Dixon Phillips is a former collegiate athlete, Pasco County firefighter and former union president of IAFF Local 4420. In this third conversation, he unpacks the history, mistruths and realities of Florida's Amendment 3, the negative impact it will have on Florida's first responders and the safety of their citizens. We also discuss proactive solutions to government overspending from community medicine to the 24/72 firefighter shift. "As President of IAFF Local 4420, Pasco County Professional Firefighters, I proudly represented over 800 members who serve our community with dedication and professionalism. In this role, I led collective bargaining efforts, negotiate contracts, handle member grievances and disciplinary matters, and advocated for legislative change and appropriations that directly impact the fire service. With nearly a decade of experience as a firefighter paramedic, I understood the challenges our members face on the job and fought every day to ensure they have the support, protections, and resources they need. Whether it's pushing for better benefits, addressing workplace issues, or securing funding at the local and state level, I was committed to advancing the rights and well-being of our membership."
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Welcome to the Behind the Shield podcast. As always, my name is James Geering and this week I wanted to address a contentious issue here in the state of Florida that I know a lot of states around the country are looking at and that is Amendment 3. Now this amendment has been proposed to cut property taxes, but the downstream effect is going to be incredibly detrimental to so many first responder agencies and therefore the safety of the citizens that they serve. So
I am not the person to be speaking on this. I invited Dixon Phillips back for a third conversation. Now, Dixon is a firefighter. He's a new father. He's a former union president of Pasco County, and he's also become a trusted voice when it comes to the 2472, having been part of the team that created that in his own department. So Dixon does an incredible job of really unpacking this topic for the rest of us, from the history of
the amendment, some of the behind the scenes on how quickly this was put through and the reasons for it. Debunking some of the rhetoric around where alternative money is and the city and county's inability to actually access that funds. Of course, we talk about the downstream effects on our ability to deliver when it comes to public safety, on the impact of the first responders and their families. And then we propose several other solutions that would make many of these budgets far more
fiscally efficient without Amendment 3. So I hope this serves as an educational tool so that when you and other people that listen to this go to the poll booth, they at least understand why they are either for it or against it. And as you will hear, many, many of the first responders in the state of Florida, myself included, are vehemently opposed to it. So with that being said, I welcome back onto the show, Dixon Phillips.
Enjoy. Well, Dixon, I want to start by saying thank you for coming back for the third time onto the Behind the Shield podcast today. Thank you for having me back. It's always great. Always
great to talk to you. See you. It's awesome. You have bags under your eyes for a good reason at the moment. So let's start with that as an icebreaker. Recently, you had a child. So talk to me about the pre and post of fatherhood that you've just been experiencing. Yeah, you know, my son is actually three months today. You know, it was before he was here. I mean, I was union president of a large local. The reason why I stepped down was to be at home and to be a dad,
right, and enjoy family for the first time in a long time. So before he was born, it was kind of a sprint. There was a lot of things going on. One of the things that we are here to really discuss today was happening. We had a long legislative session. We were in the middle of negotiations for a new contract, et cetera. So I didn't really get to enjoy much of the before. Right. But since since he's been born, it's been the most unbelievable thing I've ever experienced. It's. It's the greatest
thing that's ever happened to me. You know, we just recently took him to the Florida Aquarium for the first time last week and just kind of seeing, you know, his eyes light up, his face light up, you know, in some of those areas. It's just the coolest thing ever. So little sleep deprived. My wife is a lot more sleep deprived than I am, especially I was recently promoted. We had our promotional exam in September. studying for that you know she was really the caregiver
for him for you know probably four weeks so uh she was awesome throughout that whole process and you know now now it's my turn now i'm up so it's uh it's been good the nights are the nights are getting better it seems every week but uh yeah it's been the greatest thing i've ever experienced we're gonna revisit the 2472 later in this conversation, because we've, we've been a year since we last discussed it, but while we're on this topic, what is your perceptions
of the, the load as far as shift work and a child, and then reflecting back to when you worked at the 2448, you know, what would have been the difference? Oh, it would have been tremendous. I mean, you know, now going to work, you feel refreshed or you feel better. Right. When you get off, just a lot more energy, willingness to go out and do things. You know, I really haven't. I can't tell you the last time I came home off
shift and, you know, took a nap. Right. And I'm not at a station that sleeps every night either. So looking back on before we went to 2472, it would have been extremely difficult, especially at that time. You know, I was going back to our first episode that we were together. The overtime was outrageous, right? We had 162 firefighters leave in a period of two years. So if you were a firefighter paramedic, which I was at the time, I mean, the overtime was nonstop. So, you know,
yes, you work 24, 48, but at least two, maybe even three times a month, it was really 48, 24s. And I couldn't imagine having a child during that time. you know, definitely not experiencing the things that I've been able to experience, enjoy, you know, watching him grow from newborn to three months and just, you know, seeing that progression. And now, now that we're finally, you know, taking them out in public and seeing
all those things, I don't think the experience would be nearly the same as it is today. We'll just put a pin in that and obviously we'll revisit that later. But I think it's an important perspective. You did 24 -48 for a long time. You just made the transition this last year. Now you have a child. I think it's really powerful to hear that. And then as you said, you add in the mandatory overtime and these parents that are kept from their family. And then obviously the spouse has to take that load for an extra 24. And then there's the kind of guilt and shame and the friction
that's created. So I think it's just a really powerful testimony. But we'll circle around. Let's get to Amendment 3. So November 3rd, there's this very, very contested bill that's being proposed. I haven't met a first responder in person that hasn't said anything other than this is going to be horrendous for us. My corrections friends have said the same thing. So what I wanted to do was invite arguably one of the most respected voices. in general, who also is very well educated
on the political side, which is you, to really educate myself and everyone listening on, you've already told me you're going to do this way, you know, the history of this bill initially, you know, some of the reasons why people might support it, and then, you know, some of the downstream effects, and then, you know, later on, we'll obviously get to some other. money -saving initiatives that aren't being talked about at the moment. So I'm going to give you the mic if you just want to start from the beginning. Yeah, well, I appreciate you reaching out and having me on.
