can see that I can see that I think that plays are
actually kind of a little more locked in for me than the musicals like I think Liberation is winning I do think Salesman is winning Oedipus could give it a run for its money but ultimately Salesman is currently running that's always an advantage which of course then goes against my whole thing about Liberation but Liberation just won the Pulitzer and
SPEAKER_01you know The Balusters is closing at the end of June anyway Giant is closing at the end of June anyway so it doesn't matter that Liberation is closed and I think that Leslie Manville is winning actress I think that Laurie Metcalf is winning featured actress I think that um It's down to Nathan and John Lithgow for actor. Part of me thinks it's going to be Lithgow because he'll be like the one award for giant. Part of me is like, I don't know. What if Nathan wins in like this big old sweep for salesman? Because I think Joe Mantello ultimately is winning.
SPEAKER_01And then if he doesn't win, it'll be Whitney White for Liberation. Featured actor is sort of up for grabs. I don't know where that's going. My heart says Alden for Becky Shaw, but maybe... Maybe it's Ruben Santiago Hudson Maybe it's Christopher Abbott I don't know Help me Let's see I'm pulling this up Christopher Abbott Best
performance by an actor in a featured role In a play Chris Abbott Danny Burstein Who I love by the way Let's see
SPEAKER_00Brandon J. Durden Aldrin Ehrenreich Ehrenreich, yeah Ruben Santiago Hudson and Richard Thomas yeah legitimately could not could not tell you who this was going to go to I mean I can tell you who I would let do things to
SPEAKER_01me in what order in this category do me do me the order sir Well, it depends on what task I'm asking them to do. Alden is stepping on my neck. Christopher Abbott is pulling my hair. Ruben Santiago Hudson is educating me. Danny Burstein is comforting me. And then Richard Thomas is scolding me. That's a Far Side comic waiting to happen. Yeah, I get abused, then I get healed, and then I get shamed.
SPEAKER_00Was this all happening simultaneously or when...
SPEAKER_01One after the other. I don't think I can handle it simultaneously. I need it to happen in succession. I mean, five minutes a piece, but yeah, in succession.
SPEAKER_00Five minutes each. Okay. All right.
SPEAKER_01That's 25 minutes of pure fun. I guess the thing is that I guess I'll say this. The two who I really doubt are going to get this are Danny for, um, Marjorie prime and Richard Thomas for the balusters. I, I love the Richard got in. I think that as, as I said, I think the balusters has an amazing ensemble. Danny getting in his wonderful Marjorie prime for me, best acting of the season across the board. but Marjorie Prime is closed Ballisters is quite an ensemble piece and I think if anyone's going to win for the Ballisters it would be Mary
Louise Burke I think she's the biggest threat Laurie Metcalf has and then so then it goes down to Alden
SPEAKER_01Chris and Ruben no Alden Chris Ruben and then who is the fourth Alden Chris Ruben Danny Danny Richard but no there's a sixth one there's Brandon oh Brandon J. Dearden for Waiting for Gatto also not happening thrilled he's in there not happening so yeah so it's it's it's Chris Alden and Ruben of those three I would vote for Alden I think Ruben has a great narrative Chris is in the more kind
of like seismic cultural hit right now and that helps his case a lot um and like the whether we want to admit it or not these things matter they they infiltrate our brains when we're thinking about the quality of performance and especially when it comes down to like oh well it's these two and I don't know who to pick well Ruben's such a
SPEAKER_01legend and and he you know one only 35 years ago or whatever it was and and he deserves one again or are you investing in the stage careers of Christopher Abbott and Alden Ehrenreich you know well that comes down again to what I'm gonna call for lack of better term personal branding because like who if it's all things being equal performance wise show wise you're gonna go with like at the back of your head unconsciously you're
SPEAKER_00gonna go with who you like more And that comes from familiarity, who smiled at you, who gave you a good interaction on a red carpet once, you know, whatever all of that is, it all goes back to branding. And so that's like this time of the year, you know, this May is always terrible in, I guess, a good way for publicists and the nominees because they're out there for this exact reason. Not only doing their eight shows a week, but going in press interview after interview after performance after interview
because they want to be out there campaigning to be top of mind front and center
SPEAKER_00when people are thinking of who to vote for. Oh, again, I'm only as good as the last thing that you've seen me in. Well, if the last thing you saw me in this morning was an interview on Good Morning America, I guess I'll vote for you.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Yeah. I mean, people have reached out to me about sort of like, oh, did you see the cast interview about this and that? Like, does that sway you in any way? And... I'm sure it sways some people for me it always comes down to the actual show itself and then sort of how it's been sitting with me over time but I mean also listen the whole idea of investment is true as well not just in terms of productions but in terms of the people in order to keep having good theater we need to invest in the people we think are going to make the good
