Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Join us as Joe McClane shares his extraordinary journey from the Church of Christ to becoming a renowned figure in Catholic broadcasting. Joe's conversion story is one of profound transformation, marked by a personal struggle with addiction and a marriage on the brink. Hear how embracing Catholicism at his wife's request not only salvaged his relationship but also led him to a path of spiritual redemption and purpose. Expect a deep dive into the complexities of faith as Joe recounts pivotal moments of personal growth and the influences that guided his journey. His exploration of early Christian writings reveals the foundational truths that solidified his Catholic beliefs while offering profound insights into the interplay between personal history and spiritual awakening. We also touch on the broader challenges within the Catholic Church, navigating through controversies, theological discussions, and societal issues, all while highlighting Joe's work with Catholic organizations and his commitment to helping others. The episode captures a wide spectrum of topics, from humorous anecdotes about teaching driving to women to serious discussions on the future of the Church. We review societal tensions and global issues, debate the future dynamics of the papal conclave, and suggest potential candidates for the next pontificate. Joe McClain's appearance is a testament to resilience and faith, offering a narrative that is as engaging as it is enlightening while inviting listeners to reflect on their spiritual journeys. Support the show Get 10% off an amazing Black Monk Rosary by going to https://www.blackmonkrosaries.com/?ref=AVOIDINGBABYLON and using code AVOIDINGBABYLON at checkout! Check out our sponsor, Nic Nac, at www.nicnac.com and use code "AB25%" for 25% off of your first order! Please subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKsxnv80ByFV4OGvt_kImjQ?sub_confirmation=1 https://www.avoidingbabylon.com Merchandise: https://avoiding-babylon-shop.fourthwall.com Locals Community: https://avoidingbabylon.locals.com Full Premium/Locals Shows on Audio Podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1987412/subscribe RSS Feed for Podcast Apps: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1987412.rss
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 1Sancte, sancte, amare morti necradas nos In tes peraverunt.
Speaker 2You need to stay inside the road markings. Keep going, keep going, keep going. You need to stay inside the road markings, Keep going keep going, keep going, keep going.
Speaker 1Oh, what's?
Speaker 2wrong. You're doing it again. Look, see the marking. Yeah, why are you going over there? I want to move to the middle. Well then, you need to check your mirrors and signal, otherwise you're going to crash into another car and they have no idea that you're going to change lane. We're very close to that line still, so just try and keep the lane. Remember beyonce to the left. Careful, you're about to crash again I'm trying to go this way well then go that way feel it though yeah, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop, stop.
Speaker 2Why aren't you stopping? The policeman was shaking his head. What do you mean? You were going into them. Why, why?
Speaker 4Could you imagine being a freaking driving instructor and having to deal with teaching women how to drive? Unbelievable oh boy. All right, welcome back everybody. It's been a while since we did a women driving segment at the beginning of the show. So last week or the week before, we saw Joe McClain in our comments and I said hey, joe, would you like to come on and hang with us? I have been paying attention to Joe for years now. I used to watch his archery videos and whole bunch of different stuff he was doing and I was trying to remember where I first started watching it.
Speaker 4Joe, did you work for Catholic answers?
Speaker 6No, I didn't. I did write with Matt Fradd. I was the first chapter of the book called Delivered the Catholic Answers, published way back in the day. But I worked. The first Catholic apostolate I worked for full time was an apostolate out of Texas called Fullness to Truth, catholic Evangelization Ministries. Then I spent a decade after that. I worked a decade for the Guadalupe Radio Network and now I work for the Station Across Catholic Media Network out of Buffalo.
Speaker 4Decade for the guadalupe radio network and now work for the station across catholic media network out of buffalo. Yeah, so you do like a real professional morning radio show and you started putting it on youtube now. Like I, so I spend a lot of time in my truck and I'm driving around a lot, so I do catch your show quite often. You guys do a very, very good job over there. It's very uh, professionals. Nothing like this outfit that we're running that, that's funny. Are you a convert or are you a cradle?
Speaker 6I am. No, I was raised Church of Christ, but I was a pagan heathen for the most part. When I asked my wife to marry me, she said I had to become Catholic and I knew that that wouldn't go over well in my family, but it didn't matter because I was not practicing any Christianity anyway. I was also a third degree master mason at the time. So I went to RCIA and became Catholic in 1999, got married in 2000,. September 30th of the year 2000 in Manchester, new Hampshire.
Speaker 6Two years later, my wife asked for a divorce, which led to actually it led to a mystical encounter with Jesus that not only saved my marriage, made it possible for us to have children praise be to God but put me on a wild rollercoaster ride. So I wouldn't be here today if it wasn't for that experience. It was pretty amazing.
Speaker 4So wait a minute, I have to dig into that a tiny bit. But wait, tex Cathedra's in here and he is a, uh, church of christ convert too, and I have to be honest, I'm not a fan of church of christ converse. We need to be infiltrators.
Speaker 6We haven't taught you the secret handshake yet, man um, so wait a minute.
Speaker 4So you, you're married two years and your wife asked for a divorce. Yeah, and that actually winds up saving your marriage. Because you so was your initial rcia thing just going through the motions just to become a hundred percent?
Speaker 6yeah, she said she said I'd become catholic, and I said, okay, fine, sure, whatever. I mean, I actually think about it at first. When she because it's a whole, I don't know how much, how much of your life I should waste on the details of this story but we were actually. Actually I had a I decided to go and do something crazy to ask her to marry me, cause I wanted to hedge my bet that she would say yes. So there's a in Manchester, new Hampshire, there's a place called Rock Remen and it's this giant hundred foot face cliff, but the backside, you can climb up the backside of it and teenagers go out there to smoke weed, it's really the deal.
Speaker 6And side of it, and teenagers go out there to smoke weed, it's really the deal. And, uh, and you can over, you can you look and look over the entire city of manchester. So it's a. It was a cool place and so I carried a oak dining room table up there and um, and I has set out a like a red tablecloth with bone, white china plates and red candelabra and and I take notes I, uh, well, I blindfolded my uh, my then girlfriend at the time and I took her up to the top of this of this rock rem in this mountain, just as the sun was setting over the city.
Speaker 6So it was beautiful skies, it was reds and oranges and purples and all that. And all the stoner kids are like dude, what is going on? I actually killed myself. I mean mean literally. I got the scars, blood, sweat and tears to pay for the ring. I paid cash. It was $3,000. It was three quarters of a carat of a diamond and I was so proud of the fact that I was able to buy this ring. I was making peanuts this time. And so I'm there, she's there blindfolded. She doesn't know what's going on. I tell her to take off the blindfold and I'm on my knees with this red leather Actually it was white leather ring box and this was 1998, and it had a light inside the ring box, inside the lid.
Speaker 6So the light made the diamond look even bigger than what it was. I thought she's never going to know. It's only three quarters of a carat until afterward, married probably. So I'm there, I open the thing up and I say, hey, will you marry me? And she looks over me because I'm on my knees and she sees the table with the lobster on it Red lobster bone, white plates, red tablecloth, and she's Portuguese, her family's from the Azores, she's first generation American and she says, ooh, lobster, I don't know what.
Speaker 6Like excuse me. I'm like no, will you marry me? She's like, oh, yes, of course. So we're sitting down and she's like sitting there. I don't know if you've ever hung out with Portuguese people from the Azores, but what they do to shellfish is probably not right. Okay, they do like just sucking things. I'm from texas. Okay, if I want lobster, it's deshelled in garlic butter, all right, I don't know what you're doing, but this, this is, this is weird, like I should have asked that question first. But anyway, she's, you know, sucking things out of the, the skull of this.
Speaker 6You know, mud bug from the ocean and uh. And she says, you know, you're gonna have to become catholic, right? And I was like wait, what? I'm sorry, excuse me, we didn't discuss this. We didn't discuss anything. How long had you been dating? I met her in 97. I got off the train in Garden Station Boston April 1st 1997. I moved with my dad.
Speaker 6I was trying to get into the radio business. I had gone to radio school in Oklahoma, so I sold my car, bought a one-way train ticket to go up to uh, to the, to new England, moved into my dad's place in New Hampshire, southern New Hampshire, and got a job at two radio stations in Southern New Hampshire and I met her through my work in radio actually at the time. What?
Speaker 4kind of radio were you doing Like? Were you like the? Weather the WBAB and doing like in between radio breaks and stuff up 10 spots to number five oh, my god, I wasn't doing that.
Speaker 6No, I worked at wnhq 92.1 in milford, new hampshire and I was the weekend jock there and then during the week I would cut spots, you know commercials, things like that. And then I got a gig doing the morning show, uh, on whob 106.3 in n At the time it was an alternative rock station, so a lot of like Nirvana stuff like that. And that's where I met her. I was working with her old college friend and so she started listening to the morning show and it led to us meeting and it was kind of a very mystical moment, the first time we ever met too.
Speaker 6I had a lot of these mystical moments in this journey. But long story short is she asked me to become Catholic and I thought about it for a minute and I said you know, my family is probably going to disown me if I become Catholic, because the Church of Christ doesn't really like the Catholic Church. But I said to myself and this is where I think was really the real mystical moments along my journey were like moments of clarity. You know how you you can lie to yourself all the time. Like you buy your own BS, like I. There was these moments where I wasn't buying my own BS anymore, like this was one of them.
Speaker 6Like I said to myself well, why do you care, seriously, why do you care, do you? You don't practice Christianity, you don't go to church, like you live like a pagan heathen. So all roads lead to heaven anyway, right. So why do you care? If that's what she asked, go for it. So that's kind of what I did. So I showed up to RCI class to punch the ticket. I was even kind of confrontational too, because I didn't want anybody to believe I was really bought and sold into it. I was just kind of going through the motions. So I played the whole curmudgeon card, trying to be a contrarian every time they.
Speaker 6You know we were at RCI class or whatever. So yeah, that was kind of my journey. In fact, fun story is the priest who married us. He was an old priest and he'd been around the block a time or two, so you know, he kind of knew what we were, we were cohabitating, he knew the deal, he wasn't dumb and the day of our marriage, september 30th, the year 2000, I'm wearing my kilt because of my Scottish heritage, I'm in the back, I'm in the sacristy with the priest and it's just him and I, and we're like almost ready to go out, like she's ready to walk down the aisle, we're close out, like she's ready to walk down the aisle, we're close, and he turns to me and he says, hey, would you like to go to confession?
Speaker 6And I'm like um, no, he goes in the name of the father and the son of the holy ghost, you know. And I was like um, um, um, I'd only been to confession one other time. That was to check the box, just to get you know, get my. So it was like he was trying to do one last opportunity to get me to the altar in a state of grace. I was addicted to pornography, we were cohabitating, I was a very selfish person and he knew that this wasn't going to be a good way to start a marriage.
Speaker 6So he was trying his best to get us to the altar, you know properly.
Speaker 4And uh boy, it was just like like a two by four across the face you know, I gotta, I gotta, I gotta, I gotta dig into this a tiny bit. So so you go through about two years of marriage and things get very dicey and your wife asks for a divorce. Are you comfortable sharing that mystical?
Speaker 6experience you had. Oh sure, I've done it a billion times. I just I never know how much to bore people with the details no what do you mean this?
Speaker 4is. This is better than listening to anthony, okay, so but I also think that people uh like it's good for us to hear conversion stories once in a while, like yeah, yeah, yeah so, um, I again, I was addicted to pornography, and when you're addicted to pornography, you know your brain, your brain doesn't work well.
Speaker 6In fact, I wrote a book on that. I I like I said I helped write, delivered with Matt Fred at Catholic answers. And then I wrote my own book on on, uh, overcoming pornography and the techniques I use and all of that, and I even wrote a whole chapter on the science of the brain what happens to the brain when you're addicted to porn. And so you don't see the world correctly. You really have a messed up vision of the people around you, the relationships, all these things. So I was in a bad way. And then I was also the place I was working, which was not a radio station at the time.
Speaker 6My environment was really bad, you know. My peer group was really bad, so I was just not. I wasn't bringing home love, honor, respect. My wife had caught me using porn a number of times and I was basically destroying her heart. And then, you know, not long after we bought our house, after we got married, her, basically her whole family showed up at my front door and needed a place to live. And then I got very bitter and angry and jaded and I began to severely disrespect my, my in-laws, my family and um.
Speaker 6Then the then, the day came where I got laid off and I didn't even bring home a paycheck and my wife was done. She was just done. Like you don't even bring home a paycheck, like what good are you? And uh, so she's like I'm done, I'm out of here, I want a divorce. You she wrote it out of the piece of paper. You take this, I take that. And then she was gone and um, I didn't like the piece you're missing. And actually I made a whole movie about this. I made a documentary film, released it in 2019 on the feast of saint mexico day, about the father wound.
Speaker 6So the piece here is I grew up with a father wound because my parents were divorced when I was six and my dad. I encountered pornography for the first time when I was like four, five years old with my father and I was chasing my dad's affirmation, my dad's affection. My whole life as a boy, as a teenager, growing up as a young man in the Marine Corps, I was constantly trying to get my father to approve of me, but it was a lot of competition because my dad was always with some new woman. You know, there was always another mom, another stepmom, another girlfriend, another something.
