First, you hear the music. Then the composer explains how he built it. Donnacha Dennehy is a Grammy-winning Irish composer and Princeton professor who has built music from the notes between the notes in a singer’s voice, the physical sensation of giddiness, and the changing light across an entire year. I’m Vonn, a 19-year-old college student and composer, and I’m currently writing a piece of my own on a deadline. I wanted to understand how someone like Donnacha finds an idea worth pursuing and turns it into finished music. In this conversation, we listen to three pieces: “Head” from his new album Limina, Grá agus Bás, and “July” from the Grammy-winning Land of Winter. If Donnacha’s music is new to you, that is part of the experience. We play each excerpt before he takes us inside it. Donnacha explains how sean-nós singing led him to build harmony from the microtonal movement of a singer’s voice, why he wrote a piano concerto around the personality of a particular performer, and how the changing amount of daylight across a year determined the shape of Land of Winter. He also describes what winning a Grammy felt like, including the strange moment when the statuette arrived at his house by FedEx. At the end, I ask Donnacha to give me homework for the piece I’m writing. He does not give me a theory exercise. He tells me to shut off the internet, put away my phone, set a clock, and complete five protected one-hour writing sessions over two days. That is now my assignment. If you have ever struggled to protect your creative time or turn an idea into finished work, this conversation is for you. Follow Beyond the Notes to find out what I write and whether Donnacha’s assignment changes the way I compose. WATCH THE VIDEO VERSION https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qHGyFdQh_b8 LEARN MORE Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier https://beyondwithvonn.com Donnacha Dennehy https://www.donnachadennehy.com/home Listen to Limina https://www.nonesuch.com/albums/limina Listen to Land of Winter https://www.nonesuch.com/albums/land-of-winter
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01I'm Von Veneer, a 19-year-old composer and college student learning from the best in the music industry on my podcast, Beyond the Notes. This week, Donica Dennehy. Let me tell you about one of his most famous pieces, Gras August Baas. Start with Shan O's, the ancient style of Irish singing, unaccompanied. What could possibly go behind that in a new innovative form? Donica had an amazing idea. Analyze all the pitches between the notes and the singer's voice, then build the harmony from the overtone series.
SPEAKER_01What does that even mean? We'll get into that this episode. But when he finished writing, people noticed. The Guardian gave the album five out of five stars, and NPR included it as one of its top 50 of 2011. And more recently, he won a Guggenheim Fellowship, which gave him the freedom to write what he wanted to write. An album called Land of Winter, which won him the Grammy. And his new album, Limina, came out on August 28th, making it the perfect time for me to talk to him. He even gave me some homework, which has really helped me in my composition process.
SPEAKER_01If you ever have trouble in the creative process figuring out what comes next and want to cut out distractions, he gave me the perfect solution straight from a Grammy winner. Make sure you're subscribed to see whether his advice changes the way I compose and to stay up to date with everything we're doing on the podcast. I'm Von Veneer. My guest today is Grammy winner Donica Dennehy. This is Beyond the Notes. Donica, welcome to the show. Oh, thank you. Thanks, Vaughn. Absolutely. Very excited to have you.
SPEAKER_01I'd like to fast forward today to your new record, Limina. Um it came out um from None Such Records. Uh, you know, you've got the National Symphony of Ireland playing on it, two concertos, uh, big project for you. Um, so I'd like to just start by talking about um one of your movements, which is called Head. Um so I'll I'll play a little clip of it and then we can we can break it down if that sounds okay with you. Absolutely. All right.
SPEAKER_01Is that what you're after? Or what what was the idea?
SPEAKER_00Oh, so instead of calling it head, I could have called it dopamine in the head. Um yeah, it does have a kind of giddy quality, quite joyful, uh, and then can kind of turn on a dime at other points. Um so that's the first movement of the piano concerto, which is called Limina. Uh and the the idea is that you go to these thresholds and then behind beyond them. Um I actually was once gonna call a piece dopamine or serotonin.
SPEAKER_00I can't remember. Yeah, no card. And I did write a piece for a very short piece for Sachs Quartet called Um Mild Artificially what was this mild artificial medium lasting happiness. Um but it's not so mild to be. But this I think I was just drawn to the kind of almost joyful, almost um how would you say uh technicolor kind of quality of it.
