Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier

Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier artwork

Can Music Stay Human in the Age of AI? | David Fogel on AI, Classical Music & Creativity

May 12, 202631 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

David Fogel has spent decades working in artificial intelligence. He is also a composer, musician, and founder of the Symphonina Foundation. In this episode of Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier, David joins Vonn to talk about music, creativity, artificial intelligence, and the future of human expression in a world where technology can increasingly imitate what artists do. The conversation also explores David’s work with the Symphonina Foundation, his belief in shorter symphonic forms for modern listeners, and the challenge of keeping orchestral music meaningful for new generations. At the center of the episode is a question that reaches beyond music: As AI becomes more powerful, can music stay human? Follow The Symphonina Foundation: Website: https://symphonina.org/ Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/SymphoninaFoundation/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@thesymphoninafoundation3199 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/symphoninafoundation TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@symphonina Follow David Fogel: David Fogel music website: https://www.davidfogelmusic.com/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@davidfogel8191 Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/davidbfogel/ Email: david.fogel@symphonina.org David Fogel interviews Vonn Vanier: https://symphonina.org/podcast-vonn-vanier Follow Beyond the Notes: YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@beyondwithvonn Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/beyondwithvonn Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/beyondwithvonn TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@beyondwithvonn Follow Vonn Vanier: Website: https://vonnvanier.com/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@vonnvanier Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/vonnvanier Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/vonnvanier/ TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@vonnvanier Subscribe to Beyond the Notes with Vonn Vanier for conversations with composers, performers, producers, and creative thinkers shaping the future of music.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01And it's not like people, young people, don't like symphony music. They do. They like it in movies, they get it in games, but they're not predisposed to come to listen to it very often at a at a symphony performance.

SPEAKER_00That's David Fogel. He spent more than 40 years working in AI. A lifelong musician, he's also a composer and the founder of the Symfonina Foundation. That background gives him a rare perspective on two of the biggest questions facing classical music. How does classical music reach young people? And what happens when AI can generate music on command? To reach new listeners, David created the Symfonina. It's a three-movement mini symphony around 12 minutes long.

SPEAKER_00That brings us to his other passion, AI.

SPEAKER_01If you're just doing, like, hey, do you like these lyrics? Or do you like this music where each token is probistically generating the next one, you can get things that you do like. And then, you know, the question really is, how how good can you get that to be? And the other question is, why are you doing it?

SPEAKER_00In this conversation, we discuss why David is not especially interested in machine-made songs for their own sake, how AI can help artists explore, and what may be missing before machines can create something truly spectacular. My guest today is David Fogle. I'm Von Veneer, and you're listening to Beyond the Notes. Hey guys, just real quick before we get back into the episode, we're on the road to a hundred subscribers, and I'd love it if you could be one of those a hundred. So hit the like and subscribe buttons and share it with your friend if you think the episode is good.

SPEAKER_00And let's get back to the show. David, thank you so much for joining us today. Oh, it's my pleasure, Vaughn. Thanks for having me. Absolutely. So you created a new kind of piece called the Symfonina, which is basically a a short little symphony. So can you tell us the story behind that and how you came up with it and what was going on in that moment for you?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, absolutely. So uh I've I'm a musician. I'm I've been fortunate to be many things in my life, but I started playing piano when I was five, and I started playing sax and later heavy metal guitar. And but through all that, I went through the I went to the symphony as a kid, and we even had field trips to the symphony to go see the nutcracker or whatever it might be, you know. And so jumped forward 50 years, and I go to the San Diego Symphony seven years ago on a Sunday afternoon. I get there a little early, and I'm looking around, and I I can't help but notice I mean I'm laughing, I was crying.

SPEAKER_01I I couldn't help but notice I was pretty much the youngest person there. And at 54, I'm thinking, okay, well, where are all the young people? Because like they should, you know, symphony music is great, and it's not like people, young people don't like symphony music. They do, they like it in movies, they get it in games, but they're not predisposed to come to listen to it very often at a at a symphony performance. And I've been working at that time with a colleague Gary Gray from Los Angeles, who's done a lot, I mean, he's a longtime music industry veteran, done a lot of work for Disney and Amazon and people at the highest levels.