I appreciate your kind words. Amendment 3 is obviously, it's probably one of the most controversial topics that I've seen in my career that has come up. I first want to start off by saying I support property tax relief just as much as I would imagine The vast majority, if not 100 percent of homeowners in the state of Florida. You just heard I'm a new father. Right. Starting my family feeling the pressures of the pump just went filled up
today. Right. Four dollars and 20 cents a gallon going to the grocery stores and seeing the cost of goods. Everybody's dollar is smaller today than it ever was before. In the same breath, talking about the governor, the governor, Governor DeSantis has been a. Huge supporter of first responders in the state of Florida, right? We can go back to looking at the cancer presumption bill back in 2018, 2019, the firefighter health and safety bill, which we're going to touch on as well. That includes a reduction of recommendation
to reduce the work week to 42 hours, strengthening the firefighter bill of rights. Just recently in this session, establishing a one and a half percent COLA with a five -year attachment point for firefighters or first responders hired after 2011. I mean, he has been a supporter. first responders, and we have always supported him. But there are a lot of issues here with Amendment 3 and what the impacts are potentially in some areas and what they are going to be in others, in other departments that there's no way around
it, right? When we talk about the history, right, it's important to know kind of what the process is in the state of Florida. So I think the first important piece is to kind of look at the history of when we've had property tax reform in the state of Florida and kind of the mechanism that is in place that is codified in the Florida Constitution of how we get there. Right. So the first step, in my opinion, would be to talk about the Florida Taxation and Budget Reform Commission. Right. So they meet every 20 years. They are codified
in the Florida Constitution, Article 11, Section 6. The last time they met was in 2007, which is going to be an important date when we go back to look at Amendment 1. That was put on the ballot in 2008. They are scheduled to meet at the beginning of 2027. And when you look at how what the formation of that commission is, they have 29 members. Twenty five members are voting members. Four of them are non -voting members. Of the 25 voting members, 11 of them are appointed by the governor
of Florida. Seven are appointed by the Senate president and seven are appointed by the speaker of the House. for your non -voting members two are appointed by the senate president and two are appointed by the speaker of the house so when you think about you know we everybody knows property tax reform is on the forefront of every legislator's mind it was being discussed and we were in tallahassee in 2025 right getting our opinions uh certain protections that that would be needed in in the language uh for this
to to work so that public safety didn't see reductions um It makes you question, right, why are we here in November when the Tax Commission is set to meet at the beginning of 2027 that has 11 members appointed by the governor? So to kind of, I printed off the language in the Florida Constitution that speaks to the Tax Commission. So I just want to read it. This is from Article 11, Section 6 of the Florida Constitution. The Commission
shall examine the state budgetary process, the revenue needs and expenditure processes of the state, the appropriateness of the tax structure of the state, and government productivity and efficiency. Review policy as it relates to the ability of state and local government to tax and adequately fund governmental operations and capital facilities required to meet the state's needs during the next 20 -year period. Determine methods favored by the citizens of the state to fund the needs of the state. including alternative methods for raising sufficient revenues for the needs of the state, determine measures that could
be instituted to effectively gather funds from existing tax sources, examine constitutional limitations on taxation and expenditures at the state and local level, and review the state's comprehensive planning, budgeting, and needs assessment processes to determine whether the resulting information adequately supports a strategic decision -making process. The commission shall hold public hearings as it deems necessary to carry out its responsibilities under this section. The commission shall issue a report of the results to the review carried out and propose to the legislature any recommended statutory changes
related to the taxation or budgetary laws of the state. Not later than 180 days prior to the general election in the second year, which would be 2028, following the year in which the commission is established, the commission shall file with the custodian of state records its proposal, if any, of a revision of this constitution or any part of it dealing with taxation or the state budgetary process. So all of that to say is that this is the body that is codified in the Florida Constitution to review. The revenues, the needs
of the state, the wants of the citizens and come up with a plan, a comprehensive plan to address the wants of the citizens while also addressing the needs of local government and state government. So I think that's what makes this really confusing when you look at the timing. Right. The question I ask myself, I've been asking for several months now, is why would you not allow the commission specifically established to evaluate Florida's. tax and budget systems to examine the proposed changes first. The same commission that has 11
voting members that are appointed by the governor himself, seven appointed by the Senate president. Now, the Senate president just recently, two days ago, came out and said he's going to vote no on Amendment 3. But back in June, he was extremely supportive. So was the Florida Speaker of the House, Danny Perez, right? They passed it in both chambers, majority vote, and put it on the ballot. My personal this is my personal opinion. It simply comes down to voter turnout. Right.
We can't wait for 2027, because if you look at what every what is going on nationally, internationally, right, whether it's Russia, Ukraine, Gaza and Israel, the Iran war, you know, fuel prices, etc. All these things have created an environment where there is a large concern. from the Republican Party that Democrat voters are going to show up in force in midterm elections. When you look at both internal and external polling, NPAs or
independents are voting anywhere between 60 and 70 percent Democrat. When you look at the breakdown in the state of Florida of registered voters between Republican, Democrat and NPA, if the NPAs receive 70 percent, give 70 percent of the vote to the Democrat Party, it's going to be a very rough November. for Republicans in the state of Florida. So how do you ensure that Republican voters in the state of Florida make it to the polls? You put out property tax reform. And I think when we look at the numbers, it shows that.
So let me pull it up real quick. So your Florida Republican midterm turnout in 2018 was 71 % versus the 2016 presidential turnout, which was at 81%, right? Your 2020 presidential turnout was 83 .8. And your 2022 midterm is 63 .4. So the data shows that registered Florida Republican voters do not show up for midterm elections, right? They show up for presidential elections. So to
me, that's the reason why this is put on the ballot today versus waiting until the tax commission gives their findings and gives their recommendations to the legislature in 2027, moving into 2028. What's also interesting is. The way that this Ohio Amendment 3 came about, right, during session, the House of Representatives put together seven different property tax reform bills. Every one of them was entirely different, you know, just
ideas kind of thrown on a page for discussion, go through committees. You know, unfortunately, there was a line item in. fiscal year 25, if we go back to June 30th of 2025, there was a line item in that budget to fund a study to fund a study to look into property tax relief. That would have been done through the Florida Office of Economic and Demographic Research. That is
typically what you see when you are going to provide a piece of legislation that is going to have some type of economic impact. Usually the year before the legislature, the governor approve. money to be spent to get the study to see what that fiscal impact is going to be, right? That is not at all the process of what took place with Amendment 3. Amendment 3 came out, I want to say, May 29th. It was a Friday afternoon. The following Tuesday morning, it was approved
in both chambers and put on the ballot. The legislature did not even know what the economic impact was going to be until two or three weeks after it was approved in both chambers. And that number came out to twelve point one billion dollars of reduction in revenue. So it was just very rushed. I mean, I'm just going to ask you and any of the listeners, I mean, if. You see a lot of comparison to government budgets and your budget at home. If you're going to refinance your house, if you're going to buy a car, if you're going to pull a HELOC, if you're going
to make a large capital expense, you're going to buy a pool, etc. Are you making that decision in 96 hours? I'm just getting shit -faced and doing it in the next hour. That's the way you do it, right? And end up in a mountain of debt and no way to pay for it. No, when things... in your personal life are going to create a a major economic impact we're talking a major purchase uh that a major purchase reduces you know the amount of liquid money that you have at home
right um when you look when you look to do those things in your own life you take time to evaluate whether or not it's feasible whether or not it makes sense can we afford it can we not afford it how do we get there Right. If it's a want versus a need, how do we get there? If it's a need? Well, I got to figure out how I'm going to get it done. But it's far greater than 96 hours to do something at that level. So I guess
the next part. for me, would be to look back at Amendment 1. We referenced it briefly, talking about the Florida Tax Commission. The last time they met was in 2007. Amendment 1 was put on the ballot and passed in 2008 with 64 % approval. So a lot of things that you'll see online is that Amendment 1 had no impact in public safety, first responders, law enforcement, et cetera. It's very hard to pinpoint whether or not Amendment 1 actually was the reason for firefighter and law enforcement layoffs because we also had the
Great Recession in 2008, right, which economic collapse, a reduction in property values. You know, it was a perfect storm for the nightmare scenario. But the reality is that there were. Firefighter layoffs. There was a massive impact to public safety that was felt all the way to 2013. You were still seeing layoffs and fire stations closed and law enforcement reductions. And you still see some agencies have not fully
recovered from the 2008 Amendment 1 or the recession, right? Whichever was a contributor, they all contributed to the result. But the point of it. is when you look back in history, right, that's how we know what's going to happen in the future. Florida has already experienced what happens to public safety, specifically staffing, when local government revenue reduces sharply. That is what we were talking about here, right? So
just a few examples that I have. 35 firefighters were laid off in Lehigh Acres. Stations were closed. ALS, Advanced Life Support Ambulances, were reduced. Hialeah had 17 firefighters laid off. Pasco County, my own agency, reduced multiple engines from three -man personnel to two -man. We look at Jacksonville Sheriff eliminated 129 positions, including 49 sworn officers. Immokalee, a third of their firefighters laid off. Statewide
