Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Behind The Shield

Behind The Shield artwork

John Ryan (Prosecuting the Masterminds of 9/11, Crimefighting in the 80's and Refinding the Kindness of 9/12)

Nov 5, 20262 hr 33 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

John Ryan is a seasoned law enforcement professional with over four decades of distinguished service at the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey Police Department. He rose through the ranks from Police Officer to Detective Lieutenant Commander and served as Chief of Department in 2012. Throughout his career, he held leadership roles in multiple regional, federal, and joint task forces, including the FBI’s Joint Terrorism Task Force where he served as a Commander for both the NY Office and the Newark FBI. He was part of the Executive Board for both the NY office and Newark FBI, NYPD HIDTA, NJSP Regional Operations Center and the U.S. Marshals Fugitive Task Force. He served as the Commander of the Rescue and Recovery Task Force Operation at the World Trade Center from September 11, 2001, until its conclusion in June 2002, and has been involved in every aspect of the rebuilding mission. His career reflects a deep commitment to public safety, interagency collaboration, and national resilience.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

This episode is sponsored by a company who has truly found a solution to an age -old problem, and that is Carna Bunker Gear. One of the most prevalent conversations in the fire service is should we or should we not train in our bunker gear? Now, the answer to both is yes. As most of us are aware, the carcinogens from structure fires, of which there are over 260 that are dangerous to human health, not to mention the PFAS and other chemicals that are within our gear from the manufacturing process, are factors that we

obviously want to minimize. Now, the other side of the coin is that we do need to train in our gear. There is no way to acclimatize the heat retention and lack of mobility than to actually wear the gear. So seeing this problem himself, firefighter and exercise physiologist Ryan Conley developed a carcinogen -free gear at a much lower cost that can be used in non -IDLH atmosphere and training that does not require puncture or tear resistance. Now, as someone who always trained

in gear myself throughout my career, I wish this technology was around then. And I got to test it personally while coaching my tactical athlete class a few weeks ago and can testify that it not only simulates the heat retention of frontline gear, but also the lack of mobility, which is imperative at operating at a high level on the fire ground. Now, some additional benefits include being able to doff the gear when you do get banged out for a call, increasing the lifespan of your frontline bunker gear, And then also public education.

Think of the number of times that we allow, for example, schoolchildren to wear our gear when it's infused with all these carcinogens. So there are so many real -world applications for a fraction of the cost of IDLH -rated bunker gear. So if you want to hear the whole story behind this, listen to my conversation with Ryan Conley on episode 1175 of the Behind the Shield podcast, or go to carnabunkergear .com. Welcome to the Behind the Shield podcast. As always, my name

is James Geering, and this week it is my absolute honor to welcome on the show, Port Authority Police Department veteran, former chief of department, and head of rescue and recovery after 9 -11, John Ryan. Now, in this conversation, we discuss a host of topics, from his journey into law enforcement, fighting crime in the 80s and 90s, The nucleus of homelessness, runaways and gangs. The first World Trade Center bombing. 9 -11. The kindness

and compassion of 9 -12. How those responsible still have not been served justice. And so much more. Now I want to add in that as you will hear, I struggle to remember the name of one of my former guests and I wanted to put it in this intro instead. I was referring to Peter Bitwinski, a Port Authority accountant, which was episode 1005. Now, before we get to this incredible conversation, as I say every week, please just take a moment.

Go to whichever app you listen to this on. Subscribe to the show. Leave feedback and leave a rating. Every single five -star rating truly does elevate this podcast, therefore making it easier for others to find. And this is a free library of over 1 ,300 episodes now. So all I ask in return is that you help share these incredible men and women's stories so I can get them to every single

person on planet Earth who needs to hear them. So with that being said... I introduce to you, John Ryan. Enjoy. Well, John, I want to start

by saying two things. Firstly, thank you to our mutual friend, Sarah Wilkinson, for making this connection. And secondly, I want to welcome you onto the Behind the Shield podcast today. Thanks for having me. And thanks for taking Sarah's suggestion there. So it means a lot to me on both parts. Well, I mean, likewise, this is the interesting thing. You know, when people, when I started the podcast a long time ago, people said, aren't you afraid that you're going to run out of people to interview? And I said, no,

there's not enough days in the week to interview all these people. And the more people I have as a guest on the show, the more when someone says, oh, I think you should listen to this person. Obviously, you know, if Sarah Wilkinson suggests someone, then, you know, you're like, okay, that must be a good person. And here we are. So thank you again. There's a thread that runs through all of us that has brought us together through a lot of, you know, sad and also, you know, uplifting events. Absolutely. And we were just talking

before we hit record about Will Jimenez, which we'll get into, but that's another, you know, mutual thread. So, yeah. Well, let's start at the very beginning. Where on planet Earth are we even finding you today? So today I'm in Long Island, New York, and actually in Seaford, Long Island. So tell me where you were born and tell me a little bit about your family dynamic, what your parents did, how many siblings. So I was

born in Brooklyn, Brooklyn, New York there. I have three siblings there, a sister, two brothers, all from Brooklyn. Poor, but good people. My father had a cleaning business there for uniforms that were commonly used there with the construction.

And the long showmen there that were very close to where we lived, but also where he had his store. You mentioned about the... The connection you have with the World Trade, even prior to you putting the uniform on, was that part of the connection? It was, you know, when we grew up in South Brooklyn there, where, you know, during the time that we were growing up, you know, was not a very good neighborhood there. So to keep me out of trouble there, I had a very

Brooklyn activity there. I flew pigeons on the roof of the house that I lived in there. So, looking south, actually southwest, I actually was observing the original World Trade Center being built from the roof of the house in Brooklyn. Interesting. What about sports and exercise? What were you playing and doing as a young man?

So, I played baseball, basketball, pretty much all the urban sports. uh sports there not too many uh you know uh football players came from that area there uh your you know soccer was just really starting there but you know primarily it was baseball and uh basketball and what about career aspirations did you have members of your family in police and fire or was there something even something else in your mind at the time

Yeah, no, no immediate family in police or fire, but, you know, family friends that were in the police department, you know, in in South Brooklyn at that time there, you know, there was a lot of a lot of fires. Unfortunately, there are a lot of the buildings there were, you know, being set on fire. You know, so I got to see all of that activity there. Along with the police activity there, there was a methadone clinic not too far from where we grew up there. And, you know, that

drew a lot of police activity there. So it sort of created an early interest, you know, in both those fields, but more importantly, in the police field. I know when I listen to, you know, the generation that were firefighters then. And when you were a firefighter post 9 -11, it's very strange to hear that there was violence and animosity towards the firefighters especially. But that's what you hear from the war years sometimes in some of the boroughs. So were you seeing that

firsthand as a young man? Not so much from the violence towards firefighters there, but definitely the fire activity there in the 60s and 70s there. you know, what they would call, you know, lightning there. A lot of set fires there that were burning buildings down there, you know, as part of the pre -gentrifications and neighborhoods there. Instead of demolishing them there and rebuilding there, they used to set them on fire. You know,

and a lot of times it also was, you know, where they would be dumping trash. So it was sort of a way of, you know, getting rid of the trash. They would light a fire and, you know, and then... require an FDNY response to it. And not so much in Brooklyn, but there were some areas there that was sort of like a conversion from early housing to industrial areas there. And a lot of those areas there where the early housing was there would get burnt down there to clear

space for the construction of more industrial. areas there, especially in South Brooklyn. But a lot of what you were talking about there in regards to the violence there occurred in other boroughs like the Bronx and upper Manhattan. It's so foreign for us. And I've seen violence against firefighters even in Paris with some of the protesters doing the same thing. But I think most of us in the American Fire Service, it's very rare to have violence against one of

us. I've had people on the show that were stabbed and some other people that were a victim of violence. But when you hear about the way that that particular profession was viewed back then in certain areas of the country. It's almost hard to wrap your head around when you've been a firefighter in a younger generation. Yeah. So New York is kind of unique in that sense there is that the firefighters have always been viewed favorably because they respond to people in their time of need as opposed

to the police. Not so much today there, but during the 80s and 90s, you sort of had a lot of the violence towards the fire department was coming from the police department and vice versa. There was a lot of conflict there between the two agencies back then there, especially at scenes of incidents. What was the origin of that, knowing how well most agencies work together these days? Well,

you know, the origin of it was really sort of, you know, competition there between the fire department and the NYPD, especially from an ESU emergency service unit standpoint there. So a lot of times they're at scenes of vehicle accidents and, you know, not so much fires, but vehicle accidents and other, you know, things there where they would. be, uh, a need for people like trained, uh, either, you know, FDNY special operations

command or, you know, um, NYPD ESU units there. So there was a lot of times there when, if they came on the scene together, um, you know, it, it actually resulted in fisticuffs, you know. So what changed? How, how were they able to kind of figure out, um, a way of allocating the specialties and reducing the conflict? Under the Giuliani administration there, they created the Office of Emergency Management, and they chose representatives

from all of the different agencies, departments there. And they came up with a SIMS document, City Incident Management System, that sort of defined which departments had roles in specific emergencies there. So between that and having the representatives from the Office of Emergency Management on scene as responders back then to basically act as referees there to keep the people from fighting. So, you know, that sort of quelled

it at that time. It's interesting to just hear little snippets of history like that. I mean, if you look far enough back in the fire service history, they were different. fire brigades fighting with each other so it's we've come a long way that's for sure yeah no i mean you know if you go really back in the the history of new york there you know there was separate fire departments brooklyn had their own queens had their own manhattan had their own you know and it was then unified under the the fdny And the same thing with the

NYPD. That's a more recent history there. You had the New York City Transit Police Department, New York City Housing Police Department, and that was all merged under Giuliani there into the one NYPD. So going back to your kind of journey into uniform, you mentioned that you knew of police officers. What was it that sent you down? the pursuit of law enforcement and why did you choose the port authority specifically so you

know not only myself there but a lot of people growing up in in that area of brooklyn there you know it was sort of like a way of uh you know um moving up in a sense there you know it's like uh civil service jobs they're offered you you know a steady uh job you know benefits and pay you know and so A lot of people from those areas there, people that stayed out of trouble, either took the FDNY test, the NYPD test. But

as I mentioned earlier there, actually watching the construction of the World Trade Center there, the first World Trade Center there from the roof there flying pigeons. I also had friends of mine there that once they were complete, actually... started working there as guides on the observation deck. And they mentioned to me that there was some openings there. And I wound up taking an

application there, applied for it there, and wound up getting a job as a guide at the observation deck there at the World Trade Center there. So that was really my first introduction, not only to the World Trade Center, but also to the Port Authority. So for people listening, most of us are naive. Explain the difference between the jurisdictions of the Port Authority versus NYPD. Yeah, so the, you know, the Port Authority, you know, always has lived in the shadows of the

NYPD there. 35 ,000 member of police department there, you know, I mean, and just by their reputation there and also, you know. TV shows, NYPD Blue, you know, all of the shows there that, you know, we used to laugh and say that there would never be a PAPD Blue television show there. But the difference is, is that the Port Authority Police Department is a bi -state agency. They're actually the, which might have changed now, but at that,

at one point, they were the 26th largest police department in the United States. You know, and they have bi -state jurisdiction. They have, full police powers in the entire state of New York and the entire state of New Jersey, because a lot of the areas that they patrol actually touch both of those states. So that's the primary difference between them. The other thing there that's different is that they perform the aircraft

rescue firefighting. So not only are they... Police officers in two states, but they also, in a lot of cases, there are firefighters there that perform a form of specialized firefighting there at the area airports, Newark, JFK, LaGuardia, Teterboro. So they're unique in that sense as well as that some of the firefighters that I know there, I used to always kid them there and tell them. You know, if you look at a Port Authority

police fire truck there, you know, the thing that makes it special is that the word police is on it. You know, so, you know, it sort of distinguishes it there. But, you know, they provide a very high level of service, a very high level of training, you know, and it's for that unique function. So the other part of it there is that, you know, you really can't come into or out of New York, you know, without encountering or. going through a Port Authority facility. So the