theater so you know voting for Joe Mantello or Whitney White is a good investment they make good theater if I vote for Alden Ehrenreich will he come back to Broadway again like am I throwing it away to a movie actor who you know came back who came to theater on a
SPEAKER_01lark and won't ever be here again I think in a lot of ways people get PTSD with um like James Corden right of he wins for one man two governors deservedly so it was a phenomenal performance but he grabs that Tony and runs Hollywood and I think a lot of people are like fuck like we could have given that to somebody else who would have taken that Tony and invested it in in Broadway and he didn't was art this season or last season it was this season but what does that matter
I thought he was great he was the best thing in it for sure and I hate to say that because I don't like the man yeah he was by far the best thing in it and it took him 14 years to come back you know that's fair yeah I will say there are there is a certain vibe I get this season on certain shows based off like of what's been
SPEAKER_01winning and sort of where where the fandoms are of like It's not necessarily from past theater seasons but last year with the Emilia Perez of it all where Emilia Perez kind of kept winning all of these awards and everyone else in the world was like the fuck is happening? and it ultimately took like a major cancellation for that movie to topple at the Oscars but I do think that there's something to be said for the disparity between
what like what theater fans see and then what voters see and then wondering like does that influence voters at all are they aware of sort of the online presence of any of these nominees I don't know that goes back to the representation and are you
SPEAKER_00voting for what you want theater to be or are you voting for like as a critic are you voting for what you like because it's too sometimes oftentimes two different paths you know I want I want show a to be Matt Koplik
like again if you're a theater reviewer a theater critic are you gonna vote for what you thought was the best show or what you think is the most impactful message wise or people pick and choose with that shit though it's because they'll do it for like play or they'll do it for I don't know revival of a musical not usually but
SPEAKER_01sometimes but if voters were voting based off of oh this is really prescient for right now Cabaret would have beaten merrily we roll along but ultimately that revival was not liked as much or one would argue at all or like Harmony would have been nominated for 20 Tonys because people would have talked about like well considering everything that's going on right now with anti-Semitism it's really a beautiful commentary and then they blanked at
SPEAKER_01nominations and I think that I was asking you that question about social media kind of with my own answer in my head but also was genuinely interested in your thoughts which is like I don't think that voters ultimately care what people say online because if there's one thing voters hate it's being told who to vote for and there are some I think the worst Tony campaigns are the ones that actually lead with the like Mm-hmm
SPEAKER_01and said so brilliantly. But yeah, I mean, I think that there are a handful of people who think to themselves, well, the subject matter is just so important right now. Usually it's sort of like important subject matter. Hated how they handled it, though. So I'm going to go for the show that maybe was less important, but did the thing,
SPEAKER_00to quote Ariana DeBose. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, I remember, I forget what year it is, but when Hadestown won over the prom, that was a big... at least in my circles that was an upset I don't know if that was expected but you go back to like I think the prom was a show that needs to be out there it's a message people need to hear it's a something you know it was original story and again not hating on Hadestown it's a great show but
I don't know I mean what what's changing lives more if we're talking about social commentary the prom or Hadestown and the prom should so which one do you vote for and why I guess I'm this is where I'm cynical like I'm not sure how many lives get changed by Broadway musicals these days just by how expensive and exclusive they
SPEAKER_01are and also how echo chambery they can get I think what helps I hate to say this the movie of the prom probably was made more of an impact than the stage musical just by like reaching more people even though the movie is far worse than the stage show yeah yeah yeah I don't know I feel like in a perfect world the show that you think speaks to the moment that is also happens to be the best musical of the season tie in and then sometimes it's like the musical that had the highest reach but ultimately missed the mark
Like you can't bring yourself to vote for it there's and then it doesn't always have to be about like important subject matter sometimes it's just like on an artistic level they take all these risks speaking of follies you know light in the
