Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind The Shield

Behind The Shield artwork

Erica Hay (The Deadly Cost of Organizational Betrayal, Sex Crimes and Compassionate Policing) - Episode 1304

Nov 12, 20262 hr 14 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Erica L. Hay is the owner and managing attorney of Spartan Law of Florida, PLLC, bringing more than 30 years of combined experience in law enforcement, criminal justice, and legal practice. Before becoming an attorney, she served more than 28 years in Florida law enforcement, including supervisory and investigative roles with the Marion County Sheriff’s Office and Ocala Police Department. Her practice focuses on representing law enforcement officers, correctional officers, firefighters, and other public employees in labor and employment matters, administrative investigations, disciplinary proceedings, grievances, and arbitration. She serves as a collective bargaining negotiator for the Police Benevolent Association and Fraternal Order of Police, and as a Critical Response Attorney for the Police Benevolent Association. Erica also has experience in criminal defense, civil litigation, and dependency law. She has completed Florida Supreme Court-approved arbitration training and family law mediation training. Her combined law enforcement and legal background informs her approach to workplace rights, public safety, and dispute resolution.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This episode is sponsored by a company who has truly found a solution to an age -old problem, and that is Carna Bunker Gear. One of the most prevalent conversations in the fire service is should we or should we not train in our bunker gear? Now, the answer to both is yes. As most of us are aware, the carcinogens from structure fires, of which there are over 260 that are dangerous to human health, not to mention the PFAS and other chemicals that are within our gear from the manufacturing process, are factors that we

obviously want to minimize. Now, the other side of the coin is that we do need to train in our gear. There is no way to acclimatize the heat retention and lack of mobility than to actually wear the gear. So seeing this problem himself, firefighter and exercise physiologist Ryan Conley developed a carcinogen -free gear at a much lower cost that can be used in non -IDLH atmosphere and training that does not require puncture or tear resistance. Now, as someone who always trained

in gear myself throughout my career, I wish this technology was around then. And I got to test it personally while coaching my tactical athlete class a few weeks ago and can testify that it not only simulates the heat retention of frontline gear, but also the lack of mobility, which is imperative at operating at a high level on the fire ground. Now, some additional benefits include being able to doff the gear when you do get banged out for a call, increasing the lifespan of your frontline bunker gear, And then also public education.

Think of the number of times that we allow, for example, schoolchildren to wear our gear when it's infused with all these carcinogens. So there are so many real -world applications for a fraction of the cost of IDLH -rated bunker gear. So if you want to hear the whole story behind this, listen to my conversation with Ryan Conley on episode 1175 of the Behind the Shield podcast, or go to carnabunkergear .com. Welcome to the

Behind the Shield podcast. As always, my name is James Geering, and this week it is my absolute honor to welcome on the show veteran law enforcement officer turned lawyer, Erica Hay. Now, in this conversation, we discuss a host of topics from the deadly consequences of organizational betrayal, her journey into policing, homelessness, the opioid crisis, sex crimes, and so much more. Now, before we get to this incredible conversation,

as I say every week, please just take a moment. Go to whichever app you listen to this on, subscribe to the show, leave feedback and leave a rating. Every single five -star rating truly does elevate this podcast, therefore making it easier for others to find. And this is a free library of over 1 ,300 episodes now. So all I ask in return is that you help share these incredible men and

women's stories so I can get them to every single person on planet Earth who needs to hear them. So with that being said, I introduce to you... Erica Hay. Enjoy. Well, Erica, I want to start

by saying thank you so much for taking the time this morning and coming on the Behind the Shield podcast. I'm so happy to be here and thank you for giving me a voice. And I want to thank you as well to all of our mutual friends for making this connection in the first place. Seems like the circles that we travel in, you know, definitely overlap. Very first question, where on planet Earth are we finding you today? I'm at home in Ocala. Brilliant. Which side of town do you live,

by the way? You don't have to be specific. South end towards Bellevue. Okay, brilliant. Not too far from me then. All right, well, let's start at the very beginning of your journey. So tell me where you were born and tell me a little bit about your family dynamic, what your parents did, how many siblings. Sure. So I have two brothers. I have my parents. My dad was a firefighter. a career firefighter his entire life and then when he retired he became a volunteer fire chief

and we grew up right in like the outskirts of washington dc in an area called cabin john maryland um i have my mom was a police and fire photographer so she would respond to the scenes and take like you know action pictures of the fire calls and she's had you know numerous photographs like printed in Firehouse Magazine and newspapers. But that was my life and their career. Grew up

in the fire service, you know, as a child. All of my uncles, I have four of them, were firefighters. One is still a firefighter. The rest are retired. I have every male cousin in my family is a firefighter. One's a Baltimore City firefighter. Others are still in the outskirts, surrounding Washington, D .C. area. So my entire life was surrounded by firefighters and growing up in the fire station.

What were the pros and what were the cons of having parents in those professions? I don't think there was any cons for us. My dad would work a 24 hour shift. You know, he was a hard worker, but then also on their days off, you know, they did side jobs. So, of course, I guess a con could be the salaries. Firefighters could always make more money. That's a that's a little plug there. But there was really it was all pros.

Like when he worked a shift, we would go hang out at the fire station. We would hang out, you know. play around the fire station. They'd have softball games on the weekends, you know, with another station would come over and they would play, you know, there, like, it was just a, it was a great childhood. Great. Nothing, nothing negative. What about the impact of maybe some of the things that your mom saw through the lens when she was doing her side? So, you know, they

didn't hide anything from us. So maybe that exposure. helped, you know, me later in life, in my later career. But it didn't really affect us. And, you know, my parents were a good team. So I think that them working together, you know, to keep our family together, keep us involved in everything was just a real positive. What about sports and exercise? What were you playing and doing back then? Oh, I did everything. I played soccer.

I traveled playing soccer. I did softball, basketball. cheerleading in high school you name it i did it i ran track for a little while as well now you have these two parents that are in the fire service were you dreaming of becoming a firefighter or was law enforcement already in your head by that point wow that's an interesting story right there so i um was going to of course consider you know being a firefighter but I started volunteering,

I think it was, I was 16 and I put the mask on, the breathing apparatus mask. And I'm not sure exactly what it's called, but where they black out the, like, so you can't see, like if you're actually in a fire, you know, covered, you know, or in smoke, so you can't see. And I freaked out. I could not stand it. So from that moment on, I decided to go with law enforcement. It's so funny because, you know, cops will say, I

can never do your job to firefighters and vice versa. And wild lamb will say it's a municipal and vice versa. And the reality is, obviously, there's an element of each of those that we're just suited for, you know. And I have so much admiration for someone who drives around in a patrol car that might have to go from zero to 100 with someone much bigger, much stronger, maybe even better trained. Maybe, you know, a prior military person, you know, who's good with a firearm. And so it's interesting how each of our personalities tends to suit one of these

different uniform professions. Yeah. My brother, of course, started out really young. I think he was five. You know, I remember, you know, he always had fire trucks. He, of course, became a volunteer, became a firefighter. Eventually, I think. he ended up as a captain at savannah fire department we did move to georgia eventually but he was a captain in savannah and then he became a chief and he's been a chief i think for the last 11 years um at a fire station in

georgia amazing so walk me through then you're in the blacked out mask you're like hell no how does that lead you into the world of law enforcement instead So I don't know. I just think that maybe since my whole family was in public service, like I didn't really consider anything else. Of course, you know, being around all the firefighters, you know, the police officers would come to the station. They would be there for dinners. I did have one uncle on the other side of my family that was a police officer. So it was just, I

think, a natural progression for a family that's in service. So it was really also something I was, you know. looking to do because it seemed exciting so I went right into it. How did that bring you to Central Florida or North Central Florida specifically? So my parents retired and then we moved to Florida and then I ended up moving here with them and my younger brother my of course my other brother who was a firefighter in Georgia stayed there. What was it like as

far as the competitive nature of trying to be hired as a law enforcement back in the mid -90s? Oh, interesting you asked that because it did change what I had to do at first. You could only get into the police academy at the time by being sponsored. So I moved here. I did not know anyone. So I had to go to the corrections academy first. So I became a corrections officer and Did that for a year and a half until I could get through

the crossover academy, which I did the crossover law enforcement academy. And as soon as I became sworn, I got picked up by the Marion County Sheriff's Office and got hired there. In California, when I worked in Anaheim, I know the law enforcement kind of rite of passage was corrections first, and then you would end up on the street. What value do you think there is in a young person in law enforcement seeing the jails or the prisons first before they go on the streets? That is such a great question. I absolutely believe that

it should be mandatory to do at least a year or two in the jail. It taught me so much. I was a young 21 -year -old girl, minimal life experience. you know getting thrown into the florida department of corrections um with a lot of people with a lot of you know street experience life experience that i did not have and it taught me a lot of things it taught me that you know just because people were there didn't mean they were bad it

means that they you know had a lot of maybe bad experiences, made some bad decisions, but they were still people. They treated me with respect because I treated them with respect. And it taught me how to talk to people that weren't the same as me, didn't have the same experiences as me. And I think it would be valuable for any young person to start there first, just to learn some life skills and how to talk with people because that's so essential in law enforcement. I know

you were very young, so I don't know if you'd be having this profound observation at that age, but was there any element of seeing contributing factors that led these men and or women behind bars that maybe infused some compassion and empathy when you were on the streets? Oh, absolutely. Mental health, mental health issues, you know, in the correctional setting at the prison level. They are usually medicated on a regular basis.

So they are on their meds consistently. So, you know, I think that's a little bit better than, you know, what I learned later on the streets when they're off their meds. But, you know, still the mental health issues and of course addiction, drugs and alcohol are, you know, I say, I guess maybe on an equal, you know, playing field with mental health issues. As you said, you were somewhat bright eyed and bushy tailed. You go into corrections.

What did Marion County look like? And again, in the mid 90s, when through a law enforcement officer's eyes. Wow. It's changed a lot. So I'd say at the time, you know, there was a lot of there was, of course, always domestic violence. Right. That I don't think ever goes away. And there was. you know, street level drug dealing at that time, which has gone away. So there was

a lot of crack dealers, you know, on the street. There was prostitution looked different back then. There were, you know, prostitutes that were walking the streets, you know, different than what's going on today. You know, things are more remote now. You know, your drug dealers are using more cell phones and electronics to communicate. And, you know. You get escorts in a different way these days. Where was the red light district? Was it Pine? Oh, South Pine Ave.