Port Authority Police are the primary jurisdiction in all of those locations, including the World Trade Center, as they were around 9 -11. Now, why the World Trade Center specifically and not some of the other high -rises in New York? Because it's a connection, not only... It was actually built by the Port Authority in New York and New Jersey to bring... world trade together into one structure one 16 acre um area in low manhattan

there um and in doing that there they uh you know they they construction constructed the world trade center but they also um have that in the base of it there the port authority trans hutchlin railroad so it's another bi -state uh connection there because you have the path trains that run from new jersey into new york bringing people into the world trade center complex and other areas in manhattan so you find yourself being

a guide on the observation tower firstly talk to me about that role what was that like even in that time yeah it was basically i mean you know it's kind of funny how you know things transition over time there but um you know it was a uh a job there that provided you with a lot of knowledge about not only the World Trade Center, but also not only Manhattan, but all of the five boroughs, pretty much everything that was within sight of the observatory at the top of the World Trade

Center. So you became very knowledgeable about other buildings, other areas of the skyline. And depending on how clear it was that day there, you could see all the way up to West Point. and actually see the curvature of the earth if it was a really clear day, like in the fall this time of the year, you know, from that area, from up top. So, you know, so your job was to, you know, provide information. They did have some scripted, you know, speeches there that you did,

you know, if you had a post on the elevator that was taking tourists and other people up to the observation deck there. Yeah, primarily was to provide information and guidance to people that were visiting the area. I had a guest on, and I hope my tiny little brain isn't going to let me down. He worked for Port Authority as a civilian. He was one of two men that helped carry a wheelchair -bound colleague down. They made it out, and he's also one of the guides in the 9 -11 Museum.

I think, was it Richard? It's like a Polish last name. Does that ring a bell? um it does i just can't recall his name there yeah there was a number of uh port authority civilians there you know just you know a lot of people don't realize this there you know and um a lot of other agencies you know in specific to the fdny there because of the losses that they suffered on 9 11 there you know sort of have uh monopolized 9 11 in some ways but a lot of people don't realize there

that you know the world trade center was the Port Authority's headquarters as well. Not only did they construct it there, but that was also where all of their executive offices were. And like any large, so the World Trade Center itself had its own zip code. And like any large municipality there, because of the volume of people and services that the World Trade Center provided there, specialties

there so besides the executive officers there they had maintenance they had automotive they had pretty much everything that would mirror a municipality there as far as services there so a lot of those civilians there you know being as familiar with the buildings as they were you know on 9 11 and predating 9 11 going all the way back to the 1993 attack you know um really assumed the role of uh responders on that day and were guiding people to the best location

that they could escape from the horrific occurrences that were taking place. And as a result of it, 47 of them lost their lives as well. The reason I brought him up, and again, like yourself, I just cannot remember the name, and I apologize, was he was talking about working there prior and conversations about... you know the fear of a plane hitting obviously because they were so high but also at this point and i think this was in the 90s when he was working there the

diligence with which they were performing a lot of the drills i think he was there in the first attack too um and how that had improved after the first attack so now we're going all the way back to the 70s what was the conversation when you were on the observation tower as far as you know the the the fear of some sort of aircraft hitting and then the emergency procedures back then? So when they first constructed the World Trade Center there, it was actually constructed

with that in mind, and it was based on an incident that had occurred at the Empire State Building. So a military aircraft was flying over New York during a very foggy night. and wound up crashing into the Empire State Building. So when they constructed the World Trade Center, they took into consideration there what was the largest aircraft at that time so that it would withstand the impact of what was considered to be the greatest

impact of an aircraft. And so then besides the aircraft, We were living in a different period at that time. There really wasn't thought of that aircraft would be used as a weapon. It was more geared towards an accident, like had occurred in the previous incident that I talked about at the Empire State Building. So walk me through

then how you went from that role to trying to be a law enforcement officer. I had taken a series of tests. I had taken the NYPD test. I had taken the FDNY test. I had taken a Port Authority police test. I think, you know, my memory serves me right. I had taken the New York State police test and had taken a number of them. And I actually got called by the NYPD first and, you know, was

going through the process of that there. And actually, just as I was finishing up the process for the NYPD, and actually starting their academy there, I got called for the Port Authority Police. And I was driving my investigator from the NYPD crazy there because, like I said, there I had family friends that were on the NYPD there. And, you know, that was really, you know, my intentions was to join that department there. And the Port

Authority Police Department, just at that point, you know, also had a very strange work chart that, you know, instead of having two days off, they counted the number of hours between, you know, when you finish up a day tour and then you're off one day and then the next day you would come back at midnight, but you'd have 48 hours off in between. And that wasn't something that I was really interested in there. But that changed. And, you know, they had adopted a similar

work chart to the NYPD. So I wound up taking the Port Authority Police position, you know, and again, you know, had reservations about it there. But, you know, the job is a very appealing job. You know, a lot of different opportunities. You know, when I first went on, I was actually assigned at the John F. Kennedy Airport there. So, you know, being a kid from South Brooklyn, they're not really having much access to planes

or, you know, so it was really a very intriguing, you know, opportunity for me. You know, I spent, you know, very little time there. And then, you know. Being more comfortable, you know, in the city environment there, you know, I wound up, you know, accepting a transfer to 42nd Street Times Square, the Port Authority bus terminal, you know, where I wound up spending, you know, like 23 years, you know, prior to 9 -11, you know, in various roles from a juvenile officer.

You know, I mean, at that time in the 80s and 90s, you know, Times Square was really no man's land. You know, and being a juvenile officer there, you know, really, you know, gave you the opportunity to help a lot of people that were in crisis there, you know, either being victims of human trafficking or runaways who, you know, had family issues, you know, and then besides being a youth service officer, part of that,

you know, very world renowned. Port Authority Police Youth Services Unit there. I was also a CPOP, a community police officer, you know, and that position sort of came about as they were trying to transition Times Square into becoming Disney. So it was kind of funny there. I remember going to the first meeting there with the, they had created this Times Square Business Improvement District there. When Times Square was really filled with porn and prostitution and all kinds

of other deviant activity there, robberies. And they were talking about how Disney was going to transition it there. And I turned to the person next to me there and said, it may look like Disney, but it won't be Disney characters. How hard was it to get hired back in the late 70s when you were trying? So that was another thing there that sort of played into it there is that right

around 1977, New York City had gone through a very bad period there. They had a fiscal crisis and they were actually laying off police officers for the first time. So that sort of played into my selection of the Port Authority police as well there because the NYPD at that time was not considered as secure a job. And they actually, at the same time that I got hired there, they had actually hired a number of NYPD people that

had been laid off there and had taken the Port Authority police test there and came on board as well. Even when I was testing to become a firefighter, and we're talking 2003, 2004, when I was actually trying to get hired. It was incredibly competitive. And I've used that as kind of a barometer for recruitment, how it used to be, how it should be versus what we're seeing now. Now, you have a career that spans numerous decades.

Through your eyes, what are the things that have contributed to a lesser recruitment? And if you were king for a day, what would you change to inspire young men and women to put the uniform on? So, you know, and just talking Port Authority Police specific there, you know, in the 80s and 90s there, you know, so we sort of have always had to, because we worked within the confines of bigger agencies, either the NYPD on the New

York side, Newark, Jersey City, Fort Lee, other police departments on the Jersey side, including the New Jersey State Police. So in a lot of ways, we sort of became, you know, better at policing than all of those agencies combined because we had to adapt to their agency. You know, so like in New York, you know, if you made an arrest, you know, you had to process it through the NYPD

system, the court system, but as well as, you know, their system. you know vouchering evidence and and other things there so um you know like anything in life there you know when you uh have to learn other people's um you know uh methods you know and makes you a better person and a better in this case, better police officer there, because not only do you know your system, but you get to know their system as well. And a lot

of those bigger agencies there, there's a lot of turnover. People move from one unit to another. Whereas with the Port Authority Police Department there, unless you take a transfer or go to the aircraft rescue firefighting, you're pretty much in the same place, same command, could be for your entire career. Knowledge is power. When you learn things there and you become good at it, in a lot of cases there, if you're interacting

with these other agencies there, they sort of even came to depend upon us as subject matter experts of their systems. Very interesting. Well, going back to Times Square then. So you go from JFK to Times Square. Firstly, paint the picture. As far as gang activity, homelessness, runaway, sex trafficking, the things that you saw then, because if someone goes and stands in Times Square now, they're not going to obviously have the same experience as, you know, 40 years prior.

Yeah. So, you know, Times Square back then there was pretty much like I described earlier is no man's land. And, you know, all of those activities that you just described, runaway, homeless, you know, it was sort of, you know. repository there for all of those activities there. So, you know, people, homeless tended to gather there, you know, either to seek shelter at the Port Authority, you know, or Penn Station, you know, or the transit

systems. And also because, you know, it gave them a ready source of income from the panhandling, you know, with the people that were commuting through those areas there. So from a runaway standpoint there, you know, it was always an area that attracted or seemed to attract people, you know, from out of state there. And then, you know, from a crime standpoint there, you had a lot of prostitution, you had pimps, you

had, you know, gangs, you had drug activity, you had porn theaters. you know uh legal uh activity there and you know just if you were to go back there and look at the history uh you know in in particular during the the 70s 80s 90s and probably even before that there but um you know a lot of the uh very newsworthy crime you know

either occurred in that area or had a connection to it there you know some i mean even some serial killers there that you know um uh were arrested there not specifically in times square but you know when their activity was uh looked at there you know it had links to it there you know and then what really sort of changed and made it even worse was in the uh the late 80s early 90s there you know you had the crack epidemic and um Ninth Avenue in the 40s, adjacent to Times

Square, was really looked at as the birthplace of crack. Because of the impact that it had on people's systems and their desire for it. amount of robberies that were occurred to fuel their crack crazed, you know, addictions, you know, was significant. I mean, I remember working one Sunday, I was actually having breakfast in one of the restaurants there on 4218. And, you know,

