Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Bleeding Daylight

Bleeding Daylight artwork

Sheila Krygsheld - Knowing What You Believe and Why

Jul 5, 202628 minAudio

Sheila Krygsheld has spent years helping everyday Christians move from simply believing to truly understanding why they believe. A former college religion professor, wife, mum and grandmother of six, Sheila is the author of What Makes You Say That? How to Study What You Believe So You Can Share It with Others. Her journey into apologetics began not in a classroom, but in crisis, when her daughter's traumatic brain injury forced her to confront what she actually believed about God, suffering and healing. In this conversation, Sheila unpacks the balance between head knowledge and heart knowledge, why deconstruction doesn't have to mean walking away from faith altogether, and how Christians can hold firm convictions while still extending grace to those who see things differently. From college campuses to kitchen tables, Sheila offers practical, hard-won wisdom for anyone who wants to know not just what they believe, but why. WEBLINKS Sheila Krygsheld’s Website Sheila Krygsheld on Facebook Sheila Krygsheld on Instagram What Makes You Say That?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Wherever there are shadows, there are people ready to kick at the darkness until it bleeds daylight. This is Bleeding Daylight with your host, Rodney Olsen. Welcome to Bleeding Daylight, thanks for being here. A full library of episodes is waiting for you at bleedingdaylight.net. You'll also find all our social media links there. Join the conversation. Follow Bleeding Daylight on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube. I'd love to connect with you.

If you're a person of faith, do you know enough about that faith to be able to give a reason for the hope within you? Where is the balance between head knowledge and heart knowledge, knowing about God and experiencing God? Today's guest gives us practical ideas in going deeper in both our knowledge and experience of faith. Sheila Krygsheld has spent years helping everyday Christians move from, I just believe it, to here's why I believe it.

She's a wife, mum and grandmother of six, a former college religion professor and the author of What Makes You Say That? How to Study What You Believe So You Can Share It With Others, a book for those who want to share their faith with confidence. From classrooms in Wisconsin to leadership training in Malawi, Sheila's whole mission is helping people know what they believe and why it matters. Sheila, welcome to Bleeding Daylight. Thank you so much. It's such a pleasure to be here. You have spent years teaching biblical studies and apologetics at a college level.

What first sparked your love for digging deep into the scripture rather than just reading it on the surface as so many do? I was a stay-at-home mom for a very long time, and I had a daughter who had a car accident her senior year of high school. It left her with a traumatic brain injury. She couldn't walk. She couldn't talk. The miracle is she's doing beautifully now, and God has healed her. But it threw me into a faith crisis because someone had told me that she was getting better because my husband and I did good things for people all the time.

The karmic cycle was actually going to come full circle. That's why my daughter was getting better. And I said, well, no, I think God is why the Lord is blessing her, and that's why she's getting better. I couldn't rationalize out what karma was and how to defend my faith in the midst of something so small. So I decided that I was going to go back to school and get a master's in biblical studies, and that just wasn't enough. I thought, well, I need to learn how to defend my faith, the faith that I have so deeply rooted. And so then I went back for a master's in apologetics just so that I could learn how to use Scripture to defend my faith.

Thankfully, in your case, your daughter recovered and was getting better, and people would put it down to all kinds of things, but you wanted to know why. We know that for many people, things don't end so well. They enter into a time of tragedy in their family, and that's what really rocks their faith. So how important is it that all of us get a better handle on what our faith is about before those sorts of things hit? Amen. That's true. How important? I think it's very important.

Nobody wants to be seen as incompetent or as uncredible. Everybody wants to be known as a credible witness to whatever it is that they're in or whatever situation they're in. We do this in our careers. We do this in our daily life. As a mom, we do it, or as a dad. But when it comes to our faith, a lot of times we just kind of let it ride. We're going to go to Bible study. We're going to go to church. But what happens when you're in Bible study and it starts to change you?

That's when the rubber hits the road. So knowing what you believe from those situations and actually being able to articulate it, when the tragedies do come, that's the peace that comes, that passes all understanding. That's the time where you can really cling on to what it is that you believe. A lot of people find biblical studies, to the depth that you've gone to, they can tend to think, well, that's all going to be dry and I want to experience God. Is there room for both, that experience of who God is and that study and understanding?

Yeah, that's funny that you say that. In my book, I have a form that I use to write out my own beliefs. At the very bottom, the last thing that I say is, how does this make me know God or his nature better? What does the scripture reveal about God's nature and who God is? And so if we start to experience scripture through the eyes of the one who actually wrote scripture to us, then it starts to really become an experience and not just something that it's a rote list of rules and stuff we got to do.

