Matt Reviews: Oedipus, The Baker’s Wife, Prince F*ggot & Two Strangers Carry A Cake…
1 hr 33 minAudio
Episode Summary In this bonus review episode, Matt tackles four very different productions - Oedipus, The Baker’s Wife, Prince F*ggot, and Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York. From classics, revivals, new works, and small downtown gems, he breaks down what sings, what stumbles, and what you might want to spend your money (or not spend your money) on this season. He also addresses audience questions about ticket pricing, press seats, and the realities of covering an entire Broadway season as a critic and podcaster. Timestamps 00:00 - Intro & Season Updates Live-show successes, upcoming cabaret dates for Broadway Breakdown, and how bonus review episodes will fit into the schedule. 02:30 - On Ticket Pricing, Press Seats & “Cringe” Feedback Matt clarifies misconceptions about requesting press tickets and discusses the financial/logistical realities of reviewing an entire season. 10:20 - Oedipus Overview of the production, standout performances, and early-season Tony nomination predictions - particularly in featured actor/actress categories. 18:10 - The Baker’s Wife A full dive into the show’s infamously chaotic production history, the new Classic Stage Company staging, Schwartz’s revisions over the years, and performances that make (or don’t make) the revival sing. 33:00 - Prince Faggot A nuanced review of the play’s thematic ambition, its monologue structure, moments that soar, moments that miss, and why the final monologue feels disconnected from the whole. Plus praise for the cast and a shout-out to excellent house staff. 45:55 - Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York A discussion of structure, pace, tone, and how well (or not) the piece handles its ideas about connection and modern loneliness. (Transcript references structural critique connected to this section.) Key People Mentioned * Mark Strong, Lesley Manville, Robert Icke - Stars and Director/Adapter of Oedipus * Stephen Schwartz - composer/lyricist of The Baker’s Wife * Carol Demas, Patti LuPone, Paul Sorvino - original Baker’s Wife figures in the show’s rocky history * Ariana DeBose, Scott Bakula, Nathan Lee Graham, Judy Kuhn - members of the CSC production of The Baker’s Wife * David Greenspan - praised in Prince F*ggot * Kuhnsie - featured Diva of the Week, singing “Meadowlark” * Sam Tutty, Christiana Pitts - Stars of Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York Resources & Links * Telecharge - tickets for shows mentioned: https://www.telecharge.com/ * Broadway Breakdown Discord * Broadway Breakdown Substack Listener Discussion Questions * Which of the four shows reviewed would you prioritize seeing, and why? * How do you balance ticket prices with the desire to keep up with a Broadway season - what makes a show “worth it” to you? * For revivals like The Baker’s Wife, do you prefer faithfulness to the original vision or bold reinvention? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown, a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American theater's most exclusive address, Broadway. I am your host, Matt Koplik, the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast hosts. And we've got a bonus episode for you guys today, a nice bonus review episode. It's a lot of stuff we got to cover, so I will jump into it in just a second, but I want to give you guys a quick update on some stuff. First of all,
SPEAKER_00Our first live musical episode, Broadway Breakdown, a cabaret now at Green Room 42, was a big success. We had a very good turnout, both in person and on the live stream. And the response was such from both the audience and from Green Room 42 that we actually will be having more musical live episodes, aka more cabarets, aka more shows, into the new year. I will give more information on that shortly, probably in... sometime in mid or end of December. But for now,
SPEAKER_00I can tell you that our next show will be in March, followed by one in May and then in June. And they're going to be a little more focused on specific themes than this first one, because this first one, we weren't sure what it was going to be or how many times we were going to get to do it. So we kind of just threw all of the spaghetti at the wall to see what stuck. So the next shows will be a little more focused on themes. So that's the first thing. More shows for Broadway Breakdown and Cabaret now in March and May and June. Today we will be covering Oedipus at Studio 54,
SPEAKER_00the baker's wife, Prince Fagote, and two strangers carry a cake across New York. That is this episode as a bonus episode. Thursday will be a review of Wicked for Good with a special guest. You guys will find out who that is shortly. And then after this, there will be another bonus episode, a review episode of Ragtime and Queen of Versailles. Queen of Versailles will be an interesting one because I'm actually seeing it back to back.
SPEAKER_00I am seeing it. I'm recording this on Sunday, November 23rd. I will be seeing it Monday, November 24th and Tuesday. So I can see Sherry Renee Scott as well. Do not say that I do not give you all of the things. I also just want to say. So for Broadway Breakdown and Cabaret Now, I asked people to submit questions anonymously online that I could then pick out of Sally Bull and read on stage. And I unfortunately did not get enough time to read all of them, but I did get a chance to sort of look them all over after the fact.
SPEAKER_00And there were some that I... found that were pretty consistent, a lot of questions about ticket pricing. But I had one question in particular that wasn't a question. It was, once again, one of when I do these anonymous submissions, whether it's for Sally Bull or for my Ask Me Anythings on Instagram, there's always a person. And I'm starting to think it's one person in particular because the writing has been very similar each time it happens, where I am told that while they enjoy the podcast mostly, sometimes they find me condescending,
SPEAKER_00or in this case, they use the words cringe, and specifically about how they felt I was constantly pushing for free tickets, which I suppose is what I talk about on the podcast when I contact press teams to see shows. So I kind of want to clear the air on that because I don't know how many people also feel that way. But in case you do, I just sort of want to be specific about that. I'm not going to address the cringe thing because that is that person's experience with me.
SPEAKER_00That's not necessarily a fact. I do try very hard to, you know, be self-aware and not be too obnoxious about stuff. But of course, I am a human being and I'm me. So I tend to be obnoxious from time to time, as we all do. When it comes to tickets, when I talk about reaching out to press teams, I am not trying to push for free stuff. I'm not here going, oh my God, please give me all the free things, daddy.
SPEAKER_00I want it. I'm an influencer. That's not my vibe. And I would hope that you all would know that that's not my vibe. Press seats are commonplace for all critics, as well as industry folks and for influencers, which again, I am not. Critics do not pay to see shows. They get tickets from the press team, from the producers, to then see the show. And while I personally do not think of myself as specifically
only a critic, many of you do.
SPEAKER_00And I do, in fact, do reviews on this podcast. And it has become very clear from the listenership from the Discord, which if you haven't joined yet, join now, there is a great demand for me to cover as much of the season as possible as soon as possible. And the only way I can do that is to correspond with each show's press team to see if and when I can get in to see those shows. Because if I see the show as close to opening as possible then I can review the show as soon after opening as possible.
If that's not the case then I have to figure out another way to see that show. Because one of the things that also was submitted a lot for the cabaret for questions was a lot of people talking about ticket pricing and how absurd it all
SPEAKER_00is. And yes, it's very absurd. And no, there is no show that's worth $499. So if you were thinking of paying that for chess, which like five of you asked that question to me, is chess worth $499? No, it's not. I haven't even seen it yet. I can tell you it's not. But I'm not sitting here being tone deaf about the economy, about people's incomes. I'm aware of how expensive tickets are, which is why I'm very particular about what I highly recommend to people, because I see these things knowing that people are shelling out a lot of money for them and going,
SPEAKER_00is this even worth it? And 80% of the time it's not. But Already seeing everything in one season and paying for everything is already very expensive, but also just not feasible scheduling-wise. And also, because we take this podcast seriously, because this podcast has created a sizable footprint in the community, we now have relationships with every press team on Broadway. But because we are not the New York Times and because podcasts are still a very
SPEAKER_00alien world to a lot of Broadway producers— sizable as our listenership is, as our footprint is, we don't get into everything, but we still try. And some shows tell you right off the bat. Some shows make you wait a while, which is why when I say I'm waiting to see what such and such has to say, it's just a matter of logistics. So I'm not being... What's the word I'm looking for? I have no expectations with any show. I make the effort. I put the outreach and then sometimes I get surprised with what I get a yes to and what I don't.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, I'm not being greedy about it. I'm not being tone deaf. It's just this is how this works. Every podcast you listen to that goes to see shows, they are also reaching out to press teams to see if they can get in. Friends of our podcast do it as well for their own podcasts. So that's just the way that this industry works. I am not vying for free stuff out of entitlement. I am doing what we all do, and I'm just being transparent about it, as I always am. I overshare, as we know.
SPEAKER_00So that's what that is. So if anyone else finds that cringe, that is your reaction to a reality. Moving on. The first show we are going to cover in this episode is Oedipus. Actually, no, before we even do that, I want to give a quick shout out to friend of the pod, Preston Max Allen, whose play is Caroline at MCC just finished their run at the end of October. I got a chance to see it in a pretty full house, which was exciting. The production was directed by David Cromer.
SPEAKER_00Also, other thing, I had accidentally given some misinformation about Bug at Manhattan Theater Club, and I had said that Tracy Lutz was directing it. He is not. Cromer is directing it, as he had done in Chicago. I think I had misread my press packet, and just saw Let's His Name in bold and went, oh, he's directing it too. How fun. No, he's not directing this production. So I apologize, everybody, for putting that misinformation out there. David Cromer also has directed Caroline, and it was starring Chloe Grace Moretz and Amy Lendecker and
River Leip-Smith.
