Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Bleeding Daylight

Bleeding Daylight artwork

David Pendergrass - Finding Truth Beyond Doubt

Sep 6, 202636 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Dr David Pendergrass is a pastor, biblical scholar and pastoral counsellor with a PhD in historical theology, and in this episode he talks with Rodney Olsen with striking honesty about the doubt that has shaped nearly 30 years of ministry. David shares the story of his dramatic call to ministry as a teenager, then walks through the two seasons in his life when he walked away from faith intellectually, driven by a deep fear of being "duped" by something that simply wasn't true. He explains how he worked through that doubt by seeking out trusted mentors, reading widely, and eventually writing his own book. The conversation moves beyond David's personal story into the bigger questions facing the church today: why so many people quietly deconstruct their faith rather than work through their doubts, why so few pastors have the theological training to sit with hard questions, and why David believes the true test of any gospel message is whether it would still hold up for believers suffering under persecution overseas. He also offers practical, compassionate steps for anyone currently wrestling with their own doubts, and a challenge to church leaders to be more honest about what they don't know. WEBLINKS David’s Website David on YouTube

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Wherever there are shadows, there are people ready to kick at the darkness until it bleeds daylight. This is Bleeding Daylight with your host, Rodney Olsen. Welcome to Bleeding Daylight. Thank you for listening. There are hundreds more inspirational episodes waiting for you at bleedingdaylight.net. Please find and follow Bleeding Daylight on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube, and it'd be great to connect with you.

What do you do when some of the things you've been taught about faith cause you to start doubting? Have you ever been told that you should believe without questioning? Is it okay to admit your doubts to others or even to God? Today's guest has travelled that journey. Today's guest is someone who's spent nearly 30 years wrestling with the big questions of faith and helping others do the same.

Dr David Pendergrass is a pastor, biblical scholar and pastoral counsellor with a PhD in historical theology. But what is perhaps most striking is his honesty about doubt. He walked away from faith intellectually twice before finding his way to a belief that could hold both his heart and his mind. He's taught scripture, revitalised churches, counselled couples through hard seasons and written extensively on what it means to move from simply knowing truth to actually living it. David, welcome to Bleeding Daylight.

Thank you so much. Really, my honour. Faith is never just about experience, but it's also not just about intellectual knowledge. I'm wondering if you can take me back to that profound experience you had of being called to ministry. Oh, very good question. Yeah, I became a Christian when I was around the age of six or seven, but I wanted to be an astronaut all my life. I was active in churches and I was 18 years old. At the time I was living in a place called Nashville, Tennessee, and I was coming home from a Bible study for a youth group, as I often did, in my mom's old car.

And there was a cassette of a singer who was popular in the States back in the 80s and 90s called Wayne Watson. And he wrote a song predicated upon the Beatitudes, and the song was called Blessed Are. It's a fantastic song. And there was a line in that song, it was talking about hunger and thirst for righteousness, and he says, those who hunger and thirst, I'm going to paraphrase, but he says, satisfied by none but Christ, this idea that they were hungry, hungry. And there was a season in my life for probably six months or so, I'd done a workbook called Experiencing God by Henry Blackaby.

It was really popular at the time. I had met him in person a couple of times. That verse and that song, I'd heard many times, but that night in particular, after that Bible study, just nailed it. I just had this incredible prayer, worship, praise time. I was telling God, that's it. It's like a hunger. I can't get enough of you. And I remember distinctly in that bumpy 30-minute drive home, by the time I parked, I was crying. I was tearing up. Had a thing back in the 1900s called cassettes. You got to push rewind. I'd rewind and push play, rewind and push play, because I thought that was it, and I was crying. And I just prayed and prayed and said, God, this is it.

I'll do whatever you want. The rest of my life, I'll do whatever. And I had this profound sense as if God said, okay, that's what I want. It was something like, okay, there's a sense of affirmation. I stopped the music and I cried and I prayed, and it wasn't just affective. It wasn't just a good therapy session. It wasn't just a good song. I've had great songs in my life. It was not that. I went inside a little different person. And I told my mom about the next morning before I was a senior in high school. I grew up in Baptist, in Baptist world, that's called the cult of ministry.

