As the 2025/2026 barrels towards the finish line, Matt is joined by Breakdown fave Sam Eckmann (Gold Derby) to discuss how this year’s Tony race has changed. From a surprisingly thin Best Musical field to a hyper-competitive Play Revival race, they explore how industry sentiment, voter behavior, and late-season openings could reshape the narrative in the final stretch. If you think you know where the Tonys are headed… think again. Important LinksRevue-ing the 2025/2026 Season: Green Room 42 Tix The (Slightly Early) Tony Awards Show: Green Room 42 Tix Sam Eckmann: Gold Derby Broadway Breakdown: Discord Broadway Breakdown: Substack Guest bioSam Eckmann is an awards expert and contributor at Gold Derby, where he covers Broadway, film, and television races with a sharp eye for trends and voter psychology. A frequent Tony Awards predictor, Sam brings both data-driven insight and deep theater knowledge to the Broadway Breakdown universe. Timestamps * 0:00 - Intro + framing the 2026 Tony race * 2:00 - Best Musical: a weak frontrunner year? * 6:00 - Why Two Strangers leads - but isn’t unbeatable * 9:00 - The “original score vs. jukebox” debate * 14:00 - Musical Revival showdown: Ragtime vs. Cats: The Jellicle Ball * 29:00 - Play Revival: the most competitive category of the season * 40:00 - Lead Actor (Play): crowded field, shifting frontrunners * 45:00 - Director (Musical): why this race is wide open * 50:00 - Will The Queen of Versailles still show up on nomination morning? * 1:00:00 - Can comedy win? The Titanique question * 1:08:00 - Lead Actress (Play): stacked, messy, unpredictable * 1:14:00 - Final predictions in flux + shows to watch before nominations * 1:18:00 - Closing thoughts + diva send-off Listener discussion questions * In a year with no clear Best Musical juggernaut, should voters prioritize originality, impact, or long-term viability when choosing a winner? * Do you think Tony voters consciously avoid rewarding jukebox musicals - or is that narrative overstated? * Which category feels most unpredictable to you this season, and what would genuinely surprise you on nomination morning? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Why not? Think of the prestige. No. Think of the respect. No, no, no. Think of the Tony.
SPEAKER_01Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the broadway podcast hosts and we're back on our tony bullshit because believe it or not the nominations are less than a month away the season has officially started to wrap up and thus we called on our dear friend your cunty uncle please welcome back gold derby's own sam ekman hi sam hi
matt i'm so glad to be the cunty uncle cunty uncle sam baby i'm always on my tony bullshit so it's i'm
SPEAKER_00glad to be here it's the appropriate time
SPEAKER_01As well, we love to have you on your Tony bullshit too. And this is different because your first entry onto the podcast was more about like helping our listeners learn how to predict. And then your second one was just like feet to the flame. The Tonys are in four days. Who be winning? And that was a lot of high stakes. This is a little different. We're not necessarily making bold predictions so much as we're kind of having a little bit of column A, column B. We're talking about now that everything has started performances this season. Not everything has opened. You and I haven't seen everything yet,
but we are healthily into that point of April where the conversation is getting a
SPEAKER_01little more real and things are starting to crystallize. So I wanted to chat with you about what you've seen, what you've heard, and where we both sort of feel like the wind is blowing in certain categories and with certain shows. I guess first up with Let's just start with the big one, because it's technically the biggest category, and yet it's the most underwhelming this year, I find, which is Best Musical.
SPEAKER_00Underwhelming, you say? Yeah, I mean, hot take, I think. What do you mean? You want more than six shows that are eligible for a category? God, you're so demanding. I feel like I needed to be more specific to my genie a few years ago when I was
SPEAKER_01like, God, 13 new musicals this season. I should have been like 10. 10 would be great. Nine or 10. I don't need... Not five, not six. Nine or 10. That'd be great. But sort of what are we... feeling right now on this april 6th that we record about best musical because i feel like for a long time everyone was going well it's going to be two strangers by default because no one knows what those final four are going to look like and we're trying to know what they're going to look like yeah i feel pretty comfortable
saying what my four nominees will be the winner is a little bit more of an iffy
SPEAKER_00thing but i do feel like The nominees will likely end up being Two Strangers, The Lost Boys, Schmigadoon, and Titanique. I would agree with that. It's hard to see the others. I mean, Queen of Versailles is gone. Rip her. And I don't think that's going to make enough of an impact to be remembered as a closed musical getting in. Many people were not kind to that one. And Beaches, I haven't seen it yet, so I can't comment on what it is.
SPEAKER_00But I think... The fact that it's like a limited run that we know is not going to like continue afterwards, not going to have a huge commercial life on Broadway, I think is going to hurt its chances, even if it is really good. So it's not completely out of the running. You know, it could open to rapturous reviews and get in or something else could really fail and Beechers takes its spot. But otherwise, I think the four nominees are pretty likely cemented in stone
at this point. It's just a matter of which one of the four gets to pull ahead for the win. Yeah, I think for what everyone I've spoken to who's either a voter or a nominator, there's There's no ill will towards two strangers so much as that I think a lot of people I
SPEAKER_01had spoken to wanted to like a little bit more than they did. And there was a bit of I don't want to vote for it because it's the only option. So it's not that they're rooting for it to not win so much as they're like, I would like to have options. So this spring is very much like Lost Boys, Titanic, Titanic, like please just work so I can I can have variety. That would be really nice. So if I vote for two strangers, it's because I want to not because I have to. Yeah. Yeah. Which I think is fair.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I don't know anyone who's like hating on two strangers. I just think as a Tony front runner, it's a little bit of a weaker front runner than we've seen. It's like it would be very easy to overtake it because I just I think a lot of people have it at number one because it's an original score it's very charming um and it has that sort of intimate character driven feel that a lot of best musical uh winners have had recently like um kimberly
akimbo uh maybe happy
SPEAKER_00ending but i don't know that i feel the same real passion for it as musicals like that, because I don't think it's, you know, it's a very cute kind of like rom-com story. And I think the two actors are great. I think I had a really good time. I don't think it's necessarily doing anything quite as new or as different as maybe those shows did that people are lumping it into the same category. So I think everyone's kind of waiting for like, is there going to be another one that really knocks us out of the park?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Because I don't think it's... Two Strangers is, I would say, the frontrunner right now, but is not an unbeatable frontrunner.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think what helps with something also like a Kimberly Akimbo or a band's visit or a maybe happy ending is there's... Kimberly Kimbo and Banzos had creative teams that were tried and true in the Broadway community and or came from like Atlantic Theater Company and maybe Happy Ending had Michael Arden and people that could be sort of. the face of the underdog campaign where it was two strangers there's really nobody involved that's of that's like a major force in the broadway
community sam toady has become a very liked person in the community but he you know there's no history
SPEAKER_01with him and and no history with the creators in any way. So I agree with you. What Two Strangers has going in its favor is it is original, it is a solid show, and it does have that small charm piece to it, which a lot of Best Musical winners the last 10 to 12 years have really had going for them. But you could also argue that, like, there's an underdog element to the other three as well. Just even if they're bigger, they also are not sure things. And...
SPEAKER_01That's sort of what helps any of them, I would say, is that it's rare that the voters for Best Musical vote for the sure thing anymore. It used to be like, oh, what's the biggest hit? You're going to win it. And now it's like, no, which one really needs our vote? Which one will close a week after Tony's if we don't vote for it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they're very aware of which musicals will vote. Probably be okay if they don't win. And then which ones really kind of need the box office boost and that stamp of approval with their vote?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, that sort of goes into what you and I spoke about on your very first episode, what I did last year with the myths and trends. There's always the myth of the elusive road voter at the Tony Awards. People always go, what's going to tour well? That road vote, they're going to really, you know, tilt the scale. And it's like, A, they're actually not as big a percentage of the body as you think they are. They're about 10 percent, which were 800 plus voters. That's 80 people.
SPEAKER_00Which is nothing. It used to be a higher percentage, which is why that became known. They used to be around 25 to 27 percent of the voting body. And they haven't been that for a long time.