SPEAKER_00The play follows Moretz as a single mother named Maddie, who is raising a trans child caroline uh recently uh trans or to say um recently identifying as trans and The production mostly just follows Maddie as she takes Caroline away from an abusive boyfriend in their home to her childhood home, which she hasn't been to since before Caroline was born, where she reconnects with her mother,
SPEAKER_00who she's estranged from. And Maddie was a bad kid and stole money and did a lot of drugs. And the play deals with not just the realities of... trans health and the hurdles that trans people, especially trans children, face just to find their own journey of equilibrium and identity and independence. But also the play deals with redemption and second chances and what it is to be a parent and whether you know if you're doing the right thing for your child or if you're even
truly raising the child that you have or the child that you want and it's a very lovely play i was very impressed by it uh reasonably funny while still being heartfelt and uh lived in the third act didn't really work so well for me i will say there was a sort of major twist that happened between maddie and her mother raya that felt a little out of left field and it's not that it got resolved but it got dealt with very quickly towards the end felt a little rushed considering how much time was
SPEAKER_00spent on the rest of the piece especially maddie's own owning up to her past mistakes and dealing with her addiction and how she's been sort of going through the steps to be okay or to be as okay as she can be. It was a very lovely grown-up piece. And I have always known Preston for their musicals, like We Are the Tigers and Carrie 2. And so it was interesting to see this play, which is so not those musicals. But I was very proud of Preston.
SPEAKER_00So well done, Preston. Moving on to Oedipus. This production is at Studio 54, and it is adapted by Robert Icke from the Greek tragedy Oedipus Rex by Sophocles. It was originally commissioned in Amsterdam by Eva van Hofe, but was then eventually translated into English, where it played at the Wyndham's Theatre in the West End, and it won me Olivier for Best Revival. Ick, I had only known for his modern adaptation of The Doctor that
starred Juliet Stevenson and played here at the Park Avenue Armory after having played in London.
SPEAKER_00Stevenson, unfortunately, had gotten sick and then had a major family tragedy and had to leave the production. So I saw her understudy, who was very good. But I was a little... half and half about the production itself. I didn't realize that Robert Icke had done the stage adaptation of 1984 at the Hudson, which I remember was sort of met with a mixed reception. I didn't get to see it, so I can't comment on its actual qualité. Just that was the reputation it had when it played. And I did not know much about this production, but considering it was Ick and from the aesthetic that I'd seen
from the poster and
SPEAKER_00from photos, it seemed like this was going to be another modern adaptation of a classic, which is something that Ick has done in the past. Orestria, I believe, is what he had done and Mary Stewart. So this that is exactly what this is. It is the Greek tragedy. Oedipus Rex, which then launched the Oedipal Complex as we come to know it, the man who killed his father and slept with his mother. And Ick has taken it and moved it to present day and fully
rewritten the text. There are parts of it that I'm sure are verbatim from the original Greek tragedy,
SPEAKER_00but from my ears, it mostly sounded like a whole new text. And it follows Oedipus, Oedipus in this production as it's pronounced Oedipus, who is married to Jocasta, played by Leslie Manville. Oedipus is played by Mark Strong. And Oedipus is this hotshot politician who is on election night of his campaign to be the leader of his country. And all the meanwhile, his mother, played by Anne Reed, keeps telling him,
I need to speak with you alone because Oedipus has talked about how there was
SPEAKER_00discrepancies about his birth. So he said he announced that he was going to release his birth certificate. And on top of this, because he was married to Jocasta, who, as we learn, was the wife of the man who Yeah.
And so he said that when elected, he is going to look into Jocasta's first husband's death.
SPEAKER_00And so that way he can inform the people that there is no connection. There's no foul play. All is fine. And so there's a lot of chaos on his team, specifically Jocasta's brother, who is played by John Carroll Lynch, playing Creole, who is the head of Oedipus's political campaign and is telling him like that was a really bad thing to do and read his mother's like I need to talk to you after you
mentioning your birth certificate and of course everything kind of gets keep getting pushed back and back and back and a soothsayer finds his way into the office to tell Oedipus that he will not be leader Creole will be the leader of the country that Oedipus before the
SPEAKER_00day is out will have killed his father and has slept with his mother and And this is troubling to Oedipus because his father, as he knows it, is in the hospital right now with cancer. And he's like, I don't plan to kill him, but he's dying, so that's a really awful thing for you to say. He's like, and I have no plan of sleeping with Anne Reed. And he tells this to Leslie Manville, and Leslie Manville dies. is also sort of laughs it all off and they have three kids and so the whole show is
following the next two hours of their lives from him making this announcement about his birth certificate the soothsayer giving him the prophecy to when the election results come out and there is a clock on stage in his office in his campaign office that it's counting down to when the polls are closed and they can get election results.
SPEAKER_00And as that's happening, it immediately sets attention in the theater of, oh, God, because the show itself is two hours, no intermission. So when the curtain comes up and you see that there's like an hour and 50 on the clock and we already spent like three minutes before this with a pre-taped segment, like, OK, we've got like seven minutes of holy fuck balls. after that clock goes off. When is the shoe going to drop? When is all of the chaos going to happen? And as an adaptation, Ick has done a really masterful job of
SPEAKER_00stretching it out just enough that it never feels like a slog, but also you don't feel like you're rushing into things. It is exceptionally well paced. And the clock, as I said, adds this tension that even when nothing's really happening on stage or nothing that you think is terribly important is happening on stage, you still look at the clock and you go, okay, but we've got 55 minutes to go. Like, like a lot of very you know watchable engaging things have happened but like the drama hasn't happened yet and like okay i feel like it's coming soon and of course
it does and i don't want to give too much away about sort of how ick has re conceptualized a lot of the plot points of oedipus for this adaptation because all of the same story beats of oedipus are here it's just how they are done is
SPEAKER_00different and Again, without giving me too much away, Leslie Manville has a very long monologue that explains what her situation was with her first husband who had died, how she came to be in his life, how she came to be his wife, and of course explaining about a child that she had had and what had actually happened to the child. And a lot of this has to do with the age she was at the time and because of how long ago it was and where society was at in terms of medical practices and her relationship with
this man and the
SPEAKER_00first husband's political stature. Without again, I don't think this is giving too much away, but it was we are told from the beginning that her first marriage was a May-December romance. how may december it was is not fully explained until much later and that that's when it goes from a scandalous age gap to a crime and this this whole monologue is just this devastating journey that manville takes you on and as
it's happening the clock is ticking down by minutes and then eventually by seconds and it is this
SPEAKER_00masterful theatrical device that they use. I guess, I mean, I don't think this is spoiling much, but I loved this. This is absolutely my favorite thing I've seen so far of the season. Now, granted, I do still have to see Ragtime. I do have to see Queen of Versailles. I do have to see Art and Marjorie Prime. Not Art. I've seen Marjorie Prime and Mamma Mia. I apologize. I did famously see Art, as you guys remember from that episode. But as of right now, this is my favorite thing of the Broadway season. It's actually my favorite thing I've seen all season long,
including off-Broadway.
SPEAKER_00This includes Bo. This includes Batboy. I just think it's so... It is the combination of all the things about live theater we love, the dynamicism. Is that the right word? Because dynamics, dynamicism. Yeah, I think that's the right word or right pronunciation of it. But it's, you know, the dynamics we love of live theater while also not overblowing it too quickly. It makes you wait and earn it, but the waiting doesn't feel like a slog.
SPEAKER_00The waiting is entertaining in its own right. And there is... Wit and there is intelligence and there is craft, but there's also violence and danger and a little bit of sexiness. Mark Strong and Leslie Manville's characters, they're a married couple. They've been happily married for 25 years and they are still so into each other and they are so sexual with each other. There is... a scene when they're alone sort of talking early earlier in the play this is before
manville's really you know big monologue there's a scene where they're alone after you know having sent the kids away and his mother's away and all these things and they're talking in there and they're sort of recommitting to each other and going
SPEAKER_00over the past and whatnot and it gets to a moment where mark strong Sorry if this is triggering for anybody in terms of sexuality, but this is sort of how it all goes. Mark Strong goes down on Leslie Manville. And of course, they get interrupted and they go off stage to have sex. But I was telling my friend Danny that I was watching this moment in the play Oedipus and Mark Strong goes down on Leslie Manville.
SPEAKER_00And I thought to myself, oh, they're performing the title song. I was very proud of that. I was very, very proud of that. What can I say? I am literally a child. But... Manville and Strong and everyone in the production, nobody goes for overly theatrical Greek trauma from the start. It is very much it begins as sort of West Wing House of Cards, the diplomat kind of show with the political jargon and
everyone sort of Aaron Sorkoning dialogue all over the place and zip zap zopping and everything feels just
SPEAKER_00organic. And that's already very impressive. It's always hard to be that kind of dropped in and organic when you are live on stage and what is still at its origins, a Greek tragedy. But when this piece builds to its epic conclusion, it's just the heat getting turned up every 15 minutes. So when we get to, again, spoiler alerts, the devastating realization that Leslie Manville is Mark
Strong's mother and that Leslie Manville's character takes her own life and then Mark Strong blinds himself.