I saw, you know, a couple being robbed, and I went out and, you know, grabbed the person that was robbing them. And, you know, like, Actually, what happened was there was a couple and the husband was walking. He had a gold chain on there. They were from New Jersey. And a person ripped the gold chain off. He started to chase him and then had a heart attack in chasing him. When he went down, his wife bent down to help him, put her purse down. And a guy came and grabbed the purse. I grabbed that guy. And within 10

feet, there was another group robbing somebody else. On 42nd Street between 7th and 8th Avenue on that day, there were over 50 robberies. If you were to go fast forward to today, there's not 50 robberies in the entire city. So that just gives you a window into how crazy it was back then. And a lot of it was, like I said, was driven by the crack addictions. It's really

interesting trying to reverse engineer. how we get to a place like that. Because as I said, there's no toddler in the world that's dreaming of becoming homeless or a prostitute one day. It's the way that their life unfolds. And were their mentors positive or were they negative? Going back to when you were working with juveniles, what did you see as a common denominator of the backgrounds that was sending them into, whether it was running away, finding themselves being trafficked, finding themselves being addicts,

et cetera? You know, so that was kind of interesting there is that there was really no one like, you know, cookie cutter, you know, way of looking at that there. You know, there were kids there that came from really, you know, good families and very well to do families there. But, you know, there was always an attraction to Times Square. You know, I guess, you know, it's pretty much like there is today there. And, you know, everybody wants to come to Times Square on New Year's Eve, you know, or, you know, just to. see the activities, see the billboards and stuff like that there. But there was also an element

there that we sort of viewed or not viewed, but dealt with there. They were sort of like throwaway kids, kids that grew up in urban areas there that really didn't have a lot of family structure and wound up migrating and joining gangs. And then we used in a lot of ways. to either transport guns or drugs. Myself included, we were involved in a lot of what became precedent -setting arrests

of juveniles there under the runaway statute because they were transporting guns or drugs there that had impact and served as a guide to law enforcement throughout the entire state. So they were precedent -setting cases there that reinforced the use of the runaway statue to stop somebody, search them, and recover contraband. But what was always surprising to a lot of people

is that they didn't realize the volume of numbers that we dealt with. So in the height of that there, that youth services unit there, we would have as many as 3 ,000. contacts with kids that were either just traveling through or were involved in some type of illegal activity in the Times Square area. And a lot of it was also where they were being victimized by human trafficking, by

the pimps that had a presence in the area as well. So they used to basically either have people that served as spotters there to look for these kids. And if they were unattended, try to lure them into going with them there and wind up being victimized there in the sex trade that was rampant throughout the area. But that was really our function was to... to try to prevent them before

they got introduced into the street environment there and returned them home or to the group home. And the other thing is that right adjacent to the Times Square area, there was a runaway structure called the Covenant House that was a shelter for young women. While it served a very useful purpose, it also served as an attraction. They had a 10 o 'clock curfew, and a lot of them

had come from the five boroughs. So when they were allowed to leave the Covenant House there, they would go out and hang out with their boyfriends or friends that came from the five boroughs. And then at the completion of that there, They'd go back to coming in house because there was a 10 o 'clock curfew. And then their friends would go on rampages throughout Times Square, robbing people, selling drugs and other illegal activity. What about the violence from the gangs?

When you look at the origin story, kind of post -Vietnam, a lot of these gangs, especially in the California side, arguably initially it is a group of certain colors or creeds that are staying together so that they're not being preyed upon. by whoever it is that's around them. And it would appear that it was really the introduction of drug sales that really turned the gangs into the violence a lot of us know, certainly the 80s and 90s especially. What were you seeing,

if anything, when you first put the uniform on versus the 80s and 90s? To your point there, a lot of it was drug -fueled. So they were either sellers or buyers. And then if they were buyers, to feed their addictions there, they would be committing crime, robberies and everything else there. If they were the sellers there, they were usually connected to some of the street gangs, either Bloods, MS -13 there. But the Times Square

area was pretty much the gang activity was Bloods. And then you had other... criminal activity there. You had, you know, a lot of it was, you know, scams, you know, the shell games, you know, the three -card Monty dealers there, you know, people selling, you know, what looked like, you know, a VCR in a box there that was filled with newspapers, you know, all kinds of street activity. And then

the other thing was, you know, you had the window washers there that you know so when people were driving into the city because they were afraid to take public transportation and they'd stop at a light and then uh you know the squeegee people would uh you know inundate them there and you know basically shake them down there like you know not to damage their car you know by um you know uh hitting it with one of the squeegees or something else there you know so um you know it was really you know uh uh we said

it Many, many times there was like being in the bar scene in, you know, Star Wars. You know, there was all kinds of characters there, you know, that basically became the, you know, the faces of Times Square. But the drug activity was really what fueled, you know, a lot of the violence there because either they were, you know, addicted to crack and, you know, and the addiction was so good, so great there that they,

you know it overcame their desire to eat and and everything else there so to try to get money to buy crack there they would commit violent robberies there you know with the from a police standpoint there you know it was really more you know to protect the commuters that were coming in to work in the city so we um combined between the papd the nypd back then the new york city transit police um you know we created what we described as basically sheep runs it was like

you know specific streets and and and avenues there that they'd be a higher police presence on so sort of to protect you know the sheep or the people in this case they're going through those corridors here to go to work you know the the problems would arise there where you know sometimes people would come into the city and then they'd wander off of those you know main thoroughfares there to side streets there that were less protected and had a less police presence there and then become victims, you know, so.

This is always an interesting question to ask anyone in law enforcement. I think, you know, again, someone with a career that span the length that yours has is be interesting. When, when I first started this podcast, keep this very short, because a lot of people heard the story, but my mom had moved to Portugal. She's been there 25 years now. And she said to me, Hey, did you know what they did about addiction in Portugal? And basically, they had had a huge epidemic. A lot of Portuguese soldiers went over

to one of their former colonies or current colonies in a war, came back and brought basically a heroin addiction back, crippled the country. Addiction was rampant. And they had tried the lock them all up model, and it just wasn't working. And Portugal is a very interesting dynamic because they really are very kind of democratic in the way. They make decisions and they ask the people and they kind of vote as a nation. And so they tried something different where they took addicts,

not smugglers, not dealers, but addicts from the criminal side and put them into the health side and put a lot of the funding into mental health counseling, addiction counseling, job creation, housing, and they completely reversed their issue. And it's now in a lot of the world held as like the model when it comes to that. Without loading the question, though, I think it's an incredible model, but without loading the question, through your eyes, has the Arrest

the Addicts model worked for you? Or is there another way that you would do it if you were king for a day, having seen decades of struggles through your eyes? So sadly, people, once they get involved in drugs, for the most part, it's like a 95 % failure rate. of trying to rehabilitate them you know um and sadly you know you sort of saw them transition from you know being somewhat normal looking your normal weight uh you know

to being you know during especially during the crack period you know whether you'd see them their desire to smoke crack over overwhelmed their system and then they'd stop eating you know they'd spend all their money or whatever they stole or you know on crack And you'd start to see there, they'd start to lose weight. And, you know, if they didn't overdose or die from, you know, the drug affliction, you know, when

they were transported to rehab, you know, you'd see them come back, you know, and really it was the area there that was part of the addiction because you'd seen them come back and they'd be all cleaned up. And then they go through the whole cycle again of, you know, addiction there. And sadly, I mean, you know, most of them died off, you know. You know, today with marijuana being, you know, the drug of choice, you know, there's less of that there. But there's also

issues, you know, that have impact on society as a whole. I mean, you can't walk through a street in New York without being engulfed in, you know, the odor of marijuana. The legalization may have lessened the number of people that get arrested, but the impact that it has both on their personal lives, but the impact that it

has on society there is still not where it should be yet. I think this is what's interesting. If you look at the Northwest and some of these other areas that have made it, They've only decriminalized, but they haven't put the funding in. How do we get people better? And I think the concept that someone becomes an addict because there's a void that they're trying to fill, alcohol, gambling, infidelity, drugs, whatever it is, I think that's the missing piece. And you hit it perfectly. If you take an addict who's clean, you put them

back in the exact same environment they were high before. what are their chances of success? You take someone who put them on a diet and then you put them back into eating, you know, fried food and no exercise, same thing. So, but it is interesting, you know, listening to people that have, you know, literally seen it for years and years and years and just getting their perspective of, you know, what elements might work and what elements, you know, would be a big challenge. Yeah, no, and that's the thing there. So, you know, I mean, and then you had other things there along the way, you know, you had the AIDS epidemic there, you know, which really got its, you know,

start also, sadly, in the not too far from the Times Square area, you know, there was St. Clair's Hospital was sort of, you know, viewed as the, you know, the AIDS hospital there, you know, but a lot of that. grew out of you know drug addiction there sharing and needles you know um uh there used to be a um a blood bank on 40th street and eighth avenue there and you know uh people that like myself that worked in the area you know on you know it was closed on weekends there but on monday morning there you'd see all of the uh the homeless and everybody else lining

up to donate blood you know because they would get and be getting paid to either you know, fund their drug addictions or their alcohol addictions, you know. So, and, you know, sadly, you know, I mean, fast forward to today, you know, a lot of those people that are addicted to drugs, there were a result of injuries there, you know, where they were given, you know, pain medication as a result of their injury and their rehab for

the injury and then became addicted to it. So drugs are a very dangerous element in our society there, either from an addiction standpoint there or from an illegal activity standpoint there. But from a victim standpoint there, it's really the key is to prevent people from getting involved in it there. Because like I said, 95 % of the people there, there's no... rehab for them you

know once they're involved in drugs you know they basically you know become a dependent upon it there to the point there that you know they can't function without it you know so talk to me about Giuliani and what the the principles were that turned Times Square from this very dangerous area in New York to the tourist trap that we see today so it Really had to do with the introduction of Disney at the time, you know,

and being an anchor, you know, element there that was going to provide, you know, clean entertainment there as opposed to the numerous porno theaters and other, you know, illicit activity. And then being supported by the businesses there, you know, so there was a lot of money being made by the illegal activities there. The prostitution, the porn. So they had to turn that page there.

So they created the Times Square Business Improvement District. And what that did was that provided services that sort of mirrored the city's services there, whether it be sanitation services, there were private security that created a better sense of safety. cleaning up the graffiti, changing the codes to close down the porn theaters, and

arresting the low -level quality of life offenses there, whether it be panhandling, prostitution. And really, it transitioned the whole area and made it... where people could come to Times Square safely. And then it was really a transformation, not only at Times Square, but of the entire city.

So you had eight years of Giuliani, and then you had 12 years of Mayor Bloomberg after that. So I describe it there at the end of that 20 -year period, which in a lot of cases with police and fire, it was a career. That's really what changed the entire complex, complexion of the city. And it was really, I describe it as like, it was like utopia, because the city was clean and crime was low. And I would have no problem

recommending people to come to the city and experience it. Under the Bloomberg administration, you had the creation of the High Line, which was an elevated park that utilized an abandoned train tracks there that ran along the west side and turned it into a really beautiful park. You had the redevelopment of the waterfront. I mean, at the end of the day, Manhattan's an island. You know, and not only Manhattan, but Brooklyn, Queens

had waterfront areas there. And those gentrifications are still continuing today. So they really, you know, made it to the point there that, you know, at the height of that there, besides the city being clean and safe, you know, you also had tourism that reached almost 70 million people. You know, so New York became that go to place because people felt safe coming here. You know, and there was a lot to. as there is today but today you know the safety isn't what it was then

you know did when you when you kind of zoom out did it send the people that were the problem to other areas or did you create an environment that was so hard to to be in the criminal world that you actually deterred other people from going into it well there was a number of things there that were done you know under those administrations there was also um you know there was a significant reduction in the welfare roles um you know which

also you know tended to be a lot of people there that were dependent on the services there so you know if they would supplement their um you know their benefits there with criminal activity there or panic handling you know so um It was really the whole change of that quality of life, you know, so if you were driving into the city, you know, whereas before, you know, you might have been stopped at a light and, you know, a squeegee person came up and that sort of set the tone as to how you felt about your visit

to New York. That was all stopped, you know, because they would get arrested, you know, and they would, you know, be, they also established, you know, community courts, courts there that, you know, these low level. uh you know crimes you know or uh or um offenses there would be steered towards there and then they'd have to clean you know the street or do some other public service type of a you know uh a sentence you know so it really you know it took away the the

