Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Broadway Breakdown

Broadway Breakdown artwork

BONUS: Matt on Behind the Awards

Aug 30, 20261 hr 9 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

While you’re waiting for Broadway Breakdown to come back in full, enjoy this crossover bonus episode of Matt on the podcast Behind the Awards. Once again talking all things Fall Broadway!!! This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_03My name is TR Knight and you're listening to Behind the Awards. [music]

SPEAKER_01Hello and welcome to Behind the Awards. I'm Isla. I'm here with Bruce. Back from vacation.

SPEAKER_02Back from vacation. Absolutely. Spent a little time away on the open waters on a cruise, which was Just fantastic.

SPEAKER_01It's really quite the

SPEAKER_02way to travel.

SPEAKER_01I know. And you don't even realize you're traveling, right? You said sailing, you don't even know.

SPEAKER_02I know. You're on a moving city, basically.

SPEAKER_01I know. It's so much fun. It is.

SPEAKER_02It's great. Speaking of fun, though.

SPEAKER_01But now, yes, now it's back to business. Back to business. Our business is fun.

SPEAKER_02So we would say if we had to classify our favorite quote-unquote season, it'd be Tony season, right? Yes. Is there another?

SPEAKER_01Easily.

SPEAKER_02But we are on the precipice of what gets us to Tony season, which is the kickoff of the Broadway season, the fall season. Right.

SPEAKER_01I mean, technically, it's already started, right? Anything after the cutoff date. But there haven't been any new Broadway shows. There was celebrity autobiography, but I'm not sure that that qualifies in the same way that other shows do.

SPEAKER_02I don't know how the committees at large and all of that will clarify.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_02But our first true show of the season is Paranormal Activity.

SPEAKER_01I am going on Thursday. I'm so excited.

SPEAKER_02Yes, and I am going on Saturday. I can't wait to see what kind of effects, what kind of tech... Because I would imagine, based on what I know, that they're going to have to lean very heavily into that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I hear it's really scary. So I'm looking forward to it.

SPEAKER_02Well, so with the start of the fall season and all the things anticipated, we felt it wasn't too soon to have those type of conversations of what we're looking forward to seeing the most. Yeah. Or, you know, just what is maybe the most intriguing. So we invited a friend to come along for the ride with us. And for the next hour, we'll have both Isla, myself, and Matt Koplik on discussing our fall preview.

SPEAKER_01Well, we have such a special guest. I love his podcast, Broadway Breakdown. Let's welcome. I think he's wrong when he says the least famous host, but let's welcome Matt Koplik. Hello.

SPEAKER_03Hello.

SPEAKER_02Thank you for having me too.

SPEAKER_01Thanks

SPEAKER_02for joining us. We're combining forces to try to, you know, see what we can unearth about the fall Broadway season.

SPEAKER_03For sure. Yeah. You need all the minds you can get for this.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Well, congratulations on the success of your show. Thank you. Likewise. Yes. Thank you. I'm a listener. And so now you're on your own. You are no longer with the Broadway Podcast Network, which is fine, right? Yes.

SPEAKER_03I would say every like two months I get inquiries from listeners of like, what's the drama? What's the tea? And the truth, it's so boring. It results to me that I did want to just, I wanted to take a, basically I took a sabbatical for a year. I was like, I want to try it out on my own and see what I can do. And they were very supportive. They were like, we don't want you to go. So like, what can we do? And I was like, just give me, I said, give me a year. And if it's a, and if it's a mistake, you get to say, I told you so. And we'll all let bygones be bygones, but it's been going well. So everything's good.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Excellent. Well, we're happy for you. And you had Alan Seals as a guest from our network.

SPEAKER_03I did. I did. That was that was a very good episode. And yeah, Alan's awesome. He and I hang out all the time. We see shows together. So it's yeah, it's all it remains one big old family.

SPEAKER_01Yes. So so for those who are worried, no need to worry.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I'm so sorry to tell you that there's simply no drama there. There's drama in other places, but not with Broadway Breakdown.

SPEAKER_01Well, there's drama with this upcoming season already. So let's jump into it. So I used to love the fall preview TV guide issue. Do you remember that? So and you would go through all the shows and that no longer exists because pretty much TV doesn't really exist in the way we knew it.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I figured we would do it for the Broadway season for the fall.

SPEAKER_03So perfect.

SPEAKER_01Now, I'm very interested because I know that you have seen some of the shows already in London and

SPEAKER_03I saw a big one that's coming from London. I did not see Rosamund Pike's show, Inter Alia, but I'm very much looking forward to it. I heard very good things about it.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I am somewhat looking forward to it, but nothing against her. It's just I have trouble with a one-person show. I tend to want more people to get a little bored.

SPEAKER_03I thought it was a one person show, but then I went on the Wikipedia page and there were two other actors listed. So I don't know if that's like prerecorded stuff or if they actually are a part of the show at any point. I agree with you. I always have trouble with one person shows when they work. They work beautifully.

SPEAKER_01Yes.

SPEAKER_03And when they don't work, you're like, how many lights are on the ceiling?

SPEAKER_01Yeah. The best way to do it is Every Brilliant Thing where it's sort of like a trick where it's not really a one person show.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And you're a part of it. It's interactive. Yeah. Yeah. I think the best one person shows I've seen have been like Jefferson Maze and I Am My Own Wife where it's just, you know, I know.

SPEAKER_01Miss the fabulous Jean Smart because, again, I just felt like I couldn't sit through a one person.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, you did good on that one. Oh, good. Listen, we love Jean Smart in this house. I think every house loves her. But Call Me Izzy was not a triumph in that respect for her.

SPEAKER_01If it was a two hour show about Charlene, forget it. I'd be there in a second.

SPEAKER_02Well, that's a whole different world. Yes.

SPEAKER_01All right. So the show that you saw, was it Paddington?

SPEAKER_03It sure was.

SPEAKER_01Oh, my gosh. So tell. How is it?

SPEAKER_03Well, so I guess I should start with I don't know how you two feel about Paddington just like as a as an individual. But I fell back in love with Paddington when the movies came out. I enjoyed him as a kid. But, you know, this is America. We tend to like. Corduroy more than we like Paddington. Sure. Yeah, Paddington was like more kind of niche in America as a kid. But I always liked him because I'm a bit of an Anglophile. And then when the movies came out, I was like, Oh my God, I forgot like how just delightful he is. And so I've just been obsessed with that IP for like 13 years now at this point.

SPEAKER_03So the musical I went in with like two brains, two minds. One was like, this is going to be like And so for the first five minutes, I couldn't relax because I was like, I got to remember it all. And when I realized that it's basically the first movies, I was like, oh, OK, so I don't I know where the plot's going to go. I can relax a little bit. Long story short, it is extraordinarily delightful. It's quite a spectacle without being overwhelming. And there's a lot of charm and a lot of finesse to it.

SPEAKER_03The score is full of bops. I think my only It's a little windy, but nothing that I don't think like five minutes of shaving off from both acts couldn't fix because there's nothing fundamentally wrong with the show. It's just like you watch and you go, this scene could have ended 20 seconds ago. And you feel that way about 10 or 12 times. And when you just like shave off 20 seconds from every other scene, magically the show is eight minutes shorter and it's like super tight. And as I understand it, they are looking into that for Broadway.