SPEAKER_00I mean, again, it's spoilers, but this is a thousands-year-old tragedy and people tend to know these things about it. But when we get to that, it is so earned and it is so... Juicy is so basic of a word to use for it, but it is so satisfying to get to this heightened fever pitch of melodramatics because it has built so quickly.
intricately and so methodically but so naturally to this moment and it allows the actors to play every shade of acting you can again a super hyper shakespearean greek tragedy drama naturalistic screen acting it just goes all over the place without ever feeling wildly off the beaten path and i cannot recommend it highly
SPEAKER_00enough i thought it was so fantastic the only downside to seeing oedipus is with a prestige play from London like this, you get a crowd of folks who, I will be honest, even before COVID, but especially post-COVID, have fully not understood how to be back in a theater again. And this is going to sound incredibly general and simplistic, but I keep seeing it. For all of the shit that Gen Z and Gen Alpha get for their
social media use,
SPEAKER_00for their phone usage, and it's true, you can see them on their phones all the time, and it's definitely bad. Boomer generation is just as bad, if not worse. Turning off their phones? Couldn't be bothered. Dropping their phones constantly all the time. There were so many dropped phones in Oedipus. It was really fucking upsetting. And at Studio 54, there's no carpet. It's all hardwood. So you hear all of it. And I just wanted to scream. But just know that like you have to kind of go in and take a deep breath and know that those are going to happen. And unfortunately,
I have a very sensitive ear to the phone drops and people unwrapping candies and
SPEAKER_00shit like that. And eventually you just have to let it go. It's not totally possible for someone like me, but you can help yourself a little bit. So that's just something to think about with Oedipus of like that kind of crowd. But otherwise, there's nothing about it that I wouldn't recommend. In terms of Tony Award chances, I still am not sure how this is going to go with Revival v. Play because it is ultimately an entirely new script. I'm going to say Revival. And I mean, either category, I think it's getting in.
SPEAKER_00But Revival, I think it's especially getting in. I would be absolutely shocked if Mark Strong and Leslie Manville are not nominated for this. They're both just too phenomenal. I think Ike will get nominated for director. I think sound is very likely for them. The sound design in this production is fantastic. There's a lot of intricate work happening with all of the TV screens that are going on all throughout the offices. It's a very impressive set. Realistic, but again, very stylized. Featured actor and actress, I could see John Carroll Lynch getting in as Creole.
SPEAKER_00I had only known him from his film work, primarily from Fargo. He's Francis McDormand's husband in that. Featured actor and actress, I feel like is going to be a little packed this year between liberation and, unfortunately, art. But also, you know, there's... danny burstein for marjorie prime and and there's also actors coming up for proof and for joe turner's come and gone so we'll see how that goes but i could see john carol lynch getting in for a featured actor i would love to see anne reed get in for featured actress she has a really wonderful uh speech
towards the end but i i
SPEAKER_00would imagine she's going to get uh forgotten so i would i would definitely put some money on a nomination for revival actor actress and director and then possibly sound as well so that's where we are for either push uh next one we're going to do is the baker's wife then we're going to take a quick break i will then be going off to see slam frank downtown at the asylum and when i come back i will finish recording this uh also if you're watching this on youtube or on spotify which is probably like 30 of you, you may be wondering, like, what is this setup? Why do I look like I'm in the bad boy cave?
SPEAKER_00The room that I normally record in is going through some renovations. And so everything has been moved out, including the desk that I usually record on. So I'm in my room where there is no desk, just a little cavern. And I recorded this too late in the day because other things were happening in the morning and the afternoon. So I just have my ring light. And so I just I look like I am sitting in a pool of darkness with just a little spotlight on me uh so that's what's going on if you're watching this uh and that will
continue for i think the next two episodes if you watch any of the videos but then after that it'll be back to normal so the baker's wife is at classic stage company this is the infamous musical that closed out of town after like six months on the road firing uh uh
SPEAKER_00Carol Demis and then bringing on Patti LuPone, having Topol for most of the run, then firing him and bringing in Paul Sorvino, closing at the Kennedy Center in D.C. a week before they were supposed to open on Broadway. It's like a major, major troubled show that ultimately, because of the score by Stephen Schwartz, primarily songs like Proud Lady and Meadowlark and Where's the Warmth, has endured and constantly brought attention to itself on a show that needed fixing and was given a production in London directed by Trevor Nunn. And that became sort of the go-to version for the better part
of two decades.
SPEAKER_00But then Schwartz kind of came back to it and made more changes. I know that Friend of the Pod Rob Schneider did a production of it at J2 Spotlight and made some changes to it that Schwartz really liked. And Schwartz took those changes and brought them to the Manure Chocolate Factory, where Gordon Greenberg directed that production. And what we have here is ultimately a transfer of that production. I'm not sure how much was changed, if anything, but it looks very similar to that production. It is the same director. So for all intents and purposes, this feels like a transfer of production.
SPEAKER_00The plot, so to speak, centers around a small village in France in the 1930s, right before World War II is about to break out. And the town has lost its baker. And so there has been no bread. But then a new baker, Amable, shows up. And he brings his young wife, Geneviève. And everyone's like, yeah, we got the bread now. We have all the baked goods, the darts and the bread. And everyone's very, very happy. But then, a young man in the town, Dominique, who is like a chauffeur for the town mayor,
SPEAKER_00the corrupt mayor, played by Nathan Lee Graham. And Dominique is super into Jean-Vievre. And after like a minute of resisting, Jean-Vievre is like, I think I'm going to go off with Dominique and bang my brains out. And she does. And Amable is very sad and does not make sa prête. And the townspeople are like, but where is sa prête? you know, Jean Vieves asks, where is the warmth? The townspeople are like, where is the bread? And they're like, where is the bread? Where's the warmth for our bread? You know what I mean? And ultimately they go and search for Jean Vieves,
SPEAKER_00but it doesn't matter because Jean Vieves asks, where is the warmth? And comes back to Amable and everyone gets their bread and all is well. It's a very slight plot. It is based off of the French film from the 1930s that also was meant to be a slight plot, but the whole point of it was sort of vibes and charm. And indeed, this production is rather charming. I thought it was a solid, if not amazing, production of what is ultimately a very flawed film. musical the first things first it looks absolutely stunning the
set design by jason sherwood costumes by katherine zuber and lighting by bradley king king as we know from natasha pierre the the whole look of it is beautiful it's a little it's a
SPEAKER_00little disney worldy in some ways like it And I don't mean that in a negative way, but you know, when you're on the queue for a ride at Disney World, this felt this looked and felt like the queue for a ride at Disney World. Like this would have been the queue for a Ratatouille ride at Disney World. And I mean that with all the praise in my heart. So that's the first thing. It looks stunning and fills the intimate space very well without overwhelming it. The music is given a very strong treatment. The music direction is by Charlie Alterman, as well as the arrangements.
And then it has orchestrations by David Cullen and a score that I have only ever heard in pieces with a very large orchestra to hear it with a smaller band.
SPEAKER_00It didn't sound tinny. It sounded very charmingly intimate and had a lot of personality to it. And I thought that that was very tricky. That was very tricky line to walk. It is a strong cast overall. The high points in the cast are absolutely the people who play the townsfolk. We, of course, have my beloved Kuhnsey. We have Sally Murphy. But beyond that, we have Robert Cuccioli. We have Will Rowland, Kevin De La Guilla. We have Nathan Lee Graham, Arnie Burton. We have Alma Cuervo. And they all do wonderful work.
SPEAKER_00The biggest complaint I would have, and this is extended to also our leads, Ariana DeBose, Scott Bakula, and then semi-lead Kevin William Paul as Dominique, is there is very inconsistent work happening here when it comes to accents. Yes, we are in France. Some people do an accent, like a hard accent. Kevin de la Guilla as the town drunk is going full-blown drunk in Lumiere. He's like, oh, was that bigger's wife? She has on off, for she is so young, and he is so old. Blah, blah, blah.
SPEAKER_00We have Will Roland, who's not doing an accent at all. Alma Cuervo's not doing an accent. Arnie Burton's kind of doing a, like, British accent, from what I can recall. Nathan Lee Graham is doing his Nathan Lee Graham thing, where it's, like, kind of transatlantic. I also love the Wild Party reunion for Nathan Lee Graham and Sally Murphy in his production. Hallelujah. Sally's not doing an accent. Kunesy's not doing an accent. Robert Cuccioli, I think, is doing a light accent. Scott Bakula and Ariana DeBose are also kind of doing a light French accent, which just sort of sounds like,
SPEAKER_00especially from her, it's like if she were doing a... seductive cat in a cartoon voice that would be the voice she's doing she's like oh amable for the bread is so warm yes no yes it's it's if kevin de la guila is going all the way up and will roland is not doing anything at all debose is sort of somewhere in the middle where it's not that it is a realistic accent so much as that It sounds like an accent she's not willing to fully commit to.
