Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

Deep Dive: HOW I LEARNED TO DRIVE w/ Margaret Hall

Feb 19, 20261 hr 57 minAudio

CONTENT DISCLAIMER: This episode discusses a play which depicts predatorial relationships, sexual assault, and grooming. In this episode, Matt sits down with Breakdown fam Margaret Hall (Playbill, Gemignani) to unpack Paula Vogel’s Pulitzer Prize-winning play How I Learned to Drive. Together, they explore the play’s nonlinear structure, its daring tonal shifts, and nuanced depiction of predatory relationships, violation, and survival. From its acclaimed 1997 premiere to its long overdue 2022 Broadway debut, this conversation examines why Vogel’s play remains as urgent - and as debated - as ever. Important Broadway Breakdown Links Sondheim. Webber. Koplik. A Birthday Threesome: Tix Broadway Breakdown: Discord Broadway Breakdown: Substack Margaret Hall: Website Margaret Hall is a theater journalist and critic whose work has appeared in Playbill and beyond. Known for her thoughtful analysis and deep knowledge of contemporary theater, Margaret brings both scholarly rigor and emotional intelligence to this discussion - making her an ideal guide through Vogel’s intricate, memory-driven script and its evolving cultural context. Timestamps 00:00 - Introduction and why How I Learned to Drive still sparks conversation 05:12 - Paula Vogel’s background and the play’s 1997 premiere 12:45 - Plot overview: Li’l Bit, Uncle Peck, and the mechanics of memory 22:30 - The Greek Chorus device and Vogel’s nonlinear structure 31:18 - Tone, humor, and discomfort: why the play feels dangerous 41:07 - Original Off-Broadway production and early critical response 58:34 - The 2022 Broadway revival: returning cast and creative team 1:10:21 - Tony Awards recognition and contemporary reception 1:18:46 - Directorial interpretation and performance nuance 1:27:05 - The play in the #MeToo era: shifting audience lenses 1:36:40 - Legacy, pedagogy, and why the play continues to be produced 1:45:12 - Final thoughts: is this a “masterpiece,” and what does that mean? Key people mentioned Paula Vogel - Playwright Mark Brokaw - Original Off-Broadway and Broadway revival director Mary-Louise Parker - Original Li’l Bit (1997) David Morse - Original Uncle Peck (1997) Johanna Day - Greek Chorus (original production) Norbert Leo Butz - Uncle Peck (2012) Listener discussion questions How does Vogel’s use of a nonlinear structure affect the audience’s response to Li’l Bit and Uncle Peck, as opposed to If the play were presented in chronological order? Is it important for an audience to not always be comfortable? What play can you think of that lured an audience in with difficult subject matter? How has How I Learned to Drive shifted your perception (if it has at all) on survival? As always, join the conversation on Substack and in the Broadway Breakdown Discord - and let us know where this play ranks in your personal American theater canon. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00On the still of the night, I held you tight.

SPEAKER_03Hello, all you theater lovers, both out in crowd and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. This series is called Matt's Picks, and it is covering shows that you all suggested that I did not pick out of a bowl, but I wanted to cover anyway. Our guest today is a friend of the pod. I believe this is her third time on, maybe fourth?

SPEAKER_01I think third official.

SPEAKER_03Third official, third official. Although she has definitely contributed some information to me on some of my researches. But that's strictly off the record, I suppose. You would best know her from her work as a writer on Playbill. You would also know her from her work on Gemignani, Life and Lessons from Boudouin and Beyond. Or also a more recent work where she was co-editor of Blood, Sweat, and Queers, a vampiric... Sorry, I have the full title here. Vampiric Love Stories. She's also, according to her website, and I don't know why she would lie about this,

but she is the youngest known nominator in the History of the Drama Desk Awards.

SPEAKER_01I got bullied by Peter Felicia into putting that on my website. It is true. It feels hokey to state, but it's true.

SPEAKER_03I mean, facts are facts, and you can't argue with the facts. However, let's be real. You best know her from her appearances on this podcast. It is Margaret Hall. Hi, Margaret.

SPEAKER_01Hi, Maggie. Hi.

SPEAKER_03How have you been since I last saw you?

SPEAKER_01Since you last saw me? Well, I did laundry. I meal prepped. I got very excited about some casting news we're going to get at midnight.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I'm very excited about that, too. I realize I've actually now seen you twice in two weeks, which is... It's such a luxury for us.

SPEAKER_01So wonderful.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Because we try to see each other, but it tends to be more that we see each other by accident because we're both so busy, but our paths cross all the time. But we had two times in two weeks where we, like, made a point to see each other, and we did it.

SPEAKER_01Every once in a while, the industry will allow you to see your friends. It is not often, but sometimes you get that moment. Right.

SPEAKER_03It's true. I will be grateful for the industry that it has not forced me into rooms with people I didn't want to see again. But maybe that's because I'm not going into all those rooms all that much.

SPEAKER_01Fair. It's happened to me occasionally, but it's not regular.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. I find that I'm more pleasantly surprised to see people at things than finding someone there and going, oh, God, this person. Although, in my defense, the number of people that I would be happy to see in a room is a lot longer of a list than the people I would not be happy to see.

SPEAKER_01100% agreed. Yesh.

SPEAKER_03I hope that everyone feels the same about me. Maybe I'm that person who's like, I keep running into goddamn conflict. What am I going to do? Boy, did you see my reaction when I ran into you at that reading this summer?

SPEAKER_01I almost jumped out of my skin. I was so happy.

SPEAKER_03You were like Ponyo hugging Sosuke. It was great. Oh, my God. It was great.

SPEAKER_01Lovely. What a good surprise.

SPEAKER_03Yes. And that was the reading that I was in, everybody.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03Never forget that he sometimes goes on stage, which is a good reminder for everyone that there will be a link to tickets for Sondheim Weber Koplik, a birthday threesome at Green Room 42, March 6th at 7 p.m. Woo-hoo, woo-hoo. Very exciting stuff. Margaret, Maggie.

SPEAKER_01Matthew.

SPEAKER_03What are we discussing today?

SPEAKER_01We are discussing Paula Vogel's How I Learned to Drive.

SPEAKER_03The Pulitzer Prize winning How I Learned to Drive. I will do a quick recap of this for everyone and then we'll get into the deepest of dives for it. I should probably put a warning now for anyone that this is a play that deals with very complicated and very traumatic issues. It's a very dark subject matter. And it's one that I'm personally very excited to finally tackle. But if you have any triggers when it comes to sexual assault, sexual abuse,

SPEAKER_03grooming, gaslighting, motor vehicles.

SPEAKER_02Incest.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, incest. That old chestnut. But in fairness to this play, it's not aspects of love. So the incest is a little more meant to be grossing you out and not meant to sort of be like Romeo and Juliet.

SPEAKER_01No, not at all.

SPEAKER_03No. But yeah, so if this is anything that troubles you or that you really don't think you can handle listening to, I understand and would recommend that maybe you wait for the next week's episode. Please know that Margaret and I are very empathetic people who come to this with our own baggage and journeys. And we will be dealing with this, I hope, in a tasteful manner on my end. I know you will, but I can't speak for myself.

SPEAKER_01We'll keep you on a short leash.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. But also, this is Broadway Breakdown, so this is not going to be trauma dumping. This is not a therapy session. It's a mix of the both, which I think is emblematic of the play itself. This is a play that is surprisingly funny, surprisingly tender, and surprisingly even... Is it even keeled or even peeled? I never...

SPEAKER_01Even keeled.

SPEAKER_03Even keeled. Thank you. So with that in mind, let's jump into the synopsis as per stage agent. Paula Vogel's groundbreaking and controversial play, How I Learned to Drive, tells the story of a young girl who grows up in a complex and sexually abusive relationship with her uncle in 1960s Maryland. The play follows the young girl a little bit. from her adolescence through college years and ends with her as a 30-something adult. Although Lil' Bit and her uncle share a mutual understanding and care deeply for one another, the years of manipulation and sexual confusion eventually drive

them apart and

SPEAKER_03wreak havoc on both of their psyches. I would say that that's relatively accurate without giving too much of the plot away.

SPEAKER_01I'd give it an 8.5 out of 10.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I'm not sure how I would do a better job, but I'm sure that there's one that could be done. I'd be interested to see how Paula would write a nut graph for it at this point in her life. Sure. Well, her pitch at the time, her elevator pitch when she was sort of sending this play out all over New York was that it was Lolita from the perspective of Lolita, which I think that's a very good elevator pitch.

SPEAKER_01And in the 90s especially.

SPEAKER_03Oh, for sure. Before, you know, this play premiered in New York City in 1997. And when you read it and watch it now, knowing all the conversations that we've had since then, it's surprising how in-depth this play goes when this was something that wasn't discussed at all in the 90s. So it's really masterful how well it's held up in that respect.

SPEAKER_01She's a master of her craft.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean, I won't lie. I've been very open about my dislike for mother play, but I also was, I was talking to a friend about this today. Hey, Wyatt, if you're listening, I think I'm so hard on mother play because I like Vogel so much. This is, I've said many times, this is one of my favorite plays, top three plays for me. I also really enjoy Indecent. I've only gotten to read Baltimore Waltz. We read it in college, but I never got to see it staged. I would imagine it's very good staged, but yeah. With Mother Play, I was like, oh my God, Vogel,

SPEAKER_03Landau, Ceeley Keen and Bolger, even Lange and Parsons. And I was like ready for it to be my personality. It was not. And I got very angry. That tends to be my pattern when I want something to be amazing, when I think it's going to really like blow my socks off and it doesn't, I get resentful.

SPEAKER_01I get it. I won't name names, but I have a couple of artists that are very important to me. And I have a lot more leeway. I think it's the writer in me. I have a lot more leeway for someone writing a project that isn't necessarily for me, but I know it's something they needed to get out of themselves. That's kind of how I approach mother play of. I think that's a story Vogel needed to tell. And therefore I am glad Vogel told it. Um,

SPEAKER_01When I get like not resentful, but I get mad and specifically some of the people I'm thinking of are artists that I am lucky enough to know personally. I will send an email and be like, hey, is when I can tell they're telling something that isn't true to who they are and their perspective on the world. That's the stuff that will really rankle me. If I think it's honest and I just don't happen to like it, I respect it much more than if I think it's dishonest.

SPEAKER_03Oh, for sure. For sure. And I also feel like I've been very good about talking about works and recognizing if it's not for me, but seeing the craft, seeing the expertise.

SPEAKER_01You are very good at that.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. And that's a professional drama desk nominator, everybody. She knows of what she speak.

SPEAKER_01Oh, boy. So, Maggie, how did this show, how did How I Learned to Drive enter your chat? So... properly college i was aware of it in high school but this is not exactly the kind of script you get at your public library in suburban ohio um but i was like aware of the concept of it i'd probably like read some kind of a reference to it in like

SPEAKER_01a pulitzer compendium or something But in college, a friend of mine did a scene from it in scene study class, and that led me down the rabbit hole, which I think is true for a lot of BFA students, is they find a lot of material through the stuff their friends are doing.

SPEAKER_03That's absolutely true. Do you remember which scene it was?

SPEAKER_01The photography scene.

