WARNING: This episode deals with discussions of mental health and su*cide. Caution before listening. And with that, Matt’s Picks has come to a close with the final choice: NEXT TO NORMAL. Former guest Brian Nash (@brianjnash) returns to discuss the Tony/Pulitzer winning musical and many (though not nearly ALL) of its intricacies: mental health, complex relationship dynamics, and banging music. The two also discuss differences between the Broadway and London productions, fandoms, and how to perfect a Broadway diva imitation. Have a good August! @mattkoplik JOIN THE PATREON! Become a Company Member of The Broadway Breakdown Green Room for early episodes and exclusive content! Important Links: * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Listener Discussion Questions: “How do you feel NEXT TO NORMAL handles mental health and treatment? What would you say is its attitude towards medication and therapy?” “How would you describe the character of Gabe and is agency in the musical?” “Does this show need danger in its performances in order to fully register with audiences?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik. I'm so sorry. But with us today is a friend of the pod. He has not been on in such a long time due to his busy, busy schedule and honestly not finding a show worthy of his brain until now.
SPEAKER_00So please welcome back Mr. Brian Nash. Hi, Brian. Oh, hi, Matt. How are you? I'm great. It's so good to see your dumb, dumb gay face.
SPEAKER_01Oh, it is gay and it is dumb and it is jet lagged as shit, but that's fine. Well, I wasn't going to say anything because then you would have to say something about how I look right now. This lighting is homophobic. I'm sitting basically directly in a sunbeam that is making everything look so gray. Girl, it's a lot. You look very distinguished.
SPEAKER_00Sure, we'll say that. We haven't had you on in almost four years. That's terrifying. Because I know because you were on for the Hamilton episode, which we recorded in November of 2022. Why do you remember that date, Matt? Oh, Brian. Yeah, I think I mentioned this on the pod a little bit, but yeah, without giving too much away, we'll just say, if you guys ever want to debate just how much energy I put up, the day that Brian and I recorded the Hamilton episode, I was extremely going through it.
SPEAKER_00And if you want to re-listen to it and try to clock any moments, then maybe I'm going through it. I don't think you can tell. I put up a really good front. The only thing is that my mom comes in in the middle of recording to give me food. And that wasn't her being like, sorry to interrupt, I'm your mother. It was genuinely, I had not eaten for 24 hours. And she was like, you have a friend in front of you here on a microphone. I will listen back to the audio and know if you ate or not.
SPEAKER_01So the Hamilton episode, which is also very, very long. Matt is putting on the bravest of faces, borderline in tears for half of it, and housing French toast.
SPEAKER_00Pretty much, yeah. Which is honestly perfect for the episode we're talking about today. But yeah, and I probably will connect it a little bit to that time. I think I told you everything like right before we went on mic and it's like seeing your face go constant. I'm like, OK, so Skylar Sisters and you're like, sure.
SPEAKER_01Are we still talking about Burn? Are we doing are we talking about that song? Because are we just skipping it? Let's just skip it. Let's skip it.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, I think this will be what is ultimately a more intense show, but I think we're both in a lighter place for it.
SPEAKER_01I sincerely fucking hope so.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Brian, what are we talking about today?
SPEAKER_01We are talking about Next to Normals, which is a musical by Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkie. Broadway season 08? 08-09, yeah. 08-09 season, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I will do more of the deep dive on that in just a second. Before we do any of that, I have two major things I have to do. One is a new review that we got on Apple Podcasts. So please cue the line in the Piazza overture. Five stars. You're a star, Matt. There's a comment there. I can't get enough of Broadway Breakdown. Thank you for all the theatrical insight you share and for the labor of love that is podcasting. I credit you with my Tony ballot prediction win in my friend group. Bless you for that. You're welcome. So remember, guys, when it comes to Tony time,
SPEAKER_00this is the key podcast to listen to if you want to get a good ballot in your Tony party. You should get a cut. You know what she can do? She can join the Patreon, the Broadway Breakdown Green Room, $5 a month. This is a great time to remind you all.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm. See, that's the thing. Like if you you should do a Patreon like a paywall thing where you house the Tony predictions behind that.
SPEAKER_00Well, we're the patron is very brand new. She's she's a little baby right now. She's younger than Gabe was when he died. And so spoiler spoiler for I guess now's a good time to say spoilers for next normal. But sure. Yeah. As the Patreon continues, we're figuring out more of like just how much content will be on there and what will be excluded from the main feed. At the moment, what we're doing is just episodes early and then two exclusive episodes a month.
SPEAKER_00One is a cast party Q&A with me and the other is our Green Room Roundtable where we do rankings, which you know about because you contributed to that one. And then the one after that is going to be Best Actress in a Musical Tony Fantasy League or Fantasy Draft. Yeah, going to be certain categories and everybody's going to make their picks. It's going to be so faggy, but it's going to be delicious. God damn it, Matt. Yeah, I think I want to make sure you're there for that one. Gay! Yes, yes. Well, because you're going to have some choices, and I love it.
SPEAKER_00Certainly, I always do. But also, last thing, big, big, big news. As of a week and a half ago, I am officially a voter for the Drama Desk Awards. Oh, God help us all. Listen, the establishment needs my taste. It really does. If you were underwhelmed by some of the winners at the Tonys this year, at some of the Dramatis winners, guess who's coming in to shake shit up? Me and Jennifer Ashley Tepper.
SPEAKER_00But I think the two of us combined are enough to really make things, you know, shake the system a bit.
SPEAKER_01Did they only allow the two of you in or were there more? I think there were more.
SPEAKER_00I just I just know she was. Anyway, so next to normal. Sure. So next to normal for the uncultured fucks, this is OK, this is via MTI. They who license. They write, Dad's an architect. Mom rushes to pack lunches and pour cereal. Their daughter and son are bright, wisecracking teens, appearing to be a typical American family. And yet, their lives are anything but normal. Not even next to normal, because the mother has been battling bipolar disorder for 16 years.
SPEAKER_00Next to Normal takes audiences into the minds and hearts of each character, presenting their family's story with love, sympathy, and heart. I mean, it's not totally an inaccurate description, but it is an interesting way to open.
SPEAKER_01What in the CW sitcom is this? What the fuck? Yeah. Also, leading with Dan is really a choice. Dad's an architect, is he? Do we ever see him at work? Is that ever mentioned? Not once. Well, because she keeps taking him away from work. Yeah. The only time is like when she talks about them both being undergrads. Yeah. That is literally the only time. She's like, I thought I'd be too busy. That's it. That is the only time architecture is ever mentioned.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's a vibe to open with that. But like there are no lies necessarily in all of that. It's just it's a weird way to word it all. So, Brian, how did Next Normal enter your chat?
SPEAKER_01Next to Normal entered my chat in a very weird way. Okay, picture it. 2006, maybe? I was on a gay family Rosie O'Donnell cruise. That is a 2006 sentence. Yep, pretty much. And as was typical of the, the company was called Our Family. So it was for like gays and lesbians and their multi-ethnic babies. This was very cute. And because it was Rosie involved and kind of spearheading it,
SPEAKER_01there were so many Broadway folk on board. So 2006, that particular cruise, Alice Ripley and Emily Skinner were doing like a late night cabaret in the lounge. Skinner had just done workshops of Little Mermaid. So she did Poor Unfortunate Souls, which was great. Alice did a number from this show she'd just done a reading of that was hoping to come to Broadway that I think was still being called Feeling Electric at that point.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, and I think... I don't have a recording of it, but I think she did I Miss the Mountains. That's kind of what I remember. And I'm like, oh, that's cool. That's cute. And then my boyfriend at the time proposed to me later that evening on the front of the ship and I felt cornered and I said yes, even though I didn't want to. Yeah. And I oop. Okay. And I oop. So that is the first time I heard anything from The Next to Normals. And then saw the, I didn't see it off Broadway.
SPEAKER_01I saw the transfer. So I saw original cast and then I saw when Brian went in. And that's it for the Broadway production. And then we'll get into later stuff later on. How did it enter your chat, Matt?
SPEAKER_00Well, Brian, thank you for asking. As you know, I am a theater fan. Shocking. But I had been so from an early age and like even as a kid was like interested in the business side of stuff would read the grosses, would read the trades. Like my dad got me a weekly subscription to Variety because I was so annoying about it. And My first knowledge of Next to Normal was a review in Variety for the second stage production, which had a photo of Alice Tripoli holding the birthday cake and Brian Darcy James next to her.
SPEAKER_00And a lot of reviews were very big about like, don't spoil the show, don't spoil the show. And unfortunately, like you can't really talk about the show without spoiling it. It's one of those things where it is a great twist and it's done early enough, but it does make it difficult to talk about the show with people who don't know it because you're like, to talk about the themes and not undersell it, you have to talk about what the themes are tied to anyway. So the review was a little vague, and it was talking about how there was a show there, but it just didn't work yet.
SPEAKER_00And it was a genuine rock musical, and Spring Awakening had just come out, so everyone was like, oh, this might be the next Spring Awakening show. There was a feeling that they could... Transfer it to Broadway that same season. Because, you know, In the Heights and Passing Stranger are obviously going to be like the critical darlings, but no one really thought that Xanadu was going to do well. That sort of surprised people. And everyone was sort of like, you know, Crybaby who? But Next to Normal ended up not doing that, so Crybaby became the fourth Tony nominee.
SPEAKER_00And so the big thing with Next to Normal that was surprising that I remember everyone was talking about in the trades was it was the first... So I saw it on Broadway.
SPEAKER_00And I remember being a little whelmed by it at the time. I was in the front row. It was right after it had opened. And I just wasn't super taken with it. And I'm a very big proponent of like, I only stand when I'm really... Feeling like I saw something that hit me. And so I didn't stand. I applauded. I was I looked up and I was the front row. So like Alice Ripley saw me and she absolutely like gave me a death glare.
SPEAKER_00And it's one of my it's one of my prouder moments. And I kind of put it away. I have bought into it a lot more since then, and it's primarily due to a specific production that got a pro shot recently, and we'll talk about that a little bit. But I think it's sort of the interesting thing for me of this pro shot has not only revitalized the show's relevance, but has created an even more fervent fan base than the first time around. Because the first time around, it was an intense fan base and was maybe...
SPEAKER_00Along with Spring Awakening, like an early indicator of like the Paris social relationships that fans and actors had to like maneuver. Yeah. Yeah. And so I think I also stayed clear of the show because even though in addition not loving it, I just didn't like the vibe of the fandom. But anyway, yeah. So that's my that's that's my whole history with Next to Normal. So when you got to see it on the Broadway, what was your feeling?
SPEAKER_01I loved it. I thought it was gorgeous. I thought it was devastating. I loved the performances. I thought the staging was pretty incredible. I took a friend who got obsessed with it. He saw it I think seven times in various permutations of the cast. And so I really... I love a rock musical. I am a rent girly from way back. I fully slept out on the street several times to see that damn show, including in a Chicago winter to see Anthony Rapp in it.
SPEAKER_00Those who don't understand, Brian is a dedicated person. I see things. Well, anyone who follows you on Instagram, and if you don't do it now, you'll know that this is a boy who follows Tori Amos around everywhere.
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, so we can discuss that as well. So I am, I was unfamiliar with the parasocial fandom of Next to Normal just because I wasn't really in, I wasn't about the message boards or anything at that point. I'd kind of like ducked out of that. And so I didn't know how bad it had gotten. But If you know Tori Amos, that is also an angsty, angsty fan base. And people who tend to kind of tap into deeply emotional subject matter
SPEAKER_01that tackles some, you know, pretty intense topics. Knows that that fan base is going to kind of glom onto the person who's creating that in a very intense way. So it is unsurprising to me that the fandom of a musical about a woman with bipolar disorder and suicidal tendencies is going to be pretty intense.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it got very bad. Yeah. That and Spring Awakening are the two fan bases of my youth that I just remember getting so turned off by and I think were instrumental to me as a teenager of making sure I didn't become that. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And also, I don't desire to know what fucking yogurt shop Aaron Tveit goes to on Wednesdays. Like, who cares? Who the fuck cares? Yeah, so that was always my thing that I think also kind of kept me away from him. But yeah, shows like Next Normal. These shows that seem to be about the underdog in some respect that deal with isolation and depression and loneliness and this idea of being on the edge and almost going too far but finding your way back. The people who struggle with those things every day are always looking for some sort
SPEAKER_00of connection, some sort of identification. And when they find it in some way with shows like these. It is easy for that passion to go too far. And especially in the early Wild West days of social media, because at that point it was just basically Facebook and Twitter and YouTube, sort of. People were doing vlogs and whatnot.
SPEAKER_01Look, when it's the Newsies fan base, that's a fan base who loves this show and loves these performers because they're adorable twinks who can do jump splits.
SPEAKER_00That's how we have Offsiders and Lost Boys now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, seriously. It's just newsies, you know, in different pants and slightly different hats occasionally.
SPEAKER_00And slightly different teeth now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Those, you know, the twinks know they need to be Instagram ready now. But having a fan base that's seeing themselves reflected in a woman who is literally fucking nuts is going to be a slightly more intense and maybe dangerous fan base.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I also find stories about families are triggering and fodder for a lot of people, which is not to diminish the genuine joy that the show brings to a lot of people. As I said, I have found my corner of joy with it now. But yeah, it's it's. For me, it's always been the piece itself is what gives me the joy, not necessarily the people. Sometimes I really love a performance and I gravitate towards that. But then again, it becomes like I really love the craft.