Yeah. Yeah. From the pizza hut, the old pizza hut to, you know, downtown. So, I mean, we're kind of moving forward a little bit. What changed, whether it was the policing itself or like you said, technology as well, what changed to take some of that street crime off our streets and send it to more remote locations or reduce it even? I just think, you know, time, you know, and everything changes. Like, like we would do prostitution stings back in the day on the streets,

but then we eventually moved to hotels because of Craigslist. You know, people would post, you know, things on Craigslist and that's how you would, you know, they would solicit, you know, something like that. And so I think technology is really a huge issue and cell phones. Like, you know, we had cell phones, but. They're the old flip phones. We didn't have what we do now, like mini computers in our pockets now. What about the level of homicide? It's hard to kind

of figure out if it's just we're more aware of it now because everything is given to you almost live through social media. But it seems like our area does have a lot of shootings, a lot of killing. We just had that double homicide over ice cream. by a roommate the other day, and they were all in their 60s and 70s. So we're getting these bizarre crimes, which of course goes back to the mental health crisis. But it's always interesting because politicians will present figures, oh, it's getting better. But this is the law enforcement and legal community that

we really need to ask. So what are you seeing? Obviously, our population is certainly swelled as far as the prevalence of violent crime in our area. I think it's just grown steadily. with our population. I don't think it's out of control. I don't think that, you know, we're not a huge metropolitan city. So, you know, thank God for that. We don't have the extreme level of violent crime that other areas do. And we do, we are,

I think, really blessed to have proactive law enforcement agencies, you know, a proactive state attorney that is going after criminals and support. law enforcement so you know there's other areas in north central florida that aren't as supportive you know to their law enforcement agencies um so i think we're just really lucky to be in this area where everyone supports proactive law enforcement to keep everything under control what about specialty teams while you're still with the sheriff's office

what were the areas that you were working in so i was at the sheriff's office for 10 years um so i you know, was on the streets. Then I became a property crimes detective. Then I got promoted right around 9 -11. So I became a sergeant in the terrorist intelligence unit that was newly formed. So I stayed in there. And then after, you know, my 10th year, I transitioned to the Ocala Police Department. That was after. an election

at the sheriff's office so i ended up moving uh to ocala police department it's an interesting perspective so you're on a certain career track what impact did that political element have and to the point where you actually moved um departments i think anyone that's involved at a sheriff's office can relate that you know if you don't support the person that was elected life can become harder and it did unnecessarily um so

you know i spoke with then at the time assistant chief rodney smith he said come on over and i went over there and i started new but you know i had known everybody that worked over there for years you know it's still a small town so it was a pretty smooth transition um and everyone was really welcoming it was it was nice That kind of transition spans the opioid crisis and the pill mills were very much in our area, obviously a little bit further south, but in our state.

What did you see in this area as far as the impact of that? You mentioned crack earlier in your career. Did you see that infuse into our area too? Yes. So that transition is really a sad transition when you look at it from today's perspective backwards, right? So at the time, We absolutely needed to do something about the pill mills, right? So they enacted a lot of laws, got really tough on enforcement, a lot of prescription fraud,

targeted that. But then what happened is once that got under control, what came in? Heroin came into Ocala. Fentanyl came into Ocala. And that changed the game here as well, which... of course it's a huge negative i i wouldn't want either you know the pills or fentanyl and heroin but it made it a way more deadly deadly game for people you know when that when we transition from crack to the pill mills to heroin and fentanyl

was there a certain socioeconomic group that you saw were most susceptible to the crack addiction um Yeah, of course, just lower income people. You don't find the majority of people smoking crack are your professionals. Yeah, there absolutely were some that they do, but of course, the lower socioeconomic citizens. And what about the opioid

crisis? Were you seeing the same socioeconomic group or was it more diverse? So, I mean, I guess it... As time progresses, it does become a little more diverse. More middle -class people were able to get the pills. So yeah, I think it did affect a more diverse group. And then continuing with the heroin and fentanyl, it's affecting everybody these days. So I think it's just spread everywhere. See, this is what's interesting.

Obviously, that was a slightly loaded question that led you through there. But because... There was a sense of kind of like HIV, a lot of people thought was a gay disease and some people thought it was punishment by some higher power. With the crack epidemic, I think there was a little disconnection because that was those people over there. It's not us. And then I feel like when the opioid crisis hit, people realized, oh no, it's all of us. And your cocaine or your scotch

might have been your crutch before, but now... This is the new crutch. And I think it really does peel back the curtain on the fact that we have a mental health crisis of all classes throughout this country. And that is, you know, the nucleus of the school shootings. That is a nucleus of someone killing two roommates over a tub of ice cream or dying from a fentanyl overdose in a fire station. And I think now we're kind of forced to acknowledge that it isn't those people over there. It's a human issue that we're dealing with. Yeah. And if you remember, I'm not sure

exactly when it happened, but I know there was a big push to reduce the mental health facilities and increase incarceration. That was, you know, I think before I even became a law enforcement officer. But with that comes consequences. So we have more people incarcerated. We have more people with mental health problems incarcerated rather than getting treatment. So, you know, did it make it worse? I don't know. Maybe. I think it was the Reagan administration, not. I can't stand both sides to be very clear, but

that was when the homelessness went through the roof as well because they emptied all these psych facilities and a lot of these mentally challenged people were now on the streets. Yeah, that's right. With that being said too, what about homelessness? What have you seen as far as the trajectory of that? I had Ben, the Ocala mayor on, I think it was probably like three years ago now, whenever he was about to be elected. And I know that was something he was very passionate about himself. But what have you seen over the last couple of decades or so? It's been steady. I don't see

an increase or decrease in the amount of homelessness. I mean, it stayed steady as far as the population increases, we get more homeless. I think that what is affected is whether we see them or not. So if, you know, in communities where they have a place, you know, for homeless people to stay, you know, more shelters, you know, better housing, you know, you don't see them as much, but they're still there and they're still here in our community.

And it's definitely something that, you know, we need to focus on. And then our homeless veterans, like there's no reason in this world a veteran should be homeless. Like we have the resources to provide. shelter for every homeless vet who is also sometimes struggling with mental health issues that we should make them a priority. Absolutely. I believe 10 % of our homeless are veterans, the statistic, which is insane. I want to put

something to you that I ask everyone. I've asked a lot of people, but especially in law enforcement, because you are a profession that was told to enforce drug prohibition laws. The backstory I always tell is when I started this podcast a couple of years ago, my mom had said to me, because she lives in Portugal now, she moved about 25 years ago. She said, do you know what they did here for the addiction crisis? And what had happened, a lot of Portuguese soldiers had gone over to one of their colonies in Africa, fought in a war, come back, and this kind of

heroin addiction just blew up in Portugal. And they had tried the arrest your way out of addiction model from the US and it didn't work. And they have the humility to say, you know what, this isn't working, let's try something else. And they did it very democratically. They put it to the country, had a referendum. And they said, what if we take addicts, not smugglers, not dealers, but addicts, and we put them in the hands of the health professionals rather than the cells? And within eight years, they went from the highest

level of addiction. I've said this for years, and I haven't checked if that's Europe or the world, but it's regardless, the highest to the lowest. And now Portugal is literally used as a model around the world on how you reverse addiction. So it's not legalization. You're not putting drugs on shelves in publics. It's just when you stop an addict with the user's amount, they're not arrested, but they're unlike just... decriminalizing like you've seen in the Northwest, they're taking that money and they're putting it into addiction

counseling, mental health counseling, housing, job creation. So you're putting these people back on their feet and surrounding them with resources so they can actually get through their sobriety. What is your perspective on the drug prohibition, the way that we've done it, the arresting? And if you were queen for a day, what would you do differently? What we're doing obviously isn't working. But I have to just clarify with

this information. So when I started out my law enforcement career, you know, when you're going after, you know, criminals, I don't see criminals the same now as I did then. Right. So when you're a young cop on the streets, like you do a traffic stop, you stop someone and. wow they had marijuana you know you think you're really making a difference in the community right and you stop someone with drugs on them you take them to jail um you think

you're doing something really good but then you know when those business owners like the red light district the ones on south pine they would get mad at us and i i never understood why until now because we were taking away their only clients right then, you know, when you arrest someone and put them in jail, you know, for a minor misdemeanor marijuana arrest, you know, that guy or girl, you know, could be the sole provider, you know,

for their children. And you don't think of the impact when you're doing it, right? So now that, you know, I'm older, I have my own family to support, I understand that. I think if I were to go back, I would definitely do things different, you know, maybe give a notice to a peer, maybe, you know, have some other options rather than just incarceration. So, you know, I would absolutely want to expand, you know, drug court, mental

health court, give some options. But sometimes there are, you know, those incidents here that we've had where People with serious mental health issues have caused a lot of harm. So if they are not either incarcerated or hospitalized in a secure facility, they harm our innocent citizens. And I can't really justify that. There's a balance.

It's not really working right now because those people with mental health issues are not getting the treatment they need. when they need it. I just don't know what the answer is. Yeah. I mean, I think it's the compassion and empathy that's in a lot of the holy books that people have stickers slapped to their cars. But there's always going to be those anomalies. There's the ones that are just too broken and they have to be kept away, whether they're criminals and they're kept in a prison, whether they're just mentally dangerous and so they're kept in a facility. I mean, that's

a no -brainer, of course. As you said at the beginning of your career, seeing a lot of these people had just been in environments that created poor decisions. The Portuguese model, you're not giving these people criminal records. So therefore, now it's not even harder for them to find a place to live, a job. And then it frees up the courts, it frees up law enforcement to pursue the traffickers, to pursue the dealers, to pursue human trafficking, all the things that are attached to the drug world. And so you cut the head off the snake. If you haven't got a

bunch of people that are looking for a drug anymore because you've given them the ability to heal, now it's just simply supply and demand. So you'll always have those anomalies and that's what facilities are for. And I think the dealing and the smuggling, absolutely. And usually there's other crimes attached to that. But I think that that proactive model where you just see people as hurting and it happens that their drug of choice is illicit whilst the people looking down their nose at them. drinking themselves into oblivion with alcohol, and no one seems to care about that,

or gambling or porn or infidelity or social media or whatever the thing is. So I think there's a really strong case for let's try a more proactive approach because it's not just decriminalizing. It's putting all those other pieces in place to take that middle 80 % that you can help. You're going to have a certain amount that you just can't, but at least you're trying. But just a thing you can arrest your way out of crime. I haven't really had anyone on here in the law enforcement community or legal community. Judge