SPEAKER_03So that fills me with a lot of hope. But yeah, I mean, I think it's going to do really well here. It's a genuine family show in the grand tradition of Disney Renaissance movies where kids will like it. It's beautiful to look at. It's so sweet. Adults will like it because it's actually quite clever and it's it doesn't dumb down to the kids. So I just I think it's going to do really well here. I'm very excited to see how New York accepts it.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I think it's

SPEAKER_02always funny when you look at like something coming over from London, like, you know, Mincemeat did great. Six has done great. But then there are shows that either way go there or come here and they just the audiences are just completely different and it doesn't work.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's interesting. There are shows that have done so well in London that I know will never come here just because it's such a different mentality. And I'm actually kind of, speaking of the fall, I'm a little... Wary of how Benjamin Button is going to be received here at the public because I did enjoy it. It is incredibly saccharine and it takes a minute for you to warm up to it, especially like an American audience. And so I'll be interested to see how New York accepts that show

SPEAKER_03because it's like it is so earnest to the degree where you're like, OK, can we like cut the sugar with a little bit of salt? Yeah. And I think. Something like Paddington, it's very British just in terms of the local references. They'll make jokes about a neighborhood or the tube or things like that, which just needs to be tweaked because they'll make a joke about Marleybone and... Everyone in New York will be like, what's Marleybone?

SPEAKER_01I'm like, it's a neighborhood. Yeah, I don't know.

SPEAKER_03It's a neighborhood. But so that's the thing is they'll be like, well, in Marleybone with the substance and everyone's like, oh, yes, everyone knows that about that area, which is that

SPEAKER_02you can easily be like, well, in Astoria.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. And I think it's just one of those things where it's like, OK, do we cut the joke altogether or do we tweak it so we give more context to the audience, which is interesting. Right. Right. Right. Pattington's intelligently trying to get ahead of that. And then sometimes just like certain humor just lands better there than it does here.

SPEAKER_03So, oh, yeah. But I think overall, it's not an incredibly British show. I actually think Mincemeat is more like, quote unquote, British than Pattington is.

SPEAKER_01I don't know what they thought Tammy Faye was in England. Had they ever seen her?

SPEAKER_03Yeah, it kind of feels like they read about her in a newspaper clipping and then did their own version of it.

SPEAKER_01They got it so wrong.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And I don't know what that show was. I genuinely don't.

SPEAKER_01I mean, the actress was fine, but she wasn't Tammy Faye.

SPEAKER_03No, she didn't. She that was the thing is like she put her all into it. I was like, yeah, you're doing this monumental achievement. The one thing you're not doing is Tammy Faye. Although to be fair, I kind of feel the same way about Jonathan Groff and Justin Time where I'm like, you're doing everything except being Bobby Darin. But I think because Justin Time is more successful as a show, it's yeah. And Groff is just so charming. Like we let it go. Yes.

SPEAKER_01Right. And then they also gave a workaround because they said This is Jonathan Groff as Bobby Darin. This is his version.

SPEAKER_03You and I both know they added that because they're like, he can't do the impression. So like Paddington being like, we're going to cut the Marley Bone joke. Like, let's get ahead of this and say, right. Open with him as Groff. Because like, I guarantee you in all the workshops that that was not there before. And they're like, could you try the voice? And he can't do it. So they just added that. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. But also for people, at least of my generation and younger, we don't really know Bobby Darin. We know Tammy Faye.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Bobby Darin is like is I hate this is gonna sound so mean. I don't mean it this way, but I think of him as off brand Sinatra of just.

SPEAKER_02Sure.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Deep voice croonery. But yeah. Yeah. Tammy Faye is a little more recent and there's more public footage about her than there is about Bobby Darin. Like a lot of Bobby Darin's movies are lost to time. You kind of just have to go by his records. Yeah. So yeah, I get that. I get that for sure.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I mean, and we would have loved the camp, but they didn't give us any.

SPEAKER_03They didn't give us any camp. There was like two moments of camp the entire show. The rest of it was just boring.

SPEAKER_01I know.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Anyway. Anyway.

SPEAKER_02She's not this season. So speaking of camp and icons and people we know, what are

SPEAKER_03our thoughts on Dolly? From the word I had of Out of Town, my hope is that they spent this last year massively overhauling it because... Even in Dollywood, everyone was primed to love it. They sold out, but the reviews were basically like, yeah, work on it, which for Dollywood is code for this is a massive train wreck. The reason why I'm not optimistic is that Dolly, God bless her, is not in the prime of her songwriting life now.

SPEAKER_03And she has written some new songs for this. The book writer is the woman who wrote the screenplay for Christmas on the Square, which, granted, is my holiday heroine every year, but not because it's quality, because it is the camp that Tammy Faye didn't give us.

SPEAKER_01And also, she doesn't know how to write a Broadway show. Come on.

SPEAKER_03This is the woman who wrote one of my favorite line pieces of dialogue ever, which is the pastor and his wife sharing some eggnog together. And he says to the best Christmas gift we could ever give each other. Getting fertility treatments is better than anything that comes in paper.

SPEAKER_01And I'm like, I mean, this woman's writing

SPEAKER_03a Broadway show.

SPEAKER_01But the problem is that I don't know. I mean, she's good friends with Dolly. So I don't know that Dolly will know enough. Well, not know enough, but. Be business savvy enough to get someone else. But they do have someone helping her, but I don't know that they're going to take all the advice given.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. You don't know what's going on behind the scenes if this is basically a ghostwriter, if this is a dramaturg who can only give feedback. Bard's share as the director is a little odd, especially for a show this troubled out of town because he's not really... He's not a forceful chief on his shows. He's pretty soft when it comes to his collaborators. He's a little more of a taskmaster with actors, but with writers and with production, he's a little more like, yeah, let's see how it all goes.

SPEAKER_03And sometimes that's worked with something like Piazza that worked beautifully. And then for something like Women on the Verge, it really couldn't come together. And the fact that Dolly's coming into town from a troubled place doesn't give me a lot of hope. If they figured it out, I will be thrilled. We don't want bad shows to come in. We want all of these shows to be bangers.

SPEAKER_01Especially Dolly. Who doesn't love Dolly? That's the thing.

SPEAKER_03You want this to be... There's really no equivalent because there's not really a bio jukebox musical that I think is amazing. You could say her beautiful, but I want it to be even more interesting than beautiful. I want it to be halfway between beautiful and Jersey Boys. Have that. That story of her life like Carol's might give it some theatricality and some edge like Jersey Boys because she's lived a very amazing life and has had a lot of has overcome so much.

SPEAKER_03And you don't want it to be this glorified portrait of her. She's already such a good person. Like show us the bruises, show us her mistakes. That's what makes it interesting theater. And I'm not convinced that's what they're going to do.

SPEAKER_01I don't think they will do it.

SPEAKER_02I mean, because everybody roots for Dolly, right? I mean, she put a post up and everyone's like, you know, going around like, you know, ants at a picnic. But the issue is, is that unless you're going to give it something, the story needs to be interesting, right? And that was one of the issues. I loved A Beautiful Noise for what it is because I'm a huge Neil Diamond fan, but... Where was the adversity? Where am I rooting for you? Other than the fact that I like your music and I think you're a great songwriter

SPEAKER_02or whatever the case is, there needs to be some adversity. Like Tina overcame Ike and that helped that musical help sustain a little bit more.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think my issue with most of these jukebox musicals, the bio jukebox musicals, I should say, and Beautiful Noise, I will give credit that they came up with what I thought was a really interesting narrative device with the thing. I wished that they explored it more deeply because it's sort of like it starts strong and then it ends really lovingly. It's sort of in the middle. It becomes pretty standard. And pretty much every bio jukebox musical post Jersey Boys, like beautiful onwards, kind of has two adversities no matter what.