SPEAKER_00And the same is true of Bacula. So I don't want to like harp all of that critique on DuBose. Other people do it, specifically Bacula. What actors like Sally Murphy and Kuhnsey do is they do their normal speaking voice. And then whenever it comes to a name or a town, then they do a French pronunciation. And I think that is the correct way to go about this. Because either like everyone needs to do an accent or no one should do an accent. And I think the best sort of middle ground is the no accent French pronunciation.
SPEAKER_00But for some reason, no one's on the same page with that. And I don't know why. My issues with the show, I was with a friend of the pod. Well, he actually hasn't been on the pod yet, but I've been on his show quite a few times, Patrick Pacheco. And first of all, Patrick asked me to tap his leg every time somebody went into their mix or head voice, because I guess he... the he had always heard of it but he was never able to clock it and i stopped doing it after a while because i just kept hitting him over and over and over again and then uh after like 10 minutes he's like um has has has it
stopped are people belting now it's like oh no i just i stopped doing it because i thought you wanted me i figured you were tired of me tapping you um and he was like no i i still like to know so we were doing that but we both kind of agreed that for a show that has
SPEAKER_00such a passionate following and the lore of baker's wife is that it's this like i'm like a mac and mabel it's the score that keeps it alive that people want to try to fix it and neither one of us was super enamored with the score i again i had only really known metal meadowlark where is the warmth and proud lady i didn't really know the rest i think i might have heard it once or twice in the past but never really gave it a full listen and metal arc is a full-on banger and where's the warmth is very nice if not quite as like special as metal arc and proud lady is is is fun enough
SPEAKER_00But I didn't really know Chaison. I did not know Bread or The Luckiest Man in the World, songs like that. I think a lot of the score is kind of just sort of fine. It's not really super memorable for me or very special for me. And so that was kind of surprising on my end. And Patrick's end as well. We both kind of felt that way. And the story is very slight. It... this is going to be a theme for the rest of the episode so i apologize for anyone
who thinks that i'm just an uncultured fuck who wants everything to be short i don't care technically speaking how long any show is but every story only gets so much time before uh you start to lose interest and with the baker's wife for a slight show that's really just about the townsfolk and how they want their bread um
SPEAKER_00This show, this two and a half hour, two act show with an intermission cannot sustain that length. for me, because there's very little conflict. It takes a very long time to get to any kind of conflict. And the show also wants to have its cake and eat it too and be about the townsfolk as well as about Jean-Vivre and Dominique and be this sort of intricate web of sort of like a French Nashville where everyone's got stuff going on and you watch paths sort of always cross and the stakes are never totally high, but it's still engaging because we like the characters and the
intricacies of their
SPEAKER_00lives. And that is true. But again, I think that Either we need to put more of a focus on Jean Villave and Amable's relationship and have everyone else truly be a side character with facets, or we need to really even out the playing field and... spread out the Immobly Geneviève stuff throughout the French village stuff for me. Because the Geneviève storyline is not given a lot of room to breathe.
SPEAKER_00And when it is focused on, it's focused on so intensely that that you feel like you get a little bit of whiplash when she goes away. We get a little bit of her and Amable's life together when they arrive. Merci Madame is a nice little charming song. Oh, I also knew Merci Madame. And I will say, I do like the recording with Sorvino and Lupone. I think it's incredibly sweet. especially impressive considering how much Patti LuPone hated being in the Baker's Wife and was like running on fumes by the time they closed and
knew Sorvino for like all of five seconds because he came in for like the last two weeks of the run.
SPEAKER_00But I digress. That number is a very sweet number between them. But then... We don't get much development after that. And the next time we come back to them, we get Geneviève's song about her past life, you know, having been involved with married men and having had that passion before. And again, it's sort of each time we come back to the immobile Geneviève storyline, we come back to it with such intensity that you think that we're going to get more of it. But we get about the same amount of it as we get other plot lines. And for Geneviève,
I feel as if the show does not really earn Metal Lark.
SPEAKER_00Nor does Metal Lark really fit in with the rest of the show. On its own, Metal Lark is a phenomenal three-act song to sing in a concert or a cabaret. It's beautiful. It has a build to it. The lyrics are fine. But also... It is a song that is not even the act one finale. It's the penultimate act one finale and is supposed to be this major decision that this lady has to make that is ultimately a very selfish and cruel decision,
SPEAKER_00but one of fight or flight. Right. And one that many of us can relate to it. A character doesn't always have to make a kind decision for us to still want to watch them. In fact, I would argue it's when they make mistakes that we want to like them more. And the musical doesn't, in its current stage, does not build enough of a will-they-won't-they undeniable heated chemistry between Dominique and Jean-Vievre that builds up to the breaking point of him giving her the ultimatum of run away with me and her being genuinely conflicted.
It also doesn't help that Ariana DeBose and Kevin William Paul have no chemistry.
SPEAKER_00Greenberg and Paul have decided that this Dominique, and it's also in the writing, but also their interpretation of him, is that he's not a Lothario. He's just a guy in love with love. And he just so happens to be really into Jean Villave. And like, is that such a crime? He means well. He's just, you know... They want to make him more of an Antony and Sweeney Todd and less of an Anatole and Grey Comet. And I think he doesn't have to fully be a dick, but you need a bit more of that sexual energy, that heat from Anatole that throws Geneviève for a loop so we
can understand where
SPEAKER_00she's coming from of like, oh, I thought that I turned this part of myself off, but oh my God, these feelings that I'm having and let it bubble. We only get, we get one character meet cute with them that lasts all of 90 seconds. And then it's like 10 minutes later till we see them together again. And it's, again, like a 20-second scene that's inside of a larger scene with the townsfolk. And then he makes his declaration like 20 minutes later. And it just feels disjointed. And Meadowlark has to do a lot of heavy lifting to make us buy how conflicted
SPEAKER_00Genevieve feels and then lead her to this decision. I also realized that metal arc in a lot of ways. For those of you who are like old school listeners of the podcast, you might remember John Miscavige and I had that game, Jukebox That Musical. And I had done one with Whitney Houston songs set in a Shonda Rhimes world where, you know, it was like Philippa Sue and Taylor Louderman were, you know, studying to be veterinarians. And B.B. North was like one of the teachers. And I think even Ariana DePose was in that fake musical.
But I want to say it was Louderman had like what I called the Shonda Rhimes
SPEAKER_00monologue where a character is in a fight. And then at the breaking point, that character says something that seems so out of left field. And something like, you know, my aunt used to have a pet rabbit and goes on this three minute monologue about the rabbit and the aunt and growing up with the codependent. relationship with this rabbit and then saying like and in conclusion you don't get to tell me what to do because i'm not your pet rabbit and that's a that's a shonda rhymes monologue you see it on gray's anatomy all the time scandal whatnot uh and
metal arc for me is kind of like a shonda rhymes monologue because it's like the
SPEAKER_00run away with me well who does he think i am When I was a girl, I had a favorite story and goes on a three minute song about the story of the metal arc and then comes back to. And now here I am and I am just like the metal arc and I will not die like the metal arc. It's a it's a it's a Shonda Rhimes monologue. It's a great song, but it is a Shonda Rhimes monologue. Which I will say, at my performance, DeBose sang fine. She acted it pretty well. I think Ariana DeBose is a better actress than she gets credit for.
And I maintain that she was my pick for featured actress in a musical in Summer.
SPEAKER_00But... Jean Vievre is just not as compelling a character for me as everyone else is. Metal Ark is the big song. And she sang it fine. We're used to fuller voices like a Patti LuPone or even purer voices with greater range like a Liz Calloway or Judy Kuhn to sing it. And DuBose does not have that. Her voice is too modern and too poppy. So the notes are coming out. She's negotiating it, but you can hear her negotiating it. And she's also rushing through it and trying to find the story
beats in it to
SPEAKER_00commit to the choice that Geneviève makes. And it just it doesn't totally land. It's not a train wreck, but it doesn't fully land. I actually think she does a lot better with Where is the Warmth. Scott Bakula does a very nice job with Amable. I think he's just simply too handsome and too virile to really make it work for himself. But, you know, what a terrible punishment it is to be still so hot as you get older. And I found out he played... in a production in the past of baker's wife i'm pretty sure
which makes a lot of sense because i was watching kevin william paul and i remember thinking to myself damn i'll bet scott bacula could have played this role in his heyday and like
SPEAKER_00really fucking nailed it uh trying to think what else i can say about it i know that there's a lot of talk about this maybe transferring i if they do godspeed i don't think that it's one that would be successful as a transfer they also would have to reconfigure the design for a proscenium space because circle in the square is not going to be empty anytime soon i do believe there will be a cast recording which i'm not mad about uh as i said it's a mostly well sung production kevin william paul unfortunately is clearly a high tenor trying to sing a baritone role and trying
to make Proud Lady sound really powerful and thrilling and it's just too low in his register so he's actually pushing and sounds rather flat or even sharp on a lot of stuff which is a shame because I bet if they raised the key by like a full step it would really sit
SPEAKER_00in his sweet spot. Everyone else is very charming or very engaging Sally Murphy once again playing a woman in a very troubling marriage and watching her both be free away from her husband and trying to placate her husband and but being afraid, but still trying to, but still being a person was really thrilling to have. She and Kunze have one scene and a second act together. It's 90 seconds long and it's my favorite 90 seconds in the whole show. You know who's great in this show? Judy Kun. Judy Kun absolutely fucking walks away with this show.