Gary Sanders has been on, for example, from drug court that has said anything other than it's just it's not working. It is not working. One good thing that has changed over time is that the way law enforcement, the Marion County Sheriff's Office and Ocala Police Department here investigate overdose deaths. It's not just a medical call. It used to just be a medical response. And that was it. We were done with it. Now they are homicide investigations. The drug unit comes out, you

know, investigations comes out and they work the case backwards. They find out, you know, who was this dealer? Who sold them these drugs? And then they go after them to arrest them. And I absolutely think that that is an amazing way to treat it. Absolutely. Well, another area I know that you worked in was sex crimes. So talk to me about, you know, your entrance into that world. What were you seeing? And then was there an impact on your mental health working with

that field? such serious crimes that as a law enforcement officer, if I couldn't solve them, it was extremely frustrating. It was extremely

hard to deal with because, you know, property crimes, you know, you know. someone breaks into a house um that's a huge violation but like you know you catch them you get the property back you can move on to the next burglary right but you know when you have a murder or a sex crime you know that you know is such a horrific crime to the victims and when you can't solve that To me, it was a little overwhelming. So I liked

when I supervised that unit because I could ensure everything was, you know, being done correctly. But the personal toll on me, I did not like investigating those myself. But there's also, you know, other factors, you know, with robberies and sex crimes that come in to play that are a little concerning. have a robbery call but it was a drug deal gone bad you know you have a sex crime investigation

when someone you know got caught cheating on someone and so they claim rape um and you know that just underscores the importance of the investigation so you don't um you know wrongfully convict someone so you do a thorough investigation so you can really come to the truth of the matter of what happened. Let's expand on that a little bit more because I know there was a tragedy recently that

you and I talked about. And then there's other things that are related to this conversation that you and I have discussed. The weaponizing of a rape accusation. Of course, anyone who has been violated in any way, the perpetrator needs to be held accountable. Irrefutable fact. I didn't realize how high the prevalence was of weaponizing a rape charge and the devastating effects from loss of career to even suicide that can happen

in these cases. So how frequent does that happen? And what have you seen as far as the detrimental effects? Quite frequently, unfortunately, and especially in... in terms of you know injunctions when you know someone applies for an injunction for protection um you know it is very important to go through all those facts and make sure that they are true because that has consequences right

so say you have a law enforcement officer and someone's trying to get an injunction against them um you know what you're referring to is you know a previous case that that I think I mentioned to you where someone moved away with their child. They didn't follow court procedures, so then they filed a false injunction against the law enforcement officer. He temporarily lost his job, lost the right to have his firearm, lost his child until we went through and proved

that all the allegations were false, every single one of them. This was done to weaponize the court system, you know, by providing false information against someone that absolutely could have destroyed their career. But for, you know, him having to retain an attorney to legally battle that for months and months. You know, ultimately, he did get his daughter back and he's the primary caregiver. So, you know, everything did work out. But, you

know, there are. so many consequences to you know someone filing a false report and they should also be held accountable I you know they should be charged with filing false reports as well so on the the true victim side what are some of the common denominators if any for you know someone being the victim of sexual assault well that's that's a really hard question um I mean,

because there's just so many different factors. I don't think there's anything I could specifically list. You know, there's domestic incidents, you know, that happened. There's stranger, you know, cases where you have, you know, a serial rapist, which we had that in Ocala before. And that was just women in the wrong place at the wrong time. But of course, you know, those cases, there were arrests made and those guys were taken into custody, thank God. So, you know, at least here in this area, it's, you know, just depends on the day

and what's going on. Of course, drugs and alcohol, you know, for some of the younger victims, you know, that could be a factor. There's just so many. What about if, this is such a hard question as well, you know, let's take a younger person. What would you advise them? So that they were covering their tracks and trying to lower the possibility of a false accusation like that.

Wow. You know, they need to know someone's age, first of all. There's people that aren't truthful. So, you know, check some ID, right? How about what I tell my son, you know? You just have to protect yourself at all times. So any risky behavior,

you know, anything done, you know, at the spur of the moment is just a bad thing to do when it comes to intimate behavior. You know, you've got to know someone. You've got to know who they are. You've got to have a relationship. There shouldn't be any drugs or alcohol involved and there should be no impairment and just know the person you're with. You have to be able to trust them and have some sort of relationship where, and that can always go bad as well. So all the

advice that we could possibly give could just turn on a dime. Absolutely. Well, you mentioned checking the ID. Another thing that seems like it's so much more prevalent, but I don't know, again, if it's just exposure now through social media, is the sexual predator, the pedophile, pedophile specifically. It seems like our police departments, like every day, there's just pictures and pictures and pictures and pictures. And you kind of have this impression, like, is everyone a pedophile in the whole of Marion County? So

what is the actual truth? Is this something that is increasing in the population? Is it just becoming more visible now? Like, what are the factors that are leading to so many of these? More visible in technology, making it easier. So you cannot let your children. go on the internet i would say keep the phones away from them um instagram tick tock keep your kids off of social media as long as you can until they're old enough to figure these things out it is i think i don't

think it's increasing i just think visibility is increasing and parents that um let their children you know go places you know unfortunately my daughter never spent the night at a friend's house because i was i would always prevent it you know she complains about it to this day but i wasn't going to let you know my daughter become a victim it's so sad because that was the same same with me my son you know would would you know go to play dates but i would always vet

the parents first basically they didn't realize they were being vetted but they were and then even one time he expressed an interest in the cub scouts and i was like all right we'll go rock climbing we'll do lots of things that they do but For me personally, I wasn't comfortable with it. And it's so sad because there's been schools that my son has been at where teachers or custodians or whoever it was are wearing an orange and white jumpsuit on our local news. So if the exposure is a thing that's showing us more and more people, that's terrifying because

it means that when we were all young, there were as many predators then. Yeah. And just talking to your children, keep them informed and make them feel comfortable, you know, to tell you things. If your child doesn't feel comfortable telling you every single thing that happens to them throughout the day, that's a problem. You know, and question your kids, talk to them about things, you know. I mean, I don't think I mentioned this in the beginning, but, you know, I have a son and a daughter. My daughter's an attorney now up in Gainesville and my son, he's a senior

at UF. Now, my daughter did go to FSU. So we are a house divided with FSU and UF. But both of them probably have the same horror stories about me as a parent and not allowing them to go places or do things unless me or my husband was present with them and never being able to spend the night at anyone's house when they weren't a teenager. Yeah. And it's not even fear mongering. It's just I'm the same with driving. Like my

son and my bonus boy, both of them, I drilled into them. The maneuvering the vehicle is 10 % of driving. It's everyone else and how they're driving and how you respond to that and how you give yourself space to react. And you're not looking at your phone and all these other things. And it's because I've cut countless people out of cars or scraped them off the road or whatever it was. So you've seen it. It's not that the sky is falling. It's just that you have seen behind the curtain of what could happen. And all it takes is that one moment, you know, of

poor decision making. Either you take a pill that someone gives you at a party or you, you know, don't tell the driver that you're with to slow down and let you out. Because I told my son that if anyone's driving like a dick, tell him to pull over. I don't care where you are. I will come pick you up. But do not stay in that car. So, yeah, it's a razor line between not scaring the shit out of your kids. They never want to do anything, but also infusing those lessons. Yeah. All right. Well, then you mentioned law. What made you decide to transition out of

wearing a uniform in law enforcement and go into the legal world? So I always think, you know, in the back of my mind when I was in college, I thought, you know, I think being an attorney, you know, I would really love that. And then my daughter, you know, of course, decided to go to law school. So I stayed as a law enforcement officer so I could pay for her to get through school. And then the. year she graduated is when i started law school so i was working as an investigation sergeant at ocala police department and i was

going to law school at night and then i finished after three and a half years and passed the bar and immediately transitioned into being an attorney with the specific goal of representing law enforcement officers correctional officers and firefighters they absolutely all need protection from their employers from citizens from everyone because

i feel like sometimes when you become a police officer or firefighter you give up some of your rights like you know you can't post your opinion on social media because it's going to reflect badly on your agency so i feel like you know public servants needed someone to defend them. And that is exactly what I do now. I asked you about how competitive it was when you first joined law enforcement. We have seen just a nosedive in recruitment and retention, the fireside, which

is a side that I know in the last 10 years, I would say at worst. What are you seeing as far as the environment? when it comes to young people wanting to be police officers from 95 to where you are today? Oh, wow. So, you know, I know many people started out, you know, young in their career. I did. But due to the massive population

growth, right, and the need for so many more law enforcement officers and firefighters, you have to fill that somehow. And, you know, most people are already involved in their careers when they get a little bit older. They're not going to most people don't switch, you know, around 35, 40 years old and say, oh, I want to be a cop or I want to be a firefighter. You have this whole new generation of kids that need jobs and firefighter salaries and law enforcement salaries. You know, we've been fighting for them to go up for years. And they are, you know, it

is a decent starting wage for somebody. But, you know, they are, it's such a young workforce across the board because they are the only ones that can fill this need right now. People say, actually it's Walt Dix, I'll credit him. He's the union representative for our area, the Southeast. And he said, we don't have a recruitment problem. We have a retention problem. And, you know. It really is that organizational betrayal element of the people who are in charge not addressing

the issues that are contributing to the mandatory overtimes, the physical and mental health issues that we're seeing. And it's funny because I just posted, I asked Claude, the AI program, to give me a map on the number of 911 calls over the last 30 years. So pretty much from when you started. And it went from, I think it was 110 million to 240 million in America. And then I said, all right, map out now the number of firefighters. And it was basically a straight line. And in

the career one, sorry, the volunteer one actually descended at the end. So you have asked the same number of firefighters to do more than double the amount of calls. And obviously this includes law enforcement, certainly EMS. And so there is that organizational betrayal. So I truly believe that there are enough 21 and older people that would be cops, that would be firefighters, but they're also very intelligent. They look at some of these working conditions, the mandatory overtime

and all the things and go, well, that doesn't sound great. I could be a welder, work 40 hours a week. still be a tradesperson and come home to my family every night. And then some of them look at what we're going to talk about today, these toxic environments and go, I don't want to be in that. I thought firefighter was about helping people. What's this bullshit all about? So I don't believe that we need to go into schools and beg 18 year olds to be cops and firefighters. I think we need to fix the things that are broken so that someone can go and get. a little bit

of life experience, maybe do four years in the military and then come into our professions with the physical and mental skill set you need to respond to the worst things in your community? Yeah, I think that we definitely need, you know, the younger generation because of the sheer amount of calls, right? So if we only have, you know,

you know, the ones that we had, you know, 30 years ago, right? The burden on current firefighters is so overwhelming that if we don't add in this new generation and add in these numbers, like, I don't think we'll be able to, you know, function. I don't, I think. the trauma and the stress on the ones that are there is already too much. So how do we reduce that, but still maintain the mental health of the new guys coming on board? Like there's got to be a focus on it. And I think

we're just mass adding, you know, officers and firefighters without addressing that at the same time. Yeah, well, exactly. We're arguably we're employing people who are on the right fit. And I only say that because. At its height, if you're testing to be a cop or a firefighter, there might be a list of 200 people and they take 20 or 30. So you're taking the top 10 % of a list. Now you ask a lot of people, they're taking everyone. Everyone that puts an app that makes it through the process gets a badge. So I think when you