It's when it hits that heart with the experiencing the power of scripture, I would say. We hear a lot of young people who get to the age of going to college or university or whatever it is for them. It's in those sorts of institutions that they lose their faith because they come up against some of the big questions that their family environment or their church has not prepared them for. I'm wondering if that's sometimes because parents don't fully understand what they believe and they're too afraid to delve into it in case they find it comes up wanting.

You're right. I actually think it's very naive for a parent to say, I'm going to let my child choose whatever religion they want to believe because there's so many out there. I'm going to let them choose. Well, I guess I look at that like if you had the absolute truth or the best of something in your possession and you knew it and you knew it was the best and then you just didn't give it to them because you didn't feel like it or you didn't want to. Well, that's an epic fail. You've got to give your kids the best foot forward in those situations because there's a lot of confusion on those college campuses.

I know I've been on several. 1 Peter 3.15 says we should be responsible for the hope that we have. We should be able to give a defense for the hope that we have. And I agree that's true. But I think we forget that it says you, that little word of you, your hope. It's not anybody else's. I don't have to respond to anybody else's hope but my own and tell my experience from my hope and that I have. And when you're authentic and credible and you sit there and you listen to someone's hurt or their feelings or whatever it is that's pulling them away from scripture, you can tell them the source of hope that you have from your experience, maybe your tragedies, maybe your problems, and then be able to help them.

Were there things as you started to study more deeply that surprised you about this faith that you already held? Ah, yes, yes. One of the things that was weird, maybe everybody knows, I don't think so, but one thing that just really struck me like a truck was how from Genesis to Revelation there's one solid story. It's that golden thread that's run all the way through scripture. And it's that story of redemption, how God didn't leave humanity out to fend for themselves.

Humanity is, we're redeemed and God provided that redemption story. Okay, so we know that. What I thought has really been like an aha moment was there were 40 authors over 1,500 years written on three continents. If I started a story now, in 1,500 years it would be done, and there were 40 authors who wrote that story, would it have my original thought process in mind? I don't think so. In fact, I know it wouldn't. It's kind of like that telephone game, you know.

It just gets to be all messed up. That was one of the really big things about scripture that I just really thought was incredibly fascinating that God had this one theme in mind, and he just followed it through through the whole entire Bible. Oftentimes people can see the Old Testament and New Testament as very different, and they point towards an angry, wrathful God in the Old Testament, and yet a God of love that comes to us through Jesus. And yet, there's a thread of mercy and a thread of wanting reconciliation throughout.

Was that something that struck you again and again as you studied the scripture? It did. I know here in America and here in Australia, I mean, we're very proud people. We often get mixed up in the good that we have and think we deserve that. And I don't think there's enough vision that people have back to the word to say, okay, Lord, I see that you've given me mercy for these things. And unfortunately, in our day and age, I don't think people see that. So as I translate that, because you're talking about the college campuses, as I translate that back to the college campuses, I had a lot of students who seemed to think that their families, even though they were paying for their college, that they deserved that.

And unfortunately, it's not things that we deserve. And we need to make a paradigm shift, I think, and help our children see you got to have some skin in the game. You got to make it your own. This ain't your mama's shampoo. Well, it ain't your mama's faith either. I know that the things that you have written and the things that you've explored are helpful for all Christians, but you particularly want to help Christian women to understand their faith. Why is that? I think women have such a burden of proof as the kids age.

We hit so many stages. I, at one time, had a preschooler, grade schooler, middle schooler, and high schooler. I had all four. And it was like, oh, my gosh, one time you're doing this, and the next minute you're in high school, and the next minute you're looking at a college. And you were in so many different levels. I think my heart for moms comes from the fact that when I was tattered and torn and pulled in so many different places, it did me good to actually sit and be able to talk high level to my high schooler and say, listen, this is in culture, and this is something you got to watch out for.

But also, my preschooler, who we're potty training, well, you know, we've got to work with that, too. And I think as we can take those levels, women, they just really need it. I do mentor at a pregnancy center. And you don't have to be pregnant to get help. We spiritually mentor. After your family's gone, what do you do? There's just so many questions with women, maybe just because I am one. We see a big movement these days in what people call deconstruction of faith. And we hear even of some big names in the Christian world who have walked away from faith and say that they no longer believe.