SPEAKER_03If it's a man, it's that the success gets the better of him and he becomes a distant father. And then he learns to be a better father once it's been too late, because usually there's some tragedy, like a kid dies or his wife divorces him and they all leave him. And when it's a woman, it's that she's with a bad man, but then she gets rid of the bad man. So that's Tina. That's beautiful. That's the Donna Summer musical. That's the Cher show. It's sort of like clockwork. And I mean, listen, Dolly has a husband she's been with for decades. So already there's a new challenge there. But yeah, we'll just we'll see.

SPEAKER_03We'll see.

SPEAKER_01It could be the story of the tattoos we never see.

SPEAKER_03That's true. That is true. That is true. I mean, I just want I want a whole section about nine to five and not necessarily the making of it, but how she was treated in the press at before that movie came out. And then once the movie came out, how. I'm nervous that it's going to become diva worship and not actually the nuanced perspective that made her such a beloved icon, you know?

SPEAKER_01You know, I also think part of the problem with Bart's share is that he excels when it's a class vehicle. And nobody wants this to be that. Dolly leans into the campiness of herself and, you know, the drag that she puts on.

SPEAKER_03She says it costs a lot of money to look this cheap and intentionally so. Yeah, like this is a musical that should have been a Tommy Tune vehicle like 35 years ago. I mean, yeah, yeah, yeah. He's who I want.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And then none of the actresses that are cast as Dolly remind me anything of Dolly, too. That's another thing. But I haven't seen them yet.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. My hope is that they capture her essence, if not necessarily her physical spirit. But

SPEAKER_01we'll see.

SPEAKER_03We'll see. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01We'll see. Right. All right, Bruce, what else is coming?

SPEAKER_02Well, I'm going to get into what may not be coming. Can we do that?

SPEAKER_01Yes, definitely. That's a big one.

SPEAKER_02Dream Girls feels like. There was all of this huge announcement. Here it comes. And all of that seems to have fallen by the wayside. I mean, producers leaving and casting issues. I'm not convinced that we're going to get it.

SPEAKER_01We think it's not coming. What do you think? What have you heard?

SPEAKER_03What I had heard was that they had officially but not actually announced that they were pushing a year. Part of the reason for that in their minds was they were looking at the landscape of revivals this season and looking at the fall. You can't really tell, but when you start to look at the spring, it gets very packed. And it was very important to them that this be an event revival. And that already having Evita in the spring, plus Sound of Music and Full Monty,

SPEAKER_03there are rumors coming up once again that Next to Normal is happening. And so that's just a lot of heavy hitters. And this is going to be an expensive commercial revival. And if they have any chance of recouping or anything like that, they need Tony Buzz and all that stuff. I think they want to move it another year in hopes that next year will be a lighter revival season. No, that's best laid plans, you know, and all that. But also, yeah, like this happens a lot with Dreamgirls, right? We get these announcements that it's coming. We had that national tour in 09 that was going to come to Broadway when it was over.

SPEAKER_03That didn't happen. The London production, you know, was getting workshopped over and over and over again to come here. That didn't happen. Dreamgirls is one of those musicals for me, similar to Evita, where Dreamgirls is a better version of Evita, but they're musicals that I think are great, but not necessarily good, if you know what I mean. They have this greatness about them. It's these scores that just get into your throat. Dreamgirls has this energy that's electric. Again, I would argue, I think the first act of Dreamgirls is so strong.

SPEAKER_03But it writes all of these checks that it can't quite cash in the second act because it's too many things that they have to wrap up and they don't really get a chance to. The second act still has a lot of greatness about it, but it's not necessarily a good second act. And what made it work the first time was, you know, a collection of talent that Broadway hadn't really seen at the forefront. So that was exciting. It was a sound that Broadway hadn't really heard done yet with this like fusion of Broadway and 60s and 70s. And modern 80s and and a technical wizardry that they hadn't seen.

SPEAKER_03And Michael Bennett, this once in a lifetime kind of not just talent, but musical theater mind. He is one of the few musical theater directors I can think of who just had this innate sense of knowing what an audience wanted and and. I think she's a wonderful talent. I have yet to see

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Okay, I'll give you $100,000 now. So it's things like that.

SPEAKER_03And it's such a massive show. I think that you actually kind of need two directors on it. Like you need someone who can give you some of the historical lived in context, but also then somebody who knows what it needs as a musical. You know, we're also I'm wondering if we're too far away from the 60s now that so much of the musical references will excite audiences the way that they did in 1981.

SPEAKER_01Like, it's true.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And also, you know, part of the magic of Dreamgirls was that Tony moment with Jennifer Holiday.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. That star is born moment of a song that most people hadn't heard yet. Like that's whenever I. I went to see Wicked a few years ago for the first time since I saw like the original company and people asked like, oh, was it just as good? I said, no, because in 2003, 1900 people had never heard Defying Gravity before. And like, you can't write that. And the same thing with that I am telling you now it's the song. At the time, it was a song no one had heard. But like. I don't know if you guys are bootleg queens the way that I am, but I really enjoy listening to audio from performances of that era.

SPEAKER_03And I have audio of the opening night of Dreamgirls. Then there's a bootleg of the show like towards right after it opens. And there are just certain moments that the audience bursts into applause, not just because of the excitement of the show, but because there are references to things that they get. So like the Apollo sequence, When one of the acts comes on and starts doing me and my baby going downtown, the choreography they're doing is so Motown, like, realistic. The audience is just like, because it's only 14, 15 years earlier.

SPEAKER_03They're like, oh, like, yes, yes, yes. That's a great point. Thank you.

SPEAKER_01At the time, too, there was also the Diana Ross factor, whereas how is she going to react to this? Yeah, there was that it was dangerous then. It's not dangerous now.

SPEAKER_03No, it's it's it's more of establishment now. And there's also like there's middling. I think the movie kind of did more harm than good for that show because it did bring it to a larger audience, but the movie is not the show in a lot of ways. And I think people's expectations of what the show should be now have changed because of the movie, which I think is unfortunate. People want Beyonce for Dina. I'm like, that's not what that role is. Beyonce physically is a Dina, but her voice is simply too powerful for that role.

SPEAKER_03Shirley Ralph did an interview where she talked about this with like, You need to have a lack of ego to sing Dina because it's not that you're a bad singer. It's just it has to be so diametrically opposed to Effie. And that's where the tension musically lies. So if you're belting Dreamgirls, if you're belting One Night Only, it ruins it. The whole point is that Effie belts One Night Only and then your smooth tone for white audiences One Night Only. But directors won't do that. Casting directors won't do that now. They want everyone to rip the house down. I'm like, but that's not...

SPEAKER_03The root of the show. There is riffing in there. There is vocal dynamics in there. But you also do need some restraint. And I just want like everyone kind of has a different point of view of what the show needs to be now. And which is kind of why the train can't ever leave the station. But which track do we take?