fix... what's broken and and you get more of the right candidate coming to you you can fill those extra spots because obviously the calls have gone up the population has gone up that means the number of potential cops and firefighters has also gone up in your community but are you attracting them or are we losing them to other trades yeah i think that you know the salary is attractive to the younger people and You know, coming out of high school, getting a great salary,

you know, is is a good thing. But once they realize what this job entails, they realize, hey, this just is not for me and they go and that's it. But, you know, can organizations do a better job of helping manage those expectations and managing the stress that they go through? Absolutely. You know, they have to pay attention to why these. younger people are leaving like are we doing valuable exit interviews you know are we really

paying attention to the factors that are making them leave after we invest so much time in training them every agency should do that if you don't you're you're wasting a lot of like you know our money you know on bringing people in training them for millions of dollars and then they're just quitting you know it does it doesn't make sense yeah exactly and then we're seeing you know that there is improvement in florida like for the fire specifically the dead horse i flog as a 24 72 the 42 hour work week for our firefighters and you know pasco county and uh kasimi and destin

and palm beach county is literally like any day now they're doing it and they're already seeing amazing results they got lists you know huge lists again for people wanting to work the people they're hiring are veterans of this profession now so we're seeing that then they're layering it with talking about fitness standards and free access to mental health tools. And now you've got this perfect storm of health and not only health, but performance. So in your world, when you pull over the teenager at two in the morning and they're nervous and reaching for their driving license, you don't shoot them thinking they're

going for a weapon because they're rested, they're recovered, they're highly trained. And the chances of making a mistake like us barreling into a minivan and intersection go down as well. So the proof is in the pudding. We're seeing. how to do it. And locally here, you know, Marion and Ocala are in the process of transitioning to that too. I would argue by force rather than volunteering to, but regardless, we've made it happen. But one of the things that I've talked

about on here already is the issue I have is if you had certain people at the helm when these departments were spiraling down, especially if they were losing firefighters. I'm talking about as in passing away, that is an issue to me. If those people aren't either changing completely how they are or you're changing who's at the helm, then that trajectory is still going to carry on. And even if you've changed certain things that would attract young people, if there's

a toxic culture, it's still going to deter a lot of people. That was kind of illustrated initially by a hazing incident that we had a year ago. So let's transition to that now. From the outside initially, talk to me about your impression of when that first broke out. Tell everyone listening what it was. And then let's talk about how you became personally involved. So two things before I jump into that. So I worked, you know. in Marion

County's law enforcement officer for 28 years. And I relied on the men and women of the Cal Fire Rescue and Marion County Fire Rescue every day I went to work. You know, they are fantastic. They are top notch. I, no matter what I hear, what I say today, I just don't want any of them to ever think that I'm criticizing them or what they do. But my questions about leadership are

different. OK, so I just want to be clear that it should never be confused with the criticism of the firefighters or paramedics or EMTs and other personnel who show up for us every day. This is some leadership things. And so the second thing is what put Marion County Fire Rescue on my radar first? And that was an incident with. anthony gillen are you familiar with that yeah we're friends with the halligan okay so it didn't

my concerns didn't begin with station 21 they began here and this is what i think was a huge catalyst for everyone that works there to see or to break the trust um with the administration the county administration the leaders at the fire department um You know, his story raises the bigger question of what happens when the people that risk their lives for the public need

protection from the system and the people they serve. Right. So, you know, I feel like, you know, Anthony was not treated, you know, properly. I feel that, you know, by, you know. upper administration and county administration and that broke the trust i think everyone saw that you know anthony was severely hurt in a line of duty training accident and i'm not going to say you know my

personal opinion is that he was tossed away you know for liability issues and um that's what put that on my radar so then um comes let's fast forward to the station 21 incident um and we can start there if you want um uh i you know got contacted through a friend of a friend um that captain payette um you know needed some

help um because of that incident and that's how i got involved um where would you like me to start with all that well let's just for i'm sure there's very few people that aren't familiar with it because it became national news but talk to me about you know what the accusation was as far as hazing and then let's talk about you know where victor was during that time and then this you know talk about the termination and move forward from there okay so you know when

It initially comes out, you know, how do we hear about something, right? We hear about it on social media, press conferences, and then, you know, eventually all the facts shake out, right? It sometimes takes a little bit of time. But I feel like, you know, when politics becomes involved, you know, fear of liability issues become involved,

it kind of changes the landscape of how things are handled, right? So initially, you know, things were reported, law enforcement was contacted, there was an investigation done, but, you know, and there were post -Miranda interviews done of the people that were accused, right? Later, you know, Fire Department officials took that

information that they came from the sheriff's office investigation and made their decisions based on the law enforcement investigation, not an independent investigation that they conducted. I'm not exactly sure where you want me to start with this. Wherever you feel would be the best place. I'm going to say this. The early public

statements and the intense public pressure may have made it harder for the decision makers to reconsider the initial narrative they put out there with these press conferences. You know, we had four young firefighters who were goofing around at a fire station, okay? I'm not trying

to diminish what happened to the firefighter that reported this, right? But we also need to keep, you know, in context here that that firefighter later, you know, testified for the four young kids that were involved in this, did not want the consequences that they had initially, you know, been charged with to happen. He also wrote

initially that, you know, the two supervisors that I was directly involved with, of course, one is Captain Payette, was sleeping when this happened. The victim did. So, you know, how we jump from, you know, what could have been just a minor incident that could have been dealt with, you know. Somehow at the station level, even if law enforcement was involved or, you know,

by holding off, letting law enforcement do their investigation and then conducting an investigation with all the fire department personnel, we jumped right to fire them all. They terminated them all. They brought them in and said, you know, you're going to be fired. You can either resign or you're terminated. And that is a huge failure. I believe, of the fire department administration and the county administration. This became a year long battle that we fought. But it, I mean,

there's so many more things that, you know, we can go into. You know, my first involvement with Captain Piette was at the pre -termination conference with the county. There were two, you know, you go in there, you're supposed to be informed of the charges against you so you can defend yourself. It's actually, there's case law. Look, anyone

can Google Loudermill hearings and see, you know, that to defend your career, that Captain Piet was there for 20 years. need to be informed of what the charges are against you you know what the supporting evidence is so you can actually defend you know what the charges are well we were told by assistant county administrator amanda tart and deputy chief graf that if we wanted that documentation we could do a public records

request so that right there is a huge problem okay so we weren't given that information Eventually, we did get it through a public records request. And we used all that information, of course, to try and help get Vic his job back. But that also came with all the consequences of someone that had lost their job. You know, Vic was terminated. He has a wife and three children. You know, Vic

went and got a part -time job at a local business. He then applied for a... Job at the Florida Department of Corrections because it had state retirement and he had started there during this whole process so he could take care of his family. So, you know, during my observation, the termination letters had already been drafted when we sat

down at that table. OK, and at that table is the county administrators, me, Vic and the the union. And the union and I stood up. They fought for Vic. They voiced their opinions, you know, of what was going on. And, you know, it's really important that we remember that the firefighter union, all those guys are employees. You know,

they still have to go to work every day. Even if they disagree with management, they're still in there fighting. you know, against management, the people that are going to make decisions against them as well. So that's a really, you know, interesting perspective here for them. They're, you know, putting their jobs and reputations at risk for the members. So, you know, obviously I'm a huge, you know, advocate for fire and police unions. That's, you know, where I get most of my clients.

And also, I think it's so important that there are, you know contracts their collective bargaining agreements that we have because department policies and the collective bargaining agreements and the firefighter bill of rights don't always cover everything that we need to protect firefighters and that's a whole another story we can go into the firefighter bill of rights and what i think needs to happen with that Yeah, let's go there

for a second, because I know Jennifer just did a piece on that the other day. So I remember being given a little card that I had to carry in my wallet. And thank God, touch wood, I never had that issue during my career. What are the pros? What are the intentions of that? And where are the holes that we need to know about? So there isn't parity between the officer's Bill of Rights and the firefighter Bill of Rights. The firefighter Bill of Rights is just weaker, period. the firefighter bill of rights does not

contain certain provisions that the law enforcement bill of rights does. And it really needs to, like, we really need someone in Florida, a Florida legislator to step up and revise this and, you know, bring it forward as soon as possible, because there is no entitlement or consequences for. Fire administration, if they just want to, you

know, what happened here, they relied on Marion County Sheriff's Office investigation, those post -Morana interviews, and they fired everybody. There's no provision that they have to do their own independent investigation. So here, Marion County Fire Rescue chose not to interview, you know. these firefighters involved in this incident, and they chose not to interview Payette. And it's the easy way out. You know, they just said, oh, we're relying on this, you're fired, you know. And obviously that, you know, didn't work

out at the end of the day, but it still, you know, allowed them to cause harm to, I don't even know how many people got terminated. I'm not sure. I know County Commissioner, former County Commissioner Carl Zalek, you know, did a statement online. indicating how many people were fired over this incident like he was proud of it. And that's an absolute shame. Yeah, well, I mean, there's video of him laughing at the

union a few years ago back when they were earning next to nothing. And that just shows the character of a certain individual that feels the need to put a cowboy hat on and parade themselves in videos around Ocala, but when it actually comes to stepping up and leading. does absolutely nothing. So that's my personal perspective on that. The termination decision that they made, was that once the Marion County Sheriff's Office investigation was concluded, that they already made a, you know, they closed the case by that point? So,

you know, that's an arrest had been made, right? So the probable cause affidavit had been written. The young firefighters, I believe, had been arrested at that point. But of course, you know, as investigations evolve and more evidence comes along, which ultimately affected the outcome of the state attorney's office. You know, those things can change a little bit. The investigation can change. And then you have, you know, four kids that they're, you know,

essentially telling them, hey, you're going to be arrested for kidnapping, whatever the charges were, all these felonies like they're terrified, you know. And they're interviewing them and they're worried about their freedom. So they used those interviews and the facts that were relayed during at least Kaylee Bradley's hysterical interview, which is heartbreaking to watch and listen to against her, against Vic. And then she ended

up clarifying that statement. to administration, to county administration, and they still questioned her and still didn't believe it. So, you know, at what point, you know, unless you do your own investigation, develop your own cause, you know, you cannot rely on someone else's criminal investigation for an administrative investigation and it's just a complete disservice to any firefighter you know to tell them hey we're not going to

do an investigation hey we're not going to you know look into things independently we're just going to you know go off of whatever it is we learn from someone else and write a report that looked like chat gpt wrote it read it off in a pdc hearing and take your job and every manner of making money away from you and turn and walk the other way, which is what they did. We talked about the weaponizing of a rape accusation. Being