And we don't want to just write them off in a simplistic way. But what do you think is driving that? Obviously, sin. Obviously, sin. I think one of the things for deconstruction is the culture that's around us. We've allowed it to seep into the private places of our heart. I would never encourage anyone to deconstruct unless they reconstruct. I think it's a misunderstanding to walk away from your faith completely. I would say for those people, if you're going to deconstruct, you definitely need to have a place within your deconstruction where you're going to consider reconstruction.

You can't throw the baby out with the bathwater. You've got to have a little bit more depth to your faith to be able to reconstruct. You hear some people like, I got unbaptized. Well, if you didn't care about baptism, why are you unbaptizing? That doesn't make sense. So, to me, some of these things that we kind of go through, I think with the deconstruction, I just would love to hold someone's hand through that. We know that there are traditions and there are beliefs in churches that are well-meaning but don't necessarily line up with Scripture.

So, it is important that we do throw those aside. But as you say, still holding to the truth. How can someone go through that? I mean, you've already touched on part of that. But how can someone go through that? If what they're hearing at church is no longer making sense to them or is not filling that need, obviously, we need to turn to Jesus and fully know who He is. But what are the first steps that we need to take? One of the first steps you need to take is to find someone to mentor you.

I would never want to walk a road alone, especially within my faith. I probably have four or five people right now that I do Bible studies with on a daily or a weekly basis that I just mentor along. They might be questioning their faith in some ways. Some of them know. But some of the people that I mentor at my job, I would say, yeah, church hurt is such a huge problem. Everybody has a personal story. And I would love to say to someone like that, you can't throw the baby out with the bathwater.

You have to still come back to that central argument or the central piece, which is Christ. So you've got to deal with that. You can't just throw that out too. You've got to deal with Christ. You can't say that the people that are around Christ, that's why you don't want to be there. Well, they're not Christ. You've got to deal with Christ alone. That's like these traditions and the different things. I was a very young girl, debated with my dad. I said my new husband, he wanted to move. And we were going back to the town that we were in. And I didn't want to go to his church because I didn't believe all the theology that was there.

And my dad, just for all that he was worth, I said, Dad, you know, I just don't know what to do. And he said, you don't have to believe everything within that congregation. You just have to do the salvific things. So the things that are salvation oriented. And I would say that's probably where you can draw the line, where God brings you to that point. Your book is called What Makes You Say That? What's the story behind that title? And what moment in your own life made you realize that so many Christians do struggle to answer that question?

Their political landscape over here, we've had a lot of trouble with a lot of huge ideologies. This one believes this, this believes that. And everybody through the political landscape of 2024 with us, I was just so irritated to see how everyone, left wing, right wing, independent, anybody, people were just spouting off online and not knowing the truth. You know, the only truth that I know like is authentically truth, truth is Scripture. So I bring myself back to Scripture.

What caused me to think about this title was if you don't care whether you're credible, then you need to become a seeker of truth. And if you don't care what Scripture says, well, you need to start taking a stand on it and you need to come back to that. So one of the famous questions that I always ask people is, what makes you say that? I finally started realizing that that would be probably the title of my book. Probably the moment that I saw it was through that, that political landscape. I myself had a struggle with my oldest daughter at times explaining what I believe.

I would get frustrated and angry and just, you know, key up and like, how come you don't understand this? And I would get angry and yet I couldn't tell her and parse out for her what I believed. She frustrated me, but then I frustrated myself. By the time I got to the fourth kid, I think I got it a little more figured out. He was always very gracious to me. We would do our arguing and, you know, wrestling back and forth. And then I would just say, I think we're getting out of control. You need to go. I need to go. I'm going to go sit in my office. And then shortly thereafter, he'd come back in and say, okay, let's talk about this more rationally.

And I'd go, perfect. That's what I was aiming for. With people, they struggle so hard with explaining what they believe to their kids. And yet, how do you do that? I said that myself. And so that's why I want people to ask themselves, what makes me say what I say? Why do I say that I love Jesus? Why do I say that I'm Catholic or I'm Protestant or whatever? Why do I say that I'm a believer, I'm a Christian? It's so important for us to know because we need to share that with others. And it's not easy to evangelize and go out and say, okay, today I'm going to meet 10 people and introduce them to Christ.

It's your lifestyle. So live it and be comfortable in your faith because it's not an if or when you feel comfortable. It's definitely you got to do it. It's not a choice. We know that apologetics or understanding our faith and understanding what's in the Scriptures is very important. That's that knowledge piece. But we also know that we're not going to be drawn to Christ unless we're drawn by the Holy Spirit. How do we balance that information with that calling of the Holy Spirit upon our lives?

