Dr. Stacy Cecchet, Ph.D., ABPP, is a forensic and operational psychologist with over a decade of experience supporting law enforcement, tactical teams, investigative units, and other high-demand professionals. Her work focuses on behavioral analysis, investigative strategy, offender typologies, interview strategy, human performance under stress, and functional wellness in operational environments. She consults on complex and high-risk investigations and provides training to investigators, undercover units, tactical teams, K9 handlers, peer support teams, and command staff. Her work helps agencies apply psychological science to improve operational decision-making, performance, stress management, and long-term readiness. Dr. Cecchet considers it a professional responsibility and an honor to support those who serve in these demanding roles. https://drstacycecchet.com/
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
This episode is sponsored by Active 911, a respected leader in the emergency communication and software field, providing alerting, mapping, and scene resources for over half a million first responders worldwide. Now, as you know, I only bring sponsors on this show who are A, coming from an altruistic place and B, truly bringing solutions to problems. And the origin story of Active 911 begins with volunteer firefighter and tech entrepreneur Joseph
Sullivan. After missing a critical call from a dispatch error, Joseph set out to create a solution to ensure that we are not only dispatched on time. but also provide us with resources and information for the call and location. So there are three different products under the Active 911 umbrella. The first is Active Alert, a dispatch system integrated into a CAD connection, providing fast, reliable alerting, maps, data, pre -plans,
hydrant locations, and even the locations of incoming units and their specialties. The second arm is Active Comms. Now, many of us have experienced problems when it came to communication using our traditional radios. So Active 911 found a way of tapping into the incredible capabilities of modern day smartphones and integrate that into our communication, providing both increased range and low latency. So to learn more about Active 911 or to try their free trial, go to
Active911 .com. And if you want to hear more about the origin and spectrum of products that they offer, listen to episode 1243 of the Behind the Shield podcast with the creator and founder, Joseph Sullivan. Welcome to the Behind the Shield podcast. As always, my name is James Geering. And this week, it is my absolute honor to welcome on the show, board certified psychologist with a specialized expertise in operational psychology.
criminal behavior analysis, and human performance optimization, Dr. Stacey Chiquette. Now, in this conversation, we discuss a host of topics from her journey into the world of psychology, specializing in pediatrics, her work with the Internet Crimes Against Children Unit, the impact of that work on our first responders, pedophiles in power, unchecked narcissism, the ripple effects of the pandemic, important red flags for parents, and
so much more. Now, before we get to this incredible conversation, as I say every week, please just take a moment. Go to whichever app you listen to this on, subscribe to the show, leave feedback, and leave a rating. Every single five -star rating truly does elevate this podcast, therefore making it easier for others to find. And this is a free library of well over 1 ,200 episodes now. So all I ask in return is that you help share these
incredible men and women's stories so I can get them to every single person on planet Earth who needs to hear them. So with that being said, I introduce to you... Dr. Stacey Chiquette. Enjoy.
Well, Stacey, I want to start by saying two things. Firstly, thank you to our mutual friend Brad Beeler for making this connection, and this is a long time coming. And secondly, I want to welcome you onto the Behind the Shield podcast today. Thank you so much for having me, and huge thanks to Brad as well. So where on planet Earth are we finding you this morning? I'm in the Pacific Northwest, and we have sunshine today, so it's a fine day over here. I'm glad to hear it. I'm in Florida. So we have sunshine almost every day. And this time of year, it's a lot of sunshine.
It's too much sunshine. Too much sunshine. You'll never hear a Pacific Northwesterner complain about that. No, no. That's why people come here for a week and then they go home in the summer. And it's beautiful. I love it here. But yeah, our favorite time of year, my favorite time of year here is the winter. It's gorgeous then. All right. Well, let's start the very beginning of your timeline. So tell me where you were born. And tell me a little bit about your family dynamic, what your parents did, how many siblings? Oh, okay. Well, I was born and raised in Northern
California, raised for, I would say, probably, you know, half my youth, and then finished up the last few years of high school up in the Pacific Northwest area. And I have two sisters and... Like so many people in the first responder space, I feel like you have people that have these really beautiful developmental histories. You know,
they come from first responder families or they come from families that have these really inspiring stories that led them into this space or, you know, they're really faith -based and that led them into being a first responder. you find people that had a very very difficult developmental history um and i you know i think it's something like 50 of first responders have at least one uh like adverse childhood experience which already even just the one is is like 15 higher than the
general population so it's yeah it's always interesting asking about developmental history in this in this population It's funny, I've heard even higher statistics, so that a lot of us have an ACEs of six. And, you know, when I compare that, and maybe it's a skewed perspective, but a lot of the people I've had on the show that are wearing uniform, myself included, there are a lot of elements that you can see created a desire in a young child to build an armor, to be the protector,
to be part of a tribe where they feel safe, you know, the very, very tenets that we find in our professions. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And I mean, the idea of serving your community, right, that can be done in so many different ways. But there's something very unique about an individual that chooses to serve their community in a first responder capacity, right? There's something qualitatively different about that. And yeah, you're absolutely right. There's a huge part
of it is, you know, wanting to have that. that family, that tribe, and wanting to have that sense of safety and security. Although I feel like for... At least for our law enforcement community right now, there is not a very, very much of a sense of safety for them at all with all the anti -law enforcement sentiment and the idea of even feeling safe going out in the communities that they serve isn't present for everybody, depending on the community that they're in. So
we've just seen fundamental changes in that since 2020. And, you know, that's had really significant consequences for their mental health status. Well, I know I'm putting you in a corner because you're the one normally asking these questions. So without being specific then, when you reflect back on your formative years, were there elements you think that contributed to you also being someone who wanted to stop people being hurt? Yeah, definitely. I mean, I, you know, like so
many of our colleagues, I've had a... difficult developmental history. And I always felt really strongly about making sure that kids felt safe at home, felt safe at school, had trusted adults that they could go to. I mean, there's so much research out there on the impact of adverse childhood experiences. And we talk about the impact of ACEs, you know, throughout the lifespan. But there's also this other part of research that talks about how even having just one safe adult
a teacher a coach a neighbor a mentor is life -changing for kids and so from a very young age i was always very interested in the psychology behind that and in serving our community and volunteering i always did a lot of volunteer work usually in a space where i was you know working with kids or families and i just kind of carried that through as i went through college and graduate school and residency and my postdoc and all of the things and was able to really
shape my career into something that's incredibly meaningful to me because of that. What about sports and exercise? What were you playing and doing when you were in the school ages? Well, I was one of those kids that played the sports, even though I was horribly uncoordinated. So huge thanks to coaches and teammates that allowed me to participate, even though I am not I don't have great gross motor skills. I'm the person that like walks into the corner of the table all the time and, you know, rams my elbow or
into the door jam. But I grew up swimming competitively. And I mean, from probably I think I started swimming. Gosh. maybe when I was six it was called minnows was the swim team for like the littles it's adorable and I swam all through high school and then I played volleyball in um in high school as well and then when I went to college it was mostly just you know like independently working out or you know doing some kind of sports with friends
or whatever but nothing formal or organized We've got a swimming facility that just built about three or four years ago near me. And they literally have, I think, events from all over the state come and host there. It's an Olympic sized pool and they've got, you know, strength and conditioning, all the things. But they've got a summer camp at the moment. And I think it's the young kids, but it's the manatees. And I was thinking, I don't know if that's the best name for, you know, maybe kids that are self -aware about their body being called the manatees in that particular group. So they might want to rebrand that one.
Yeah, maybe they might want to rebrand that. Yeah. So you mentioned about the mentor was interesting because this is a conversation I'm sure we'll take a deeper dive into this, but. The ACEs, you know, we have a high kind of score on average in the first responder and military profession. And I'm told that it kind of mirrors what you see in the incarcerated population as well, which shows you that you have hurt children getting to a crossroads and their mentor might be a history teacher or a sports coach, or it might be a drug
dealer or a gangbanger. And then, you know, off you go to that direction. So talk to me about, you know, that mentor and if you want to even expand on that topic as far as that, you know, my philosophy is we all have the potential to really heal from this trauma. You're not labeled by it, but the mentors in your life do often dictate which direction you go. Yeah, I definitely agree with that. And I also think, you know, when we talk about resilience, we talk about
it as if resilience is. is kind of the be all end all of, you know, navigating, you know, adverse childhood experiences or things like that. But I think one of the things that mentorship can instill in children or really can instill in anybody at any age is the addition of grit and hardiness. And it's not, you know, resilience is the, the. ability to overcome adversity. And
it actually doesn't really imply anything about how you're going to be once you overcome the adversity, you're just you're overcoming the adversity. And that's what resilience means. And if you're lucky, you're able to have post traumatic growth. So that's the hardiness piece that's coming out stronger than you were. at the beginning of things and you know that that requires a growth mindset that requires um you know believing in something bigger than yourself in some sort of way it doesn't have to be religious
right it could be in any capacity but you have to be able to make meaning from your suffering and meaning from the adversity and seek to grow from that and that's something that I think a lot of people learn from mentorship, from teachers talking about it, from reading about it in books or seeing something inspiring in movies, from witnessing it in your friends. And then the other part of that is grit. And grittiness is, again,
adversity, overcoming adversity, but it's overcoming adversity in pursuit of a goal. So it's being goal oriented, even when the deck is stacked against you and doing hard things and having really good delayed gratification. And that can also be something that's really hard to learn or understand if you don't get to see that modeled in your home or in your community. And the only time you see that is maybe if a teacher is encouraging you or a coach is encouraging you. So mentorship really just provides so many gifts to everyone.
Everybody in all stages of life, not just kids. I'm jumping ahead again, but I think we're already kind of opening this door. When I first was made aware of the mental health crisis conversation in the first responders was literally only about 10 years ago. We had a local battalion chief take his own life and he put a Facebook post on. And that's really what kind of ran through social media, which obviously back then was still being looked at a lot more. And it initiated
this conversation. Obviously, there were some people in our community that have been talking about this for a long time, and most of us just weren't paying attention or weren't aware of their work. And so the learning curve has been extremely steep from pretty much ignorant through to the conversations we're having today. And my perspective is we've kind of got our trouser leg caught on the sad story of first responder PTSD, and they keep killing themselves and the alcoholism. And those are obviously... a real thing. I mean, we know it's a real thing, but
when it's a sad story, it's hard to break away from that kind of victim mentality that's attached to it. And these people are a victim and we'll obviously unpack the compounding factors to that. But where I think we're missing the point, and I know this is an area that you specialize in, is the performance conversation. that when you take those struggles that you have when you were younger, and I would like to see it happen at the front door of a fire department or a police department where they say, look, the fact that you're here, you've probably been through some shit, let's be honest. So let's start right there.
But for you to operate in a flow state or as close to a flow state in a gunfight, in a primary search in the middle of a structure fire, a pediatric cardiac arrest at three in the morning, we need you to have your mind clear. So we're going to use the tools. to work towards a flow state the same way as your favorite football player or baseball player would to win you know yes their championship and then that puts exactly in positivity and excitement into the the mental health conversation and if you focus on performance obviously you're
pulling people away from suicide ideation and addiction and all these other areas so i think we're missing that in my profession that growth mindset when it comes to post -traumatic growth and how How exciting James 2 .0 could be if he's able to, you know, work through some of the things of his early life and then breath work and meditation and work on his sleep and now be an optimal firefighter or police officer? Yes, 100 percent, 100 percent.
You know, so I do a lot of work. around operational readiness and functional wellness and human performance optimization. And I think one of the most important things that I talk about when I'm working with peer support teams or training command or even just working one -on -one with people is that we are not operating in a silo and we treat behavioral health as if it's its own. kind of special pillar.
And behavioral health is not operating in a vacuum. And just like you said, it's impacted by, you know, nutrition, sleep, our family relationships, our interpersonal relationships, our cognitive style, our emotion regulation skills, our developmental history, and how activated our central nervous system is. And, you know, there's so many components to it. And we're not going to make the progress that we should be making if we continue to think
of behavioral health as something siloed. And I mean, I'm working with, you know, agencies now that are, you know, looking at the role of financial stress in wellness, and they're bringing in financial advisors and providing financial workshops for their people. You know, I know so many first responders that will stay in this field much longer than they should, even when they're eligible for retirement, because they don't feel like they can retire financially. You know, maybe they've got a... you know, a
kid in high school or a kid still in college or, you know, they had a divorce and lost half their pension. And, you know, they will tell me I want to leave, but I can't. And if we can help people understand from the very beginning, like you were saying, as soon as they walk in the door at the academy, what financial health and wellness looks like and how to plan appropriately, that could also be a huge game changer for people. And yeah, there are so many areas that could
be addressed. And I think that until we're able to really look at things holistically, we're going to kind of plateau with wellness. Absolutely. Well, kind of going back on the timeline again, when you were in the school age, were you already thinking about the world of psychology or was there something else in your mind? Oh, geez. You know, I think that, I don't know if I would
say I was thinking about the world of psychology because I probably didn't know much about. that really in like elementary school and middle school. But I definitely had an awareness of, you know, friends that I had where it felt like maybe something was happening at home and they weren't safe or something felt weird. You know, and kids are really good at identifying when something feels weird. You know, they'll be able to say, you
know, it makes my tummy hurt or, you know, my body feels really tight. You know, they might not be able to verbalize all of the things that an adult would, but kids can identify those things really well. And so I definitely had an awareness of like when I would go to friends' houses or, you know, interact with somebody and my body would feel. And I remember that I had a friend in middle school who was not safe in her home because her mother was really violent. And I
remember, you know, really struggling to understand how that. continued to happen. Because I, I told the school, I told my parents, I'm pretty sure that CPS made a visit, just based on things that I you know, heard from that friend as we got older. But nothing was actually done about it. And I remember being really distressed about that. And that's kind of the theme throughout
my formative years is recognizing when people are in these situations that... they don't feel safe or they're not healthy. And thinking about ways that we can help, that I could help either as a friend or a peer or something like that, help them move past that in some way. And obviously as a kid, there's nothing that I could really do other than, you know, you tell a safe grownup or you tell a teacher or something like that. But as I got older into high school and college
and graduate school, you know, realizing how powerful it is to just listen to somebody and just provide a space where they can just say the things, right? They can finally talk about what's happening and not see horror or judgment or have somebody telling them, well, did you do this thing? You should say this thing, this or that. But just the power of just being present with somebody is really transformative sometimes.
