Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beyond Coaching

Beyond Coaching artwork

Why Sports Don't Automatically Build Character

Oct 26, 202643 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

In this episode of Beyond Coaching, part four of The 3D Journey series, Rob Ramseyer continues his conversation with Wes Simmons of the 3D Institute about what it takes to develop athletes, build healthy team cultures, and lead with intention. Wes explains how the 3D Coaching framework evolved and why effective coach education requires more than quick strategies and practical takeaways. Coaches must understand the principles behind their decisions if they want to apply them consistently, especially when facing adversity. The conversation examines research on the impact of 3D Coaching, the transfer of values from coaches to athletes, and a critical distinction between performance character and moral character. As Wes explains, sports can develop qualities such as discipline, perseverance, and commitment, but those qualities do not automatically make someone a good teammate or person. Without intentional leadership, the same drive that fuels achievement can also fuel selfishness, unhealthy rivalry, and jealousy. Rob and Wes also discuss why leaders should view success as a platform for developing others rather than a pedestal to defend, how athletic directors can support coaches through difficult seasons, and why relationships and intentional culture-building matter to long-term success. The episode concludes with a preview of the 3D Culture Summit, scheduled for June 22-23, 2027, in St. Joseph, Missouri. In This Episode How the 3D Coaching framework evolved Why understanding matters more than simply collecting coaching strategies What research suggests about 3D Coaching and non-cognitive skills Why sports do not automatically build moral character The difference between performance character and moral character How coaches influence the values of their athletes Why success should be a platform for developing others How athletic directors can support coaches under pressure Why relationships and intentional culture-building matter What to expect from the 3D Culture Summit About The 3D Journey The 3D Journey is a 12-part series on Beyond Coaching featuring conversations with Wes Simmons and the 3D Institute about the principles, research, and practices behind 3D Coaching. The series builds toward the 3D Culture Summit in St. Joseph, Missouri, on June 22-23, 2027. Learn More About the 3D Institute The 3D Institute helps coaches and leaders build cultures that develop skills, strengthen mindsets, and shape identity and purpose. Explore 3D Institute courses and resources: https://3dinstitute.com/3d-journey-trial/ Make sure to mention the Impactful Coaching Project if you enroll! Apple Podcasts: Spotify: YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@Impactfulcoachingproject Substack: This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit impactfulcoachingproject.substack.com/subscribe

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

[music]

SPEAKER_02Welcome back to another episode of Beyond Coaching. This is episode four of the 3D Journey, our 12-part series with Wes Simmons and the 3D Institute, building toward the 3D Culture Summit next summer in St. Joe, Missouri. Quick note, ICP has a partnership with 3D, and we've worked together with them for a while. But we're doing this series, I'm very excited about it. Quick recap, if you haven't heard the episodes, episode one is Wes's story and how 3D started. Episode two was talking about the framework and the three dimensions.

SPEAKER_02And episode three was the definition of a coach, a covered courage that takes a person of importance to where they want or need to go. And now we're on to episode four. So Wes, thanks for being here again.

SPEAKER_01It's been a great journey so far. I look forward to this episode.

SPEAKER_02All right. We're going to dive right in. I'm kind of going on some tangents today from what we originally planned, but some of this is from questions I've gotten since some of the episodes. So Dimension 2, there's five parts of it. People are curious, how'd you come up with those five? Because there's about 50 options you could come up with. So dive into that a little bit.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, really, I think The rough draft of 3D was, it was more than a rough draft, but it was inherited by us from Jeff, really. I mean, Jeff was part of founding 3D Institute, but the baseline of training that we built from really was from the course that he developed at UCF years ago. And in the original model and the research, there wasn't five, there was eight. Motivation, Confidence, Emotions, Team, Cohesion, and Goal Setting, which are the five you're referring to.

SPEAKER_01I think the original model, I may have to dig into the archives here a little bit in my mind, but focus was one, mental imagery was one, and I think the other one was intensity. So those are the original eight, but when we decided to move it out of the academic environment, more into the professional development environment, Something just had to go. We had to chop it. It was already long enough. I think the original version of that training was like seven and a half hours

SPEAKER_01that we put online and put out there. And people would say, man, that's pretty long. I'm like, well, when you're starting with a full semester, three-hour grad class and you condense that down to seven and a half hours, it's all a matter of perspective. To me, that's pretty short. There's a lot of work down to that. But we've continued to whittle it away. And I would say the reason we chose those five of the eight, those were the five most pressing issues and needs that we were discerning from coaches at that time, especially.

