Matt Reviews: JOE TURNER'S COME AND GONE & THE BALUSTERS
52 minAudio
Matt takes on two plays operating at very different registers: a revival of August Wilson’s Joe Turner’s Come and Gone and the sharp, contemporary satire The Balusters. One is a richly layered American classic exploring identity, history, and spiritual belonging; the other, a biting ensemble piece dissecting privilege, power, and social performance. Matt unpacks how each production handles tone, acting, and directorial vision - plus whether either has the momentum to factor into this year’s Tony Awards race. Important Links * Broadway Breakdown Live!: Green Room 42 Tix * Broadway Breakdown: Discord * Broadway Breakdown: Substack * Broadway Breakdown: Youtube Timestamps * 0:00 - Intro + Drama Desk noms Joe Turner’s Come and Gone * 9:40 - Recap and Review * 30:14 - Tony Awards outlook for Joe Turner’s Come and Gone The Balusters * 31:50 - Recap and Review * 48:43 - Tony Awards outlook + comparison between both shows Listener discussion questions * What makes a revival of a classic like Joe Turner’s Come and Gone feel urgent and necessary today? * How far can satire push discomfort before it risks alienating its audience, as in The Balusters? This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bwaybreakdown.substack.com
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Broadway Broadway We've missed it so We're leaving soon And taking June To star her in a show Hello all you theater lovers both out and proud and on the deal and welcome back to Broadway Breakdown a podcast discussing the history and legacy of American
SPEAKER_00theater's most exclusive address Broadway. I am your host Matt Koplik the least famous and most opinionated of all the Broadway podcast host and it is our second to last review episode it's going to be a little bit of a quickie one today despite the fact that it is technically two shows that we are recording um we just have a lot of stuff going down and I want to get sort of the nitty-gritty of it all and really you know get to the meat for y'all since um I've been known to talk a little much on this podcast a couple little bits of business we should get into first off
SPEAKER_00The last review that we read on the podcast, it got cut off right before the final sentence, and the lovely individual who wrote the review said, I don't know why that my King of Versailles five-star review got cut off, but the last sentence was simply, Dear Matt, don't you dare take vacations from us? But I need vacations. It's what keeps my skin so glowing, which if you're watching this on YouTube, you'll know that my skin, she's glowing. You never guessed it on 57, right?
SPEAKER_00Look at this, taut, firm, and nice and pale. Next up, we actually have another new review that we gotta read, so let's quickly cue up the light and the piazza overture, please. This is from Always a New Yorker. Five stars, informative and entertaining. I eagerly await new episodes each week, especially when Matt does reviews, like this one, and deep dives, which you will get back to when the Tonys are over. I moved away from New York several years ago Matt Koplik Matt Koplik
I know his information is credible oh and the sass and fun personality are an added bonus for listening thank you Matt your devotion is appreciated heart emoji thank you always a New Yorker I appreciate your appreciation and yes indeed we are quite
SPEAKER_00sassy here Next up on the agenda we have a couple of bits of Broadway news fun fact it's been officially announced Evita starring Rachel Zegler coming in next spring of the Schubert Theater to be announced now what Schubert Theater will that be who's to say but it seems like it's going to be the Winter Garden but we're going to hold our tongue about that officially right now it's just allegedly until they say a little something something about that so that's exciting we're going to be Matt Koplik
SPEAKER_00The rumor right now is The Majestic, but we'll see about that. So that's three. Damn Yankees has been announced. And then there are rumors that after the Tony Awards, they will announce Next to Normal with Casey Levy. So we'll see about that. And if that's true, then we're going to be munching, munching, munching really nicely. They also announced the new season for the public theater, at least leading up through the winter, which includes... The New York premiere of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button seems like they're going for the Girl from the North Country route of doing an off-Broadway run which
SPEAKER_00will most likely sell out. If it gets good reviews, if word of mouth is strong, they will move it to a Broadway theater that spring which is very exciting for them. and I do have it on very good authority that Paddington will announce their Broadway transfer around the time of the Tony Awards so that's next season's already shaping up quite nicely we also have Drama Desk nominations that came out today on the day that we're recording this and similar to Out of Critics Circle and Drama League y'all you ask how does this affect the Tony Awards race the bottom line is that it doesn't
SPEAKER_00You know, we had a couple of shows that weren't eligible for Drama Desks this season, like Liberation, like Cat's Jellicle Ball, like Titanic. I mean, elements of those productions were eligible, like, you know, new designs or staging or certain performances that weren't from the off-Broadway runs. So for like Titanic, Leighton Williams is nominated because he was not eligible for the off-Broadway run. He's new to the Broadway production. For Cat's Jellicle Ball, they were nominated for costumes and set and I believe sound? Maybe?