We had the pandemic obviously a few years ago, and I've heard this from several people in your field or similar fields, that one of the biggest tragedies about the schools closing down was a lot of times that was where the outcries were made. That was where the children felt safe. They were confiding in teachers or counselors, and that was taken away for some of them, you know, a year plus. What was your perspective from the children's mental health point of view? Of the way that the pandemic was handled. I mean, obviously there was initially a, you know, a
threat and people had to adjust, but the unspoken ripple effect of the way that they isolated children during that time. Oh, I mean, I think we're still seeing downstream impacts from that, that just, we had no way to really anticipate. You know, I think, I think there's a number of. There's so many ways, actually, our kids were impacted by that. You know, so in the area that I work
in, I work with law enforcement and I've been embedded with law enforcement for, you know, almost a decade, but working collaboratively with law enforcement for almost two decades at this point. And, you know, I tend to think about. impacts, behavioral health impacts on kids, not just in terms of the traditional behavioral health impacts, depression, anxiety, social skills, things like that, but also in terms of vulnerability
to exploitation. And we, of course, we saw kids really struggling to learn and practice developmentally appropriate social skills. We saw kids, you know, really struggling to learn the academic skills that they needed. We saw kids becoming more and more isolated. I mean, so many families had to work, right? And so the kids were on the computer. doing school or supposed to be doing school.
And there was very little supervision because parents were working, whether parents were working on their computer in the other room, you know, or in a first responder field and actually going to work physically. I mean, just these kids were really, really isolated for so many reasons and isolated from their peers in ways that they had never been before. And then you look at, you know, the the role of masking in in child development so of course you have the the you know mask mandates
and and concerned for viral transmission and things like that and so masking is what it is but in terms of like when you look at the part of the face that's covered with a mask you have these kids that are only seeing this part of faces for sometimes years and 70 % of our communication is nonverbal. And so we're having these kids that are not learning how to read any sort of nonverbal communication on somebody's face because
all they're seeing is this. And maybe we'll see research is always at least two years behind what we're seeing anecdotally just because of how long it takes to spin up a research study, conduct the research. get the findings publish it all the things um you know maybe we'll see that some kids now have some like supercharged ability to read you know just like the the micro uh ocular expressions i don't know but i feel like there's there's so much that happens in the rest of our face and even in our shoulders
and our posture um and our kids just didn't get the opportunity to learn how to read those skills and others in in real time and i think that That's had a lot of impacts in how kids are navigating the social environment now. You know, so many kids missed all these major developmental milestones, like, you know, high school dances and prom and graduation ceremonies. And they were just robbed of so, so much. And then you look at, you know,
anxiety about, you know, getting sick or anxiety about germs or, you know, things that maybe kids weren't. particularly concerned about wasn't even on their radar on the front end and now they're very very worried about that and you have grief and loss from family members that that passed away that you know they probably would have had in their lives for longer and then in addition to all of that you have kids unsupervised on the internet and wherever kids are is where we have our child predators. And
so we had more kids being victimized online than we have ever had before. And our law enforcement officers and NCMEC and all these incredible agencies designed to protect kids were not equipped to deal with that. And we're still flooded with... reports of online child exploitation. There are so many. We could have every law enforcement officer in the country working on these cases,
and we would still have a backlog. And so it's just had these massive impacts on child victimization and exploitation. And this is what we need to hear. This is the thing. I'm not out here beating a drum that James Gearing has all the answers. I asked the people, boots on the ground, the people that were in the hotspots that did have a lot of the fatalities, the people that built... morgues outside hospitals that never got used once and had to disassemble them again you know the the people in your your field the teachers i mean so many of these voices because the biggest
tragedy aside from obviously the human losses was the fact that no lessons were learned and no one seemed to care about well what what did we do well what did we do wrong what should we change next time and now we know it's pretty hard proof that i'm coming from a profession that wears a mask There's only a certain kind of mask that's fit that is, you know, is actually going to make a difference. And I was just, I was at a doctor's office with my wife a couple of days ago, and there was a sign on the side saying, wear a cloth mask. I don't know if it was still left over, but a cloth mask. So cut
up a t -shirt, put some elastic on it and slap it over. That's not going to do anything. So you're, like you said, you know, what, what are the things that were necessary, isolating people with, you know. pre -existing conditions also immune disease the elderly keep them away keep them safe but don't tell the children that they're murderers and force vaccines on them if there's no efficacy of the vaccine if that's you know the children are able to navigate this this virus and still go to school so it's not that you know oh you guys were all wrong or you guys were all
right it's just okay what what was right what was wrong and what was very damaging so that when the next virus comes what are we going to do differently? And I think if it wasn't, you know, if we didn't need, for example, to have a mask on everyone, then that's an important takeaway. If we didn't need to stop everyone from going to work or going to school, that's an important takeaway. How can we adjust it? But if we don't have the conversations like you and I are having now retroactively, as we call it in the fire service, a tailboard critique, then you're not going to learn any lessons. And
it was a very much, as soon as it was done, sweep it under the rug. But as you just said, but people are still suffering from the poor decisions that were made then. And when that includes our children being preyed upon, we sure as hell should be talking about this. Yeah, I think technology moves so quickly that it is so hard to anticipate even six months from now. you know, how offenders will victimize our kids online because there's
always something new coming out, a new app, a new game, you know, some new way of exploitation. And so I understand it can be really daunting to figure out how to proactively combat that. But I agree. I mean, we definitely need to be addressing it and talking about it and thinking about what we can put in place proactively. And, you know, regardless of... what comes next let's say something comes next and and absolutely everybody has to wear masks let's say we all agree every
which would never happen nobody would ever agree about all the things but in this pretend world even in that setting where legitimately everybody has to wear a mask um i think that we can we can learn about from this past pandemic, how viral transmission occurs in open spaces. And I mean, seeing kids, you know, you know, at playgrounds, even now, sometimes still wearing masks. I think that there are probably some some flexible ways
that we can think about navigating supporting our kids development and healthy ways. It's just it's really hard to do in the moment when your limbic system has hijacked your brain. And you go into, you know, your fight, flight, freeze, fawn space, and you're just in this survival mode. And you can't really think through downstream impacts or even, you know, what can we learn from this right now and how can we change it? And I, you know, I talked to so many psychologists
during the pandemic. And here with the Washington State Department of Health, I was, you know, I was able to work on a behavioral health strike team that was pushing out guidance across the state. for not only first responders and behavioral health providers, but teachers and pediatricians and people around the state looking at kids' mental health and teachers' mental health and all these things and some ways to help promote connection and all of these really important
pro -social skills that have such huge impacts on mental health. And I think that there is a lot that we can learn from that and be more aware of when this happens again in the future. What was interesting, you just made me think about this because I got a friend who was a leader in the SEAL teams who lives in your area in the Pacific Northwest. And when we first spoke about this virus, I've never heard him so angry, so animated, so fearful. And this is someone who
was in combat for decades. And as you then saw, like you said, this kind of World War I trench mentality, where you were either all on one side or all the other, like in the podcast, we were talking before we hit record, the reason I do three a week is because of COVID. Because I was looking left and looking right and going, why aren't people just saying, yeah, in the middle, there's some of this and some of this. But what are the actionable things that you can do in the meantime? So I had nutritionists and farmers and psychologists and strength and conditioning coaches and all the people. So at least they
could access that information while they were being told they couldn't leave their home. But the ease with which the community was cleaved to the point that friends and families were broken apart. To me, and I say this with compassion, not with judgment, really alluded to the fact that there was a simmering mental health crisis nationally, that people could go from zero to 100 without the ability to take a step back and critically think about this thing, wait a few
weeks, see the results, are their bodies lying everywhere in the street, and then kind of deescalate. But it would seem very, very quickly from zero to 100. Where if you didn't subscribe to the Chinese conspiracy or, you know, wrap everyone in plastic, you know, if you were in the middle, you're a heretic. If you didn't go one or the other, then you were vilified, you were demonized. And that was almost, again, one of the saddest things to see how quickly people would drag to one of the two extremes. Yeah, you know, it's
interesting for me to, from a psychological standpoint, to think about that because Prior to the pandemic, it's hard for me to identify, you know, very many times in my lifetime where I saw something that was so polarizing for every community. You know, of course, you have things that will be polarizing and only in certain groups or things
like that. But this was, you know, impacting people. across all walks of life. And I mean, of course, you have things like, you know, the Vietnam War, right? That was very polarizing. But it's hard for me to recall that really happening in my lifetime prior to COVID. And now I feel like, and I'm sure there's something I'm not thinking of. But, you know, now I feel like... That's almost the default. You know, we look at politics, right? And people are like all one
side or all the other. And there is very little middle ground and very little discussion of like, yeah, what about some of this? And what about some of this? And it's just the other side is demonized. It doesn't matter. And we're, you know, we see the same thing happening where, you know, people are just continuing friendships. They're cutting family members out of this. their lives. They're having massive conflicts with coworkers. And I feel like it's becoming more and more common to see these really, really divisive
responses to things that I wouldn't expect to create such a divide necessarily. I'm going to take you on one more rabbit hole, then we'll get back to your psychology journey. I'm here for it. I'm here for it. I just had Gabor Mate on the show, and he had actually talked about this in his book. And this is a realization I only had probably about a year ago. And it was listening to one of Joe Rogan's guests just make a comment. And they were talking about people
of power and abuse of power and that kind of thing. And Joe had made some comment like, well, the head of this drug company is obviously a turd or whatever phrase he used. And this guy said, no, but he's hurting too. And then they just carried on with the conversation. But I'm like, well, wait a second, timeout. As you and I both know, when there's a mental health conversation in our kind of atmosphere, it's the firefighter, the cop, the dispatcher, the EMT that's struggling. And it's the people on the street. It's us. But there's no conversation about mental health or
even sociopath elements in positions of power that are incredibly dangerous. And what I've kind of realized now is if you are, again, that hurt child that never did any work, that then you could, in theory, become the head of Purdue Pharma, where your product kills 100 ,000 Americans every year and you sleep soundly in your bed, or the head of William Morris Tobacco, or maybe even a president or a prime minister. And this is an interesting kind of new conversation. we
are held to what they call fit for duty. If James can't do the job, he's struggling, he's drinking too much, whatever, I'm taken off the rig until hopefully you get me the tools that I need help and I come back stronger and now I'm a beacon of light for other people of healing. But we don't have that conversation with these people who arguably at some point are sociopaths. If you're the head of, if you're the Sackler family and you deliberately prey upon communities knowing that addiction will happen so you could profit. That is sociopathy. So what is your take on that?