SPEAKER_03Interesting. Okay, okay. I would have thought it would be the hotel scene, but yeah, the photography scene makes a lot of sense. She was exploring a very specific part of herself that she had not yet been able to

SPEAKER_01engage with. And it was really captivating to watch. And knowing what little I did know about the play and then watching that scene, it was such a dichotomy of like, I don't know how these two things I know about this piece now fit together. I need to read the full thing to see how these link.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. And then do you remember when you finally got to see it performed?

SPEAKER_01So I've never actually seen it fully live. My engagement with the revival was through this beautiful, beautiful company that I know we are both fans of. This program called the Theater on Film and Tape Archive. I love Toft. I love you, Steve. I love you, Brandon. Hey, guys. They're the best. Matt and I actually just went and watched the 1997 production to both be on the same page about that original as well going into this.

SPEAKER_01Toft is great. We love Toft. And so that was the first time I watched a staging of it was the recording of the revival.

SPEAKER_03Right. And do you remember when you watched that? Was that for this or was that a while ago?

SPEAKER_01It was a couple of years ago. So I do the My Life in the Theater series playbill. And if I am doing a playwright or a composer lyricist, if I'm not already very familiar with their work, like I didn't really need to brush up on Stephen Schwartz. But if for whatever reason, I'm like, oh, I feel like there's a gap in my knowledge before I do the interview. I will go to Toft and I'll watch what I can. And we did one with Paula. So I watched as much as I could.

SPEAKER_03Amazing. So you watched the revival of How I Learned to Drive. What were the other things you watched?

SPEAKER_01I watched Indecent. And they didn't have a full recording, but they had like pieces of Baltimore Waltz.

SPEAKER_03With Cherry Jones?

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03I would like to go and see some of those pieces. How did you find the pieces?

SPEAKER_01I love Indecent.

SPEAKER_03I have... Sorry, not Indecent, the pieces of Baltimore Waltz.

SPEAKER_01Oh, the pieces of Baltimore Waltz. I liked it. I feel like I cannot in any direction make a formal declaration until I've seen it in full.

SPEAKER_03Sure.

SPEAKER_01But having read the piece and seen the bits that I saw, I enjoyed.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. You can't make a full declaration. What are you, a professional or something?

SPEAKER_01How dare I have ethics.

SPEAKER_03Oh, my God. And not in this community. My God. Oh, my God. Oh, my God. I also first became aware of this play in college, not through any classes. No one that I know ever did scenes from it. Maybe someone in the acting class and the BFA acting program did it. But we never shared many classes with them. So it's just I wouldn't know for sure. But I'd always heard about it. and particularly had always heard about Mary Louise Parker and David Morris'

SPEAKER_03performances from the original Vineyard production. That's something that growing up in New York City and being a theater fan and trying to get to know as many people as I could who had been around longer than I had and had theater-going memories, a lot of the... So when I was in high school, I was taking acting classes and was getting coached on college auditions by professionals who were working on Broadway at that time who were about 10 to 15 years older than me. And this was one of those things that was talked a lot about to

me of like to them, Marylees Parker and David Morris in the Vineyard premiere of How I Learned to Drive

SPEAKER_03to them was like the gold standard.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm. It very much reminded me of probably the golden age of all of those legends,

SPEAKER_03all saying Lorette Taylor and the Glass Menagerie, one after the other. Every teacher has that performance that they just become evangelicals for.

SPEAKER_01I'm notorious amongst my students. I never shut up about Michael Cerveris and in the next room. Surprise, surprise.

SPEAKER_03There she is.

SPEAKER_01Everyone has that performance that will never leave their brain.

SPEAKER_03One thousand percent. I will say I've got a few. My Michael Service performance is fun home. But also Michael Service brings it to every ball. So I don't feel like there's a best actor alive.

SPEAKER_01And I will fight anyone who says otherwise. There are other incredibly talented performers. He has a kaleidoscope.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. He's actually somebody, part of me was like, oh, he could maybe play Uncle Peck, but in the way he sort of did in Fun Home, a version of Uncle Peck, I would say.

SPEAKER_01This is absolutely the kind of role he could play. One of my big takeaways after having just seen him play Scrooge in A Christmas Carol is I want him to get to play happy more because it was so joyous watching him play Scrooge like post-Revelation wake up when he's just so happy running around and enjoying Christmas. I would like to see him play happy next.

SPEAKER_03Sure. Well, I think that's sort of what makes Peck such an interesting role is that for all the monstrous things that he is, the key to him is that he's quite charming. And that was something that Ben Brantley couldn't get over in his initial review at the Vineyard. It's fascinating. You read that review and it's a total love letter to David Morse. I'm like very positive about Mary Louise Parker, but he can't get over David Morse.

SPEAKER_01It's wild. But it also it reminds me. Not to invoke a name no one wants to hear, but it reminds me of everything around American Beauty and people talking about Kevin Spacey. Although, I mean, as far as I know, David is a lovely person. There's something that captivates people when they see people they perceive to be good playing bad really, really well. yeah i think with american beauty at the time it was viewed as

such like a tour de force narrative for spacey and it took a few years for the rest of the world to be

SPEAKER_03like and annette benning is also very amazing in that movie that's

SPEAKER_01It's here, too. Can we play it?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And that probably should have won that year. And now she may never, so it sucks. But anyway, yeah, I knew about it. I had heard about it. And then in college, we had a teacher who mentioned an encounter he'd had with Paula Vogel in a car on their way to, I think, doing... a show together like at a theater company and her talking a bit about her process about writing this play which we'll talk about in a second and i never knew what the subject matter of the play was so when he was discussing it

to us in class i was like oh shit oh oh oh shit so that's what the title means and i finally got to

SPEAKER_03see it live in 2012 2013 at second stage okay yeah Yeah, that was with Elizabeth Reeser as Lil' Bit and Norbert Leo Butz as Peck. And that was kind of an American beauty narrative where that production, all everyone could talk about was Norbert Leo Butz, this tour de force for him as Peck. And it actually really unbalanced the production.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I love Elizabeth, but Norbert his entire career has been a force of charisma. It's just who he is. It's what makes him a star is he has that energy that you can't not watch. And that's a really tricky thing to play with in a show like this where... You're having to watch someone who just has such an inherently likable energy play someone that truly is doing abhorrent things, but in a way that isn't, like,

SPEAKER_01horror movie grotesque. Yeah, because the way that the play is written and the way that it's usually staged...

SPEAKER_03It's all very hyper-theatrical, stylized, abstract. So you only on one occasion, we'll get to that occasion, do you see the horrors literally happen. Everything else is done in a way that it's kind of to our comfort.

SPEAKER_01And Paula does a masterful job of it. She takes a topic that this is the kind of play... I think trigger warnings in theater in general are a good thing. I think it's always better for people to have information if they need it. This is the kind of play that I would not take someone to if I did not talk to them about it beforehand to make sure they were good.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I would not tell them what the plot was, but I would... Similar to what we did at the top of, like, these are the themes it's going to cover.

SPEAKER_01Is this something you can handle right now?

SPEAKER_03Exactly. And I'm not... I've always been a huge champion of, you know, going outside of your comfort zone a little bit and really kind of confronting some difficult things that you need to do. And I practice what I preach because in 2022, I saw the revival with my mother and that was very much an experience and we will talk about it, I swear. This play to me is... It's a memory play.

SPEAKER_03It's a play about understanding and absolvement. It's a memory play and a therapy session all in one without it actually being so on the nose about either because it jumps around with the chronology of events a little bit. But mostly what it does is it just sort of goes – it goes mostly backwards in time with one or two jump forward again. And the purpose of that is – Vogel wants us to get the shock of Lil' Bit and Peck's

relationship over and done

SPEAKER_03with as soon as possible. And the way she does that is when we see them for the first time, they've been in this... dynamic for a few years now and it's kind of become routine for them and because they're so casual about it we kind of get sucked into the casualness very quickly and then as it keeps going backwards in time part of us is we're trying to piece together sort of the narrative here but we're also going like okay but then when did this start and how did it start? I'm like, goddamn, how early does it go?

Because we first meet them when she's 17 and then it's 16 and it's happening and 15

SPEAKER_03and it's happening. It's like, how early did this begin? And we eventually get the answer and it's terrible. But because it's the brilliance of the play of... of suckering you into the charm of this man and and what we think is the independence of little bit as much as as as she can have throughout all of this and they're very complicated feelings for each other and then when you see what the inciting incident is at the very end of the play that started this whole thing it's

SPEAKER_03like oh no no no no no this always was awful this always was assault but But it also tackles the complicated feelings one can have for the person who damaged them in many ways, but also gave them so much at the same time.

SPEAKER_01It's... The kind of play that I've been talking a lot about issue plays today, actually, and it's what I wish that term actually meant of someone taking a really well-rounded, thoughtful approach to presenting something to an audience of like, this is what it is like to be inside this. Mm hmm. You can stand outside it and judge it from all angles. And I'm not saying those judgments are wrong, but when you are inside it,

SPEAKER_01this is what it feels like. And I think that's the best way to coax an audience into an empathetic experience.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And I think what helps is this is a situation that Vogel had real life experience with. And so she was able to put in her truth and put in all of the complicated feelings and thoughts she had about it that had been living within within her for decades. She had a lot of time to stew on this subject matter and her story in particular. And so when she all came out on the page, In a lot of ways, it was very easy for her to write because she kind of went with

what happened.

SPEAKER_03And then she used her dramatist brain to make it compelling theater. And then the smart, nuanced side of her made sure to give both characters their do and their barbs. Because a little bit... is not a perfect victim in the way that, you know, people always complain about when stories of sexual violence occur. She has her own... She's done her own damage, not necessarily in her...

in her grooming, but post Peck, she has done damage to others, we learned.

SPEAKER_03There's a story of her, you know, she paints it as seducing a young man. We never really know the age of the young man. It could possibly be considered legally assault and statutory rape, but we don't ever know. And she connects it to her time with Peck. And it keeps you... having to constantly think and work about how you feel about both these characters all the time. And that's what makes this play, in my opinion, so brilliant.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I really... Oh, sorry. No? I really do think it is one of, if not the, best depictions of childhood sexual assault on stage. I think it's a really difficult conversation and thing that, like... I have friends with social work degrees, and they still really struggle to talk about recidivism and cycles. And when it comes to this stuff, it's a really icky,

uncomfortable thing that most well-adjusted human beings do not love to discuss.

SPEAKER_01It's not, I guess, flashy would be the term for it. It just... If it is not something you yourself has experienced, it is not a place you want to go in your psyche.

SPEAKER_03Right.

SPEAKER_01And even if you have experience, you don't necessarily want to go there. You just know where it is.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. You know where the bride married.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And this is just such... Even Kiel, that phrase you used earlier, I think is a good term for it. She doesn't pull a single punch... But that is true for every character in the piece. It would be very easy and probably would have been easier for her to write just a straight up here's why my uncle is the devil piece.

SPEAKER_01He does not come out of this good by any means. And I think it's one of the benefits of this not being the first play Vogel sat down to write, and not even the first semi-autobiographical piece that Vogel sat down to write. I go back, I talk to a lot of young dramatists in every flavor. And we talk a lot about sort of putting yourself in your work and when should you and when shouldn't you. I am all for artists pulling from their own life when it is

something they feel they need to do. I always think you need to have written at least one thing that's not about you first. Because I think it teaches you the tools you need to safely mine your own life.