SPEAKER_00She sounds incredible. Who is the, who the fuck is surprised by that? She is incredibly engaging and emotional, but she also, bitch gets laughs in this show. For a woman who I never really found funny in her youth, She has found a way to be funny in the 21st century, and I am here for it. Judy Kuhn, be funny, and we are thrilled. She has an absolutely terrible marriage to Robert Cuccioli. The show, obviously, based off of a very, I would say, misogynistic... The show is based off a very misogynistic movie,
SPEAKER_00and... The show wants to have it both ways. It wants to have a more modern sensibility. It's crazy to think that this was written in the 1970s. It feels like it was written in the 1940s. And I don't mean that in like a, oh my God, what a classic golden age musical. Like it's charming, but it's very slight. And it feels kind of like one of the musicals that writers of the golden age were fighting to get produced while Rodgers and Hammerstein were like on the rise and breaking the barriers and creating more integrated musicals. They're like, can we get more shows like the princess musicals again? And so it's just like it just feels very kind of simplistic and
not always in a
SPEAKER_00good way, sometimes in a way where you go, I feel like there's a song here not because it's warranted, but because you're writing a musical. Have you ever gone to a musical or a reading of a musical and watched a number where you're like, there's no reason for this number to be here other than the fact that the writers are writing a musical? It's not needed in the story or in the character's development or anything like that. It's just here because you're like, we have a musical and we need a song now. We should have another song. And that's, for me, a lot of the case with Baker's Wife. Too many times where I'm like, there's a song here because you're writing a musical, not because it's needed. And I wish it could be an hour and 45,
no intermission, hour and 40, no intermission.
SPEAKER_00and really just be the, you know, bump mal that it should be, as opposed to still kind of a little overbloated of a show. Even in this more intimate theater with, I'm sure, shaving off a whole bunch of minutes from the original runtime in the 1970s, it is still a little too fatty and a little too airy. And I would really strongly advise Schwartz and team to go back and like make some hard decisions on cutting because I think it would allow the show to fly even higher than it currently does because it's a very nice
production of a very
SPEAKER_00flawed musical, but it's not quite thrilling enough for me, not quite special enough for me, but it is worth seeing. I don't know when we're going to see it again in this city, especially at this level, but yeah, I'm glad I saw it. So that's it on Baker's Wife. We're going to take a quick break and we're going to get into Prince Fagote and then two strangers carry a cake across New York. So, Let's take that break. Billy, I beg to differ with you. How do you mean? You're the top. You're an arrow collar. You're the top.
SPEAKER_00You're a Coolidge dollar. You're the nimble tread of the feet of... And we are back in the break. I went to go to the asylum and saw a slam Frank. I have no comment on that for the meanwhile. It's still in development. But when I came back, I looked at the beautiful image of me from the first part looking like I was Floyd Collins in the cave. And I was like, oh, I'll just turn the light on in the background and sort of blur it a little bit. And if any of you are watching it on Spotify or YouTube,
SPEAKER_00you will just deal with seeing some of my messy ass room behind me. Think of it as insight into more of who I am as a person. And ain't that really underwhelming? So next up on our docket is Prince Faggot. Prince Faggot, spelled F-A-G-G-O-T. From this point forward, I will be going back and forth between faggot and faggot. If that word is traumatizing or triggering to you, I apologize. But it is indeed the name of the play. Currently playing at Studio Seaview till, I believe,
SPEAKER_00mid to end of December, something like that. After a sold-out run at Playwrights Horizons, the play is by Jordan Tannehill, and the director—I have it in my notes—the director is Shyok Misha Chowdhury. Yes, those are the creatives. Currently starring John McRae, Rachel Crowell, David Greenspan. I had one performer out when I saw it—
Mehir Kumar, he was out the afternoon that I saw, so I saw Keshav Mudliar.
SPEAKER_00And he was very good, I must say. The premise of the play, for those who do not know, is inspired by a paparazzi photo of Prince George sort of in a candid photo looking very objectively fae. And the play begins with all of the actors sitting on the stage, observing the photo and looking at photos of themselves at that age and sort of seeing if they could tell whether it was obvious at that moment
if they were queer
SPEAKER_00or not. And there are some transgender actresses on stage as well. So when we see photos of them as children, they are male presenting in the photos. And it's various degrees of obviousness with each performer of their queerness. and talking about the premise of the play, which is flash-forwarding 20 years, about, maybe 15 years, to Prince George, a little bit older, and what the world would look like for him if he actually were gay.
SPEAKER_00Because I guess from the photo... And the online culture, as well as the premise of this play in general, there is an outcry from people of the queer community sexualizing a young child by talking about his sexuality. And the play's argument at the top, and it goes on for a very long spell at the top of the play, their argument is, isn't the world already sexualizing children at a young age by just assuming that they're straight?
SPEAKER_00And they go on the same arguments that we all have gone on before of, you know, it's weird to ask a six-year-old boy, oh, do you have a little girlfriend yet? And yes, people will claim, oh, we're joking, and it's teasing. It's like, yes, but you are... You are putting a sexual component on them even if you are not talking about the sex itself. Joking about a relationship is the same way as joking about whether he might be gay or not. It's part of who you are. It's part of your DNA. It doesn't necessarily mean that you are sexualizing the child.
And that is the play's argument as it then goes into this alternate universe of
SPEAKER_00what Prince George would look like as a queer young man. And the play then kind of takes certain terms of kink and self-expression and queer identity and status, wealth discrepancy. And the... advertisements for it have definitely been leaning towards the this play is so um
controversial it's so provocative it's so scandalously sexual you won't believe the
SPEAKER_00shit you see on stage and there is some stuff that i was like oh We watched that. There is a fully shown sex scene between George and his boyfriend. The catalyst of the play within the play is George, at about 19 or 20, comes home from uni to introduce his parents to his boyfriend. And he is out.
SPEAKER_00His parents know that he's gay. And their issue with the boyfriend is not the gayness, but rather once he's dating George, he has to be thoroughly background checked and his life doesn't become his own anymore. He becomes a public figure. He gets scrutinized. He has to behave a certain way in public. And there is a burden on him as the years continue with George of The fact that it can't just be about how they feel about each other, but what their duty is to the country as a whole and what it
even means to be a
SPEAKER_00royal or to be in this class of people. And the play also does have fun with some double casting of actors. Again, it is a play within a play. And there is a sensuality to it, and there's a passion to it, and there's an intelligence to it. It felt a bit to me that this play was trying to cover a lot of ground. And when you're covering a lot of ground in a very short period of time, it's hard to really flesh out every topic that you're covering
and flesh out every
SPEAKER_00character that you have. And pardon me one second, I just need to grab my tea. And... In sort of an alternate, an inverse, I would say, of Baker's Wife and of other shows that we've talked about on this podcast, I don't know if Prince Fogote really... delved deeply into all of the subjects it was trying to cover, and if they gave themselves enough time to do that,
SPEAKER_00it's possible they spent too much time on certain moments, on certain topics that felt a little repetitive or stretched out too thin, while other subjects were barely scratched. I didn't find it terribly sexy or sensual or provocative. There is a turn for the kink that the show eventually... dives very deeply into especially with george as he gets older and gets more into a hole of his of depression um when his relationship breaks up
and he spirals out from that and the weight of his obligations as a royal starts to come down on him
SPEAKER_00he spirals with drugs and clubbing and other things, and there is a decent amount of male nudity, which was always welcome on the stage since we've had so much male gaze on the female form. Why not have some male gaze on the male form? But this is all to say that it felt a little bit of pomp and circumstance for not a great deal of meat. Uh...
SPEAKER_00That said, I also think that the play is kind of undervalued right now because I felt that when the show opened at playwrights, it had a very natural, enthusiastic response. And then it kind of took on a life of its own. And As is the case with everything that gets a lot of buzz and becomes successful, there then becomes not a backlash, but a counter argument to it of, oh, it's not as good as people say. Oh, it's not as provocative as people say. And I do think it's not quite as provocative as people say.
I think it is good and I think it's very intelligent and quite funny and a very
SPEAKER_00well cast piece. Everyone in the show is very strong. I did think that John McRae was giving a really phenomenally committed and delightful performance. My personal takeaway, I mean, this is a show that has K. Todd Freeman in it. who mostly plays William, but I believe plays a few other small parts. But David Greenspan, for me, was like the absolute highlight of the company. He plays a servant in the palace.