SPEAKER_00Um and the I why it was cut head was basically as it starts right up in the top register and just keeps on succumbing to gravity. Uh each one is like at a different part. So the second movement is called chest, which is actually quite sort of um beautiful and yearning as well. And then the last one is called nervous system, which I was originally going to call gut, and I thought, oh gut, but also sort of as if it comes out from all the kind of nerves, and I do think of it as starting in the gut, actually, that last one.
SPEAKER_00And so there is this kind of thing in which each movement has a kind of bobbly construct out of which it transcends. Um, I did also think of when I thought of head, I thought of a heady rush, which is you know, this idea of a kind of almost giddiness or lightheadedness that you get when you're excited. Um but uh that's why it is, and and also there are always these patterns that are the head, and you either have a unison with it, or and then the unison starts to break, becoming counterpoint, so it lodges to counterpoint.
SPEAKER_00But there's a great joy, I think, in unison. Actually, Irish music is full of unison. There's something about unison playing that's just a kind of sort of ecstatic. Uh and so it's it's all kind of unisons that then lodge to produce counterpoint. So that's the kind of other idea of it. So these head patterns generating uh tails, as it were.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I um I got my start as a chorister, you know, musically my start as a chorister, and there's this concept of like head voiced and head voice and chest voice, and that's kind of what that reminds me of. Uh yeah, and I was thinking of those terms, yes. Right. Yeah. And with Limina, did you um I think like also the concerto aspect is interesting um that you had this piano soloist. How did you navigate that? Did you write specifically for for her and and like what was that like?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, the the soloist is her name is Eliza McCarthy. She came to me to want to commission this um concerto. Now I know her well because she's a really great contemporary music pianist in um London who plays often with this group that I founded, um but uh called Crash Ensemble. And she played in my operas and things like that. And so I know what type of player she is, a very rhythmic player, incredible.
SPEAKER_00I mean, if someone can have you know, talk about people having perfect pitch, she almost has perfect rhythm, not just in terms of getting it right, but the way she inhabits the rhythm in terms of like in the pocket, as it were. And um I liked that I knew so much about Eliza already, you know, her kind of humor and everything. I I decided so for the violin concerto, it's an incredibly virtuosic piece, and the violin kind of zooms in and out of the orchestra, and there's all this textual stuff.
SPEAKER_00And then well, the second movement, which I don't know if you've heard it yet, because it hasn't really it haven't been released yet, there's a kind of a floating quality. Uh but in the other two movements it's really visceral, this kind of vertiginous kind of zooming around. With the piano concerto, I thought more of the solo being one among equals to some extent, where like the whole ensemble is in unison with her in the first movement, uh, and then she just builds up this power and emerges from it.
SPEAKER_00In the second movement, so I I thought of these interest or what I thought of as interesting kind of constructs for how she was going to relate to the what was originally an ensemble then became a chamber oxer. And in the second movement it's it's always rhythmic but not pitch unison, and they are these expanding palindrums, if you want to call them, these little patterns that go larger and larger back in and begin.
SPEAKER_00And then gradually she starts ornamenting them. So there's ways in which she marks out her individuality gradually in these movements. And that's how I played with the whereas in the violin concerto it's more of a solo against the mask.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well, they're both uh both lovely pieces, and I congratulate you on the new release. I'd like to I'd I'd like to shift attention to um to something a little bit older, um not as recent. Uh your piece, Gras August Boz, Love and Death. Um so same thing, I'll I'll play a little segment and then we can we can break it down. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Um profound sound to it. And I know a lot of your your work comes out of Chanos singing, which is this uh well, you you know much more, of course, uh this Irish um traditional style of singing. Um so can you tell us about that and like what that kind of style does to the music?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So it's probably one of the earliest styles of singing that I encountered. My grandmother used to have these parties. A party might be too grand a term. It's this kind of gathering where people would come in from all around and do whatever darcette piece. And it would go for a long time. And people would sing in this style too. And so I had encountered it from that time, and I would play the flute as well, and you know, do my party piece.
SPEAKER_00And uh I adored these as a kid. These would go on two o'clock in the morning, longer even. And um I so it had a pro profound influence on me even then. I also remember once seeing a woman keen at a grave, uh in also in this very region, Nock and agree. Uh and um that just it took me a long time before I incorporated anything like that into my music, but I did in this piece about the famine called The Hunger, uh, which also I wrote using Erlo Leonard, who's this Shan No singer that you hear here.