staffing reduction, statewide hiring freezes. The Fortis Air Force Association, they reported 56 percent. of the agencies reduced both sworn law and civilian positions 37 were forced to reduce both training hours and the types of training that they were providing and 25 of them were prohibited from purchasing required operational equipment they were prohibited from purchasing the replacements so sheriff car goes down whatever breaks down a repair totaled they had no way
to replace that they weren't allowed to replace that uh that vehicle so to ignore What occurred in that time as a result of both Amendment 1 and the recession, to just say that that didn't exist, it's dangerous. It creates this belief that everything is going to be fine. I think that's where we are today. If you look at the language of Amendment 3, it has a list of mandates,
I guess you would say, of what is required to be funded, and public safety is listed as number one. The reality is... They're required to fund public safety today, right? In Florida statute, it requires a county to have a sheriff, right? It authorizes counties to fund fire rescue, to provide fire protection. That language is fluff, right? It's a feel -good language. It doesn't do or change anything. It doesn't state that each county and city must maintain the current
budget that they have today. And with increases based on the CPI. Right. It doesn't have any protective language. I mean, it just says you have to fund it. But at what level? Right. When we look at our reduction in revenue and you're paying for the mandated sources and we're going to dive right into Pasco County's budget here in a little bit and we'll go through all the numbers and you'll see that in year one, Pasco County funding the mandated services, they're going to be two point eight million dollars short. That's in year one. In year two, you're looking at an extra. $60 million once the exemption moves
to $250 ,000. How do you make that up? If we are required to spend on these items and year one, we're $3 million short, there is going to be a reduction somewhere, right? Whether it's going to be a reduction or it's going to be a response in the form of raising mill rates or non -advalorum taxes or different fees, assessments, etc. There is going... You're going to have to recuperate at a minimum in Pasco County, $3 million
just to maintain status quo, funding the mandated items. So one thing that's kind of gotten lost in the shuffle that, you know, a lot of people, when we talk about fire departments, agencies, you know, I have a list here. It is independent special districts throughout the state of Florida, specifically for fire. Now you also have them for police. I'm a firefighter, so I don't have the numbers for police or corrections there in
a special independent or dependent district, but they do exist. And we have quite a bit in the state of Florida, especially when you look down towards South Florida. But we have 38 independent special districts in the state of Florida that are fire, fire department, fire department districts. The belief, if you watch TV, if you look at social media, et cetera, is. There's all this fluff in government budgets. Before I get any further, I do want to say I'm not here to dispute that number. I think that it's very well documented
the increase in local budgets over the last six or seven years, the percent increase, the dollar increase. There's a lot of conversations that you can have for the reasoning why. We had higher home values, new construction homes than ever before, tax assessed values with what the real estate market was. 2022 to 2024. Obviously, we had exponential growth when we look at the population of the state of Florida. There's a lot of reasons, but either way, not here to dispute the numbers right there. The budgets have grown. But when
you look at the fluff specifically for the independent special districts, they don't, and I shouldn't say this as a blanket statement, right? Because every one of them are going to be different based on what they have written in charters and et cetera. But they don't have the ability to just move money from the county budget over to the independent fire district right so what i have here is i have the state attorney general opinion it just so happens to come out of pasco county um you know specifically for date city fire rescue
which you know existed in the early uh you know eventually was taken over by pasco in the early 2000s so the question posed to the state attorney general was may monies from the county's general fund be used to help operate a fire tax district established by the Board of County Commissioners of Pasco County to provide fire protection in the unincorporated area of Pasco County. So the question is essentially, can we use Pasco County general fund money to provide funds to the Dade City Fire Rescue Special District? The answer,
pursuant to this legislative authorization, the use of monies in the county's general fund derived in part from a county tax on property situate within municipalities. could not be used to operate a fire tax district created within the unincorporated area of pasco county so that that poses a hell of a question right now for the 38 independent special fire districts throughout the state of florida what are you going to do are we looking at loans they can take a loan they can take a
loan from that county general fund right there is a repayment period that they have to meet in order to do it are we looking at grants so we're looking at appropriations You know, appropriations are not guaranteed. And what we've seen in the state of Florida, you know, that's really my bread and butter in Pasco County is dealing with our appropriation request in Tallahassee. What we have seen in the last several years is the budget for appropriations has cut nearly in half. Right. There was this discussion before there, you know, a trust fund was originally included in the language for Amendment 3. The trust fund
was deleted because there is a large question. Where do you get the money, right? When we're looking towards the future, you know, two, three, four years from now, there is a projection that the state's budget is going to be at a deficit. So how can you fund a trust fund without knowing where the money is going to come from, right? The trust fund was deleted. That trust fund was there specifically for this scenario, for these special districts, for your rural counties, rural cities that are going to be devastated by Amendment
3. It's not an answer. And I'll use Palm Harbor as an example, right? So Palm Harbor, they are an independent fire district. Their mill rate cap is two mills. They are currently at their mill rate cap. They've been at it, I believe, since 2018. So there is no movement for them in terms of we can just increase the mill rates and those that are still paying property taxes will recuperate some, hopefully most of the money
that's going to lose. That's not an option. 85 % of their budget funds personnel. They're looking at a hit of 25, 27%. Well, I'm not a mathematician, but 20 to 25 % takes you down to 80 or 75 % of what they're operating in today, right? And their personnel is budgeted at 85. So they're looking at a reduction. They're looking at staffing cuts. They're looking at station closure. They're looking at some options. to reduce the money that is
being spent because they don't right now have an option to recuperate those funds. Are firefighters going to be laid off in Pasco County? More than likely not. Hillsborough, Tampa, probably not, right? But when we look Central Florida to the panhandle and we look at some of those rural departments, you know, police, sheriffs, they are going to be hurt. drastically uh by amendment three you know south florida i mean miami -dade
for an example i want to say they're going to lose 243 million dollars that is a astronomical hit how how do we get there how do you get that money back you know we can talk about the fluff talking about the fluff the xf spending the the large increase in budgets but local governments cannot run local government like we can run our household, right? We can take money and just
spend it on whatever we want. If we need, we need to fund, you know, your car breaks down. Okay, well, I can take some money from what I'm spending over here, provide it over here, right? We're very fluid with our money. Local government is not. They're governed by multiple different statutes. We look at a budget, right? You see the pie chart, but really it's more like silos. Each silo is governed by Florida statute, by different charters, bond agreements, et cetera. It is very difficult and some impossible to move
money from one silo to another. You can obviously have fund transfers and all that, but it depends on where the money is coming from out of which fund. You got anything or are we just going to jump right into Pasco County as an example? Let's jump in. You're on the flow. All right. So I'm going to use Pasco County. That's obviously where I work. That's what I know. So when you look
at the total budget, somewhere in the ballpark of around $2 .3 billion, right? But that's not your operating budget. You have your general fund budget in Pasco is $567 million. That is our operating budget. Amendment 3 would result in a reduction of $96 .1 million in year one, which takes us down to $473 million. That shortfall that I talked about earlier is $2 .8 million.
That is only funding the items that are listed in Amendment 3 as what is mandated taxpayer ad valorem taxes can be used for, right? We're looking at a $2 .8 million deficit in year one. In year two, that reduction increases from 96 .1 to 156 .1 million dollars. So, you know, do the math. You're looking at 60 million dollars without something happening, without a mill rate increase,
without establishing assessments and fees. You start to ask yourself, where does that money come from? And if the money can't come from anywhere, then obviously we're talking staffing cuts. Right. And this isn't just, you know, you have money in the reserves. That's also, you know. There, right? Local government should have 16 .7%. That's the national standard in their reserves. Usually in Florida, local governments carry higher, right? 25 to 30 % because we have these things called
hurricanes. When a hurricane comes and devastates the community, there is a shit ton of money that is required to help your community get back to some sort of normal, right? I mean, we're paying for... Just public safety, equipment, overtime, you know, for personnel, both law and fire, depending on the devastation. Are you having, you know, USAR teams come to your area? Are you requesting out of state resources? Are we getting FEMA teams? All of that is paid for by the local by the local
government, hoping that the following year they're going to be reimbursed dollar for dollar from the federal government. And in a majority of time, they just put all that money they received. back in to fill what they spent into the reserves, right? To bring that number back up so they can be prepared for the next hurricane season. So you can draw from the reserves. That's fine. That'll last how long? Two years. You know, I can say this with confidence because we were in negotiations. We ran. In audit, we had an
economist look at the county's budget and their money, and we found $156 million in unrestricted funds, right? So money that can be spent. Well, year two, the reduction is $156 .1 million. So I can tell you where that money is going to be spent. So say all of that to say, if you do not, if you cannot make up the deficit with money that is already there, then two things are going to have to happen. Other taxes, non ad valorem.