SPEAKER_00No. Wigan and Hair. And then they were nominated for choreography because even though a lot of the choreography is actually quite similar to off-Broadway, it's a new space. So a lot of it had to be reshaped for the proscenium house. So it is technically speaking new choreography. So they were eligible. Other shows did quite well Ragtime did pretty well Chess got a revival nomination and Nick Christopher got a nomination which ultimately just continues the narrative that I've been saying of best actor in a musical we got four slots and five I mean Casey Levy once again kind of just keeping the good
times rolling uh I don't think she was nominated to the Outer Critics Circle she might have been I can't
SPEAKER_00recall um but yeah I mean it's just it's a different voting body it's a different nominating body it's same thing as Drama League and Outer Critics Circle uh
Off-Broadway is eligible as well as Broadway so there's cross-pollination with those nominees really Mexodus and Bo the Musical were really the big nomination winners today for the Drama Desk which more tells you that whatever the Tonys shape up with new musicals however those nominations roll out people in New York are not
SPEAKER_00really thrillingly motivated by any of them Each show has its fan base, but there's no groundswell of support for any specific one like there was for, say, maybe Happy Ending last year or Kimberly Akimbo or things like that. So these nominations, again, they don't really matter. There's no overlap in... voting bodies this is once again not like the Oscars where precursors can matter because SAG aka the Actor Awards has a nominating body that also nominates for the Oscars and also votes for the Oscars BAFTA has nominating
voting bodies that vote for the Oscars as well as does the Directors Guild as does the Writers Guild Golden Globes don't really but they can give you sort of some momentum so all the um Dramadesk and Autocritic Circle can really do is provide opportunities for people to win and give speeches and help propel their campaign as they head towards the Tony Awards but even that doesn't always work out um I talked about this two seasons ago right that was no three seasons ago 2023 was the
year when Sean Hayes
SPEAKER_00won for Goodnight Oscar because um uh Steven McKinley Henderson was nominated for Between Riverside and Crazy and I was in the room for the Drama Desk Awards I was in the room for the Drama League Awards and when he was announced at the Drama League Awards he did not win Annalie Ashford won but when Henderson was when his name was announced as the nominees on the on the dais he got by far the loudest applause and the longest applause and and there was really such support for him and then
at the drama desks he won and again in the room it was just it was so powerful and I thought like oh my god I think I think he really could win people really want to see him win and
SPEAKER_00then Sean Hayes won And so that's there's no real tangible way to figure out where the wind is blowing with these awards. They're fun. They're nice little pre-Tony nominations and awards. and they can give you sort of a bit of insight into like how some bodies in New York are feeling but also like outer critic circle drama desks they will throw random curveballs in there like they really drama desk it's like I think eight or
SPEAKER_00nine nominators it's a small body again like we're talking like a seventh the size of the Tony nominating committee they really loved seat of our pants not the case for a lot of other people so here we are moving on we have two shows we have to review today the second Broadway revival of August Wilson's Joe Turner's Come and Gone and the premiere of David Lindsay Abair's The Balusters which is at Manhattan Theater Club I'm going to start with Joe Turner's Come and Gone going to the
balusters and then we're going to wrap things up on the quicker side today so y'all can discuss on either Discord or Instagram or Substack if you have any other questions or things that I didn't cover or even on YouTube Joe Turner's Come and Gone I should start up
SPEAKER_00front with saying that unfortunately my Opinion on this production is a little corrupted because I had the worst audience experience I've ever had on a Broadway show I've definitely read about people having terrible audience experiences on Broadway and I have for sure had my experiences that have been annoying when I was at Oedipus you know it was an older crowd and there were definitely one or two cell phones that went off at the most inopportune times and Studio 54 has a hardwood floor so cell
phones dropping out of
SPEAKER_00people's coats were would hit the floor at in opportune times but it overall was still a respectful audience even if we are living in an age where people are just so fucking stupid people have the most knowledgeable opinions they claim about politics or gender or whatever and then when they get to a theater they don't know how to turn their phones off they go oh I'm just a sexy little baby I don't know how to do this bitch you know how to do this my 102 year old grandmother knows how to turn off her cell phone and she knows
that she needs to turn off her cell phone before she goes to see a Broadway show so what is your goddamn excuse you don't have one you don't want to have one um but this is to say Joe Turner's come and gone this audience was on another level from a year
SPEAKER_00Yes, cell phones going off. I counted up to 13 cell phones going off in act one alone. I stopped counting in act two because I was really trying to focus, but it was so egregious. People also just taking out their phones to text, to take photos of the stage. People were consistently late. I think by the time the last person I saw enter the theater, we were at like the hour mark of the play. People talking throughout the show. There was a gentleman who got out of his seat to sit in the aisle so he could watch the show more comfortably. He got reprimanded and had to go back into his seat. People eating, people moving around their plastic shopping bags and paper shopping bags,