We're always looking at the ground of the men and women in the uniform, but some of these positions of power, some of these companies that really truly are a detriment to the men, women, and children of America that profit off them, the mental health conversation of some of those positions and the conversation is if they are not fit for duty, should they be in that position in the first place? I mean, there's been a lot of research done looking at, like we'll use the term snakes
in suits. That's the name of a book that Robert Hare wrote, who's a Canadian researcher, psychologist who has done a lot of work looking at psychopathy and how to assess for psychopathy. And, you know, the reality is that We think of a psychopath as somebody that's a serial killer. The reality is that many serial killers are not psychopaths. But that's the only kind of portrayal that we
have of them in, you know, media or books or things like that, usually. But the reality is that in order to... be a CEO of a Fortune 500 company or, you know, hold a position where you have a lot of power over a lot of people, you do have to have some of those traits in order to be really successful. I mean, you don't have to be. Certainly there are CEOs that are lovely human beings and are not psychopaths in any way,
shape or form. But it is not uncommon to see some of the people that are in the highest positions of power or you know have the the most um you know status in a very large company have traits that are are congruent with psychopathy you know this this callousness this superficial charm you know really lack of regard for others um you know parasitic lifestyle they just like suck up whatever they need from everybody else and
just kind of move on. You know, no empathy or regard for the 100 ,000 people they're laying off, right? That's why their company is so successful. They, you know, they'll buy a company and just, you know, cleave it in two and fire all these people. Don't think twice about it. You know, cut all these corners or make all these changes and get this huge profit, right? And that's their bottom line. I think it takes a particular type of person to do that and to really only focus
on whatever their bottom line is, typically profit. There are some people that do that very well, and they're probably not well themselves. And so, yeah, I think that we do see that a lot. We see that in leadership in first responder agencies as well. One of the things that I like to point out when I'm talking to people and they're really struggling with you know, someone in leadership or struggling with a public figure or, you know, something like that is that, you know, a lot
of times that that person that they're struggling with, whether it's somebody they actually know, right, or somebody that they don't really know, but they're still struggling, that person is not well. And once I'm able to kind of reframe it, because people will say like, oh, that person's crazy. But we use crazy in such a colloquial way that doesn't really have a lot of, it can mean so many things, doesn't have a lot of specific meaning. But to say, yeah, you're right. Actually, I think that person's probably really unwell. And you can see this change on their face where
they're realizing, oh, yes, actually, you're right. They probably are really unwell. And it doesn't negate, you know, whatever inappropriate behavior or actions that they've done. But it's a different lens with which to interpret that behavior. And then it also helps, I think, shift the locus of control, right? Like, so this is a them issue, right? This is about them. They are not well, and this is about them. This is
not about me. And being able to reframe that can be really powerful. Well, I think this is the danger and going back to what you said about the polarization, which again has spanned, you know, two administrations now, you know, 10 years at least, where when you put someone who is just not fit for a position and, you know, they're benefiting from the, you know, a divided nation, then this is now affecting, you know, 350 million people because of, you know, one or two people
that never did the work. And then the goal is to address this with compassion and empathy and say, look, this is a fire chief, for example. They go home five o 'clock every night. You know, their people are working eight weeks because of mandatory overtime. They've got numerous suicides. Fire chief sleeps at night. This is a problem. Like you said, this is this is the same thing. This isn't a president now. It's a fire chief. The goal is that that person goes and does the work and they come back. As we just talked about, post -traumatic growth, better for it, compassion and empathy returned. And now they turn the ship
around and they start being the leader. That's the ultimate goal. That would be incredible. Yeah. But option B is if they don't, then they do not need to be in that position because they don't have the traits that it takes. And it's very, very simple. A leader brings people together. They care about the well -being, the safety of their fire department, their nation, whatever it is. But a tyrant, a dictator divides and crushes and rules with fear. So, you know, just like you said, there are so many good examples of great leaders. I think the president of Finland
is a person to really look at at the moment. I mean, he's so articulate. They're a very, you know, very healthy country, amazing education system. So that's someone you can say, all right, well, then we need someone kind of looks like this guy or, you know, a female version of or whatever. But, you know, if you just said dying on your sword because you swore that you would be all. left or all right, you're also part of the problem because you're not acknowledging that the person that you think is your messiah is actually someone who's mentally ill. I think the challenge that I see a lot with the first
responder community is that it's very difficult to hold leadership accountable. So if you have a chief or a commander or a deputy chief or assistant chief or somebody that has a lot of power, it can be really hard to hold them accountable from the perspective of the people on the bottom. And so often, especially in government, what I see is the problematic supervisors just get
promoted out instead of actually having a real... consequence. And until we're able to start, until we're able to stop that, promoting problem people out of their position and just moving them to just continue the damage that they're inflicting, until we're, you know, we're able to stop that, until we're able to hold people accountable and also provide effective, corrective action. Just having a punitive response, certainly for some
people, having a punitive response, especially if their behavior isn't really congruent with who they are. They acted in a way that they're already embarrassed about, and now there's a punitive response. They're unlikely to repeat that behavior. But for somebody that really doesn't care about how they're behaving and isn't likely to take responsibility, just having a punishment isn't going to do anything. We're not very good at thinking about... what the corrective action should be. And, you know, I'm embedded with a number of law enforcement agencies across our
state. And, you know, it's really it's really incredible how many agencies I work with that are now approaching me when there is, you know, an internal investigation occurring and they're saying, hey, we want to better understand. you know how a behavior like this occurs and what does that mean is this actually a manifestation of somebody that's really struggling with a behavioral health issue and what sort of intervention can we can we offer or can we recommend? Instead
of just saying, no, we're going to put you on admin leave for 25 days and then you can come back to work. Now they're saying, you know, what if we offer them therapy? What if we offer them this great, you know, substance abuse treatment or, you know, support in this very specific way? And that is how we help grow. our first responder community in a really healthy direction. That's how we create this post -traumatic growth. And that's what we need to be doing instead of just having these punitive responses or just ignoring
the issue altogether. Well, this is what I've said. You get a lot of people that say they're dealing with someone at the moment, DUI or whatever it was. And I always ask them, what were they like when you hired them? oh man they were amazing the best rookie we ever had and they won this award it's like okay so then don't you think that some of the reason why they're struggling now is the job itself and if you just let them go you've done a huge disservice because you have an opportunity this person now has obviously
taken a down you know a nosedive and emotionally and so wrapping them around in the resources they need again going back to the post -traumatic growth they can not only be where they were before, but even better than they were before. And I'm sure you've heard this a million times. The people that did the work, people that had the courage to say, I need help, and then into whatever it was, whether it was just simply talk therapy, or they went on a psychedelic retreat, or whatever the perfect toolbox for them, their own unique toolbox was, and they come out the other end,
every single one of those people like, dude, it was crazy. Once I went back to the station, people would pull me to the corner all over the place and be like, hey, how did you do that? Because I've been going through some stuff. So behind this mask, so many people are struggling. But if you just say the moment you mess up, we're going to terminate you. To give you a parallel, my son was in middle school and was going through some stuff emotionally. He was seeing a counselor. There was some kind of... Not physical violence,
but a very toxic relationship between his mother and her boyfriend at the time. And it was definitely having an effect on him. And again, that feeling safe, as you said. And he was crying in school one day. And they put him on a 72 -hour hold without even telling me. What? Yes. I swear to God. I called because I didn't have a call from him. He normally called me to say he was on the bus on his way home. And they said, oh, Mr. Gearns is the principal. We're dealing with your son right now. We'll let you know. I call back. Nothing. And then they tell me, oh, he's in the psych
facility. Now, that was something that was happening in Florida. And I, you know, added to all the voices that were already, you know, fighting it. And someone had already put in legislation to get it changed. But it was a knee jerk after Parkland. And I pulled police records and there were over 100 children had been Baker active in that year alone. So what do you think that did for the? Little boys and girls of at this point, the Liberty Middle School in Ocala, how
often do you think they were going to tell people how they're feeling now? When you said the moment you say that you're struggling in any way, we're going to take your shoelaces and your belt and we're going to put you in a white room for three days and you can't see your parents. And the ripple effect of that, you know, we're still unwrapping to this day. But this is to your point with the first responders. If you have that punitive only lens in our profession. And you tell a cop you're going to take his gun the moment he says he's struggling, or she, then all you're doing is telling people, hey, don't actually tell us
about your mental health. I mean, we'll just find out when you stick that gun in your mouth. But apart from that, just keep it to yourself. And it couldn't be more toxic, the polar opposite of what is absolutely needed. And like you said, even if someone's done something a little bit more... you know, unwarranted, like a DUI or something like that, this is a red flag that's held straight in your face as someone that was an amazing employee is now hurting. And by disciplining them only and not giving them the outlets that
they need, you're just disregarding the years of service they gave you before. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, I have... a task force that i worked with in another state and that was an internet crimes against children task force and when i first started connecting with them um i met them at a conference and i was talking to the the task force commander and and some of the sergeants and they were telling me that they had been asking their agency for wellness
programming for their ICAC task force because everybody was really struggling. And, you know, internet crimes against children is a whole nother level of crime type for people to be exposed to. And it's fundamentally different, I think, than what we see in a lot of other spaces. And it requires, I think, unique wellness programming. And so these investigators, these supervisors were saying to their agency, hey, we need wellness programming specific. for our investigators that
are that are doing this work um you know what are our options for for that and the agency came back to them and said okay we hear that you are not doing well because of this work so what we're going to do is we're going to have you do a fitness for duty evaluation every six months and i i was appalled i was appalled and absolutely horrified that it could not be a worse response And all
that did is exactly what you said, is it taught this group of people that they, not only can they not tell anybody at their agency when they're not doing okay, they cannot ask for help, but they are not safe. They are not safe in their role because the first time that somebody even suspects that they are struggling, there will be a potentially catastrophic consequence to their career. And it is so unjust and so disrespectful
to all of the years of service and sacrifice that our first responders have made. It is just horrifying. So let's flip that on its head. What are the models that you've seen that should be held as the gold standard in our profession for continuous, obviously, access to mental health counseling? And then, God forbid, someone really enters a crisis mode. So we're in a pretend world right now where everybody has all the funding
they need and there are all the culturally competent providers available. So in this pretend world, I mean, I think the gold standard is looking at, you know, behavioral health through the lens of functional wellness and operational readiness. So you would have, you know, a culturally competent clinician available for behavioral health support, but you would also have culturally competent nutritionists, culturally competent physical
and occupational therapists, right? Because there are very unique injuries that first responders experience and very unique types of muscle strain that first responders experience and there are specific ways that They can go through physical therapy or occupational therapy and correct that. And if they don't have a clinician that's culturally competent, that's going to be really problematic. You know, so having having somebody available like that, having somebody available for financial
counseling and to help, you know, with with financial advising. And all of these things really should be available starting at the academy level or even pre academy workshops talking about this. There also should be family based support. We're terrible at that. We're terrible at that. So many first responders that I know will tell me that they want to protect their spouse from the reality of this work. Their spouse doesn't need to be exposed to this trauma and doesn't need
to hear about the horrific things that they've... seen or heard or experienced in their daily life. And so they, you know, they don't talk about work with their spouse. And then essentially what we see is people getting divorced because they can't decide what to have for dinner. Right. This is this is the thing that I hear all the time is I don't I don't want to tell my spouse what's happening because I don't want them to be impacted. And so when I come home and I've had a really bad day, you know, my spouse asked me what I want for dinner and I tell them I don't
care. But the spouse knows something's wrong and is thinking, you won't talk to me. I don't know what's happening. The only way I can take care of you is by at least giving you like your high preference meal. Let me cook you a meal that you'll like. And the first responder is like, no, actually, I really don't care because I have massive decision fatigue. I cannot think through this. Like I would eat toast. It doesn't matter to me. Make ramen, right? I don't care. I cannot pick. And then the spouse is back to
being like, no, just tell me. Why won't you tell me? And then the first responder is like, why won't you just let me go? Right. Like, I don't care. And then people are getting a divorce because they can't decide what to have for dinner. And it's just this like this entrenched black and white thinking, not knowing how to communicate. And if we can help our first responders understand the difference between process and content, content is like, I saw these things today. That's irrelevant. What you saw or heard or experienced, that is
irrelevant in this context. It is irrelevant. What matters is how you are impacted. What is the process? My day went sideways. I can't stop thinking about this call or I can't get the sound out of my head or I can't stop worrying, you know, about our kids' safety, right? It doesn't matter what the thing was that triggered that, what the details of that were. What matters is you're communicating with your loved ones. how you are being impacted, and then they can support you. Oh, you can't stop thinking about this.
Okay. Let's do something to distract you. I know you love watching the stand -up comedy. Let's watch that together. Or do you want to go work out together? Or do you want to take the dog for a long walk and all, you know, put the kids to bed, right? But then our loved ones can meet us where we're at when they understand what's going on. But we just naturally kind of default to shutting them out because we don't want to traumatize them. And we also see that with colleagues. You know, we'll see people saying, well, I don't want to tell my colleague about this horrible thing that I... I'm dealing with because I don't
want them to be traumatized or I don't want to stress them out. But we get stuck in content and we forget about process. And I think if we can, again, at the academy level, help our new recruits understand those differences and give them tools for how to communicate with their loved ones and with their friends. man, they're going to be starting on such stronger footing. And also working with family members and loved ones to explain to them, these are some of the experiences that your first responder family member may have. These are some of the ways that
they may manifest some of their challenges. And here are some tools for you in your toolbox, right? And so we need all of these different pieces. We need to teach people how to sleep. People are so bad at sleeping in this space. It's so hard. And, you know, knowing how to how to, you know, navigate things when the reality is you aren't going to sleep. Right. I mean, I work with, you know, spec ops teams and tactical teams. And the reality is that sometimes they're
going to be downrange and they're not going to sleep for 72 hours. Right. The idea of like, oh, you need to sleep eight hours like this on the table. They're not doing that. So if that's not on the table, how can you appropriately manage your caffeine consumption? So that way you have, you know, optimal peak plasma levels of your caffeine. You know, what type of mechanism do you want to be ingesting the caffeine? You know, what kind of dosing time frame are we looking at? How can you have a period of restorative rest even if you can't sleep? But if you've got,
you know, 15 minutes on the. helicopter you know and you don't have to be totally you know activated in that in those 15 minutes can we pre -plan how you can get some restorative rest and so we need to be providing that support as well you know it needs to really be thinking about the whole person and then also talking about what does it mean to have growth mindset and and to you know to be forward thinking and how to be a flexible thinker you know just all all of these different pieces that is what a great
great wellness program would look like treating the whole person and all the systems that they're involved in and also promoting people being a whole person for so many first responders that is their entire identity all their friends are first responders all they do is watch first responder shows or read first responder books or listen to first responder podcasts and all they do is is think about being a first responder and helping people remember that they can have hobbies outside of that and they can have friends outside of
that and they can you know have a life outside of their their role as a first responder absolutely you hit on sleep which uh is a big you know talking point for me in the fire service on average most firefighters work 56 hour weeks so 24 on 48 off we have a retention recruitment crisis like pd does but ours really is more from The unwillingness to address the things that are broken in the way that we're worked because a police officer,
even though they're going to do 12, they're still working basically a 40 hour work week, your doctors, your nurses, everyone else. The people that you're going to call to come get your kid out of a burning building at three in the morning is working 56. And now because of overtime, they're working 80 hours that week. And, you know, it's insane. I've had a lot of people from the sleep medicine world and, you know, psychologists and psychiatrists and neuroscientists. But I think it's an important thing to understand. Now, the law enforcement side, I think there are some forward thinking ways of giving them more rest and recovery. But
when it comes to mental health in the fire service specifically. There's, again, old world thinking, well, it's what James saw. It was that minivan full of kids. It was whatever. That's why he's struggling. Now, obviously, now we know what happened to James from zero to 27 before he went into the fire department. But the sleep deprivation is something that they've just turned their head against. That's not a thing. And now people are realizing it is. And there's a movement to go to a 42 -hour week, which is happening here in Florida. And it's amazing to watch. With that
all being said, talk to me about the relationship between sleep deprivation and suicide ideation, depression, anxiety, addiction, et cetera. I mean, sleep is a cornerstone of our health and wellness, not just our mental health, right, but our physical health, our health in every single aspect. And, you know, I actually I do a lot of I do a lot of sleep training. So I do
a lot of workshops for various different law enforcement groups on sleep, how to sleep, tactical sleep, you know, recovery strategies, restorative rest, you know, all of those pieces. And when I first started doing sleep workshops and sleep training for law enforcement, I. you know i was thinking about how do you know how do i start the training what are the most important things to include you know in the beginning as we kind of ease into all of this and i i had the the first kind of quarter of this training that i
was doing where i was talking about sleep hygiene and i remember putting the training together thinking gosh i bet you everybody already knows all about this and they're going to be bored to tears as i'm lecturing them about sleep hygiene uh but on the off chance there's like one or two people you know in this group of 50 that don't know i'm going to include it just in case and if everybody's giving me these non -verbals of like we already know all this move on you know i can just like zip through and jump ahead
and so when i so i was nervous about having this chunk of the presentation where everybody was going to be bored. And I was 100 % certain that people were going to hate that part of the presentation because it's too repetitive. And then when I fast forward to when I get to the training and I'm starting it and I say, okay, you know, we're going to talk about sleep hygiene. And I'm assuming most of you, you know, already know what that is. But how many of you, you know, haven't heard the term sleep hygiene before? And almost every single person rose their hand. And I just remember
being shocked because in grad school, I mean, they beat that into you. This is sleep is like the number one thing that you address with your patients. Right. And and I just I was shocked. I couldn't believe that they hadn't even heard the term sleep hygiene. And so so much of the the health and wellness stuff that I do revolves around sleep. I mean, I don't I don't ever do. any sort of wellness workshops or training or consultation without talking about sleep. Because
a lot of times there are some little things that we can do to shape up sleep in a really big way, like these really small kind of bite -sized changes that we can make to net a really big downstream impact. But I would say just as often I talk with people and what they say is, I've always been a bad sleeper, right? You have two people. You have the one person that's like, I can go to sleep anytime, look. And they just fall asleep, right? On demand. They can have like four espresso shots and just pass out afterwards. And then you have the people that are like, oh, you know, my whole life, I've never been a good sleeper.
