Backstage Pass is a special Broadway Breakdown mini-series taking listeners behind the curtain of the Off-Broadway production Marcel on the Train at Classic Stage Company. Across the season, we’ve explored every layer of the process - from producing and writing to design and performance - offering a rare, holistic look at how a new play gets made. This final episode turns its focus forward: what happens after opening night? The GuestsProducers Mitch Marois and Maxwell Beer of Mix and Match Productions return to close out the series. Having shepherded Marcel on the Train from development through its world premiere, they’re uniquely positioned to speak to the realities of sustaining a new work - what comes next, what success actually looks like, and how a show builds a life beyond its first production. Important Links:Mix and Match Productions Time Stamps:00:00 - Introduction to the final Backstage Pass episode and the journey of Marcel on the Train 01:00 - Reconnecting with Mitch Marois and Maxwell Beer post-opening: immediate reflections on the run 03:30 - What defines “success” for a new Off-Broadway production today07:00 - The realities of extending a show’s life: transfers, licensing, and future productions12:30 - Lessons learned from the premiere process and what they’d do differently next time16:00 - Building momentum: how word-of-mouth and critical response factor into next steps19:30 - The long game: developing new work vs. sustaining existing projects23:00 - Producing as advocacy: championing stories like Marcel Marceau’s for modern audiences26:00 - Final thoughts on the future of Marcel on the Train and closing out the series Listener Question What did you think of our first BACKSTAGE PASS series? What did you learn? What do you hope to learn from it in future series? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_02Hello, all you theater lovers, both out and proud and on the DL, and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown and our final episode of Backstage Pass, the premiere season, giving you an insider's look at the goings-on of our fabulous, often infuriating industry. The train has arrived at the station. Yes, we are closing out our journey with Marcel on the train at Classic Stage Company. Written by Ethan Slater and Marshall Paylett, the play tells the true story of Marcel Marceau before he became the world's most famous mime, when he was a young man in Nazi-occupied France helping guide
Jewish children to
SPEAKER_02safety during World War II. In this final episode, we go back to our good old friends over at Mix and Match Productions, Mitch Moroy and Maxwell Beer. Uh, Thanks for our good pal Elaine and the backstage pass she got us, I was able to catch Mitch and Max in their office a few days after Marcel's opening. Try to say catch Mitch and Max. That's really hard to do 10 times fast. Granted, I didn't have the usual equipment, but still, it is fun to hear how a production moves forward after its
world premiere and what
SPEAKER_02plans lie ahead. Yeah, so again, like the equipment we had while recording this was not our usual recording equipment, but it's still solid quality um but you know what judge for yourself let's head on over shall we let's go max mitch it's been a morning already um so here we are it's
SPEAKER_02After opening night, you guys have gone through the hellfire of it all. First of all, how are we feeling? Great. Tired.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I think those are the correct words. Great and tired. Great and tired is about as close to honesty as one can get.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Absolutely. So firstly, when we last spoke, you guys were just about to start rehearsals. And I have no idea what's happened since then. Talk to me sort of from your guys' perspective, from that day we recorded to right now, what the process has been like on your end with this show and sort of what's... Yeah, just the process from first rehearsal to now.
SPEAKER_01I think the... One of the biggest things with a production like this too, because I think last time we talked about it being this is an enhanced production, this is Classic Stage's production, technically, but because we have this amazing relationship with Jill and the team at Classic Stage and with Ethan Marshall and the cast and the designers and everybody, we were much more hands-on and really in the room and really present than I think a lot of commercial producers usually are in a process like this.
SPEAKER_01With that being said, at the end of the day, I think back to from the West Wing, there's the quote, like, let Bartlett be Bartlett. And a lot of what it was was just like, okay, let Marshall, Marshall's gotta figure this out. Ethan's gotta figure this out. Designer's gotta figure this out. We are here to support. We are here to cheer on. We are here to give Uh, give thoughts when asked, uh, and just like be the helpful sounding board because it's such a quick process.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Understanding that when you have a thought or an opinion to trust the collaboration. and the collaboration that you've developed over many years so that you might not have to necessarily bring up that thought in that moment because you trust that the director and the writer and the actor are having those thoughts anyway and so it is a lot of just sitting there and observing and you know when they want to ask your opinion or when you feel like actually this is really important the more silent you are the more
SPEAKER_00Wait, those moments will carry.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's also when it's been great too. Like, thank God there's two of us. Thank God there's a Max and I mentioned this so that like we could make our own eye contact. And when we were both, when I was scared about something or when Max was nervous about something, we could then be like, okay, we've said it out loud. I need to just say this out loud to somebody that I'm concerned about ABC or XYZ. We both know that now is not the time to bring it up. They'll probably figure it out tomorrow in rehearsal or in tech in two days or whatever. But I just need to say it out loud to somebody.