SPEAKER_01Looking back at it now, you know, or in light of 2026, I think things like focus could make a fresh case for itself in a digitally distracted age. But that's the reason for the five.

SPEAKER_02Okay. Yeah, it's interesting. So as I've gone to the ICP stuff and I've taken all your guys' stuff, the coach education, you can't be too short.

SPEAKER_01You're always pressed to

SPEAKER_02make it shorter. And we actually did a study with you guys where did a survey with coaches who took your course and took a competitor's course. And one of the benefits they saw of yours was you had trimmed the fat and it was really

SPEAKER_01concise, but they still want it shorter.

SPEAKER_02So that's something I think all of us wrestle that work with coaches is they want it quick, but you need it impactful, and there's certainly a tension there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, we've always wrestled internally with what do people want and what do they need? It's like, okay, we could give them the cliff notes, but if we trim too much of the fat, in some ways we violate one of our own principles that we teach, which is understanding is the basis for care. So we can give you a strategy, we can give you a cliff note, an idea, a nugget, but sometimes, you know, there's a little more understanding that needs to be conveyed so that you're not, you know, so you're effective at using these strategies and principles and understanding truly

SPEAKER_01the why underneath it.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Sounds like you're a covered carriage taking somebody where they need to go, not necessarily where they want to go at times.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, We always kind of joke because we get that feedback a lot. Just make it practical. Just give us the practical strategies. I don't need all the information. I just want to know what to do. I appreciate that more than most people realize because I want to run as well. I want to grab and go and we're all busy and I'll figure it out on the way and I'm kind of like that. I've rethought that over the years. I truly appreciate Mark, who really is Mark Hole.

SPEAKER_01He's the one that's really made that deposit in the 3D lexicon, if you will, that understanding is the basis of care. And if you really want to care well, keep it as simple as possible, but not more so. Well, you can't learn it and understand it unless

SPEAKER_02you sit in it. I don't know if this is the right phrase, but drink deeply from it for a long time and just dive into it. And yeah, that's certainly attention. I think the work you do provides because we actually have this thing. We developed an ICP of the trajectory of a coach's career, and it's kind of this shape like a U and the X axis is time.

SPEAKER_02The y-axis, I'm sorry, yeah, and the y-axis is what you know. And at the start of a career, you think you know a lot more than you actually do. And as you learn, you start thinking you know less because you realize how much is out there and you keep learning, learning, learning. But there's a time in a coach's career, I think, where they think they know it all and then all of a sudden they think they know a lot more than they do again. And keeping coaches in that space where they want to learn and there's a level up there of adapting, I think matters a lot.

SPEAKER_01Along those lines, one of the things we talk a lot about internally is the difference between the fire hydrant approach, which is like everything. It feels like there's so much information out there that everyone's drinking from a fire hydrant versus a soaker hose approach. And 3D, our certification courses, especially, even though it is fairly lengthy, three and a half hours, again, those things are relative. That's maybe an episode and a half of a Netflix series, people like to binge.

SPEAKER_01But because we've whittled it down from a three hour masterclass to three and a half hours of literal content, It's all the greatest hits. It's very weighty or substantive content. I like to think of it like eating a steak. You don't want to just gobble down a steak and not enjoy it. You want to take time to enjoy it, but then you also need time to process before you just keep on eating. We encourage a soaker hose approach or Chew on it approach, however you want to describe it.

SPEAKER_01But yes, best not just binged or taking it, you know, like a fire hydrant. Drink deeply, as you said.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So for those that are thinking about doing it, we've evolved it. Friends, where every one of our new coaches does it, all our head coaches and full-time coaches. And I tell them I don't want them to get it done in shorter than four months because I want them to take their time, think about it, talk about it, and not rush through it. And I think there's a piece, I actually said this to One of our new coaches today where we were just talking about season getting going and the challenges as a first-time head coach. And I said, you know what, I enjoy these conversations, but I'm really looking forward to them after you lose your first three in a row.

SPEAKER_02Because then you absorb it, you know, and you deal with the pressure. And, okay, can I act out these principles and live in the three dimensions even when things are going bad? And that's hard to do if you haven't really absorbed this stuff.