SPEAKER_01piazza a musical that I adore was expected to kind of blank that year at the Tonys because everyone thought it was boring and it ultimately won a lot of awards while missing out on musical to Spamalot which absolutely doesn't do anything nearly as adventurous or ambitious as Light in the Piazza but ultimately voters felt that it nailed its assignment better even if it was a lower mark and so I mean there's always that exception to the rule and then I feel like last year for Best Play
SPEAKER_01Purpose is a play that I like. I think it's a little fatty, but sometimes it felt like voters voted for that because they thought it was an important piece. I think what more contributed to that was people liking Brandon Jacobs Jenkins and being like, we want to give you a genuine Tony now because you won for appropriate but you didn't win for appropriate like you're you get the Tony but like you're we want to give you an actual award as a writer and and I feel like that was sort of a real uh
Motivation for a lot of voters of him in particular and then a lot of other writers in that category were newer younger writers that I'm sure voters were like your nomination is your award and this is an investment for your next play come back and do it again and you will win yeah yeah I can see that I and I mean along those lines too I can't wait to see what best wool brings up next writes next you know for a second I thought you said best role and that you fucked up the art and I was like best role best wall best wall best wall yeah let's see
what let's see what miss wall comes up with if you're nasty yes I want to see what I want to see what
SPEAKER_00she comes up with um like the the I I have high hopes and I have I have high wishes, not high hopes. Knowing the financials of Jellicle Ball, I don't have high hopes, but I'd be pleasantly surprised if they can last a year on their financials because it's an expensive cast. It's an expensive show. And it's one of those things, again, where I think they need to win to get that boost to keep them going, to allow them to recoup, to allow them to change more lives. Because it's allowing people to see themselves in a way on
stage that they never have before. And it's funny because, you know, on my podcast, I've interviewed some people lately that were literally in like middle school or high school when Hamilton came out and now they're post-college late into their 20s and they're starting to write their own stuff or have been writing their own stuff that is very sounds very much like
SPEAKER_00Hamilton it's very much influenced by that by that you know by Lynn reaching for the sky and hitting it and you know captured lightning in a bottle but you have something you need something like a Tony Wynn for Jellicle Ball to keep it going and in the zeitgeist I think and I really hope I do hope to get it to inspire people to like To change the game and to make it, I think, you know, in the next couple of decades, we're going to have to, like, figure out some way to release the stranglehold that's on
Broadway because it is
SPEAKER_00too exclusive. It is too expensive. And, you know, some of that is going to come from literal political government-like subsidies if we can get that. Look at how successful London and West End is because... The government out there subsidizes the arts and it doesn't cost a bajillion dollars to go see sit front row and see your favorite celebrity but yeah something's gonna change and I think that now you know we just need to be voting for well I don't know we need to be voting for for the best show and whatever the
best means to you is obviously very subjective but for me I would vote for something that's gonna make a lasting impression if they hit if they hit their goal
SPEAKER_00What's beyond that? It's going to make a lasting impression and be important to people. Yeah. And just what excites you and not just not necessarily makes you feel good. I don't want to go on that because I think that what makes you feel good is a
SPEAKER_01slippery slope to then like what kind of numbs you into complacency. The my the comeback I always say to people because, you know, me, Alan, I'm an asshole. I do. I do. Yeah. And I know your asshole. Yeah. And I'll talk to friends or whatever And they'll be like, why'd you think of Pretty Woman? I'm like, it's a piece of shit And they'll be like, well, you know, my mom came in from the Burbs And she loved it And yeah, she doesn't, you know, go to a lot of high art theater But I'm like,
SPEAKER_01yeah, listen, enjoyed her experience, whatever And they go, well, you know, say what you will But like, it makes her feel good, it brings her joy And it makes other people feel good and brings them joy And I always say, you could say the same thing about crack that's not enough for me to then say but of course you're right here's its success no no no like yeah feel good all you want but also like I want to be I if the show that can both challenge and excite me at the same time
Much like you do with me personally every day Alan That's from like that's the magic of theater And I don't want to go into any specific show this season But there have been a few Some plays some musicals Where I'm like oh this is both As you said with like Oedipus You know what it's about And yet that production flips
