What happens when coaches and athletes make sport the center of their identity? In this episode of Beyond Coaching, Rob Ramseyer talks with Dustin Galyon about giving sport its rightful place. They explore why coaching cannot ultimately be about wins, losses, championships, or individual performance. Sport is a powerful vehicle for developing people, but it should never become the destination. Dustin and Rob discuss the responsibility coaches have to use their platform to help athletes discover an identity that is bigger than sport and a sense of purpose that extends beyond the scoreboard. In This Episode * Why coaching has to be about more than winning and losing * Sport as a vehicle for personal transformation * The danger of allowing sport to become an athlete’s identity * Why an athlete’s worth cannot be determined by performance * The difference between transactional and transformational coaching * How coaches can intentionally develop the whole person * The responsibility coaches have to model the identity they want athletes to develop * Helping athletes navigate life beyond their sport * How coaches can pursue excellence and winning without making the scoreboard the source of their identity The Big Takeaway Give sport its rightful place, and give identity something far greater its rightful place. Coaches can compete intensely, pursue championships, and demand excellence while still recognizing that sport is only one part of an athlete’s life. The goal is not to care less about sport. It is to understand what sport is ultimately for. About Beyond Coaching Beyond Coaching is produced by the Impactful Coaching Project, which focuses on helping coaches better understand and develop the whole person. The podcast explores coaching, leadership, culture, identity, and what it means to coach the 21st-century athlete. Links Beyond Coaching: https://beyondcoaching.alitu.com Impactful Coaching Project: https://impactfulcoachingproject.com ICP Substack: ICP YouTube:https://www.youtube.com/@Impactfulcoachingproject This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit impactfulcoachingproject.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
[music]
SPEAKER_01Welcome back to another episode of Beyond Coaching. Got Dustin joining me again today. Thanks for having me. Hey, you're welcome. Something I think both of us say often is if what we're doing in our day jobs at Friends is just about the sport, it's a total waste of time. Why don't you dive into that and give some depth to that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, I would say, I would say two things about it to begin. I often say this to recruits all over the country, Christian or not, that's how I frame it, right? If you're a healthy human, you're gonna love what we have to offer. How we love our guys, encourage our guys, challenge our guys, hold our guys accountable. I say that to say, for me, the why in coaching is far beyond the wins, loss and the rings, which by the way, I'll go back to an earlier episode we did.
SPEAKER_00If you want to do the transformational really well, if you want to have a chance, I would even say to do the transformational piece of coaching, then the transactional piece better be hemmed up. And again, abbreviation transactional, the things that we say we're going to do, and we do them both player and coach that are oftentimes
SPEAKER_01geared just towards sport. Also competence. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00But if that's it, then what, then, I mean, then what we're saying is you and I are, are putting our success, um, our identity on the shoulders of 18 to 22 year olds that run up and down a hardwood floor play on a hundred yards. Like it's ridiculous when you say it out loud. Right. Yet, that vehicle of sport for real life transformation, I mean, in many ways, the most fertile, most impactful ground that you can walk on.
SPEAKER_00For me, if this thing isn't about giving young people a chance to encounter who Christ is, I, I, there's no way I could do it. I could do it, but it wouldn't, I, but I wouldn't. And so for people who are like, hey, I'm not a Christian or, hey, my why is different. I'm not saying that, um, that, that may be okay for them, but it's gotta be more than just winning.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Often when I speak to groups, I plan a volunteer. Sometimes I don't even plan a volunteer in the crowd, but I ask, ask for a volunteer and I say, pretend I'm a alien from outer space. Describe and then ask them for their favorite sport. Yeah. So what's your favorite sport, Dustin? Golf. Let's illustrate the silliness of this. Okay. What is golf?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's a, it's a game that's played outside on a whole lot of grass.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I'm already feeling this. I'm with you already. You hit a ball. I mean, it's sillier. You hit? What do you mean hit a ball? Well, you take a club. What's a club? You get the point. Yeah. Just the silliness of it all where it's made up adversity and challenge. Yeah. But yet, I mean, we've been advocates of FCA and 3D coaching. They have a saying of, um, There's not a more powerful phrase in the English language,
SPEAKER_01especially in the United States, for Coach Says. So this silliness gives you a platform to speak into kids' life. And for me and you, the faith piece is instrumental to that. But whatever it is, if you're not intentionally taking care of that, not working towards a platform to better the world, better humans, whatever idealistic thing we want to say, then what are you doing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And when we talk about sport in the US, I mean, it's elevated. I mean, I would just ask you this, and again, I'm not knocking, so I won't even say a name, but how many times do you say, who do you wanna be like, or who's your hero? And we name the greatest athlete And we don't have a personal relationship. We don't really know them. Oftentimes we say that and maybe that person wouldn't model, right? What we would call healthy life standards, et cetera.