SPEAKER_00just like constant, constant disruptions. And I don't have misophonia, but I do have a sensitivity to things like noises like that at a show when I'm really trying to stay connected to the piece. So all of that was making it very difficult for me. to properly assess the production so everything I say from here on out please if it take if it after all that you're like I don't trust Matt's opinion by all means don't trust my opinion take it with a full grain of salt um before I get into spoilers I'll say this is a play that I do really enjoy of
August Wilson's Fences it remains my favorite Wilson play which is kind of a basic answer because it's such a straightforward play of his it's like on the more traditional side I would
SPEAKER_00say Joe Turner's come and gone at least in the sequential order of his plays premiering on Broadway is the first one where he got weird and existential and a little mystical and that carried over to plays like The Piano Lesson and so they're bolder swings and they're weirder shows but there's also something really powerful and magical about them and I had seen Joe Turner's Come and Gone in 2009 via Lincoln Center Theater that production was infamously directed by Bart Sher which had a massive uproar at the time still is kind of a
little side-eyed today which I understand it did ultimately get really strong reviews a great deal of Tony nominations a few wins and is mostly looked on fondly despite the um
SPEAKER_00social and political gray area of that production. It did really Capture my interest and I helped me really understand and enjoy that play so I came into this production not wary I want I knew that I liked the show I was interested what they did I have never really been super enamored with Debbie Allen as a director before but I do think she's a talented and smart woman so I was interested to see what she brought to it I thought the cast they assembled was really strong um I overall was kind of
Mid to slightly negative on this production there are things about it to enjoy but it never really congealed for me now again take it with a grain of salt because my audience experience was such that it absolutely could have impacted my view of this
SPEAKER_00production but I really tried to kind of take away what I saw on stage and apply it to here so the plot now we'll get into the spoilers of it all I suppose the plot takes place in a boarding house I believe in Chicago circa the 1910s it's like 1911 I want to say sorry not Chicago Pittsburgh what am I saying it's the Pittsburgh series that Wilson does I'm an idiot sometimes guys ignore me but yeah it's a boarding house in Pittsburgh circa the 1910s I believe specifically 1911
and it follows all the different souls that are residing there you have Bertha Holly and Seth Holly a married couple who run the boarding house Seth is the grandson of a freed slave I believe so he's and he lives in the north and so he's grown up in the north so all he's ever known is freedom but that is a theme that is
SPEAKER_00very prominent in the show of black individuals who have always known freedom and those who have had their freedom given to them later in life or taken away somewhere in life and then given back to them because other boarders in the house are Bynum Walker who's sort of like a mystical medicine man played by Ruben Santiago Hudson and he tells a story of having a vision of a shiny man who gave him the meaning of life but he can't really
remember what that meaning
SPEAKER_00was so he's always sort of in search for the shiny man and as a mystical man he also has a power to bond individuals together so a lot of people come to him so they can be bound to a loved one or a lost one which brings us to Harold Loomis who's played Harold Loomis sorry that's played by Joshua Boone he is a very dark mysterious man who shows up at the boarding house with his daughter Zonia and he has been spending the last
couple of years roaming The country in search of his missing wife Martha because Harold got married to a woman named Martha they had their daughter Zonia and then Harold was kidnapped by a bounty hunter named Joe Turner and was then basically on a slave gang for the
SPEAKER_00better part of a decade I want to say like seven-ish years and when he was finally freed from this unjust slavery Martha had disappeared and so he went so he took his daughter and now they've been searching for her and so they're residing in the boarding house while they look for her and then there are other people in the boarding house a young man named Jeremy a young woman named Maddie another young woman named Molly and they all sort of intersect and intertwine and everyone is
searching for something and and that something ultimately is a purpose and a freedom and everyone has different opinions on what that means for them or how to
SPEAKER_00go about it and that is um impacted by their own history with enslavement someone like Seth Holley has never known slavery and he is a major capitalist he is believes in the American dream and he believes in the power of money in your hand and what it can do for you and he does not necessarily have he's not necessarily beholden to his brethren because his he belongs to the clergy of money and that is and
so his relationship with his wife is interesting because they have a respectful relationship but it's
SPEAKER_00definitely a working relationship Bertha is is of the mindset of life is to be enjoyed and life is to laugh and to love and to live and so anything that happens to you that that impacts you negatively that it's a trauma let's say it's best to let it wash off of you so you can continue to dance and sing in the face of oppression and she tells this to you know young women like Maddie in the show who arrives at the boarding house because the man she
loved has abandoned her and she wants Bynum to bound her bind her to her man but he doesn't do this because he thinks that this is not the right thing for Maddie Maddie then falls in with
SPEAKER_00Jeremy and in the boarding house they start to have a thing but then Jeremy falls for the she's not a lady of the night so much as she's a like a professional party girl uh molly cunning and molly doesn't work molly is taken care of that is that is molly's uh memorandum for her life and jeremy likes the polish and the prettiness and the sheen of molly so he fully abandons maddie for molly uh which maddie then