SPEAKER_01it on its head and that's sort of the challenge of oh like I thought I came in knowing where all the plot points were going to be and yet like it's completely thrown me and so that is challenging and it excites me and I feel good because I'm seeing something that's challenging and exciting me not just something that's like uh embolstering what I already know or what I felt beforehand going in well that's why I say like when I'm looking when I'm thinking of revivals there's only three in the
category of revival of musical like Jellicle Ball Ragtime and Rocky Horror and if you're going off of the criteria that I like to talk about a lot on my podcast is if you're going to revive something make it different like there's got to be a
SPEAKER_00reason to bring it back well Angelica Ball did exactly that yeah exactly listen Ragtime uh Rocky Horror I think brought Rocky Horror uh Rocky Horror brought that property to a space that it um that's very meta it's in Studio 54 cats took felines and made them puss and Ragtime
SPEAKER_01was like what if the turn of the century looked like AAI They all do something very different But no, I hear you I just I hate The argument from people who are like, but it's Cats. It's not a very good musical. Even though I like this production, I'm like, then you should vote for it for a revival because that's the whole fucking point. But this is not a Cats... If you hated it before and you liked it now, it did its job. It did its job. I point to,
yet again, John Doyle's revival of The Color Purple, a show that...
SPEAKER_01yeah yeah um I was looking at the plays here too I mean Edipus Fallen Angels I liked Fallen Angels I thought Rose and Kelly's performances were wonderful
you know it didn't the show didn't blow me away even actually every brilliant thing I thought was
SPEAKER_00performed very well by Mr. Radcliffe by Mr. Potter I haven't seen Mariska but that's a completely different energy it's a very serious subject matter right and Daniel come Dan comes off this very light-hearted and bubbly about it because that's who he is and I think that's a wonderful juxtaposition and I'm worried that Mariska won't carry that through not that that is relevant to our Tony discussion um and then who did they just announce today there's another
announcement today Tracee Ellis Ross Tracee Ellis Ross that yeah and it wasn't today a day or two ago yeah gonna make her Broadway debut doing it too I think she
SPEAKER_00might be good I think she's actually kind of in
SPEAKER_01perfect casting yeah and I love Mariska but she's granted i have not seen her outside of svu i don't think the world has in 30 years so it's like we all know her as this big heavy so it'll be interesting to see what that is i the revival of a play category is mostly fine i would take out either every brilliant thing or fallen angels for marjorie prime fallen angels is is fun it absolutely is mostly just an excuse for kelly and rose to look stunning get
SPEAKER_01sloppy and then look weird which I'm all here for I love that those two women are doing that with each other I think that's a joy and then every brilliant thing I've talked about like I think Daniel's great it's a fun experience I don't know if I think much of it as a play and I don't think this production necessarily does anything to improve that for me it was a fun experience but I don't think I thought much of it outside of the community gathering that it provides it's like a community building exercise
SPEAKER_00Right, so that if we're going by our criteria that we were just talking about for revival of a musical, then if I didn't like it before and I like it now, then Oedipus has my vote. Hands down.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think Oedipus would have my vote too. The only way Salesman would have my vote over Oedipus, and this is, I'm sort of splitting hairs here, but ultimately Oedipus was like so at the top of the year for me. Salesman was a play that I knew very well, I had seen before, and I went in being like, Okay, here we go. And it surprised me. But, Oedipus, as you said, it is this thing that everybody just knows and still made you go, what's going to happen next? I think where people get a little up in arms about it,
understandable, is that it's not the Sophocles text it is a rewritten modernized text and so one could argue it's actually a new play inspired by Oedipus Rex which is fair but it's in revival and thus that's where I shall vote for it well let's see the original play let's see best play we've got Ballister's Giant Liberation Little Bear Ridge Road I guess we
SPEAKER_00could add it I mean you could have five yeah I think if we if Oedipus were considered a new play I think that would have been enough for us to have five nominees maybe before if we had Oedipus and then we had Bowser's Giant Liberation little bear routine call me Izzy is there a ninth play in there ninth new play I feel like there is I feel like there is I feel like
SPEAKER_01I'm missing one I'm currently up to eight uh Maybe we still would have only had four. Was All Out considered for Tony's? I feel like it was, so maybe that would have been eight. Oh, right, right, right. Yeah, I don't know. Sorry, maybe that would have been nine. I don't know. I don't do damn math. This math ain't mathin'. Yeah, this mat, this mat ain't mathin'.