SPEAKER_00Process-wise, the whole thing was incredibly smooth. Something I feel so proud of on the other side is that we really assembled a team. And we as Marshall and Jill and us, everyone. The team assembled... There was not a single asshole in the entire team. There was not a bad seed. There was not someone that caused some toxic rumor to spread. Now everyone's wondering, what is my standing in this company?
SPEAKER_00What do people think of me? It was all love and it was all support from day one that was sincere and genuine. And that lasted the entire time. And I think that also goes to...
SPEAKER_01I was talking to Jill, I was talking to the interim general manager, Heather Shields as well about this, that this is a group that was all so mission aligned. all the designers, all the associate designers, the whole cast, everybody at Classic Stage, I think Marshall as like the captain of the ship, set the tone real well, but also Jill too as artistic director of like, this is the goal for the project here, this is why we're doing this, this is what we're going to make together, and the fact that it's going to be together,
SPEAKER_01and like, everybody's working at scale. You know, everybody, no one here is getting rich off of this right now. So, you know, that can also, that can lead to people being annoyed, that can lead to the long nights being, you know, all this kind of crap. But they, because everybody was so mission aligned from the get go, The vibe was just great. Like it was, even when we got scared, even when we got, you know, shit broke down, the damn benches, like, you know, we did a five alarm fire on like,
SPEAKER_01why aren't the benches coming up and what the hell's going on there? Everybody went into gear, everybody was entirely Game and said yes and and problems got solved with smiles on faces.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, the biggest hurdle that we had was probably a Set issue we were using a little bit of automation in our show with the you know making a train car appear out of seemingly nowhere and You know we realized after our first day of tech rehearsal that the mechanics we were using We're not going to work And that was a real hurdle and a real challenge. And instead of, you know, freaking out instead of tensions rising, We all sat down and we figured out how do we solve this five
alarm fire because it
SPEAKER_00was also an issue of safety. And we had to trust that our set was going to be the safest possible for our actors, for our crew. And we knew we had a dress rehearsal coming up in six days. So we had very limited amount of time. There was a moment where we thought, well, we have to cancel our dress rehearsal and our first preview. But what happens is theater people are generally amazing people and treat each other so well. And we had another scene shop
that does Broadway-level shows come in and look at this off-Broadway-level set and
SPEAKER_00say, hey, what you guys are doing isn't far off from the correct thing. If you just tweak this here, tweak this here, we can make this happen. But we need to see what's in our supply on Monday when the shop opens in order to give you an accurate read of when we will be able to solve the problem. So there was a 48-hour window during our tech rehearsal.
SPEAKER_01We were like, this could be a very simple fix or this could be $100,000.
SPEAKER_00Or this could be us canceling our first week of previews and losing, you know, days and days of audience response before critics come. But also that like solution goes back to Williamstown because we did a workshop at
SPEAKER_01Williamstown in 2024. And Stephen Kaus of Williamstown and now Hudson Scenic, he had been there for the workshops there. He knew the show. Like the theater people family, there's only five people that work in the damn industry, honestly, at the end of the day. And he was willing to step in with his team and his guys and look at what's possible and recognizing what we were trying to do here under the nonprofit ages and all this jazz to like, make it fricking happen. And that is like why we're here today.
SPEAKER_01People stepped up to the plate and believed in the mission. And Marshall did handle all of that so fucking well.
SPEAKER_00Like,
SPEAKER_01yeah, I think one of the things that I'm most impressed by in this whole process was, you know, when something like that occurs, uh, I don't know that I've ever seen a director be as calm, be as like welcoming to suggestion, be as like open and honest and not like I've seen directors flip tables. We've all seen directors, we've all seen artistic directors, we've all seen people behave in ways that no one should, especially when you're the leader.
SPEAKER_01And the way Marshall handled that was like, Fucking incredible. A masterclass. Yeah, truly a masterclass. Yeah. Sorry, we've talked all this into your podcast, dude. Sorry. No, we're just going through our experience.
SPEAKER_02I'm realizing that we've just been like going and going.
SPEAKER_00But there was a moment.
SPEAKER_01Also, this is where video would have been helpful so everyone can know what my face just
SPEAKER_02looked like when you said that. No, this is an interview series, Mitch. And we're doing the interview part. They're reflecting.
SPEAKER_00Yes, if anything,
SPEAKER_02I wish more of my guests, when I do my deep dives and shit, like, talked like this, because there are times when I'm like, so yeah, that thing, and they'll go, mm-hmm. I'm like, would you like to talk? Yeah, would you like to add on to it? Please.
SPEAKER_00There's an and to the yes. Anyway, so you were going to say no. Like, three Mondays ago, I'm standing in our kitchen, and we do not know if we'll be able to have our first preview. And we're minutes away from Hudson Scenic Shop opening and letting us know, do they have the materials in stock? And we look at our phones and we go, oh my goodness, they have it. They've got the clamps that we need. Hell yes, the show can go forward. There is... You know, having now gone through the experience of waiting for reviews
to come out,
SPEAKER_00waiting for the set to be fixed, waiting to, you know, hear what audiences will think after seeing the show for the first time. And we realized while the audience is in the seats that this was the first time an audience had ever experienced the show without stage directions also being read. Yeah, that first, yeah,
SPEAKER_01that invited tech, that invited dress rather was like, yeah, the first time humans had seen it. without it being like under fluorescent lights.
