Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beyond the Text: The Intellectual Historian's Podcast

Beyond the Text: The Intellectual Historian's Podcast artwork

Who Had the Right to Rule? England and the Crisis of Authority

Nov 2, 202616 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail Was seventeenth-century England travelling inevitably towards constitutional liberty? Samuel Woodall explores a century in which monarchy, Parliament, religion and conscience repeatedly collided, from James VI and I to the Civil Wars and the Glorious Revolution. Drawing on Quentin Skinner, J. G. A. Pocock, Patrick Collinson, Johann Sommerville, John Morrill, Jonathan Scott, Mark Goldie and Steve Pincus, this solo episode examines how intellectual historians reconstruct arguments in their own historical settings. We consider divine right and the ancient constitution, Charles I and the crisis across the Stuart kingdoms, the Levellers and Putney Debates, Hobbes and Harrington, Restoration politics, Locke, and the contested settlement of 1688-89. CHAPTERS 00:00 Introduction 01:23 Historians and method 03:45 James VI and I 06:02 Charles I and the Civil Wars 09:20 Cromwell, Hobbes and Harrington 10:33 Restoration and Locke 12:24 James II and the Glorious Revolution 14:29 Conclusion: who has the authority to judge? PRIMARY WORKS DISCUSSED James VI and I, The True Law of Free Monarchies and Basilikon Doron Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan James Harrington, The Commonwealth of Oceana Robert Filmer, Patriarcha John Locke, Two Treatises of Government STAY CONNECTED Essays and reading guides: https://theintellectualhistorian.com/ Free monthly newsletter: https://theintellectualhistorian.com/newsletter/ Beyond the Text: https://beyondthetext.co.uk/podcasts/ History of Ideas Reading Club: https://thehistoryofideasclub.co.uk/ Support the podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/2238237/support Hosted by Samuel Woodall. Theme: “Queens Arrival” by Red Planet, licensed through TakeTones. Support the show

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome back to Beyond the Text with me, Samuel Woodall. When we describe the 17th century in England, we often tell a deceptively tidy story. A king believes in divine rights, parliament resists, civil war follows. The king is executed, monarchy returns, and then the glorious revolution of 1688 establishes constitutional government. It sounds like a difficult but ultimately direct journey from absolutism to liberty, but intellectual history makes that story much less comfortable and much more interesting.

SPEAKER_00The people who lived through this century did not know that it would end with a Bill of Rights, a Toleration Act, and a Protestant succession. They argued within several competing languages at once scripture, natural law, common law, classical republicanism, providence, sovereignty, and the ancient constitution. The meaning of liberty itself changed as those arguments collided. So this episode is about more than a sequence of constitutional events. It asks our Englishmen and women imagined authority, conscience, and political obligation during a century in which every secure answer seemed capable of becoming a new problem.

SPEAKER_00One of the most influential guides to this world is Quentin Skinner. Skinner asks us to recover what political writers were doing with their words and in their own circumstances. A treatise is not simply a container of timeless propositions. It might defend a contested institution, undermine an opponent, redefine a familiar term, or make a previously dangerous claim speakable. This approach stops us from treating James I as a failed version of a modern constitutional monarch, or John Locke as though he had written directly for a 21st century liberal democracy.

SPEAKER_00J. G. A. Pocock added another powerful idea. Political argument takes place through historically available languages. In 17th century England, one of those languages concerned the ancient constitution. Lawyers and parliamentarians appealed to an immemorial inheritance of law and liberty. Yet the history on which they relied was itself contested. Arguments about the Norman conquest, feudalism, and common law became arguments about who possessed authority in the present.

SPEAKER_00Patrick Collinson's phrase the monarchical republic helps us see that the tension did not begin in 1642. Elizabethan England had already combined personal monarchy with a powerful ethic of council, office holding and service to the Commonwealth. The crown was central, but so was the idea that magistrates and political elites owed duties to the public good. James inherited this mixed political imagination in 1603. Later historians widened the frame, and Johann Somerville reconstructed the ideological conflicts of the early Stuart period and insisted that James was a serious political thinker.