And I let it simmer for a while. I didn't tell someone immediately besides her. But over the next few days and then weeks, it just simply did not go away. I still love, love in a small, hell, astrophysics and science, all that space. But all of a sudden, my desires simply changed. And instead of thinking about trumpet scholarships and engineering and all this stuff, it was, no, it's going to be something in ministry. I chose it, but it chose me too. I mean, it's both and it seems to me. What that vocation would be, I didn't know. I had no angels speak to me.

It was just simple. You have a new direction. At first I thought maybe youth ministry. And then maybe I thought it was going to be music ministry. I was a music major for a while. I started in singing a quartet. And then about my master's degree, I really felt called more to do scholarship. And I had professors who believed I could do it. That's a big deal when you don't feel like you can. And so I applied for PhD programs and then thought I was going to be a professor for a while and then ended up eventually in pastoral ministry as a real sweet spot in leadership. But that's more than you ask. But yeah, that was a very big deal for me. Still is.

It's interesting that we can have an experience like that. And then as you say, you go on to do a lot of that book learning, learning about the faith. You're backing up experience with all that information, all that understanding of who God is. And yet you deal with doubt. Why do you think it is that we can have an experience of God in a very real way as you did? We can learn so much and say, yes, it all stacks up. And yet doubt starts to creep into our mind.

Great question. And doubt hit me really hard. I grew up in a home where I would say good evangelical theology was taught. I didn't have a lot of biblical knowledge, so I could sound like a normal Billy Graham sermon, you might say, but I didn't know where to find it. I didn't know a lot of Bible trivia facts. In my undergraduate degree and then some of my master's, that's when I really started to learn biblical stuff. And so it raised an enormous amount of questions, particularly about some things I had been taught and some things not, some things just ignorance of. I didn't know that at all.

But boy, that's troublesome. What do you mean there's textual variance? It raised a lot of questions. And it became kind of a snowball of intellectual inquiries of a lot of unanswered questions, a lot of things some people didn't tell me before. But in addition to that, I don't think it's really intellectual. I think there's also an emotional and spiritual component to this. And at the time it did feel like a kind of a spiritual warfare. I know the difference because today I'm always wanting to learn. I'm ignorant. I'm so ignorant. Ask my wife. I mean, so I'm not omniscient, even though all my degrees, I still love learning, but I don't feel scared.

I don't feel dark. I don't feel lonely. I don't feel despair because I'm ignorant. But in that season I did. So it wasn't just knowledge. It was knowledge mixed with a sense of what if none of this is true and it probably isn't true. My wife is a perfect example of a disciple of Jesus for whom this never occurred. She never went to higher education. And even then she's still bright and knowledgeable, but she's never had this kind of crisis of faith. She has her own questions and doubts here and there. But I did. Boy, I did. And so for me, what I did was I had professors that I really respected, one or two in particular.

I mean, I literally typed up questions of everything I could think of, and I would go to him, meet with him, and he'd say, now go read these books, go read these books. So I had a few live people to whom I could go that I trusted who wouldn't just say, just go pray about it. Secondly, of course, I had good authors. People like C.S. Lewis was very formative for me, very, very helpful. And to have people for whom Christianity both needed to make sense and feel right. For all my life, it had felt right, and it kind of made sense. Not everyone has to go through that or even does go through that, but boy, I did. And I'm glad I did. At the time, I was not glad at all.

I went to my undergraduate for about a year, year and a half. I was dating my wife, who's a Christian. Then we got married. She's saying, I'm about to marry this guy. What if he leaves Christianity? It was a very tough time. And then I was good for about a year and a half. And then it happened about six months of my bachelor's degree again, but that was shorter. I just had this, for whatever reason, overarching virtue. I don't want to be duped. If this stuff is stupid, I don't want to believe it. There's a speaker here in California, I think it's Greg Coco. He says, believing in Santa Claus felt good and made me a good little boy.

But it's gibberish. No one converts to Santaism late in life. Just because Christianity made me feel good, it made me a good little boy because I'm scared of being judged. That doesn't mean it's true at all. I remember that just really, I didn't hear that quote until many years later, but that's exactly what I was thinking back when I was 19, 20 years old. I thought, I want it to be true. That's all I've known. But if it's not, I don't, I've got to go. It was unflinching. And so I looked at all the world religions, the major things they taught, in addition to Christianity, of course, just even naturalism, atheism. I just went one by one by one, go these don't sound persuasive.