SPEAKER_00I don't love the person. But, you know, there are plenty of performers I've met now where I'm like, oh, yeah, you're so talented. Oh, I met you now. Yeah, we don't have to do that part again, but I'll see you and stuff. Yeah. But yeah, but I think we'll start diving into the actual material of the show now. But this is we're kind of tiptoeing around the subject just because in order to talk about the material itself, we also kind of have to talk about the effect it has on audiences. And, you know,
SPEAKER_00it also always comes with a backlash in terms of how it portrays mental health and how it portrays therapy and ECT. And I did some research on my own yesterday, not to sound like a Long Island mom who's like, I did my research on vaccines and here's what the Internet told me. But I wanted to sort of see like, OK, what how is ECT practiced today? What is the, you know, medical communities feeling on it? What is the backlash of it? Why do people feel a certain kind of way and X, Y, Z? And then I read some essays about Next to Normal and its relationship with ECT.
SPEAKER_00And there are also a lot of YouTubers now because the pro shot is out of people saying, you know, I'm doing my reaction to Next Normal and telling you the things that gets right, things that doesn't get right as a person who has bipolar, somebody who has PTSD, things like that. So I thought it's I like having all this information out there. The problem is, is like it's up to you to filter it, which is. Fucking scary and dangerous. But yeah, we'll talk some more about it. So speaking of the woman who's fucking nuts, our leading character is Miss Diana Goodman.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Dear, dear Diana Goodman. She has been through it. I love musicals about women named Diana. Oh. That's it. That's the mashup we need. Just the entire show. Just combine them.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Just do the entire plot of Diana Goodman, but it's to the score of Diana.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So Dr. Madden, like when he emerges as the rock star, comes up as James Hewitt on the pony.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Duh. Duh.
SPEAKER_00I love it. I love it. I love it. So who is she? What's her life? What's her story? Who is she when we meet her?
SPEAKER_01Where is she at? So we meet her as the MTI description, as a typical suburban mom. She's staying home and she's making sandwiches. So, yeah, they try to set it up as like, yeah, we're the perfect loving family. And then she starts to have a gentle mental break throughout the opening number. And finally ends it.
SPEAKER_00And we were introduced to the rest of the family throughout the number because when the number begins, it's three in the morning and her son has come home late. And through that, people start weaving in and out. The son goes to his room. The husband comes out. She says, I'm going to fuck you in five minutes. And so they do that. And then we meet the teenage daughter who's younger than the son. And she's very smart, but she's manic and clearly on the edge of a breakdown as well. And Everyone's just sort of trying to get through the day. Just another day, they say.
SPEAKER_01Typical opening number, but with a twist. Which, at second stage, they opened with Light, which is now the closing number of the show.
SPEAKER_00Which I bookend with those songs.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, which I'd forgotten about because I actually texted Charlie Alterman, who was the MD of the Off-Broadway and Broadway Productions and Kennedy Center. And I was like, okay, so that theme that comes in at the very top of the prologue, was there a name? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00God damn it. I was going to sneeze.
SPEAKER_01Oh, God damn it.
SPEAKER_00Fuck you next to normal. I wanted to sneeze. But it was it was just Dan and Natalie and Diana. Like they were all just singing light sort of in different pools. And then it went into Gabe showing up late in the night. And so they just cut all that and went straight into Gabe showing up early, which I think is correct. Like just to quote Diana, dive in with both feet. Yep, yep. It's a very good move.
SPEAKER_01The changes that they made between Off-Broadway and Arena Stage were remarkable. Like, that is just a pure lesson in go ahead and kill your darlings.
SPEAKER_00Speaking of Gunkel, Adam Ellsbury, he did see it Off-Broadway, and then I think he said he saw the very first Broadway preview, or maybe it was the second Broadway preview, something like that. And he liked it at second stage, but similar to the critics, he was like, there's stuff here that needs to go. And he told me the feeling he had watching Act One, just going like, oh, they fixed it. They got it. And he just had that feeling for the rest of the show, which is, that's a very exciting feeling to see a show that you enjoy but know that the potential hasn't been met and then seeing it again and they met it.
SPEAKER_00Because like they... As Brian was saying, they made actual changes. This wasn't like, oh, we cut a line here, we moved some stuff around. No, they fucking cut songs, they added songs, they rewrote whole lyrics to songs. They went in.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I kind of felt that when I saw Dear Evan Hansen at second stage. And I'm like, oh, okay, this is in good shape, but they will definitely make some changes. That Sincerely Me song has got to go. Boo. And yet... And yet, and yet, like, why does everyone try to write Teenage Boys that way? Okay. Yeah,
SPEAKER_00but like, how many times have we seen this happen with shows where we're like, oh, that's clearly a booger, get her out of here. And it just stays. It just stays. I don't know why. Like, they... They understood it took them so long to realize that like Costco, the song where Diana has a breakdown at Costco had to go because the show had been in development for a decade by that point. And it took second stage for them to go, oh, this needs to get cut.
SPEAKER_01Well, interestingly, it felt like the tone was always supposed to be, even from the 10-minute BMI workshop version that they did in, what, 98, 99? Yeah. It was supposed to be kind of a comic, ironic look at ECT, which is why the Phelan Electric title, which is terrible, stuck with it for so long. Phelan Apostrophe Electric. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Girl, no. Which is to say, hold on to what you were going to say for like 30 seconds as I just lead us up to this moment. The show started as an idea by Brian Yorkie because Yorkie and Tom Kitt met at the BMI workshop and started collaborating together. And at BMI, you have to do a final presentation. You have to do like a 10, 15 minute musical. And Yorkie was watching a story about ECT electroshock therapy. And he literally went like, they're still doing that because our collective minds think back of like the 50s
SPEAKER_00and 60s, which is like this barbaric thing. And so he wanted to make a musical about that. They called it Feel and Electric. And they spent the next like four years kind of fleshing it out into a full musical. They did an actual reading in 2002 at a theater in Washington, the Village Theater in Issaquah, Washington, where Yorkie was the associate artistic director. Then they would do a string of readings for a few years in New York, one of which starred Sherry Renee Scott and Norbert Leovitz, which my God, I want the audio of that.
SPEAKER_01Sherry talks about it in the show that they did together, Two Hander, where basically after last five years, just casting directors put them together and everything. So they did readings of that. They did readings of Honeymooners. There were like four different projects that they were just paired together on continually.
SPEAKER_00But like as well they should have because they're awesome together. Yeah. But like, I want a sideshow with Sherry Renee Scott and Norbert Leo Butts. But, you know, nobody lets me do what I want. Nobody lets me do what I want. But so, yeah, they do one. Then they do a premiere at the second annual Nymph. This is where a lot of musicals that you've come to love, like Title of the Show, premiered. The season that they do it was the second one. So that was Yank and Gutenberg. That was 2004? I think so. 2004 or 2005. Okay. 2004 or 2005, something like that.
SPEAKER_00This one starred Amy Spanger and Anthony Rapp and Annalie Ashford. It won no awards that year because none were really given, but there were 12 productions that were given a quote-unquote Next Link selection, which provided funding and support for a future production. Feeling Electric was not selected, but I believe that is where David Stone came to find it, and he came on board as the producer, and they did further development at Second Stage with Alice Ripley, Greg Edelman, Phoebe Stroll, and Skylar Astin. And Stone and Second Stage were the ones who were like, you need to change the title.
SPEAKER_00This title is terrible. And so they changed the title, but the tone remained the same, which is why people were so confused. And so that goes back to what Brian was saying earlier of the sarcastic, quippy, satirical tone.
SPEAKER_01And keeping the tune Feeling Electric, because Feeling Electric at Second Stage was the closing of Act One.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the doctor sang it, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. And it was like a, you know, a big old rock number about electroshock therapy. And that's what you left act
SPEAKER_00one with. Think about how Next Normal actually ends now. It used to be a big, fun rock number for Dr. Madden.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. And then going back to what Matt was saying, there was a number. So at the end of the opening number now, Diana has her first mental break where she's making sandwiches on the floor. They saved that and just the number got a big old traditional musical theater button. And then we went to Costco with Diana and she had her mental break whilst shopping in Costco with a number called More, More, More.
SPEAKER_00Mm hmm.
SPEAKER_01It was not great. But again, it was very silly. The tone of it was wildly different than anything that's in Next to Normal now. And it set you up for a show that it's not.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's also... I watched some of it. It's a very overly staged number, more so than that production ended up being. Because what I remember about the original production was sort of... Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Say what you will about the original staging, but it did have that kind of just Michael Greif vibe of unit scaffoldy set, not a lot going on on the stage, and it's really just about how the physical bodies move in the space, as opposed to like, oh, we got a pile of bells and whistles. So it did feel very Wren-like.
SPEAKER_00I'm also the only one who really had gripes with the original staging. And there are things in the original staging that I like, certain details that they put in that I actually will talk about when we compare it to the London production. Just certain things that I remember Greif did. And then I went back to the library to watch it again so I could really kind of think about the nuances of everything. And they filmed it, I think, in November of 2009. So Aaron was back because he left... Aaron left the summer after the Tonys to do Catch Me If You Can in Seattle, I think.
SPEAKER_00And then he came back that winter to finish out his contract. And it was interesting watching it again, what Greif was doing on a larger canvas than being up front and up close like I was. So yeah, that was interesting to me. What is your favorite number in this show, Brian?
SPEAKER_01Um, it changes. It really depends. I mean, I think I Am The One is incredible. And the way it keeps coming back, I feel, is very, very effective. Yeah. If you don't know, I am the one is- It's a great scene. I think really feels like the show to me. It's where it crystallizes the most for me. I mean, I Miss the Mountains is incredible. I think it's gorgeous and does really good things.
SPEAKER_01We can talk about the London versus the original later because I have thoughts.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01But yeah.
SPEAKER_00What is your favorite? Um, I do think that the opening is pretty fantastic. I think it sets up the scene and the tone really well. I... If I'm listening to anything, it might also be You Don't Know into I Am The One. I think that whole sequence is fantastic. I also really love... I tend to like sequences in Next Normal more than, like, the singular songs. You know, I think every teenager really likes Superboy and the Invisible Girl.
SPEAKER_00I actually... I like it less now over time. I think it's a perfectly good song, but it also comes right after such a banger scene. And it's so short that I'm always like every time I've watched it now with like the London production and going back to the library, it's, you know, you have this extended sequence and then you get a two and a half minute number with an applause break. And you're not used to that a lot in Next Normal. You tend to have longer stretches with applause. So for me, I'm always like it's like a little pit stop.
SPEAKER_01Very much so. And I think that's actually a lot of what they fixed between Second Stage and Arena. Like, they did create more extended sequences. Like, they cut the button from the opening number. They cut a lot of buttons, which is great. Yeah. Which is why Superboy and the Visible Girl, but it's like, clap, clap, clap, clap, clap. Feels weird. Yeah. But I feel like it's a... Better and more complicated score than it gets credit for. Oh, for sure. It's a rock musical.
SPEAKER_01It is. There are rock vibes to it. But as a score, musically, it is so complicated. Superboy and the Invisible Girl is in 11-8. Like, it is in a time signature that does not exist. And there's a lot of kind of dropped beats and added beats in order to make it feel less square and more unsteady just kind of throughout the score. And I think it's incredibly smart musical writing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, there's, I think, I've always thought that the score was fantastic and rightfully won the Tony that year. For me, again, it's just, it's the longer sequences. The Make Up Your Mind sequence, I think, is fantastic. I love how it intertwines all the different characters. Yeah. I've always kind of... Whenever I've re-listened to it, I've always kind of trailed off before Act 1 ends. I don't know if it's that I don't want to go to a dark emotional place when I listen to it or if it's just that the songs don't do it for me as well.
SPEAKER_00And watching the London pro shot and then watching it at the library, I think Act 2 actually has a lot more nuance than it gets credit for. And we'll talk about that with a certain story beat that happens with Diana. There is a song that I... I don't like. I just flat out don't like. And I wish that they would take another stab at it. It's called The Song of Forgetting. Sing a Song of Forgetting. I'm just like, I think we can try that once more.
SPEAKER_01It is gently on the nose. And I don't know who we're talking to or why. There are these moments in the kind of opening number where we break the fourth wall. And I don't know who we're talking to or why. And then we never do that again. And I do think that it's deliberate, but I kind of don't know why.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it plays fast and loose with theatrical storytelling devices, which it's not a ding against the show, but... I think it is a symptom of how fast and loose it plays the material. With that comes some dramaturgical hiccups. Very few shows are like objectively perfect, but it is something to consider. Yeah, like, you know, Dan has a side to the audience in the opening number that he never really does again. The like, I never know what she's talking about.
SPEAKER_00It's yeah. It's like, who is he talking to?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. That always bothered me in a way that I think it's on purpose to kind of let us into this world and then we kind of forget that we're in the world and then the world is just happening to us. Whereas if we didn't have those kind of moments where the characters are clocking, where things are going a little askew, we wouldn't necessarily know that this is their everyday existence. That he's clocking it and then letting it go and
SPEAKER_00deliberately letting it go. Yeah. I don't know if there's a quote-unquote fix for that at the beginning to make that clear and not break the fourth wall. I don't know. Maybe. Maybe there is. All I'm saying is I would like to maybe rewrite Song of Forgetting. And hey, if there are a couple of lines here and there we want to take another pass at, absolutely. Because I do think the show works very well. I think there are moments we could make even better.
SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. Song of Forgetting is a little gently on the nose. It's the only song I
SPEAKER_00don't like.