entitlement programs and reduced the the ranks of people you know that were getting basically handouts um um and The key thing there was that as serious crime dropped and the police were addressing these quality of life offenses there, it really gave a sense of safe movement throughout the city there. And it was a more pleasant experience

for people. Absolutely. I wish we'd see that with the millionaires and billionaires too. Richard Sackler from Purdue Pharma that was behind OxyContin being made to clean out trash from the parks and that kind of thing. Yeah. No, and that's the thing is that there's a lot of layers of responsibility for things. And sadly, a lot of people that are on the bottom of that. spectrum there are the ones that get victimized there

you know either true you know entitlement programs in which they become dependent you know um as opposed to being you know self -sufficient members of society um you know um and then it becomes a a challenge and impacts all the other services absolutely yes so whether it be housing i mean just recently did you see you know how poorly You know, the big cities, New York, Chicago,

you know, San Francisco, I mean, you know, created these sanctuary cities, you know, which then drew, you know, people there that were dependent upon services there. And, you know, again, the quality of life went down. You know, they were in New York, they were putting them up in hotels, you know, so which then. Since they were being paid by the federal government there to house people there, there was no incentive there to

maintain their facilities and use it for tourism. So you see the tourism numbers drop, and then it becoming, instead of a positive thing, it becomes more of a plight on the city. This is what I see over and over again. a political dive, but overall, just the pendulum is constantly at the extreme rather than in the middle, which

is, yes, there are certain groups that need to be brought in and welcomed and taken care of. But there's also a limit on how many and making sure that you're primarily taking care of the people that are already here. And I think that this is what's very sad is you see these extremes used to make a political point rather than just to make the country better and take care of everyone. Yeah, I mean, you know, and if you look at history, I mean, this is really nothing new in that sense there. I mean, if you go back to when the ships

were coming into Ellis Island there, you know, there was a screening process, you know, and unlike here where people either walk across or fly into the country, you know, back then, you know, they... They spent time on a ship and then they got here and they were screened. And in a lot of cases there, if they had health issues or things that they thought would be detrimental to society, they were turned around and sent back. You know, so, you know, it's that element

of, you know, screening is nothing new. You know, it's just again, you know. No matter how great a country you are as our country is, there is limits to what you can do. We can't be the savior to the entire world. That's why they have the State Department and other assets there that go and provide services there to try to develop

countries. to a point there that, you know, they can sustain their own populations as opposed to, you know, sending them here. Absolutely. Well, speaking of international communities, let's talk about February 26th, 1993. So on February 26th there, you know, you had Ramzi Youssef and several others. you know uh attacked the world

trade center setting off a van uh full of a you know uh explosives in the underground garage of the world trade center you know and um you know and these are the things there that sort of you know get lost in a lot of this there is that you know in 93 there it killed six people um and not that anyone life is any more important than any other life uh one of those six people was a a woman by the name of Monica Rodriguez

Smith. You know, she was actually from Ecuador. You know, and her and her husband, Ed Smith, you know, had gotten up that morning. You know, she was seven months pregnant at the time. And the only reason she was going into work that day, that was going to be her last day at work, was because her office mates were giving her a baby shower. And, you know, she got up, her and her husband had breakfast. They had already selected a name for their son. He was going to be a junior. You know, he kissed his wife goodbye.

And hours later, that all changed when she was one of the six people that was killed, you know, in the underground parking garage. But four of those six people were Port Authority employees, civilians, including Monica Rodriguez -Smith. You know, and over 1 ,003 people were injured as well. It was sort of a wake -up call because prior to the attack, the Port Authority Police Department had done a vulnerability assessment

of all of its facilities there that were under their jurisdiction. And they had actually identified in the World Trade Center a vulnerability of the underground parking garages. You know, to your earlier point there, you know, a lot of the upscale businesses and tenants of the World Trade Center, you know, didn't want to be impacted by having a screening process. You know, so they didn't institute those. And, you know, the van

was allowed to get into the underground garage, detonate, you know, and cause damage beyond just a loss of life. It led to enhancements of the World Trade Center to the point there that a lot of lives were saved on 9 -11 as a result of the 1993 attack. What impact did that event have just on the Port Authority family? I mean, such a devastating attack, not only on your real

estate, but so many of your men and women were either killed or injured. So the 93 attack, there was sort of a wake -up call. not only for the Port Authority Police Department, the Port Authority, and the country as a whole, because I think there was this disbelief that we could be attacked. And terrorism was sort of a new entity that came into play. And the other thing is that it was

sort of like this disbelief because the explosion had occurred. below ground you know in the parking garages there other than in the initial day of the attack there we sort of smoke and and the windows were broken out and people were coming out and distressed there from being exposed to the smoke um you know the cleanup and the the uh repairs happened relatively quick but but it was not a visual uh scene because the damage

was below grade so uh people really moved on very quickly from it there um you know and to the credit of the port authority i mean they did such a great job in cleaning it up that you know it was and the attack occurred on february 26th the buildings were reoccupied at the end of april so Again, people have short memories there and moved on. And it wasn't until 9 -11

there that if you talk to the families from the 93 attack, that they sort of felt sadly that they finally got recognized for their losses. We still hold a... A ceremony every year on the anniversary of the attack, you know, to gather and remember those lost, but also to interact with the family members. And, you know, again,

like I said, they, you know, sort of felt, you know, overlooked until 9 -11. And now they're included in the family members of the 9 -11 attacks. Before we get to 9 -11 itself. from when you put the uniform on until that point, what were some of the other, we would call career calls that you had? So, you know, again, spending most

of my time up in Times Square there, you know, we also did drug interdiction, you know, so a lot of the couriers there were bringing guns and drugs into the city, you know, using, you know, buses, you know, our Amtrak. You know, so we were very much involved in that there, you know. And then, you know, to your earlier point there, you know, Times Square was sort of the attraction for a lot of people from the

outer boroughs. You know, so they would come there, gangs would come there and get involved in robberies and assaults and stabbing, shootings. You know, there was one day. I said, if I was to do this today, I'd be on the cover of every paper. But, you know, you're talking at a period there was like 2 ,300 homicides in the city. I had gone to roll call and gotten a wanted poster about a person that was wanted for a homicide

in the 23 precinct. And I turned that a roll call. And shortly after turning out, you know, I observed the individual. Took him into custody, contacted the 23 precinct. They came down and, you know, arrested him. You know, actually, I arrested him, but turned him over to them, you know, for processing there. I then turned back out and on 4218, you know, encountered another wanted person that was wanted for a stabbing

homicide in Central Park. So I arrested that person, brought him back, contacted Central Park Precinct. Their detective unit came down, and I turned over custody of him. And then I wound up holding over to the afternoon tour, and there was a person had been robbed and shot and killed for their Shetland coat in the Rockaways. And, you know, we received information that the person

wanted for that shooting there might be looking to flee the city through the Port Authority. And I went out and I was on 41st Street there between 7th and 8th Avenue there. And I observed somebody drinking a beer in front of a bodega that was on that street there wearing a Shetland jacket. And when I walked across and looked across, I could actually see like reddish. reddish tinge on the jacket and uh and arrested him for the uh homicide there in rockaway so but within 16

hours i had arrested three people for um you know uh that were wanted for homicides in the city and like i said if that occurred today you know i would have been on a the cover of uh you know and you know from a a recognition standpoint there um you know uh In today's matrix there, each one of them would have been a medal, an excellent police duty medal. But because it was such a common occurrence back then there, they actually combined all three of them into one

medal. So again, it's just a reflection on how bad it was back then. How dangerous was it to be a police officer as well? Because when you look back at some of the officers in... the LA area during the 80s, you can understand how there really was a war between Crips and Bloods, but also law enforcement and gangs. And it doesn't make some of the things like Rodney King the right thing to do, but you've also got to take

into account what was the environment. And I would argue now, I mean, police officers are being executed while they sit in the car having their lunch, for crying out loud. So I don't think that's a side that people really get to hear. What was the fear from the law enforcement side as far as the danger towards them back then? Yeah, so the one thing that is dramatically different between then and now is that, you know, back then, you know, as bad as things were, you know, we sort of had, we had the feeling that we had

the support of the police department. but also of the district attorney's office. So we were really viewed as the good guys back then. And we really were that thin blue line between complete chaos and not having any sense of safety. So people were happy to see you if they were walking through the area. you know they were happy to

see a police officer there especially if they became a victim you know and you actually apprehended the person there that you know was responsible for the for the crime so um you know but you also had to be careful i mean you know uh you know the mindset was that you could get hurt you know so i mean there wasn't too many days there that you know you didn't involve in some type of you know uh fisticuffs with people from the street there because especially during the crack epidemic you know i mean trying to apprehend them there you always turned into a fight you

know but um you know uh like any you know special operations command you develop skills you know in dealing with the threats that you were faced with you know Do you think that lack of support from administrations is one of the reasons that we struggle on the recruitment and retention side now? Yeah, you know, a lot of people don't realize it, that, you know, and even during those periods there where we felt support, you know, 90 % of the police department's personnel live

off of what 10 % of the people do. You know, it's really that 10 % that's the dividing line between, you know. getting things done and not getting things done. You see people all the time there, police officers basically standing around doing nothing there other than providing a presence, not actively patrolling their neighborhood or their post, engaging people, talking to people.

So what you have today there is that there's really a divide between that. in that community policing there. Back in those days, everybody knew who was the drunk that was hanging out, who was the drug dealer. There was that respect that they had that if you told somebody to move on, They moved on. You know, they didn't become, you know, adversarial. You know, they knew that

if they didn't, you know, that there were consequences to come with that. You know, I always say there that, you know, back in those days there, there wasn't a cop worth the assault that didn't have a box full of knives that they removed from people. You know, they didn't necessarily arrest them, you know, but that little bit of activity, you know, encountering them, patting them down, removing the knife, you know. um you know and then not arresting them you know sort of created a rapport you know as crazy as it sounds is that you know

they said hey you know the cop was in bed he didn't lock me up for having a knife you know um but it primarily it removed the knife you know from their their means of you know getting into a fight now you know stabbing somebody you know so you know all of that um really you know community -based policing, you know, is not what you have today. You know, I mean, everything is challenged. Everything is questioned. You know, so while, you know, stop and frisk really

got out of hand, you know, on the then Commissioner Kelly, you know, and Mayor Bloomberg, you know, we really missed an opportunity there because crime was so low. What they really needed to do was they needed to focus not so much. As they had in the past on the quantity, you know, there was a lot of arrests, a lot of people arrested there that really sort of turned that page and got it to the point that it was really the utopia, the low crime, you know, clean city. You know,

at that point there, instead of continuing those tactics there that they had, you know, the high stop and frisk and other. quality of life things there. They really needed to then focus more on the quality of the arrest, you know, going after the remnants of, you know, the drug dealers, the people that were career criminals, you know, and putting resources into making sure that those cases, you know, you know, when they did arrest

people were, you know. followed through to the point of prosecution and jail. So we really sort of missed an opportunity there because the quantity of crime was so low that we could have really maintained it there. And then you had to change the administrations. You had the Blasio administration there that sort of you know, started the change for bail reform and, you know, the decriminalization

of a lot of the quality of life offenses there that really what the majority of the people, when they encounter those people, you know, you're out to dinner, especially, you know, during a time where they had the outdoor. dining areas because they're covert and stuff like that. And now you're sitting down to dinner and somebody comes up and tries to panhandle you. You know, that's the encounter that sets the tone for how your visit went, you know, that you were, you know, encountered by this person asking you for money. Not so much, you know, the violent crime,

