Pudding season is almost over. But before we can do final predictions, we need to look back at Tony Awards of the past to make sense of our Tony Awards future. Friend of the pod Robbie Rozelle (@divarobbie) returns to drum up some fun Tony trivia and discuss patterns and evolutions of Tony Award wins. PLUS! A fun interview with the star and co-creator of Blood/Love Carey Renee Sharp! Check it out!! Important Links: * Broadway Breakdown Live: Green Room 42 Tix! * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Time Stamps: 0:00 - Intro 0:40 - Discussion w/ Robbie Rozelle 1:14:37 - Interview w/ Carey Renee Sharp Listener Discussion Questions: “Do you think a Legacy Win is real? Who would you say has won it?” “Do you think this is a year where nostalgia will be rewarded or uncertain future?” “Do you determine a revival’s success on the quality of the material being revived?” This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Hello all you theatre lovers both out and proud and on the DL and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theatre's most exclusive address Broadway I am your host Matt Koplik the least
SPEAKER_03famous and most opinionated Robbie Rofucking Zell Which, honestly, Diva Robbie is my Zelle,
so if anybody wants to slide in, that's great.
SPEAKER_03I mean, should I just fully say your union name, which is Robbie Rizelle, and then...
SPEAKER_01What union? I make cast albums. I get paid with Chipotle gift cards.
SPEAKER_03Listen, in some circles, that's a union. Sure Just buckle up because who knows where today is going to go Exactly Hi Matt Hi love It's 10am who the fuck knows what's going to happen So Robbie today is going to be more sort of a freewheeling When is it not freewheeling But fun day for us of We are So little so little but that's also kind of how i rolls is
yeah you don't give a packet normally but it's really you said we started doing packets but for Tony shit yeah but like not but like for deep dives and stuff for sure Tony shit just like I don't know just come on and we're gonna talk about all of it and then but we're gonna talk for an hour an hour and a half two hours when is a podcast just an audiobook like here we are um so you gave me precious little
SPEAKER_01to go on and here we are yeah But that's sort of I think what the beauty of what today is is us looking at the trivia that interests us and what those conversations can pertain to you buckle up buckle up buckle up and buckle in yeah so yes over you're looking over of best score and best book winners at the Tony Awards what has been some interesting
SPEAKER_03trivia to come along your path Oh gosh so I sort of went back to I started at 2008 and moved forward looking at musicals that like I was looking for like key indicators of like well this is
SPEAKER_01interesting blah blah blah I'm going to throw a question to you right at the front. What composer has worked on multiple Tony-nominated Best Musicals but not as a composer of a said musical? What composer has worked on multiple Tony-nominated Best Musicals but not as the composer?
SPEAKER_03Correct. I'm going to say Tom Kitt? You are correct.
SPEAKER_01Great, because he is the king of the jukebox. Yeah. do you know the four musicals that he that have been nominated for best musical that he was either the arranger or orchestrator of but did not write one was Spongebob right he did do Spongebob yeah and this is between 2008 and present day yeah and we're looking mostly at jukeboxes yeah did he work on American Idiot he
SPEAKER_03sure did Okay, great. I'm two for two out of four. Ain't bad. Oh, God. Oh, God. Jeez. Oh, Lord. Oh, my. I'm running. I'm running through these right now. No, no, no. Okay.
SPEAKER_00I'm going to ask for one quick hint. Is one of them a COVID gas leak? Yes. Okay. Is it Jagged Little Pill? It sure is. Okay. Okay. So that's three. And I can't think of the fourth The fourth nominated was Hell's Kitchen Okay So when it comes to Tom Kitt as your arranger Almost guaranteed a Best Musical nomination Not guaranteed yet a winner Maybe Because he also
did Head Over Heels
SPEAKER_01Not nominated he also did he's like the king of them I'm looking at other ones so sorry Everyday Rapture which is I guess technically a jukebox musical but not nominated he's sort of all over than that it's fascinating to me he's fascinating to me he is I mean he's got a wonderful ear and he's one of those people where I think he's a very good composer but I actually also think that his biggest gift is his versatility as
SPEAKER_00an arranger and being able to make a jukebox show sound like a cohesive whole I mean that's kind of the brilliance of what he did with Spongebob of that that's a score written by 90,000 different people he can pull all the strings tie them together and make it sound like it's of a piece maybe yeah we should do a revival of no strings and have Tom Kitt do the arrangement of it to include strings it would just be strings it would just be
SPEAKER_03strings yeah All things is what it's called now. That's fascinating. While looking at these best score winners and these best book winners, have you seen a pattern in regards to wins for either category in relation to Best Musical?
SPEAKER_01So, yes. Interestingly, hold on. I'm looking at best score winners that did not win Best Musical. One, two, three, four, five. have won Best Score, but not Best Musical in the last, what are we looking at, 15 years, which is very strange. There is a year, however, where only plays were nominated.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Which that's part of the reason. Next to Normal won Best Score, also Tom Kitt, but did not win Best Musical. Newsies won Best Score, but not Best Musical. Christmas Carol, like we said, play. One Best Score Not Best Musical Six One Best Score Not Best Musical And Sup Same Thing But Generally Your Best Score Is Taking Home Best Musical Generally I Find It Interesting When Something Wins Best Score But Doesn't Win Best
Musical Because Like What What's That Doing You Know What I Mean How Can You How Can Your Score Be
SPEAKER_01The Best But I Guess Because Of Overall Production I think production definitely plays a part into it and sometimes I mean like I think it's more interesting when a show is nominated for best score and like nothing else or very few things after that like Bridges of Madison County or Women on the Verge sure because that's one of those things where you listen to the album and you go oh there's such great material here and then you see it on stage and clearly nominators are like it works better as a listening experience yeah yes But Bridges,
Jen's Guide won Best Musical over Bridges And it also won Best Book It's just, what a weird In looking through these I was sort of comparing this year To the year
SPEAKER_01Memphis won everything In terms of just like To quote Robbie Razzell,
SPEAKER_00somebody had to Yeah,
SPEAKER_01somebody had to And like, I guess there was no Lightning Thief this year So it could just be all plays Memphis is the only musical of that category that has an original score everything else is jukebox and yeah the thing that we we've mentioned a bit on the podcast
SPEAKER_03before is jukebox musicals so rarely win when they have it's either been like COVID so it's Moulin Rouge Jersey Boys where it was just such a phenomenon that like it couldn't not win Jurassic Chaperone put up a big old fight but ultimately like Jersey Boys by that point had been running for like nine months it was such a behemoth and then Memphis that year was also the year of Adam's Family which is the most produced musical in
high school so yes God
SPEAKER_01bless
SPEAKER_00Although in fairness to the Tonys, the version that's produced is an updated version of what was on Broadway Correct
SPEAKER_01Can we talk about the Pulitzer and what the Pulitzer has to do? Not a lot We talk about, you talk a lot Oh, I'm using the royal we like a non-probable breakdown You talk a lot about other wars being precursors And do you think the Pulitzer plays a part in that? Yes and no the truth is that up until last year it really didn't I think in the
last 20 years so like from 2006 to now yeah three musicals have won three musicals
SPEAKER_03have won two of which went on to win best musical yes uh I believe Clybourne Park I mean I also look at the Clybourne Park Purpose and August Osage County I think those might be the only Pulitzer winners for drama in the last 20 years to go on to win best play uh I'm almost positive purpose and maybe liberation this year we'll see yeah well I do ultimately think liberation
will win but yeah I mean before like yeah basically in the earlier part of the 21st
SPEAKER_00century But I feel like the tide is kind of turning now because...
for plays in the last 15 years it was sort of like you know you had Fat Ham you had English you had Cost of Living between Riverside and Crazy Sweat and those all went those all went on to get a best play nomination but not win and then last year O'Mary was nominated but didn't win and Purpose won and I was like I mean that's kind of how this has been going for a while of you're the finalist for the Pulitzer you win best play but then Purpose ends up winning so I feel like I don't know maybe the Pulitzer is becoming a guarantor again for your best
play you know sure
SPEAKER_01yeah um musical lens No, no, no. I was truly only looking at it through the musical lens where Next to Normal, Hamilton and Strange Loop were nominated or won the Pulitzer. Next to Normal, as you know, did not win Best Musical. It's just because musicals so rarely win the Pulitzer. I guess it's not so much an indication,
but it's just interesting to me that that
SPEAKER_01It's more of a precursor than, I guess, other awards. I don't know why.