SPEAKER_00And without it being like Vietnam 20 years later, you know, when you have to be like, oh, maybe our storytelling isn't as clear when you're just getting visual cues. Maybe we need something else to help the audience. And that's where a lot of the work during previews started to begin of, all right, where can we clarify? Where can we strengthen and beef up? But also where can we, you know, we had to cut When we first started running the show, we were running at about 1.53. Yeah. And now we're running at 1.39, between 1.37 and 1.39 consistently.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they got 12 minutes from the show from preview one to when they froze it a week and a half later.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I think it was a week and a half of, like, working previews there.
SPEAKER_00Which is fucking insane. Our writers are also, you know, director and actor, so they didn't have until the day off. to really sit down with the script and go, let's fix this. We all knew during that first week of, oh, this moment can be tightened. Do we love these beats? How do we maybe make these four beats into two beats or three beats? Those classic fun puzzle questions, which is why everyone got into making theater in the first place. Uh, and you know, through enough of those conversations, we were able to get the show to a runtime that we felt was
exactly what we promised
SPEAKER_00audiences on the website.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I mean, 15 minutes in two weeks is impressive. There are Broadway shows that shave off five minutes in a month. Yeah, truly. Yeah. I'm, I'm always down for tighter, faster, you know, what was the thing that we said?
SPEAKER_01Um, uh, It was like Smarter, Faster, Sadder. Oh, sure. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We were like, yeah, that's what we're doing.
SPEAKER_02I just like tighter and meaner. That is how I view all the preview process. Make it tighter and meaner.
SPEAKER_00I can keep going. Just like the things that we discovered throughout the previews.
SPEAKER_02Whatever you want to talk about, Max, this is your interview, baby. And I think... We will get to opening night and all that other good stuff.
SPEAKER_01I think the process from... Like, you know, we talked about tech, the process though from, you know, once preview started, the collaboration between us and Jill Rafson and Heather Shields, the interim GM, right now in Classic Stage, the four of us in lockstep, on, okay, what are the, you know, on the GM front, the kinds of things that need to be built, things that need to be fixed, things that need to be adjusted, cool, cool, cool. Also, Heather has a brilliant creative mind, so her input there.
SPEAKER_01Jill, as artistic director, our group chat with the three of us, me, Max, and Jill, just like, yo, I think this, you think that, cool, we're aligned here. If I maybe felt something different, but they feel something, great, cool, two out of three, let's go. And when to talk. about certain things with, uh, with the creatives. With the creatives. Yeah. When to, because also they, that it gets to like Max said, the trust of it all of like we, they, they, they figured a lot of this out without us ever having to say a damn word because
SPEAKER_01these are growing artists at the top of their game. And if you give them the, you know, ability to make cool shit, they will make cool shit. Uh, and they will come up with solutions and they will come up with these things. And so, but then figuring out when, yeah, we've been sitting silent here. When is it, When have we earned the right to say, okay, this part of the thing, we're all really concerned about that. Or this isn't landing, we know what your intention is here. It's not landing the way you think it is for us or for audience. We need to have a conversation about that. And that was a lot of the preview process of watching them
figure stuff out and
SPEAKER_01then stepping in.
SPEAKER_00We knew we had to land the opening of our show. We knew, and tonally especially, because it is a very tricky, you know, World War II piece using a lot of Jewish joy and levity to withstand these situations, which I think is very intrinsic to the Jewish experience. But, you know, in play form, when audiences have been conditioned over many, many, many decades to go, we are seeing Holocaust play. It is heavy. It is deep. We had to really work on that first scene.
SPEAKER_00But in establishing that tone and spending time on that and, you know, the other cuts that went around that, we also realized like, oh, we're not spending as much time paying attention to our ending as we maybe needed to. And so a lot of the second week of previews became, we need to clarify our ending. How are audiences going to take away the central message that we're trying to say? And I think there were, you know, conversations about, oh, are they understanding our rather heady concept?
Does the audience even need to understand our rather heady concept to understand
SPEAKER_00the emotional core of the story, which we all agreed upon was, you know, The ways that people help us through difficult times, even when we may not realize it in the moment, you know, when they're trying to help us. But those lessons throughout time, how those stay with us and how those help us get through the difficult situations. And so trying to distill that central information, that central message, while not...
SPEAKER_00making the show feel like, all right, we've ended once, now we've ended twice, now we've ended a third time. How do we make all of these endings into one cohesive thing? And I think what we landed on is really effective in sort of trying to get the best version of what we were able to do in the time constraint that we have. But it was also one of those things of, great, this is perfect for now and we can't wait to figure out what is
the next version of
SPEAKER_00this, but it's still giving us, getting us the reaction from the audience that we desired. But there was a lot of like, the show ends, the audience isn't applauding. Why isn't the audience applauding? How do we teach the audience to applaud? We're ending the show on a sound effect of a ding. Do we need to end it on a musical note that is the tonic, you know, so the audience feels a sense of resolve. Oh, by closing the doors at the back of the stage, are we making the audience feel, oh, we've traveled too far to a new location.