SPEAKER_01Not for a long time. Probably not since Avenue Q days. My assumption is post Avenue Q, they were like, we need to expand this body. Because also those road voters really mad when they did vote for Avenue Q and Avenue Q said, psych, we're going to Vegas. I mean, a Hamilton or a Dear Van Hansen, sure, but those were such undeniable hits, both commercially and critically, that they were never not going to get the vote. Something like A Fun Home or A Gentleman's Guide or A Band's Visit have gone up against bigger musicals and won, and that helps them with going on the road.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and because, like, you know, it was like Gentleman's Guide versus Beautiful, the Carole King musical, right? And Aladdin. Sure. But like we're talking with a nitty gritty here.
SPEAKER_01Who it really came down to for sure.
SPEAKER_00And if you're if you're a presenter, like a road presenter, like I would be like, well, I know I can sell the Carole King musical. I can't sell Gentleman's Guide to, you know, whatever regional market I'm in, unless it has that stamp of approval of Tony winner best musical. Otherwise, it doesn't really have a successful tour. Maybe I'm not going to book it.
SPEAKER_01It's also, it's weird. This is a year where Best Musical could go to a jukebox or non-original score musical for the first time since, really since Jersey Boys. I'm not counting Moulin Rouge because that's a COVID year. They were all jukebox musicals.
SPEAKER_03But that's always...
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's always been a detriment for Best Musical winners of if you're a jukebox musical, you could maybe get close to winning, but you probably won't. The argument was that the year of Strange Loop, when the ceremony ended, everyone going in thought it was going to be Strange Loop versus Six, and it turns out it was Strange Loop versus MJ. And MJ probably got very close to winning and ultimately didn't because it was a jukebox musical.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think MJ got very close. There were also people last year saying Hell's Kitchen was going to win, but I always, and like the broken record every Tony season, and I'm sure producers don't like hearing it, but it's just really hard right now as we see it with the win. to win as a musical that has a pre-existing score. I think that voters are really aware of what they are saying is the best, what they're lifting up with that award.
And because I think Best Musical is really the one from the season oftentimes that
SPEAKER_00is remembered long after. And that, you know, like kids in high school that are coming into the theater realm, that's like what they pay attention to. The Tonys are a huge advertising tool. And I think there has been a concerted effort, you know, the last 15 years to say we want to uplift our own people, like our own composers and artists. lyricists who are creating new musicals and it's not we don't want to look back at our list of winners and it's just pop artists and rock you know
rock artists in there so that has really been a deciding factor like everyone last year was like it's definitely Hell's Kitchen it's definitely Hell's Kitchen and there was like a i feel like there was a scramble of everyone in the industry of like okay we can't do that there's stuff's in the outsiders like which is it going to be and i think the outsiders felt a little bit more cool um and so that eventually got the vote but they i feel like everyone was like hell's kitchen has a lot of buzz right now we can't go that way like we can give it other trophies but we're not going to go
SPEAKER_00that way what stuff's our outsiders folks yeah i've
SPEAKER_01I will not name names, but I will say I have three different voters say to me during that, like the week leading up to when their ballots were cast. They literally go, I can't bring myself to vote for Hell's Kitchen. I just I didn't like it. I'm not for jukebox musicals. And they're like, they literally said what you said. They're like, for me, it's down to stuff and outsiders. And then they literally said, I have to think which vote will go the farthest, like which show will like which one am I doing? like, you know, throwing a drop of water on a giant forest fire or which one
actually will create
SPEAKER_01change. And which I think is also a lot of people going, I think Outsiders is... As you said, the cooler one, I think people were impressed by the production of it all. When Danya Tamor won for Outsiders, that's when I went, oh, they're going to win. This is happening now. And people didn't believe me, but I said, just you watch Henry Higgins. This is a spam-a-lot year where all you need to win is to rector and you're fine. But yeah, no, it's a true thing. And it's important for people to remember, which again, point... two strangers and even lost boys it gives them a little bit of
an edge over our other two potential nominees but i don't know this is a weird year anything can happen yeah sinko has written a few new songs for schmigadoon and it's not like pop music so maybe some people won't hold that as much against that show but will it be
SPEAKER_01enough for them to be eligible for score don't know we'll see when when i see it we'll figure it out but uh you know aladdin convinced them that they had enough material for score and that wasn't i was still not sure there's 50 of the musical's new material for the stage but i think they counted a few of the songs that ashman wrote that weren't in the movie and it's like yeah that's but like we've seen proud of like proud of your boy already yeah existed and stuff exactly and and uh high adventure and all
that stuff like that like those those songs were written fucking 30 years ago um but yeah i digress okay so that's musical uh talk to what's a category you'd like to get into for a second uh well we could just go to the the actual big one with the huge race which is
SPEAKER_00musical revival
SPEAKER_01Oh, sure. Yeah. I was going to talk about Play Revival as well, because that one actually has the most contenders of any major category this season. But yeah, let's do Musical Revival.
SPEAKER_00That one, I've been thinking like the Tony producers should really hold that to be the last category of the night, because I do feel like that is the big battle that everyone is going to be looking at.
SPEAKER_01For sure. It's not going to be helped by the fact that Jellicle Ball won a bunch of stuff last year when it was eligible, which means Ragtime is going to win Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle and most likely Drama League, which gives the impression that it's going to sweep, especially because people online don't, A, don't know that these are different voting bodies and B, don't know that Jellicle Ball was eligible last year. So they're just going to have a lot of opinions on Instagram. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I mean, look, those two shows are both, in my opinion, exceptional. And I think they would make either one a great winner. But I think that is like, I feel like Ragtime and Cats the Jellicle Ball will be... leading the nominations more than any other shows. One of those is going to get the most nominations. And even other revivals like Rocky Horror Show and Chess have the potential to get
SPEAKER_00more nominations than several of the new musicals. It's true.
SPEAKER_01I was being very bullish about Chess's chances about two months ago. I think that it might do a little bit better than i originally anticipated but i do ultimately think that rocky horror is the third slot there for revival yeah i'm guessing rocky horror too um but there's you know we haven't seen i haven't seen it yet there's i think rocky horror is kind of a double-edged sword in that it is such a beloved
SPEAKER_00cult classic and also because of that people will have certain expectations going in and i'm hopeful and believe that sam pinkleton is going to meet them uh because he's awesome but uh you never know people could just be like i have my set idea of what i want from the show and maybe it's different from what they're doing we have to see how it gets what the reactions are i'm glad you said that i literally had that exact conversation with someone the other day because that's the thing about as one thing we have been sort of skirting around is
SPEAKER_01that again an All of the shows we're talking about have either opened and closed or they're fully open or they're in previews. So there's talk online about them. And Rocky Horror's preview process has been a fascinating one because the buzz is all over the place there. are people who are like they've pulled it off this works it's so good people who are like i don't know what i just saw but that's not my rocky horror and it's truly as you said this this property has been around for decades it's lives in various
mediums and people have their own history with it and as you said what they want from it and especially when it comes to rocky horror on broadway that's a very specific blend that's not going to please everyone and in fact it's ironic that so
SPEAKER_01many people talk about this one and compare it to the last Broadway revival, because if you read the reviews of the last Broadway revival, those reviews are not favorable. They're all kind of going, I don't, you know, everyone in it's so talented, but I don't think Rocky Horror should be on Broadway. Not like this anyway. And now 25 years later, we look back and we go, what a good revival that was.
SPEAKER_00Right. I think, you know, that's an area where the critics and audiences and industry diverged because a lot of people look back at that 2000 revival and go like, this was perfect Broadway Rocky Horror and lift that up as like this roundabout version has to match that. So you never know. I think I'm predicting it as the third movie. slot there i still am yeah my other thing is just roundabout tends to get that
nomination even when the production is not one of their best ones and it was just
SPEAKER_01not to say anything about rocky horror but roundabout has had some underbaked revivals in the past that have still managed to get that nomination and from all accounts this rocky horror is not underbaked it's it is good even if it's not everyone's expectation for it so i think that's definitely enough and the big thing about it that i've hear is that luke evans like is that bitch and and does command as frankenfurter and will be the third lock in actor in a musical for sure which is nice to hear
SPEAKER_00I mean, so far, she looks great. So I'm excited.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I think it's still unclear if we have four or five slots for Best Actor in a Musical this year, but I do think the three that are locked up...