arrested doesn't mean that you're guilty. Being arrested means that you're arrested. So had they allowed that case to conclude? Were these people all found guilty in a court of law or were they jumping the gun basically mid -investigation? Oh, they jumped the gun. Well, I can't say mid -investigation because they didn't do their own investigation, but they did it after Marion County's initial investigation. And then if you look into it more, you'll see that the evidence, like some of the pictures that were taken of the victims'

alleged injuries, you know, once clarified were not injuries. So, I mean, you know, the things that they said were, you know, belt marks were not. But then... you know how how easy is it to make all these accusations and come out publicly and ruin someone's reputation and cause all this harm but then where are they when it's found not to be true or found that the facts were wrong are they doing a press conference to correct that no everyone's reputation their careers are

gone and they just move on about you know the next day next thing okay you know what else they did they um they fire department changed the policy right on investigations but i i don't believe the union was consulted you know they should have been um but they didn't i don't believe and if you were to compare the old policy and the new policy you'd be shocked at what they did they just gave themselves more latitude to

decide to terminate someone based on their opinions. So they corrected it to help them the next time not give firefighters any rights again. What really gets me is the human cost. And if I think back now, I can still see all those young kids in their mugshots being paraded around national news, because you can imagine my feed is all the, you know, all the fire stuff from all over the country, all over the world. What impact

did that have? that organizational betrayal on the individuals, the mental health, the family dynamics that you were seeing through your own eyes? So I know right now the firefighters are going, I've heard that they're going through the process of losing, I think, what they had already earned. I believe their EMT certification is on the line right now. I'm not sure what stage

of the process they're in right now. But, of course, they were all tried and convicted in the court of public opinion. So, you know, we have these kids that lose their career, lost their jobs, lost any, you know, way to support themselves, had to, of course, hire attorneys. Some have family to support them. Some didn't have family to support them. And then where are they today? You know, I just saw two of them at Vic's funeral. You know, they are not doing

well. You know, they were members of this family, right? And then they got kicked out of the family and then nobody follows up with them. You know, why not? I know the union has followed up with them. Union members have. I know, you know, I have. I know that, you know, I'm sure there are some people in the fire department that's followed up with them, but, you know, they matter. They mattered then. And, you know. There was nothing

to help them. And the members of Station 21, you know, after this incident, the people that remained there, you know, did, you know, did they go there and help all those guys? Did they go there and help, you know, everyone that remained at the station that still had to deal with this fallout? They just lost all of these employees. And then what this also does to them is it terrifies them. you know if they goof around or play a joke are they going to get terminated you know are they going to lose their job you have supervisors

that um you know do they have to report everything you know do they have to report you know something minor it just calls into so many questions and it kind of breaks the trust that any of them had ever formed with the upper administration at the fire department You know, there's no trust anymore. I don't think. I really think that, you know, the county needs to reconsider the leadership there and see if, you know, it is

completely broken and if things can be repaired. I want to clarify as well, people use the word hazing. Firehouse antics are essential in the firehouse. gallows humor i would argue is essential in our professions collectively there's obviously a line and this is it kind of reminds me of uh when i would talk to my son about swearing i've got a bit of a what your guys call potty mouth myself and as you know i would always obviously

shield him from that and i wouldn't swear around my son you know it kind of came out more as he got into his teens but i would tell him that people can be incredibly cruel and not use a single swear word you can call someone a you know an obese you know disgusting pig not say a single swear word and be so mean and then conversely you can stub your toe and say oh and there's no ill intention whatsoever and it's the same with what we're talking about if it's harmless

practical jokes and fun and banter by a group of people that basically have already have a relationship where they go back and forth. If you listen to the banter on Truck One in Anaheim back when I was working there, it was me, my partner was from South Africa, our captain was a Scottish -American, and our engineer was a Mexican -American. I'm talking about our heritage. You can imagine the banter that went on, but we all adore each other, and they were the groomsmen in my wedding. You know what I mean? So I think

this is the other thing that got blurred. is what was deemed acceptable in that firehouse, was it coming from a place of hatred or was it coming from a place of love and was simply people joking and offloading? Who knows what calls they'd seen days and weeks prior to that? And I think that's an important distinction. Conversely, we know that there are elements of their leadership that are hateful and thrive on bullying and fear. So you've got an administration that allows bullying.

that is demonizing a firehouse that they're calling antics bullying so there's a disconnect there as well that's a great point you know you live with people for 24 hours you know as a cop like we always joke you know like i wish we could go to a 24 you know on schedule so i could sleep part of my my shift right but you know the the truth is is that you guys are living together for 24 hours you're a family you know what i mean like Antics are going to go on. And to use

all these buzzwords, I hate even saying this word, but the waterboarding, come on, like, let's be realistic. Okay. Let's really look at it, what it was. Let's not exaggerate here. Let's not, you know, use some keywords to make the press conference sound better. You know, let's not. destroy people's lives before we make a public statement when we know all the facts, you know, and ultimately the facts came out that,

you know, there was no intent to harm anyone here. It just, you know, was, you know, those antics that went on a little too long and this really could have been dealt with in a different way. Marion lost two young firefighters 12 weeks apart. um alan and trip and i think they were numbers three and four in three years at that point i think it was something like that and

when i talk about mental health it's never a thing it's it's a perfect storm of all the things from unaddressed childhood trauma to you know um sleep deprivation huge huge you know impact on mental health you know the side effects of psych meds alcohol you know relationship issues financial issues etc So the thing is, all right, well, which of these can we control? Well, we can control sleep deprivation by creating an environment where we get an extra 24 hours of sleep and we forced a high level of recruitment and retention so we don't have mandatory overtime.

Beautiful. Okay, we're addressing that. Childhood trauma. Okay, well, why don't we talk about mental health at the front door and accept that the fact that you want to be a cop or a firefighter, you've been through some shit. So let's start working through it on day one. Actionable will forge performance. Organizational betrayal is another massive one. And Kelly O'Dare, who's a researcher in our profession and founder of Second Alarm Project, she did a paper on toxic environments and organizational betrayal and suicide mental health. And there's a story I've

told on here about my previous department, Reedy Creek, and what happened when we lost one of our guys and the funeral and the massive toxic environment that I encountered. But one of the stories that haunts me from Marion is there was a near miss that they had. A young paramedic was in one of the hospital right next to where I live. I think they just offloaded a patient. He took the paralytic that we use to intubate, injected himself with it, walked into ER, said, I just did this and then collapsed. And I'm not

working for them. I'm not volunteering with them. I heard about this through the grapevine. And as the months went by, I was asking people, who was this? And my firefighter, oh, I don't know. Where are they now? Oh, I don't know. And this is someone who was wearing the same badge, wearing the same uniform as you, that had a failed, thank God, suicide attempt in the most horrible way to suffocate themselves with a paralytic. And no one knows who it was. No one knows how they're

doing. No one knows where they are now. And I eventually, we're talking years later, I was training at the gym, coaching at the gym. And one of the women that I had was a former classmate of this guy. And he said, he's okay. He was let go, I believe. The fact check me on that. And he's now in a different state doing a different profession. Okay, thank God. Like, I know this person is okay now. But that is the point. If you have an environment where that happens. everyone should be scrambling to be, all right, well,

then what do we do differently? My God, that could have been so awful. We almost lost someone. What do we need to change? And it wasn't. If I'm understanding what I've been told, if that person was let go, it goes back to what you're talking about with Tony. Well, this is an issue. Let's just cut it off at the root, which could not be more opposite of what you're supposed to do as a firefighter brotherhood and sisterhood. So that's, you know, I've seen these numerous suicides. I keep hearing about numerous near misses, attempts that thank God they weren't successful. That is a cultural issue because

we're talking about a 500 strong department with now, as we're going to get into, yet another suicide. So talk to me about, you know, you're trying to help Victor get his job back. Lead me through that case and let's talk about the tragedy that we learned of a couple of weeks ago. Relating Victor's and the example you just gave, I think we could tie isolation into this. So they isolate the person, they isolate the incident, you know, the isolation of Victor,

the isolation of all the individual firefighters that were fired that, you know, administration told people not to reach out to them, not to contact them. not to follow up with them because they there was an investigation like that. Isolation kills people because they feel absolutely abandoned. We cannot isolate people when they're in trouble. Now, a little bit of this fear comes in where, you know, you don't want people talking about

the incident. You don't want people, you know, you know, getting their story straight. I understand that from an administrative and a leadership perspective, but. you are essentially telling your own people and everyone under you to not contact people when they are going through probably the hardest times of their life. So how can you be there for them when you are completely isolating them from everyone? It's such a huge factor. And in the law enforcement world, there's a confidentially

factor during an IA. you know, when there's an internal affairs complaint, like you're not supposed to, you know, talk about it. You can't talk about it, but that doesn't mean you can't reach out to the officer or the firefighter and just say, how are you doing? You know, do you need anything? Can I help you with anything? You know, that isolation factor is huge. And that has to be avoided, you know, during the time I was not

familiar. with the example you just gave that is absolutely heartbreaking um but you know all these lessons all these things that happen should not be hidden just like we were talking about our kids you have to keep people informed you have to keep your kids informed so they know you know what not to do what, you know, how to react to things better. How can we help them? If we keep, you know, hiding this and keeping this behavior, you know, a secret and isolating

our firefighters and our police officers when they're going through a crisis, this is going to keep happening. It's going to. We have to get out in front of it. You know, there's nothing to hide here. It is what it is. We have to deal with it or we're going to keep losing people. Loss of tribe is absolutely crushing. And it really became aware when I was talking to Sebastian Junger years ago on his book, Tribe. And you have these people that will be in a great mental place, you know, in the middle of Fallujah or whatever it is, because they're around their

people. They're with their tribe. And it's not until they transition out of, you know, the uniform that it really hits them. And we see it with so many of our retirees. You know, they struggle a lot of times after because I am a cop. I am a firefighter. When you think about it, we wrote a blank check to lay down our lives for complete strangers. And we're wearing this uniform and this badge is the same as everyone around me in the station, on the rig, wherever it is. And for that tribe that you said you would die for

your brothers and sisters to then turn their back on you, if you look at it as the origin of tribe, if we were ostracized from a tribe, that meant death. starvation, mauled by a bear, killed by an opposing tribe, you were probably going to die. So it's in our DNA that when we have a tribe, that we feel safe. And when we're ostracized, we feel unsafe. And that is why we see whether it's retirement, whether someone's even promotion out of a station, especially as organizational betrayal is in our very core,

that is so detrimental emotionally and mentally to us. Yeah. And I mean, I remember people, you know, Some reaching out to Vic while this was going on, you know, being afraid that, you know, administration would find out that they were calling to check on them or, you know, checking in with them or talking with him, not about anything about the case, just seeing if he was okay. You know, he just lost his ability to take care of his family. You know, like, why wouldn't we reach

