Few films blur the line between autobiography and spectacle quite like All That Jazz. In this Deep Dive, Matt is joined by Podmother Ali Gordon to unpack this fever dream of a film that acts as both a harsh backstage look of the world of Broadway and an ever harsher self-portrait of director Bob Fosse. Together, Matt and Ali explore how the movie captures the obsession, ego, and cost of making art, and why it remains one of the most daring - and unsettling - works in the musical theater canon. Important LinksBroadway Breakdown at Green Room 42: Link for Tix Broadway Breakdown: Discord Broadway Breakdown: Substack Ali Gordon is a writer, comic, and Breakdown fan favorite. Known for her sharp analysis and deep appreciation for the intersection of film and stage, Ali brings both intellectual rigor and playful curiosity to a piece as dense, messy, and brilliant as All That Jazz. Timestamps 00:00 - Why All That Jazz still feels dangerous04:30 - Bob Fosse: myth vs. man10:15 - Plot overview: Joe Gideon as Fosse surrogate18:40 - Editing, structure, and breaking narrative rules26:00 - Choreography on film vs. stage34:10 - Performance analysis: Roy Scheider and Ann Reinking parallels42:20 - The “Bye Bye Life” sequence and theatrical death50:00 - Addiction, ego, and the cost of genius58:30 - Awards, reception, and industry impact1:05:10 - Why the film still divides audiences1:12:00 - Legacy: can something like this be made today? Listener discussion questions * Is All That Jazz a celebration of artistic genius - or a warning about it? * How does the film change your perception of Bob Fosse as an artist? * Could a film this stylized and self-critical succeed in today’s industry? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01We're warming up so we're
SPEAKER_03Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL. And welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. This series is called Matt's Picks, and it is covering shows that I did not pick out of Sally Bull, but I wanted to cover anyway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And guess who's back in the house? Guess who's back in the house?
SPEAKER_00Back in the house. Shoes click clacking about. Thank you. Heels click clacking about. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03I didn't remember the next lyric, but I needed you to.
SPEAKER_00Fine, fresh, feminine, you know, and so on and so forth.
SPEAKER_03Anyway, it's pod mother Allie Gordon.
SPEAKER_00Hello, Allie. Hello. I like that the unt of your thing has gotten more and more. It's sort of like late in the run and you're having fun with the character choices now. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03One thousand percent.
SPEAKER_00Like and you were already having fun. Like it's like Annalie Ashford where it was like, you didn't need to get bigger. But it has, I suppose. I guess those choices have gotten longer and bigger.
SPEAKER_03I don't. We're not in a relationship. I don't know why you feel the need to neg me. But OK, pop off, sis.
SPEAKER_00I do kind of need a little.
SPEAKER_03You need what? To nag me a little?
SPEAKER_00Just like a little, little bit.
SPEAKER_03Because my my self-esteem is just so confident that.
SPEAKER_00No, because we have like a sexy, a sexy will they won't they.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that is true. We really do.
SPEAKER_00Do you know what I'm saying? Like, I'm assuming that people aren't tuning in to hear what we have to say, but to imagine what we might be doing when cameras go down.
SPEAKER_03This is very true. You and I have discussed once or twice in our very, very distant youths of like the alternate universe where I am straight and we are together and like the madness that that would be.
SPEAKER_00It would not be good. I think it would sort of be like Bob Fosse and Quinn Ferdinand.
SPEAKER_03Kind of a little bit.
SPEAKER_00Except that neither of us are dancers.
SPEAKER_03Well, there's photographic proof of you doing a ballet.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I mean, that's not, I mean, that is true.
SPEAKER_03But Alessandra Gordon, we are beating around the bush, so to speak, because what are we here to discuss for the foreseeable future?
SPEAKER_00We're here to discuss a movie with lots of boob, but no bush at all.
SPEAKER_03That's true. Everyone, for a 70s movie, everyone is pretty razored.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And nothing below the belt. Nobody. Nobody. Well, there's butt.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there's a lot of butt. But also even like the men, it's hairy chests and like a little bit of the back of the neck.
SPEAKER_00But like nothing below the belt. Nothing below the belt, really. We're here to talk about one of my favorite movies of all time. So again, I don't know how I keep guys sort of lucking out until like talking about these things I really love on your podcast. So thanks. But we're talking about All That Jazz, which is an amazing movie.
SPEAKER_03It is. I mean, it's because I like you and I like talking about things we love together. I am waiting for the thing you and I both dislike or one of us dislikes to have a kind of combative episode. Because also it's the things that you've loved that you've come on for also are things that I've loved. So we haven't discussed anything.
SPEAKER_00Right. Even things that are like a little like. Not contentious, I suppose, but just like not like easy wins. Like it's so like for me to be like, well, I think the best musical of all time is Sweeney Todd. It's very easy for you to be like, great choice. Yeah. Like you don't have to share that opinion.
SPEAKER_02You have a lot of evidence to back that up.
SPEAKER_00Correct. But then even when I come on and I'm like, I love Kiss of the Spider-Man. I know it's not perfect, but I think it's like a great show with like a lot of merit and like a lot of heart. And it really impacts me. And you're like, yeah, sure. I agree with that. Like, you know what I mean? Even the things are. Well, OK, so actually I have a question that this movie made me think about.
SPEAKER_02Go for it.
SPEAKER_00Do you know how much I love Pippin?
SPEAKER_03I mean... I love Pippin. Sorry, that's a very loaded question for me, for you, because you're asking me, in the last 20 years of our friendship, have we discussed your love of this show? The short answer is most likely. The longer answer is I can't remember, but I am sure we have talked about it.
SPEAKER_00Sure. I was just going to say, I wonder... When I'm thinking about shows that I'm like, wow, that show is, like, everything to me. But I don't know if everybody feels that way. Like, I was thinking about that last time when we were watching the movie. And I was like, goddammit, I love Pippin. I would give anything to go see a great production of Pippin right now. I don't know if you share that. Maybe we can fight about that later.
SPEAKER_03No, I felt as a teen that I... Maybe we never discussed it because as teens, we talked about our mutual love of Amadeus and Angels in America and we felt very alone in that as teenagers of the odds.
SPEAKER_00And we were correct to be ostracized for those opinions as teenagers.
SPEAKER_03At that age, yes. But I also I just always stuck to my guns that I always thought that Pippin was actually a great musical. Yeah, I think it's amazing. That just often never gets done well because, you know, it tends to be high schools or regional theaters that like think it's just an easy ticket seller, which it is. Right. Gore is so much fun. But I always say like that book, the book is not flimsy. The book is very much a concept book a la Follies or Company. But there are lines in that show that get a laugh no matter who says it.
SPEAKER_00I agree with that. And I think it is another great addition to the anti-hero musical because with
SPEAKER_03Pippin, he sucks.
SPEAKER_00He sucks. He really sucks.
SPEAKER_03And the show knows that he sucks.
SPEAKER_00The show has a whole song about how he kind of sucks.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And I think he's actually one of the hardest roles in musical theater. And I think my issue with... how Pippin tends to be done, and this is also a Fosse thing, and I sort of felt this way about the revival, is yes, it would be lovely to have a very hot, beautiful young man play Pippin who looks great with his shirt off. I think that there's something to an everyman playing Pippin who's also genuinely an actor who can make you not necessarily root for him, but want to keep watching him fail.
SPEAKER_03And then that break, that watershed moment he has at the end, that breakthrough of like, oh, I'm not special. I just need to, I don't need to like change the world. I just need to be of the world.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Very nice way to put that.
SPEAKER_03Thank you. It's almost like I do this from time to time.
SPEAKER_00From time to time to time. But you know what? I just, you, I say this every time I'm on the podcast because I think I sometimes take for granted that how great you've gotten at, like, putting complicated thoughts into easily understandable and digestible... statements. I don't know what the word is I'm looking for here. You're complimenting me about my statements by making a terrible statement.
SPEAKER_03I understand.
SPEAKER_00Correct. Yeah. I mean, like, what am I, a writer? Shut up.
SPEAKER_03You have a book for something, my God.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Don't fucking look that up. I just feel like you've always been very smart and you've always had great opinions or at the very least, very defined opinions. Yeah. Like, like, do I mean, like you are not somebody who's easily swayed. You're like, this is my opinion. And I have it. You've just gotten so good at just like putting it into words in like a way that a person could like a good lyric. You could listen to it once and understand it. You know what I mean? Like, you don't have to really like dig deep into parsing what you're trying to say. Thank you. You're like, I get it. I understand. So that was a really nice way to say that.
SPEAKER_03I mean, you don't help much when you're on the podcast.
SPEAKER_00No, I don't help at all. You're actually to distract. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you distract me with your ginormous titties. Yeah. And your eloquence is that of a brain-dead cactus. Thank you. But I keep you on anyway because I just love you too.
SPEAKER_00Cactuses can often be quite tall.
SPEAKER_03Well, you are, I find you a very lanky gal.
SPEAKER_00That's so untrue that I, I mean, like, I love you for saying that. I have a short torso, short arms, short legs.
SPEAKER_03Let me be clear. You're not a kid, though. You're not six feet tall. But I don't know, I always found you proportionally, like, lanky and limber.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. I mean, like, but then you see Anne Ranking and... All that jazz, but those legs that go forever. And you're like, well, you look at Anne Ranking and all that jazz and you want to kill yourself.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. Yeah. But you love Pippin. Speaking of Anne Ranking, who was in Pippin.
SPEAKER_00Who was in Pippin. And also Leland Palmer, who famously was in Pippin. Sure.
SPEAKER_03She sure was. There's a lot more Pippin overlap in this movie than I think people realize. And we'll get to what those details are in a second. You were talking about Pippin and all that jazz.
SPEAKER_00Honestly, I was just saying I wonder if that's one of those musicals that we wouldn't share that opinion on just because like I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I think it's in, like, my top five favorite musicals of all time. Like, I love Pippin so much. It's only top five. I only like it more and more as I get older. I think my opinion on how to cast Pippin, for me, stems from my days as wanting to be an actor. You know when you're an actor and you're watching stuff, you're like, what part can I play? Or, like, what parts should I be playing, but no one will be brave enough to cast me?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03That is how I envisioned myself playing Pippin was like, oh, I'm not John Rubenstein circa 1972. I'm more of an everyman. So like I that was I was like, if someone was brave enough to let like a little old twiggy gay me do it, I think that would be really nice. I think you could also, if somebody was brave enough, really kill it as Pastrata. Oh, my God. So that is that is my.
SPEAKER_00Someone was brave enough.
SPEAKER_03If someone was brave enough. My God. Yeah. Let me play fucking Fistrata. I think you'd be really good. I'd kill it as Fistrata.
SPEAKER_00I really think you would. I would need to get back into dancery shape because I am also not a dancer. But there was a time when we were teens where I was pursuing more dance than I have since then.
SPEAKER_03So I need to do more of that again. But did you see I'm going to say one insane thing that's not actually off tangent.
SPEAKER_00Did you see Bad Cinderella?
SPEAKER_03Yes, I saw Bad Cinderella.
SPEAKER_00Okay, thank God. Bad Cinderella, that whole subplot with her wanting to fuck her stepson or whatever, that couldn't have flown. Pippin walked so that Bad Cinderella could soar.
SPEAKER_03Same theater, too, by the way. Oh, my God. It all ties together.
SPEAKER_00It's all connected.
SPEAKER_03It's all connected. See, that's why I talk to you, so that you can put these things into perspective.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03For someone as pretty as I am and as charming as I am, it's important to remember that I have the most stupid brain and that this is just what I bring to the table. This is when I'm single. I meet beautiful boys and, sorry, men, beautiful men.
SPEAKER_00They are all of age. Men, beautiful men.
SPEAKER_03We go get a drink and they look at me and they go, how can you be single? And I go, well, did you know that Bat Cinderella and Pippin are in the same theater? And they go... uh-huh oh would you look at that i have i have to go yeah like did you know that idina menzel fell through the same trap door that len carrie you once rose out of his sweeney todd and they're like i have diarrhea i have to go home now did you know that that lisa minnelli went into chicago for five weeks because gwen verdant swallowed either a piece of confetti or a piece or a feather nobody knows nobody
SPEAKER_03knows different accounts well
SPEAKER_00Wait, I, okay. We got to start talking about all that jazz, but this is going to help. This is going to help.
SPEAKER_03I don't care anymore. Keep calling.
SPEAKER_00You sent some helpful links or things to read, watch, whatever, to sort of like a primer before this. I did not have to engage with it in a huge way because this is a movie I've seen probably like 50 times. So I was like, I got this. And I also, spoiler alert for later, saw it in a theater for the first time ever. Like I've seen it many times, but never in a theater. I saw it in a theater for the first time last night. So it's fresh. Right.
SPEAKER_03We're going to talk about that. I watched it last night again to refresh, but not in the theater.
SPEAKER_00But one of the only things I did not know that was in one of those little documentaries that you sent me was that that rising platform that they use in the Bye Bye Life sequence at the end is from the act. Oh, I didn't know that. Because they were running out of money. And the guy who was the scenic designer was like, well, I made this for Liza Minnelli for the act. And obviously they had a relationship from Liza with a Z. And they're like, can we use this thing from the act? And Liza was like, sure. And so that platform from the act, that felt like seeing a celeb.
SPEAKER_03I was like, oh, my God, the platform from the act. Platform from the act. I love your work. I really do love your work, the platform from the act. Designer Ali Gordon is Tony Walton, who won a Tony for Pippin, all connects. And more importantly, was the first Mr. Julie Andrews.
SPEAKER_00oh my God, you're so right. And what theater did that take place in? I'm just kidding. That's so, there you go. But yeah, anyway, so that was my sort of celeb sighting of the evening was being like, that's the platform from the act.
SPEAKER_03That is indeed the platform from the act. I did do a little extra reading this past week of the Bob Fosse bio again, because we're going to connect all this in addition to the movie as well as like the aftermath of this movie and then sort of where What works it has given us since then and sort of how I feel like this movie crystallized the Fosse legend and the Fosse reputation. And without this movie, I don't think we would have Fosse Verdon,
SPEAKER_03which is a mixed blessing for me.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I think a blessing simply in that. How do I phrase this one in a way that doesn't sound so stupid? I just like I like when people know that theater is complicated. Like, I think there is a large portion of people who are not theater lovers or fans who think of theater as being quite fluffy and sort of like, yeah, you write a show and you put a show up and like don't think of like complicated legacies and personalities and. Do you know what I mean? Like, which I'm sure that if they thought about it a little harder, they'd be like, well, Picasso was a complicated man. I'm sure there are Picassos in theater, too.