SPEAKER_01I can't imagine how difficult the experience of this play, winning a Pulitzer and going on to become internationally acclaimed, would have been if Vogel had not known where her own lines of boundary were with this, and if she just straight up poured it out diaristically. She finds just the right line between this is a real story and this is everyone's story, and I think that's what makes it a true masterpiece.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, it's a very well-rounded take on Little Bits' experience. And I think it also helps that it is the character looking back on it all rather than living through it in real time. I think we can go in a little bit sort of the how we got here and then go a bit more into the depths of this play. So Vogel, at this point, had made a big splash in Baltimore Waltz, which was done in New York, I think at the Atlantic Theatre Company.

SPEAKER_01Sounds right.

SPEAKER_03Sounds right. She became the artist in residence for Perseverance Theater, which is in Juneau, Alaska. And she was going to write a play. So you can hear all about this, by the way, through Miss Maggie Hall's wonderful work with my life in theater. There's a giant section on how I learned to drive when Vogel talks about it. And I shit you not when she says, OK, here's how I learned to drive happened. She spends six minutes talking about the story of farinelli this um castrati you know

countertenor and his and his uh experience with the king of spain yes which would go on to become the play farinelli and the king with mark rylance but she goes on the entire journey of

SPEAKER_01this story give me the script paula

SPEAKER_03It was just so funny. She's like going on about it. Because I mean, she had done like three years of research on this. It was something really interested in her. And it was going to be because it was the moment of where Farinelli became sort of this confidant and muse and inspiration and reason for living for the gang of Spain and became like one of the few people who could tell him what to do because his singing voice was so beautiful. But then his voice started to fail him. And so he went back to Italy to sort of retrain his voice. And that was where the play was going to start. And it was going to star Cherry Jones. It was going to be workshopped with her.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Look, Castrati people, that's just another like incredibly complex, difficult people don't like to talk about a thing. People need to get on the Castrati train right now because they are adapting and Rice's cry to heaven and it's going to star Nicholas Holt and Aaron Taylor Johnson and it's going to change your life.

SPEAKER_03I mean, I think that this is where Ariana Grande comes in and helps people because she famously had a sketch a year ago on SNL that was all about Castrati. Sandberg and Maya Rudolph.

SPEAKER_01Insane.

SPEAKER_03And the great wig and facial expression of Ariana Grande. I'm convinced that that's what's got her Oscar nomination a year ago was Wicked came out and then everyone saw that sketch and like, oh, maybe the girl has range. My Slack profile photo for a significant length of time was a photo of Ariana

SPEAKER_01Grande in that fuck ass wig.

SPEAKER_03With the castrati. But so Vogel, I don't know if she had fully written it yet or it was going to be developed when Cherry and she got to Perseverance Theater Company. But she gets to the airport and gets a phone call from Cherry Jones and she says, Paula, I'm in such a dilemma. I don't know what to do. I auditioned for the heiress at Lincoln Center. I didn't think I was going to get it, but I got it. What do I do? And Paula's like, you're going to do the heiress on Broadway. Screw my play.

SPEAKER_01I love Cherry. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And like it was the show that changed Cherry's life forever. What a good friend on both sides of Cherry going to Paula with this and Paula

SPEAKER_01saying, no, I'm stepping in as a friend and telling you, you need to do this. One thousand percent like Cherry wanting to do the right thing by her friend and

SPEAKER_03trying to be honorable and Paula being like, thank you so much for that. But like, no, no, no, no. It's this is the obvious answer. And it ended up being the right choice for both of them, because then what happened was Paula gets on the plane going, fuck, I have no play and Cherry's not coming. And so she decides in that moment that she's going to write this play now. In articles leading up to the premiere at the Vineyard, the story goes that she'd had the idea in her head. And she talks about this a bit in My Life in the Theater.

She really loves the novel Lolita, which I appreciate because I also love that novel. And I get very mad when I listen to people talk about that novel on interviews and don't understand what that novel is doing and then try to drag said novel out.

SPEAKER_03I really enjoy Nicole Byers' podcast, Why Won't You Date Me? But she has an interview with Jamila Jamil from The Good Place. And it's a really good interview. But they get into Lolita for a hot second. And to be fair, they're mostly talking about the Lolita fashion pop culture element, which was having a resurgence at that time with the baby doll dresses and baby voice. But they also talk about the novel a little bit. And they're like, that novel's so weird. I was like, yeah, it's meant to be. It is Nabokov literally manipulating us into sympathizing with

a child predator. congrats you are supposed to be uncomfortable absolutely i remember reading it because it's like the most such beautiful flowery poetry as you're reading it and every three pages i would just go wait a second and it's like you stop it right now and on top of that you're it's an unreliable narrator and you have to read between the lines of what is actually happening in dolores's brain that he humbert humbert

SPEAKER_03cannot understand And so she wanted with that in mind, and I think part of the reason why she connected to that was her own personal history with her uncle. And so she wanted to write a piece that gives Dolores a voice as also and also would kind of exercise some of her demons. And she gets off the plane and everyone says, where's Cherry? She goes, so funny story. Cherry's booked and blessed, but not to worry. I think I got something. And she said she wrote it pretty quickly that it was the summer in Alaska.

SPEAKER_03So there was almost no nighttime. So she was like, I basically took power naps throughout the day and I would write 20 hours a day for two weeks and the play was fully formed. They do a reading. It goes incredibly well. She sends it to her agent, who sends it all over New York, and literally every nonprofit in New York City tells them, ooh, girl, you might want to workshop this one. It's not ready yet. I don't think you know who these characters are. And Paula Vogel had said in My Life in the Theater, she's like, it's one of the few times in my life where I stood my ground, and she said I think it would help that I had seen it done in Juneau.

SPEAKER_03And so I knew that it worked. And... One last person they sent it to was the artistic director at Vineyard. He read it, called her up. This was like November, I guess. And he says, we're going to do it in March. We would like to do a reading in January, not because we think you need any notes, but because we want to try out some casting options. And they had her meet the director, Mark Brokaw. She loved him. They do the reading with Mary Louise Parker and David Morris. At that point, Mary Louise Parker was best known for her breakthrough in Prelude to a Kiss on

SPEAKER_03Broadway about six, seven years prior, and then had done quite a few sizable movies that she had large parts in, but she wasn't really like a movie star.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. The best way I would describe it, like, you know how when they talk about Sex and the City and how big of a deal it was that Sarah Jessica Parker was doing TV because she was a movie star? I'm like, OK, Sarah Jessica Parker was a well-known movie actress. I don't know if I would call her a movie star. You know what I mean?

SPEAKER_01I won't tell Matthew you said that.

SPEAKER_03He was more famous than she was at the time.

SPEAKER_01He undeniably was. No, it's his favorite little gripe. Whenever anyone asks him about Sex and the City, he loves to tell the story about how he told Sarah to say no. And I'm like, why are we still telling the story, Matthew?

SPEAKER_03You don't look good in this story, Matthew.

SPEAKER_01You don't.

SPEAKER_03No, but it's OK because that show paid for all of their homes. But so but this is to say there's there's I feel like people are more understanding of what I mean by this with Mary Louise Parker now because we have so few movie stars now, what we have known movie actors.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Right. And so Mary Louise Parker had become a known movie actor and had done a little bit of theater post Prelude to a Kiss, did the terrible bus stop revival where she met Billy Crudup.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, but she hadn't really paid out the theater check that was written to her when she did Prelude because Prelude was very much like, who is this girl? This is going to be one of our great ladies of the stage. And then she runs immediately off to Hollywood and does like two bad shows in New York. And I was like, oh, God. Yeah, listen, I understand. Once Nell Carter won that Tony for Amy Smith, she was like, and I'm out TV, which you can't. Don't we all miss Nell? But like you can't begrudge someone for wanting that exposure. And as Carrie Coon said,

you need more exposure like that in order to do the projects you want to do.

SPEAKER_01It's only gotten harder, only gotten harder. But so she and David Morris do it at the Vineyard where it's an immediate success.

SPEAKER_03And they transfer it to a theater called Century Theater, which I don't know if that exists anymore.

SPEAKER_01Not really.

SPEAKER_03They said it's across the street from where Vineyard was slash is. Has Vineyard been in the same location since its impetus?

SPEAKER_01I don't think since impetus, but I think since 97, yeah.

SPEAKER_03Okay. Okay. So then I wonder, maybe it's where the Daryl Roth Theater now is?

SPEAKER_01Maybe. The thing that's tricky about that whole sort of... triangle between the villages and Washington Square Park and Union Square, just like that sort of part of Manhattan. That used to be the theater district. That whole area around Astor Place was one of the original theater districts. And while a lot of it has now been converted into office space and shops and things like that, the bones are still there that a lot of those buildings could

revert back into

SPEAKER_01theaters if they so chose. I don't think 90% of them are going to, but there could be... I'm not entirely sure where Century was on that block, but the bones of it are probably still there.

SPEAKER_03Probably. Yeah, I mean, listen, that Petco is going to remain a Petco. It's not going to become the Union Square Theater ever again. No. People like their Petco, but it's fine. It's okay. It's all right. It's whatever. Thanks, Jake. Yeah, the show does run for a year. Vogel wins the Pulitzer for it, and Morse and Parker get... massive acclaim they win basically every award i think they could have won for their off-broadway run i think there might have there's the only thing they didn't win was like the drama league which i don't even know if that was even happening yet at that point um i have it written down somewhere it's

because they won the

SPEAKER_03lord tell they won Parker and Morris won the Lortel and the Drama Desk. Oh, they didn't win the Outer Critics Circle, but Vogel did. Vogel did. And she won the New York Drama Critics Awards. I think Morris and Parker got an honorary award at the Outer Critics Circle, or maybe it was the New York Drama Critics. There's one awards group where they didn't win a competitive award. They jointly received honorary awards. That is like a nominator's way of guaranteeing you get something because they feel

SPEAKER_01that strongly.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And it's sort of like we want to we want to be fair to everyone else who isn't you. So you're going to get a separate thing to know that we think that highly of you. But yeah, this was like this show really kind of made a huge splash at a time when you still could with off Broadway. But the fact that it became as huge as it was and never transferred to Broadway, I think is.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's what it's like. You still can become a big deal off Broadway. But then you're almost like expected to then come in. And it's the O'Mary effect.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Sorry.

SPEAKER_01There was like a very, I think, conscious decision made very early in the journey in the 90s of like, this is an off-Broadway play. We are not looking for that scale of commercial that comes with Broadway.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. There weren't a lot of Broadway theaters at the time in 1997 that were intimate enough to accommodate this production.

SPEAKER_01I mean, there had been, I don't know if the culture of Broadway, I mean, Late 90s, we're looking at the Disney proliferation beginning to kick off on Broadway. There's some interesting work happening for sure, but I don't necessarily know if a Broadway audience would have come running to this piece.

SPEAKER_03I don't know if they would. You look at what was winning best play in the 90s, and the ones that are the toughest subject matters are things like Angels in America, which is, you know, dealing with the AIDS crisis. But also, that is something on a more epic scale. Sure. And for a lot of audiences, it is something that maybe is a little more over there and is, again, a play that feels massively important that they're doing the work by seeing, right?

SPEAKER_01It's a play that almost feels like a Greek epic.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And then even like Love, Valor, Compassion, which is technically a more intimate piece, is also done in a highly theatrical style. It's three and a half hours long. It has that grandeur about it. How I Learned to Drive is 90 to 100 minutes, depending on your tempo. And it is unrelenting. It's not trauma porn, but it is unrelenting.