SPEAKER_00But because they do this sport thing at a one of 1% level, I mean, we worship it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, we, we move, we move pieces of our life around so that we can do this sport thing. And it goes further. I think the bigger conversation is like sport has a rightful place in society and day to day and whatever. And I don't know if we always put it though in that rightful spot. Um, if it, I w I would further say. If the identity is in wins and losses, the wins won't be as sweet and the losses will be devastating. And that rollercoaster,
SPEAKER_00I don't know how you can be the best version of you based on
SPEAKER_01the scoreboard. Oh, that's what I was going to say. It eventually ends in a very rough ending, I think. But to use biblical terms, I think what we're talking about is sport as an idol in how we help Coaches or how coaches can lead in a way that helps move people away from that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I'm going to bring up Wayne Simeon. I remember having a conversation with Wayne Simeon. A friend of the pod. No doubt. And if you don't know, long story short, Division I college basketball won an award finalist or in the conversation for player of the year.
SPEAKER_01I think we talked about he's the tallest guest of the pod.
SPEAKER_00First round draft pick, I think in the NBA. And he talks about. When his identity became more than sport, the freedom that came into that, right? Now, it also, I think, I won't speak for him, I also believe that long-term, it took him away from basketball sooner than he ever imagined or could have been, right? I mean, he stepped away from that to do ministry, I believe, far before any of the contract offers ended.
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_00I think as coaches, it enriches the day-to-day because I think now the wins become in preparation. The wins become in the journey of how you do it. The wins become in how do you do hard together. And by the way, when I say that, I know there's somebody listening like, oh, be soft. No, all those things equate winning. If you do all those things better, you win more. And so the other piece of that is how do you give perspective to student athletes who this is all they know? And they came, they want to be great.
SPEAKER_00They want to win. And then if that doesn't happen or when that doesn't happen or it doesn't happen at the level they want it to, how do you have that convo of like, man, your worth is way bigger than this? How do you advise coaches to do that?
SPEAKER_01Oh, I think a couple things. I think you can't give away what you don't have.
SPEAKER_00Good.
SPEAKER_01So that goes back to, I think there's a very real element of faith there for me. But I think there's also the constant piece of character development that we talk about. I think that's number one. I think number two, and I've evolved over time on this, is not... Not expecting kids to be at a place that they shouldn't. If they've been lived in this culture and been told that sport is an end-all be-all, which I really think a vast majority of our population that participate
SPEAKER_01in sport is getting that message. We can't be shocked when that's where they're at when they get to us. So what's our game plan for How we run our programs, conversation, character development, faith development programs, to where there's a journey to explore what that means.
SPEAKER_00I'll say this, see if you agree or disagree. My first head coaching job, I understood the opportunity, but not responsibility. And I was so impatient with all the, all the life, I'll call it life stuff. And I wanted and felt guilty that if guys didn't believe like I believed, if guys didn't say this was truth of what I fully believe is true,
SPEAKER_00then I felt in some ways like I was failing guys versus now I would say my job is to model that.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think I take it a step even further of when I was coaching early on and 18-year-olds acted like 18-year-olds. I took it as a personal affront. And how dare you act like this? We say we're about that as opposed to now I look at it and say, what a wonderful opportunity to build in somebody's lives when they're at that moment.