learns the lesson for herself of she needs to not put all of her faith and all of her value into the love and support of a man which is such a random side tangent but I do not actually watch Love is Blind on Netflix I watch people talk about Love is Blind on YouTube I really am the worst because I don't want to give Netflix the
SPEAKER_00views I don't want them to think that I you know care because ultimately I don't care I care about people's opinions about love is blind like Trixie and Katya watching all the different seasons and there's a bachelor love is blind YouTube channel that covers all of it in a very very snarky way which I appreciate but I think it's the most recent season or it was two seasons ago where there was a very smart very lovely very empathetic young black woman who really gave her all into this relationship and gave the benefit
of the doubt to the man that she had tied herself to and got engaged to and they made it to the altar and even though he gave her all of the reasons to doubt him she said you know what we've made it this far and I believe in you and I believe that we can work on whatever problems come our way and he basically said that's really sweet of you but
SPEAKER_00I'm out She learned she said you know it was so sad but you know she's in her wedding dress in her confessional and she was like I'm tired and I'm done giving these men the benefit of the doubt I am going to just focus on me and anyone who can appreciate that can come along for the ride and I'm like that's right bitch you do that and that's ultimately where Maddie Campbell is and Joe Turner's come and gone by the end she's like I should probably just focus on Maddie because ultimately that's what Molly Cunningham does she focuses on Molly and she gets men anyway they're sort of like a nice benefit to quote Charlotte York they're
nice guys to have fun
SPEAKER_00with but this is to say in the end Harold Loomis does reunite with his wife Martha because uh there is a another sort of he's not really a bounty hunter they call him like the people finder uh he's a like the only white the only white character in the show uh what's his name sorry I'm I'm blanking on this it's not is it Jeremy No it's not no Tripp Taylor is Jeremy so then wait um it is
Rutherford Rutherford Selig like Kyle Selig that's an easy one to remember the one white guy in this show has the same last name as Kyle Selig who is a white guy see these six degrees of
SPEAKER_00separation see how my brain is broken Rutherford is basically like a people finder and Harold hires him to find his wife and Rutherford is often there because he hires Seth Hawley to make him pots and pans for his business endeavors so that's extra income for Seth basically buyers who would not buy from a black individual a black maker like Seth Seth uses Rutherford as like a middleman to sell his stuff Sutherford finds Martha and we find out that the reason why Martha showed up is because Martha had hired Bynum Walker to bind her to her
daughter Zonia so she
SPEAKER_00could find her again and that is when Harold finally releases the Pain of the seven years he was on with that he was in enslavement and frees himself from the ties that he has of Martha of his of Zonya and Spoiler alert here stabs himself or slices himself because he's not it's not a mortal wound he does not die from this he but he bleeds and the
blood turns him shining and that is when Bynum says the last words which is Harold Loomis you shine
SPEAKER_00in like new money and that's when the play ends is a odd play and there is some as I said there's some mystical elements in there especially at the end of act one there is a scene where the members of the boarding house and Bertha and Seth have a congregation where they sing and dance and chant all over the kitchen and living room And they And Seth Harold Loomis shows up And puts a stop to all
this Why are we singing?
SPEAKER_00Why are we dancing? And goes into tongues and has a vision of skeletons walking across the ocean and having this vision of Africa and God and going into this dark tunnel of his emotions and of his trauma that lashes out against the joy and the optimism of everyone else and their faith in their religion. and of God because the other turn is that while Harold was
enslaved Martha his wife found Jesus specifically found white Jesus and is trying to heal and save Harold from all of his pain and all of his sins so he can be washed clean and either join
SPEAKER_00Martha or at least join Martha in heaven at some point And when you're doing Joe Turner in the same way when you're doing the piano lesson, you need to have a deft hand of one foot in this world and of these emotions and this pain, while also having a foot in the mystical and tying the two together in a way so they flow in and out of each other. There's also been a trend lately with August Wilson of finding
the humor in Wilson
SPEAKER_00plays, which I deeply appreciate because if you just leaned into the weight of them all, it would be insufferable. Because Wilson is a poet, but he also was that bitch who could find humor in even the darkest of subjects matters and really turn a phrase on its head that caught you off guard. and so in some ways if you just sort of allow the play to unfold you are playing with house money but you do need to have a sleight of hand in order to navigate an
audience through the odd corners that Wilson plays like Joe Turner's Come and Gone walk through I rightfully cannot say that Debbie Allen for me did that she what she does have is she has a solid control of her ensemble it's a good dynamic that everyone has I think some performances are slightly better than others part of this is because some roles are meatier than others I mean the number one MVP is Ruben Santiago Hudson as Bynum but that's also because Hudson is like the living
SPEAKER_00interpreter of Wilson he's just that his Wilson text lives in Hudson's bones and he just can go off for hours and it just it flows freely from his lips while also living deep in his soul and doesn't feel flowery doesn't feel forced it's just it's the perfect embodiment of what a Wilson text can do As I said, I don't think there's anyone in the adult company who's
necessarily a weak link, but I do think some people are not on the same page of tone as everybody else.