Taxes, so the homestead exemption doesn't apply, are established. Mill rates are increased or we have reductions, right? And then you got to pick your poison. What are you going to reduce? Because everything that we are funding is what is listed as mandated in Amendment 3. Someone is going to get a cut. Historically, public safety takes that hit because public safety is 60 to 65 percent of every municipality's budget. So
that's where the money is. That's where we take it from. When we go into that $2 .3 billion, you know, this is from fiscal year 26, already stated that $567 million is in the general fund operating budget, right? So let's talk about our other silos. So you have your transportation impact fees, right? That's governed by Florida Statute 163 .31801. It is restricted use eligible for eligible infrastructure, capital equipment or vehicles associated with growth. So you can
build a fire station. You can buy the fire truck. You can't pay for the firefighters out of that money. Right. You have your tourist development fees. That's governed by Florida Statute 125 .0104. Restricted use authorized only for tourism related issues. You have your fuel taxes, Florida Statute 336 .025. only for transportation expenditures, waste and wastewater funds, Florida Statute 153 .11, uses for utility operations and debt obligations.
Then you have your bond -funded capital projects. So those are governed by your bond covenants and debt laws, but they must be used based on what the bond terms are. Then you have your federal and state grant or appropriations. If you look in that $2 .3 billion budget, there's 500 plus million from the federal government as a reimbursement. for the hurricanes uh helena and milton in 2024 and the money that was spent there in our community because pasco was devastated by both of those hurricanes that money can only be used for what
the awards authorized purpose is so you can't just take your grant and appropriation and use it on whatever you want right and then you have your general fund reserves which we've already talked about but those are governed under florida statute 129 uh both 01 and 06 the unrestricted funds can be used to be moved. There isn't a lot of, what's the word I'm looking for, maneuvering that can be done when we look at these things, right? I mean, if Tallahassee wanted local governments
to be able to just move money however which way they could and wanted in preparation for Amendment 3, then why didn't we see changes to those statutes in 25 and in 26? If that was the goal, if that was the plan, then why were we not preemptive in changing Florida statute so that you could just willingly move money? I guess I go back to my other point. The answer is we did this in 96 hours. The study was vetoed. Seven different
bills were put, told they were going to be vetoed. And this was done to nobody's knowledge. And I can personally tell you. The own cabinet members were unaware of what was coming. I had a meeting with the lieutenant governor two months prior, and what he told us was coming was not even close. So this is a conundrum, I guess, right? Where
do you get the money in your budgets when moving it is either not legal or not very easy? Do we now look at... Non -advalorum taxes, different assessments, different fees. So now you're looking at, OK, we're going to slap this MSBU on every plot of land in Pasco County that's going to fund fire rescue. Well, now people who are not paying anything for fire rescue based on their
homestead exemption are now paying more than they ever had before. Right. Are we going to increase the mill rates, increase the mill rates up high enough to where those that were paying what they were paying? are going to be paying just as much, if not more, than what they are today. It's, I don't know, I guess the point of it is that money just can't freely move, right? Especially between legally restricted funds. And when you see people come out against it,
right? We know that the Sheriff's Association is against them. And Grady Judd has been very vocal against Amendment 3. He is a very strong lifelong conservative, right? So to hear someone like him come out and speak against it, and you see all the posts on social media, right? Calling them, you know, every name under the sun and this and this. Or he's just telling you what the numbers say, right? I mean, every different municipality is going to be affected differently.
Your larger areas, they may be able to absorb this hit more than others. You know, your Polk counties, your Alachua counties, your Marion counties, right? You go to the panhandle and look at some of those areas. They're not going to be able to absorb it. But there are two quotes that I wanted to share. One of them was by Lieutenant Governor Jay Collins, and that was on August 4th. The lieutenant governor was appointed to that position by the governor. And his quote
was speaking to Governor DeSantis' frustration of the trust funding. I think he's frustrated with the fact that the trust fund's not there, that we didn't protect law enforcement in fire, and we put those people who we should stand beside at risk. This lieutenant governor saying that. Senate President Ben Albritton, right, who was the Senate president when Amendment 3 passed his chamber. And it's very well documented how he felt about it at that time. Well, now, four months later, you're able to see what the impact
is going to be in his local area. And on October, I'm sorry, yes, October 20th. He came out and said he was going to vote no on Amendment 3 and stated that Amendment 3 would eliminate up to 30 percent of resources for Florida's rural counties, gutting essential support for our law enforcement, emergency response services and critical infrastructure. Senator Albrin is once again been a lifelong, strong conservative. You can look at his voting record and see that. Right. This isn't these
aren't people who. These are very well -respected people, especially from the Republican Party, as conservatives, fiscal conservatives. And they are telling you that Amendment 3 is going to hurt law enforcement and public safety, to take what they are saying and to only— To just throw it away. Oh, they're just crooked. Right. They live off this money. It's just ridiculous. And once again, you look at the history and ignoring
what happened post -Amendment one. Right. Combination of two things. But once again, we saw what happens to the public safety community when local government revenue takes a sharp decline. And that is what is going to happen. Public safety holds the lion's share of the money. That is where you take. It's just reality. It's what history tells us. You know, obviously, I support voting no on Amendment 3 for all the concerns that we that I just spoke
about. You hear this thing and, you know, the governor responded to Senator Albright yesterday stating that if it wasn't for Amendment 3, there would be zero property tax reform coming out of Tallahassee. And that's just not true. Right. It's just not true. I mean, the Taxation Reform Commission is meeting starting early 2027. The last time they met, we saw Amendment 1. So to say that you would see zero is just not accurate.
It's just not true. I think I was up in Tallahassee six different times this session on top of the three special sessions that were called, was up there all last year in 2025. legislators were talking about property tax reform it is their number one ticket item right it's the one thing that they know that they want to address they want to increase the affordability in florida you hear you know uh congressman donald's who's running for governor he talks about it right
now right make florida more affordable it is the number one topic of discussion it is going to continue to be the number one topic of discussion i think that the appropriate thing especially when we're talking about changing the language of the state constitution the appropriate thing to do is have a study done have the commission that is codified in the constitution that their only duty is to examine all of the things that we are talking about and then come up with a comprehensive plan the only responsible thing
to do is to vote no on amendment 3 because i promise you that there will be some type of property tax reform on the ballot in 2028. It is going to happen. So we'll see what happens. We have less than two weeks from today. So, you know, but I hope that I, you know, that helped clear up a lot of the misinformation that is being
shared online because there is a ton of it. We'll see. Well, firstly, thank you because you've just articulated and explained a concept that most of us know is simply amendment three. That's it. And then these politicians angry about one side, these politicians angry about the other and the rest of us are left confused. And you've really kind of explained it in a way that, you know, for example, if a number is given to you and like, oh, this is how much money they've
got. And it's like, well, it's not because it's broken up into these areas and there are. rules and regulations and laws that don't allow you to access certain parts of the fund. So I've learned so much in the last 45 minutes. I'm sure everyone listening has as well. I want to now kind of lean into the side that I do understand, which is the impact on our profession and our ability to deliver service. We know that call volume across the country has increased exponentially. And one of the underlying factors, and someone
gave me this stat a few months ago, 25 % of the GDP of the US national budget goes on healthcare. And so as we are getting fatter and sicker and 75 % of Americans are overweight, of which I think it's 45 % are morbidly obese or obese, excuse me. You think about the increasing strain on the 911 system, because when things go wrong, People go to their phone, they push three buttons,
and then magically two, three, four minutes later, a group of trained professionals show up in this national healthcare system where you pay taxes and people take care of you. And that's it. No questions asked until you get to obviously the hospital. And now that's going to be fragmented. Now the station that was supposed to be responding to the drowning child or the choking or the school shooting. That's now browned out or closed down. And so now they're having to come from eight miles away instead of three miles away. And maybe
the crew that used to have four now has three or two. And so I don't think people understand the impact when they are having their worst fucking day ever that the ripple effect of these cuts could make. Because we already know nationally, I get phone calls, you get phone calls every day. about departments that are literally drowning. And Marion County is a good example of that. They were forced into making change before their department collapsed. 500 line personnel, they
