Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Somebody tried to get our sponsors to drop us, and it accidentally became the funniest kind of promo. We start with that sponsor-email drama, why it failed, and what it reveals about modern cancel tactics in podcasting. Then we veer into something that sounds like a bit but is very real: an AI voice assistant that can place phone calls. We used it to prank the producer, and the laughter quickly turns into a real conversation about how automated calling changes harassment, persuasion, and online influence overnight. After the chaos, we settle into the main event: Cardinal Zen’s critique of the Synod on Synodality. We read large chunks, pause often, and say the quiet part out loud about what feels solid and what feels off. That takes us straight into Vatican II debates, the long shadow of religious liberty, and why so many Catholics feel like modern catechesis is failing their kids. We talk Baltimore Catechism, the “separated brethren” language problem, and why confusion doesn’t start with one pope, one document, or one decade. We also dig into the mechanics of synodal politics: hidden agendas, pre-planned outcomes, study groups, and the Fiducia Supplicans fallout. If you care about Church authority, Catholic moral theology, and what “local experimentation” does to unity, you’ll hear exactly why we think this moment matters and why “subtle” leadership can be more dangerous than loud leadership. Subscribe, share this with a friend who follows Catholic Church news, and leave a review with your take: is the synodal process reform or a loophole machine? Support the show Get 10% off an amazing Black Monk Rosary by going to https://www.blackmonkrosaries.com/?ref=AVOIDINGBABYLON and using code AVOIDINGBABYLON at checkout! Check out our sponsor, Nic Nac, at www.nicnac.com and use code "AB25%" for 25% off of your first order! Please subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKsxnv80ByFV4OGvt_kImjQ?sub_confirmation=1 https://www.avoidingbabylon.com Merchandise: https://avoiding-babylon-shop.fourthwall.com Locals Community: https://avoidingbabylon.locals.com Full Premium/Locals Shows on Audio Podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1987412/subscribe RSS Feed for Podcast Apps: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1987412.rss
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_01I know what I'll do. I'll write an email to their sponsors. That'll show those Avoiding Baplan jerks what happens when you mess with MAGA. Dear sponsors, you idiots must not even watch the Avoiding Baplin podcast or know about the stupidity they have been promoting. You better tune in and decide if what they're promoting really aligns with your values. That'll show them.
SPEAKER_07Hmm. Wonder what this is about. Hmm. I've never actually watched the podcast. Maybe I should check it out.
SPEAKER_00Other podcasts acting like baby boomers. Move over millennials. It's time for zoomers. This is just a way to do that. No cap. Listen to the avoiding Babylon podcast. Do you want a cat that glow up? Infinite kids.
SPEAKER_04We're gonna do the Fred stuff on the other side. Because I know Fred's a narcissist, and he will pay for locals to see what we have to say about him. He's he's always mad thing. He is as bad as Jim. He's as bad as Jim, but he's not as good as Jim. Like he's you know, yeah, I agree.
SPEAKER_05And you know what? I didn't see Jim getting a billion pictures taken of him on his knees praying out in front of churches during the COVID. Fred was like the original e-girl, performatively praying for pictures.
SPEAKER_04So for those of you who are confused, we will on the other side give the whole backstory, but man, I got screenshots, I got a lot, so we'll have to get into all that. On another note, I found a great way to troll Rob, which is I have my grogbot.
SPEAKER_05I have my I got a voicemail this morning. I'm like, what is this?
SPEAKER_03So wait, I told Grogbot I gotta pull this up. It's so funny, dude. It was so funny.
SPEAKER_05Hold on. Should I play the voicemail I got? You want me to play? Yeah, yeah, yeah. Because I didn't hear it. I don't know what it said. I'm gonna pull a U and just play it right into the Yeah, go ahead. Oh no, did I delete it? Did I delete it in spite?
SPEAKER_04Yes, Fred Simon. I'll tell you, man. Thank goodness I did not reveal the name of the priest coming on the pilgrimage with me. Because you know, you know his bishop will be getting a call from this mental patient.
SPEAKER_05I did, I deleted it.
SPEAKER_04Oh, come on. Is it in is it in like deleted files that you can recover?
SPEAKER_03Uh no.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so I said, um, so I get a message from Grokbot this morning that says, hey, just so you know, I can now make phone calls. So like, all right, so the backstory to the reason it's even telling me that is there's a uh my my kids have this uh thing with their school lunch program, like you have to put money into the system, and my kids are out of school now, and the money's in the system, and they won't let you withdraw it or like you have to go through this whole process.
SPEAKER_04So I had Grokbot search the website for a way to contact them. They sent them an email, but you have to actually make a phone call. So Grokbot tells me this morning, hey, by the way, I have phone call capabilities if you'd like me to make the phone call to the Pay Schools thing to get your money back. I said, Um, that's great. I said, Can you call Robert Blyton in my contacts and tell him that you're just checking on him to make sure he's staying on top of posting daily clips? So it says, It says, sure, I found him in your contacts.
SPEAKER_04Before I set up the call, do you want me to give your number? Then if he wants to talk to you directly, I can put you on the call. I said, No, no number, just call him. If he wants to talk to me, tell him that I'm too busy for him, and from now on, all correspondences will be through you.
SPEAKER_05When I told it to call you back and tell you to go screw yourself, it said, Don't worry, I'll keep it light-hearted banter. I'm like, I wanted to tell it, no, make it angry, but you want to hear yours? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So we're we're now having crock pots.
SPEAKER_03I just thought it was a freaking hilarious way this morning to bother you, and I figured you would laugh at it.
SPEAKER_05I'm gonna see if I can set mine up to call you every 10 minutes.
SPEAKER_03Dude, I will kill you.
SPEAKER_04Um, I don't have the patience to watch YouTube except for Catholics named Anthony who talk about tradition, and of course, Tim Gordon, even though his name isn't Anthony. Oh, speaking of Tim Gordon, so Tim wanted to come on, but okay, so we are limited on the amount of shows we have until Italy. So tonight we have three shows after tonight, and then I'm gone. So I told Tim it was too short a notice, but he wanted to come on and talk Aristotle. Uh, I told him we would at least throw a plug to the to the uh class that he's teaching.
SPEAKER_04Um so uh when I get back, maybe we'll have Tim on and we'll discuss Aristotle. Because that's that's Tim's like that's when he's in the zone, like philosophy and stuff. So um let me just give the plug for his class. Where the hell is Telegram? Um sorry, guys. Uh okay, so starting this Friday, Tim Gordon is teaching a class on how to master the more most important secular book in history in the in the history of the world, Aristotle's Ethics. No adult can afford to not know this book by this Thanksgiving.