Speaker 6But so and I, when my wife asked for a divorce, it was the first weekend in April of 2002. And the reality was severe. I had actually become a man just like my dad, divorced and broken, and I didn't know what to do about that. So I, I remember I went and found the Bible, and I don't have it here, but I do still have it. I think it's stored somewhere, but it was no, actually it's on the shelf right over there.
Speaker 6I have the St Joseph's edition. I don't recommend that translation, by the way, but I had the St Joseph's edition of the Bible that they gave me in RCIA class and I took it off and I opened it to the very last place that it had been opened and that was back in RCIA class and that was Matthew, chapter five. We were going over the Beatitudes, and the night we went over the Beatitudes from Matthew, chapter five in RCIA. I had a mystical encounter that night too, when they got to. Blessed are the pure in spirit, for they shall see God.
Speaker 6Time stopped for me, like literally time stopped, and I had this sort of interior dialogue where I said to myself, wow, I'm addicted to porn, there's no way I'm going to see God. Like, that's impossible, like. And then I said to myself, I'm a slave to my addiction to pornography. And I said, maybe someday down the road, long time from now, I'll be free, because this is true and I know that where I am I'm a slave and hopefully someday I'll be free.
Speaker 6So I was having that kind of a conversation and time was like still. And that was very, extremely weird to me because again, I was the kind of guy who I believed my lies, I believed my BS, I believed my game. You know that I had been playing for so long and to have these moments of real clear conversation, even just with yourself, let alone, you know, with God, it would just, it seems so otherworldly to me. So that was the last time I had opened up the Bible back in our estate class. So I pulled it out first weekend in April 2002, I pull it open to the same and I start reading the Beatitudes, because I didn't really know what else to do, you know, and I get to Matthew, chapter five, and then I start reading blessed are the pure in spirit.
Speaker 6I found myself on my knees and the words came coming out of my mouth. I didn't intend to say them, but they just kind of came out Lord, I cannot do this, you have to do this. And then that was the moment that I had an interior locution. But I got to be honest, I didn't. It's not like I could see the Lord, but I could feel him better than I can feel, like my, my can of water here, like it was.
Speaker 6It was palpable. But he gave me three interior locutions. He exhorted me to purity, that I would be chaste and pure, and I had to go look that up in the dictionary. I didn't know what either of those words really meant. To be honest, I had been addicted to porn since I was a little boy. So for 20 years, 20 plus years, all I knew of the world was pornography and whatever. So I had to figure that out. Later I would be pure, I would be chaste. He also put on my heart that I would fix my marriage, that I had broke it, that I was going to fix it. In fact, he gave me this vision, this premonition.
Speaker 6However you want to word it, premonition, however you want to word it, he let me understand like intuitively. He let me understand the passion that I must go through to win my heart, to win my wife's heart back, that there would be a suffering that would be needed, but I was to take it. He made that clear to me that I was to take it like joining him on the cross, and boy, I can tell you that it was a real suffering afterwards. And then the third thing he really put on my heart was an insatiable hunger and a desire to get to know him. You know it's really kind of weird and odd to even talk about these sort of interior locution type of things, but like, so the God of the universe takes time out of his busy schedule to come talk to you, right, like, like you're that special, right buddy, but you know it's.
Speaker 6You don't like I didn't know anything about him. I went to Sunday school as a kid in the church of Christ. I went through RCIA class, so that pretty much makes me a theologian for crying out loud. But I didn't know this. I didn't know a single thing, not really, about who this person was. So I was like a madman to get to know him. And so I was like, every day I'd pick up my Bible and I would read. I wrote that I read that Bible cover to cover. I was like I would turn on the radio and this was in New Hampshire and there was no Catholic radio. All I had was Protestant radio.
Speaker 6So I'm like, I'm like turning it on to hear them preach the word and if they, if they, stopped to talk about the weather, let alone anything else, I would scream at the radio. Shut up, you preach. That's all I want to hear is the is the word of God and you know and again, I didn't know anything about anything, not really. So I remember like the first thing I did after that experience was I called my wife and I told her what happened. She immediately curses me out.
Speaker 6Now she's first gen Portuguese, American, so she knows how to curse, like like construction workers. Okay, so she. So she chewed me out. She read me out really good, but when she was done I said, hey, I'm going to go to church this Sunday, Will you go with me? She chewed me out again, but that Sunday she went to church with me. Praise be to God. And it really did. It really did save our marriage. I mean, it was hard, though. There was like years of pain and suffering that we had to go through as a couple. But the other part of that was it set me on a big journey towards the Catholic faith, even though I was already Catholic.
Speaker 6I went to mass because I'm going to go to church this Sunday was already Catholic. I went to mass because I'm going to go to church this Sunday. Where should I go? Well, I guess I'm Catholic, so I'm going to go to mass. And then I had a neighbor who was a fallen away Catholic. He abandoned the faith and became a Baptist and he was trying to get me to go to the Baptist church. And again, I didn't know anything about anything at the time, but I remember just saying to him you know, I've been to all the Protestant churches as a kid, I grew up, you know, and what I feel in the sanctuary, I know I will not feel at your church. So I said, listen, I don't believe in this Catholic thing, but I'm going to stay put until I know exactly where to go.
Speaker 6And so that set me on the journey to figure out where was the truth. And I felt like a guy who stood in the door of the church with his back to the tabernacle, looking out into the world, looking to try to find truth, and the whole time was over my shoulder and I just didn't know it at the time. And, um I I was challenged by, uh, by two people actually. The first was a man by the name of allister beg.
Speaker 4he's uh, I used to listen I posted something the other day because he's retiring. He's retiring, okay, oh good praise god he's retiring, stepping down, and I used to listen to him every day. I had a very similar story where I didn't know anything and I just start listening to protestant radio.
Speaker 6I'm listening to you know, whatever that radio station has hey, kenegraph and the bible answer man and rc sprawl and all of you I bought rc sprawl's book on romans and stuff.
Speaker 4sure I was listening to him. They preached an anti-Catholic sermon one day and I went, whoa, something's wrong here. And it led me to finding Scott Hahn's conversion story and that was a wrap.
Speaker 6The rest, as they say, is history. Yeah, I actually went to go see David Jeremiah. I loved him. Greg Laurie, all those dudes, all anti-Catholic dudes at that, but at any rate so Alistair Begg made me Catholic. I got to write that book someday. But I was listening to him preach one day and he was preaching this anti-Catholic sermon and he said, you know, he said it with his Scottish accent, of course, but he said, you know, it was Constantine who corrupted the body of Christ. It was Constantine who corrupted the church, brought in all these pagan ideas that became the Catholic church.
Speaker 6And a light bulb went off in my head and I'm like, oh, all I got to do is go backwards in time, Like surely, surely the you know, the Christians back in the day had something to say? Surely they wrote something, had left something behind that I can go find and read. That would, you know, give me some idea about how the earliest Christians thought of scripture or liturgy or mass or worship or anything. So that was the first idea was to figure out how to find the earliest possible writings.
Speaker 6And I made myself a deal because Alistair Begg, you know, really put this seed of doubt in my heart about authority. And so I stopped reading my Bible cover to cover. I was afraid, actually, I was afraid that what I read I didn't quite understand. By what authority do I say I understand what I'm reading here? It seems like a simple thing, but I had this real crisis in me. So I stopped reading that and I made myself a deal I'm going to go find out the earliest possible writings that are not. They have to be written after the Bible and before Constantine was even conceived in his mother's womb.
Speaker 6So that time period I said I'm going to go read that stuff, figure that part out and whatever that leads me to, that's what I'm going to go. I don't care if it's in Mecca and whatever that leads me to, that's what I'm going to go. I don't care if it's in Mecca, I don't care if it's in Salt Lake City, I'm going to go. That's where I'm going to go. So I just went on to. This was before Google, so it was WebCrawler. I went into WebCrawler and typed in early Christian writings and I found a website that said earlychristianwritingscom, which still exists today. It's a Protestant site and they have a chronological list of all these documents, which they think are chronological based on the average assumptions of their Protestant theologians.
Speaker 6So you know, but they're all there and I just said, okay, let's start at the beginning. And I started with the Didache. I never heard of the Didache before, so I started reading the Didache and you know it talks about the way of light, the way of darkness, the way of life, the way of death. Talks about things like baptism, for instance. Oh, I'm like, oh yeah, full immersion, baby, that's how they did it. Oh wait, I can have any amount of water, I don't. I don't have to be immersed as long as it's poured three times in the Trinitarian formula, and that sounds awfully Catholic, whatever.
Speaker 6And then they talked about like you have to go to confession before receiving communion on Sundays, what Like that's. We're okay, I'm gonna, let's, we're gonna move on to the next one, Ignatius of Antioch. You know, he's the first one to use the word Catholic to describe the church, and of course he talks about the flesh of christ. He mentions the blessed mother. I mean it just goes on. And on the shepherd of harmies, clement of rome, I mean I just read all this stuff, justin the martyr. And then you get to tritilian. You read the flesh of christ. It's a sledgehammer to protestantism. Well before protestantism was a thing and uh, and by the time I got through that I was very convinced that the early church was was definitely Protestant, very Catholic.
Speaker 6But while that was happening, I had another lady challenge me from our parish because she could see things were not great in our marriage and at church she could see we were on a journey. So she shows up and comes over to our house one day and she's trying to get to know us and she hands me a tape set cassette tapes. I'm old, so it was cassette tapes back in the day and it was a set by a man by the name of Dr Scott Hahn. I never heard of him before and it was calling all Bible Christians to be Catholic and vice versa, and I listened to it and it was my first exposure to Catholic apologetics.
Speaker 6It was the first time I heard any responses to all of the anti-Catholic stuff that you hear all the time and I was blown away by that. So of course I picked up his book and read Rome Sweet Home. And then in fact I have this book right here. I keep it handy all the time because I'm leading a Bible study off of it. It's arguably my favorite Scott Hahn book of all time, which is the Father who Keeps His Promises. I love it because it's the watered down version of his doctoral thesis, which I also have, which is this thick and way over my head. But this a knucklehead can understand this.
Speaker 6This is super sweet, super easy, and it gives you that 60,000 foot view of sacred scripture. So it all makes sense. And I read that and that exposed me to typology for the first time. And then first comes love. And then that exposed me to the family of god, so the sisters and brothers and the saints that go before us, the role of the blessed virgin mary and, of course, hail, holy queen, all those things. And my mind was blown. And I remember the day I gave my heart to the catholic church. Um, I had done a study of john, chapter six, in the original Greek.
Speaker 6Okay, because I have to be. You know, I couldn't trust my translation. So I simply looked up a tool, translated every word, and then I said to myself wow, my translation is pretty good. Actually, Maybe next time I'll just trust my translation. But anyway, I remember thinking to myself Jesus was being very literal here. You know, Greek word sarx, the Greek word trogon, hunk of dripping bloody meat, chewing, gnawing, tearing. You know it's like he's not being symbolic in any way.
Speaker 6And then, of course, they all leave him and abandon him over that particular teaching. And St Peter says where else are we to go? You alone have the words of life. So I was convinced I was done. But I still struggle with the Pope, I still struggle with the Blessed Virgin Mary and the role of the intercession of the saints. So, but I said, Lord, I believe, help my unbelief. You're going to have to help me with all this other stuff, but I'm on board, you know, help me go. And then it actually kicked off a war with my father which forced me to study my faith even harder, because you know, it was a, an apologetics war which lasted for many, many years.
Speaker 6So that's the, that's the nutshell version of my journey.
Speaker 4So OK, so now you're working for which radio station you work for now?
Speaker 6The Station of the Cross Catholic Media Network, based out of Buffalo, new York.
Speaker 4Now, how do they approach the way you're handling the current situation? Because I know I mean I don't think relevant radio lets their hosts step out too much.
Speaker 6I don't think like there's a lot of you know, I spent 10 years for the at the Guadalupe Radio Network, so I know exactly what the. You know, uh, what the industry is like. In fact, fact, for the longest time, I thought the pinnacle of my career success will be to work, you know, at EWTN. I love EWTN. I don't, I don't, I don't. I don't want to be too critical of EWTN. There's some great things I can still say about what they're doing today, but I can also tell you that I won't be working for EWTN at this point.
Speaker 6You that I won't be working for EWTN at this point. My goal's changed. But for me, I spent a decade. I started the Catholic Radio Station in my neck of the woods here in Houston, texas, back in 2013. And you have to play nice with everybody, right? So you have to be Mr Catholic Radio Guy for a city of 7 million people and I'm working seven days a week. I'm in parishes doing, you know, announcements at masses. I'm at events. I'm emceeing galas everywhere, all over the town, and you wear yourself then and you want to be everybody's best friend, so everybody will help you spread the word about your radio station so we can raise the money we need to operate, etc.
Speaker 6Etc. Etc. Well, while you're doing that, like like I can't, I I emceed, I can't tell you how many sister pantsuit galas I I emceed, you know, and the, and they're all like 90 years old and it was just and I'm just sitting here just wondering, like, what am I doing? Like man, at some points, you know, like if I have to hang out with one more permanent deacon with his centering prayer postulate, Like oh my heavens, like I can't.
Speaker 4I can't. When did it break for you? When, like when does that? When does that? Because man people don't realize. Summer of 2018 is the answer. Yeah, because people don't realize. Before McCarrick, it's like the Catholic speaking circuit is this tight knit community. It's like you see the same speakers going around and then a couple of people decided to step out of line and they kind of get pushed out. It's like, oh, we can't talk to this guy anymore. We can't talk to this guy anymore.
