Send us Fan Mail John Foxe’s Acts and Monuments was one of the most influential books of the English Reformation. In the first of three solo episodes, Samuel Woodall explores how Foxe transformed persecution, exile and martyrdom into a history of Protestant England - and asks what we gain and lose when suffering becomes national memory. From Foxe’s continental exile and the Lollards to the Marian burnings, the episode examines the book’s woodcuts, documentary sources, changing editions and collaborative production. It also considers the tension between a powerful Protestant identity and the disturbing question preserved in these stories: should governments have the power to kill people for belief? CHAPTERS 00:00 Theme and introduction 01:10 John Foxe’s life and exile 02:24 The Lollards and a Protestant prehistory 03:38 Edward VI, Mary I and religious reversal 04:28 Martyr narratives and the woodcuts 05:08 Foxe’s sources and historical evidence 05:45 The book’s physical form and the power of print 06:41 Cranmer’s story 07:09 A book that kept changing 08:39 How to read martyr stories 09:07 A network of Protestant remembrance 09:31 The making - and costs - of Protestant England 10:35 Persecution, memory and the next episode READ ALONG John Foxe, Acts and Monuments: The Unabridged Acts and Monuments Online, University of Sheffield: https://www.dhi.ac.uk/foxe/ SELECTED READING John N. King (ed.), Foxe’s Book of Martyrs: Select Narratives. Alexandra Walsham, Charitable Hatred: Tolerance and Intolerance in England, 1500-1700. Susan Royal, Lollards in the English Reformation: History, Radicalism and John Foxe. EXPLORE AND DISCUSS Beyond the Text: https://beyondthetext.co.uk The Intellectual Historian: https://theintellectualhistorian.com The History of Ideas Reading Club: https://thehistoryofideasclub.co.uk Music: “Queens Arrival” - Red Planet / TakeTones. Cover: illustrative artwork created for this episode. Support the show
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00There are books that record history, and there are books that help a society decide what its history means. John Fox's Acts and Monuments belongs firmly in the second category. Most people know it by a later and more memorable name, Fox's Book of Martyrs. It gathered stories of religious persecution across centuries. But its emotional centre was the burning of Protestants during the reign of Mary I. It gave those deaths a pattern. They were not isolated punishments imposed by a Tudor government.
SPEAKER_00In Fox's telling, they formed part of a much longer struggle between the true church and the forces that tried to silence it. That is what makes the book so important for intellectual history. Fox did not merely preserve testimony, he arranged the past so that English Protestants could recognize themselves within it. Fox was born in Lincolnshire in 1516 or 1517 and studied at Oxford. As the English Reformation developed under Henry VIII and Edward VI, Fox became committed to evangelical religion.
SPEAKER_00His beliefs made England dangerous after the accession of the Catholic Mary I in 1553, and he joined the Protestant exiles on the continent. Exile mattered. It separated reformers from their homes, placed them among other European Protestants, and gave them time to interpret what was happening in England. Fox worked on Latin accounts of persecution in Strasbourg and Basel. The first appeared in 1554, followed by a larger Latin martyrology in 1559.
SPEAKER_00When he returned to Elizabethan England, he transformed that project into the enormous English Acts and Monuments printed by John Day in 1563. The familiar title Book of Martyrs is useful, but it can also be misleading. Fox was attempting something larger than a collection of heroic deaths. He was writing an ecclesiastical history, tracing what he believed was the Church of Christ through conflict with corruption, false doctrine, and coercive power. That history stretched back well before Henry VIII.
SPEAKER_00Fox placed medieval dissenters, especially John Wycliffe and the Lollards, into a Protestant genealogy. People condemned as heretics by medieval authorities could now appear as witnesses to truth that the Reformation had recovered. This was an extraordinary act of historical revision. It gave English Protestantism a prehistory. Reform no longer looked like a sudden import from Luther's Germany. Fox could present it as the recovery of a faith that had survived among English believers for generations.
SPEAKER_00The Lollard inheritance was not simple. Medieval dissenters had varied positions on preaching, sacraments, oaths, and church authority, and they did not describe themselves as early Elizabethan Protestants. Fox had to translate their conflicts into the categories of his own reformation. That selective work is precisely why they matter. By converting condemned heretics into spiritual ancestors, Fox demonstrated that historical reputation depended upon the institutions doing the naming. The same could appear as a danger to Christian society in one century and as a witness to Christian truth in another.
SPEAKER_00Fox's story was shaped by the speed with which Tudor religion changed. Under Edward VI, who reigned from 1547 to 53, Protestant reform accelerated, chantries were dissolved, clerical marriage was permitted, and the Book of Common Prayer appeared in 1549. Reformers such as Thomas Cranmer became central figures in the effort to define a Protestant Church of England. Then came reversal. Mary restored papal authority and Catholic worship. From 1555, nearly 300 Protestants were executed for heresy.
SPEAKER_00Bishops Hugh Latimer and Nicholas Ridley were burned at Oxford in October 1555. Cranmer followed in March 1556 after first signing recantations and then dramatically rejecting them at his execution. Fox gave these deaths narrative form. The Martists speak, pray, endure pain, and refuse to abandon the truth as Fox understood it. Their bodies are destroyed, but their constancy defeats the authorities who condemn them. The execution intended to demonstrate the power of the church and state is turned into evidence of their moral failure.
