I could hardly ask for a better location. On a sunny, fall afternoon, on a boat on the Vltava, I played trumpet, gave a talk, played a fujara, and read some poetry. This was my fourth day with the fujara and my third public concert with the instrument. I was requested for an encore so, hey, that’s not too bad! The crowd is a group of practicing anarchists, so they are no strangers to the concept. However, the religious history was new to some of them. I was time-limited to 15 minutes. As I mention in my first words, this talk is modeled after the golden age of radio. In the early twentieth century, it was not uncommon for radio programming to include many different types of sound in one hour. It wasn’t until radios went into cars did programming become more fixed. When the radio was in the home, people sat and gave their attention to the variety show. In the car, the radio became background music. In the talk, I recited my translation of The Bloody Sonnets, sonnet #9. You can read it in Wasted Blood or in the link below. The audience, as you can imagine, is privacy sensitive. So I’ve made some cuts and edit to video to respect that. For all of you reading and watching along, I appreciate your support. It’s certainly not cheap to go to Prague and deliver these talks, but I also have many friends there so I enjoy the trip. So, I’m not necessarily asking for your financial support, but of course you can become a paid member or purchase the physical or digital version of Wasted Blood. I would appreciate it greatly though if you liked and shared this post so that it can reach others as I do keep this publication without a paywall. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit bitpunkfm.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01All right, thank you for attending the talk. Anarchy with a Religious Face. In the early 20th century, in the golden age of radio, Before all this advanced technology, radio programs used to be more of a variety show. So in a single hour, you would hear music, you would hear speaking, you would hear poetry, you would hear comedy, you would hear audio drama.
SPEAKER_01This is how it worked up until radio started to be installed into cars and the medium changed. This talk is modeled after the golden age of radio in its format.
SPEAKER_00Yay. [music]
SPEAKER_01So religious anarchy has this paradox to it. How do you have religion and anarchy go together? Anarchy is no gods, no masters, and religion has both of them. So how do we square this circle? It is kind of the concept, as I understand it, as religious anarchy is one god, one master. So depending on the religion, this thread of philosophical thought happens in many different religions. In this talk, we'll be focusing on Christian anarchy only because of,
SPEAKER_01this is the one I'm most familiar with, but this thought shows up in most of the major religions as well. So, and if we're talking about Christian anarchy, we have to go back to the OG, Anarchist, who of course is Jesus. And so, Christian anarchists believe that Jesus was himself an anarchist. And why do they come to his position? Well, he was not very friends of the state. I mean, I personally stopped paying attention to politicians after Pontius Pilate.
SPEAKER_01If he got it wrong, they have not improved. So, what Christian anarchists will do is they will go through and kind of go through the parables and offer their interpretations of the parables and how they fit this Christian anarchy. For example, most people probably know the saying that, give unto Caesar what is Caesar's. Well, statists will go and say, see this is This is exactly why Christians should follow this authority
SPEAKER_01because Jesus is saying, here's this authority. But no, no. Christian anarchists will say, actually, the way this parable went down is Jesus said, someone asked Jesus, of course, hey, if I join your religion, do I have to pay taxes? This is obviously why people are motivated for religion. Jesus goes, well, I know you are trying to trick me. Fetch me a coin. And so they fetched Jesus a coin. And he says, give unto Caesar what is Caesar's. Now, Jacques Ellul,
SPEAKER_01who we'll talk about a little bit later, he says what Jesus actually means there is that fiat shitcoin was actually He's stamped with the face of Caesar. So when Jesus is saying, give unto Caesar what to Caesar, he's saying, let Caesar rug pull this currency. This currency is not of God. It's not that we should have, this has no authority over us here. And so essentially in Christian anarchy especially, it is this kind of interpretation of going through.