SPEAKER_01I was talking to him, you know, about general facts of life and and also some facts I didn't know, which is that like in when we've converted to listening to our music on on the phone, the average length of a tune has gone from just over four minutes to under three minutes. And if one might think it's probably more like two minutes and thirty. And it's just a function, I think, of our general short attention spans. They're getting shorter all the time. So in music, I think between hip-hop and rock and RB and all the genres except classical country, everything, they've all done a really good job of migrating their music to that streaming format and our shorter attention spans, particularly for young people.

SPEAKER_01But classical music, not so much. So if you aren't already predisposed to be looking for Tchaikovsky or Rachmaninoff or heaven forbid Mahler, which can be very long, you're not you're not going to go, you're not going to go to do it. You're not going, you're not going to get to your phone to stream it. So in classical music, growing up as a piano player, we have things called sonatas. They have a certain format, and then you also have things called sonatinas, which are kind of short sonatas. So, in an analogy to that, I said, well, why do we need like these full hour-length symphonies?

SPEAKER_01Why don't we have a symphonina, which would play in about 10 to 12 minutes with three or four melodic movements, each one being about the same length of time playing as a typical streaming pop tune? And you get to the end of it, and you can keep listening to more classical music or symphonic music, if you want to call it, in that format. Or you can go listen to Taylor Swift if you want to. You know, it's up to you. But it'll fit the format that you are accustomed to. So I started writing them. I wrote, I wrote the first one probably 2017 into 2018, and kept going from there.

SPEAKER_01And people liked them. So uh I started the Symphonina Foundation and we got us got ourselves 501c3 approved by the IRS as a nonprofit charity, so people can donate and have it good to go to a good cause. And Gary and I, another colleague and I founded it, and we've been uh making advances with it each year. Up to this point now, we've been able to have a composer contest each year where we have prize money for the winner and the runner-up,$2,000 on$1,000 for the best symphony of the year. And then I think almost as important or more important, we record the winner and the runner-up live, either with the Budapest Scoring Orchestra in Hungary or with an orchestra of players from around the world that I've curated, where each one records their part separately, and then I do the engineering to make them all sound like they played together in one room.

SPEAKER_01And Gary does the mastering. And then we released an album each year, and we had introduced it in the Symphonina in 22. We had Advent of the Symphonia in 23, and Advent and the Symphonina made number one on Billboard, charted for two weeks. It was number six the second week. And we released Ascension Symphony and Arising last year, and one of the tracks there won the best uh classical composition at the Hollywood Independent Music Awards last year, and two pieces were nominated. So we we're just about finished with the competition for this year for next year's album, or this year's album, I should say now that's already 2026.

SPEAKER_01And the other thing I do with the foundation is uh I do a podcast just like you were doing, where I interview people from the symphonic world. They could be Grammy winners or they could be students who aspire to be players in the future at the pro level. You know, we talk to everybody and put the spotlight on everybody. You know, you know, everybody's important. Some are more important than others or more special than others, I guess that's fair, but but we try to have it be reflective of what's going on in the symphonic world. And it's been just great. I've met so many wonderful people through the Grammy submission process we submit each year, as well as all the independent music awards and just getting to know everybody who's involved in symphonic music.

SPEAKER_01We all have the same feeling, I think, about trying to save it. But we have to be able to be more enticing to young people, uh, both from the listening perspective, understanding what symphonic music is all about and can be all about, but also offering opportunities for composers and performers. There's so many great composers these days. We don't always have to listen to Beethoven and Tchaikovsky and Mozart and Brahms and all those guys, you know? And that's what we're up. That's what we're up to. We're trying to make the world a better place through symphonic music, and we've had a lot of positive response.

SPEAKER_00What uh what have you found to be the general response to so far from young people who have listened to this?

SPEAKER_01Great. Not just young people, older people. And and really it's been great, not just on the listening side, but on the wanting to participate side. So as it turns out, for the last two years, the winner and runner-up from our composer competition were in their 20s or maybe 30 years old. So fairly young. In our competition, we don't have any identification uh for the entry. Unlike let's say in the Grammys, where you know it's Beyonce's tunes, beyond you're voting for Beyonce, right?