SPEAKER_01I agree. I agree. That's when your value system is really tested, you know? Because I do think a lot of people understand, just even from a transactional side of things, that, okay, the people I'm coaching, they are more than just a physical skill set. There is a mind, there is a heart, and it does kind of make sense that if I can optimize all three, well, I can get a better performance. And so that's, so people begin that journey in earnest.

SPEAKER_01But what hasn't really been tested is the why. They're just about the performance. How do you respond when it does go bad? Do you stay true to the process? Do you continue to value the person in the face of the pressure?

SPEAKER_02That's

SPEAKER_01the real test.

SPEAKER_02And that's where I think AD's principles really matter. We have a first-year head coach right now in another sport going through really difficult years in wins and losses. But the coach is doing a tremendous job. You know, I feel good about it. And part of my role is continually reminding the coach of that and going back to the principles and why we do what we do. And so I think my leadership probably matters there as much as anything when they're challenged, taking them back to their purpose, which you guys talk all the time about.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's an interesting thought. I've often wondered if an athletic director in today's culture Handed the keys of a basketball program to John Wooden. Would he have the opportunity in today's culture to succeed? Because it took him 10 years to lay that foundation, right? They didn't win a national championship, I believe for 10 years, but then they won 10 in a row, something like that. But now it's like three and a half years. And if you don't have that margin by the admin to your point,

SPEAKER_01To lay the foundation of purpose, not a quick fix. And just the transient nature of coaching in general in college. Rarely do you even see a coach there for more than three and a half, four years. It doesn't seem like anymore.

SPEAKER_02They'd certainly have to keep the AD off social media in that 10 years and talk themselves into firing somebody. Okay, last time we talked briefly. I want to dive into it more about the research Mark Bauer did. Mark is the AD at University of Nebraska-Carney, did his doctoral dissertation studying essentially soft skills in 3D. Let's dive into that a little bit more. So give us the high level on that because it statistically proved a lot of things we've always thought about 3D.

SPEAKER_02Yeah.

SPEAKER_01The story really goes back to an article that was written probably about 2015 or 16. I'd have to go back and look at the record books because I could pinpoint it because my alma mater, Northwest Missouri State, their football team at that time had a 30-game winning streak going. And it was the longest and current active winning streak in college football. And not only that, at that point, Northwest had been, you know, statistically against all divisions, I think, either the or the second most winningest program in the previous two decades,

SPEAKER_01something like that. And there's a guy named Brian Davidson. Brian, Was connected with Joel Osborne. He's now the head coach at the Benedictine for the Ravens football team. But at the time he was at Northwest, both from Harlan, Iowa, and they had a connection. And he reached out to Joel and said, hey, I've got this assessment called the MindView Profile, and I would like to test it or use it to get on the inside of the minds

SPEAKER_01of champions. And to measure what they called the non-cognitive skills of champions. What they did was they had, I believe they had all the coaches more or less rank the players based on their own interactions with them and experience with them. You know, this is a complete oversimplification, but. Number one, this is your captain type. This is your poster child, teammate, leader,

SPEAKER_01always on time, always doing the right things versus down at the other end of the spectrum, the kids that were consistently not dependable or showing up or constantly in trouble and a lot of subjectivity in that process. But the polar extremes would certainly tell a story, right? And he wanted to assess, you know, how well does what the research show match up to the coach's experience? And it was a very interesting article.

SPEAKER_01You can still find it. It's called Inside the Minds of Champions by Brian Davidson. But I saw that and I go, wow, okay, that could be a tool that perhaps we could use to measure the impact of 3D training. Because a lot of the non-cognitive skills they're measuring Or the second to third dimension aspects of our framework. Well, around that time, Mark Bauer from the University of Nebraska-Carney, he was transitioning from the head coach, wrestling coach role into the AD role, was wanting to get his doctorate.

SPEAKER_01He was doing that at Creighton University. And years ago, he had been exposed to 3D and it captured his imagination. So when he reached out and asked, hey, I'd like to study the impact of 3D on coaches in the workforce. How can we do that? Well, I was able to then connect Brian and Mark, and we were able to put about 150 grad students, which primarily were coaches in the workforce. They were from Emporia State University, Clemson University, and Georgia Southern University.