And then I had enough questions answered. Eventually I wrote a book when I was teaching in high school. It changed my ministry perspective as well. Whenever I teach, preach virtually all the time, I always lean toward the skeptic. The person goes, are you sure? Or this sounds pretty stupid. Or I just have a profound empathy and compassion for those who are on the fence or they've got questions. I personally get really worked up when I hear people say, I had questions and my pastor said, you know, just pray about it.

Or they don't ask those questions. I feel pretty defensive for such people. They don't need my help, but I do feel very protective for them. So I'm glad I went through it now because it influenced my teaching and preaching. And then eventually I wrote a book called A Skeptic Challenge to the Christian, where I give in about 200 pages, all the main reasons why I find Christianity to be the most persuasive of all the world religions. And why I think it's also not just the most persuasive compared to, but why I think it's true. I'm still a skeptical kind of person, no doubt about it, but I'm not a skeptic, of course. I made up my mind that it's true.

We live in an age where when people come to doubt, oftentimes we're hearing this term of deconstruction. The things that they were taught when they were young, no longer satisfy. But it seems rather than do what you did and going through the process of finding out what actually is truth, they will walk away from faith. And this is not to diminish the experience they're having. Obviously there are real doubts. How can we avoid going through that? How can we actually go through that period of doubt and say, this is what I'm feeling.

Where do I go now? Yeah, boy, another great question. I did a video on my YouTube channel, that exact question of my deconstruction, because I have a deep compassion for those who are going through it. And I say in the video spot five or six kind of major tips, but just to reiterate some of them now. One is, and this is difficult to do in evangelical cultures and my experience in the States, this is not uniform. It's not ubiquitous, but it is common for them not to feel safe to say what you just said, or I just said, like in public and public spaces, because it had to whisper.

I don't know if I believe that's true and Noah's Ark or this or that. And so I think as much as possible for those are going to deconstruction, I encourage to say there are people who are safe for whom they are not anxious. They will not shame you or judge you if you have questions or doubts or you're uncertain. You might have to work harder to find them. And I deeply commiserate with that need to find. God was very gracious to me that I had some people who are also not scared, like the professors and so forth. So that was very helpful. If you can find someone.

Secondly, I'd say if you can't find a human, there are books. Because it's emotional and spiritual as well, I also have now over 20 years experience in individual and couples counseling, that I have yet to meet a person or read from people deconstruction. And I've read it a lot from videos and books and whatever, who didn't have a deep emotional or spiritual thing, who eventually left. I don't know, maybe they were caught in some addiction and people said, let's not do that. And they felt judged, or maybe their spouse had an affair, or maybe their pastor molested them.

There's some deep wound or woundedness. So as a therapist, as a Christian counselor, my first question for people who doubt has been through all my ministry is not ever, it's never been, what are your major questions? My first question always is, can you tell me for a second, what are you afraid might happen if this were true? Deep inside, what are you afraid of? After I built some rapport with them, because usually it's driven by some fear. And I've met people who say, I'm afraid if it's true, I have to go back to church and they're going to molest me again. Or I've got to be my parents, but they're very manipulative, or I've got to this, or I've got to choose between what science tells me or my particular church's teaching on Genesis or this or that, or Revelation or whatever it might be.

If I choose, I'm going to lose all my friends and family, David. So I spend more time on the emotional, psychological, spiritual side. But then I still say, if they go, no, it's really just intellectual questions, well, then let's explore it. If that's a struggle to which you are going or have been on the fence about that, I would encourage you to say that there are people who can be supportive, even if they're in books. And secondly, of course, ask yourself, is there a type of emotional wound that you're trying to protect? And I would address that first. And by analogy, I do the same thing with people grieving.

Let's say I don't feel very close to God. My first question is not, what sin is in your life? I never ask that. I say, tell me for a second, what loss have you had in your life? Almost always a mom, a dad, a son from childhood or recently, and they're not grieved enough. And so if I grieve this, if I accept Christianity, I'm mad at God because my mom died or whomever. So I found oftentimes that's the case. In my own life, I don't remember having an emotional thing, but the spiritual thing was very real, intellectual and spiritual. My fear at the time was being duped. I had a big, strong fear of being seen or being and being seen as stupid.