SPEAKER_00He also plays the royal family's PR woman. He plays a news reporter as well as himself. And every actor in the play gets a moment to sort of break the fourth wall and talk a little bit about their history with sexuality or their comments on the play itself. And it's them as themselves, not as one of the characters in the show. And so one performer, for example, which one is it? Rachel Crowell talks about the scene that we watch of George and his boyfriend having sex and then having a conversation in the nude and sort
of the comfort they
SPEAKER_00have with that. And Crowell sort of talks about her resentment of that scene. And then David Greenspan talks about his relationship to kink as the play does cover it a bit and talks about his realization while talking with a friend one day during brunch about sort of the origins of kink or rather I should say the origins of kink in gay men for the modern age and having a very personal story about it,
SPEAKER_00if not necessarily his own experiences with it. And I thought a lot of that was really good. It didn't always all connect with me. And sometimes it felt a little bit like It felt just similarly connected to the main issue I have the play of covering so much ground, but not enough time to cover all of it and wanting to really express everything almost for fear that someone in the audience might stand up and go, but what about this? And this play kind of wants to be able to beat that person to the punch.
SPEAKER_00And there's no play that's going to be able to cover everything. What the best you can do is focus on a very specific character or storyline or subject and flesh it out as much as you can so that way the audience can be incentivized to talk about it afterwards and have theories and conversations. You don't want to be a piece of Provocation? I feel like I keep making up words that sound right but aren't
totally right.
SPEAKER_00It's like Edward Norton in Glass Onion, the abbreviate, things like that. But when you're trying to be a provocative piece, as this one definitely is, you are trying to rankle some chains and you are trying to make people ask some questions and therefore you cannot cover everything and so you have to sort of let that go but the intelligence and the heart of the piece and the passion of the piece for me is enough to if not win me over make me
SPEAKER_00recommend it as a piece of theater, both as a piece of queer theater and just also as a creative piece. I think it is not as strong as the reviews from playwrights would have you believe, but I also think it is better than its biggest detractors would have you believe. Again, it is very well cast. I really must speak again the high praises I have for David Greenspan. It is stylish. It is reasonably well paced. It does kind of just end.
they're the final performer who gets to speak their monologue at the end again this sort of ties into what i was saying before of issues with some of the monologues the final monologue does not for me connect to the rest of the play it feels very out of left field and it might be the playwright's intention but it wasn't powerful to me because i wasn't quite sure what the point of it was and how it related to
SPEAKER_00the rest of the show other than just the term princess and It's no slight to the actress who is very charming and captivating, but it just it did not feel earned to me. And I was left pondering what, why this? Not in a why this, but like, why this? You know, like questions like why, what, how are all good questions to have when you leave a show?
SPEAKER_00but the tone of which you say it is the difference. There's a difference between like, what was that? And like, what was that? It's just so, you don't want a question to be asked dismissively, you want it to be asked engagingly. And for as many moments of Prince Fogote, where I had questions that were engaging, it is unfortunate that the last 10 minutes for me were questions of slight dismissiveness. But I mean, that's really all I can say about it. I don't have a ton of bold opinions on it.
SPEAKER_00I walked out pleased that I saw it. I also want to be thankful to the house staff. I had bought a Rush standing room seat for it. And I went to my standing section and there appeared to be some unsold seats in the house. And five minutes before the show began, the house staff took us in standing room and put us in house seats. Not house seats like, you know, specialized seats, but seats in the house that were not occupied that evening or sorry, that afternoon. What am I saying?
SPEAKER_00And so I really appreciated that from them. I really enjoyed that policy. They also were doing the yonder pouches, which makes sense. There is a great deal of nudity in the piece, and I'm sure there's a lot of stuff about it. They don't want getting leaked from audience members. And they are very strict about the yonder pouches. They make you do it in front of them. You are not allowed to enter the theater until you do it. So if you're somebody who absolutely refuses to put their phone in a pouch for two hours because, my God, my rights— You know, that's your prerogative.
SPEAKER_00Uh... I don't understand someone who is so offended by the idea of putting their phone in a pouch for two hours while they watch a show. You shouldn't have your phone readily available during the show to begin with. So just put it in the yonder pouch. You're already putting it on airplane mode or powering it off. It's already useless to you until you leave. They're not taking it away from you. They're just ensuring that you can't whip it out to take a photo or someone else cannot. And if that bothers you,
SPEAKER_00I would say that that's an indicator of what kind of person you are. I'm glad that John McRae is here in the States, though, because I saw him and everybody's talking about Jamie in London, and he is a very, very talented man with not an ounce of body fat on him. If you're someone like me, it absolutely does give you a body complex. For everyone else, I hope it doesn't do a damn thing other than make them appreciate the talent that is McRae and admire the body that I'm sure he works very hard to keep.
SPEAKER_00I look at it and I go, well... I shan't be eating for the next two days other than a glass of water. Because I am what? Broken. Moving on from Prince Fogote, I really have nothing else to say. And I feel like I'm going to be spinning myself in circles, trying to pad the time talking more about it. So why don't we move on to Two Strangers, Carry a Cake, Across New York. This is a transfer from the West End. This is a piece written by Jim Barn and Kit Buchan,
SPEAKER_00starring Christiana Pitts and Sam Tutti, directed by Tim Jackson. I had heard relatively strong things about this when it was in London. It definitely had a fan base. Sam Tutti has a fan base from being Evan Hansen in the West End and winning the Olivier Award for it. It was being performed at the ART. It started like an out-of-town tryout. And I had asked someone involved with it. how they felt about it. And they said it was, you know, they were like, it's a good show. But, you know, I think we could maybe shave some time off of it.
SPEAKER_00And I don't think that's going to happen. And I said, OK, well, you know, no harm, no foul. I'm sure I'll enjoy it. And the word of mouth from previews was pretty strong. And so I went. I went with Friend of the Pod, Robbie Ruzzle, who had seen it before, I think in London. Yes, he had seen it in London. And I was ready to be charmed. I was ready to just sort of get swept up in it. The premise of the show, it's on two people. It's a two-person show. Christiana Pitts plays Robin.
a lifelong New Yorker originally from Brooklyn who now resides in Manhattan and
SPEAKER_00works at a coffee shop. And she is doing all of these errands for her older sister who's about to get married in a May-December romance. One of her jobs is to pick up at the airport her soon-to-be brother-in-law's son, Dougal, who is arriving from London. That is Sam Tutti. And Dougal is coming because his father, who he's been sort of estranged from his whole life, has invited him to the wedding. And Dougal and Robin end up sort of spending the day together,
SPEAKER_00the day before the wedding together, partly because Dougal doesn't know anyone else in New York. He's on a budget and he is very much a golden retriever of a boy who... loves everything wants to enjoy everything sees the bright side of stuff is a big movie obsessive and he's and it's his first time in New York so he's very excited and he likes to make jokes about Robin being his cool older aunt even though she's like three years older than him again uh Dougal's father is significantly older than Robin's uh sister and
One of the tasks that Robin then has to do is she has to pick up the wedding cake in Brooklyn and Dougal accompanies her and they take the cake to Manhattan to drop
SPEAKER_00off at Robin's sister. Now, if you want to avoid any more major spoilers, skip ahead like about a minute and I'll get back to sort of talking about the show and I'll do my best as I critique the show slash talk about the show to avoid those spoilers too much. But... We find out that Robin isn't going to the wedding because she hasn't been invited. Her sister won't let her come. And we also find out that Dougal was not invited by his father. Robin's sister invited him because Dougal's father had not
mentioned him to Robin's sister and she found out about him and she didn't want any secrets and she didn't want it to be this like embarrassing blemish on their relationship to anybody.
SPEAKER_00We find out from Dougal that his father left, I think even before he was born, left from England to come to America and would send him birthday presents every now and then and Christmas cards that eventually would stop. But he has this idea in his head of his father being a great guy. Robin breaks the news to him eventually that his father did not invite him. Robin's sister invited him. And we find out that the reason why Robin's sister has not invited her to the wedding is because at some point Robin had had an affair with Dougal's father when he was still with Robin's sister.
SPEAKER_00Uh... She ends up getting invited. The top tier of the cake gets destroyed, but the rest of the cake is delivered. Dougal doesn't go to the wedding. And he and Robin have a sort of connection that ends with Dougal going home. Now, again, someone like a baker's wife... This is a show that very much had been called charming and intimate and, you know, just a glorious bonbon of a show.
SPEAKER_00For me, I wouldn't say charming. I would say cute. I found this cute. I also found it similar to Baker's Wife, rather slight. This is another show that is a little over two hours with an intermission. I do not think that it justifies that length. Not a great deal happens. It is a very episodic show. And in truth, a show like any, listen, any show we talk about, right? We find the flaws when something doesn't work for us.
SPEAKER_00And when something does work for us, we either don't mind the flaws or we look at the flaws differently than somebody else. And, I mean, we're talking to a guy right now whose favorite musical is Carousel, and I see where people have issues with it, but where they come to attack it, I view it very differently, and so I justify it as such. A show like Two Strangers Carry a Cake across New York, which from now on we will be calling Two Strangers, I think that it would be disingenuous for anyone to say that it
doesn't have bumps.