And for the people that have never been good sleepers, they really don't actually have any hope that that could ever change because that's just what it's been like for them. And there's definitely, you know, these genetic factors that influence somebody's, you know. natural sleep -wake cycle and all sorts of other pieces. But there are many ways that we can help our first responders sleep better, even if they've never
been quote -unquote good sleepers. And I feel like we just don't even try. When I first started in this space a decade ago, I would go to different trainings that other clinicians were giving for first responders because I want to know what are my people learning. And even now, I'll still go to these other trainings at conferences and things like that. And they get the same content over and over. Don't drink alcohol. You need to sleep eight hours a night, exercise, and make
healthy food choices. I'm like, have you ever met a first responder in your life? This is the most useless information you could give them. First of all, do you think that they don't know that? Right. It's like, oh, I need to do those things. Great. I can just do that now. That's not how that works. How about you give them the tools to do these things? But then after the you need to do all these things, they're like, OK, time's up. And people are like, wait, but how do I sleep? OK, if drinking is the literal only coping skill I have, what might I do if
you take that away from me? Right. Like what they don't have any other coping skills. And so, you know, we have this huge gap in how we're supporting people. And sleep is a is a really. critical component of that. And we know that, you know, chronic sleep deficits, I won't even say sleep deprivation, obviously, right, you sleep deprivation is a very real thing. But even just on the more mild end of sleep deficits, like somebody is only consistently getting six
hours of sleep, which most people that I know would be like, wow, six hours, that's amazing. But even if you're just getting six hours of sleep, we see significant long -term physical health impacts, long -term cognitive impacts and long -term mental health impacts. If you are not sleeping well, if you're not getting the REM sleep that you need, the stage three sleep that you need, the deep. restorative sleep where we're having cellular repair, our immune
system is strengthening, we're consolidating our memories and what we've learned in the day and transferring it into long -term memory, we're going to have a really big problem with, you know, learning new skills, being, you know, balanced and having good emotion regulation. Our pain management is going to be way below where it should be. Our stress tolerance, our vulnerability to burnout and moral injury and vicarious trauma
is going to skyrocket because we don't have the cognitive resources necessary to balance. those mental health impacts. I mean, it's just staggering how much that impacts things. And even if you just look at burnout, right? So burnout is a very, very specific construct for first responders. We use the term burnout all the time colloquially, you know, oh, I'm burnt out, just to mean like you're kind of tapped out, you're tired, you need a break. But in the first responder space,
burnout is a very specific construct that is directly related to organizational stress. So burnout means that you have experienced so much organizational stress, so much administrative stress, that you are physically, emotionally, psychologically depleted. Burnout, as it relates to organizational stress, is the number one predictor of suicide for first responders. It is not exposure to trauma, which is what everybody thinks. It
is consistently shown that organizational stress is the number one predictor of suicide for our people. And that is where we see the biggest gaps in behavioral health support. You know, so much behavioral health programming is we are giving you the individual EAP. We're giving you. Maybe if you're lucky, you can work out on duty and maybe you can have a once a year consult
with nutrition or you can go to this workshop or something like that. And everything is put on the individual. It is your responsibility to do all the things. And if you have a problem, that's because you're not doing the things you should be doing. But that's actually... That doesn't make any sense when you look at the role of organizational stress, right? There's only so much that an individual can do. They can do all the things to take care of themselves. They can do all the things. But when there is a massive
amount of organizational betrayal and moral injury and poor leadership and a toxic culture that is not being addressed in any capacity, we've got a fundamental problem. And that cannot be changed on the individual level. That needs to be addressed on the organizational level. And it is very rare for me to see that being done. You see, that's so pertinent. That goes back to the narcissist, the psychopath in the position of power. And I see this a lot. The toxic environment
that contributes to numerous suicides. And it's another one of the elephants in the room. And the number of people that I've heard that... are revered around the country as pioneers in this kind of training or whatever. And you ask them, well, how are you receiving your own department? Oh my God, don't even start. And this is the problem. It's like now it's kind of the tall poppy syndrome and they just cut their head off, sit down, shut up. We don't want to hear it. And this is between the sleep deprivation and the woeful work weeks that we've seen in the
first responder professions. I mean, out in Southern California, that area, I mean. Oh, my God, I saw there was a San Jose firefighter that I think they'd made, was it like $2 million or a million dollars in three years, something like that. And that wasn't because that was a base pay. That was overtime, you know, and that's insane. Don't get me wrong. But this is the problem is that that means that that person worked, you know, how many 24 hour shifts in that month. And so you've got that sleep deprivation side, then you add that lack of support. And that lack
of ownership, because just like COVID, if a fire department, let's say, has turned a corner, well, the conversation still has to be, well, how did we get there? Who was responsible for getting there? We need to change those people and get the people that are going to lead us out of this. So, yeah, that that toxic, you know, organizational betrayal. You enter this profession, you wear the patch on your shoulder. I'm part of a tribe. And then one day that tribe turns their back on you because you had a good shoot and they threw you under the bus for the media. Or, you know, you did everything right. And then you
listen to a public complaint and you went on their side, whatever the thing was. And for a lot of these men and women, there's not many straws left on that camel's back before it collapses. And the lack of support, that lack of belonging in the very tribe that you literally swore that you would die for a complete stranger for, I've heard it over and over again. It's absolutely crushing for some of these men and women. Yeah, absolutely. One of the things that I hear from...
From people most often when they're really struggling, particularly, obviously, when the organizational stress is really high is, you know, they'll talk about their their unit, their chain of command, their department, whatever their, you know, group of reference is. And they say things like, yeah, you know, we eat our young. Right. And it just shows you how impactful those feelings of betrayal are and how prevalent it is. And it's. It's devastating.
You know, when we can make meaning from our suffering, right, we're in a good place, right? If the time we spend away from our families is worth it, if our kids' plays and sporting events and vacation days and our physical health and our mental health, if all these sacrifices that we are making are for the greater good and we feel like they're
worth it, we're in a good place. Our suffering has meaning. But when our suffering has no meaning, we feel like nothing we do makes a difference. We're always in the wrong. It's never appreciated. You know, we never have good outcomes for cases or responses or whatever it is, right? Now our suffering doesn't have a meaning anymore. And that's incredibly, incredibly dangerous for our first responders because if their suffering doesn't
have meaning, what do they do with that? And we don't give them very many tools to navigate that. Well, this is what you hear even when, you know, the transition into retirement. And again, this is what kills me. The numbers that we present as this is how many suicides we have is absolute bullshit because, as I say to our military guests, we don't have a VA for first responders. So they're only counting the people
that they know were suicide that were wearing a uniform pretty much at the time or within 24 hours, whatever it is, which is the tip of the iceberg compared to how many people took the uniform off for the last time, found themselves in a one -bedroom apartment after their divorce. Everything starts flooding and they lost their purpose. They lost their tribe. They lost their identity. And then, you know, they make a decision that they can't come back from. So, you know, we know that loss of purpose is detrimental because our retiree death count is a perfect example
of that. But we don't acknowledge that group at all. We don't count them. We don't, you know, that's not factored into any of the statistics. So then you have that loss of purpose. And it could even be just like, take my profession again, sending people off to. you know responses that just aren't emergencies and there's a solution for that it's a three -tier system where you can use telehealth now to take those calls away so you've woken up a crew of four people to respond to someone you know who rolled their ankle two days ago and now it hurts a bit you know that
that is another kind of betrayal like well i just missed my kids you know ballet recycle to do this extra shift because you're understaffed now i'm running on this bullshit That's layering it too. So I couldn't agree more. If you're going to ask these men and women to be away from their families, make it a lean working environment. When they stay, make sure they're only staying for the smallest amount of time. They perform at the highest level. And then make sure that you kind of curate what they're even responding to so that they do feel like it was worth being
there. But we've allowed it to devolve now where police, fire, EMS responds to everything. We are the response to, Every kind of downside of where we failed as a nation from a leadership point of view, from the homelessness to the sex work to the addiction crisis to the gang membership. Well, the first responders will clean it up. They'll be fine. And then you end up, like you said, with this massive moral injury. And in my career, one of the biggest things, it wasn't like I suffered from it, but I felt the weight
of it is the inability to save. You might send me. But some of these people are going to die regardless. Well, that's another moral injury. We did everything right and they still died. And they keep getting sicker and fatter and the gang's getting bigger. And then you have that too. So it's a Jenga tower of these elements. And for some of us, like you said, it's that what do you want for dinner that's the final straw. Yeah, absolutely. And I think in terms of thinking about retirement, I try to reframe
that for the agencies I work with and the units that I work with as transition planning in general, because certainly retirement is a huge gap. We need to be helping people plan for retirement and understand what they may experience once they transition out of this space, particularly for people where this is their entire identity, right? What can they do to start building up their identity in other areas before they transition out? So we definitely, we... we fail majorly with transition planning for retirement, but
we also don't do well, at least in law enforcement. I don't think we do well with our, our individuals that are forced to leave our specialty units. So I, you know, all I'm embedded right with internet crimes against children. So I'm, I'm only going to talk about ICAC cause that's where I, you know, where I have the greatest expertise, but you know, I'll see, I'll see my investigators that are in this space and, and. so, so many of us are ride or die. This is all we want to do. all day every day is investigate crimes against
children it is the most righteous fulfilling work you know somebody feels like they could ever do and this is their passion um and somebody could feel like that about narcotics or counter -terrorism right that's not unique to icac right anybody could feel like that people can feel like that about patrol um but but in this case you know in the icac example you have people that are feeling so fulfilled from this work and I think that there is very little understanding in general from the law enforcement community and from leadership in particular of what ICAC
actually is. People think that ICAC is, you know, topless 12 year olds, you know, or like tweens that are sexting. And the reality is like, we don't even investigate those cases because we don't have enough bodies to do so. We are. prioritizing the cases with infants and toddlers, child torture, really, really horrific offending. Those are the cases that we work because we can't work all of them. And so you have people that are
working these cases and then administration will find out, wait, you work child torture cases? You're viewing videos of infants and toddlers being tortured for four hours a day sometimes? oh, that can't be good for you. Okay, we want to protect your mental health. So actually, starting tomorrow, you're going to be in property crimes, or you're going to go back to patrol, or you're going to go wherever, right? You're going to go wherever the place is. And I do think genuinely,
I hope at least, that the majority of the time that that happens, it is coming from a place of good intent. absolute ignorance uh but hopefully good intent right of thinking oh my gosh i had no idea what icac was and now i'm horrified and i don't want you to not be okay so i'm gonna do you a solid and put you someplace else and for the people that want to be doing icac that is probably one of the most dangerous things
that can happen to them because they go from doing the most fulfilling, meaningful work to now being in some role where not only do they not find any value in what they're doing, regardless of whether or not we know externally every single role in the first responder space is incredibly valuable. including the role of a janitor, right? Janitorial staff is critical for the success of first responders because if the garbage is overflowing and there's no sanitation, like our first responders aren't going to be able to do their job, right? So literally every role is critical, but it's easy to say that as an outsider.
So they go from doing the most fulfilling work they could possibly be doing to now being in this role that doesn't have any value or meaning to them. And not only that, but they are still thinking about the work that they were doing before and all the children that are being victimized that they're not getting to, they're cases that were left unfinished. They're incredibly valuable institutional and subject matter expertise knowledge that is now going nowhere. And now they're also with people that are like, oh, you did child
sex crimes? I could never do that, right? Like, oh, that's, well, I don't want to know. And so now they can't even talk about what they experienced. Their gallows humor is horrifying to people. And they have no space to talk about anything. And they're incredibly isolated. And the risk of suicide skyrockets about six months post -force transfer from ICAC. The suicide rate skyrockets. And it is just horrifying how little awareness
there is about... the importance of transition planning. And certainly some agencies have mandatory rotations, right? Like it is what it is, you're going to rotate every three years, every five years, or whatever, right? It is what it is. And that's how the agency set up. And you can't not do that. And even when somebody knows that that's coming, there still isn't transition planning, we're still not preparing them for whatever the next thing is that they're going to go do. And it feels very, very difficult for so many people
to move into a different space when that's not what they want. And I think that, you know, whether it's leaving a specialty unit when it's not your choice or retirement or going out on disability, right? I know so many people that have had to leave the first responder space because of PTSD or severe depression, you know, or panic or something like that. And they don't want to leave the field. That's not what they want. They're humiliated. They're devastated. They're distressed. And now they have to leave their people, their community,
the fulfilling work that they were doing because they aren't well enough to keep doing it. And the moral injury from that alone is so damaging. So we have very little transition support in any of the areas that are needed. Sorry, I'll get off my soapbox now. No, no, no. I'm going to step up next to you. No, I see this, you know, and another area that I don't think people really comprehend when it comes to my profession is up to the rank of lieutenant and sometimes captain,
depending on the structure. You're still in the station. You're still on the rig. You're still with the crew. You know, you're part of something, but then you promote to battalion chief or admin chief. And now you've gone from that cohesion and that, you know, that, that. table where you exactly like you said the the gallows humor and the banter and the offloading to now you're pushing papers now you know you're you're completely detached so there's that there's retirement there's the the the uh the injuries you know and even even if you do have a medical retirement one of the things that i can't stand about the way
that we do it is now it's like well no you're now you're hurt so stay hurt you're gonna you're not gonna you know we're not gonna give you this money if you if you try and get well Well, that's such a backward mindset. I mean, what if you spend more time, like you said, with the PT and the rehab or even, you know, let's really kind of expand a little bit wider. What if it is Ibogaine that finally gets you back on your feet? And you can actually then go back to duty or bring down your disability requirement. But I've got friends that hurt their backs that literally
the whole time when they should have been in the gym because I hurt my back. And luckily, I found movement practices where I never had surgery. But they were like, we want to give you light duty. I'm like, no, I'm a full -time athlete rehabbing a sports injury. And so I'm going to go to Cairo. I'm going to go to the gym. I'm going to do movement practices. This is my full -time job now. I'll see you when I'm good again. And that's what I did. But some of my friends went the surgery route. And then they lay on a couch for a year because they were worried that some dude in a bush was going to take a picture of them and then debunk their whole claim.