SPEAKER_04Uh thank think oh, I don't know if you mistook mistyped there. Uh, less in less than four weeks from now, you will have read and mastered this book if you take this class. And Tim, uh, I sent the link to there, Rob, if you could just post the link. But uh he's going, he's gonna go through uh Aristotle's Ethics. It's a four-week class. He's gonna send me two of the first two because he's doing one this week and then one next week. So he's gonna send me those, and I'm gonna try and listen to those on the plane. And uh then when I get back, maybe we'll do a little an episode about it.
SPEAKER_04Um other than that, uh, we have to talk about Cardinal Zen tonight because everybody's raving about the Cardinal Zen thing, and I'm reading it and I'm just going, What a disaster this is. Like he sounds like a beneficantist. He does. It's like he is he is uh uh acting like Francis was the first problem, you know.
SPEAKER_04Right. We'll we'll go through it. Um but before we do, should we just do the ad rings now since we did that whole intro about ads? So yeah, Fred reached out to our sponsors and tried to have our sponsors get rid of us.
SPEAKER_05Little does he know, they're our friends.
SPEAKER_04We have the best sponsors on the planet, and not only that, do you know how much worse it would be for them if they actually did like like it's okay? Let's let's see.
SPEAKER_05Can you imagine the taffy video that would be made about them?
SPEAKER_04Let's see. We could either have one mental patient boomer mad at us, or Anthony and Rob could go on about how we abandoned them because of that one mental patient boomer. I think they'd rather deal with you, Fred. So, but knickknacks. If you're watching this episode, I need some knick-knacks before Italy. I'm running very low. Didn't they send you knick knacks? Not not anytime. Recently, recently, that like months ago. I'm almost through those, man.
SPEAKER_05I wonder if they've been sending them to me thinking I was gonna send you half of them because I am I am drowning in knick knacks right now.
SPEAKER_04Oh, dude, no, they sent me so far. I've gotten two packages from them. One when we first started, and they sent me another one a couple months ago.
SPEAKER_05But I definitely need more check with them.
SPEAKER_04Definitely need more, and I'm also gonna have like a ton of young men who we can get hooked on your product, guys. Like, you gotta get the first. I'm putting it in my stowaway. First off, that's not what you call it. Are you kidding me? I'll freak out if I don't have knick knacks. I'm bringing in knick-knacks and newports. What else? I don't even need glue.
SPEAKER_05I think in Europe you can get like the 100 milligram zins, though.
SPEAKER_04I don't like the European Zins. I really don't like the European Zins. But um, yeah, so knicknack.com, Knickknack, if you're listening, please send me a little package. Uh go to knicknack.com, use code AB25% for 25% off your first purchase. Use code AB10 for 10% off all subsequent purchases. Knickknacks are the greatest sponsor. We are so grateful to them that they did not cave to the cancel mob and the liberal maniac Fred Simon. Thank you for standing by us, Nick Knacks.
SPEAKER_04We love you.
SPEAKER_05Also, go to Black Monk. Well, he's gonna come kneel in front of your office and pray for pictures right there.
SPEAKER_04Uh also for Black Monk Rosary, uh, the gift, the the winner of the rosary, um, the winner of the rosary contest. They received their rosary and sent me a message, and that message said, Anthony, I received the rosary this afternoon. It's certainly a thing to behold. Thank you for sending it out to Oregon. I look forward to having this nine-pound weapon blessed this Sunday, and then giving it to the gentleman who gave me the miraculous medal two and a half years ago. Keep Avoiding Babylon coming, and may God bless you and Rob and your families.
SPEAKER_04Guys, if you have not gotten a Black Monk Rosary yet, you really do need to. If you don't have a Black Monk Rosary, you're not on the team. Use code Avoiding Babylon at checkout for 10% off. And TLM Ryan, you guys got like two weeks left to get his planner. I'm no, I know it's getting expensive, but guys, it isn't it isn't Lent yet, so you guys don't even have to buy lobster yet. So if you think if you think you're spending a lot on knickknacks, rosaries, and planners.
SPEAKER_05Just wait till we bring the lobster and wine back.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, once Lent comes and you guys have to buy lobster, that's what is really gonna get expensive. So go to uh what's it what's Ryan's site? Bring it up.
SPEAKER_05Penitentplanner.com.
SPEAKER_04Uh penitentplanners.com. Penitentplanners.com. So TLM Ryan and his Novus Ordo Planner, guys. That's what we gotta push here.
SPEAKER_05We're gonna push Fred's tweet about him.
SPEAKER_03With the notebook. He put the Marvel novel. Guys, this show's gonna be all over the place tonight. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_05I hope you didn't come for like a yeah. Well, we have we have Ryan's in the chat stuff.
SPEAKER_04Pre-conciliar radio and their post-conciliar calendar. How about stakes and cigars this year? Once Pentecost comes, we're selling for Lay Mignon. Um, no, man. Honestly, our sponsors are freaking awesome though.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04All of them. Wine, lobster, nicotine. And shoplobster, go to shoplobster.com. They just sent Rob and I lobsters. I still I made them the other night, and I still have eight left that I'm going to make for my parents this weekend. Because I'm gonna see my parents before we go. But um, I kind of just want to like talk personal stuff. I don't even know. We'll do the Cardinal Zed stuff because I know I I see Catholic Esquire's in here, and he's doing again because he wants us to go the he wants us to go through this. Uh Ant, if I date your daughter, can I get a black monk?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, but you're not gonna like the way Ant gives it to you, probably.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, listen. This this dating my daughter stuff, everybody better chill.
SPEAKER_05Hear that, guys? I'm not gonna put up those comments on screen anymore, apparently.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, yeah. Enough, enough with the dating Anthony's daughter stuff. Well, uh anyway. Um, all right, let's bring the Cardinal's end suite up. Okay. So um while you're bringing it up, on the plane ride to Italy, uh, I was talking with American Reform this morning, and he sent me You were not on a plane to Italy this morning. No, no, no. I was talking with American Reform this morning, and he sent me a book that I'm going to read on the plane ride to Italy. Okay. I'm sorry. There you go.
SPEAKER_04I'm a little all over the place today. Um so on the plane ride to Italy. I plan on reading this book, and I am pretty sure when I come back, it's gonna be one of those holy crap, Rob, we have to have one of these deep episodes. Um, it is man, he sent me so many screenshots of it already. All right, The Plot Against the Church by Maurice Pinet. So I ordered a hardcover copy and I got the PDF.