SPEAKER_00Most shows have bumps. But also, because this show relies so heavily on trying to earnestly win you over and make you fall in love with it and its characters, if you were not able to do so, all the things that it's trying to do just seem off. And where I think the show succeeds is first with its two leads. Christiana Pitts is very good as Robin. I had seen her in A Bronx Tale and King Kong. She mostly is the wet blanket to Sam Tutti's Dougal,
who's much more, you know, ebullient. And I actually think that for me, Robin is the more interesting character.
SPEAKER_00She has a more... colorful background her history i think is more interesting her backstory has a lot more uh depth to it i appreciate her current situation with her sister and with the job and i and she's a bit of a killjoy throughout the show but that's also kind of the point is for every time that doogle is so up she's kind of down. And then every now and then she will have a surprising up.
SPEAKER_00Dougal, I find to be on paper an incredibly annoying character. And if it weren't for Sam Tutti, Tutti or Tutti? Because I've watched videos in London where they're like, Sam Tutti. So I don't know if it's meant to be Tutti or Tutti. And they just say Tutti like Tutti in the UK. But I'm going to keep saying Sam Tutti. But Sam Tutti is such a wonderfully talented, charming individual, great stage presence, a great voice, and a really innate sense of comedy.
SPEAKER_00If it weren't for him, I think that this character in the show at large would not work half as well as it does. And I don't think it is incredibly successful as it is. And so without him, I would probably find the show unbearable. But because he is in it, I do find the show bearable. The thing about Robin is for all of the things about her that I find interesting, the way that it comes about throughout the show, they keep teasing in act one things that happened in her past. And, oh, the only person left in her life besides her sister is her grandmother,
who she and her sister used to live with when they were kids and they grew up with
SPEAKER_00her. She basically was like a mom to her. But she she left Brooklyn to follow her sister to Manhattan and she hasn't spoken to her grandmother in two years. And there's no real reason for that. I was asking on the Discord channel if anyone could connect the dots as to why. And there's a song in Act 1 where Robin sings about being happy and like, oh, yes, it would be so easy to be happy and just say that I'm happy and tell my grandma, hey, grandma, guess what? I'm back and I'm happy. And so they were saying, oh,
she hasn't really been happy since she moved to New York and she can't really bring
SPEAKER_00herself to admit that to herself and to her grandmother. And that's why she hasn't been back for two years. To which I said that is a fair argument. I would counter argue that the show does not actually connect those dots directly. clear enough it's it still reads as a plot point that is brought up and then kind of quickly abandoned because we learn from the spoiler alert jump ahead 15 seconds affair that Robin had with Dougal's father
SPEAKER_00That that was a major breaking point with her and her sister. But also it's kind of indicated that her sister has always been a selfish person. And Robin has also always kind of coveted what her sister had. She idolized her. She loved her. And at some point it's possible that those emotions kind of took a wrong turn with Dougal's dad. But also it's never really... I'm not even going to say explained. It's never really explored as to what happened in that scenario. It is teased that Robin had a situationship with a guy.
And she says he could make you feel on top of the world or worthless the next second.
SPEAKER_00But then there's no, again, there's no exploration as to with, spoiler, Dougal's dad, what got her to that moment, why that moment lasted as long as it did. Was it genuine for her? Was it genuine for him? What was the fallout of of this? You know, we we see the result of the fallout, but we don't explore the actual reasons for it because it's a major thing to do to not only have an affair with an with an older man, but one who is engaged to your sister, who you claim to idolize.
SPEAKER_00And then while you try to get back on the good side of your sister, what does that mean with you and this man as you're picking up his son? What does that mean with the son? Because the life will continue when the show ends. So what goes on from there? They also kind of do this very... I won't say like semi-tragic goodbye between Dougal and Robin because he has to go back home now. I remember just watching it going like, I mean, Instagram's a thing. WhatsApp is a thing.
They can still be in contact even if they're not in each other's lives anymore. I also will say for a show that's supposed to be a romance, I did not buy the romance.
SPEAKER_00I bought a friendship. I bought... a connection, but not a romantic one. I didn't see a spark between them so much as an ease. And granted, some wonderful relationships begin with an ease like that, but... I did not get any kind of chemistry leading to what could have been love between Pitts and Tootie, or between Dougal and Robin in general, because the actors have a rapport with each other that works very well, but the characters do not have that,
SPEAKER_00like, will they, won't they. It doesn't even have an enemies to lovers kind of thing. It just goes from... golden retriever and person who's annoyed with said golden retriever to the icicle human melting a little bit the retriever calming down a little bit and then having a fun friendly adventure in the city when it takes a turn for the romantic i just sat there not buying it. And I don't know if that's my own cold heart. I don't know if that's the writing. I also didn't necessarily find the songs to be all that spectacular.
SPEAKER_00They're not bad. This is not a bad score. Like it's got enough catchiness to it. I think the lyrics are actually pretty intricately clever. But I also they would also end and I would often feel like I had felt with half of the score of Baker's Wife. Like there were songs where I went, I don't think that was necessary. I think that's there because this is a musical and they feel they need another song now. And. that's a shame because when the songs do work, even if I wasn't like, oh my God, I can't wait to go home and listen to that one again.
SPEAKER_00I was like, that was a song that made sense. That was worthwhile. I'm glad that it happened. It was well, well done. I also think that the show is very well designed. It's pretty simple set. It's a turntable filled with suitcases of various sizes and different configurations. And of course, as the set spins, And different suitcases will open to create a new location. And I thought that was very clever and well done. When they're sort of at a standstill,
it looks a bit like an apocalyptic airport.
SPEAKER_00But that's when it's at a standstill, which is almost never. Usually it's turning or when it's standing still, something's open to create a location. But when we're in sort of like a no man's land and the suitcases are just there, you're like, huh. It's like if the Cold War continued and nuclear war arrived at LaGuardia. That's sort of just my take on it. Yeah, I'm trying to think of other things to talk about with this show. The truth is, like, again, not a lot...
happens small things happen and and in many ways it's sort of like the whole show is a falling in love montage that you see in a rom-com which i actually talk about in my own play and i swear i'm not plugging my own play but you know in rom-coms
SPEAKER_00like something's gotta give or pretty woman or things like that there's usually a 90 second two minute montage covering you know a certain amount of time where the two characters do a bunch of small everyday things and they go for a walk uh you know on the sidewalk while they eat ice cream and they laugh and one like smushes some ice cream the other one's face or They're reading in bed or they're cooking or they're hanging out with each other's friends. And it's the little things that make them eventually fall a little bit more in love with each other each time until by the end of the montage,
SPEAKER_00we're like, oh, they are fully in love. Two Strangers is kind of that montage for two hours with songs, except that the little moments didn't make me believe that they were falling in love. It made me believe that two lonely people were getting closer, but not necessarily as an almost couple, rather just two lost souls, finding a connection, someone in the world being like, I see you, I care about you, I think you're awesome. And as I part, just know that like, you're awesome and you deserve happiness.
SPEAKER_00And I think that that actually would have been more nuanced and adult. It didn't have to be a rom-com because when it comes to stories about love, all audience members are going to be judging whether they buy the romance or not. And sometimes it can be judged based off of the actor's chemistry. It can be judged off of whether the material itself builds to a moment where you buy the falling in love or at the very least the idea that love could happen. And I, yeah, I just don't find in this show that that's the case.
SPEAKER_00And maybe that is ultimately the the weakness of it that sort of dissipates to all the other elements of the show that make me not love it so much. And granted, this is now a New York Times critics pick. But as we've said before, that means nothing. The overall response to the show was kind of muted positive. It does have its fans and I'm sure it can do well. Tony chances. I think that given how light of a season it is for musicals, we have a best musical nomination in the bag because, again, this is not a
SPEAKER_00bad show. I don't think you can look at the writing and go, oh, this is objectively terrible. It cannot work for you. It didn't totally work for me. But Their biggest crime for me ultimately is that I think it's just overly padded. I don't think that it should be a two-actor. I don't think it should be two hours. Because when act one ends, you're not really left with a lot of questions. There's a sort of spending Dougal's dad's credit card adventure
throughout the city. There's like the hanging question of, oh, why can't Robin go to the wedding?
SPEAKER_00But other than that, there's not a lot of stakes. There's not a lot of tension. So it ends and you go, okay, sure. Yeah, like act two is probably going to be more of the same of this. And the truth is that it kind of is. You need to usually end a first act with something on the line. It doesn't have to be the most dramatic stakes on the line, but something's got to be on the line. And nothing's really on the line at the end of act one of two strangers. It's just sort of like pleasantry. Which is sort of the double-edged sword of this show of just
like constantly
SPEAKER_00pleasant, never really thrilling. And again, I wouldn't even say charming for me. Cute, but slight. Tony chances, though. Again, musical, I think, is a lock. It's a light season. We're looking at four new musicals right now, which means three musicals. nominees, and this one is definitely the better received show between us and Versailles, just objectively. So I think also then score and book are pretty much locks. I think that Sam Tutti is a lock for actor.
Christiana Pitts probably would be a strong contender in Actress as well, just as a nominee.