SPEAKER_02And then I heard that somebody I heard that, you know, they were having trouble casting an Effie that was willing to do eight shows a week. And Which I think you find any, I don't know, college senior that's like trying to get a showcase somewhere. Tell her she's doing the Dream Girls revival as Effie White. Yeah, they'll do it. And she's, what time should I be there? Yeah. So maybe you're trying to get a name because I know like Amber Riley's going on record to say, I won't do Broadway unless it's less than eight shows a week.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So, you know, it's that juxtaposition too. Like find that. Diamond in the Rough that nobody knows.

SPEAKER_01Like Jennifer Holliday was at the

SPEAKER_03time. She was, I think, 21 at the time. But I will also say, that score can... Totally wreck your voice if you don't have some kind of technique. For sure. I think you're shooting yourself in the foot.

SPEAKER_03Jennifer Holliday famously skipped shows all the time because she's like, if you want me to sing this the way you want me to sing this, I will be calling out constantly. And she did. I think, you know, I mean, Rachel Zegler is, I think, doing seven out of eight. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03There's a way around that, you know, like do like the once Leah joined Funny Girl and Julie Banco became sort of like the prime alternate star. Exactly. Like, I think they they lucked into it because the producers of Funny Girl just kind of messed up left and right for so long before it all sort Like a Donna Murphy. I mean, that's.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely.

SPEAKER_01Right. And to keep your performers healthier and they can stay in the show longer.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. Yeah. Like, don't put the pressure on them of like, oh, no, you have to go on because if your understudy goes on, we lose 30 percent of the audience. It's like, no, no. Take tonight off so you can come back tomorrow. Great. And do the rest of the week.

SPEAKER_01And tell people ahead of time so people aren't disappointed.

SPEAKER_03One thousand percent. Louder for the people and the back. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's the thing. I remember going to Merrily and being so disappointed that Lindsay Mendez wasn't there and being kind of mad at her for a long time because she was out so much.

SPEAKER_03And so I think what made me mad, not even just for her, but the producers, was I went, I saw it twice. Once was a Tony performance, like for Tony voters. And we were notified 72 hours before that she was actually going to be out. Yeah. And said, like, do you want to reschedule your tickets? And my voter friend said no, because he actually already seen the show with her. We were going for my benefit. But I was like, oh, so there's I guess to her credit, she's telling them like she's giving them notice. The producers are like fully not saying anything there.

SPEAKER_03And which I think is absurd because she did call out a lot on that show. Now, the good news is that I had seen her understudy, who was fantastic, but. It's similar to like anytime Leah would call out in Funny Girls sort of, you know, whenever and they wouldn't tell the audience right before. Audiences then get mad and performers have to work twice as hard to win them over. Yeah. Sometimes it works out really well. It did work out for Lindsay's understudy at Merrily. And I went back a second time to see Lindsay in the show. The other one, speaking of Donna Murphy, this isn't this wasn't their fault because this was

SPEAKER_03a fully announced like Donna was doing the Tuesdays at this point. But half of the audience was there to see Donna and half the audience was mad because they couldn't afford to get in to see that. So they're like, this is the forms we could get. So half the audience was like this. But the beauty of that was that the entire cast then worked harder. And so by the end of the show, the audience jumped to their feet the same way they did with that. But in my opinion, it actually was more earned. So I enjoyed it. All right.

SPEAKER_01So two things to that. One, how do you not love Donna Murphy? So it doesn't even matter.

SPEAKER_03You know, I can understand why she she sometimes will pick shows that are not for everyone. I understand that my my grandmother hated passion with a passion. So it took her like 10 years to warm up to Tana Murphy.

SPEAKER_01But two, it's a great point because. That is a way to make shows more affordable to people. So I think that that's just a great option to have. That's another really good thing that they can do because people, that's a huge conversation. Is Broadway too expensive, you know?

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So, and for many people it is. Yes. But, you know, for me, it's not anything against the understudies, because if you're an understudy on Broadway, you're amazing. But the thing is, I like to see the Tony performances. I like to see who's going to get nominated so I can have that conversation. Yeah. So that's the point. So that's why I was so irritated when Lindsay Mendes wasn't there.

SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, that's what we all do. Right. You, me, Bruce have like we have to talk about those who are eligible and getting nominated. So if we see the show and they're out and then we get to Tony conversations, it's like, well, I like what do you think? Well, I can't speak on Lindsay. Right. Like if Leslie has a chance. So, yeah, it's that. And I get more frustrated if it's a show I don't like and the eligible person is out because I'm like, I'm going to have to. Goddamn, see this again now at the show that I didn't like very much that I didn't want to go see to begin with. Exactly.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. It's like this is already a homework and now it's like double homework. Like this is algebra and I don't want to be.

SPEAKER_01Right. And, you know, we don't always get comp for these shows, you know.

SPEAKER_03That's what I tell my listeners all the time. I've been very fortunate to get, you know, press seats for a lot of stuff now. But that's also a new development. I wasn't doing that for a long time. I had to build a reputation with the podcast for a long time and buy tickets and ask friends with press seats to let me come along and all these things. But even with The press seats I get now, like, yeah, you're right. It isn't everything. Right. And I'm not, I actually, fun fact, I got accepted as a Drama Desk voter this summer.

SPEAKER_01Oh, congratulations.

SPEAKER_03Thank you. The downside of that means I actually now officially have to see like three times the amount of shows that I was already seeing because they're like, you have to see a minimum 35 off Broadway. I was like, okay. Yeah. With that, the drama desk don't necessarily have seats always lined up for you. Sometimes they do, which is nice. But often, like, you have to reach out on your own to the press teams and say, like, I am a drama desk voter. Like, I need to try to see you. And sometimes they're like, yeah, absolutely, we can accommodate you. And other ones are like, we're so sorry. Like, we literally have been told to just keep it to, like,

SPEAKER_03The Times, The Post, Hollywood Reporter, and, you know, the official, like, Tony nominators. Or if it's off-Broadway, like, the drama desk nominators, and that's it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_03And yeah, so it's you do what you do.

SPEAKER_00Hi, I'm Jasmine Amy Rogers. You are listening to Behind the Awards. We'll be right back.

SPEAKER_01All right. So one show that I'm really, really looking forward to is Other Desert Cities. Julie Louis-Dreyfus, Ed Harris, Lily Rabe.

SPEAKER_02It's got a great cast.

SPEAKER_01It really does. It's going to get the Stranger Things people in. What do you think, Matt? Are you looking forward to this show?

SPEAKER_03I'm looking forward to this cast.

SPEAKER_01Okay. I have not seen this show ever before.

SPEAKER_03Okay, Bruce, have you ever

SPEAKER_01seen it?

SPEAKER_03I have not. Okay. I saw it originally on Broadway. And I think that was a thing about expectations was it was such a such a thing off Broadway. And so I saw it right before it opened on Broadway because it was it just had this heat on it. And it was amazing acting. And it was it was it was Judith Light and soccer chanting like fantastic performances. Yeah, I remember thinking that the play was fine. And I actually was surprised when this was announced. I made a post of my story of like,

SPEAKER_03I love this cast and I'm not sure if I think that like this is the play that is exciting to me. And I had a few people be like, oh my God, it's in my top five of all time. I was like, you kept that quiet for 10 years. No one really talks about this play much anymore. So it's a solid play. It's a solid living room family drama. You'll be able to see the twists coming like It's kind of a mile away. But yeah, I think it's a good cast.