lost 528 people in five years. And that's a descending line. So obviously there was a point of impact where there was going to be no department. The downstream costs of just replacing those bodies who then walked out the back door. over five years was i think it was 32 .5 million dollars that i was paying marion county taxpayers were paying so this is what pisses me off about this whole amendment three is that there are and we will get to one of the the solutions there are
solutions to addressing the problems but we first have got to identify all right well then where is the money being wasted We shouldn't ask a taxpayer for even more money, but if we can show them every single penny that you are spending on your taxes is going to this high level of service, and God forbid you have your worst day, a group of highly trained, well -rested first responders are going to come to your house from the station that is closest and in vehicles that
they have the right staffing, and they are going to give your loved one the highest chance of survival. But in this recruitment retention crisis that we have, you've talked about the millions that Pascoe was losing. I've just shown the millions that Marion was losing. And they have both, you know, you're already there and they're beginning their journey to proactively address that. And I just learned from one of my friends the other day that Marion County now is fully staffed. So overtime has all but gone away. They got some medics that they're waiting to clear, but basically
overtime has gone away in the three shifts and now they're moving to the four. We'll get to that in a minute. But my point is, there are so many proactive solutions that you can make huge savings in these cities, in these counties, even within fire rescue and law enforcement. But to defund, we know doesn't work. We had a beautiful example of that just a few years ago. So to cut money from first responder agencies is a lunacy that we've already seen the results
from. Because to your point, many, many departments haven't recovered from 08, Amendment 1, and like you said, the crisis simultaneously. And there's a lot of departments that they're still running on three instead of four on an engine or two instead of three, and they're still browned out rigs or stations. So to say, well, the solution is, well, let's just cut more of them. But through this budget cut, it makes no sense. The question we should be asking is, where is the money being
wasted in these cities and counties? What are the solutions that other departments are using that are addressing that? What can we do in other places? We make up 4 % America, 4 % of the world's population. We have 20 % of the world's prison population. We consume 75%. of the world's opioids. We are one of the only countries that has our children rehearsing their murders in school. There are many, many areas that we should be talking about that we could make a massive dent
in reducing the budget, addressing homelessness, addressing addiction, addressing obesity, and therefore taking the strain off these first responder agencies. So now they last longer. They don't get hurt as much. The vehicles don't get as worn down. And then you have that downstream cost as well. So I want people to just take what you've talked about and then add in, and I want to get your thoughts on this too. When you're having your worst fucking day ever and your kid is dying in front of you, how important was that budget
cut that you voted because that person wanted to get higher in their political career versus actually prioritizing what is most important to you in that moment? Yeah. Morbid question for me to say, you know, this part, you almost made me chuckle when you said that firefighters show up in two, three or four minutes, because I don't think that's anywhere in the state of Florida. All right. I mean, there's a couple a couple issues, right? I mean, I know we're
definitely gearing towards a 24 -72 conversation, reduction of overtime, increase of personnel. But real quick, that just made me think of something that I kind of meant to say earlier. That type of change can also effectively be done in Tallahassee. Right. So I would guess that 90 plus percent of fire departments in the state of Florida do not meet NFPA standards in terms of response time and personnel on trucks. That the probably
roughly the same number are not ISO one departments. Right. They do not have a fire station every five miles like the recommendation is to have. When we look at the cost. of just building a fire station right we're looking at numbers in pasco county on the low end 14 million right there our city of tampa is getting ready to build a new fire station and i believe that theirs is upwards of 20 million dollars of what the cost is when you look at those numbers and you
say it's unbelievable right there's no way that it costs 14 million dollars to build a damn fire station it's There just can't be right. Somebody is retiring off of this job. Unfortunately, we get back to Tallahassee again. Right. When we look at procurement laws. So when a local government is going to put out a bid for a new fire station, there are Florida statutes that govern that process. There are Florida statutes that established standards of contractors and, you know, other businesses
that are even able to put. a bid in for that contract. Now, those laws obviously were established to protect taxpayer dollars because the last thing that you want to do is provide, you know, a station bid to a company that is barely staying afloat, right? And now we get six months down the line and now they're bankrupt. But what those laws have done is you've effectively created a monopoly, right? Now we're looking at wasteful spending of taxpayer dollars simply because of the statutes that we have in the state of Florida
that govern. So that would be the first step to me. And it is something that I've already started discussing. I know for professional firefighters, that's definitely on their item list. I've had conversations with local commissioners as well as state representatives about these issues. But that alone, a change in procurement laws, we will see a reduction in spending by local governments. If you if everything comes cheaper, we're paying less for it. Right. And you could.
see a natural reduction in property taxes there. Getting into the wasteful spending of other agencies, right? And not talking about, not going to a 24 -72, having a 24 -48 schedule, hiring mandatory overtime, et cetera. In Pasco County, I think it's very well known, right? We transitioned to D -shift in April of this year, or in January of this year, I'm sorry. You know, that whole
discussion going to the D shift was really it was all about money. Right. So quick numbers, just if you didn't watch the first episode, you know, I'll bring them back up. So in fiscal years, 22 and 23, we lost 162 firefighters. They left to go work at other agencies that alone cost four point seven million dollars. And what the cost for those firefighters to get them in the door was them leaving resulted in five and a half to six million dollars a year in overtime. When we look at our dollars spent, fiscal year
22, $6 million. Fiscal year 23, $5 .5 million. And then the D -SHIFT was put into our contract. And we saw in fiscal year 24, we had a reduction down to $3 .1 million in overtime. The year before we went to D -SHIFT, and I don't have those numbers to give you hours or a dollar amount, but I can tell you that overtime was nearly impossible to come by. because we were fully staffed for nearly an entire year before D -Shift. I mean, there were days where we had extra staffing.
We had three -man rescues. We had four -man engines. You know, we were staffing tankers and brush trucks in preparation to go to D -Shift, and it was the greatest thing in the world, right? You were finally there. You finally had enough people to efficiently do what we do, right? No matter what, firemen are going to get it done. Fire's going to go out. We're going to do our job on medical calls. But more people, more trained professionals makes that more efficient. And it increases survivability. It increases property conservation, decreases property loss, right?
All those things that impact the constituents that we serve. We saw Governor DeSantis back again for the things that he's done for firefighters, first responders in the state of Florida. The Firefighter Health and Safety Bill last year, right? With the recommendation of the 4 -Hour Workweek. And our union president, John Michael, you know, he makes this joke all the time. I mean, if you're not the first to the watering hole, you're not going to drink. So when we were doing D shift, that was the point for us is we had the ability to get this done. We have a very
pro fire commission, pro fire county administration, HR director that was looking at all these things. Math was obviously included, but also looking into. Our health and safety numbers, you know, we are very proactive when it comes to decontamination, cancer reduction, PTSD, you know, all these things. So how do we make that work -life balance for firefighters? How do we entice people to come work in Pasco County? The reality is we're not
going to make what Miami -Dade makes. We're not going to make what city of Tampa makes, right? But people tend to work and stay. at those places where they have a great life, right? And it's worked. Now, since D -SHIFT is implemented, we're struggling with some overtime again. It's just one of those things. It's a brand new thing. We're the largest agency in the Southeast United States to make this transition. There wasn't a lot of people out there that you could call
and say, how did you guys do this, right? Especially on our scale. You know, we've identified some issues when we made that transition of what is now, you know, causing some overtime. It's not at the level of what it was, but, you know, we're actively working to try and address those issues. You know, we applied for a safer grant this year. We did not receive the safer grant. So depending on Amendment 3, you know, we can see what we need to do. you know, hopefully in next fiscal
year to address hiring more firefighters, you know, more positions. I'm confident that we will reapply for a safer grant next year. But the reduction in work hours incentivizes more firefighters to come work for your agency. When you have vacancies, they're required to hire overtime. It is an unbudgeted cost. It is expensive. Whereas you could take
those funds, implement the D -SHIFT, and you save money long term. And it's all a part of it. And that's where it's kind of confusing for us in Pasco County with the Amendment 3, the conversations that are being had. Because we have five conservatives on our Board of County Commission. always make moves with taxpayers you know in mind uh just recently just this year prior prior to the vote of november you know we had a minimal increase in the firearms to