SPEAKER_00It looks like Next to Normal won the Pulitzer after the Tony Awards. It looks like they won in May of 2010. Or, sorry, April of 2010. And I wonder if they had won in May of 2009, or April of 2009, if that would have had a better... Would it have won Best Musical? If that, yeah, that could have given them a bigger push to best musical because there was a late in the game swell of support for next to normal,
SPEAKER_00but similar to drowsy chaperone. It's one of those things where like, I think the runway was a little too short to really build up a good case for them to win. Like by that point, Billy Elliot had been sort of running the table for the better part of a year. and it just sort of became super inevitable and if Next Normal maybe had opened a month earlier and could have been eligible for the Pulitzer of that year that would have given them another month of fan support they could have won the Pulitzer that April and then that would have built up to their winning in June but this is the
kind of butterfly effect Robbie that you can't play God because who knows what
SPEAKER_00would have happened Who's to say? Who's to say? Maybe we would have had a coronavirus 10 years earlier because of all this.
SPEAKER_03Oh my god. Oh my god. Oh my god. What do you have for me? Well, I've got a... Okay, so here's a fun thing for you. How... Okay, I'll go easy first and do musical, but when it comes to best director, in the last... Let's say of this century, how many off the top of your head can you name who have won Best Director of Musical that wasn't tied to a Best Musical winner or a Best
Revival of a Musical
SPEAKER_03winner? That's fascinating.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm. Because it exists, but it's more common pre-21st century than post-21st century. Sure. Christopher Ashley? Mm-hmm. For Come From Away There's one more big one Or two more big ones actually I should say I'm gonna get there I swear to you I can see your eyes
going back in time Yeah
SPEAKER_01truly Hmm John Rando for Urine Tone that's that's another one and then there's one more there's another John for Sondheim for oh John Doyle yeah for Sweeney oh right
SPEAKER_03Sweeney did not win they did not win Revival yeah that was that was actually considered a big upset because Sweeney was considered such a lock to win when they won director and orchestrations everyone's like well here we go yeah Triple Crown and then Pajama Game pulled up a major surprise and yeah so that's something that I always talk
SPEAKER_00about of it's not Matt Koplik wasn't nominated for revival because no one was really quite sure what to make of that sure of course and if it had been eligible for revival I think it probably would have won and then George C. Wolfe wins for Bring It to Noise Bring It to Funk over Michael
Greif for Rent which is one of those awards where it's like Michael Greif who somehow just can't he's been nominated five times yeah there's usually a reason like I think with Bring It to Noise similar to Christopher Ashley for Come From Away like that was so clearly the runner up of the year while the big sort of pop culture juggernaut of Renton Dear Evan Hansen wins it's like well we will acknowledge your work on a musical we like a great deal but we just can't quite bring ourselves to vote for
SPEAKER_01best musical yeah yeah wild yeah What are your thoughts on Legacy Wings?
SPEAKER_03I think that they're not completely real.
SPEAKER_00I don't think someone wins on Legacy alone. There has to be one or two other elements to go along with it. I think Legacy can kind of for Tony's give you that little extra push legacy wins used to be a bigger thing in the Oscars back in the day they're they're less so now like I know people talk about Stephanie J Block winning for Cher Show sort of being like a well she's been nominated a bunch we like her this is sort of like a career win and that's partially true but also it helped that Stephanie J Block was playing a real person
SPEAKER_00Yeah. wasn't really liked enough for Beth to win like if the prom had also won score or if they had won book that year I think Beth would have had a better shot but it was sort of a show where it's like it had its fans but just not
enough in the Tony committee I'm trying to think about anyone else who I would call their win like a
SPEAKER_01legacy win I would call Kelly's win a legacy win for sure but also you have to the thing about that is again like it's tied to she's in the best revival winner and is in a role that has a history of of winning um and sure so like I I think on the same page here it adds to it but I don't think that alone is the reason why somebody wins you know what I mean yeah because in my mind David Yazbek's Tony Award for the band's visit mm-hmm
is a legacy win that is to me not his best score by a mile I think I would view more of a legacy win like Julie Stein for Hallelujah Baby you know where sure sure it's like objectively not his best score but also where you say should have been
SPEAKER_00gypsy or Funny Girl and like similar to Yazbek with Bands Visit though like that's the best musical winner so it's very easy to just tie it into there what would you have given Spongebob best score over Bands Visit that year Robbie Spongebob is certainly the score I go back to more so likely yes I think that's more an issue though because there were so many people you know every song was assigned to a different
SPEAKER_01person yeah and so That's a great question What else was nominated that season? I think it was also Frozen and Mean Girls Hmm Yeah Maybe Mean Girls Band's Visit was not for me I like to say but yeah huh not okay Omar Sharif I see I know for me I think Bands Visit is probably the winner of that season while also agreeing with you it's not
Yazbek's best um okay and I but also Yazbek had the misfortune before Bands Visit is sort of every time he was nominated there was always just sort of the undeniable
SPEAKER_00option right now for him yeah producers juggernaut lightning the piazzas is like epic avant-garde score women on the verge loses to Book of Mormon Book of Mormon is a huge juggernaut women on the verge to close by that point I mean that's actually something to also talk about is closed shows and how often they can win so speaking of performances without looking it up Robbie Rizal because we're gonna keep it for a second can you name for me the last time a performance in a closed musical won a Tony Award
the last time a performance in a closed musical won a tony award performance oh that's so key was it donna murphy and passion had that closed no passion had opened it closed like four months later uh it's a little later than than passion great
SPEAKER_03okay post passion pre piazza ppp The triple P Performance And a crappy prize coming right on up We need a triple P It sure is No No I can't It was Martin Short and Little Me Right Talk about an undeniable juggernaut And one over Parade Brent Carver Another closed P Yeah I mean yeah that was and that actually is sort of a bit of a
makeup win too with Martin Short because not that he was gonna win for Goodbye Girl but the whole narrative of Martin Short and the Goodbye Girl was the show blows but like he proves himself to be a true musical theater leading man now let's put him in
SPEAKER_00something that's right for him does promises promises and encores really does well with that that was going to transfer yeah and then that kind of fell apart and so little me while there was people were mixed on that revival in general he was considered sort of undeniable and him winning was sort of like a foregone conclusion at that point because the only person who was in a running musical in that category was Tom Wopat for Annie Get Your Gun and if if you're voting for Frank Butler and Annie Get Your Gun chances are your
Annie Get Your Gun
SPEAKER_00is not gunning but somehow won Best Actress yikes well again was running yeah over wonderful Carolee Carmelo I think even Bernadette Peters knows it should have been Carolee but it was sort of a Bernadette's show was running Bernadette is very beloved and like Bernadette was fine in Annie Get Your Gun I think everyone expected a train wreck and she worked very hard to be aggressively fine and we were like you know what Bernie fine there
you go but like Bernadette Peters for me is sort of like the Tony Awards version of
SPEAKER_00Renee Zellweger I love her and it sucks that like of her two wins one of them is like one of her most mediocre performances and I wish that they were for her better performances but I'm happy she has the two Tonys god bless what are your thoughts on plays being nominated for best score over musicals it depends on what the score is I'm so happy when it's stereophonic I think that's deserved I agree I think Janine Tesori being nominated for 12th night
SPEAKER_03rules I love that always There are other ones where I'm like I call bullshit a little bit I call a little bit of bullshit on Joe Turner's Come and Gone I call a little bit of bullshit on
SPEAKER_002010 with Enron and Fences What would you sub out this year? I would sub out Joe Turner for Queen of Versailles which is not a fully successful score but is a more of a score and I do think that and I do think there is stuff in there I think far worse scores than Queen of Versailles have been nominated in the past I think Queen of Versailles just has such a stank on it which is not
SPEAKER_01undeserved but I mean the dead wizard song absolutely but like we fucking nominated Aspects of Love Robbie we did that it was a different time we were totally okay with you you were not alive I was barely alive when that show was on Broadway I was like two months too young to be Michael
SPEAKER_00Ball's love interest in Aspects of Love when I was born you guys if you having seen Matt live like doing Broadway Breakdown live one of the funniest things that I've seen this year is him recreating a tab version of Aspects of Love with Todd Bonapane Amy Jo Jackson puppets and Amy Jo singing a duet with herself using a compact mirror it is better than anything I saw on Broadway this season oh thank you baby and her making out with herself in the compact mirror yeah
It was unhinged in the best way And that's just an organic plug for people to see you Thank you Now's a good time to tell you all that June 1st is our next live show Our last live show for the season We're going to take a hiatus and come back
SPEAKER_03sometime in the fall for our next live show But yes, June 1st And there are going to be prizes, everybody If you partake in the Tony trivia at the live show You could win either two house seats to the Lost Boys Or two tickets to the Heated Rivalry Unauthorized Parody Musical I haven't seen that on Friday. Well then, Robbie, you could win tickets to Lost Boys. Which I saw. Well, you could see it again. Or heated rivalry again. Oh, we could see Boop. We could see Boop. We could see Boop.