out, you know, and try to take care of him? And it's that fear that administration puts into people that they can't reach out. that prevents them, you know, for their own self -preservation. I can't blame them for that. You know, they have their own families to take care of, you know, the union, you know, like I said before, they all are firefighters there at the agency, you know, but they're sticking up for Vic, sticking up for Lieutenant Bowers, you know, they're at their, to their own detriment, you know, that's

why, you know, the. Police Benevolent Association, the PBAs, who I get most of my work through, and they transitioned a while ago to a different model of representation. So they hire independent reps and attorneys to represent officers where, you know, it used to be an internal union like most fire departments have now because of that pressure that is on the union personnel that still work there. that they get retaliated against, they get judged, they get questioned about what

they're doing constantly. It takes that internal factor out and we can represent people without that fear. And I love that. I don't have that fear anymore. I remember being an officer and getting in trouble because I did that quite frequently. you know in that fear of what's going to happen and administration and the fear of the reps that were there to help me you know worrying about their jobs after they just went up against the chief and the deputy chief and told them what they're doing is wrong you know it's it's a bad

place it's a bad place yeah i agree completely and this is what we're talking about before we hit record you know my superpower now is i don't work for an agency and i'm not out here just emptily talking i'm bringing solutions to problems but I wouldn't be able to do this if I worked for an agency still. And that's sad because all you're trying to do is fix things that are causing either divorces or illnesses or, God forbid, even lives. That's all you're trying to do. But the resistance to these conversations is fucking

nauseating. Yeah, it's so true. There's so many things that I could... say that need to be fixed there, you know, now very specifically, like during Vic's investigation, you know, of course I did a lot of public records requests. I found that there were so many complaints to human resources that guess what happened? Human resources got them and guess where they went? Right back to the fire department and then the chiefs or whoever gave it to the supervisor that the firefighter

complained on. So then what did they face? Now they know, oh, no, this guy complains on me and now I get to deal with it. And so all they get is retaliated against. So there's a huge HR failure there. You know, that needs to be addressed. And then when, you know, there is a complaint that is investigated by HR and, you know, they say, OK, yeah, this was wrong. That's it. They drop it. No, that's not what should happen. The person that either made the mistakes or the policy

that was wrong needs to be rewritten. The person that made that bad decision needs to be addressed. Whether they tell them that they need to change the way they're supervising or change what they're addressing, nothing is fixed. And then you're putting these firefighters who try to... file complaints and try to make a better working environment in a bad place because they just get, you know, retaliated against. HR and fire department administration should be completely independent of each other.

But here in Marion County, it's a very incestuous relationship. So just to recap, Captain Payette was asleep. And obviously this was nighttime when that alleged hazing incident happened. I would often go to bed at like nine, nine thirty, knowing that we're just going to get murdered all night. So nothing wrong with that. So even if it was the middle of the day, I mean, I'm a big believer in naps, but he was in his own dorm away from what happened. He's terminated. You're fighting to get his job back. What was

the result of that fight and what rank did he return to the department at? So during the fight, you know, we had to, of course, public records, request some records like so it didn't just end at the inquiry. of you know was he asleep or not it was the next day when they were all talking about it and what he knew and what he related to supervisors right so and this is all public record now anyone can pull it so we got the gps you know tracking results from i think it's tower

one i think is what it's called so vic the next morning left and uh with some of the other guys and went to a training when the younger kids were there talking about it at the fire station. So we were able to dispute that. He wasn't there when they were talking about it. Then the moment he heard about it, he went and told his battalion chief. The battalion chief also got fired. And to me, the battalion chief had a very logical response. Hey, okay. We know about this now.

I do know that it's currently being investigated by people higher than me. That's it. That's the end of the inquiry. Like, so, I mean, it's all very logical what happened, but when you have someone, and let's talk about this for a minute, I don't know, you know, if there was a, you know, an ultimatum from somebody above the chiefs. You know, I've heard speculation that, you know, a politician got involved and said, fire them all. I don't know if that's true or not, but

if that happened and we let that happen or the chiefs let that happen and the county administrators let that happen, that is a problem. Because if we choose chiefs and deputy chiefs that we cannot trust and that we cannot trust to do investigations and treat our firefighters well, then they should not be here. That's it. Yeah, well, it's moral courage. And this is what I've talked about so often, just doing the right thing. And to allow a politician to tell you how you're going to,

you know, run or betray your firefighters is insanity. You know, you should be pushing back. And if they're asking to do that, well, that sounds like a perfect opportunity to go to a newspaper and say, hey, guess what I've been asked by this fucking asshole over here, who's padding his way or her way. I don't know who you're talking about to a presidential run or whatever it is. Like, no. These people are leaving their families for 24, actually 48 hours because we have to mandatory overtime because we're so, you know, chronically understaffed at the moment. And again, you know, slide this in there. We've

got Amendment 3 coming now. So, you know, good luck with that when you're trying to staff your departments with even less money. But yeah, I mean, these people should be, you know, fighting for their people. And there are some excellent, excellent examples of great, great leaders in the fire service. all over the country. But I would argue that the really good ones are the exception, not the rule. And that's tragic. So this is what you're paid for. This is why you get that huge salary for these difficult decisions

like this. And you fucking failed. You failed. Are we allowed to use the F word on here? Oh, yeah. Am I? I do all the time. Yes. I should have told you that an hour and a half ago. It would have been more colorful. I've been holding back, but they failed really fucking bad. Really fucking bad. We failed Vic. And the time, what's really important is that when we have the chance to help someone and show compassion, it's too

late when they're gone and it's too late for Vic. It's not too late for all the firefighters that are still there and left behind for us to find someone that's going to do the right thing. It's not too late to change the Firefighter Bill of Rights. It's not too late to look at the policy that they revised to see that they gave themselves more of a right to terminate our firefighters and revise that. All of these things need to be addressed. for every firefighter that still

works there today and that is joining the fire service daily. Absolutely. And I think people just forget, like I always use as an example, your average firefighter could be dead asleep. And I say dead asleep because we're never like truly asleep because you've got one eye open. The tones go off at two in the morning. You get out of bed, you jump into a rig, you drive lights and sirens, you know, through traffic. It might be in the middle of a storm. This is Florida. And you get to this house. The house is on fire.

There's a fire in the ground floor. And then you've got someone screaming at their kids on the second floor, stuck in a bedroom. You pull off a ladder. You climb the ladder. You breach the window. You make entry. You search. You find a child. You come back down the ladder with the child. The ambulance is held up by a railroad. Where I used to work, the tracks were right between our first use. It was held up by the train. So now you doff your gear and you start working a cardiac arrest on a three -year -old. That is the person who you're fighting a budget. That

is the person who you're okay with working 56, 80 hours a week. That is the person that you're talking shit about because of a hazing incident that you saw in some paper somewhere. No one else is fucking prepared to do that. You know, I'm sorry, but if you had wanted to be a firefighter, you'd be a firefighter, but you're not. You're an accountant, you're a barista, you're a mechanic, you're whatever. And those are all great callings as well. But people don't understand the risk that these people take for us when we sleep soundly in our bed. And that is just one call. Then you

clean up your gear, you get back on the rig and you get toned out for another one. Oh, three teenagers. You know, dying in a crash car on 441. All right, clean up, go back. Okay, now we've got a baby. It's probably a SIDS call. This is what we run day in, day out. And so these men and women deserve all of the respect, all of the support. And, you know, set a high bar. Not everyone can do this job. Let's be very, very clear. So make it competitive so that you only get the best people who are capable of this.

The rhetoric that you hear people talking about firefighters, oh, they sleep all day, what are we buying you at the store and all this bullshit, that people are just so uneducated. They deserve the support from the public, but they also deserve a union, which, as you've illustrated, absolutely stepped up in this case, and or an administration that supports them. Because no one else. There is no other profession where your skill set is so diverse that you could be hanging off a rope one minute, then climbing down a sewer the next, then trying to cut someone out of a plane that's

stuck in a tree, then all the EMS stuff, then now you're at a school shooting. It is the Swiss army knife of the first responder professions. And they are paid so poorly. They are worked into the ground. And when things like this happen, they become a political scapegoat. It's heartbreaking. that we are even having this conversation, right? Like, I think what, part of what got me here

today, you know, is that the way we failed Vic, you know, from the very first moment, not just Vic, every firefighter that worked at Station 21, every single firefighter at Marion County Fire Rescue in some way has been failed. Anthony Gillen, you know, tremendous firefighter, even better human. And we absolutely failed him. He

got hurt at work. He is a hero and we should not have allowed Marion County to just throw him away. And I feel like when we allow these things to happen to our firefighters and our police officers, You know, someone is throwing them away. And like you, you know, I'm not going to let that happen. I'm going to fight, you know,

as hard as I can. So to circle back around to your question, you know, we, you know, went through the whole grievance process with Vic. You know, we got all of our facts together. found more information that we didn't know about. We found comparables, you know, things that had happened at Marion County Fire Rescue way worse than what had occurred at Station 21, where firefighters were treated differently, which I'm okay with because they weren't fired. They were reassigned,

demoted, or trained, which is always a good response not to just throw people away. We got to the mediation stage. That is where a stage where contractually the union attorneys had to take over. And at mediation, Vic was able to keep his job as a firefighter. And at the end of the day, that's all he wanted from the very beginning. I said, what do you want out of this? And he's like, I want to take care of my family. And I

want. to be a firefighter and after 20 years of his life you know this was you know his first and second love you know work and his family i'm not gonna say which was more important to him because i think they're equally as important to him um but we were able to you know get his job back but all of what happened takes its toll mentally on someone and they fight battles that um obviously some of us are more aware of than

others but those battles are ones that should be contemplated by our leaders when they make these decisions hey i'm i'm terminating you know captain payette you know hey like you know should i pause for a second and say you know Should we do our own investigation? Should we ask some questions? Should we wait for the sheriff's office to finish their entire investigation and the state attorney's office to review everything? You know, those charges weren't filed for months

for a reason because there was so much more information that needed to come out. But hey, Marion County Fire Rescue had already convicted them in the media and then fired them. So, you know, that's essentially the problem. So Vic was a 20 -year firefighter. He had the rank of captain. Again, as we've shown, did nothing wrong during this whole thing. What rank was he brought back as?

Driver. And what was their reasoning when he had done nothing wrong for the demotion? They lost faith in him as a supervisor because he was sleeping. Isn't there a thing of the pot calling the kettle black, I think is what it is? Yes, absolutely. So if I had the ability to terminate today, I would terminate because I have lost faith in every single one of them. From the, you know, Assistant County Administrator,

Tart, to Banza, to Graf, and Kruger, all of them. I've lost faith in all of them as leaders. Obviously, again, a lot of us locally know exactly how, you know, Vic's journey concluded. But talk to me about that, you know. When did you find out? And for people that don't know the story, you know, what happened to Vic? Take your time, Erica.