you so that we could Do some things in this fiscal year. You know, we have a new station coming online that we partially funded through state appropriation. So increasing the MSTU minimally to be able to afford for those firefighters. Also putting a new aerial truck in service. We just had a three alarm apartment fire that we had to call for mutual aid because we didn't have the aerial devices that were necessary. So to be able to now staff truck three. And at the same time, there was an equal reduction to
the general fund. right to kind of show where pasco county commissioners are looking at the money right like understanding that public safety is a priority so we need to add a little money here but also recognizing that the taxpayers also they don't need an increase right it can just be a cost neutral but we're giving more money to their fire department so you know we've done a lot of things another thing as we talk about overdoses and you know the strain on ems that we see from just citizens that don't have health insurance. They don't have primary health
providers. So we have a mobile integrated health team. Our MIH team is funded right now solely off of grant funding. We received a good amount of opioid money from the state of Florida a couple years ago, and we established this team, partnered with some regional hospitals to get some of their team members to kind of go and ride with our MIH members. And what they do is they go out to those addresses those 911 callers that call every day right whether it is for overdoses or
it's the elderly patient that calls you to come check her blood blood pressure or check her blood sugar because her glucometer is broken and she can't afford to buy another one right those types of things all we do is we send an email to our mih team They schedule a visit. They go out there. If there's a problem with something like that, like a glucometer, which that was in my zone. That was a patient we ran on every single day. The MIH team got involved. She received her glucometer. We don't go out there to check her blood sugar anymore, right? So we are starting to see a reduction
in those type of calls, a reduction in the overall call volume. Granted, our call volume is increasing, but not at the pace at which it should be, right? some improvement in our call volume by our MIH team. That is something that we're hoping will be implemented all throughout the state of Florida, right? I mean, not only does it reduce the call volume, the wear and tear in the vehicles, you know, we look, I mean, fuel costs, right? I mean, diesel is $6 a gallon right now. So you add that in. On top of it is best for the citizens of
Pasco County, right? We are helping that individual that is is an addict is addicted right we're helping them get them the treatment that they need our mi our mih team will follow them throughout the entire process you know constant communication constant follow -up visits making sure that they're staying on the right track and every month they put out their success stories and they have a stack of them so that is something that we've implemented in pasco county that has been wildly successful it is something that uh We've been
having a lot of conversations with some of our electeds up in Tallahassee, you know, representatives and state senators to try and get a bill implemented that allows mobile integrated health to acquire funding through different avenues. So it's something that we're working on. I mean, there's a lot of ways to save taxpayer dollars. It takes a commitment by the local community to do what is best. If we're talking about saving money
in the fire rescue space, to do not only what is best for their members, but to also do what is best for their constituents. And it also takes the members up in Tallahassee to look at some of the things that they don't necessarily look at and say, hey, how can we make changes to procurement? How can we make changes here? What can we do here to just reduce the money that we're spending on projects? We'll be able to build fire stations faster. So we'll be able to get to our communities, you know, talking about response times. That's one of the biggest things. You need fire stations
in these areas, especially over the last six years, as we've seen the influx of people into the state of Florida. Right. Our call volumes have only extended. They haven't shortened. Right. You can't build a fire station because it's 14 to 20 million dollars. How do we get there? And we have an area in our county, very affluent, a lot of young. Well, well off families. It takes 15 to 18 minutes to respond to their community.
And it is one of the largest communities in Pasco County. Right. We've had pediatric cardiac arrest in that community that it takes you 15 minutes to get to. I mean, James, you're a first responder. What do you believe that outcome was? Right. So we have to. We need changes at both Tallahassee and at the local level when it comes to public safety. Reduce the work week. Healthier, more
well, I guess is a way to put it. Firefighters, more fire stations, more crews on the roads. Decrease those call volume, the response times. Get to people faster. And now you have a firefighter that is rested. That is sound mind, sound judgment, and the outcomes are only going to improve. But it is a multifaceted issue that needs to be addressed,
but we need people that are willing to address it. And I understand what Amendment 3 is trying to address, but in my opinion, it's just not the answer. And I like to say that it's not just my opinion. It is every respected leader. in the public safety community throughout the state of Florida. We have legislators telling you the same thing, Senate President Ben Allbritton, Lieutenant Governor Jay Collins. What this is going to do to the public safety community is
not going to benefit anybody in the state of Florida, right? We're going to see longer response times than we already do. And it's going to make this state inherently unsafe. Don't want to wake up in a world five years from now. You know, I think the biggest fear for me personally. So I live in the city of Tampa and city of Tampa fire station, station 12. It's just up the street. It's on Hillsborough Avenue, you know, maybe a mile from my house with a three month old son.
I want to know that if something happens when I'm at work, when my wife calls 911, that an ambulance shows up. And I say that because I've lived in this area my entire life. That station never had an ambulance until a couple of years ago, right? Now that I'm a new father, I don't want that ambulance to disappear. I mean, that's the lifeline for my house. So, yeah. I mean,
that's a powerful perspective because it kind of circles around to the beginning of this conversation, which is what matters most to you. And in that moment, your infant is choking and let's say your wife is there and she's not able to... To open the airway and you need that crew to respond, are you thinking about tax cuts? Are you thinking about who you're voting for in November? No, you're thinking about your loved one. And this is the thing. There is not a firefighter in America that is, you know, going to the bathroom on a
gold toilet and wearing, you know, diamond -encrusted suits to work. I mean, we're talking about normal people that are just trying to obviously, you know. pay their bills at home that are leaving their loved ones to sit in a fire station for 24 hours, just in case you are having your worst day. And all they're asking is, can we please have the right amount of people and the right amount of vehicles in our station so that when we get that call, we are ready. And the false economy, and that's been such a resounding theme
throughout pretty much the life of this podcast, the false economy of arresting addicts. rather than addressing the mental health crisis. You know what I mean? The false economy of relying on overtime to fill vacancies in a fire department rather than realizing that it's to match the crazy increase in call load that we just need more firefighters and we need more shifts because you need the rest and recovery. And if you look at the origin story of our union, the IAFF, Walt Dix was educating me. That's it. It's the work
week. You had firefighters that basically were at the station all week and were like, we need to go home to our families. And then it became a 24 -24. And then the workload increased 24 -48. And now it's exploded. And again, think about that. Three quarters of the nation are overweight. So how many of those people need to call 911? Whether it's an actual medical necessity or whether the insurance has priced them out. And that's the only way that they're going to get help. And everyone else just goes about their
day not realizing that when you push three numbers on that phone, it is fire and EMS that respond to those calls. And then again, we know that defunding the police doesn't work. We know that penalizing schools for not doing well on a standardized test doesn't work. The false economy of these Victorian -esque philosophies that if you just punish, it will make things better. has repeatedly been shown to be absolute bullshit but if you actually invest on the front end there's a desmond
tutu quote we keep pulling bodies out of the river instead of going upstream to find out why they're falling in in the first place that's it that's it and this is what this amendment three is doing is just pulling more bodies out the river that is even more bodies and one of them is someone that you love dearly instead of going well what is causing All the areas where we are wasting taxpayers' money. Can we ultimately be more fiscally efficient and therefore reduce property taxes? But that means a healthier society.
And if a fifth of your national budget is spent on health care, and yet we are one of the least healthy countries on the planet, which is a national security issue, by the way, as well. And we're not talking about that. And 100 ,000 Americans die from opioids every year. which was created by an FDA -approved painkiller, and the person who approved it now works for Purdue Pharma, or certainly did after that, the problem isn't the firefighter. The problem isn't the family
who's waiting for that firefighter to show up. It's upstream. And so to your point, the solutions are... to wait for an analysis of what to really do, to look at Pasco County and Palm Beach and Gainesville and go, everyone wants to work for you. You're fully staffed. Your overtime has all but gone away. Your people seem healthier and happier. How do we do that? Can you show us how to do that? England, tell us about NHS. Finland, tell us about your education system.