SPEAKER_01It's the only one I don't like. I mean, every time I do, so like when I'm playing out in the world and people ask for I'm Alive, which is weirdly frequent, that lyric just feels insane out of context. Oh, sure. And listening back to the second stage, like the old lyrics were very much not good. They do that. They knew, and they kind of fixed. But, you know, a character who is very much dead, just screaming about how alive he is, is hilarious to me.
SPEAKER_01Like, girl, protesting
SPEAKER_00too much. Well, I think that's the other thing of the vagueness of Gabe. So, okay, so... If you want more context, then I'm assuming everyone who's listening to this knows Next to Normal pretty well. I'm sure there are people who love the show with every fiber of their being who found this on their For You page and probably clicked off in the first five minutes when we didn't immediately start talking about Jack Wolf. But, but I, but I don't know. Anyway, uh, Diana, we find out, was diagnosed with bipolar disorder when she was about 21, 22.
SPEAKER_00But she also says that she's not convinced and her doctors weren't convinced that that was fully the extent of it. So we have a name, but we're also being told don't. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so what we learn is that they are not a family of four. It is not Diana, Dan, Gabe, and Natalie. It is simply Diana, Dan, and Natalie. Because Gabe was their first child who died when he was eight months old. And Diana... Has been holding on to Gabe in some way, which I want to talk about that as well, of like, what exactly is this manifestation of Gabe? Has he always been there? Is this something that's happened before? Is this new?
SPEAKER_00Like, what is this going on with him? Because the introduction of him seems to be kind of this taboo subject, and that's sort of what makes the plot start to spiral, is the fact that, like, she's physically... Interacting with him in front of the family in a way that causes things to go into chaos. But you have an actor playing an 18-year-old version of Gabe, or what Diana would imagine Gabe is.
SPEAKER_00And in different interviews with different collaborators and different actors, there's always a different mentality of what that role represents and what his intentions are. And I would love to discuss it with you. Because I don't fucking know. And I'm trying to figure it out for myself. And of course, things are open to interpretation. But yeah, there's... Yeah. How would you describe this role?
SPEAKER_01Huh. I mean, it is... It is challenging to describe, and I kind of didn't clock how... Much was influenced by the original production, the original staging, until I watched the London Pro shot. Because the tone of how they create and manifest Gabe is very different than the original Broadway. He's kind of fucking evil in the original production, I feel. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01He's trying to kind of manifest himself in a way that is incredibly aggressive. I mean, he's kind-ish to Diana when he's not trying to get her to, you know, do things to herself. Unalive herself, yeah. But he is vicious with Dan. He's absolutely vicious in trying to get Dan to acknowledge him. Yeah. And... I felt in the London production,
SPEAKER_01that kid was so sad and he's like just trying to come back in a way.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01As opposed to impose himself on the family. It's weird being a twink ghost. It's a challenge. Twink ghostery is, you know, it's a hard profession.
SPEAKER_00There's got to be more of those, of twink ghost roles in musical theater. Maybe that's our first Broadway Breakdown merch of like the names of- Twink ghosts. Twink ghosts, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, in that kind of American Apparel font. Yeah, like the name list. Huh. Who are our other twink ghosts?
SPEAKER_00I don't know. You think about that for a second. So my thinking of Gabe, which I actually... Another reason why I'm really partial to the London production is because of how they portray him and how Jack plays him. He was this sort of... Malevolent creature in the original production of, you know, first he's this all-American boy and then as the reveal happens that he doesn't exist really on stage, they had Aaron and then Kyle Dean Massey sort of snake around the stage all the time
SPEAKER_00and you would go up and down on all the levels and he would always sort of look around and be brooding. As Brian said, he kind of comes across as very evil, but also like in control, like this overlooming presence. And I think that's partly why I never... I bought the show at the time because I didn't buy that. I didn't buy that as a storytelling device that he is this creature that's in control of everything. And it made the finale with Dan kind of confusing to me for a while. I wasn't quite sure what was going on.
SPEAKER_00And the London production kind of unlocked it for me in a way, which is that Gabe just genuinely doesn't exist. He is a representation of grief and trauma and all of these things and jealousy for Natalie and all these things. And so he acts to each character as How they feel about him. So he's not actually in control. He is domineering and mean-spirited to Natalie because that's how she's kind of feeling about that presence. He is comforting and seductive to Diana because that's how she feels about him.
SPEAKER_00And he is invisible and annoying to Dan and then eventually aggressive with Dan because that's what he needs. But this idea of... I'm alive. It's not necessarily him as a creature singing to the audience. I am now in power and control and I can do all of these things. He doesn't actually do anything. He's a The whole point of Dan is that he will never actually say Gabe's name. He doesn't want to talk about the son.
SPEAKER_00When Gabe died, his mentality was give Diana a couple of months to process because we learned that Gabe was an unplanned pregnancy when they were in college. They got married to... Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And it kept just becoming this foundation that was built on rotten ground. And so Diana kept being told to put that in the past, but in the past. And yet she was still sort of harboring all of these emotions and emotions. All these feelings with no place to go. And so Dan's whole arc with Gabe is eventually being able to recognize him and acknowledge him and open up the floodgates too. That was such a painful thing that I never really allowed myself to access. Now I will.
SPEAKER_00Which is why in the London production, his interaction, Jamie Parker and Jack Wolf's interaction, I actually really love. Because it's a little bit like a wrestling match. Like, no, no, you will, you have to say my name. And he does. And it becomes like, it's painful, but it is freeing. And I really enjoyed that. Whereas in in New York, I was like I remember like Aaron coming out of the shadows like a goddamn snake. I'm like, oh, God, is he going to murder Dan? And I go, no, he can't do that. He's not real. But then he like hugged him. And I was like, what is going on?
SPEAKER_00I don't I remember just being very, very confused. And maybe it's because I was a dumb 19 year old. But that was me at the time.
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, look, that scene, the writing is very effective. I think the way it was kind of staged in New York, again, I didn't realize it was less good until I watched the London Pro shot. Basically, he's like, hugs him, you know, Brian Darcy James slash Bobby Spencer says, says, Gabe, Gabe, Gabriel. Then he hugs him, he's like, hi, dad, and then he just kind of runs out. After the acknowledgement, what struck me is that how... Gabe is then removed to the upper level of the house in London, and he's just broken.
SPEAKER_01Like, he is so sad because he's been released, and now he has nowhere to go. And I think that's, like, Gabe finally letting go of the family, and now is just a sad, lonely ghost child.
SPEAKER_00He's officially just a ghost twink.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And now he doesn't exist and he doesn't have any anchor. And so as the family is healing, he's broken. Yeah. And I loved that. I didn't expect to love that. I was trying to look up, I'm looking up the lyric, because what you were saying about I'm Alive, about how he's, you know, the London version was less about him manifesting his power. That kind of goes against the lyric that he's got in the opening. What is it that like, the world will feel... No, uh, in the opening, like the world will feel my power and obey.
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah. Is that the lyric for just another day when the, uh, another stolen hour when the world will feel my power and obey. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So, I mean, the direction for New York feels based on that line.
SPEAKER_00Um, and London was like, no one will remember that. I just, I genuinely feel like the London production with both direction and honestly with performances, I just feel like it actually has a better understanding of mania and hallucination. And I don't know, like, obviously what I appreciate about Jack Wolf's performance is he does play Gabe Lewis. Yes. Yes.
SPEAKER_00An ID and a tight t-shirt, which is, you know, nice working. And boxers for that opening number. But people also conflated the two memories of the opening number in I'm Alive because they'd be like, to watch Aaron debate in boxers sliding around on those poles. I was like, he didn't do that. Nope. He was in boxers and then he was on the poles. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Which, you know, is my typical Saturday.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I'm hoping that I'm making sense to the listeners here. Everybody always wants to do the easier thing. No matter who you are, the harder thing is always exhausting. And sometimes the harder thing is acknowledging the pain that you have. Sometimes the harder thing is Working through the pain that you have. So like Diana, what makes Gabe seductive to her is that it's easier to stay in this soft landing spot with 18-year-old Gabe than to actually work
SPEAKER_00through therapy of letting him go. Dan, it's easier to just not acknowledge him than to actually talk about this awful thing that happened when he was 22 that... Kind of fully destroyed his life, even though he has managed to build something on that. As I said, it's on rotted ground. And Natalie kind of blames Gabe, even though Gabe has never actually done anything to her other than die of a bowel obstruction. And so... Again, he's not actually doing anything.
SPEAKER_00How he acts on stage is based off of what the actual physical characters on Earth are feeling about him and doing with their own lives. Does that make sense? And I'm not trying to put autonomy on people who are struggling and say, like, if you're not working on it, you're the problem. But... Just tying it to that role is sort of how I've always felt about it now. How I've always felt about it now. I haven't always felt that way. I feel about it that way now. And it was something that I just sort of watched with the London production of...
SPEAKER_00Even when when Jack would like have an evil grin on his face, I would go like, but I don't think that you're evil. I think that you're evil to him. I think you're evil to her. And I think you're caring to her. So like, I don't think that Gabe is seducing Diana to unalive herself. I think that Diana is in that moment of the I Dreamed to Dance, which is when after her breakthrough in therapy, she's supposed to go home and like sit with Gabe's things and like fully release him. And she should. That is ultimately what will set her free.
SPEAKER_00But she can't do it. And it's not that literally the ghost of Gabe whispers in her ear, kill yourself. It's that she's just like, I can't. She's like, I just can't do it. And it's a theatrically enticing way to show it by having the actor representing Gabe be there for her. That is a way for audiences to understand what's going on. It gets more complicated because then people think this is a ring situation. What was that Sarah Michelle Gellar movie where she was in the haunted Japanese house?
SPEAKER_01Oh.
SPEAKER_00Buffy the Vampire Slayer? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01No. Cruel Intentions? No, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00The jump scare, there was like the Japanese ghost boy twink in her bed and he's like, ah! Okay, whatever. Okay, American Horror Story. The first season of American Horror Story with the murder house. Sure, sure, sure. And what's his face? Evan, what's his face? But he basically convinces the daughter to kill herself because everyone... Everyone who moves in the house dies. And so I just feel like that Gabe is not the murder house in Next to Normal.
SPEAKER_00He's not actually physically able to tell characters what to do. He is a theatrical device of a manifestation of each character's trauma and grief and disorder. That's what I guess I'm trying to get around. That's a very long monologue. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I think each of those characters are kind of a representation of how one deals with grief and different stages of how one deals with grief. I mean, Dana's just denial. And Dana kind of goes back and forth in between bargaining and depression. And Natalie is just anger. Partly because she never knew him. But his absence has affected her entire life and is the reason she exists. Mm-hmm. And Diana says, like, and I think she knows that.
SPEAKER_00She says, I know she knows. Yeah. They never said it, but Natalie absolutely knows. Because, first of all, Natalie's very smart. And we talked about this in the Light of the Piazza episode. Parents in troubled homes think that they hide this shit from their kids. They don't. The kids always know. They always know. Mm-hmm. They talked about this with Natalie was a big change between second stage and arena of like just the tone of the character. She was more of a draw wisecracking teen at second stage and they infused her with
SPEAKER_00a lot more hurt, which of course makes her more rageful. But yeah. Because that rage came from a very raw, real place, audiences were able to attach themselves to her. They understood why she was lashing out. It wasn't just like, this annoying fucking millennial. It's like, no, this kid is going through shit and neither of her parents are helping her. They both are making it worse.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, replacing her first major song, which is perfect now, was basically the same vibe before. Interestingly, they changed the piece of music that she's practicing and made it Mozart instead. What was the original piece? Invention in Sea. Chopin? I can't remember. Yeah, I threw my classical training out the window once I graduated from college. Ditched that opera degree real quick.
SPEAKER_00Anybody who's watching this can see the La Boheme poster behind Brian right now.
SPEAKER_01Yes, but it's the Broadway production.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it's the Baz Luhrmann La Boheme.
SPEAKER_01It's the Baz Luhrmann, which I saw 22 times.
SPEAKER_00See, that's the kind of Broadway fandom that I'm on board with.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, there were also three casts. So you can see all of them. One of which was Alfie Boe. We were just talking about the Les Mis arena concert, which I saw Alfie do. And I'm like, yeah, that's about the same kind of performance he was giving in 2002. Moms love Alfie Boe. They love Alfie Boe and good for them. Know your demo. But so Natalie... Oh, Nellie, yeah. So they replaced her song, and in second stage, she was kind of just screaming for no reason.
SPEAKER_01And there was a calmness and a ramp up to the new tune. The Mozart was crazy, flat fucking crazy. Um... That shows, like, the reason why she's the way she is, is, like, if she is perfect, if she does everything exactly right and becomes, you know, the brainiac golden child, then she can justify her existence to her mother. And she'll finally be seen, which we get in Superboy and the Invisible Girl.
SPEAKER_01More of her trying to justify herself.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because it's sort of the... All of this shit that I've gone through has to be worth it somehow. And if I do not achieve this, then it was all for nothing. I'm just someone who went through something awful, which is, you know, sometimes people write plays, Brian, and you just go, I can't let that just be a thing that happened to me. This has to be for something. And, you know, she talks about I'm going to graduate early.
SPEAKER_00I'm going to get my scholarship. I'm going to go to Yale. And all I have to do is do this last perfect thing and it's all going to be great. And it's clearly not what will make her feel happy. It's not bringing her joy, but it is a goal that she thinks is achievable. But it's also like it's hurting her as well. It's another thing that's hurting her.