So I got a call from a firefighter telling me what happened. You know, and, you know, you always question yourself, you know, when's the last time, you know, I talked to them? What's the, you know, what's the last conversation that we had together? You know, could I have reached

out more? You know, what could I have, you know, done differently? You know, and the last text I sent to him was that I'm so excited for you. And that came from a text that he sent to me saying we needed to get together, that he wanted to give me something. Of course, I said no. And

he was just so happy that he got his job back as a firefighter. And I was so excited for him to start, not knowing how hard it had all been. But we have to do something to make sure that

Vic's passing isn't in vain. I think the fire department needs to look at themselves, you know, and I'm not placing blame on any, you know, one person or entity, but, you know, Marion County needs to look at how they handle things. Marion County Fire Rescue needs to look at how they handle things. Something has to change because what's happening now is not working, you know.

So we stop this, not just for BIC, but for every firefighter and law enforcement officer that has taken their lives, you know, across the state of Florida as well. I saw, you know, Seminole County lost a firefighter as well. Like, we have to do something, whether it's, you know, more legal protections, you know, let's change the Firefighter Bill of Rights. Let's revise, you know, Marion County's policy during contract negotiations, you know. Let's work on that. Let's

add some more language in there about investigations and progressive discipline. And let's not just allow people to jump to a termination for someone that was sleeping. There's so many things that have to be done and we have to keep talking about it. And I think the fact that you're doing this is allowing us to keep talking about it. I think the Ocala Gazette. you know, and their continued coverage of this entire incident, you know, is

giving, you know, Victor a voice and giving firefighters a voice that otherwise, you know, no one would hear. So I appreciate you so much, you know, allowing me to even come on and you talking about this and continuing to try to help. vick vick's family and everyone else in the fire service well i started this podcast 10 years ago because i was sick of going to firefighter funerals and

i couldn't go to vicks because of the same i'm still sick of it but there's if anyone's seen uh my profile pictures these names written on my back and there's a thing that orange county does every year my friend started i called the 343 hero challenge and the very first year i did it which was I think 11 years ago now, I had six names on my back, six firefighters that I personally knew that I'd lost from my departments. And the last year, which was a year ago now,

it literally said, there's no more room for the names on my back. I had literally the year before been covered front and back with all the names. And this is just firefighters in the areas that I had worked, not the other 48 states. So this is it. This is what makes me so angry. I don't care if I'm disliked by the people that are at fault. I couldn't give a fuck about a popularity contest because I care about one less coffin being lowered into a grave with an American flag

draped over it. That's what matters. And we've got to have these difficult conversations. And I want to thank you. I've got some more questions, but for you stepping up, for Jennifer stepping up, for everyone that's been out there. beating the drum like you said the union fighting for everyone in this particular case that is all we're trying to do is just get these men and women to go home you know and and just to underline my point earlier it's not one thing on the mental health side it's this perfect storm and if you start picking apart these areas you can improve

it but if you compound those areas you make it even worse and you take someone's job and identity and their ability to provide And then that's probably going to have an impact on family dynamics and all these other things. It's going to get worse and worse and worse. Are they going to sleep well through all that? No. So now you've added that as well. So we have the ability to make such massive changes that will make us healthier physically, healthier mentally, perform at a higher level, make fewer mistakes, be more into

the job, have a better sense of humor. I mean, all these things. If you add a toxic environment, the equal and opposite is true. And sadly, the numbers don't lie. I completely agree. I think it comes down to accountability without abandonment, right? So I grew up in a firefighter family. I know the bond at the firehouse and the responsibility

that comes with it. I mean, I also know that the uniform doesn't... make anyone perfect and there are things you know there's serious misconduct that has to be addressed um and the people that are harmed like they deserve to be heard and protected but we cannot let like public pressure fear or an early narrative or place an investigation we can't forget the young firefighters the supervisors

their families the victim or the union members who you know put their own professional relationships on the line to stand up for fair treatment. And leadership is not measured by like how fast someone can end a career, right? It's measured by the willingness to like gather the facts, listen, you know, to everything that happened, act proportionately,

you know, revisit a decision. When the evidence warrants it, which has never been done here. We can't change what happened at Station 21, right? But we can decide whether its legacy will be more broken lives, more losses, or will it result in better investigations and more rights for our firefighters, more accountable leadership, and room for... everyone to rebuild what we have

right now, because it is so needed. One thing I've been talking about recently, when we talk about the mental health crisis, we talk about us, usually the firefighter, the cop, the soldier that's boots on the ground, we see the horrible shit, therefore, we're the ones that get PTSD, etc. That's a very, you know, myopic narrative, because obviously there's layers to everything. But what people forget A lot of those people then progress. The good leaders spend a lot of

time on the ground and then go to chief positions. Some of them scurry up the promotional ladder as quickly as they can to avoid any time in the street. But the mental health issue doesn't stop at the chief level. And the illustration I make is Purdue Pharma that is behind the opioid crisis we talked about earlier that costs 100 ,000 American lives every year that was FDA approved and that pays politicians millions. in lobbying money to make them the next president. The Sackler family, they sleep soundly in their beds. That's

a sociopath. And I would argue the same thing applies to a police or a fire or an EMS chief that is ahead of a department that has had numerous suicides or overdoses or can't get people to work for them. And they sleep soundly in their beds. So this is another part. We are told, oh, James, you're not fit for duty because you broke down or you went, you know. take an antidepressant or whatever the thing is so therefore you can't be on the street well where is that fit for duty lens at the chief level at the county commissioner

level that you're losing human beings men and women with families and you are basically unmoved by that i would argue you are not fit for duty and you should not be in that position and you yourself need to probably go get some mental health help because i want you to also be a happy healthy human being But your compassion and empathy seems to be fucking devoid. So something is broken that you need to fix. And in the meantime, it is extremely irresponsible and dangerous to put you in a chief's position. And I'm not picking

on the chief. A position of authority where you make decisions, you could be a chief, deputy chief, county commissioner, whatever it is, then your decisions can be detrimental to numerous people below you. I think I've said it so many times over the years that you know, we have to have people that have the ability, we have to have leaders that have the ability to put themselves in other people's shoes, okay? Like, if you cannot,

you know, put yourself in Vic's position at that time, in that moment, and that's what happened, like, I understand you're a chief, right? I understand you have different responsibilities, but when you're making decisions, You know, to do things to subordinates, you have to be able to put yourself in their shoes so you can see what decision they made at that time and why they made it. I don't think we have that right now. I think that as far as the county commission level right now, we have two new county commissioners that are

just on board. So we have an excellent chance to start new. We have fresh ideas and they can hopefully jump in and hit the ground running and help Marion County Fire Rescue and County Administration form a new path ahead because the one that we're on is still headed in the wrong direction. Absolutely. Well, I want to shift slightly talking about service and doing

something good in the world. i know you we've got a mutual friend casey walsh again powerful you know organizational portrayal story and casey's past as well but you guys are connected through canines united so how did you even become involved with that organization and talk to me about what you guys do there so um jeremy nix um was a canine handler when i was at the sheriff's office one of the best i've ever worked with if not the best but then i also have you know the connection

with Casey Walsh. She is an amazing canine handler as well. I by no means was as good as them, but I was a canine handler and a canine sergeant for a few years, and they both helped me along the way. So they were both involved with Canines United, which is a nonprofit that helps. canine units across Florida and across the United States. So Jeremy Nix reached out and they needed someone on their board. So I volunteered to be on the

board of Canines United. So it's a wonderful organization that helps the best of the best of us. And of course, I just, you know, love canines anyway. And they do so many good things. just blessed to be a part of it, but we all have such a deep connection through law enforcement here in this area and how we all end up in the same organization is, is a pretty, pretty cool connection there. Absolutely. Well, Jeremy's

coming on the show in a couple of days as well. So there's, there's that, you know, it's funny how the guests always seem to come at the right time. And here we are with two of you in the same week. Yeah. All right. Well, I want to throw a few closing questions at you before I let you go. What about film, television and documentaries that you love? That's another weird thing with me, huh? Like I, I love 300, the movie, because

there's a lot of violence in it. And I love, you know. Sparta, you know, my law firm is Spartan Law for a reason. I try not to watch much television or documentaries anymore because real life is so, you know, involved with me now. Like every case I have could be a documentary, you know, right now at this point. Why do you think that

true crime has become so popular in the documentary and docu -series space? Oh, that's a good question, because it's fascinating, I think, for normal people to try to figure out why people commit crimes, which is a great thing. Right. Because, you know, I think, of course, the majority of people are good and could never contemplate, you know, doing the crazy things that some of these people do. So I think it's fascinating to learn about it. I don't like watching it because

it annoys me. Because I would do things differently or why didn't they do this or why didn't they do that? So our household tries to avoid true crime. Like I said, my mom started out as a police and fire photographer, but she ended up as an evidence technician. So, you know, her and I cannot watch true crime or documentaries because of all the. things that they say can be done with evidence really can't be done like you can't just you know swap something and come back automatically with a dna result it doesn't work like that so

i've always found it interesting when i was a teenager i liked the horror genre and even kind of like the gore gory stuff and then about god what was i 20 -ish I literally had a moment like, what am I doing? Why is this entertaining? And then when I became a firefighter and you see that stuff in real life, it's even more of a turnoff now. And the ghosty shows I still love, the jump scares and the creepy dolls and all that stuff, those are great films. But the slasher

flicks, I just can't because it's what... we've seen in real life. And it's always interesting. I think there's, there's only one person I can think of that I know still loves those kinds of films that, that wears a uniform. Most of us tend not to watch those. Yeah. I like to watch like live, you know, vehicle pursuit chases like in LA or other places. I love that so much because that just, you know, gets my adrenaline going, but that's about it. Yeah, well, I can't watch the fire ones. I'm actually working on making

my book into a show because the fire ones, basically, they're soap operas. Anything to do with the fire service, you know, and everyone looks like a model and they rescue everyone. And, you know, more recently, the firehouse is completely mathematically diverse, covering all the things. And it's like, that's not how it is. You know, there's these different, you know. dynamics in different departments different stations but it's a dirty job and a lot of times people die you know that's the reality

of it so i haven't found a show yet that really reflects the real american fire slash ems service and i'm hoping that i can you know bring that to the screen but uh yeah but i'm sure in law enforcement must be so awful because you know you're demonized so often on screen too yeah i don't know are there any um you know like firefighter shows like you know how there was cops where you watch them like in progress are there any firefighter shows like that like live someone made someone actually made a really astute um