SPEAKER_00John Morrill placed religion back at the centre of the civil wars. Jonathan Scott situated England within the British kingdoms and a European crisis running through much of the century. Mark Goldie showed the density of restoration argument about allegiance, toleration, and resistance. And Steve Pincus then challenged the picture of 1688 as an almost bloodless adjustment, presenting it instead as a transformative revolution in religion, political economy, and state power. Together these historians encourage us to replace a single road to modernity with a field of arguments whose outcomes remain open.

SPEAKER_00James had been King James VI of Scotland since 1567, when Elizabeth I died in March 1603. He also became James I of England at this point. The union of the crowns placed England, Scotland, and Ireland under one monarch, but it did not create a single British state. Different churches, legal systems, and political institutions remained. The intellectual problem of ruling several kingdoms would shadow the Stuart monarchy for decades. James was also unusual because he wrote extensively about government.

SPEAKER_00In the True Law of Free Monarchies, published in 1598, and Basilican Doran, first published in 1599, he defended hereditary monarchy and the divine origin of royal authority. Kings were accountable to God and were not merely delegates of the people. That language sounds absolute, and James could speak provocatively about kings as God on earth. Yet Somerville warns us not to flatten James into a caricature. James also insisted that a good king ruled according to law and for the public good.

SPEAKER_00His absolutist principles coexisted with a moral account of royal duty. The difficulty was practical as much as theoretical. If the king judged when necessity required exceptional action, who could hold him to his duties without claiming a power above him? Religion sharpened that difficulty. At the Hampton Court Conference in 1604, James resisted further Puritan reform of the Church of England, while approving the translation that became the King James Bible in 1611. His famous association between bishops and monarchy expressed a political fear.

SPEAKER_00Challenges to episcopal authority might encourage challenges to royal authority. But conformity never removed religious plurality. Puritans wanted further reformation, Catholics lived under legal disabilities, and Protestant anxieties intensified as continental Europe entered the Thirty Years' War in 1618. James therefore left a mixed legacy. He had articulated monarchy with great intellectual confidence, but he had also exposed the questions that would torment his son's reign, whether taxation required consent, whether royal prerogative could override ordinary law, and whether religious uniformity protected political order or destabilized it.

SPEAKER_00Charles I inherited such a throne in 1625. Conflict escalated through forced loans, imprisonment without stated cause, and disputes over war finance. The petition of right in 1628 asserted limits on taxation, arbitrary imprisonment, billeting, and martial law. Charles dissolved Parliament in 1629 and governed without it for eleven years. The crisis that ended the personal rule began across the Stuart kingdoms. The attempt to impose a new prayer book in Scotland in 1637 helped provoke the National Covenant of 1638 and the Bishop's Wars.

SPEAKER_00Military failure forced Charles to summon Parliament in 1640. This is why a narrowly English story is insufficient. Religious and constitutional conflicts moved between Scotland, England, and Ireland, especially after rebellion erupted in Ireland in 1641. By 1642, King and Parliament were at war. Neither side began by announcing a revolution. Parliamentarian writers such as Henry Parker argued that royal power was derivative and that Parliament could act for the safety of the people in an emergency.

SPEAKER_00Royalists replied that divided sovereignty meant anarchy. The central question was no longer simply whether the king had broken particular laws. It was where final authority resided when the institutions of government accused one another of destroying the Constitution. This is where Skinner's history of Neo-Roman liberty becomes important. For writers shaped by Roman sources, freedom could mean more than non-interference. A personal community living under an arbitrary power was unfree even if that power happened to interfere very little.