SPEAKER_01And she never really, the sad thing is like she never really finds pure joy. The closest thing we get to Natalie enjoying herself is when she's stolen all of her mother's medication and is going to clubs.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, fucked out of her mind. Four clubs on a Tuesday night or something like that is,
SPEAKER_01that's a lot. Yeah. I'm also wondering, so do we know where they all live? No idea. I don't know what the fuck club she's going to fucked up at 17 years old
SPEAKER_00or 16 years old. I'm also wondering, you know, where do they live where there are four different clubs she can go to on a Tuesday night? Clearly they go there. They live someplace where there's a downtown. But yeah, because Diana talks about having to speed downtown to save Gabe. And yeah. So, yeah, they don't live like in a city, but maybe a suburb near a city. But then I don't know. This is the dramaturgical shit that gets in my head. They could just they could just say, hey, instead of saying like, this is the fourth club this week,
SPEAKER_00like you've gone to this club three times this week. It could be like the one club in town. That's all you got to say. Yeah. Yorkie. These are just the things I'm like, hey, can we just come back and change that?
SPEAKER_01And they did change things in London. Like they updated a bunch of stuff. They included X. They included X. They updated the length of time that a parent is allowed to grieve.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Went from clinically from four months to six months. There's like lots of little tiny changes that they made. Um, so like do that, like fix that little kind of weird moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Those are the things that I think are more actual fixes rather than, um, the hiccups we were talking about earlier, but, and, and, you know, maybe rewriting songs we're forgetting, but if you want to, if you want to, I would like it. Just Jen Simard, always.
SPEAKER_01Come back to Jen Simard.
SPEAKER_00Jen Simard is Diana Goodman. I miss the mountains.
SPEAKER_01Look, people love a strong, interesting vocal placement on a Diana Goodman. Sure.
SPEAKER_00I also think that Jen Simard's Tony's coming when she does her first like serious. I think her next show is going to be a serious show and people are going to have their minds fucking blown and she's going to win a Tony for that.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I hope so. I hope so. I also just want her to go to television, make a pile of money and then come back.
SPEAKER_00Oh, sure. Sure. Make a pile of money. Get an extra like 10 million Instagram followers so she can then pick whatever show she wants to do. Yeah. I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Oh, God. The list of revivals.
SPEAKER_00As Bob Fosse said to Bebe Neuwirth when she asked if it was okay for her to leave Sweet Charity for a few weeks to film Cheers, he said, there's no shame in making money, Bebe. And she said, got it. And then she became a pretty decent TV star and got to headline and shit after that. Yeah, and got Tonys and delights. So I guess for anyone who's wondering what the fuck Song of Forgetting is, uh... One of the plot lines with Diana is, you know,
SPEAKER_00them all throughout act one trying to find ways to give her a more balanced chemical, more chemical balance in her brain. And so they start with her psychopharmacologist and all the different pills. Great number. Yeah, it's a very good number.
SPEAKER_01Still works. And that's the thing. That's one of the like irony laden tunes from the original draft that actually still works.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. What they learned also is going whole hog on the emotion doesn't mean that the show needs to be a cry fest from start to finish. You actually do need laughter to break the tension. We talked about this in Piazza and sort of how I felt that James Lapine missed the boat with the original production of Passion. They were so concerned about laughter that they did everything in their power to cut it. And I feel like post-productions of Broadway of Passion... Figured out how to incorporate humor to make that show breathe,
SPEAKER_00because you can't just do two hours of love me or I'll die. Like, there's actual humor in that show. And Next to Normal has a lot of humor in it as well, and that isn't one of the few, like, actual humorous numbers. But the thing with Diana is, you know, she... She goes on these pills, she eventually flushes them down the toilet, and then they go to a new therapist, which she has all these breakthroughs on, but that leads to a major relapse and an attempt at suicide. And the final grasp is the doctor recommending ECT, electroshock therapy.
SPEAKER_00And Diana and Dan eventually agree to do it and that's how Act 1 ends and then Act 2 she comes home after three weeks of ECT with major memory loss. Severe memory loss. 19 years worth. And... There's a lot of conversation about that plot device. We'll just say that. But it does lead to the song literally of Song of Forgetting. She comes home. She doesn't know who Natalie is. She knows who Dan is, sort of. And she does know it's their house.
SPEAKER_00And they start showing her photographs, just a reminder of things. And Dan won't It does have a good lyric in it that I think is fun, which is, um... Dan's showing something from their honeymoon or their wedding, a flower from their wedding. And he goes, it was perfect. Everything we dreamed it would be. And Natalie's like, no, it wasn't. And he goes, no, that's how I remember it.
SPEAKER_00She goes, it was everything we'd hoped. And she says, it was raining. It was Portland. You eloped. I mean, really, dad? Portland. Portland. Yeah. Portland, dad. And that always gets a nice laugh, which I appreciate.
SPEAKER_01Which, again, not knowing where the fuck we are. So do we mean Portland, Maine or Oregon? I'm thinking Oregon. I am too. I don't know why. So are they in some kind of like... I don't know why the whole thing feels Seattle to me. I was thinking the same thing. Jesus Christ.
SPEAKER_00What is wrong with us? I felt like they lived maybe... Like right on the outskirts of Seattle. Yeah. Like close enough that they could get to like midtown in 20 minutes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I don't know why it feels Seattle to me, but yeah. Sure as hell don't feel San Francisco.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00No. Or Austin. Or Austin. Yes. San Jose.
SPEAKER_01Or Santa Fe.
SPEAKER_00Oh. Or San Diego. Everything happens in Santa Fe in musicals. It's true. Or everybody's always trying to get to Santa Fe in musicals.
SPEAKER_01Why is that? Why is that like the fucking mecca of late 90s, early 2000s musical theater?
SPEAKER_00I think because it's a decent rhyme. You can do something with Faye in a way you can't do with Diego.
SPEAKER_01Well...
SPEAKER_00Most of them are pretty fey. I want someone to sing a song about San Diego, as Ron Burgundy pronounces it.
SPEAKER_01Sing a song of Diago.
SPEAKER_00Sure. That's what we can replace Song of Forgetting with. That's the new lyric. Well, the problem is then you go, sing a song of Diago, it's better than Mar-a-Lago. Yeah, it gets bad. Key Largo, yeah. My favorite movie is Fargo. Lumbago? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Lumbago.
SPEAKER_00Sure. Great. We got it. We're getting there. I think we're in the right mental state for talking about this show. Come on, rhymingdictionary.com. This episode brought to you by rhymingdictionary.com.
SPEAKER_01It's .com. Wait, what is that? Did you ever watch Homestar Runner? No.
SPEAKER_00What is she?
SPEAKER_01She was an early early 2000s like internet kind of meme site. There were all these animated shorts and they are brilliant. There are a bunch of characters. But the lead character is Homestar Runner who was this kind of like white oblong thing with a little like propeller being on. It's like Homestar Runner. It's .com. It's just the weirdest thing ever. And there is a kind of Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So let's, why don't we talk about what we want to talk about? There was a, the thing about the Broadway production of Next to Normal was that it did end up being quite successful. It ran for almost two years. Yeah. Won the Pulitzer in 2010, which was actually controversial. Brian, did you know this?
SPEAKER_01I didn't know that until you, like, I literally never heard that until you sent me that Guardian article. Was it the Guardian? Mm-hmm. It was basically like, it's controversial that Next to Normal won the Pulitzer. Yeah. Why?
SPEAKER_00Because this is the third time this has happened on the podcast where we covered a show that had Pulitzer drama, but Pulitzer drama for the Pulitzer for drama. But it boils down to that it was submitted. It was not selected as a as a finalist, but the production invited the voting board to the show anyway. And the board decided that they were going to give it to next to normal. And so that was the that was the drama, which honestly, like.
SPEAKER_00Part of me respects the Next Normal team for, like, going rogue about that, of, like, we disagree with the judges and we think we're good, why don't you all come? Part of me is also, like, that's a little Corinne from that one season of The Bachelor that I watched where she, like... Yeah, but is David Stone really going to follow the rules?
SPEAKER_00I guess not. I guess not.
SPEAKER_01Between him and Rudin, like, you know, of the Broadway producers of Note, like, yeah, we're not we're not going to like, oh, no, the Pulitzer committee didn't like our show. It's like, fine. No, come see it. And honestly, I feel like the show does deserve it. The show they got to deserves it.
SPEAKER_00What were the finalists that year for the Pulitzer? It was, okay, Pulitzer for Drama, Next to Normal. The finalists were, okay, it was the Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo, the elaborate entrance of Chad Deity, which I have never heard of, but it's Christopher Diaz. Is Christopher Diaz the one who wrote the book for Hell's Kitchen? In the Next Room or The Vibrator played by Sarah Rule? Which was a perfectly fine play.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Is Christopher Diaz who I'm thinking of? Yes, he wrote the book for Hell's Kitchen. So in my mind, yeah, I'm okay with Next Normal winning it. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Again, is it a slight dick move? Sure. But also, part of me wonders if, you know, someone sort of looked at the nominees and he was like, I'm sorry, these three, these three Peggy's? And went, uh-uh-uh. Voters, come to my show. Mm-hmm. You will prefer this over the scripts that you were just sent.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and honestly, I always feel there is a little bit of a musicals with the Pulitzer Committee. Sure. It happens rarely. Yeah, how many have actually won six in the recent years?
SPEAKER_00In the recent years, yeah, maybe more like that. But overall, I think it's 11. It's Strange Loop, Hamilton, Next to Normal, Rent, Sunday in the Park with George, A Chorus Line, How to Succeed, Fiorello, which is so fucking random. So dumb. South Pacific. South Pacific. Of the Icing. I feel like there's an 11th one. Or maybe it's just those 10.
SPEAKER_01Okay. The fact that you got Of the Icing... Bravo. Thank you. Bravo. Girl, what podcast do you think you're on? I hope that this knowledge will someday get you laid at least once.
SPEAKER_00That knowledge is never going to be what gets me laid. That knowledge is what's going to keep me from ever getting pregnant or getting someone else pregnant. Because in the middle of the act, I'm going to say, well, Of the Icing was the first musical to win the Pulitzer, but George Grosham was not given I don't know. There is a lid for every pot and a top for every you.
SPEAKER_01Can we stop this narrative that I'm a power bottom? I'm not. I never said power bottom. You said it. I want to go on record here.
SPEAKER_00You sit top for every me. What are the listeners supposed to feel in this moment? They've met you. Some of them have. Listen, stop it.
SPEAKER_01People will listen to you for three hours rattle on about Fiorello. So I think they're familiar with the work.
SPEAKER_00But it's also not true, Brian. Stop this. I know it's not true. Then stop being mean to me.
SPEAKER_01Look, no bottom shaming. There is no bottom shaming, because most
SPEAKER_00power bottoms are demon twinks or Patti LuPone. I just spent 12 days on a boat with Patti LuPone.
SPEAKER_01She is not a power bottom. She is a, you know, aggressive verse top. If you say so. We are furious, but we are sailing.
SPEAKER_00I'm sorry. Isn't that what every bottom says? I am furious, but I am sailing. I am taking this joystick and I am sailing the choppy seas. I'm sorry. That's what power bottoms say.
SPEAKER_01Look, I'm just saying, like, you knowing that much about Fiorello and of the icing is going to stand you in good stead. Sure, we'll see. Speaking of someone who really, like, Like the moment that I knew that my relationship was going to become a relationship is when we were talking like post-coitally about Ann Miller's soup commercial.
SPEAKER_00There you go. Sometimes there's nothing one can say. What I will say is, have you seen the clip of Patti LuPone coaching a teenage girl singing I Miss the Mountains from Next to Normal? And she says, do you even know what the song is about? And Patti goes, it's about sex. It's about an orgasm. This is a song about an orgasm.
SPEAKER_01Clearly, Patti was not one of the Tony voters that year.
SPEAKER_00No, but I have wondered, what would an early 90s Patti LuPone be like as Diana Goodman?
SPEAKER_01Oh. Sensational, to quote Kola Skola. Like, how would it look? Sensational.
SPEAKER_02It would be great.
SPEAKER_00My only Alistair, the impression I can do is her Didn't I See This Movie, which is, Didn't
SPEAKER_02I See This Movie?
SPEAKER_00Didn't I Cree? Didn't I Cree?
SPEAKER_01See, okay, look, the key to a Ripley as Diana Goodman impression is to just think slightly Swedish. Sure.
SPEAKER_00No, every time I try to do Swedish, I just do Alice Ripley. Every time I try to do Carolee Carmelo, I just start doing Alice Ripley. Or it's Irish, it becomes Irish.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I wish I could get the early Carolee Carmelo vibrato, because then that would just, you know, it would be so easy to then get that impression locked in. Just leave your vibrator in, Brian, and then you'll get it. Yeah, just turn it up to like 17 and then that's the key. It's the speed. Like a power drill it is. Fully, fully that. So to pivot. You don't know this. Like, I can't get it.
SPEAKER_00Every time I do Carolee's Do It Alone, Leo, it just becomes Irish. Do it alone, Leo. Do it all by yourself.
SPEAKER_01You're the only one who matters after all.
SPEAKER_00They're
SPEAKER_01dancing in the streets, Leo. Pray your voice is alert. Not enough to read through that door. Slightly Sean Connery.
SPEAKER_00It becomes Irish Scottish. I can't do it. I try and I just always go into, do it alone, Leo. But, um... How else does one do it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. It's always good to find, you need to find like that one in to a vocal impression. Like Judy Garland, everything has to go through R.
SPEAKER_02Like it's gotta be, I miss the mountains, I miss a lonely climb.
SPEAKER_00We start dreamcasting these older divas in their prime as Diana Goodman and it just becomes a treasure trove of what the fuck are you? Liza.