SPEAKER_04And just to uh uh just to um Tim's throwing me off.
SPEAKER_02Tim just texted me. Um what the heck was I just gonna say?
SPEAKER_05Tell Grok to call him back and tell him to stop.
SPEAKER_04Um, hang on. What the heck? I need to I need to gather my thoughts.
SPEAKER_02I'm all over the place tonight.
SPEAKER_04Um I wanted I want you to just see the the one quote that I posted today from it. Because it has to do with what we're about to read from Cardinal Zen.
SPEAKER_02Um why is Twitter so annoying? Well, you're on it. Yeah, and I do tweet a lot. You do.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and he's a penitent planner, he can't remember what he's gonna do on his own show.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so the all right, so this book that I'm going to read on the plane, it was written right before the council. Okay? This is a this is a quote from the introduction. A further disastrous plan which is being prepared is that the church shall contradict itself so as a result to sacrifice its regard with the faithful. For later it will broadcast that an institution which contradicts itself cannot be divine. With this proof, they wish to desolate the church, the churches, and achieve that the faithful lose their confidence in the clergy and abandon them.
SPEAKER_04It is intended to cause the church to declare that what it has represented for centuries as bad is now good. Among such maneuvers, spun for this purpose, one particularly stands out on account of its importance and refers, in fact, to the conduct of Holy Church towards the damned Jews. As Saint Augustine calls them, and in and this in reference both to those who nailed Christ to the cross as also to their descendants who are both arch enemies of Christianity. Um, maybe we could do next Tuesday because we're gonna do we're we got tonight planned.
SPEAKER_04Let me just see uh maybe next Tuesday. Tim's texting me right now. So let me uh as long as we don't have a guest for next Tuesday lined up, I don't think we do. We'll just maybe we'll just do next Tuesday. Um so yeah, this whole this whole plot against the church, the whole idea of the council, this whole book is about the fifth column that infiltrates the church during the council. And the whole thing is about how the teaching on the Jews is no longer going to be taught by the church.
SPEAKER_04It's about getting the church to declare that it is against anti-Semitism, all the stuff that we saw happen, all the stuff that comes out in the documents of the council. So I'm looking forward to reading this book and getting a getting like a view of what was this was because it was written in 1962. It's not like it was written after the council, it's not like it was written after the liturgy was changed. This was written in the lead up after the council was set and planned, and it was released during the council, I guess.
SPEAKER_04What year did the council start?
SPEAKER_0562.
SPEAKER_04So it was it was handed out to all the council fathers, all the council fathers got a copy of this book, and the whole thing is basically about the subversion of the Jews into the council. So I'm gonna read that. So let's go. Do you have Cardinal Zen's tweet? Let's bring that up.
SPEAKER_05Yep, I sure do. Give me one second.
SPEAKER_04There's a ton of good stuff in this tweet, by the way. There's a ton of good stuff in this tweet, and a lot of people are happy about it, and it's it is good, but the whole framing of it is off because he's trying to pitch it like synod bad, council good. And it goes to show you that even the best of the cardinals out there, because Cardinal Zen is clearly a devout Catholic who loves our Lord and loves the church. It's just the Kool-Aid these guys drank during this period.
SPEAKER_05They just um so Cardinal Zen's what 90s, nine mid-90s, right? Yeah. So he would have been born, well, let's just say what 1930s? So he would have been I don't know when he was ordained, but he would have probably been a priest during the council, right?
SPEAKER_04He's in his 30s, right? So I mean, I would imagine he was ordained. Wait, is your virtual assistant calling me right now? Why would it be doing that?
SPEAKER_07Hello. Hey there, I'm a virtual assistant calling for Rob, producer at Avoiding Babylon, on a recorded line to read the Gettysburg address.
SPEAKER_06Are you out of your mind?
SPEAKER_04All right.
SPEAKER_05Oh, it's as it says you answer, but hung up before the reading started.
SPEAKER_04Reading the Gettysburg address.
SPEAKER_05All right, so I could have it do it in a Hawaiian pigeon.
SPEAKER_04We're gonna play around with it after. Stop distracted. Okay, okay. So while remembering St. Charles Barromeo, A, today is the feast day of St. Charles Barromeo. He was a great Archbishop of Milan, the largest diocese in Italy. The Council of Trent, which had to resolve many problems, had taken place at that time. The Protestant Reformation contained heresies and defined the sacraments, rejecting the Eucharist and the true priesthood, and the council served as a counter-reformation. However, there were also internal issues within the church that required a thorough reform.
SPEAKER_04The powers of the nobility had weakened the church, and the formation of the clergy had been greatly neglected. The council lasted 18 years under the leadership of three popes. Our second Vatican Council lasted four years under two popes, John the XXIII, who began it, and Paul VI, who continued and concluded it. A great deal of work followed the Council of Trent. Many diocesan synods at Milan and many other dioceses, parti uh partly under the influence of St. Charles Barromeo, truly brought forth the fruits envisioned by the Council of Trent.
SPEAKER_04B. Many years after the Second Vatican Council, we must regrettably acknowledge today that it has not been sufficiently fruitful. It has been under constant attack by those who claim to be continuing the council, arguing that its reform was not completed, while on the other hand, there are those who suspect that the council contains assertions contrary to the tradition of the church. So this is like why I read that whole preamble, right? It's that the mission of the subversion was to get the church to contradict itself so that those people would look on and go, the church can't be divine because it contradicted itself.
SPEAKER_04There are tons of people who say that. That is the entire argument from the Eastern Ortho, all the Ortho Bros say that. Every liberal Catholic says it, and the super trad say it. Right? Like they're not saying the church isn't divine, they're saying that this can't be the church, things like that, you know, the set the the novice or sect like that.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Following the following the example of St. Charles Baromeo was the Archbishop of Krakow, Krakow or Krakow?
SPEAKER_05Uh Croody.
SPEAKER_04Either, either or it depends on who later became uh Pope John Paul II. He worked strenuously within with his diocesan community to ensure that the churches, uh that the council's documents were thoroughly understood and their teachings put into practice. Obviously, this did not happen in all the dioceses of the church. Man, there's it's so interesting how I would have agreed with that statement years ago.