SPEAKER_01And the more bells and whistles you add to it, the worse it is. It's the kind of play that thrives if you strip it down to its nervous system.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. If this had transferred directly to Broadway, like immediately after opening, I think it would have been up against The Last Night of Ballyhoo, I want to say. What was it? 1997 Tony Awards, which is, you know, a good play, but it's... Yeah, Last Night of Ballyhoo. I love my brain. I love me. It is absolutely The Last Night of Ballyhoo by Alfred Uri. But that would have been if they opened, got the reviews they got, and were like, okay, so we're going to go into the – actually, they couldn't go into the haze because Last Night of Ballyhoo was in the haze. They're like, we're going into the booth in a week.

SPEAKER_03Everybody, see you there. But The Last Night of Ballyhoo also, it deals with anti-Semitism. It also has a lot of comedic elements to it. It's also done in the past but in a more – literal sense it's you know it's I think it's the 40s maybe and it's also Alfred Urie who was having a moment in the 90s yeah he he had his Pulitzer from Drive to Miss Daisy and then eventually his Oscar like it was he was more of a known quantity than Paula Vogel was Vogel was more on the rise at that point and then even if that had come in the following year you want to know

what won best play in 1998 art that is what won best play oh that could be a whole other conversation

SPEAKER_03I've already had it with myself when I reviewed the revival. And I got to tell you, Maggie Hall, there is no weirder conversation than with yourself about art. Just saying.

SPEAKER_01Yes, but... Probably up there.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. We have a couple of major productions with How I Learned to Drive and a couple of notable play films. Off-Broadway, Jane Atkinson, Molly Ringwald, and Molly Ringwald...

SPEAKER_01I would have loved to have seen Molly do this because the thing that... So, Mary Louise is perfect for this part. I think it's a, like, career-best performance, what she gives in this play. Yeah. Molly Ringwald brings such a specific cultural baggage with her, especially in the late 90s, having come off her pop culture dominating run of the 80s, playing like the girl next door, it girl.

SPEAKER_01Her in this role must have been crazy.

SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. From all accounts, she was successful in the role. And when she took over, she brought it over to L.A., which must have been its own kind of moment. But yeah, it's sort of, as you said, it's that meta commentary of the ultimate girl next door playing a role where you don't want to know what's been happening next door. And Mary Louise Parker... What makes Ray Louise Parker such a fascinating actress is she has this unknowable

SPEAKER_03quality about her. It's like this sort of ghostly mask. And it's not that she's hiding anything. It's almost that... She is such an intelligent woman, obviously, but I feel like her characters often are so intelligent that they are navigating these complicated feelings in real time, and they're always kind of stepping back for a second to figure it all out. And you're watching her grapple with it in real time. And that is not necessarily cutesy girl next door-y like Ringwald,

SPEAKER_03but it allows a character like Little Bit, who is hyper-intelligent, and analytical, it marries those qualities together in a really beautiful way. It's what made her such a perfect favorite, something like Prelude to a Kiss, that sort of otherworldly quality about her, that etherealness, if you will.

SPEAKER_01That etherealness, but also she is one of the only performers of any gender that I've ever seen really be able to grasp and not just touch but hold on to That particular flavor that can come with grooming of that you're so mature for your age. Where you see the child believing and internalizing that while also somehow still seeing them as the child they are.

SPEAKER_01Not playing up the kid thing so much that it gets hokey, but also not straight up playing them like an adult. It's a really fine line that... And Mary Louise finds it and she lives on that balance beam in this play. And she also finds a way to make disassociation on stage captivating.

SPEAKER_03One thousand percent.

SPEAKER_01I think that's incredibly difficult because, I mean, when you're on stage and the lights are in your eyes, and especially when you have extended monologues like Little Bit has... Your instinct is going to be to want to try and fill with life in some way. And she had, like, this sense of self. And she worked things out with Mark Brokaw and David Morse that she had, like, the space and the silence. And, like, you could feel the air around her in some scenes. And...

SPEAKER_01I don't know if maybe for someone who's never experienced disassociation, if they wouldn't clock it. But as someone who has, you immediately know when she's tapping out in these interactions. And she's like, okay, now I have to let him do his thing. I'm going to go somewhere else.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. There is something that I did not get the first time I saw the play in 2012. Mm-hmm. and part of this was the production, part of this was grappling myself with my own baggage, was I did not get that disassociation and that negotiation and that gaslighting between Peck and Lillipit. When I returned to it in 2022, the manipulation of Peck and the

negotiation with herself a little bit of every scene because there are scenes where a little bit is unaware of what Peck is doing to her because simply she's too

SPEAKER_03young. The thing about you're so mature for your age is even with someone like a little bit where that might be true, she is still her age. And that is something that Mary Louise Parker does really well in both versions of the play of having physical... ticks that are very teenager without it being broad it's just like it's it's sort of like with each age of little bit as she gets younger and younger she finds a new

thing that a little bit does that probably got smoothed out as she got older and

SPEAKER_03started to get a little more worn down by her relationship with peck and it's less cutesy but it is it reminds you that even if little bit is perceptive even if she does have a good vocabulary she's a good learner she is still a kid in so many ways and she is trying to navigate weird waters with a man who has had so many more years of experience than her and has done this before and and

SPEAKER_03has confused her into thinking that she is in control. So when he makes requests, she can feel like, I'm letting him do this. This is a favor to him. He's not doing anything to me. They're always talking about how she draws the line. She makes the rules. That's something that is repeated all the time. And it's just simply not true.

SPEAKER_01But he's done an incredibly good job of making her think it is so. And that's how it can go on for so long. The scene that I think exemplifies both of what we're talking about here, the martini scene. And when she's throwing back the dry martinis, and you watch Mary Louise as depicting a teen get drunker and drunker, not falling into drunk actor stereotypes either.

SPEAKER_01But you watch... Her find the difference between disassociation, drunken, like, lack of awareness, dulled sensation, and then also real fear. And that really struck me when we were watching the 97 recording together. Just the way that it was filmed, you could really see that moment in the car when he goes to get

the blanket and You watch her almost come out of this stupor that he's worked her into with the

SPEAKER_01alcohol and the years of grooming. You watch her almost be like, wait, this isn't right. And then you watch him put her back under. And it's so insidious, but it's such delicate, well-placed acting. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it is. There are times when there's a crack in the veneer of what Peck has built with Lil' Bit throughout the relationship, where you see Lil' Bit clocking. what may not be right or what might not be safe or healthy for her. But then also genuine fear or genuine confusion, like when he goes to get the blanket, the fear she has for a quick second of not knowing what he's about to do,

SPEAKER_03it's a genuine impulse. And when he comes back to bring her a blanket, she's relaxed a bit more, but... that doesn't take away from the fact that there's a part of her that always feels like he could do something to her. Because I guess, you know, we're beating her on the bush here, but I don't want to talk about it too much right now because I want to get into it later. Because it was interesting for me watching the 97 video with you and watching it live in 2022 and the years of difference between the productions and the performances of the very first time that Peck assaulted a little bit.

SPEAKER_03And that always... You see, when you know that that's the moment that started it all, you see the trauma that still lives in her bones come out every now and then when they have interactions.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03You know, and one of the I would so the martini scene is one thing, which is when little bit turns 16, she gets she goes for her driver's license. She aces the test and she and Peck to celebrate do a long drive to a very historic inn where they go for seafood. And he lets her drink martinis because Peck, we learn, is an alcoholic. Suffers from alcoholism. And part of the deal that she has with him ever since she was 13 was once a week

SPEAKER_03we'll get together, but you can't drink when we're together. And so that has become a ritual of when they're together, he doesn't drink. Which is another thing that she has put on her shoulders of, well, if I don't keep this up, what's he going to do? Which is, again, another form of abuse and manipulation. It is not this child's job.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03To help this man heal.

SPEAKER_01She is 100% internalized that it is.

SPEAKER_03Yes. Well, also because the inciting incident to this relationship, the mother says the worst thing you could say to your child, which is if anything happens, I am holding you responsible.

SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03Woof! Woof, woof, woof, woof, woof.

SPEAKER_01So, and get back to mother play.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm. So, Lil'Bit has a better relationship with her mother than either child does in mother play. It's not a great relationship, but it's a better relationship.

SPEAKER_01It's a better relationship. I do wonder... How much of that depends on the status of Vogel's own mother at the time each piece was written.

SPEAKER_03It's possible. It's also possible that my feelings on the relationship are due to Joanna Day's performance as the mother.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, Joanna Day is incredible.

SPEAKER_03Yes. And so in this play, outside of Little Bit and Peck, there are three other performers, an actress who plays the female chorus, an actor who plays the male chorus, and an actress who plays the teen chorus. And they play multiple roles. They play Little Bit's family, her mother, her aunt, her grandfather, her grandmother – kids at school, a guy that little bit seduces on the bus, and so on and so forth. And... First of all, I did not realize that in the original Off-Broadway production,

SPEAKER_03we had Joanna Day, who would go on to be a Tony nominee for Sweat and would do the production again in 2022. We also had Carrie O'Malley as the teen chorus. Many would remember Carrie O'Malley as the baker's wife and the Vanessa Williams into the woods, but among other things. And then Michael Showalter is the male chorus. Wild. Wild, right? Who the fuck had that? I'm like, okay, stacked cast. But... The Joanna Day plays both Little Bit's mother and her aunt.

SPEAKER_03Her aunt Mary is married to Peck. So Peck is her uncle through marriage. But he has known Little Bit ever since she was born. There is a line of she was so small that she fit in his hand. He held her on the very first day she was born, which adds a whole other level to all of this. But yes, yes. There's the we have a conversation with a little bit her mother and her grandmother about sex. And her mother is much more honest and forthcoming. And she is more open to the idea of her daughter being sexually

active and trying

SPEAKER_03to give her all the right information, which I think is always the correct thing to do. And then we have her aunt who.

SPEAKER_01Her grandfather, right?

SPEAKER_03Well, sorry, her grandmother in that scene. But her aunt, who's married to Peck, has a monologue in the last third of the show. I think it's right before the hotel scene. And I didn't realize this, but I definitely internalized this monologue when I wrote my own play and wrote the monologue for Aaron, which anyone who watched yours truly knows the monologue I'm talking about, which is a character who is tied to somebody And it's a whole monologue of denial.

SPEAKER_03And it is a monologue that is perfectly crafted to, again, say things that are probably true and lead up front with all of the positives that they feel and that they think can be proven correct about the person they're talking about. And then any sympathy we might have had for this person twists. Aunt Mary, who we are all going, oh my God, this poor woman, she doesn't know who she's married to. She doesn't know the monster that she has. And she thinks she's got this great husband. And then we find out that she's known all along.

SPEAKER_03And not only that, but has known about Peck's troubles. Peck is absolutely not the first person. And the play makes this abundantly clear because he has a monologue with a nephew of his when he goes back home. Because again, Peck is not... of little bits actual blood family he's from further down south and he only goes home occasionally he's done he doesn't visit his family very often and the implication is that his family is embarrassed by him because they don't feel like that he lived up to his potential and maybe part of that is

true but there is definitely an argument to be made that they don't want him there because he's

SPEAKER_01dangerous that's what i always think

SPEAKER_03Yeah, and that is made very clear when we watch again what should be a kind moment between uncle and nephew turn into the beginnings of a horror scene.

SPEAKER_01Oh, my God. When he brings up the treehouse.