SPEAKER_01Sure, sure. What's her fuck? Oh God, I'm having a mini stroke. Original Miss Hannigan. Dorothy Loudon. Oh, my God.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that would have been fucking nuts. That would have been a Diana Goodman straight from the vagina. She would just be bumping and grinding her way all through it. So when did you watch the London pro shot? Was it purely for this episode or had you seen it before? Purely for this.
SPEAKER_01No, I was going to go see it in London and then I heard it was coming over, so I just didn't. And then I just didn't watch the pro shot basically because... I didn't know how I was going to feel about it, honestly. And I absolutely fell in love with the production a third of the way through. I fully got on board. I didn't know J.B. Parker was in it, and I loved him in Into the Woods, like,
SPEAKER_01loved, loved, loved him, and I thought he, like, I was so happy to see him in this. Yeah. And yeah, I honestly, like full disclosure and might get tased for this, wasn't sure how I was going to feel about Casey in it. Because I've seen her in, you know, a bunch of things, but wasn't sure how much this would line up. And I like my Diana vocal to be a little dirty.
SPEAKER_01Sure. To be honest. I mean, you know, being an Alice Stan from, you know, the OG, and I went down to go see Rachel Bay Jones do it at the Kennedy Center. And I thought that performance was fucking perfect. There was such grit on it. With Alice, especially towards the end of the run, it got challenging because it is a beast of a role. And to put yourself through that eight times a week for counting second stage
SPEAKER_01and workshops for two years is going to take its toll. Yeah. And she is a balls-to-the-wall singer at all points. So I saw Alice towards the end of her run, and it was tough. It was tough on her vocally. Rachel had all of the range on it and all of the power, but it came from a real rock place. And it went to that kind of raspy Rachel Bay Jones thing up top, and it was fucking thrilling. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It was incredible. She sang the shit out of it. She was acting her face off. Brandon Dixon was a really good match for her.
SPEAKER_02Do you have audio
SPEAKER_00of it by any chance? Any audio?
SPEAKER_01No? Maybe? Okay. Uh, I'll send it to you offline. Um, yes.
SPEAKER_00I can't believe I haven't. How did I not? I don't know because you don't love me like you say you do. You call me a demon twink power bottom on my show and then you don't even have the audacity to send me audio of Rachel Bay Jones the next to normal.
SPEAKER_01Fine, fine, fine. Look, I just send everything automatically to Adam and I assume he sends it to you.
SPEAKER_00No, I usually have to bring it up. Listen, anytime I ask Adam if he has something, I get it within five seconds. But his mind doesn't go, I must send this to Matt. It tends to be, oh, yeah, I should send that to you. And then he does. But I'm always like the fifth on everybody's list. People think of me five months later. No, no, no. I had a similar mentality going into Next to Normal, this production, as you did. Again, it was a show that wasn't incredibly important to me.
SPEAKER_00The reviews from the Donmar were mostly solid because this was, for all intents and purposes, a premiere for the West End. I think it had been done once in London, like briefly sort of off West End a few years ago, but this was like a genuine West End premiere. And so there was a lot of the reviews were both on the material as well as the production. And the feeling mostly was was strong, if not like overly rapturous. And it got Olivier nominated. It sold out. So they transferred it that summer. I was in London.
SPEAKER_00The week before it started previews because they didn't announce the transfer until after I had booked my tickets. So I was actually I was a little annoyed and I debated asking my mom if we could push back a week so I could see it. But then I ended up not doing it. But that tends to be. A recurring theme with me with London is every time I go like something really awesome is about to start the moment I leave. Like I just missed that. I had just missed Follies at the National. I had just missed the company with Patty and Rosalie Craig.
SPEAKER_00But the word of mouth once it had transferred was such that like, oh, this clicks even better than it did at Donmar. And so when the... Pro Shot came out. I watched it. I have said openly on this podcast, I think Casey is an extraordinarily talented individual. I think she is one of the most misused talents on Broadway. I think she keeps getting put in things. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But Mother in Ragtime and Rose Stoppnik and Carolina Change are acting-wise a good fit for her because she is also a very good actress. But then the roles are a fit for her vocally, like Ghost and Frozen. It's like, well, those are non-acting roles. So it's very rare that she gets a role for me where I'm like, oh, the vocals and the acting challenge mesh well for you. Murder Ballad was one where I went, oh, this is perfect for you. And so next to normal, I was like, okay, we'll see. And I was... I don't know how you felt.
SPEAKER_00I personally was genuinely blown away by what she brought to it. I thought it was such, I found it to be very raw and it is a very healthy vocal place. You know, there is no danger in that respect, but I don't,
SPEAKER_01Mind it because I thought it sounded quite lovely.
SPEAKER_00And there are certain notes that she hit that Alice never hit. Like in just another day when they get to the end of the it hurts bit. She goes, it only hurts when I say. I just remember she belted that and I was like, has that always been in the score? Because I've never heard that.
SPEAKER_01It's been there, but Alice flipped it. And so it gets lost in the blend. So that's the thing. I've never seen anything that I felt was like... Again, some of you, like an exact match for what Casey can do. I didn't see Murder Ballad, but yeah, I thought I agree with you on Mother. I want a more legit voice on it. Yeah, a thicker fold. Yeah, just a little meaty fold. Casey's voice doesn't live in the past. It lives in the now. Yeah, and so it does feel occasionally a little too pop for me on that.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, like, Casey Levy doing Long Distance and Carolina Change is like, you know, hanging a picture with a sledgehammer.
SPEAKER_00Like, you don't need that much voice on it. It's asking Diana Ross to sing Send in the Clowns. It's like, that's not... There are certain songs where when you actually have too good of a singer on it, it actually, I'm not gonna say ruins, ruins is a harsh term. She didn't do a bad job, but like, you know what I mean? When there are songs that are meant for a limited voice and then you put a stellar voice on it, the song Everything starts to change in a way that's that's not great. And it's unfair to her because I'm like, what is she supposed to do?
SPEAKER_00Like fucking give herself laryngitis so she can give us Vian Cox realness? Like, no, she's yeah, she's not going to do that for our benefit.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, it is like Shirley Bassey doing Son of the Clowns. Like, it's just, which, hilarious.
SPEAKER_00Well, let's be, no, let's be, okay, that's, I think that's being harsh to Casey because Casey would not over-sing something intentionally so. Shirley Bassey would.
SPEAKER_01Yes, which, okay, if for the listeners, if you don't know Shirley Bassey's Andrew Lloyd Webber album, you need to go and listen to Shirley Bassey singing Starlight Express, clearly having never heard the song, reading the lyrics off a piece of paper, and they're swinging it.
SPEAKER_02It is insane. There are modulations. She is screaming about a train and has no idea what is happening.
SPEAKER_01She is drunk off her ass, clearly. It is amazing. Favorite thing ever.
SPEAKER_00But also, it's that thing of, you know, I think it's easier for people to understand when someone is vocally not up to the task of something. It's harder for people to comprehend what it means to be vocally overqualified and what that does for songs sometimes. So that's what I mean. So back to what you were saying as you were leading up to your intro of Casey in this show.
SPEAKER_01So Casey, like, I... God, I thought she was absolutely devastating in it. I thought she was incredible. It was such a good match. My only, my only little like quibble with it is Miss the Mountains. She ends it up. She like adds, you know, it's a little too riffy. It's a little too big and ends it with an added high note and occasional additional riffs. She's still medicated at this point. Yeah, she still should be in a depressive state and that made it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it made it too bright and too big. When I think when you eventually get to that key change and that one D that she pops the I miss a lonely climb is the only moment where she starts to feel a little bit of herself.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then, like, I feel like she needs to get pulled back in. So it's like, I miss my life. I miss my life. Like, it doesn't need to
SPEAKER_00end that big. Yeah, it becomes, well, and you watch the recording, it becomes a bit of a showstopper, which, you know, it's a great standalone song, but... I get very perturbed with numbers that, dramatically speaking, are not showstoppers, but musically speaking, become showstoppers. Speaking of Rick Time, I was after Rick Time again recently for reasons. And my thoughts on the show remain. My thoughts on this production actually have gotten a little bit worse. But there were certain numbers where dramatically, it's meant to be this big, devastating...
SPEAKER_00Yeah. You cannot tell me that this number moves you because you're not applauding the emotion and the storytelling on a high note. You're applauding the high note. And you can't, I'm sorry, you can't convince me otherwise. You can do a whole bunch of gobbledygook like I do on this podcast.
SPEAKER_00I will still smell your bullshit. Right. I love that Casey does. I have some notes on the London pro shot. Part of it is how it's filmed. I don't think it's perfect. It's very heavily edited. And sometimes that works really nicely. And other times I'm like, we can just stay on this shot for another three seconds. I get very... I'm like, there's a sweeter spot. I think you need to be more of a stage capture with benefits than trying to actually be a full-blown movie because you never will be.
SPEAKER_00You'll never be glamour, but... And then, you know, there's a couple of accent pieces that are not great. Like, I think Jamie Parker is wonderful in it. His American accent is very Kermit the Frog. Just, you know, I am the one who healed you. And he's so good that I hate to say it because it sounds like that I'm nagging on his performance. I'm not. It's just listen to him. Listen to him in his American accent. I'm sorry, but you hear Kermit.
SPEAKER_01So who is the human in The Muppet Next to Normal?
SPEAKER_00I mean, I hate to say it, I think it's Diana. I think that's the only way to make it palatable. She's the human and everyone else is a Muppet. That's what makes her crazy.
SPEAKER_01Oh, maybe. Maybe that's the world she's creating. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, yeah, unless it's, unless it's Natalie, but I, no. Or Dr. Madden. Or it's the doctor. Yeah, I think it's Dr. Madden.
SPEAKER_01Everyone else is a Muppet. Everyone else is a Muppet. I mean, Piggy being Diana is kind of hysterical, but... Sure.
SPEAKER_00Especially when Casey picks up that chair and starts swinging it, that's something Piggy would do, but... Yeah. Yeah, I mean, that's, I think that's my only other real qualms, other than the camera angles and then some of the accent work, uh... The amount of emotion that that production has is astounding. There are a couple of times where I'm like, I don't think we need to sob here. There's a lot of sobbing. There's a lot of sobbing. And I would say 90% of it is... Effective and make sense. There are a couple of moments. And who knows?
SPEAKER_00It might be that people were getting emotional because they filmed it towards the end of the run. They filmed it over a couple of days. So I'm sure there's also a lot of exhaustion in there. I'm sure there are moments that Eleanor Worthington Cox wasn't necessarily crying on the eight show a week, but because it was the 12th take of the scene, she's like,
SPEAKER_01please let me go home.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01She's just like, stop it. They're making British equity money.
SPEAKER_00I mean, come on. I know. It's roof. It's roof. But otherwise, I think it's pretty astounding. What I love about Casey's performance, and I love it about it in the beginning, and I don't want to disregard what Alice did because I want to make it clear, when Alice opened the show, the whole narrative around her performance was how, like, Wild and organic and raw it was. You know, you didn't see a performance like this in a musical often. And it was. There is that energy to it. But also Alice did not come out the gate manic in the opening.
SPEAKER_00Rewatching that production at the library, I was surprised how many times Greif wanted to surprise the audience, like with twists. And a couple of things I think for me undermined the emotional potency of the show because of that. And part of it is Diana. You know, Alice plays it very, I hate to say calm, but like a little calm at the beginning of Just Another Day. And so the bread sandwich making becomes this twist about her. Like at first you think she's just sort of a little eccentric. She says weird things.
SPEAKER_00She says Happy Easter because the calendar is still on April. But then she starts to get manic and it's like, oh no, something's wrong here. Casey, something's wrong off It's not overdone, but you can tell she's in the middle of an episode already. The way she's overly sexual with Dan, the way she's not even just offering sex, but even after they've had sex, she's just being a little too much. And Natalie can clock in when she says she's on fire this morning, and it gives you this...
SPEAKER_00He's a ghost. He's a twin ghost. Ghost. Boys, we'll make it tragic.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. I don't know. We'll come up with a theme song about Twinkoats. We'll do it at some point. And we'll have the AI voice of Shirley Bassey sing it. So when Casey's doing the sandwiches, rather than being a twist, it becomes a culmination of everything that's been building up to that number. That number has a frantic energy in the London production that I'd never felt it had in the original. And part of it is the design. It's very simple. And I also just love that when the number ends and they're watching her, the way she says...
SPEAKER_00Everything is good. I'm just making sandwiches on the floor. With Alice, it was done sort of as a punchline. She like realizes that she's lost the thread for a minute. She goes, everything's fine. I'm just making sandwiches on the floor. But Casey's still making the sandwiches and she's and in her mind, it all makes sense. And this was a video I was watching of someone talking about this as they were sort of reacting to the video. They said the thing about having these manic highs is and what makes it scary to you is everything makes sense to you. And the moment you realize it's making sense to no one else is
SPEAKER_00when it gets terrifying because then you can't trust yourself anymore. And so that is sort of what Casey is playing of like everything is always going to make sense to Diana until someone points out that it doesn't. And that's when she gets you see like the switch go off in her brain of like, oh, shit, I just had an episode and I didn't even realize it. And I love that. And that carries over to the scenes where she's having pain and confusion and frustration. I just, yeah, I know. I just really like it. You watch it and I'm like, yep, that's what Casey Levy can do.