SPEAKER_00But like, I think they don't because they think of musical theater as being sort of like sunshine and rainbows or like kind of corny. And so I am happy for the Fosse burden of it all because I just like when people know that, like, Theater is a lot of things and theater can be sweet charity, but also theater can be Sweetie Todd, but also theater can be a womanizer genius. Do you know what I mean? Like, I don't know. Like, I am happy when people sort of cross into the public knowledge sphere. Put a pin in that because I have a lot to say about all of that regarding to Fosse.
SPEAKER_03But before we do any of that, we have a brief summary of the plot of All That Jazz as per the Criterion Collection. Cool. Is it preternaturally?
SPEAKER_00Preternaturally, yes.
SPEAKER_03Preternaturally. See, you're the smart one. The preternaturally gifted director and choreographer Bob Bossie turned to the camera on his own life for this madly imaginative, self-exhortiating,
SPEAKER_00Excoriating? Is that what I'm saying? Because that means like being really hard on yourself.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yes, yes, yes. Excoriating. Musical masterpiece. I really can be quite dumb sometimes. Roy, I knew what this word was. I just never had said it out loud in my life before. Yeah. Roy Scheider gives the performance of his career as Joe Gideon, whose exhausting work schedule mounting a Broadway production by day, editing his latest movie by night, and routine of amphetamines, booze, and sex are putting his health at serious risk. Fosse burrows into Gideon's and his own mind, rendering his interior world as a phantasmagoric spectacle assembled with visionary
editing that makes dance come alive on screen as never before and overflowing with
SPEAKER_03sublime footwork by the likes of Anne Reinking. Leland Palmer and Ben Vereen, all that jazz pushes the musical genre to personal depths and virtuosic aesthetic heights. I would say that is a pretty accurate thing. Yeah, I agree with all those points.
SPEAKER_00It's one of the... Dance has maybe never looked better on camera. Like, it is such an incredible capture of dance. From rehearsal room dance to audition dance to big, gorgeous fantasy musical numbers. Like, it captures dance in a way that, like... I think it's probably good for the history of dance for the next 400 years. Like, like, thank God someone got that dance on camera. Um, it's beautiful. It's so good. Um, and everybody's sweaty.
SPEAKER_00It's great. Honestly, like I say that with like love. Like, I think like it is an amazing to see, um, the effort that good dance takes when they do the erotica scene i do get very uncomfortable for the men in suits they're not because of the content but because everyone else is so sweaty i'm like oh god it must be stifling there hot in that room yeah and the guy going back and forth going smoke smoke smoke smoke smoke so it's hot and smoky in there yeah but do you remember when this movie came into your
SPEAKER_03life when it entered your chat
SPEAKER_00Yes, I actually do. I watched it for the first time my sophomore year of college, not even as part of a class, but because a friend of mine was like, have you ever seen all that jazz? And I was like, no. Actually, it was my friend Carlos. Carlos Valdez. Do you know Carlos? Have you met Carlos?
SPEAKER_03I have met Carlos, actually. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Carlos is the best. So Carlos was like, we should watch this movie. Wasn't Carlos at your wedding? Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Sorry. Maybe I should reiterate this. We know each other. Yeah, there you go. We have a history.
SPEAKER_00Cool, cool, cool. Great. But yes, so he was like, I just saw this movie. Maybe he watched it in a film class. I don't know. But he was like, this movie just fucking blew my mind. Let's have a movie night. Rented it from the library, took the DVD back. It was like, you know, four or five of us watching it in a living room on a college TV. So I'm sure it wasn't like the way Bob Fosse intended it to be watched, but whatever. Yeah. And I remember that final image hits and the song, which I feel like I don't know why I'm talking about it like there's spoilers. But it has such an impactful final moment.
SPEAKER_00We sat through the entirety of the credits in silence. Which for, let's say, five or six opinionated musical theater students is basically a miracle.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Can you imagine ever having five musical theater students having just watched a
SPEAKER_00musical sit in silence to think about it? To think for a second? I was about to say, the only time that happened to me in college, it wasn't a musical.
SPEAKER_03It was four of us in my apartment having just watched Schindler's List. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So we had a similar experience.
SPEAKER_03We did. I mean, in a lot of ways, Schindler's List is the ballet. There's a great deal of dance in that.
SPEAKER_00And Ethel Merman sings the final song.
SPEAKER_02She do. She says, he's got a list. It's Schindler's List.
SPEAKER_00Holy shit. Did Spielberg ever consider that? Getting the audience out. Tapping.
SPEAKER_03I think he regretted not making it a musical, and that's why he gave us the 2022 West Side Story.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. But yeah, anyway, so we watched the film and were stunned to silence. And I still feel that way. Like, I, like, last night, like, felt exhausted by the end of the movie. Just by having seen it so many times, I was still like, I can't believe it ends this way. It just hits you. It does. um so yeah i saw that and then immediately was like that's the best movie i've ever seen um and then spent years tracking it down because it's like
available nowhere then like maybe my senior year just out of college somebody told me what the criterion collection was and i was like great and so then i bought the dvd off the criterion collection and then have shown it to every other human i've ever met yeah you know what i mean anytime anybody comes into my life i'm always like have you seen all that jazz like yeah do you need to do you need to see this we should see
SPEAKER_00this
SPEAKER_03I'm not sure why it's so difficult to obtain online. When people were more into physical media, which apparently is making a comeback, I didn't know. Which I love that. In the same way our generation started buying vinyl records and playing them in earnest, Gen Z is buying DVDs and playing them in earnest.
SPEAKER_00As well they should. With all these mergers and everything. Sorry, not to be on a soapbox. But like with all of the the news currently about like all the mergers and the billionaires who can buy each other's companies and how people say they're in a deal, but it's all a lie and a facade. So this other person gets like if you like something and you think it's important to you, you should buy it in physical media immediately because you never know when those things could be gone forever. So just because some asshole idiot billionaire was like, what's all that jazz and just like wipes it. So go buy DVDs.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I feel like people are starting to remember all of a sudden that despite everything, this is a capitalist society. And if you want to make a statement, you make it with your money and you do it in person. You don't put a tweet out or a reel out and hope that it changes the world. It rarely does. You go and you buy the thing and you and you have the thing. So if it matters to you, if it's something that you feel is reflective of and taste something you'd want to show other people something you'd
want to revisit someday if you have even this tiniest inkling of like it would really bum me out if this disappeared from the internet forever you should go get it a bummer to say because we've been conditioned to think over the last decade of life that things will be online forever uh and things will in some ways but like other things won't and other people get to make those decisions you have no say on it so go buy all
SPEAKER_00that jazz
SPEAKER_03Yeah, go buy it. I cannot endorse that more. I think I've had my DVD of it for... 16 years now something like that because i discovered this movie i want to say in middle school it was playing oh my god yeah well you and i were well i mean yeah i'm saying that like we weren't reading angels in america when we were in high school i was gonna say like i don't know if we had similar upbringings in terms of like media censorship i feel like we kind of did it where my parents were that our parents were like you should watch anything you want i don't
really give a shit
SPEAKER_03kind of yeah yeah my parents were more sort of like When I was really little, when I was like eight or nine and I'd want to see something that was inappropriate, they would basically say, like, can you tell me what this is and why you want to see it? Because usually I couldn't. I was like, I want to see American Beauty. And they're like, you don't know what the fuck you're talking about. But then as I got older, you know, 12, 13, like, yeah, no, read, watch whatever you want. But, you know, don't make it a secret and we'll talk about it. Yes. And I feel like I was channel surfing with my dad one night
when I was like 13 and all that jazz was on Showtime and we watched it and I was obsessed with it because
SPEAKER_03even as a kid, the movie of Cabaret didn't totally grab me.
SPEAKER_00Totally. I have come to like the movie of Cabaret more as I get older. Didn't as much when I was like a young, hungry theater teen who was like, fear someone to watch Cabaret. Now I'm like, oh, I think this movie is incredible. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's a camera is objectively a great movie. I still don't fully love it. Not because I think it's bad. Just it's I get a little bit of an ice coldiness from it.
SPEAKER_00I feel the same. I think that was intentional, but I agree with you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. But I mean, it's ironic because that's sort of one of the things that Fosse was always sort of dinged for in his career was his remove and his distance and his cynicism and whatnot. And Cabaret is a piece that actually has a lot of messy heart to it. And so the movie, it does. The movie does have heart. I mean, the final scene with Liza before when she and Michael York kind of it's whatever right before she has the abortion. That's a very emotional scene. But still, I'll watch it and I'll go I'll appreciate it more than I fangirl over it.
SPEAKER_03But Cabaret really was a groundbreaking movie musical for its time. And so it's hard for, I think, a lot of theater fans to look at it for the first time now and not sort of see the watershed moment that it was.
SPEAKER_00I feel that way with all that jazz. I think because like the fantasy of it all has become so commonplace now and people when people are like, it's a musical, but don't worry, the music's just in their head. I think it's become like almost like a trope. But like, I don't think people realize like how much we wouldn't have like the great Chicago movie of the 2000s without all that jazz.
SPEAKER_03I agree, but I also think, I mean, all that jazz, even when it came out, it was not critically rapturously received. I think the only review I could find that was really like, no, this is a phenomenal film, was the New York Times of all... Papers, no less. But like most of the reviews, if they liked it, they sort of begrudgingly liked it. And if they were mixed negative on it, they were like, this is so derivative of Fellini. Who does Fosse think he is? Like, why should we care?
SPEAKER_00It's funny because it's like, have you seen it? I'm sorry. This is like an insane question. Like, have you seen eight and a half? Not nine, but eight and a half.
SPEAKER_03Yes, I have. It's an amazing movie, but I don't feel like it is similar at all to All That Jazz. I guess at the center it's about a guy and his women, but the styles are not at all the same. No, the conceit is the same of a thinly veiled autobiographical film about a director going through a challenging moment in their creativity and Looking back on their past and their present and their very unclear future.
SPEAKER_03So in that respect, like the log lines very much are the same. Sure. And I do think there is a bit of... I mean, you can't just say Italian cinema. You kind of have to say Fellini, because by 79, Fellini just was Italian cinema. So there is some of that aesthetic in the fantasy sequences, in Jessica Lange's aesthetic, in all of the stuff that's sort of in Joe's mind, like in all the backstage situations where he's talking with Lange, a.k.a. Angelique.
SPEAKER_03There's some of that and some of the makeup and hair, but the... The bulk of the movie in the real world is not Fellini at all.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_03Anything that's sort of like William Friedkin in that aesthetic.
SPEAKER_00I fully feel that. Thank you. And I fully agree. Also, I think it's hard not to with Roy Scheider being like, William Friedkin.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that was I didn't even make that connection.
SPEAKER_00But still, I actually still agree with you regardless. I think there's only one scene in all that jazz that oopsie, I just knocked my camera. I think there's only one scene in all that jazz that I think is really good that I think is like basically directly a Fellini ripoff, which is when they're doing the read through of the show and the show is bad and hokey. And it's just the sound effects of him like walking around the room and breaking the pencil and deep breathing. That's basically like the opening from eight and a half where he's like having the panic attack in the car.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's it, though. Like, to me, that is the only thing where I'm like, you probably saw that in that movie and were like, that's really effective. I'm going to use that. Everything else feels so inherently Bob Fosse to me.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. But there's I mean, there are other movies that did it as well that nobody cared about. They Mike Nichols does that same effect in The Graduate when Ben comes out in like the scuba suit of just sort of.
SPEAKER_00What year is The Graduate?
SPEAKER_03Graduate is 60.
SPEAKER_00Wow. That's earlier than I thought.
SPEAKER_0367, maybe. OK. Yeah. Yeah. Um, yeah, no, it's, and, and, and eight and a half, I think is 61, 60 or 61. Yeah. Um, but so like, I mean, with Fellini, Fellini broke the rules in so many ways and it was such style and such like effervescence in this. The thing about Fellini films and the same thing with Fosse is like, and there's, I think there's a reason why Fosse adapted a Fellini film to stage and turning it into Sweet Charity. They both had this sense of style that was amazing.
It's not that it was accidental, but like that wasn't what they cared about.
SPEAKER_03Aesthetic was not the thing that they were like, I need everyone.
SPEAKER_00Aesthetic is not king. Yes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. They were not like, I want everyone to look like a model. I want everyone to be picture perfect. They had a feeling and a melancholy and a messiness within them that. always translated to this really chic aesthetic. But people would just focus on the aesthetic and not what was going on inside. It's like the one thing in the movie version of Nine that they actually get right as Kate Hudson is like so obsessed with the aesthetic of Guido Contini's films. And he's basically like, I'm going through a mental crisis on every film and all you can pay attention to is
SPEAKER_00Nicole Kidman's makeup. Yeah. I also, okay, this is another thing that I just like, was something I was thinking about after seeing the film last night. Mm-hmm. Which is also because I was doing a little bit of research on, like, just, like, the public opinion and the jokes and the things like that. Because, like, you know, it's a thinly veiled autobiography to the point where the original drafts of the script, of which much changed, said Kander and Ebb, said Hal Prince, said people's, like, exact names.
SPEAKER_00His real friends, like, it would be like Patty, like Patty Chayefsky. Right. And so then obviously it changed a lot and probably for the better. And also I think because he was able to get away from truth, he was able to like make better characters. Like my guess is that probably if he had committed to calling them Kander and Ebb, the portrayal of the songwriters wouldn't have been so... cruel. Like, because, like, he did have a good relationship with Kander and Eb and probably was not out to, like, embarrass them. So the minute it becomes not them, he's able to be like, oh, now I get to make fun of everybody I've ever worked with,
SPEAKER_00including, like, Stephen Schwartz. I was about to say, yeah. Like, being, like, a prude. Yeah, exactly. So it's, like, it's helpful to go away from reality because it allows you to, like, make make a better statement about like what it's like to work with people like blank, as opposed to being like, I'm working exactly with Fred Ebb, who probably wasn't like that at all. Do you know what I mean? Well,
SPEAKER_03so for people who don't know, although you should, because this movie is so incredible, you should just fucking watch it. But it is a thinly veiled account of Fosse's year from like the fall of 74 to the summer of 75. Right. of when he's editing the movie Lenny and preparing the musical Chicago for rehearsals, has a heart attack, has to... They have to shut down the show for four months while he recovers. And in real life, Fosse came back from open-heart surgery,
SPEAKER_03you know, definitely weaker, more cynical, and... got Chicago back up on its feet. They open in the summer of 75, right after A Chorus Line moves from off-Broadway to Broadway. But it is ultimately that time. And everyone in it is either exactly a counterpart to his real life. So like Audrey Paris is Gwen Verdon.