That mattered to me a lot. And I see it in my life not to be seen as a dummy, as like, you'll be a laughingstock. If a smart person meets you and you believe in the fairy tales, you'll be an idiot. So at the time that was important for that part of me, it's not anymore, but at the time it sure was. And if I had therapists that said that to me, it would have saved me some time, frankly, I would address that quicker than I did. If you are deconstructing, no, there are people who can commiserate with you. They're really, really good books by specialists. What I found is the people typically deconstruct and then they go read Sam Harris, Richard Dawkins or whatever and go, Oh, I read so-and-so.

I'm all for books. I don't burn the books. My follow-up question is great. Did you read Richard Bauckham? Did you read Craig Keener? Did you read Richard Burge? Do you know who these people are? Do you know who Ben Whittington III is? Have you read N.T. Wright? That is, they don't know anybody in this field of New Testament scholarship, real genuine world-class historians, but they read a guy who's an evolutionist who knows nothing about Christianity and that's what persuaded them. I guess my response is if you're really interested in Christianity, if it's not just a ruse, rather you're like, I don't care about this stuff anyway.

I want to go have sex with my girlfriend. I don't care about Christianity. That's your motivation. I met people like that. But if you're genuinely interested, go talk to actual biblical scholars. And then if they don't persuade you, and I mean talk quotation in books, if they don't persuade you, fine. But there's really, really good resources out there to help you have those intellectual questions answered. And from my perspective, I think they're very persuasive. You might not think so, but a lot of us do. You mentioned this fear of being duped, and even some of the things that you were taught as you were growing up just turned out to not be the case.

And even for those who have questions, not feeling that they can ask those questions and go back to their church and ask, do you think there is perhaps those people in charge of those churches that are leading those churches don't actually have the answers themselves, and they don't want to be found out. They don't want to go through the rigor of dealing with their doubts. Amen. Hallelujah, yes. I agree. Yes. Respectfully, most pastors and leaders of the average-sized church, at least in America, most of them have received very little to no formal theological training.

And even if they have a master's degree, they might have a master's in something, but they spend more time in administration, budgeting, and whatever. Even some people have demons. Very few people in the pulpit at all can read the original languages. They never learned Greek and Hebrew. They never learned exegesis. They've never, ever read Second Temple Jewish literature. They don't know what the TLC is. They don't know what the acronym stands for, though everybody in scholarship knows what that is. And so that's not their specialty. They might be fantastic with hospital visits. They might be very charismatic, might be great singers, might be good fundraisers.

They might be phenomenal moms and dads. Absolutely. It just means it's not their training. So, absolutely, I concur. I've known, as peers, many, many, many pastors who did not have the training, so they don't know what to say when someone asks a question. If I may, from an insider, criticize that or constructive feedback that, and that is to say, I sure wish they did a better job of saying, I don't know, let's find out together. Because I think oftentimes emotionally their own anxiety comes up, their own fear comes up, as you suggest.

I mean, so instead what they do is either shut it down to avoid it, or they shame the person for asking the question. And of course, not to mention, there's a whole bunch of pastors who don't believe it at all anymore, but that's the only gig they know, so they have a paycheck. And there's a whole website called Former Clergy Project or something. It's thousands of ex-clergy who said they had too many questions about it, and then they left the faith. So it's a real terrible phenomenon of people trying to lead others, and they themselves are simply not trained for the job. And evangelicalism that I think, particularly in Pentecostalism, Charismatic traditions, where there's been a historical and historic diminishing of formal education.

I had the unicorn, I was in a PhD with a guy, he was from a one-miss Pentecostal background. You're a literate man, I know what that is, but he was such a good guy. He used to say, what are you doing here? He would laugh, he goes, he's a good old boy. He said, yeah, I know, I'm weird. Like, yeah, I mean, oh my goodness. So yeah, but in general, but my point of that is what happens in our church, at least in America, it breeds in a culture where charisma becomes authoritative, and the amount of people who attend become your metric of success, not how well they're able to read the biblical text.