SPEAKER_03I love everyone who's in it. And I think they're actually all appropriate for their roles, which is not always the case. But yeah, I'm excited. I'm really excited to see, if I do get in to see it, I'm really excited to see Julia on stage because I think she's going to crush.

SPEAKER_01She can do anything. But yeah, this is her Broadway debut, isn't it? Yeah, I thought so. Yeah. So it'll be interesting.

SPEAKER_03I love that woman so much. I mean, I just finished a Veep rewatch. I was like, God damn, she's amazing.

SPEAKER_01I still have not seen Veep yet.

SPEAKER_03I keep telling Isla she's got to watch it.

SPEAKER_01I know, I know.

SPEAKER_03So good. It's so good. When it first came out, it was towards the end of the Obama administration. I remember I stopped watching it at the time because I just went, they're all so incompetent. Why hasn't she fired all of them? This is so unrealistic. And then ironically, when Trump got elected, that's when I started watching it back again. I was like, oh, yeah, no, this is great. All right.

SPEAKER_01So is Avita going to get the same reaction here that it's getting in London?

SPEAKER_03I'm not sure. I mostly think yes. Maybe not quite. Not quite that response because. Andrew Lloyd Webber just, he hits harder there than he does here. He's, he's, audiences do like him here, but he's a bit more of a national treasure over there. And especially his big ones are like really big there. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03She's in the thick of the conversation now. Yeah, I think it'll do well. It's a full calendar year that they plan to run. So there's less scarcity of seats that way. And I'm also interested to see what they end up doing for the balcony sequence. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So I think I don't know if it'll do as well, but also that metric we're talking about was just such an enormous level of success in London that most shows don't get in general. So even if they get like two thirds of that success, they're in the black.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I also feel like here people are just more jaded. Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_02I also wonder if the disaster maybe, I don't know, of the last revival of Arbita, does that make people hungrier for a new one or does it make them go in with like their arms folded and like, what am I doing?

SPEAKER_03You know, I think the only people that are going to have that grudge about the last Evita are Gaiman. I think I think that most people have forgotten that revival happened because I think disaster is a harsh term just because that implies that it's memorable. It wasn't it was it was just like I'm assuming you saw Bruce then. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I did not see it, but I've heard. I've seen clips and I've done, you know, I've done my deep part.

SPEAKER_03It was so, so dull. It is the thing. It was, the tempos were deadly. It looked beautiful. The lighting was stunning. It was a gorgeous set. It was over choreographed. Ricky Martin had no swagger. Elena Roger, just her, she technically could sing it. She hit all the notes. It's not the voice you want for that role. When you're walking away with Michael Service's Perrone being like the performance that you're doing something wrong. And I think that I think anyone who was upset by that revival might be excited

SPEAKER_03about this revival if only because Rachel's performance has become such a positive talking point that even if there are those who maybe don't love what Jamie Lloyd does with the production, they'll love Rachel. And ultimately, you know, gay men around the world, they just want a new diva to worship. And Evita does that for them. And Rachel and Evita is allegedly giving that kind of a performance.

SPEAKER_01And she's so well cast in it too.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I've watched some clips and she sings that role in a way where it doesn't have quite the danger that Patti LuPone had. And normally I would be a little, not miffed, but like I've always kind of said I love that role when it's sung by someone where like you think that they don't have the E, but then the E comes out and it's amazing. And Rachel, you're like, she's got it. But even with that comfort, I still am very pleased with her vocal performance. So that's saying something for me.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, the clips I've seen of her are really fantastic.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. But we have a revival coming in the fall of this season, a musical revival.

SPEAKER_01Which one are you talking about?

SPEAKER_03The Gay Fantastics. Oh, that's true.

SPEAKER_01Yes. All right. I don't love the Fantastics. I don't think many people love the Fantastics, but I'm excited to see how this is.

SPEAKER_03Why don't you love the Fantastics? I just get bored. You have a problem with whimsy, Isla? I don't.

SPEAKER_01I was in the Fantastics, so I liked doing it much more than watching it.

SPEAKER_03It's such a delightful show. It does kind of wear out its welcome under the best of circumstances in like an 80 seat theater with a ladder and a black box. So I'm interested to see how it fares in the haze, which like is the smallest theater on Broadway, but might as well be the Gershwin for that show.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Yeah. But I think it's in really good hands with Chris Catelli.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, Chris Catelli definitely has a good sense of musical theater about him, and he's an inventive choreographer. I think I'm always a little wary of queer takes on older shows, not because I don't accept them. I'm literally working on one right now, but I'm always like, Is this one that actually works or is this something you just wanted to try? And allegedly they've done a production of it already and they said it works. So I'm hopeful. But yeah, I mean, I love that score.

SPEAKER_03I think that score is just so delightful. But yeah, I'm intrigued. We'll put it that way. I'm intrigued.

SPEAKER_01And is it mothers instead of fathers?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Which I think that works. If only a I'm like, OK, we're not going to take away the only female role like we got to change some of the genders here. But also, I think if we're doing two gay boys like, yeah, we need to Olivia Colman's on stage because gay boys and their mothers, that's a whole.

SPEAKER_01Right. Well, that could make it a lot more interesting. I agree. Girls and their fathers. I think that's, you know, we've seen that a zillion times.

SPEAKER_03One thousand percent. Yeah, for sure.

SPEAKER_01So do we know who's in it yet? Has there been any rumors? They have not announced.

SPEAKER_03As far as I know, nobody was precast in it. They're in the middle of casting. We should probably find out at some point next month, I would say, because they start performances in October. So I would imagine that they're going to announce soon.

SPEAKER_01And are they going to say rape or are they changing it to abduction? I think

SPEAKER_03it's abduction. I think they changed that to abduction a while ago.

SPEAKER_01Like just across the board.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, across the board. Like, I think like 20-ish years ago, they changed it to abduction. Yeah. People were all... I feel like people in the 90s were already looking at that and going,

SPEAKER_01um, why?

SPEAKER_03I know. And Tom Jones had to be like, well, in old colloquial terms, like, yeah, right, right. But now it's 1997. Change it.

SPEAKER_01Right. Nobody think about olden times.

SPEAKER_03Exactly.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that was a change for the better. Usually I like to stay true to the, you know, the spirit, but...

SPEAKER_03Same.

SPEAKER_01I think... We're now honoring the spirit of it by changing it in this

SPEAKER_03case. You're simply altering a word so that way the rest of the piece can stay what it is.

SPEAKER_01Otherwise, people are only going to talk about race.

SPEAKER_03Exactly, exactly. You don't want to distract from what the intention of the show is. And I mean, I talk about this all the time with like Golden Age revivals. People say like, oh, you don't want to change any bit. I go, if we did it completely as written, the ensemble numbers would be boring because ensemble numbers in The Golden Age, if it's Oklahoma or Carousel Lake, it's the song, then they do an encore, then they do a dance break, then they do one more encore. And now we're like, we can't do that. So yeah, they do the song into a dance break, into a final chorus button. I'm like, yeah, that's already changing the text a little bit,

SPEAKER_03but it's just adapting it to modern sensibilities.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And nobody wants to be there for three hours anymore.