SPEAKER_01Gwen Verdon, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Katie, played by Anne Rankin, is Anne Rankin. Anne Rankin.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How about that? And there are even people in the movie who kind of play themselves like Mary
SPEAKER_03McCarthy or McCary or whatever her name is. The original Mama Morton is in all that jazz. She's at that table read.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yes. Yes, yes, yes.
SPEAKER_03She won't stop laughing. She's like howling with laughter.
SPEAKER_00She has a very funny like 45 seconds on screen, but she is very funny.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. In the scene that Allie was talking about where they're doing the first table read and it's all silent, you only hear the ASMR of Joe's pencil, of his fingernails, but you're watching everyone lose their minds from the script. She's in it and she's losing her mind. The set model they do is a version of Tony Walton's set model for Chicago. And even the movie that he's editing is called The Stand-Up. And, you know, Lenny is based on Lenny Bruce.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And like Joe Gideon sounds, you know, it's like it's like what's Bill Schwinn or whatever they called him. Gordon Schwinn. You know what I mean? It's like it's like it's like when you're like, look, I know it's me. I'm trying to hide it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I understand that the idea of making, financing, producing a movie that is just about yourself for the first draft literally uses your own name. It takes a good amount of ego to even consider that as an idea. But there was a thing I was thinking about last night, not to like defend Bob Fosse in a world that doesn't need any defense. Like everyone knows he's a genius. But like, Like Matt was saying, this was coming off the heels of an amazing year for him where
he was the first
SPEAKER_00person to, and I think maybe the only person since, to win an Emmy, a Tony, and an Oscar in the same year. The same year. Like we talk about that as being a lifetime achievement. Like he came close in the same year. And so there's a funny feeling that I felt last night when I was watching this and sort of like doing some research on it. Where people were like, who does this guy think he is? And I was like, one of the greatest of all time. That's who thinks he is. Like, I think that there's almost a more interesting read of the
movie if you're able to
SPEAKER_00sort of like get rid of the fucking, he made a movie about himself and be like, yes, he made a movie about himself. We all know he's talented. He knows he's talented. What's he going to do? Act all fucking humble that he said that he's talented? He knows he's talented. Let's get to the important stuff, which is, am I a good person? Where will I go when I die? Have I left a good legacy for the people I care about? Certainly I left a good legacy of the things I've made. Is it more important to me? Like, he doesn't answer that question. It's just simply a question that is asked, which is like, what's more important to me? That I left behind a legacy of fantastic work.
And I died in an interesting way where I was not ordinary or that I fucked up my
SPEAKER_00daughter forever. You know what I mean? Like, I think it's almost bolder that he does not answer that question but dares to ask it because I don't think there is an answer to that question. And I think that he is actually in some ways humble enough to say, I don't know the answer to that question. I am simply aware that I have done that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think so. It's important to note, first of all, that the idea for this movie did not come from Bob Fosse going, you know, who has an amazing story to tell me? That was not what happened. He and the co-screen writer whose name is Robert Alan Arthur. They were going to adapt a book together that dealt with very similar themes of a
SPEAKER_00man on his deathbed. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_03And they fully came up with the screenplay, I think around the time that Chicago was in rehearsals, I think. And the screenplay was finished and it was good. But basically what Fossey says in the biography is like basically that the screenplay was great. It was too smart and complicated for him to tackle. He's like, I'm not a good enough film dramatic director to tackle this. So, you know, let's put that one aside and let's think of something else.
And so they start to look at that time of Fossey's life where he almost died and
SPEAKER_03comes out the other end with, you know, ultimately a creative achievement that wasn't really appreciated when it opened. But then people kind of appreciated it, but then they kind of didn't. And what was going on with his wife, because there was a whole dynamic with him and Gwen Verdon of He was doing the show for her. And that was a and as part sort of like as an apology to her. Then he has his heart attack and he kind of resents the fact that he's doing this for her.
SPEAKER_00And we're talking about Chicago, by the way.
SPEAKER_03Yes, Chicago. And so but to all this is to say he comes out the other end of that. But then there's this idea that Fosse starts having a death wish because once he finishes Chicago, he kind of goes harder on himself. And he then does dancing, which is two and a half hours of pure fucking dance. And as it promises in the title, as it promises in the title, which was another one. When that show came out, all of Broadway had the reaction to that, that Hollywood had to all that jazz, which was like, who the fuck does Bob Fosse think he is just creating a show
with no book,
SPEAKER_03no original story? Like, it's just his choreography. What the fuck? And then the show runs for five years.
SPEAKER_00Right. But it's also like, look... I think that if he wasn't aware that he was not a good guy, it would be harder to be like, guys, shut the fuck up about it. Look how good he is as a creative person. But I think this movie, in a way, in a complicated way, shows that he's aware of his complicated legacy and how bad of a dude he was to many people in his life. And now we're supposed to be like, so he's aware, so should we forgive him? Should we be kinder to him? Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
SPEAKER_00But it's like when we get to the... The conversation to me of like, oh, he's got so much ego is almost is like so baseline where it's like, of course he does. He actually is kind of right to feel that way. Like, I'm not sure if that means his actions were correct, but his ego was not baseless. His ego was completely based on all of his achievements and all of the great sort of groundbreaking yet to be topped things that he did in his short period of time.
so anyway that's what i was thinking about just because like i feel like you can't read a review of this movie or a critical essay or something that doesn't start with something like a guy making a movie of his own life who does he think he is and i'm like okay shut up let's get to the next part which is the good part and the interesting part let's let's sort of get over the fact that like this is about his life and also to be like what if i died yeah and let me put it on film and let me make it disgusting and gruesome and i fuck up in every turn i don't do anything
SPEAKER_00right Like, I don't even die right. I fuck up there, too.
SPEAKER_03I'll also say every idea is a bad idea unless you make it good.
SPEAKER_00Every idea is a bad idea unless you make it good. That is actually what they were saying at the end of Sunday Park with George.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's that is what that was a cut line from Playwrights Horizons. It was Celeste number two. Yeah. Came out of the painting. It's every idea is a bad idea.
SPEAKER_00Unless you make it good.
SPEAKER_03Until you make it good. Not unless you make it good. But you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00That was the pre-draft for Let It Come From You, Then It Will Be True. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03That's exactly what it was. When I do my workshops at Florida Thespian talking to kids about analyzing musicals, I go, every musical sounds like a stupid idea if you say it a certain kind of way. And it's all it's ultimately just, you know, are you going to do a good job with him with all that jazz? He ultimately makes a good work of it. Have you read the biography, the Fosse biography?
SPEAKER_00Yes, I read it. I've revisited parts of it. I probably only read it in its entirety. That's a big old volume. I think I probably read it in like 2011. Do you mean like I think it's been like a while.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think I read it cover to cover 14 years ago. I have recently picked it up again, just like little pieces here and there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll come back and revisit parts of it just to be like, oh, yeah, I remember that anecdote or whatever, but I haven't read it the full time yet.
SPEAKER_03Because the thing about Fosse that everyone talks about... Is that he, his ego was not him walking around going, look how great I am. That was actually kind of what Michael Bennett was like. That's what sort of Jerome Robbins was like. Fosse was, had such insecurity and it stems from first the fact that he wanted to be a star performer. That was what he wanted to do.
SPEAKER_00And didn't have the juice to be a star performer.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. And like fell into becoming a star choreographer and then eventually director. And like he there's a there's an anecdote of when he wins his Tony for pajama game, which really like catapults his career. He tells his second wife, Joan McCraken, He's like, it's so weird. I got into this business to be an actor. He's like, and now I have my pick of the letter as a choreographer. And so many people could only wish to have that kind of success. But he was just so thrown by it. He's like, I've been banging my head against the wall for years trying to get noticed. And now I'm getting all these offers,
but it's not for what I set out to do.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, what I wanted. And so that's also, and that insecurity kind of always fueled him. And it's ultimately... he was the kind of genius that came with fear because he didn't really know where it came from. He knew when it was good, but he didn't really have, in his opinion, the instincts to make it good on the spot. He would watch someone like a Jerome Robbins and he would watch Jerome Robbins just like know instinctively how to make something work. And he always aspired to be that.
SPEAKER_03But Fossey, I feel like for me, is the genius that I relate to, not because I'm a genius, but because his taste... most likely exceeded his ability yes which is actually a great problem to have yeah when you are a person whose taste exceeds your ability you are constantly striving to be better and you are pretty humble about not humble necessarily but you are more open to throwing things away because you are like this has not met my taste level yet yeah and i trust my taste but i just don't think this
is at my taste
SPEAKER_00level yet
SPEAKER_03But so with the movie as well, the thing that he did was, first, he and Robert Allen Arthur, they went around and they interviewed everyone in Fossey's life. They interviewed Gwen Verdon and Anne Rankin, Kendra and Ebb. They even interviewed, I think, Hal Prince and Marty Richards, like all these people.
SPEAKER_00All these people who are in the movie, essentially.
SPEAKER_03And Fossey had... grudges against a lot of people who had no grudges against him so the john lithgow character uh sergeant what's what's his first name oh no it's like george or god what is it i'm gonna find it um john lithgow plays lucas sergeant lucas sergeant
SPEAKER_00lucas i love when ladies like you're my second favorite director can we talk about that scene for a quick second then i'll get to that there's a scene so in the movie joe gideon uh they are rehearsing the beginning of this show new york to la which is essentially chicago and uh with a little bit of pippin as
SPEAKER_03well and we'll get to that in a second but The producer of the show is having lunch with John Lithgow, a.k.a. Lucas Sargent. And they're talking about how good the show is. And oh, I guess. Oh, it's.
SPEAKER_00Joe's already in the hospital. But I believe he's either about to go in for open heart surgery or he's come out of
SPEAKER_03the open heart surgery. But like things are starting to look good, they say. So they're thinking that Joe's going to be able to come back to do the show because they reached out to John Lithgow, Lucas Sargent.
SPEAKER_00Just in case.
SPEAKER_03Just in case. Yes. When he went into the hospital, like, oh, in case he doesn't make it out, we need the show to go up again. Would you be willing to do it? Oh, let me look at this. I'll take some notes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And so they're at the diner talking and they say, oh, Joe's going to make it.
SPEAKER_03I think it'll be good. And John Lithgow's like, oh, by the way, here's your script back. I gave you a couple of notes, like full three.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yellow pages all poking out. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, problems they have. And as this is happening, this woman who, by the way, reminds me of the Native American woman who accepted Marlon Brando's Oscar for The Godfather. That's what she looks like to me. Am I wrong?
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_03Like the long, straight black hair and like the very... What's her name?
SPEAKER_03I mean, Little Feather is a very striking woman. It's the only reason why I make the connection because like that's a face that I won't forget. Yeah. So I watch her in this movie. I'm like, you look a lot like her. But I digress. She goes up to John Lithgow. She's like, I'm so sorry to bother you. Are you Lucas Sargent? Would you sign my napkin? I'm an aspiring actress. And next to Joe Gideon, you are my favorite director. And I'm so sorry your last show was a flop.
SPEAKER_00I'm so sorry your last show was a flop. By the way, I was going to ask you this because I was watching it last night and I was like, what show is he teching? Is it based on anything? Is it totally manufacturing something?
SPEAKER_03Here's the thing. First of all, that woman. I'm like, good luck trying to have a career in New York now, honey. You just insulted the second most powerful director in New York to his face. Second of all, Lucas Sargent is not solely Hal Prince.
SPEAKER_00He's also Michael Bennett. He's also. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And he's also Gower champion. He's he is those three combined. He aesthetically and personality wise is most like Hal Prince. And allegedly Hal Prince was who they reached out to in case Fosse died and couldn't continue with Chicago. Also, like in the original version of the script, his character is named Hal Prince. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Like I said, this movie is better for the fact that they moved away from it being biography and sort of being like, this is what Hal Prince was like. It's more fun to watch this kind of like amalgam of directors. It's also more fun to watch this amalgam of directors through the eye of Insecure Fosse as opposed to as a true biography of being like, Hal Prince is actually a pretty nice guy. It's like, who gives a shit? Yeah. If I want to know that, I'll read a book about him. I really want to know what Fosse thinks about him, which is that he thinks he's this like slimy little pretentious.
SPEAKER_03But it all comes back to personal stuff that's not rooted in reality. What it is, is that Hal Prince was one of the co-producers of Pajama Game, which launched Fosse's career. But Fosse also like didn't do all the choreography on Pajama Game. Jerome Robbins kind of came in and showed Doctor a little bit because... It was Fosse's first musical. He was in over his head. So, like, Steam Heat is pure Fosse. Right. Hernando's Hideaway is pure Fosse. But, like, Once a Year Day is kind of Jerome Robbins and things like that. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But so as Fosse got to do more in the shows...
he would still kind of have a vendetta against anybody who knew more than him and
SPEAKER_03was going against him. So, like, they're doing damn Yankees. They're out of town. And there's this big Act 2 number that Fosse's created that they get to Philadelphia and Hal Prince is like, we got to cut it. You know, it's 12 minutes long. The show's running too long. And Bob Fosse's like, you're out to get me, blah, blah, blah. And just, like, always had this thing against Hal Prince. And I think after... New Girl in Town, they never worked together again. Wow. And part of the reason why he wanted to do the cabaret movie was he wanted to take it from Hal Prince. Meanwhile, Hal Prince is like, Fosse's great.
SPEAKER_03He's very talented. Yeah, he's like, good guy. The only thing he ever said against Fosse was when he saw Chicago on Broadway and he said to Kandrinev, please tell Bob Fosse that Chicago in the 1920s is not, no, the Weimar Republic at the same time. They're very different aesthetics. Sondheim actually had a nastier thing to say about him in the Fosse bio, which was, he said, oh, Bob came to see Follies and he's been making a career out of the last 20 minutes of Follies ever since. Oh,
SPEAKER_00That's delightful. That's so mean. I love that. He's not wrong.
SPEAKER_03You know, so that thing is like, he's not wrong.
SPEAKER_00He's not wrong. But Fosse saw all the things they were trying to do in the last 20 minutes of
SPEAKER_03Loveland and all that.
SPEAKER_00And has done it more successfully, which is why Sondheim, I'm sure, is a little bit meh about it.
SPEAKER_03A larger mass of people, for sure.