So, I feel like I mentioned this a little bit before, but speaking of Boop, I... Deluded myself for about a minute into thinking Jasmine Amy Rogers could win for Boop last year recorded that prediction finished the episode and by the moment I hit upload I regretted that prediction on Mike but it was too late at that point
SPEAKER_03she's good though Well that's the thing I got wrapped up in the fact that she was so good and there was this real aura around the investment of a new leading lady on Broadway but the
SPEAKER_00truth was that Boop was just not good enough or I think I mistook those situations with the Michaela Diamond and Parade situation
SPEAKER_03of like, no, no, no, your nomination is your blue chip this is your investment now take it and make us not regret this and you will win the next time yeah for sure and who do you think that is this
year whose nomination is like the blue chip is the win yeah um well so it has to be somebody who's if not
SPEAKER_00fully new on the newish side um young um So I think if we're looking in the leading performances, I think that's kind of Sam Tutty, but that's tricky because he's English, so he's not going to have a lot of opportunities to be here. Possibly Ali in Lost Boys. I feel like his nomination is sort of a bit of a blue chip. And whatever his next project is, if he can lay it up with maybe a leading role in a strong show that's not Tommy,
SPEAKER_00then that can be a nomination and then potentially a win. I'm trying to think about leading actress because ultimately like really none of those women in leading actresses this year are new on the scene like Christiane Pitts has been in has led two different Broadway shows before Two Strangers Sarah Chase has been in a bunch of shows Stephanie Shue is a fucking Oscar nominee she's not she's not new sure she's not new but she is because she doesn't do musicals all
SPEAKER_01that often yeah you know i i think sarah chase is like good for you your nomination is your win yeah it's not that that's something the nomination is the win i don't look at sarah chase's nomination is an investment in her just yet so much as it's sort of like i don't know it's like it's a good boost for her i think that this can it's the robin herger nomination one thousand percent one thousand percent yeah um i do want a
SPEAKER_03t-shirt though that says stephanie shoe is not brand new you do love a perfect rhyme again if you go see Broadway Breakdown live you will hear all of the perfect rhymes of one Matt Koplik it's something I compliment him
SPEAKER_01on even though I don't like him very much Robby comes up to me after every show with a face that could melt steel usually looks me dead in the eyes so furious with me and he'll say something along the lines of your fucking rhymes and it's it's how I know I did a good job because my mom will be happy but Robby will be mad at me and that's and I'll be thrilled I
SPEAKER_00will say one of my favorite rhymes I did this past show just to guys again you know promote myself but the opening number began with Crime of the Century from Ragtime and it's the um I was uh Hugh put me on a velvet swing and made me wear well hardly anything ruined at the age of 15 and I made it I'm known for hot takes small and grand and also trashing finding neverland hated it
SPEAKER_03since 2015 and I was very proud of being able to include the 15. Len Aaron's Wishes. she wishes when I interview her which I think is happening I will inform her that I took her lyric and I made it better listen your lyrics are great and historically fun Lynn but they don't trash Finding Neverland and mine do so do yeah yeah yeah make them hear you would be better if we could include a dig on Paradise Square as well but you know that's for another show where are we we were
talking about trivia
SPEAKER_03I don't know the sun comes up and I think about you so that's normal it's almost next to normal but no I'd asked you about performances in closed musicals we have had more performances in closed plays win in the last couple of years most recently I would
SPEAKER_00say Carrie Young in Pearly Victorious Frances Chu in Yellowface She was, they both were. I mean, to be fair, both Frances Jew and Yellowface and Carrie Young and Pearlie Victorious had PBS broadcasts of their shows come out around the time of the Tonys, which I do think helped their case. Mm-hmm. Just because, you know, recency bias is a thing. It's hard for a lot of voters to look back on six months ago and go, oh, yes, I did really love that performance. I have to remember that excitement and drama back up again.
SPEAKER_00It helps when you have a little bit of a, what's I'm looking for? I have a testament to it via filmed media but I mean that's something that I think people are looking at with like Leslie Manville this year for Oedipus of like her big hurdle is her show is closed but I would also argue she is one of three closed nominees and I view her more as a Martin short of like it's I don't think they're giving it to Kelly or Rose for Fallen Angels I think their nominations are the wins so it's like okay of our three clothes ladies liberation
is probably winning which could boost Susanna Flood a bit or they can go we're already honoring liberation I should say yeah I don't think voters look at it as the royal we like I do I think they're going I'm already honoring liberation I liked Oedipus or even like I was mid on Oedipus but I loved Leslie Manville here we
SPEAKER_03go If you were guessing, looking at score and book for this season, where are people leaning? Jesus Christ. Well, actually, that's the other thing you were asking was about score and play. So before I answer that, can I ask you, what are your thoughts about plays getting nominated for best score?
SPEAKER_01I understand it sometimes, and sometimes I go, okay. Stereophonic made absolute sense. Talk about an album I go to all the time. but like Angels in America getting a nom or To Kill a Mockingbird okay why or this season with two plays that's like weird in a season that had musicals even though they really bent around their own rules to like get Schmigadoon
in there as a score
SPEAKER_01nominee I don't know I mean it doesn't say best original score of a musical it's just best original score and so but it does give the same sort of we're shutting out Victor Victoria and big vibes of the news and I to to what end yeah I think I guess part of it is the Tony Awards are you an arbiter of taste or are you there to sell tickets to the thing I think that's the tricky thing is that you it's and what and
what makes it a fun award show to figure out is it's a mixture because not every voter is thinking about tickets and some voters are truly just going with this is what I liked the most this is what I thought was good and then there are voters who are like this is what I think is going to help sell Broadway and it's sort of you you can't really lean one way or the other when predicting because it'll never really work out the
SPEAKER_00Matt Koplik Mm-hmm
so this ties now into your question about this year for best book and best score when the nominations came out I was convinced it was a three-way race amongst two strangers Schmingadoon and Lost Boys and now I'm kind of feeling like it's a two-way race between Schmingadoon and Lost Boys and it's ultimately that neither
SPEAKER_00show has a large enough body of Vociferous support that I can hear in like the voting community so much as that like both of them have a solid base and then it's just like okay which one has six votes more two strangers could ultimately still win I know a lot of people appreciate how the original component of it all they find it charming but also I mean maybe I'm in my own bubble maybe you're hearing differently I just feel like people aren't talking about two strangers as much as they were
six months ago
SPEAKER_01Yeah, because everything comes in in April now. And so we saw it together. That's a fall show. And so it's sort of fallen out unless Sam Tutty pulls through because he's so charming.