SPEAKER_04It's what what what John Paul II did was there was such a a liberal push under Paul the Sixth. That John Paul II coming in and putting the brakes on some of this stuff seemed like a lurch to the right. but it was still a lurch to the left. It was just it was just so insane under Paul the Sixth That John Paul II coming out and writing something like Veritatus Splendor seemed like, oh, we're putting the brakes on all this stuff, and the church still believes the things that it claims, you know, that all the things about morality.
SPEAKER_04But it was so sneaky what was going on with religious liberty and how much that Rob, don't you look at religious liberty so completely differently now than you did even like five years ago?
SPEAKER_05Uh I don't know about five years ago. Um ten years ago, yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_04We were we were always suspicious of it like from from when we started the show, right? Like so from when we started the show, we were already suspicious of it. I just think we've learned so much more through conversations, the papal encyclical theories, and then just experience of seeing the fruits of religious freedom in our own country over the past 10 years.
SPEAKER_05I you know, it's one of those. Things I think even as a as a kid cradle Catholic, like the idea of religious liberty was always kind of silly to me. But um yeah, just it's within the last couple of years where I think I've realized just how central of an issue it is to the problems in the world today.
SPEAKER_04I I would have never thought how even probably look because I always make the statement I'm like, look, religious liberty or religious tolerance is one thing when you're dealing with Protestants and Catholics agreeing to not be violent towards each other, and you know, but what an issue it is for your children to be in a public school with a bunch of Protestants and your kids are Catholic, like it it's let alone the foreigners we have now, right? Right. It's so much worse there. But what it puts in your kids' head is like doubt, it puts doubt in your kids' head immediately.
SPEAKER_05You can't claim to have the one and the one true religion and also claim that all religions are a path to God.
SPEAKER_04Not even just that, every one of those kids all think they have the one true religion. So that in itself is something that it worked in my that's what happened in my head as a kid. It was like, well, the Jews think they're right, and the Muslims think they're right, and the Protestants think they're right. Like, who are we to say that we're right? Everybody just thinks they're right, and you just believe whatever you were raised to believe. And it's not until you investigate the claims of the church that your faith is solidified, because only the church actually has like the proof behind it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So it it's just I I never realize how central this issue is and how problematic it is in the church. I would have even said all the things John Paul said, like I I would have said uh he he he had good motives in it. I might still say that. I don't I don't know if John Paul understood the how how duplicitous it was what he was doing. I think he thought, I think after the after World War II, I think the propaganda was so strong that it's possible he thought he was bringing hostilities to an end throughout the world.
SPEAKER_04Like like the Catholic mind was conditioned to think religious wars were religion was the cause of all wars. But all even today, all wars are religious wars. Uh even secular wars are religious wars because it's it's like revolution is a religious war.
SPEAKER_05Okay, but yeah, that stuff didn't really start until like the 19th century. Before that, vast majority of wars were over like resources.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's true. Especially Catholic countries fighting Catholic countries, those weren't religious wars.
SPEAKER_05I mean, the matter of fact, the study was done, and it's like two percent of all wars have been due to religion and not second.
SPEAKER_04I think I'm being hyperbolic when I say it, though. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah. I mean, uh the the ideological wars over the last 200 years, two, three hundred years. Yeah, I mean, whether you're fighting for Nazism, communism, whatever, yeah, those I mean that's a religion, right?
SPEAKER_04I don't I don't mean it in the way the secular world describes it. Like the secular world describes it like the church is burning heretics at the stake. Yeah, yeah, I don't mean it like that. I mean, even the like the Protestant Reformation is a religious war, and then even World War II is a religious war when you think about the ideologies behind it. You're fighting you're fighting, you know, it's not religion in the proper sense, obviously, but um but the the I think the Catholic mind after World War II, the pressure they were they were putting on people, they really did trick them into thinking a lot of Catholics thought they were responsible for the Holocaust.
SPEAKER_04That that Christians were responsible for hatred of the Jews.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_04So, um okay, so popes Paul VI, John Paul II, and Benedict the 16th did a great deal to ensure that the council achieved its desired purpose and they succeeded to a certain extent. Many bishops found themselves in difficult in difficulty after the council. Did I miss something?
SPEAKER_05No. I said, did they?
SPEAKER_04Like, did they actually many bishops found themselves in difficulty after the council because they did not know how to explain to the faithful precisely what the council had changed in the life of the church and what it had not changed. The Holy See, under the leadership of Cardinal Ratzinger, following extensive consultations throughout the church, drew up a catechism containing the entire dogmatic, moral, and liturgical doctrine of the church, set out in a systematic order. However, the sheer volume of the catechism may have put people off, and not many have actually studied it.
SPEAKER_04Catechism, man. I'm the don't don't the the Rob, you're putting your kids through catechism class right now. Like I can't, yeah. Yeah, one of them. I can't tell you how important it is to drill the Baltimore Catechism into your kids' heads because they're learning nothing at that class.
SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah, we go through that. We go through that ourselves.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that like the just the wrought memorization of things are it's super important for young kids to go through that stuff because we were taught nothing in religion class when we were kids. Religion class, especially when you're younger, it's like coloring books and nonsense and it's crossword puzzles. It's so dumb how they how they do it. It's just so ridiculous. These kids that go to religion class are not being taught a single thing.
SPEAKER_05No, it's all it's all about feels.
SPEAKER_04And they're and they're being taught you're in the church if you're a person of goodwill, whether you're Protestant, Muslim, Jewish.
SPEAKER_05Anyone that's that's what that's what one of your kids' books literally said, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and and in a way, they're playing off the church, it subsists mainly in the church, but our separated brothers and sisters, like that's what they're playing on. They're playing on that whole idea of the church, the the true church subsists mainly in the Catholic Church, but like I don't know how much of a fan I am of calling Protestants our separated brothers and sisters anymore.
SPEAKER_05I've never been comfortable with it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, look, it's it's one of those things where like if you're talking to a Protestant, it's a great cat, it's like, oh, you're our separated brethren.
SPEAKER_05It's like, no, no, you're not.
SPEAKER_04No, they're heretics.
SPEAKER_05But Protestant converts love using the phrase, so maybe um I like I don't I understand it like not nearly as many of them probably have valid baptisms as as we're led to believe, right? And two, even the ones who do have separated themselves from the church, there are many other uh many other ways, right? So no, they're not they're not are they really Christian? Not really.
SPEAKER_04See, I don't see that. I think speaking of invalid baptisms, like I know the church recognizes the baptisms of of certain denominations because they did the right formula, but I still think the church should do a conditional baptism of the person that comes in.
