Send us Fan Mail Did John Foxe’s Book of Martyrs create English anti-Catholicism - or give an existing conflict its most enduring stories? In the second of three solo episodes, Samuel Woodall examines the image of “Bloody Mary”, the changing editions of Acts and Monuments, the papal bull against Elizabeth I and Robert Persons’s Catholic response. The discussion asks how rival histories turned persecution into national memory, and why memories of suffering could encourage both religious exclusion and sympathy for conscience. CHAPTERS 00:00 Theme and introduction 01:07 Foxe’s polemical history 03:28 Why the editions and political context matter 05:25 Robert Persons and the Catholic response 07:24 Evidence, credibility and rival histories 07:57 Memory, identity and the Catholic other 09:01 Tolerance and intolerance together 10:14 Did Foxe create English anti-Catholicism? 11:21 The question of toleration READ ALONG John Foxe, Acts and Monuments: The Unabridged Acts and Monuments Online, University of Sheffield: https://www.dhi.ac.uk/foxe/ SELECTED READING John Foxe, Acts and Monuments (English editions: 1563, 1570, 1576 and 1583). Robert Persons (also known as Parsons), A Treatise of Three Conversions of England (1603-1604). Alexandra Walsham, Charitable Hatred: Tolerance and Intolerance in England, 1500-1700. PREVIOUS EPISODE Foxe’s Book of Martyrs and the Making of Protestant England: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2238237/episodes/20104628 EXPLORE AND DISCUSS Beyond the Text: https://beyondthetext.co.uk The Intellectual Historian: https://theintellectualhistorian.com The History of Ideas Reading Club: https://thehistoryofideasclub.co.uk Music: “Queens Arrival” - Red Planet / TakeTones. Cover: illustrative artwork created for this episode. Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00The image of Mary I as Bloody Mary remains one of the most durable reputations in English history. It survives in school textbooks, popular documentaries, and the shorthand through which Tudor England is remembered. John Fox did not invent every element of that image, but his acts and monuments gave it a narrative power that few later histories could escape. So the question for this episode is direct. Did Fox create English anti-Catholicism?
SPEAKER_00The tempting answer is yes. Fox depicted papal authority as an enemy of the true church, placed Protestant suffering at the centre of national history, and filled his book with memorable scenes of Catholic officials sending believers to the fire. But the closer we look, the less satisfactory a simple answer becomes. We should begin by admitting what the book is. Ax and Monuments is not neutral between Catholicism and Protestantism. Fox believed that the Reformation restored Christian truth.
SPEAKER_00He attacked the papacy, rejected Catholic teaching, and interpreted persecution through an apocalyptic conflict between Christ and Antichrist. The martyrs' stories reinforce that contrast. Protestant prisoners reason from scripture, confront hostile examiners, and remain constant at death. Their persecutors frequently appear cruel, evasive, or spiritually blind. The structure makes sympathy flow in one direction. Historians such as William Hallor emphasized the way Fox helped create an idea of England as an elect Protestant nation.
SPEAKER_00Christopher Hay and other revisionists drew attention to the pressure propaganda and political management involved in making England Protestant. From that perspective, the Book of Martyrs did more than preserve memory. It trained generations to understand Catholicism through the Marian fires. There is real force in that argument. Fox's work helped make the burnings of the 1550s more culturally prominent than many other acts of Tudor violence. The repeated additions, abridgments, sermons, and later retellings carried those memories into the 17th century and beyond.
SPEAKER_00The numbers themselves mattered. Nearly 300 Protestants were executed during Mary's reign, but Fox transformed a grim total into individual lives. He named trades, towns, families, examinations, and final words. This local detail allowed readers to imagine persecution entering ordinary English communities rather than remaining an abstract decision of bishops and counsellors. The label Bloody Mary was not a neutral summary of her reign. It condensed a Protestant judgment about legitimate and illegitimate violence.
SPEAKER_00Other Tudor monarchs also used execution and coercion, and Protestants had supported punishments for religious error. Fox's narrative nevertheless made Marion fire the defining violence against which later government could be judged. But anti-papal polemic is not identical to an unchanging hatred of every Catholic, nor does the book's later use tell us everything about the intentions and choices of its author. Fox's four English editions appeared in 1563, 1570, 1576, and 1583.
SPEAKER_00Each responded to new evidence, criticism, and political circumstance. This textual movement complicates any claim that the book carried one fixed quantity of anti-Catholic hostility from beginning to end. The 1563 edition appeared early in Elizabeth's reign, when the religious settlement was still being established. By 1570, the situation had changed. Pope Pius V issued regnans in Excelsis, excommunicating Elizabeth, denying her right to rule, and releasing her subjects from obedience.
SPEAKER_00A copy was posted in London. The bull intensified the association between Catholic allegiance and political danger. The much larger second edition of Acts and Monuments appeared in this atmosphere. We should be cautious about treating every revision as a direct reaction to one document. A book of more than 2,000 pages had a long process of collection and printing. Nevertheless, the changing political context affected how readers understood Fox's attacks upon Rome.
SPEAKER_00After 1570, the papacy could be represented not only as a religious opponent, but as a power challenging the legitimacy of the English monarch. Later plots, missionary activity, and the Spanish Armada would intensify that fusion of religion and national security. This is why historical context matters. Anti-Catholicism was not a single prejudice operating at the same temperature throughout the century. It could grow sharper during moments of diplomatic crisis, rebellion, war, or fear of assassination.