SPEAKER_03When he brings up the treehouse. It's the scene we're talking about is there's a monologue that Peck has with his young nephew, little Bobby, Bebe, when he goes back home for a little bit and they're fishing and we never see little Bobby. He's he's, you know, Peck.

SPEAKER_01He's very intentionally just someone Peck is speaking to. There is no actual young boy on stage. exactly and peck is showing him how to fish and and telling him his memories of being a boy in that same area and bobby starts to cry once the fish is caught and because he's he's afraid that the fish is in pain and so peck takes it off and throws it back and first he tries to say like oh you know you don't want the other boys to laugh at you like maybe like toughen up a bit and when he realizes that that's not the way to go he goes the other way takes the fish off and he comforts

SPEAKER_03him And tells him, you know, it's okay. Men have feelings. We cry. We cry all the time. And there's nothing wrong with that. Don't let anyone tell you different. He's like, how are you feeling? You feeling okay? Great. He goes, hey, listen, there's a treehouse around here that I used to go to a lot as a kid. I think it's still around. I would love to show it to you. But this is our special thing. Don't tell your mom. Don't tell your sisters. Don't tell your aunt. And you just know what's about to happen.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03He even brings up like them sharing a beer together. And we don't know how young little Bobby is, but he's not 18.

SPEAKER_01I always picture like five or six. Yeah, I think when I'm trying to be less traumatized, I picture about 10. The way he reacts to the fish and not knowing if the fish is in, it just reads as so kindergarten to me.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it does. But also, I was a very sensitive kid and cried pretty much all the time until I was 12. So that's me projecting. So it could be 5, it could be 10, it could be 7. Again, the one thing we both can say, he ain't 18.

SPEAKER_01No.

SPEAKER_03And so little bit is not this isolated incident. Not that it would make it any better if she were. But Aunt Mary is very aware of Peck's quote unquote troubles. And she ties it to his time in the army. He fought in World War II and he won't talk about what happened. But she knows that something did. He has moods. He has waves of melancholy on we and she thinks that it's her job to bring him back. And she views his relationship with little bit as a manipulation on little bits part.

SPEAKER_03She blames her and says she knows what she's doing. And I'm counting the days till she goes to college because I would like my husband back. And again, any sympathy we might have had for this woman goes out the window. And unfortunately, this is a very realistic monologue.

SPEAKER_02Very.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I was just listening to my friend Patrick's true crime podcast called The Secrets We Berry or something like that. And it's this family where they always thought that their father had left when they were kids and their mother remarried this really abusive man. And many, many years later, they learned that their father actually didn't leave them. He was murdered and buried in their basement. Yeah. And one of the things is the stepfather started to abuse the two daughters in the family sexually into their teens.

And the mother didn't believe the daughters when they told her about this when they

SPEAKER_03were younger. But then as time goes by and the stepfather dies and all this stuff, the mother's on her dying bed. She's on her deathbed, and she's dying of cancer, and she turns to one of the daughters, the one who's still around, and asks her, was she in love with his stepfather or not? And when you hear that, you go, oh, oh, your psychosis was in deep. That this is where your brain went. That it wasn't abuse. That it was an affair.

SPEAKER_01No. Yeah, it's an... We're not going to linger on this for too long. But it is a really devastating statistic. The number of women that will stay with men that abuse their children. It's a really quite horrifying thing. There are many psychology books written about it. I have a weird journey with this particular monologue of Little Bit Ants.

where i think it's kind of like a masterpiece and i would immediately be mad at anyone who brought it in for an audition yeah unless you're like specifically

SPEAKER_01auditioning for this play

SPEAKER_03it's, it's a, it's a hard one to grapple with out of context. It's,

SPEAKER_01I think it's the kind of thing that like, if you just like brought it in for like your master's audition or whatever, you have killed that room for every single person who's coming in after you. Cause unless you have like the hardest hearted audition person in front of you, and maybe you do, but hopefully you have someone who still has feeling in their chest. Uh, It's not going to leave their mind by the time the next person comes in for their 90 seconds.

SPEAKER_01It's so well written. The comparison I have made before when talking about this monologue is the song The Ballad of Booth from Assassins. And the ways in which you're lulled into believing this narrative about a person that they are telling you about themselves. And then just at the right moment when they know they've got you on the hook fish style.

SPEAKER_01you're pulled up and thrust into the reality that is dark and is bad. And it's incredibly effective. It's startling. It's shocking. It's upsetting. And it's supposed to be. And it's really very easy to get sort of lost in talking about how brilliant Mary Louise and David were. Bringing back Joanna for the revival was a brilliant stroke because what she does with that piece... I feel like I would need decompression therapy after every show.

SPEAKER_03Well, famously, with the revival, Mary Louise Parker did not stage door. She had it in her contract that she would go straight from Bows out the stage door into a car and head home because that's what she needed to do it eight times a week.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Which I highly respect. Let's actually talk a little bit about sort of our views on both productions and the time in between them. First of all, this 1997 video. Who do we have to thank for this video, Margaret Hall?

SPEAKER_01Oh, I love you Paul Newman.

SPEAKER_03Thank you, Paul Newman. Maggie, walk our listeners through this. You and I sit down at Toft and we begin the video.

SPEAKER_01It's a freezing day in New York. It's one of those true cold winter days. We're bundled up. We both make our way during our lunch hours to the Theater on Film and Tape Archive. We say hello to Steve. We make our way in. We sit down at our tandem computers. We press play. We have our headphones on. We're locked in. This presentation is presented to you by Newman's own. And I pause. And I rewind.

SPEAKER_01And we watch it.

SPEAKER_03It doesn't even consult me either. No. She felt so harshly about it. She instinctively went and rewound it.

SPEAKER_01Wait a second. Let's go back 10 seconds. Play it back. Presented to you by Newman's own. I am glad the salad dressing contributed to some theater.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And the lemonade.

SPEAKER_01It's the fact that it's Newman's own. It's not Paul Newman. It's not his foundation, which exists. It's Newman's own. That truly... I'm going to cherish that fact for the rest of my life. It's going to come up regularly. I'm also now going to be very annoying and try and figure out every single Toft recording that Newman's own underwrote. I want to know what they picked.

If only more shows could be preserved because of salad dressing and lemonade, you know?

SPEAKER_01Give me the Dead Outler recording brought to you by Heinz. Listen, if K-pop had appealed to Newman's own, we would have a K-pop recording at Toft. Come on, Paul. Get on the ghost of your board.

SPEAKER_03Literally. Joanne Woodard, come on, just get on in there. Haunt that board.

SPEAKER_01This is what haunting is for.

SPEAKER_03Exactly.

SPEAKER_01David Velasco haunts his theater until a show comes along that he likes. Do it with the Newman's own board.

SPEAKER_03Haunt your chairman's bedroom every night.

SPEAKER_01The idea of them like Christmas caroling it, but it's just Paul, Joanna, and like, I don't know, Paul's bestie. Robert, it can be Robert Redford. Robert Redford's dead now. The three of them show up. And they're just like, we are going to wheel you into taking all of this money you've made. Yes, I know most of it goes to the children's charities. What about a play about child sexual assault? Goodbye. It killed me. It took a lot of self-control to not get really loud in that

screening room.

SPEAKER_01And if it had just been us and Steve, I would have. But there were a couple other people watching Jelly's Last Jam that I was like, we cannot interrupt their experience right now. But the second time I played, I remember turning in and I just went, is that the same Newman? Is there a different Newman zone I don't know about?

SPEAKER_03I don't think so. I think that's the only one. And, you know... That's now a third use I've had for Newman's Own in this world.

SPEAKER_01It's like, I don't love corporatism in theater. I do love that Newman's Own is the reason we have a record of the original off-Broadway production of How I Learned to Drive. If corporations want to get involved in theater, that is the way to do it. Don't fuss with the creation of it. Let artists make what they want to make and then just give them money.

SPEAKER_03No, 1,000%. The money, please, and then we will be on our very merry way.

SPEAKER_01Leave all the people alone, but give her a check. Yeah, it's like this recording of Slave Play is made possible by Jelly Belly. The one that someone suggested is like a joke a while ago. And I was like, but like, do you realize that's real? Like, you don't actually know that this is real. Someone made a joke a couple of weeks ago about how like Ford should sponsor the Ragtime Tony performance. And I was like, do you realize where Ragtime premiered on Broadway?

SPEAKER_03Yes. Has no one told you about the birth name of the Lyric Theater?

SPEAKER_01Not the dead name of the lyric.

SPEAKER_03I'm happy. I think there are a few things that we are allowed to dead name. One is Twitter.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03And the other is Broadway theaters. I'm allowed to dead name the Ella Hirschfeldtons and call it the Martin Beck from time to time when I so choose.

SPEAKER_01Yes. When it makes sense. Yeah. No. I had to, like, explain the concept of the Ford Performing Arts Center to this person. And I watched the light go out in their eyes a little bit. And I'm like, I mean, yeah. Why do you think Terrence McNally, of all people, was kind of this gentle on Henry Ford? Why do you think he does not reappear when J.P. Morgan does?

SPEAKER_03We're just saying. We're just saying. Follow the money.

SPEAKER_01Follow the money, baby.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm. So... What is something that sticks out to you between 97 and 2022?

SPEAKER_01Oh, Mary Louise, Mary Louise. I truly cannot imagine what Mary Louise had to go through mentally to get herself back in that headspace now as a mother.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01It's one thing to be playing Little Bit. She's not actually Little Bit's age. She's not 11. But she was like what? Early 30s?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, she's about 32, 33 when she did the show the first time.

SPEAKER_01And she's very much an adult, but she's close enough that you're still shedding some of that coming-of-age skin. By the time she comes back to it... Children of her own. She and Paula have known each other longer than everything that went down with Uncle Peck in Little Bit happened. She's lived through the Me Too movement and witnessed that.

SPEAKER_01I just... I think a lot about... Actors who have to play abused children after raising children themselves, because I think it changes your relationship with that dynamic when you are playing from the perspective of, I have been a child, so I know what it is to play a child, versus I have been a parent, and I am playing this child while also understanding something much more intrinsically deep about the person who is abusing me.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01It's so messy, but in like a dramatically rich kind of way. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03It's the thing that is burned in my brain. So... When comparing the two, I swear to God, I did not mean to go down this road when I asked you this question. And I do want to talk more about sort of the back and forth. But I think now is a good time, if I may take the floor for a second, to talk a little bit more about the baggage that I've always sort of made light of and hinted at on this podcast before, which is to say that when I was in high school and going to school in New York City and technically speaking,

SPEAKER_03living in Jersey, either with my parents in Jersey or with my grandmother in Manhattan, I And I spent a lot of time on my own in Manhattan. And one of the things I started doing was taking voice lessons in New York. And I'd been doing that for a while with one specific teacher throughout middle school, but then I began high school with a different one. So meeting this much older man when I was 14, probably like 30 years my senior. And over the course of my five years with him, Things took a turn for the sexual and it was slow and it was deliberate.

SPEAKER_03And when you're young, you don't. And you're me, by the way. The other thing is people. These these predators have a sick sense for recognizing the children who are young. Not with the flock. And that is something that's very important a little bit as well, right? She has friends, but she doesn't really have confidants. She goes to school with who she talks to, but she doesn't have kids who she does sleepovers with.