I joined the chorus of copious other people who went through biblical training to say, we're in dangerous waters. I mean, frankly, I'll be authentic. It's embarrassing to me how ignorant so many people are. It's not embarrassing to be ignorant. It's people in positions of authority trying to teach other people. I always think about James, right? He says, you should not want to be teachers. You'll be judged doubly. I take that very seriously. God can still use them. Of course, he can speak through donkeys. I hope he speaks through this donkey talking right now. I believe he does. I know he does.

Absolutely. My only point is I still think we have the moral responsibility as church leaders and teachers to do as much rigorous training as we can possibly do with the resources we have. That's very different in the villages of India. I've got Indian pastors there who work in the mud. They don't have access. Of course not. I send them my resources for free. Of course. I'm not shaming people because they're ignorant or whatever. What's embarrassing to me is how that culture is bred and buttressed and supported. It's like a huge train that doesn't seem like it's going to derail.

That's unfortunate. I suspect there are a lot of pastors who don't feel comfortable with the discussion of deconstruction because they themselves don't know what the answers are or are scared to bring it up themselves. I agree. Is part of the problem with doubt the additions that we've put onto the Christian faith that we have added so much over the years that if you are Christian, you vote in this particular way, you think in this particular way. When we see those extra bits and pieces that we've added onto faith start to crumble, we believe that that's our faith crumbling.

When, as you say, when you go back to the scriptures, that's not there in the text. Completely. I genuinely completely concur. People say, well, I think I'm losing my faith. I was a faith in what? I'm not being silly. I'm not being sarcastic. I really mean the faith in what I'm listening. What are you losing faith? You know, God. OK, which God? I mean, talk to me about the God you think you're leaving. Talk to me about the Jesus you think you are now abandoning, because that's what you're doing. You're saying Jesus, does he not exist as an authoritative? If you had a quote-unquote religious experience, baptismal experience and so forth, if you had that and now you're not, are you saying you were delusional when that occurred?

Or are you saying, no, I wasn't delusional. It really happened. It's really real. I'm just saying, no, I don't want to do it. Like, I'm divorcing a person who's real. OK, why? In my experience, those accretions, I'm really leaving a faith that is, in my heart and mind, manipulative, or I have to be a Calvinist, or I have to believe in a certain interpretation of Revelation, or I have to be a dispensationalist. So I often go back, very often, especially my YouTube comments. I had an email correspondence with a guy the other day about that. I go, you can disagree.

He's talking about judges and Joshua and the warfare. I said, let's, for the sake of argument, say it's all fairy tale, that none of that happened. So what? You can still be a Christian. It might change your understanding of the authority of the text, or if you have a view of inerrancy, great, but that doesn't mean you're not a Christian. This all or nothingness that so many people and so many leaders make people believe, I think, causes great damage. Even for you to say these accretions, I concur with that, but that always assumes we're on the same page that some things are non-negotiable, some things are negotiable.

Some things are essential, so I think those words aren't in the Greek, in the Testament, but I can argue, I think persuasively, the concepture is. When you read Acts, it never says you have to believe 50 things of an average statement of faith you see now in a church. They didn't require those kind of things. I think those things still matter, but when we talk about Christianity, let's go back to brass tacks. And in my works, I try my best in my own books and workbooks to go back to brass tacks to say, this seems to be at the core. Can we at least keep the bullseye? People might disagree with me that it's not the bullseye.

That's fine, but I do know that I'm coming out of an almost out of training to say, I think I am presenting what Lewis would call mere Christianity. We don't have to throw the proverbial baby out the bathwater. Sometimes we're leaving a faith that wasn't real in the first place. Sometimes we're leaving something that was dysfunctional and bad. Those are good things. It just means they're so scared to go back. And I could tell so many pastoral stories of people who have come to my church, praised Jesus, and I didn't step church for 12 years, 25, I've been church for 30 years because of what happened to me, and finally kind of tipped their toe in the water, as it were, to come back.

And I was like, I'm so proud of you. I can't imagine how much courage it took because there's enough faith, enough string to say, okay, let's try this and go without all the other stuff added to it. You mentioned that you try to help to resource those pastors in places like India who are working under very difficult circumstances. Is that part of the test that we can put on to the faith that we say we believe in, that this might preach well in Australia or Canada or the US, but will it preach in India?