which people were being victimized, but it was really that quality of life encounter that sort of changed people's impression of how the city was, you know. One more thing and I want to go to 9 -11, but one of the things coming from a man who is a firefighter and a paramedic so not in any way shape or form the law enforcement side it strikes me though being a martial artist and understanding you know the the the application of force and the uh the um what's that term oh

my goodness i'm blanking on it anyway um that if you have one police officer in a car then it really is which of those two individuals is the larger of that equation. So if you have a big, strong police officer that's an athlete, they are great at their defensive tactics, they're a good marksman, then the chances of the perceived

criminal of doing something bad is going to be a lot less. But if the person that gets out is a six -month rookie, who's 110 pounds and maybe hasn't been held to a fitness standard or you know trained to a high level now that equation has shifted but where i feel as a complete you know um white belt looking at law enforcement that there's the ability to offset that quite significantly is if you have two people to a car and now it's the force multiplier that's the term i was looking at now you've not you

know it's not just two you've kind of multiplied those bodies so if you've got one person who is trying to be arrested and you've got two well -trained officers, now the chances of having to kill that person, for example, diminish rapidly. Through my very naive eyes, what is your perspective on one versus two officers per car? Yeah, so when I have the front view of having done this

for 45 years, it's really not the numbers. you know it's the uh demeanor and you know the the street smarts and the um you know the verbal aggression that a person you know a police officer sets there when they they take control of a situation there um you know i mean the thing you see today there that which you know sort of irks me in a lot of ways there because you know when i was

um you know a street cop there you know for the most part i work by myself maybe you know um one or two never really more than another officer um you know say your your your street smarts and your observation skills there were you know a lot better today everything is a group you know as a strategic response group you know or critical response group. So everything is done

in groups. And there was a funny situation there is that a lot of those police officers that are parts of those units there, they're basically more of a visual deterrent. It's like they don't have any independent police responsibilities there. Everything is like sort of just an image post. So there was one of them there was on duty in Times Square and they actually, you know,

again, that that isolation there, which I don't think is a good thing. He was behind, you know, the bike racks, the you know, that they use to control the direction and crowds. And there was a person there that was sort of taunting him. And rather than have that conversation with that person there, that particular officer dialed 311. Because he saw it wasn't an imminent threat,

but he was feeling uncomfortable that this person was taunting him. So he had learned that you only use 911 for a crime, but you can call 311 for a non... emergency type of reason. And not so much for a police officer, but for, you know, for the citizens of the city. So he wound up calling 311 and saying that, you know, that this person was taunting him. So needless to say, you know, he experienced quite a significant

amount of ribbing afterwards, you know, once everybody got to the scene and realized that it was the cop that was calling 311, you know. So, but that's what I mean about, you know. uh street smarts there you know if you will look at the history of policing in new york in particular um you know or in new jersey and newark you know jersey city you know there weren't groups of cops on you know uh you know due to staffing shortages and everything else there you know it was basically one or two cops that you know

uh patrolled a specific post or area uh you know and as a result of it there they If they were good, like I said, 90 % of the police departments live off of what 10 % of the people do. Today, it's probably like 98 % live off of what 2 % try to do. But everything is a group mentality there, and that doesn't lend to developing those street smarts that you need to be a good, active police officer. So, you know, they need to really

and, you know, a lot of that comes from also knowing there that you have the support not only of the police department, but also of the district attorney's office, you know, as opposed to being viewed in a negative fashion there. And that's sort of why they migrated to more of these group, you know, responses there is that, you know, it's so that they can, you know, sort of, you know, provide, you know, way of provide providing a broader you know description of what occurred

you know between that and body cameras you know as opposed to you know the way it would be you know scripted years ago let's go to 9 -11 then let's start with how that day unfolded you know through your eyes personally and then we'll get to obviously the days and weeks after yeah so 9 -11 um Actually, it was sort of an outgrowth of our previous discussions there is that I was working in Times Square. I was actually partaking

in that business improvement district there. But one of the lingering issues that we had were gangs and gangs associated with the Bloods and Covenant House that Groupon, I mentioned to you earlier. that drew these gangs from the outer boroughs to come and see their girlfriends and other occupants of Covenant House and then go and commit crime, robberies, sell drugs in Times

Square. So trying to address that one last lingering issue there, I actually had a meeting scheduled on 9 -11 with an undercover. And having gone back and forth with that undercover to trying to find a date that worked for both of us, it was actually 9 -11. And he was going to be in court at 100 Center Street in Lower Manhattan, basically blocks from the World Trade Center. And I was going to meet him there, not realizing that it was my daughter's first day of preschool.

And she was going to the afternoon session. So I initially said, because, you know, it was such a challenge trying to find a date that worked for both of us, that I would go in, you know, attend the meeting and then come home, you know, in time to go to see my daughter attend her first day of preschool. And then looking at the timeline and everything else, realizing that it, you know, was probably not a good idea. You know, I wound up taking the day off initially. And then shortly

after 8 .46 in the morning there, I got a call that said a plane had hit the World Trade Center. And like a lot of people, I thought it was a small plane. And then I saw the second plane hit and realized that we're under attack. At that point there, I started making my way in. Initially, I went to Kennedy Airport. And then from Kennedy Airport, I made my way into Manhattan there. By the time I got down to the World Trade Center, both towers had collapsed. But then,

you know, approximately like 515 there, building seven collapsed into the street. And then, you know, trying to make sense out of all of the chaos and all of the, you know, the impact. You know, I mean, like I said, having been involved with the World Trade Center since it was constructed, you know. sort of in disbelief that they were no longer there. It was sort of like, you know, you kept thinking that you were just having a bad nightmare and that you're going to wake up

and say, you know, wow, you know, you couldn't believe what I saw in my sleep, you know. But then, you know, we spent, you know, trying to organize in that day there. There were two Marines that came down, two retired Marines that were walking through the site. And they thought they heard somebody. And it turned out to be Will Jimeno, John McLaughlin, and initially Dominic

Pizzullo, three Port Authority cops there that were buried in the collapse of the North Tower. And, you know, then they came and got us. And, you know, sadly, you know. While Will and John McLaughlin, even though they were seriously injured and were buried in the collapse of the buildings there, initially Dominic Pizzullo had survived.

And he, unlike the two of them, was not buried in the debris. But he wouldn't leave their side. And then there was a secondary collapse and a chunk of concrete hit him in the head and killed him. Then people spent the next 18 hours getting Will and John out in very dire circumstances there. Two NYPD issue officers there, Scott Strauss

and Patty McGee, actually spent a lot of time with Will. and were successful in, again, very dire circumstances there, unknowing whether or not they were seconds away from either losing their lives as well. But then other people were able to get John McLaughlin out, and it sort of gave us hope. that we were going to find other

survivors throughout the voids there that were formed when the towers collapsed. Unfortunately, other than John and Will and a woman from the Port Authority, Giselle, and a group of people that were coming down a staircase there. I describe it that there's a lot of karma that sort of come into play in different parts of it there. think that there might have been a greater power at

work there. It's like the group that were coming down the staircase, they had encountered a woman that was not very mobile. And the evacuation order had already been given. And when they encountered her, she was telling them to go on. Some people did go on. And shortly after that, the tower collapsed. Those that went on were killed. Those that were above them were killed. Those that opted to stay with the woman survived. you know, with the exception of one of them having a broken arm. You know, so, you know, those little things

there, you know, again, people caring for people, you know, putting themselves at risk, you know, to try to help and save, you know, another human being, you know, really, you know, besides, you know, saving lives, there also gave us hope that we were going to find other people. But that wasn't the case. I know there's every so often on my feed, you know, pictures will pop up from inside history as some of these other pages that,

you know, sometimes they're very powerful and pertinent. Sometimes they're more political or trying to sell you stuff. But there's one that pops up every so often. And it's one of the ERs in that area with all the doctors and nurses outside. And it was basically all these trauma teams that were activated waiting for people. But there was no one. And again, there was obviously people that were injured from the collapse itself when they were in the streets and those kind of things. But the level of casualties that they

were expecting, the fact that they didn't come, that image is just so heartbreaking for these people in this emergency room waiting for someone to try and save and there wasn't anyone. Yeah, no. And I know those images that you're talking about there, you see them. See all the medical staff standing outside awaiting people to help. And, you know, the majority of the people that they were helping were people that had respiratory issues as a result of being caught in the collapse,

you know, in the dust clouds that, you know, I mean, a lot of people don't realize, you know, you had 200, 210 story buildings, you know, and each floor was an acre. So you had 220 acres of concrete. that was pulverized into dust along with the glass and the windows you know so that's what really formed those clouds so inhaling concrete dust is not a good thing you know your lungs are a very wet environment there that you know once those elements get in there you know they

don't they don't dissipate you know and it's not something so that was the majority of the people that they were they were helping uh you know that had been caught in that dust cloud afterwards there but um You know, just, you know, touching upon the people that were lost, you know, the majority of the 2 ,753 people that were lost at the Trade Center were above the impact flows. You know, other than the first responders and people that were, you know, killed on the street, either from, sadly, from people

that were jumping, you know, or from debris from the planes or the buildings as they collapsed. But the people that were above the impact floors. So in the North Tower, when Flight 11 struck the North Tower, it severed all of the staircases. So nobody above the impact floors in the North Tower were able to get out. You know, I mean, amazingly, you know, when you think about the

impact and the fact that the company is still in existence, you had Cantor Fitzgerald, 658 people, Marsh, you know. another large number of people. But they were all above the impact floor, people from the Windows of the World restaurant. The South Tower, one staircase stayed intact. But again, the majority of the people that were lost in the South Tower were above the impact floors. One staircase stayed intact, and there was a young man by the name of Wells Crowler.

You may have heard his story. He was As a young man, his father was a volunteer fireman in Nyack, New York, and he used to attend events with his dad. And there was one occasion there was a dress -up event, and his dad had put a white handkerchief in his jacket, and Wells wanted one as well. And then his dad thought... Better of it, Darren went back and got him a red handkerchief and

said, that's for sure. This is for blowing your nose. So from that day on there, Willis carried a red handkerchief with him. He grew up. He, at the age of 16, became a volunteer fireman in Nyack, New York as well. Then, you know, as he became a young man, he wound up working in the financial district, you know, and actually was working in the South Tower above the impact floors. But he was able to find that one staircase that stayed intact. And it's believed that he led as many as 16 people from the tower to safety,

but unfortunately was killed when the South Tower collapsed. When we recovered him, he was actually in the footprint of what was the command post in the South Tower. So his story basically stayed untold until one day his mom. Allison was reading accounts of survivors and they were all talking about being rescued by a young man wearing a red bandana. So Allison sent pictures of Wells to them and they recognized him as the person.