Now, I feel like we're starting something new rather than wrapping up where we've already been. So it was all these psychological games we were playing to figure out how do we
SPEAKER_00stick the ending of our show. And I think what we have on that stage is something we're really proud of. That was a long rant, but... Well, you guys have been through a lot, and you have a lot of things to say.
SPEAKER_02It's all been built up in here, so this is your avenue. So, opening happened. Reviews have come out. Talk to me about the critical reception, how you guys feel, and then where we go from here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think the reception has been positive. Has been, I would say, vast majority positive. There are people that... don't get the artistic swing that this is. You know, people, the like fundamental DNA of the show of like, we have these adults playing the children. There are certain things that like, if you're not down for some of what we're doing in here, some of the like, the way that the really specifically Jewish humor is woven in,
SPEAKER_01if you're not down for that, then like, yeah, you're not going to like the show. And like, that's okay. We met yesterday with, um, Ethan and Marshall, and that was one of the first things I said to them, was like, reading all of these reminded me, or it was just like a good thing of like, okay, the thick skin of this kind of industry where I, people won't necessarily understand what we're doing because this is a big artistic swing. This is someone non-linear. We are asking an audience to really buckle up and join us on a
very specific
SPEAKER_01artistic, capital T, theater with an RV ride. And if you're down, hell yeah. If you're not down, oh, the show's not for you.
SPEAKER_00That's okay.
SPEAKER_01That is 100% okay. But... What we've all been saying this entire time for the last few years over developing it too is that the majority of audiences will be down for the ride. And I think that actually manifests itself in the reviews. The vast majority of the reviews, even when it's, you know, a mixed positive review, there's notes of like, okay, we, you know, there's useful things about like, okay, clarifying Marcel's art. or, you know, tone things that, yeah, we are excited to, you know, cool, look at. And also, you know, they had two weeks of tech, or one week of tech and two weeks of preview,
SPEAKER_01so they just need to, like, settle into their show and figure out what the tone is still. There's a lot of stuff like that that I'm excited for the cast to explore over the next month of the run. But the vast majority of the reviews were either, like, wow, I totally get what you're doing here. This is giving me the kind of joy that I was hoping for. This is giving me, I got the tension of this scene. I got all of that. Or, ooh, not for me. The majority, the minority of reviews that were like, ah, this is, I don't like the, I don't like this kind of thing in a lot of ways.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It was like, actually, I thought validating.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. There seemed to be a little bit of like, not an education problem, but it was just like, all right, you're not picking up what we're putting down and, We had some of our mentors come during previews and, you know, it was something that we knew we were taking a big artistic swing and it was something that throughout the preview process that I was very nervous and aware of, of this won't be everyone's thing and maybe critics will respond to that. And I think some of them certainly did and others,
you know, are looking for, I, you know,
SPEAKER_00A common occurrence has been, you know, by using flash forwards, you know, we're diffusing the tension of do the kids live or do the kids die? And, you know, that's something that artistically we fundamentally disagree in because just because you see one flash forward doesn't necessarily mean that they all live. And also, you know, just because we're using humor, which we know works in other mediums like Jojo Rabbit, you know, doesn't mean that it doesn't work in this context just because
it maybe didn't
SPEAKER_00resonate with that, you know, with that critic. I also, I think it's a special torture that I wish on my enemies in the house, like classic stage where as a producer, you're able to see every face in that theater. If you look around the house while you're sitting in there, And so we had the experience of watching critics very visibly watch our show and, you know, have their thoughts. And that's an exercise in restraint and in believing in your show.
SPEAKER_00And the mentor said, like, this is a swing. This won't be for everyone. And hearing a mentor say that was unbelievably comforting. Because I don't know about you, Matt, we grew up loving musicals, loving a lot of down the middle, something that's commercial, something that does appeal to the masses. And to be part of making something that may not be that, that may be a bigger swing, is incredibly vulnerable and is incredibly scary. And because this is the first time,
it feels a lot bigger than maybe the second or third or fourth time will feel.
SPEAKER_00But... Overall, like, net positive, do we wish, you know, we got, like, in full blatant terms, do we wish there was a critic's pick that said, go to Broadway, the doors are open, pick any house you want? Sure, that would make our lives easier. But also... But also, would it even? Would it? No.
SPEAKER_01Like, actually, would it? No. You still have to... No. I think the elephant in the room with that is a New York Times critic's pick
SPEAKER_02doesn't do shit anymore. Because you have to see who's writing for them.
SPEAKER_01Well, I...