So even when we do have people in that kind of, you know, potentially retiring out, we're not looking at it as a lens of, well, can we at least get you retired at a lower late so you're healthier and you can go do something else? We're like, well, you're broken. So stay broken and we'll send you a check every month. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. It is appalling how we... how we treat people that are going out on disability, whether it's medical or physical, physical or mental health. It's just appalling. And that
idea of, yeah, you need to stay injured or impaired is wild. You know, when I think about, as you were talking about that, I was thinking about your question earlier about, you know, what might ideal kind of wellness programming look like. And I think One thing that I didn't mention that I think is really important when considering that gold standard of wellness programming, again, where we have unlimited money and unlimited culturally competent providers, there's a difference between
pull -out support. This is the same thing that we talk about with kids at school that need special education services and intervention. You can either remove the child from school and give them the reading intervention or the math intervention or the social skills or whatever the programming is. You can remove the first responder from the field and send them to physical therapy, which actually we don't do. What we do is we make them take sick leave and go on their own time to physical therapy or to go see their therapist or to go
do the sleep study or whatever. And then they come back. And when they come back, they've now lost time. They've lost whatever training they were going to get in the field. And now they're bogged down with all these things that they have to do to make up for it versus having a push in model. Oh, you have a back injury. Our culturally competent physical therapist is going to come with you. So we're just going to pull you off the road or out of your shift while you're still at the precinct or you're still at the station
or you're still at the office. And you're going to go to the gym with the physical therapist and they're going to spend an hour with you. And then you can go back to the road or go back to. You know, whatever the station, whatever you're doing, you know, oh, you need some financial counseling or nutritional support or you need therapy. Yeah, you're doing that while you're on duty because this is then a work related injury. And we're going to push in the supports to you on duty. So you're not losing time away from your family. You're not losing your sick leave or your vacation time. And you're getting the
supports where you actually need it. And we don't do that. We just don't do that. Absolutely. Well, you've mentioned ICAC. So let's kind of go back now. You enter the psychology field in higher education. What makes you go down the road of the exploitation of children? Kind of lead me how you found yourself working alongside law enforcement. So it's actually. the opposite of what I always thought I was going to do. I mean,
as I mentioned before, I was always really focused on supporting kids and working with kids. And when, you know, when I was in college and studying psychology, you know, all my volunteer work, any, you know, internships I did, everything was focused on working with kids, you know, at a children's hospital, you know, at a Head Start. preschool program, at schools, you know, everything was really focused on kids. And in particular, kids that had been victimized or had really unique
needs in some sort of capacity. And when I got into grad school, my mentor, this is going back to talking about mentorship, Dr. John Thoburn, he just, he fundamentally changed my life in so many ways. I mean, he is like my, my father. Um, you know, he, he married my husband and I, he did my son's baby naming ceremony. Um, and,
and he's just such a, a pillar in my life. And, um, I, I remember talking to John, maybe my gosh, I must've been my second year of grad school. And I was, you know, all kids focused, dialed in support kids that have been victimized. And John said to me in this really loving, kind way, he's really good at delivering hard feedback. You know, he said, you know, everything that you're doing is focused on working with victims.
And that is going to give you only an understanding of a victim mindset. You need to see the other side. You cannot only be focused on this. You're not going to be a good provider if this is all you do. This is all your training and all your experience. You need to have more well -rounded training before you specialize. And I, of course, I didn't like it when John told me that and was very like, you know. That can't be right. Right.
That can't be right. It must be that I should study the thing that I want to specialize in and only that thing. And John was like, no, that's not right. And so I ended up really going to extremes with that feedback. And I did a rotation at our prison here in Washington. And I was there. I was only supposed to be there for a year and actually ended up being there for two years. And I. loved it. It was shocking to me. I thought I was going to hate it. I, you know, I had no
idea what I was doing. I was a baby, baby clinician. I wasn't even a real clinician, right? I'm still in grad school trying to figure out how to do all these things. You know, how does therapy work? What do you say after? Hi, I'm Stacy, right? How do you even start therapy? So I was really in the infancy of trying to figure all this out. But I had, I had two two experiences that were really, really profound. And one of them was this gentleman that I was working with for therapy.
And he... really was like a dream patient for anybody that is just trying to figure out how this works like any you know clinician in their in the infancy of their career you know he was respectful he came to therapy on time he showed up to all the sessions he did his homework he was insightful like he was a dream to work with like he was just it was so easy and he was really motivated Which isn't always the case, especially when you've got somebody that's incarcerated that's going to therapy. You never really know
what you're going to get. Are they going to be motivated? Are they doing it because they want to? Or are there other reasons, you know, secondary gain? And I really liked him and I didn't know his criminal history. I didn't look up his criminal history. I was just only focused on. He was severely depressed, had multiple really, really significant suicide attempts that he arguably, I don't know how he survived them. And he made a comment about how he was really relieved that he was incarcerated.
He was life without the possibility of parole. And he made a comment about, you know, not. He knew that if he was ever released from prison, he wouldn't be able to be safe around kids, and he hated himself for that. And I was kind of in that moment where I realized that he was a sex offender, and I put two and two together, and he had been incarcerated for rape of a child, and he'd had a number of other child -related
sex crimes before that. And I had this... huge kind of internal crisis where I was like what does this say about me that I liked this person um as a patient and now I'm finding out that I should hate them they're a horrible person and I should have no respect for them and I should hate them and it really it did my mind in really messed with me for a long time trying to like reconcile the two because it was they just seemed like polar opposites, right? And I have worked
with victims for so long that I just couldn't wrap my mind around it. And this was exactly the experience that John wanted me to have. And I had to, for a long time, I had to make this gentleman like two different people in my head, right? So like the person that committed those crimes was like this different person. And I was working with this new version of him. And it took me a long time to be able to integrate all of that and to realize that He is a whole person. And there are people in this world that
can do horrible things and are not horrible humans. Certainly, you have people that do horrible things and are horrible humans. Evil incarnate, there is no place for them in this world. But that's actually probably the exception, not the rule. Right. Like we talked about, there's so many individuals incarcerated that have very similar developmental histories as other people in protector
roles. Right. And there's these defining features that totally shift the trajectory of their life. And so it really helped me realize how impactful. you know, all these different experiences can be and mentorship and understanding support and redirection and proper intervention. And, you know, it just, it really helped me see the shades of gray and really understand the value of early
intervention and prevention and how we can really, we can provide an off ramp. Like people don't have to end up over here. We can change that much earlier if we know how to. So that was this really profound experience for me. And shaped how I viewed kind of working with children that had been victims, how I viewed, you know, offenders. And then around that same time. I met a forensic psychologist in the prison, Dr. Brendan Schultz. And I remember meeting him. We had some weekly
psychology meeting where we're rounding on everybody that is being seen and all the treatment interventions and things like that. And Schultz was the only forensic psychologist and he was doing the forensic evaluations for our most violent sex offenders and was doing a risk and recidivism evaluation to determine if they... could be released or if they needed to be civilly committed to a different program once their sentence was over and I remember
him talking about these evaluations and I was like what is forensic psychology what is a forensic evaluation I mean I knew what a neuropsych eval was and what a regular psychological evaluation was but this forensic piece was so new and Poor Brendan. I harassed him so bad, asking him so many questions about what is forensic psychology? What do you do? All the things. And Brendan was like, like, I don't have time for you. I'm really busy. No, like, you need to go figure this out
on your own someplace else. And I begged him to train me and mentor me. And I remember him being like, okay. you can come and you can sit in my office and watch what I do, but you are not allowed to speak. Do not interrupt me. You just sit there and be quiet. And I was like, done. I will do anything. I need to learn about this. And so after a few days, he was like, okay, fine. You can talk and. I will mentor you. And I was ecstatic. I'm really good at just harassing
people and wearing them down until they acquiesce to whatever I'm asking for. And so working with Brendan was life -changing. The way that I got to use my brain doing these forensic evaluations was unlike anything I'd ever experienced. And you're putting together, you're solving this puzzle and you don't know what the picture is. You don't have all the pieces. You don't know where the pieces are that you're missing. And you have to figure all of that out. And so it was this really incredible way of using my brain.
And part of doing these forensic evaluations is reviewing criminal history, records from wherever somebody has been incarcerated, behavioral health records, medical records, all of these pieces. And I found myself being really interested in the... the law enforcement records, their criminal history. And I always had questions about, you know, but well, what does this mean? Or, you know, why didn't they, you know, ask this question? And I always wanted more information from the
law enforcement records. And not like they were lacking in any way, just I always have 800 questions about everything that I'm doing at any given time. And when I, so I discovered this. passion for forensic psychology. And that was how I had this dual specialization for child psychology and forensic psychology. And so then I did, you know, I did my internships. I did a dual residency. I did two postdocs, everything, you know, equally focused on, you know, child psychology and then forensic psychology. And then I had a practice
where I was working with kids and families clinically that had been victimized. And then I was conducting forensic evaluations and testifying as an expert in court. a lot of the evaluations were around children that had been victimized and looking at, you know, how they'd been impacted and what we needed to do to, you know, restore them as much as possible. And then, you know, also evaluating, you know, these offenders and looking at how likely they were to recidivate and, you know,
all these other pieces to them. It was through those forensic evaluations that I had more and more interactions with law enforcement. And I started building these relationships with law enforcement in a way where they became really collaborative. And then I started having investigators call me and say, hey, you know, I've got this case. Can I ask you something about it? Or what do you think about this person? You know, and I mean, I have thousands of hours that I've spent interviewing. offenders, some of our most violent
offenders, our most violent sex offenders, as well as interviewing our child victims. And so, you know, I have I've had these experiences that I've been able to view through the lens of a forensic psychologist and now translate them operationally for law enforcement to help them interpret behavior. And so doing behavioral analysis, you know, criminal behavioral profiling just kind of emerged naturally from that space. And eventually it became such a huge part of what
I was doing that I closed my clinical practice and I became full -time embedded with law enforcement. And now I split my time providing behavioral health support to our Internet Crimes Against Children investigators and our Crimes Against Children investigators. as well as actually, you know, consulting nationally and internationally on our cases themselves. So I do a lot of consultation for, you know, child torture cases, infants and toddlers, you know, a lot of really horrific dark web, you know, offender behavior, encrypted
chat stuff. And I specialize in a lot of undercover work, you know, undercover infiltration and chat and things like that. It really, it sounds like these things are not at all connected, right? Like how did I start working with kids that were victims and now end up working with law enforcement and hunting pedophiles? But the reality is like, it's two sides of the same coin, right? These
looking at how somebody's developmental history can like fundamentally shape them throughout their lives and how. We can have somebody that ends up in this protector role, this first responder role, this hero role, selflessly serving their community, making all these sacrifices for others, doing everything that they can to keep people that are vulnerable safe and to keep children safe. And then also how things can go sideways.
And now we're looking for these offenders and trying to keep them from. continuing to create harm and it really it feels like it's two sides of the same coin to me and it's just really come full circle i mean such a unique perspective that you had that you have excuse me um one of the questions i want to ask you because i've had mixed responses to this There's many, many behaviors we've talked about where you can absolutely point to elements of childhood trauma, being
unaddressed that contributed to everything from struggling with mental health in a uniform to being an addict living under a bridge somewhere. And you think, okay, well, if I reverse engineer this and get to that child and send them down a different direction, then maybe they would be in a much better place. Talk to me about... if any, the common denominators that you see as far as the background of these sex offenders that you've been working their cases? Oh, goodness. I could talk about this for so long. Good. One
of my favorite topics. So here's the thing. I think that in general, sex offenders are really misunderstood in the sense that particularly for our child sex offenders, right? We hear a lot in court, from the defense, we hear in the news, you know, these individuals that are arrested
for sexually offending against children will say, you know, I'm acting out my trauma or, you know, it's because I was victimized myself. And, you know, I just didn't know any better. I'm just repeating this pattern. And that sounds kind of like maybe that would make sense. It sounds like that. that works um you know from like the surface level uh place um and actually it couldn't be further from the truth um and
what we know is that you know The kids that are victimized, it's like in the single digits, the ones that go on to offend themselves sexually. It's very, very small percentages. And then when we do these, you know, polygraph studies and we look at, you know, offenders that have gone through sex offender treatment and have done all these things, you know, there's a really high percentage of people of these sex offenders that will say at the time of their arrest. you
know i was sexually abused as a child that's my defense for doing this and like really really high percentages and then actually when you do polygraphs and when you get sex finder treatment programming going and then you you know you re -examine things it's actually the equivalent is the general population so it's maybe like 20 25 percent of uh of child sex offenders or sexually abuse themselves which is the same as the general population in prison like they're not special in that way um and so then the question
is well how did this happen right because we want to have answers we want to know how we can predict and control that that we can prevent that from happening and the reality is like we don't know we don't know we know that there are um very likely some particularly impactful formative experiences that these individuals have um you know even like aside from you know that that percentage of sexual abuse that's the same as the general population in prison right but there's
you know early exposure to pornography adult pornography doesn't have to be you know child sexual abuse material um you can have uh you know physical abuse neglect um you know high aces for for other you know, in other areas. You know, they could have their own histories of, you know, being bullied or isolated at school, you know, learning disabilities, cognitive delays. There are all sorts of things that that stack up. But the reality is, is we don't really know
why individuals become pedophiles or child sex offenders. We just don't because there are lots of people that could have the exact same developmental history, including sexual abuse history or early exposure pornography or things like that, that fundamentally are not sexually attracted to children, will never be sexually attracted to children and are not going down that path. And we don't really know what distinguishes the two, but we do know that it's not sexual abuse history. And
I think that... You know, that that's really problematic because I mean, obviously, that's problematic, but, you know, it's particularly problematic depending on the the the state that you're in and the way that we navigate juvenile offenses. But, you know, we have a lot of juveniles that we will come into contact with in the law enforcement space. And we. aren't able to prosecute those cases for various reasons. There's a lot
of hesitancy to put consequences, put legal consequences in place for our youthful offenders. And I completely understand that. And we know so much about how incarceration of youth has such negative impacts. We know all of this research is very clear. And at the same time, when we have a 15 year old that is downloading and viewing content of infants
and toddlers being tortured, we cannot say, well, their parents know about it. It's going to be fine. That's not how that works. Because likely there's a problem in the home. Maybe not 100 % of the time, but more likely than not, there's a problem in the home. And the parents know about it, quote unquote, is not that this is not the solution. This is not going to fix anything. Right. And even if it were, let's say, again, in this pretend world, parents are shocked. They find out they have all the money to put their
child into treatment and get them all the support they need and pay for this, the programming at school to support them. We don't actually even have programs to send these kids to. So even if we did have the resources, like the financial resources, the parents were super dialed in and able to help. We don't have any place to send them. So we're really, really lacking in appropriate intervention for this particular kind of youthful offender. And we're going to be in really hot water because we have this relatively new crime
type that is emerging called sadistic online offending, which I know is not the point of our conversation today. But the majority of offenders. that are engaging in this behavior are youthful and we don't know what to do with them there's also a really high rate of neurodivergence amongst these offenders and we we just we have no idea what to do with them there's also a lot of individuals that are first responders that are neurodivergent and we do not do a good job of providing the
right supports to them because i think that they can People that have a unique way of viewing the world and interpreting data really can be leveraged. They have such incredible strengths. And we don't navigate that well, I don't think, which is just a side note. Yeah, no, and it's funny. I see it more and more in our profession. Like you said, there are absolutely assets, but we've also got to navigate how we see the world, the mental health impact, et cetera, in uniform
too. I want to get to a case when we talk about wrongful convictions in a minute, but that involves a youth offender. But while we're on that topic, firstly, for parents, God forbid, whether it's your own child, whether it's your child's friend, what would be some of the warning signs that a parent, a teacher would see from a child that maybe is leaning into this kind of crime that you're talking about? I'm so glad you asked that.