SPEAKER_00I won't speak about the child actors. There are two child actors. One is Zonya Luma. the other one is Ruben Scott Ruben Scott is like a neighboring boy who has two separate scenes with Zonya and there's two sets of child actors for those roles at different performances I am not one for child actors for the most part this production didn't really do anything to convince me otherwise of that that's all I'll sort of leave with that um but I do think that um the actress playing Martha Loomis her name is uh Abigail
uh on on Winali I'm sorry if I if I butchered that but I just wanted to give her her due uh she comes in sort of with a lived in history with Harold uh again played
SPEAKER_00by Joshua Boone they have um you can sort of feel the history between them and it part of it is because the scene is that they are speaking different languages to each other essentially but it was a scene that i felt was a little at a disconnect it felt like joshua boone was in a bit of a different play from abigail uh trip taylor i thought was on the same page as um maddie campbell played by nomeni sierra uh were up but that play is a different play from the one that Taraji and
Cedric the Entertainer
SPEAKER_00are in I will say Taraji P. Henson and Cedric start off really strong they have a really good first act and then I found that their second act wasn't weak so much as it kind of just stayed where it was it didn't evolve from the first act and Joshua Boone is Harold Loomis he gets the brooding and he gets the dark and stormy energy but there's also There's like one foot that's wrong in his performance and I can't rightfully say what it is. Part of it is that Harold is written to not know how to be with
other people and it's hard to play that and not feel like you the actor yourself are sticking out like a sore thumb it's a really tricky role and Boone really gets the troubled elements of Loomis for me but when it comes to the interacting with other people it is hard not to feel like it is he having trouble being on the same page as his fellow actors it doesn't feel like trapeze artists catching each other it feels like actors clashing
SPEAKER_00which the um fortunately benefits the text because of what Loomis is going through but it doesn't it still doesn't really blend for me in that kind of way um i also i don't feel that alan uh has a great sense of pacing if the production is very choppy the scene transitions are slow and cumbersome and they don't and and scenes will sort of just end they won't flow into a transition which will then flow into the next scene it's very sort of stop and start stop and start i also find aesthetically the set is not really um does not really beholden
to what the actors
SPEAKER_00need now in the share production when uh Loomis has his vision at the end of act one there was a great moment where the furniture of the boarding house sort of melted into the stage and it became this more abstract no man's land of the boarding house that then kept on into the second act and then when Loomis has his Alan keeps both moments sort of in the real world which just makes the moments feel a little bit off uh
Alan ultimately does not get in the way of the play but I also don't think she helps the trickier parts when the play is more sort of earthbound and people interacting with people it's fine it works the actors are good the text is strong when it needs a more assured hand is where I feel like she is a bit weaker and it's
SPEAKER_00strange because she comes from the world of dance she is also a rhythm and movement there was in this production. So that was sort of for me where I was with Joe Turner. That said, it is still strong clay. This production is not bad, but I was sort of a little mixed on it. But as I also mentioned, my audience experience was so terrible that it could be that that just fully impacted my enjoyment of it. I do think Tony Wise will see this nominated for revival I do think that Ruben Santiago Hudson is going to be in featured actor of everyone
else Boone is definitely a contender he has such a meaty role featured actor is both like really crowded and a bit of a no man's land at the same time so it could be that Ruben is like the sole nominee here in that category of everyone else Taraji could get in She's good She equips herself really nicely I don't I think featured actors in a play is simply so crowded Unless she and Cedric somehow get put into lead Which really shouldn't happen It's an ensemble piece Every role has always been deemed featured So it would be strange for them to be put into lead
for this And if they're put in lead then Cedric could get in Because there's like one or two slots in actor Lead actor that's up for grabs Taraji could too But I ultimately think
SPEAKER_00that Rose Byrne and Kelly O'Hara are getting in for Fallen Angels yeah um that's sort of where I'm at with this I don't necessarily see Debbie Allen getting nominated for director I think we have um Joe Mantello and Whitney White and Robert Icke as locks for director of a play and then um Trip Coleman and Ann Kaufman and Kenny Leon are all sort of like duking it out for those last two slots but Alan hasn't been nominated for director before it would be nice to have another woman in there to have another woman of color in there in
addition to Whitney White but she doesn't really have a strong track record as a director or as a creative at the Tony Awards she's been nominated as a performer but I don't think she's ever been nominated as a choreographer or director before so while this could be her first there's not really a precedent for people to go oh well we've done it before
SPEAKER_00we should do it again um but that's where we are with Joe Turner the Ballisters um I will go rather quickly on this the Ballisters is the premiere play by uh I'm sorry it's the Broadway premiere of David Lindsay Haber who is a Tony winner and Pulitzer runners this is not his Broadway premiere but it's the play's Broadway it follows a homeowners association in a random suburb it is implied that it's you know potentially Pennsylvania or it could be straight out of close to New York City
they talk about the suburb being close enough to a major city that any people who work in a city can get to their town rather rather quickly but it's not so close
SPEAKER_00that it still doesn't feel like a really nice suburb and I'll start up front and say uh my feeling on this play was I fucking loved it and I did not expect to I went into the balusters actually in quite a shitty mood I had had an experience after Schmugadoon that was not my favorite the night before and I woke up that morning just like really fucking bummed and just not happy to be going to a two-show day it was the balusters followed by beaches so I went into the
SPEAKER_00balusters just okay well let's see and I hadn't heard much about it and I'll tell you by the end I was so happy it made me so happy to see a really strong play with an impeccable ensemble Kenny Leon has had a really nuanced hand with this you know strong work with his actors uh strong comedic timing good sense of tone uh beautifully designed I just I was I was on board from start to finish There are bumps you could find in it, for sure. I think almost no work is really objectively perfect.