Norway, how are you doing? Prisons. Portugal, how did you decriminalize drugs? These places have found the solutions. And that is how you will save literally trillions of dollars ultimately. We know exactly why the prices are what they are at the petrol station. And we know that the gas companies have record profits this year. And yet you want to cut firefighters. I mean, it just makes no sense. I hope that people through this conversation, and I want to revisit the
24 -72 before I let you go, but I hope between your education and just looking in the mirror and saying what is most important to me, that people remove the blinders that this is some incredible initiative that's going to save the state money and realize it's a complete false economy that A, is going to cost more money downstream, but more importantly, could cost the life of someone that you adore. All fantastic points and all true. You know, there are a lot of things
that we can do to fix the overspending. I mean, when you look at fire service specifically, right, reducing the work week, it's proven to work. It's proven to save taxpayer dollars. When we look at the procurement process in Tallahassee, right, because that doesn't just affect fire rescue. It affects the sheriffs. It affects road and bridge. It affects utilities. Right. It shouldn't cost. $1 .3 million to fix a quarter mile stretch of road. It shouldn't cost that much money. But the only way that we're going to fix it is the
legislators in Tallahassee have to address those issues. Local governments, local fire chiefs have to address the staffing issues in their agencies. And the way that you do that, you have to incentivize people to come work for you. You have to reduce the work week. It's proven to work. It's proven. I think one of the best things that we've seen this year is how many organizations especially up in central florida are going to the 24 72 schedule they finally see that it works
the math behind it works it just works and with amendment 3 i don't know how we get there i don't know how with amendment 3 fire departments across the state are going to be able to reach the recommendation And the firefighter health and safety bill that was signed into law by the governor. I don't know how they reduce the work week to 42 hours. I don't know how they make some of these some of the departments going back to the independent
fire districts. I don't know how they maintain their staffing. I don't know how they maintain their stations. And they don't either. Right. And that's the concern. When we are looking at something such as Amendment 3, it is the duty. Of state government to provide you with the answers. We're doing this and this is how these are going to be continued to continue to be funded. Right. But to just Blake and blanket statement, the
money's there. Sure. The money's there. This law, this law, this law doesn't allow them to use it. So now what? Ah, you're a rhino. Greedy union guy. greedy politician, whatever other thing they want to call you. I am very confident going back again, if Amendment 3 fails, I'm very confident with the members of the Florida legislature,
whoever the incoming governor is going to be. With the tax commission meeting in early 2027, I am confident that we are going to see something on the ballot in 2028 that is going to address Property tax reform. And hopefully in the two sessions prior to the 2028 election, we also see changes in the procurement laws. You know, we see changes in maybe some of these statutes that were listed that allow free flowing of money
from silo to silo. Right. I mean, those statutes are there to prevent fraud, to prevent money from just disappearing. Right. That's why they exist. But maybe there's changes. It's, to me, the way that Amendment 3 just happened. I mean, we've never seen a bill be introduced, just a bill, a law, be introduced and four days later signed into law. It doesn't happen. And here
we are doing it with a constitutional amendment. And we didn't know what the financial impact was going to be until three weeks later, in the year before the study to show the financial impact was vetoed. We've never seen this before. It's irresponsible. It's irresponsible. And the last thing that we want to do is pass an amendment that has so many questions versus answers and wake up two, three years from now and say, well, shit, now we have to go amend the Florida constitution
again. It doesn't happen. So I hope some people listen to this podcast. Those that are It's undecided. Really listen. You do your own research. It's the same thing that I've told our membership back home. I put a post on our internal Facebook page just a couple of days ago. I'm not here to convince you how to vote. I'm not. You vote how you want. You vote how you believe. All I'm
asking is that you do your own research. You turn off the TV. You get off of social media. The internet is a marvelous place. I mean, shit, now we have AI. You don't even have to search for it on your own. It'll give it to you. Right. Verify the things that I've said, you know, and read it for yourself. Then make an educated decision on what you're going to do at the ballot box, you know, over the next couple of weeks. But this is the biggest threat to the fire service
since we since 2008. It's the biggest threat to public safety probably that we've ever seen. You know, it has potential to be devastating for police and fire throughout the state of Florida. You know, there are some sheriffs, there are some fire chiefs that are out there that are, you know, having press conferences and saying that it's all going to be fine. They're all going to do this. And like I said, this is not a one size fits all amendment. Right. There are going to be other places that are going to be fine.
That may be, you know, Miami -Dade County, maybe the sheriff's office. does have a lot of fluff in their budget. Maybe they have been overspending. Maybe they have been hoarding money away. And that's why they're not going to feel this, right? But the truth of the matter is that that does not apply to Leelman. That does not apply to Palm Harbor. It doesn't apply to Marion County or to Gainesville or to Fort Walton, right? It doesn't apply to those places. It may apply for
down there, down South Florida. But this is going to be the effects of Amendment 3 will be felt throughout the public safety community, throughout the entire state of Florida. So I'm just asking everybody that's listening to this episode, do your own research. Ask the questions. And if there aren't answers, I think that gives you your answer on how you should vote for something that is drastic. And talk to your local community.
Talk to your local county. I mean, we see it, right? The public is looking at local budgets more so than ever before. So ask why that fire department in your local area is spending millions of dollars in overtime. Ask them why. Ask them why they can't implement a 42 -hour work week that is recommended by the governor of Florida. Ask them why they can't, why they're not willing to, why they're not willing to save taxpayer dollars, why they're not willing to add an MIH
program. You know, other things that are going to cut the response times down, cut the wear and tear of vehicles. All of these save money long term for taxpayers. They need to start asking those questions. When the public starts asking those questions and those commissioners or city council fire chiefs, when they can't answer them, then they get held accountable or they change. And that's the way that this is going to work. That's the only way it can work moving forward. I'll add as well, if you need the resources,
just go to the Behind the Shield podcast under 2472. I think if I'm not mistaken, your HR director was one of the people, I think, that said that, you know, use that. But I know, you know, Plano, Texas and Williston, I've had so many people reach out like, yeah, we use things and it's free. It's completely free. And it's got you and guys from Gainesville and all these other departments that have literally walked us through. how they did it, some of the pitfalls, as you just alluded to, you know, there's still now a need to slightly overhire because you want
to make that overtime all but go away. And if you just simply staffed, you've still got, you know, sicknesses and injuries and, you know, vacations and all the other things that you need to project for as well. So, you know, there are so many beautiful, I love the integrated 911 system. Let's start. taking some of the people out of the responses and let's connect them with urgent cares and treat at home and all these things. It's used technology. I think that's a beautiful third example to how we address this. I also want to hit one more area and then I want
to talk about the things that you've seen with the 2472. But for people listening that actually care about their first responders and they see the suicides or the cancers or some of the other areas. The fire service is already struggling and some of these departments like yours have found the solutions, but the other ones are still struggling. And if you're going to now slash the budget, that means that even more first responders are going to be forced into overtime. And I say forced because we don't have the option to go
home. You are told you have to stay. You're wearing a badge. It's a different kind of expectation than if you worked in a bank or a supermarket. So the men and women that are already kept from their families way too much are now being told you've got to stay even more because we can't keep people, we can't hire people, and you're going to see more cancers and more suicides. So if you actually give a shit about your first responders and their health and their performance and their relationships and their families, then this is another layer to this because it's already
crumbling. And then you slash the budgets, you watch, you know, there will be some departments that just won't be there. Imagine, so people have said this to me, imagine calling 911 and it was just a dial tone and your worst day and your kids trapped in the second floor in the bedroom and you call a number and no one fucking picks up anymore. That is not scaremongering. That is a genuine concern because if you don't have enough people, you have no fire department. It's as simple as that. You know. Something like
that was actually said on the House floor in the chamber when Amendment 3 was up for a vote in June. I don't have the exact quote in front of me. I was sitting in the gallery, but it was essentially local cities are going to have to decide whether they want to keep their city police or if they're going to have the sheriffs come in and service. Well, the sheriffs are effectively getting a cut here, too. So now you're asking the agency that is this size to now serve another.