I think when we look at kids, I think the biggest thing for parents, teachers, pediatricians, anybody that's working with kids to look for is a change in their baseline. behavior right so if you've got a kiddo that is normally really social and outgoing and has a lot of friends and is well liked and now they are incredibly isolated they don't spend time with their friends in real life
anymore they're not interested in sports or extracurriculars they're in their room all the time with the door closed you know that's a huge indicator that something's happening what that is right we don't necessarily know but there's that's an indicator that something's happening And, you know, as things stack up where now you're seeing kids are having these like disproportionate emotional reactions to things, they're tied to their electronic devices. So they're always on their computer,
their laptop, their iPad, their phone, right? Tied to them in a way where parents cannot get them off of them. And if they do try and restrict access, right, there's this massive meltdown or explosive behavior. You see a lot of, for kids that are being victimized, you see a lot of anxiety around being tied to their device. And for kids that are engaging in offending behavior, you can see a lot of irritability and aggression around wanting access to their device. Because
for a lot of kids, for a lot of youthful offenders that are offending online, usually against other kids, that's not how... real life is for them, usually they're really struggling to navigate the social climate in real life. They can be bullied. They, you know, again, you know, with neurodivergence, right, we can see a lot of difficulty reading social cues and feeling like they fit in with their peers. But when they're online, they can be anything they want to be. And they
can script these social communications that they hear their peers saying or that they see in movies and they can they can type that out. And nobody knows that they don't actually internally understand what they are supposed to be feeling when they say something like that because they're just reading it. Right. And so they can be whoever they want to be online. And so you'll see them, you know, really feeling fulfilled, really feeling powerful and loving the leverage that they have. over people and that control and dominance. And
they get really fixated on it and will spend their entire day on the computer, their entire day online. So those big changes in baseline, big changes in interests, changes in relationships with peers. You know, another thing is that for kiddos that are being victimized. Particularly when we look at sadistic online exploitation, you know, there's a wide range of harms that children are forced to engage in by the offender.
So we see a lot of self -harm. We see a lot of harm of family pets, harm of siblings. And so you'll have kids that, you know, maybe normally would wear shorts and a T -shirt in the summertime or in the spring. And now they are only wearing long sleeves and long pants. And it's because they don't want anybody to see. the cutting or the self -harm that they've engaged in on their bodies, oftentimes on their chest, on their stomach. And so you'll see this change in how they physically
present as well. But it is not uncommon for me to hear from parents that they didn't know that their child was being victimized. Or that they didn't know that their child was engaging in offending behavior. Now, sometimes I think parents don't know that their child's engaging in offending behavior out of like willful ignorance. They just, they don't want to know. But there are really two, I'm speaking in very, you know, broad.
broad terms here, but there are two types of invisible children. You have your invisible children, your traditional invisible children that we think of, you know, that are, you know, kiddos from these low socioeconomic brackets, minority groups, you know, that are in, you know, in poverty, their parents are always working, they're never home, or, you know, parents are using substances and not parenting, right? They're really neglected. You have this kind of traditional group that we might think of. But then you also have kids from well -off families sometimes even really wealthy families and their parents are never
home and these kids are invisible because they're wealthy nobody's going to report that family at a cps teachers aren't going to say anything they go to these private schools and they you know they're raised by nannies or raising themselves and they're just left to their own devices and they they are invisible as well and um You know, it's really, really hard for anybody to even see what's happening in a child if the child is invisible to everybody around them. And in
school, we have a really bad habit of, and this is the same thing as what we talked about before with how we navigate first responder issues. But, you know, instead of looking at a kiddo that's having behavior problems and thinking, gosh, what's going on outside of school? Right. We we tend to be very punitive. We punish the child. They have exclusionary discipline. They're suspended. They're expelled. They're sent out of the classroom. They lose learning opportunities.
They lose opportunities to develop social skills with their peers. And so they just become more and more and more isolated and punished. believe more and more that there are these bad kids. And then the only other kids that they can hang out with and that will accept them are other quote unquote bad kids, right? Other isolated, marginalized kids. And it's just this really big snowball. It's very difficult to derail. I love that phrase. Did I answer your question? No, no, you did. You did. Absolutely. And I'm
going to circle around, but I've always loved that phrase. Rather than saying what's wrong with you, asking, well, what happened to you? Because it is. I was talking to my wife the other day, and my son, he's 18 now, and we're talking about why the girls are not always attracted to the nice guys. And I hope to God I've raised him to be a nice young man so far. But when you reflect back, there is a draw to that. But it's almost, like you said, a trauma bond. And how many people have gone to their reunions 10, 20 years later? heartthrob is now an absolute shit
show or they're not here anymore they're behind behind bars or whatever it is and so yeah i mean it mirrors exactly what we talked about when someone's behavior you know is not um within what we would call the normal parameters then did they wake up one day to decide to be a dickhead or is it outward expression of the pain that's still going on inside the head Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And, you know, especially with kids, I mean, we can put all the intervention possible
in place in school, for example. Let's say you happen to have a very well -resourced school, which is not very common. But let's say you do have a well -resourced school and they're pushing all the supports in for the kiddo. It's not going to do a whole lot if we're sending them home to this unsafe, chaotic environment. right and and vice versa if they're getting support at home but then we're sending them to school where they're being bullied and victimized and isolated and they don't feel safe or supported or heard
and they can't learn we're going to be in trouble. And so we really need to have, just like we were talking about with like optimal wellness programming for first responders as holistically focused, looking at the whole person. That's also what we need to be doing for kids. We need to look at the whole child and all of the different systems in their lives and put interventions in place across all of them. And that's really hard to do. What about prevalence? Obviously, the last
20 years or so as the internet has really become more popular, as social media has become a way for us to look through the lens of basically anywhere on the planet now, including war zones. level of sexual abuse of children always been at this level are we seeing it increasing um because of the visibility or is it even increasing as far as the the frequency because the number of men for example i've had on the show that
was sexually abused when they were younger blew me away how many people are wearing a uniform now but then you see so many first responders being caught up in these you know these pedophile rings so is is Is this a reflection of what we just didn't realize that was behind the curtain? Or is this actually getting worse as time goes on? And that is such a good question. You know, I ask myself that all the time. I talk about that with colleagues all the time. We don't really
know. But I have some hypotheses. I think that... So, of course, pedophilia and child sexual abuse, I mean, not everybody that offends against a child is a pedophile. Some people sexually abuse children for other reasons, whether it's power and control, motivation, whether they're sadistically motivated, trying to harm. you know, the caregiver of the child, other mental health reasons, right?
Which also like does people's head ends to think, wait, I'm sorry, people can sexually abuse children when they're not pedophiles, but that's true, right? But, you know, we've always seen that type of victimization of children. And when you look at... For example, ICAC, right? People that are viewing child sexual abuse material. We call that CSAM or are producing CSAM, things like that. You know, people were always doing that. They just were. you know, sending it through
the Postal Service, which is why the Postal Service actually was an instrumental agency in standing up our national ICAC task force in the 90s. And so, you know, we just we saw it manifest differently in print form and Polaroids, VHS versus, you know, digitally now and on the dark web and encrypted chat. Right. I mean, technology is just going so fast. So I think in some respects. You know, we're just identifying it more often. We're coming
across it more often. And maybe it wasn't necessarily occurring at a lower rate before. It's just easier to identify now. But which is kind of what I think a lot of people were hypothesizing or have been hypothesizing. Except there was a report that recently came out. It came out in 2026, just a few months ago. And it had more than 20 ,000 respondents. And the individuals that completed
the survey were individuals that were searching on the dark web for child sexual abuse material and were encountering child sexual abuse material. So all of these individuals were invited to participate in a survey. Shocker to nobody, offenders lie. So I am always very skeptical of offender -based self -report data because I just in general think it's frequently not accurate. And a perfect example of that is like, you'll hear people talk about
female pedophiles, female sex offenders as unicorns, right? That makes me want to poke my eardrum out every time I hear that. And women look like unicorns, female pedophiles look like unicorns because When you look at the criminal based data, it looks like they're hardly ever occurring. Right. The incarceration rates for female sex offenders is like one to three percent in the U .S. compared to the male sex offender population. But when you look at victim based data, it's
a very different picture. And actually, you know, up to 24 percent of pedophiles are. women. And I don't math. But even I know that 24%, almost a quarter is not a unicorn. So we have big issues when we just look at offender reports and offender based data. So I'm very, very skeptical of that. But This report, not only did they have more than 20 ,000 participants, which is a huge number
of participants, but this report was completely transparent about the questions that they asked, the validity measures that they used, how they weeded out and detected people that were just randomly responding or that were intentionally trying to skew the results. A lot of times when I read reports, they are not transparent about that, which also makes me doubt the veracity of their reporting. But man, this report was phenomenal. And where I'm going with this is that I, and I think a lot of other people, have
been under the impression that the majority of the time that a youth is exposed to child sexual abuse material, in general, the majority is because they're being shown it in an attempt to groom them. That way somebody can offend against them. Anecdotally, that is what I hear. That's what I see in victim cases that I work with youth. That's how they're exposed. But what came out from this report is that almost half the time,
these individuals reported that they came across child sexual abuse material accidentally. They came across it randomly in a Google search or it was pushed out in a chat that they were in. And despite the fact that they were exposed, accidentally, a huge percentage of that group was then independently searching for that content before they were even 18 years old. So something's happening where even if a youth is not being
groomed and being shown that content for grooming reasons, even if they're just exposed accidentally, something's happening Some blend from their developmental history, whatever's happening in their environment, now that exposure is triggering something in them, and now they are seeking that material out. And we don't know why that's happening, which is terrifying. But that makes me concerned that actually we are legitimately seeing an increase
in people seeking out this content. and thinking about kids in this way now i don't mean seeing an increase like you know like a hundred times more people are doing this now it's not all what i'm saying we actually i actually have no idea what the increase would be right could be two percent could be thirty percent we have no idea um and it's probably going to be some time before our data can catch up um but That was a really shocking piece of research that I encountered
recently. And that's also really shocking because like I talked about with the sadistic online exploitation behavior, which is this, you know, new crime type that we're just really struggling to figure out how to navigate. It's currently being classified as domestic terrorism. And I will. This is a hill that I will die on and people will be mad, but it is fundamentally not domestic terrorism. And I will argue with anybody about that classification. And it's incredibly dangerous
to classify this behavior as domestic terrorism because then we do not understand the lens that we need to use to interpret this offending behavior and how the victims are being impacted, which means we don't know how to investigate the cases. We don't know how to identify additional offenders or additional victims. We don't know how to put interventions in place. place to prevent these youthful offenders from continuing to engage in this behavior. So that's a whole nother conversation that I feel very strongly about. But the point of that is, is that with the sadistic online exploitation, which in general is not sexually
motivated, it's really just motivated by engaging in harm. It's motivated by harm, by feeling powerful, by feeling strong, by feeling special, by racking up points, just like in a video game and gaming, getting status. One of the ways that these offenders create harm is by exposing their victims to CSAM. They're exposing them to child sexual abuse material, and they're making them create that content. And so my concern is, man, if this exposure is
happening not through grooming with the purpose of sexually abusing this youth, but it's happening through some other type of victimization, what are the downstream implications going to be? for these kids that are being victimized this way. And we do not know. We don't know. And we need to figure it out. Many elements of what you've been describing remind me of Lieutenant Colonel Dave Grossman's perspective. He wrote a book, Assassination Generation, on the school shootings that we have. And when you break down,
and again, we're talking again, the COVID, you know, World War I trenches, where every time some god -awful... massacre happens at a school it's like well are you for guns are you against guns you know that's it that's the singular conversation and it's disgusting um but you know he does a great job of breaking down you know everything from operant conditioning through the video games themselves to the impact of sleep deprivation to the power that this person who doesn't feel loved or seen in the real world has when they are you know player number six on this game.