SPEAKER_00Dependence itself was the problem. Parliamentarian and later Republican arguments could therefore describe government by prerogative as a condition approaching servitude. The collapse of censorship and the expansion of print made the 1640s intellectually extraordinary. Levellers such as John Lilburn, Richard Overton, and William Woolwyn demanded legal equality, wider political participation, and protections for conscience. At the Putney debates in 1647, soldiers and officers disputed whether political rights followed from property, social position, or a more basic claim to consent.

SPEAKER_00The surviving records does not give us modern democracy in finished form, but it captures political assumptions being tested in public under the pressure of war. Religious radicalism was inseparable from this political experimentation. Independents, Baptists, seekers, fifth monarchists, and Quakers questioned established churches and clerical authority in different ways. John Morrill's description of the conflict as a war of religion remains valuable because disputes about worship, salvation, and church government shaped political allegiance.

SPEAKER_00Religion was not a decorative language placed over material interests. It helped people identify tyranny, duty, and the purposes for which political power existed. The execution of Charles I on 30 January 1649 transformed the crisis. The monarchy and House of Lords were abolished, and England became a commonwealth. But destroying kingship did not settle sovereignty. The Republic struggled to reconcile army power, parliamentary authority, and demands for reform. Oliver Cromwell became Lord Protector in 1653, ruling under a written constitution, but within a regime that never secured broad agreement about its legitimacy.

SPEAKER_00Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan appeared in 1651. Hobbes accepted the radical premise that political authority was artificial rather than naturally paternal. Individuals authorized a sovereign because the alternative was insecurity and civil war. Yet the sovereign, whether one person or an assembly, had to possess undivided power. Hobbes' answer to the centuries' conflict was not divine right, but political construction. Authority arose through authorization, and had to be strong enough to end rival claims to judgment.

SPEAKER_00James Harrington's Oceana, published in 1656, offered a very different diagnosis. Harrington linked political power to the distribution of property and imagined a republic sustained by rotation, agrarian balance, and institutional design. The contrast with Hobbes' revealing, one sought peace through unified sovereignty, the other sought durable liberty through a balanced republic. Both were trying to make political order possible after inherited authority had collapsed. But the monarchy returned under Charles II in 1660, but restoration could not erase the intellectual consequences of revolution.

SPEAKER_00Parliament, the army, religious dissent, and regicide had all become part of political memory. The restored Church of England attempted to secure uniformity, while dissenters faced exclusion and persecution. Debates about toleration were therefore debates about the relationship between conscience and civic loyalty. The exclusion crisis of 1679 to 1681 brought these conflicts into new combinations. Opponents of the Catholic heir, the future James II, argued that Protestantism and liberty were endangered.

SPEAKER_00Their opponents defended hereditary succession and warned that resistance revived the chaos of civil war. The labels Whig and Tory emerged from the struggle. Political parties were not yet modern organizations, but the language of party, interest in organized opposition, was becoming unavoidable. Sir Robert Filmer's Patriarcha, published in 1680 from an earlier manuscript, defended patriarchal monarchy and attacked theories based on natural freedom and consent. John Locke's two Treatises of Government, written substantially during the exclusion years and published after 1688, answered the patriarchal account.

SPEAKER_00Locke argued that political society rested upon consent, the government existed to protect rights, and that rulers who destroyed their trust could be resisted. Mark Goldie's work helps us avoid treating Locke as the solitary inventor of modern liberalism. Locke participated in crowded arguments about church, state, resistance, property, and toleration. His language acquired meaning through those controversies and its limits matter. His toleration did not extend equally to everyone, while empire and colonial property formed part of the wider world in which English liberty was articulated.

SPEAKER_00James II became king in 1685. His Catholicism, use of dispensing powers, standing army, and efforts to promote toleration by royal prerogative convinced many former defenders of monarchy that the Constitution and Protestant religion were in danger. In June 1688, the birth of a male heir raised the prospect of a Catholic dynasty. A group of English nobles invited William of Orange to intervene. William landed in November, James fled in December, and 1689, William and Mary accepted the crown.