SPEAKER_00And I wish Broadway would use it more.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. And maybe we'll get it. I don't know if we are. The rumor
SPEAKER_00is no. Yeah, it keeps going back and forth. The rumor was that it was coming and then that it wasn't and then that it was, but only with her and that they were going to hold off until the Tonys to announce it. And then it was off again. And then there was a rumor that Pink was doing it with her daughter. Yep. Which I kind of call bullshit on.
SPEAKER_01Mm hmm. A, because I don't think Pink wants to do it shows a week. B, Pink is not an actress in any real way, like has not done a lot of television or film or theater.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we have never seen Pink put in work as an actress. Maybe she has the goods, I don't know, but we've never seen it. And I don't know if she even knows that she has it.
SPEAKER_01And this would be a heavy fucking lift for your first thing. Can I act? Let me do this devastating, in-depth, heavy, heavy lift.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, a role that has fully destroyed trained actresses in the last 17 years.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, several. And that was the thing with Alice's original performance. It was kind of a performance that we had not seen since Tanya in Carolina Change. Just a woman throwing herself full push into the piece.
SPEAKER_00Keep talking sexy to me, Brian. Talk more about Tanya Pinkins in Carolina Change.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. That performance devastated me and, you know, then got to know Tonya later on and work with her on a bunch of stuff. Last musical I ever did in New York was Tonya's production of Mother Courage.
SPEAKER_00And that's what turned you off of doing theater in New York ever again.
SPEAKER_01And that's why I basically stopped doing theater in New York. Go read the Times articles. But Alice's performance was just so guttural and brilliant. And so to see Casey do that kind of work while still being able to maintain it vocally, but still be fully emotionally accessible, it's gorgeous. It's really lovely. So I hope she gets to do it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's really, it's really fucking hard to do because when we talk about healthy singing, which, you know, we should always prioritize. I want people to have long vocal careers. Sure. And I've, I've also talked about, you know, certain scores for me that are really only thrilling when there is that little bit of danger to it. I've said before, I don't actually know if I think Dead Girl Walking is a good song or if it's just that Barrett Wilbur Whedon or Freak Voice does it for me on that. And or like I actually genuinely think that Evita is a phenomenal score or
SPEAKER_00if it's just that Patti LuPone and her freak ass 29 year old voice could do what it could do because really no other woman after Patti has been able to thrill me on that score. The only one who's been able to do it since is Rachel Zegler. Rachel Zegler. But healthy, healthy, healthy, healthy, which is craziness to me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I went back and saw Evita the next day. Like, I went to go see Evita because I'm like, okay, I should go see this. And was so thrilled with how it was sung that I had a slot open for another show the next day in London. I'm like, I could go see Benjamin Button. I'm like, or I could camp out of the box office and see if a single becomes available to see Evita again. And went back the next day. And it's unbelievably thrilling the way she's singing that score.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And it's... Beautifully placed.
SPEAKER_00That was another one. Avita was starting three weeks after I left London, and I regret it to just say. Should have gone back, bitch. Should have gone back. Well, you know, maybe I'll finally get to see it at the Drama Desk if I would have. The thing about the ECT that I want to just mention to people, because this is a hot bun discussion with the show, is it is often said that when you do ECT, There is some temporary memory loss. Emphasis on the temporary and it's usually short term.
SPEAKER_00They often say when you there's like a whole there's a whole section in the Mayo Clinic website talking about like, here's what ECT actually is. Here's how we do it. Like, here's why you shouldn't be afraid of it. And like, here are all the concerns people have and we understand. But here's blah, blah, blah, blah. They're like, you are sedated, you are given muscle relaxants, you are, you know, it's very short moments, very low current, blah, blah. And they say, yeah, you wake up, you're confused for a few hours, like you may not remember where you are, eventually it'll all come back.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes you get, you know, memory loss, it tends to be short term and a lot of it comes back. They say, like, in very rare cases, a couple of months will go missing, and in extraordinarily rare cases, a couple of years. It seems like 0.001% of patients have a 19-year gap, and Diana's the 119-year. And what the show talks about, which doctors have also said, Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00For someone like Diana, that starts with the loss of Gabe, and that is why it's such a large block. Now, is it super realistic? Not necessarily. Is it possible? Sure, a lot of things are possible. But the show makes it a point to—I don't even think they make it a point. But the very fact that Diana starts to regain her memories and the very fact that once the Gabe— Quota is unlocked by Dr. Madden because, again, Dan will not—doesn't want to bring it up to her. He's saying, in time, we'll tell her about it in time.
SPEAKER_00And then Madden is the one who reveals to her that she had a son, and then it all sort of comes flooding back. She also is kind of in a more balanced place in Act 2. She's able to hold these— Um, coherent conversations with Natalie and with Dan in a way that I don't think she was really ever able to in act one. And so I hate to say this. I don't know if this sounds controversial or not. In a lot of ways, next to normal kind of shows you that the ECT worked a little bit.
SPEAKER_00And I think that a lot of audiences misinterpret it. Like she has the memory loss of it. ECT is a hack. And, and this show is putting a dangerous stigma on, on electroshock therapy and bipolar disorder. I'm like, I don't know it. Like they're using a lot of dramatic Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Maybe, oh, that's it. Maybe Gabe got kicked by a horse.
SPEAKER_00That's what it was. But this time in the stomach, it was a bowel obstruction.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And that's why you don't bring an eight-month-old to a petting zoo. And that's why you always leave a note. Like, yeah. I mean, the thing is, yes, she does end up in a much better place. And it did kind of, forgetting Gabe entirely gave her a way to approach him in a different way and let him go. Yeah. In a way that she couldn't before. So the point of,
SPEAKER_01especially when they were first talking about writing the show about ECT, was that they wanted to be critical of it. And said they wrote a piece that does show that a kind of Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Whether they meant it or not, I don't know. I don't know. But I watch it and I go, to say that it worked implies that there's one cure-all thing for mental health. There isn't. It's a constant. It's something that you live with and it's a constant that you have to keep working with. And sometimes the right medication only works for 10 years and then all a sudden your brain chemistry gets too used to it and then something else happens.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I do think that, in this case, it does help her, whether anyone in the show openly says it or not. Because as you said, yeah, she's able to approach the Gabe trauma objectively first. And as she remembers it objectively, she then starts to live in it again. And then is able to fight for the closure that she never got. And... Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And learning that maybe they had the wrong mentality for what their best was all along.
SPEAKER_00How would you describe Dan as a person and then how he is with Diana?
SPEAKER_01Look, everyone in this piece is just trying to get through their another day. It only hurts when I breathe. It only hurts when I work. It only hurts when I... All those lines in the opening.
SPEAKER_00It only hurts when I say...
SPEAKER_01Yeah. She's holding a frying pan, by the way. Yeah. Casey. Which, the thing is, like, it's interesting that Gabe's line is, it only hurts when I'm here.
SPEAKER_00That's his first one. It only hurts when I'm here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then she says, it only
SPEAKER_00hurts when he
SPEAKER_01goes. Yeah. Which is interesting. Like, it does... It does play more into the Jack Wolf London version of Gabe is trying to get something. He's trying to get basically back to the land of the living. And when he's kind of removed from that, he's devastated sitting on the upper platform. Oh, P.S., by the way, one note... I don't need the band on stage for every rock musical.
SPEAKER_01I don't need it. I don't fucking need it. I don't understand why, you know, we did in the original production, but now every production of Next Normal has to have the band on stage in the upper level of the house.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I found it distracting in the London production as well, especially because they have the screens and they keep going up and down and up and down. I'm like, just, I want to live with the characters.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Why is Gabe hanging out in the drum room? Fucking close it.
SPEAKER_00The drummers are hot, Brian, and let Gabe get his boy.
SPEAKER_01Look, I only know a few gay drummers, and they're great. They're lovely. They know what to do with their hands.
SPEAKER_00They do. And they've got good rhythm.
SPEAKER_01And, you know, they can bang it out. So, shout out to Justin Tambini in London. Hi. My favorite, like one of my favorite gay drummers in the world. Like, well, he's bad, but whatever. He should have played that show. I'm sure Jack would have enjoyed that. But yeah, so side note, if you're directing next to normal, hide the band. It's fine. It's fine. But Dan. We're talking about Dan. So look, he is just trying to get through.
SPEAKER_01And if we're going ahead with the kind of theory of everyone being a representation of different ways to deal with grief, yes, he is in denial. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And yes, we'll do whatever we have to do. We'll go see another doctor. We will go and get new meds and we'll make it better. We're just going to make this better. And... His it's going to be good and like that little optimistic fanfare that happens at the top of it is the way he's going to get through every day. He's going to shunt aside whatever he was feeling in order to make sure she's okay and to try to make things stable for Natalie. So I don't think he's a villain at all.
SPEAKER_01Is what he's doing misguided? Absolutely. But he's just trying to make it okay at any cost.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think we get a brief flashback of them as college undergrads when she's pregnant. And you see that he has much more passion for the idea of them getting married and having this baby than she does at first. And she says, you know, when the baby came, it all made sense. And I think that what surprised her is how... Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00I also think they also added a song for Dan in between second stage and arena, which is the, I think it's called I Was Here. I was here. Which has a great reveal in the Broadway staging. It's one of my favorite things that Greif does, which is because they talked about how the audience never really understood the gravity of Diana trying to take her own life. And so when Dan goes back to the house to clean up, he's on the chair that Diana was in, and he's wiping the chair, puts his hand in the bucket,
SPEAKER_00and wrings the rag out and drains it, and blood comes out. And I just remember the entire audience going, ugh! And because it was such you weren't expecting it because he first did it with water, then goes on the chair, puts it inside and then drags out. I have to imagine that there were two rags in that bucket. One had water and one had blood. Yeah, because it's just it's so good. But it was one of those moments where he's doing it sort of.
SPEAKER_00He's he's not like devastated when he's doing it. He's kind of like. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I have not watched the movie. Okay. Have you read all the books then?
SPEAKER_00No. Okay.
SPEAKER_01I've just seen the series.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so I don't want to spoil too much, but Charlie and Nick go through their biggest rough patch in the movie slash the final book of the series. And one of the things is, I mean, this part isn't a spoiler for you, Charlie's had a lot of issues leading up to this movie. And actually his... Discussion of when he's in the health facility saying, you know, part of me wonders if I originally didn't want to get better, not because I didn't want to be healthy, but because the idea of putting in that works just sounded so exhausting.
SPEAKER_00It's felt easier to just stay where I was. That was a breakthrough for me in sort of locking in on Diana. But because of all of those years with Nick and Charlie together of, you know, Nick being Charlie's protector from bullies, Nick helping Charlie through his eating disorder... And then like Charlie in the movie, he's really kind of blossoming, blossoming. He's, you know, doing well in school. He's coming up. He has a job. He's doing a lot of things that you should do. He's growing up. And while Nick is very happy for him,
SPEAKER_00Nick is also kind of realizing that so much of his life has been wrapped around, wrapped up in being Charlie's protector. And rather than Yeah. Because, you know, we're together because he needed me. I still need him to need me.
SPEAKER_00And I find that same mentality with Dan here of like, if I'm not here to help her, who am I? Who am I even to her? I need her to need me. So while he does want her to get better and he's never going to do anything to make her not get better, it's also he's now used to the idea of being the savior and being the protector. And I think that I just think that that's not that that's something that he prides himself on so much as that that's part of his normal now. And he's not even aware of it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, he spent 18 years being her caretaker, sole provider for this family. And he Diana can't drive. Yeah. Like he is literally the driving force in the family. So because she fucking can't and Natalie doesn't have her license yet.
SPEAKER_00No, maybe she does. I think she's got her learners. No, she does. I think she does have her license because they talk about Diana teaching Natalie to drive and they ran over the cat.
SPEAKER_01Right. Yeah. They ran over the cat and then. Like, she's... Well, here's the question. So, there's a moment where Diana at the end is like, okay, I'm going to take you to your dance.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01How?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question. Well, so first thing is, it appears that Natalie drives Diana to her doctor. That is... Right. I have to take my mom to her doctor.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, part of the reason why Diana calls out for Natalie is she, you know, needs someone to take her. So, they go. I don't know. Maybe in that moment, Diana... Decides she's going to drive Natalie now. I don't know. Don't. Don't do it. Don't you do it. Don't you do it, little girl. I know. But also, maybe Natalie is the one who drives, and it's more that Diana is escorting her there. It's just the idea of, I'm your mother, so you may be driving, but I'm taking you.
SPEAKER_00But then the question becomes, how does Diana get home? Yeah. These are things. These are insignificant details. But I think what I love about... That interaction with her and Natalie, because it is an almost completely rewritten scene from second stage. The dramatic moment remains. Nothing in the story really changes with Next to Normal. They kept the plot pretty intact, but they would take other cracks at how to get in there.
SPEAKER_00And that scene between her and Natalie, I always enjoy because you understand... Just from the way that it's written and the way that both Alice and Casey have played it, that she is in a more stable place. For how long, who knows? But in this moment, she's got her feet on the ground and she's able to talk concisely and clearly. And Natalie wants it, but she also can't trust it because for 16 years that hasn't been her life with Diana. And she still wants to be the daughter in this moment.
SPEAKER_00Okay. She's she's saying what she needs to say, which is like, basically, you've been a terrible mom to me for 16 years, not because of your of where you are mentally, because of like all the other things that have that have contributed to this. I'm just like with the Gabe of it all. And. Diana doesn't deny it. She doesn't argue with her, but she does say the thing that no one was willing to say, which is exactly what happened with Gabe.