SPEAKER_01So if you can imagine all those musicians submitting their things anonymously, it would be a very different outcome in the Grammys, I think. Anyway, that's my it's my hypothesis. In our case, you know, someone older, someone experienced, John Williams could submit something to us and we would anonymize it. And you might know it's John Williams just because of how it sounds, maybe he has his own style, but but it's a fair competition across all those things. And and young people have submitted and they've done very well. And I think in terms also in terms of the younger performers that I've been able to find from around the world for our International Symphony and Orchestra that I mentioned, about half of the orchestra, we have about 50 players, about half of the orchestra are young people who are aspiring to be professional and are really happy for the opportunity to record something and be on an album with elite players from around the world, too.

SPEAKER_01We have people who are like Yamaha artists or Steinway artists, or one case, uh Oleg Boyshek, who's the deputy concertmaster for Lviv Opera in Ukraine, who's runner-up on Ukraine's Got Talent playing three violins at one time. I've seen the video of that. I really don't understand how he did it, but there it is with three violins at one time. I don't, okay, I have to go back and remind myself how he actually did it. But people who are of that caliber and people of that caliber want to put their time into recording these things for us.

SPEAKER_01And, you know, I think we've had a really very positive reception. And we just were named this last quarter um the George Chamberlain Community Leadership Award, too, for nonprofits in San Diego. So other people are taking note of what we're doing. So yeah, it's been extremely positive and and continues to be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, wonderful. So to go back to the question, though, of um of attention, do you think nowadays artists, just in general with music, that's that's a general um goal of theirs? They're they're experimenting with trying to keep the listeners' attention rather than working with the art. Or do you think that's part of what they should be doing?

SPEAKER_01That's a good question. You know, I think, well, anytime you think about like a TikTok reel or a Facebook reel, it's all seemingly about attention. It's almost not about the content. It's how long can I keep you glued to my video? Yeah, I'm not not even really understanding the the point of that, but but I would hope that I mean I'm a little older, so to me it's like if you don't have something worthwhile to say, maybe you should just stop talking and let someone else who has something important to say say it, rather than keep them from the next thing that is important.

SPEAKER_01So yes, I think we're all we're all competing for attention and the things that you can do that try to maintain that attention, or at least have it be recognized when someone's amenable to listen, uh, are important. So they have to they have to be in the mood to listen or of the mindset to listen, and then hopefully they can make the choice uh to listen.

SPEAKER_00Uh-huh. Is there was there like any moment in any of any of your uh symphony in our writings that you think are like that stands out to you as something that's surprising or or attention grabbing?

SPEAKER_01In my own right in my own writing? Yeah, you know, in I always try to have something that's a hook. It gets back to the Lionel Richie saying that you know you should always have a hook in your music. That's from 1980s. But it's but it's true. I think good music like that, when it's melodic, has a hook in it at some point and something that you're gonna come back to, maybe a theme that you're gonna return to. It doesn't have to be exactly the same. It could be, it could be in a different key. I think you know, the famous person for modulating to a new key is Barry Manilo.

SPEAKER_01Not that I write like Barry Manilo, but you know, it always was something you knew was coming. Here it comes, and there it is, and now it fulfilled the it fulfilled the promise, you know. So there's different things like that. But I always try to have a story in mind when I'm writing a Sinfonina, whether the story is about um, in my, for example, my Sinfonina number eight, it's a story of a piano and a cello that can't be together anymore, and the piano takes a a ride to a new city on a train in the second movement and meets a jazzy clarinet in the third movement, and they live happily ever after along with the orchestra, or or my symphonina number seven, which I wrote in memory of my best friend who passed away when we were 24.