SPEAKER_00The constitutional settlement included the Declaration and then the Bill of Rights, which condemned suspensing and dispensing laws without parliamentary consent. Regularized parliamentary claims and restricted royal power. The Toleration Act gave limited freedom of worship to many Protestant dissenters, although it did not create religious equality. A new regime also developed through war, taxation, public credit, and expanding administration. What kind of revolution was this? A traditional account presented 1688 as conservative and consensual, a restoration of ancient liberties rather than the invention of a new order.

SPEAKER_00That language was important to contemporaries. It enabled revolutionaries to deny that they were simply repeating 1649. Pincus, however, argues to see a larger and more conflictual transformation. In his interpretation, 1688 involved rival programs of modernization, international war, political economy, and the remaking of the state. The revolution was neither bloodless across the British and Irish kingdoms nor complete in a single winter. Scotland, Ireland, the Atlantic world, and European conflict all belonged to its history.

SPEAKER_00Pocock and Goldie add another layer. The settlement could be defended through different political languages, ancient constitution, providence, contract, resistance, Protestant interest, and the public good. There was no single ideology of 1688. Even Locke's account of government by consent was only one way of making the new regime legitimate. So the English 17th century matters because it did not dissolve the problem of authority once and for all. It changed the terms on which that problem could be argued.

SPEAKER_00Divine rights survived, but it no longer monopolized the defence of monarchy. Religious conscience gained protection, but within firm limits. Ideas of consent and resistance expanded, while empire, exclusion, and equality grew among them. Parliament became more powerful, but parliamentary authority could itself be accused of tyranny. Intellectual historians then help us hear this century without forcing its voices into a victory parade for modern liberalism. Skinner recovers political action in language, Pocock reveals inherited vocabularies and contested histories.

SPEAKER_00Collinson locates Republican duties within monarchy, Somerville restores the seriousness of royalist argument. Merrill returns religion at its center. Scott reconnects England to Britain and Europe. Goldie reconstructs the crowded politics of allegiance and toleration. Pincus makes 1688 revolutionary again. What emerges is not a straight line, but a century of repeated experiments in making power answerable without making government impossible. That is why James I, the Civil War, and the Glorious Revolution belong within one intellectual history.

SPEAKER_00Each moment reopened the same question in a new form. When rulers, laws, churches, and conscience collide, who has the authority to judge? If you enjoyed this episode, you can find more conversations about the history of ideas through Beyond the Text and further essays, reading guides, and updates at the intellectualhistorian.com. Thank you for listening, and we'll see you next time. Bye bye.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Who Were James VI & I and Robert Bellarmine? | Part 1

    Nov 18, 202630 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Who were James VI and I and Robert Bellarmine - and why did their arguments about religion become arguments about the right to rule? In the first of three Beyond the Text conversations, Samuel Woodall...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Why Read the Great Books? Reimagining Justice with Jack Thomson

    Nov 16, 202621 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail What can Cicero, Augustine and Thomas More teach us about justice - and why should busy adults make time to read them together? Samuel Woodall turns the tables on his co-host Jack Thomson to discuss the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Is Utopia Actually Good? | Thomas More 3

    Nov 13, 202625 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Would you want to live in Thomas More’s Utopia? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson explore Book Two of Utopia: its 54 cities, elected magistrates, shared property and six-hour working day. The island...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Does Society Create the Crimes It Punishes? | Thomas More 2

    Nov 11, 202622 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Why punish theft without asking what drives people to steal? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson turn to Book One of Thomas More’s Utopia. Through the conversation between More, Peter Giles and Raphael...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Thomas More 1 | Who Was Thomas More, and Why Did He Imagine Nowhere?

    Nov 9, 202622 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail Who was Thomas More before he became a martyr - and why did a man at the heart of Tudor government imagine a society called “nowhere”? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson begin a new Beyond the Text series...

    Credit the people on this episode