SPEAKER_05So my wife just texted me because she's listening. She says, and she she's a Protestant convert, she says she she hates the phrase separated brethren. Yeah, you know, she doesn't feel like she was a separate separated brethren before she was.
SPEAKER_04You know why, yeah, but you have to understand how brainwashed everybody is from Catholic answers and like the usual route into apologetics into the church. So many people are just brainwashed by that whole separated brothers and sisters, and Jews are our elder brothers in the faith. Like that's how people come in, so that's how they learn to speak, and that's how it's like that's how you have a polite conversation with a Protestant. You call them our separated brethren, and you know, Bishop Sheen used that phraseology.
SPEAKER_04And oh okay, see, forces opposed to the council have been troubling the church throughout these years. Regrettably, in these recent years, we have had the supreme head of the of our church who, whilst proclaiming the great validity of the Second Vatican Council, was in fact not faithful to its decrees.
SPEAKER_05What decrees? Well, do you see what he just said? What actual decrees?
SPEAKER_04Go back a tiny bit. Regrettably, in these recent years, we have had the supreme he he's a beneficantist.
SPEAKER_05I don't get that position. I mean, he he's not because he still says this the supreme head of our church. I know, I know, but yeah, I I see what you yeah, he thinks there was some sort of rupture, not necessarily one in which invalidated the papacy, right? Yeah, no, I don't think he he definitely believes there's a rupture that happened with France, right?
SPEAKER_04He doesn't I'm not saying he thinks Francis was not a real pope, I'm not saying he thinks Leo is not a real pope. He I think he thinks everything was fine up until Francis.
SPEAKER_05Well, here's the thing I think the people who think that think that because of Benedict. If instead of Benedict, who was a little bit, you know, if if JP2 was a little bit further to the right than Paul VI, then Benedict was a little bit further to the right than JP2. But if instead of Benedict you had someone, someone who was somewhere between JP2 and Francis, it wouldn't have been such a drastic if for if you had had Leo.
SPEAKER_05If you had Leo between JP2 and Francis, I think you would clearly see that devolution, but instead you have Benedict, so it looks like we were going the other way and then turned around.
SPEAKER_04I think after Benedict would have been Leo, then Francis would like it's almost like they're out of order.
SPEAKER_05In ideology, kind of, yeah. And that's why they had to get rid of Benedict, right?
SPEAKER_04Because the same ideology, it is the same ideology, it's uh in no, because you know, you you got Francis was Francis ratcheted it all the way to the left, and then Leo comes in to like plug, like, oh, slow down, slow down, slow down, right? But the overton window shifted, and now people are just like content that Leo is not saying stuff like there was in Amoris Letitia and stuff like that.
SPEAKER_04Man, yeah, look, I I get some people thinking that there's a rupture after Benedict. But the more you look into this, you kind of just see this one continuous stream. It really is. It's it's all the same error, it it all stems from religious liberty, like it really does stem from religious liberty, yeah, and it stems from our posture towards the Jews, specifically, right?
SPEAKER_04It's it's religious liberty in general, but it's specifically our posture towards the Jews, our our inability to uh discuss the Jewish question, to wrestle with uh the role of the Jews in salvation history, in the apocalypse, yeah, all this stuff. Like this is this is a fundamental, this is the fundamental, it really is not about liturgy, it's really not about liturgy. Well, liturgy is part of it, but liturgy is not the cause of it, no, right.
SPEAKER_04And we and we know that because we had these super based popes with the proper liturgy, and this stuff this stuff still came in. So it's not like, oh, let's just get the right liturgy in and get a super base pope and this stuff ends. No, if that really did happen, if after Leo you get some super base pope and the liturgy goes back, you're just you're going to see persecution in a way you've never seen. Because the church, the world is so used to the church on this liberal pivot and progressive pivot that to to to flip something back to what it was in the preconcilia era, forget it.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you the the even though the church has very little like um moral standing in the world today, I mean obviously it does, right? It's you know, the it's the church of Christ. Um, but the world doesn't think so. I think the church would actually lose whatever moral standing it has left with the rest of the world if it did an about face. And I'm not saying it, I'm not I'm not, I'm not using that as an argument to say it shouldn't, but um, but yeah, like you were saying, we saw we read so many of the documents that were, like you said, Uber-based, and they did not do a single thing to slow the the steamroller that was secular liberalism, which is really just a tool of Judaism.
SPEAKER_04I think this went from outside the church to inside the church. So we we I was on with Gaspers last night with Josh and Hitchbourne, and we discussed the moralia of Job that Pope Gregory wrote. Uh Hitchborne kind of took us through it, and and Pope Gregory posited that um the book of Job is an allegory for the life of the church. So Job, the first bunch of things that happen to him are all external. Um, you know, he's getting lesions on his on his body and he loses everything.
SPEAKER_04But then Satan goes and tells tells God, um, well, sure, he's of course he still loves you, but you haven't let me touch his person. And then God allows him to touch his person, and then he loses his family, and he gets, you know, all these things start becoming spiritual um harm. So if you look at the the church after the reformation, it's all the outer things to her externals are like the church is besieged on all fronts from the externals, all the governments of the world are no longer Catholic, and they all start, and you start seeing this great persecution from without.
SPEAKER_04But then at the council, and it lines up with the whole con uh the whole locution that Pope Leo the Thirteenth has, where he sees God and the devil in that hundred-year period. Like Michael Hitchborn, if you guys didn't watch that show last night, it's really good. And especially that segment, Hitchbourne kind of takes us through all of it, talking about Pope Leo XIII's locution, uh, about the 75 to 100 year period, and he takes us through uh how Job, how everything, you know, so the church is beset from outside, then after the council, it's beset from inside.
SPEAKER_04But all of this ties into especially with the Jewish question stuff, because the synagogue enters the church. That's essentially what happens, and you have the synagogue of Satan within the church now, and it ties into the idea that we have to be delivered up to the religious leaders like our Lord did. And if you and if you even think to PO, Rob St. PO think about what the church did to him.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, think right, like you think about like how much he was delivered up to his religious leaders, he's literally suffering the wounds of Christ.
SPEAKER_05I was gonna say, I think, yeah, I think the stem the stigmata he suffered.
SPEAKER_04Like he his life definitely a Christ figure, right? His life is an example of the passion of the church, St. P.O., right? The man is literally the living through this the passion his whole life, and he gets handed over to the religious leaders just like Christ did. Like he's he's actually the saint for our times for us to understand what we're going through right now. But at no time, and and he lives through the council, he lives through the liturgical changes. At no time, the Saint P.O.