SPEAKER_00It should be four, what I'm... Okay, four. Based on what I'm hearing from, like, Lost Boys, I think they're only pushing L.J. Bennett as the lead. And I think unless they... Unless Roundabout decides to try and make Brad and Janet leads and push Andrew Durand up, which is not what happened before, then we only have eight guys eligible for lead actor. And so Constantine is going to be considered featured then for Titanic, do we think?
SPEAKER_01I believe he is. We'll see what happens. I think he's going featured.
SPEAKER_00We'll see. You can come back to this after it opens and say how wrong or right I am.
SPEAKER_01Oh, they love to do that for all of us. Wait, so it's chess. Right. Chess. Right. That's four. Rocky Harming's five. Shpingadoon. Lost Boys. Two Strangers. So, yeah, I guess if Constantine ends up getting put in lead, then that's nine and we get five. Otherwise, it's four. And I do think that Joshua, Henry, Sam Toody and Luke would be, in my opinion, the locks. Which means that fourth nominee for lead actor, which means the fourth slot, I think, is sort of a cage match amongst a few very talented men.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So we'll see. We'll see.
SPEAKER_00Well, then it's all up to you, Titanic. Put Constantine in lead and we'll get a fifth slot.
SPEAKER_01Let's get that fifth slot, baby. Come on. You know what to do. That man fills out those pants so nicely. Let's let's. He does what we all want, what we all need. Although if we put him in featured, that helps because featured actor in a musical, I think is weirdly kind of a weird, it's a weird one this year where I'm not, because a lot of the major contenders are still kind of sowing their oats in their preview process. It's hard to know who really has the juice to get a nomination. And there's a lot of different opinions from reports from like,
titanic rocky harsh mega dune of like what featured actors are and lost boys even of which featured actors are really popping off the stage um which means i feel like we could get a situation like 2024 where it's like oh we got uh two guys from outsiders like one of maybe i didn't expect or one i didn't expect like it's it's there's always one or two people that get in there that are not not worthy just not
SPEAKER_01who you expected you know
SPEAKER_00Well, I think it's, you know, sometimes a really dominant show can pull in a lot of nominees, which if we want to talk about featured actor and segue there right now, I think that is a category where that is going to happen because I was actually just like updating my my predictions uh for that and trying to see who i thought you know would be in or out which is again hard because so many of them haven't opened but i feel like it's you know a place where cats the jellicle
ball could get two to
SPEAKER_00three nominations very easily
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure. I know the industry sentiment is, you know, very much with Andre DeShields.
SPEAKER_00And so he's like sitting atop my predictions. And he just, you know, comes in like this grand deity. I swear to God, Deuteronomy's...
SPEAKER_01Looking like gay Aslan in that show. deuteronomy's entrance when i saw it lasted it must have lasted 10 minutes the mc just kept going and andre like was like i'm gonna take a minute and was dancing his ass off up there and everyone was just eating it up and i don't think there's like i don't think there's many performers there's like maybe a handful of performers
SPEAKER_00who could just like come in and like bop around on stage and have the whole audience going nuts and he's one of them but i was really surprised you know i love sydney james harcourt and i think he could get in and he's like has a lot of stage time he has a lot of presence and then junior labasia who's a legendary ballroom figure i like gus the theater cat ended and i was in total tears i did not expect that and i like
i fell in love with this production at pack and i really there were things i really worried about like wouldn't translate which proved to be unfounded i loved it again on broadway
SPEAKER_00But what Junior is doing in this moment, in that intimate of a theater, resonates so much more powerfully than the way he did it at PAC. It's really, really beautiful. And I was like, he somehow with Gus the Theater Cat created a moment that is just as emotionally effective as memory to me. I absolutely loved it. And I was like, maybe he also gets in. he really could i think the thing about gus that is to its
benefit for a nomination but might not be quite enough for the award is that it's not it is it is not a uh burn the house down kind of song like memory and it's not and gus is not on stage as much as deuteronomy but what he has is in all of this chaos and glitter and and disco magic gus is one of the few quiet moments where everything just stops and
SPEAKER_01And it proves that this is not a production that's all surfaced. Like there's real depth and a taste level of knowing when to pull back. And he does command the room and the attention. And there's a historical precedent. The actor who originated Gus in 1982 was nominated for a Tony. So it can happen again. It can happen again. It's the unexpected one because, as you said, it's not the big flashing number.
SPEAKER_00But he just hits you right in the feels. I never wanted it to end. So that's the thing I was talking with someone else about when it came to featured
SPEAKER_01performances. I feel like you and I spoke about this last year. I have found that when it comes to featured performances in musicals, both actor and actress, it tends to go back and forth depending on the season. But usually the winner as a featured performer either has like a big song and that actually can be Augusta Theater Cat. Or they set a mood, which is ultimately like an Andre in Hadestown or a Danny Burstein in Moulin Rouge. And Andre kind of does it again in Cats of like setting the mood. Also, I forgot the name of the performer who plays Munkus Strat,
but he also does that.
SPEAKER_00For sure, yes.
SPEAKER_01Does that all show long. And that can be one of those random surprises where people go, oh, I never thought about that. But I guess he really does hold it all together. It's like, yep. And people notice. People notice. I think the biggest issue... cats jellicle ball will have when it comes to votes is not the marketability of it but because that the energy in that theater is so party vibe and not everyone in the audience is going to be a community member of of electricity they will be their own
streaking banshee of support uh i think some older voters will be at cats and will be annoyed by audiences like that and will then have a grudge against jellicle ball but that's a story for actual wins not nominations that's not where we're at yet but i'm just i'm as somebody who also very much is pro jellicle ball i don't want listeners to think that i am have blinders on i'm very aware that like it does have
SPEAKER_01things going against it for certain voters um But we had someone in the Discord the other day say that they are convinced that Bryce Pinkham is going to win for chess, which I think is a very bold prediction. I'll be interested to see if he gets in with, as you said, Ragtime and Cats kind of having all of these potential options. And then we also really don't know how Schmigadoon or Titanic is going to land with voters. Those shows are sort of like a goldmine of featured nominees as well.
Yeah, I had Bryce in my top five, I think, earlier in the season when not as much has opened.
SPEAKER_00But it's a tough, I don't know, it's a tough lineup. I do think, I don't know that I see him winning for that just because I don't think... I think the show is as strong as some of, will be as strong of a contender as like Ragtime or Cats. And I think it could miss out in several key categories. And I think if your show is not one of the really dominant ones of the awards ceremony, then you really have to be like an undeniable force that people
just like can't say
SPEAKER_00no to. Because otherwise, like... people end up just like checking off the show that they really like down the line in many cases. I could definitely see Bryce getting in. He's a past nominee. Um... I, you know, when I was at chess, the audience, they ate him up like everyone was laughing at him. So I know a lot of people like a lot of people don't like the modern references that they put in the Arbiter's, you know, new script. But he commits to the bit and he's really entertaining and he
has a couple of
SPEAKER_00really great numbers and he gives it his all. I thought he was great.
SPEAKER_01He's such a talented man. I liked what he did with his number of the arbiter. And yeah, no, he gets a lot of material that I don't enjoy, but he absolutely does his best to sell it. I'm not saying he wouldn't get nominated. While I did not enjoy chess, I I'm also, as I said, if I'm not putting my blinders on for Jellicle Ball, I'm also choosing not to put my blinders on for chess. I do not enjoy it. And interestingly enough, this is another case where Bryce is a featured player who does set the tone for the show. And the question is, do you like said tone?
SPEAKER_01I did not, but plenty of people did. I think... As you said, Bryce would have to kind of be a sort of Stephanie J. Block and Cher Show situation. That's, I think, the last time somebody won for a musical that wasn't in the main categories. And that was a ultimately star vehicle, bio musical. There's a metric in which voters could measure SJB's performance of how much like Cher does she remind me of Cher? So if Chess is not a revival nominee and doesn't get a book
nomination, I think
SPEAKER_01in order for Bryce to win, he would have to be one of, like, a slew of other nominations that the show has. Like, they would have to get nominated for Nick and Leah and orchestrations and lighting and choreography. Like, they wouldn't... If they were not going to get a revival, they'd have to get, like, five or six under the line. Under the... Under the line?
SPEAKER_00Below the line.
SPEAKER_01Below the line, that's fine.
SPEAKER_00Below the line.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, thank you. He works for Gold Derby.