SPEAKER_00Everyone can find fault with anything. But it comes down to, does it work for you? And the balusters worked for me. And I'll talk about why in a hot second. As I said, to follow the homeowners association in this suburb, the new member of the association is Anika Noni Rose, who plays a character named Kira. She is new to the neighborhood. She and her husband, who's, I believe, a lawyer, just bought this beautiful, beautiful home. and they've hired a well-known housekeeper in the neighborhood
named Luz who up until now was working for the president of the homeowners association named Elliot played by Richard Thomas but she left working for him and started working for Kira and this is a you know Chekhov's gun that's used later in the play the inciting
SPEAKER_00incident is that Kira lives right outside of an intersection that is that is prone to accidents because a traffic light was put on a neighboring street where there are a lot of businesses and a lot of cars to avoid said traffic light now go through Kira's street and because of a hill and a sort of hidden curve a lot of cars don't stop and they don't see each other and there's no stop sign or a traffic light there as well and so there are a lot of accidents and Kira would like something to be done about it
before somebody gets killed whether that's a stop sign or a traffic light and the president Elliot uh
SPEAKER_00kind of keeps shutting that down. And Kira starts to get more people from the association on her side, but Elliot still finds ways to shut it down. And then there becomes questions of loyalty, of motivations. We find corruption within the association. Surprise, a structured government entity has toxic malpractice in there. but without giving too much away ultimately Elliot has his own
reasons for wanting to keep the street as it is plus to keep the traffic light where it's at Elliot's
SPEAKER_00whole ideal is this town is landmarked the homes are preserved to look a certain kind of way he wants to preserve the history of the town to preserve its aesthetic and he even uses this as a point to Kira part of the reason why she wanted to live in this town is she loved the aesthetic it felt so safe it felt so traditional it looked so beautiful it's a very prized community people are often clamoring to live there and well you know
SPEAKER_00Kira keeps on trying to find compromises. Elliot keeps shutting off those compromises in not an aggressive way. What makes Elliot such a wonderful villain is he's genuinely acting how he thinks is best and with a smile on his face like he's a soda jerk from the 1950s. and he is always talking in his opinion incredibly rationally about why things can't happen and then it's revealed that oh he has a connection with this person who can make that decision and that person who can make that decision and he feels like he's being undermined left and right by the group and while he thinks he's not
being vindictive he thinks that he's just having a conversation with his cohorts he is being vindictive and he is being bratty and and about not getting his way and a lot of things start to come to a head and a lot of people in the association start to reveal their own gripes against each other microaggressions of racism and sexism and homophobia and of woke performative heroism and it all kind of comes to a crashing head and in the end no one is right but everyone is
more right about one
SPEAKER_00thing than another it is ultimately an extraordinarily funny play Amazing one-liners If you can make some arguments against it you could say that David Lindsay a bear means a little heavily on certain stereotypes to make certain points everyone is always like one shade worse than you might see them in the real world but ultimately this is theater and we do heighten things a little bit to make a larger statement everyone in the there's really nobody in the play who is fully a hero and no one
who's fully a villain some people are more a villain than others Elliot is absolutely the most villain of everyone in the show but Kira is not a perfect warrior uh she has her own microaggressions she you know loses her um housekeeper but and she treats Luz with with kindness and respect but also we see that like there's a moment where Margaret Cullen who plays Rick Ackerman who has known Luz for years while she's worked for Elliot and asks her like how her son's doing oh
how's his job oh that's so great he's such a go-getter we're so proud of him and Kira's like oh I didn't know you had a son you didn't tell me and Luz is like yeah I told you you just don't remember I've told you a few times and Luz doesn't say it to be a bitch but she's like it's just a matter of fact she's like yeah no I've
SPEAKER_00told you I've told you a few times and walks away and when Kira eventually asks Luz why she stopped working for Elliot. It's not because she genuinely cares about Luz's well-being. She uses it as a pawn against Elliot in the final meeting. And I don't want to give away necessarily why Luz didn't work for Elliot, but it has to do with the house that Kira bought. if anyone is like maybe the most pure in the show it is the character of Luz the housekeeper there is a bit of a narrative in this show of like
the working class is pure the working class is the most innocent they're the most saintly you know the sort of like the richer you are the more corrupt you are the more power you have the more corrupt you are which let's be clear like there's absolutely a major truth
SPEAKER_00to that but it is like the one maybe After School Specialty thing about the play is that the most working class character is the one with the least amount of flaws. And sometimes it feels more for narrative purposes than because it loses an actual human being. Everyone else has their own shades of toxicity. For example, there is the extremely progressive, like overly progressive, I would say, character in the show, Willow Gibbons, who is vegan and uber,
SPEAKER_00uber liberal. She has a partner who's trans. And I think Willow even identifies as non-binary, I can't recall. And there's a moment where Willow, and Willow like kind of has one major punching bag, which is a member, Alan, who is outside of Elliot, the only other white cisgender heterosexual male. in the group everyone else is either a woman or a person of color and Willow really makes Alan her punching bag and Alan kind of finally snaps and explains all the ways in which he finds himself to be a good person and trying
very hard and it's something that I think a lot of his diatribe is something I think a lot of people
SPEAKER_00can relate to but his eagerness to be Absolved is something that is something it's something that I think a lot of people feel but it's cringe to say it openly so earnestly and it also falls on deaf ears so it doesn't even matter but then when Willow kind of goes back in on Alan about his privilege and whatnot and not speaking for everyone in the group she is then corrected on this by a