Is it the same belief that we're taking to other Asian countries or African countries? Is this something that is universal across the world? Will this work, or are we just attaching too much of our culture to what we say we believe? Yeah, so that litmus test I use all the time. It's a frightening, awesome, and terrible litmus test, but I think mandatory, that is when it comes to suffering. So everything I say in the background of mine, something about the cross, Mark 834, right, if you're going to follow me, deny your will to give a cross to follow me.

Whatever comes out of my mouth, ever, on a video, in a sermon, a lesson, or my literature, if that's not true, I don't know, it's not cross-cultural. First, it's not true to Jesus, and two, it's not cross-cultural. And I just heard a guy who means well, I'm visiting a certain church recently, and he said on the stage, big bold on the font, going through Malachi, and God wants you to be prosperous. He wants you to be, I thought, I just, my first thought was what you just said. How could you conceivably say that to those in India right now, and those all in Africa, and other countries that are being slaughtered, beheaded, the churches, people being burned alive.

There's a fantastic, fantastic, depressing book called Suffering by Craig Keener, every Christian should read. I should be required reading Suffering by Craig Keener. The litany of things through which Christians go. I don't think suffering is the sine qua non, the only mark a person must go through in order to be a Christian. I'm just saying, obviously, as you just said, but if it doesn't preach there, then I think your gospel's wrong. Now, why would I say such a thing? Because Jesus did. Jesus did.

Picking up a cross and being willing to be put to shame and killed for him, to me, is an absolute essential or non-negotiable to the gospel. Any understanding of the teaching of Jesus outside of that is at the core. I mean, Jesus went to the cross. To me, it's a no-brainer. I agree. Our gospel shouldn't sound American. It shouldn't sound white. It shouldn't sound Australian. It just shouldn't. I get worked up about that. I'm taking a deep breath right now. I get worked up. I do. I just, it drives me bonkers.

We're not trying to colonize people. We're trying to recruit people to be disciples of Jesus. If there's any type of culture it should sound like, it's first century Judaism, because that would be appropriate. When we look at things like, as you mentioned, this prosperity gospel, I remember hearing John Piper talking about why are we trying to dress up something that the world already wants, rather than the distinct differences that there are in Christianity. Do you think that we've tried to do that for too long, to just dress up and attract people in at any cost, rather than that intellectual rigor, that real understanding of what is at stake here?

In America, particularly larger churches and evangelical churches, I'm most familiar with that. I've worked in Methodist and Disciples of Christ and Baptist and on and on. So I have about five denominations. I have some experience, but I don't know all the churches. I've struggled with that too, personally. The benefit of the doubt is to say the leaders who do that, I experience this often in churches when I visit, the benefit of the doubt is to say that the leaders who do that, that being, they'll say things like, God, they're kind of vague, God wants to bless you, he's for you, wants

you to prosper, that kind of stuff, is that they're trying their best for Christianity to sound attractive, so they'll come and listen. They're going to go fishing, get the fish closer, and then we're going to let them leave them there. That benefit of the doubt. My response is, in my experience, that has never happened. They go fishing, they bring them closer, what they have now is another fish who thinks God wants you to prosper. It's not like they come close and then they say, now let's study good exegesis of Mark 8. They might say some of that, but in general, that's not from the pulpit all the time. The worst case scenario, which is one more I'm afraid of, one would be the leaders think this stuff is true, which would be just terribly dangerous and embarrassing.

I don't know what God would think of all of us. But the other would be simply they're doing it, and they simply messed up. They're trying hard to be attractive. Jesus doesn't need my protection in the least bit, but I do feel a natural kind of defense for people I care about to be ripped out of context, whether it's my friend, my family, you. If someone said, Bob said blank, no, he didn't. I heard Rodney said, no, he didn't. I was there. And that's what it was Jesus. So when they say, what God really wants, or Jesus and I go, no, he didn't say that. Why would you say that?