SPEAKER_02I don't know that I agree with that, necessarily. I think for off-Broadway, it can help, but you look at the last couple of critics' picks that closed on Broadway within a month or two. That's what I mean. Because of how frequently it's been thrown about, there have been plenty of shows that have found Broadway success without a critics' pick, as well as shows that haven't had success with it. So I hear you about that. What I want to ask you guys, and I'm going to ask this to everyone else involved in the other episodes, in regards to reviews, When you're reading a criticism,
SPEAKER_02how do you differentiate between this doesn't really apply to us, they don't get it, or, oh, that's actually a really good point. And like, we should internalize this for later.
SPEAKER_01I think there were some reviews that Like if there was, I can think of two reviews that had truly nothing that they could find that they actually dug in the show that they actually liked in it. And to me, that's just like, oh, cool. Put that aside. To me, that's like, that's a we're not for you. Yeah, we're not for you. And like, that's okay. There's not a ton to learn from that. If you can't find anything that you liked in it, that's nothing really to do. Then there are some reviews that, the reviews that are just like, all auditory and all everything.
SPEAKER_01I also kind of put that aside. Like that's great for marketing. That's great for pull quotes. That's like, there's nothing to learn from that so much besides like, Oh, it worked for you. Uh, and like, that's really cool. Um, the, we maybe got like, we got a couple reviews where, um, they were positive and then like talking about like Marcel's arc could be clearer or some things like that to take away from it. But then there are some reviews that are just like, Oh, you're giving me a book report. And you're not really giving me an actual opinion. You're not really giving me anything to grow with. You're just kind of saying things and maybe you're just kind of cynical.
Yeah, what you really start to pick up on are who are the critics that want us to succeed?
SPEAKER_00Even though you didn't love the show, you know, you can still write about it as if you want it to succeed and offer insights that are valuable to the creative process going forward. And I think, you know, we're discerning people that mostly got liberal arts educations that work in the arts that, like, I think you can read a review and pick up on, you know, who is rooting for you and who just could give less of a crap and the people who don't care. Great. Amazing. Not for you. No resentment.
SPEAKER_01But Matt, I think, because, like, you write a lot of reviews. Like, us as producers coming from it, like, you know, yeah, my favorite reviews are the ones where, like, A reviewer takes the time to give genuine, honest feedback, genuine, honest critique, free of cynicism. You've started making a name for yourself with your reviews, and you're famous for a snarky quip. When we say that that's the kind of stuff that we like to see,
SPEAKER_01how does that resonate with the way you go into writing a review? That, okay. I'm interested.
SPEAKER_02Snarky is a trigger word for me. No, just because that's like the word that a lot of people have used against me in the past. I never actually thought of myself as snarky. I can be a bitch sometimes if I see a show that I thought wasted my time. There have been shows that I thought were bad.
SPEAKER_03That's a difference.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there have been shows that I thought were bad, but I'm not an asshole about it because I'm like, you know what, you tried something, I think you didn't do a good job with it, but like, Better than the doubt, everyone here is trying. Yeah, exactly. It's usually only after the fact that I'll get a little bitchier. I've said this before. I tried to be very fair to a show like Lempika that I did not think worked. The creative team's response to the critical reception after that made me a bigger bitch about it.
SPEAKER_00Sure.
SPEAKER_02Because I was like, fuck you guys for that. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That is so true. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02I was like, no, no, no, no, no. Now I'm going to be mean. Yeah. I thought that something like Back to the Future was a perfectly adequately made show, but because I thought it was so lazy, I got mad, and thus I was an asshole about it. So that's me. When it comes to, I go into every show I see, because I don't think of myself as a critic, I think of myself as a fan,
SPEAKER_01and as somebody who- I think that's the difference. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And also, I've worked on shows, I've been in shows, I'm still working on and being in shows sometimes, so I don't look at this as, I'm a failed actor, writer, director who's doing this because he can't do anything else. I'm still getting work in that field and I don't want to piss anybody off, but I also want to be honest. So I go in and I try to think, what is it that they're trying to achieve? Is that clear to me? Do I think they succeeded that? That's the first question. Then did I like it as second? Cause then sometimes there were shows that I think aren't really that successful, but somehow they worked for me.
SPEAKER_02And I made that differentiation or shows from like, usually it's plays where the musicals from like, they did what they set out to do. Not for me, though. And that is sort of, I think, the difference for a lot of critics. Let's say I saw Marcel, because I still haven't seen it yet, because you guys are very well sold. If I were to see it, and I were to go, They figured out what they want. It works. It's not my kind of Holocaust show because that's the other thing is everyone has their view of what a Holocaust story should be. For some people, it's zone of interest. For some people, it's life is beautiful and there's no in between.
SPEAKER_02And so if I were to write that review, I would write it in that way that you would say, like it would say not for me, but I would explain all the ways in which it is successful as what it does. And hopefully that would be helpful for you guys. if I were to see something that I thought didn't work, I would explain all the ways why I think it doesn't work. And then sometimes offer, uh, reasons. Uh, I have a review on the podcast for boop where I literally like go down in a bullet list of like all the ways in which I personally would fix poop. Um, yeah. Smash too.