SPEAKER_01And we did a pre-post analysis using the MindView profile with the intervention in between being the 3D certification course taught in a university three-hour grad credit class. And as you can imagine, there's a lot of different variables in there. So there's not absolute conclusive claims that you can make even from a study like this because of some of those variables. But when 12 of the 13 Moved in a positive direction,

SPEAKER_01and eight of those were statistically significant. You can't just say, yeah, 3D does this, but you can definitely say, 3D is doing something and it's pretty good, or it's definitely a

SPEAKER_02piece of puzzle.

SPEAKER_01So that was a little bit of the background of that study.

SPEAKER_02Can I interrupt real quick? Shameless plug, we'll be releasing a podcast episode of A Conversation with Brian next month. Because we've, on your recommendation, we used him with friends and actually did a pre and post after we did 3D, very similar results. But yeah, Brian's still doing amazing work.

SPEAKER_01Good. Well, good. In a couple of months, he can set straight anything that I got wrong there, but that's the gist of it. Mark Bauer, though, the other part of his study that was very unique and very interesting was not just the impact of a training like 3D can have on a coaching staff's non-cognitive skills. That was half of the study. But the other half of it looked at what they called the transfer of value. It was looking at the transfer of values in the coaching environment.

SPEAKER_01Uniquely a coach-athlete environment, a team setting, a group that's journeying together through a season. It was very fascinating to have his research back up kind of what we already knew as well, but to see it. And here's the gist of that. Part of the study was this. Values transfer will happen between coach, the authority, and those under their care. It's automatic.

SPEAKER_01Now, the question is, is it intentional? But what his research showed is that the tracks are greased and values transfer will take place from the authority to the team and Connecting the whole study together, he was making the case, that's why we need to make sure that coaches are trained in the areas they can have the greatest impact and are intentional about imparting those values to the next generation because the value transfer will happen.

SPEAKER_02I'm sure I'm stealing this from somewhere, but I can't remember where of, and I've come to deeply believe this, of sport isn't going to be a neutral impact on a kid's life. I think it either has extreme positive But if it's not done intentionally, I'd bet my money on having a negative values impact. Would you agree with that?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, you may be remembering some of the stuff we refer to the actual 3D certification course because it was the Josephson Institute and then it was called the Hamm Beller Moral Reasoning Survey that what they did was they studied The moral reasoning of athletes over, I mean, years, it was like 72,000 athletes that they studied over time. And the conclusive evidence of both of those organizations, the Hamm-Beller Moral Reasoning Survey and the Josephson Institute was this,

SPEAKER_01left to itself, the longer a student athlete or an athlete is involved in competitive athletics, again, left to itself, The more it undermines or erodes moral reasoning. And I think it's, once you get past the offense of that, because if you're like me, I've been taught my whole life, I've heard it, sports builds character. Sports builds character. And I think that's true, but it's only about half true. It depends on how we define character.

SPEAKER_01Because When we do this in workshops, because we've done this for years, a lot of times we will ask coaches about that saying, how many of you heard that sports build character? And usually about half the room nervously raises their hand because they know it's a setup of some sort, which it is. But those bold souls that raise their hand and I say, okay, what character does sport build? We always get the same basic answers, hard work, commitment, sacrifice.

SPEAKER_01Perseverance, overcoming adversity, those types of attributes. And I agree that a competitive sporting environment can build those character attributes in a person. The problem is those are amoral. That's not compass, that's fuel. Without compass, I mean, those will fuel you. Those will get you somewhere you can't get from point A to point B, right?

SPEAKER_01Without the attributes of greatness, at least if you're trying to win in the process or be proficient or successful. The problem is what about the moral compass side of that? And so in our 3D training, this is especially in the third dimension content, this is where we'll spend time talking about what is the difference between the attributes of greatness, the fuel, the performance character, And the attributes of goodness, the attributes of moral character. Performance character, that's what determines will I get up and sacrifice and go to the weight room

SPEAKER_01in January at 6 a.m. for workouts when I don't want to and that kind of stuff. But the moral attributes are like, what kind of teammate am I? Right? And so what those research is showing is that sport left to itself, it's great at coaching the aspects of greatness. The problem is most coaches kind of let the good and the bad play themselves out. And sometimes that greatness fuels the attributes of goodness and it produces things of excellence. But sometimes those attributes of greatness fuel things like selfish ambition

SPEAKER_01or unhealthy rivalry or jealousy. Yeah, we want you to be great at justice. We want you to stay committed to love. We want you to persevere toward the right causes that help relationships and add to a transcendent cause and all those things. But you could easily apply those things in a sporting environment to the areas of self-interest. And when the great fuels the good, it produces beautiful things.