SPEAKER_03No, no. People won't accept the three-hour Les Mis anymore. I was like, isn't that the point of Les Mis? Right.

SPEAKER_01You kind of go through the whole life of this character.

SPEAKER_03Isn't Lema supposed to cover like all three meals that day? It's like, I'm supposed to do breakfast, lunch and dinner. What are we doing here? Right. Like the inheritance. I got to make a sandwich and apple. Yeah. I got to make some French toast. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Come on. Well, okay. So speaking of revivals and long shows and what are our thoughts on Sound of Music? Jasmine Amy Rogers at the lead of it. I love that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. I love her.

SPEAKER_02She just, seeing her in Boop, which I didn't love. Same. I loved her. I didn't love Boop. Same. And now seeing her in Spelling Bee where she takes on this role of Olive in a way that is so different than anything you've seen her do and is just tugging on every heart emotion. I'm like, she could really do anything, like literally anything. I will show up and buy a ticket for it.

SPEAKER_03Did you see her do Wild Party at Encores? I saw clips. I did not. I couldn't find the time to get there. Sure. She was pretty astounding in that for a role that she's actually like a little too young for. And, you know, they only have, you know, two days and a prayer to get the shows up. What she what she did in so little time was pretty astounding to me. And. I mean, obviously she's got the talent to back it up, but she's been very smart and her team have been very smart of making sure whatever her next project is, is not a replica of the previous project.

SPEAKER_03People will put in their heads like, oh, Jasmine is adaptable. Jasmine can do anything. So that excites me. And she has the charm. She has the carefree spirit and energy for Maria. And she's got this amazing voice. So I am so on board with that casting. And I'm on board with Sound of Music at the Beaumont. I'm less thrilled by Lear being the director. Really? And she has pleased enough audience members in the past and critics in the past that maybe she'll be able to do that for them again.

SPEAKER_03Whether it pleases me is another story.

SPEAKER_01I'm not sure we're going to see anything new. No, no.

SPEAKER_03Have we ever seen anything new from her? No. It's also not going to be the hills are alive. It's going to be the backdrop is alive with the sound of projections. She doesn't know what to do with set with set design. Yeah. But I digress. And the Sound of Music, the stage musical, is not the property that I think people remember it to be. Similar with Dreamgirls in the movie, this is a case where the movie actually improved on the musical. Yeah. And there's like there's which is not to say the musical is bad.

SPEAKER_03There are certain elements of the musical that make it still very potent and relevant, but just certain story structure moments and song placements are just better in the movie. And so whether they try to include some of those changes to the stage show like they did in the 90s revival or if they're going to stay true to the original source material, I don't know. But yeah. I do think this is a show where you do need a director who can sort of put a foot in both. Like, okay, let's look at how the show is structured. Where can we improve it from the movie influences? Because also that's what audiences are going to want to see.

SPEAKER_03And how do we make this show still feel alive today? And that's not really something that Lear's great at. Lear's really good at finding scripts that she doesn't have to do much work on because they just sort of They're strong on their own.

SPEAKER_01Ragtime.

SPEAKER_03Ragtime into the woods of just sort of shows where like, okay, like we can let the material speak for itself. And she casts her shows very well. And the actors are really good at elevating it. But then other shows that need more work, like Oliver and Encores, like Once Upon a Mattress, which had a new book that I really kind of detested, or even Hercules at Paper Mill. She doesn't really know how to spin that into gold or semi-gold. And Sound of Music, solid as it is as a musical, you do actually need a bit of a hand to make that work.

SPEAKER_03Same thing with like Bart with Dolly of just sort of, I don't know if this is a show that's right for him. And then I don't think that this is a show that will be necessarily right for Lear. But yeah.

SPEAKER_01For me, if you're not going to bring anything fresh to it, then why do I want to go see it? The Sound of Music, you know, it's a dusty old musical that's wonderful, but, you know, we've seen it a million times before. So for this, I don't want a museum piece. So we'll see. We'll see what she's going to do.

SPEAKER_03The best revivals will always make you feel like that show was either written today or written recently. And there are multiple ways you can do that. You can do a Jamie Lloyd deconstruction like in Sunset Boulevard. You can do a total overhaul concept like Angelica Ball. Or you can do... A South Pacific or a Brian Stokes Mitchell Kiss Me Kate where it's like we're doing the show. We're just treating it with respect and giving it life and energy. So it's not necessarily a bold interpretation so much as like,

SPEAKER_03oh, it just feels fresh, you know?

SPEAKER_01Right. Right. That's what I would look for in this. Just a modern feel.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. Make it just make it like the hills and make it feel alive.

SPEAKER_01Exactly. Exactly. But she didn't cast Carrie Underwood, so that's good.

SPEAKER_03God, yeah. Thank God for that. Or Laura Osnes. My God. Casting Jasmine is the first sign for me. They're like, okay, maybe they're going to totally mess it up.

SPEAKER_01Right, right, right. And then who's going to be the captain, we'll see.

SPEAKER_03The rumor I was hearing was Patrick Wilson.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a yeah. So and that's perfect because he's the right age, but he also looks young enough to to be appropriate for her.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, they can't they can't be equals age wise. He has seven kids and and then she's and she's also like. Like new. She's a novice. She's she's not a fully formed nun yet. So she's got to be young. So you need you. There has to be an age difference, but you don't want it to be

SPEAKER_02like a lot like this paper thin line.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Right. And I hate to say this because we always want to say, you know, beauty comes from comes from within. But like if you have a Captain Von Trapp, who's Patrick Wilson, if the age difference isn't too much, the whole audience will be like, I get it. I get it.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_02I also heard a rumor about the Reverend Mother, which... Miss Headley?

SPEAKER_03Yes. We're hoping. If that's true, I will be thrilled and curious.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03It means we're not getting an old soprano-y Climb Every Mountain. We're getting the godfather of Nubia.

SPEAKER_01And that's the way to modernize it, to make it feel fresh.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I think I'm not opposed to a belted Climb Every Mountain. I'm... I'm curious as to if they're simply just like altering keys but keeping the sort of like classic tone of it or if like, no, no, no, we're adding a whole new flavor to it. I don't know. I love Heather so much and I want her back on Broadway as much as possible. She also will do what she wants. So, like, I'm curious as to what she would do with Mother Abbess.

SPEAKER_03I think that she, yeah, she's always a wild card. You never know.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, which makes them fun.

SPEAKER_02I also do love her, like, So, so much. And like, same, want her back on Broadway. And then I'm like, but do I want her back on Broadway in this?

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I don't know. I wanted her back on Broadway in Gypsy. That's what I wanted. Well, that I remember.

SPEAKER_02Well, so when I heard that she was going to be the vacation cover, I bought it like just the rumor of it. I bought a ticket because I was like, well, it's true. I'm not going to be able to get a ticket. So I'll buy one and then I'll worry about what to do with it later.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, exactly. Yeah.

SPEAKER_02Monteagle was outstanding and I went and saw her and she was wonderful. But, but there's, you know,

SPEAKER_03there's only one Heather Headley and, and it's, it's not a common and other people's talents just so much that like Heather came to Broadway. With Lion King and then like fully just annihilated with Aida. And then she left us. She left us for 16 years and and comes back and revitalizes the color purple, a revival that I already loved that she made it go from 0.5 to an 11. And I was and I was like, yes, yes.