So his story then became, you know. told uh and it was the man in the red bandana and he had attended you know boston college there so the the school itself um you know actually embraced it and then all their sports teams now have a patch of red cloth on it there you know in recognition of wells um you know so um even when we uh we opened the museum you know um the then president obama you know recognized you know the heroics

of Wells during that horrific day. But the other thing is that not only for survivors, but also for recovery. So from of the 2 ,753 people, to this day, 1 ,098 people have not been identified. So almost 40 % of the people lost on 9 -11 were never identified. And the hopes is that even

though we recovered over 20 ,000 sets of remains and those remains are stored with the medical examiner's office in the hopes that as the DNA process gets better, that we might be able to identify even more of those people that are still not listed as recovered. The thought also is that when the footprints of the two towers there, the fire is burnt. to the third week in December. And we actually had the Department of Energy

do flyovers and map the site. And in some areas there, they got temperature readings as high as like 1700 degrees. So anybody lost in those areas there was basically cremated. It's horrendous. You talked about the man with the red bandana. There was a paramedic that went down with the ESU to find Will and Jonathan. The one area that

I think is so important for us to really remember, and Michael Greer just did a good documentary on this, is the kindness of 9 -12, as a lot of people kind of romanticize. And even during COVID, you heard the phrase, I miss 9 -12. Now, people obviously do not miss a devastating attack that costs thousands of lives. But it was when everyone came together, when everyone saw each other as Americans, not their race, not who they pray to, who they lie with, but just a nation. And it obviously extended far outside that. It was

the world that came together for us. Talk to me about that through your eyes. This tragic event happens on 9 -11. What did you see as far as the community of New York and beyond in response to that attack? Yeah, so that and it really was like, you know, somebody threw a switch in the whole, you know, means of people caring, you know, turn for the good, you know, and it was even an issue like prior, just prior to 9 -11

era. whether or not we were going to place flags on the buses and on the trains. And overnight, that issue went away. But to the support, it was amazing there. It was one of the things there that really gave us an uplifting feeling. When we were doing the rescue recovery operation there, both coming in in the morning there, coming down West Street there to head to the site, and then going home in the evening, you know, West Street

was lined with people, you know, with signs and shouting and, you know, and all positive things, you know, and they did that day in and day out, you know, and then there were volunteers, you know, that, you know, supported, you know, either the food areas there that were stood up there, you know. both celebrities and everyday people and you know uh just that whole sense of caring and and support you know i mean because of the

amount of death um between the civilian population the uh port authority police department the greatest loss of law enforcement personnel in the history of our world The FDNY, the NYPD, you know, there were challenges even to have people attend the funerals. So people from the communities there turned out, you know, and attended those funerals,

you know, in recognition of the people that were lost. So it was really a whole coming together of not only the country, but to your point there about the world, you know, 93 countries lost people on 9 -11. You know, so it wasn't just an attack on New York or an attack on the United States. It really was an attack on the world, you know, and the impact of it was great. And, you know, one of the things there in bringing a lot of people through the 9 -11 Memorial and

Museum and, you know, especially our foreign partners there, you know, I always make it a point to look up and identify the people that came from their country. And, you know, when I do that and then I identify them and show them, you know, what's been submitted on their behalf, you always feel a sense of unity that comes over those people. And they might be a little standoffish in the beginning, but once they realize that, you know, people that they have a lot in common

with there were also lost, you know, it seems to be a great, you know, olive branch of connection. And it sort of reminds me of, you know, that feeling that we had right after 9 -11, you know, on 9 -12 and, you know, in the weeks, months and, you know, years that has sort of diminished over time, you know, back to the hostilities that we had prior to 9 -11. Absolutely. I think,

again, you know, as we sit here today in 2026, I just wish we could kind of bottle that and get everyone to drink a pint of it. go back to the gratitude and the community that we saw then. And we can't. This is the thing. I don't think that we need to have tragedies to be reminded of that. No, and that's the thing is that, you know, I have a lot of faith in human beings there. You know, I like to think there that, you know, the majority of the people are good. You know, I mean, you know, it saddens me to see events

that have been unfolding there in France and Germany. And here in the United States, having spent a lot of time post 9 -11 there, embedded with the protesters there, it was very disheartening there. I remember being on West Street there, just north of the World Trade Center. And like I described earlier there, when we were leaving after 9 -11 there, we were encountering all goodwill.

from the people that were lined up on West Street there. And then, you know, more recently there, you know, in 2020 there, when the protests and the riots, you know, we were encountering people on West Street there that were shouting at us there that we were going to lose our jobs. You know, so it was a complete 360 from, you know, the goodwill that we had encountered right after 9 -11. You know, but it's a very organized movement. It's not just something, a random protest against

some individual act that resulted in people protesting. This is a whole revolution of ideologies that people are trying to instill on us as a society. So, and I point this out, the one luxury I have of having been doing this for so long is that there are remnants of the 60s and 70s there that were protesting back then against the Vietnam

War and other things in society that today are the guiding forces behind the new... people that are protesting. You know, the advantage that the new people have today is social media and other means of communication. Before, you know, it might have been isolated to small areas. Now it's a global movement, you know, as you've seen playing out in more recent days in France and

Germany, you know, Norway and a lot of the European countries. Well, what's interesting is, you know, I think protesting You know, peaceful, truly peaceful protesting can be a show of force by a nation that's demanding that their leaders actually invest in the nation, not their own bank accounts. So I think there's a lot of power behind a peaceful protest. The Million Man March is a good example of that. But what I see from both extremes is that you can easily infiltrate

a protest and create violence. And we saw it in Paris. Paris overall was a very peaceful protest until the few ruined it for the massive. And then it also then takes the power away from that protest. So the violence element you can see is a very deliberate attempt to ultimately debunk the very thing that people are trying to protest for in the first place. So it's a political tool used by both extremes, no question. Yeah, a lot

of the protests hide behind that First Amendment right of free speech. But that doesn't mean that you get to damage and destroy property of other people. That's not the whole belief behind having a free society. It's like graffiti. It's viewed as street art. if it's your building that's getting graffitied you know and you know it's not something

that you gave permission to do you know um yeah that you know just sort of undermines the the entire principles of it there you know so it's uh you know the challenges of a free society there but you know um you know and then you know knowing what it is the cause that you're actually protesting for you know i mean like i said being embedded with The protest is there during the, you know, Occupy Wall Street there, Black Lives

Matter. You know, if you ever had conversations with a lot of people that were actually protesting, you know, they could not give you a viable answer as to what it was that they were protesting. You know, it was sort of like just a sheep mentality. You know, it was like, you know, there were people that were leading them and they were just, you know, providing, you know, support to that. believed movement you know it's like yeah trying to yes not get into the the political uh world of it

there it's like you know having you know transgender people you know try to argue that there's you know more than just you know two sexes males and females you know i mean at the end of the day you know uh you know biologically you know it's male or female you know So to have a whole movement that's now trying to instill that belief to people that hopefully have more common sense

and are able to view it for what it is, it's, again, a misguided protest. When it comes to that conversation, I think we've gone so far away from what we've always expected. There's this whole thing at the moment that there's not an acceptance, for example, of homosexuality. And if you look back at the 60s, the 70s, the

80s, we had artists and actors that were completely out. So we're almost like being told a lie that it's not acceptable now. It's very, very accepted. At the same time, when it's constantly rammed down your throat, your average person doesn't walk around saying, I'm heterosexual and ramming that down the throat or vice versa. And even with the athlete thing, I mean, there's no argument. Everyone should have their division. But if there's an anatomical advantage, then you need to create

two more divisions, transition to male, transition to female. And then you've got another area that's fair. And those groups can compete fairly against each other. whatever the sports is. And again, it's that middle of the road conversation. But what you're seeing, again, to our point is, you know, you have someone who will just, you know, gladly destroy their family and friendships over a politician, you know, or like you said, a movement over, you know, and a terrible tragedy and a

mistake by people in uniform but it doesn't reflect the entire first responder profession rather than stand in the middle and have a nuanced conversation of how can we stop that happening again without burning the whole place to the ground you know so i think there's there are groups though that love that extremism they love that violence and chaos because as one of my guests said a long time ago If you get the peasants in a medieval village arguing with each other, then they forget to look at the castle. That's what it's really about. Who are the people who are ultimately

benefiting from this chaos? And it's the people that we should be looking at and go, they're the problem. Yeah, I mean, and that's exactly it. We're a nation of laws. Morality and in order to maintain that society there, it's the 95 % of the world or 98 % of the world shouldn't have to change their views or their opinions based

on the 2 % of people. And to your point, elements of society there that have alternate lifestyles there have always existed. It's just a matter of... whether they stayed in their pocket or in their community. But that's existed not only within alternate lifestyles there, but also within different cultures. new york city being you know

the prime you know location where a lot of immigrants settled there you know you had italian neighborhoods you had irish neighborhoods you had chinese neighborhoods you had you know um uh norwegian neighborhoods there you had areas there that you know because like -minded people sort of were drawn together you know they didn't try to change the rest of you know society there to acclimate to theirs you know and i think that's an important part that gets missed is that people through immigration

that come here should have some desire to want to adopt our way of life. I would assume that's why they're coming here, for a better life, not where they're going to change our society to what they experienced before. Yeah. And I think there's a happy medium there too. You can be proud to be an American and also proud of your

heritage. I'm still British. I was born and bred in Britain, but I wore an American flag on my shoulder the whole time I was working as a firefighter. Those two things can exist, but I don't fly Union Jacks for my car when I'm driving either. But you take New York, I mean, just about every other weekend or... Sometimes there's a parade that's specific to that cultural background, whether it be the Israeli Day Parade, the St. Patrick's

Day Parade, the Columbian Day Parade. So people get to really celebrate their culture and what their culture provided to the greater metropolis there, whether it be through food or some other. cultural amenity. Absolutely. Well, I want to kind of round off the 9 -11 element, and then we're just going to walk through towards your

transition out. I know that you were appointed the role of being in charge of rescue and recovery. Talk to me about the following weeks and months and then how you came to the decision for May 30th to be the final day of the recovery. On September 12th, I was appointed the day tour commander at a rescue recovery operation by then Chief Morris, who was so the Port Authority police

suffering so much loss there, including our superintendent, Fred Marone, one of our chiefs, James Romito. You know, so and the loss of our headquarters at the World Trade Center, our loss of our police station at the World Trade Center, you know. We were trying to bring calm to the chaos. And then Chief Morris assigned me as the day tour commander to rescue recovery operation. And Lieutenant Keegan, Lieutenant Moss for the midnights, Mark

Winslow. So we were basically left to ourselves to do the rescue and recovery operation there. So it was a 24 -hour operation there. And like I said, our initial goal was to try to rescue people that may have been trapped in voids and other areas within the site. And once we got to that, we interacted with the femur. urban

search and rescue teams that have deployments around the world in times of disasters. So they had basically identified like the 14 -day period of survival. So if somebody was trapped without food and water, that 14 days is sort of what they've experienced there, whether it be in earthquakes or other devastations around the world. So once we got past that, That 14 -day period there, it transitioned from a rescue to a recovery operation.