And now literally, as you said, they're beating the high score element that we've seen in some of these school shootings. And again, it really alludes to the breakdown of community, of an intact household, of the ability to be seen, to feel seen, to feel safe, to feel loved, and the impact that we're seeing, the ripple effect. And it does seem to be a parallel between that horrendous... epidemic that we have in this country especially and what you're talking about now
not so much the grooming the pedophilia which i want to get to in just a second but this feeling of being power this feeling of being special this feeling of one -upping the other person that did that last time Yeah, absolutely. And, you know, I mean, we're seeing, you know, this huge, it feels like, this huge increase in incel culture. You know, we're seeing incel culture coming into mainstream conversations. You know, we're seeing youth radicalized in ways that we
just were never anticipating and we didn't see even five years ago. And, you know, back to... one of the things that we've talked about briefly earlier, right, this, this presence of like neurodivergent youth that are being victimized and also that are engaging in offending behavior, you know, neurodivergent youth are not more likely to engage in offending behavior in any way, shape, or form. What they are is significantly more vulnerable
to exploitation and to being victimized in a way where they become radicalized or become embedded in this offending population. And it's really interesting to see you know, how all of this is growing with, you know, more and more kids online. You know, we talked about COVID, right? There were kids that were online then that had
never spent any time on a screen. And then that just became the way of life for them. And it's just, you know, it's really impacting. how our kids are being exploited, how our kids are being exposed to really, really unsafe content, unsafe groups, unsafe rhetoric, ideology, all sorts of things. And we don't have a lot in place to navigate that. We're really in the infancy of
studying this. I do feel hopeful about us getting some insight and getting some programs going to prevent this. I don't know if you know about the group, the Hacking Games. It's a phenomenal, phenomenal group. And what they're doing is they're really looking at how we can take these youth that are online, engaging in behaviors that are are criminalized, you know, hacking, you know.
hacking government infrastructure or hacking their schools or hacking video games and doing all these things and realizing that the majority of these youth that are engaging in these highly criminalized behaviors with pretty significant consequences, they're probably bored to tears. in in their real life um they're incredibly bright they have a really hard time connecting with their peers more likely than not uh parents probably aren't sure what to do with them um you know
they're probably really isolated and the hacking games is saying hey uh kids you guys families if you are realizing that you are struggling in this area right you're bored and you're trying to see what else you can hack into what games you can crack how you can put all these mods in place We've got something for you. We can teach you ethical hacking. We can teach you how to be smarter and better at what you're doing and serve your community or serve your country. And here are all these incredible ways that you can learn and grow and actually use your skills
for good. So they're working really hard to put those off ramps in place for youth that are maybe engaging in an unsafe behavior or dabbling in it or are fully engaged in it. And they're giving them these really beautiful off ramps to understand the impact of their behavior. and then transition it into something, you know, really resilient and hardy and gritty with post -traumatic growth and then actually serving their community. And the Hacking Games is also, they've got a nonprofit
that's doing really incredible work as well. But this is one example of a group that's starting to look at how can we... How can we really see the bigger picture around these kids that are engaging in unsafe behaviors? And what can we do to put all the supports around them? to fundamentally change their developmental trajectory. And the UN is working on research around youth radicalization right now. And NCMEC and the Canadian Center
for Child Protection, they've got all these programs to support victims that have been exploited, family therapy, individual therapy. They have programs to help them take back control of their images online. So we've got a lot of these organizations that are starting to see the whole child. think about how we can holistically support them to get them back on track. So I do feel really hopeful about that. I do think that we will see, you know, huge impacts from that in the long term. But while we're spinning that stuff up, we also
really need to be continuing the research and continuing to understand. how and why these things are happening because that is going to enable us to better intervene and to better identify when we can intervene. And so I do feel hopeful about it. I'm going to go the other side now. We've been talking a lot about these young offenders and that was fascinating, by the way. And this is the whole point of this, you know, hearing solutions to these problems. That's it. And there's always people out there that have found, you know, maybe not the whole fix, but are moving
towards that way. And that's incredibly optimistic. One of the things that I really struggle with, and I've said about this particular case for a long, long time, you know, you have these people in the positions of power who are blatantly. grooming or, you know, preying upon children. But because in this case, they wear a glove and they can moonwalk, then people like, oh, no, no, no, but that person. So we've got obviously the whole Epstein list and that's, you know, another separate conversation. But in Netflix, there was just an incredible documentary on the
Michael Jackson case. And I've always said, remove the name Michael Jackson, insert the creepy dude from down the street. but all the things that happened what would you think he'd be hanging from a tree in five minutes you know he would so when you look at the whole jackson case and you look at the outcry then i think it was a 23 million dollar payment to silence that particular child and then you know the the the outcry then was kind of denied in court and then later the adult kids um i forget the names now you know
they say actually this did happen you've got child sexual material found in the room. There's briefcases full of porn. There's sending away parents. There's the kids always stay in the bed. Remove Michael Jackson, put in any other dude. It's an open and shut case. So talk to me about that, whether it's the Catholic Church, whether it's the scouting organizations. There is a history of people in power who are able to circumnavigate what a normal person. would
encounter as far as, you know, whether they even made it out alive, the criminal path that they would be put on. So if you wouldn't mind, elaborate on, you know, when positions of power actually work against the very thing that you and your law enforcement colleagues are fighting for. We see that all the time. And yeah, I mean, the two examples that you gave are fantastic examples of this. You know, I... So I'm going to answer your question by telling a slightly different
story. But one of the things that I get asked, because I consult with, you know, with schools and religious institutions and, you know, lots of different groups around keeping kids safe and, you know, navigating keeping kids safe online, keeping kids safe in person. And, you know, sometimes I'll get calls from schools or religious groups or. camps or whatever and they'll say hey um you know we are getting reports that there are
a lot of kids that we think may have been victimized by a particular staff member teacher religious leader whoever right but a particular staff member um you know 15 years ago we don't know who it is though that victimized the kids or that allegedly victimize the kids you know how can we figure this out how do we go about investigating this because the victims won't make the disclosure so what are our options for figuring this out and you you really only need to ask one question
and the question is who are you 100 certain it is not and it is almost always that person Because you hit the nail on the head when you said like, if it's some creepy person, if it's that real weird teacher that makes your stomach feel all tense and you can like smell them across the room and you just know that there is something wrong, you are never going to leave your child alone with them. We don't leave our children alone with weird, creepy people, right? Who do
we leave our children alone with? The most beloved. Teachers, leaders, supervisors, coaches, right? The ones that they're always the kids' favorite. They know all the, they remember all the personal details about the kids and the families. They're incredible at grooming, not just the kids, but the parents of the kids and their colleagues, right? They're so well -liked, really charismatic. And that is why people leave their children alone with them. And nobody suspects. anything because
they are so well liked and they have groomed everybody so well that when they invite kids for a sleepover or when they want to give the parents a break and so they'll take the kids camping or why not take the kids to Disneyland and they'll, you know, parents don't need to worry about it. They'll handle everything. Parents are like, this is great. This is great. This person cares about my kids just like I do. Everybody loves this person. And of course, yeah, we're
so lucky that we have this person in our lives. And they just don't think anything of it, right? But any time you hear that a child is sleeping in bed with an adult that is not their parent, I don't understand how we could interpret that in any other... way right like no safe grown -up would allow another child in their bed right
so even if you even if your kid's best friend who is your it's like your kid right your families are super close that best friend has a sleepover and let's say that kid is eight or even six and they come into your room in the middle of the night and they're like oh I'm scared can I sleep with you A healthy a healthy adult is going to be like, oh, buddy, let's go back to the room and I can sit with you or we can sit on the couch and I'll read you a book. Or do you want to call your mom and dad? Right. Like no safe parent
is going to be like, yeah, kid, get into bed with me. No way. Right? Safe grownups don't ever ask kids to keep secrets. Safe grownups do not put other kids on their lap. You know, safe grownups do not do these things. And so anytime we hear that that is happening with a child, we should automatically assume that we have a massive, massive problem. Anytime a child says, oh, so -and -so tickled me, but they told me to keep it a secret. I'm sorry, what? What? What was
that? What safe grownup is going to ask a child, first of all, to keep a secret? We might ask a child to keep a surprise because we're going to tell somebody shortly and it will make them so happy, right? Like, oh, we made this thing for daddy for his birthday. Let's keep this a surprise until next week when we can give it to him, right? Or we're having a party. We're going to keep this a surprise. But safe grownups don't ask kids to keep secrets. And then also safe grownups are not tickling. other people's kids right i mean that's weird um i i just yeah
so i have a lot of parents though that will say like hey my kid said this thing to me i'm probably just confused right like it's probably not what they thought it was like why would a child say that to you if that's not what happened this is not a developmentally normal thing for a child to report to their parents why would they say that no we need to believe our children when they say something like that But it just it feels very difficult for parents to wrap their head around when especially the person is somebody
in a position of power, be loved, has a lot of money or resources or influence. Parents don't want to believe it. And I understand why they don't want to believe it. But but we need to believe our children. We need to start stop giving people a free pass simply because they have money or power or influence. That's just not how this works. Why do you think all these years later, even now he's dead as well, but when this whole predator conversation... is front and center
now some of it obviously is hollywood eyes and it's you know a kid being thrown in front of the back of a you know in the back of a van in some foreign country when even as we know most of the the actual um trafficking is happening right here in the u .s but it's become a national conversation why do you think there's still such a resistance to believe that for example in this particular case that michael jackson who sent people's children, you know, fat parents away and insisted on the children sleeping in the bed. And we know that there was child pornographic
material in the room. Like it is a complete open and shut case that there is still a large portion of the country that were like, no, he was innocent. No, that never happened. No, you know, he was found innocent in a court. Well, so was OJ. So a lot of people that did things, you know, that's the part like he's already gone now. It's OK to say, you know, maybe I was wrong. But again, with the pandemic, with some of these other things, there seems to be I feel there's more value in someone just saying, you know, refusing to say,
you know, I was wrong. I think that sometimes that is more important than people actually acknowledging the truth. You know, I think. that two things I think are really at play in cases like you're referencing. And I mean, just to be clear, like I didn't work on the Michael Jackson case. I haven't reviewed any evidence. Like I don't actually have any official opinions about that. I don't get sued for slander as a clinician, like commenting
on something that I haven't viewed with my own eyes. But I can say like in cases like that, which are... prevalent. You know, I think on the one hand, we, we will do anything to avoid what's called cognitive dissonance. Cognitive dissonance is when we experience two opposing feelings, or where we believe two opposing things to be true. So for example, this person is a
great musician and changed the face of pop and has catchy songs and I love them and I have great memories from childhood from listening to their songs. And also they were engaging in horrific offending behavior. Because if both things are true, that feels too uncomfortable. We can't have that, right? So either we have to say... No, their music was never that good. I didn't actually like it. We have to diminish their musical
acumen and then, you know, uphold the... they were engaging in horrific offending behavior or we have to say well maybe it wasn't that bad or maybe we don't know the whole story or somebody's probably just trying to get money um that way we can have this other part be true no they are a good musician and a pop idol but we can't have both things be true that feels very uncomfortable to have cognitive dissonance like that and so instead what we'll do is we we choose one to
diminish and devalue, to reduce those feelings of discomfort. So I definitely think that happens. The other reality is that one of the things that makes some predators so incredibly skilled, and again, it's usually the ones that are really well -liked and really good at grooming everybody around them and navigating the social climate. But one of the things that they do, is they make it so that children doubt themselves, doubt their
memory of what happened, doubt their understanding of what happened. And we see that also with parents inadvertently. So if a child says, hey, somebody touched my body this way or this thing happened, you know, and the parent responds, are you sure? They're not really happening. Are you lying? Right? The kid is like. oh my, I mean, I thought it really happened, but maybe I'm lying. Maybe I misremembered that, right? And then, you know,
in general, right, victims have a very difficult time reporting a coherent narrative of their experiences because of the way that the brain is impacting when it is experiencing trauma. And so it's really hard for victims to have this coherent narrative. So a lot of times they'll say, you know, the story one way this time and then the next time they'll tell it a different way or they'll remember something that they forgot initially or vice versa. And that is really fundamentally how the neuropsychology of trauma works. But
to somebody that doesn't know anything about that, it seems like... You're going to doubt the veracity of their reporting. It seems like they're not being honest and you can't trust what they're saying because their story is changing. It sounds good to be like, well, somebody is telling the truth. They're going to just tell the same story every time. But actually, when somebody tells me the exact same story every time, I actually am probably going to question that a little bit because that sounds pretty well rehearsed. And I don't mean like somebody that's done a lot of therapy, right, and done
all the things and can now tell their. Their trauma. That's not what I'm talking about. I'm talking about somebody that is not in survivor mode right there and victim mode. And they're talking about how they were victimized. And so I think it's very easy to for. family members of the offender, for defense attorneys, for people to go on a campaign and make people doubt the truthfulness of a victim's reporting by highlighting where their story has deviated. I'd see that
all the time in the forensic cases I work, where a child will report that they were sexually assaulted at school. And then the school attorneys or the district attorneys will say, well, the child said, you know, this thing happened first. Now their story is totally different and they have the audacity to call into credibility the child's reporting. And honestly, they should be ashamed of themselves. And I don't know how they sleep at night, but that's a different conversation. But we see that all the time, right? Is that they will call into question the truthfulness
of the reporting simply because the story changes. Well, why did you say it happened and then you recanted? Well, half the time. They're terrified, they're bullied, they're being impacted even more by coming forward with their story. They're pressured under duress into recanting, whether it's by their parents or by external parties, right? Who knows? And so it's really common to see that, that they'll come forward and then they'll recant or they'll change something or
they'll come forward. And so it makes people look like they're not being honest in their reporting. the truth is probably the opposite. And again, I don't have an evaluated victim statements. I don't have an opinion about anybody in specific. I just like all the disclaimers there, right? But I mean, in general, like I see this all the time in the cases that I work. I do have an opinion, so I'll say it online because, again, I felt this a long time and I feel watching the court case just verified it. Wade Robson is one of
the two that had the outcry much later on. But just to your point, their defense, even though some of these victims described the room, described where this pornography was, described certain unusual elements of Michael Jackson's genitalia, it was the air quotes wishy -washiness of these children's testimonies that the defense attorney you know honed in on you know so it just goes to show the manipulation which that's a good segue to the very last thing i'll ask you before we go to some closing questions because i know we've been talking two and a half hours already
um on the other side of this i had a guest greg kelly um and there was a show on netflix called outcry and he was a senior in high school football player in texas and He, his parents, I think one of his parents got ill. So they ended up moving to somewhere else. So I think it was his mother could get treatment. So one of the other team members, his friend offered to put him up in their home. Their home also had a daycare in it. Now, fast forward a few weeks or months,
whatever it was, one of the children had an outcry and Mr. Greg touched me and, you know, off it went. And he was ultimately arrested. He was convicted. Now, bearing in mind, he's a convicted sex offender, pedophile in prison. I don't know how the hell he even managed to navigate that, survive that. Thank God, an incredible lawyer from, I think it was the Innocence Project, got involved and ended up picking apart the case. And, you know, it was a wrongful conviction.