SPEAKER_01But, uh, those are our favorite reviews as a producer for any one's show. That's what I want to see. Like as an industry, we all, I'll be honest. Like, industry-wise, like, whenever we're texting folks or seeing folks out, like, when a review comes out that is particularly cynical against a project, it, like, all we then sit and say is, like, this just isn't good for us as an industry. Like, if we as an industry and if our critics can't, like, at least go in rooting for a project in the same way that,
SPEAKER_01like, We have auditions today for a different show. And casting directors always say, every actor that goes in for that audition, they are rooting for you to succeed. I go into a show rooting for it to succeed. And I don't know that every critic that we've got goes into projects rooting for them to succeed. But that's also like matter here or there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's always been the case. I think that's especially the case now because things get more traction when they're negative. You see that on TikTok, you see that on YouTube. Like all the YouTube video essays, the ones that are more popular are the ones that are like, the 30 reasons why Bridgerton is awful. Like it's that kind of stuff rather than like the 10 reasons why Bridgerton works. So I feel that to my bones. But also, yeah, I mean, I... when I'm talking about a show and also like people can give or take whatever I say, but as somebody who also writes,
SPEAKER_02I'm like, no, by all means, like come up with an idea for me, please. I'm exhausted. Like give me something. I may not agree with that, but it might inspire a different idea.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's what, yeah. But something actually you said, uh, that is, I think actually really interesting for where we're at right now with this one, uh, that the show is really well sold. Like, as you say here, there are, you know, Like a couple dozen tickets. Yeah. That's it. And that's really exciting. And so from like the classic stage perspective, this is a smash hit. This is, you know, box office doing incredibly well. Everything that this show needs to do for the nonprofit is doing it. Yeah. And now as Max and I and the rest of Dean look like, you know, Max and I have the kind of the years of whatever the hell comes next.
SPEAKER_01I see this next month of run as we're establishing a brand. so that audiences can start understanding what the hell this is. Now we have pull quotes. We have ways to educate an audience that we didn't have before and to educate the industry on a broader sense too. People know about the show and we're very lucky and grateful for that, but a lot of people don't still. And so how do we start using this time that's left because it doesn't have to be used for selling tickets at Classic Stage, which is kind of cool of like,
SPEAKER_01what are we putting out there? What is the messaging that is going out there to establish and build a base brand here for whatever we can build as a next? And we also acknowledge it's, you know, we have less than a month of a run left.
SPEAKER_00You know, we close in less than a month. So we really like getting people in trying to establish this brand is a sprint. Like I know we just got to opening night, but something I'm starting to realize also, because I, you know, we're at the show most nights, especially during previews, we'll be there every night. And even when you're not expecting to see someone is exactly the moment that you'll see a very important person there that, you know, you have to turn it on and you have to talk to them and you thank them for coming to the show and you want to get their thoughts and all of that.
SPEAKER_00You know, we had a co-producer come to the show you know, just kind of buy themselves a ticket and come in one afternoon and thank God one of us was there. So we could say, thank you so much for being here. Thank you so much for your support. So even though, you know, the hard part of getting the show up and running is done, now it's about the planting the seeds for the next step, which is a very active role for us. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. We're starting, um, Yeah, so like as we sit here from a business perspective. Last week we met again with the commercial general manager that we brought on as like most, they helped negotiate the contract around us working with Classic Stage and stuff. And we said, okay, cool, now we need to really start figuring out could this be, what would this look like on Broadway? And start putting around, start figuring out what the parameters around that would be. And the first thing that you have to do with them is launch into a first class deal.
SPEAKER_01When we say first class, that is a Broadway deal. First class is used also for all of your actor listeners. They'll recognize that too as what is a first class tour versus a second class tour. The first national tour of a Broadway show will be a first class production as well. Broadway is first class. What we're doing, if you're doing a commercial off-Broadway, that would be second class. The third year of your national tour could be going second class in terms of the size of the theaters, in terms of the
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the length of the run at each. Yeah, yeah, all that jazz. But like now, so we're in this like developmental agreement with our general manager. which is great. But now we want to like start building and seeing what could be possible. So great. First thing we got to do is enter our first class agreement. And the first thing we said to them was like, I've never signed a first class agreement with the general managers. And thankfully these general managers are really awesome. They were like, cool, we hear you. Here's what this looks like. Here's how, you know, what this would mean. They're willing to meet us with,
you know, the funding of it and the paying of all that.
SPEAKER_01But it's, you know, we spend the next six to eight weeks of, okay, what are the different scenarios? How could this work? How long a run would it need to be in order for investors to make some money back and all that jazz. Try to figure it out and try to meet with the theater owners. A lot of them have already come to see the show, which is exciting. They're buying their tickets still, which is exciting. And see if there's a home here in New York. Explore London too.