SPEAKER_00That's an industry term for the design and craft categories.
SPEAKER_01Yes, for design and mostly tech stuff. Things that are not director or picture. Um... let's talk for a quick second about Best Play Revival. And by quick second, I mean five seconds, because this is, of all the big, big ones, of the Play Musical, Musical Revival, Play Revival, Play Revival has the most options. It's going to be the only five-nominee category of those top four. At the beginning of the season, I felt like it was pretty clear what they were going to be, and then it got less clear, and then it got clear again,
SPEAKER_01and now it's becoming a little less clear again. It had who I thought were locks, I'm starting to think some of my locks may not be locks anymore. Especially now that we're, so we're recording this on the day that Becky Shaw is due to open. Word of mouth on Becky Shaw is extremely strong. This will be considered a revival. Death of a Salesman opens later this week as well. I see Becky Shaw the day before this episode comes out. I've seen Death of a Salesman. I have yet to see Proof or Joe Turner's come and gone. But those I think are the only other revivals I have yet to see.
SPEAKER_01But I don't know. I feel like I have what I think are my three locks, but I'm also not confident in that either. I think if I'm trying to call locks, this one is so competitive, I think there's only two locks. Which are?
SPEAKER_00Which are Death of a Salesman and Oedipus.
SPEAKER_01Okay. I think I can handle that.
SPEAKER_00I want there to be more locks because I love a lot of these shows, but this is a really competitive race this year. Yeah, I had a very strong feeling about Marjorie Prime's chances in December. And now I am getting very sad that, like, that's a show that could actually blank on May 5th. Which would be crazy. After I saw Marjorie Prime, I was like, this should absolutely win Revival. I thought it was some of the most exquisite acting. Nominate this whole company. It was incredible.
SPEAKER_00But now I'm like, oh, this closed so long ago. Are they going to forget it with all of these new...
SPEAKER_01Things that are top of mind. Especially with featured actress being perhaps the most competitive category of the season.
SPEAKER_00Most competitive acting category, for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Not only are there so many options, there are so many good options. It's like, the fuck do we do? Because before March... And they announced that Cynthia Nixon and June Squibb are going to be eligible for featured. I was like, oh, OK, great. Like, they'll most likely get in. Fantastic. And Betsy Adem for Liberation. Here we go. And then, you know, people are talking about Mary Louise Burke in The Balusters. They're talking about Linda Eamond for Becky Shaw. They're talking about Carrie Young for Proof.
SPEAKER_01I've now seen Salesman. I do think Laurie Metcalf will get nominated for Salesman, where she will definitely be put in feature. That's where Linda always is. And it becomes it's just sort of like well fuck like who of my who of my loves are not going to make it in right i think they should have pushed june squib into lead i do too i really think that was a miscalculation in terms of like in terms of strategy i think she would have you know that's not guaranteed in lead either because
SPEAKER_00there's a lot of great women there but i think she could have cemented a slot there a lot easier and not saying she won't get nominated i do think she has a great narrative she would be the like she would ironically uh usurp lois smith who originally played marjorie prime off broadway as you know the oldest she could be the oldest tony winner ever if she were to like get nominated and win because she's 96 um which is just like nuts that she's 96 and on broadway i
like to think that lois smith and june squib have a joan crawford betty davis relationship going on that no one knows about and the june squib is pulling her joan crawford moment with the oscars it's like getting nominated beating lois
SPEAKER_01smith's record for a role that she had originated it's just like So bitchy. It's absolutely not true. Those two women are absolute, you know, teddy bears. But just like, wouldn't that be great to find out?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they should make a fake rivalry.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, I think. God, someone get June Squibb's press agent on the phone because I think this is a great idea. It would be a viral video. And I think it would get nominators to nominate her and then people to actually vote for her.
SPEAKER_00If you need someone to write snippy little comebacks. We could, let's just write a script for them and we'll put it in the, we'll put it in the trades. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01As a nice little awards campaign. Remember when Audra and Cherry Jones did that for Fakesies when they were up against each other?
SPEAKER_00Who was that in?
SPEAKER_01Was that the year?
SPEAKER_00It was like Time Out or something and they had like a fake fight. I love that. I don't remember that.
SPEAKER_01That was the year of Glassmanagerie and Lady Day?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. I think it only works for women like that who have nothing to prove because they've done it all. Like we can't have the ingenues of mean girls do that to each other because people would take it too seriously. But when it's Audra and Cherry or like June and Lois for everyone's like, they would never actually do that because they're the goats.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. But yeah, featured actress, man. I don't know. I'm very scared. I refuse to make a genuine prediction until like another two to three weeks from now.
SPEAKER_00It's, I mean, I have to say, I know some people will think it's like the boring pick because a character, but like Laurie Metcalf shot way out front for me after seeing Death of a Salesman.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. She's definitely getting nominated. I'm still bullish on her winning, but also I think about it and like at this point, I guess Salesman is the front runner for Revival now because it'll be playing. It's selling well. It's a good Revival. And it's also like It is the most directory Joe Mantello has been in a very long time. And I think that's exciting to people. I think he has shot up in my predictions for a director of a
play this year because of that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I was totally in the camp. Like when they announced this, I was like, we just had Death of a Salesman. Like, are we doing? I mean, I love Death of a Salesman. Arthur Miller, you know, I'll read him all day. But I was like, don't we like have other things to do? Do we need one? Like it's always performed. And then I saw this one and I was like, there are lines of dialogue that i have like studied analyzed performed seen done millions of times and i felt like i was hearing lines that i
had never heard before because it's just i thought it was like a remarkable production of this play um and you're right like joe mantello's direction is a more like it's so specific and like
SPEAKER_00conceptual um and i was like oh wow this is this could be it you know this play that we thought like oh this again he's made feel so urgent and new um i think the one thing we should talk about that you know one thing to note that could hold it back is that there is the opportunity for voters to reward playwrights in this category because of the There's a rule now for the classics, quote unquote classics, that get a Best Revival nomination,
SPEAKER_00even though it's their first time on Broadway, where the writers of said shows appear on the ballot and are eligible to be Tony nominees and winners. because they didn't have the opportunity when their play or musical first debuted. And there's a lot of shows like Oedipus and Marjorie Prime and Becky Shaw. And is there one other one I'm forgetting? Every Brilliant Thing, Bug. So there's a lot of shows up there.
SPEAKER_00which, you know, it could be an opportunity to honor a writer and it's something that feels really new because it hasn't been seen on Broadway. So that could be a really appealing thing for voters.
SPEAKER_01It's true. I mean, I'm saying this having, I will be seeing Becky Shaw in literally 48 hours so I can make a more clear-headed decision about that. But yeah, I think that That definitely helps when it comes to revival. I think it helps a little bit more when it's down to like two options and someone's undecided. They'll go, well, I want to give this playwright their flowers because, you know, as you said, Arthur Miller has had his flowers. But I mean, if it's if it's not really down to two for some voters, they might just go for salesmen.
SPEAKER_01But I'll see. I mean, I think with something like Every Brilliant thing, that for me is more of a likelihood for Daniel than the show. I feel like it's a nice play. It's more of a really excellent exercise in community building than it is in playwriting. And it's also a really wonderful vehicle for him. So I... I don't have him as a lock, but I have him as a likely fourth. Right now, my three locks are, for actor in a play,
are Mark Strong for Oedipus.
SPEAKER_01Oedipus, sorry. We must call it Oedipus. Nathan Lane for Salesman and Lithgow for Giant. And then I have Radcliffe as a most likely contender. And then I keep hearing, speaking of Becky Shaw, I keep forgetting to say his full name, but it's Alden, the guy from Solo. Alden Aaron Reich, yeah. Yes. I keep hearing about his performance and how great he is.
SPEAKER_00But he is. I don't think I don't think anyone from Becky Shaw will be in lead. I think that will be.
SPEAKER_01We'll see. Yeah. I mean,
SPEAKER_00if if second stage didn't push June Squibb to lead for Marjorie Prime, they're definitely not pushing anyone to lead. Maybe they learned their lesson. Maybe they learned. Yeah, they're making.
SPEAKER_01Oh, shit. Now June may not get nominated. We can't have that again.