SPEAKER_03And then she left us again. Stop it. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01She's toying with us.

SPEAKER_03She's my toxic boyfriend. I'm like, she's telling me she loves me and sending me flowers and then ghosting me for a week. I'm like, Heather, thanks for like a couple of months, please.

SPEAKER_01All right, so here's a show that I'm very curious about, Paranormal Activity. What is that going to be? Is it going to be another Greyhouse? I don't know. I didn't love Greyhouse.

SPEAKER_03I don't know anyone who loved Greyhouse. But Greyhouse also promised us And I'm so down for that.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01But I'm interested to see what they're going to do with it.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, I'm intrigued. It's also technically our first show of the Broadway season. So, yeah.

SPEAKER_01So here's the thing. Bruce and I, we would love to go see something now. There's nothing to see. Why can't they bring something big now or even not so big? I mean, I understand that it doesn't. You would

SPEAKER_03think that by now producers and landlords would have learned from past mistakes. And granted, there are some shows that do genuinely need to open in April because they won't be able to last the three months from opening to Tony nominations. Like, A show like say, I'm trying to think like Fun Home opening in April of 2015 was the correct choice because they needed the reviews, the nominations to help with the sales. Right. For every time people talk about you really need to open in March or April,

SPEAKER_03I'm like, okay, well, you know, Hairspray opened in August. Hamilton opened in July. Moulin Rouge opened in July. If you think you have the juice, you can open. And in fact, there's nothing else around. So all the press is going to be about you for like three months.

SPEAKER_01And all the ticket sales will be yours.

SPEAKER_03Exactly. If you're if you're the fresh show in town, like that's actually something that Paranormal Activity is smart about starting when they're starting. They've got a runway to just sort of be the only show for like a month and a half. So if it if it works at all, they get. So much attention for a while before anything else comes in. And I think that's also kind of smart for, I guess, Wanted. Wanted's coming around October, November. I think that starts before Galileo. So they'll have a lot of juice of being the only new musical at the moment, which will help them. But yeah, I don't know why Warriors is waiting so long to come in.

SPEAKER_03Warriors should be coming in in October. They are as confident about it as they say they are. They would have so much attention in the fall. And they'd be coming around Halloween, which is like a perfect time to open Warriors.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, they're going to get attention no matter what.

SPEAKER_03Sure.

SPEAKER_01But then it's

SPEAKER_03like the hairspray producers thing. Like, well, then open sooner. And then. Right. And then and then you don't have to worry about Paddington because you'll have had like six months of being like the Broadway big thing. And Paddington has to like catch up with you, you know, leading up to the Tonys. I'm telling you guys, every producer needs to hire me as a consultant because it's so obvious to me. And right. And yet we keep making these mistakes.

SPEAKER_01Right.

SPEAKER_02Because every time we have a Tony conversation, it's like, well, will you remember X show? You know, will will the voters remember this show? But if you're the Hairspray of the season.

SPEAKER_00The Liberation. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, and I think I think the being remembered really only is a problem if the show has closed. But even then, like as I said, Liberation still won play. Leslie Manville still won Actress for Eat It.

SPEAKER_01English did well in its year.

SPEAKER_03You can still at least get nominated if you if you were good. Winning is a little harder. But if you're up, I would say if you're a play, less so. Musicals may be a little harder, but also, you know, You're not opening in the summer or the fall in hopes and planning to close by January. Like you're hoping to run to the Tony. So if you close by January, chances are there something wasn't going well in your in your show. Like the show wasn't working. You didn't get the reviews you wanted. And but like if the show is good, if you do get the reviews,

SPEAKER_03I'm sorry, you can you can whip that up into something for sure.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Unless your opening is a limited reviews exclusively. Yeah. That, you know.

SPEAKER_03The Fantastics is going to have a hard time being remembered in the spring because that's a limited run from the fall to like January, February. But if it's amazing, they will get nominated. They won't win. Right.

SPEAKER_01Of course, people will remember.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. People remember the things they love.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, on the other hand, Queen of Versailles, no opening date would have helped that show.

SPEAKER_03No. Doesn't matter. Yeah. They just didn't do the work on that show, which is a shame because they

SPEAKER_01could have. They had the time.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. And I maintain I think the idea for that show is a good one. It's just they did not know what tone to take. Always maintain that Queen of Versailles was a good idea. And every like 45 minutes for like 90 seconds, you would see what they were trying to do. Like, yeah. But then it would go away again.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Just watch the documentary. Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Or not. Now that we've got 9000 seasons of Real Housewives, I don't even need to watch the documentary.

SPEAKER_01That's true, too. But see, that's the promise. Like that audience could have been so served with that show and they just weren't.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah. Did you did either of you see it with Sherry?

SPEAKER_01Yes, I did.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. It was better with Sherry. Really? Yeah. Sherry got a better idea of what that character needed to be and what the tone of the show needed to be. And so it's not like she magically fixed it, but more consistently throughout the night, you saw what the promise could have been.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Interesting. Right. The show didn't fail because of her. No.

SPEAKER_03And also, like, I think Chenoweth worked very hard and I applaud her for taking for doing a role that's different from her comfort zone. But also having seen her and Sherry, like there are things in Chenoweth that are just ingrained in her being now as a performer. She like while she was trying to go outside of her comfort zone, something she couldn't resist still doing as like as a performer who is notorious for being a comedic genius and like Right. Being so likable on stage. Like, yeah, you're having a hard time finding a middle ground with this woman. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01There were just so many issues with that show. But that's another season.

SPEAKER_03But we look at the past to learn lessons for the future.

SPEAKER_01Absolutely. So, Bruce, a fun fact about Matt as we wrap up. Did you know that Matt is in my Tony book?

SPEAKER_02I do now. I used to get little sneak peeks of little pages and things, which I loved. I didn't get a sneak peek of that page.

SPEAKER_01Well, because I didn't know I was putting him in when I did. Matt, do you want to tell everyone? Yeah, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_03This is one of my favorite things of all time. So I am an alumnus now of the New York City Gay Men's Chorus, but in the 2022 Tony Awards, I was an active member. And Angela Lansbury was being honored for the 2022 Tony Awards. And as part of the... Honoring her performance, they asked the chorus to sing a 60-second clip of MAME. And I got included in that. And I was front and center with the 30 of us, which is just like 10% of the chorus.

SPEAKER_03And there's a photo in Isla's book of that ceremony and of the chorus singing MAME. And I am in the photo. It's clearly me. It's not a full close-up of me, but it's close enough that you can tell it's me.

SPEAKER_01Oh, right in the middle, too.

SPEAKER_03Right in the middle. And I'm like, I read a Tony book. It's so exciting.

SPEAKER_01Were you so surprised?

SPEAKER_03So when the book came out, because I think I we brought you on the podcast, I think a little after it was published. So it was already in bookstores. So because I tell you on on Mike about. Yeah. Yeah. Because I went to a Barnes and Noble and I was like, I wonder how late this Tony book goes to, like how recent of the Tonys that she go up to. So I'm flipping through and like, oh, we get to 2022. I'm like, I just, I wonder. And then boom, it was right there. And I was like, I didn't expect it, but I was like, maybe, maybe, maybe there's a chance.