SPEAKER_03She doesn't have anyone she can really confide in. She's a lot smarter than the other kids, but also it's the fact that she's more physically developed and that has ostracized her from a lot of the other kids. And Uncle Peck has... found that in her and exploits it both for his own personal gain but then also to build up her own ego and confidence of they don't recognize how special you are they don't recognize how much better you are than them how smarter you are than them i do and i'm here i'm he's basically using the phrase it

gets better for his own personal gain and using that to gaslight her and even if it could be possibly

SPEAKER_03true it's now tied to this very toxic thing which is 1000% what was going on with me with my voice teacher was like by the book textbook grooming of a year or two of gaining trust of being more of a mentor figure. Let me tell you about these amazing older movies, these actors, these writers like I want to expand your brain. You're so smart for your age. Let me make you smarter. And then eventually, once there's been trust established, then it becomes, oh, it's so weird. I had a dream about you the other night,

and I never thought about this before.

SPEAKER_03But it – oh, my God. It's testing the waters. Yeah. And recognizing that I, as a teenager, while I was out of the closet, I went to a school that was like – very gay i had said to him i said to people all the time i did not date in high school because i went to a school that was primarily dancers and they all dated each other so even though i was like a little string bean i thought i was the fat ugly friend and spent most of my high school years feeling such a way and then like would go to stage four manor and still couldn't get any maggie

i couldn't i couldn't give it away till my last year and i was like now i'm going off to college

SPEAKER_03i was like where was this experience is when i wanted it when i needed it

SPEAKER_01I get it. I was an Interlochen kid. Same flavor, different type of tree.

SPEAKER_03Grr, grr, grr, grr. We're in the canoe together, paddling in a lake that no one else is occupying. You turned the paddling into a dance, and I appreciate that. That's taking your pain and making it. All right.

SPEAKER_01Only way to survive.

SPEAKER_03Only way to survive. But you obviously, you keep sort of stepping further and further in. And the way that it was pitched to me when I was a teenager was like, this is our sexy little secret. Like we're, this is forbidden, but like not in the way that's illegal, in a way that's like hot and I just can't resist myself you're just so special and it wasn't until I went off to college and I remember the exact moment when everything turned in my brain about what was going on because I was at a gathering where we were all drinking and doing sort of like a truth or dare whatever all

this other stuff and I had let slip what it was how what had happened with me and my voice teacher thinking like oh my god it's my sexy little secret and everyone just looked at me

SPEAKER_03like are you okay mm-hmm And I was like, oh, yeah, totally fine. And then I flipped it off and I didn't bring it up again. And I would make up lies surrounding it to kind of barricade that truth.

SPEAKER_01Yep.

SPEAKER_03And I didn't really come to terms with it until I left college. And then Me Too happened. And I wanted to talk about it with people later. But it wasn't, the atmosphere was not one that was open to male victims at the moment. We had to wait a little bit longer for that. And then COVID hit. And he died. And that was when I felt okay to talk about it.

Mostly because there was a part of me that was like, I don't want to go public.

SPEAKER_03I don't desire to ruin this guy's life. For all I know, I was the only one. This is like what's going on in my brain. And so many people thought so highly of him. He was, you know, a major advocate for all these other things. And in my brain, I'm like, maybe I was the fluke. Who knows? I'm sure I wasn't. But like, it was, it took a long time for me to grapple with what exactly I had gone through, what it was that it had done to me. And the other thing is that, and I talked about this in the Downstate episode with Itai,

SPEAKER_03When somebody is telling you that you are special, that you are smart, that you are attractive, that you are all these exceptional things. You don't want to think that they were all lies to get you to do what they wanted you to do.

SPEAKER_01It's psychological warfare.

SPEAKER_031,000%. You wanted to believe it was genuine. And the irony is that twice this has been used against me. The other was Bub many years later. But there was less of a power dynamic there and an age discrepancy. But it was the same thing of like... You tell me you care about me. You tell me I'm special. You tell me I'm smart. Is it just that you recognized what I needed to hear to let you do the things you did? And you don't want to believe that's true.

And I think what makes it complicated, what makes it even worse is like there's a world in which

SPEAKER_03All the things they said were true. They just took the truth to manipulate you, which shouldn't rob you of your intelligence, which shouldn't rob you of thinking you're attractive. But it can do a number on you kind of forever.

SPEAKER_01Yep. It's forever.

SPEAKER_03And I tell my mother all of this. spring of 2021 and i think i eventually tell my father and they're rightfully devastated especially because they were so hypersensitive about me being openly gay at such a young age and in new york they were constantly on the lookout for like who is going to attack my baby and this was something where like it was it was a long time coming it was a very long process it was a long game and

And I never said anything at the time because I didn't think it was abuse. And by the time I recognized that it was abuse, it had been so long since it had happened.

SPEAKER_03How do you begin that conversation with your parents about that? But I have the conversation with her and with him and all this time. And then a year later, my mother and I go to see how I learned to drive together.

SPEAKER_01You're braver than me.

SPEAKER_03I mean, we're also... Let me tell you another story. I see Brokeback Mountain with my parents three months after coming out of the closet. Like, this is...

SPEAKER_01In a lot of ways... I've sat through some wild stuff with my mother, but... I mean, like, Fun Home is one.

SPEAKER_03Oh, that's easy potatoes for me. My mom and I sat together and watched salt burn alone in her apartment.

SPEAKER_01Fun Home is particularly resonant for specific reasons in our family. But there are certain traumas that I have lived through, that my mother is aware that I have lived through, that I will never witness a piece of art next to her about.

SPEAKER_03Sure, sure.

SPEAKER_01Because I know the amount of guilt she carries. And I know that neither of us would be able to process the piece of art in front of each other because we would become hyper vigilant of the other. Yeah, I will say it was this is sort of I think the power of this play and the power of theater. And this was actually one of the earlier sentences in the New York Times review for

SPEAKER_03this revival was was this particular scene, which was the hotel scene. Which is once a little bit goes off to college, she's getting letters and gifts from Peck almost daily. And each letter has a number on it and the number gets lower. And what you realize is he is counting down the days till she turns 18. And she confronts him in a hotel room near her college. And they have this... It's not even a battle. It is her with the time apart from him once she has had a

significant amount of space and time alone from him and engaging with other people closer to her age and

SPEAKER_03sort of seeing what her life is supposed to be right now. She is coming to terms with... in real time, the toxicity of her relationship with him, the family dynamics aside, the age gap aside, just what their relationship is, what the foundation it is built on. And She doesn't really have the words yet to express why she needs to take flight.

SPEAKER_03But it's just the fight or flight. But she just knows that it's flight. And she is going over and over again the flight. And he, once again, is trying to use his manipulations on her. And he's using some truths of saying to her... He's again, because he's like he's aiming to get into into bed with her as well as trying to endear himself to her again. But he says to her, your family has made you fearful of men and of sex. And it's just not the truth. Like men don't have to be the enemy to you. And he's not wrong. We watched the scene with her and her mother and her grandmother and her

SPEAKER_03grandmother just says over and over again, hurts like hell. Men are the enemy. You don't do it before marriage. Like it's it's the worst.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And so he's using that truth against her. And my mom and I are watching the scene together and we're watching him, just the simple request, will you just lay here with me? Our clothes will be on. And you're watching him sink into bliss in this moment and watching her tense up and fly out of her head and out of her body.

SPEAKER_01You watch her disassociate.

SPEAKER_03Mm hmm. Mm hmm. And in a way you think, oh, maybe this is the first time she's really fully disassociated. Not so. That scene gave me anxiety watching, but it was great to see the thing that will stick in my brain forever. And I will talk about this scene now and then we'll sort of talk about the rest of it, because this ties back into the earlier question of the difference between 97 to 2022. which is the first time that Peck assaults a little bit.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Now, why is the play called How I Learned to Drive? If you want to answer for the... Sorry. That was a genuine question set up, Maggie.

SPEAKER_01Sorry, my brain went to the scene and was replaying it. It is called How I Learned to Drive because the way Peck gets alone time with Little Bit, the way he normalizes the amount of time they are spending together, just the two of them with no one else paying attention to them, is by teaching her how to drive. Theoretically promising to give her independence while making her dependent on him.

SPEAKER_03Yes. And what makes it complicated is there are moments where it's an excuse to be alone. That's the very first scene we see them together. But then you also see a scene where he is genuinely teaching her and she is resistant at first, partly because her brain is switching to like, oh, is this sexy time while also kind of needling at him. about all the ways in which he's not really a good man when he's like well you got he's like first you lock the doors and she's like but then i'd

be locked in here with you and she's saying it in a joking manner but all jokes have a little nugget of truth in them you know and this all comes back to the first time they're alone

SPEAKER_03together which is she's 11 and it's Through circumstances, she wants to ride back home in the car with Uncle Peck. I guess she wants to stay at the beach longer than the rest of the family. And the only way to do that is if she goes home with Peck. And her mother says, no, I don't like the way your uncle looks at you. He spends too much time paying attention to you. A little bit fights back. I don't, you know, my dad left. I deserve a father figure. I can handle Uncle Peck. And that's where her mother says, well, if anything does happen, I hold you responsible.

SPEAKER_03They get in the car. And Mary Louise Parker doesn't speak. The actress playing the teen chorus speaks. And does all of Little Bit's lines. In the like the only moment of vague caricature in the entire play of like a true

SPEAKER_01little girl voice.

SPEAKER_03Yep. Intent. Yes. And intentionally so. And it is the only time someone speaks as little bit as well, by the way, because, yes, as we were saying earlier, throughout the entire play, it's always been Mary Louise Parker, whether she's 33 or 53. And even when she's acting as a little bit throughout the ages, you still have in the back of your brain hearing the mature woman voice of Mary Louise Parker. And now, yes, as Maggie said, we have the teenage chorus actress voicing 11-year-old a little

bit in a genuine

SPEAKER_03childlike manner to really emphasize just how young she is. And they're driving back, and it's late. And he takes off the highway and goes on the scenic route. And he says, hey... Do you want to drive for a little bit? I can't drive. It's not legal. And he goes, no, it's fine. No one's around. You know, you just grab your hands on the wheel and guide for a little bit. She goes, well, my feet can't reach the pedals. Again, just how young she is. And he goes, I'll put my feet on the pedals. You sit in my lap and just hold.

SPEAKER_03And he does. She does. And he does. And as she has her hands on the wheel and he says, just stare at the road. We're going to do it for just a minute. That is when he... He grabs her from above the shirt at first and then underneath the shirt. And you hear the teenage chorus trying to protest very weakly and then saying this isn't happening. And the entire time that this scene is happening, you just watch Mary Louise Parker remember it all sort of in

real time as she's

SPEAKER_03living through it. And what was fascinating to me when watching it in 97 was Watching Mary Louise Parker with David Morse molesting her, her face was gone, but it was also, like, not affectionate, but almost kind of longing. Do you remember? Like, her face, like, got very close to his. And it wasn't romantic. It wasn't sexy. But it was more sort of like she was trying to remember what he looked like in that moment. It was not absolute.