observation in an interview probably about a year ago now but they said that yeah even if there are they do exist but they will only show the successes you know they don't want to see you know you're like i i in 14 years i never had a code save ever I was the fucking grim reaper of paramedicine where, you know, you have the brain bleeds and, you know, the triple A's and just our hearts that don't want to restart and all the, you know, gory stuff. And yeah, people just died all the time. I saved lots of lives, precodes and all that stuff. But yeah, but that's

so the documentaries are still subject to the kind of Hollywoodization of our profession. they tend to steer away. And then conversely, which is also a massive shame, is when there is a documentary made on mental health in the fire service, it's just sad and depressing. They're not looking at all the tools that are working on post -traumatic growth and how you can become more resilient on the other side of finding your own unique toolbox. And when you change shifts, you can then massively improve the mental health and

all the... But what next element? We just stop at the, yeah, it's really sad. Firefighters are dying all the time. So we do a disservice for that message too, because we're just making it sound like a victim issue rather than, no, this is an absolutely preventable element that's not only costing lives, but it's costing performance. When you take an athlete and you use sports psychology and rest and recovery, your athlete performs at a higher level and they win the Super Bowl, the Stanley Cup. people who's you know literally saving lives you're working into the ground and

then we're just you know we're treading water at best so there's another missing piece which i'm hoping to fill as well is like no let's talk about what you can do let's talk about what is already working that we know our solutions and this is the whole point of this conversation i never forget from that organization after we lost you know um the two young men a few years ago alan and trip that the statement was literally made, we don't have the answers. And I'm like, motherfucker, we do have the answers. This is

what makes me so fucking angry is that no one wants to listen. The answers are out there. The science is out there on the mental health element, on the sleep, on all these different things. And you enact all of those, that then begins the domino effect of starting to reverse these issues and saving more lives. And it's not that you're going to save every single person, but wouldn't you want to save one more, 10 more, 20 more? And so this is what's so frustrating is that there isn't this actual 360 view of what

our profession really looks like and digging into the things that people don't want to talk about. The mandatory overtime and the understaffing and the mismanagement and the organizational betrayal. And it's not just the calls. The calls are this much. of the firefighter mental health story and this much of the recruitment and retention story so there's so much more that the public needs to know and then we wouldn't have so many they sleep all night why are we buying them food at public's stories because finally someone would have told the story properly and the public will

understand just exactly what these men and women actually do for them yeah i mean what they actually do is just sacrifice their own mental and physical well -being to save others Every day. I mean, and that's exactly what they do. Exactly. Yeah. So the next question, is there a person you'd recommend to come on this podcast as a guest to speak to the first responders, military and associated professions of the world? Wow. I don't

know of one person specifically, but I think that UCF Restores has a specific. program for firefighters. They incorporate firefighters' families. They meet with firefighter wives to ask them questions like, you know, what is it that you think would help your, you know, your spouse? What, you know, what they can do to improve

their services. I participated in that once, you know, and I send many of my clients to UCF Restores. Anyone at UCF Restores that focuses, whether you're focusing on law enforcement or firefighters, they have a specific program that focuses on this, and they are extremely successful. And they have helped so many of the people that I have represented along the way in really traumatic

incidents. Because I am a critical response attorney. I go to all the officer -involved shootings, and I'm there. you know, with the officer right after it happens and through the entire process, whether, you know, through the whole, how they're treated with the agency, if they're sued, if there is a lawsuit later, like I'm there through the whole thing. And UCF Restores is consistently, you know, stepping up to help these people through the most traumatic incidents they've experienced.

I need to. actually pull the trigger and connect with someone because UCF Restores has been on my radio for years. University of Miami and their cancer research and fire service, the same. And maybe because they're so prominent, it's the ones that I haven't interacted with. But I know that we're connected on social media and other areas, but I'll take this as a sign to actually finally reach out and get someone. While we're quickly on the subject, you will see the negative rhetoric when we have an officer involved shooting.

basically acting as if police officers are just waiting for the opportunity to kill someone, especially if it's a minority or whatever, this ridiculous extremist rhetoric that we get. Through your lens, talk to me about the impact that you're seeing on these officers when they are put in a position where they are forced to take a life. Yeah, it's, you know, Monday morning quarterbacking by people that have no idea what... it takes

you know to pull that trigger what it takes to be in that uniform and drive towards danger when everyone else is trying to get away from danger so i think that tuning out all that rhetoric is so important um not listening to it not listening to people second guess what you did like you know the legal standard is reasonable officer

at the time of the incident and it's the totality of the circumstances and no one has the ability to put themselves back into that place at that time and you know deal with what the officer is thinking and seeing at that time and I would hope that anyone that listens you know if they were to see a body cam video of something know that that doesn't tell the whole story you know you can't see everything in a body cam You can't see everything from an in -car camera or just audio. Like there's so much more. So I think,

you know, once again, we go back to this whole underlying theme of an investigation, right? You have to investigate. You have to take every single detail and every single fact and prove it or disprove it. And then, you know, you can come out with some conclusions, but you can't just see something on video and make a knee jerk. reaction or see a photograph and make some sort of ultimate conclusion and put that out there to the public especially when you're a leader because people listen to you and there's no way

to dial that back once you put that narrative out there and that's a real shame it's a real disservice to all of our police officers and firefighters absolutely all right well then the last question before we make sure everyone knows where to find you what do you do to decompress oh Oh, decompress. Okay. So I have actually been doing some stuff to decompress cause I really needed to. So I took up art. Like I'm, I'm not very good at it. Right. Um, I wish I had my art

to show you, but I have to go pick it up. I go to, um, Caso's palette. I, I been doing some painting. I've been doing some clay work and I've just been, you know, doing things that are mindless. I can sit there and make a pot or a cup or, you know, do some art just to try to get my mind off of everything. And then little trips like weekend trips. Like I just went out of town to Georgia with a friend last weekend and we went to some museums and went to the mountains

and just hiked, went down and saw a waterfall and just, you know, not think about things for a little while. That's all. Brilliant. Well, if people want to reach out to you from a legal perspective, they just want to reach out in the other way, where are the best places online to do that? So I'm going to give my cell phone out. Please be a little respectful. It is on all the time because I do go to officer involved shootings, but my cell phone is 352 -427 -9707. I will talk

to anyone. Do not like when attorneys don't answer the phone. I always answer my phone. It's been blowing up while we've been in here, too. So we have a lot of people to call back. But if anyone needs me ever, just call. If I can't help you, I can find someone to help you. If you just need to vent, I'm here to listen. Like I have found, you know, through all of this that sometimes. You know, you just have to be there for people. And I'm glad that I'm in a place where I can

fight for people. It makes me so happy. So like what we talked about right before, like I'm not attached to any agency now. So I can say what I want. I can feel how I want. And that's OK. So anyway, I'm always here for anyone that needs me. They can call anytime. Brilliant. Well, you obviously have given me some incredible advice. the last few months. So, you know, I can vouch for the fact that you were there when I needed you to. So thank you. Are there any closing comments,

thoughts before we round this off? Yes. So I just think that it's important to, as time goes on, you know, let's not forget Ashley Payette. Let's not forget his daughters, Alexis, Aubrey, Bree, and, you know, she likes to be called Bree, and Georgia. Like, let's... Stay in touch with them. Let's reach out to see if they need anything. Let's donate to the Marion County Firefighters of the Netherlands Fund if we can. There's a

meal train going right now for Ashley. And let's just stay in touch and help people and don't let time, you know, end these relationships. So I lost an officer, Jared Forsythe. when I was at Ocala Police Department. And to this day, like, you know, I still talk to his mom, you know, Amy Forsythe. She's a good friend. And, you know, I think I will always be friends with

her, you know, and that, you know, came from being a stranger to, you know, me being Jared's kind of work mom. And then, you know, when we lost him, we stayed in touch with her. So let's try to keep in touch with Ashley. and the girls and the family and if there's anything you know people can donate or you know do for the family let's do it and let's not forget about them that's something i've heard from so many widows in this particular case that's who i was always talking

to was there was so many people there at the beginning and so few after that initial thing and again it's not that People were just callous and careless, especially in the fire service. They're back in that meat grinder getting 24, 48 -hour shifts. I think what's a great solution is just to assign someone in the union or whoever it is to be that person who just checks in. It doesn't have to be them constantly, but reminding people that were close to that family, hey, have you checked in on so -and -so? Because, again,

that tribal element, there's a lot of people I know, and they know that everyone cares. it goes quiet very, very quickly. So I think it's a really important point. Everyone is around these families at the moment, but what are we going to do to make sure that six months, a year, two years from now, people are still circling around and checking on them. One day, family dynamics will shift and that will be an amazing thing too. But knowing that you are not forgotten, I think is so important. So with that being said,

I want to thank you so much. you know, for your vulnerability, for your, you know, courage when it comes to talking about this thing, your advocacy, because they're worth it. This is the bottom line. These people are worth the fight and they're worth pushing for change. And it's a tragedy that we've lost who we've lost, but the way that we honor them is in their memory. We change, we force change. We make sure that doesn't happen yet again. So I want to thank you so, so much.

for being so generous with your time and coming on the Behind the Shield podcast today. Thank you so much for having me.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leif Babin - Navy SEAL Leadership Lessons, Native American Culture and Military Transition.

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 58 minAudio

    Leif Babin is a former Navy SEAL, author and co-founder of Echelon Front. We discuss his childhood in Texas, the Native American community, his journey into the Navy, leadership in the first responder professions, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Adrian Dillehay and Sir Michael Branch - Fire Service Mentorship, Line of Duty Deaths and Leadership

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 45 minAudio

    Fire Chief Adrian Dillehay serves as the executive leader of the Westfield Fire Department, where he began his fire service career in 2007. An East Aldine native, he joined the Houston Fire Department in 2011 and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Josh Brolin II - Catharsis through Writing, Internet Trolls and the Importance of Family

    Nov 16, 20262 hr 1 minAudio

    Josh Brolin is a former wildland firefighter, actor and writer. In this second interview, we discuss social media, fame, family, kindness, trolls, adventure, writing and much more. Josh's Book: From Under the Truck....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Steph Crossland - Street Medicine, Surviving a Near Fatal Accident and the World of Emergency Nursing)

    Nov 14, 20263 hr 3 minAudio

    Steph Crossland spent her firefighting career with Orange County rising to the rank of Lieutenant. After a near fatal accident, she transitioned to full time ICU nursing. We discuss her journey into the fire service,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Jason Vale (The Healing Power of Juicing, Reversing Disease and Overcoming Addiction) - Episode 370

    Nov 11, 20261 hr 2 minAudio

    Jason Vale aka "The Juice Master" is an author, filmmaker and creator of the Juicy Retreats. We discuss childhood trauma, owning your history, how he reclaimed his health, disease reversal, addiction, forging resilience...

    Credit the people on this episode