SPEAKER_04say Paul VI is an anti-pope, John the 20th turns an anti-pope. Like, no, I'm sorry, he doesn't. There's a the it's just look, I understand this stuff is bonkers that we're looking at, and we're and we're still we're criticizing Zen because he won't see what the main problem is. But none of this stuff invalidates the orders and the and and things like that, in my opinion. Still, I still don't think it does. And I just think we're living through the passion in a really severe way. All right, bring bring it up. Let's let's let's run through the rest of this.
SPEAKER_04Pope Francis was certainly admirable for his kindness and especial concern for the poor and weak. However, this kindness and predilection having uh have lacked balance. He seemed to believe that out of compassion for these people, one can even compromise on the truth. He believed that the primary danger within the church is clericalism and thought that through a general consultation of the people of God he could succeed in having his line of thinking approved. He was certainly a reformist.
SPEAKER_04He destroyed many good things built upon by his predecessors, built up by his predecessors. He did not appreciate the entire struggle in defense of orthodoxy waged by John Paul II. Defense of Orthodox.
SPEAKER_05Well, first off, we don't capitalize orthodoxy in English unless we're talking about the East.
SPEAKER_04But well, also for you younger guys, though, for you younger guys, you actually don't know what it looks like to have like the press against the Pope. You guys don't know what it looks like to seem like the left hates the Pope. Because we have had two consecutive Popes where they were the darling of the left. Yeah, you never see media criticism of Leo, you never saw media criticism of Francis, ever.
SPEAKER_04Where you did see that stuff with John Paul II and Benedict. Like Benedict, when Benedict gave his Regensburg address, holy cow, did they lose their minds? We should do an episode on that, Rob. We should. We should actually, that would be a good one to have Gordon on for. Like he he uh he's done like a ton on that. So maybe if we get him on, we'll do Aristotle and the Regensburg Address. Um but yeah, Benedict the Regensburg Address. I mean, it's been so long since I've read it, but he's basically talking about um he's talking about how Islam spreads through the sword and Christianity is spread through evangelism, but he's also talking about religious indifferentism.
SPEAKER_04He calls it the not the tyranny. What did he call it, Rob?
SPEAKER_05Um the the the the dictator is it the dictatorship of relativism?
SPEAKER_04Moral relativism. Moral relativism, yeah, yeah. The dictatorship of relativism is that what Benedict was always going on about. And because Benedict really did look, he for all his problems, the man did believe the Catholic faith. He really did, you know, and he saw how moral relativism was becoming a dictatorship. How he saw how and it is interesting that like gay marriage and stuff wasn't legalized until he was out of the picture. He was he was way more of a catacomb than Francis.
SPEAKER_05I mean, it happened well what I think.
SPEAKER_04in 2013. So he was definitely a catacomb holding that back. But when he was talking about that, he was talking about how nowadays, if you don't go along with the current thing, you'll be excommunicated. Like he saw this new thing coming as a dictatorship, and he saw it as some kind of ape of the church. He wasn't talking about the church, though, he was talking about the secular world and saying how if you don't go along with the current thing, you'll be cut off and you'll be excommunicated.
SPEAKER_04It's like the modern version of excommunication. Like Benedict really did have some deep insights into stuff like that. Um so, okay, so he did not appreciate the entire struggle in defense of orthodoxy waged by John Paul II and Benedict. He abolished the synod of bishops, which had been established by Paul VI towards the end of the Second Vatican Council as a sort of continuation miniature version of the council intended to provide the Pope with the count with counsel from the episcopate of the entire church through their elected representatives.
SPEAKER_04This is a democratization of the church, essentially. Um the synod has been done away with, and in its place, something else has been created, what might be termed a demoh a democratic consultation of the entire people of God. Um D. How can people directly consult the entire people of God? Pope Francis said that a shepherd must have a feel for the scent of his sheep, but how can a pope in Rome possess this sense? It is the bishops who can truly sense the scent of their own sheep, and they in turn bring this insight to the Pope so that they may see what today's problems are and how to tackle them.
SPEAKER_04By emphasizing the etymological meaning of the word synod, the synod on synodality has overlooked the historical reality of what synods actually are. The synod is, by definition, a matter of the bishops or for the bishops.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, that is generally what a synod was historically in the church.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, this holy synod, it was almost like synonymous with council.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it was just a local council of local bishops, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um, okay. The fact is that behind all this lay hidden agendas. After all these years of the synodal process, they have failed to get their hidden agendas, in fact, not so hidden, fulfilled. There was relentless manipulation and strict control of the process. Process, yet it was a failure, despite every effort to strike uh to stifle genuine discussion. The objectives that the Pope evidently entrusted to the Synod Secretariat were not achieved. Even within the limited time for free speech in the assembly, it was evident the synod members rejected those objectives, changing the hierarchical constitution of the church, ordaining women to the scroll up.
SPEAKER_04Ordaining women to the priesthood, starting with the diet diaconate, the free choice of celibacy for the Roman clergy and the sexual morality radically updated under the LGBTQ banner. So, like he what he's saying here is even with these synods, the bishops came and they tried voicing their concerns, and it was a pre-planned agenda that was teamrolled through. So that they got phrases into the documents in the magisterial documents that you never had seen before, calling calling people gay, even had never been seen in a church document, you know, like even like giving the the allowance to that identity.
SPEAKER_02Um I just want to check something on uh where the heck is it? I gotta make sure I have this ready to go. Oh that's a good sorry guys, give me a sec.
SPEAKER_05Um while you look up that, I'm gonna pop a knick-knack, which contains nicotine and maybe addict uh an addictive chemical, and that's definitely not why I'm popping a knick-knack right now. Did I forget to say hold that? I think so, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um shoot, why can't I? There we go. Okay, I got it.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so uh as this attempt failed, the Pope then removed these controversial topics from the Sonata and handed them over to study groups, the formation criteria of which were unknown, and these groups were expected to report their conclusions directly to the Pope. Scroll up that the cause of homosexuals had been one of the hidden agendas was highlighted by the publication of the document Fiducia Supplicans, which approved the blessings of same-sex couples issued between two sessions of the ongoing synod without consulting the synod participants.
SPEAKER_05One can say though, well, the homosexual agenda was in the closet until fiduciar supplicants.
SPEAKER_04Not even that. We just haven't talked about any of this stuff in so long, right? It's it's like you know, you kind of forget how nuts it was under Francis. Man, the document threatened to cause a terrible breaking up of the church. Pope Francis and the Cardinal, and the Cardinal had to appease the public outcry with an attitude of condescending understanding, yet without any genuine retraction. That's accurate.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Um it's funny, it's it's very accurate because Francis cannot do a single thing without coming off as condescending.