SPEAKER_01you know, see who we can get in to see the show this month, but we'll also have the archival and all those things and put together some numbers based off of what a London, whether it's, you know, at a place like, you know, Chocolate Factory or, you know, West End run or things like that, so that we can have those educated conversations about like, okay, maybe it's not Broadway first, maybe it is a London run as a next step, but spend a lot of time and a lot of work building all of this out so that as, you know,
SPEAKER_01you have all of these meetings and you see what strike's going first, you're ready to just, like, boom, activate it and go. But that's the next six weeks? Yeah. Like, it's a very active six weeks. Six, eight, I mean, like, that's the next, like, three months. Yeah. I've just, like, figured, like, I feel like by the time we get to, like, end of May, early June, I will have a sense of, like, what... feels like the feasible next step. Maybe not concrete exactly what it is,
SPEAKER_01but I feel like a couple of doors will have shut, maybe some new ones will have opened. We have three months of just fact-finding, gathering everything, and just making sure we're prepared for all of the options that are out there. So you would say then the rest of this off-Broadway run is about getting in as many
SPEAKER_02people into the show as possible, collecting as much data as possible so after the fact you can do an examination and get, as you said, get those pieces together and figure out by end of May, early June, the next phase.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, I would argue, I would argue it's not about, it's about getting the people in now, but doing all of that while they're coming in too. Sure. It's really building the plane while you're flying it. Yeah. Um, uh, because shows oftentimes wait too long. Uh, uh, that is something we see all the time and more so with like out of town tryouts of shows where like the show will like do their out of town and then like it ends and they're like, okay, great. what now? And we don't want to fall into that trap. You know, we took a big swing by having the world premiere of this off Broadway. And, you know, there's only a few upwardly mobile ways to move the show.
SPEAKER_01But there are a lot of like lateral or downward ways to move the show. So, you know,
SPEAKER_02Yeah, figuring it out. Is there anybody else at the table with you guys with these decisions while you think about the next steps? Is it mostly you two?
SPEAKER_01Well, we're the lead producers on this. Max and I, Mix and Match Productions, as of right now, we're the only lead producers on this show. Would we love to share the burden, to share the heavy weight of the crown with somebody? Potentially. As long as we're all artistically aligned and aligned also commercially on what this could be. We see this as a... toolbox of a show we see this as probably a limited engagement you know we see we see it as a solution to the theater owner's problem of i have the fall i have a
show booked in the spring but i don't have anything in the fall what can i find for
SPEAKER_0020 weeks in this theater and because we've developed this show on You know, pretty cheaply like we have the ability to insert for those 16 to 20 weeks and create a business plan that can recoup and that is feasible. So we're really excited about that. But that also means anything we do next can't be, you know, at the expense of our development costs because that's going to make it that that other step. that much harder we have the potential to come out of this with
between five and six hundred K encumbered on the show when I say encumbered I mean like from the time that like Max and I first optioned this piece four years ago to getting
SPEAKER_01through the closing of this world premiere there will have been, you know, $500,000 to $600,000 spent. Which is on the low end for shows.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Like, that is incredibly low, you know, there are you know some musicals come into broadway with four and a half million dollars encumbered on them uh even new plays uh uh one to two yeah sometimes you know they're starting you know fully commercial at like you know a la jolla or something like that no we were very lucky in uh the deal that we were able to get with classic stage um to make it happen and again it comes to that mission alignment of like No, you guys, we have a plan about a mime in the Holocaust.
This needs to be built cheaply and artistically excitingly within a very confined sandbox.
SPEAKER_01That's the kind of artistic swing that this needs to be. Not throw, you know, 10 million fucking dollars at it, at this, you know, at this level of it and, you know,
SPEAKER_02turn it into something massive. Julie Tamar found dead. No, I love that. That's fantastic. Do you guys have any closing statements? Because this will be, I think, the final episode of this series. So, yeah, I mean, no pressure. But whatever you say is how everyone's going to feel about this show forever and ever and ever. And will also be a statement on your legacy specifically next.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good, good. I, like, the one thing that comes to my head is just how freaking proud I am. of the entire company and of the show and that as a team, we all took an artistic swing and based on what I feel and the feedback that we've heard, it is a swing that is one cohesive vision from the directors to the producers, to the designers, to the writers, to the performers. We are telling one story and we're having a fricking blast and
how lucky are we.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. If Nothing else like we've had this moment in the woods.
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01Max and I and this entire team, you know I I feel in my bones that this deserves to be seen on a bigger stage by more people I feel like the story is important and the art that we're making is important There's so much out of our control when it comes to making that a thing and I'm so excited to do the work to try to make that happen. The reality, though, is more likely than not that it won't.
SPEAKER_01Shows try to get to Broadway every day. And if we are able to make this a Broadway play, it will be not just a small miracle, but a major miracle. Any show that gets to that stage, it is a miracle. So many things had to happen. So many things had to happen. So many people had to believe So many doors have to be opened at the exact right time. It's beshared, right? Like, it has to be that. That's meant to be everyone, in case you didn't know.