SPEAKER_00Fox's text both shaped those fears and was reread through them. The battle over memory did not remain one-sided. In 1603 and 1604, the Jesuit Robert Parsons published a treatise of three conversions of England. Parsons offered a Catholic national history against Fox's Protestant account. He challenged Fox's evidence, disputed individual martyr stories, and accused him of turning religious disagreement into a mythology of persecution.
SPEAKER_00This was more than a quarrel about facts. Fox and Parsons were competing to define England's Christian past. Who represented continuity? Who had introduced novelty? Which deaths counted as martyrdom, and which were lawful punishments for heresy or treason. The dispute extended to the Lollards and to vernacular scripture. Fox treated medieval dissenters as Protestant forebears. Parsons argued that Fox distorted both their beliefs and the actions of Catholic authorities.
SPEAKER_00Each side understood that control of the pre-Reformation past could strengthen its claim to represent the authentic English Church. Parsons also reminds us that English Catholics possessed memories of persecution of their own. Missionary priests were imprisoned and executed under Elizabeth. Catholic households faced searches and recusancy penalties, and conformity could be demanded through law. Catholic writers could therefore reverse Stokes' accusation.
SPEAKER_00Protestants condemned Marian persecution while defending coercion when they controlled the state. This did not mean the two regimes identical, and it did not settle arguments about whether particular prosecutions concerned belief or treason. It did show that martyrdom was a contested political category. The same execution could be described by one side as witness to faith, and by the other as lawful punishment for rebellion. The struggle over Fox was therefore also a struggle over credibility.
SPEAKER_00Who counted as a trustworthy witness? Were recantations voluntary? Were reported miracles, speeches, and acts of courage, remembered accurately? Fox's critics attack details because weakening the evidence could weaken the larger Protestant account of Providence. That is a useful reminder. Confessional identities were not created only by attacking an enemy, they were created by offering rival histories of the same nation. Martyrologies perform at least two tasks.
SPEAKER_00They define the virtues of the community, and they preserve the terror of persecution. Fox's martyrs demonstrate courage, scriptural knowledge, constancy, and willingness to die rather than betray conscience. Their persecutors become the negative image against which those virtues are displayed. This clearly encouraged a Catholic other, yet the emotional force of the book came from more than doctrine. Many of its readers belong to families and communities that remembered imprisonment, exile, or death under Mary.
SPEAKER_00Fox gave traumatized memory an organized form. Trauma does not automatically produce toleration. It can produce fear, suspicion, and desire to prevent the former persecutor from recovering power. The memory of Protestant suffering could justify restrictions on Catholics just as easily as it could generate sympathy for persecuted conscience. Alexandra Wolcham's work is important here because it resists a straight path from Reformation violence to enlightened toleration.
SPEAKER_00Tolerance and intolerance could coexist. Neighbours might accommodate religious difference in daily life while endorsing severe laws in principle. People could condemn the cruelty used against their own community and still accept coercion against beliefs they regarded as dangerous. Fox himself embodies this ambivalence. He regarded Catholic doctrine as error and the papacy as a profound danger. He did not offer a modern equality of religions, but his opposition to burning people for belief sometimes extended beyond the boundaries of his own confession.
SPEAKER_00The distinction between papist, Catholic, a recusan, a traitor could all collapse in popular language, even when political thinkers tried to keep the categories apart. That collapse is one reason Fox's legacy cannot be judged only by his personal intentions. Images and narratives acquire lives beyond their authors. A story created to memorialize martyrs can later be used to justify exclusion of the community associated with their persecutors.
SPEAKER_00Fox undoubtedly strengthened an enduring Protestant memory of Catholic persecution. His book helped make the Marion Burning central to English identity and contributed to the black legend of Bloody Mary. Later generations repeatedly drew upon his images and stories when they feared popery, foreign power, or Catholic succession. But he did not create anti-Catholicism from nothing, and the book cannot be reduced to a simple instruction to hate Catholics. It emerged from actual persecution, a European confessional conflict, and a political struggle over the English crown.
SPEAKER_00Its hostility was directed especially at papal authority and coercive institutions, although ordinary Catholics could suffer from the culture that language helps sustain. The more revealing conclusion is that Fox helped create a Protestant historical consciousness. Anti-Catholicism was part of it, but so were Providence, national election, scriptural literacy, martyrdom, and a permanent suspicion of religious coercion. That question is at the heart of our final episode on Fox and Toleration.
SPEAKER_00This has been Beyond the Text. Follow the podcast to hear it.
Send us Fan Mail Who were James VI and I and Robert Bellarmine - and why did their arguments about religion become arguments about the right to rule? In the first of three Beyond the Text conversations, Samuel Woodall...
Send us Fan Mail What can Cicero, Augustine and Thomas More teach us about justice - and why should busy adults make time to read them together? Samuel Woodall turns the tables on his co-host Jack Thomson to discuss the...
Send us Fan Mail Would you want to live in Thomas More’s Utopia? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson explore Book Two of Utopia: its 54 cities, elected magistrates, shared property and six-hour working day. The island...
Send us Fan Mail Why punish theft without asking what drives people to steal? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson turn to Book One of Thomas More’s Utopia. Through the conversation between More, Peter Giles and Raphael...
Send us Fan Mail Who was Thomas More before he became a martyr - and why did a man at the heart of Tudor government imagine a society called “nowhere”? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson begin a new Beyond the Text series...