SPEAKER_00I do think Alden is the most likely acting nominee from Becky Shaw. He's a definite driving force in it.
SPEAKER_01I'm a fan of his. I think he's such a unique, specific talent. And crazy that he's as leading man-looking as he is and also has the gift of a comic actor, of a secondary character, which I think is unfair. You can't be pretty like that and also be able to play weirdos. god does not give with both hands stop it well so those are your your three locks for lead are you not going with then the leading men for adrian
brody and john burnfield right now well i did just finish this weekend having seen dog day afternoon giant and fear of 13 so yeah i that is exactly what i'm saying sam
SPEAKER_00I have not seen Fear of 13 yet. So I can't comment on that.
SPEAKER_01I wonder if Fear of 13 is better when you're close. Because I was I had a good seat, but I was a little far away. And I wonder if it's a show that thrives on intimacy that that premiered at the Donmar, which is like less than 300 seats. This is Jones, which is 1100. It felt a little... I mean, it's important subject matter, but it felt a little just... I made a joke on my story. I took a screenshot from the SNL sketch of the drama club where they're all in black and doing their own...
self-written sketch show for their parents and it's them being like, wow, yeah, mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01We're 17 and we're so groundbreaking. And the show felt a little bit like that to me, which is a shame because I love Cromer and I love a lot of that cast. But yeah, I'm not predicting Brody. But maybe I'll eat my words. Especially if Alden's not considered lead, then Brody could get in. But not John Barthol. Poor John Barthol. I think John is doing his darndest in Dog Day Afternoon. I just think that it's such a misconceived production.
SPEAKER_00I mean, the show is not probably going to get nominated for Best Play. However, I thought Jon Bernthal was doing really great work. And I do think he, even if the play is missing the top category, just like the needs of that role and how emotive he is the whole time he hardly ever leaves the stage, I do think he could still get a nomination. Yeah. I think what will help him is I do think he'll get a Drama League nomination.
And those tend to be the first ones to come out the bat, which what those nominations do is...
SPEAKER_01It puts it in people's brains of, oh, are they an option down the line? Should I think about them when I'm casting my nomination ballot? And so that helps someone like him. And I think even if Dog Day Afternoon will not get a Best Play nomination, I do think that is Liberation, Little Bear Ridge Road, Giant, and the Balusters in exactly that order. You have Little Bear Ridge Road as second? Maybe Ballister's a second. So yeah, I would say Liberation, the Ballister's, Giant, and Little Bear Ridge Road. I think that's the order of likelihood of winning.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, that's my order right now.
SPEAKER_00I can't decide what to do with my final slot in that one. I do think Liberation Giant and The Balusters are in, for sure. But then I feel like, I don't know, I guess Little Barrage Road has the reviews and it has the Laurie Metcalf of it all. So maybe I should just do that. But I'm like, what if there's, I don't know, would they remember all the way back to Punch, which feels like this much grander script?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, I was not a fan of either play, but I do think Little Bear Ridge Road is objectively the better play. But there is there is that one scene in Act Two of Punch that just like really destroyed me. The one where they're all sitting together in the therapy session.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But ultimately, I think the thing with Little Bear Ridge Road that's making me a little iffy is that is that a best play possibility for a nomination that then also gets no nominations anywhere else?
SPEAKER_00Well, that happens all the time. Does it? It's a weird quirk of the Tonys. Yeah. Now I can't remember the name of it. Tracy Letts' The Minutes was in for best play. It's a weird thing because it happens all the time because plays and revivals or new works and revivals are split in the top category, but then have to compete against each other everywhere else. So you can have a year that is really... heavy towards one or the other or like there's more options
that are more well liked in one of those banks uh and then so there's just whether it's new work or revival one of the categories just kind of has this one like oh this one could only
SPEAKER_00get in here and it was like shoved out in every other category yeah
SPEAKER_01From what I understand, with the Balusters, what helps with the Balusters is the Manhattan Theater Club of it all. David Lindsay Abair is a writer that is very well liked, has only been nominated for Best Play once, though, which is crazy. Apparently the play is quite good and there are opportunities to nominate the cast. So I think that always, it always helps, even if it's just one or two nominations to boost them up. But what I was going to say with Dog Day Afternoon, what I think helps Jon Bernthal is, even though it's not going to get in for play, I do think it's, if not a lock,
SPEAKER_01a very strong nomination contender for all the tech categories, for set, for costumes, for sound, for lighting. And that helps them sort of boost Jon Bernthal up there with all of those nominations. So, yeah, I guess that's what I would say with Bernthal. Something that really interests me is director of a musical because I feel like there are... I only have one real luck for me, which is Jellicle Ball,
SPEAKER_01just because it's the biggest creative swing of all of these shows. And we know that it lands for the most part for everyone. Yeah. Everything else is sort of like anyone could get pushed out for anyone based on like a two nominator difference of opinion, you know, while Ragtime is a very beloved musical, there is a difference of opinion on the success of this revival or even like how much creative sway this revival even does,
SPEAKER_01which is. for debate but i also sort of point to last year with gypsy with george c wolf not getting nominated for gypsy because there was a difference of opinion of exactly how much he put into that show um so like right now i'm thinking jellicle ball ragtime two strangers and then like lost boys and schmigadoon or like maybe it's not ragtime and maybe like titanic gets in there randomly because they were able to nail the moving from off broadway to broadway or maybe lost boys is such a clusterfuck that lost
boys goes out and
SPEAKER_01ragtime remains it's or like maybe sam pinkleton really does It does land the plane with Rocky Horror and it's like Ragtime is out for Rocky Horror or Schmigadoon is out for Rocky Horror. For me right now, it's just such a puzzle piece with just Jellicle Ball being the only thing I'm willing to put a chip down on, you know?
SPEAKER_00That is definitely my number one. And I have a hard time seeing the Jellicle Ball losing director because they're so... Everything depends on their kind of reinvention of that material. I do think Ragtime, I feel pretty comfortable about Lear getting in. It's again, I think Ragtime and Cats will be the two dominant forces of this year's Tonys. And I... I think enough people love that production that she's getting in. From there, it gets a little shaky.
SPEAKER_00I think, as of right now, I have Rocky Horror, Two Strangers, and Lost Boys filling out the category. But all of those have pluses and minuses. We haven't seen Rocky Horror yet, so maybe people will decide... he didn't do it. I like 2000 show better, or maybe it will be brilliant and it'll be everyone's favorite version. We don't know. And then two strangers, I think is a really tightly directed show. And I really loved how they used,
you know, how he used the set with just two people and not,
SPEAKER_00I think it would be worthy of it. But again, it's a small show. If people think of, like, Two Strangers is so small and there's just two characters, maybe they think that, you know, Tim Jackson didn't have as much to do there. They might look at, like, the bigger productions to nominate. And Lost Boys is another big question mark. But I have, you know, Michael Arden now has a proven track record. This is a really... you know, gargantuan production, so I've heard. So that's in there for now.
But I do think Christopher Gatelli, I think, is my next in line if Schmigadoon performs well.
SPEAKER_01I also, what Lear and the director of Two Strangers have going for them as well, is that they're both working with turntables. And turntables do quite nicely with directing.
SPEAKER_00We love a turntable. We love a turntable.
SPEAKER_01I mean, with Ragsheim, it is technically a donut because the center don't move, just the outer ring. But she do circle. She do twirl. The Two Strangers... But staging and design, I think, is really clever. And I was surprised a few people I was speaking to weren't predicting Two Strangers for scenic design of a musical. I was like, I think that's a lock for a design nomination because, I mean, it's not like aesthetically beautiful. It's a lot of white and gray suitcases. But the way that it becomes multiple locations,
SPEAKER_01even if it's not your vote to win, you can't deny that it is creative and well executed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's a great concept with a really brilliant use of space. I don't think it's going to win because it's not the quote-unquote typical thing that wins. The biggest, grandest thing does, but it should still get into scenic design for sure.
SPEAKER_01Every 15 years, we get the set winner that's not the most set. It's the best set, but every 15 years is not a great average. Very rarely do the voters actually pick Bob Crowley for once. Usually it's... Usually it's Eugene Lee for Wicked.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's typically what they go with.
SPEAKER_01Although I guess that leads a more controversial question for you, Sam, which is, is there a world in which we see some Queen of Versailles nominations?