SPEAKER_01But when the great fuels the bad, it produces some of the ugliest stuff you'll ever see in sport. So that research plus marks, you know, the values transfer will happen. Are we being intentional? If we are, there's not a better environment to impart the attributes of greatness and goodness to the next generation. If we're not intentional, man, it's a crapshoot and we may end up unwittingly training somebody to be great

SPEAKER_02at being selfish

SPEAKER_01or something like that.

SPEAKER_02So how do we, I mean, guard our hearts is the terminology that's coming to mind of I mean, you can go down that road and be pursuing goodness and greatness. That conflict comes and you don't even realize you're going down the selfish, self-centered path. I think one of your answers is going to be keep revisiting your purpose statement, but go a layer beneath that for me. How do we help each other and how do we help ourselves stay out of that selfishness path?

SPEAKER_01That's a great question. I mean, I think that is the journey. It's always the temptation to deviate from the path is

SPEAKER_02to get on the path of self-serving.

SPEAKER_01I think maybe one of the ways to think about it is how do you define success? Do you view success as a pedestal where there's room for want? And therefore you scratch and claw your way to get there. And then you spend all your time there fending off all would be threats because they threaten your position of being number one.

SPEAKER_01Well, the alternative way to think about it, I believe is to not view success as a pedestal, but do you see it as a platform? Because on a platform, I mean, think of like a stage. I'm up above the crowd, perhaps on a stage, but on a platform, I've got room to pull lots of other people up and it doesn't threaten my position at all. And so just those kind of thoughts and I think premeditating that is essential.

SPEAKER_01Like having those definitions of what success is in your mind before the pressurized moment will give you a shot. And then the pressure will still squeeze some of the junk out of us in the moment, maybe, but we can quickly get back. But it's a journey, right? I mean, in some ways, that is the journey, is to remain others-minded and not just purely self-centered. And to operate from love, not fear.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I just got done. There was a new really good biography of Tom Brady that was released in the last month. I just got done reading it. And for him to perform at the high level he did for so long, and he would say this, it was, it got to the point it was, it was always selfish on some level of the time he had to devote, but it was his priority over his family and everything. And he had some really honest moments in that book of quotes of like,

SPEAKER_02it takes what it takes, and he was going to do it. And I wonder I don't know if he changes. I think you get to that level of performance and like athletic success. It just breeds that. But I do wonder if early on if there were ways to to intercede because I do wonder now if he'd say it was worth it of the goodness versus greatness and all those things. And yeah, I don't know. I don't know what the question was there.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I hear what you're saying now. Part of it is understanding the continuum of youth sports, too, from, you know, at that level that Tom Brady's operating, I mean, it is no doubt a power performance and even entertainment model of sports. I mean, by very definition, it is transactional. And for him to be the top of that game, I mean, there's going to be a level that in some ways it's a tar baby. It's going to get stuck on you. You have to operate transactionally at some level to truly platform,

SPEAKER_01pedestal, whatever you want to call it, but to be at the top of your game, it's a different beast, right? The problem is at the other end of the spectrum, you've got more of this play, pleasure, recreational model. And what tends to be the trend in sport is that this power performance model is being pressed down younger and younger and younger and younger and younger on kids. And that's really where the problem is. Years ago, I used to teach 3D at the university level as a three-hour grad class live

SPEAKER_01on Monday nights. And it was funny, when we were doing this model or this segment, we actually talked a lot about When that power performance model presses down, what does it actually produce? Like you got the masses going, man, if I want to be the next Tom Brady, I got to do this, this, and this, and this, and this.

SPEAKER_01And so when I showed the class, and it's old now, but you can still find it on YouTube. It was an ESPN 30 for 30 called Broke, which is kind of a double entendre. Broke, meaning it was spotlighting at the time how two-thirds of NFL players, and I think it was over 70% of NBA basketball players, two years out of their short career, were completely bankrupt and divorced. So broke, yeah, it meant financial, but again, it had a double meaning, just kind of broken lives.