SPEAKER_00He is. And I think I've said before, if anyone is going to be Joshua Henry, it is going to be Sam Tutty. I don't actually predict that happening, but that's my one thought. Well it's my one sort of like no 0.1% chance like if if the mosquito came down and hit the paperweight in the wrong way so it shifted the weight just enough that it knocked something off its access like it's one of those things where it's so unlikely but it's not impossible just because everything's a possibility. Two Strangers I feel like was trying to go for the maybe happy
ending model which maybe happy ending is the first best musical winner probably since Gentleman's Guide to genuinely like hold out since winter and have it work out for them which is beautiful for maybe happy ending but when it happened I was a little annoyed
SPEAKER_00because like Every time a win happens that sort of changes everybody's perception, there becomes the new narrative. So like the road vote myth started because when Avenue Q beat Wicked, the narrative was they lied to road presenters and said they were going to tour and ended up doing Vegas and so like the road presenters were the people who really like got Avenue Q over the edge which is possible but again like could just be a matter of Avenue Q won by 45 votes and those 45 were the road presenters and then Gentleman's
Guide opens in the fall to great reviews and basically struggles isn't like on Death's Door but is
SPEAKER_00struggling to I saw it for free seven times because my best friend ran that theater and they were
SPEAKER_01struggling like they were papering to just get it through to the awards Yeah I mean it's it's you look at the grosses for Gentleman's Guide between I guess it opened in October or November up until April when the nominee May when the nominations came out and you see like holidays it does well and then like January February it's like really on life support March it's slowly kind of picking up a little bit and then April's when it really explodes but because of that and then like it wins and it recoups and it goes on the road and so
people start to think oh
SPEAKER_03like if you're the little show that could like you can you can open in the fall and like we'll keep you running because like we think like because Gentleman's Guy did it why can't we and and that was never a reality again until literally 11 years later with maybe a happy ending it was a full 11 years in between the two where the same narrative happened and so maybe happy ending one I was like oh god some other like small show that could is going to open in the fall and lose millions of dollars and
SPEAKER_00the Hope that they're going to win best musical and it looked like two strangers was going to do the same thing the difference between two strangers may be happy ending and gentleman's guide is while two strangers got solid reviews it did not get the raves that may be happy ending got and gentleman's guide got and in particular two strangers is reviews is actually kind of on equal footing to all the other best musical nominees and so it's not like they can claim we're the best reviewed musical of the year they're not they don't have the most nominations of the year like it's just it is a show that some people love some people like some people
are mixed on and it's now kind of getting lost in the shuffle so to answer your earlier question I think if two strangers wins score or book then I think that that's an indication of it winning musical it has to win one of those though I think the moment Schmigadoon
SPEAKER_00wins book that has best musical and I think the moment I'm contradicting myself here because I'm like they each have to win one of these but like if Lost Boys wins score I think that gives it its path to best musical if Schmigadoon wins book that gives it a path to best musical Two Strangers has to win one or the other like if Lost Boys won book for some reason it would throw me but I wouldn't that would not make me go oh now they're winning best musical in the same way like if Schmigadoon won score it would throw me but I wouldn't go oh you're winning best musical I think Schmigadoon needs to win book and
right now that's
SPEAKER_00kind of because the majority of the energy I'm hearing is Schmigadoon. I think that they're the front runner now for book, which means two strangers could win score.
SPEAKER_03And that would be that would be a thing. And that would that would be an event that happens.
SPEAKER_01Listen, there are scores that have won where I've gone, huh, you know? Yeah. But there are not many shows that win I mean there's only one musical that's won best musical with no writing awards in the past 15 that I looked at which is Moulin Rouge did not win best book And Outsiders didn't win Oh yeah you're right so sorry But Outsiders did win director and so did Moulin Rouge
There's one musical that won both writing awards but not best musical which is SUFFS
SPEAKER_01Right, right, right, right.
SPEAKER_00So speaking of John Rando for a second, I remember that was when Sufts won Book and Score, but then not Best Musical. I remember there were people who do not know their history. This is why trivia matters. And they go, how could that happen? And I go, it's actually happened twice before this century. We have Drowsy Chaperone won Score and Book, and then Urintown won Score and Book. But to add insult to injury, Urintown also won Director and You liked what was on stage it won all those things make it make sense what won over urine tone
Millie right which of course that was right after 9-11 and so people were I'm not laughing at 9-11 but like people were looking for joy and a good time so that's
SPEAKER_01where Millie was Millie met the moment
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Millie was an old-fashioned musical theater comedy that was also a celebration of New York City. It had the narrative of A Star is Born with Sutton Foster. It made people feel good. Like, you're in town. People, I think, were saying, like, this is objectively the better musical, but Millie is the show I need right now.
SPEAKER_01Honestly, that could be the reason Schminkadoon wins. It's the musical to meet the moment. You know, I saw everything this season. Um... And... Honestly, that's probably where I would give it to. I think I liked Two Strangers a little more, but Schminkajun feels like a Broadway musical in a way most of the shows nominated do not.
SPEAKER_00Right. I think that each show has something to go by and it's different from each other nominee, which is fun. But for me, none of the nominees are like totally the full package. But That's sort of why I'm kind of still on the fence. Like, again, I do think it's ultimately Schwingadoon for all the reasons you said, but... Yeah. Because usually when you look back on Best Musical of the last 12, 13 years...
Uh-huh.
SPEAKER_03Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. so undeniable Evan Hansen it becoming a sensation was kind of took everybody by surprise in a lot of ways it is this small intimate human musical that the Tonys really like to honor you look at Kimberly Akimbo and Strange Loop and maybe Happy
Ending those are the shows that they tend to go for now for Best Musical and so you
SPEAKER_00would think that that's Two Strangers but at the same time Schmigadoon is still like a human story set within a meta spoof so like it is high concept even if its ultimate aim is to just like entertain entertain so it does have that going for it and then making the score eligible I think in a lot of ways will allow maybe uneducated voters to be okay with voting for it because again jukebox has been such a Roadblock for many musicals yeah yeah yeah yeah it's
fascinating to me that that score is eligible since are there new songs in it question mark if you were to ask their press team there's almost a dozen but the truth of the matter is is there are songs that I did some digging afterwards because I hadn't really watched the TV
SPEAKER_00show enough to say fully but I then listened to the Soundtrack and sort of correlated it with the songs that are in the show and what it sounds like is I think there are two genuinely new songs that Cinco Paul wrote and then there are other songs that were in the TV show that he wrote new lyrics for but the melody was the same I see and what are your thoughts on because Cinco is the only nominated writer but the series had a writer's room
so all of that was
SPEAKER_01developed and by a group of people written by committee like TV shows often are and so this one person getting potentially an award and certainly a nomination for what was developed by a number of people what are your thoughts for that
SPEAKER_00Dreamgirls came from improvisations from the company Loretta Devine has
gone on record to say that she's the one who coined showbiz is just showbiz and like that became a motif in the show chorus line as well a lot of the material in chorus line is lifted
SPEAKER_00directly from those tapes straight from those tapes yeah yeah and so it's There is a bit of a ick factor for me on that.