Speaker 6Our Catholic world is so clicky. It's just pathetic how clicky it is and I've never truly fit in any of those clicks, so I've always been on the outskirts. I started podcasting in 2006, 2005. I was creating Catholic podcasts back in the day and I've always just been on the periphery of all of these cliques because I never quite fit in. I didn't go to Steubenville, so I don't fit into that. I'm not a net guy. I didn't belong to the Catholic apostolate on the college campus or any of these things, so I never quite got along with anybody.
Speaker 6But for me what really changed it was summer of 2018. It was McCarrick. One thing I didn't share earlier was the bishop who confirmed me at Easter Vigil 1999, he was a bishop under cardinal law. He was the vicar general in the Archdiocese of Boston under cardinal law. He admitted in court his guilt that he was moving around homosexual priests to hide them and they were abusing more and more young men.
Speaker 6We want to talk about children. It's post-pubescent males by and large of the victims, so we're talking a homosexual problem here. And that bishop admitted his guilt in court and refused to resign. Even after that he's like I'm not going anywhere. I'm not going anywhere. He refused. So I didn't really know that when he like confirmed to me and it was like after the whole thing broke in 2001, I read into the newspaper and I'm like, what did I get myself into?
Speaker 6Yeah, you've got to be kidding me. And then, of course, uh, you will all remember 2004, the dallas accords, you know. Uh, cardinal mccarrick promised us him and Cardinal Gregory, who's the proletarian of DC today. He was sitting right next to McCarrick the two besties. He's in the chief predator inn, the chief predator inn, the wolf in the hen house saying hey guys, don't you worry, we're going to take care of the hens, don't you worry.
Speaker 6And it's because of Cardinal McCarrick that I got to go now to get certified with their safe environment thing, because Cardinal McCarrick set it up Exactly, which also helps to train people how to do crime. Let that sink in, let that sink in. But anyway. So I, you know, I sort of I wanted to believe that the Catholic church was going to clean its house and repent of its sins, make good, move on and, and this, this issue has been dealt with.
Speaker 6And then, of course, you start to hear more stories and you start to see things, and but you don't want to be like, listen, I can't rock the boat, man, I got it's career suicide. I represent an organization that has to play nice with bishops, you know, and I want to get along with all my friends around town, you know. So you just. But then Cardinal McCarrick and I said I can't do this anymore. I said I'm going to die, I'm going to go to, I'm going to go to my judge and I'm going to have to give an account for what I did with not only my microphone. But was I willing to stand up for truth?
Speaker 6Let the chips fall where they may, even if that meant I got, you know, excommunicated from from my job and from my community and my friends and all the rest. I'm like I have to give an account, I can't do this anymore. So that was the day that was like that. That was the time. That really changed for me and I just said I will no longer pretend as though there's not a massive, huge problem in Holy Mother Church that needs to be called out. So I just started doing that and there was a lot of things happening behind the scenes at my apostle at the time and I was rising in the ranks at the network and I started doing a morning show for them as well, and, and then I started to have conversations that were difficult and that upset some people, and so people were calling to complain, some people stopped donating, you know, and, and it became really touch and go.
Speaker 6But, to be honest with you, that's not what the deal breaker was, not really. The deal breaker was when I, when I started sharing about my love for the traditional latin mass and growing in in, uh, and I I didn't start that way, trust me, it was I had a real difficult time with the latin mass to begin with, but it grows on you and once it's got a hold of you, you, just you you start to appreciate more and more the intentionality of the liturgy, the sacredness of the liturgy, the sacrificial nature of the liturgy, and I decided that I wasn't going to avoid it simply because there were people in the room who didn't go to the traditional Latin mass right.
Speaker 6Like I'm not going to not talk about what I love just because you're in the room, like that doesn't make any sense to me. So that was getting me in trouble more and more. I tried to work those differences out, I tried to hang on, but ultimately I knew that if I continued to do what I did at that apostolate I would end up. I would end up ruining that apostolate, and that did not sit well with me, because there was many people on my team who weren't on the same page with me. Were they willing to take the same risks? I was no, no, they weren't.
Speaker 6And I didn't feel comfortable with that. So I resigned so that I could pursue my conscience and let them do whatever they were going to do. And then the Station of the Cross. We are well suited for each other. Station cross has been bold and courageous now for years. Praise be to God because they, they've seen the writing on the wall for a long time. Jim Wright, who, and his wife Joanne who founded it 25 years ago. You know they're, they're pull no punches crying out loud.
Speaker 6You know my scandals are in buffalo. They just sold the church to the muslims. They're gonna sell a seminary to the freemasons, you know. So it's like like they're enough is enough and that's where they're at. It was a perfect fit for me that in that way, so I was able to come on board and do the morning show for them.
Speaker 4And, uh, it's been growing ever since that's pretty awesome, yeah, like even the fact that you'll have a guy like anthony stein on. You know, stein's pretty. He's pretty bold in the things he comes out of anthony stein. He's me too. I talked to him but, like who else?
Speaker 6like I, I've had crazy conversations that I would never be able to have in a million years. Uh, you know, ed maza has been on the show. Um, you know, like anthony stein, I've had a ton of people that there'd be no way of having those same conversations anywhere else in Catholic radio. Not really there's I mean Virgin Most Powerful, but they don't own any radio stations, so they're content creators. They're not content distributors, whereas, like, we own a radio network of 20 stations across all of the Northeast. So you know, it's a different set of risks and and a different ball game.
Speaker 6But I've had so many great and crazy conversations that I I'm like I've even had them like be going. I don't even know how this is going to go if I'm still employed after this. I will give god praise and uh
Speaker 4and it always seems to work out, so I'm very, very grateful um, yeah, because, uh, I mean even this nonsense we're looking at right now. So now we'll get to the show topic, what we're going to do on Locals tonight, me and Nick. I put a couple of clips of Matt Fradd and Trent Horn In the show thing that we have, so we're going to go over those, because Trent is on his fundamentalist Catholic thing right now and I want to critique a little bit of what he said, and then we might get into the longshoreman thing a little bit.
Speaker 4Me and Rob are having a bit of a disagreement. This might be the next. They suspended.
Speaker 6You hear they suspended. Yeah, yeah, praise be to God.
Speaker 4Yeah, that's a. That's a. We might discuss that a little bit. That'll be over on Locals. But, rob, why don't we play the Tuco clip of him inventing these new sins that we all need to confess? Let's just take a look at this and see what fun we're having with this synod, because I honestly think we are going to end up. I'll be honest, I was actually surprised that they dropped that little statement about no female deacons, because usually what they've been doing since Tuco is in is nothing happens at the Synod, but they drop a document right before from the DDF and one right after.
Speaker 4So, like last time, we got well, no, the same sex blessings. One was closer to Christmas, but we got another one. It was just like the stuff that you thought they were going to do in the Synod, they just did in the document before the Synod. So the Synod had no you know?
Speaker 6Did you see the group Study Group 5's summation of their conversation about this?
Speaker 4No.
Speaker 6I read it on my show this morning. They're leaving the door wide open for female deacons. Of course they are. I read it on my show this morning.
Speaker 4They're leaving the door wide open for female deacons. Of course they are. Yeah, they come out and they make a statement saying no, francis, you know his heart on it, we're not, there's no room for it. We keep studying it, we're going to keep the door wide open.
Speaker 6Yes, exactly, and just light a candle, just pray about it. Just pray about it, it's going to be fine.
Speaker 4These sins that they're bringing up are actually like an affront to reason and like we gotta. Let's just listen to what they have to say, because it's so preposterous.
Speaker 1Cardinal Victor Manuel Fernandez, prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith. I ask forgiveness, feeling shame for all the times that in the church especially us pastors, who are entrusted with the task of confirming our brothers and sisters in the faith, have not been able to guard and propose the gospel as a living source of eternal newness, indoctrinating it and risking reducing it to a pile of dead stones to be thrown at others.
Speaker 1I beg forgiveness, feeling shame for all the times we have given doctrinal justification to inhuman treatment. I ask forgiveness, feeling shame for when we have not been credible witnesses of the fact that the truth is free, for when we have obstructed the various legitimate enculturations of the truth of Jesus Christ, who always travels the paths of history and life to be found by those who want to follow him with fidelity and joy.
Speaker 1I ask forgiveness, feeling shame for the actions and omissions that have been prevented and still make, that have prevented and still make difficult the recomposition in unity of the Christian faith and the authentic fraternity of all mankind.
Speaker 7Forgive us, lord, I think that's it.
Speaker 4I think that's it for his the idea that they're having this fake penitential service and instead of getting up and saying we ask forgiveness for allowing homosexuality to run rampant in our clergy, for allowing us to, we ask forgiveness for not passing on the faith to the next generation like the things they've actually done wrong, they make up this nonsense that has forgiveness for closing our parishes during COVID. Yeah like absolutely that they didn't ask forgiveness for taking the sacraments away during that freaking, all that big ordeal.
Speaker 8Crypto my man.
Speaker 4Ducat is the man.
Speaker 8I want to know what crypto does for work. I'm just like bro.
Speaker 4We may be having a meeting with him soon. But yeah, nick, what do you have at this one, because I haven't let you talk much this episode one, because I haven't let you talk much this episode.
Speaker 8Well, really, just what I was looking at is all of those statements. You know, the first one I can maybe give a little bit of a pass on, but the rest of them are just ambiguous. They don't make any sense. They can be interpreted in all kinds of ways, but they get worse and worse. So, whenever you see the buzzwords about human fraternity at the end and also the statement about you know, not being good about having good Christian unity, I assume what that's referring to is some type of ecumenical gesture on the Catholic Church not being one with other quote Christian denominations. But this again goes to show me that they have a fundamental lack of understanding of just basic Catholic ecclesiology.
Speaker 8Ecclesiology Pius XI is explicitly clear in Mortalianimos, his document against ecumenism, where he explicitly states that the prayer of our Lord in the Garden of Gethsemane Lord may they all be one is fulfilled in the Catholic Church and the unity of faith and the unity of charity is fulfilled in the Catholic Church. So there is, of course, a good desire that we should have for all people to come to the church, but it's the ecumenism of return. You've split from the church. You need to come back. It's not this unity of. We sinned against you, you sinned against us, and now the church is kind of split here, there and everywhere, and maybe one day we can kind of come together.
Speaker 8When you put that along with this human fraternity nonsense, which again it rings of Freemasonry there, it's very, very concerning. So I think what viewers need to do is say how are we supposed to look at this synod? And I always tell people look at it through the lens of politics, secular politics. These individuals know that it's not a bunch of traddy YouTubers that are really going to get their gumption rolling. It's going to be political leaders in Europe, political leaders in the United States, who are going to be wanting them to promote these messages.
Speaker 8We saw somewhere, we saw this post on Twitter, but I think it was like the Belgian president, something like that. It was one of the leaders of the Northern European nations who called out Pope Francis and said that he's wanting to have a private meeting with Pope Francis to apparently chastise him for Pope Francis's recent comments on abortion, saying that abortion is murder. And that's what I've said a long time. If the Catholic Church actually starts to really be public about her beliefs. Eventually you're going to have the UN that comes in and just slaps it down and say get back in your place.
Speaker 5Yeah, I mean, mean what we just saw, tuko, do I mean? That's just a marxist struggle session. You know, if you, if you look at mao or jim jones and the people temple, if you've ever listened to those tapes from jim jones, this is what they did in those, those meetings in the middle of the night. They would confess all their supposed socialist sins to each other. Yeah, yeah.
Speaker 6The other thing I like to say too is you know, I believe I, I, it's my firm opinion that pope francis and let's just put fernandez on the same ticket here, the the francis uh fernandez ticket, they write they like to ride the line of heterodoxy, orthodoxy as closely as they possibly can without crossing over it. I know there's a lot of people who disagree with that. They think they crossed over it, but my opinion is I don't think Pope Francis is dumb. I think he's a pretty smart guy and I think he's very astute politically, as you just said, nicholas, and I think he rides that line, knowing that, as the Supreme Pontiff, he can't cross that line.
Speaker 6He's got to get as close as he can, though, and just let people think he has, because he also knows that there's lots of people bishops, cardinals, priests and lay folk in the church that would happily take the ball from him and cross that line all day, every day. And hey, who am I to judge? Right? So it becomes this ambiguous, loosey-goosey thing, and when you make statements like turning doctrine into stones to hurl at people, well, there's a huge section of Holy Mother Church, the body of Christ, who are going to interpret that, you know, as.
Speaker 6Oh well, then all doctrine is then optional because we don't want to hurl any stones now and there won't be there just won't be this clarification and this, this uh, you know the language of ambiguity and vagueness. It's very fascinating because I'm going through saint hildegard's five beasts right now to prepare to I'm doing like a whole series on the antichrist on my youtube channel. So I'm doing the next installment's going to be on hildegard's Five Beasts and you get to the gray wolf. I mean the Black Pig era of her vision talks about leaders who corrupt right, and then the gray wolf live in the ambiguity.
Speaker 6The gray wolf era, which is the era right before the Antichrist, lives in the ambiguity. You know what does it really mean? Who knows, who knows, because that's part of the scandal to lead the world towards greater corruption. But it also says in that vision that this is going to be a time that's going to test like fire the faithful and a small remnant will come from it. And it's that remnant that is now prepared like Gideon's army that's been culled down to the only 300. That's the army that's going to face the Antichrist and the final tribulation and if you didn't prepare them through fire and persecution, they would never be ready for the real, for the real deal, for the game with the antichrist.
Speaker 6So I feel like we're probably on the precipice of that. I hate to say that, but I believe that's where we're at, because, you see, this strategy of ambiguity, just it's, it's an everyday occurrence at the vatican these days, and the gobbledygook language of you know just oh, my feelings are so surreal. I'm just like, oh, my heavens, man, put down the blunt, step back and take a breather.
Speaker 4It's. It's at a point where, well, the thing is, I think we've been so desensitized to Francis over the last 10 years that, like so when, when that first initial thing with mccarrick happens in 2018, I think we all had this apocalyptic imagery in our heads. We were all talking about the third secret of fatima that wasn't talked about and we were all going through this thinking we were on the precipice of something coming, and then we go through that 2020 ordeal and we're like, holy, and I think we've been desensitized the last four years specifically to kind of get lulled into this feeling of nothing ever happens.
Speaker 4But I really do think we're on like something's about to happen, and it's about to happen in the secular world and in the church at the same time. So I don't know if it's going to coincide with France's passing and secular society collapsing at the same time, but I do wonder, because we will be fooled, right? So whatever's going to come is not going to be so simple to know like, oh well, this is the way to go, like I really do think even the elect may be fooled.
Speaker 4So it's a tricky thing to make sure you don't fall for the wrong thing. Like you see, this whole, this whole dynamic between the Pope's planers versus the trads, and it's like the Pope's planers are just doing their best to stay loyal to the Pope, because that's what it's always been. You stay in communion with the bishops and the Pope. But when the things that are coming out of the Vatican are so insane right now, but when the things that are coming out of the Vatican are so insane right now, like, you have to understand people's reticence to accept that and just say wait a minute, there's something so completely off with this right now.
Speaker 4Francis does not care about theology, he cares about power. He uses ambiguity to move the pieces on the chessboard for his own purpose. He's not really an ideologue, but uses ideologues for his purposes. He's not really an ideologue, but uses ideal ideologues for his purposes. Well, what I worry the most about is that what he's done by elevating certain people is assure the chaos continues after he's gone, like I don't know how we get out of this mess with the fiasco he's caused in person.
Speaker 6That's interesting too, because last year I did a documentary film on the End Times and I went to Rome and I was traveling around Rome but I interviewed a bunch of people. One of the people I interviewed was Edward Penton, and he's done some fantastic reporting. Oh yeah, sure. You know it's one of the bright spots of EWTN. I say, you know, they're still doing some really great work. Edward Penton, I was asking him because he wrote a book on the potential candidates for the next pontificate. And I asked him. I said, say what do you think you've written that book? Do you want to revise your book? I mean, are any new? You got a lot of new Cardinals.
Speaker 6Now what are you thinking? And uh, he said he said something very interesting. He said you're going to be surprised, I think, in the next conclave. Yes, francis has stacked the deck, there's no question. He says, but a lot of these men do not have the stomach for the, for the chaos and for the drama that francis tucho and the rest they, that they have. Uh, they love the drama, right, they're drama queens, uh. But there's a lot of these men that they're picked and, yeah, they're more liberal or whatever, but they're not like, they're not, they're functionaries.
Speaker 6They're functionaries, they're not truly on board. So he says it's quite possible that you're going to get a guy who is in that category, but as soon as he becomes pope he's going to fall more towards the middle and he's going to want to calm things down and just have some peace again. And he says you might find a very interesting next pontificate. If that's the case, and certainly I would say, if you get like a Pisa Bala, I could totally see a decent pontificate out of Cardinal Pisa Bala, if that might be possible. If you get a Tagli, nope, sorry.
Speaker 6Tagli, I think, would be bad news for Holy Mother Church. So it all depends At the end of the day. I guess you know my opinion and a nickel get you just about nowhere. So I guess we're going to have to, like Nancy Pelosi says, pass it to find out what's in it. But you know, and I always come back to and this is the spoiler for my documentary film, so you don't have to bother watching it is live in a state of grace, pursue virtue, be obedient to your state in life, and it will not matter what comes out of the Vatican and it won't matter who sits in the White house, because you will be doing the thing that you're supposed to do.
Speaker 6And at the end of the day, I think catholics need to remember that we can't I mean, it's how it's not charitable to pretend as though everything the pope says is okay when you know very well, it's not. Yeah, like it's not charitable to spin everything into this most positive you know thing so that, so that less informed catholics will just buy it, hook, line and sinker and then they're misled. How is that charity?
Speaker 4that's not charity no, and also the news headlines that come out are are pitting it so that the average person watching isn't actually paying it like we are. We're church nerds like we pay attention to this stuff right, so like yeah we're like in the know, but your average person only sees the headlines that are coming out of the wall street journal or whatever. Yeah, exactly right. So they're all hearing oh, francis is allowing gay blessings now. They're all hearing this liberalization of of the church from the mainstream press, because that's what they're reporting on. But there is still a segment of people who are converted by hard truths, right, like those doctrinal stones he's talking about throwing.
Speaker 4There are so many people who came into the church specifically for those doctrinal stones, because those hard truths God uses as a two by four upside the side of our heads sometimes to wake us up from our sleep. And I mean I've talked about it before it was like the teaching on birth control is what convinced me that the church was what it claimed to be. It's like all these other denominations are falling left and right and the only one who kept its teaching on this. Because it's because when you really play out the ramifications of birth control, it leads to the collapse of society, which it absolutely did.
Speaker 4I mean it just feminism just completely destroyed the culture that we're in. It all comes down to that stupid bill. So these doctrinal stones they're talking about throwing are the very things that will actually lead that remnant eventually, although they'll procure that remnant.
Speaker 6I think when the heat gets turned up on Holy Mother Church, I think most are going to abandon the faith. I mean, how many Catholics are really going to want to die for the faith or even lose their job for the faith? I mean, it doesn't have to go to bloodshed before people are like. You know what I'm out Right now. There's a lot of people who are leaving just because they see the scandals in the church and they've had enough of it and they don't want the drama and, to be honest, they really want more of this world than they care to admit. All they really want is blue skies, sunshine, money in their back pocket and they want their kids to go to a great school, get great jobs, be in debt up to their eyeballs with mortgages and second car loans and have a beautiful spouse.
Speaker 6Good kids live in great neighborhoods. That's the extent of their dreams. And as long as that's true, I can tell you the apostasy won't take much to actually happen.
Speaker 8Yeah, no, you bring up a lot of good points. I think that, to touch upon a question that you posed on, how close does Pope Francis get to the line, it was something I addressed in a recent show that I did, where I said that I would agree with that statement 98% of the time I would say 98% of the time he does mess around with ambiguity and, as a great archbishop of the last century said, whose name will go unnamed you guys know who I'm talking about he said that the devil hides an ambiguity and it was perfect because the spirit of God, of course, is going to speak truth.
Speaker 8He's not going to be ambiguous. And so I think that Pope Francis dabbles in ambiguity because, politically speaking, that's a smart idea for a politician. But I also think that Pope Francis wants to leave some type of lasting legacy on the church documents that have been released a lot of times, which reflect ambiguity but have enough ambiguity to where we see large swaths of the liberal, quote-unquote church going ahead and performing, for instance, things like gave blessings. You see these things going on, they're going on unperturbed, nothing's being done about it, etc.
Speaker 8We see things like that. But then, also with this last statement, where Pope Francis has, I guess, tripled down, where he says that all religions lead to God and that the Holy Ghost in some form or fashion divinely inspires these religions which, by the way, those statements are not new to Pope Francis. You can find those statements in John Paul II. You can find those statements in Benedict. The internet was just not a thing back in the 80s, and so that's why, unless you were at a society chapel, you just didn't hear about those things. So we've seen these things come out, but they've pushed the line to the point where it becomes ludicrous to assume, as I said on my show, that Pope Francis is just so unexposed to Catholicism that he just doesn't happen to know that Christianity is the unique religion of God.
Speaker 8You know what I'm saying? He would have to either be A right just like, completely bewildered, or he knows what he's doing and he's pushing the line. So I think that what we are seeing is particularly in these last couple statements. Pope Francis knows that his time is going to be short. He's going to turn 88 in December and he's looking for a legacy that he has to live, and through people like Fernandez saying these statements about doctrinal stones, all that does is number one weaken doctrine in the face of the public.
Speaker 8Who's paying attention? Which is sad, by the way, because Vatican I is explicit that the role of the papacy is to safeguard the Catholic faith. They use the term pure to keep the Catholic faith pure and to give the gospel to the world, but then also it only applies to that leftist wing, that leftist cause. So what I think we're seeing is that, through Fernandez, we are going to see some type of legacy building. We're in the last stages of the pontificate.
Speaker 4We're seeing the legacy built at the moment yeah, I wonder how that's going to play out. Rob, pull up that catholic world report article I put in and it because it talks about the silliness of the lack of transparency at this synod. I'm trying to get it to come up on my phone and I can't get it to come up. Let's see if we could. Uh, yeah, can you put it up on screen? Let's see. Try to make it a little bigger for me, because I can't get it to come up on my stupid phone. All right, let's see. Um, all right. So now we run into a gag rule imposed on the synod participants by its managers in order to guarantee freedom of expression.
Speaker 4Like it's just so silly. They're not allowed to discuss what they're discussing. But this is supposed to be transparency. So participants at the synod uh spent two days before the start of its final session in the closed retreat with. That ended with a penitential liturgy. The synod office provided the participants with a list of seven sins. So we go from the seven deadly sins to these seven new sins for which forgiveness would be sought. It did not say who would be doing the forgiving. Put it bluntly as this, all this struck me as a rather odd way to launch a meeting.
Speaker 4Consider a couple of sins on that list Sin against peace, sin against creation, against indigenous populations, against migrants, sin against poverty Right off the bat. Let's go with this, because the whole thing with migration is I think it's one of the most diabolical things that Francis has done through his papacy this idea that we need to open our borders to cultures that are far into the Christian West. It is the very thing that is going to bring the chastisement upon Christian Europe.
Speaker 4So you open the gates and you encourage the leaders of these nations to do it, bring these people into the country, and they are going to be. You saw what is going on in France. So, joe, on your show this morning you talked about the church in France got smeared with theses like the things that they are doing to Christian Europe. The chastisement in Europe is going to be biblical because the faith is Europe. So the fact that they have turned their back completely on God and allowed the hordes of the non-believers in and to change their society like that, it's going to be similar to what God does with the Assyrians in Israel, where he allows the Assyrians to come in and just completely destroy Israel at that time.
Speaker 6Yeah, it is, and I would say it's already biblical. Over there there are some bright spots, though. I mean France. There seems to be a great movement towards some fidelity by some in the church. Praise, be to God. Of course, the one pilgrimage that happens every year is growing leaps and bounds. The people from all over the world are going to that. That's certainly good news, but it's more negative news than anything. Everybody thinks that Poland is really good, but Poland's not far behind Ireland, not really. I would say. Hungary is probably better off than Poland these days when it comes to the faith.
Speaker 6So you know, the reality is we're in a post-Christian era, and I say this a lot too. You know Fulton Sheen God love him. I'm a fan of Fulton Sheen, despite. You know fulton sheen, god love him. Um, I'm a fan of fulton sheen, despite. You know some of the things he said towards the end. Uh, he, he would talk about the era of the laity. I'm not. I'm not on board with the whole era of the laity. Sorry guys, we have a role, there's no question. We have a role. We have to play that role. We have to be obedient to that role. There's no question we got to step. But I do not believe for one second that if me and every other lay guy steps up, that we're going to truly impact the world in the way that it's meant to be impacted, because it's not our job, it's not our role, what it is, it belongs to the bishops, the pope, the cardinals, the bishops, and I believe that there is a number of bishops.
Speaker 6I've known Bishop Strickland since before he was bishop. In fact, the first time I ever met him, he was still Monsignor and I could see the deer in the headlight look in his eyes because he had just been told hey, you're going to be the bishop. And that experience literally changed the rest of his life, as we all know. But my point is I believe that there is a number of men who are what I call fence setters. You know they're not. They're in the gray zone, they're in the. They're living this life in the ambiguity. They're administrators, they're corporate CEOs, they're priests or branch managers and they are living this life because that's the way they were trained and they were told if you want a career, you go along to get along and you just do it, and so that's what they've been doing and, frankly, they were trained that and it still is this way today in seminaries you can get a good, solid orthodox dare I say, conservative or even traditional young man to go to the seminary and they're going to spit out a corporate machine of a priest.
Speaker 6And the problem is we have all these fence sitters and I believe that if we can fan the flame of a few of these bishops to get off that fence to make a decision, to be zealous instead of lukewarm instead of cold, but to be zealous for the faith to become the next Strickland, they don't have to be deep theologians, they don't have to be the greatest thinker in mind of their time or a preacher like Fulton Sheen was. They just need to be faithful. And what I've said now for years, because I've had a unique perspective, having been somebody who's you know been you know the most connected Catholic in a diocese before, and I've known all the rich folks before they don't take my calls anymore, but anyway, I said to this one guy who was, you know, multi, multi, multi millionaire, I mean probably hundreds of millions of dollars in his net wealth, I don't know, but he was a very rich man and I said to him, I said to him one night, I said you know how we're going to get the cardinal to change.
Speaker 6He goes how's that? I said you're going to tell him why? Why would I do that? I said, when I talk to him, who am I? I'm the knucklehead catholic radio guy. I'm a nobody. He's never going to listen to me. I did try once, by the way. I said but I said but you, you're the biggest donor in town, you, he will listen to. If you encourage him to be courageous, to get off that fence and to stand for something, he may just do it because you asked him to. And I believe that if we can motivate, if we ever, if we ever get chance, if the Holy Ghost ever gives us an opportunity to plant a seed of encouragement in the heart of a bishop, we should never fail to take that opportunity and we should encourage them get off the fence, because you might have a guy that you might criticize today, but tomorrow might be another Bishop Strickland that might proclaim truth, despite the fact that it might get them fired or worse.
Speaker 6And I think when we do that, if we can move more bishops off the fence, you will start to see change only when the bishops decide to convert every soul, not some souls. You know, the Jewish souls need conversion. The Muslims, the Hindus, the Buddhists, the atheists, all of the souls have to be converted in their diocese, not just some of them. And when they decide to do that, you will see, in fact, great change, my opinion thousand percent, thousand percent yeah, you saw.
Speaker 4You saw it go the other way too, with some bishops where, like shown born, we thought was a good guy back in the day yeah you thought he was a good guy. Then francis comes out and you saw the freaking, the pride flag fly with this guy. It was crazy. I like the. It was shocking to watch his transformation. You know, and it's. Yeah, I think that if real persecution comes, I think you'll see men that may seem like fence sitters. Now choose a side, you know, and that's kind of it's.
Speaker 4Look, we went to the Catholic identity conference last weekend I did and there was a Nigerian Bishop that spoke there. Last weekend I did, and, uh, there was a nigerian bishop that spoke there and one thing he talked about his whole talk was about, uh, um, persecution of nigerian catholics and he talked about how the muslims would come in and they would just murder people, blow up a church, people would be dying, and he ended by telling us but you want to know something? The mass attendance for nigerian catholics is 94, and the reason it's 94 is because they're being persecuted, and the reason it's 17 in the us is because we have it so freaking easy.
Speaker 4But if anything actually does, come where, even look, like you said, if you get, you may get a middle of the road pope next who doesn't have the courage to continue on the revolution, like that's been going on. But all of a sudden, if the world turns on them, you may see a uh, uh like a, uh, a saint thomas more moment. Or uh, uh like a. You may see a guy go from being milquetoast to saying no, um, you know, god forges us in that fire at times. So I would agree, yeah it's quite possible.
Speaker 6But you do live in interesting times. The good news is, it's quite possible. We do live in interesting times. The good news is it's not boring.
Speaker 4Praise be to god, yeah no, and also you have to really think of the perspective of the guys who started the traditional movement. These guys were having mass in the basement and there was 12 people there. Yeah, I went to that conference last week and there was 800 people there. We're talking about people that are flocking to the traditional mass because they're seeking out the traditional faith. They see they're not being taught the faith in their local parishes so they're seeking out somewhere to go. That's Orthodox. There is no era of the laity and there is no new springtime In regards to the laity.
Speaker 4Laity are primarily meant to live their faith through their family and secular channels, ie community and workplace. Yeah, that's absolutely true. That is. That is interesting that you um brought that up. The other thing is, um, I saw you put up an old clip, uh, uh, with uh, joshua charles recently and josh and I uh, josh. Josh a a good friend of mine. We talk regularly. But his whole thesis on the, on the as Christianity spreads, with the demons being held back by God during that period, and how they're being loosed on the earth right now, I mean I don't see how anybody could not see it that way.
Speaker 4The things that are popping up, the way things are playing out in society around us. Sure, you just see this loosening of spirits and people actually going to subconsciously worship in the way they did when these demons were actually worshiped, but they don't even realize that's what they're doing.
Speaker 6I mean, how much anecdotal evidence does one need to know? Things are really ramped. I mean, when I was a kid, I'm 50. So when I was a kid, grew up in the 80s, of course, born in the 70s, and you know homosexuality was a thing, and of course there were. You know, mtv had lots of guys wearing makeup with weird hair, yeah, but homosexuality was still a very, very minor part of society, incredibly minor. You know, fast forward only 30 years and the pride parades are off the hook and all of a sudden, everybody's gay.
Speaker 6You're gay, I'm gay, everybody's gay. You know, it's like it's transgender ideology. You know library time. I mean we're living in absolute bizarre times. And then, of course, talk to an exorcist. Ask any exorcist you want. Hey, listen, don't even go ask Father Ripperger, because he's too darn trad for you, right? Go ask some other exorcist. There's lots to go around that are just Novus Ordo exorcists. Ask them, they will all tell you that everything is like a hockey stick chart. It's just skyrocket all the way.
Speaker 6So I mean, we're on the brink of war all the time now. I mean, as a kid we were still doing the Cold War thing, so we would have, you know, nuclear drills in school. Like they're going to have to bring that back now because we're always on the brink of war. Iran, if Iran, you know, figures out how to break the Iron Dome over Israel, it's on boys. Russia's going to team up with China and Iran on one side and we're all going to be on the other side. And we know, once you get dressed up for a party, you got to dance. Nobody goes home until they dance and the war hawks won't be happy until the blood runs and their banks fill.
Speaker 6And they always get rich in war. And that's because we're always on this brink. And, of course, the next pandemic or all that it's like we live in such insane, crazy times Now. Look what happened post-hurricane Complete devastation, volunteers are being threatened to be arrested and supplies and money is being confiscated. And there's not enough money in FEMA's account because they gave it to the illegal immigrant crisis that we're also dealing with. Listen, I lived through in. There's not enough money in fema's account because they gave it to the illegal immigrant crisis that we're also dealing with. Listen, my, I live through harvey, my, my house, my neighborhood flooded.
Speaker 6I had a people from tennessee in their boat in my front yard to try to rescue us back in uh during harvey. So I I can appreciate what it's like to have volunteers come and they're threatening to arrest them like this is the bizarre world upside down world. Put a mask on by yourself in a car what?
Speaker 4We forget what we've been. We're all.
Speaker 6we all have TSTs If you can't come to the conclusion I'm not a prophet, I'm not the son of a prophet, I you know you don't have to be a prophet to come to a conclusion that says no, the water's boiling, some shoe is going to drop at some point. You know St Augustine. He was really in his book the City of God, which I got behind me over here. I think it's in the third book. I want to say it's around. I think even it makes a statement in the first chapter of that book where he talks about almost like a criticism, like, oh, you don't believe that's actually going to happen, that the world will come to an end, that the world will come to an end, that the Antichrist will show up and there'll be a persecution.
Speaker 6Well, stick around, you're going to find out the hard way then. Like my paraphrase of his words, but he was criticizing the Christians who were like, oh, it's never going to happen. You guys always say it's the end of the world, it never is going to happen. And Augustine's like it's going to happen and you need to be ready for when and when and if it does happen during your lifetime. So there's so many crazy things and for anybody to be like oh you're just, it's just the end of the world. Sky's falling stuff. I'm like, are you kidding me?
Speaker 7they're hoarding toilet paper, right now because of anthony's buddies, longshoremen who just obviously want to get a massive pay raise out of this deal I, I'm stirring a pot.
Speaker 4No, let's start. I saw the ex-tweets passing earlier today we're going to go over to locals and we're going to get into some stuff because I want to see Joe's opinion on how Trent is handling his new book on fundamentalism. Because it's a strange thing that this, you know, I like Trent because it's a. It's a strange thing that this, you know, I like trent. Trent's my friend. He does a lot of this weird fence sitting thing too and I dude, it's 1000 just being a spin doctor.
Speaker 8I know I'm gonna stir the pot right before we go to locals, but just to give people a little bit of an incentive. It's 1000 just being a spin doctor. Cnn is catholic answers.
Speaker 6Catholic answers I don't know.
Speaker 4Cnn has really cleaned up their act a lot I have to tell you guys a little little behind the scenes. Break down the fourth wall a little bit in the green room before the show. I go, joe, we're gonna talk like a little bit about trent and matt frat on the other side. I'm like you don't have to come.
Speaker 6He's like I don't care, let's go then nobody cares what I think it's fine, it's all good great.
Speaker 4So all right, guys. If not, here's the thing I will ask you guys. If you guys can't come to locals and support us, what I will ask is that you share the show. Like you can't imagine how much it helps when you share the show. You can't imagine how much it helps when you share the show on social media. So if you really can't afford to help us over on Locals, shoot this out on Twitter, shoot it out on Facebook, shoot it out on wherever your social media presence is, just getting people used to seeing our show and people tweeting it out and stuff that really does help and gets people to check us out and give us a chance for the first time. So we could really use the help. Hit like subscribe and, if you can.
Speaker 4It's five bucks a month. It's like it's a cup of coffee a month. It's $5 for a cup of coffee now at this point. So help us out. I'm not a longshoreman. I don't make that kind of money, but we do need all the help we can get. So, cryptoducket, thank you so much for all your help. I saw what was it. Andy Malone. Thank you so much for your super chat and we will see you guys on the other side. Take us out, rob. Okay, all right, we're on the other side.
Speaker 4So before we get into the trend stuff like okay, so the longshoreman thing, I'm obviously stirring the pot a little bit as I'm going oh no way really. But the thing is I really don't think people really like these guys don't make that much money. They're starting pay as a 20 bucks. They go up to 50. I think their base salary is around like 120 grand. They're living in port cities. The guys that you're seeing that are hitting that 200 grand. These are guys that are working 14 hour days.
Speaker 4I mean, I imagine their union is similar to the guys that I'm working with and the guys that had 200 grand are working night shifts nonstop. It's not crazy to ask, if you're living in New York or Boston to to make like we're supposed to want people to be able to support a family on a single income, how the hell they're supposed to do that.
Speaker 6Can I go down a rabbit hole real quick? That's related to that. Sure, you remember, remember, you guys might remember this this was probably, I don't know, six years, maybe ago seven, maybe I forget, but it was a while back when um mike voris, at church militant, was railing against all the catholic radio, catholic answers and listen. At the time I was the guy in the ewt and catholic radio world who defended church militants right to have a seat at the table. Yeah, I'm like, I don't like everything they do, but they're talking about stories we're not covering, so they're filling the gap.
Speaker 6Praise be to god, you should not worry about it. But when mike started coming out because he hated the fact that the establishment catholic media, which I belong to, um didn't approve of him, like him or welcome him in then he basically came out and he kind of got really nasty and one of the things he did that really upset me was he started outing everybody's salary dude. I remember this happening.
Speaker 4He he outed drew mariani for making like 90 grand a year and I'm like who the hell can eat a family? No, it was.
Speaker 6Tim Staples. That got me, though. He was like. Tim Staples makes over six figures a year and I'm like hold up, timeout I go. Tim Staples lives in San Diego, california. Do you have any idea what it costs to live in San Diego? Do you know what it costs to buy a house in San Diego? He's got six kids, okay. Do you know what it costs to buy a house in San Diego? He's got six kids Okay. If you're a layperson and you work in a 501c3 like I do, at what point is it okay and at what point is it not okay? Is my car? I drive a 20-year-old Tahoe.
Speaker 6Is that okay? Or does it need to be 21 years for your comfort? Do my kids need to live in poverty and never get a vacation just so that you feel better about yourself?
Speaker 4Michael Boris comes out and he's like I make $60,000. I was like Michael you're a homosexual who lives alone.
Speaker 6With no children Okay, cool.
Speaker 4And you live in Detroit. You literally live in the slums alone, dude Half the homes are for free anyway. Not just that. I guarantee his house was paid for by church militant.
Speaker 6He used it as a as an asset, like all of it, and then when you found out all the crap that came out afterward, well, he was paying for everything with my company expense well, you just triggered me because I'm thinking you know, listen, I don't fault the guy who hustles and works hard, and if you work at cnn that was one of my dreams once too is to go to to CNN, the majors right, go to the big leagues, and boy it's a slaughterhouse, though I mean like they're hustling, you got to hustle so hard 24, seven. You're cranking out books, you're cranking out talk sets.
Speaker 6You're going on the road. You have to earn your keep, and it's a sweatshop. So Tim has been there for a number of years now 20, probably 20 plus years. He's worked his tail off. You may not agree with everything he says, but I don't fault the guy for making whatever he makes Good on him. God bless him. He's earned it. And I would say the same with a longshoreman. Now, I would say this, though when you're a longshoreman and and because I used to be a logistics manager and I used to ship a bunch of stuff overseas and I had a strike happen at the port in California, up in the San Francisco Oakland area, and then I think it happened again, I don't know, anyway, so I'd been through this it's one thing to say hey, we demand a better working environment.
Speaker 6We demand livable wages, especially in places like New York. I don't know why anybody lives there. It's the worst taxes in the country. Shame on all of you who live in New York. You should all pack up and move, it's just terrible.
Speaker 1It's a beautiful state.
Speaker 6It's just totally wasted on high taxes and liberals. But anyway, you have to make a livable wage. You shouldn't be living in poverty. So there's one thing. But you can't hold the entire country hostage.
Speaker 4Yeah, no, I understand that. So listen, so everyone's making a big deal. They're like they offer them a 50% raise and it's like all right. So look, you have to understand what we've been through the past four years Wages have been stagnant and everything costs 30% more. So I made in 2019, 30% more than I make now, and everything costs 30% more now.
Speaker 5So it's like you really add all that in but should I hold a gun to my president's head to get a 50% pay increase?
Speaker 4No, but here's the thing.
Speaker 6The FBI might be listening. I don't think.
Speaker 4The thing is the thing is the president can put an end to it at any. So they ended the strike anyway, so like they did end it, so it's kind of pointless. But, the thing is, the president could have ended it at any time and put a moratorium, an 80 day moratorium, on it to get us through the holiday season and all that and let them go back to negotiation. Biden wouldn't do that because it would have been political suicide to go.
Speaker 6Reagan did it with the with the air control tower people. Reagan was a Republican.
Speaker 4Democrats are supposed to be, you know.
Speaker 8And the Dems are only leading unions, if you trust the cooked polls by eight points. As a comparison, biden carried him by 19 and Bill clinton carried him by 33, and so, no, it's not the same world it used to be. I don't know a single guy.
Speaker 4I work construction, that's what I do. I don't know a single guy and I'm talking even even guys that are immigrants, like like south american immigrants that are now here legally and they have their citizenship. They're like, I don't want these freaking immigrants coming in, like even those guys are voting trump. You know it's pretty crazy. So well, I, yeah. The whole idea is, it's not as much money as you think it is, and if it, if they are pulling that 200 000 number, I'm telling you these guys are slaves to their career, right, but they're not seeing their family they're getting well compensated for it but you should be well compensated if you're sacrificing.
Speaker 4That much is all I'm saying. It's like you guys don't know what it's like to wake up at 4 am, go to work, get home at 7 pm at night.
Speaker 6That's I used to do every day for me.
Speaker 8I literally'm out of bed before four every morning yeah, so you know I I know I know a degree about what it's like, but my only real overall thoughts about it. I'm really sympathetic to the strike just because I've worked really, really hard blue-collar jobs before and you get very, very little. And, as they said, the world does depend upon the blue-collar worker and upon unions. And I'll leave the conversation at this because we could keep going on about it. Said, like, the world does depend upon the blue collar worker and upon unions what? And? And I'll leave the conversation at this because you know we could keep going on about it. But I think in the future we as a society are going to have to have a conversation about realistically, if the united states is to keep up economically with, say, china or other countries, eventually realistically it's going to have to go to some type of robotic automation and something to that form.
Speaker 4Well, I think that's the biggest gripe, right? They're saying automation is coming. Look, they're in a field that's going to be automated, so how?
Speaker 8do you move? It's the question of how can we have a soft landing. Move past this, because I really am for the worker, because when you look especially a lot of these union guys, they've been doing this their whole life. Their dads did this their whole life, their grandfathers did this. It's a generational thing, and so you can't treat them like well, it can't be like China, where it's just like, oh well, let's just go get another job, that's how I feel about it. And stuff like that. And so I'm like, okay, yeah, we'll have to point that needs to be addressed.
Speaker 8But we can talk about now some yeah, let's get all right. So, Rob, let's play the.
Speaker 4Let's skip the first clip I put in. Let's go. Young Earth Creation You're Not on the Team. Let's go with that one. It's a short clip.
Speaker 8Why is Trent Horn being so gay? I'm sorry, I'm just, I'm so.
Speaker 6You haven't even seen the clip yet. What are you talking about? I already know I already know.
Speaker 7Humanism and radical fascism look very similar as authoritarian movements. As I said, the horseshoe is critiqued. But just for this illustration and I see that a lot that the Catholic progressives and the Catholic fundamentalists is like a horseshoe, like NFP and contraception. So the far left in the church will say NFP and contraception are the same thing. So we should treat contraception like NFP and say it's not bad. So the forbidden becomes permissible. But on the far right they'll say contraception and NFP are the same thing. So we should treat NFP like contraception. So the permissible becomes forbidden.
Speaker 7And so it creates scrupulosity, it creates burdens people weren't meant to carry and it leads to burnout. And you're thinking this would. This is what I have to do to be catholic. I don't want to be catholic anymore. Or saying like to be a good catholic, you have to reject the theory of evolution like it's permissible. You, you, you don't have to believe in theory, you don't have to believe the earth is round to be catholic. I think it really helps. But then it becomes it's obligatory, like if you want to be a real good catholic, you're, you're. You're not on the but, yeah, this, this, these obligatory standards the church doesn't impose.
Speaker 7You're not on the team if you don't pray your daily rosary? Yeah, yeah. Who says what is that up?
Speaker 6just shut up we just want to create unnecessary barriers we don't want to listen.
Speaker 7Virgin mary might have had something to say about that.
Speaker 8I'm sorry, I'm I'm not trying to be like, trying to keep my language together, I'm not trying to be mean, I like to be nice. You guys know this. But trent is just getting on my nerves more and more. He's getting more and more and I'm just going to let this all out and then I'm going to leave it to you three to have a more civil conversation. But this is just ridiculous on so many multiple levels. First off, he's doing the whole centrist thing where he's trying to pretend that the Catholic Answers world and the JP2 world and the Benedict Ratzingerian world, they're just the normie, the normal conservative, centrist world, and it's just the weird fundamentalists that are off in the corner.
Speaker 8Aside from just like, making up names for like normal Catholics who just want to pray and like live a normal life and don't want to be gaslit 24, seven by an establishment media which are nothing more than spin doctors is just disingenuous to me. But then if you're going to say you're not on the team for not praying the rosary, okay, our Lady of Fatima requests it. You don't have to be a devotee of Fatima, right? No one forces you to believe that, but you do have to believe it's legitimate in the sense that the church has approved it.
Speaker 8It would be at least the mortal sin of temerity just to toss it so, just to get on your high horse and take a shot at. I guess making a Taylor Marshall reference there is just disingenuous. I don't know what Trent's whole issue is. I mean he essentially, in the very first video where he discussed this whole subject, he basically threw St Alphonsus Liguori and the entire moral tradition completely under the bus to defend a Catholic e-girl, because he knows that the white knighting thing is a little bit more interesting to, uh, normie catholics than you know, citing charles boulart's theory about the four delectations of physical touch.
Speaker 8And so it's just, I'm just, they're just spin doctors. You got you guys. So okay, so you're being vague.
Speaker 6Nicholas, I wish you'd really come out with what you're feeling inside and just maybe we should light a candle and just have a moment here.
Speaker 4Let me ask you this when do you stand on on young earth creation, evolution right off the bat? This is so fun.
Speaker 6I did an entire. I had a semester in college, I was a. It was actually like a flash course. I was that, got a tech degree and I had to do. I had to build a program with flash before Adobe bought it, and I decided to make my project on young earth creationism. So I built a, an interface where you would be taught. Uh, young earth creationism is Protestant stuff, cause I only had Protestant resources at the time. This was well before Hugh Hugh Owen started anything with the colby center. But uh, you know.
Speaker 6So I I have some experience with young earth creation theories and I think they're very, very credible. In fact, I think it's disingenuous to fluff them off and ignore them. I think it's just disingenuous. It lacks. It lacks sincerity. Just to go to oh, that last sounds stupid. The earth can only be 10 000000 years old at max. Like that's dumb. Like well, there's so many questions that can't be explained otherwise. You know that I think it's disingenuous, so I think that's part of my issue with a lot of Catholics, whether it's Trent Horn or others.
Speaker 6But you got to think, though, as well. I guess I have a unique perspective, in the sense that trent works for catholic answers and, as nicholas says, catholic answers. Seen it? Uh well, catholic answers is under the boot of cardinal mcelroy. Yeah, it's based out of san diego and they haven't moved. I wish they would. I think I it's part of the reason why trent is back in texas. Uh, because they did relax after they had a sea change with leadership there. They were able to relax that a little bit, but they didn't move their headquarters.
Speaker 6So they're constantly under the thumb and the shadow of Cardinal McElroy and they still want great relationships with every bishop everywhere. Right, they want to stay in their good favor. So they're never, even if they believe it personally, they're never going to rock that boat too far. And I believe you could talk about things like the traditional mass, or you can talk about issues with the synodality or Pope Francis or Tuchel or any of those things. They're going to talk about it to some degree, but they're never going to go too far down those roads. And I believe this is one of those, because it seems fanciful to most minds.
Speaker 6Because why? Why we've been indoctrinated through public education and, dare I say, even catholic private education, that that the theory of evolution is is legit. Right, because it was a priest who came up with the big bang theory. So we gotta go man.
Speaker 4It's so annoying how they present it like that because, as a catholic, you're being taught no. No, we believe in evolution. No, we don't necessarily believe in evolution. We can.
Speaker 5I have no problem believing that a species can adapt to its environment yeah use the example a hundred times when they brought yeah, you italians adapted and learned english, kind of exactly right when they brought european hogs over.
Speaker 4They developed tusks over the over a century or two like Something like that can happen, but you're not going to see that hog turn into something else let's talk about philosophy.
Speaker 6I'm not a philosopher, but I at least know this much. The whatness of a thing never changes, right? Never. So if a dinosaur grew feathers and is now a chicken, then a chicken is still a dinosaur. Yeah, Its whatness doesn't change, even if some of its features adapted to their environments. And you know, I hunt. I like to kill and eat deer. I like to feed deer to my family Deer. How big a deer is or how small a deer is is simply a factor of food.
Speaker 6Mm-hmm. You go to Kansas where they eat a lot of corn and ag fields, they're going to be giant. If you go to the East Pine Woods of East Texas, they're scrawny little things because their food sources are just not as good. So things change over time and frankly, it doesn't even take that much time. I watched that great documentary film a few years back called castaway. I don't know if you saw that film. Uh, I said documentary was a joke, but um yeah, it was a bit with wilson the soccer ball. yeah, but like, like, even, like, look, even look how they demonstrated how you know he, he, his character changed from the first time he's on the island to probably a year later or whatever it was, and then you know he's a completely different, you know looking man throwing a spear in the water.
Speaker 6He's, he's, he's, he's lean. He's got no fat on him anymore because his food sources change. His hair has grown out Like he just looks completely and his skin is now tan, right Like. If I'm out in the sun for more than a half a second, I turn red. But I guarantee that if I had to be out in the sun for years on end, my skin would adapt and it would look like. It would look more like you good looking guy who can sometimes speak english. You know that's what we're talking about and it just seems disingenuous to fluff the whole thing off well, the thing with evolution, especially for me, is I look at the damage it has caused.
Speaker 4It has. It is every single atheist regime forces people to believe it. The whole idea is to undermine the Christian creation story, right? So it's oh, that stuff in Genesis is just, you know, that's just what is Barron called. He's like oh, this is just fancy literature or some form of literature or something. It's like you. If you start thinking like that, you start saying, okay, now the Bible isn't history and the thing is it doesn't have to be a scientific account, but it is an historical account. So you do have to believe the historical account in Genesis.
Speaker 4You do have to believe that there was a major, freaking flood that happened and that a world ended in that flood and something else comes out of it after that flood. So the whole evolution thing, kind of it. It started with me reading e michael jones's logos rising and then it became rob and I just going on this quest of interviewing pam act, pamela acker and uh, uh, what's his name? From the colby center and like it. Just, it made me just realize what a fraud evolution is, because if you watch any evolution documentary, any documentary about the, about the earth and it's you know, and it's evolution.
Speaker 4It is such fantasy, it is such nonsense. Oh, it started off as molten lava, and then water appears, and then what I love is the changing time scale.
Speaker 6Every documentary that comes out has a new time scale. It used to be 1 billion years ago, now it's 7 billion years ago can we? Come up with at least a constant.
Speaker 4It's a magic number. When you say, when you say something like 160 million years ago, people just go that's, that's, that number is just inconceivable it's because they're in the whole trust the experts crowd mode, and they do that because none of the experts actually know.
Speaker 8What I think is interesting about Trent's position is that he's essentially asserting that if you hold on to a legitimate position in the church, that you are now this far-right Catholic fundamentalist, which is hilarious to me, because again he's trying to say, oh, be in the middle, stay away from these things. But one of these positions is the historic and a good position that catholics can licitly hold. But now apparently you're just far right. This is what I'm saying. Is that the guys who are seeing that the average catholic who's actually paying attention, they're saying, hey, uh, this whole nonsense that we've seen from the vatican, it ain't shipping out, so we want to go back to more traditional forums.
Speaker 8They're seeing that they're going to be losing revenue, they're going to be losing fan bases, they're going to be losing the the whole scope on things and eventually they have to just kind of pull people back to the middle and say, no, don't become one of those weird fundamentalists the chat's getting a little wild, like we might want to post this be wild, because they should be mad at this nonsense you're always one that say you want to see it.
Speaker 4Oh, but they've got a little bit of rib it was evolving quickly. Praise be to god pray the rosary, you're not on the team. He's not saying you're not catholic if you don't pray.
Speaker 8He's encouraging people to pray the road to pray because people weren't, literally in the 80s and the 90s for decades. I mean, this is one of the few things I give jp2 a little bit of credit for is that he actually tried to promote rosary devotion but for a long time you would literally be kicked out of seminary if you were praying the rosary, if you were trying to sneak off to adoration or something. They thought that that was superstition. But that's the mainstream normie world that they're gonna have to deal with and wrestle with. And to throw taylor under the bus. It's kind of like how he's been throwing.
Speaker 8He keeps trent, continues to continue to push the needle and complain about his epic defeat with Tim Gordon. He's clearly sad and mad that he lost that debate years and years ago, but he continues to bring it up like some old lady. I don't know what the deal is.
Speaker 6I think if Trent were here right now, I think he would probably say listen, I wasn't saying you shouldn't pray the rosary every day. I was simply trying to make the point that you don't have to pray the rosary to be Catholic. He's right about that. I just think he chose poor words to try to communicate that, because clearly the Virgin of Heaven has asked us all to pray the rosary every day.
Speaker 8So many times.
Speaker 6I think that it's just bad choice of words. I want to give Trent the benefit of the doubt, so I'm a Trent-splainer at this point.
Speaker 4He's just friends with school shooters. It's gay, Stop it. I don't want to strawman him like I feel like he's strawmanning us. So I'm glad you said that because, like I said, he's a good dude. I think he's look, he's trying to sell a book. Hey, I think he's look, he's trying to sell a book.
Speaker 6Was it you that he was thinking that you were calling him a post player with that video that came out? It was a week ago or something like that, when he was addressing the Pope. I was proud of Trent for coming out with that video, because the guy who works at Catholic Answers is not going to come out with a video like that. So it might not have been like as much as we would want it to be, but it was pretty far for a guy who works for Catholic Answers like as much as we would want it to be, but it was pretty far for a guy who works for Catholic answers. So I thought it was pretty courageous for him. And then I laughed when he's like I know people are going to call me a Pope explainer right now and I thought maybe it was you he was talking about.
Speaker 4It's possible. It's possible.
Speaker 5All right, let's play the one on liturgy, rob, and then we'll we Joe out of here because I feel bad Joe's got to wake up at the same time as I do in the morning. It's not fun getting up at 4 am.
Speaker 8I feel like I'm about to rage. I've not seen this clip, but I feel like I'm about to rage.
Speaker 4I just love that Joe fits right in over here, seamlessly comes in and just fits right in with our flow on this show. Four minutes. Goodness gracious well, we don't have to play the whole thing, but maybe this is part of the stabilizing feature. Where that got it?
Speaker 3I got it, so you got a champ um, where we we were afraid, and we then kind of flee the normies at our parish that are current, that occasionally bust out that godforsaken guitar and we try to find increasingly niche places to worship. And I see this a lot right. I mean, you've got okay. You think of the journey of someone who's like the charismatic Catholic, who gets over that and then kind of disparages that and sees a lot of the errors in that and then goes to like a regular novice order but then gets sick of the life teen stuff which we had in the 90s, right, and then goes to a novice or a parish that doesn't have our god is an awesome god.
Speaker 3And then he goes to the trad church and then he's, he gets, and then he goes to orthodoxy. But I bet you, within five minutes from now, you are going to see people getting kind of tired of orthodoxy. And so now we're going Coptic right, and then we're going to like the nichest thing we can find.
Speaker 7Ethiopic Tawahedo orthodoxy. Do you understand what I'm?
Speaker 1trying to say no, bro man.
Speaker 7Yeah, you're smarter than me. Tell me what. I'm trying to say. I see what you're saying. If someone is seeking, it's not just someone.
Speaker 3I just feel like this is there's this thing within the church where we are doing that, people are doing that. In droves. We're doing that.
Speaker 5For every one person that leaves the church that direction, there's 10 that go the other way, though.
Speaker 8What I'm chuckling at and you brought it up perfectly, rob is like we have a massive issue where the vast majority of professing catholics believe in open heresies on both faith and morals, and conservative catholic media can't help but talk about these weirdos, man, they just want to go to their niche, latin mass, and maybe they're going to go even further. That's not the reason I go to the latin mass is to be niche. I wish it was everywhere because I would not have to drive very far right, that'd be awesome. I I go to latin mass because I've actually studied the issues and I've come to the conclusion that this is the the fullest expression of catholicity that you can possibly get in the western right.
Speaker 8Those are the reasons that I go. Um, so just kind of to assume that this is some type of like niche club, I think is a straw man for, uh, an actual intellectual position of where people both of those guys have gone east.
Speaker 4Yeah, well, yeah yeah matt admits that in this. In this clip he says you know who am I to talk? I I. You know I say that. But the irony of most of these guys who defend the novus ordo is they escape it too, but they don't want to go to the the Latin mass because the trads are a bit too much for them. But they they even sense there's something catastrophically wrong in the typical Novus Ordo parish.
Speaker 8But they won't study the issue. That's what. That's what I'm saying. Like all of these conversations I've seen for the past five years of being Catholic, they're not actually addressing the root causes. So, like, when is the last time that we're going to say pints with aquinas? Say, okay, let's actually look at what ani balibunini said, like the fact that he was gleeful that they were destroying the roman right and that he was proud of that fact. Or the fact that the rome was doing investigations and realized that vast amounts of people on that team and then later on, like the, the head of the um, the congregation of bishops, were freemasons, that's.
Speaker 8But see, that's too controversial, that sounds too nuts, so you can't go there.
Speaker 4It sounds too conspiracy theorist.
Speaker 8Yeah, cause you lose money. You lose money, you lose donors that are going to keep your show afloat, and that's what I'm saying, and I and I really appreciated that Joe brought this up Like we have a responsibility to tell the truth, because christ is going to judge us by everything we say. So it's one thing again, maybe just to be wrong on an issue, but it's like you guys are at the top of the catholic influencer scale and you guys can't open a book and just be honest like that. These guys are nasty guys, you know, as trump would say, it's nasty people really bad.
Speaker 4Can I steal really?
Speaker 7bad can I?
Speaker 4steal man a little bit, um, because I look, I find myself in this position to Nick, like you, something will seem so clear to me and it's like this is like. This is just so insane, but you still have that, especially for, like, that's a cradle Catholic, like there's something intuitive about cradle Catholics that want to stay faithful to the Pope and the magisterium, even if it seems like it's going off the rails. Right, you still want to just that Catholic instinct, to just all right, I got to obey the Pope, even though, dude, I've actually had to sit and think am I being too rash on some of my judgments with him?
Speaker 4Because I just saw Eric Sammons came out and he said he's not going to criticize Francis anymore and it's like, am I doing the wrong thing here? But all I'm doing is saying what's on my heart. I'm not like trying to.
Speaker 6Kennedy Hall made a similar statement months ago, by the way.
Speaker 4What was that?
Speaker 6He basically said cause I I reached out to him one day to respond to something the pope was doing or saying I forget what it was now. Um, and he's like, listen, I don't, I don't really comment on the pope anymore, it's like I that's. You know, it'd be like every day, every day is there something? So it's just like one more thing and he goes I just don't see the fruit of it anymore, you know. So he, he, he made something very similar. I don't know how public he made that, but he, he certainly made that to me, and I think Eric's kind of in the same boat, although Eric seemed to articulate that he felt personally conflicted over his own criticisms of the Holy Father as doing more harm than good.
Speaker 6And God love him. If he's sincere on that, it's fine. But, like I said earlier, I don't think it's charitable to Pope Francis to not say something hey, the house is on fire. Man, you need to get a fire extinguisher, like right now, because the house is on fire. Like that's charity.
Speaker 4I think it comes down to worrying that we're man like you get clicks off of it right, so it's like you don't want to be that.
Speaker 6I think there's some distinctions made too. Like, if you don't have a YouTube channel, you're not social media guru or you're not an influencer or whatever. You're just a Catholic, living your life, going to work every day, coming home, paying the bills, doing your thing. Like, yeah, you don't need to have any public statements about the Pope, in my opinion. But if your coworker asks you because, like my whole family's not catholic, I'm the only catholic and they're like exactly what is your pope doing?
Speaker 6You know, my dad said to me this was a few years back. Um, my dad said to me uh, like out of the blue, because he knew that we had bad times in our life together because of this our religion issue, so we hadn't talked about the faith, nothing. And then all of a sudden, he's like your pope, this seems to be real bad. And I said you don't even know the half of it. And he was like what? Like it changed the dynamic of the conversation. I think he expected me to defend him and to sort of explain things and spin things. And I'm like you don't even know the half of it. And I started opening up about the real issues and the corruption within the church and he was like wow, and what that does in that specific case?
Speaker 6What it does is it plants a seed in his mind of well then, why do you stay Catholic? Because it's true, because it's true, because I'm not going to leave Jesus or Peter, even because there's a Judas, and I'm not going to leave Jesus because there's a Peter. You know what I mean. I'm here because it's true and I certainly'm not going to leave Jesus because there's a Peter. You know what I mean. Like, I'm here because it's true and I certainly am not going to abandon Peter, I'm not going to abandon the pontificate. I believe firmly that Matthew, chapter 24, gives us a very clear indication that our Lord and Savior expects us to suffer under the boot of a drunk master with the keys in his hand.
Speaker 6Master with the keys in his hand while the, while the lord is away on business and the chief steward, the guy with the keys gets drunk and beats the stewards. I, I fully believe jesus expects us to take the beating until he returns. We're not allowed to leave. We're not allowed to go set up another house and go escape from it and and find respite. We're expected to take it and persevere until the end and then, when he returns, guess what? The guy with the keys gets cast into the outer darkness.
Speaker 4So yeah, when the leaders of, when the leaders of israel were unfaithful, they didn't cease being the people of god, right, right, like they don't cease being the, they didn't lose isaiah 20, you have precedent, biblical precedent, that the, the guy with the keys, the chief steward gets you were a bad guy.
Speaker 6I'm here to replace you, I'm taking your keys, I'm taking your vestments, I'm going to put it on another guy and you are getting cast out like it's business as usual. So you got a bad guy, he, he gets moved on and you go on to the next one, and the train keeps rolling and I think we give ourselves a pass too often to save ourselves from I don't, I'm not under this guy, he's not my pope. So like, no, I hate to tell you he's your pope, I mean, but he was invalidly uh, you know elected.
Speaker 4That may be true, but that and a nickel has got us nothing, because we still get the airplane interviews every time the guy's on that plane exactly I because I, because I'm friends with patrick coffin and I've had that conversation with him too, and it's like I, I understand, you see all the evidence and this is the conclusion you come to and I'm I'm kind of we're stuck, no matter what but yeah, and I'm, and I'm, I'm a bit agnostic to it, where it's like this definitely could be true, I mean, uh, yeah, I've had ed maza on twice to talk about the issue.
Speaker 6I I've had a few others too. I can't remember everybody, but Ed Mazza for sure is you know a set of a contest and we had that conversation. I told him on the air I'm like Ed, you make great statements, but I'm sorry, I just don't agree with you because we are practically having to live through this pontificate. A hundred percent of all cardinals on planet earth call him the pope. A hundred percent of all governments on planet earth acknowledge him as the head of the state right.
Speaker 4So it's, whether he's the pope or not, he has full juridical power over the entity that the whole world precisely catholic church.
Speaker 6So even the swiss guard listens to him that's it.
Speaker 4Like there's no, there's nothing we can do about me blaming him an antipope. It means nothing. Nothing, grand scheme scheme of things.
Speaker 6We should pray fast and do penance for him because, he will face his judgment and millstones are made for such occasions. So if he's a soul that God loves and wants to go to heaven forever, so we need to do sacrifices for him that he will have a conversion before he dies, because he's caused much harm to the body of Christ. Christ, and you know what? Uh, that's where we're at. We should suffer well for for pope francis, for however many days he has left, and he's his health surprises me. I'm gonna be honest. Like he, he looks like he's terrible, but then he just flew all over the world, you know.
Speaker 6So it's like who?
Speaker 4knows and he's not. He's not joe biden, senile or anything either, like he's still very coherent, has his wits about him. It's like you almost wish you saw a little more, because, biden, how much stuff could he have liked.
Speaker 6Pray for that. Can he make a valid confession at this point?
Speaker 4I wonder that. I honestly do wonder if he could make a valid confession at this point.
Speaker 8That's a good question, anthony, to kind of answer your steelman, because I think your steelman is a common one. I think it's a good one. I think that, if we, you always have to check your intentions and say why am I criticizing Pope Francis? If it's legitimately out of righteous indignation and wanting to see people see the truth, that's one thing. If it's just to get clicks, obviously, as we've talked about, that's another thing. But I think we are shooting ourselves in the foot if we don't criticize what's going on and what I mean by this.
Speaker 8In the long run. This is what I see. You know now I'm on Twitter, right, thanks to Anthony, and I see Protestant Twitter and I see Orthodox Twitter. I see Protestant YouTube, orthodox YouTube. They are all using Pope Francis against us. But it's not to say pope francis is just off his rocker. It's to say the papacy is fake. Yeah, we, I I was not around for this because I wasn't catholic, but I know that from what people have talked about under benedict, under jp2, the catholic answers apologetics crowd would always defend the papacy and they would say well, we don't worship the pope, we don't worship the Pope, we don't obey the Pope.
Speaker 8In everything right, like if he misspeaks, he misspeaks and we can call him out and things like that. But then the minute that we actually get Francis, that whole narrative changes into essentially and I'm just being honest, they treat the man as if he is God and cannot say one thing wrong. And if you think he's saying something wrong, you're the problem and they gaslight you. So what I'm saying is that, long-term, if we want people to come into the Catholic church, we need to do two things One, we need to defend the office of the papacy, because that's what Christ instituted, as opposed to what a guy in the office is always saying.
Speaker 8And then, number two, we have to recognize that from the outside, our faith right now looks ridiculous, because we are saying, on the one hand, you have to belong to this institution, which is uniquely established by Christ, which is necessary for salvation, while on the other hand, the guy who's in charge of the institution is saying that all religions lead to God and the vast majority of Catholics who are inside of that body, according to statistics, don't hold to that faith as a male. That looks stupid, that just looks absolutely idiotic.
Speaker 8And so I'm just saying, long-term, I think we will be the ones coming out smelling like a bed of roses, because we'll say, yeah, let's defend the office of the papacy according to the principles of Vatican I, as opposed to trying to create all of these clever theories. It's good that you have this good instinct, but recognize that the good instinct is actually doing more harm than good to the actual Catholic apologetic.
Speaker 6You know. As a public person, I feel like I have to make it clear where I stand. I agree, you know more than the private person does. I don't believe a private person has an obligation to make it clear. You know unless, unless asked or whatever.
Speaker 4Nobody respects a guy who's a fence sitter either. Like nobody. Like people are just looking at like dude, pick a side, like don't freaking, sit there and try to play. Play everybody. Like you, don't have any harsh opinions. Like you have to.
Speaker 6You have to say what you believe. Agreed, yeah, interesting times, huh, very, very not boring very interesting times.
Speaker 4I think it's one of the most exciting times in history to be catholic, so I don't know if anybody's thinking about leaving. You're nuts. We're just gearing up for the end credits and you see the story progressing. We're coming. We're coming to the climax of the movie. Don't go anywhere, guys.
Speaker 6You know, I had an interesting dream the other night. Um, I've lately been having some very vivid, crazy dreams, and one of the dreams I had just the other day was it was the last thing I dreamt before waking up for work and I dreamt that, uh, I was in some sort of government agency maybe intelligence, I don't even know but my boss wanted to assassinate me. It's the weirdest dream ever. And they were coming for me. But I had a security team and they had a security team. We agreed to meet and have a conversation. Well, as soon as we get there, my team leaves me, abandons me, and so, long story short is they were taking me away, and I knew they were goingandons me.
Speaker 6And so I long story short is I they were going to, they were taking me away and I knew they were going to shoot me. And I thought to myself are they going to shoot me in the head? Are they going to shoot me in the heart? How many people are going to shoot me? I was just thinking this whole time, like I'm in the car being taken out to be shot, and then I thought to myself have I confessed all my sins? Like the reality of I'm about to meet my maker. Holy crap, have I confessed all my sins? And in my dream I started praying the act of contrition. I mean, it was so incredibly vivid to me and I just I bring that up to say we're all on.
Speaker 6We just don't know the day or the hour. We don't know our time. The Pope doesn't know his time. Joe Biden doesn't know his time. But Our time? The Pope doesn't know his time, joe Biden doesn't know his time. But we do know a time is coming. It could come for the whole world, it could come for just me tomorrow, and we're all so distracted by all the things in the world. Are we living in a state of grace? Are we pursuing virtue? If we only did that, imagine what could happen, you know. But we're sitting here fighting an uphill battle and we're so worried about what other people think and say and feel that we can't admit we're young earth creationists or that it's even a possibility.
Speaker 6Right, we have to have to avoid that. We have to avoid talking about politics and religion at thanksgiving and christmas, and and we have to explain the pope away. I mean college us. I just wish, I just wish some of these post planners would just be more sincere about it and just be like hey, I don't agree. I think this is crazy. I still love the Pope, he's got, I've got his back, but I don't.
Speaker 4I think most of them have the same doubts we have. They just think it's a sin to even think the things that we're saying out loud like ultramontanism and they're and they're afraid to lose.
Speaker 6You're right. I'll give you another anecdotal story. Years and years ago I was with the first apostle that I was full-time at. I was working with Scott Hahn a lot and I had him in the car I picked him up at the airport and I'm driving and he was telling me about how all these televised evangelical pastors with massive audiences were calling him in the middle of the night and it dawned on me just how God was using him to reach people that most of us are never gonna reach, and he was really planting seeds in their heart.
Speaker 6And he would tell me about how some of these people would come to the conclusion that the Catholic church was the true faith, but they were not willing to go any further than that because they were not willing to sacrifice all the money, the fame and the relationships that they had built. And when he said that, I was just like you know what that means Like there's no invincible ignorance here. Yeah, no, Like that's heavy. Yeah. And I feel like the same is true for a lot, and it certainly was true for me professionally until the McCarrick thing.
Speaker 6I was like nope, I have a career to see to. I got to get someplace. I got people to feed, a mortgage to pay, so I can appreciate how difficult that is. But at the end of the day we have to make a choice.
Speaker 4I have so much respect for those of you like even even Patrick Coffin leaving Catholic Answers because he wanted to have something to say in Catholic Answers. Because he wanted to have something to say. All of the guys that because there was a period where things were getting so bad where I was like, where is Steve Ray and Scott Howell, all those guys that converted me back in the day, why are they so silent right now? And you started to hear them start to speak up recently and then get slapped, they tow the line they go very close to it, and then they get in trouble for it.
Speaker 6Then they go back on message. Yeah, steve Ray is an interesting character. I've known Steve for years, worked with him a lot. A very interesting bird. He is wildly anti-Joe Biden, for sure pro-Trump hey let's go. I don't think he likes the Pope much either. I think he's even made lots of public statements in regards to that. But even he will ride that line very carefully because he knows, you know, he's got to keep his pilgrimage business going Right, like that's what I mean. He's retired, he. He doesn't really need the money, to be honest, but but he wants to see the gravy train keep going.
Speaker 6He doesn't want to see a good thing in so. So that's true for a lot of people, and Scott Hansen is definitely in that boat. St Paul Center's got a lot of great relationships with a lot of prelates and you can't rock that boat too far.
Speaker 8The love of money is the root of all evil.
Speaker 4He's employing a lot of look, it's also just not just him, right, right, well, that's the other thing. You're employing 150 people that are all working at this center. Now that you just got they just got another donation open up an affiliate in washington dc.
Speaker 6They got, I mean it's if I were scott and he should never take my advice, right. But if I were scott I would probably resign and just leave quietly and say I'm going off to retirement and I want st paul's center to continue on or do whatever, and then let the next guy have to wrestle with his conscience on that one, and then he personally could just go off and do his own thing.
Speaker 4He doesn't need the money either yeah, no, no way with the amount of books that guy's written. So, joe man, this was so fun to get to know you, man. Hey, when was the first time you came across us, by the way?
Speaker 6oh, my wife watches you guys on occasion, so to be honest with you the only reason why I'm on is so that my wife will be impressed oh, that's so awesome.
Speaker 4Tell your wife I said hello, do that.
Speaker 6Yeah, I mean I pop in on occasion, but you guys are like night owls, right. So, like this is past my bedtime, I'm usually in bed by the time you guys are having these uh, you know spicy meatball conversations so I only get to watch every once in a while I work construction.
Speaker 4So I'm up 4 am, so I usually like my routine is when do you sleep? I'm not much, so I get texts all throughout the night from them on my ride in the morning I catch anthony stein live at like 4, 15, um, and then, you know, usually around 7 I see you pop on, I'll throw you on for a little bit. I mean, I'm working in between, so it's not like I'm steadily focused on it, but I but I do my best and, uh, I try to pay attention to what is going on out in the Catholic, you know sphere. Like I, I like to know what other people are saying, what other people are doing, and yeah, me too.
Speaker 6I tend to watch your, your content. It went, you know, post like not live because you guys are too late live. So I'll watch stuff that's uh, been posted on youtube or whatever and um, and you know, I like to catch the conversations too, just to see what people are saying. That's part of what, like, I have one foot in the in the radio world and one foot in youtube digital world, so I have to, and it's crazy what I I have. You you can't see it, but I actually have like five cameras.
Speaker 4That's around oh no, I see it on your actual youtube show. I like sometimes you get the behind the camera here.
Speaker 6I got cameras there, everywhere, all over the place, and I'm I got switches and it just I my mind goes schizophrenic sometimes trying to remember what buttons to push all the time it's well, you know what it is because you're in broadcasting too.
Speaker 4Though, like, like, people don't realize there's an art to conversation, right, it's. It's. A lot of people think like, oh, I'll just start a YouTube channel, like it's not that easy to know how to keep the conversation going and how to make sure you I mean for you you got to hit the post.
Speaker 6So I've been in the business a long, long time. Like I said, radio in the 90s, I started podcasting in 2005, when it was brand spanking new, and I produced lots of content over the years, done a bunch of radio now, worked for three different radio apostolates. I can say the one thing I've always tried to do is I try to steal from people who are much better at it than me, no matter if they're Catholic or not. So I've stole a lot from people like Glenn Beck, for instance, and a bunch of people. Obviously they're great because they are special in some way.
Speaker 6They can tell stories, they captivate the audience, they hook them and they bring them along for the ride. And then you're listening right. So now I can communicate something that you're going to listen to, because I did these other things. And then when I look at the landscape of Catholic talking heads, I really figure out, because part of my issue is I've worked with so many different great Catholics that I for a long time thought I had to be just like them. I thought I had to be just like Scott Hahn. I thought I had to be just like Deacon Harold Burke-Sivers or all of these people that I worked with for so long and then I realized I got to figure out what it means to be me and find my voice my thing.
Speaker 6So I tried to bring what I feel is like the best of different genres and fields in media and combine them into a live program. So I don't like doing anything pre-recorded. I like it live. I like the dynamism of live. Even if I screw it up, even if I fumble the ball, I feel the exact same way. I would, just I want to go live and the energy is better, but here's the here's the thing that bugs me a lot about the radio world. The radio used to be King when I was a kid, all I wanted to do. I loved radio as a kid.
Speaker 6Wkrp is my favorite show. I love that favorite show. I love that like I dreamed about being on radio. But the era has passed and this in 2005, when I started podcasting, people are like what is that? Like, oh, that's so cute. Yeah, kid, maybe one day you'll be a pro in the biz, you know, and and it's like it's flipping right. So now it's like I I try to invite guests to be on my radio show and they well, what time is that in the morning? 7am, I can't care. And too many times I'll say to these guys I'm like you're a male, correct.
Speaker 6Like, yeah, I'm a man. Well, men can get themselves out of bed whenever they need to. Last time I checked, I mean, like, don't be a Sally, get out of bed one day a week. I'm going to kill you. But like so there's a lot of very well-known Catholic talking heads. I can name names. I will not do so. That will not be on my show, just because I won't, because it's too early for them. I'm like it's 7. Am. What time do you get out of bed, you lazy bum?
Speaker 4Like you know, get out of bed. That's why it's like when I say hitting the post, people probably don't even know what that means. It's like you have a commercial break coming up so you have to end your words perfectly time to as that commercial breaks coming up. It's like radio really was king for me growing up too, like I was, I listened to Rush Limbaugh all the time, like all those shows I always wanted to be a talk show host. Like I always thought, I had the chops to be a talk show host.
Speaker 6And you, like, I always thought I had the chops to be a talk show host, you know and you do, but there, but there's there's a diff. The radio and podcasting are different animals, and I think a lot of people don't understand that. They're just not the same, and uh, and what I try to do, though, is I try to combine these two genres as best I can into one. So when I talk on the radio, I talk, talk to the audience listening to me on a radio station, but I look into the camera so that I'm talking to the viewer watching us on rumble, facebook, youtube x or wherever else, because we simulcast everywhere, and uh, and then because I, during the radio side of my show, I don't read the comments, I I read them, but I don't really interact with them, but I do an entire, like after show that's all on video, and then that feels exactly like this does right here.
Speaker 6Yeah, it is, it is. The conversation goes wherever it wants to go and the audience drives it.
Speaker 4I love it. Uh, I may, I may call you for some tips and stuff. Man, I really do love what you, what you're doing over there. You have a very professional look to you and all that.
Speaker 6Well, you're too kind, thank you.
Speaker 4No, I appreciate you coming on, joe. It was really awesome getting to meet somebody. I've been watching from the sidelines for a long time. We're glad you gave us your time. We'll get you back on. We'll give you a little time to sleep this one off. It might be a bit too necessary. We'll give you back on. This is definitely a fun conversation. We appreciate you coming on, brother.
Speaker 6All right guys. God bless you all. Have a great night. People find you, uh, the station of the crosscom forward slash ACT, but you can look for Joe McClain on YouTube.
Speaker 4That's a great place to find me Go find Joe and Joe McClain on YouTube, you can see. If you missed the live show, you can catch the stuff like that. So all right, joe, it was really great meeting you. We'll see you, uh, soon. We'll see you then. Thank you.
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! One viral clip trashes the Knights of Columbus as a boomer “wife guy”...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Somebody tried to get our sponsors to drop us, and it accidentally became...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! You can feel it after this election: the old scripts are breaking. We sit...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! That new trailer moment where Christian TV starts to look like superhero...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A single word can flip a villain into a victim, and that’s what sent us...