SPEAKER_01And it's like, okay, if the whole system's Trying to get everyone to get to that pinnacle, but that pinnacle ends up ruining your life. Why are we trying to shove that model down younger and younger on kids? It doesn't work on me in any way, except for very few people. It makes you go, hmm.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we're pretty dumb is what I'm thinking. But yeah, you just look up to that success and think you follow it. And here's the counterintuitive thing. And this last thing I'll say on Brady, but reading that book, In the organization, like with the Patriots, he's an unbelievable leader. And granted, he was really good, which helped. But they talked about his ability to build relationships and his level of humility with his teammates and interacting on their personal level. That's where his power came from, they thought.

SPEAKER_02So you have this dichotomy of stuff I don't believe in and then stuff I do. And whether you're at the Patriots, you're in the lowest level of youth sports, people are still people. And they want to be valued, and that's how you gain power and influence in some way. So it's fascinating.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Well, definitely we're all a mixed bag, right, of good and great. And so, you know, I think by the end of it all, hopefully he has figured out how to get the right blend of that. And it sounds like he did, you know, because he had the respect of his teammates while pursuing extreme high levels of success. I mean, we see the same thing like Mahomes, right? I mean, he's... He's a pretty good mix, I think.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, but probably insane. But Patrick, if you want to come on the podcast with us, we'll let you defend yourself. Just call us. All right, I'm going to catch you off guard on the last one. I want to see what you think on this. So what do you still wonder about? Or like, what do you think you haven't figured out within the three dimensions or how to do this really well?

SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, The initial reaction I have to that is really what we've been kind of working on. I wonder, can we show in a tangible way with a study, with data, that coaches' education is an investment not only in your coaches, which it is,

SPEAKER_01And not only in the athletes that they influence, which it is, but what does training a coaching staff do to all of the numbers that a school district cares about? Things like attendance and GPA and test scores and discipline referrals and, you know, those kinds of metrics, because I've heard enough stories Of how even just one of the right coaches,

SPEAKER_01one coach can impact all those on a campus. What might it look like if all were trained? And what does that do to the numbers? So we're beginning to explore and look for opportunities to prove that out. And we've got a university partner ready to come with us on that.

SPEAKER_02Cool. Well, shameless, shameless plug. And this is the college level, but. So we started with 3D at Fridge University. I think it was 2020, 2021, somewhere around there. And we do evaluations every year of our program with every single student athlete. And every metric has gone up significantly. And we've won more.

SPEAKER_01So, you know, is

SPEAKER_02that the only thing? Absolutely not. But if it's not part of it, I'd be darned. It's got to be.

SPEAKER_01Do I remember right where you told me, because I've been tracking that with you a little bit as you've shared that with us. It seems like one of the years there was a really counterintuitive stat that showed, because during that time, your student athlete population is about doubled, hasn't it?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, we've gone up from 460 to 750 in this time period.

SPEAKER_01So with the infusion of 300 athletes into the athletic department, I can't assume that that's because you're adding sports. That was mostly, I mean, maybe a couple, but-

SPEAKER_02It was both.

SPEAKER_01Is it generally safe to say that as numbers have gone up, shots of playing time have gone down for the majority?

SPEAKER_02Yeah. Or opportunity to play has been on the JV.

SPEAKER_01Okay, great. Yeah. But really the point I'm getting there is there's no more than, you know, the same number of starters on the varsity baseball team, there's nine spots, you know, or whatever. But as those numbers have grown, am I correct in remembering that their actual satisfaction has gone up as their opportunity to play may have gone down?

SPEAKER_02Yes. I'll throw two numbers at you. So it's a scale of one to four, one worst, four best. And the overall score, first year we did it was 3.14. Last year, with the most student athletes we ever had, it was 3.56. And then here's the one I love the most. One of the questions we ask every year is, my coach values me as a person outside my sport. First year we measured 324. Last year, 3.58. That's pretty

SPEAKER_01big jumps on a four-point scale.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. I wish I'd go back and do a five-point scale, but I was stupid. But it still proves its point. I mean, another one, I grew as a person of integrity because of my sport participation. First year, 3.18. Last year, 3.52.

SPEAKER_01Do you believe that as those kind of impacts have been made, that is specifically a big part of why the winning has gone up?