SPEAKER_00So as an adult, I had gone off and studied in America after being in Ireland in the University of Illinois, then went to Holland, um, briefly in France, back to Ireland, set up my own group, Crash Ensemble, very much involved in contemporary classical music international in a way. Um, but I really wanted to do something with this Shann Nos tradition that I knew. And um I contacted dear Lo Leonard, not so sure whether I wanted to write a piece for him, who's this great Chandler singer that you hear here, or just learn how to do Shannose singing from him.
SPEAKER_00But in the end, he sort of said, Oh, I think you should write me a piece. And we met for about a year and a half where I would record him singing songs, um, I would transcribe them by hand just to get uh ideas of what he was doing with them, and also analyze it with this software called Melodyne, which would show me where the pitch was shifting. And then I started because I was quite interested in the notes between the notes and the way it worked, uh harmonizing it with overtones, just overtones of one fundamental. Or maybe maybe I'll go between the that became the basis then for how Grogus Boss started, where I took these two essentially two Shannot songs as the kind of inspirations.
SPEAKER_00One was Ashlin Gall, the other was Tom Shinta de Huma. Um so Ashling Gaal means bright vision, Tom Shinter the Huma is a bit darker, it means I'm spread upon I'm stretched across your grave. And um and actually that one I only really in Gros only used the words from it, whereas Ashling Gall, some of the pitch material influenced it. And then I started riffing off it, just myself working with Irla. And um I made a version because he didn't read music either.
SPEAKER_00Uh he kind of vaguely reads it now, but I made a version where I sang the whole thing. Um in I record myself in a logic audio uh singing it, and he would listen on his iPod then. And um course I don't sing it in this beautiful way like he does. Um but what's interesting about it is it is a unaccompanied vocal tradition, so quite separate from the dance music in a way, and um because it's unaccompanied, I think, you get a lot of microtonal inflection, and that's something that I focused in on it.
SPEAKER_00Yet it's rooted in a modality, you know. Often in fact, the really sad songs are essentially major, Ionian, or you can get some hint on De Orion or whatever, but there's a lot of brightness in the sound, and yet the way it's inflected gives it this kind of bittersweet quality. So yeah, I adored it. I I didn't just tap into this for Groggus Boss, which for me was a really almost I think of it as a very important shift in in my music when I wrote this piece.
SPEAKER_00Uh I also use it in The Hunger Later, which is about the fun. Um and I remember when I wrote Gro, and we came to the premiere, which was with my group, Crash Ensemble, and I was sitting down at the back of the hall, and I couldn't even open my eyes. I was so nervous. I thought I might have done something really bad here or something interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01I think it comes together really well. And the the other side of it, of course, is like that the non-traditional side, like the spectral analysis aspect. So, first of all, for any viewers who don't know what that is, can you can you explain what spectral analysis is and how it actually like plays out in your piece?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So I as I say there was uh uh um when you asked me what one of these Eureka moments for me, one of the Eureka moments was when I first heard Grizzay, and he basically orchestrated the spectrum. Uh and I thought, oh my god, it's amazing. It's gone into the interior of the sound. And um and I became fascinated with it then, and not so much with uh microtone music per se, but what you could do with just the overtones.
SPEAKER_00And this piece goes in and out of what you of overtone bass chords. So the ensemble, so it was Crash Ensemble, which was my group, which was so I it was a luxury, would tune to a G overtone series for doing this. Um so the bass was the lower notes of a double bass, for those of you who know are usually tune to E and A. In this piece they're tuned to D and G. And then the G, so um the second lowest string of this, uh the player, Maliki, would um do the sixteen overtones of the and everyone would tune to those sixteen overtones.
SPEAKER_00So you get the eleventh, the thirteenth harmonic, which happens in the flute, different instruments, and everyone would tune exactly not to a tuner, but to this to the natural harmonics of the of the bass. So there was this kind of embodied understanding of it in the piece. And then I ha I wrote what's called a max patch, triggered by the percussionist, which added in extra harmonics for some of these pillars of sound uh as well, which I did by um getting the strings, playing it as non vibrato as possible, and then tuning them absolutely precisely to higher overtones as well.