SPEAKER_04It is interesting how we how we couldn't, right?
SPEAKER_05You know, it's maybe I have more in common with the man than I thought.
SPEAKER_04Um no, nothing. Maybe you have more in common with the man than you thought. Is that what you said? Yeah. Um, hold on. I'm actually looking for um I'm looking for highlights from that book that I that I that I'm going to read that I thought might be relevant right here, but um, all right, whatever. Um, okay, so uh all right, so that yeah, you you do you do probably temperament-wise have a lot in common with Francis.
SPEAKER_04Probably temperament-wise, probably, yeah. Uh, that the cause of homosexuals particularly, particularly close to Francis' heart is evident in his special favor toward Father James Martin, SJ of Outreach, fan of the show, friend of the show. Uh Father James Martin, friend of the show, outreach, as well as his famous quote, Who Am I to judge? Uh, where is uh Father Martin tonight? Haven't seen him. You got a shout out in a Cardinal's Ed suite, and you're not here. You kidding me? Skojick is here.
SPEAKER_05Someone was taking someone, I'm like, someone was taking him like, Why are you taking Skojick? Well, he's here. Oh, there he is. There you go.
SPEAKER_04Hey, there he is. Friend of the show, Father James Martin. Uh, and recently something has happened which made us realize to our horror that the whole lengthy discourse on the Sonatal process is intended to provide a tool for justifying anything. You want to know what's funny, Steve's here? Steve can't help himself, he still has to check in on this crap. Well, you know, maybe he just likes watching us. No, he's a drug addict, dude. We can't I'm telling you, even when I stopped going to mass for those two years, I was constantly checking like stuff, like stuff like that.
SPEAKER_04You just can't every time Francis would say something, I would just seethe. Even though I was like, I don't care about this stuff anymore, I'm not dealing with it. So even us, like we we've said we don't care what's going on in Rome, but Cardinals then pops off, and you just can't help yourself. You gotta read it.
SPEAKER_05We could have tried. Um there were just no other good stories.
SPEAKER_04Well, there wasn't much anything else, but I did want to I read this this morning, I was like, man, this whole the whole framing's off. But and recently something has happened which made us realize to our horror that the whole lengthy discourse on the sonatal process is intended to provide a tool for justifying anything. At the end of Section D, we mentioned study groups. Now, the final report on group nine has been published in which, assuming arbitrarily, that the Sonatal method is sacrosanct when it comes to the study of homosexuality, they reach the conclusion that the sexual act between a homosexual couple is a gift from God.
SPEAKER_04Is this uh is this not blasphemy? It's a good question. Is it blasphemy?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, right?
SPEAKER_04Because like marriage is so intrinsically tied to the Trinity. Like Saint Paul uses marriage as the symbol for us to see as the union between Christ, the bridegroom, and the church. So it's definitely a version of blasphemy, that's for sure. Well, blasphemy just in the sense of something sacred, blaspheming something sacred. Like it doesn't have to be against God or something.
SPEAKER_05Like you could blaspheme against the saints, you could blaspheme against anything because uh as they relate to God, yeah.
SPEAKER_04100%. Um, they've reached the conclusion that the sexual act between a same-sex couple is a gift from God. Man, is this not blasphemy? It is incredible that such a thing could appear in a publication issued by the Holy See. I agree. Like enraging. It should scandalize everyone. Confusion has reigned for years, but now it has reached the bottom. The groups are supposed to limit the results of their study to the Pope. Now the Pope is Pope Leo. Did he see the report before its publication? And did he give his consent?
SPEAKER_04Of course. Of course. All this stuff, like all this stuff. Like anybody that doesn't like the people that think I mean I hope nobody in our audience you guys know Leo is the same thing, right? It's the same thing. It's just it's it's Francis, just you know, a little a little more finesse.
SPEAKER_05Uh everything, I guess the difference, and I guess I I guess it's a difference I feel more than anything, like there's no real evidence for, but like uh Francis felt like he was gonna shove it down your throat no matter what, right? Like he like he was an ideologue in the sense of like Lenin or Trotsky, you know.
SPEAKER_05Uh whereas Leo feels more like he just thinks that's what Catholicism actually is, whereas Francis was gonna make Catholicism that no matter what. Yeah, you know, so like I don't disagree that they're that in many ways they're largely similar. I just think there's maybe a lot more malice to Francis.
SPEAKER_04Um I have a I have a priest friend. Uh he's never been on the show, uh, so it's not a priest that's been on this show. He's a he's a diocesan priest, not even a traditional priest. He um he is a traditional priest. I don't want to say that. He's he's he's he's a but he's a diocesan priest. He uh early on in Leo's papacy, he was telling me Leo is far more dangerous than Francis. And like this isn't some super trad SSPX priest, it's just a diocesan priest, and he's like, I'm telling you, Leo is far more dangerous than Francis was.
SPEAKER_04And it's because Francis raised alarm bells, yeah, and everybody was like, Oh my goodness, but Leo is so much more subtle, but it's the same thing, it's it's it's it's the same thing we're always saying about like the conservative who's pushing feminism is where you know it's well what it's it's it's the it's the problem with the Republican Party, for instance, right?
SPEAKER_05Like it's the fact that uh that they're the lesser evil, right? So it's it's a it's a far more insidious um evil that that like just leeches into it, you know, instead of instead of forcing it, it just slowly infects it.
SPEAKER_04Um we knew this was gonna happen. Francis chose 80% of the cardinal electors, it was always going to happen. There really was never any doubt. Yeah, no, I I um it's look, the revolution continues, guys. It's not gonna it's not gonna get any better. Um so everything that happens in the church falls under the jurisdiction of the reigning pope. He could even cut short an ongoing ecumenical council. There's a saying, no pope rules from the grave. Um, so by the way, during the Jubilee year, there was that triumphal entry into St.
SPEAKER_04Peter's, which was obviously a pride parade, a true desecration of the basilica, and yet no protest from the Holy See. The only protest from the Holy See is when the S Moran Pontifican pilgrimage comes through. F. It is said that the doctrine of the faith does not consist solely of sexual morality. This is true. The most important thing is the love of God, yet no one rejects God for no reason. Rather, it is always because one is drawn towards some other values, one ends up worshiping another false divinity.