SPEAKER_00Yes, 100%. I love that. I mean, we, now that we, now, I don't know if it's maybe that, like, We can now hold him as a legend, a deceased legend, and also sort of like be more like, yeah, he was also a real guy now that Sondheim is dead. Like when they young Sheldonified him in Blue Moon. Did you see Blue Moon yet?
SPEAKER_03I saw Blue Moon.
SPEAKER_00You didn't like Blue Moon? No.
SPEAKER_03I liked it fine. We can talk about that more if we talk about fuck you. Anyway, I like that they were like, here's a little boy and he's very smart and he's so mean.
SPEAKER_00And I was like, yeah. I enjoyed that.
SPEAKER_03Sondheim could be a raging bitch sometimes, but also like, I'm glad that I, in the end, I'm glad I didn't meet him because if I tried to be a raging bitch back to him, he would have. He would have killed you. He would have ripped your head off. I would have been like, he would have said something mean to me and I would have said right back to him, well, you ran out of musical ideas after 1995. But, um, Thank you. The other thing in All That Jazz is the composer, songwriter, Fred Ebb in particular took a lot of grievances against that character because he was like, I thought we were friends. Why do you hate me?
SPEAKER_00And that character is like a buffoon. But that's why also I'm saying it's better that this character is not really Fred Ebb.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's why I'm glad that he didn't say Fred Ebb either because he is a buffoon and also the character isn't Fred Ebb. The character is actually Stephen Schwartz.
SPEAKER_00That's what I think. More and more when I watch it, I'm like, this is Stephen Schwartz. Right. Because there's a lot of Pippin in all that jazz in the creating of New York to L.A.
SPEAKER_03The erotica sequence. Erotica sequence is basically what Fosse did to with you. Yeah. But also Stephen Schwartz threatened to walk off the project like he didn't get to
SPEAKER_00keep it because they were like, you're a genius. They like it was like a huge source of. Well, it was a standoff between Fosse had just lost the battle in the movie of Cabaret.
SPEAKER_03He wanted to fire Joel Grey. And he said to the producers, you either I walk or Joel Grey walks. And they go, you can walk. We're keeping Joel Grey.
SPEAKER_00Wait, why did he hate Joel Grey so much?
SPEAKER_03Because he wanted to play the emcee.
SPEAKER_00Didn't know that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That's Joel Grey's theory, because he said he basically was like, I was the only one who didn't have a good time on that movie because Bob Fosse treated me so terribly. Everyone else, he was like really lovely, too. And his theory is that it's because Fosse wanted to play the emcee. But also, I think Fosse kind of wanted the other thing is Fosse didn't want any semblance of Hal Prince's cabaret.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, totally.
SPEAKER_03He wanted to make it his own.
SPEAKER_00His own thing. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03But then with Pippin, you know, Stephen Schwartz, who at that point only had Godspell to his name,
SPEAKER_00was like,
SPEAKER_03I will walk from this thing. And Bob Fosse is like, I'll walk from this thing. I have more clout than you than you, kid. So like he got his way. But also the character of Victoria and all that jazz, the ensemble dancer who he beds and then berates constantly throughout rehearsals.
SPEAKER_00Makes her a better dancer, so to speak. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, yes, he does make her a better dancer. That's what everyone agrees on. But that character is based off of a woman in the chorus of Pippin, who he had hired. And the line about hiring her when she can't sing, or rather the composer not wanting her because she's not a good singer.
SPEAKER_00Tone deaf, right.
SPEAKER_03That was based off of a conversation, a fight that Schwartz and Fossey had had about and ranking for Pippin.
SPEAKER_00That's funny.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Anne Reilly's a much better singer than people sort of give credit for her or whatever. Especially if you listen to her in the 70s, she's not bad at all. Things get a lot riskier in the 80s and especially by the time she does the Chicago Revival. I agree with that.
SPEAKER_00But even then, but like in this period, in this era. Oh my God, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I think she sounds great. Listen to her in Good Time Charlie. She's belting her face off. And it's like the only thing I've listened to where I went, oh, I can hear how you were as Cassie in A Chorus Line now.
SPEAKER_00Totally. Totally.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Totally.
SPEAKER_03What's your favorite number in all that jazz, by the way?
SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. That's impossible. I mean, I think my favorite number is... There'll be some changes made, honestly. Like, it's the thing that I... when I'm, like, thinking about all that jazz and, like, have to go watch something on YouTube, like, that is the one that I watch. I think Anne Reinking's performance in it is so incredible. I just love it. I mean, it's really hard not to love Everything Old is New Again because it's just, like, so unbelievably charming. It's got amazing choreography. And just, like, it's just joy.
SPEAKER_00But also, like, I honestly really have never... fully appreciated how good Roy Scheider is in that moment too in not pulling too much focus like it's truly about them but just like watching a new kind of love shine out of his face like you see him in such an unguarded moment where you're like wow I don't know if we ever see Joe Gideon like this ever again in the film he says I love you a lot as he admits and It's maybe the only time you actually see, like, real love on his face. Yeah. And it's,
SPEAKER_00like, some of the most truthful stuff you learn about him, even though he doesn't say anything. It's really amazing. It's also one of the few times you see him willingly able to accept the love that's
SPEAKER_03being thrown at him.
SPEAKER_00Yes. Yes. Because it's so innocent. I need to win in every interaction. I kind of need to own women. I don't really know what love is. I'm fucked up. Like he's very honest about it. And it's like one of the few times you see him like accepting
love and also like reflecting love in a way that is not completely mired in like I had too many sexual
SPEAKER_00experiences too young and I'm kind of fucked up about this. Do you know what I mean? It's great. I mean, like that's amazing. I mean, it's all amazing. It's all so good. Honestly, last night. I cried watching the movie a lot. I cried like a lot, which is strange because I'm not sure if that's like a reaction many people have to the movie, whatever. But also like it's strange to have seen a movie so many times and suddenly had this reaction. I don't think I've ever cried before watching the movie. And I really cried a lot in the number that the daughter does in the fantasy sequence where she's like all dressed up like an older woman
and kind of like,
SPEAKER_00you know, like a tart with her makeup and the heels. She can't walk in the heels.
SPEAKER_03One of these days.
SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. That really fucked me up last night bad. That really fucked me up.
SPEAKER_03Because you also can't walk in heels?
SPEAKER_00Because I also can't walk in heels. It's so sad.
SPEAKER_03It's a very sad song. It does have one of my favorite shots in the movie, which is the slow motion shot of Anne Rankin jumping in the air and kissing at the camera.
SPEAKER_00Oh, so cunt. it really is but also just like when they all get down to like that like white hearse and drive away into like nothingness and they're like you're gonna leave a little girl without a father it really like got me i was like this is so sad this is like really devastating the beginning of that song is serving bugsy malone cunty realness and but then i hate bugsy malone but whatever oh so do i okay great but it
SPEAKER_03does remind you that even at that age jodie foster was that girl yeah that is true she's the only she is serving um kieran and shipka in a movie where everyone else is serving rugrats yeah and and it's it's you watch her on another planet yeah yeah totally on another planet but that's sort of what um young little um michelle is serving yeah i'm like all dolled up and also has those creepy creepy shots of the doctors and surgeons with the love that it's so it's that is so
SPEAKER_00good
SPEAKER_03It is. But I love so I love that whole fantasy sequence of while he's in surgery, while he's under and imagining Leland Palmer singing to him and then Anne Reinking singing to him and then daughter Michelle singing to him and the women of his that he's used and abused singing to him. Yeah, and something that a lot of people in Fosse's life... Everyone in his life who saw the movie agreed that he was extraordinarily hard on himself. They were like... Because the conversation of...
SPEAKER_03Is that you? Is that Joe Gideon? He would always say, like, it's not me. It's Joe Gideon. I swear it's Joe Gideon. And then everyone's like, Bob.
SPEAKER_00Sure. Yeah. Sure, Dan.
SPEAKER_03We saw your first draft.
SPEAKER_00Sure. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And not even that. He was like, no, because, you know, we adapted him. And then when Roy Scheider came on, because Roy Scheider was a replacement for Richard Dreyfuss, which I'm so glad that was the case, because Dreyfuss would have ruined this movie.
SPEAKER_00You really think so?
SPEAKER_03I really do.
SPEAKER_00I'm not sure if I feel the same way, but I'm just I am still so happy. I think Dreyfuss is.
SPEAKER_03His charm comes from a manic energy, which Fazi does not have. And I think if you make Joe Gideon a manic individual, he becomes insufferable. Whereas with Scheider, it's the laid back reserve and almost like calm in the face of... of a storm that makes him so seductive.
SPEAKER_00And just, like, his, like, his dark eyes sort of revealing nothing. Or, like, when he's in the hospital and everyone's lecturing him, he's like, yeah, sure. Do you know what I'm talking about? Yeah, when Cliff Gorman's like, I'm not saying you're a queer, but you do have tendencies.
SPEAKER_03And he's like, wrong.
SPEAKER_00Like, I feel like he, like, sells that in a way. I don't know how many other actors could really sell that. So do you know the other actors that were trying to have considered for this? In general?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I know they were looking at Shirley MacLaine again. Shirley MacLaine they really wanted for... For Leland Palmer, for Gwen Verne.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but she was doing the turning point, I believe, at that moment. No, no, the turning point was over. I think she just had reservations about doing another Gwen Verne role.
SPEAKER_00I mean, as well she should. As well they all should have. It's sort of crazy. It's like, hey, we all learned our lesson, let's... not do that and it's unclear why he went with Leland Palmer because from my research she did not audition he fully sought her out and she was like I haven't seen you in five years like not since Pippin I don't know like why you want me also I found God now so I don't know if I should do this movie he's like you're gonna do
SPEAKER_03it and the thinking is that If Gwen had been working at the time of Pippin, Fastrata would have been her role.
SPEAKER_00Yes, right. Gwen Verdon probably would have been in Pippin, but she was doing something else, so she couldn't have been in Pippin.
SPEAKER_03She wasn't really working at that point. She had retired after Redhead to have their daughter, what's her face?
SPEAKER_00Nicole. Nicole.
SPEAKER_03Nicole, yes. I was going to say Nina, but I'm like, no, that's Al Hirschfeld. Nicole. They had to have their daughter, Nicole. And then I think once Nicole was like three or four is when Gwen went back to do Sweet Charity. And then she kind of went back to being a mom again. And part of the reason why Chicago happened was, A, Roxy Hart was a dream role for Gwen. And it took them forever to get the rights because Maureen Watkins just wouldn't die. But then she was like, oh, this time I don't want it to just be a star vehicle for me. She's like, I want this to be a show that I develop. I want to produce it.
SPEAKER_00I want to have a nest egg for the rest of my life.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yes. And I want royalties for my daughter and things like that. And so that was that. But yeah, I don't think Gwen was really performing at the time that Pippin was happening. Plus, she and Fossey, they had officially separated, even though they were still very much...
SPEAKER_00Never divorced. Yeah, totally.
SPEAKER_03Never divorced. Still in each other's lives. Their relationship... was far less contentious than the relationship of Audrey and Joe Gideon in the movie.
SPEAKER_00Like,
SPEAKER_03even though they... The movie kind of portrays them as sort of, like, contentious buddies who have a past. And the... Story goes that Verdon and Fossey, even when they were like at their most, like at each other's throats, it was still very much like if someone would maybe say something negative about them to them, like if someone was going to Gwen and they're like, well, you know, Bobby's a dick. She'd be like, you don't have to say that.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. But I do. I feel that that is present in the movie in a way. It is.
SPEAKER_03It's just a little more biting in the movie.
SPEAKER_00It's a little more biting. But again, if he's being more hard on himself, more self-excoriating than in reality, then I can see how he's like, well, this is what Gwen's really thinking, even though she'd never say it. You know what I mean? Like being harder on himself than is true. But like her being like, it's the best thing you've ever made, you asshole, is such a great line because it's like she can't. She is one of the people who understands him the best, not just as a person, but as a performer and as a creator.
And so when he makes this erotica sequence that threatens to basically tank the
SPEAKER_00show because it's like, who's going to walk? Who's going to say no? Are they going to pull money, pull funding? It's her dream show, her dream vehicle, a la Chicago. She's playing a role that she's maybe not right for, a 24-year-old woman. Again, kind of Roxy Hart-esque. Like, this is all sort of Chicago adjacent. And then she's like, yeah, well, the number that you made is impeccable, incredible. Going to ruin the show. I hate you for doing it. It's incredible. You're one of a kind talent. No one could have done that but you. Why did you do that to me? Why are you putting me in this position? I hate you and I love you.
SPEAKER_00Do you know what I mean? It's like, I feel so real. To me, it feels so realistic. i never got to like like she had her producer head on for that moment i always got it as um it's like kathy in last five years when she's saying it's like yes he's insane but look what he can do it's that it's that line but with so much more like
SPEAKER_03actual pain about it of like you like you I also see the thing you're just talking about with Gwen Verdon being like,
SPEAKER_00this is not just a musical. This is not just a star vehicle. I'm not just trying to get a Tony. I want to make a thing that lasts forever. I want something that makes me money for my kid, for my family, for my life. And it's like, if you put this number in this show, all the producers are being like, there goes the family audience. Now Frank Sinatra will never record it. And it's like, I think she is thinking about that. And I think that she's the only person who has good enough taste for... whose first reaction isn't fuck you for doing it. It's it's incredible. And and fuck you for doing it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Like, you know what I mean? Like, she's the only person who can have that be her first reaction. Does the does the movie imply that Audrey is on the producing team for this? Okay, so I think so. I think so. Okay. Simply because, like, it seems to me it's a script she kind of circled.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00So maybe if she's not a producer, she's a creative whatever.
SPEAKER_03They do say, and what is actually my favorite dramatic scene of her rehearsing, warming up alone in the studio, and they're having that argument while she's dancing. Yes. He says, I'm only doing this because you want to play that goddamn 24-year-old. Right. So, like, they do say it is her desire for the show.
SPEAKER_00Also, I always interpreted her as being on the leadership end of it when they're talking to the cast saying we're going to have to postpone the show for four months because Joe Gideon's in the hospital and everybody's mood is so sour. And the producers, like, don't quite know how to, like, lighten the mood. Like, they're trying to be nice, but, like, they can't stop talking money and everybody's mood is bad. And then she gets up and starts being like, it's going to be huge. It's going to be great. And she starts quite literally tap dancing. Yeah. Like, to cheer people up. Like, to me, that doesn't read as, like, lead actress. To me, that reads as, like... something between the two.