SPEAKER_00And that's the kind of way I went out. So it it's a kind of it creates this for me a fascinatingly rich and uh elusive sort of sound. But where I depart from, let's say, the the early spectral composers of the seventies, you know, Griset, Murray and beyond, you know, that that really came into the 70s, eighties, and it's it's still a very much important current in in music today.
SPEAKER_00Is that mine combines with a kind of modality as well.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So to shift gears a little bit, you um you recently won a Grammy uh for your piece, Land of Winter. So huge congratulations, obviously. Um I talked uh to another one of my guests um a few months ago named uh Taylor Igstee. He's a jazz composer, also Grammy winner, and he said that night when he he won his first one, he like he went back to his hotel like and ate a cheeseburger while like being in a in the bathtub or something like that.
SPEAKER_01So can you like what was your experience like just on that night? Was it something like that?
SPEAKER_00Um it was it felt all a bit surreal, very Hollywood, you know. I mean, the main thing, the main attraction for those events are the rock stars, you know, because you go into the crypto arena and it's Trevor Noah, you know, into uh so um you have to understand it in that context. However, it was nice. I did feel um some sort of how would you say well, recognition for the work or whatever.
SPEAKER_00Uh I didn't eat a cheeseburger or did I? Actually? No, we went to a restaurant, my wife and I, uh, but we we had a drink. Uh and oh, I think I ate some. I think I ate a small risotto. Uh is kind of um not quite a cheeseburger then. That's no a little classier. Well, it um it is kind of um surreal. And I think it only really dawned on me later when the actual statue arrived at the house via FedEx.
SPEAKER_00Um and um and then you're like, oh, okay. Uh and so it did feel um it did feel nice, all right, like through some recognition. Um you just never know with these things though, too. They're a crapshoot, and that at the time it worked out for me. I mean, I I'm happy it happened for that piece though, too, for Lando Winter. Yeah. Which I think of as um for me it's kind of it's there up with Grog's boss in my head as a kind of a s a statement that I wanted to make.
SPEAKER_00And that piece wasn't even commissioned at the start. Uh I was lucky enough writing it that I I then got a grant, got a Guggenheim writing it. So it was more it was a passion project, really. Yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00It's so nice that that turned out to to to get a prize and stuff like that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01It's crazy to think they just FedEx your you know, your statuette, but I guess that's how they do it. Somewhere, unless they they took it on a horse. Yeah, I I I've never thought about it before. That's that's something. It's just to see the box one day. Well, anyway, I'd like to to play once again just a little segment of the piece for for our listeners. Um then So that that, of course, is July, and it's one of the twelve months that you wrote for.
SPEAKER_01And I think it's like of of all twelve, it's probably my favorite personally. Can you explain like what the idea was and why you just started on December and what you're trying to achieve with the piece as a whole? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Oh, I I I even remember the day I came up with the idea of it. I was in Iceland finishing this piece that I I mentioned already, Tesla Atom, and it uh it was um finishing recording it. And it was December the 21st, um uh at the shortest day of the year in Iceland when we finished the recording. And I remember like rising, it was kind of dark, then the day sort of gradually crept in.
SPEAKER_00And we kind of I think we broke for lunch, and by the time we finished lunch, the day was was uh was being swallowed by darkness. I thought, oh my god, this is like Ireland uh in December, the way in the the day is barely there, you're always rising in darkness in December, and um and the way the light contracts so much in winter, and and then the light just gets longer and longer till July or end of June and then starts to contract again.
SPEAKER_00And that was the idea that you were measuring out a year by how much light there was. Uh and I thought of I'm very fascinated with time in music, and this was a kind of recurrent time, yeah, yeah, this expanding and contraction. Uh and also there's linear time, which we all find kind of terrifying. It's uh you know, like that. I quote this in the notes for it, uh, this quote from Samuel Beckett, 30,000 knights, hard to believe so few.
SPEAKER_00Basically normal life smile. And um and so it plays with those two forces circular, um comforting time in a way, and linear, terrifying time. And uh I had the idea all the time to divide into months. So and I wanted to start in winter, basically enter end in winter. Now, to all Americans, they think, oh, November's not winter, but in Ireland November is winter.