SPEAKER_00Buh-duh-buh. okay uh I think that's oh punch right so punch that would have been nine sorry call me Izzy punch that's two liberation I forgot that was the season punch I loved punch that was that hit no pun intended hit me hard uh Alan yes sir who did you see
SPEAKER_01punch with uh you yeah that's why you loved punch well we left and we were like punch drunk punch drunk and in love I talk about it all the time that act 2 scene with Will Harrison Victoria Clark Sam Robards and the therapist that group scene I heard a pin drop in that theater beautiful shit I'm bummed that didn't get nominated now that I realize that that was this season he got nominated and the show just won the Olivier but yeah I mean
yeah it's tight it is it's a toy race if you okay so I haven't given many predictions right now I will do more so in a week or two but Alan in this moment right here right now do you want to give a prediction or do you want to tell us uh who you'd vote for in like the top couple of categories and then we'll sign off all right let's see best
SPEAKER_00play liberation I've already said that best musical oh god I This is tough. I would vote for Titanic, but I'm gonna say it's gonna go to Lost Boys. Okay. All right. Best book. I think everybody watching this on YouTube because Helen is fucking with a pen right now.
SPEAKER_00Gosh, who would I vote for? For book? For book, I would give this, I think, also to Tanya Nick. Yeah. I think it's going to go to Schmugadoon. Mm-hmm. um best original score written for the theater we've got death of a salesman Joe Turner's coming gun Lost Boy Schmigadoon two strangers um original score original score original score Lost Boys um I would vote for I really
liked it um don't know
SPEAKER_00who would go to but I'm going Lost Boys let's see revival of a play Revival Revival Oedipus we talked about that Revival of a musical Jellicle Ball we talked about that um performance of an actor in a leading role in a play um oh man Mark Strong and Oedipus that performance though know what I'm saying but Will Harris I sat next time at the drama desks by the way did you tell him that I said hey speaking of Oedipus I'm right here hey buddy oh man between
Will Harris John
SPEAKER_00Lithgow and Mark Strong Oh dude Dude Um I'm gonna go with Will Harrison Great I'm voting for Will Harrison He loves your love Actress in a leading role in a play Oh man Carrie Coon was great Rose Byrne was great Susanna Flood was great Leslie Manville and Oedipus Kelly O'Hara Kelly O'Hara was she was great to least I think her character was the least interesting out of all of those five
characters I'm gonna
SPEAKER_00go with Susanna I'm gonna go with Susanna Flood on this one nice Best performance by an actor in a leading role in the musical oh man Chris Nicholas Christopher Joshua Henry Brandon I love Brandon he's a friend of mine I want to I think Joshua's gonna take it I think Joshua's gonna take it but that's a tough category this is a really tough category watch me watch me vote for Sam Tutte just
SPEAKER_01to fuck with everybody
SPEAKER_00Okay, I'll give you two more. Let's see. Performance by an actress in a leading role in a musical. Sarah Chase, Stephanie Hsu, Casey Levy, Marla Mendel, Christiani Pitts. Who left me saying, God, I want to see her again? Casey or Marla? Casey or Marla or Christiani? Casey or Marla or Christiani? Eeny, meeny, miny, moe. Catch a Tony by its toe. I'm going with Marla. Hot take.