SPEAKER_01Uh unfortunate situation there where in the first movement he's the violin and I'm the piano, and he passes away at the end of the first movement and comes to visit me in the second movement, tell me it's okay. And I didn't think it was okay. So the third third movement's very frustrated, angry, going through the phases of grief. Uh so you know, whatever whatever story it is that you're trying to tell, I think if you tell it with passion and and like I said, that degree of surprise as you're ex explaining the story, then I think you can maintain the attention that you want.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I mean absolutely. I think for any artist, regardless of the the specific medium or or style, there's that human element that that attracts an audience in its own right. So I I also wanted to talk about today uh the advent of AI in society and you know a whole wave of of different changes that come with that. And and one of those is in music. You have a PhD, you're you've worked in AI for for a long, long time. Can you talk about how you think AI is gonna change music?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, it's already it's already changed it quite a bit, I guess, in the short term. I I think for for background, you know, my dad was one of the pioneers in AI in the 1960s, Larry Fogle. Kind of a famous guy in our in our world. Wrote the first book on simulating evolution for artificial intelligence in 1966. And so with him as a dad, I I followed in his footsteps and got started working in AI when I was 20, so 41 years ago, something like that. I think I published my first paper in 1986 and have over 250 peer-reviewed papers and journals and conferences and things like that that I've worked on different aspects of machine learning, whether it's for defense or homeland security or medicine or finance or professional sports or games or pretty much anything industry, anything you name, I've done something close to it.

SPEAKER_01So I've seen a lot, but I've not used AI really or not researched it in music so much. And up until about, I would say, maybe three years ago, I think we'd all probably agree that during the COVID time it wasn't so much like AI music was a thing, really. But after that, you know, it's it's kind of exponentially gotten better in its quality to the point where, yeah, I mean, you can push a button and generate music. But you know, if you go back to two things, I think.

SPEAKER_01One, when I was a kid, I had a little board game, and I don't remember exactly how it worked, but I had a pair of dice, and I think it was called Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart, and there's a quote in there from Mozart, which is like, you can write as many German waltzes as you want by throwing dice. And the idea being that as long as you have the transitions between chord tonal centers, you can throw the dice and randomly go from A minor to D minor or A minor to D seven or wherever you're gonna go, and then it'll lead you home, as long as it leads you home, and as long as your melody resolves when you get home, and you're in three, four time in a waltz, then you're okay.

SPEAKER_01Another thing that and that's kind of like the the randomness of making music that is sensible but not with the genius that Mozart would write with, right? Another thing was from my PhD dissertation, which was not this was not my work, it was just an example that I was citing near the end of the book that I wrote as my dissertation, where I think it was Arthur Bennett from Scientific American had cited some other work where this person took Shakespeare and did the transition matrix for all first-order letter transitions and generated what would come from that just randomly, right?

SPEAKER_01As a Markov chain. And so it's gibberish. But when you do it up at like eighth or ninth order, it starts making words that are Shakespearean words, and it doesn't mean anything. The computer obviously has no idea of what it's talking about because it's it's not. It's just water throwing, flowing through a complex pipe at that point, probabilistically. It doesn't know that it's a pipe, it doesn't know that it has water going through it, it's just spraying it out the other end like abstract art. And you can control a little bit about what the pipe is and maybe what the water is, but that's it's like your prompt, right?

SPEAKER_01So from that, you can generate things that really I not being an educated Shakespearean person, I would read it and go, I don't understand it, but I didn't really understand Shakespeare that much either. And it sure looks like Shakespeare's, and that was just at ninth order. So you can imagine if you have like a trillion weights in a neural net that's processing tokens on some very large probabilistic scale, you can generate language, you can generate the illusion of knowledge, you can generate the illusion of anything. And when something is subjective and it's your opinion of it, right, where it's not trying to say is one tenth plus one-sixth equal to eight fifteenths, which ChatGPT told me last year.

SPEAKER_01That's not correct, by the way. Um if you're just doing like, hey, do you like these lyrics, or do you like this music where each token is probabilistically generating the next one, you can get things that you do like. And then you know the question really is how how good can you get that to be? And the other question is why are you doing it? So the why to me is very important because I'm all about the humanity of the arts, whether it's music or anything else. And I'm just not that interested in listening to AI music for its own sake.