SPEAKER_00Again, it's a smaller field, but given the amount of material she has and and the mountains she has to move to make a character that ultimately is a killjoy not be a killjoy or rather be a killjoy that we want to watch is very uh well well done Direction, maybe. Small shows like this are always tricky to figure out, and this does have a bit of a spectacle element to it with the
turntable and the
SPEAKER_00constantly shifting set. I would imagine that the design categories are going to kind of miss this one. Again, the set is well used, but I don't know if it's a kind of set like once where The specificity of it is very impressive. And then ultimately the flexibility of it is what's surprising. The flexibility of the set you expect to see.
And while it does have a couple of surprises up its sleeve, it's not overall surprising.
SPEAKER_00a set that makes you go, oh my God, that was ingenious. There are moments where you go, oh, that was clever. But more often than not, you're sort of like, mm-hmm, it's there. So yeah, I guess musical, director, scorebook, actor, and actress are all strong, if not total locks. And then, I mean, if we're going to have any design, it would be probably set and lighting. But again, I don't think so. Maybe orchestrations? I don't know how many revivals this season have new orchestrations. I think Jellicle Ball and Rocky Horror are about it.
SPEAKER_00So we shall see. That's really it for Two Strangers Carry a Cake Across New York. I can't really think what else to talk about with this one. It's the the reveals that they do in act two. are not quite powerful enough for me to feel like they justify waiting so long to get them. And there are other things that just aren't covered that are hinted at earlier on in the show. Similar to Wicked and Wicked for Good,
when you're watching Wicked on stage,
SPEAKER_00a lot happens in Act 1. And a lot happens in Act 2, but very quickly. And not every check that Act 1 writes gets cashed in Act 2 for Wicked, but you're only really given 15 minutes to wait for it. And because it's a lot and it happens very quickly, in the moment, it's a little easier to forgive. Whereas with the movies, there's more time to sit in both stories and a full year to wait in between. So when a great deal of those checks from Wicked, Part 1, are not cashed in Wicked for Good... you can imagine some people getting frustrated.
And for Two Strangers, less happens in both acts and in a much slower clip.
SPEAKER_00So even though it's not a year you're waiting, it's just 15 minutes, you still get a little annoyed, or at least I did, that... Plot points that are hinted at or character moments that are lived in in Act 1 do not really come back to roost in Part 2. Act 2, I should say. There's also a scene in a Chinese restaurant that I thought just went on too long and had a song that I absolutely would have cut. This show also suffers from the thing that a lot of shows suffer. And without saying anything that I feel about Slam Frank,
SPEAKER_00I will say that one thing that it suffers from is multiple endings. The last 20 minutes for both shows start to feel a little endless because you're not sure when the ending is coming because you already thought that the ending was going to happen 10 minutes ago. Something feels like it's building towards a conclusion, and then there's more. And then you're like, okay, maybe this is the one now. But then there's more. And then you stop... expecting the ending to happen and you just sort of sit there going well i guess i'm here for another 40 minutes because there were two times we could have gotten off the road and we didn't and that's always frustrating and i
talked about that with maybe happy ending as well that that being a musical where you're like oh it feels like we're about to end and we didn't oh it feels like we're about to end and we didn't but it's a little less egregious and maybe happy ending the the fake out
SPEAKER_00endings are not as Epic is the wrong word because there's nothing truly epic about Two Strangers, but there are moments in it where it's like, and here is the... Like, here's the really impactful moment that you want to go out on a high on. And they have, like, four of those pretty close in a row before they ultimately end on a much quieter note. And, you know, the same thing is true of maybe Happy Ending and also with Slam Frank. And I just wish that there was a way to kind of pause everything,
go in there with a creative team and like figure out how to not make it feel like false conclusions and let it build to the moment where everything comes to an end. And I think we're past that point now, but that's sort of my biggest issue with it.
SPEAKER_00But that's also just a big issue with most modern musicals these days. I do recommend the performances. I think that they're both really strong. And again, Sam Tutte, if it weren't for him, I think Duke would become a new entry in the most obnoxious characters in musical theater. Because he's sort of the male British version of the Manic Pixie Dream Girl. He is always there to assist the other person and help them better their lives and believe in themselves and... and say things that are like off the cuff,
but charming while also being a little bit annoying.
SPEAKER_00And he, you know, while the show gives him a history and an inner light, so it's not like he just comes out of nowhere in order to serve the main character. Whenever he's on stage, it is always to serve Robin. And there are so many times where he should just go. But because he can't read Social Accuser, because he has no one else to talk to, he just sticks it out and keeps on letting everything be water off at Duck's back. And when they give him a more emotional number in Act 2, which, similar to the Dear Bill number in Operation Mincemeat,
SPEAKER_00it's a very nice number that also goes on... for far too long, where he's having a phone call with his mom back in England. And it's a number that Tutti is able to really live in and get emotional without going overly Evan Hansen about it. And it's nice. But also, again, it doesn't feel totally earned because the Dougal in that moment is not the Dougal we have known. Now, it could be a mask off situation where he is able to let go of the manic pixie dream boy that he has been playing for so long.
But we don't see any indication before this number that it could be a mask. And then once that number's over, he goes back to having that mask on him again. So I think it's meant to be this is who he is and he's having a crisis of faith and then he's able to pull through and go back to being the Labrador he always was
SPEAKER_00meant to be. And I think because Toddy is such a... is it has has lived with this role for so long he did it in the west end as well he's able to wear all of the characters idiosyncrasies on his skin pretty naturally but again that's not for me a quality of the writing that's a quality of the actor and especially of the actor having had so much time to experience the material um Because maybe, you know, if we were seeing an actor doing this for the first time,
SPEAKER_00even if they were as good as Teddy is or talented as he is, because they haven't had a chance to live with it for so long, we would see all the flaws exposed in that role. Yeah. And that's me sounding a lot more critical of the show than I mean to be. While I wasn't won over by it, I don't think it's a bad show. I think that it's a show with fat to it, and I would be interested to see how it works in a different production with different actors, just to see how people would feel about it.
SPEAKER_00But I also don't think that this show is incredible. I don't find this show to be overwhelmingly disarming. Yeah. It's entirely possible also that I've become very cynical in my years of theater going. So it's making me cringe. But... I ultimately want every show I see to be good. I want it to be the one that lifts me out of my doldrums. And Oedipus was that for me. That made me go, oh, fuck, right. This is what can happen when a show is smart,
SPEAKER_00when it is creative, when it is brilliantly acted and knows exactly how much time it has for its story. And shows like Baker's Wife and Two Strangers and Prince Fogote, all I felt had issues of knowing when to leave, knowing if they could go any longer of tone, and also sort of like relying on the vibes that they want an audience to feel to make up for any shortcomings they might have.
SPEAKER_00People forgive a lot with the right vibe. And I would say that Two Strangers wants to give the charm, warm embrace, you know, blanket of a musical vibe. And it doesn't quite do that for me. It's more sort of Elfie's sex cardigan minus the sex. Like, it covers you, but it's thin and it can easily fall off. And that's, I guess, where I'm going to leave it for two strangers. I've got nothing else to say about it beyond that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Stay tuned for Thursday's episode where we do our review of Wicked for Good with a very special guest. After that will be another review episode of Ragtime and Queen of Versailles. And then after that will be the part two of Great Comet with Natalie Walker. I know it's been a crazy time. We're doing the best we can. We're figuring things out. We're This bonus episode is actually an indication of changes that we're making slash, you know, looking back on past seasons for inspiration of,
SPEAKER_00like, where to kind of go forward with. So, yeah, there will probably be more bonus episodes in the future and hopefully episodes that cover specific shows to review and not just doing... Catch up reviews in one big clump because we want to be able to give you guys reviews that you can search and give these reviews enough time soon after I see the show that I can really dive as deep as I can with them and make you feel like you got the full picture on everything.
SPEAKER_00Because I always feel like with these group reviews, I never give the full picture to listeners. But maybe that's a good thing. Maybe it's about giving you guys just enough information to decide for yourselves if you are going to see it or if you can recommend it to someone else. You let me know. If you like the podcast, make sure to give us a nice five-star rating or review on either Apple or Spotify. It all helps with the algorithm. Make sure to join the Discord channel or the Substack if you haven't already. I don't need to pimp out my show for you guys because it's done.
SPEAKER_00It happened. But there will be some pimping of it in the new year. Again, it'll be March, May, and June. I will give specific dates soon enough. I think for our diva this week, I would like to close us out with... It has been a minute. And because she is so good in Baker's Wife, we are going to close out with Kyunzi. In fact, I'm going to close out with a totally legal recording of her metal arc when she did Baker's Wife in Boston, I think like 15,
SPEAKER_0016 years ago, maybe even 20 years ago. I can't recall. But it's a gorgeous metal arc. Surprise, surprise. And I think you all will really enjoy it. So that's it for now. Take it away. Kyunzi. Bye. For me, my Zelda, sing for me until the morning. Set me free, my Zelda, and I'll buy you a price of jewel, and I'll blow you away and walk, and I'll love you for life if you will. Sing for me.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...