Apologetics tends to be heady, philosophical. I always say I can play in that sandbox. I can sit there and I can listen to the William Lane Craigs and the Mike Lacones and the people like that. I can sit there and listen to them. And even Nabeel Qureshi, I know he's not around anymore, but his stuff really affected me. But that knowledge, yeah, we always seek that because we want to be known as being smart. But the Holy Spirit distills that information and that's where apologetics is helpful.

It helps us defend what we believe because the Holy Spirit has touched us or is working in us and using Scripture to change us and form us. Obviously, we can't do it without the power of the Holy Spirit, but apologetics can be heady and intellectual. And I personally don't play there. I don't play in that sandbox, as I said. I kind of move myself away from that and work more in the hand-to-hand discipleship, helping people, because that's where I feel the Holy Spirit, for me, lives a little bit more in depth.

Coming back to your book, obviously people have had an opportunity to read it now. What's the response that you're getting back? Are there people saying, this is just what I needed? This is helping to explain some of the things just as you needed back at that time when your daughter was involved in that accident? Is it helpful in that way for so many? Right. It is. I read a book by Mary Jo Sharp called Defending Your Faith. That was before I went to apologetic school. And I was positive that Mary Jo was going to tell me exactly what I believed.

And I was going to go out, and I was going to be like, oh, whew, I'm done with this now. I know what I believe, and it's over. And I was mad at her, because when I got done with the book, I'm like, what the heck? This woman didn't tell me anything more. Actually, she's been a professor of mine, so I can say she's an incredible person. But that was not in her intent of her book. Our faith is our own, and we have to own it. We have to be responsible for our own faith. And when people look at my book and they read it, they're like, wow, I really see the purpose and the reason now.

They've really come to enjoy being able to understand what they believe. I challenge you to go back to the end of your Bible and to your concordance and look up topics that might culture, you know, words are redefined. Our poor children, they don't know what the original meanings of words were. So, I think for us, it's just really good to go back to that source. Probably, there would be people that would have read your book with that same thing in mind of, now I'm going to know what I believe, and have come out thinking, now I have a map to find out what I believe.

For someone listening who perhaps grew up in church, but never really studied the Bible for themselves to this point, where would you suggest that they start if they do want to build a stronger Christian worldview? You know the stories. You've known Noah's Ark, and you know David and all those stories. But what I would say is start at the words that people just use in general conversation, salvation. Take the form and write salvation at the top, and then search the Scriptures about salvation or being saved. Take those topics that, so what do I believe about salvation?

Or what do I believe about being saved? What do I believe about faith? Do I really know what faith is? What about belief? Do I know what belief is? Sanctification, use these big words, justification, all these words that come in Scripture. You take the form that's in there, and you'll use it, and you'll just be able to parse out what these things mean through Scripture for yourself. And then on the other hand, those who haven't grown up in church, and we see people that come to know Jesus, and yet they don't have that background.

And when they turn up at church, and some of these stories, as you say, stories about David, or stories about Noah and the Ark, they're really at a loss because they've never had that. Is there a different starting point for them? I would say no. I would say do the same thing. The thing that's beautiful is if you use your study Bible well, they give you references in the bottom and along the side to actually go back to other stories in Scripture in the Old Testament. I think the stories in the Bible are just so beautiful when I compare it to my own life.

I'm going through something, and here this person is going through something. How did they react? How do I react? That's actually a beautiful thing, but you've got to look into the study guide, the little area at the bottom underneath your Scripture, and see where they all mash together and how the Lord does that. But if you're someone that has not grown up in the church and doesn't have that knowledge, that doesn't make you less of a person, and that certainly doesn't make you less of a Christian. You get to make your faith your own, just like everybody else.

And the beauty is if you came as an adult, you missed all those young years. Oh, well, let's not sit and sulk about that. Let's move on. Have a little bit of a type A personality, move into something, and let's really learn about it because you can do it. You've mentioned a number of times that we need to make that faith our own, but obviously it's not choose-your-own-adventure. There are central truths in the Scripture that we agree on, and yet we do know that even the greatest theologians over time would have differences of opinion over certain doctrine.

So how do we strike that balance of knowing what are the essential rocks of our faith and what are those things that we can say, yeah, I don't quite agree on that area? Right. Kind of like what my dad said to me was, is it a salvific issue? Is it a salvation issue? If it's not a salvation issue, then sometimes I just say, I'm not going to worry my head over that if I'm not worried about it. God will bring it to me. The opinion difference is people are going to argue that all day long. I just don't get enjoyment out of watching that or being a part of that.