SPEAKER_03I think when the script works I feel less icky. So like with Spelling Bee I feel a little less icky because I think that script is just so good. For something like Schmigadoon where I do find it's not
SPEAKER_00Shmigadoon is more this happens and then this happens and then this happens and so and which I feel like probably makes more sense in a TV show where you're coming back every 30
SPEAKER_00minutes to a new storyline so I don't think that St. Paul has necessarily condensed that series to make it a fully formed musical so I'm I'm I have more of an ick factor about that but um there yeah but there is
SPEAKER_03historical precedent for it yeah It's just it's interesting to me mostly because like the cast contributions of Spelling Bee were always known and talked about but I feel like this isn't being
SPEAKER_01talked about at all that it was created in a writer's room it's just very interesting to me I yeah I'm not sure what that's about I don't know if I mean I'm sure the production doesn't want to mention it too much because they have been sort
SPEAKER_00of going with the whole it's St. Go Paul's brainchild and you know it is like it was his idea the TV show and and he definitely spearheaded a lot of the TV show but maybe also it's sort of the like well if you know how TV works and like you would know that it's a writer's room so like that's that's not on us if you're not aware of that you know sure yeah but I mean Titanic is having the same kind of backlash with its book right now where members of the original companies talk about their lack of credit for helping develop that script mm-hmm
they sure are they're going everywhere that's the show I think wins best book Titanic it's what I would vote for yeah so that's fascinating that they're sort of have to navigate both that and the general manager of the off-bradway production um so wild listen listen we can always debate who wrote the book for Titanic but there's no debate about who cooked the book for Titanic and
that's why you go to Broadway Breakdown live at the green room god that was funny thank you thank you
SPEAKER_01I've had one coffee I'm so sorry to all your fans with Misophonia because I've been sucking down and I see like it's my job but I keep trying to mute the mic so that I don't upset people too much we appreciate you listen I only with words yes I just drown you with my
SPEAKER_03words Have you so actually speaking of performances for a second going back because I just remember with the the sort of what we call the blue chip nomination the investment nomination I did speak to Instagram the other day and I asked everyone like when was the last time a twink won a Tony for performing and it's been
SPEAKER_00interesting what people consider a twink because yeah I've learned that to many people twink is a state of mind much like daddy and I'm a little more like no no I mean like genuinely a young person someone under the age of you know 32 winning a performance Tony and the I mean I think Miles Frost won
SPEAKER_03under the age of 30 for MJ and yes and then before and then before Miles was um Ben Platt for Evan Hansen and so young performers can win they just don't frequently win it's sort of like um like a like the alleged legacy vote of they have they have to be part of something that is also a little too undeniable for us to vote yes I I mean twink is a state of mind
SPEAKER_01um That's what people are telling me I disagree I disagree Wild You're absolutely right You know as I'm thinking back And like It's not Jared Emick No that's I'm sorry that's Daddy Jared Emick is Daddy Even then he was Daddy I would not call him Daddy But I would call him Twonk then Fine I'll take Twonk Yeah I guess you could say In its way Ben Platt
who never was a twink but was young yeah but that's the exception and not the rule and is that because is that because their voters or nominators think they'll get it
SPEAKER_01down the line I think there's a little bit of that in the same way of there's notoriously a narrative that Oscars don't give best actor to young actors you have to get nominated a few times and earn it like that's sort of the whole joke of why Timothee Chalamet hasn't won yet why it took Leonardo DiCaprio 20 years to win I think Tony's have a little bit of that as well of yeah you need to prove to us
SPEAKER_00Right. I mean even Ben Platt with Evan Hansen he had been in the
theater community for a bit at that point had done Book of Mormon on Broadway and on the road and so people knew that he was a dyed in the wool theater kid he was the real deal so this star turning right Hansen no one really thought of as a fluke Sutton winning for Millie
SPEAKER_00is both uh we're investing in a new ingenue a star is born but also Sun had been in like four or five Broadway shows by that point it wasn't a flute it was a crowning same thing with Jesse Mueller and Beautiful it was like no we're we're not we are investing in you but we also know that you've had the body of
SPEAKER_01Jesse had done so much and shown so much by the point of Beautiful so many different sides from from from Clear Day the jazz singing Clear Day to the into the woods Cinderella like showing truly every side of her voice and self yeah it's weird that Jesse was was able to kind of still have that narrative of new girl on the block with beautiful while also kind of the same narrative of it's her time
SPEAKER_00you know yeah
SPEAKER_01But, you know, I can't think of anybody who has appeared and just become a theater star who can sell shows on Their Name Alone, short of, I guess, Audra when she first appeared.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Smart girl. Yeah.
and she can what are some other trivias we have to learn from the first woman to win a Tony for writing a musical score is that Betty Compton no like solo I thought you meant like because Betty Compton has did win Tony's but of course she did yeah
SPEAKER_00yeah yeah yeah yeah the Cyndi Lauper first woman a solo woman to win best score and then Janine Tesori Lisa Crone first all-female team to win score and where is their next
SPEAKER_03musical because I want it Tesori's writing a musical right now good yeah fuck I forgot what it was but somebody told me about it and it was like I was like oh fuck that's perfect god I forget but Tesori is working on something I don't know about Krohn I can't speak for Lisa Krohn do you know the first woman do you know the first woman to win best play at the Tonys no I sure do now plays are a
SPEAKER_01blind spot for me so
SPEAKER_03Well, they're musicals before they add the songs. It's like how rosé is red wine before it's fully fermented. Plays are the rosés of musicals. That's another t-shirt. Put it on a t-shirt. Yep. Your merch drop is going to be huge. Stephanie Hsu is not brand new.
SPEAKER_00Plays are the rosés of musicals. And everyone in New York is going to see people wearing that merch and going, the fuck? Yeah. But Wendy Wasserstein, first female playwright to win. Right, of course. Yeah. I believe Marcia Norman's the first woman to win the Pulitzer, but Wasserstein's the first woman to win it. for Nightmother yes and then I believe Marcia Norman's the first solo female writer to win best book at the Tonys because Comden would co-write
with Green yes famously
SPEAKER_03yeah famously so you know shattered glass everywhere that's wild to me
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't have much more in the way of trivia. I was just mostly looking for trends. Of the shows of the last 15 years that have won Best Musical, which do you think will reappear at Encores at some point, and which do you think will be forgotten to time?
SPEAKER_00So between 2011 to today, which best musical winner do I think is most likely to appear at Encores and which one do I think is most lost to time? I think Gentleman's Guide is probably the most likely to show up at Encores.
SPEAKER_01I would agree with that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. And I hate to say it, but probably Band's Visit is the most likely to get lost to time. I don't think it's going to be completely forgotten but I do think that it's going to be it's going to be like somewhere between a kismet and a wonderful town where it's going to get done but but it's more sort of like it has its passionate fans and then it has the people who are like oh yeah sure that show
for sure yeah would
SPEAKER_00you say those are your answers as well for the best musical winners or
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you know, as I was looking through, et cetera, probably if we went later, I would probably say Memphis gets lost to time forever.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yes. Well, if we're including 2010, then Memphis is absolutely lost to time. People aren't even really. It's already lost.
SPEAKER_01When's the last time you heard of somebody doing it?
SPEAKER_03No, I mean, I only hear people mention it. I never hear people doing it.