Like I get the sense that she has her fingers in more pies than just being like on the lead.
SPEAKER_03Sure. I think I'm trying to think of this as somebody who maybe doesn't know the lore of Gwen Verdon and Bob Bossing in Chicago. And I think that there's a world someone could see this and think to themselves that is her just trying to be a group leader as well as everyone knowing that she's been to the hospital and all this other stuff. But also who's to say? I think it also just is a great opportunity for Leland Palmer to be a great dramatic actress.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Also, like something I learned from doing some research for this was that her performance wasn't really very warmly received.
SPEAKER_03I mean, nothing was really warmly received in this movie. I'm sort of shocked by that because I think she's so fucking great in the movie. Everyone's great in this movie. Roy Scheider, from what I could read, Roy Scheider was the only thing that was consistently singled out in all of...
SPEAKER_00Didn't he get an Oscar nomination? Am I wrong?
SPEAKER_03He did. Rightfully so.
SPEAKER_00Rightfully so.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And the Oscars, also according to the Fosse biography, the Oscar nominations took everyone by surprise as well as the wins because, again, the critical reception was sort of mixed, leaning towards negative. But what ended like Scheider got a Golden Globe nomination, which even then, like the Golden Globes weren't super influential, but they were like the really first big award show pre-Oscar. So if you weren't nominated for stuff, you weren't in the kind of out of.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you weren't in the conversation.
SPEAKER_03And so he was nominated and I think everyone just sort of assumed, oh, he'll probably get nominated. But like, I don't know about All That Jazz. And what happened was that All That Jazz actually ended up being a surprise box office hit. And like the world, not just America, like the world really liked it and kind of rebuffed the critics, which is a common trend in the late 70s, early 80s of movies and Broadway shows that the prestigious critics like this is not the real thing.
SPEAKER_00And people being like, well, I think it is. So fuck you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Like, I mean, that's the story of Evita, right? Of Evita kind of got dismissed by American critics and audiences were like, well, fuck you. I like it. Same thing with Pippin. I think Jaws kind of got sort of mediocre reviews. The Exorcist got mediocre reviews. And America as a whole was like, no, this is amazing. And you're all idiots. But so because of that, there became a lot of buzz about it. So the movie got a bunch of nominations. It ultimately lost Best Picture director and actor to Kramer versus Kramer.
SPEAKER_00Which is a really good movie.
SPEAKER_03It's a really good movie. It's the difference for me. And Kramer vs. Kramer also was like, that was the big hit of the year.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, she was that girl.
SPEAKER_03She really was that girl. And the one thing that I can't deny Kramer vs. Kramer is like, It's a strong film. It holds up in a lot of ways. All That Jazz excites me more, but also All That Jazz is about something that's far more stylized and just weird and messy.
SPEAKER_00I think Kramer vs. Kramer is an amazing movie. I like All That Jazz better. It's in my top five movies. Kramer vs. Kramer is not in my top five movies, but it'd be hard to say... That is not like sort of an American classic film.
SPEAKER_03We're not taking away Meryl's first Oscar for that movie. She's wonderful. I would maybe take away Jane Alexander's nomination for Kramer vs. Kramer and give that to Leland Palmer. Yeah. She's just so good. I think, again, the thing about this movie also is that it is such an acerbic take on everyone. And so even the people in Fossey's life who sought it... were very thrown by it and there was a divide in terms of how to respond about it like Gwen Verdon and ranking Ben Vereen they were all like I
have no words like it's similar to Leland Palmer in the movie of it's the best thing you've ever made and fuck you it was it was a lot of like I can't talk to you for a week and when I talk to you in a week we'll talk about the movie but like right now right now I
SPEAKER_03just need to take a second right yeah right now don't talk to me And but then when they all came back, what they said to him was like, you're why were you so mean to yourself? Like, you're like, you're a son of a bitch, but you're not that kind of a son of a bitch. I am. I am still in your life for a reason. And people like Fred Ebb said, no, no, no. And I think Patty Chayefsky said the same thing, too, of like, no, no, no. This is his ultimate con of he beats himself up and goes like, I'm such a terrible person. Why would you stick around?
SPEAKER_00So you can forgive him.
SPEAKER_03Yes. It's to absolve him, but he doesn't actually grow from it. And it's funny because I think the more and more I watch it and the more and more
SPEAKER_00time goes on, I actually don't think that was his long con. Like, I really don't think so either. Like, I don't think he was like, I'm going to make this movie so people feel sorry for me. So people go, oh, he had a hard past. He has to he has to fuck women. He had a hard life.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I don't think he did that as a kid.
SPEAKER_00I don't think he made it for that reason. I think he made it because he hated himself. Like many great artists do. They're like, I'm a piece of shit. I'm a nobody. I got nothing underneath here. It's all tap dancing on top. He has the best line in the movie. Well, the best line in the movie is how dare you use my phone to call someone who isn't gay. But the second best line is when he goes... That's when he goes, I hate show. You see, this is it. I hate show business.
SPEAKER_03Joe, you love show business.
SPEAKER_00He goes, yeah, I love show business. I'll go either way. Like, to me, that is like the backbone of the movie, which is like, it's a horrible business. People backstab you. They don't give a shit about you. You could be lying dead in the hospital and already talking to your replacement. Also, where else can you see art like this? Where else can you make stuff like this? Where else can you have people like this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, and every day I feel differently about it. I'll go either way. Like, that's how I feel today. I'll feel differently tomorrow. Yeah. Also, do you have to take, I have to wait, I have to ask you a question. Yes. Do you have to take an ad break?
SPEAKER_02Do you need to pee?
SPEAKER_00I have to pee.
SPEAKER_03Okay, we'll take an ad break in one second. Before we take an ad break and you pee, I need to say this one last thing.
SPEAKER_00Please.
SPEAKER_03The other great line of this movie belongs to Anne Ranking. And you got to know what I'm talking about.
SPEAKER_00I just wish you weren't so generous with your cock.
SPEAKER_03There we go.
SPEAKER_00Because it's such a good line that he has to write it down. He's like, that's good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think there's, I have, okay, so I've yet to actually see The Fablemans, but Blank Check won't shut up. I know, Blank Check won't shut up. I don't care. Spielberg does not mean that much to me as it does to straight men and you. I don't care.
SPEAKER_00It's just a good movie.
SPEAKER_03Sure, I'll watch it eventually. But like, here's my thing. I listen to movie podcasts like Blank Check and this had Oscar buzz and Big Picture a lot, which is frustrating because for every episode I love, they'll talk about stuff that I'm like, I want to just get in there and strangle you all, which is I'm sure a lot of people feel when they listen to this podcast.
SPEAKER_00Totally. And we're talking about heels click clacking about and they're like, what the fuck are you talking about?
SPEAKER_03Or when I say things like, I don't know, I've got issues with the libretto of ragtime and just like the whole tone of the show and people being like, gosh, I'm a masterpiece. But so the there's that apparently there's a scene in Fablemans when Michelle Williams and what's his face from There'll Be Blood tell the one that. paul dano yes i was about to say the one that tarantino hates paul dano they're telling the kids we're getting a divorce and the spielberg avatar starts imagining how he would film this scene while he's like living it yeah this is straight out of
that one moment of all that joe gideon is talking to katie he she's walked in on
SPEAKER_03him with another woman and she they're having like a conversation about this stuff and then she calls a boy in her ballet class who's not gay that's the line ally was talking about how dare you use my phone to call someone who's not gay and she was like well you can go out with any woman you want he's like yeah any woman but like i stay in with you and the it gets very real for a second and she's like i know who you are i i love you for a very specific reason and what we have is real and then she says i just wish you weren't so generous with your cock and rather than that actually sink in as a human it hits him as an
artist and he's like fuck i gotta write that line down that's good i gotta write that i gotta write that down yeah and then he like leaves the room to go do that basically and then they end up resolving their their argument but like that is who he is in a nutshell of in this very real moment he's like that's a really good one-liner i gotta write that down yeah and and on that note ali gordon let's take a quick break i'm free to
SPEAKER_01pee how do you mean you're the top yeah And we're back. I also was remembering while I was peeing that I asked a question that we have not
SPEAKER_00answered, which is, do you think it's a specific show they're sort of baking fun of when they go see the Hal Prince type director directing something that is a flop? Like, is there a show that that's supposed to be, do you think?
SPEAKER_03I don't think it's meant to be a specific show. If I may, I want to now tie this into the Blue Moon of it all, the Fosse Ferdinand of it all, the Tick Tick Boom of it all, which is that it looks to me like it is Fosse making fun of the Hal Prince aesthetic. Because it's this very avant-garde, esoteric fuck kind of a set of just like, it's a bed on a platform.
SPEAKER_00With a floating window. Floating window. And white curtains.
SPEAKER_03And he keeps telling Jules Fisher, literally the famous line of his editor Jules Fisher is like, more shadowy, more shadowy, darker. It's a seduction scene. Right. And which is Prince... It took critics a while to start digging on Prince, what they were digging Fosse on, which was like, oh, a black box with like dark lighting and and mylar, you know, black paneling on the end. Like how how how Prince of you? Yeah, it took them until the 80s to start doing that with Prince.
SPEAKER_03They were doing that with Fosse pretty much right after Pippin. And I think Fossey was doing it as a way of like, can no one else see that Hal has the same style for all of the pros?
SPEAKER_00He's like, it's a fucking bed on a platform. Yeah. It's really funny. That scene is just so funny. Actually, the interesting thing is that, so Fossey was very spiteful towards Fossey. Hal Prince because he always felt like Hal Prince had it out for him over the years
SPEAKER_03and anything Hal did as far as Fosse was aware was a slight. Gower Champion I think Fosse was jealous of because Champion always got the kind of success and reviews that Fosse never got for shows that were not nearly as boundary pushing as what Fosse was doing. But, like, you know, because I'll get to that in a second. And then Bennett is sort of this wunderkind who gets to come up and, like, kind of have none of Fosse's problems. You know, he comes up through the ranks and has all of the innate
instincts that Robbins had that Fosse kind of had to work to learn and gets all of the accolades and all of
SPEAKER_03the money and all of the prestige and notoriety for A Chorus Line, a show that... To be clear, Fosse wasn't alone in this. All of Michael Bennett's contemporaries thought very little of a chorus line. Sondheim, Prince.
SPEAKER_01Really?
SPEAKER_03They all thought it was sentimental and kind of cheap.
SPEAKER_01I didn't know that.
SPEAKER_03I mean, we're talking like a very elite circle of people.
SPEAKER_01But yeah,
SPEAKER_03I think also if a chorus line ran for two years, no one would have, they would have not bothered. They would have been like, chorus line's cute. She's a good show. But it became what it became.
SPEAKER_00And then they were like, it wasn't even that good in the first place.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's sort of how I am with certain shows right now where it's like the fan base is so loud that I'm like, I liked it fine. I thought it was OK. But now you're being so annoying that you're making me hate it.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You're making me wonder what you guys are seeing in it now.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And making me kind of resentful that I, A, that I can't feel this way and B, I'm sort of like, what is going on here? But so with Bennett, Fosse was really kind of also kind of spiteful on, which is ironic because Bennett idolized Fosse and wanted to be him so badly. And in fact, when he was making all that jazz for the audition sequence on the Palace stage, Fosse said, I'm going to do an eight minutes when it takes Michael Bennett two hours to do every night.
SPEAKER_00I mean, look, and can I be honest?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00He does. Now, it's missing all the joy and whimsy and love of a chorus line. So not to bash on a chorus line, but he does do that. He does do the last 20 minutes of Follies and the first hour and 45 minutes of a chorus line pretty effectively in a shorter amount of time in this movie. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03You can't deny. No, the hospital dream sequence is a far creepier. And I would say, I mean, I know you cried. I don't find the last 20 minutes quite as heartbreaking as I find parts of Loveland and Follies.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also don't know if I cried because I found it heartbreaking. I think I cried because I was like...
SPEAKER_03moved, disturbed, feeling something. I didn't mean to put words in your mouth. I like to put other things in there, but the moment in the ending of the movie that gets me is, it is ultimately the bye-bye life sequence. A, it's just, it's astonishingly executed. Even more astonishing when you learn, as you were saying earlier, is that that sequence was supposed to be entirely different. It became this sequence.
SPEAKER_00They ran out of money, essentially.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. A second studio had to take it on because the studio they were with wouldn't give them any more money. And so they, like, caught a deal, I think, with Fox, maybe. And they're like, hey, if you give us an extra million... Can you work a deal with the other studio about who gets domestic and international distribution? And we won't make the finale we planned on making. We'll make a cheaper one, but we still need to make the finale. Because originally it was going to be the opening night of New York, L.A.
SPEAKER_00Interspersed with something like this, which was also supposed to be a fantasy sequence, but not this full fantasy sequence.
SPEAKER_03Yes. And they were going to end it with... Not him in the body bag, but with like the response to New York, L.A., which was it becomes a hit. And Lucas Sargent gets all of the credit because Lucas Sargent's the one who takes it on. And Lucas Sargent does his own thing with it. Like a lot of Joe Gideon stuff gets sort of thrown out, which might have been for the better, because if you look at the way Audrey Paris is in that table read, she's not happy with how that script is.
SPEAKER_00No, she thinks it's bad. And it is bad. Yeah. They pretty unequivocally say about four lines of dialogue and they're all bad.
SPEAKER_03So you see, Sandy, everyone in L.A. has a car. I had a girlfriend who bought one just to get to the bathroom. The last line of the show being only in America can a 24 year old girl like me own
SPEAKER_00a house like this in Beverly Hills. Then the lights go down and the show is over.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That fucking rocks. That's the funniest line of dialogue I've written for anything.
SPEAKER_02Not since Christine Baranski. Don't even start because even though we're friends who grew up here together.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. Yeah. It had big Cher Show energy.
SPEAKER_02Oh, my God. The Cher Show's like second line of dialogue was her dad being like, honey, it's 1953.
SPEAKER_00Women can be anything. It was like one of my favorite lines of dialogue I've ever seen. Like I would do anything in my life to have a time traveling apparatus and go back to see Cher Show again. I would do anything to see Cher Show again. Okay.
SPEAKER_02I would here lies Allie Gordon. She would have done anything to see Cher Show again.
SPEAKER_00It was such a night of my life. Like it was like one of the definitive nights of my life. And see, I have forgotten more about the Cher show than Cher herself has done in her own life. I wrote down everything. The lights came down at intermission and I was with my friend and we were like, we have to write down everything that just happened so we don't forget. I wrote down every line of dialogue that like blew my mind. He loves you like I love this bong. I wrote down every line of dialogue. I'm not wrong. I'm Robert Altman.