SPEAKER_01I I am interested in listening to it to reverse engineer it, to understand it, to try to understand if I've got surprised by something that it created through its probabilistic moves. Like what was that that I just heard? How did that chord change go? How did that key change go? Why did that melody work? What were the chord tones that it was? Did it go outside? Is it still inside? It just sounds outside, all those kind of things. So, from an instruction tool point of view, I'm very interested. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Do you so on that point as someone who you know uh obviously is a musician but also works in AI and has worked in it for a long time, do you what would you say to artists who are for you know for AI and music versus against uh just from the unique perspective you have?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I guess if you're if you're on one side or the other side, I guess I would try to say be open to the other side because there's there's reasons for being tempering your enthusiasm on on either of those all or nothing positions. I do think there's a lot that we can learn from how music is created or how poetry is created, how a good oratory is created, how visual media, maybe how dance, my daughter's been a dancer. I would say the same for that in choreography, you know.

SPEAKER_01I any of those things, like it's it's sort of like an interactive evolutionary algorithm at that point where you are the fitness function, you get to say what you like and you don't, and then the algorithm gets to go give you something new, however it generated it, maybe mutation and selection or crossover recombination or just picking something else out from a random start, you know, any of these things can work. But at the end, again, from the educational point of view, I think it's best if we can try to understand why it is that we like what we like, and then hopefully that'll help us to create more of what we like and and maybe push those boundaries a little bit further to explore things that we wouldn't have thought of otherwise.

SPEAKER_01That's another thing, too, when you're dealing with conventional approaches, you know, people get taught a certain way, and there's things that we all, you know, we hold these truths to be self-evident kind of thing in in music theory, and that's great. But you know, if you think about like where did Barry Harris get his ideas for for changing up scales in in jazz music? Well, by exploring, right? So if you if there's it's nothing wrong to say we can't explore using an AI tool, that's that's wonderful. Maybe we'll come up with something that we can all appreciate as being new and and useful.

SPEAKER_00Where do you see AI uh evolving? How do um with you have much more knowledge than I do about the actual technology. Is it what's it gonna look like in five years, ten years for for music? Wow.

SPEAKER_01Well, my easy answer is I don't know, but you know, I think let's let's back up a little bit here. There's a lot of focus right now on all the gen AI part of AI, which is one aspect of AI. It's not so much the aspect that I've worked on, right? I've worked on more machine learning and neural networks and evolutionary algorithms primarily, a little bit of fuzzy logic, but mostly and reinforcement learning, but uh mostly evolutionary algorithms and and neural networks in my career. The predictive part of large language models, that whole transformer approach, has been able to generate a lot of useful content.

SPEAKER_01Uh if you want to create a letter, you know, anything like that, it's great for starting it. It's probably not great for just hitting go. So it could it get better at that? Yeah, it could certainly get better. Maybe it'll get to the point where you can just say, hey, I write me a letter to Vaughn, thank him for having me on the podcast, and hit go. Never see it. Like, and trust it that it's gonna be fine. But you know, until it's until it's at that that level, you you still wanna you still wanna have control over what it is that you're producing. I I do anyway.

SPEAKER_01So it's fine for for generating ideas. And generating um yeah, for generating ideas for like brainstorming, but then ultimately you have to take control of it. Where's it gonna be five years from now? Well, you know, uh like I I mentioned an example. I was working with my daughter on a statistics class for her, which was my my undergrad as part of my math degree. I took 13 classes in statistics, which most people would say is 13 classes too many, and they're probably right, but um it's okay. I like the stuff. So she had a stats question.

SPEAKER_01We were doing something in two-sample mean t tests, and there's a formula I remembered, and I was like, Yeah, I wonder if ChatGPT remembers this formula too. So, of course, you know, you go type it in, it's got the formula just fine. And so we plugged in the numbers because, like, hey, can it can it figure the answer? And like I said, it takes one tenth plus one sixth, and it tells me it's eight fifteenths. I'm like, no. So then I'm like, well, it can't add. So it doesn't know fractions, which is like fifth grade math, right? But it could do calculus for you, which makes you which makes you go back and question, well, does it really know what it's doing?