incorporated area what are the response times there you know you got someone breaking into your house your your spouse your child you know goes into cardiac arrest how long are you willing to wait i can tell you the math says hopefully you're waiting less than eight minutes if not chance of survivability falls off a cliff so you know it is a real It's a real thing that we are going to be facing. I don't believe it'll be every agency throughout the state of Florida,
but it will be a large amount. And there will be areas that will have fire stations closed. There will be areas that will have sheriffs and police get laid off. It is going to happen. Some of these areas are already struggling financially. Imagine taking away 30 % of the budget. They're going to cease to exist, like you said. It is. It's a concern. And you shouldn't be concerned
about that. Right. When we're when we're talking about something such as Amendment three, you should have the answers. You shouldn't have to worry about whether or not police or fire are going to show up to your house. And you got a lot of people out there that will say, right, they've never called 911. I can promise you this. Every person that walks on this earth one day, you are going to call 911. or your spouses it is a matter of time everybody's day comes right we all we all die we all pass away somebody or
you is going to call 9 -1 -1 at some point in time in your life and you damn sure better hope than when you pick up the phone and dial number one someone answers and answers quickly and number two you got a crew coming to your house to come save your life but you know they i guess going to the cancer conversation um when we look at the cancer presumption bill Right. So local governments, they have to pay on your first diagnosis of cancer. The firefighter receives $25 ,000 check. That's
to help cover the treatments, out -of -pocket expenses, etc. They also are required to cover all of your co -pays, your PTO, your out -of -pockets, all of that on top of $25 ,000. If that firefighter passes away, the family receives a $75 ,000 check. So that is another financial impact. the taxpayers are paying for with amendment three you have some agencies that are doing nothing in terms of cancer prevention we have some that are doing very little you have some like pasco
county that are doing right now the industry standard where where does the reduction come from if you're going to reduce budgets right what's the most important is to run 911 calls is to have the people on the streets to have the stations in service right cancer prevention suicide prevention. Those are things that, I'm going to sound terrible when I say this, they're not required to run 911, right? But they are
absolutely necessary. How do you fund them? Do we see cuts to those programs? I would imagine some areas that's got to be on the top of the list, right? Anything you can do before you cut personnel, you do. And it has long -term effects, right? When someone goes out on PTSD. Because we have the PTSD bill, like you said, you know, if they're gone for a month, somebody is filling that position on overtime. Somebody's diagnosed with cancer. Someone's filling that position with overtime. Reducing the work week. I mean,
I want to say, I mean, you've shared a couple studies, you know, what sleep deprivation does for cancer risk. You know, we know what the firefighter cancer presumption bill says in terms of financial obligation for the city or county. All of those things are going to reduce cost. And Amendment 3 passes, nobody is going to be able to expand or implement any of those programs, which down the line is going to cost more money in paying
for the treatments and backfilling the physician. Something that just popped in my head too, if you have a diminished level of service in police, fire, and EMS, what is that going to do to your home insurance if insurers start looking at that? And then longer term, what is that going to do to the value of your home? Are you going to see your neighborhood prices start to fall? Crime goes up. You know what I mean? So there's that
as well. Again, these downstream effects. I want to end with some of the successes that you've seen with 2472. We've laid out the financial reasons for it. It makes perfect sense. It's a proactive solution. I've said this many times. There is nothing more fiscally responsible than having a firefighter paid straight time that is highly trained and well rested. And that is what the 2472 does, along with fitness standards, which I love. Talk to me, though, about what you're seeing as far as the camaraderie in the
department now. And then what kind of candidate are you actually getting testing these days, too? Well, you know. it definitely was a change, a culture change, right. Having like the ghost shift, the shift that you never see, you know? Um, so we actually brought back log books that way everyone can know what was going on. But I mean, the crews, I mean, my entire career, I've been blessed to have great crews at, at my, every station I'm at, um, you know, where
I'm at right now, we are just a big giant, you know, fucked up family. Um, but yeah, it's been great. You know, the, um, The attitude is different. The attitude of the agency has improved. Everybody is happier, at least in my crews, the crews I interact with. Everybody loves a schedule. I mean, we haven't had one person complain about the fact that they work 24 -72s. The type of
candidate, the most qualified, paramedic cert, experienced from other agencies, you know, you name it. We get it. You know, there's always a every time we open for hiring, it's we have more applicants than we've ever had before. More people interview. Well, you know, we just had I think we just hired a recent class of 15 or 16. They interviewed 40. They wanted to hire
30. It's it's the best problem to have. Right. Being able to have difficult conversations with who you're going to pick versus the other, because all of them are great. And you can see it in our orientees, right? I mean, you know, we're still hiring some people that are, you know, green, right? And that's what you should do as well. But those that are coming with experience, I mean, they, a fantastic addition to Pasco County.
You know, we're seeing, we've seen several applicants come, you know, paramedic years of service and full flu SAR. Just. That type of firefighter coming into your community, it's such an addition. You know, you can't really explain what that means for everything that we do. It's just it's been it's been great. We have no shortage of applicants. That's for that's for sure. So I would say it's been incredibly successful. Home
life is fantastic. And that's the best part, you know. So it's been great. Work -life is great. I have no complaints. I have no complaints at all. So it's been wonderful. Before Marion announced the change, one of their chiefs had been telling their firefighters that it was failing in Gainesville and that they weren't able to hire anyone. And I'm going to quote one of my Gainesville friends
when I called him. And I had their union leader on shortly after, and he debunked all of that. It was basically trying to justify. Maori are not doing anything rather than what was actually going on in Gainesville. But my friend who was part of the union leadership, Matt Harrison, who's been on the show as well, he said, James, if they told us that we were going back to 2448, the entire department would quit. So I think that's a win. That seems like it's doing pretty well. That's a huge win. That's a huge win. All right. Well, I'm going to round off there. Is
there any other areas that you want to talk about before we close out? No, I think we hammered Amendment 3 quite a bit. We talked about some of the successes. No, I think everybody out there that's undecided, even those that are dead set on what they believe, like I said, do yourself a favor. Turn off the TV, get off social media, and take a look for yourself. Don't automatically dismiss the concerns because not all. And I'm
sure not the majority are saying the things that we're saying about Amendment 3 because we're crooked. Right. That's just not true. So do your own research, make an educated decision on your ballot over the next couple of weeks. Early voting going on right now. Election Day, obviously, is November 3rd. And, you know, we see what happens. Well, I want to thank you. Like I said, you. literally are the perfect voice because, you know, we talked about one of the politicians has been, you know, vocal about opposing it.
I wasn't able to make that connection, but in all honesty, I think this was better because you're not a politician, no disrespect to him, but you're a firefighter and a father and a union, a former union president. So you've got such a, a powerful lens and there's no. political journey that you're padding or anything like that um so those this is the whole point this podcast don't listen to the politicians listen to the people that are there whether it's gaza or you know florida in this case listen to the voices who are actually boots on the ground and
then like you said listen to lots of them and then make your own own decision but There's a yes and yes response to this. Yes, we need to be more fiscally responsible with taxpayers' money because these men and women are working their asses off for 40 plus hours a week and trying to pay their mortgage and feed their kids. But where can we actually do it where it's proactive and really effective? And obviously the Amendment 3 option is clearly... not addressing any of those. And as we discussed, it's probably going
to cost you more money down the road, including you think you just save money and then your city has to slap on a different tax to stop the fire and police from completely dissolving. So I hope there has been an education. It's been an education for me, and I'm sure a lot of people listening are going to be a lot clearer in the way they view, and now they're going to... They're going to know why they're voting for or against. So I want to thank you so much for the third time for being so generous with your time and coming on the Behind the Shield podcast. Well, I want
to thank you for having me. Thank you for your kind words. Thank you for everything that you do for fire service, not only in Florida, but throughout the entire country. You know, you are a powerful voice and have improved the lives of firefighters, not only throughout this state, but in multiple others. So thank you for everything that you do as well.
Leif Babin is a former Navy SEAL, author and co-founder of Echelon Front. We discuss his childhood in Texas, the Native American community, his journey into the Navy, leadership in the first responder professions, the...
Fire Chief Adrian Dillehay serves as the executive leader of the Westfield Fire Department, where he began his fire service career in 2007. An East Aldine native, he joined the Houston Fire Department in 2011 and...
Josh Brolin is a former wildland firefighter, actor and writer. In this second interview, we discuss social media, fame, family, kindness, trolls, adventure, writing and much more. Josh's Book: From Under the Truck....
Steph Crossland spent her firefighting career with Orange County rising to the rank of Lieutenant. After a near fatal accident, she transitioned to full time ICU nursing. We discuss her journey into the fire service,...
Erica L. Hay is the owner and managing attorney of Spartan Law of Florida, PLLC, bringing more than 30 years of combined experience in law enforcement, criminal justice, and legal practice. Before becoming an attorney,...