SPEAKER_00And that kind of, by giving Natalie that information that she never had before, is sort of an act of trust. You know, of... My sister sometimes will complain when she's like, why don't our parents tell us the truth about this situation that's going on? I'll be like, well, because we're their kids and they still think of us that way. And she's like, right, but I'm 39. I'm like, yeah. Yeah, I'm like, but it doesn't matter how old we get. Our parents are always going to think of us that way. And so I think Diana giving Natalie this closed off piece of information for
SPEAKER_00the first time is a way of saying like, I am opening up to you more and trusting you more. And that is the only investment I can give you right now. But take it and know that that's what I'm doing. And Natalie accepts it, which then I think is how Natalie is able to then briefly be the parent again for Dan at the end of the show. I love, I do really love, I really love when Diana leaves and Dan and Gabe have their moment and Natalie shows up.
SPEAKER_00And Dan finally breaks down. He finally has this real big cry, which he's always needed. It fills up this whole entire show. And for the first time, Natalie's not Thinking about, you know, her own pain anymore because it's always been like, mom, like your mother is going through something, but it's always her or like, Natalie, we need to talk about this. I don't want to. And then she sees just how much her dad's been bottling up and she comes to his aid and she begins the song of light of like, okay, let's, let's start slow.
SPEAKER_00Let's turn on some lights. You can't sit here all alone. I just, I always get very moved when people show up for people and stuff. It doesn't happen often in life. So when it happens in shows, I'm very happy.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01Like that moment is so lovely and I'm really glad that that's part of the reason why they cut it from the top of the second stage version. So our first introduction to light is Natalie basically turning on the light for her father. And that's another moment in London where when she said when Natalie says something along the lines of like, okay, I guess it's just us now. And you watch Gabe break. Mm-hmm. And it's like, it's finally his exclusion from the family.
SPEAKER_00Like, he's been let go. And then, what does Jack Wolf do? He walks past Eleanor Worthington Cox, lightly puts his hand on her hand, and then walks away, and Eleanor Worthington Cox does like a quick, whoo! Yeah, she's like, the fuck was that?
SPEAKER_01Yep, which, great. Yeah. Because she's the only one who hasn't like really interacted with him. Yeah. Like in a kind of text way. It did also kind of remind me of what they're doing at Rocky Horror now. With the callbacks, with the asshole and slut callbacks, because I saw first preview and no one knew what to do. And so now when somebody calls out asshole or slut at Brennan and Jad, Janet and Brad, Brennan and Jad, did I just have a stroke?
SPEAKER_01Do you smell toast?
SPEAKER_00Through the screen.
SPEAKER_01It's just another day. Day. Jesus Christ. So when the audience yells, asshole and slotted at Jen and Brad, they just kind of look around like they've heard a whisper of a ghost somewhere. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, I love it. I love it so much.
SPEAKER_01Great fucking bit. It's so good.
SPEAKER_00It always sounds... The reaction is exactly that. I always describe it as like they heard something in the pipes of like... Yeah. Like in the wall. They're like, what? What was that? It's so good. It's so funny.
SPEAKER_01It's so good. Have you seen it with... You saw it with Sherry, yeah? Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00No, I want to go back to see it with Sherry. If I can... Find a way to do it. I want to see it with Sherry before Stephanie, Andrew, and Luke leave. You need to. Because I'm sure that Kevin and Lauren will all be good, but I was such a fan of Stephanie. And I saw it the night before it opened, and I thought that she had it figured out, and I'm sure it's even better now.
SPEAKER_01It clicked in a way, because I saw Sherry's first performance in. So it was still the understudy on for Columbia. And all of a sudden the show clicked in a way that it really had not early on in previews. Mainly because, you know, Sherry knows how to set a fucking tone. And it is perfect.
SPEAKER_00I think we talked about this because you... Okay, so you did send me the audio of Sherry. Sorry, I did. He didn't do that. No, no, no. No, but... I had said one of the biggest problems with the original company, with Rocky Horror, and I enjoy my Juliette Lewis, she's not a musical theater girly. She started that show on an uneasy foot and ended it on an uneasy foot. So even all the goodwill that had been built up after science fiction, and it took a while, but we eventually got there.
SPEAKER_00And then it all kind of dissipated with the finale. And I was like, ugh. And I've just imagined because Sherry is Sherry and knows what to do, You build the goodwill earlier, so you can enjoy the show earlier, and then it doesn't dissipate at the end. You're just like, yeah. And we end with Sherry and her big old tits.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And the thing is, Sherry knows how to do... It's kind of like what she was doing in that first reveal in Queen of Versailles, where when the screen swiped aside and you saw Kristen, and Kristen was just sitting there begging the audience to love her. And... The screen swiped aside, and Sherry was just kind of staring vacantly out at the audience. I'm like, oh, you have a point of view on this woman. Juliette Lewis was so deadpan in science fiction, she might as well have actually been dead. And just vocally uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_01Sherry is giving, like, glaze, kind of, Michael Rennie was, like, I am setting a tone, and then I'm going to skrellt a bunch of E-flats at you. Of course she is, because she can, and she always should. Did you see her thing yesterday? Of her, like, in the car.
SPEAKER_00Adam sent it to me, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Jesus Christ. Because I saw Aida in Chicago out of town before it came in. And, you know, opening number's happening. And then we get to, this is the story of a love that flourishes in a time of gain of lovers. She, like, belts an F. And I sat bolt upright in my little gay chair. And I was like, who the fuck is this woman? And what is this show? And I am in. And her... 30 years later, 25 years later, 25, just on a road trip, just fully screen belting it in the car.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_00If you guys don't know what we're talking about, either join the Discord because somebody posted it there or just go to Sierra Boggess' Instagram. She shared it and Gunkel shared it with me. Listen, in this house, we will always worship Sherry Renee Scott. And I've said this before. There are two double features that shapes who I am. One double feature made me gay. One double feature made me an esoteric fuck. The first one is seeing... Maren Mazian, Amy Spanger, Kiss Me Kate, and Michael Burress, followed by Sherry Renee Scott and Heather Headley and Aida,
SPEAKER_00literally, and Adam Pascal, honestly, both leading men with hairy chests. I think within like four months, three or four months of each other, I'm pretty sure that's what made me gay. And then four years later, Caroline or Change in May of 2004, followed by Lennon and Piazza in April of 2005. Turned me into the theater kid I am. So that's, yeah, that's what you have to blame everybody. Sexy, squelting, esoteric fuckery. Yes. And, and again, just two deep dives in a row. I'm just like, and Michael Perez.
SPEAKER_00It's just.
SPEAKER_01Oh, I know. Look, lean into a niche. But also Amy Spanger and Sherry Renee Scott, both early Diana Goodmans. True. Ooh, you know who'd be a good Diana Goodman? Hmm. Heather Headley. Oh, that placement. Heather. Heather.
SPEAKER_02I miss the mountains.
SPEAKER_00Like just every vowel is opposite. Yeah. Yeah. But which works for that role. I'm sorry. It does. I think there are multiple ways to get into Diana. And I think the way that Casey does it is perfect for Casey. And what I love about what Casey Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Alice had a really strong balance early in the run, but I agree. I think as it got further along, things started to fall off the rails. I would love to hear, Rachel... You will. Thank you. Thank you. I'm interested to know what Christiane Knoll was like. She did it in Connecticut at Hartford, I believe. I'm sure it was nice. I'm sure it was perfectly fine. I read that she did it. She did like the first major regional production, I think. No, that's not true. But she did a major regional production. And I'm always going, what was she like?
SPEAKER_00But now I'm just wondering, you know, what would Heather bring to it? Sherry, unfortunately, is past the age because the thing is, Diana and Dan are younger than people realize.
SPEAKER_01They are in their early 40s. And that is the thing that does freak me out a little bit. Like, Casey Levy doesn't seem like a Diana to me. She seems too young. And then you do the math and you're like, oh, fuck. Like, Natalie Joy Johnson just played it recently. I'm like, Natalie Joy Johnson is not anybody's mom. And then you do the math and then it's like, okay, she's... Probably a little, she will not mind me saying this, a little older than Alice was when she did it.
SPEAKER_01She just reads younger because, you know, 46 in these days is very different than 46 in 2007, is very different than 46 in 1953. It's true.
SPEAKER_00I mean, listen, Casey... She takes very good care of herself, and that is a beautiful thing. Also, she's only like, what, 44, 45?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. She's like 44.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I also feel like she's always a bit younger than people think, just because she's been around for like 22 years. Yeah. Came from Canada and immediately booked Broadway and just kept working because she's exceptionally well hydrated.
SPEAKER_01But that's it. I saw Natalie do it at Barrington Stage and that was a performance that she sang the hell out of it and the acting of it. Again, get a comic actor to do a devastating piece and you're going to be surprised as hell.
SPEAKER_00Listen, we talk about this all the time, of some of the best actors have been able to master comedy and drama, or started in comedy and then threw us all for a wrench. Sally Fields, one of the best criers in film, used to be the flying goddamn nun, okay? The flying nun! Robin Williams of Morgan Mindy fame, amazing dramatic actor. Or fucking Emma Thompson used to be in sketch comedy. Look at what we're talking about, Mia. The... Oh, the last thing I wanted to ask you about the material itself,
SPEAKER_00the Gabe thing of, because what makes the reveal of Gabe happens early in the show after I Miss the Mountains and Diana's offer for meds and they're doing It's Gonna Be Good. And it all culminates with Natalie's boyfriend, Henry, who we haven't spoken of once this entire episode. He's lovely. He's, yeah. I think Henry's like a very sweet, soft heart who... I'll be honest, I've always kind of never totally bought that relationship on paper. It's really up to the actors to sell it to me.
SPEAKER_00And I did think Adam Chandler Barat was so adorable on the Broadway production. I'm a little less up on the guy in the London cast, but I think he and Eleanor have very good chemistry. And so I'm not as big on his performance, but I'm okay with the relationship, if that makes sense.
SPEAKER_01I'm fine with it. I think Adam really made that performance, made that role work in a way that I've rarely seen work that well since.
SPEAKER_00Well, because he's also often meant to be comedic relief. He's a stoner and he breaks Natalie out of her shell. And there are things he says that it's very easy to not get a laugh on that Adam made seem so easy. And the... Yeah, it's like just certain lines that I've watched other Henrys not get the laugh on, like towards the end of the, have you heard from your mom? Yeah, she's with my grandparents, beat, do they exist?
SPEAKER_00And like, or like, do they actually exist? And I've heard, like the guy in London says this sort of like as a joke and the audience kind of chuckles and I saw it done in Brooklyn and the Henry was like, Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So this is to say, yeah, he's it's the easy way to get exposition out as you invite someone new who doesn't know anything or, you know, in a friend group who doesn't like it's the brilliant thing about sex the city is always in those friend groups when one of them has a story going on. You always have three girls at the table know the story, but one doesn't. So it's like Miranda is not doesn't know. But so like Carrie will begin and Charlotte will like add a detail. So it doesn't sound so exposition heavy. It sounds like a conversation. But so Henry doesn't really know the family. And when he shows up, Diana comes out with a birthday cake.
SPEAKER_00And I remember Adam used to get a laugh on this because he would look around and go like, huh, whose birthday is it? And you just saw Jen Damiano just go. She played it very well. I remember Eleanor Worthington Cox, she was much more kind of, it was like the floor fell out from under her when she said my brothers. Because in London, it kind of is implied that this might be the first time that this has been openly done by Diana. Whereas on Broadway, it felt a little bit more like it's happened in the past.
SPEAKER_00And I want to chat with you a bit more before we get to the final conclusion of this episode. Final conclusion. What am I? But there's only one conclusion, Brian. But yeah, it's the, I didn't know you had a brother. I don't. He died when I was a baby. And that, it's just important to re-say that on mic because some people will be like, but I don't know next to normal. How is it we find out that Gabe is a ghost twink? Natalie tells us. And you should always trust an ingenue.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. A sad, sad perfectionist ingenue.
SPEAKER_00Yes. But so my question for you is in your interpretation, the Gabe stuff has this. Do we think this is a new occurrence or is this something that has always been kind of happening with Diana? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Okay, I think it's new in its frequency and how much it's manifesting. I think he might have always been there as a little bit of a voice in her head, but now he's just really showing up as subconsciously he is going to turn 18 and leave the house. So she's trying to hold on to him as long as possible. I do think it's manifested a little bit just in that...
SPEAKER_01Jennifer, no. Natalie knows that it's his birthday. Like, this is a day that's known in this house.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And yet...
SPEAKER_01If we don't ever talk about him and he's something that doesn't exist, I don't know why she would know that it was his birthday.
SPEAKER_00That's the thing that always confused me of, has this happened before? Is this a date that everyone knows but we just don't talk about? Or... Is Natalie maybe putting the pieces together of it's no one's birthday, but mom has a cake. Oh God, it must be Gabe's birthday. I think if I were doing the dramaturgy for a production or just flat out directing a production, I think there is
SPEAKER_00lot of meal to be had of this idea of Natalie being told at an early age that she had a brother who died before she was born. And over the years, she would ask a question here and there and only get one answer out of every like 10 and then just eventually stopped asking. But it is still information that it's all this information that everybody knows. But there's also something kind of, I don't know, it's kind of bleak about if it is actually Gabe's birthday on that day,
SPEAKER_00how they're all acting on In general, before Diana comes out with the cake. Like, just no acknowledgement at all. And the bubbliness of that song and of... Because, like, Dan has to know. If it's his birthday, Dan must remember. Is he also not being manic in the song to push it so far down? Has Natalie just forgotten because it's been 16 years and she never knew Gabe? And Henry's just purely giddy because he doesn't know that Gabe fucking exists.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. And he's just meeting his girlfriend's family for the first time. Mm-hmm. Because they've been dating for 16 weeks.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Nine weeks? Nine weeks and three days. Something like that. Sorry. Sorry, everybody. What is time?