But I can't remember if there was even an admission of guilt at that point. I forget. I don't want to say that because I can't remember 100%. But, you know, the yoga shop murders, you know, the Central Park five, there's numerous examples of just as you said, with a child, a grown up now or an 18 year old being manipulated in interrogation. And I can't remember if it was Brad or someone else I talked to recently said that is the worst way. of interrogating because the chances of a wrongful conviction go up exponentially. So
I know we kind of touched on it before we hit record. Talk to me now as far as the psychology when it comes to interrogation or interviewing to ensure that you don't get the wrong person, that you don't incarcerate an individual. Meanwhile, in this case, a sexual predator goes free and then ultimately rapes another woman until they figure out who the right person was, which was the roommate, the other. player the whole time. So flipping that on its head now, we've gone from the victim of a predator being discredited
for their outcry. Talk to me about how anyone in law enforcement listening can ensure that their investigation, their interview techniques are not entering into the threshold where you're pursuing a a claim of guilt, even though it's coming from the wrong place. I don't know if I phrased that properly. Yeah, yeah. So definitely, you know, one of the things that I spend a lot
of time doing is training investigators to better understand the different typologies or motivations for engaging in... sexual offending against children and then what does that mean about what is that likely not always what does that likely mean about who that person is how can you establish rapport with them how can you connect to them quickly um and help facilitate um a really strong effective interview and i mean you know all the
research shows that you know aggressive interviewing um is is not only not particularly effective there are a lot of unethical things that can happen and then and also you know bad bad confessions bad admissions of guilt and you know you don't you don't want that right we want to make sure that we are you know arresting the person responsible for engaging in that offending behavior. And, you know, I, I just, I worked with such phenomenal investigators. I feel so fortunate. And I work
with some investigators that are so skilled at interviewing, you know, Brad is probably one of the finest interviewers that I, you know, I've had the pleasure of working with. And Brad and I have worked a number of cases together and talked about interview strategy. And, you know, I think that there's not a lot of of interviewing that's taught. You know, we typically think of like using the read technique and that was like the be all end all for a very long time. And,
you know, there are some other countries like in the UK where they've got the peace model, but we don't give our investigators a whole lot of. A whole lot of variety in terms of like the tools that they can use for interviewing strategies, depending on the type of individual that you're interacting with. And certainly some people have, you know, more opportunities for training than others. But in general, there's not a whole lot that they get. And I think the most important
thing is that we need to interact with people from a place of curiosity. and from a place of neutrality so the idea of coming on really strong we have all this evidence that you don't actually have or somebody said they saw you or you know trying to intimidate somebody into giving a confession um it's not ethical and it's not effective and we're not going to get anything from that that
we're going to feel good about. But when you're able to connect with somebody on a human level and approach their experiences with curiosity, which can be really hard to do when you feel that shock and horror about their offending behavior, especially take, for example, a child sexual abuse case. It's hard to be curious about how somebody engaged in child sexual abuse when what you feel is shock and horror and maybe a little bit of violence. But if we can stay rooted in
the curiosity, we can have these conversations that will create a space for this other person to start to actually open up and talk about their experiences and how they got to where they are. Because there are a lot of individuals that we interview. Again, I'm really like distilling this down to the... you know, crimes against children space. But there are a lot of individuals that we interview that sexually abuse children, that are true pedophiles, are truly sexually
attracted to children, and also hate themselves for it, and are ashamed and horrified, but they can't stop themselves from engaging in that behavior. And if we give them a space where they feel safe to finally finally disclose that not only are they going to feel this tremendous sense of relief that they've finally told somebody this huge secret that they've been carrying around with them for since they were probably 13 14 15 themselves
um but they also feel safe enough now to tell us all of the kids that they've victimized before maybe we were going to get only the one victim in the case but now because we've treated them with respect, like a human, and we've created a space where we're curious and they can make any disclosures and we're not going to react with disgust and horror, even if that's what we feel internally, right? We're not demonstrating that externally. Now they can also tell us all the other things that they've done, all the other
victims that they have, all the other, you know, behaviors that they've engaged in. And now we can really keep kids safe in a way. that is fundamentally different than what we were going to get before. So I think if we can shift how we view offenders for the interview, we can be much more productive. Beautiful. Well, I want to shift to some closing questions. Be mindful of your time before we hit three hours. The first question I love to
ask, is there a book or are there books that you love to recommend? It can be related to our discussion today or completely unrelated. I mean, so one book that I really. like to recommend um may also be traumatizing for people so there there's a caveat right the things that i read are probably not uh normal things for people to read um but there's a book called predators um by um i can't remember if it's ann salter
or anna salter actually i have the book on my bookshelf right over there um but it's a it's a phenomenal book horrifying to read so just Don't keep it on your nightstand and read it in bed. But it is a really good book to read, particularly for individuals in law enforcement that want to better understand how these offenders operate and how they think. But it's a really good book giving a very accurate view of who
these people are and how this behavior occurs. So I really like that. I mean, of course, there's The Body Keeps the Score, which is probably a really common book that people listening to your podcast have already read. But I think that people don't truly understand. How much we internalize stress and trauma and how much just even cortisol, long -term, you know, cortisol production in
our body impacts things. Like it impacts our fertility, our risk of type 2 diabetes, increases our risk of developing osteoporosis and cancer. And I mean, like so, so many ways. And, you know, understanding how sleep impacts all of that. So that's a really, really good book. I, you know, I read, I read primarily research articles, less books, because I don't know why I, I'm always
interested in understanding how somebody got to the conclusions that they've reached right and so research reading research articles journal articles is very appealing to me because i want to be able to analyze the veracity of their findings and look at their methodology for collecting the data and how they analyzed it and kind of form my own opinions about how how i'm interpreting their findings so a lot of it is research articles but i think the two books that i would recommend because i'm an icac are is predators um and then
the the body keeps the score really really good and there's i mean emotional survival for law enforcement by gil martin right that's really popular that's a great book for people as well what about television documentaries and films any of those that you love um i well again Again, being an ICAC, I'm so sorry. Everything is like coming out so biased for me to the, you know, skewed to the ICAC side. But that's just, you
know, I live and breathe that. There is a documentary that came out by the BBC and it's called The Darkest Web. And it is. a difficult watch. I won't lie about that. It's a difficult watch, but it really examines how offenders are using the dark web to share and exchange child sexual
exploitation and abuse material. It looks at how investigators are navigating these cases. and the impact that it has on the investigators working these cases. And one of the finest investigators that I have ever had the pleasure of knowing and that I have the pleasure of calling a good friend of mine is in that documentary. And even knowing him as a colleague, I work cases with him. I've profiled cases for him. He's also a
very dear friend of mine. Even knowing him in that space, just watching this documentary and watching him in this documentary, just fundamentally impacted how I view people that do this work. Still, even though I've been doing this for so long, it's still impacted me and the impact that this work has on everybody. You know, we all pay to play. And when that payment, that sacrifice
has meaning, we're going to be okay. But when there's no meaning behind it, if your agency just rips you away from that work for no reason because of big egos or out of a misguided attempt to, you know, quote unquote, protect your mental health, it's got catastrophic impacts. And I think that this documentary is incredibly well done and really illuminates a lot of. a lot of
challenges that we're seeing from investigating dark web cases and, and internet based crimes to, you know, supporting our investigators and figuring out, you know, how to, how to navigate, you know, prosecuting the cases and how to support victims and, you know, all of the pieces. So it's, it's incredibly well done. Well, speaking of amazing people, is there a person that you recommend to come on this podcast as a guest to speak to the first responders, military and
associated professions of the world? I mean, Greg Swire, that's who I was just talking about in in that documentary. He is an incredible human being, a phenomenal investigator and is very transparent about how. being in the first responder space has impacted him and all of the things that he is doing and has done to continue to be healthy. And he's a huge advocate for, you
know, holistic behavioral health support and looking at, you know, all the different ways that somebody in this space can take care of themselves. talk about sleep all the time, you know, processing trauma, organizational stress, navigating parenting with, you know, viewing this material. How do you view this material? And then parent, right? Without like anxiety. And, you know, it's just, it fundamentally changes how you view the world being in this space. And
I think that he would be a phenomenal guest. I would love to get him on if you're able to help make the connection. Yeah, happy to do that. Thank you. All right. Well, then the last question before we make sure everyone knows where to find you, as you just alluded to, a lot of people in the psychology, psychiatry space, they are receiving a lot of trauma as they're listening. Now, obviously, you're layering that with the cases that you're working. What are the tools that you use to decompress, to offload some of
this trauma so that when you walk through the door and you're simply mum again, you're able to do it with a clear mind? Oh, you know, I think I feel like it's always a moving target, right? Some days are easier than others. Some weeks are easier than others. You know, I think that probably one of the biggest ones for me is having really good social support from other colleagues in this space. So for a long time, and I've been doing this work for a long time, and probably
for the majority of the two decades that I've been working in this space, I didn't have colleagues that I could consult with or that I could call when I was not okay from a case. And it's really only been in the last handful of years that I've cultivated a really phenomenal group of colleagues that know what it's like to be embedded with first responders, that particularly with law
enforcement. I can call them anytime and say, hey, this thing happened. You have a minute. And I can just process with them. And it is so incredibly helpful. The other thing is that, you know, we know all of the research shows how incredibly beneficial mindfulness and meditation are, how incredibly beneficial, you know, yoga is. And one of the... The best things about that is you don't have to like it in order to benefit from it. So yoga makes me feel violent, but I
still benefit when I do it. And I hate mindfulness and meditation. I can't sit still. I always want to be doing something. I fall asleep if I'm trying to meditate. But the great news is I don't have to like any of those things in order for them to deactivate my limbic system for me. I just have to do them. So I really like the Headspace app. I promote it all the time. I am not being paid by them, although they can feel free to give me money if they would like. But I love the Headspace app. I just, I really like the
voices that they have, like the narrators for the guided meditations and the exercises from that app. I like that I can select different times and, you know, different focuses for the mindfulness and or, you know, meditation exercises. I'll use that, you know, sometimes I'll use that in the car when I'm driving. Obviously, I'm not closing my eyes, right? But I'm just kind of like quieting my brain and it's guiding kind of my thoughts, which is, you know, mindfulness. being present and meditation guiding my thoughts.
Or I'll, you know, I'll listen to it when I'm trying to fall asleep, if I'm having a hard time turning my brain off. So I really like headspace, mindfulness and meditation. And then yoga also incorporates those, those pieces, but it has the, you know, the physical fitness piece too, which helps just quiet things down for me a little bit. So yeah, those are my go -tos. And I'm a bibliophile. I love reading. That's the only file that is not bad. So bibliophiles, I'm always
reading something different, but I read a lot for pleasure, like nothing that has to do with work or offenders or criminal behavior or anything like that. So I just read a lot for pleasure, all sorts of different things. And reading is really helpful for me to just turn my brain off. Hard for me to turn my brain off if I'm watching a movie or TV. I'll just get spun up about something and then have lost 20 minutes of whatever I'm watching. But when I am reading, I am super dialed in and don't even hear what's happening in the world around me, much to my family's frustration
sometimes. So reading is definitely my go -to for that. I've used Headspace, I think, for about 10 years now. And I had Andy Puddicombe, the founder, the English voice on the show. And it was amazing. We actually grew up about 10 miles from each other in England originally. But yeah, I mean, to this day. Oh my gosh. Yeah, I just, I love it. And same as exactly like you said, sometimes you feel like you're doing a longer one. Sometimes you're on edge and like, okay, five minutes. That's all I need. Five minutes with some breath work. But yeah, it's been my ride and die too. So I can't speak highly enough
of it. Yeah, I love Headspace. Tell him I think he's awesome. He did a great job. Yeah, I will. I'm trying to get a hold of him again. I think he went and became a monk again. I think he made all that money. Probably wasn't even trying to make all that money, but he did. And I think he sold the business and he's off grid again now. So if I ever reconnect, I'll definitely, definitely let you know. All right. So people listening then, if they want to learn more about you, reach out to you, where are the best places online to do that? They can find me on my website.
It's nothing fancy. It's just drstacychiquette .com. Pretty simple. I recently did a TEDx talk on internet safety and how parents can talk to their kids about that. So for parents that are struggling to find the right words or figure out how to take those first steps into talking about that with their kids, which can feel so overwhelming and so intense. intimidating. Um, that could be a great resource to help kind of
spark some ideas for how to navigate those conversations. Um, but I have, yeah, I have a lot of resources on my, on my website so people can feel free to reach out to me that way. Brilliant. Well, I want to say thank you so much. I literally could talk for another three hours, but my bladder and your time probably won't tolerate that. So I want to thank you. So, I mean, it's been amazing. We've gone through so many areas from mental health in our professions, the first responders and your world and psychology, all the way through to the vulnerability of our children and even
the potential predatory elements of our children. I want to thank you so, so much for being so generous with your time today and coming on the Behind the Shield podcast. Thank you so much for having me. This was wonderful. And my husband always teases me that I can make any conversation end up being about pedophiles. And I've done that today, which wasn't the intention of our conversation. But I've done that once again. So thank you for letting me talk about my most favorite topic, law enforcement wellness and
Leif Babin is a former Navy SEAL, author and co-founder of Echelon Front. We discuss his childhood in Texas, the Native American community, his journey into the Navy, leadership in the first responder professions, the...
Fire Chief Adrian Dillehay serves as the executive leader of the Westfield Fire Department, where he began his fire service career in 2007. An East Aldine native, he joined the Houston Fire Department in 2011 and...
Josh Brolin is a former wildland firefighter, actor and writer. In this second interview, we discuss social media, fame, family, kindness, trolls, adventure, writing and much more. Josh's Book: From Under the Truck....
Steph Crossland spent her firefighting career with Orange County rising to the rank of Lieutenant. After a near fatal accident, she transitioned to full time ICU nursing. We discuss her journey into the fire service,...
Erica L. Hay is the owner and managing attorney of Spartan Law of Florida, PLLC, bringing more than 30 years of combined experience in law enforcement, criminal justice, and legal practice. Before becoming an attorney,...