SPEAKER_01And the answer is no, it's just predicting what comes next unless it defaults into a calculator mode. And if it defaults into calculator mode, you get the right answer. But then I think we would both agree a calculator is not intelligent, it's just it's already pre-programmed to do what you told it to do. It's gonna find its lowest energy state, just like a rock is gonna find its lowest energy state if you drop it, right? So, from my point of view, anyway, not intelligent. Can we get those kind of tools to be at the commander data level five to ten years from now where we would just say, hey, you know, go go pilot this rocket ship, and by the way, compose me a symphony too while you're at it.

SPEAKER_01Because you think commander data could do that, right? So I I don't I don't know because I think there's something in inherently intrinsically missing if it's only doing predictive modeling. It doesn't really to my mind, let's put it this way, I you know, because I don't I don't know that anybody can look inside our brain and know where we know things. Maybe somebody can say, well, in this region of the brain, you know these things, and you know, they're but if you start to say, well, which which neuron, they'd say, well, it's not like that, David.

SPEAKER_01It's across all these things, and there's the connections, and by the way, they're changing in time and the strengths are changing, and it depends on your stimulus, and what did you eat today? And all these, you know, dare you did you have a lot of sugar? It might change things, and are you on some medication that might change some other things, right? That's like, yeah, did you just have anesthesia? That would be a different thing. So it's it's complicated, right, at that point. But can you get to the point where you would trust that an LLM would tell you, I know what I'm doing? If you ask an LLM right now, do you know what you're doing? It'll tell you no. Right? It'll say no.

SPEAKER_01I'm just predicting what's coming next, token by token, etc. It's the illusion of knowledge. Okay. Well, fair enough. So somehow we've got to bridge that that gap, that chasm, to get to the point where not only do we have faith that it really does know what it's doing, but it can demonstrate to us that it understands something. This is kind of an obtuse example, but it it it took me all the way to college math, which I mean it should have been sooner than that for me to get asked a question in a math class like, why is one plus one equal to two?

SPEAKER_01Like we all accept that one plus one is equal to two. Why is two plus one equal to three? And then what is three? What you know what and so the professor, like, actually there's an answer to those questions. The the answer is like there's something called a successor function in math, which is the plus one, and then there's an ordered list of numbers, which are the natural numbers, one, two, three, four, five, whatever. And so two is defined as the successor of one, and three is defined as a successor of two, and so forth. And then you say, well, what's three? And you know, we're on video here, so I I guess if I held up, you know, like my fingers like that, and I gave you another example of like the maybe three awards I might have on my my shelf there or something, whatever it might be.

SPEAKER_01Whatever that property is that those things have in common, that's what three is, right? I don't I don't really know how at this point you get that into an LLM. How do you get that into an LLM? I don't I don't know. So yeah, there's a lot, there's a lot of open space to try to. We were talking before we got started. Like, okay, 25 years ago, I'm I'm on a Pentium 450 machine with my friend Kumar Cellapilla, who did all the programming, to get a checkers program to teach itself how to play checkers, and it did really very well, but it took six months to teach itself how to play just from the rules of the game.

SPEAKER_01And when we moved on to chess, we had the first chess program that beat a human master in the United States, 2006, uh James Quan, that took seven months of just letting it letting it run. And that we've come so far in 25 years, it's really it truly is impressive. And it's you know that to say it couldn't happen in five years, or I don't want to say anything like that. It's just just an amazingly fast upward trajectory. I just don't see exactly how to get there.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. So to summarize what you're saying, if I understood correctly, you think it'll almost take a certain level of kind of general intelligence uh to you know to achieve something really spectacular in the world of AI music rather than then just sort of tapering off at the end of the year.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so for spectacular, I'd say yes. I think we need to have and there's some sort of um you know it's it's uh overused word of a paradigm shift or something like that, but something that's not current not contained in the current framework, as at least as I understand it. So not working at OpenAI or any of these other places, they may have things that uh they're working on that but not only do I not understand, but I don't know about. And if they are, that's great. And maybe that success is right around the corner. But to my limited knowledge, I would say it's something's something's still missing, and I'm not sure exactly how to how to plug that in.