SPEAKER_03Can you can you I'm not wrong about Robert Altman.
SPEAKER_00It's I'm not wrong, comma. I'm Robert Altman.
SPEAKER_03Oh, OK.
SPEAKER_00And it was like a twist, like you weren't supposed to know who it was. You were like, who's this guy? Who is this guy talking to Cher? And she was like, he was like, you're a star. You're right to be in this movie. And she was like, what if you're wrong? And he said, I'm not wrong. I'm Robert Altman. All I remember about the Cher show was I remember Emily Skinner was there.
SPEAKER_03Michael Burress was there and was not nearly naked enough, in my opinion.
SPEAKER_00No, he also played Robert Altman.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Could he not have played a naked Robert Altman?
SPEAKER_00Sure. I'm not wrong. I'm naked, comma, and I'm Robert Altman.
SPEAKER_03And I'm Robert Altman. Is the Cher show for you what Diana the Musical is to me?
SPEAKER_00I think so.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_00I think so. Because I also enjoyed watching Diana, but I don't think that I was like... On my I like I wasn't like if I could have watched the share show standing, you know, like when a guy's watching football, you know, like when a guy's watching football and they get real close, they get real close to the screen. Not because they need to see better, but because the intensity of it, they're like, I have to be as close as possible. That is how I wish I could have watched the share show. I wish I could have been standing at the lip of the stage. Just sort of like, oh, like just like sort of like taking it all in.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That was me both times I saw Diana on Broadway. I was basically on my knees, mouth open. And I was like, please, daddy. All over it. All over me.
SPEAKER_00And like, I really, I really enjoyed watching Diana. But I don't think I felt that way. Like, I think that for me, that is your show.
SPEAKER_03You know what Ruby Michael Bress would have been so phenomenal in? All that jazz. So true. Yeah. Here's the thing. Bob Fosse choreography, yes, it is sexy. Erotica is very titillating. But what I've always found about Bob Fosse... to be true, is he has such a sense of humor with his choreography. He makes funny choreography. You look at Rich Man's Froog, you look at the rich kid rag in Little Meat,
SPEAKER_03you even look at... Big Spender's actually really fucking funny.
SPEAKER_00Big Spender's hilarious. Honestly, even things that are not meant to be funny, he finds moments of... comedy or of, like, dark comedy, like the glory sequence in Pippin.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00The Manson Trio, yeah. The Manson Trio. Even, like, the Manson Trio has, like, a sense of humor, but also just, like, the staging behind it of the ways people are dying. Mm-hmm. Being like, ha-ha, it's comedic, it's cartoonish. Violence is... Basically, the lesson that Pippin learns from it is that he cannot handle violence. Violence is very real. But it's in a sort of ironic way. They present it in a bloodless kind of cartoonish way. And we see him go, I can't see that ever again. Which I actually think is more effective than like Game of
Thrones seeing it and
SPEAKER_00being like, this is real. Like we get to see the stylized version. He sees the real version. And there's comedy in it, even though that moment is not funny. Like it's really clever. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Well, and you even look at the With You orgy sequence. The male ensemble grabbing Pippin by every limb and lifting him up in the air and lowering him down. And each time he gets lowered, a different woman of the ensemble rolls in front of him. Right. That's funny. So it becomes an assembly line of sex. And it takes what is ultimately a salacious... activity for a lot of audiences and makes it palatable by having an attitude about it and a commentary about it and ultimately it is that like yes
you know free love is great and and sex to make you feel good but eventually when you're doing it to prove something to get away from something it becomes mechanical and it doesn't matter how many people you bed ultimately you just become like it's the it's the um
SPEAKER_03like you i imagine those uh guys on Jersey Shore being like, I'm a fuck machine. And Bob Fox is like, right. Isn't that terrible? Here's what a fuck machine does.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. This is what it looks like to be a fuck machine. Yeah. Yeah. It's all great. It also is such an incredible celebration of the human body. Like, he choreographs in a way that makes bodies look so phenomenal and not even in a sexy way. In that way that, like, almost when you see, like, a great piece of, like, visual art that you're like, wow, this person managed to capture... Like, they made it out of stone. How'd they make this muscle look so real? Or, like, oh, my God, this real life is so... It's like it feels like a photograph.
SPEAKER_00It's like she's hunched over that desk in a way that's so real. Like, his choreography makes the body look so strong and athletic and funny and powerful and muscular and... and sexy and like he just like he just makes the body look so good and sometimes he looks makes it makes it look good like in a sexy way where you're like jesus christ like look at her look at her gorgeous legs but sometimes he just like you just like wow like the body is an incredible tool and i'm like so blessed to have one like he
SPEAKER_00makes me go like wow human bodies are phenomenal do you mean
SPEAKER_03I mean, this is where Sandal Bergman, as basically the cheetah Rivera stand-in for Take Off With Us, what he does on her body—and granted, he did not choreograph this on her. He choreographed this on a different woman who, a week before they shot it, quit because he was like, okay, so for the erotica thing, I think— Cheryl's going to go topless. And she was like, um, no, that was not in my contract and you're not going to get me to do nudity.
SPEAKER_00Is that the blonde woman who's at the top? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. That was supposed to be a woman by, I believe, by the name of Cheryl Clark. And she quit a few days before they were due to film it because he announced at the last second he wanted her topless and she said no. So he called Sandal Bergman, who he had worked with, I believe on Pippin.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03He definitely had worked with her. I can't remember if it was Pippin or other stuff, but called her up last second. He's like, hey, can you learn two numbers in a weekend and film it for me? But also you got to be topless at the end. And she was like, okay, fine. But what he does with her for the first section of the takeoff with us is seductive, playful, cheeky, very like whatever Lola wants, right? Yes, she's gorgeous. He's not... He's not exploiting that for any kind of sensuality.
SPEAKER_03Rather, he is using her as a secret weapon to entice the audience. And then when they get to erotica, it becomes a much more forceful weapon of sensuality. And even though she looks stunning, it stops turning us on.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it gets spooky.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, which is intentional.
SPEAKER_00It gets real spooky, which is, yeah, it's amazing. Actually, he is so incredible. He is such a hand on the dial of this, like, fine, fine line where it, like, it kind of goes, it kind of slips from sexy to creepy in a way. And you're, like, sort of like, whoa, when did we get here? Like, there's not, like, a hard line or a funny moment or, like, it's just, like, suddenly you're like, oh, I'm uncomfortable. Yeah. And you don't kind of remember when you got there. Yeah. It's really amazing. It's also the kind of vulnerability of a human being where the
mystery becomes gone
SPEAKER_03and thus they become a little less sexy. It's the once you know what somebody looks like when they come. You either have to be in love with them or you have to never see them again. 1,000%. As John Mulaney said, anyone who's seen my dick and met my parents needs to die. But yet, like, it's every person who I have been with, Miss Allie Gordon, who has sort of been in my life, it's either, like... We did that once or twice.
SPEAKER_03It was nice. But now, like, we've learned to become, like, just really good friends. The very Gwen Fosse of it all. Or it's like, I can't be your friend. I know what you look like when you've gone to that moment.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And I think that because Fosse really only... Fossey's mentality has always been like, once I've seen you climax, I can't ever see you again. With the exceptions of Gwen and ranking Joan McCraken. McCraken? McLaughlin? McCraken. And then his first wife. Because Fossey had a wife who he cheated on with Joan and then he cheated on and married Joan. Then he cheated on Joan with Gwen.
SPEAKER_00Gwen. And then Joan died. And so on and so forth. and then cheated on Gwen with everybody everyone yeah but then he and Gwen split he got with Anne Ranking then cheated on Anne with everybody he and Anne split it's like he also was Julie Haggerty for a while like and Jessica Lange for a while
SPEAKER_03Jessica Lange I know yeah craziness but I I do think that because of how Bob Fosse was introduced to sex, which is ultimately that he was assaulted as a 13-year-old. And that moment is shown in the movie a little differently, but not that differently.
SPEAKER_00I think it's most close to life in Fosse-Verdon. I think I get the sense from reading stuff that what happens in Fosse-Verdon is pretty... Pretty accurate.
SPEAKER_03Pretty accurate. Yeah. Which is less that it's one individual moment and more like a series of moments, which is just like he was a kid who shouldn't have been around sex and was not just
SPEAKER_00around quote unquote adult things, but like literally sex, like witnessing it and having it done to him and like just like things that like shouldn't have happened to somebody that young.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, without getting too far into it, Fossey allegedly lost his virginity by sex happening to him, not by having sex with somebody. And it happened more than once with women who are much older than he was and with multiple women around him. So it wasn't it wasn't even private. It was like a very public spectacle. Yeah. his youth and his inexperience kind of made him easy prey to these older burlesque women.
SPEAKER_03So that, for that to be your introduction, it's actually, maybe it's because I'm on a Mad Men deep dive right now or right now. There's so much Don Draper, there's so much Bob Fosse in Don Draper.
SPEAKER_00Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_03To the point that you're like, did Matt Weiner watch all that jazz and kind of take notes on what to give Don for his origins?
SPEAKER_00I think in some ways, maybe. Like, I think it's funny that like all that jazz was, wasn't so warmly received because like to me when I talk when I hear film directors and things talk about things they're always like well and of course we watched all that jazz like to me it seems to be like this sort of like foundational text yeah so like I would be shocked shocked if if Matt Weiner wasn't like oh yeah I mean we
SPEAKER_03we watched all that jazz yeah we we watched that Well, ultimately, that comes down to what I've spoken about a lot on this pod lately, which is that there is no deciding factor on the quality of a work except for time. Time is what decides if what you made was good or not, because critics can give you all the praise in the world. And then in 10 years, everyone turns around and denies it or vice versa. Nobody likes it. And then 10 years later, everybody loves it. You can win all the Oscars and all the Tonys and people look
back and go, what were we doing?
SPEAKER_00Or being like, what show is that? I don't even remember that show.
SPEAKER_03And it doesn't matter if you're a passionate fan now. 20 years from now, everyone would be like, that show doesn't exist. And All That Jazz is a movie where, again, like the critics denied it. The public liked it, not to the extent that they liked Kramer vs. Kramer, but enough to make it profitable, enough to buck the critics. It goes on to win four Oscars, art direction, costume design, editing, and I think score. Yeah, four. Four Oscars. Should have won cinematography, but I think they lost their pocketbook.
SPEAKER_03They lost to Apocalypse Now. Whatever, Coppola. Whatever, man.
SPEAKER_00But also at the time, this is something I learned yesterday from reading stuff about it after the movie. They name dropped Stanley Kubrick in the film, which is so funny because Bob Fosse also thought he was great. But Stanley Kubrick, when he saw the film, did not take him 10 years to say this. He said, I think it's the best film I've ever seen.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00So he did say that. Some people were on it. Gideon is watching the latest cut of the stand up and he says something about Kubrick. He like has his hands, his head in his hands. He's like, do you think Stanley Kubrick ever gets depressed?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Such a funny line.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's so great. It must feel great. I think I think that's actually the ultimate validation for someone like Fossey, who clearly thinks highly of Kubrick.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, name dropped him.
SPEAKER_03Except for Kubrick to say, like, I just watched your movie. I think it's incredible.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And it's like, well, you know what you're talking about. And I think you're amazing. So because it's for someone like Fosse and it's not just the work, but it's them as a person. It's like, I think part of the reason why Fosse starts to like sour in his relationships is the moment someone like Gwen Verdon or Anne Rankin says, like, no, I choose you. It becomes, well, what's wrong with you that you chose me?
SPEAKER_00Exactly. But then it's that same. I mean, it's it's so great because it's so truthful. We're like everybody or most people have sort of a streak of self-loathing. And most people or the average person can keep it at bay. Some people can't. But like almost everyone in the world is a little bit like I'm a hack. I'm a loser. What's wrong with me? At some point, you know what I mean? And then like many people who are great have this like, you know, two sides of a coin where one of it is like there's something wrong with you for
SPEAKER_00trusting me because I know I'm garbage and I've got nothing to give you. So if you what's wrong with you that you think there's something here when there isn't. And then the other side of it is like. It's so fantastically parodied in all that jazz when they're watching the local New York TV review of the Lenny movie, which I forget what it's called, The Stand-Up.
SPEAKER_03The Stand-Up, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And she's like, ripping it to shreds is not a nice thing to say about it. The only time she says anything nice, she gives the credit to the actor and not the director. And then she's like, and that's why I give this on my classic rating of four balloons, half a balloon. And you're like... Making fun of these critics who not only don't have good opinions, but also have like dumb gimmicky bullshit where like you'd watch her thing and go like, why should I ever trust your opinions? Even if I agree with you, you've framed it around this like hacky bullshit daytime TV balloon regard.
SPEAKER_00It's like, fuck you. So it's like he's both saying like. I'm nothing. I've got nothing. Don't look too hard because you'll see my nothing at the core of me. And also like, and you also are even less than nothing. If I'm nothing, you're dirt. What the fuck's wrong with you? Like, lady who thinks she can critique me. You know what I mean? It's like, it's such a... But then he takes it super to heart is the thing.
SPEAKER_03Right. It's the... And everyone's telling him, like, she doesn't know what she's talking about. Oh, she's so stupid.
SPEAKER_00But it's funny because I think Joe Gideon takes it to heart, but I think Bob Fosse is overtly making fun of...
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00You know, critics in general. But that's so funny. Like, everybody knows what that feels like to be like, what's wrong with me? I can't go out there. I can't show myself. And then the minute somebody says something against you, you're like, why would I ever listen to you? You're wearing pleated khakis and loafers with no socks.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I couldn't possibly I couldn't possibly take your opinion to heart. You look like a girl. You look like a garbage nightmare. Like, look at the fuck out of my face. And you're like, oh, I guess I actually do have an ego. You know what I mean? It's the stories of Fosse, you know, battling with Hal Prince, not wanting to cut the ballet.