SPEAKER_01It felt like that to me. It also... It felt like... I mean, I have some trauma-related memory stuff.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it reminded me of the look that I know I get on my face when I am trying really

SPEAKER_01hard to remember something I have repressed.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Of, like, when you're going so deep inside yourself, you're suddenly inside it. Specifically in the 97, that scene really felt to me like we are watching... adult little bit go back to that scene almost telephone wire fun home style and we hear the voice she knows what's actually happening but with her adult brain she

SPEAKER_01sits in this moment and registers it in a real way

SPEAKER_03Yeah, that is how I felt watching it in 2022. Okay. That is because the way – for me, what I got from Mary Louise Parker that second time was it was everything you were saying, but it was more isolated. It was – it felt like – and this – and the revival – is actually a little bit longer than the original production by like about five to 10 minutes. And there's no changes. They didn't add material. But there are things where they take a bit more time with.

And the revival was still funny and it was still engaging and it was still theatrical.

SPEAKER_03But there were certain scenes where Mary Louise Parker and David Morse allowed more uncomfortable air to happen. And that scene, I remember that scene in the car being twice as long as it was in the 97 video. And part of it was making the audience have to sit in it as well with her. But also watching Mary Louise Parker just... sit in this memory and and her whole body her whole face was sort of a shell of itself as it was happening because she was reliving it but she

also wasn't she was in it and she wasn't a part of it at the same time and it was just it's an image i will never forget it is burned in my brain her face the the actress voicing her and

SPEAKER_03all of it is just it just stuck with me and that was something where Because with my situation when I was a teenager, it wasn't quite – the inciting incident wasn't that. It was a slower process and then a longer tease of like maybe yes, maybe no. And no one's journey with grooming and gaslighting is equally the same. But that is a moment I think a lot of people can relate to of – An experience when you,

SPEAKER_03before you're ready for it, or even if you have had experiences and like another moment happens that you didn't want, whatever. And the disassociation. We could also just call it how I learned to drive or disassociation. Brought to you by Newman's Own. Or Jelly Belly, depending on the year. But you... You're you're as you said this earlier of sort of like the I'm going to live outside of myself right now while they do what they need to do.

SPEAKER_03So this can just end.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And it is a form of survival that I don't think a lot of people would look at on

SPEAKER_03the surface as a genuine fight, but it is its own way of fighting. It is a life or death, teeth in the skin fight in the moment when you are living it.

SPEAKER_01It looks like submission. In reality, it is the exact opposite.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. Because no one knows what they would do until it happens.

SPEAKER_01And no one knows what they would do in any specific situation. The way you might react to Peck is different than she might have reacted to any other man in her life.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm. And she has a great deal of sympathy for him the many years later. And I think part of that is needing to forgive him and recognizing the things about herself today that she likes that are possibly helped by her. Knowing him in the past, such as driving, such as her knowledge of literature and her and her skill at analyzing literature

SPEAKER_03and teaching courses on literature. You know, he the thing about Peck that is true is he is the only one in her immediate family who supports her dream of going to college and and doing something. And again, it is unfortunately tied to this very toxic give and take dynamic that they have. But in order for her to survive and eventually thrive, she has to be able to forgive him to let go of the monstrous

ties that the good

SPEAKER_03things she has about herself are tied to, you know?

SPEAKER_01It's the double-edged sword of the title. He set her free from... But he irreparably scarred her in the process.

SPEAKER_03Yes, 1,000%. And that is something that I think, unfortunately, too many of us can identify with. Yeah. Yeah. And do you think that the play... I don't think it provides tools because the play isn't interested in answers and it isn't interested in being a survivalist guide. But do you think people who maybe have their own little bit stories can watch How I Learned to Drive and find some recognition in moving on and

forgiving and not

SPEAKER_03forgetting, but forgiving?

SPEAKER_01I think we are the proof.

SPEAKER_03That is true. Another Mary Louise Parker show. Thank you so much. It all ties together. It's one big old conspiracy. What else can we talk about? I mean, I feel like we talked about so much and yet I feel like we haven't talked about nearly enough.

SPEAKER_01Ask me whatever you want to ask me, baby.

SPEAKER_03What's something that is on your brain? What's something that we haven't discussed that you really want to talk about? Anything.

SPEAKER_01I want to talk about the direction a bit.

SPEAKER_03Go for it. Floor is yours. I think this is the kind of play that can die a fast death if it is over-directed.

SPEAKER_01If you're scared of that awkward dead air... And one of the things that I think is just so smart about Mark Brokaw, and he isn't spoken about in the way I wish he was, in terms of his sort of almost scalpel-like precision when he really locks in on a script.

SPEAKER_02Hmm.

SPEAKER_01The space he gave everything, both in terms of speed and verbalization, but also not putting all the bells... Vineyard is not, like, the richest off-Broadway company in the world, especially in the 90s. But, like, they could have theoretically had more set than they did. They could have beefed things up in different ways. He had the forethought, and I'm sure this was also a conversation between him and Paula, that no... It's a memory play, and her memories often are fuzzy at best.

We are not doing a kitchen sink drama where you're seeing a perfectly rendered...

SPEAKER_01They are literally getting into a car. No, they are on chairs that are moved as needed. It makes it... I think... Kind of the perfect play for little bits to find in college. And because it's like not intimidating to grab on to for scene study.

SPEAKER_01Because if you load up, there are other people in this play, but it is like psychologically it's a two-hander. If you're doing stuff in scene study, you need two people. You don't really, unless you're like really committed to doing the scene with the mother and the grandmother, which would be an interesting choice, but not necessarily a choice I've seen done in scene study.

SPEAKER_03And don't forget that Grandpa shows up for a little bit too.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. Grandpa's got to walk in, be an asshole and walk out. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Classic ramps.

SPEAKER_01Oh, yeah. But. If you like just look up like a photo of this production. It doesn't look intimidating. Yeah. It allows you to laser focus in on the words, and it also then makes the audience laser focus in on the words. When you don't give them any other distractions, your words better be damn good. And Vogel is damn good.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's interesting because the play begins in a far more poetic, perfumey vernacular than it continues on to be. And I think part of that is Vogel as a writer, as well as a little bit as a storyteller. trying to disarm us by painting a much more luscious picture than the story really deserves because we need kind of to be set into a theatrical mindset and a storytelling mindset before we get that first jolt which is a

little bit and peck in the car necking and then when her saying we got to get back she goes uncle peck and that's when the audience goes oh shit yep this goes deeper than we realized

SPEAKER_01In the recording of the revival, you can hear someone make like a full body gasp when she says it. And I'm like, that's so fascinating to me. To be coming to this like highly acclaimed revival with the original stars of this play and have no idea what you're in for. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03I mean, that's sort of... When you are able to see something with very little knowledge about it, I'm a big proponent of, yeah, don't do any more research. Just go in. I mean, again, sort of maybe ask around like, hey, here are my triggers. I don't do well when I see things like this. But otherwise, try to go on blind because, yeah, like I remember when we saw it, there were people in the audience who didn't know. And I think that was sort of... don't call it a double-edged sword because it's not it's it's it's a great thing but like manhattan theater club subscribers who know mary

louise parker know david morris have probably had heard of the play but didn't really know what it was about or or like weeds fans just go see mary louise parker like oh my god i'm gonna go see i'm gonna go see my favorite weeds girl and then they realize what the play is about it was it was like seeing rachel mcadams and mary jane yeah oh that great in

SPEAKER_01person

SPEAKER_03Yeah, there was I mean, there was some asshole who was drunk and shouted, I love you, Rachel McAdams, and got escorted out. But they're like, it was a very respectful audience. Same theater, too.

SPEAKER_01But also MTC again, we're living it right now with Carrie Coon and Buck of Gilded Age and White Lotus

SPEAKER_03people going. White Lotus people are showing up and getting a really confronting play about

SPEAKER_01conspiracy theories and mental health.

SPEAKER_03Thank you, Manhattan Theater Club, for taking the wine moms into the theater and pulling the rug out from underneath them.

SPEAKER_01Thank you, Lynn. We are grateful for your service.

SPEAKER_03Yes. Well, and now Nikki.

SPEAKER_01Nikki's the new one. Yeah, but I think Bug is like the last thing.

SPEAKER_03Oh, no, it is. It is. It is. But we want to say thank you to both ladies.

SPEAKER_01Thank you for your service, Lynn. And Nikki, I am so excited to see where you go. uh absolutely maybe next season we do baltimore waltz maybe oh get sherry back can we just get all the vogels can we have a vogel renaissance do you remember how like there was a couple years where just like every single play that stop art had ever written suddenly was running at the same time yeah can we just have a logo renaissance i think she deserves it do

SPEAKER_03I think we do a Vogel Renaissance. I think Roundabout does a McNally Festival.

SPEAKER_01I think. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03That would be nice. I would enjoy that immensely. And then I will hold a sit-in at Signature Theater Center and every theater will be

SPEAKER_01playing a different Sarah Rule play. And you can all come and cry with me. Fantastic. And I will hold a salon and we will do about five hours worth of Durang one acts.

SPEAKER_03Thank you so much.

SPEAKER_01Oh, love. Beautiful. And this is where Amy Jo Jackson and I will finally get to do For Whom the Southern

SPEAKER_03Bell Tolls together.

SPEAKER_01Oh, please give me a ticket.

SPEAKER_03It's so good. My God. Mary Louise Parker needs to do for whom this up in belt holes. That bitch is funny. Let's have her be funny again.

SPEAKER_01She's so funny. This is like a total like side thing. But just thinking about the unknowing people and how I learned to drive up at all. Every once in a while, it does enter my brain that like. 9-11 and Paula Vogel being assaulted as a child. is the reason we have that really pretty boy in the Godspell revival singing Beautiful City.

SPEAKER_03Hunter Parrish?

SPEAKER_01Yes, that guy. Everyone's called, like, the things that had to converge for this song to be written, not for Godspell, and for this boy to get famous, being on weeds with Mary Louise Parker, to be famous at just the right time, to be cast in this revival. Well, if he's cast, he needs, like, a song. Beautiful City.

SPEAKER_03Wait, Beautiful City was written for the revival post-9-11? I thought it was written for the movie.

SPEAKER_01Oh, you're right. It was written for the movie, and then he tweaked the lyrics for 9-11.

SPEAKER_03Got it. Okay. So, sorry. I also just want to say, you've seen Arrested Development, yes?

SPEAKER_01I've seen, like, bits and pieces.

SPEAKER_03Okay. David Cross on Arrested Development. he's talking about his marriage to, um, Lindsay played by Portia de Rossi and Jason Bateman's like, okay, so when did the trouble start? And Cross goes, well, I don't want to blame everything on nine 11, but that certainly didn't help. And just like you taking a beat and saying, if I may pivot for a second and just opening with nine 11, it was like, where is she going? One day we should do a series where we just cover the season

after nine 11 and, Because I'm currently going through it with one of my classes right now where I feel like a broken record whenever they ask anything about dance in New York City.

SPEAKER_01And my answer to every single one of their questions is, well, AIDS. Yeah. It's also true of the theater industry. It's like, well, 9-11.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, so you mean the 2001 to 2002 Broadway season, that one specifically?

SPEAKER_01I mean, specifically from September 12th.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01To September 12th.

SPEAKER_03Got it. So, well, I have covered a couple of shows from that season on here separately. I've covered Millie and You're in Town and Mamma Mia and The Goat. The Goat. Or who is Sylvia?

SPEAKER_01The Goat.

SPEAKER_03The Goat. But, yeah, I mean, I would love to kind of do a couple of seasons in general. Because not just deep dives on the shows, but, like, talking about... culture that year.