SPEAKER_00So as we as we wrap up here, I'm wondering again, we've heard a lot about how music is evolving, and especially in the last 30 years or so, we've we've seen more need for attracting young people and um in the last just few years, AI and the and the birth of that and its role in music. So how do you think classical music in general is gonna change with each of those two factors uh in in the upcoming years and decades?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think we're gonna get I think we're gonna one, I think we're gonna be pretty successful with the Symfonina format as time goes on. And I do think that that's gonna be a success in its own right. I certainly hope so. And I think it's also going to be what I had hoped it would be, which is a uh bridge to bringing the audience back to the symphony orchestras of the world and having them not only appreciate the symphoninas that they've listened to through streaming, but also being reintroduced, if you would, to the classics and also provide more opportunities for new composers to create the new classics for the next hundred to two hundred years, so that in the year 2300, maybe some people will still be listening to Beethoven and Mozart.

SPEAKER_01I hope so, but maybe they'll be also listening to the the new classical per uh composers who uh I might add are won't all be white men, you know, there's that too. So we live in a diverse world, and it's more diverse now, and it deserves to be uh recognized that way too. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00To think, you know, Bach lived 300 years ago, and since his time, you know, he was already incredibly advanced, but since his time, classical music has continued to live on for those three centuries and develop and evolve and see new technologies like the piano and even things that seem you know normal to us now. So it's I think even with its troubles, it's hopefully reasonable to to think that it's gonna continue to live on and just going to evolve as time goes by with the And I think it has to work as a business, you know, for the symphony orchestras of the world too, really.

SPEAKER_01If I re remember correctly, there's a statistic of that it might be a few years old now, but it's probably still true that most symphony orchestras are are run as charities, meaning that they get more from donations than they get from ticket sales. And I understand that. Um, and it would be nice if they got more from ticket sales, not by raising the prices so much, but maybe by lowering the prices and inviting more people to come who might then become longtime patrons for their particular symphony. So I certainly would encourage encourage them to do that. And then also, you know, think about what the audience wants to hear, especially the audience that's maybe 40 years and younger, and I pick them like they're the the ones who are the parents of the kids, not just the kids, but the parents of the kids who can introduce their kids to symphonic music, not just in movies and games, but just for its own sake.

SPEAKER_00Well, we'll we'll hope for the best and you know continue with work like yours and and other efforts, hopefully, hopefully make it happen. Yeah, I hope so. Well, David, thank you so much again. It's it's been quite the joy to to hear you know everything from your from your knowledge of AI and your interest in composition and and how this blends so interestingly together. So it's been been a pleasure. Thank you so much for being here. Thank you so much, Vaughn. I greatly appreciate it.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. A Grammy Winner Told Me to Listen to These 3 Albums as Homework

    Oct 8, 202637 minAudio

    I’m a 19-year-old college student and composer learning how to build a life in music by talking with incredible musicians who have already built one. Today, I’m talking with Taylor Eigsti, a jazz pianist, composer, and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. This Grammy-Winner Told Me to Shut Out the World and Write | Donnacha Dennehy

    Sep 24, 202630 minAudio

    First, you hear the music. Then the composer explains how he built it. Donnacha Dennehy is a Grammy-winning Irish composer and Princeton professor who has built music from the notes between the notes in a singer’s...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Two Days Before the Super Bowl, This Superstar Needed New Music. Chris Had 10 Hours.

    Aug 11, 202635 minAudio

    The call came at 10 p.m. on a Friday. The Super Bowl was Sunday. One of the singers had just scrapped the arrangement she was meant to perform and Chris Walden had until morning to write her a new one for a full...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Miguel del Aguila: How to Grow Classical Music Beyond the Classics

    Jun 30, 202659 minAudio

    3x Grammy-nominated composer Miguel del Aguila joins Vonn Vanier for a conversation about how classical music can grow beyond the classics without losing what makes it powerful. Miguel reflects on finding his own voice...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Peter Askim on Conducting, Composing, and The Next Festival

    May 26, 202634 minAudio

    Peter Askim is a composer, conductor, educator, former orchestral bassist, Music Director of the Wilmington Symphony Orchestra, Director of Orchestral Activities at North Carolina State University, and Founder and...

    Credit the people on this episode