SPEAKER_00I do think it's getting nominated for things. Talk to me.
SPEAKER_01Call me, baby. Listen, I know all the girlies love to hate on this show, and it's the cool thing to do.
SPEAKER_00And it for sure was not my favorite show. However, it's going to pull in nominations. We have, like, if you want to talk set design, I think it's definitely getting into there. It's Dane Laffery. It is... a season that doesn't have a lot of big sets that we're just like, we're talking about two straight, like if two strangers got in, you know, if that came in last season, I don't know that it would, it might be on the bubble or not get a scenic design nomination, but there's not a lot this season that are like these big,
SPEAKER_00big, you know productions um so i do think queen of versailles gets in for set it has a lot of costumes it has a lot of ornate costumes you know in those marie antoinette sequences um so it could certainly get in there um and also best score i do think i think it's getting into best score we don't have that many eligible shows Because we don't know, maybe Schmigadoon will be able to get into that, maybe not.
SPEAKER_00But if they're not, we only have Two Strangers, Lost Boys, and Beaches as the musicals other than Queen of Versailles with score. So I feel like they're going to put Stephen Schwartz in for at least having some melodic, you know, Champagne Wishes and Caviar Dreams is at least catchy.
SPEAKER_01I enjoy that song quite a lot.
SPEAKER_00I know you do. It's the only song in the show that I like from start to finish, to be fair.
SPEAKER_01Make sure you tell your husband that. Sam's husband has fully yelled at me in public because I had the audacity to say that I didn't think Queen of Versailles was the worst thing of all time.
SPEAKER_00He was not a fan. They're not going to put in two strangers and four plays into... There's going to have to be at least one of them because there's not enough new musicals to fill out the category. So I do think Death of a Salesman probably gets in for score. I think it has a really beautiful, particularly at the beginning and the end of the piece to set the tone and bring you into the world they're creating. And maybe Proof will get in as well, depending. But I think I have Queen of Versailles in like third or fourth
place for a score.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Wouldn't it be lovely if Marjorie Prime got in there as well? I remember Marjorie Prime's music being so lovely.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the tough thing with score for plays is there's not a cast recording to listen to. It's a closed show, and so it's hard to remember all of the moments that you might have liked while you saw it so many months later. So I don't know if... I would love Marjorie Prem to get in, but I'm not predicting that to get in.
SPEAKER_01I would love to see Peter Pan with you, Sam, because I imagine in the second act when Tinkerbell is dying and Peter Pan says to all the children, clap your hands and Tinkerbell will live. Kids are clapping their hands. You just turn to the kids and go, that's not going to do it. That fairy's dead.
SPEAKER_00I am not a monster. I'm just telling you about... Marjorie Prime is one of my top shows this season. Okay, girl. I'm just talking.
SPEAKER_01I am an innocent young boy untouched by this world.
SPEAKER_00You're not innocent in the least, but that's cute.
SPEAKER_01I'm innocent. I am an ingenue. And all I want is something to believe in in this world. And if maybe that is a Marjorie Prime Best Score nomination, Sam, I need you to let me have this because when I do eventually get devastated by that not happening, you will be able to say I told you so. But right now you can just look at me and go whatever it takes to get you out of bed in the morning, sweetie. I didn't hear anything you said after Ingenue because you're not an Ingenue anymore.
SPEAKER_00You're a dame.
SPEAKER_01You come on to my show. You come over my face.
SPEAKER_00You invited me. I don't know. I did invite you. So what does it say to me?
SPEAKER_01I asked for this.
SPEAKER_00No, I'm just, I'm not being a monster. I'm not being mean. I'm just saying in the world of awards predictions, you sometimes, aka always, have to kill your darlings. Things I like don't get in all the time. And I'm just, you know, it's the figuring out how... a voter's mind is going to work and i you're right you're right i was just it's going to be tough for them dreaming big for a second a la marty supreme but look how that turned out for marty you know well the ballet dancers
took him out they sure did i i think it was an ariana grande campaign i think she said if my movie can't get nominated for anything then his movie's not going to win for anything and
SPEAKER_01that's
SPEAKER_00I don't think it needed any help from any other campaigns. I think they did it all themselves.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, this is true. This is true.
SPEAKER_00So I'm trying to think of some other categories. Oh, I guess leading actress in a musical. She's weird. Let's talk about her for a second. Yeah. She's here. She's weird. Get used to her. I think... Beauty and she's grace. We're going to finally have Mother from Ragtime win a Tony. And we're not talking about wins yet, but I do think... I think she's out front. And I think if anyone can take it away, it would be Marla Mendel for Titanic.
SPEAKER_01So Titanic opens in a week. or a little less than weak the world will turn upside down after this episode comes out and we will have a very different opinion or maybe the same exact opinions we always had regarding marla and titanic i said this a while ago if they are able to make it work in that theater i think they have a good shot at a couple of things because the show itself for me has always worked in this fascinatingly stupid way that a lot of people are able to really appreciate especially
because stupidity is so hard to do well and and you know when it's being done well you you're able to taste the coffee as opposed to the senka and marla is such the face of that show both as the lead actress as a co-book writer co-conceiver of the whole thing and it is sort of this um massive achievement on her end now granted i don't know the last time a leading actress in a musical won for such a boldly
SPEAKER_01comedic performance outside of maybe Hello Dolly, but let's not pretend that Marla and Bette Midler are the same people in the same plane of buzz with their shows. Usually there's a little bit of tears involved, a little bit of power ballads in Act 2 involved, which...
SPEAKER_00Tears of Hello Dolly.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Listen, I think if Bette didn't have that Horace Let Me Go monologue at the end of Act One, Tony voters would have said, absolutely not. Give Patty a third Tony now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's the heart. Yeah, you need a little bit of that. Yeah. And there's no moment in Titanic when Selene looks out to the audience and she
SPEAKER_01goes, it was a very cold day. And I remember the screams, such screams, and the survivor's guilt that I do have. No, no moment like that in Titanic. In fact, she, spoiler alert, she saves everybody. That's... And he gets away with what it gets away with. I started to sing very well. But, you know, Mother has a much more emotional journey. And I also just really enjoy Casey. I think she's such a talented actress.
SPEAKER_01I don't always feel like Broadway applies her correctly. They because she's a good actress and because she's a good singer. I think a lot of times probably go, oh, so we can put you in anything then. It's like, well, she'll do her best to make it work. But like you want to put her in things that are right for her. And I think Mother in Ragtime is probably the closest we've had on Broadway for her since like hair off Broadway since Murder Ballad. But that's a that's a deep cut. I'm waiting.
SPEAKER_01I just I'm waiting for that Tony to happen. And then the next day, the British producers of Next to Normal announced that transfer because for sure, they're not going to announce it before the votes, because like if she were to they were to announce it before the votes, everyone would be like, well, we can give it to her for that next year.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but that never works. That always backfires. And whether it's theater or film, that is a terrible award strategy because people always go, we'll give it to him next time. And then something happens next time and they don't get it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then you're Glenn Close and you're 92 years old without an Oscar in your hand. Right. And you look back and you go, should we have done it then? Should we have given it to her for the big chill?
SPEAKER_00Or anything? I guess. She lost Fatal Attraction to Cher?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Fatal Attraction to Cher. Dangerous Liaisons was to Jodie Foster. They could have given it to her for that.
SPEAKER_00For sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, especially since Jodie was going to win again three years later.
SPEAKER_00For the better, well, I mean, my more favorite performance from Jodie.
SPEAKER_01That's neither here nor there. That's also not a hot take. I think even Jodie Foster would be like, yes, Silence of the Lambs, baby. Jodie Foster's like, I can't play pinball machines anymore because of the accused Silence of the Lambs all the way. Okay, yeah, so we have Casey. I mean, she's out front for sure. I do think Marla is in there. I would argue Christiana Pitts probably for two strangers. Ia most likely for Chess. And then number five is tricky for me.
SPEAKER_01Because... people enjoy the Vosk, how much they will want to get her in there for beaches is remains to be seen. Uh, of course we do have actresses getting in for shows of lesser caliber because we like them. Hello, Donna Murphy and the people in the picture. Uh, I don't Carmelo in scandalous, which I fucking saw on opening night. I, I have, I have earned the right to be gay and snippy. Okay. Okay. I was there.