SPEAKER_01I don't even hear them mention it. it's it's it's Timu Hairspray yes yes it is good for you thank you really got me Timu Hairspray yes correct correct I mean also looking through the last 10-15 years speaking of revivals because I think one of the more contentious races this year is revival of a musical people not sure where it's going to go you look at the best
SPEAKER_00revival winners yes and you see it and you see a trend of overall awarding bold productions of musicals that maybe are not the best musicals nominated but are the most bold productions but like sure what I had said because people in their argument this year with ragtime versus cats cats is people got cats jail like a barrel is because Rocky Horror is just happy to be at the table it's the Carrie Coon from White Lotus it's just and I'm just happy to be at the table
and then I would probably say that uh that Leslie Bibb is Ragtime and um the other one the act the actress is Jellicle Ball uh because she's the one who gets fucked on that trip but so the the people going oh well you know Cats is still Cats and Ragtime is a good musical and so I look back at each past revival winner and go
SPEAKER_00okay well like was that revival of the better musical and I think a lot of times you could say no sunset is not as good of musical as gypsy but ends up winning merrily for all of the things about it I love I think is objectively not as good of a musical as cabaret but But those productions, very different productions, I would say same thing with Once on this Island versus My Fair Lady. Once on this Island, I probably enjoy more than My Fair Lady, but I think My Fair Lady is like it's planted itself as one of the great musicals of the last hundred years.
SPEAKER_00I don't know I don't have an answer Robbie I was pitching it to you
I would say to me for me it's Cats over this production of Ragtime I think this reinterpretation of Cats is brilliant and also the original Cats won Best Musical
SPEAKER_01something Ragtime has never done Ragtime has never won the big award whether it's best musical or best revival with the last revival but the re and this production of Ragtime is what's good about it is very good but what is not is like a sound do you do you think speaking of that actually sorry to interrupt you but yeah Sweeney Todd won best musical and then has had three
different revivals to
SPEAKER_00never win revival yeah which I think is interesting I wonder if it actually hurts a show like ragtime like impossibly hurt Sweeney that a lot of people hold that show in such high regard that if a production doesn't really clear the bar it really gives them an attitude about it whereas something like yes of course it does kind of look well I wanted to know speak more on that
SPEAKER_01please because Because with the advent of YouTube And us being able to go back And watch that original production In its many forms Ragtime will always be Especially that original cast Is top tier Truly top tier And every subsequent production Of it Is less than One They're not spending the money anymore Like this production They sing a full ass duet About a car that's not on stage
SPEAKER_00No, that car's at Salesman.
SPEAKER_01Wheels of a Dream. Yeah, exactly. So, another reason that he stole the car from Ragtime and put it on stage in Salesman.
SPEAKER_00He went backstage and he stole it.
SPEAKER_01He said, let me take this not Model T and put it on stage. But, because likely illegal money that was spent on the original Ragtime you saw it on stage you don't see it in other productions of it the last show had a golf cart in place of a car this production doesn't even have that and for me the best thing going for Ragtime right now is they're using the original orchestration and it was just huge and a good deal of the cast is very very
good but Cats is a full reinvention I keep comparing this Cats and the roundabout 1776 in this regard I just saw you make a face so let me for a second I'm like well which roundabout
SPEAKER_011776 oh correct yes the most recent one the non-male 1776 Matt Koplik yeah okay yes because of it's that 1776 felt half-baked somebody had an idea but didn't they were making blueberry muffins and forgot to put the blueberries in so they sprinkled a few on top and that was the show right this cats though is so thoroughly thought through of
the categories that they're walking translating into why is this cat here in body and you know whatever they're doing every element of it is thought through and so it is a glorious reinvention of a property that came in as a spectacle won best musical won all these awards and ran so long that it became a joke all the time
SPEAKER_01like outside of Cats is a joke everywhere and then to see this show that I truly thought I'm seeing cats and then just jaw on the floor because the expectations I think downtown when I saw it the expectations were so low because it's cats like how good can it be even with the cast assembled Andre De Shields etc and
it was such a full reinterpretation that I was mesmerized and I still am I've seen
SPEAKER_01it three times now and I it's it's astounding what these directors and choreographers and this cast and everybody around it have done to a property that's oh god 40 some years old to make it feel like a brand new show yeah and they have not done that to ragtime No I think some would argue you don't need to do that to ragtime but also and this is not this is more sort of me looking at the past and trying
to apply it to now and seeing because it's not every reinvention gets awarded as you said some reinventions like the most recent 1776 it's not just oh you did something new it's you have to do something new and follow through and give it a point of view yeah yeah and make it fully realized and I do think usually when you look at winners of this category that is where they go there are a few exceptions and then with those exceptions there's always a caveat so like I would say the last
traditional revival that won was like Hello Dolly with Bette Midler and in a lot of ways that in a lot of ways that was kind of a reinvention because we were doing
SPEAKER_00more of these pared down revivals and It became so much about reinventing the wheel and Bette Miller's dolly was, well, what if we just gave you opulence and understood what our assignment was? And there was a joy bomb about all of that. Pajama Game winning over Sweeney Todd. I know a lot of people look at it as sort of a side eye. Sweeney Todd was its own reinvention of that musical. But I would argue a lot of people were divided on what John Doyle did with Sweeney Todd.
and also because there was such a love for that material it's like what do you mean it's set in an asylum what do you mean they're all playing the instruments like that's I don't love that and in a lot of ways pajama game was a genuine revival everyone thought oh that dusty old golden age musical we just saw that at encore is like it's it's fine it's not exciting and god bless them at roundabout they made
SPEAKER_00that show sexy and exciting um and that so that was fantastic
SPEAKER_03It's hard to think of a revival winning that seems so... safe that won over something that was more you know yeah there was people thought maybe the Hugh Jackman music man could win over company because oh it was such a big hit and ultimately no they they gave a lot of love to company because even though there were not everything fully worked in that production so much of it did work and it was such a big swing the fact that it could hit so
well as it did was
SPEAKER_00astounding and People were divided about as we like to call it woke lahoma but it did ultimately win over a more kind of by the numbers kiss me k and it's not about what's the best material it's about who does the best with the material that they have right and that's the same as also of revival play I suppose revival of a play isn't interesting to me because sometimes it does feel like they're rewarding the play itself and not the production sure but it's never overly
egregious it's more it's more like boils down to okay we've got two great revivals here we're gonna pick the one that is ultimately the better play and and that becomes its own discussion like
SPEAKER_00last year Eureka Day winning part of me wonders if that's because of the four options we had we had two great plays which was Our Town and Romeo and Juliet productions that a lot of people didn't really enjoy then you had Eureka Day and Yellow Face which were much better productions and maybe they went with ultimately the show that they thought was the better play overall who's to say I don't know but that's sort of like where my mind goes yeah I mean that's certainly
SPEAKER_01fair I don't what is this season is it going to be Death of a Salesman I think so I think it's down to Salesman and Oedipus and I ultimately think Salesman's gonna win A because it's still running B it's it is a lovely production and and has the reviews to back it up and the nominations and is like fucking making hand over fist right now at the box office which is I don't think any of us
SPEAKER_00really expected expected yeah yeah yeah Yeah. And so I just think that there's a narrative behind that. If Salesman doesn't win, it is ultimately going to be that people are not quite ready yet to reward Bruden with open arms. Yeah. But also, like, the Tonys have proven that ultimately they don't care about online backlash. They're like, we're going to vote for who we want and have done so. So we'll see. We'll see.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Boy, that's, I guess... to me the plays are more fascinating this year than the musicals which is as a musical theater girly makes me a little sad but yeah it's also interesting to me that Ragtime got a number of acting nominations and likely wins and Cats has won which I actually think is the winner in that category Andre De
Shields but Ragtime has the benefit of being eligible in multiple performance categories,
SPEAKER_01whereas Cats just has the two that it's eligible for. right and I think ragtime also has the benefit of while it's an abundance of
SPEAKER_00characters every character has minimum two songs and minimum a scene where they get to shout about the indignities of this country which is enough for well except for Sarah Sarah basically dies believing that the country is good which was silly of her but we don't want to kick a dead girl while she's down but the rest of the cast of crack time has a moment where they're like back to before success wheels of a dream this country and I think that's a lot that's enough that's enough for nominators to go
yes it's yes uh and that's enough material and cats genuinely is like everybody
SPEAKER_00gets a number and it's much more of a genuine ensemble piece and so I can understand my belief my hot take is I would imagine like Three or four members of Jellicle Ball found their way onto multiple nominators ballots. And it was just ultimately spread a little too thin that none of them could crack the five. I would imagine like Sidney James Harcourt and Junior Lubeja probably were like a number six and seven or seven or eight. I would imagine that Tempris probably was like right at six.