SPEAKER_01My favorite season of all time, and yes, I have partial nostalgia goggles, but also I legitimately believe it is some of the most concise, best theater on Broadway in my lifetime. 2015, 2016? The season before when Hamilton came roaring in. Was that 2014, 2015? 2014, 2015. The fun home year. That year... Even just 2015 if we isolate it out.

SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_01Impeccable year.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Unimpeccable.

SPEAKER_03I do really love that 2015, Tony. I love Fun Home. I have a soft spot for Something Rotten. I need to give—I know it's behind you. I need to give American in Paris another go because I saw it.

SPEAKER_02It's perfect. I saw it from the balcony of the palace, and I think I was a little too far. I had respect for the visit, really enjoyed Curious Incident, fucking love Hand to God.

SPEAKER_03It was a good year. She was a good year. And that was also the King and I 20th century on the town year, also good revivals.

SPEAKER_01And it was also the King Charles III year, a play that no one talks about anymore, but now that we're living in it, I think about it all the time.

SPEAKER_03And King Charles III, that was the end of 2015 into Hamilton Tonys, yes?

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03Yes, yes, yes, yes. There we go. That's what I'm thinking of. Because Curious Incident was November, December of 2014, but it was the 2015 Tony Awards.

SPEAKER_01Have you done an episode on Curious Incident?

SPEAKER_03No, I probably should.

SPEAKER_01Call me when you're ready.

SPEAKER_03I will. I will. Has that been recorded at Toft? National View.

SPEAKER_01Sorry. I laughed as I drank. Yes, it has.

SPEAKER_03Okay, fantastic. Because the National, I think, did a National Live for it in London as well, correct?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. That might be the recording that I've seen in Toft. But just as an autistic person, I've got notes.

SPEAKER_03As well, you should. That's a full Toft recording. That's not a Newman's own that Toft has.

SPEAKER_01I didn't notice Paul Newman's name on it. I will. I'm not joking. I will investigate and I will get this data back to you and you can disseminate it to your readers however you want. I am dying to know if this is the only time they ever did this or if there is just a period of time where Newman's own underwrote a bunch of off-Broadway recordings. I like to think that there's some person working at Newman's Own in the 90s who's

SPEAKER_03like the cultural, to quote the birdcage, the cultural attaché for Newman's Own, who's going around New York City at all the off-Broadway and off-off-Broadway theaters and then reporting back to Newman and saying, this is the thing we need to give money to to make sure it gets preserved.

SPEAKER_01It's just... Like, of all the plays...

SPEAKER_03I mean, props to them. It's one of the best ones.

SPEAKER_01Major props to them. But I'm trying to think, like, is there a company right now that is not about survivors in any way? That you think would be like, yeah, let me throw my name on that.

SPEAKER_03I don't know. I don't have answers for you. Much like how I learned to drive, I don't have answers.

SPEAKER_01Different worlds?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I was looking through my notes here. We covered most of the stuff. The oyster dinner, the bus scene. Let's see.

SPEAKER_01A note on the bus scene. One line that I think just encapsulates such an interesting facet of who both Little Bit and Paula are as playwrights speaking through character. When she's talking about who did it to him.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Of like trying to follow back the chain. Because, I mean, we have no evidence that it was done to him. It could have originated with him. But we here in the 21st century know the statistics enough to know how likely it is that it is a cycle.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And. That is sort of the beauty, the frustration, and the brilliance of this play, again, of how few answers actually there are because Uncle Peck is this sort of unknowable being in a lot of ways. We get hints at his past, of his war past, of his family dynamic, how he's treated in Little Bits' family. The scene that we think...

The scene that we think starts their relationship is when she's 13 and it's

SPEAKER_03Christmas and Peck is in the kitchen washing the dishes and he is desolé. He is just very down. And before that, we get the Aunt Mary monologue where we learn that he gets these waves of melancholy that are triggered from his PTSD and And we think that might that might be it. And we hear from a little bit that like Uncle Peck is also kind of retreating. He was most likely the butt of a lot of jokes with the family, specifically grandpa. And that is a little bit extend the courtesy of let's meet up

once a week.

SPEAKER_03You won't drink. And, you know, you can talk to me about all the things that are troubling you and all this stuff. And. It's this false. promise from Vogel like oh maybe this was when it all began and it just and his manipulation took it in the terrible direction and then of course it goes one scene further like no no no no it started far worse than that but the thing about him is is it could have started because of the PTSD from the war it

could be that this was

SPEAKER_03a way for him to feel like he had some sort of control again, that he had some way to feel like a man and smart again. It could have been that someone did it to him when he was younger and it manifested as such. We don't fully know and people could choose their own adventure. Vogel gives us enough clues about who he is and where he's coming from that you can make that choice for yourself. I do believe that it was done to him.

SPEAKER_01I do too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Specifically the way he talks about the treehouse of like, oh, it's this place I used to go to when I was a kid. It's our special secret place. Felt like maybe taking that little boy back to wherever he had something done to him when he was little.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And the way that he manipulates a little bit, it's not through this animalistic urge that overcomes him because of his PTSD, of his depression or anything like that. You're watching him constantly shift the conversation over and over and over again, spinning it round and round until you don't even know where you are. For example, the photography scene, which we didn't really get much in depth of, but it is sort of,

SPEAKER_03once again, similar to the oyster scene or when they're driving and necking scene of he's taking photos of her in his... Yeah.

SPEAKER_03you're more well-developed than women, you know, 10 years older than you, and you're better than all the boys in school, and they'll come around at some point, but for now, like, I get to enjoy. And when he lets slip, like, oh, maybe this will be a portfolio to send to Playboy when you're 18, and she doesn't like this, and then he starts spinning it again and making it seem like we're not doing anything wrong, and I take it back, and everything's fine, and this is all good, and then says I love you in hopes that she will keep going, and that's when she unbuttons her blouse, and it becomes, you're watching him

try to smooth over all of her fears through language she either doesn't understand

SPEAKER_03or an overabundance of information that she can't fully file all at once. And then sweeping it all away with the big headline of, I love you. I care about you. to make her feel safe and to feel like she is doing something just for him we are in this safe space together and you're with someone who loves you more than anyone else in this world and that is when she gives him ultimately what he wants the entire time yep under the guise of this is your choice which is just and again you he doesn't he is not written he isn't performed as like this mr

burns of like

SPEAKER_01excellent because that would be too easy yep but it is still insidious

SPEAKER_03Oh, 1,000%. It's very rare that you see a child... It's very rare that you see that kind of gaslighting and abuse happen in a way that's so obvious. It's actually what I really loved about that scene in Stereophonic towards the end of Act 1 between Peter and... What's-her-face? The C.V. Nix stand-in. Because he is gaslighting her the entire time, but he earnestly believes what he is saying and is using... facts that aren't full true,

but are enough of the truth that it can confuse her into believing his narrative. And that is the same thing that Peck does because he genuinely believes what he's doing. Have you ever watched Anna Kendrick's interviews either on Call Her Daddy or

SPEAKER_03Armchair Expert where she talked about her relationship?

SPEAKER_01I haven't watched those interviews, but I am familiar.

SPEAKER_03Yes. She talked about the man she had been with for like six years and specifically says that it really wasn't until the last year that it shifted. And she said it was this really kind of major light switch. But she talked about how what made it so confusing was that when they would argue and he would... gaslight her she's like you you hear about it in these terms and you see it on tv and in movies or rather bad tv and movies in a way where it's so obviously being done she said you aren't prepared for when it's done more

realistically which is like the person telling it to you genuinely believes what they're telling you or at least wants you to believe that they genuinely believe it and that is what confuses you when someone is crying in your face of like i love you and nothing is and we're

SPEAKER_03not doing anything wrong it fucks with your sense of reality. Like, well, am I actually the problem? You don't want to be the problem, but you also don't know if your instincts... It makes you question your instincts, and that is ultimately what Gaslighting does perfectly.

SPEAKER_02Mm-hmm.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. I don't have anything else to say. I'm kind of spent.

SPEAKER_01Fair.

SPEAKER_03Do you feel like we spoke a lot about this play? I feel like we have started a journey that I hope a lot of your readers go down. readers people reading out here you have listeners i have readers they're close but yeah well i do i do have people who join the Substack because we do sort of like article recaps of episodes now because not everybody enjoys the podcast format but they like but they do like the content i produce so we're trying to produce more yeah we're trying to produce more episode uh written recaps of

stuff so people read

SPEAKER_01some of this stuff but yeah i hope that in the world

SPEAKER_03I hope that people seek out this play and absorb all of its richness and magnificence for themselves.

SPEAKER_01And I hope they give themselves grace with it. You are allowed to make it through a couple scenes and then need to put it down for a day and then come back.

SPEAKER_03One thousand percent. And I hope that people can forgive themselves for their past traumas, their own mistakes, the mistakes that were done onto them, the hardships that were done onto them that maybe they wish they could have done differently. We we can only learn and move forward and and let go of as much of what we can.

SPEAKER_01It is not a failure to survive.

SPEAKER_03I agree with that. I can't say it any better than that, Ms. Writer. So I'm going to let you close us out with that one. Maggie Hall, where can people find you if you want them to find you?

SPEAKER_01www.margaret-hall.com has links to everything on Playbill. If you search my name, you'll see like 20 articles a day. I'm a busy bee over there. Blood, Sweat, and Queers, which Matt was so sweet to plug at the beginning. That is my newest... book project. I am the co-editor and I wrote the foreword for it. It's out of Brooklyn's Contrarian Publishing. A portion of the proceeds go to The Trevor Project to help prevent trans suicide here in the United States. It's a bunch of really beautiful queer vampire love stories

from every stripe of the rainbow.

SPEAKER_01It's wonderful. It's incredibly gay. I love it. Also, we got Jim and Yanni. Just hit five years since I first met Paul, which is crazy. Five years of Jim and Yanni, Life and Lessons from Broadway and Beyond. It's craziness. And then keep an eye on my socials. It's Margaret Hall on all socials. There is some really exciting stuff coming down the pipeline this year. Bunch of announcements that are coming in the spring. And I am excited to connect with more people through it.

SPEAKER_03We're very excited for you, my love. If you want to follow me, I'm on Instagram only at Matt Coplich, usual spelling. If you want to, you know, promote the podcast, give us a nice five-star rating or review. We got a couple of new ones since I was in London. I will read those on a future episode. We're going long as it is here. Make sure to join our Substack if you haven't, especially join our Discord channel if you haven't, so you can talk about the podcast. Correct me on anything I got wrong or anything I said that was just the worst podcast.

SPEAKER_01If you know where the century is, let us know.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, where the fuck that theater was. Please let us know. And then also, if you are in the Cité and are available March 6th at 7 p.m., make sure to buy your ticket for Sondheim-Weber Koppelka Birthday Threesome. It'll be a lot of fun. If you aren't going to be in the city, but you have an hour and a half free the following week, buy a ticket to the live stream. Green Room 42 allows you to view the live stream up until a week after the show goes up. So that'll be exciting. Margaret, we close out with a Broadway diva. Who closes us out on this one?

SPEAKER_01Oh, my mother, the love of my life, my spirit angel. Let's go for Elaine Stritch.

SPEAKER_03Absolutely. I love it. I love it so much. All right. Thank you so much, guys. We'll see you for whatever when the next one is. We'll see you then. Take it away, Elaine. Bye.

SPEAKER_00Pound and 42nd Street To be in a show Oh, Broadway baby Learning how to sing and dance Waiting for that one big chance to be in the show

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode