Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Beginner's Mind

Beginner's Mind artwork

#116: Yair Reem - From Net Zero to Gigatons: The Extantia Capital Blueprint for Climate Tech Investing

Sep 14, 20232 hr 4 minAudio

Did you know that the fight against climate change is shaping up to be the biggest business opportunity since the rise of the internet? Imagine a multi-trillion-dollar market waiting to be tapped! Yair Reem and his €300M venture capital firm, Extantia Capital, are not just imagining it - they're building it. Tune in to discover how you can be part of this green gold rush! 🎙️ What's in the Episode: 1️⃣ The Urgency of Climate Change: Yair discusses why climate change is not just an environmental issue but a ticking time bomb that affects every sector of the economy. 2️⃣ The Role of Venture Capital: Learn how Extantia Capital is more than just a fund - it's a €300M platform that unites mission-driven entrepreneurs, scientists, and business leaders to advance the transition to a greener future. 3️⃣ The Multi-Trillion Dollar Opportunity: Yair shares insights into how the fight against climate change creates unprecedented business opportunities, potentially even 100x bigger than the internet revolution. 👨‍💼 About Yair Reem: Yair Reem is more than an investor; he's a builder. From childhood Legos to Electrical Engineering and co-founding Extantia Capital, his path is fueled by a drive to make impact. With experience on both sides of investment, he knows what makes a firm succeed. His motto, "Do well by doing good," shows his belief that profit and impact can coexist. 💡 LINKS TO MORE CONTENT Host: Speaker 📌 Quotes: (21:10) "The technologies we have today can only take us halfway to net zero emissions. There's a lot of technology that still needs to be developed and scaled to make it ready for the mass market." (23:38) "To bridge the 50% gap in fighting climate change, we need to deploy capital to motivate scientists to develop new solutions and companies to scale those solutions." (57:58) "When we look at the intersection of public and private sectors, we see that regulators are essential for both basic research and for making certain industries profitable where they currently aren't. But the key question remains: How do we ensure that these profits are reinvested to drive down costs and improve processes, rather than being siphoned off for other uses?" (1:07:08) "The worst time to raise money is when you need it; the best time is when you don't." (1:36:32) "We don't just take a good team and build a good product with them; we take a good team with a good product and help make that an excellent business." (2:01:12) "My wish is that we will see much more peace in the future, thanks to ubiquitous and cheap energy." ⏰ Timestamps: (03:30) Yair Reem's Journey: Electrical Engineering to Climate Tech (09:33) Urgency of Climate Change (21:10) Tech Gap: Net Zero Emissions by 2050 (22:06) Tech Innovation in Climate Change (23:38) Bridging the 50% Gap (30:36) Sustainability, Growth, Social Justice (40:38) Short-Term Sacrifice for Long-Term Gain (42:31) Role of Regulation in Climate Solutions (48:47) Financial Returns in Climate Investments (59:01) Airline Profits: Bankruptcy to Flourishing (1:03:34) The Tim Cook Effect (1:13:02) VC Ecosystems: Secret Sauce (1:19:57) Art of Syndication in High-Stakes (1:28:35) Retrofitting the Future (1:39:40) Uninvestable Cap Tables (1:40:56) Negotiating Equity with Universities (1:47:44) Double-Edged Sword of Secondary Investments (2:01:05) Future of Energy: Ubiquitous, Free Access Send us Fan Mail Support the show Join the Podcast Newsletter: Link Your Next Move: Link

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

Christian SoschnerDid you know that the future of energy could be both ubiquitous and free? Imagine a world where geopolitical tensions over energy resources are a thing of the past. This isn't just a dream. It's a vision that today's guest believes is entirely possible.

SPEAKER_06And my wish is that we will see much more peace in the future thanks to Ubiquities and cheap energy. You know, we say that uh instead of just being a unicorn, we want them to abate a gigaton. Um, so these are as it was coined, like gigacorns. So we would love to have that one of our companies at the end of the day, that we can come in 30 years' time and say, you see that technology, you see these lithium-ion batteries?

SPEAKER_06That was the company that we uh we backed and helped scale the likelihood that you know, if three guys, four guys uh are coming together out of university and are starting a company that all of you are gonna stay forever, uh, and even forever can be even after for more than a year together, um is not high.

Christian SoschnerYayer VM is a visionary investor and the driving force behind Extancia Capital, a venture capital firm lesser focused on climate tech and sustainable solutions. They are not just chasing unicorns, they are hunting gigacorns that can evade a gigaton of carbon emissions. In this episode, we will navigate through five critical conversations that could be game changers for your investment portfolio and your company's sustainability goals.

Christian SoschnerNumber one is the pitfalls of cap tables. Learn why a poorly structured cap table can be a deal breaker for investors. The second topic we delve into is the importance of westing. Discover why westing is crucial for startup founders. The third topic, the future of energy. Get insights into how energy could become both ubiquitous and free. The fourth topic is geopolitical implications.

Christian SoschnerUnderstand how energy independence could reshape global politics. And the fifth one, advice for founders. Gain actionable advice on how to make your startup VC ready. So if you're a CEO or investor interested in the future of energy and sustainable investing, you can't afford to miss this episode. So go ahead, hit that subscribe button, leave a comment, and share this podcast.

Christian SoschnerYour support helps us deliver more insightful content like this for free. Trust me, you will want to listen to the entire episode to get the full scope of Yah's vision for a more sustainable and peaceful future. Yeah, yeah. How how how should I spell your name correctly? I'm uh not so I don't speak your mother tongue, Hebrew. Thanks a lot, Christian. Um, the the right way is uh Yahir. Yah ear, yeah, ear.

Christian SoschnerWhat is the meaning of the name? Will give light. Will give light, that's a great name. That's a great name. And your second name, Rem, how do I spell that correctly in in in Hebrew? Uh that would be Re M. Re M. So there is a break, it's Yahir and Re M. Correct. Re M means uh an oryx in Hebrew. Cool, cool name, great name, great name. And you're you you're you're based in Germany, basically, in Berlin. Correct.

Christian SoschnerHow come that you moved from from Israel to Germany?

SPEAKER_06Because life is full of surprises. So uh basically I came uh one year uh for one year, and that is already uh 14 years ago. So I came to check uh this uh distance relationship with that. I had uh with my girlfriend back then who's from Germany, and it turned out to be uh a good one. So I uh stayed, and we have two kids, uh 11 and 9 years old, and time flies.

Christian SoschnerCongratulations, congratulations a lot. How is Berlin these days?

SPEAKER_06Well, I think the city is changing and always for for the better, but definitely being here already for 14 years, you've you've seen it through going through uh the different cycles, uh especially on uh on the innovation side, on the high-tech side, on the real estate market. Um, so it's been it's been a while now.

Christian SoschnerYeah, yeah. Let's get into the topic of the podcast, your journey into the intersection of venture capital and climate tech with Extancia extension. What is how do I spell the name of the fund correctly? Extancia capital. Extancia capital. Uh, how did you you uh develop into the role of a venture capitalist?

SPEAKER_06Uh that's a very good uh question. So, I mean, again, uh like everything else uh in life by chance. Um, in my background, so I always liked uh playing and building things and uh playing Lego. So I ended up studying electrical engineering um and was an engineer for a while, uh predominantly in the telecommunication uh um space. So I really like uh technology. Uh with uh the move to Germany, as I just mentioned, I um needed to decide what I want to do next.

SPEAKER_06So it was uh either joining uh or uh the first option would have been to join a startup. Um but uh talking about the changes in in Berlin back then, like almost 15 years ago in Berlin, there weren't a lot of uh hardcore, hardware, B2B technology startups.

Christian SoschnerThis was around 2007, 2008, right? Correct, correct.

SPEAKER_06We had a bit of a financial crisis back then, so it was a really interesting yes, and and most of the stuff that was here was uh Zamber Brothers back then, offline to online models, B2C, digital, uh less of uh uh hardware and B2B uh topics. Um, so I ended up uh eventually uh getting to know uh people at um Hassel Plattner Ventures, uh, which was the investment arm of Hassel Plattner, the co-founder and chairman of SAP.

SPEAKER_06And uh started as an analyst um that knew something about technologies. The fund was always looking at B2B topics, and ended up doing all kinds of roles over the following decade from analyst to investment manager to CFO and eventually uh managing director of of the fund. So that's kind of how I transitioned um to venture capital.

Christian SoschnerAnd why did you decide to go for climate tech? I mean, venture capital is in almost every high-tech area. I have a background in life science, med tech, digital health, but there are also uh space, space exploration, for example. What drew you to climate tech?

SPEAKER_06Great. So uh I think it's it's something that grows on you, right? It's not something that you wake up in the morning and you say, okay, this is what I want to do. Exactly. Um, but I think over the years, um, in venture capital, especially at House of Longer, most of the stuff that we were doing was software. So, first of all, that was a little bit of strange for me because I'm a hardware engineer, but I was actually doing a lot of uh software investments uh over the years uh because of the connection also to SAP.

SPEAKER_06So a lot of enterprise software, infrastructure software, um, a lot of uh that. Um, but then here and there we touched upon upon uh hardware topics. So, for example, semiconductors um and other things. And then when I joined, that was around 2010. And basically, these were still the heydays of Cleantech 1.0. So back then, uh, apart from doing software, uh, our mandate as a fund was also to do cleantech.

SPEAKER_06And uh therefore at the time we were looking at stuff, we did something also, and we looked at a lot of uh things before in 2012 things started uh uh basically uh the bubble burst of of the cleantech 1.0. Um and with that we learned uh many lessons. So I think that was the first time that I actually started looking into the topic and understanding the dynamics of of the market, but Extancia didn't exist in 2010 and 12 or that was as part as as Hassel Platform Ventures.

SPEAKER_06Extancia is we need another decade to get to Extancia. And and when did you decide to form Extancia? So we decided to do that around 2019. Basically, uh, my partners and I have known each other for many years. Uh one of the partners has uh kids in the same age, and you know, Kita is the kindergarten, is is the best place to network without parents. Meanwhile, the kids are in school and they are independent, they go alone, they come alone, so you don't interact with the parents as much as you used to do in the kindergarten.

SPEAKER_06And then you talk and you hear what the others are doing and and the connections, and that's how we started talking about uh with my partners uh over the years. Uh um, basically, to uh what are you doing? What are these guys doing? And um my partners started going into uh uh environmental uh in investments, or uh in German you say Umwelt Technologien, yeah, or some sort of cleantech uh topics also around 2015-16 into what today is uh is uh uh geothermal that is uh that is today very uh widespread, but at the time it was very innovative and in its uh initial.

SPEAKER_06And through that, and I was also engaged in in the topics looked into the into what was going on in North America. So basically, I think that after 2015, so maybe if we talk about clinic climate tech, I think that we had some kind of uh dead period between 312 and and 15, 16, uh, because everybody was burned and a lot of billions were burned in in that round. Uh so everybody were licking their wounds, but the topic remained.

Christian SoschnerWas this was this was this so such a hard time, 2012 to 2015-16, that uh really after the bubble burst, people didn't want to touch uh clean tech anymore?

SPEAKER_06By all means, really, so the there was no there was no capital available, and even as things started back in 2016, let's say 17, and even when we started in in 2019, 2020, at the height of the pandemic, um it wasn't clear that this is gonna be what is it today. Yeah, the topic climate tech was the the the name climatech was just being started back in 2020-ish, and what how we think about it today is really the last couple of years.

Christian SoschnerSo basically so you basically went with your partners into an area where everybody said no, we don't interrupt. Why why did you why did you do that?

SPEAKER_06I think you know it started with uh, you know, you know, sometimes I say it's uh it depends to who I'm talking, right? So the the you know, it at some point that, and this is when when you were talking about how you end up in climate, is that after doing a decade of software investments and which was great and with a lot of success, you ask yourself, okay, what do I want to do next? And for sure I wanted to start my own fund and be an entrepreneur and start start something from scratch.

SPEAKER_06And what is the one thing that I want to focus and spend my time? What is the one thing that I over this decade of doing things? What was a lot of fun for me? So software is kind of ruled out, going back to the roots of uh of the of the hardware.

Christian SoschnerUm but this sorry to interrupt you, but this would have been the easy route because I remember software, everybody up to 2020 wanted to invest in anything with software.

SPEAKER_06For sure. And all my friends, you know, coming from Israel, all my friends are in cybersecurity pretty much and and are doing very well. Um, but I like the road not taken. So um maybe it's the harder one. Um, so that was maybe uh one thing, and the other is is definitely on something that is meaningful on on a global scale. Yeah, and and I think this is climate is is definitely one of those. For sure, there are others like like healthcare for, for example, or education.

Christian SoschnerNow, climate is definitely something that uh is very important. For I had recently a podcast with uh Dr. Kimberly Miner from uh she works at NASA, and it was very eye-opening uh her comments on the state of the climate. So I think it's a very important factor.

SPEAKER_06Yes, definitely. And and in this regard, I I think that um maybe the the beginning, the genesis was too good. Yeah, we want we want to dedicate out our ourselves to something that we can really uh uh make a big difference, and maybe maybe also create a return. Um, and we will come to that maybe later in the discussion. But pretty fast we understood that there is a huge business opportunity here, and it's actually worth pursuing as a full-fledged venture capital.

SPEAKER_06And that's kind of coming full circle uh how I landed up in uh in climate, in venture climate, and also how we came together and thought, okay, this is worth pursuing.

Christian SoschnerThat's great. Let's dissect our podcast conversation into several parts. Let's start uh first talking about your mission in climate change and what climate change basically is, how you view the problem as a fund. Then let's dive a little bit into the current political landscape, uh, how it, especially in Europe, how it helps or prohibits development in climate change. And then let's talk about uh where you as a fund see the big opportunities. And uh, I got uh aware of your um profile with your posts about cap tables, and I would love to explore also this part with you because it's uh one part that founders usually don't talk about and don't have an eye on, but I think it's very important to have that covered, if that's okay with you.

Christian SoschnerLet's let's start with the first part. Uh, your investment strategy with Extancia Capital, how do you contribute to the broader picture of climate change?

SPEAKER_06So maybe maybe we should start a little bit earlier. It's it's uh to understand the problem. And and the problem is that we don't have time. Um is uh yeah, we're running out of time if we want to save the planet, so to speak, um, from the global warming and and getting to stopping at 1.5 degrees or stopping at two degrees or stopping somewhere, then we need to change. And and to change that would mean, and that's coming maybe later also to the to the business opportunity, we need to fundamentally change everything we know.

SPEAKER_06Everything, every uh unlike other things that we do uh uh with cybersecurity or healthcare, yeah, it these these are industries. Here, in order to reach the goal of stopping the climate change, we have to change all industries. Every single item needs to change. The uh the way this uh computer is being manufactured, the way things we're wearing are manufactured, and etc.

SPEAKER_06etc. This is also where why hardware plays such a big role because at the end of the day we're talking about molecules. CO2 is a molecule, molecule is a physical item, and you cannot just um blockchain it away or or sus it away. So you have to come, it can help, yeah, for sure, but it cannot be the entire solution, right? I mean, you we have cars that are running, or planes, or ships that are running on fuel.

SPEAKER_06Again, you cannot replace it with blockchain, right? So you you you have to write to find other sources, and that's why most of the stuff that we're looking at is is is is hardware. So basically, in order to um to do this, we need technologies, we need new solutions. Some of them, as we're looking today, are looking very trivial, but they were not a decade ago, right?

SPEAKER_06So if we're looking, for example, we're talking about uh solar panels or fuel cells or lithium ion batteries, yeah. These all look like commodities today, but lithium-ion battery was invented or came to the market the first time in 1991. So basically, at that time, that was an innovative technology. Now, that means that it took these 20 years, 30 years in order to come to full scale in the market.

SPEAKER_06That means that if we want to do something about climate, we have these next decades, the next two decades, that we have to come with innovative solutions. Basically, the the thing is that we have a carbon budget. Carbon budget is how much of CO2 or CO2 equivalents of green, let's say greenhouse gas emissions, right? Uh, because methane and others are also uh uh greenhouse gases emissions, uh, how much of that are we allowed to pollute to emit generally if we want to stay below 1.5 degrees or two degrees?

SPEAKER_06And the numbers vary, right? I mean, the good scenarios, bad scenarios, etc. But in all the scenarios, if we want to uh um do something, then we have to change the amount of emissions till the end of this decade if we want to stay below 1.5, and if we want to stay below two degrees, we have to reduce emissions uh in the next 20 years.

SPEAKER_06So that means that we don't have a lot of time, it means that all these technologies that we already have, we need to deploy them, we need to accelerate the deployment of those technologies. But the challenge is that those technologies can get us only halfway to net zero. So at the end of the day, by 2050, we want to be at zero emissions or net zero emissions or almost zero emissions, right?

SPEAKER_06What is almost zero? There are things that will still emit, part of it is the natural cycle, but then we will have to compensate with something else. Okay, so that it's we're talking about net zero. So everything we have today, the technology we have today, according to International Um Energy Association, um are just good to take you halfway. So there is a lot of technology that needs to be there, but it's still not there, and it's not like it's not invented usually.

SPEAKER_06So it's not like we need to do pure RD, pure science, but we need to scale it, and we need to bring it into a position that it is ready for mass market, and ready for mass market is means that it's at a price point that is ready for it to scale. And we can talk about that also about that later, also when we talk about political landscape, etc. But that boils down at the end of the day, long story short, is that we need a lot of technology innovation in order to beat climate change.

SPEAKER_06And that is why Extancia here. Extantia here is a venture capital, because the the um Asset class that is responsible on technology innovation, historically, is the one that has pushed technology innovation is venture capital. And we believe that you need a fund that is dedicated to the topic, that is climate first, in order to think how do you do things, uh, the right things first, and then naturally with the VCIs to scale and not do the other way around, like the generalists that you first invest and then you color it green.

SPEAKER_06And sometimes it's light green, sometimes it's dark green, but it's not necessarily moving the needle. I mean, if we look backwards 20 years, what has been done where venture capital historically invested, um, then you see it's a lot of that is mobility. But mobility is just maybe 20% of the problem.

Christian SoschnerOkay, so it was basically Tesla uh cars, electric cars, uh that exactly.

SPEAKER_06Electric cars is uh electric electrification of mobility, let's say.

Christian SoschnerYeah, did they did that did I get it right? So basically, if we uh deploy all technology that we have to fight climate change today, we still have a gap of uh 50% to make up. So we cannot uh tackle the entire problems with the existing technology. Uh to bridge that gap, the 50% gap, someone needs to deploy capital to motivate scientists to develop new solutions and motivate developers to develop the solutions then to the market and motivate uh companies with market access to scale the deployment of this uh technology.

Christian SoschnerMy question to you is I mean, you mentioned blockchain. So, for example, uh if blockchain fails, with currently, I think the Fed and the SEC is investigating and tries to shut down or put down something. I mean, if blockchain really fails, it's it's bad probably for micro strategy with uh a lot of Bitcoin are at 46 billion, but uh the human race won't go extinct because blockchain is not there. Uh, what's the scenario if uh climate tech fails?

Christian SoschnerIf you say, okay, we don't do it, we don't invest in climate tech, what would be the outcome for the human race?

SPEAKER_06Well, I I don't think that the human race is gonna be extinct, but but uh the world as we know it will change massively. Uh basically, the implications of even half a degree uh warming is that a lot of the stuff that we know is is gonna change. The coral reef the biggest example is that the coral reefs are gonna be extinct altogether, and that in itself is gonna start ripple effects to uh effect on nature, and uh basically with um with warming uh temperatures we'll see multiple effects.

SPEAKER_06Uh let's take agriculture, for example. Uh, crops yields are gonna go down significantly, uh, so less food to feed the planet, so more hunger. Um, and uh maybe one point on that in a second. Um, infrastructure, hurricanes that we see, fires. So infrastructure is is gonna be hit, roads, electricity, um, the coastline, the uh the water is uh levels are gonna rise up. Um and the most important that I want to emphasize is that there is a lot of social inequalities here.

SPEAKER_06So basically, the developing world is gonna be hit much harder than the developed world, and that is very unfortunate, and that in itself will trickle down because we will see much more uh massive immigration waves. So everything we see today in the Mediterranean, this is like uh um a preview, small preview of what we're gonna see if millions of people will have to um will have to migrate.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, so that in itself is gonna do a lot of debates, not to say local wars, uh, etc. So I don't want to picture a doomsday, uh, but definitely um it's gonna be very, very different than than what we as we know today.

Christian SoschnerYeah, I think the migration probably uh when I look at the newspapers these days, I think a cultural cache is already there. And if you scale it up uh and don't do it a little bit more smoothly, uh probably as also effect. Um is half is half a degree such a such a huge difference in your opinion?

SPEAKER_06It it is. It's I mean, it's uh it's definitely there there are very nice tables that show that everything, which types of birds are gonna uh vanish from the ecosystems. And as you know, I mean, this is not about necessarily about the single species that that is extinct. This is more about the um ecosystem effect that that is happening.

Christian SoschnerI mean, there are there are two ways to tackle the problem, then in my opinion. So one way is uh just prohibit traveling, you say please stay at home, you are not allowed to purchase anything anymore, uh, except what you need, so that you drive down consumption and less travel and less uh logistics. And the other side is uh technology and innovation. In your opinion, what's the role of technology and innovation? What's the contribution that will bridge that gap of 50%? How much impact will it have?

SPEAKER_06Right. So let's let's start with uh with what what you you just said. I mean, there is there is uh behavioral change and there is technology innovation. Now, it is not that we don't believe that we should all be more global uh uh citizens of the world and good corporate uh citizens. Yeah, we we have to. We have to think more about how we consume things. Do we need to consume everything that we consume?

SPEAKER_06Can we recycle? Do we really have to fly for our next vacation? Um, etc. etc. Right? So we have to be better consumers and more responsible consumers. This will come. The impact of that is estimated at getting to net zero, maybe 10%. The challenge is that as much as we want to, not the world is not going vegan. Okay, people are not gonna stop flying.

SPEAKER_06If you look at the uh the Paris um air show that just ended, it was announced that all the airline company uh the the OEMs, the Boeing and Airbus are booked out for the next 30 years or so in terms of plane deliveries. So people are not gonna fly, uh uh stop flying, and people are not gonna consume meat. And you know what? It may not be an equal and just demand to say, hey, middle classes in developing countries, now that you're you're finally in middle class and you can allow to consume meat, you're not allowed to.

SPEAKER_06So this is not necessarily a just uh um transition, and we have to make sure that the transition is is makes justice to to everybody. So I believe that it's more on us, again, coming back to technology the technologists in in the room, is to come up with solutions that enabling life uh but are more sustainable to the plan so that we can continue with the growth, and growth is not necessarily a bad thing, but it has to be decoupled from pollution, it has to be sustainable growth, green growth.

SPEAKER_06And and I'm sure that with the right solutions, we can definitely go in the right way. Um, we need to find uh maybe uh cultured meat that is uh that is very similar to meat. Maybe we need to uh invade uh cows that don't burp and fart uh anymore. So um airplanes that that are clean, be it sustainable aviation fuel, be it hydrogen-based planes, and and you name it. Yeah, but it's about us to find the solutions because it's very, very difficult to rely on human race or human nature to to change.

Christian SoschnerYeah, I think if that's possible. I mean, I often thought about uh when you look at Europe, for example, flying. Um I mean, before 1989, um, when I look back in history, uh World War II, World War I, so Europe was the battleground over centuries, basically. It was uh built on battle. And with 1945, it changed, and I think it tremendously changed after 1989, after the Cold War was over. And in my opinion, this uh possibility of many people traveling across Europe from east to west, north to south, uh made people talk to each other.

Christian SoschnerAnd when they talk to each other, they learn to understand each other, and when they understand each other, they have less intention to fight against each other. And uh sometimes I think when we prohibit traveling and we turn that down, maybe it goes the other way around then and uh in a direction that I don't want to go back. Um, I also believe that tech uh plays a crucial role, but the the the question I have to you now is uh I mean, is it really just uh the companies that have to do something, or does politic also play a role in that game?

Christian SoschnerWhat's the role of politics in your opinion? For sure.

SPEAKER_06I mean without politics, uh again, this this is probably one of the most complex topics uh out there. And usually usually number one in in a VC advice is never start a company in a highly regulated market. So this is a very regulated market. So we're acting against the advice, but hey, if we don't do it, then then nobody's gonna do it, so to speak, right? So we have to do it. Um, but definitely, so so I think that without politics, without the regulator, nothing will happen.

SPEAKER_06And in this regard, uh because the private market again, um, and we'll we can talk about that also later, but it's it goes all back to money. So, in order to move something, it's sorry for being the capitalist for a second, but but um it's all about making money. And if the private market doesn't identify the business opportunity in something, just because of scaring people with the coral reef and the birds being extinct, nothing's gonna happen.

SPEAKER_06Uh, there are so many statistics about it and behavioral uh uh psychology that talks about if you want to motivate people for action, you have to so to show good things rather than uh uh color them uh in black uh colors, right? So you have to show the opportunity rather than the um the challenges, right? Um so in that in that in that case, you have to make the private market move. So the private market is all about money.

SPEAKER_06And in order for the private market to move, you have you need to have the regulator. So that is why the decisions that the regulators that countries are taking, um, that is why the discussions, the the COP discussion, or every uh the IPP um IPCC uh reports, these are all super critical um in order to start the moving of countries in this direction and basically taking decisions or pledges to reduce emissions and then with carrots and sticks to navigate through this uh transition.

Christian SoschnerWhen I look at the uh the latest moves from regulators that I'm aware of, uh I think Biden has uh put some policies in place. Um several trillions, I think. It's uh huge climate funds. And also the European Union has uh um, I think put out uh a green deal. How do you see the influence of uh public capital flowing into the market? Does it replace private capital or does it uh add value to the anti ecosystem so that you can just do more faster, better, and quicker?

SPEAKER_06Right. So again, again, to answer that, uh I will have to start with something before. Um basically, I think that as I said, what we want to achieve is the fact that uh goods and processes, the way we do things today, we will continue doing them, but in a more sustainable way. So in a way that is not polluting as much CO2 or other greenhouse gases uh to the air as we do today.

SPEAKER_06So basically, the thing is that, and this is the interesting part of it, is that the solutions exist, right? I mean, uh we can find ways how to tank our airplanes in uh in a sustainable way today. We can uh uh do uh textiles which are fair and uh have no uh GHG emissions, etc. etc. But the challenge is that most people don't want to pay the price for it.

SPEAKER_06It's such that the sustainable solutions are usually more expensive than the gray or black or non-sustainable solutions. There are several reasons for that. Let's the the non-sustainable solutions have been perfectionized over the last 150 years. Yeah, the entire industrial revolution, all the yeah, if you look at the oil-based products, gas-based products, this has been uh perfectionized for now already more than 70 years.

SPEAKER_06So it's not by chance that these the prices are now really, really, really cheap. And especially we were just mentioning earlier about uh just transition and and social inequalities. You cannot come now to people in developing countries and tell them, okay, you know, we in Berlin Mitte, we buy now uh meat that is cultured at five times the price, you guys should do the same.

SPEAKER_06This is just it's not fair, it's not just, and it's not gonna fly. It's just not gonna happen. So basically, if the sustainable solutions would have been at the same price or cheaper than the non-sustainable solutions, then we would see a shift. Because again, we said it's all about money. So people care, you know, if it's price or climate, you know, it's not always clear, right?

SPEAKER_06Or let's put it that way, for most people it's the price because people also think short term, right? So and in irrational. So basically, what we need to do, basically, the task is to take technologies that are sustainable, but today they are more expensive and get the price down to a price parity with the uh high emitting solutions. Now, this can be done in two ways.

SPEAKER_06One is for the regulators to increase the price of pollution. This is like tax uh carbon tax, for example, so that if you're polluting, you're gonna pay more. So if you're using coal, then the price per kilowatt hour is higher. Okay, so we're starting to close the gap. And the second is that technologies that are today um rudimentary or nascent, right?

SPEAKER_06We will scale them so that with the scale, this premium that you have today will be closed down and actually may go down even further. I'll give you an example. So, for example, um, if we look at solar prices, the price of uh solar electricity a decade ago was four times more than coal.

SPEAKER_06Today it's cheaper. So today it's not economically, it's more economically viable to have solar than coal. Now you have to solve the problem of storage, etc. etc. But in terms of the price, it's a game changer. People are now deploying solar panels not just because they want to do good for the planet, but it's good for business. Yeah, it's much more attractive, and this is where we need to go with all those technologies, basically.

SPEAKER_06And that's why the regulator and what the regulator is introducing and these carrots and sticks, and I can give an example in a second, um, are crucial in order to help us close this gap.

Christian SoschnerYeah, that's true. That's true. Uh human nature, human nature, it's uh really challenging to accept short-term sacrifices for long-term gains, especially when the long-term gains are not that clear. I mean, when uh I listen to you, I think half a degree, what's the huge difference in that? But when I have to pay more now, for example, electricity. I mean, uh currently in Austria, in certain parts of Austria, uh the price per kilowatt hour is uh 0.67 cents.

Christian SoschnerUm, two years ago it was below 10 cents. And people do care then and say, okay, why why do I pay so much? Why do I pay so much? It's unfair. And they quickly then shift to the cheapest opportunity on the market. And if you say it's solar, uh then it's clear that they say, okay, I mean, instead of paying this high price, I just uh install solar panels on my roof if I have one and go with it. I think this is a very clean and understandable way. But um, where is the opportunity now for startups and investors in that game?

Christian SoschnerI mean, basically it's very much regulated, politics-driven, so they can drive the prices up and drive the prices down, which uh I think in uh might have some uh uncertainties. Uh so one year it can be up, one year it can be down. Where do you see the opportunity for investors in startups?

SPEAKER_06That's that's a very good point. And before we go to the actual uh uh topics, but I think that what's very important, and you know, the gray hair that I have just means that I've seen Cleantech 1.0 uh is that we should not rely in this regard on the regulator. Yeah, the the incentive, the subsidies, one day they are there, the other day they're not there. If they are there, it's good. But what we where we look at and the companies and how we work with them, all of those companies need to be um financially viable.

SPEAKER_06The business models need to be economically viable, even without the subsidy. So basically, we want to see a pathway with all of them starting high. Yeah, as I said, they start expensive, but as they scale, we want to see them going down to be financially attractive in themselves. Now, if the regulator steps in, it might accelerate this path, it might help us close the gap faster, but even without that, we should be able to um to become financially attractive.

SPEAKER_06And that and that's on the volatility of the regulator. Though I must say that I think Europe is probably more stable than the United States, uh, where things with one administration can change to the other administration. Um, but uh whereas in in Europe it's it's slower, yeah. But when the train leaves the station, usually these things are not completely uh revised later.

Christian SoschnerUm I I think it must be a demand. I mean, what you say is uh I think it's that the the demand for any industry, it must be otherwise. It's not sustainable. So if we cannot reach the point where consumers pay for the best tech a low and affordable price, I think it's really difficult to motivate regions outside European jurisdictions to implement the same solution. Because I mean in Europe you can regulate it and say, okay, now you have to use it and we subsidize certain areas, but I don't see a spillover effect, for example, into other countries outside the European Union if the price simply stays high and it's just subsidized.

Christian SoschnerSo I think this is a very important point that the end goal of any new development in any industry that starts with, of course, subsidizing, because otherwise you don't get it off the ground. But the end goal must always be it must be economically viable and sustainable. And without this economic viability, it doesn't become sustainable. Exactly.

SPEAKER_06And and that's why when we look at stuff, the the economic viability is one thing that we're is very important for us. So when when we're investing, it's not just about uh about um how big the impact is in absolute terms, but also when is this impact and what is the size of that impact, right? So um what is the time for impact?

SPEAKER_06Can you get something done within this decade? Or it's gonna take you three decades. Yeah, um, I give you another an example in this regard. So um nuclear uh energy. If we're looking uh um on fusion, so a lot of stuff is being done in fusion, and I think this is very good, and a lot of more money should go towards innovation in fusion because one day it's gonna be probably the energy source that is where it's all gonna live from, uh, probably together with geothermal, but um it's gonna take many, many, many more years.

SPEAKER_06Okay, like decades more. One thing. The other, if we look at nuclear fission energy that has been with us for the past 70 years, this is still by far the most expensive source of energy. So assuming that fusion will come in and immediately it will be also uh uh cheap is probably wrong. And and and that's why when we're looking at it, it's like okay, this is probably not where we as venture capital should invest.

SPEAKER_06Maybe this is still an RD topic. This is something for governments to invest or high net worth individuals to invest in, but it's not, it's still RD, it's still pure science, it's not ready for acceleration with a venture capital fund.

Christian SoschnerSo basically, without uh the governments and the regulators, uh, I mean, it's the same in the farm industry. I mean, basic science wouldn't basically exist anymore. Let's just face it. Exactly. Without basic research, we don't get the innovation. I mean, of course, companies are also innovative, but they think I think the nice thing of universities is that people really can focus 100% of their time on pure basic research and that this is an asset.

SPEAKER_06All right, there is no time pressure when we're investing, there is time pressure. There is and and we may not want it because because you know things take longer in also in the hardware, but at the end of the day, and again, we are coming back that venture capital is generally it's it's about capital markets, and our investors we take money and they have alternatives. They and some of them are pension funds, and pension funds uh are by definition, they are uh collecting money from people, mom and dad, that are savings, and they have a fiduciary duty to generate the best return for them.

SPEAKER_06So now they need to decide where to put their money and generate the best return. So, should they put it in uh stocks, in bonds, or in venture capital that is doing cybersecurity? Or should they do that in uh in a venture fund that is doing climate? And if they do that, yes, they want to do do good for the climate, but they have to return money. So we have a time pressure, we have to create a return to our investors, and we cannot just say, Oh, come back in 30 years and we may give you something.

SPEAKER_06Thank you. Then we then the problem is that I may raise money, but I won't raise it from the pension fund. And that would be a shame because the big money is that can make a difference is these institutional investors, it's the sovereign wealth fund, it's the insurers, it's the pension fund. And we need to uh uh we cannot tell them, hey, stop investing in coal, you know, uh and everything that is polluting, now store everything in cash and don't put the money to work in something else.

SPEAKER_06We have to create green financial products so that they can divert their capital. And that's why, as Estancia, one of our first missions when we started was to be um um an investor that is an institutional grade investor that helps to shift that type of capital, that people can say, ah, it's not like we don't have a lot of no, you have an alternative. Here it is the alternative, and we need to help build more of those alternatives, and we need to speak the institutional uh language, and that probably means that I need to write a hundred policies, despite that we are just 10 people, uh, because I have to be ready for this type of money with all the gorilla weight that they are coming with.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, but if we won't do that, they will not be able to take the money out of the polluting stuff. So we have to create, it's all about shifting capital. That's the story of climate change: shifting capital.

Christian SoschnerYeah, and the capital is available. Now, thanks for pointing that out. It's a discussion I very often have with startups and also with with other investors that at the end of the day, if you want to tap into the big pockets, you need to create returns. Exactly. And when you look at the landscape here in Europe, my personal opinion is you mentioned pension funds, uh they could do more in Europe, basically. And compared to the United States, for example, where I think in venture capital a lot of money is flowing from uh endowment funds, pension funds, and all these uh big entities into venture capital, because I think the the United States have a clear picture on if I invest, of course I need a return at the end of the day.

Christian SoschnerOften when I talk with founders here in Europe, and I say, look, I mean, when you present the case, you must make sure that the investor gets a minimum of 10% per year annual return, because the alternative is always the SP 500. You can always invest in the SP 500. Berkshire creates 20% sustainable returns since the 1960s. And when a bunch of funds look at this and say, look, I mean, I can give Warren Buffett more capital, or I can give it to a startup, and the startup says, Yeah, we're doing good for the world, but don't create any returns ever.

Christian SoschnerI mean, the decision is clear.

SPEAKER_05Yes, exactly.

Christian SoschnerFull stop. Yeah, so which is it's good to emphasize that. But let's let's get a little bit back to the to the to the regulators. Uh, what is the impact of these policies that we mentioned before on extancia? Did you see an impact in your investment strategy?

SPEAKER_06For sure. I mean, uh first of all, we we try to stay atop on on top of all the policies, and there are a lot of them, but but let's take the United States, uh um the U, um the U, um the EU and UK, uh the Nordics, yeah, these are the main areas where we play. And what and what we see is twofold. I said we see carrots and we see uh sticks. Sticks is more of the carbon uh uh tax that is rising over time, that the corporates that are polluting are understanding okay, hmm, this is gonna be expensive.

SPEAKER_06If we're gonna do business as usual, uh we will no longer be competitive because the price, it's it's the same as the with the price of energy. What happened with the price of energy surge, all the margins were eroded. So companies stopped being uh um economically viable, uh profitable. So that is that is basically the same. If your cogs is growing because of the tax, then you're no longer making a profit.

SPEAKER_06So they need to they understand that they need to do different stuff differently. On the other side, these there are the carrots, and the carrots are, and I'll give them a concrete example, are stuff that are making the products of our companies more attractive now. Because nobody, again, not the individual consumer and not the corporates, they like to pay more. It's it's always have we have the same discussions. It's like they ask our companies, okay, uh, how much CO2 uh you reduce with this?

SPEAKER_06Oh, this is great, but you do get we do get it for the same price, right? So no the nobody wants to pay more. So if the regulator is now giving some subsidies, this helps us accelerate those this reduction. And I'll give you one example. So hydrogen, everybody's talking about the hydrogen economy, um, and what hydrogen, and for good reasons. I mean, today hydrogen, most of it um is being used for creation of uh ammonia.

SPEAKER_06So basically, you take nitrogen together with hydrogen, and in a chemical synthetic process that was invented over 100 years ago by Haber Bosch process, uh famous uh German dual. Uh, basically, you can create uh ammonia which is used as a fertilizer and feed the world. Half of the population in the world would not have existed without synthetic ammonia, and that's where uh uh hydrogen is used today. For the creation of this hydrogen, you're using stemethane reform.

SPEAKER_06Basically, uh it's it's a method that is using a lot of heat and therefore you're emitting a lot of CO2. So, roughly 1.5 percent of global emissions today are coming from the production of uh hydrogen and green and and and ammonia. Now, to replace that and to use hydrogen as a carrier for renewable energy, as a carrier uh to fuel cars and many other things that you can do with the hydrogen, you need a lot more of that.

SPEAKER_06Hydrogen can, if you deploy hydrogen at scale, you can probably replace a good 10% of global emissions. Now, here is the problem you cannot do that in the gray method, right? I mean, you cannot do it with the emissions, that's not the sense. But with the emissions today, the price is roughly one dollar a kilo, between one to two dollars a kilo. If you want to do it in a green way, and a green way is a way that is producing hydrogen without emissions, most of the time we're talking about taking the H from H2O from water in an electrolysis process, using as a feedstock a renewable energy.

SPEAKER_06Today the price for that is anywhere between 2.5 to$6 a kilo. So let's say there is a spread, but between two times to four times more expensive. Now the Biden administration introduced the inflation reduction act that among other things is introducing a subsidy, and again, it depends on the on the use case, but you can get as a subsidy three up to three dollars per kilo.

SPEAKER_06Now you remember the the spread, it was 2.5 to 6. So if you're anywhere between uh, let's say four minus three, now you're at one, now you're competitive. If you are at three and you're minus three, all of a sudden there is free hydrogen, green hydrogen, or you're actually making money, more money. Yeah, so it's a game changer, it's it's it's it completely changes the the industry and makes it much more lucrative for entrepreneurs to go into this topic and take nascent technologies and start deploying them faster at scale because they can make money.

SPEAKER_06There is a case. And and that's these types of things are those that are making a game changer um in the market.

Christian SoschnerWhen we look at the intersection of uh public and private sector, then um, I think what from what I understood from what you said is that on one hand, we need it for basic research so that we get more innovation. On the other hand, we need the regulators to uh help companies uh um operate profitably in areas where it's not possible yet. But this leaves me one question open then how can we make sure that the profits that are flowing in the industry then are used to drive the costs down and reinvest it in improving the process rather than just pulling it out of the process and uh use it otherwise?

SPEAKER_06That that's a very good question, and I'm not sure that I have the uh I was hoping for. But I I I think that what we see now is that that's where the regulator also steps in. I mean, uh there is this uh in several countries in the European Union and and also elsewhere, um, these uh windfall or uh what is it called, uh um profits. Windfall profits, yeah. Right. Um, I think those are being taxed because because of the energy crisis, there are a few companies that make the killing where uh the others uh consumers had to pay to make these uh unusual profits, and that's where the regulator steps in and says, okay, this is not normal, this should be taxed and go back to um to the circle.

SPEAKER_06So I think that's where we will see that things are misused. Yeah, maybe some will manage to get away with it, but overall, I think the um the regulator will step in.

Christian SoschnerYeah, it was an interesting development in the last year in the energy sector in Europe. I mean, from what I observed last year, the narrative was that the energy sector is close to failing because of high cost. And a year later, when I look at the balance sheets, many of these companies who said that they're close to bankruptcy now have uh tremendous profits in the bank account. Where I say, okay, where's the justification for the high price?

SPEAKER_06Same, take the airlines, uh Luftanza, which was pretty much bankrupt because of the pandemic, yeah, and was saved by the government, uh, is now flourishing, but they pay back every every cent, right?

Christian SoschnerSo yeah, it's a it's a tricky topic. So it's an ongoing, it's an ongoing game, I think. Let's let's go back to the back.

SPEAKER_06I'm just an engineer, I don't understand anything of this.

Christian SoschnerI have I have a business background. So with uh I mean tax taxing windfall profits or how we call it in German, über gewinne is a is a tricky topic. Um, because when companies in a jurisdiction generate or have the fear that uh whatever they do when they're profitable and have the potential to reinvest, somebody steps in and takes it away. They it's easy for them then to move the company, somewhere, for example, to the US or to Latin America or to Africa or to Asia.

Christian SoschnerSo tapping at the end of the problem into the result is much more tricky and difficult than just doing something at the beginning, like uh price fixing, for example, on the market, when you see you have these uncertainties uh to create stability. But it's uh I think this is a topic for an entire entire episode on its own. Let's go back to your fund, to Estancia, capital. Um, I think we talked about pension funds. So let's assume I have a pension fund, which I don't, but let's just assume it for the for the exercise.

Christian SoschnerUh, why should I invest in you? What's what's your unique approach?

SPEAKER_06Oh, that's a very big question. Um, so basically, I I think it's a combination of many things. Um at the end of the day, all of the answers should lead to the fact that that I believe that we as a fund can generate the return that they need and do uh uh good for the for the climate. And maybe we'll talk about it in a second, but these are not two different things that are coming together.

SPEAKER_06Um now the question is how we do that. And I think the answer for that is with a lot of hard work. So if there is one thing I learned about venture capital, this is not like gambling, it's not or the investment part of doing the investment, investing part of venture capital, that's the easy part. Making money is hard, or getting that money back, and that means that whenever we invest, or before we invest and when we invest, that's really where the hard work starts.

Christian SoschnerSo there is a lot.

unknownSorry.

Christian SoschnerLet's let's start it up to let's talk about your hard work of investing. I mean, uh, after what um Apple, for example, Apple is uh past three trillion mark on the market, and now everybody knows that Apple is a success. Um, when I look back 10 years earlier, uh, around 2010, 11, 12, it was the time when Steve Jobs died. Um, and when I look at uh the articles in the press, uh, they were not talking very highly about Tim Cook back then. So a lot of articles out there say uh Steve Jobs is dead, and how can Tim Cook take over?

Christian SoschnerThere is no visionary anymore, and the company will eventually definitely fail. Uh, now we know that Tim Cook is an excellent uh CEO. He has uh, I think uh Apple had a market cap of 600 or 500 billion 10 years ago. Now we have three trillion. Um, but before, knowing this this is a sound investment, stepping in in a turnaround situation, in a crisis situation is tricky. How is it in your sector? What is your hard work? How do you identify such opportunities?

Christian SoschnerUh, how much companies do you see per year to do so?

SPEAKER_06Uh many. So we're and we're above a thousand. We crossed that mark already a few quarters ago.

Christian SoschnerUm thousand companies in a year, yeah. Wow, but uh in the first half year only.

SPEAKER_06Um what do you what do you mean? It's over over a year, so every quarter we see over 250, 300 companies every every quarter. Every quarter, this is not and the number is actually growing.

Christian SoschnerYeah, so this is one one company per day, basically, a little bit more two companies.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, that's why we have a big team, yeah. And um because there is uh unlike any other VC in the generalist one, there is a lot of knowledge that that is needed here. Um about 70 percent of the stuff that we see is related to chemistry. So we have a head of science that she's PhD chemistry and helps us to basically with her and her network of academics to assess those companies and differentiate between those companies.

SPEAKER_06Um, we have a professor of uh life cycle assessment that helps us do all our carbon math. We can talk about that also um, and basically to be able to say whether the impact and the technology is gonna be big enough. Um, naturally, we also look at uh at the market, at the team, like any other venture capital uh firm.

Christian SoschnerThat's that's a lot of work done, I guess. For sure. How much time do you spend with a company before you make an investment decision?

SPEAKER_06It depends. There are, I I think it's anywhere between uh months to years. So we have, I think the fastest was probably I don't know, uh, six months or eight months. Um, and the longest is probably two to three years that we've known the company. We've known the founders, we they were not ready in our perspective. Um, and then with uh a lot of mutual work, basically over the years, we've seen how they're making advancement till the point in time that we say, okay, now it's the time to invest.

Christian SoschnerThis is always the question I get from founders when they ask should I reach out to investors only when I am fundraising and when I'm the perfect fit for the investor, or should I start building relationships early? What's your take on that? You said the longest investment was uh three years, so that you observed the company for three years, but what's your preference?

SPEAKER_06Very clear. Always reach out uh early, always build relationships. This is um generally it's the worst time to raise money is when you need money. Yeah. So the best time to raise money is when you don't need money. Companies that are doing well and don't need money are flooded with inbound interest from investors begging to put their money into those companies.

SPEAKER_06Companies who are with their heads to uh with our uh backs to the wall and are running out of capital, nobody wants to touch, or they will get really bad terms. So naturally it it's it's a balance, but it's it's a relationship, and at the end of the day, it's a people's business. So, and we will spend a lot of time together, so you better build that relationship over time. So when the right time comes in, then you can skip that part, you know each other, and you can talk really on what matters.

Christian SoschnerYeah, I think this is probably one of the points why investing is so hard because uh when you look at the life experience of most people, they are not investors, and uh then they become investors uh over time. But usually the training in school is transactional, so you ask for money when you need it, you ask for a pay raise when you need it, uh, you pay when you need it, uh, you buy something when you need it, and investing is a lot different. So it's uh it's not so much transactional, right?

SPEAKER_06And and I think you know, the the there is the all these exercises about uh monkey choosing uh stocks. So I I would never say that we're the smartest in picking companies, right? I mean, we're doing our best to pick the right companies that we believe that would that can be winners, but uh we can probably uh we probably cannot beat the odds of the venture capital industry. I think what's important is not about picking winners, it's about making winners.

SPEAKER_06So after we do the investment, that's what I was referring to, really the hard work really start. It's about uh rolling up sleeves and uh on both ends, and basically side by side making sure that this company uh has the best chances to be successful.

Christian SoschnerLet me ask you one question at this point because I feel I'm interested now. Uh, what is your hard work that you contribute? I mean, uh Warren Buffett, for example, says uh I deploy capital, you do your work, and that's it. Uh, what is your process after the investment? What makes you unique?

SPEAKER_06I I I think that there is a huge difference between uh Warren Buffett business, private equity uh and and venture capital. There is a huge difference between a real estate uh in a topic and um and and again venture capital. I I think that you barely read in the press that I don't know, Blackstone or uh real estate developer Bauvence, you know, they started whatever they invested in a project or a company, and because of that, maybe maybe Warren Buffett had that halo.

SPEAKER_06Because of that, you think, wow, what a great company. And because of that, that company is actually gonna be a self-fulfilling prophecy, is gonna be successful. Okay, Coca-Cola is not successful because of Berkshire Highway, uh, just because they bought a big share. In the venture industry, it's different. If Sequoia is or Andreessen, tier one companies are investing in a certain company, people start saying, Oh, this is an interest company.

SPEAKER_06Corporates say, Oh, this technology has been vetted, so they buy it. So, in turn, indeed, that company is becoming successful. So the self-fulfilling prophecy of winners are making winners and becoming again winners is is very different in in the venture industry, and that's why um when we come in, we work very hard in order. We know that if also if we're gonna be successful as a firm, that in turn is gonna help us in the future to become more successful, but um not just because of the ripple effects or the um this cycle of effects, but also because uh as we get better, as we get bigger, we have the resources or the networks to make this happen.

SPEAKER_06So, for example, you you ask about how we help, right? So we have a network of service providers that work with us that all of our companies are going to. So, for example, uh a recruiter that is specialized in the energy market that we're active in. So almost every company we invest in is going through that that guy or that firm because they know us, they know the needs, they have a pool of resources, and in return, we get really the best uh uh people to our companies.

SPEAKER_06And and this is goes the same in other topics, um marketing agencies, PR agencies, uh, branding agencies, right? So um um in our topic, uh, for example, what is very much important is non-dilutive capital. So we know the best agencies that can write applications for grants. So our companies increase their winning rates of non-dilutive capital so they have more cash to be successful. So this is basically how after the investment, really the hard work uh uh starts.

Christian SoschnerYeah, it's more these days building an ecosystem than just treating it like an investment.

SPEAKER_06Right.

Christian SoschnerUm, yeah, that's true. That makes a huge difference. Um, I hope that one day in Europe we will also have the sequers and entries year around. And your fund is probably one of those.

SPEAKER_06We we try to be the one for climate at least.

Christian SoschnerYeah, that's a good thing because I had uh Sebastian Malapi a couple of months ago on my podcast, and he wrote very extensively, it's a very, very great book. He wrote very extensively about the US ecosystem in venture capital, and he spent uh I think one-third of the book on China and Asia. And then I asked the question to him, why not Europe? Because as I said, there is no venture capital here in Europe. So that's basically, but it's getting better. Um, do you see that uh also Sequoia and Andresen Horowitz uh have built ecosystems that uh basically explains their success compared to European?

Christian SoschnerWe had European funds also in the 90s, but most of them don't exist anymore. Do you think this ecosystem thinking that you have makes this huge difference?

SPEAKER_06By all means, I I think that Andreasen was maybe the first one to really institutionalize the way they think if you go to their website, you see, I don't know, 200 people. Um, because basically they've built these um integration or these teams, the support teams internally. Basically, what we're using as as in uh uh external resources, we have the go-to people whenever we want to uh send our companies to someone, they've uh basically uh in-sourced it to do it uh in-house, right?

SPEAKER_06Um and a lot of that is is about Bizdev, for example. So if they have people that are doing business development for their companies, so they talk to corporates and make uh uh introduction days for corporates to come and see the portfolio, etc. etc. So it's really full-time positions that those guys are paying for from the management fee. This is nothing that you can ask the investors to pay. So this is our money that we pay in order to bring in more resources so that we can give back um to our portfolio.

SPEAKER_06And I think this is also, I mean, in this regard, we're a bigger team uh in comparison to maybe the normal DC of our size.

Christian SoschnerSo you basically sacrifice your short-term gains against uh your management fee to pay more people, yes, uh, to provide more services. So let's let's call it services, it's just a term, it's the first term that comes to my mind to to use that services for free, basically, for to drive your companies forward, to give your companies uh a competitive advantage in the market.

SPEAKER_06Exactly.

Christian SoschnerUh I mean in terms of Andrews and Horowitz, I think the success speaks for itself. So it's uh it's undeniable that it works.

SPEAKER_06That's the that's the hypothesis.

Christian SoschnerYeah, oh, I think it definitely definitely. Um let's look about the companies you're interested in. Um, you're based in Europe, as far as I remember, and you mentioned before the Nordics and UK and Germany. Uh, which areas are you investing? Geographical areas. Are you also investing in the United States or are you focused on Europe?

SPEAKER_06Sure. So we're we're European fund. Um that means that most and we're denominated in Euros. So that means that uh most of the stuff that we're doing, let's say 60% of what we're doing is in Europe as in EU 27 kind of. Uh Europe is a big definition. Um and coming from Israel, I you know, we we always ask, hey, is it including Israel or not? Right? Sometimes Israel is Europe, sometimes Israel is not Europe, but all of a sudden the Brits are asking the same, right?

SPEAKER_06So um, so generally uh uh we invest anywhere geographically, anywhere between Israel on the east and the UK on the west, and up to the Nordics, yeah, be it in if they are using uh euro or they're using crones. Um that's kind of the space. But I said most of the stuff is it kind of in in a heart in core Europe, so to speak.

SPEAKER_06Um, we are looking at things in the states, um, but uh we believe that the market there is very developed, so there should be a very good reason for us why to invest overseas. I mean, at the end of the day, and because of the stuff that we're doing and working very closely with our companies, the time zone is something not to be underestimated, the difference. Um it's a very local uh thing. So if we do investment in the US, it's probably not going to be where we're leading an investment.

SPEAKER_06One, and two, it's because we we had a look from a topic perspective. We believe that this topic is very determinantal for climate change, and the leader is in the states, so we want to invest uh over there.

Christian SoschnerSo basically, any company that is not in Europe uh can easily solve the problem when they relocate or when they position a headquarter in Israel, in other European countries, in the United Kingdom, in the Nordic, so they can choose. And when they did so, then they are fit for in investing.

SPEAKER_06I I I think we will have a look at any company from anywhere. It's just that we will not lead the deals in companies that are not in Europe. And there needs to be a very good reason why to invest in a different time zone.

SPEAKER_03Okay, yeah.

Christian SoschnerWhat is your preferred role? Do you want to lead the investment rounds, or are you more the relaxed followers, they'll say? We do both. Yeah.

SPEAKER_06So a lot of the time, so even when we're leading around, the nature of this business of climate is that the rounds are bigger than maybe what we can take, or they will be bigger than what we can take as a single fan. And I believe that there is a lot of merits for syndication. So that's why we never take an entire round. We always leave room for followers. So maybe 60% of the time we will be the lead and others will follow, but 40% of the time it will be the other way around.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, we will follow uh someone else.

Christian SoschnerNow syndication makes absolute sense in high-stakes games, especially when the company is not yet fully to-risk. Exactly. That's a good thing. It's uh also shareholders, does not mean uh that's that's just one owner. I mean, climate change is a huge topic. Uh, and with many different approaches, you mentioned hydrogen, we talked about electric, we talked about solar, then we have wind, uh, we have all kinds of developments. Fuels, for example, I think we tackled briefly. What is your focus with Estancia?

Christian SoschnerAre you open for every every development as long as uh it has climate in it, or do we have a narrowed down focus that you would like to see?

SPEAKER_06So basically, no, we we have a we have a focus, as I said, the the climate stack where emissions are coming from is is very broad. And basically, what we're focusing on is on topics um that are wherever we are seeing green electrons and green molecules. So that would be uh most of the things that are generating energy. Energy generally is like, I mean, 75% of the problem is energy.

SPEAKER_06You just dissect it into different topics like uh electricity, heat, and fuel, right? So across mobility, uh construction, uh industry, at the end of the day, it boils back to energy. So that's where we're very uh active. The others is uh industrial processes. I mean, this is also this is the um green molecules element. So we need to have uh processes basically or materials that are doing things in a way that resource things not from dinosaur bones anymore, but rather from biomass or circular.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, so we are using the C and the H that is already in the system in order to create uh the hydrocarbons or the molecules that we um that that we need. So these are kind of the uh topics. What does it exclude? So, for example, um that means that we're not focusing on B2C topics, we're not focusing on uh biology. Yeah, most of the stuff is physics, chemistry, what we do, so less biology, less synthetic biology, alternative proteins.

SPEAKER_06Um these are also topics that we believe that in the essence of them require uh behavioral change, consumer change. And again, as we said, we believe less in consumers to change, but rather delivering uh technology. So if we will do something in those areas, we will probably be the follower. But the focus is really physics, chemistry, energy, uh, electric electrons, green um molecules.

SPEAKER_06On top of that, basically, this is replacing or avoiding future emissions, basically, right? So this is all about changing the industry. We need to undo the past, and that's where we're very active in uh CDR, carbon dioxide removal, uh, specifically in uh in all types of removals, but most uh specifically with um directory capture.

Christian SoschnerYeah, undo the past. This is uh I think a hard topic often when I think about the changes that you said. We basically it means replacing entire infrastructures, also. Uh it means ripping uh just destroying the infrastructure that has been built over 150 years and then replacing electro electric cars. I mean, the European Commission said that we want to go electric, but it really means uh replacing the entire infrastructure, and this is a huge task, in my opinion.

SPEAKER_06That that's a super interesting point that that you're touching, and one that we're very adamant, maybe even maybe religious about. Okay, um, we strongly believe in retrofits. So, whenever we can retrofit things, we think that this is much, much better for different reasons. Now, for one, because of the time to impact, yeah, because it's faster. And a tone that is abated today is not equal to a tone that would be abated tomorrow, uh, because of all the side effects.

SPEAKER_06Um, so everything that we can do faster is much better. The second is that if we need to build in new fleets of assets, be it cars, be it uh plants, uh um, be it airplanes, uh then the carbon this is all being built with a current energy mix, right? So basically what we're doing is we're increasing our carbon debt. All this needs to be compensated.

SPEAKER_06So maybe if you look at railway, like driving railway today is zero emissions, but if you're putting a new track now, it's gonna take like 30, maybe even 50 years before this track is gonna be climate neutral. So if there is any chance that I can take, so everybody's talking about hydrogen-based uh uh airplanes. I'm not talking about electrical because these will never fly, literally, uh long haul.

SPEAKER_06Uh but the hydrogen-based, um, the energy density, the volumetric energy density of hydrogen is way bigger than kerosene, than jet fuel. So you need more space. That means that if you want to have hydrogen-based airplanes, that's why you see all this futuristic uh uh stuff, because you just need more space in the wings to store the hydrogen. That means you need completely new fleets, right? But the fleets are either there, or as we heard at the beginning, there will be built more.

SPEAKER_06And the more CapEx these are there, the industry is not gonna write it off. So it's on us to find solutions fast, how you can use existing infrastructure and retrofit it. That's why e-fuels, for example, uh, don't want to go into the discussion whether it's good for cars or not, but for airplanes, for example, as sustainable aviation fuel, it's a no-brainer that this is the pathway that we have to go.

SPEAKER_06Because, yes, maybe one day we'll have hydrogen-based plans, but that would make sense when we will all the current fleet will have to go out of service. And then in 50 years, we will start introducing hydrogen-based airplanes. Maybe it's gonna be uh fusion-based airplanes by then. But um, but it makes no sense to start building infrastructure. That's why we believe that also uh uh the oil and gas industry is not gonna disappear overnight just because we tell them, hey guys, you're polluting, so stop doing this thing.

SPEAKER_06We have to find a way to work with them to decommission or repurpose the things that they're doing. So let's take a well, and instead of taking oil, what do you guys know to do best? Ah, you know to drill. So why don't you drill instead of uh uh two kilometers or five kilometers? Why don't you drill to 10 kilometers and get into geothermal? Right? So we can repurpose a lot of the stuff so that we don't have to build new stuff.

SPEAKER_06Every every And the and and that brings maybe summarizes the three criteria that we as a fund we look at uh that summarizes very nicely. So one is how big the impact is, yeah, in absolute terms. Two, how fast what is the time to impact that you have, and third, can you leverage existing assets? Can you retrofit? How is it can be incorporated into existing uh processes?

Christian SoschnerNow that's very smart. This is something that's my assumption. Good to hear that uh there's there's something behind this assumption. I did such a calculation a few years ago when I decided not to buy Tesla. So it was one thing is okay, I want to help the environment, I buy a Tesla, and my driving behavior is basically uh 2,000 kilometers per year. So it's not very much. I have a now 20-year-old diesel, and it just did a calculation and say, I mean, look, when I buy a new car, uh I negatively impact the environment and much more than just continuing driving with the diesel for 2000 kilometers, as long as it doesn't go up to 50 or 100 per year, like commercial use cases, uh, I do probably more good to the environment to use the existing asset and uh keep using it compared to someone who replaces the car every year and puts something out of it.

SPEAKER_06By all means, if you replace uh, and I'm doing the same, I have a Zoe that is secondhand and uh which I'm listing, and that's great. I also did just 2,000 kilometers uh sometimes on the weekend, right? So why do you need something new? Why do you have this is talk we're talking about consumptions? Yeah, why change a car every two years, three years? Yeah, it's perfectly good. If you are changing it, it means that you're replacing it for something new, you're creating the carbon debt again, and the return times on cars, it depends on the calculation.

SPEAKER_06If you're really fast, I would say three years. So if you hold it for three years, maybe you just paid it back, yeah, because it's not zero, right?

Christian SoschnerAnd you can burn much more money better in venture capital or when you're destroying on the stock market. Uh I mean this is a tricky question that I have to you know. I mean, you have a portfolio, so you are not a new fund with no portfolio, uh, but we have a time limit, so we can't talk about eight hours. Um, to to show potential founders or LPs what kind of portfolio companies you have. Could you pick one uh due to time constraints? Uh to just exemplify what you said uh and uh talk a little bit about how you found the asset, why you decided to invest in the asset, and what you did after the investment.

SPEAKER_06Sure. So uh why don't we talk about uh Magnotherm, for example? That's uh uh the latest uh investment that we have done. So maybe less uh we will talk a bit a little bit less about uh the post-investment, but more about what we have. So basically, we've known the company for three years, and what the company is doing is that they're reinventing the fridge. Uh, the fridge or any cooling system as we know it has been out there for anywhere between 150 to 100 uh years, and every cooling system we know, be it an air conditioner, be it uh a fridge, uh they all work the same.

SPEAKER_06It's about the basic uh thermodynamics of gases. It's about the fact that gases as they expand, they are releasing heat, or basically you feel cool, right? So they absorb heat, and and when you could then you put energy, you contract them, right? So there is heat, and again, there you have a cycle, right, of cooling and and heating. That involves one, a lot of energy, and two, that involves well, gases, and many of those gases are not good for the climate.

SPEAKER_06Now basically, what Magnotherm is doing, um, they're doing things completely different. There is a different phenomenon in in nature that there are elements out there that when you apply a magnetic field on them, well, the same thing happens. They either absorb heat, which is then you feel that it's cold, or they release heat. And if you put an engine around that, a magnetic engine around that, then you can basically build a refrigerator.

SPEAKER_06And that is called the magnetocaloric effect. It's been known for many years, over a hundred years, but uh it people struggled in order to commercialize it, and honestly, there was no incentive to do that because the real fridge or the fridge as we know it was so successful. But now, and this is at epitomizes a lot of the stuff that we see because things were cheap, because energy was cheap, and it was cheap, not just because coal was cheap or because yeah, but because because because of the price, because but nobody cared about the environmental side effects, right?

SPEAKER_06So a lot of processes and things, how to do things were just neglected, neglected because you had other ways. But now that you start thinking about it, all of a sudden, other ways that were neglected before can become the mainstream of tomorrow. And with magnetocaloric, uh, the way this magnotherm they've managed to do that, not only you save uh 50% of the energy, so every fridge basically, especially the big ones in supermarkets, they need because they consume a lot of energy because you open, close, right?

SPEAKER_06Um, they you can reduce the energy that you're using, so electricity consumption by 50%, but also because you're using magnets and you don't use gases, boom, you don't have the F-gases question anymore. So, together, this this is a fundamental change to how we do uh things. And I said, this is epitomizes really the the stuff we're looking for. That I was said, we need to reinvent the wheel, literally, right?

SPEAKER_06We need to re to do to do things in the entire industry to do things very, very uh uh in a very different uh in a very different way. Now with Magnoth, so that's what they were doing. We've known the team for three years. They started with uh very early that was a lab prototype, and the goal was to build uh um an engine that would supply that engine towards others that are manufacturers of refrigerators, etc.

SPEAKER_06etc. So it was very complex. And basically, over the two years, we've worked with uh with a team to sharpen the go-to market to the point in time that we thought, okay, the guys have done an amazing work, and you know, not everybody's listening. So the fact that that not everybody listens and executes. Um, so the fact that they've uh uh made that such an advancement was very notable to the point in time that we decided to um to invest.

SPEAKER_06And now that we have invested, we're working on uh, like we like to say, um, we don't take a good team and build a good product with them. We take a good team with a good product and help make that an excellent business, and that's what we're working now on starting to sell and bring to the market and make it an amazing company.

Christian SoschnerThat's great. So basically, it fulfills your three criteria, it has a big impact, it's fast to market, basically, so you don't have to invest or wait 10 to 20 years. So it's uh the refrigerator is there, people use it, people need it, the need is defined. And when you just solve the problem of bringing it to the customer, you have a huge impact. So it's very fast. And it leverages also existing technology, it doesn't create new needs, so it doesn't need uh replacement of their industries, so they can use the logistics that exist already, the shops that exist already, and it just replaces the old refrigerator that used.

SPEAKER_06Exactly. And the interesting part, apart from the fact that all the parts, the magnets and everything can be recycled. So one of the most amazing companies that I've seen that are thinking cradle to cradle, right? So entire life cycle, how do you not just build but also dismantle and reuse um is uh the the fact that uh um they're they're bringing it to the market, and from day one there is no premium. So the total cost of ownership is already because you use less gases, you live you use less electricity, the total cost of ownership.

SPEAKER_06The this thing is cheaper than buying a gas-based uh uh refrigerator.

Christian SoschnerReally? For a consumer.

SPEAKER_06For the consumer, for the for the supermarket. Uh they don't look so the CapEx is higher, but the OPEX is much lower. And and those refrigerators, you you look at the total cost of ownership, you don't look just at the initial price.

Christian SoschnerYeah. So it's also for the household.

SPEAKER_06You can do that also for the household, but that's not, I mean, that would be a bit B2C. So they are talking to all kinds of OEMs in this in this regard, uh, but it's not necessarily our first go-to market.

Christian SoschnerSo basically, you would need um uh a license, a license deal or something that the company steps in and says, Okay, look, uh, I can bring it to the consumer, so that'd be licensed as technology.

SPEAKER_06Exactly. I get, I guess this would go via partnership.

Christian SoschnerSo it's the typical B2B model that you're looking for. Exactly. Exactly. So good to know for founders. Um, I found your profile uh via LinkedIn, and maybe we move to the to the to the found part. And uh I got curious in one of your posts where you showed me, let me just maybe I can flash it uh quickly. Let me so it was this post where you said uninvestable cap tables. And let's talk a little bit about founders' mistakes and focus on the on cap tables in the discussion.

Christian SoschnerUh, it's a topic that I see very often uh when founders approach me and say, Can you help us uh find investors and uh tell your story better? And they look at the cap table and you see something uh like like this here. Yeah, uh, for example, I had uh a cap table once with uh a studio that owned 80% of the company with uh the founders uh part-time working in the old jobs, and I said to them, Look, I mean, it's really difficult to find investors for that because uh there is no incentive for the founders to move that forwards.

Christian SoschnerThey have their jobs, why should they dedicate their lives? And one time when I tried to found a company, I had uh I was in discussion with a license deal from a university, and the university then said, uh, we want 90% of the equity. I mean, yeah, I should bring in the money, I should bring in the team, and you request 90% of the equity. So, what incentive is there for the founding team? And it was a long discussion, and they changed their opinion then in that. And it's very good, it's really good to see that an investor puts out a chart explaining the uninvestable cap tables.

Christian SoschnerI would be interested in your uh opinion and your words, why do you see that as uninvestable for uh for the from the investor perspective?

SPEAKER_06Sure. So, first of all, this was born out of a lot of frustration, yeah. Uh, that you are getting excited about the company, about the technology, about the team, and then you start to dig deeper and you say, Okay, can you share your cup table? And then all of a sudden you're like, ooh, well, what is that? Right? Because this is not the first thing that you're asking from from a company. Um, the thing is that when you invest, you invest in the future, you're not investing in the in the past.

SPEAKER_06Basically, a lot of people contributed, so there were many people and many fathers and mothers uh to this baby, especially if it's a successful one. Um, then there are many people that were doing something, and they are all somewhere on the cup table, but some of them were very fundamental to the birth of the company or to the earlier stage of the company and will no longer be relevant for the future.

SPEAKER_06And the current value of the company is is maybe X, but you know, when we're as VCs, we're investing, we want to see it not 10x, we want to see at least 100x uh uh on the value creation. So basically, the majority of the value is yet to be created. And as we discussed, this is a lot of hard work. So we want to make sure that those who are gonna create that value are well incentivized and are able to execute on that plan.

SPEAKER_06And these are two different things, yeah. So we need to make sure that they have the incentive and that they are able to execute. And the incentive is going back to ownership, they have to have enough ownership, and the ability to execute is governance. And if we see, like one of those examples that you've shown, one investor, okay, so you think it's nice, it's okay. Maybe it's one investor, and maybe that investor doesn't even have more than 30% of the cap table.

SPEAKER_06But that investor came with, I want to have veto rights on everything. And maybe and that investor is that in itself is not great. But if that investor is also a high net worth individual that is also always on the yacht, and you cannot get a hold of her or him to get signatures to execute, you're you're you're paralyzed. You cannot work like that. So and and and and this is all real stories, yeah.

SPEAKER_06We we've seen everything. So you need to make sure that the future, if you look at the cup table, you need to make sure that there is a future value creation ability in the cup table, and quite often you do all types of mistakes in the beginning, and like the second uh law of thermodynamics, you know, uh uh once you unleash it, it's very hard to undo something. Yeah, um, so you can try, but it's difficult, it's a lot of energy to put it back.

SPEAKER_06Um so when we are so now, and many people ask me, so it's not necessarily that we drop the ball if we see these types of cup tables. Uh if the company, if we are excited about it, and again, company may be successful, company may be good company, but if you want VC money, it needs to be VC ready. It's like myself that I need I need to be institutional ready. If I want money from institutions, I need to be institutional ready.

SPEAKER_06I need to play their game. If you want money from VC, you need to play the VC game, and the cap table needs to be. If you don't want money from VC, maybe the cap table is completely okay and you can continue doing whatever you do. But if you want money from VC, it needs to look in a certain it needs to look in a certain way. And then what we try to do is clean up. Yeah, and clean up, there are all kinds of ways to do that. Secondaries, dilution of uh non-active members, uh, issuing more ESO.

SPEAKER_06There are a few cards in the sleeve, not many, but there are a few things you can try to do. But there is a lot of tax implications, and it's usually not so easy.

Christian SoschnerAnd the opportunity must be absolutely worth it. So it uh it just uh sets the hurdle uh a little bit higher.

SPEAKER_05It's time exactly, it's time consuming, and there's a lot of emotions involved.

Christian SoschnerOh, yeah. And this is something that's fun. I mean, the from from my experience, I mean the advice I give to startups usually is uh the cap table is the cap table because it shows the people who can can bring capital to the table uh repeatedly and over and over again. So make sure that people who are on the cap table uh really can provide more capital in the future when you need it to grow your operations and don't put people on the cap table just because they are friends or you like them or you need them for a year, for example, lawyer, legal advice, it's good, it's necessary, but rather pay them in cash than hand equity out to them.

Christian SoschnerAnd some founders then say, Don't worry, it's so easy. Uh investors don't have a problem with that because they can simply buy the shares of those parties. Uh, do you buy shares basically from uh from from you said a zoo of investors, for example, you have 20 advisors who then say, Yes, give us our 10x return now, and you can have all shares.

SPEAKER_06Well, it's not unheard of, right? But it it really depends in in growth stage, it's much more common that you do a hundred million round and then 10 million out of that, or I don't know, five million out of that goes to secondaries. But if you're doing a five million round, we cannot allocate a million or two million out of that for secondaries because secondaries is money that is not going into the company, right?

SPEAKER_06So we cannot now invest instead of five, invest seven. So it has to come from the overall sum. And at an early stage, we would rather see as much money as possible going into the company rather than buying out somebody. Right now, we may do that if it's um a mean to an end. Uh we want to clean up the cup table.

SPEAKER_06Maybe um we want to get a blended valuation because we buy preferred shares at a certain price and then seed shares or or common shares at a certain other price, yeah, and then we get a blended uh valuation on our holding. Um, so it's not unheard of, but it's also like it's not the first thing that we would love to do.

Christian SoschnerYeah, it's the same picture that I got. Um the training I got in the VC funded companies I worked uh 20 years ago, uh almost 20 years, 17 years ago, was that there are only two liquidity events. It was pharma, basically drug development. And they was very clear and said, look, I mean, if if an angel investor puts in any money, it's not our problem. There are two liquidity events. You have an IPO or an acquisition, right? And that's it. And if they can't bring capital to the table, then they get diluted.

Christian SoschnerAnd there was absolutely no interest in buying at early stages for the sole reason that you described as I say, we want to put our capital to work in the company. And when we have to buy shares, the capital is that basically for our LPs. It doesn't work anymore.

SPEAKER_06Exactly, exactly. So it it has to be really in very outstanding cases that we would use this type of uh mechanism.

Christian SoschnerSo basically, what advice would you give to founders then when it comes to cap table to for the majority of the cases? Because I think the outstanding when we look at the bell curve, we have uh small percentages left and right, but the majority of the cases, what advice would you give to founders?

SPEAKER_06So I think the most important thing is vesting. Um let's put that way the likelihood that you know, if three guys, four guys uh are are coming together out of university. And are starting a company that all of you are gonna stay forever, uh, and even forever can be even after for more than a year together, um, is not high.

SPEAKER_06Okay, I don't have the statistics right now, but a lot of things change. Company p votes, life p votes, uh things change. And what you want to avoid is people leaving and still holding a lot of shares. If people are not active, you they shouldn't be having more than two percent, yeah, something like something like that, and that's why you have to make sure from day one to put uh vesting on on the shares.

SPEAKER_06That's one thing. The other is if you bring in business angels and each one 10k, 50k, all these small tickets, and by the way, some of them will be able to bring in capital in kind in the future, some of them capital, some of them are capital in kind, so some of them can really make a difference for the company over the lifetime of the company, but quite fast, you have like five, ten names that are advisors or whatever angels over in the capital.

SPEAKER_06You really don't want to run after these guys for signatures, yeah. And really depends where you are in the states, it's easier with signatures and majority in Europe. Sometimes, quite often, you need signatures from everybody, um, and even from minor shareholders. So, the best advice I have here is pooling. All these people choose one that is trusted from with everybody else, and just do pooling voting.

SPEAKER_06If there is a conflict of interest topic, you can go back, but for the vast majority of signatures, that person can sign for everybody. So, pooling is definitely uh um a recommendation that I would say um to to to bear in mind. The other element, maybe uh to those that are coming out of universities uh when you negotiate uh IP transfer with universities, is no matter what you give them on.

SPEAKER_06So if if you the there are two ends, right? Either equity or royalties and a combination, right? So if this if you give equity only equity or a lot of equity, then royalties should be zero. If you give higher royalties, then equity should be zero. Don't do don't don't let them rob you on on both ends. And if you do give equity, that equity should be subject to dilution. So you would be surprised how many universities are asking, okay, we have 10%, and we will have 10% on after even after series D, we will still have 10%.

SPEAKER_06So this anti-dilution mechanism is a nightmare. So never agree to something uh like that.

Christian SoschnerNo, I couldn't agree more. I mean, I don't like TTOs having equity for for one reason. The I mean it's an academic background, and these institutions are set up to exist forever. And uh, in cases when the company doesn't work, it's no problem. But let's plan for success and not for failure. In terms of success, the person that I may have been good friends with uh at the time of the signature of the contract is definitely not the person who will sit there when I negotiate a series A.

Christian SoschnerAnd who knows, God knows who will be there. I mean, it's an academic environment. This might be someone who never did any investment before, and then you have to train this person into an investment thinking. And uh they can hold up everything, as I said. I mean, they can destroy a series A round and say, okay, we don't accept that. Uh royalty is usually much easier to handle from the terms when it comes to investment, other things. But uh, my opinion is still cap table is for people who can bring money to the table, period.

SPEAKER_06So I with your permission, I will adopt it.

Christian SoschnerYeah, yeah, sure. Sure, feel free. And then you also mentioned this. Uh, there is this nice song currently in in on Spotify, at least. I don't know if it's in the charts, but one line is uh it goes like uh it's it's funny, like people pick uh people start as strangers, then become friends, and friends become lovers and strangers again. And they always think about investing. I mean, you start with people, you come out of university, you're best friends, then you meet investors, and it's sort of kind of falling in love.

Christian SoschnerAnd at one point in time, this tips, so it's just life, and what was a love affair must not last in an eternal relationship. It can also break up. And when you have then this uh you call it a zoo of investors on the cap table with 60% of investors really hating the team, it might be tricky to get new investor support.

SPEAKER_06Yeah, and and you know, I've had I've had cases that the main challenge was just to get an agreement between the investors. So three VCs, each one had like 10% of the company, so it would there was no clear leader, and you know, we all like to think that we're very smart. So you have smart three VCs, each one is at the beginning, uh, did this investment from the beginning of the fund, the last one did it from the uh uh last investment of the fund.

SPEAKER_06Five years down the road, they have different interests, and maybe even one of the found the investors that have done the investment, she's no longer there, so there is someone else. It doesn't mean that just because it's three VCs in interests are aligned, but if you don't have a clear lead and someone that holds enough, and then it's not enough equity. So even if you put all the hard work, you're not being compensated. It just leads to endless amount of the there, then there is a negative correlation, right?

SPEAKER_06So it's minus one on the correlation between the amount of discussion and the amount of value creation, yeah.

Christian SoschnerSo and this founder should should uh should look after keeping that in check so that they increase the stakes of future rounds.

SPEAKER_06The amount of time that I've seen investors and and founders fighting over a zero is is just enormous. Yeah, that's whereas if you agree fast, there is a chance to make something on the from this zero, but if you don't, it's continue fighting, it's a zero.

Christian SoschnerAnd it's uh it takes time from value creation. All this fighting, all these discussions, it's not time used for moving the company forward, it's just politics. Uh yeah, yeah. I had just had uh I had to check the time. Uh we have six minutes left because you said you have a 2:30 your next meeting, and we are on Central European time. It's really great talking to you. Uh, let me ask you a few final questions about the future of your fund. Uh, what role do you see Extancia Capital play in Europe's climate tech landscape in the coming years?

SPEAKER_06Well, I hope that uh one of our, you know, we're investing in a portfolio of companies and in each and each of uh of those companies, uh, you know, we say that uh instead of just being a unicorn, we want them to abate a gigaton. Um, so these are as it was coined, like gigacorns. So we would love to have that one of our companies at the end of the day, that we can come in 30 years' time and say, you see that technology? You see these lithium ion batteries?

SPEAKER_06That was the company that we uh we backed and helped scale these types of solutions, that one day this will be a household, the technology will be a household technology as much as we're talking today about fuel cells, PV, or lithium ion batteries.

Christian SoschnerThat's a great question. Let me build on that with the final question. Uh, if Extancia Capital's work is successful, and after 20 years you look back and you say your work is done, um, how would the world look like? What changes and advancement would you see in your fight against climate change?

SPEAKER_06I think is every time we tried as humanity um to make a prediction on how the future is gonna look like, we fail. We beat it.

Christian SoschnerBut it's but it's fun, but it's fun.

SPEAKER_06I I think the future is gonna be different in things that we cannot even imagine. Um take uh mobile phones. Yeah, there is this famous uh adoption rate. Uh, I don't know if it was a McKinsey uh um uh report that adopted it's gonna take 20 years before some people are gonna have penetration of one. And then within a decade, the penetration was two per person. So um I I think that in many cases we will see uh major, major differences.

SPEAKER_06For example, I think that at the end of the day, energy is gonna be ubiquitous, it's gonna be free. Um, we will find solutions to that countries that are today very dominant on power because it's oil and gas or minerals. I mean, it's not uh the the geopolitics are just shifting now between one topic to another topic. Um, but eventually I think that we will be energy independent, and that's uh gonna be um a game changer on the geopolitical uh level.

SPEAKER_06I think all many of the wars we see today are because of energy, boils down to energy. And my wish is that we will see much more peace in the future thanks to Ubiquities uh and cheap energy.

Christian SoschnerI couldn't agree more. That's a great vision to end uh this recording with driving down the energy cost to zero, making it available to everybody, uh, the green version of energy so that we save our planet. That's a very great vision. Amen. Yeah, yeah. Thank you very much for this for this great conversation. I love your vision. Uh, all the best to you and your team. Keep doing your important work and drive down the energy cost and create a peaceful world for our kids.

SPEAKER_06Thank you, Christian. It's been a pleasure.

Christian SoschnerHave a great day. Bye. Bye bye. In today's episode, we have delved deep into the future of sustainable investing with Yaia Rem, exploring everything from the potential to abate a gigaton of carbon emissions to the intricacies of cap tables. We have navigated through critical conversations that could redefine your investment strategy and your company's approach to sustainability.

Christian SoschnerIf you found value in this episode, please take a moment to like, comment, and share. Your engagement is the fuel that helps me grow the show and attract more high caliber speakers to deliver game-changing insights straight to you. Remember, the future is not just something that happens, it's something we create.

Christian SoschnerSo let's create a sustainable, profitable future together. Thank you for tuning in, and we will see you in the next episode.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Spark 20: Alex Dang | Everyone Agrees? Think Again. How Venture Capitalists Decide

    Nov 1, 202629 minAudio

    Invest in the wrong startup and you lose one times your money. Miss the next Google and you lose ten thousand times. Most boards are built to avoid the first mistake. Venture capitalists play by different rules. They...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. EP 185: Ivy Nguyen | IQ, EQ and the Execution Quotient Investors Fund

    Oct 18, 20261 hr 4 minAudio

    The trait a Silicon Valley AI investor rewards most in a management team has a name almost nobody uses: XQ. IQ brings the idea and EQ reads the people across the table. The execution quotient shows in something as small...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. EP 184: Ivy Nguyen | 10,000 AI Pitches and the One Test That Matters

    Oct 15, 202659 minAudio

    In 2017 another investor told Ivy Nguyen that artificial intelligence was too small a niche to dedicate a fund to. More than ten thousand AI pitches later, every pitch deck says AI. Single funding rounds have grown...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. EP 183: Marie Schroeder | Send the Rough Deck, Not the Perfect One

    Sep 27, 20262 hr 5 minAudio

    A seed investor at Novo Holdings would rather read your rough idea than your finished pitch deck. Most founders spend a year building the deck, forming the team and waiting until the story holds together. By the time it...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. #182 - How to Lead When You Don't Know Where You Are Going: 4 Lessons from Ben Horowitz (Part 2 of 2)

    Sep 8, 202657 minAudio

    What does it mean when the most respected adviser in Silicon Valley tells you that you are the best chief executive he works with, while your company is heading straight into a wall? Bill Campbell said exactly that to...

    Credit the people on this episode