if you're voting for Titanic that's I mean that makes sense to me right right I mean again you want to go for the big story knowing where that came from how she personally involved with where it was versus where it is now she deserves all the awards great and so you said revival of musical you said Jellicle Ball revival of a play you said Oedipus yes so director of a play would you go Whitney White for liberation or would you go Robert Ick for Oedipus I'm gonna go Whitney White great I'm going Whitney White on that one I love that for you I love
that for her Yeah
SPEAKER_00Any other categories that you're not going to drop my K-bomb design of a musical what are you doing what's happening what's going on sound design sound design sound design oh let me let me pull this up um I'm shucking on my pen here folks it makes great microphone noises all right sound design of a play Justin Ellington Tom let's see so Justin Ellington for Joe Turner's coming gone Tom Gibbons for Oedipus Lee Kenny Fear of 13 Josh Schmidt for Bug Mikael Sulay for Art Desmas oh man sound design of a play I'm going Bug I thought that was great
I love I love looking in left field and finding you there so going strong strong with bugger that was a good nature noises Alan thank you so much for joining us today and for joining all the chaos of the breakdown of course happy to have me you happy to be here happy to happy to have me yes it's true I'm happy you're having me so stupid where can people find you if you want them to find
you oh my goodness at theater underscore podcast that's T-R-E on most of the channels most of the socials the theater podcast dot com I have both R-E and E-R so either one you type it in
SPEAKER_00you'll find me you can find me on the Broadway Podcast Network and yeah that's everything hit me up on any of those and but yeah hit me up on those let me know you listened say hey I listened to you on the Koplik Files let me know you're you're out there I think we should change that name sorry I don't I don't like that one bit the Koplik Files the cop links that's what we're calling it look this is this
this episode has been so copalicious hmm maybe so copalicious for you guys if you like this podcast maybe not this episode but if you like this podcast fuck you please give us a nice five-star rating or review you can follow me on instagram at mattkoplik only usual spelling uh join the Substack or the discord uh if you haven't yet make sure to get your tickets to our june 1st live show at green room 42 the slightly early tony
SPEAKER_01award show for broadway break and uh yeah that's it oh and then a fun thing you'll see a link in the description box for this episode but there is a new company that's uh slowly emerging that uh I found via Instagram we've been discussing on uh via DMs a little bit sort of what's been going down and we agreed to have um I won't call it a collab, but just cross-promotion, synergy. I'm going to call it synergy. That's a word I learned from 30 Rocks.
SPEAKER_00It's French, it's synergy.
SPEAKER_01Synergy. But it is called the Broadway Drop Shop, and they are a company that is doing... Matt Koplik that are limited edition limited edition edition limited edition drops so they're
SPEAKER_01all very exclusive only a few items for each inspired show they have the Joe sent ya so
SPEAKER_00That's a pajama game reference everybody. If you want to understand what it is, just remember it's unlimited dipshits here on the Koplik Files.
SPEAKER_01Unlimited dipshits is my dating past, Alan. I date them and then I write plays about them. That's what I do. That was a Freudian slip.
SPEAKER_00I like it that's the poll quote right there on the billboard thebroadwaydropshop.com all the unlimited dipshits you can find all the unlimited dipshits you can find Jesus Christ oh yeah that's also my dms okay that's it Alan we close out every episode with a diva I'll put her in post but what diva do you
SPEAKER_01want to close out your episode with Bette Midler I love it Bette Midler specifically auto titsling or do you want to do a different pet anything beaches related fantastic auto titsling it is all right thank you so much for listening everybody we will catch you next week with some more tony stuff take it away bet bye
SPEAKER_02The result of this swindle is pointedly clear
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...