character in the show Isaac who is a Latino man and he says to her everyone in this group who is not
SPEAKER_00white has the ability to speak for themselves and if we have a problem with Alan we can say so we do not need you to speak for us and be our savior which then of course causes Willow to go in full victim mode and feel like she has done the absolute worst thing and she cries to absolve herself of any guilt but this falls on the deaf ears of the BIPOC members of the group who have this is not a super spoiler they have this clip online of them all putting their money together because they had a bet on the white girl tears of when Willow was going to finally cry
So it shows you that even even the members of the show who have a point about their issues with microaggressions on their race with the white members they then take bets against the white members of their own idiosyncrasies and you could argue is that an aggression itself is that something that is justified based on the
SPEAKER_00historical imbalance of power racially in the group. These are discussions that The Balusters wants to have through the power of theatrical comedy. It is ultimately a satire of a group of intelligent, relatively like-minded people who are unable to or unable to have compromises with each other and how everyone wants to be the good guy everybody wants to be right and because everybody wants to be right and nobody wants to overstep no change ever really
happens because then you have someone like Elliot who sees the bad in change not necessarily in equilibrium of people's rights but just in his mind with every small change we make it is us letting go of the past and of who we are and I am a big believer that you should not be forgetting the past because to forget the past is to repeat it in the future
SPEAKER_00but you can't hold on to it especially not tangibly it's not Nothing was ever perfect in the before times there was always something that was bad for somebody that is better for that somebody now which is something that Kira points out to when Elliot tries to show her pictures of the neighborhood when Elliot was a boy and showing her how beautiful it was and how safe it was in these thriving businesses and Kira's like right but every person in the photo you showed me is white I would not have lived here back in the day you know there is still like there is a gatekeeping in this
community that is still active Elliot enforced it on Kira's house but nobody wants to think of themselves as the villain everybody wants to think of themselves as the warrior for what is
SPEAKER_00right and the more they get rebuffed the harsher and meaner and crazier they become they feel like they're not being heard they feel like they're the only one standing up for what's correct and there is something to be said for how much of the past should we let go of because everything is tied to something should we let go of all the things that brought us joy because it's tied in some way to something negative not completely but also The world moves forward it only spins forward so you do have to
make changes you do have to make compromises especially when there are legitimate concerns Kira's concern about the intersection outside of her house it's not a oh I can't sleep because people are noisy it's people are gonna get hurt people have been getting hurt why aren't we trying to fix this and Elliot's only rebuttal is well aesthetic
SPEAKER_00that's and that's not a correct answer right But as I said, Kira herself is not perfect. Nobody in this show is. And everyone has their own secrets. And you learn that not everybody who causes a microaggression does it intentionally. You see the people who are trying to do the best they can. The character of Mary Louise Burke playing Penny. She is an older woman who is doing her best and has genuinely made mistakes. There's a long-standing narrative of her mixing up the spouses
of two different
SPEAKER_00people in the community. who both have the same name but also happen to be Asian and when Penny finally learns that she's been making this mistake her response is in the narrative up until now we've been told that Penny's making this mistake because she thinks that all Asians are interchangeable and she thinks they're the same person Penny goes no that's not what it was I learned about this spouse from a friend at a function whose name was Miranda and I thought that was you so I thought
that was the name of your spouse and I thought that the other Miranda from across town thought that she was the spouse of this other person I had never known and nobody corrected me so you're all just thinking that I'm sitting here racist but I genuinely thought that you were married I know who you are I know who that other Miranda is not Miranda
SPEAKER_00Melissa sorry I thought I knew who that other Melissa was I thought you two had opposite spouses I never confused you two I thought the spouses were opposite and eventually Penny takes that information and she applies it correctly in the future and makes it a point to address Melissa and her spouse correctly and I think that is a way to that that David Lindsay Bear has shown that people can learn and people can change people don't respond well to confrontation or
condescension and empathy can let you go a long way if you let it but also it can walk all over you so you have to find that balance and the only way you find that balance is by making mistakes right but the only way someone can learn is if you
SPEAKER_00inform them that they're incorrect and why they're incorrect Bear, I think, really
has his cake and eats it too with this show of he pokes fun at everybody while also showing that everyone has the capability to be better and change and that and that that really can be applied to anyone it's ultimately why Carousel is my favorite musical the message that people don't seem to get across is what Hammerstein gets out of it is anyone can find redemption if they ask for help and we give them help
SPEAKER_00in return And I think there's been so much pain and so much hate over the last few years that has existed always but has really exposed itself in the last 10 years that a lot more people are getting more guarded and holding and tending to their own lawn instead of helping others because help has now been relabeled as doing the work for other people. and I don't think that's always necessarily the case no one can do it alone you
always need a little bit of help and who's to say that at the end of the play that this homeowners association will be better down the line or if you know more
SPEAKER_00corruption will happen to the new people in charge but you can only have you can only have optimism right it's what gets you out of bed in the morning and that's ultimately where I feel like the balusters ends whilst again still having a satirical tone to how we're all not necessarily fucked but we're all necessarily uh slightly broken So that's me on The Balusters, a play that I, once again, fucking adored. I see this absolutely as a lock for best play.