SPEAKER_01But like Sarah Chase and Schmigadoon, she and Alex Brightman are technically considered the leads, but in a show like that where they don't sing for so long, it's hard to know if you really can... yeah i tentatively have sarah chase in there like sight unseen i haven't seen it but just knowing the structure of that show and that world it makes me hesitant because she's not playing like everyone around her is going to be so much bigger and more comedic and scene chewy more likely than she is uh so
that could work
SPEAKER_00against her ultimately i'm also not sure what what the fuck's going on with shashana being in lost boys because you ask any person on any day and they'll tell you a different answer of where she should go i've i think she's going featured okay godspeed that but things could change they haven't you know made those decisions yet but like that the most i think she's going featured yeah do we
SPEAKER_01It's bringing the Versailles fit back into it all. Do we think Kristen is completely out of a nomination?
SPEAKER_00I don't think she's completely out. I mean, she gets like the number that normally would get someone a nomination in this category with that final moment. Even the critics who really hated this show and wrote really negative reviews of Queen of Versailles had nothing but like unadulterated praise for her specifically in that final number where she just gets to, you know, she's on stage alone and People tried to call it like her Rose's turn.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if the song is quite as good as Rose's turn, but it's that type of emotional moment where she gets to like, you know.
SPEAKER_01You're really saying the bold claims today, Sam. You're saying that this time next year from Queen of Versailles may not be as good as Rose's turn from Gypsy.
SPEAKER_00It might not be. It's open for debate, but it might not be. All opinions are valid.
SPEAKER_01All opinions are valid. My third and final time seeing the show was what was supposed to be Sherry Renee Scott's final performance. She ended up going on a few more times later that week. But it was supposed to be her final performance. I think every homosexual who could get into that theater was in that theater. And she shouts, I will never stop building this house right before that song begins. And a gay in the audience started whistling Rose's turn. And 200 of us all just went. you just heard i can't do it right now with i don't whistle as well but it was that
and i was in the orchestra with like andy mantis and michael arden and uh i feel like uh was jack wolf at that performance jack wolf might have been at the other one but just like all these all these broadway gays in the in the center orchestra you could feel all of us just tense up and slightly turn to the left like where
SPEAKER_01that whistling was coming from we're like who the fuck are you It's like we all know it's that it's applicable. Like the show has six minutes left and it's Sherry like shut your fucking mouth.
SPEAKER_00Some people are the unprofessionalism far too much.
SPEAKER_01Too much. Thank you. Some people don't deserve gay rights, Sam. And that includes that whistler over there. But no, like it is it is. I think with her in that role, it is such a mammoth role. and i will give her credit for doing something that is ultimately out of her wheelhouse i think that's always something to be appreciated with a performer of her level of having been known for doing something so well for so long and still with her level of success choosing a character so different
from the things she's done how successfully you find her at that is up to you especially if you then also
SPEAKER_01saw sherry and you you have the ability to compare the two um I know you didn't see Sherry, but...
SPEAKER_00I think most Tony nominees probably also didn't see Sherry.
SPEAKER_01No, I don't think they did. But the thing with Queen of Versailles that was so weird was towards the end of that run, because Sherry went on like four or five times. It sort of, it weirdly helps the reputation of the show a little bit, but worsened the reputation of Kristen. Because everyone's like, huh, with Sherry, you kind of go, maybe there is a show here somewhere. And that's not what you want to hear if you're a Kristen Chenoweth.
SPEAKER_00Well... I think she's not totally out of the running. No, I don't think so either, but I wanted to make sure I wasn't just being stupid about that. No, I think, you know, if you were going to like draw a diagram of what a typical lead actress in a musical nominee looks like, of like what that role has to contain, then I think Kristen fits that mold perfectly and she's like Broadway royalty I think it depends on how willing they are to overlook maybe their dislike of the
show itself and if they moved on from like Instagram comments that they didn't agree with too and if
SPEAKER_00that affected them at all
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I also wonder what the narrative is on that backlash now that we're about five or six months past it. If people have a different view of what of how it was handled. Yeah. And I asked that with absolutely no baggage attached. I just I don't know. I feel like whenever it comes to this kind of backlash, there's always sort of a retrospective where people go, huh. Did we maybe go too harsh or were we not harsh enough?
SPEAKER_01Stuff like that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it's also a thing that's really, for the Tonys specifically, in the nomination phase, it's almost impossible to figure out, you know, to gauge what that reaction is because you're not just asking... the industry at large. Like when it comes to the voters, you're asking the like 50 to 60 nominators, which is why sometimes you have these choices that are very singular in the Tony nominations and they go against the grain.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes it just depends on the makeup of the people in it. All you need is really a handful of them to be like, I don't care about any outside controversy. Um, And so I'm just voting on performance alone. And then Kristen gets in.
SPEAKER_01I mean, hello, Nicole Scherzinger last year, right? Just voters didn't care.
SPEAKER_00William Ivey Long.
SPEAKER_01William Ivey Long.
SPEAKER_00It's just... The one nomination for Diana. They didn't care.
SPEAKER_01They did not care. And... is it the only nomination that show deserved who's to say i i feel like that show deserves nothing and the world at the same time i adore it deserves its own new
SPEAKER_00special category best most unforgettable theatrical extravaganza We will all be talking about you for a long time award.
SPEAKER_01I just think you can call it Best Most, Diana. Yes, Best Most. Best Most, Diana.
SPEAKER_00The winner of Best Most is...
SPEAKER_01Okay, that's going to be... Davy Jones is the most.
SPEAKER_00Is that Marsha Brady that he just quoted? What else would it be? Come on. Okay, I'll go first because I'm the prettiest.
SPEAKER_01I've never heard of a George Glass at our school. But that's actually going to be my new Tony category that doesn't exist. Best most. And it can be applied to anything. Former designer or musical or play in and of itself.
SPEAKER_00I want credit. I'm taking 10%. 10% of nothing is still nothing.
SPEAKER_01Well, the moment it becomes merchandise, you'll get 10% for sure.
SPEAKER_00Great. Thank you. I'll make a hat as soon as we're done. Oh, look, you made a hat. Did we talk about best actors in the play?
SPEAKER_01I don't think we did.
SPEAKER_00We didn't. I don't think.
SPEAKER_01Who do you currently have in your in your running?
SPEAKER_00Right now, my lineup subject to change is Leslie Manville, Carrie Coon, Susanna Flood, Iowa Etabiri, or I always say her name wrong. I apologize. And Rose Byrne.
SPEAKER_01OK. Oh, so what is this scoop on Fallen Angels? What what have we been hearing?
SPEAKER_00This? Well, the scoop is that there hasn't been much buzz because for some reason they've done, like, no advertising for the show. So it's flown under the radar despite having Rose Byrne and Kelly O'Hara out front.
SPEAKER_01No advertising? What is this, a Scott Rudin production?
SPEAKER_00But I've heard from the few people I know who've seen previews, they said it is like a very funny, tight 90 minutes, and it's a riot. Amazing. I didn't get much more than that, but I'll find out next week. But I'm just thinking Rose Byrne is... You know, still riding high on her Oscar nomination. She's in kind of a sweet spot right now. And maybe she takes the last category or the last slot of the category, rather. But there's a lot of other, you know, it could be a Kelly O'Hara instead.
SPEAKER_00It could be Laurie Metcalf for A Little Barrage Road.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm. That absolutely could happen. I mean, especially if Little Bear Ridge Road does get in for play and nominators are looking for one place to get it in there as well. That could be a good Laurie situation, especially since I don't think that the nomination for her and lead actress for Little Bear Ridge Road will take away from people wanting to vote for her for Salesman and Featured.
SPEAKER_00No. Yeah, not at all. I just know that there are people who before salesmen even started performances,
SPEAKER_01there was the question of like, well, the double nomination hurt her. Has anyone ever won being nominated twice in the same year, which I don't think anyone actually ever has. People have been nominated. I don't know if anyone's ever won.
SPEAKER_00There's like six or seven people who have pulled off a double nomination.