SPEAKER_03It's him battling with Stephen Schwartz about, you know, the orgy stuff of like, no, no, what I say is going to go. And ultimately, I think it's sort of, yeah, it reveals the confidence and the ego that you do have. But I also think, again, with someone like Fosse, and I think this is true of a lot of people, and I want to ask you about this because you've created a lot of stuff. There's the imposter syndrome is one thing, but then it's God forbid you make something that people really like and you look back and you're not entirely sure how you did it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, I feel that way almost every single time I make something. But I actually weirdly think that's kind of healthy, where you're sort of like, the project is the project, and it's not the next project. Certainly, you can take some lessons or whatever, but the next project is not the last project, so you do kind of have to just be like, oh, boy, I can't believe I don't know how the fuck that one came all together. There were multiple times when I was editing my book, because I've talked about this before already, but publishing takes such a long time. And for me, I finished a draft of this book that I started like sending to
agents and editors
SPEAKER_00and publishing houses. And it wasn't accepted for another two years. And then it took a couple months for them to get notes back to me. So I was editing a real draft of my novel about two and a half years after writing it. And there were multiple moments where I was like, who wrote this? Both in good ways and bad ways. There were some moments where I was like, this sentence is incomprehensible like who the fuck wrote this and there were moments where I was like oh my god like I was really on one that day like I don't know what I was feeling I don't know what I was thinking about I don't know where I was mentally
SPEAKER_00but I sat down and wrote this and like that that paragraph is Don't change it. Like, I captured something in that moment that I don't know if I could sit down and recapture right now. Like, I don't know if I'm even close to feeling what I was feeling in that moment. And so, like, there is sort of a healthy thing of just being like, well, thank God that worked, but hands off. Like, I can't make that happen in this next one. The next one's the next one. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03But it's that scene where Joe is talking to Angelique. Let's just call her Jessica Lange. That's who she is. Let's just call her Jessica Lange. She's the angel of death, essentially, is that Joe is constantly having these conversations with a beautiful woman in white. And then the more intimate they become, the closer he gets to death in real life. And then she eventually takes off her veil and literally the veil of death is
SPEAKER_00parting to let him through. Yep.
SPEAKER_03I mean, the shot where she takes off the veil and the hat for the first time and lets her hair fall down, that's when he goes into, I guess, cardiac arrest or something. Yeah. So it's, yeah, it's really beautifully done. But he's talking to her about, you know, nothing I do is ever beautiful enough. It's never right enough. I look at a rose and I go, God damn it, that's perfect. And I ask God, like, how the hell did you make that? Why can't I make something like that?
SPEAKER_00Why can't I make something like that? Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And it's the... By the time this comes out, my Sondheim-Weber show will have already happened. But something that's interesting about both Sondheim and Weber is that neither one of them ever really had a show that... Got all of the acceptance from every nook and cranny when it came out. Every show they've ever done, there was always something. So like, yes, Sondheim had success with West Side Story, but none of the critics mentioned him. He had success with Gypsy, but like the lyrics while they got praise were like the fourth
thing praise.
SPEAKER_01Correct, correct.
SPEAKER_03Forum was a hit, but no one cared about the score. Company was sort of a hit. It won Tonys, but everyone was sort of off on it. Follies, he won a Tony, but people didn't really like it. Night Music was a hit, but also that even that wasn't like universally praised. We Need Todd was universally praised.
SPEAKER_00I mean, like he gained a reputation for things that are hard to like. essentially which like becomes a badge of honor for people who love him people like ourselves people like middle school us being like fuck you I like passion like you know what I mean like that was you okay fine I mean this is a compliment but like you know by the time of things like of night music and Pacific Overtures and Sweeney Todd It was like, look, you either like it or you hate it. Do you know what I mean? Like, this is incredible. You're going to love it. Or you're going to hate it. You must be one of those people who hates Sondheim. But like, he always had this sort of like albatross of like,
SPEAKER_00his stuff is quote unquote hard to like. It's for a specific kind of audience. There's always going to be a kind of theater goer who will never get what he does. And so for people who love him, it became a badge of honor, which was like, well, I like the thing that you don't like, you swine. I get it.
SPEAKER_03It's not even that I like it. It's that I get it and you don't get it. And the thing about like even Weber, who deservedly has gotten dogged for a lot of the stuff he's done because he's done some great. There was a time when he was a lot more adventurous and more of a risk taker. And like him or not, he has contributed some major contributions to musical theater. Right. But things like Aveda and Jesus Christ Superstar were not respected when they came out. It took audiences to say, we like this. And even then, it was only really considered a popular state.
SPEAKER_03Only until like... I would say like the late 90s, early 2000s was Evita finally deemed like a great musical. Right. Totally. And my thing about Evita is I think it's not a good musical. It's a great musical, but not a good one. But that's a whole other story for another day. Never mind. Anyway, but even Fosse, like for the success and the fame that he got, there was always something that would go against it being like this whole big hit in the Fosse bio. They talk about Sweet Charity was like the biggest hit he had had as a director up until that point. It was like a genuine success was well received. It was a big comeback for Gwen.
SPEAKER_03It was a huge get for him. Everyone's like, oh, my God, Fosse, like, truly is a director. But then they would go, but the book is just sort of kind of OK. And he's like, God damn it. Like, I fucked that part up. And then Pippin, it's like, Fosse's got all this style and he whips up a frenzy on a show that has no right to be on Broadway. And he's like, I worked really hard to try to make this show get whipped into shape. God damn it.
SPEAKER_00Yes. I mean, like, and the more you watch things like All That Jazz and the more sort of, like, time goes by, the more you're like, right, Pippin is good because Bob Fosse was part of it. Yeah. Like, it's kind of the only reason it's as lasting as it is, especially the fact that, like, there was no ending to Pippin until Bob was, like... what if it's about wanting to die in a blaze of glory and realizing that you have to, like, be part of the world first? And you're like, oh, right, that's pure Fosse.
SPEAKER_03Well, they also weren't quite sure how they were going to end it, end it. And, like, the last page of that show has changed so much over the years. And I think the ending that it became now is not the ending that Fosse wanted. Like, Fosse wanted the one of, like, not too bad for musical comedy. Ta-da!
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_03And that was the end of the show. And I think Schwartz wanted the whole, like, what if little stupid Lewis, like, gets entrapped by the...
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Theo. Theo. Lewis is the gay half-brother, right?
SPEAKER_00It would be fun, though, if they were like, let's start the show over, but this time let's have it be the gay half-brother.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Sort of a better one. Yeah. No, it's complicated. And it's still not perfect, which is partly also, again, why I love Pippin, because I'm sort of like, this show is so flawed. Like, there's something kind of inherently fucked up here. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03So few musicals are perfect. And even then, like someone's going to come along and like find a flaw that you never thought of before.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, except for Sweeney Todd.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, there is really no flaw in Sweeney Todd.
SPEAKER_00You really couldn't convince me there's flaws there. I think the only thing, the only flaw I would say about Sweeney Todd is that
SPEAKER_03For all of the plot that hinges on Joanna's life and safety, we don't actually care about her as a character.
SPEAKER_00We don't know or care about her that much, but they do try.
SPEAKER_03They do try. I argue, I've always felt that the movie does a better job of fleshing her out by honestly making her genuinely damaged by the shit that's happened to her. Yes. Like, she becomes a shell of a girl by the end of the movie, and I'm like, I want that Joanna in the musical. But that's, like, every great artist... does have a blind spot and i think sondheim and fossey actually their blind spot is like genuine passion and emotion like of the of the sondheim always had a really hard time writing earnest love songs it's not like i love you
and you don't love me and i cry in my bed at night on my own like it's i love you you love me and isn't this exciting isn't this exhilarating he's like that becomes kiss me fossey's like i don't know fossey's like i can put sex on stage i don't know how to put love
SPEAKER_03making on stage i I don't know how to put vulnerability on stage. Anytime someone's vulnerable, it needs to be done with a wink. There was a quote in the book. I'm so glad that I was reading very specific sections of this book so recently because it's all it's all useful right now. But when Cary Grant saw Sweet Charity on Broadway, he said to Gwen Verdon, it's so weird watching you on stage because every time you cry, I laugh. And every time you laugh, I cry.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm. And it's like it's the finding the humor and the pain that makes an audience laugh and then finding the innocence and joy that makes us want to be a part of it.
SPEAKER_03I think, as you were saying, in the latter half of this movie, what makes you cry is like just a the craftsmanship of it all, but also then like the exuberance that comes with it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Like. The part that got me emotionally is in the bye-bye life when he's going around the
SPEAKER_03audience and saying goodbye to everybody. And it's that shot of him hugging Michelle goodbye. Because, like, it's the last person he gets to say goodbye to. And it's just a genuine, pure, like, it's the Ariel of Triton, little mermaid, I love you daddy moment.
SPEAKER_00But also, like, she won't let go of him again, which is, like, in the beginning of the show when she has, like, returned her. She's like, oh, our weekend's over. You've got to get back to mom. She's waiting in the car. And she, like, won't.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, she won't take her legs off of him, yeah.
SPEAKER_00She's, like, doing it again. It's, like, it shows that even in his subconscious, he, like, he's so flippant about his life and cigarettes and drugs. And he's, like, I'll say goodbye to anything. I don't give a shit. But then when push comes to shove, he's, like, I fucked up and I am losing my daughter. Like, oh, my God.
SPEAKER_03And it's that with the music happening of the, oh, give it to me. Like, it's that whole thing of just, like, the musical theater Rasmid has know-how of it. I said this before. Musical theater, creating musical theater in a lot of ways is psychotic. And you have to be a little bit of a sociopath.
SPEAKER_00I agree. I think you have to be a bit of a sociopath to like it. Well, I think you have to be, I think you have to be emotionally open to like it.
SPEAKER_03I think you have to be a bit of a sociopath to make it.
SPEAKER_00Great.
SPEAKER_03Love that. In a way that I don't always subscribe to straight plays because with musicals, it's a spielberg of it all where like music ultimately has to guide you in certain directions and you are creating the human experience in a very tight amount of time. Yeah. in some ways shallow medium and you have to find a way to get an audience to buy it as well as well as slightly manipulating them into being on board with like this emotion here and like this this music makes sense right now for
this emotion and
SPEAKER_03not making it seem like it's all calculated at the same time and Fossey was so fascinated by the machinations of creating that stuff that in a weird way, by not being able to connect to earnesty in film and theater, by revealing the shallowness of making it all, he actually did reveal a great deal of emotion within himself.
SPEAKER_00I mean, sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_03No, no, it was interesting. It was sort of like his... my lack of connecting my flaws ultimately reveals a lot of pain. And he gets to have his cake and eat it too in that moment in the movie because it gets that moment of the, it's exciting musically. The shot is gorgeous. So there's already just the know-how of making it. The emotion of Michelle adds a level of authenticity that doesn't make it feel shallow. And then the shot of Leland Palmer watching them with tears in her eyes. And when he says, at least I don't have to lie to you anymore.
SPEAKER_03And then she gives a little stick out the mouth-tongue move of like, oh, he got to have his final one-liner with a little bit of a joke in there. And so it's still exciting musical theater and emotional catharsis at the same time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I was going to say like, what you're reminding me is like, that thing we were talking about of like, did Fossey and Sana have a similar problem, which is like, Always needing to have another little like layer, like nothing truly earnest. But it's funny because like in those moments, sometimes what is revealed is a really truthful thing, even if it wasn't intended with like emotional earnestness. Mm-hmm. Sweet Charity is not my favorite show of all time. I don't think there's anything wrong with Sweet Charity,
SPEAKER_00but I'm not like, I'm riding hard for Sweet Charity. But what I think is kind of amazing about Sweet Charity, where I'm sort of like, I wonder if any other team could have pulled off this specific facet of it, is the weird dichotomy of that life. Which is that like in Hey Big Spender, the women are all fucking lying. They're like, oh, you're so tall. Right. And you're like, oh, they're in control. They're sexy. They're lying to you. These pathetic men come to them for help. But then they're also like they're also victims. These are women who have no other prospects in life. They're uneducated. They don't have a family like like these are women who are
selling their bodies
SPEAKER_00because there's nothing else for them to do. So it's like you're like, OK, they're in control. They're sexy. They're powerful. Right. These men are pathetic for wanting them and they deserve a better life. And then you get that unbelievably, in my opinion, earnest sequence of something better than this where they have such simple wants and dreams and you want them to have it so bad and nobody gets that. And like the show is full of those contradictions in that way where you're like... These women are in control. They're not in control. They have a dirty job.
SPEAKER_00They're the most pure people you've ever met. Do you know what I mean? The show does not make a definitive statement on any of those things. It holds all of those truths at the same time, which is why Charity is such a good and complex character and why you feel for her so badly. And then also why people are ultimately dissatisfied with the show, which is that she doesn't win and we're so sad for her. Do you know what I mean? That is, I think, ultimately why people don't like Sweet Charity. They're like, what? the fuck is that ending it's like it's nothing like this is a play it's a fucking musical so I don't know like I don't know if somebody not like
Bob Fosse who had these complicated feelings about sex and power and women and vulnerability and being a victim and sex as an act of power and sex as an act of taking away your power and right like he had all these complicated feelings and I think they're all in Sweet Charity do you know what I mean like not just like can take away like the
SPEAKER_00contributions of people like Cy Coleman but like If we can say, sure, he's not an emotionally earnest guy. He's not the kind of person who's going to stage a love song. He sure does put a lot of really, like, really truthful earnest stuff up, which is, I think, ultimately why he and Sondheim both have that measure of success and adoration where people are like, okay, well, if you don't get it, that's fine because I get it. Because you see something in it that speaks to you, that, like, just,
SPEAKER_00like, hits a vein where you're like, this earnest love song was beautiful and emotional, but it did not hit the vein. This hit the vein. Do you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I think with Fosse and with Sondheim, Sondheim's, one could argue Sondheim's greatest contributions to musical theater came with his collaboration with Hal Prince.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. there's that is an argument uh it's the one that's most commonly made and i think that there's a debate about all of that because i think where i think this i think that the sometimes score that bleeds the most is sunday i think that of all of the shows whereas passion is has a lot of love in there it's also just quite so distant i think sunday is the only genuinely earnest emotional show at least the first act
SPEAKER_03anyway is uh And I think part of that comes from his work with Lapine, who is also very esoteric, but I would argue Lapine is a more emotional creative than Prince ever really was. Prince was a really intellectual director. He saw things in tableaus and he came up with themes. He wasn't really about, like... Let's really sit and talk about your first heartbreak, you know, even something like Losing My Mind, which is a gorgeous song and really can make you feel something is done in the
SPEAKER_03under the guise of a show of a performance. Not a Day Goes By is a beautiful song that has never worked for me in context of Merrily ever. It only works for me in a concert setting. But that's also a Merrily problem. But Fosse's greatest collaborations came with Gwen Vernon, mostly because Fosse himself was not really a collaborator. He was a talent who did not know how to play well with others because he was often a terrible... The only people he really could communicate with were dancers.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_03He treated dancers like actors, and they understood him, and that's why they always wanted to work with him. And then he had certain designers who understood him, certain writers who understood him, but... There was a lot of turnover with him because he ultimately just always wanted control. And if he didn't know how to express what he wanted, he would get furious. Gwen was sort of the Fosse whisperer. And I think she gave him a lot of humanity as well as insight into women that he did not have. And I think that helps a lot, which brings us to Legacy and Fosse Verdon for a second.