SPEAKER_00Emo Sofia was probably like at eight where, you know, like they were showing up, but they like they just needed 10% more push to get there and because Jellicle Ball isn't about a star vehicle for any of them that was maybe like what would hurt them but I I've also said I think that Andre could have a path to victory not just the legacy of it all but also being the lone performance nominee is a bit representative of the company in that
SPEAKER_01respect yes but the fact that the man is still walking and hitting the notes that he's dancing down that stage yeah and holding them forever like there that's a this is a that's a legacy Tony yeah i think that if he wins it is kind of a legacy tony but again tied to if he does win i do think it is tied to uh the very strong possibility of jellicle ball winning and and being part of a moment into movement uh like if
i think i would
SPEAKER_00call andre winning an on a legacy win if he were like I don't know if he ended up being the narrator in Rocky Horror and he's like their one win that I would that's when I'd be like that is truly a legacy win nothing else you cannot convince me otherwise Jellicle Ball there's like there's others similar to Stephanie J. Block like there's you need two or three other bullet points behind the legacy to fully push for that you know yeah I think Rachel Trach is one nomination away though from getting a legacy win herself she's a two-time nominee now yeah and
SPEAKER_00because she's wonderful in Rocky Horror I think she's so good on that show okay Robbie this has been delightful I think it's time that we start wrapping things up you and I are both busy bitches with things to get to oh my god yes sorry for my lack of energy today y'all no one knows the difference I'll edit this all together I know I know I know I know you spell Koplik C-U-N-T that's how you spell Koplik usual spelling where can people find you
SPEAKER_03if you want them to find you Diva Robbie on all platforms that are worthy or RobbieRosell.com and my semi-hit
SPEAKER_01solo album is on Spotify.
SPEAKER_03Fantastic. Okay. Guys, we are going to take a quick break and head into our post-episode interview with
SPEAKER_00the star and the creator of Blood Love, Miss Carrie Rene Sharp talking a little bit about the genesis of the show her journey coming back to performing and writing after years away from it and where her show is heading next but yeah stay tuned for our interview with Carrie there and that that's it for now thank you so much Rob Bay let's take a peek Billy I beg to differ
SPEAKER_02with you how do you mean you're the top yeah Hi, Carrie.
SPEAKER_03Thank you for coming to Broadway Breakdown.
SPEAKER_02Hi. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_03So you just closed Blood Love, a show that you co-wrote and starred in. Yeah. Amazing feat. Congratulations. Thank you. Love Love Love Love
about vampires but really focusing on my character Valerie who is she's actually like the queen of hell who has come to earth to have a human experience and it kind of became by default the very first vampire and now she has been on earth for a thousand years is starting to feel a little bit of an existential crisis and was longing for something more in her life and just kind of figuring out what's the next step for her and she meets a catalyst which is this rock star Anzik and
SPEAKER_02who kind of reawakens something in her and her love of music. It just kind of reminds me, reminds her, reminds me, but reminds her of who she is. So yeah, and there's some really lovely relationships in it between her and the devil and her and her two best friend vampires and then this rock star that she meets. So there's kind of these different angles of relationships that she's navigating.
SPEAKER_03And how is it that this musical came to be? What inspired you to create it along with your co-writer Drew DiCaro? DiCaro? DiCaro. DiCaro, great.
SPEAKER_02We, well, I owned, I opened a theater in Wisconsin in 2018. It was an old historic theater that we had renovated. It was a very interesting space because it's not a typical theater. It's kind of more of like a auditorium style. So we were able to do all kinds of really creative, interesting things there. And what we did that kind of inspired this specifically is we did a really high-end vampire ball, like a black tie vampire ball that had a little bit of, it wasn't a murder mystery, but like that's the best thing I can think of. It's sort of like a party with a plot line.
and we had original music not written by me but written by another friend of mine and a fashion show and so it was this whole event and it was very well received and so I was like you know I really want to I want to keep working on this and turn it
SPEAKER_02into more of a show and I just had a I had the inclination to start writing the music myself. I wanted to do it myself. And I hadn't written music professionally ever, and I hadn't written music for a very long time, really, period. So I met Drew through another friend of ours, the original Cleo in the show, who also wrote some of the original Yeah, yeah
um and yeah one from there and I would say about half of the songs in the show are from like the original songs that we wrote so then how did you go about from writing this in Wisconsin to having this become an off-Broadway production like you know what what was the trajectory for you first of all how long was this trajectory
SPEAKER_00and then where did it go from there
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, it's been five and a half years. So we started writing in August of 2020. And I mean, as you know, I'm sure quite well, theater development takes time. And we really had no idea what we're doing. I don't really come from this world. And Drew does not either, although he's very immersed in the music scene in L.A., but he's more of a typical songwriter producer for like, you know, artists. He's never worked. He hadn't even really seen that many musicals when we started working together because he's more of a rock artist. you know pop sort of producer so we really didn't know what
we're doing and but we just kind of drew and I and we had a very small group of us that just we kept it really close to the vest and we just kept developing workshops we do performances for like friends and family just to kind of get things put together and like kind
SPEAKER_02of figure out the storyline and where all the music needed to go and And so we've done what we did to workshop performances at my theater in Wisconsin one in 21 and one in 22. And then we did a full production in Los Angeles in fall of 2024. And then we gave the show a major overhaul all of last year pretty much we spent like a whole year like really over overhauling it. um and realizing that we wanted to do it in more of a traditional theater um such as what we did at theater 555 so that that process led us to
starting rehearsals in January and and where we are now but we have done basically four full productions now and were you Valerie this entire time while you were writing it yeah there was one workshop that Carrie Renee Fuller who's Elphaba right now and Wicked she played or she we were just doing a table workshop but um she did the part so I could just
SPEAKER_02be on writer's side because usually I'm doing both which is hard yeah I mean usually I'm kind of like okay we are gonna start rehearsals now and I'm just a performer and I really try to like not have to do any writing in that in that world and I do have to a little bit but it's like minimal but anytime that I know we have to do a lot of writing I'm just like not that's really all I'm focusing on is writing Yeah I was about to say it must be difficult to try to be performing a number during a workshop and then at some moment you have a mental beat where you go oh we need to we need to clock that for a later writing session but no I'm in the moment
SPEAKER_00I'm acting I'm acting. Yeah yeah it is a little tough and thankfully I've got a couple really wonderful I guess I'll call them assistants but you know just people that are working on the that I can kind of be like flag that or you know they'll kind of like take notes
SPEAKER_02for me so I can sort of Stay in it while I can just like quick you know get my ideas out but um yeah it is it is definitely difficult to do both
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. I mean, and also, as you said, you kind of hinted at this, but I want to talk about a little bit more. I mean, you have musical experience.