SPEAKER_03And then it happened.

SPEAKER_01How do you not put that photo? It was such a beautiful moment if you saw the show.

SPEAKER_03It was great. The only thing that upset me is that if you watched the telecast on TV or on YouTube, the way that they cut to the audience made it seem like we weren't very well received because they were like cut to Cheetah, they cut to Bernadette and they both are sort of into it. But like everyone around it was like all these businessmen around them who weren't paying attention. And I distinctly remember because Cynthia Erivo and Danielle Brooks were in the front row and they were jamming out to us. And I was like, the majority of the audience was really into it. Just the cameras happened to catch like the six white men who were not.

SPEAKER_03And so on YouTube, it looks like we were this big dud. I was like, no, no, we were not a dud. I promise you.

SPEAKER_01Never.

SPEAKER_03So speaking of Tonys.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Just super way even early to even talk about. But is anything coming up next season that you're already like? This is a lot.

SPEAKER_03I think so. Okay. Depending on if Next to Normal happens, I think Miss Rachel is a lock for actress in a musical.

SPEAKER_01Oh, for sure.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, to win, I'm saying. I think we'll look at... Evita, Full Monty, and Sound of Music as our revival nominees. Yeah. Regardless of the quality of Sound of Music and Full Monty, just Roundabout and Lincoln Center Theater get nominated kind of no matter what. I think that, oh, there's, okay, so we didn't even talk about this. There is a rumor based off of a casting notice that went out that didn't have any real information about the play, but just based off of like the small bits of details they gave.

SPEAKER_03It looks like Downstate is coming to Broadway in the fall. The question is whether it's a player or a revival. Regardless of category, I think that'll be a lock. It's a devastating, very uncomfortable play, but my God, is it brilliant. And if it comes with, and Kate Todd Freeman's in it, Oh, he's so great. And he's so great in that. So hold space for K. Todd Freeman. That'll be a nice little spoiler for your nomination predictions. I mean, Paddington, I think Paddington and Warriors will probably both do really well.

SPEAKER_03Paddington, I'm interested to see what they end up doing with the leads of that in terms of Tony's

SPEAKER_01placement.

SPEAKER_03And then whoever ends up playing Millicent, which is Pretty Little Dead Things, the Victoria Hamilton Barrett role. Whoever gets that role, as long as you don't mess it up, You're going to win.

SPEAKER_01Paddington could be a special Tony. Yeah. They could do that.

SPEAKER_03They might pull a Matilda without one.

SPEAKER_01Right. It just doesn't seem to fit.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, I think they might... It's it. There's no there's no easy way to do it, because the truth is that the man who's doing Paddington, he's not just doing the voice. He is still operating like the face from backstage. He also is on stage a lot of the show. So it's it's still a genuine musical theater performance that he shares with the person inside the costume. But I can't imagine that there's any world in which if they were to separate the two of them, that it would go well online, you know?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, right. Exactly.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01I think unless something goes horribly wrong, Julie Louis-Dreyfus will be a strong contender too.

SPEAKER_03Alison Janney as well for that show. Is Alison Janney playing the sister? Sorry, I need to look this up. One second. I apologize in real time. But as I'm looking this up, so you said Julie

SPEAKER_02Louis-Dreyfus, Isla. Anyone else? I'm also curious because as much as I think Jasmine will get nominated for Sound of Music, I also think her star is so strong. She could also, depending on what the schoolgirls play is like and the construct of that, she could be a supporting actress nominee, too. Yeah, she could be a double nominee.

SPEAKER_03That'd be awesome.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I wonder what that play even is going to be.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I think Revival of a Play is once again going to be a very crowded field with much ado and Awakening and A Few Good Men.

SPEAKER_03I know we're swimming in revivals this season, but there's a chance that most of them are going to be very good, and that'll be exciting.

SPEAKER_01I hope so. Yeah, that's what we want.

SPEAKER_02The one revival, too, I'm curious to see because they have to do a lot of reworking is Damn Yankees. Yeah. When it was in Washington, it was done in the round or a thrust. And now just in time hasn't announced closing anytime soon. And so the rumor is it's going to the Nederlander, which then they have to rework the staging. So it should be interesting.

SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think I also just think that's the smart thing for them to do rather than sit around and wait for the one theater that could house them to open up a theater, which also I don't think they could make work financially for the scale that that show is. Because while I mean, I know it did really well in But, you know, Arena Stage famously has not really been making any money lately. And part of that is, you know, for all of the for any shows they have that sell out, sometimes the overhead is too high. So that won't fly for Broadway. So I think them changing into a proscenium is smart. They can go into another theater. I have also heard the Nederlander.

SPEAKER_03I've also heard potentially the Imperial, but those are two very different landlords. So it's not necessarily like, oh, we could go to either one. It's like, no, it's it's got to be one of them because. Right.

SPEAKER_02Right.

SPEAKER_03Nederlanders and Schubert's don't like to share. But I know that Imperial is looking to also do a renovation at some point. But I know Billy Crystal's one-man show is about to go in there.

SPEAKER_01Oh, that's going to do well, too.

SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah.

SPEAKER_01That's a home run.

SPEAKER_03Who doesn't love Billy Crystal?

SPEAKER_01Right. And he loves being on Broadway so much. That's the thing. It's his joy.

SPEAKER_03Yeah. I appreciate that about him. I love it when Hollywood people come to Broadway and you can just tell it's for the love of it. Like Daniel Radcliffe comes to do theater for the love of it, which I- He certainly

SPEAKER_01doesn't need the money.

SPEAKER_03No, he certainly doesn't. And also they kept coming back year after year when he wouldn't get nominated for stuff. People forget that before Merrily, he had done like four Broadway shows, maybe five, and was never nominated for any of them.

SPEAKER_01Right. And then he wasn't going to come back, but he loved every brilliant thing. And he was wonderful in it.

SPEAKER_03He was. Yeah. He's a special little dude.

SPEAKER_01Yeah.

SPEAKER_03Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So, well, I mean, we've only covered some of it and we've talked and talked. So you'll have to come back at some point.

SPEAKER_03I would love that. Thank you both for having me. This was so fantastic. I would love to come back whenever you can have me.

SPEAKER_01Well, wonderful. Yes. You should come back mid-season and we can do like a, how are things going?

SPEAKER_03Perfect. By that point, I'll have done another London trip so I can give you guys the scoop of anything that should maybe come over here.

SPEAKER_01Perfect. Okay. Well, have fun. Thank you.

SPEAKER_03Thank you very much.

SPEAKER_01And thank you all. We'll see you next time on Behind the Awards.

SPEAKER_02See you guys. Bye-bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Patreon Preview: TONY SNUBS! (w/ Rob W Schneider, Steve Tipton, & Alex Weisman)

    Nov 19, 202627 minAudio

    What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Matt Reviews: OTHER DESERT CITIES

    Nov 15, 202633 minAudio

    Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Matt Reviews: THE HEART, I BECAME WE & Much, Much Off-Broadway

    Nov 12, 20261 hr 16 minAudio

    So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Matt Reviews: PARANORMAL ACTIVITY & THE IMAGINARY INVALID

    Nov 5, 202639 minAudio

    Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Matt Reviews: SCHOOL GIRLS (or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY)

    Nov 2, 202638 minAudio

    So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...

    Credit the people on this episode