SPEAKER_00The famous woodcuts made this argument visible. Readers could see crowds gathered around the stake, officials overseeing the sentence, and martyrs enclosed by fire. Repetition mattered. One image after another taught readers to associate Protestant faith with suffering and Catholic power with persecution. We should not treat every scene as a modern transcript. Fox used court records, letters, oral reports, earlier chronicles, and information supplied by a wide network of collaborators.
SPEAKER_00Some testimony was close to the events. Other episodes were shaped, compressed, or improved in the telling. The book is at once historical archive, literary construction, and religious argument. That combination explains its strength. A bare list of executions might document persecution. Fox's stories taught readers how to feel about it. The physical form of the book reinforced that authority. Axon Monuments was large, expensive, and visually imposing.
SPEAKER_00The 1570 edition filled two substantial volumes. Its size suggested that Protestant history was supported by an accumulated mass of names, documents, and testimonies. Readers did not need to move through every page to understand the claim being made. The monument stood before them. Printing allowed private suffering to become public memory. A letter written from prison, a remembered conversation, or the final actions of a condemned person could circulate far beyond the place of execution.
SPEAKER_00Fox and his printer John Day combined typography, marginal references, and images to guide the reader between evidence and interpretation. The result looked documentary even when its arrangement was openly polemical. Cranmer's story shows the technique particularly well. His earlier recantations made him an imperfect martyr. Fox did not erase that weakness. Instead, the narrative turned recovery from failure into its central drama.
SPEAKER_00Cranmer's decision to place the hand that signed his recantation into the flame gave Protestant readers a memorable image of repentance, courage, and restored identity. Ax and Monuments was not a single fixed text. Fox supervised four English editions in 1563, 1570, 1576, and 1583. The second edition expanded into two volumes of more than 2,000 pages.
SPEAKER_00New evidence was added, earlier passages were revised, and criticisms were answered. Fox's history changed because the political and religious world around it changed. This matters because we sometimes speak of Fox as if one sentence could represent his whole career. The digital Variorum edition now allows historians to compare the four versions and see how memory was being edited in real time. Fox was not only looking backward, he was continually deciding what the Protestant past needed to mean in the present.
SPEAKER_00His lollards are a good example. Their beliefs did not correspond neatly to the Elizabethan Church. Fox selected and reshaped their stories so that they appeared as recognizable ancestors of Protestant reform. He turned people once described as traitors and heretics into martyrs and faithful subjects. This does not make the book useless history. It makes the way Fox used history part of the evidence. His choices tell us how a Protestant culture was constructed from manuscripts, memories, judicial records, and inherited stories.
SPEAKER_00The same point changes how we use martyr stories today. Asking whether every reported sentence was spoken exactly as printed is important, but it is not the only historical question. We can also ask why a particular version was preserved, what virtues it assigned to the martyr, and what actions it encouraged in the reader. A story may be uncertain as a transcript, while remaining exceptionally powerful as evidence of cultural memory. Fox's collaboration is equally important.
SPEAKER_00Acts and monuments was not produced by a solitary author, remembering the reign of Mary from a desk. Correspondence and documents, families preserved accounts, ecclesiastical officials, opened collections and printers solved the practical problem of presenting a vast history. The book was a networked act of Protestant remembrance. Fox's achievement was therefore double. He preserved an immense body of material about persecution, and he organized that material into a Protestant account of England.
SPEAKER_00The nation could imagine itself as repeatedly called toward reform, repeatedly threatened by false religion, and repeatedly rescued through Providence. That vision was powerful, but it came at a cost. It divided the past into persecutors and witnesses, Antichrist and the true church. Complex religious lives could disappear into those categories. Catholics became associated with the machinery of persecution, even when individual Catholics had little connection to the Marian burnings.
SPEAKER_00Yet the book also retained the memory of what religious coercion did to actual people. It forced readers to confront prisons, interrogations, recantations, fear, and execution. Fox wanted to prove Protestant truth, but the stories could also raise a more unsettling question. Should any government possess the power to burn people as for belief? That question leads directly into the next episode. Did Fox's Book of Martyrs simply deepen English anti-Catholicism, or did its memory of persecution create a language in which persecution itself could be criticized?
SPEAKER_00This has been beyond the text. If you enjoyed the episode, follow the podcast for the next part of this series on Fox, confessional memory, and religious toleration.
Send us Fan Mail Who were James VI and I and Robert Bellarmine - and why did their arguments about religion become arguments about the right to rule? In the first of three Beyond the Text conversations, Samuel Woodall...
Send us Fan Mail What can Cicero, Augustine and Thomas More teach us about justice - and why should busy adults make time to read them together? Samuel Woodall turns the tables on his co-host Jack Thomson to discuss the...
Send us Fan Mail Would you want to live in Thomas More’s Utopia? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson explore Book Two of Utopia: its 54 cities, elected magistrates, shared property and six-hour working day. The island...
Send us Fan Mail Why punish theft without asking what drives people to steal? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson turn to Book One of Thomas More’s Utopia. Through the conversation between More, Peter Giles and Raphael...
Send us Fan Mail Who was Thomas More before he became a martyr - and why did a man at the heart of Tudor government imagine a society called “nowhere”? Samuel Woodall and Jack Thomson begin a new Beyond the Text series...