I heard Joel Osteen say on television years ago, he used to live in Houston, Texas for about 12 years. He was on TV all the time. He said, God wants everyone to own a home. Respect, that's one of the stupidest things I've ever heard. I immediately thought of the billions of people who can't afford a home or live in apartments or trailers. It's this kind of stuff that I think appeals to our sense of materialism and power and pleasure. I think it's disgusting. I think about Isaiah when he says, you worship me with your lips, but your hearts are far from me. Of course Jesus quotes that. I think we have a real responsibility to be as authentic and as accurate as we can to the teaching of Jesus.

And that would mean the very thing we're afraid of doing, which is be willing to pick up a cross and die for him. And there's very, very, very little pushback for a human being to hear God's for you, he's for you, he's for you, he's for you, he wants to bless you, bless you, bless you. Who doesn't want to hear that all the time? I mean, everyone likes a good pep rally. Dietrich Bonhoeffer, when he calls you, he bids men come and die. Said everyone does to die for their faith opponents, but if it's self-denial for the kingdom of God, that doesn't preach well. That doesn't fill up the stadiums.

But it's true. And so we've got to really come to grips with that. And I do go back to fussing at the leadership. It just seems to me we have a phenomenal responsibility to make sure we have to be willing to have a smaller church that might be embarrassing to us and not have the mega church because we've actually proclaimed the gospel well. We have to be willing to have to be our cross, if that so be it. I don't know anywhere around that. You've done the intellectual hard yards of looking into this idea of faith and even looking at other faiths.

You are now convinced that faith in Christ is the true way. But are there still doubts that drive you back to say, I need to discover this? Not a wholesale, I don't know if I believe any of this, but are there still times that doubt will drive you back to scripture or back to learning to say, this is another area that I want to explore? Questions, yes, because I'm always, we would say like nerding out. I mean, it just goes on and on. I love learning.

I love it. So in that sense, what does that mean? I wonder what this, how did the first century Jews think of this? I wonder what that word meant in the, okay, look up the Greek again, the Hebrew, whatever. So that all the time, as far as a kind of doubt that you might say kind of gnaws at me or I can't shake it. No, sir. That hasn't happened a long time. Hasn't a long time. I went through so many years after those seasons of doubt when I was writing my book and afterwards, I just read voraciously of numerous books that helped me.

Well, try to practice what I preached earlier, which is when I had questions, I went and read scholars. And so I kept reading until all, and if I didn't like the answer, well, I don't find that persuasive. And I let out simmer and simmer. I did that for a long time, but now I feel much more like the sea is calm. So questions, sure. So nothing that nags me, there are things I wish God would do differently, but no doubt about that. But thankfully he doesn't ask my opinion on anything. Well, not anything, but so yeah, nothing right now. So now I, I used for a long time when I'd watch atheist videos and read atheist books, cause I didn't read just Christians.

I wanted to read what atheists were saying. I want to watch what they're saying. I did it so much after a couple of years, I got to the place and I knew that I would hurt enough. When I heard all the same stuff over and over and over, it was all regurgitated. Now there's seasons of popularity. Like right now, it's really popular to say, what about animal suffering? Things like that. And I might go, Oh, what would I say about that? And I formulate my ideas and move on with life. But once I got to the place where I kind of heard it all, then I felt settled. But for me, that was rigorous, took a long time. I, like I said, my wife doesn't go through that. She doesn't go through an atheist rabbit hole on YouTube.

She couldn't care less, but I do cause I don't want to be in a dupe book. So yeah, nothing right now I can think of. I think that distinction between you and your wife is encouraging for us, because I'm sure that there's some people listening at the moment who say, I've never actually gone through that kind of doubt before. And then others who say, Hey, I'm deep in the middle of doubt. So it tells us that, Hey, for different people, we will go through different seasons. But for someone who is going through doubt at the moment, starting to go through that, and maybe they haven't felt that they've been allowed to question before, what's the starting point for them to start to head towards discovering for themselves the truth?

We're not saying you must believe Christianity and therefore this is the way to go, but to actually intellectually, honestly look at the facts before them. I would first say to you, if I know anything about God, He's okay with you questioning and doubting. If I know anything about Him, and maybe I'm delusional myself and crazy, that's absolutely a possibility. But the God I meet through the Old Testament, even through Jesus of Nazareth, loves you so much that He is not scared of your questions.