SPEAKER_01Another one is in the three temptations of Jesus. He's in the desert. And the last temptation is the devil goes to Jesus and says, see all these governments? You see all these? If you bow down to me, I will give them all to you. Jesus, of course, rejects this. But the Christian anarchy interpretation is why the devil, these governments actually belonged to the devil because that is the only way he could offer them to Jesus. So, just the fact of, we'll see this theme come up,
SPEAKER_01but the fact of having a government in this Christian anarchy belief is already that it's a corrupted thing. So, he's the OG. This is where things start. We're going to skip forward until the 15th century for a local example. I want to find some local examples, and of course we have one with Peter Helczycki. Peter Helczycki, a Czech philosopher, he is born in the same time of Jan Hus, and so this whole movement here, but he puts forth this idea called the net of faith,
SPEAKER_01and so he writes this book, The Net of Faith, and his idea is like, well, you know, Jesus said, let us catch men with this net, and we should be fishers of men. And Peter Helczycki says, this is great, I love this. But you know what? We caught two big, fat, ugly whales in this net. They ripped the net open and now our net no longer works. And who were the two whales that were caught into this net? The Pope and the Emperor. In about 314 A.D.,
SPEAKER_01when the Christian Church joins with Constantine and it becomes this fully sanctified state church. According to Peter Helczycki, this is where it all went wrong. Furthermore, Pietro Halczycki believed that Christians not only should not vote, they should not have any role in the government, they shouldn't tax each other, and he was more of an anarcho-socialist, so they believed that Christians should not own property. So this idea kind of floats around with this net of faith.
SPEAKER_01And two talks ago, I was excited to see that some of you'll hear this name again, Leo Tolstoy, Is directly inspired by the net of faith. So Leo Tolstoy, the Russian writer, writes three amazing novels, War and Peace, Anna Karenina. And then he has this spiritual crisis. He is almost committing suicide. He doesn't know what to do. He talks to all these Russian Orthodox priests. And he basically says, yeah, he's like, this is all messed up. Anna Karenina, one of the best novels. It very much critiques the elite class in Tsarist Russia.
SPEAKER_00Much of the elite class is acting the same today.
SPEAKER_01And so the book is very much the same. And he comes up with this idea, again, promoting this kind of Christian anarchism. And he's more of like a pacifist anarchist as well. Then to fast forward even more, one of the later things is Jacques Ellul. Jacques Ellul, everyone should read. He's three books that is quite famous. One is Propaganda, which I think everyone should read because in Propaganda, Jacques Aul says, the smartest and most literate, most intelligent people who believe themselves not susceptible
SPEAKER_01to propaganda are them they selves most susceptible to propaganda. So I think it's one of the best books to understand Western propaganda. The second book I think everyone here should read is The Technological Society, which he critiques very much this idea of progress based on efficiency from technology, which I think is interesting for this group. And then this third book he writes is again about Christian anarchy, again, kind of promoting this idea. And really the idea is what I said, and it's still in the beginning. It's, hey, we have, for Christian anarchists, we have Jesus, we've got the Bible.
SPEAKER_01It's very much a Protestant kind of idea, but even pushing it further that the state is evil. So this is kind of the lineage of this. There are still active philosophers in this area. Some papers are being promoted in this. But we've had now enough history. We can only take so much history before we have to hear some music. So now I'm going to play another piece. Because I'm about to read a poem, and this poem is by a Slovak poet, Hviesislav. I'm sorry for all the Slovaks in the room if this gives you kind
SPEAKER_01of like bad memories from your childhood. But I spent about nine months translating the bloody sonnets. And in this poem I'm about to read is my own translation. And Hebeza Slav would not say he was a Christian anarchist. But he is critiquing Christianity, especially for its, this is World War I, he writes this in World War I, in July and August of 1914. So he's very, he almost has a divination of how the World War I is to go.
SPEAKER_01So he's a quite inspiring poet. But you'll get the sense of what I mean on this kind of anarcho-pacifism. But first, we will introduce the Fouyera. [music]
SPEAKER_01Your Christianity is a lie filled with falsehood. Enough talk about sinners. You mimic the Tartar, Vandal, Hun, and now master their craft. You seek shelter in their sanctuaries, but creep So this is, yeah, thank you.