SPEAKER_00Uh but so that's the idea that it goes from darkness through life back to darkness, and um uh and I marked the solstices ever in everything in it. It kind of opens with the solstice in December. Uh end of June is this big sort of just overlapping overtone or spectra, as it were. Uh and then July is really bright and bubbly.
SPEAKER_00It's like the excessive, the most amount of light is in that month. But the idea of the kind of giddiness of that light, so obviously you respond to the the giddy parts in my music, like head and limina and July.
SPEAKER_01Um but so uh uh to to wrap us up, I'm starting a new tradition among my guests, um, which is I'd love to know from you. Um obviously uh you know you're a professor and an educator, but also an extremely experienced uh musician and composer. I love to if you could give me one piece of homework. Whoa.
SPEAKER_00I I think the biggest thing to kind of gain now is how to shut out the world when you're working. I have to try and do that my myself, you know. Um so I would probably give you I actually have one up here, a Pomodoro clock for whenever I get distracted. And uh you must set it to an hour uh five times in in in over two days and just just uh write um yeah.
SPEAKER_00Rather than my thinking, oh you should because you have to do what kind of really inspires you, but I think the biggest thing is to be able to not be distracted at the moment. And and I s I struggle with that too, you know? Um and but the when you like so when I do struggle with it, I have all these techniques to make me but then eventually I'm not noticing it at all because I'm in the flow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So it's something about so what I think it would be mainly yes to to shut down internet, phone, uh, everything, and have this little clock to tell you to keep it all and um and just write. But I think two two main things I think are shutting out distractions and and then trusting your ear.
SPEAKER_00So even doing stuff where you where you do it just straight off ear and then try and figure out a way of notating it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So I'm sorry, I don't have anything better.
SPEAKER_01Well, I was gonna say your your first one is perfect because right now I'm you know a little bit behind on a p deadline for a piece, um, kind of a big piece. So I'm sort of cramming for it right now and spending a lot of time, and sometimes it's like just hard to like, especially if you're composing for for long chunks of time to just be able to really focus and get in the zone. So it sounds like I need to get one of those clocks you have.
SPEAKER_00Yes, yeah, yeah. But I have I have you won't believe the amount of unread emails I have, so I shouldn't admit this. It's it's a trade-off.
SPEAKER_01You've got to compose a little, read do some emails a little bit um but no, absolutely. I'll I'll uh come definitely keep that in mind as I you know spend the next few weeks just working on this piece and hopefully it'll it'll really pay off.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, also the other thing I can say is sometimes you think you're wasting your time spending it on, you know, this kind of writing. I did this one of these songs I wrote for Don Up Show, I I I was adding up all these overtones on our melody. I thought, oh my god, and I did it by hand. Uh I've now learned how to kind of do it where I don't have to be quite as laborious. But still, I did it by hand and then I color-coded. I thought, oh, this is why am I spending so long 20 seconds of music?
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh. That 20 seconds is there forever. Yeah. And you could have done lots of other things in that time, but they're gone. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think that's one of the things that draws me to composition is once you write something or record something, it's it's there. So it's it's worth spending time on. Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah. Well, thank you so much again for everything. I mean, your your stories, your breakdown of the pieces, your advice. It's it's all super useful and inspiring to me as a young composer, and I'm sure many young viewers will also be inspired as well.
I’m a 19-year-old college student and composer learning how to build a life in music by talking with incredible musicians who have already built one. Today, I’m talking with Taylor Eigsti, a jazz pianist, composer, and...
The call came at 10 p.m. on a Friday. The Super Bowl was Sunday. One of the singers had just scrapped the arrangement she was meant to perform and Chris Walden had until morning to write her a new one for a full...
3x Grammy-nominated composer Miguel del Aguila joins Vonn Vanier for a conversation about how classical music can grow beyond the classics without losing what makes it powerful. Miguel reflects on finding his own voice...
Peter Askim is a composer, conductor, educator, former orchestral bassist, Music Director of the Wilmington Symphony Orchestra, Director of Orchestral Activities at North Carolina State University, and Founder and...
David Fogel has spent decades working in artificial intelligence. He is also a composer, musician, and founder of the Symphonina Foundation. In this episode of Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier, David joins Vonn to talk...