And the three departments, the Port Authority Police Department, the New York City Police Department, and the FDNY, all assigned people to be spotters. So we broke the site up into quadrants. There was four quadrants. And each day we would rotate. First zone, FDNY would have the second zone, NYPD would have the third zone, and then the

fourth zone would sort of be a combined process there. And then we would rotate this so that this way nobody felt slighted that they were going to be in an area where there might be less recoveries. So we did that there for nine months, from September 12th, September 11th, really, to know may 30th um you know when over the course of that time there we we removed 1 .6 million

tons of building components um and we recovered over 20 100 sets of remains uh very few people are actually recovered intact um you know and um you know so uh and we didn't do this in the beginning there but you know we developed ceremonies that um uh were the right thing to do anytime we did a recovery or remains we placed the remains in a body bag we placed the body bag on a stokes

basket drape it in an american flag get one of the on -site chaplains to come down to our press service and then um we would identify six people lack as uh pole bearers there to carry the stokes basket to one either one of the on -site morgues in the beginning or to an awaiting ambulance to be transported to the morgue. And all the workers would stop and line up and create an honor guard as the remains were removed. So we did that thousands of times. And like I said

there, sadly, still to this day, 1 ,098 people still not have been identified in the course of that. You know, if you go through the museum, you'll see things that we found that were lost during the initial settlement of Lower Manhattan there when the Dutch were settling. So those things that stayed lost for hundreds of years, but because of the thoroughness in which we did the rescue recovery operation there looking for

people, you know, they were found. So, you know, again, it's just a... A tribute to the focus and attention to detail that everybody paid in trying to recover as many people as were physically possible. And what happened to create May 30th as a date? So myself, then Joe Esposito, who

was the chief of NYPD, you know, Sal Cassano from the fire department. John Odomad from OEM, and then Mayor Bloomberg, we did a walkthrough of the site. And based on the number of trucks that were leaving the site there with building components there, and we had one of the engineers calculate how much stuff was left to go through to be sorted through there to look for remains. And we figured that based on the number of trucks

that were leaving the site daily at that point, We came up with May 30th as the date in which we would have made it through all of the material that was left to be sifted through. And then in preparation for that, as we cleared the site and we had installed the temporary bridge to complete the removal of the building components there from the two footprints of the towers, we also had exposed one of them. main columns,

the column number 1001B, which was one of the main support columns of the South Tower. So as we were clearing that area there, which was going to be the last area that was going to yield any significant remains, people started to write things and affix things to the column. It includes the words PAPD 37, NYPD 23, FDNY 343. And on the other side, the number of civilians that we thought. had been lost at that point there

so that nobody was excluded from it there. And then people started writing things on there in memory of those that were lost in dedication to units that had provided support to the rescue recovery operation. People started with fixing pictures of people that were lost. So we identified that column that was going to be the last piece of steel that was going to be removed at that point there. So actually on May 28th, once we

came up that May 30th date, some people from City Hall got involved and they started to try to monopolize the ceremony. And they were going to be excluding a lot of the people that actually had performed the rescue recovery operation. You know, so if you were a company, you know, say just as an example, you know, Amec, and you had a thousand people that, you know, supported the rescue recovery operation there. And, you

know, you were told you could have six people as part of an honor guard. You know, it wasn't a good thing. You know, and, you know, in recognition of, you know, the construction workers, the grappler operators, the crane operators, the truck drivers, you know. If you had taken all 40 ,000 police officers from all of the different agencies and all 15 ,000 firemen, we wouldn't have been able to do what we did without the iron workers, the grappler operators. They're removing and lifting

and cutting the steel and clearing areas there for us to go and search for remains. 80 % of the people that worked on the rescue recovery operation were actually, you know, construction workers, you know, not police or fire, you know. You know, and they, you know, unlike us, you know, where, you know, you know, we had a process for people to transition, you know, when they

were done with the mission. The construction workers there, if there was no work for them there, they got a pink slip and were told that, you know. Report to your union hall and find out where your next work assignment is. So to exclude them from that final day ceremony, there was like really a gut punch. And, you know, I mean, I had people coming up to me, you know, in tears, you know, I mean, because they had put their heart and soul in it as much as anybody, you know. So we we decided that we were going

to hold a workers day. So when we cut that final column down on May 28th and prepared it for the final day on May 30th, you know, we brought everybody and we did it at the, you know, in the evening hours. So this way, both tours, the day tour and the. the midnight tour could could attend and um you know so we all gathered uh you know we we cut the final column down we placed it on a flatbed truck and even in cutting it down you know um you know all of the iron workers

you know wanted the the opportunity to be the person that cut that column down so again not trying to exclude anybody what we did was we had each of them cut like an inch of the base So this way everybody was included. So then it was, you know, and also to lift it there, they had welded two, basically ears, but, you know, two, you know, lifting points at the top of the column. So it was lifted up, it was lowered down

and placed on a flatbed truck, covered in black bunting, covered in a large American flag, you know, and it was prepped for the May 30th anniversary. So contrary to what City Hall wanted to do there on the May of Bloomberg there and exclude people, you know, we achieved that on May 28th. But then again, on May 30th, you know, the ceremony that had been planned by City Hall was that the truck,

everybody was going to line up, you know, with the limited numbers on the bridge. The truck was going to drive up the ramp when it cleared the top. The people at the top of the ramp were going to fall in behind it and march out. And then that was going to be the end of the rescue recovery operation. Again, we didn't agree to that there. We did, but we didn't. So we brought everybody and we massed them together at the base of the bridge. And as the truck started

up at the ramp, instead of going from the top out, we went from the bottom up. And everybody fell in behind the truck. It was, you know, there was nobody more relieved than me when the truck cleared the top of the bridge because, you know, we had two concerns was that whether the bridge could hold the weight of the truck and the beam and the weight of all of the people that were going to be walking up it. And then the other thing was that because of the incline, you know, there was a good chance that the truck could stall and then start to roll back. And you're

talking about an event that was being broadcast live around the world. So there was nobody more happy than myself there when the truck cleared the top of the bridge and we were able to march out behind it there and, you know, declare the rescue recovery operation complete. As you alluded to with the just, you know, cessation of the construction workers journey, you know. We have police, you have fire, where hopefully there is some sort of kind of mental health support

as you're kind of coming out of this tragedy. What, as you progress through the next couple of decades, what were the struggles that you yourself had as far as processing what you'd been through, the losses that you had, the things that you had to see, and what have been some of the tools that you've used to overcome that, to try and work through it? So the biggest challenge to that, you know, sadly, is that, you know, from the exposure to all of the pulverized concrete,

the glass, the mercury that was in the light bulbs from, you know, it was really a toxic brew of chemicals that, you know, we were all exposed to there. And sadly, you know, a lot of people have died from, you know, there's more people that have died from the exposure. to the elements then died on 9 -11, you know, and a lot of it is cancer related, you know, myself included have had some issues with cancer. You know, fortunately

for me, you know, I was able to have them addressed and, you know, monitored and, you know, but a lot of people weren't as fortunate, you know, so the impact that it had on their lives and, you know, and then you know, trying to get support for their medical needs, you know, and not only themselves, but also for their families, you know, who were dealing with them, you know, through their illnesses. And in a lot of cases, like I said, through their passing. So that was the,

you know, the bigger challenge. There's another aspect of it there that's even, you know, as challenging to survivors and family members is the fact there that, you know, 26 years later, soon to be 26 years later, we still haven't convicted the five enemy combatants that are being held at Guantanamo Bay, Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. Benetage

and the others that, you know, were the planners of 9 -11, you know, and helped facilitate it there. And, you know, and the fact there that, you know, that they still not have been brought to justice is, you know, not something there that, you know, was, you know, sat well, especially with the elderly family members. the grandparents and parents who are now in their 80s and in some cases 90s and you know just like with the people that have died from the exposures a lot of family

members the elderly family members have passed away without ever having seen justice for their lost loved one so um you know those are the two big things there that you know have impacted us Myself included. And, you know, I still, you know, make regular trips to Gitmo. You know, ultimately, you know, I'll be testifying at, you know, if it ever does get to trial. But, you know, you get to interact and, you know,

spend time with family members there that, you know, are only, you know. going to be happy when finally, you know, justice is served. You know, I mean, especially in KSM's case, you know, I mean, he not only was involved with the 9 -11, but also the 93 attack, the other attacks as well. Why is it that we haven't seen, you know, the conclusion of that court case already after

25 years? instituted the military commission when they created this hybrid court, sort of between a military commission and a federal prosecution. But it was a new court and it was a new process. So the only prior one was the Nuremberg trials,

which were over and done with within 14 months. So I don't think the military commission was prepared for this to be drawn out as long as it's been. One of the big issues that you see is that we currently have the fifth judge that's sat on this case. And technically, he's the eighth. But three of them, right after they were appointed, they were either disqualified for some other basis there. But he's the fifth sitting judge.

Whereas if it had been in federal court, the federal court judges are judges for life. And you look back to the 93 attack, with the exception of Ramzi Youssef, they were all arrested, tried, and convicted within 14 months. So the fact that here we are with the greatest terrorist attack in the history of our country. And it's not a question of guilt. I mean, they've all admitted

their guilt. The issue at hand is that it's a death penalty case. And when they were captured, they were held at black sites there and interrogated by the CIA using enhanced interrogation techniques there that have been argued to nauseam by the defense there that it was torture. you know um the enhanced interrogation techniques are the same techniques that we use for our special operations

troops you know that we train them in case they get uh captured you know so um but they've been successfully arguing uh for years that um you know that it was torture so recently uh statements that were provided there to the fbi So after they were held at the black sites, and then in 2006, transferred to Gitmo, where they became the custody of the Department of Defense. Sometime

after that, there in 2007, they were interviewed by the FBI. And, you know, especially in KSM's case, there and actually in some of the others as well, you know, they all basically. admitted to their role and were proud of it there. You know, KSM refers to himself as the emir of 9 -11. You know, he's the one that proposed the use of planes to bin Laden. You know, he, you

know, admitted to beheading Daniel Pearl, you know, and, you know, his involvement in the 93 attack as well, you know, and other terrorist attacks around the world. It's not a question of guilt. It's not where they're arguing that it was a misidentification of the person. These people have all admitted to their roles in the plotting and the attacks of 9 -11. So the fact

that the defense has been able to prolong this for 25 years is... I describe it as there that the family members are all suffering from the Stockholm syndrome, except that instead of being held hostage by people, they're being held hostage by the process. And, you know, sadly, you know, like I said, you know, a number of them have passed away, you know, you know, waiting, awaiting justice, you know. And then, you know, and if

you ask me, again, I think he was influenced. By the 25th anniversary, the judge has assigned a trial date of June 5th, 2028. And subsequent to that there, he suppressed all of the statements that were given to the FBI. So there's really no obstacle to starting the trial at this point. It was the question of statements there that really was prolonging it there. But now that he's resolved those issues and the prosecution has... stated that they're not going to appeal

the suppression of them because they feel as if they have enough evidence of it and that, you know, to convict them. You know, so the fact there that, you know, we're going to have to wait now to June 5th, 2028 is again, you know, a battle against time, especially if you're, you know, the parents and grandparents who were in your 80s and 90s, you know. That timeline could be a death sentence. I want to just ask

one more question, then we'll go to some closing questions. Be mindful of your time. Who is defending these terrorists? Is it a certain country? Who are the people that are actually forming a defense for people that have murdered, we know hands down, have murdered thousands of Americans? The way it works, because it's a capital case, they have to have a what is described as a learned attorney, a civilian attorney who has handled a debt. penalty case before. So, you know, they

were all very capable people. You know, you have Gary Soward, who represented the Unabomber, you know, James Connell, who was probably the most capable of the defense attorneys. You know, you have Engel, you have Wally Ruiz, you know, you know, so they're, you know, they're the primary people. And then there are also, because it's a military commission, they're entitled to representation by a JAG, a member of the military legal process.