If there's one thing that Fosse-Verdon as a miniseries pissed me off about was it's oversimplification of their relationship and their professional relationship.
SPEAKER_03Basically saying, Verdon was the genius. She came up with all the ideas, but Fosse got all the credit, which is just simply not true. Sure.
SPEAKER_00And I mean, I think it's I think we know it's not true because of the way she and everybody else in their lives speak about them. Do you know what I mean? Like if you talk to if you if you watch the interviews on the Fosse DVD with Anne Ranking, she's certainly not sitting there being like, thank God for Gwen, because she was the only one who knew shit. But also everybody on that DVD is like, oh, my God, well, I'm not sure if we'd be here without Gwen. Like, I don't I don't know if we could have had success without Gwen. Like, do you know what I mean? Like, everybody else seems so much more fair in the retelling of it.
SPEAKER_03The part of all that jazz that I wish, if we were granted, like, 10 more minutes of screen time for all that jazz, which I do not want to change anything about this movie. I think this movie is perfect. But, like, if you're to say, like, okay, Matt, if you could change one thing, I would say I want 10 more minutes of screen time, and I would love to show Leland Palmer being a bit more to the cast as Gwen was to companies, a la the Fosse Whisperer. Yeah. which is that Gwen was known for having an encyclopedic knowledge of dance, of an encyclopedic knowledge of everything she and Bob Fosse ever did.
SPEAKER_03So like there was, I guess she took over the Broadway company of Danson. or another road company of dancing and sort of became the person to sort of check in on or whatever. And she would alter things to help the dancers to make it less of a struggle, but also keeping Fosse stuff in there. But then she would also like watch dances that Fosse had recreated with another assistant. And she'd be like, that's not what we did in 1952. Yeah, yeah, yeah. At this point, she's like, no, no, this was the move. But so it was that.
SPEAKER_03And she also she and Fosse both had vocabulary that they understood and sometimes one of them would be able to describe it better than the others so like Fosse would tell the women in Big Spender you're tired but you need to be sexy in order to make the money like you want to go home but you need to make money tonight and the only way to make money is to be sexy so you have to be sexy from here up but from here down you're exhausted and like when that didn't work Gwen Verdon would come up and say you're broken dolls you're very pretty but you've been played with all day long
SPEAKER_03And and that was the way to kind of. And she would come up with ideas, but it was and she has said herself because she there's an interview. I think it's on Aurora Spider-Woman's channel. We brought her up again. hello backstage at sweet charity for the revival with debbie allen and the interviewer is asking gwen like why don't you choreograph why don't you direct like you're you help bob with all of this stuff like you know what to do and she was like i she's like no she goes i've tried that i literally did a show out in paris she goes i she goes the problem with my time with bob is like
dancing and now i'm also conflating with another interview with probably the golden age dancing made the most sense to her when it became bob fossey's choreography like there was
SPEAKER_03She was pre him with Jack Cole and Michael Kidd. And then with Fossey was like, oh, no, this makes sense to me. And this is its most fulfilling. And once she did that, she was like, I can't really go back to other people. And everything she did just sort of felt derivative of her work with Bob. And she doesn't have a director mentality. She was like... I feel like Gwen Verdon's role was like she was the ultimate legendary dramaturg. She could come in and she could help every department with something,
SPEAKER_03not by like having it fully formed, but seeing what was there, seeing what wasn't working and having like two ideas that ultimately fix
SPEAKER_00everything. Exactly. I mean, and that's like that is like such an insane superpower. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. But it's a specific superpower that you don't often get the chance to show if you don't get to that level of being in the room. You know, like, God forbid Gwen Verdon didn't have her can-can breakthrough and didn't become the woman she did. She could still have those instincts, but she would be like the third chorus girl to the left in Damn Yankees.
SPEAKER_00And nobody would have been really listening.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. And it's fortunate and kismet that it happened that way. Fosse-Verdin did not do that. Fosse-Verdin made it very much the over side and then also kind of made it a point to really, like if all that jazz went hard on Fosse, Fosse-Verdin went harder on him to the point where I was like, oh, Nicole Fosse. Yeah. your father and mother messed you up more than you will ever admit to letting on. It's also my issue with that movie, with that miniseries, is A, that she was the only person they consulted on it. They used the bio as their source,
and then she was their only consultant.
SPEAKER_03The other thing about Fosse Verdon that annoys me, and we've talked about this before, maybe not on mic, but definitely in person, it's my issue with Tick, Tick, but it's my issue with Blue Moon. I am the person from theater who doesn't like movies and TV shows about theater that often.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03All that jazz works for me. All of that Eve works for me. I don't like watching the Sunday diner scene in Tick, Tick, Boom and seeing Cheetah and Patty and Brian Stokes Mitchell. That to me feels like I'm being, to other people look at that as like loving fan service. I look at that as force feeding a little picky.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're like, look at these jingling keys. And you're like, I'm not a baby. I don't need to look at jingling keys.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, you love that, don't you?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03It's like in Fosse of Verden when it's, you know, oh, well, we're thinking of doing this thing with, oh, you know, Liza Minnelli, don't know her that well, but maybe she'll be good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, who knows? You're like, well, I know.
SPEAKER_03It's when Andrew Scott says in Blue Moon to Ethan Hawke, well, Oscar and I are looking into adapting Lilium. I'm like, no, you're not. No one gave you Lilium for another year and a half. Shut the fuck up. And just shit like that. That stuff pisses me off. What I like in All That Jazz is if you're in the know, you know that that set design for New York, L.A. is based off of the Chicago set.
SPEAKER_00Chicago, yeah.
SPEAKER_03But they don't draw attention to it. It's just there.
SPEAKER_00And if you don't know, you don't know. Nobody in my screening last night was like... I can't believe I didn't get the movie. I mean, like, what were they doing, Chicago? Like, nobody gives a shit.
SPEAKER_03No.
SPEAKER_00They're just watching the movies. It's a good movie.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. It's a great movie, but also, like, all those Easter eggs are genuine Easter eggs. Yes. They don't call attention to themselves. I feel like now, because of the Marvel universe, Easter eggs for theater people and this shit has to be, like,
SPEAKER_00so obvious. Yes. Yeah, yeah. I know what you mean.
SPEAKER_03It's Schmigadoon. It's Schmicago, and I just, I get... And get a little annoyed. But that's honestly also the legacy of All That Jazz is the legend of Fosse, which leads us to Fosse Burden.
SPEAKER_00Things like Fosse Burden, 100%.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, things like the Fosse Dance Review and whatnot. I feel like we've spoken so much about so many things.
SPEAKER_00I unfortunately have to ratchet up that work this afternoon.
SPEAKER_03I know. So with that said, Allie Gordon, where do you think All That Jazz leaves us as a society, as an entertainment industry, as artistes?
SPEAKER_00I mean, I think it is an incredible movie. I think it is, from a purely technical standpoint, an incredible movie. Like, you know, as soon as you see a movie that leaves you cold or you're like, I'm not sure if I loved that movie, but that was clearly like, I'm so glad I saw that movie. I think even if you don't love the film, I feel like it would be hard not to feel like... you didn't i can't imagine seeing this one feeling you wasted your time do you mean like it is just it is an insane achievement and then when you add on top of it being like the premise of this movie was i almost died and i
got real close to death why didn't i show you what that was like there's sort of like a an insane voyeuristic sort of feeling there where you're like how right is he what did he see
SPEAKER_00do you mean like like it's it's so great and of course the fact that It's not just that somebody got close to death and got a chance to make a movie about it. It's that one of the premier makers of anything ever got so close to death and then got to make a movie about it. And so then, of course, how he chooses to frame his existence is through song and dance. How lucky are we? You know what I mean? It could have been that a neuroscientist got this close to death and then wrote an amazing but very technical book about it. How about if one of the foremost directors and choreographers
of our time got this
SPEAKER_00close to death and then got to make a movie about it? And you're like, great, let's see some fucking dance. So it's just an amazing achievement in a lot of ways. I think the performances are incredible. I think the dance is amazing. I don't think you have to like musicals at all to like all that jazz. In fact, I think if you kind of hate them or find them a little corny, you might even like this movie more. It speaks to an element that you feel about musicals. Where you're sort of like, but it's all fake. And it's like, he's essentially going like, yes, of course it is. And so you might actually feel seen and respected as opposed to like,
SPEAKER_00well, no, you don't get it. You know, if I can get it, you don't get it. I think it's actually kind of a great movie for people who say that they have never seen a musical they like. Do you know what I mean? I would show them all that jazz. Be like, I know it's not technically a musical, but I think you'll like it.
SPEAKER_03I was about to say, it's not really that much of a musical. For a two-hour movie, I think there are like seven numbers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's not a ton. And there's nothing... There's nothing where, like, a person's like, I'm walking down the street and I'm... It's all...
SPEAKER_03It's all diegetic.
SPEAKER_00Sequences. Diegetic sequences. So, like, that's also, I think, more palatable for those who maybe, like, don't get musicals. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03I also think that this is a great movie to watch. There's like five or six movie musicals or musical sequences I tell people to watch if they want to look at how to like film a number or like just film a movie musical. And all that jazz is definitely one of them, especially now as we're like sort of back in the era of like gritty realism and people trying to make Les Mis a documentary.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm, mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, all that shit. So I think with all that jazz, Fosse has a way of having the realism and the stylization combined so that it all works out beautifully. And it's choreographed editing. Fosse was kind of the original choreographed editor.
SPEAKER_00I feel that, too.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's just it's so good. It's one of those movies that, like, I'm sure there are people out there who hate it. I have yet to meet one.
SPEAKER_03You definitely have yet to respect one. and i and i never will but again it's just great it's just it's uh and it's such a great portrayal of the 70s just like the the costumes the music the everything like i just think it's like it's just great film yeah and everyone's sweaty everyone's dirty all the time all the men are hairy it's great yeah there's there is a lot of
SPEAKER_00body hair in all the right places it's great yes it's hot it's wonderful Yeah, guys, if you forget anything about Allie Gordon, just remember she loves body hair.
SPEAKER_03And she wrote a book about a protagonist who's a dying bottom.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's true. That is also true. You don't know how much body hair is in places.
SPEAKER_03Well, first of all, let's be clear. Allie did not write Kiss of the Spider Woman. She wrote a different book about her dying bottom. Yeah. Anyway. Okay. So, Miss Gordon, this has been lovely. Where can people find you if you want them to find you?
SPEAKER_00Sure. You can find me on Instagram at Miss Alice Nutting, M-S-A-L-I-C-E-N-U-T-T-I-N-G. Also, my book, which is about a dying bottom, is called We Have Reached the End of Our Show, which is available basically anywhere that you want to buy books. If you're like, oh, cool, I'll order that. Yeah. You can order it from Amazon. That's totally fine. But if you have a local bookstore in your area that you know you like that is like an independent bookstore, there's a great website called bookshop.org where you can order the book to that store. So if you're like, I'm going to walk over to Books Are Magic and Greenpoint,
SPEAKER_00you can be like, I'm going to order the book to pick it up there. And that way, not... The website gets a profit, but so does that bookstore. So you're helping keep indie bookstores in business, which is great. Also, it's very possible that your independent bookstore already carries it. But if you don't want to take that risk or call and ask, you can just like pop a copy over there and pick it up. And everybody wins.
SPEAKER_03You heard it from the lady herself. If you guys want to follow me on Instagram only right now, at Matt Koplick, usual spelling. If you like the podcast, nice five-star rating or review really helps us out, either on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. I don't think you can do a review on Spotify, but you can always rate it. Yeah, and I think that the next official B-Way Breakdown episode will be my birthday Ask
SPEAKER_00Me Anything. How fun. Oh my God, it's so close to your B-Day. And it's so close to your concert. What an exciting time. Yeah, by the time this comes out, the concert will have already happened.
SPEAKER_03So everyone will be singing its praises, I'm sure.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And then there's another one in May, May 3rd, reviewing the 2025-2026 season. Reviewing is written R-E-V-U-E-I-N-G. And then June 1st is our Tony episode. Sorry, our Tony show and Tony episodes. But yeah, I think that's it. Ali, what do you want to close this out with? Do we do Miss Palmer? Do we do Miss Ranking? Who do we do?
SPEAKER_00I know. I mean, that's so... I mean, like, one of my favorite performances is Anne Ranking doing I'm a Brass Band. That's one of my very favorite, favorite, favorites of all time. Or does she do that? I don't know. Like, there's a concert of her doing it, and her legs are so long. But I also love Leland Palmer doing Spread a Little Sunshine. I feel like that is iconic.
SPEAKER_03I was like, can we do Palmer? She's never done it before.
SPEAKER_00I know. Let's do Leland Palmer, Spread a Little Sunshine, and let's all imagine Matt in his star turn as Fistrata.
SPEAKER_03I'm here for it. Oh my God. Next time you're in the city, I'm going to gather a bunch of our friends together and we're going to do like a drunk sit through of Pippin and we're going to gender bend everything.
SPEAKER_00I love Pippin.
SPEAKER_03You want to be Pippin or Louis or Theo or the leading player?
SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. I don't know. I actually think, as boring as this answer is, I actually think I'd be amazing as Catherine. I'd, like, really love to play that role. I think I'd be really good as Catherine. I know that that role is not exciting, but I think I'd be great in that role. And I never say that about anything. I never say I'd be good at anything.
SPEAKER_03Can I pitch something to you?
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Can we do one night as Pippin and Catherine and then another night as Charlemagne and Vastrada?
SPEAKER_00That's really fun. I actually really, really like that.
SPEAKER_03I think that's really fun. Yeah, baby. I'm really excited for that. We're going to figure that out.
SPEAKER_00Oh, my God. Okay, great. I'll get off books for war as a science.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Depending on what side of the coast one of us is back on, we'll make it happen.
SPEAKER_00We'll make it happen. Love that. Love it, love it, love it.
SPEAKER_03All right. Guys, this is our confirmation. You have to hold us to this. All right? Yay. All right. So take it away, Miss Leland. Bye. Bye.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...