SPEAKER_00I think that whole idea of, hey, I'm busting up rocks, I'm planting like good soil or I'm watering what's growing. I think we all like the last one. Yeah. But That busting up rocks, I think there's a discernment process there too of, can we go back to that time where I was assumed for most of us, like that was it. I mean, if you looked at my life from, let's just say, 16 to 22, I could have told you life was about X, Y, and Z, but everything revolved around sport.
SPEAKER_00I mean, sleep pattern, what I, I mean, everything revolve, and my identity. Family trips. Without question. I mean, that's a whole nother section of like, are we missing, you know, you ask the question, so I'll say it. I, I oftentimes when I'm talking, uh, when we've been able to workshop with coaches, one of the questions that I'll ask with a little bit of a relationship is, hey, um, My wife and I have two young kids, right? Nine and six. What would you say to yourself at my age with young kids? What do I not know that I don't know? Just tell me as a parent,
SPEAKER_00you know, coach and Over and over and over again, I'm hearing this like, hey, it's not the end of the all. We scheduled family vacations and trips. And then when something didn't go well, we were like, hey, it's okay. Yet everything we did was to bolster, build up our kids to be athletes. And then when that world didn't go exactly like we thought, we didn't know how to respond in it. And so again, what's the rightful place of that? And I keep going back to If you hear this and you don't think that your teams
SPEAKER_00or you don't think you can coach with the same passion or the same intensity and have an identity that's bigger than win-loss, I would just profess to you that I think that's a lie. I think the best version of that comes when identity is bigger than that. We can give it its rightful place. You can get after it. There's freedom in that.
SPEAKER_01And I think there's a responsibility to Uh, utilize the gifts given to us to the best of our ability.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. If we're gonna do it, let's do it. Excellent. How does that look? Here's the other thing we, we won't often say, you know, as a Christian, I would tell you that there are people who have heard bad gospel, right? They've heard the gospel, um, abused or, or, or, or not exegeted or not just said in the right way. And so we believe lies about, that's the same in athletics. We've heard some bad lies about what it means, what our identity is as an athlete. We've heard coaches and other people and some of them say, hey, I love you, so I'm going to have you do this. That's not about love, right?
SPEAKER_00It's about coach satisfying some need or he's upset about something. So I think in there, I won't call it abuse, that's not the right word, but man, there's some bad examples out there.
SPEAKER_01And there's some awful theology of faith and sport together where, you know, Yeah, well, that's another episode. Another podcast?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, another podcast.
SPEAKER_01Interesting conversation. Final thoughts?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, give sport its rightful place and give identity in something way greater its rightful spot. It's cool to see how those things work together when done right. Yeah, right on. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Important conversation.
SPEAKER_00Thanks.
SPEAKER_01Thank you for listening to another episode of Beyond Coaching. Beyond Coaching is a podcast developed and produced by the Impactful Coaching Project with the support of Friends University. The Impactful Coaching Project seeks to develop coaches that coach the whole person and is the thought leader in coaching the 21st century athlete. The Impactful Coaching Project produces training, information and research to help coaches improve. To see more information, go to impactfulcoachingproject.substack.com.
One of my favorite books of the year so far is Collective Confidence by Dr. André Martin. Dr. Martin is an organizational psychologist who also spent considerable time working as a sport psychologist earlier in his...
What makes a transformational coach? Is it grit, resilience, competitive drive, or something deeper? In this episode of Beyond Coaching, I sit down with Dr. Brian Davidson, CEO of MindVue, to explore the mindset skills...
In this episode of Beyond Coaching, part four of The 3D Journey series, Rob Ramseyer continues his conversation with Wes Simmons of the 3D Institute about what it takes to develop athletes, build healthy team cultures,...
I wasn’t as good as I thought I was. That’s a hard lesson for any athlete to learn. I learned it playing college baseball. After being a successful high school athlete and an All-American powerlifter, I went to college...
What exactly is a coach? Most coaches would say a leader, motivator, teacher, or strategist. But Wes Simmons believes the original definition of the word gives us a much better picture of what great coaching is supposed...