SPEAKER_01Jeremy Pope, I know, did for Choir Boy. Jan Maxwell. Jan Maxwell, yeah. uh jan maxwell that was the year of the royal family i think she was and follies and follies uh i can't think of everyone else right now but yeah it's it's limited and i don't think and i'll look at this up later and maybe someone's yelling at us right now through their earphones i should know this because i wrote an article about it but it's escaping me and i think there is one person who won way back when
SPEAKER_00but Yell at us all you want, folks. Well, because I'm also thinking. I'm not an encyclopedia.
SPEAKER_01None of us are. I'm also thinking about double nominations at the Oscars, which is also rare. But I do know Jessica Lange pulled it off. She won for Tootsie when she was nominated for that and Frances. And that was a case where, you know, great as she was in Frances, it was sort of no one was beating Meryl Streep for Sophie's Choice. And with Laurie and Little Bear Ridge Road, it's like great as she was. It's like, can she beat? leslie manville and and eat a piss can she be carrie coon for bug or io for proof maybe not so she wins for salesman or maybe she doesn't win for
salesman feature i can't stress this enough i've heard like 20 different people mentioned in my dms and whatever of just like watch out for this person for a featured actress in a
SPEAKER_01play i'm like there are only five slots
SPEAKER_00Every time, well, I mean, every time I've seen a play this season, I'm like, well, they're totally the front runner for featured actress in a play. But now I have like 15 people that fit that bill. So.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, already just with what I've seen, and again, I'm seeing Ballisters and Becky Shaw in the next couple of days. I have to see Proof. I have to see Fallen Angels. We haven't even spoken about Joe Turner's come and gone, which I think also that one is just sort of the lack of buzz on that, positive or negative, I feel like is... detrimental to its chances but also who knows but i'm already thinking in my head of what i've seen i would nominate in featured actress lori for salesman and betsy item for liberation and june and cynthia for uh marjorie prime
and it's like well fuck then who's five i saw dog day afternoon and i enjoyed jessica hecht but like i can then put in jessica hecht and say sorry fucking carrie young for proof sorry
SPEAKER_01everyone in becky sean balusters shit out of luck And also Tracy Chimo in Fallen Angels. Yeah, I hear she's good. So... TBD. TB fucking D. I think it's safe to say that Waiting for Godot is still waiting. Although I could see a sound design nomination for them. Jamie Lloyd tends to get those. Yeah, I think, you know, it could even get scenic design if they really want to.
SPEAKER_00It was like one set, but a very evocative image. So...
SPEAKER_01You can get nominated for set design for play if it's only the one set. But I do hear Fallen Angels has a very decadent, art deco-y set. I don't know what this set is like for Joe Turner, but that's an option to have some really lovely design. I really liked the design for Oedipus. Obviously, it's not beautiful. It's an office, but it's so... It somehow is able to evoke tension without actually being a tense place. And the intricacies of all the different rooms and all that I
just thought was so well done.
SPEAKER_01I don't imagine Giant will get a nomination for set. The set does what it's supposed to do, but it doesn't pull you over color-wise, nor is it this intricately...
SPEAKER_00Well, I just feel like they didn't finish that house, you know?
SPEAKER_01You just kept waiting for the house to get finished.
SPEAKER_00It just seemed like they didn't finish. It was still under construction.
SPEAKER_01That's what Queen of Versailles did to you, Sam, is that it made you really think that by the end of the show, that wing would be done. I didn't hear Roald Dahl say, I'm never going to stop building this house. No, he said a lot of things about Jews. That's what he did.
SPEAKER_00He sure did.
SPEAKER_01Alas, alack. Alas, alack. Yeah, he is, um, he's not exactly a BFG now, is he?
SPEAKER_00No, he's not, Matt. That was a good one.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00It's more of a witch. I'll stop.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, he's more of a twit. He's not so fantastic, that Mr. Fox. But so I guess as we're closing up shop, because Sam's got to go in a few minutes, as do I.
SPEAKER_00What are some. What are things you're looking out for between now and beginning of May when
SPEAKER_01nominations come out? Are there any shows in particular that you kind of have your eye out for to see where the wind might blow with them?
SPEAKER_00Many. I guess Joe Turner's Come and Gone is a great play. This revival doesn't have a lot of buzz right now, so that's something I don't have a grasp on. But it does have two really great Tony Beatty featured roles in it, which are played by Ruben Santiago Hudson and and Joshua Boone. So I'm very interested to see if one or both of them become major threats for the featured actor race.
SPEAKER_00I think that's the one I'm most... Ifeon. And Proof could also be something where... I haven't seen that one yet. Hopefully we'll soon. But that's a thing where it's like, is that going to be a major player in this crowded revival race? Or is it one that's just going to be edged out because it's so competitive? The original production obviously did exceptionally well with the Tonys. So we'll see if this one is able to match it or not in such a competitive year.
SPEAKER_01Joe Turner also... is such an it's a beautiful play it's also such an odd play same thing with piano lesson and i think a lot of people who are only familiar with the lore of august wilson but don't actually know august wilson see plays like piano lesson and joe turner's coming on and they expect a super grounded fences situation yeah yeah they like they come in expecting fences and then it's all this stuff about ghosts and history and and trauma literally literalized on stage through theatricality and they go what and
that's what makes what makes them so much fun to fuck around with but also makes it a high risk high reward gamble for any production that you do so we'll see yeah
SPEAKER_00those ones i prefer bring on the ghosts Yeah, Follies should be on stage every other season as far as I'm concerned.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, no, I think that's absolutely fair. I am still... I still got my eye out on Schmigadoon and Titanic. I just sort of... I'm looking at them going... Are you going to be able to pull it off? If you can pull it off, you're going to really help make this spring more exciting. And people want it to be. So if they can, I think there's going to be a lot of joy for that. And yet, Jellicle Ball opens officially the day after we record this, but before the episode comes out. So everyone will already know what the reviews are like.
SPEAKER_01I'm expecting positives, but you never know. I don't remember what Helen Shaw said when she was the critic at The New Yorker. So, TBD. i think it will get raves but speaking of musicals i mean the lost boys is also the biggest question mark i think yeah because it didn't have any like out of town preview to go on it is a supposedly this really massive production with a lot of effects and that is i feel like that's like the one
fully original score that's going up against Two Strangers and Best Musical.
SPEAKER_00So it's kind of like, you know, the last day of eligibility. It's going to open and people will be like, does this one have what it takes to be the new front runner or not? Are we just going to revert back to where we were? Yeah, I mean, never underestimate the power of a Twink musical, is all I'll say. Forget Demon Twinks. This one is Vampire Twink. It's a whole new book. breed of twink so we don't know what we're up against here oh no a whole new breed of twink hide your kids hide your wife i'm putting that on a
hat too whole new bread of twink yeah oh no so on that note fam this has been delightful where can
SPEAKER_01people find you if you would like them to find you
SPEAKER_00You can find me on Instagram at Sam Ekman, and you can read and watch all the things I'm creating at goldderby.com.
SPEAKER_01Love it. If you want to follow me, I'm on Instagram only at Matt Koplek, usual spelling. You can subscribe to the sub stack. You can become a member of the Discord. All will be linked in the episode bio. You can give us a nice five-star rating or review. Always helps the algorithm. them if you haven't bought your tickets yet buy your tickets for either may 3rd broadway breakdown at green room 42 reviewing the 2025 2026 season or buy your tickets for june 1st the slightly early tony awards show uh there'll be a good time both i promise you and yes we do indeed have the sheet music
for caviar dreams for
SPEAKER_01the may 3rd show we will be singing it So yeah, I can't speak anymore on that. Other than also a bunch of whole new original lyrics being applied to all the musical revivals this season. Wind Beneath My Wings will be sung, but not in regards to beaches, in regards to something else. Sam, what diva do you want to close this out with today?
SPEAKER_00Oh, I always forget about your diva question. And then I have to make it on the... Because I make you do it once a year.
SPEAKER_01I know.
SPEAKER_00You make me work all the time. Because I was just watching Susie Toot's version, recreation of Liza with a Z on repeat, I'm going to go for some Liza.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Do you want specifically something from Liza with a Z or just Liza?
SPEAKER_00Anything your heart desires from Liza.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, thank you so much, Sam. We will see you guys next week. Take it away, Liza. Bye.
SPEAKER_03It's such a happy thing to hear them tingling. You gotta swing them. Ring them. Swing them. Ring them.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...