He's not mad at your questions. He's not judging you because you doubt Him at all. That may be very difficult for that person to grasp if they had a father or a mother who was distant or always mad at them, and it'd be very difficult. You might need some good counseling there. But if what I just said resonates with you, like, no, okay, that helps me hear that, well then great. But if it doesn't, if you hear that and go, Nope, I know He's not listening, I strongly encourage you to talk to a Christian counselor to figure out why it is that it's so difficult for you to believe that on an emotional level.

On an intellectual level, I would say is, the first step really is to acknowledge it. Genuinely admit it. Try your best to simply be as authentic and a piece of paper, a dear friend. I would say God Almighty, if you still believe in Him, to say, I'm struggling with this. I doubt blank. I don't understand blank, and I'm really upset about it. Just simply labeling it takes a lot of power away and the anxiety with it. So then the next step is get real specific about what your doubt is as much as possible. What is it?

Is it a question? Is it an issue? Write it down. I mean, I've done that. I had a list of them. I had a list of them. So I don't like that God, quote, sends people to hell. That's a typical way Christians say that. I don't think, use that vocabulary, but okay. Sends people to hell. Okay, what about that do you not like? It's not fair. What's not fair? What about people who've never heard about Jesus? Oh, okay, that's called the fate of the angel evangelized. There's got to be 500 books on the topic. What do you want to read? What do you want to start first? That chain of figuring out what labeling it and then figuring out what the issue is, that's how you know you're doing research.

And research is not a Google search. You might need to have the books. You might have to go talk to someone, do a little homework or a pastor or something or email people like Rodney and say, hey, who should I read? Or a library. That's fair enough. But labeling it and finding out the question, then go pursue it. And if you give yourself time, that's what it is. One after the other. Well, what about so-and-so? Wonderful. Let's go talk about that. Let's read until we find that satisfying. And if not, the whole shebang you're done and none of us persuasive. My question is going to be, if I were talking, I would say is who did you read?

But secondly, I would say, okay, well, I mean, that's, you're the judge and jury, but that's exactly what I would do. I would have been a nutshell. Those are three things I would do. There are resources on your website, including links to the book you mentioned and others that you've written. Those links are in the show notes at bleedingdaylight.net so that people can find you there. I'd love to be able to talk for hours on end because there's so much there to discover. But I just want to say, David, thank you so much for the honesty that you've taken to go on the journey that you have to overcome those doubts, but also the way that you're helping others to do that.

And thank you especially for spending time with me today on Bleeding Daylight. Thank you. Seriously, this is a great, great interview. Thank you so much for your time. And I will pray for you and your audience. Thank you so much. Thank you for listening to Bleeding Daylight. Please help us to shine more light into the darkness by sharing this episode with others. For further details and more episodes, please visit bleedingdaylight.net.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Wes Pritchett - Faith, Survival and Unexpected Grace

    Nov 15, 202630 minAudio

    At just 19, Wes Pritchett was arrested at gunpoint in Texas and spent almost seven months in the Dallas County Jail. He had been a young musician and had never been formally charged with a serious crime. In this...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Julie Remington - Rethinking Our Biblical Understanding

    Nov 8, 202628 minAudio

    How much of the Bible story in your head comes from Scripture, and how much from tradition, art and assumption? Former missionary Julie Remington found that living in another culture changed the way she reads the Bible....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Fremon Williams - Healing Father Wounds

    Nov 1, 202634 minAudio

    Some people say the wounds left by a father’s absence are psychological, while others say they’re spiritual. What if healing requires both? Fremon Williams, a husband, father, pastor, speaker and author, lost his dad at...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Eric Johnson - Faith, Counselling and Trauma Healing

    Oct 25, 202632 minAudio

    Can a psychologist hold a deep Christian faith and still take modern therapy seriously? Eric Johnson has spent more than 35 years teaching psychology and counselling, and over 25 years counselling people himself. As...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Alan and Autumn Ray - Learning To Be Married

    Oct 18, 202634 minAudio

    Why doesn’t knowing better always lead to doing better in marriage? Rodney Olsen sits down with Alan and Autumn Ray, who have been married since 1970. They met in college, and Alan spent more than 27 years in the Air...

    Credit the people on this episode