SPEAKER_00I don't think it's going to win. I still ultimately think that Liberation will win, but I can see a world in which The Balusters can make a play for it, especially since they can win at a lot of the earlier awards, which, as I said, don't have the same voting body, but it can drive a narrative of, oh, it's in Playbill and on Broadway World, they won, David Lindsay Bear won. Well he has two Tonys for Kimberly Akimbo he's yet to win for best play so that's something to be said but I do think this is a best play nominee I think they'll get in for set I could see Kenny Leon getting in for director I'll
be interested to see what the Tony administration thinks of Richard Thomas and Anika Noni Rose if they
SPEAKER_00are deemed featured or leaded Anika I think really is the lead of the play even though it is a strong ensemble piece so Anika could be deemed lead and if so she could get in there uh if she's deemed featured I think she's got a strong case to be nominated here as does Mary Louise Burke who um you know has a really strong character and it's just like the ultimate voice of David Lindsay a bear and has yet to be nominated which is um helpful Richard Thomas I think also has a really good shot at getting nominated for featured as well um oops sorry about that
so that's where we are with the balusters um and with Joe Turner's come and gone we've got one last review coming up which is the Lost Boys which I'm actually seeing in a little a little bit I'm seeing the frozen version right after I finish recording this episode uh and then I'll I will do that review and talk a little bit more about the upcoming episodes for the Tonys and yeah that's really it I've got nothing else to say I'm spent remember when I said this was going to be a tight one
SPEAKER_00and it's now like 50 minutes uh If you guys like the podcast give us a nice five star rating or review give us a rating on Spotify it always helps with the algorithm again if you write a review I will read it on the podcast you can follow me on Instagram at Matt Koplik usual spelling you can join the discord or the Substack you can join the YouTube channel if you haven't yet make sure you get your ticket for the Broadway Breakdown live show at Green Room 42 this coming Sunday at 7 o'clock you can even buy a live stream ticket if you are not in New York City in person or
if you can't watch the live stream on the day you can still buy the ticket and you can watch it later that week you have up until a week I think after the day of the
SPEAKER_00show to watch the live stream so that's fun for this episode I am going to close this out with Miss Anika Noni Rose because god damn we love her and she's back on Broadway and that's a wonderful thing to see so yes we will see you guys for the Lost Boys review after this one take it away Anika bye I'm almost
SPEAKER_03there people gonna come here from everywhere and I'm almost there I want more, more, more
What is a “Snub” anyway? Is it just someone or something that wasn’t nominated? Or does there need to be a pointed feeling behind it? Daddy Rob, Graham Cracker Crust Steve, and fellow Broadway Rain Man Alex join your...
Families are tough…especially ones with secrets. Matt reviews the revival of the Tony and Pulitzer nominated play Other Desert Cities. The starry revival is the hottest ticket in town…but is it the best? Important...
So much Off-Broadway. Such Theatre. Most Reviews. Matt delves into the Broadway-hopeful musical THE HEART, plus Mona Pirnot’s latest masterpiece I BECAME WE and a few other Off-Broadway productions he came across on his...
Spooky Sickness! Ghosts and Corsets! Wigs and Jump Scares! That’s right, we’re talking Moliere and haunted homes. Matt reviews two plays that are scaring Broadway (in two very different ways): PARANORMAL ACTIVITY and...
So. Mean. Such School. Much Girl. Matt reviews the latest show at Manhattan Theatre Club: SCHOOL GIRLS or THE AFRICAN MEAN GIRLS PLAY. Spoiler alert: he absolutely loooved it. Matt goes into the brilliance of the...