SPEAKER_01Chivie Zislav writes 32 of the sonnets. This was sonnet number nine. And so I have now explained this history of this religious thought coming up there. And I want to then show another group that puts this in practice. And this is the Religious Society of Friends, otherwise known as Quakers. Leo Tolstoy in The Kingdom of God is Within You also cites the Quakers as kind of an inspiration. And what is unique about Quakers is that they don't vote in their religious meetings.
SPEAKER_01In fact, they come to a consensus without voting. So how is this possible? This is analog blockchain. This is a protocol before technology. Somehow people are able to agree without doing it. How does this work? And so it's been going on for something like 350 years. And what they do is they're very much into sitting in silence. And this idea is sitting in silence and letting the spirit speak through them.
SPEAKER_01So there will be a meeting of which there is no real leader. There's like an administrator. But there is not really a leader of the organization. It's also a very kind of anarchist idea. So they will join in the meeting, they will have like a minute, they will maybe have to approve a budget, or they may have to do something. This is floated, this is the budget. There may be very contentious arguments, but everybody speaks with a long pause in between. Usually 30 seconds to maybe a minute of silence before the next person speaks.
SPEAKER_01So this helps everybody kind of calm down. And how does it end? It ends when there is a general consensus. It is kind of a spiritual thing of what this means. But when there is a general consensus of agreement, the... The administrator will basically say, okay, I think we approve, I have a sense that the meeting agrees, and we'll approve the budget. And then they write it in the minute. And so if you are there, anyone can veto, like essentially anyone has this veto power.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, it's quite a powerful technique. It is very inefficient. And so why, yeah, so this is the downside. So why don't they do this? And in reading Leo Tolstoy, I discovered this Kind of Slavic origin word nazilye, meaning violence. But in Russian apparently has this extra meaning of coercion. So the idea here is that voting is coercion. And it's coercion because the 51% that would do a majority vote would essentially force their will on the 49%.
SPEAKER_01And so it is much better In the American, and Quakers would say, that to have this unity, is what the word they use, to have a consensus. And if it takes longer, this is fine. Like this is just, we're on an internal timeline, not on a quarter timeline, right? So the incentives of the Long Now Project, some of you may know the Long Now Project. Yeah, exactly. So how you think about time enforces some of this. Many religious organizations probably think about time a little differently. So the inefficiency is part of the program.
SPEAKER_01And so this is how, for example, they'll come to an agreement. This is a lightning talk. It was meant to be quick, like lightning. The intention was to entertain and educate, offer you some initial exposures to this concept of religious anarchy. If you're curious, what I hope you can do is take these to other organizations, maybe think about something some other ways. Now you have some examples of other organizations that have been living these parallel societies in a more spiritual way.
SPEAKER_01It may or may not be useful to you, but I hope now you're at least aware of the history of this philosophy. So with that, thank you. Thank you very much. One more on the free era. Okay. Okay. All right. Can I have time for an encore? All right. All right. Let's do it. [music]
SPEAKER_00Josh, thank you so much. Amazing. Oh, thank you. I mean, like, yeah, all of it. Amazing.
SPEAKER_01Appreciate it. Yeah. All right. Thank you so much. Yeah.
My good friends, it is our great honor to present to you Act 2, Scene 1 of radio community theater production of Shakespeare’s Coriolanus, which we call Coriolanus.fm. Synopsis News spreads of Caius Martius’ return to...
The cast interviews continue with a voice we will miss for an act or two. Jon Murphy is our Aufidius and like a great rival, while he is not on the screen, he occupies the thoughts of those that hate or love him. As we...
Enthusiasm in infectious. Jazz music, to many, sounds chaotic and noisy. But if you find someone who appreciates that medium, that truly loves it, you can’t help but grow new eyes. Ricardo Guzman Jr and I started off...
Before Veterans Day, before Armistice Day, there was St. Martin’s Day. Americans renamed November 11th to Veterans Day in 1954 and most famously, Kurt Vonnegut, himself a veteran was not happy about it. Writing this in...
Thank you to Luciana Moroianu for the interview today! Luciana is the voice of Volumnia in coriolanus.fm. We covered topics from Romanian folk traditions, poetry in prisons, the etymology of Coriolanus’ names, and to...