So one of the things that affects me when I go there is that you look at the prosecution side and there's maybe eight to 10 people. And then you look at the defense side and there's like 30 to 40 people. All of the issues that have come up about the enhanced interrogation techniques and the torture. And then you see the enemy combatant sitting in court looking no worse than anybody else. You see them laughing. You see them dressed

in their garb. KSM's case there, he dyes his beard red. So all these things there that impact your... visual, you know, observations of them versus, you know, the person I always think about there when I see them is a woman by the name of Edna Cintron. You know, so if you go through the 9 -11 Museum, after Flat 11 strikes the North

Tower, you know, and severs all of the staircases there, there's an image of this woman, Edna Cintron. who's standing in the opening and really has no choice in life. She can't go in because if she does, she'll burn to death. And she's looking out. And sadly, when the tower collapsed, she was killed. And not only do I think of her, her being tortured by her circumstances. But I think

about her family members knowing that she was in that position and that there was nothing that they could do to help her. You know, so, you know, and then, you know, I compare that to what the argument is on behalf of these enemy combatants there who are sitting in court, you know, looking no worse for wear. And, you know, you know, so their argument doesn't weigh much with me. because of what I know that that woman went through and her family as well. Well, thank you for educating

us on that because I think that's the problem. The 25th anniversary, I've had some people on over the last 10 years that have been part of the response or like Will, for example, being from inside. But the prosecution. The dates, the impact on the families, I've never heard anyone talk about that before. So I appreciate you reminding us that that's still absolutely something that needs to be resolved. And that again, like I just did a post on this today, that it spans both sides of the political aisle

as well, that nothing has been done for 25 years. I want to round off with some quick closing questions. The first one I love to ask. Is there a book or are there books that you love to recommend? It can be related to our conversation today or completely unrelated. So, you know, I mean, there's been a number of books, you know, I mean, one that's recently was published there. And it's actually by the author. His name is John Ryan

as well. He's one of two members of the media that have spent significant. amount of time at Guantanamo covering the proceedings. But his book is basically a timeline of events from day one to current day. His publishers actually told him he needed to publish it now. His hope was that he was going to be able to complete it with

the conclusion of the trial. Again, they recommended there that he publish it today because it's America's Trial by John Ryan. And then, you know, beyond that, there are a number of other, you know, books there that were written, you know, right after 9 -11 there. I mean, the challenge with it there is that, you know, it is a lot of books that have been written and a lot of self -serving

books that have been written. as opposed to books there that really provide some insight into the events. There's a picture book. So one of the things there that I feel satisfied about was that it was about the third or fourth day there, and a fireman came to me and said that there was some person taking pictures. And I walked over, and there's this guy all dressed in black

there. his hat on backwards there. He had a wood camera, a box camera on a tripod there with a hood. And it looked like something out of an old Western. And, you know, my initial reaction was that, you know, it was just some, you know, person looking to, you know, get involved and take pictures. But there was something just genuine about him. His name is Joel Meyerowitz. I didn't

know it then, but he's a, you know, a world renowned photographer. And his book is called Aftermath. And it's a, it's only pictures, very few words. And, you know, I wound up letting him stay. And, you know, he took thousands of pictures over the course of the nine months there that we were doing the rescue recovery operation. And I come to learn that that camera was some high -end piece of equipment that allowed him to take these very clear, high -pixel panoramic photos there

that he was able to culminate into this book, F the Math. And it's a picture book, so it's a large book. And there's some sections that actually fold out. But the clarity of the photos there, and actually some of them actually have been incorporated into the 9 -11 Museum. But, you know, what I always say about it there is that, you know, all of that would have been lost to memory if not for the fact that he had taken those pictures and, you know, provided them to

the museum, but also put them into his book. time periods and different things there that occurred over the course of the nine months there. So, you know, again, as we get to the point there where I'm told there's over 100 million people that were either not born or were too young to have any of that firsthand recollection from 9 -11 living in the country today, you know,

his book is going to be and his pictures are going to be that much more valuable in providing that. future generations with an education as to the events at 9 -11 and the aftermath. Absolutely. I just saw we lost our very last D -Day veteran about two days ago. So, I mean, that's us. That's our generation, yours and mine collectively. That was our grandparents or parents. And now we've lost all but all the voices. So all we're left with is the videos and the books and the

writing to remind us of the tragedies and hope. that we will not allow people to repeat them again. And it's the same with this. One other thing in there that they've done is that they created this called StoryCorp. And actually, it goes beyond 9 -11 there. They actually have gone and interviewed World War II veterans and other places, recognizing the need to have that firsthand recollection of events there. So StoryCorp has been very... progressive in interviewing

people that had involvement with 9 -11. So a lot of things that would have been lost in previous events are being captured and maintained for future generations. Absolutely. Well, what about television films or documentaries that you love? So it is a rebuilding of the World Trade Center. You know, it was a very well done piece there.

You know, there's another one called the rescue and actually rescue recovery. The one there by Seth Kramer. You know, both of those there, you know, capture, you know, a lot of footage of actually during the rescue recovery operation. And I actually did two pieces for C -SPAN, one on January 10th on 2002, in which I guided them through two reporters from C -SPAN through the

site. And then subsequent to that there, on September 8th, 2002, I think it was, I again. brought the C -SPAN through. So you had one just months after 9 -11, and then you had the second one after the whole rescue recovery operation was over, and they already started some of the rebuilding of the site. Amazing. The next question, is there

a person that you would recommend to come on this podcast as a guest to speak to the first responders, military, and associated professionals of the world? You know, so there's a number of people, but they, unfortunately, other than myself at this point there, you know, there's not that many people left that have that whole collective experience there. You know, I mean, you know,

the military impact, you know, from 9 -11 on, you know, I mean, I've spent a lot of time with our military personnels from the SEAL, the Ranger community. You know, I mean, you know, one group I wouldn't recommend there is the horse soldiers, you know, the people that were the first people into Afghanistan afterward, you know, and, you

know, other special operations groups there, you know, the SEAL community, definitely, you know, SEAL Team 6, that group. You know, people other than Rob O 'Neill, that is, you know, and, you know, and, you know, to their credit there, you know, a lot of them probably wouldn't come on. You know, they, you know, they believe in their motto that it's the deed, not the glory, you know. So, but the horse soldiers there, you

know. you know uh i think would be a good group to have on you know um maybe not as an individual but as a group you know mark nunce you know john cano um you know um you know especially since you know there's the america's response statue which i didn't get into there you know was at the world trade center site you know um you know and that whole i mean being the first people into Afghanistan after 9 -11, you know, and everything that they did there, you know, going into battle

on horseback for the first time, you know, since World War II, I believe it was, you know, and the fact that they all survived. And the one upside to their involvement there is that, you know, now they're all bourbon salesmen. So they actually have their own, you know, bourbon there called Horse Soldier Bourbon, you know, and just the connectivity to that there. They were given World Trade Center steel. So every bottle of horse soldier bourbon is actually, you know, formed in steel that was recovered from the World

Trade Center. So, you know, it's a and even the statue that was created in recognition of them there by the artist Blumberg, you know, has a piece of World Trade Center steel embedded in its base. You know, so, you know, and. I mean, another suggestion would be, you know, Mike Keane from O 'Hara's. You know, so O 'Hara's is a bar that has a lot of connectivity to the World Trade

Center. And, you know, they were within the collapse zone. You know, so they were basically closed down and put out of business. But they stayed open and supporting the... you know the rescue recovery operation there and are still in existence today uh if you go in there i mean it's a pretty remarkable place to be because um you know there's thousands and thousands of patchers from every military group first respond the police fire

that have come through and then you know stopped into o 'hara's there um you know and affixed their patch or their logo to the walls so It's covered from head to toe, front to back. But Mike has had interactions with a cross -section of both the military and police, fire, EMS, all the people that not only responded on 9 -11, but respond on a daily basis across the country.

There's another group that I support there. It's actually from Wisconsin there. It's called Old Glory on a Flight. And, you know, they have put together flights of people, veterans from the global war on terror. And they take them on a liberty to liberty, you know, trip to New York. They select, you know, a group between 50 and 60 veterans and they bring them, you know, they

house them in the hotel in Manhattan. We take them. and give them a tour through the World Trade Center Memorial and Museum, the Liberty Park, which holds the America's Responsible Host Soldier Statue, the Greek Church, St. Nicholas, and the Koenig Sphere, which was the centerpiece of the original World Trade Center. Then we bring them over to the Statue of Liberty and bring them up in the Freedom Tower. You know, a lot

of them, you know, have issues there. They have post -traumatic stress. And, you know, I received letters from four of them recently. They're saying, you know, how impactful it was and that it changed their whole outlook on life. You know, but that group, the old Gloriana flight there, you know, Diane and the rest of her people really, you know, they've saved lives. You can't ask for a more successful program than that. They do

it out of the kindness of their hearts. It's funny, one of the letters I received from one of the veterans there, I had asked him to take a picture with me. He was so moved by the fact that I would ask him to take a picture. with me there that, you know, it was like, you know, really changed his whole outlook on life. You know, he was really in a bad place there, but it just shows you how, you know, again, you know, that feeling that we had after 9 -11, you know,

on 9 -12, you know, and it's really that camaraderie and that caring, you know, of people there that, you know, really is what makes, you know, things for the better. I couldn't agree more. Well, for people listening, if they want to reach out to you, learn more about you, where are the best places online to do that? You know, so I guess they can just Google my name. You know, I did another podcast, not as long as this one, you

know, but, you know, you know, basically along the same, you know. lines um you know describing you know the events of 9 -11 in 93 and you know my career but um you know it's best that they they can do it through that you know or they can email me you know so you can provide them my email address you know um brilliant well I

want to thank you so much. It's been such an amazing conversation. I'm so glad that we spent time, you know, in the earlier career and Times Square and some of those areas because, you know, those tragic events that you'd endured obviously was a sliver of your entire career. So I want to thank you so, so much for being so generous with your time and coming on the Behind the Shield podcast today. I appreciate you having me there. It's, you know, as I described, you know, there's a thread that runs through all of us that bonds us, you know. It's like the American flag itself.

You remove one of those threads and the whole flag comes apart. So each of us represents a thread in our way of life. So it's important that we all come together and share our experiences there for the better. So thank you. Appreciate it.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Leif Babin - Navy SEAL Leadership Lessons, Native American Culture and Military Transition.

    Nov 19, 20261 hr 58 minAudio

    Leif Babin is a former Navy SEAL, author and co-founder of Echelon Front. We discuss his childhood in Texas, the Native American community, his journey into the Navy, leadership in the first responder professions, the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Adrian Dillehay and Sir Michael Branch - Fire Service Mentorship, Line of Duty Deaths and Leadership

    Nov 17, 20261 hr 45 minAudio

    Fire Chief Adrian Dillehay serves as the executive leader of the Westfield Fire Department, where he began his fire service career in 2007. An East Aldine native, he joined the Houston Fire Department in 2011 and...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Josh Brolin II - Catharsis through Writing, Internet Trolls and the Importance of Family

    Nov 16, 20262 hr 1 minAudio

    Josh Brolin is a former wildland firefighter, actor and writer. In this second interview, we discuss social media, fame, family, kindness, trolls, adventure, writing and much more. Josh's Book: From Under the Truck....

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Steph Crossland - Street Medicine, Surviving a Near Fatal Accident and the World of Emergency Nursing)

    Nov 14, 20263 hr 3 minAudio

    Steph Crossland spent her firefighting career with Orange County rising to the rank of Lieutenant. After a near fatal accident, she transitioned to full time ICU nursing. We discuss her journey into the fire service,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Erica Hay (The Deadly Cost of Organizational Betrayal, Sex Crimes and Compassionate Policing) - Episode 1304

    Nov 12, 20262 hr 14 minAudio

    Erica L. Hay is the owner and managing attorney of Spartan Law of Florida, PLLC, bringing more than 30 years of combined experience in law enforcement, criminal justice, and legal practice. Before becoming an attorney,...

    Credit the people on this episode