SPEAKER_00You played violin starting at three. You're a writer, but then you took time away from all of that. You went into nursing and nurse-practitioning, yes?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03I'm professional. I do my job. I do my research. No, it's great. So what kind of, what brought you back to music then? Was there a moment or was it just like you missed it and you're like, and I remember being quite good at it, so I'm going to get back to it. Yeah well I mean it never like really left my life obviously I love music and just consuming music and singing in the shower you know it's not like I didn't you know you don't totally put music away in your life but I had worked I was a pediatric nurse practitioner in the in the pediatric ICU so I was working with like very sick children for 12 years I did that for 12 years and I was really
burned out I mean
SPEAKER_02I'm sure this doesn't sound surprising but it's very very sad work and Emotionally physically mentally exhausting was just burned out and I needed I just needed to step away from the field and in that time is when I'd open this theater so it just kind of I was I was producing a bunch of other acts I was bringing a lot of just singers in but also we would do these kind of like dinner theater shows and we were just doing all kinds of stuff to kind of but I was just on the producer end and and I just kept like everything we were bringing wasn't exactly
what I wanted and I
SPEAKER_02was like I feel like I can create the thing that I'm looking for but And again so we started with this party and then I just and then I was like I I want to write the music though like I want to really make this thing a show so yeah I did but it was some baby steps in the beginning and I'm very grateful to Drew and Aaron and Snake that was my original we were almost like a band like the four of us were like writing for the first year or two two years maybe the four of us were mainly writing together so they really like helped me get my confidence in this world
But yeah it took a minute it wasn't like instantaneous that I and I didn't even play the violin again in the show until 2022 because I hadn't played violin for at
SPEAKER_02least not regularly for 20 years Wow so I was quite good in high school I'd had a scholarship to go to music school and I just didn't want to do that so I was quite good when I was younger and I will never get back to that level I know that because I just it would take a level of discipline and practice that I just don't I don't have time for I don't really have the desire to I don't need to play at that level so it's okay but it was really hard coming back to it and just being like wow I used to be so good and I am so rusty yeah but I've worked hard and I do play quite a bit in the show and so it's yeah it's come together but it's taken a few years
SPEAKER_00I mean, yeah, I completely understand that. But then this is your first piece of musical theater writing then. Is that correct? Isn't it? Yeah. Professionally, yeah. I actually did a bit in high school and college, but just for fun, you know, just casual. What has been some of the biggest learning tools you've acquired by writing this musical as a now official musical theater writer, professional musical theater writer you are now?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I mean, writing is... So even though I wasn't writing musical theater, I was writing a ton. I have two graduate degrees. I was halfway through a doctorate. So obviously writing in that world is very different than writing musical theater. But there is just something about the skill of writing that you just get better at the more that you do it. And I don't think that all that writing, although it wasn't exactly what I'm doing now, of course that was helpful. And the other thing that Drew and I both are just avid readers. So we can pull from so many different things.
SPEAKER_02We just have... That experience and so i've i've learned that like all of that that you can bring to the writing process when you're creating something more creative all of that is very very helpful and i think it's been why we've been successful even though neither one of us have like written a musical before yeah and then with this run in new york what has been some of the lessons you've learned from that both as a
SPEAKER_03writer and as a performer
SPEAKER_02Well, this was very hard. I mean, I can say we're done now, so I can say this is probably the hardest thing I've ever done. You know, we knew coming to New York that we were opening ourselves up to both all the opportunity of New York and the people that are there that can help us bring this to the next level, which we certainly achieved. But you also then have all eyes on you and you know you're opening yourself up to like the critique and criticism of the very professional theater world. I mean, obviously New York is the hub of theater really for the world. So I you know and so there was a lot of good that came with
that and a little bit
SPEAKER_02of bad but I knew that was coming so you know I learned I learned that I can do it like I learned that I can work really hard and achieve this again it like it wasn't like on day one it's not like I was perfect on our first preview and I can say that it's okay and I think that's okay I mean there seems to be somewhat of an unforgiving nature of but it's just insane to me that you're expected to have a fully polished product and a fully polished performer on day one here it's just that that was difficult for me to like
SPEAKER_02Sure, yeah. is critiqued at the same level as like the show you know last weekend which is phenomenal you know but was it the same on preview day one no
yeah it wasn't it's it's that's I mean that is the nature of the beast and it's it is surprising how many people don't recognize that over and over and over again but that's where you kind of have to jinx monsoon it and like water off a duck's back it's like you know what I have to focus on my process because I'm I know I'm gonna get there and just
SPEAKER_00everyone else will see it at some point as well yeah yeah Yeah I mean also just like the stamina takes to do you know multiple shows a week and then as you said like you're making changes so you have a foot in both sides of the door like it's it's it's hard but it's physically hard it's mentally hard it's emotionally hard so believe me I understand I sympathize envy a little bit because I love attention myself but I don't envy you completely it's it's definitely a difficult time so now that the run is over can you give us a little insight into
SPEAKER_03where blood love is heading next
SPEAKER_02The other thing, well, just as you say that, like, I think the other thing that is a little different about me, and I'm going to toot my horn a little bit, I guess, is that I really am like a writer-artist. Like, I don't even really consider myself like a performer-performer. Like, there is no world in which I am auditioning for other shows. I have no interest in doing that. That's why I didn't do it. I don't want to. So I am like... The intention actually makes me uncomfortable in a lot of ways. I like to do it. I love to perform. I want to create art and music, but the intention does make me a little bit uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_02That's another thing that I'm trying to get more comfortable with. Yeah, I don't love that aspect of it.
SPEAKER_03You're like Piper Perabo in Coyote Ugly. It's like I love the writing and I love performing my songs.
SPEAKER_00It's just the people out there that I need to go away. A little bit I mean I you know I appreciate the love and like the support but it just yeah I'm certainly not doing it for the attention it makes me a little uncomfortable I understand that I think I think that's absolutely understandable but moving forward yeah can you give us any insight onto where blood love is heading next I think we all pretty much unanimously agree that we think London is
SPEAKER_02going to be a good spot for us next mm-hmm It's going to take a minute for us to move it over there and we just we just wrapped on Sunday so I think we're all just taking a minute to reset but I'm already heading back in three weeks to go to the Tony's actually and I'm going to meet with my team when I'm out there and just kind of start start dreaming what the next iteration is going to look like I think it'll be it'll evolve we'll make some changes but I think where we're at right now is like a really good starting point like I think this production was incredible and we will refine it but I think we're not so far off
No um that's wonderful have you been able to perform or go to London in the past I haven't performed in London but I've been to London many times we were just there in December right before I came out to New York to just kind of start looking at theaters and meeting with some teams out there because thankfully a lot of our teams have offices in London because obviously there's so much theater that's going between London and New York so we already have some good good people out there That's awesome yeah congrats I mean I I love London I would go there every other
SPEAKER_00week if I Yeah. I've already done some outlining to just kind of like have some scaffolding when we
SPEAKER_02go into the writing room so we're gonna do it we're gonna do it a little differently this time we learned a lot and I think that our show wouldn't be what it is if we wouldn't have gone through that somewhat messy process but I think that this time it can be a little bit more organized in our approach but um yeah it's it's an ensemble piece but I do have a I'm writing a part for myself in it because I do I like to be in it I think it helps me like write from a perspective that feel real but yeah it's it's gonna it's this one's gonna be more musical theater and more fun it's not gonna be quite as our show has some heaviness to it but yeah this one's gonna be more fun I'm down I'm excited to hear about it
yeah so where can people find you if you want them to find you on online or learn
SPEAKER_03more about your material
SPEAKER_02Yeah well you can go to our website just bloodlove.com there will be some information on there even though now we're not selling tickets or anything and then my Instagram is Carrie Renee Musics and my name is spelled weird so Carrie is C-A-R-E-Y Renee We'll make sure to spell it correctly on here so people can see you appropriately Well thank you so much Carrie as many of our listeners know we close out with a nice Broadway diva as we you know wrap up the episodes who would you
SPEAKER_00like to close out today's episode? Well my favorite Broadway diva has become a dear friend of mine and she is amazing as Elphaba right now and she's the one person that you know let me step out of the part entirely so I could be on the writer's side so Carrie Renee Fuller is just
SPEAKER_02incredible she's a force and I love her dearly so
SPEAKER_03All right, well, let's close out with some Carrie then. Yeah, amazing. We will see you guys next week. I believe that this will be the episode before our final predictions for the Tony Awards. So we'll see you guys next week for that episode. And thank you, Carrie. And take it away, Carrie. Bye!
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...