SPEAKER_01Yes. If we are lucky enough to have that happen, great. If it's not in the cards, then this was the best moment in the woods. Like, this has been fucking magical. I'm so incredibly proud of Max and I, I am so incredibly proud of this creative team. And if this is it, if this, if, you know, we do all this work and we close at the end of March and beyond that,
the work Max and I do to try to make something happen doesn't succeed the way that
SPEAKER_01we sit here and are dreaming about, then the thing that's coolest to me is that the artistic relationships that we're walking away from this, I have no doubt that every single designer on this team, the associate designers, Classic stage team, Marshall. Like, all of us, we're all going to keep working together. And that you can't say on every project. That, like, again, this is, like, truly a small miracle of a thing where, like, oh, we all actually like each other. We all respect each other. And everybody here is a brilliant fucking artist. And we're excited for what could come next, whether it's this or whatever.
SPEAKER_01Like, that, to me, is one of the biggest victories out of all of us.
SPEAKER_00To yes and Yoruba share it, I would also say Daifa. You know, like, Dianu, it would have been enough. You know, at every step, Dianu.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Well, I don't have anything snarky to say. It's hard to follow that up. It's hard to follow Dianu about some snark. I had something, and then you guys kept talking. And so I was like, well, I won't go back to my quip. We'll leave it at that. So thank you. We've got a lesson. Thank you, Mitch. Thank you, Max. Everybody, I've This has been a really exciting series on the podcast, and I hope you all enjoyed it as much as I did. And yeah,
we look forward to having more of these and hearing more about Marcel on the Train,
SPEAKER_02as well as more from Mix and Match Productions. So yeah, you know what? Even though this is a different kind of series, I think we will close out the whole thing as we normally do on Broadway Breakdown, which is you close out with a nice big Broadway deed, but a play out in your outro. Max, Mitch, Who would be a nice Broadway diva?
SPEAKER_00Mitch and I have a deep and strong love of Shoshana Bean. So if there is, even if it's, you know, maybe it starts with me from Mr. Saturday Night or any other Shoshana Bean song.
SPEAKER_01I think we can do better than Mr. Saturday Night. Can I give you a quick epilogue about Mr. Saturday Night? Sure. There we go. So Max and I, we have Mix & Match Productions. We also help run the office of Ruth and Stephen Hendel. When it came time to vote for the Tonys, that year when Shoshana was finally nominated for Mr. Saturday Night. It's an online portal to vote for the Tonys. and we were doing it together, and it came time to vote for her category,
SPEAKER_01and you know, we talk, because Ruth sees everything, you have to see everything as a Tony voter. Some Tony voters don't. Ruth really is so fucking good about that, and we go with her, and we have really honest discussions about everything there, and who it should be, et cetera, et cetera. When it came to her category, Ruth had some opinions. Ruth had some thoughts. And I was like, Ruth Hendel, I've been working with you for X amount of years by now. Shoshana Bean is finally nominated for a goddamn Tony Award. And if you do not let me sit here at this computer and click her name and press submit, I don't know if I can continue working for you. This is a seminal moment in my life.
SPEAKER_01And we have to be a part of this for her. And I gave her an idea monologue down here. And she's like, Okay, fine, vote for her.
SPEAKER_02She also was lovely in the show. I'm just trying to think of a song for Shoshana that's a little more Shoshana than Saturday Night. Bless the Lord My Soul from That God Spell. I don't know. Let me see who I know from... lost boys who can send me a boot from her.
SPEAKER_01Oh yeah, she can have some nice songs in that actually. I hope so. I hope she does.
SPEAKER_02Great, fantastic. No, I'm, I'm, I'll, well, we got, we got Shoshana. Yeah, if you've got a concert version of her, I can do better than that with JRP.
SPEAKER_00That's it.
SPEAKER_03Like, that hits.
SPEAKER_00So hard. It's really nice.
SPEAKER_02I'm sure we have a bootleg of that somewhere.
SPEAKER_00We do. We do.
SPEAKER_02Everyone's got a bootleg of her singing that song somewhere. Okay, so we'll close out with a Shoshana. Most likely J.R.B., but probably not Mr. Saturday Night. That's fair. I digress. I digress. So take it away, Shosh. We'll see you later. Bye. Alright, that is it for this first season of Backstage Pass. I want to thank Mitch and Max and Jill Rafson and Ethan and Marshall plus Lorenzo, Brandon, Jill and Sarah for their time and their insight. I want to thank all of you for tuning in today and throughout the whole series. And I want to thank our friends Paola and Fred and Beatrice,
Isaiah and of course Elaine for getting us these super exclusive Backstage Passes
SPEAKER_02today. We'll be doing more of these in the future, do not worry. But in the meantime, We're going to continue with some more tradish breakdown episodes, reviews, Tawny Ward's coverage, some more deep dives, Q&A coming up. So, yeah, stay tuned. Thanks, guys. We'll see you soon. Bye. Bye.
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...