SPEAKER_00I just know it's... It's been a minute. It's been at least two months, yeah. And in high school time, that's
SPEAKER_01basically a year. That is forever. Yeah, I mean, I think that does contribute to Dan's mania about it. Even whether or not he's acknowledging or really remembers that that's the day, that's part of the reason why he's so manic about keeping the tone light, keeping it up. But I mean, secrets in a family are weird. Like I had a brother that I didn't know existed who died before I was born. And I didn't know about it until I was like probably eight or nine.
SPEAKER_01And my sister told me. And I didn't believe her that there was a kid in between her and me who died, like was born really prematurely and died like hours after he was born. So went to my mom and asked. And she acknowledged it was true. And we just never had talked about it. And it was never spoken of in my house. And that was like the one conversation we've ever had about it. So secrets in families are weird. There is stuff that is never acknowledged.
SPEAKER_00There's also something so... To bury a child in general is a devastation that I do not ever wish to know. It's partly why I don't have kids. Yeah. And also because I have no patience. But, says the man with the four-hour podcast. But the... There is a certain devastation in burying a child of when they're an infant. Before your child can really start to have a personality, to have memories of their own, right? Of all of the loss of time, of just opportunities and all these things.
SPEAKER_00And I think that it's interesting to see how different parents treat that. Do we continually mourn the child that we lost? Or do we make that a footnote? For lack of a better term, because A, it's very painful, but also we need to continue to build upon our lives and we can't create a shrine for a very small moment of time that was extraordinarily devastating. And that is something that I think Dan does of we have to build.
SPEAKER_00And ultimately, I don't think the idea of building is wrong, but they do do it just too soon. That's the problem of. Closet into a television? Well, it depends on which version we're watching. Does she always have a television?
SPEAKER_00Does she go into the television?
SPEAKER_01They get her out of the closet in Poltergeist.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Sorry. I'm confused today. In is out, up is down, closets are TVs.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00And Patti LuPone is now a top, apparently. Patti LuPone is a first top on the seas. No, that's just in maritime law. On dry land, she is a demon twink bottom. Yep. Yeah. That also tracks. Yeah. There's vacation Patti and then there's nine to five Patti.
SPEAKER_01Oh, vacation patty is fun, you guys. Yeah. My last thing about
SPEAKER_00Next to Normal, and I forgot that this was something that always kind of bugged me until I watched London live tape. Because the thing is, their Broadway production, I felt cut against the finale of Light being, you know, this big let's all stand and sing number by having... Right.
SPEAKER_00This time it's real. And I really always liked that moment of Natalie kind of getting acknowledged for her life now. And I know Jen smiling and laughing for kind of the first time the entire show. Ever? Yeah. But I loved details like that because my thing is that the London production, for the most part, is actually extraordinarily detailed in all of the intricacies of the characters except for light, where it actually just becomes like... I hate to say this because I do love what everyone's doing for the most part,
SPEAKER_00but there's a shot of Eleanor right as she's about to sing her solo of light with Henry. She's like, you're my favorite problem, Henry. And then she just turns right out and she goes, but day after day, and it's very college- Musical theater presentation. And it sticks out like a sore thumb because the rest of those performances are so good. So when shit like that happens, again, it's just like so egregious. And that whole number is just everyone now standing forward and Casey's at the center. And it bugs me because that number often is used in, you know, showcases.
SPEAKER_00It has that sort of like, and now we're all set to stage and we sing. It's the Lost Boys. It's fucking, it's the do you hear the people sing finale. And love is the answer and we're fine. Yeah. Yes. And like light is a beautiful song, but it does have that. Now we're in five part harmony singing about how we made it through the storm.
SPEAKER_00And the original production I felt was able to cut against that for the most part in a way that the London production doesn't. And it's just so interesting because in almost every other way, I find that the London production adds even more than the Broadway production did, except for that number. And it's just a shame it's the last number. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. They bought so much goodwill at that point. I'm sure if I were in the theater watching it, I wouldn't have cared. I just would have cried.
SPEAKER_00But watching it now in my home on my couch with no pants on, furious but sailing. Not now, but also
SPEAKER_01that close-up of her going, Day after day.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. They did her a little dirty with that shot, I find, because, again, everyone else, the whole rest of the show, she's doing such wonderful work at that one shot. Yeah. And it could have been, like, just that one take. She might have done it better in multiple other takes, and that was the take they picked. And I'm sure she looked at it, and she was like,
SPEAKER_02seriously, guys? Oh, God.
SPEAKER_00She said, I have Olivia Award-winning Eleanor Worthington Cox. You are going to give me that shot? Valid. Valid. Rough. Okay. So, as we said, Next to Normal did win the Pulitzer. It also won three Tony Awards for score, actress, and tied for orchestrations with Billy Elliot, one of the few ties in Tony Award history. Sure. Okay, fine. Closed January 2011 after 733 performances. As we mentioned, it had a national tour, also with Alice Ripley. 2017, TheatreWorks Hartford with Christian Knoll.
SPEAKER_002020, Kennedy Center with Rachel B. Jones and Brander Victor Dixon. This is clearly the show that caused COVID. Yeah. And then the West End. January 2020.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00The thing about this show in terms of its legacy is that whereas... It's sort of the inverse of Light in the Piazza where Adam and I were saying like Piazza as a show hasn't really affected musical theater. Not a lot of people have tried to make another Piazza or something similar to it, but the people involved with Piazza Have created a legacy like Piazza created a legacy because of the people involved. And I personally find Next to Normal is kind of the opposite, where it's like the show has a major legacy and it had a major impact on writing
SPEAKER_00and subject matter. And yet I find that a lot of the people involved a little less so the biggest impact in terms of people involved. It's probably Aaron Tveit. This is the show that really fucking launched him. And his lack of a Tony nomination was a thing that people really screamed about at the time. And Michael Greif remains a very prominent director in musical theater. But it's this, Evan Hansen. But before either show, he had Rent, which is sort of a blank check forever.
SPEAKER_00He had Grey Garden. So that's not even really a launching point. It's a launching point for Tom Kidd and Brian Yorkey. And yet, shall we? That collaboration, yeah. Yeah. Superhero? Was it called Superhero? Superhero, that's at, where was that? Second Stage. Second Stage, yeah. They also have If Then, which is probably their biggest post-Next Normal success, and I wouldn't personally call that one a success, Sliding Doors in the Musical. Yeah. I just got I'll never forget the opening of Act Two where Idina Menzel comes on
SPEAKER_00and she's singing like stage directions where she's like standing on a corner opposite of a wedding on 37th and Amsterdam or whatever the fuck the lyrics are singing the street address of what's across the street. I'm like, can we not do that? They did rewrite the Freaky Friday musical for Disney, which Disney liked enough to license and make into a TV movie with Heidi Blickenstaff. I feel like Heidi has done Next to Normal somewhere. She has to have. She has to have. Yeah. They wrote the musical adaptation of The Visitor at the Public, which went nowhere and had a lot of drama behind it.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Kit has also done Bring It On and Almost Famous, Flying Over Sunset, Dave. And so it's just... Tom Kidd has had a lot more success post-Next Normal as an arranger and as a music supervisor, which is also what he was doing before Next Normal. And I do think that's where a lot of his talent lies in taking a lot of music and making it one big, cohesive storytelling sound. But considering how wonderful this score is, Next Normal, it is kind of...
SPEAKER_00It's frustrating that this collaboration has not yielded more consistent results. But I mean, I feel the same way about Grey Garden. So when I do that deep dive, get ready, everybody.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I wish that. I was fine with it then, what slash now, but yeah, I don't remember anything about superhero other than Kate Baldwin being wonderful and Tom Sessama being great.
SPEAKER_00Tom Sesma's always great.
SPEAKER_01Tom Sesma's always great. Why are people not talking about Tom Sesma more, Brian Nash? I don't know. Because he's never been given. He is the perfect secondary lead or random character actor. Sure. And they never get the glory that they need. But Tom Sesma is brilliant and reliable in fucking everything.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So my favorite Sweeney that I've seen live. Oh, yeah, I forgot I did that. Yeah, I think he was the last one. I saw him and Sally and Triplet do it twice in the pie shop, and they were incredible. Yeah, that's sort of where we are with Next to Normal. I guess with Spring Awakening and Next to Normal combined, it becomes this big step forward with rock music and musical theater, and we do have a lot more of it now. I would argue never quite as successfully as this. It starts leaning more into pop and like with Dear Evan Hansen,
SPEAKER_00it becomes like, okay, now we get radio hits and songs that can work outside of context. Because the thing about Next Normal is other than I Miss the Mountains, I really don't think any song works out of context. They're wonderful songs to listen to, but... I don't think that they they don't land quite as well in like a showcase. Like I watched I was at Thespians this past year and two years ago and a girl sang. So anyway, the song that Diana sings when she leaves and she's a lovely job. But I was like, why this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's vocally, it's a lovely piece vocally, but it doesn't, it's not going to hit if you're not coming out of the rest of the two hours of the show.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there are things in this show that I would recommend for like class. If you have three actors who want to do the, you don't know, I am the one, want to do that for class, like to work on it, I say fucking class. Go for it. But if and maybe for like thespians, maybe because it's hard to do scene work, musical scenes and thespians that work out of context. But yeah, if you want to like do Superboy and the Invisible Girl as a duet for, you know, a concert, I'm sorry, it just doesn't work.
SPEAKER_01It's two minutes and you're wasting your time.
SPEAKER_00And it's a duet for the last 20 seconds. Yeah. Yep. Yeah. Anyway, Brian, thank you so much for doing this today. Of course. Thanks for having me. Any last words on Xnormal before we
SPEAKER_01wrap shit up? Um, look, I'm glad that they took the time to get it right. They took the time to really lean into what the material was actually saying instead of what they wanted to say about the material, initially, and about the subject. If you're writing a musical about deep, deep things, lean the fuck in. I love that.
SPEAKER_00I think if you're going to do Next to Normal, make sure you cast actors. Like actors. And this is one of those shows like for me, like, look, he's a wild party where I'm like, you need an intimacy coordinator and you need a therapist on set. Yep. Yep. There needs to be a therapy dog in the room because it's it's a tough one. And if you're going to do it right, you're going to have to go for it. This is not a show you mark.
SPEAKER_00Well, Brian, where can people find you if you want them to find you?
SPEAKER_01I can be found on the Instagrams at Brian with an IJNash. That's about it. I have not updated my website since COVID. No. Don't bother.
SPEAKER_00Are you doing any shows in town soon? Soon. I don't know. I've got to book them. Okay. So shortly. Brian's shows are fun, guys. He did one at Greenroom 42 recently. That was a fuck ton of fun. So if you ever is doing one, I highly recommend you go. If you want to find me, I'm on Instagram at Matt Koplik, usual spelling. Make sure to join the Patreon if you haven't yet to become a company member for $5 a month. You will get your sneak preview of our first exclusive episode next week, the top 50 opening numbers in musical theater history.
SPEAKER_00If you like the podcast, make sure to give us a nice five-star rating or review. That will always help with the algorithm. You can watch us on YouTube if you'd like. Discord, if you want to join the Discord or the Substack. Otherwise, we will be going dark for most of August. We have a couple of fun surprises that may be popping up throughout August, some fun interviews and whatnot. But yeah, we will be coming back in earnest probably mid-September. Maybe after, yeah, I think the first episode, the first real episode back will be my London trip because I'm going back to London in September.
SPEAKER_01Ooh.
SPEAKER_00Field trips.
SPEAKER_01Who's earnest? Who's earnest? You said you're going to be coming back in earnest. Oh, in earnest. You're trying to pretend you're a top, so... I will punch you in the face. You knew I was going to bring it back before the end of the episode. I honestly did. You didn't see it coming? Anyway, if we're going to talk about a depressing-ass show, we need to leaven it by the end.
SPEAKER_00Next show that we do needs to be something fun, because Jesus Christ... First of all, Hamilton and I don't, I'd never found to be a depressing show. That was just a depressing day. This is definitely a depressing show. Sure, yeah, he gets shot at the end and then we're
SPEAKER_01crying about an orphanage. Yeah, it's a real fucking toe tapper.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I'm like, yeah, children need to go somewhere where I don't have to see them. An orphanage. Thank you. Thank you for your help, Eliza Hamilton. This was not a depressing day. This was a very fun day for a very sad show, and I'm sure there are a lot of fans who are going to be furious that this wasn't three straight hours of only the show. But fuck you all, this is the last episode for a minute, so I just wanted to have some fun. But yeah, no, okay, fine. The next show you do will be, I don't know, Spamalot. Of the icing. Fiorello.
SPEAKER_00Your next show is going to be Fiorello. You're welcome. No, thanks. Okay. Ryan, we close out every episode with a diva. What diva do you want to close us out with 2D?
SPEAKER_01Let us go back to Workshop Diana Goodman and go back to Sherry Renee Scott. Always.
SPEAKER_00I think we've closed out with Sherry more times this year than combined Sherry closeouts in previous years. And I'm not mad about it at all. She's in the zeitgeist. She's back. She's back, you guys. She really is. I think we'll close out with Poor Unfortunate Souls this time because I don't think we've ever done that. She's amazing. All right. Thank you so much, guys. We'll see you soon. Enjoy the preview next week and then have a good rest of your August. Take it away, Sherry. Bye.
SPEAKER_03So now I've got a voice. The boss is on a roll. You poor unfortunate.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...