I really rely on the Holy Spirit. When I start studying about something, I sit down in prayer and I say, Lord, you have got to enlighten me in this situation and help me to see what you want me to see and what's relevant for me today. Maybe I'm going to run into somebody on the street and I need to encourage them or give them something, then show me that. Give that to me because that's what I want. I want to know that everything that I've done in my day is a reflection of you. Who's at Mel Robbins says, let them talk or let them be or whatever it is.

I kind of like that. Let them talk, let them argue, and that's fine. God doesn't have you in that space. One of the beautiful things about the Christian faith is that we can have those disagreements over certain ideas and yet we can still have fellowship. How important is it for us to not build up walls, not build up the tribalism that we've seen, and you touched on the political landscape that we're seeing these days, this tribalism of you must believe exactly what I do. How important is it for us as Christians to show we don't have to agree on everything and yet we can have sweet fellowship?

Amen. I think it's super important. I talk about humility and confidence, and sometimes those seem antithetical to one another. To be humble, to accept someone else's opinion. I work in a pregnancy and the life hub where we are multigenerational. I hear it from every side of the coin. Some days I have to come home and I just have to say to my husband, it was a rough day because mentally my brain is just overloaded. But those disagreements, I think we as Christians need to rid ourselves of dissension, and God calls us to Christian unity.

If you believe so strongly about a political issue or, like you said, a theological truth that you're going to hang your hat on, I think we need to look closer introspectively to our own life and just say, Lord, I need more of you in this situation. Because that's not humble and that's not kind to be dissentive. Your book, What Makes You Say That? How to Study What You Believe, so you can share it with others. Who do you think is going to get the most out of this book? Who's the audience that you really want to grab hold of this?

The audience that I wrote the book for was women, maybe 25 to 55 or 85 or whatever. Mainly women because I find that for me, speaking to a woman, it's easy for me to go through it. But I have to say, I've had several men read the book, and one of them especially said, you lost me when you said journal. He says, I'm not going to journal. And so maybe that's where I lost my male audience. But at the end, the last two chapters, he said, I would love if you would do a workbook on the last two chapters.

So I'm hearing workbook from men. I'm hearing Bible study from women. I'm thinking probably a little more Bible study because I have to define an audience. But I could someday do a workbook too. This summer I'll be coming out with some e-books that are free on my website, and people can actually see me go through some topics and be able to write out what our apologetic is on a topic. So if they need to see it in full form, which I do. One, I do prayer in the book. Like, what do we believe about prayer? That's more that workbook style.

But women, they just tend to like that Bible study, and so that's where I kind of landed. Sheila, thank you for writing the book. I know it's a great resource for so many. And there is a link to your website in the show notes at bleedingdaylight.net so that people can find your website, find those resources that you have there, but also to be able to find the book. But I want to thank you for that, and thank you especially for spending time with me today on Bleeding Daylight. Thank you, Rodney. It's been a pleasure.

Thank you for listening to Bleeding Daylight. Please help us to shine more light into the darkness by sharing this episode with others. For further details and more episodes, please visit bleedingdaylight.net.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Wes Pritchett - Faith, Survival and Unexpected Grace

    Nov 15, 202630 minAudio

    At just 19, Wes Pritchett was arrested at gunpoint in Texas and spent almost seven months in the Dallas County Jail. He had been a young musician and had never been formally charged with a serious crime. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Julie Remington - Rethinking Our Biblical Understanding

    Nov 8, 202628 minAudio

    How much of the Bible story in your head comes from Scripture, and how much from tradition, art and assumption? Former missionary Julie Remington found that living in another culture changed the way she reads the Bible....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Fremon Williams - Healing Father Wounds

    Nov 1, 202634 minAudio

    Some people say the wounds left by a father’s absence are psychological, while others say they’re spiritual. What if healing requires both? Fremon Williams, a husband, father, pastor, speaker and author, lost his dad at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Eric Johnson - Faith, Counselling and Trauma Healing

    Oct 25, 202632 minAudio

    Can a psychologist hold a deep Christian faith and still take modern therapy seriously? Eric Johnson has spent more than 35 years teaching psychology and counselling, and over 25 years counselling people himself. As...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Alan and Autumn Ray - Learning To Be Married

    Oct 18, 202634 minAudio

    Why doesn’t knowing better always lead to doing better in marriage? Rodney Olsen sits down with Alan and Autumn Ray, who have been married since 1970. They met in college, and Alan spent more than 27 years in the Air...

    Credit the people on this episode