SPEAKER_02I'm an idealist in this one, but I don't see how it doesn't. I see our kids competing harder, competing for each other, and it lines up so much with, we also ask them what motivates them to participate in their sport. Every year it's some form of relationship. And it's not the coach as the number one or number two relationship, which I tell our coaches of, I don't think that lessens their role at all. I think their impact is just as high, but they're the cultivators of the environment where those relationships are valued.

SPEAKER_02And whether it's 3D ICP, it's the holistic approach to do it that I think gets the most out of people.

SPEAKER_01I joke with people we interview of, even

SPEAKER_02if you hate kids, this is the way to win. So fake it.

SPEAKER_01I say that tongue in cheek. I don't want any means somebody to come in that doesn't care about kids, but it's,

SPEAKER_02yeah, it's, and doing it in a systemic, intentional way is very, very hard. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01And I think that's the key, though, is just being intentional within your system to emphasize, right? A lot of times I'll, you know, We're doing something called 3D Masterclass right now, which is a community cohort. We've got 65 leaders. It was interesting because we've been intentionally in our community model trying to break out of the world of sport and invite leaders from other sectors to come and learn from the people of sport. So we are unapologetically from sport,

SPEAKER_01but our premise is if you are in a leadership role, there is a coaching aspect. Why wouldn't we learn From the experts, as far as I'm concerned, on the planet, the people in the world of sport who know how to build culture and build teams and learn to apply those kind of principles into any kind of environment. And anyway, so we're doing that. But I always start the group with the same statement, and that's, I'm probably not going to tell you anything you don't already know.

SPEAKER_01Now, maybe you didn't know individually, but collectively in the room, all the answers are in the room. We're just not having the right conversations. And so we're going to be intentional and systemic about having the right conversations. And that's where the magic happens.

SPEAKER_02Sounds like you should have a summit.

SPEAKER_01We are. We will.

SPEAKER_02Well, let's talk about that as we wrap up. So the 3D Culture Summit next summer, next June, right?

SPEAKER_01Yes. June 22nd and 23rd.

SPEAKER_02Okay. And that's what this whole series is leading up to. So St. Joe, Missouri and... You're bringing people from all over the industries to come together, right?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, the audience will be from various sectors. I still think we'll probably have the majority coaches and teachers and people from the world of education, but we'll also have an increasing number of people from the arts and business and education, government, healthcare, nonprofit sectors, along with athletics. And the conference theme In the city of coaches is bring your team, bring your dream, leave with a plan.

SPEAKER_01What we will be doing for a day and a half, it's a leadership retreat. Think of it as like coaches and captains camp, all grown up, or outside of just sport. So I'm not talking about coaches and athletes, although a coach could bring their captains if they wanted to. They should be able to get a lot out of that. But more than that, I'm thinking like, okay, athletic directors and who are your captains on your staff, your culture drivers, your influential inner circle of coaches that you may want to get away with

SPEAKER_01and bring your dream for the culture you all are trying to create. And we'll help you build that into a practical plan for the next 365. So ADs and coaches, or it might be superintendents and building administrators, or it could be a CEO and they're Their C-suite of leaders, or it could be a manager and their top leaders on the vote line right below them or whatever. So it's going to be intentionally cross-sector, but we are going to be who we are and we're going to bring some powerful voices from

SPEAKER_01the world of sport to talk to us about if you're building a culture, what does it mean and what should your approach be in the recruiting phase? How do you recruit the right people to bring their talent and their giftedness to your mission? Because great coaches are great at identifying and cultivating and inviting people to want to be a part of something bigger than themselves. All right, you got them here. Now what? Onboarding.

SPEAKER_01So we'll have other coaches speaking about how do you acclimate new team members to a team? What do you do for your freshman or when you get a transfer? What do you do to welcome them to the family? And then train them to a standard of excellence that's been established. You do those first two steps right, hopefully that sets you up for this thing called retaining, which is increasingly difficult for college athletes these days, but- It matters a

SPEAKER_02little bit though.

SPEAKER_01It does. Like, what is our strategy to keep people here and add value to their lives that's priceless? Because they're getting tempted away with all kinds of prices. Well, what are you offering that's priceless? You know, I think there is a point where if a kid's offered enough money that it probably is wise for them to go take it, right? But it's amazing to see how an athlete will jump ship from this school to this school, move across state for 25 grand.

SPEAKER_01I actually heard this story. There was an athlete in Colorado that Was a small D1 in Colorado, got recruited away to kind of a similar size D1 in California for 25 extra grand. Well, he didn't realize that half that money's gonna be spent in the move and they didn't understand the difference in taxes. He ended up losing money in the deal because he was trying to go who was paying the biggest price. Well, we can't control all that, especially in a tight budget and small college athletics or wherever.

SPEAKER_01But what do we offer this price list? Because if we can see the value add beyond dollars, that makes a case to weigh that into the decision big time. And then offboarding. Offboarding, I've had great coaches in my life. And when we were done in that program, we didn't just quietly ride off into the sunset. No, we were launched. We were launched. A banquet and there's an intentionality to mark time and put us on a trajectory

SPEAKER_01and launch us forward, right? Well, those are all decisions and intentional strategies that we can build into what we call the 3D journey map. And so you can think in terms of recruiting, onboarding, retaining, offboarding in a matrix. Those are the words at the top. On the left, you got first, second, third dimension. Can we be 3D in all four phases? That's the kind of stuff we'll be doing at camp, or excuse me, at the 3D Culture Summit.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. So if somebody wants to sign up, how do they do that?

SPEAKER_01Right now, if you go to thejosephcompany.com, not 3dinstitute.com, but go to thejosephcompany.com. That's the host of this event. We'll start getting it on the 3D Institute website soon, but thejosephcompany.com is, the Joseph Company is our nonprofit partner that helps steward our 3D community movement. So when 3D comes into a community, the Joseph Company helps organize organizations into a chapter.

SPEAKER_01Well, the chapter in St. Joseph, which is the first chapter, is our host. And so the details are on that site. Click there on the banner. You'll see a link that says 3D Culture Summit. You'll be able to read all about it there. And there's a form at the bottom of that you can opt into and be the first to know when registration opens up in January.

SPEAKER_02Cool. Well, we'll leave it there. We'll have info in the show notes. And, yeah, we got some interesting stuff planned as we move forward because it won't be all just sport in these episodes. We'll talk about stories of 3D and education and business and different places that you can put it in place. So, yeah, we'll go a lot of different routes here over the next couple of months as we lead up to next summer. So, Wes, as always, a lot of fun. Thanks for joining me again.

SPEAKER_01I look forward to next time. All right. [music]

SPEAKER_00If this podcast is helpful to you, we go deeper in our weekly Substack newsletter. Subscribe at impactfulcoachingproject.substack.com. Every Monday, we share practical leadership frameworks, insights and research for coaches, athletic directors and leaders who want to build sustainable excellence. Link is in the episode description. It's free. [music]

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How Great Teams Build Collective Confidence | Dr. André Martin

    Nov 16, 202642 minAudio

    One of my favorite books of the year so far is Collective Confidence by Dr. André Martin. Dr. Martin is an organizational psychologist who also spent considerable time working as a sport psychologist earlier in his...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Resilience, Grit, and the Mindset of Great Coaches with Brian Davidson

    Nov 2, 202634 minAudio

    What makes a transformational coach? Is it grit, resilience, competitive drive, or something deeper? In this episode of Beyond Coaching, I sit down with Dr. Brian Davidson, CEO of MindVue, to explore the mindset skills...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Podcast Short: I Wasn't as Good as I Thought I Was

    Oct 12, 202611 minAudio

    I wasn’t as good as I thought I was. That’s a hard lesson for any athlete to learn. I learned it playing college baseball. After being a successful high school athlete and an All-American powerlifter, I went to college...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. What Great Coaches Actually Do | The 3D Journey, Ep. 3

    Sep 28, 202639 minAudio

    What exactly is a coach? Most coaches would say a leader, motivator, teacher, or strategist. But Wes Simmons believes the original definition of the word gives us a much better picture of what great coaching is supposed...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Mission, Evaluation, and Developing Coaches with Darin Keizer

    Sep 21, 202634 minAudio

    New episode: Mission, Evaluation, and Developing Coaches with Darin Keizer How do we evaluate coaches in a way that actually helps them grow? Darin Keizer and I talk about mission alignment, building trust, developing...

    Credit the people on this episode