SPEAKER_05100%, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Uh St. Paul in his letter to the Romans says that the most obvious sign of the rejection of God is precisely this sin of homosexuality.
SPEAKER_05I mean, it goes against nature itself.
SPEAKER_04In in Romans, in Romans, when Saint Paul describes what happens to a person who falls into sin, like the final thing is you're so like your like sin clouds the intellect so much so that you man exchanges natural love for a woman for a man. Like that's what and it's Romans 1. I mean, if you guys have never read Romans 1, go and read it. It's it's Paul just describes exactly what happens to the reprobate mind.
SPEAKER_04Keep it up, let's keep going. Um, the enemies of God, the three enemies of our salvation are our passions, the world, and the devil. Sin, the flesh, and the devil, right? Uh, but where does the destruction of God and souls begin? Precisely with this deviation from sexual morality. For concupiscence lies within our flesh, and when indulged, it becomes an addiction, causing us to lose the power of the will. That is why even the devil says that the most important thing is to destroy the family. Moreover, it is not true that we insist solely on sexual morality.
SPEAKER_04The question of the church's hierarchical structure is far more important. I want to say, like, a lot of almost everything he's saying here is 100% spot on, like, fully in agreement. My my biggest issue is how he was framing it like John Paul II and Benedict were stalwarts of orthodoxy, and then it all just kind of devolved under Francis and Leo. Well, and that's just not the case.
SPEAKER_05I think if you here he he is putting sexual morality as like the almost like the central issue of of uh of our time, right? And if it well, and I agree with yeah, I agree with that, but if you think about it, those were issues that JP2 did fight oh he was very strongly, you know, very strongly. So so if if if Zen sees that uh as the central issue that he's worried about, and that Francis pushed very strongly in the opposite direction, then I can see why he sees JP2 as a stalwart of orthodoxy in that sense.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, look, John Paul II and Benedict both were very strong on this issue in terms of saying in terms of saying you can't even support civil unions as a Catholic. Like you can't you can't even support civil unions, where Francis comes in and he's like, Well, you know, I think we could have civil unions as a compromise.
SPEAKER_05And even go up for communion if you want to.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, that was the like some of the most destructive stuff Francis did was basically say, Hey, if you're immortal sin, go ahead and receive communion. Like the the level of sacrilege giving permission by the Pope is insane. So I do see why these guys see it as a rupture, you know. I do see why they think that this is a rupture. The the the thing is, even what John Paul II allowed for the divorce and remarried was wrong. Like realistically, right?
SPEAKER_04So John Paul II allowed for couples who were divorced and remarried without an annulment. If you were living as brother and sister, you could then go up and receive communion. But really, no couple that's divorced and remarried is living as brother and sister.
SPEAKER_05It's basically well, even if they are it's scandalous. If they haven't had an annulment, that's an invalid marriage. Like, like like me as a cradle Catholic, when I when I had my wedding, you know, to to my wife, my my first wedding, if if you want to call if you want to look at it that way, um, it was an invalid marriage, and that by itself would have, you know, stopped me from should have stopped me from going up to communion.
SPEAKER_04Right, but what what I'm like it like you'd never have heard one of the preconciliar popes give that allowance, right? But it was JP2's way of showing mercy while keeping the church's teaching intact that you're like you're in an invalid marriage, you're living in adultery. But if you're living as brother and sister, you're not committing the sin of adultery because you're not sleeping together, then that's you know, that's that's the exception. So it was like the church could keep its teaching on marriage, the church could say you still can't, but you then start the annulment factory to make it even easier for people to retain or to attain those annulments.
SPEAKER_04But in reality, it's it's wrong to even like if you're living, if you're divorced, never got an annulment, and remarried, and then have a conversion, like the idea of living with this new spouse or this new person, it's an adulterous relationship, it causes scandal, so it should not really be allowed, but it was a way for for John Paul to show mercy, you know, and it was also like a wink and a nudge. It's like, yeah, we know you guys are we know you guys are doing what you're doing behind the closed doors, but at least you know you could tell people it it's to it's to avoid scandal by you know, if you're going up and receiving, you just tell people they have a limited brother and sister, I guess.
SPEAKER_04I don't know. That's just kind of my thought on it. But um, moreover, it is not true that we insist solely on sexual morality. Did I read that already? Uh uh no, you don't. The church, the question of the church's hierarchical structure is far more fundamental today. Jesus founded the church upon the apostles with Peter as their head. Now the church must be guided by the bishops with the Pope at their head. But the entire course of the recent synod on synodality ignores the importance of the bishops. It is no longer a true synod by emphasizing the etymological meaning of the word synodality as traveling together or participation.
SPEAKER_04Significance of the historical reality of synods has been sidelined, synods and councils of bishops within the church and the synod presided over by the bishop within the diocese. What else we got? Uh uh with the conclusion of the second session of the synod, a final document was approved, which Pope Francis has incorporated into his own magisterium. He stated that it is not strictly normative, rather, each episcopal conference is to implement it experimentally. Like, this is all stuff that is so foreign to the nature of the church and the church's real ecclesiology.
SPEAKER_04Like, all this stuff is bizarre. Uh, each each conference should implement it experimentally in the matter deemed most appropriate for its own local culture, but in this way, we will end up resembling the Anglicans. No offense intended towards the Anglicans, but we are different. Like you could you saw not even that, even when they tried to have these local synodal meetings, like there was no interest in it. Nobody cares about this. It's something coming down from the top. This it's very similar to the Reformation in England.
SPEAKER_04It wasn't some grassroots reformation, it was lorded on from on top. They took away people's traditions, they took away their culture, they took away everything. And then they killed 750 Catholics a year because they force fed this new thing down their throats, and it took generations before it stuck. The world is in a state of great confusion. I was not present at the recent consistory in June, but I noted from the press that during the discussion on the question in what kind of world are we to carry out our mission today, many cardinals remarked that the fundamental problem is the loss of meaning, which is why an ever-increasing number of young people are taking their own lives.
SPEAKER_04We possess the solid doctrine that gives I I watched Anthony Stein read that this morning, and he's like, He's like, which is why an ever increasing number of young people leave this mortal coil. Like, why not just why not just say people think it's it's not 2020 anymore.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, he's still acting like it's 2020. Like we I I make joke about we make jokes about the Jews all the time, and it doesn't matter anymore, man.
SPEAKER_04If our channel isn't restricted, I promise you, man, you can say people taking their own lives.
SPEAKER_05And you know what? And when you say it, you're not going to be shadow banned. If you think you're shadow banned, people just are watching your show. Like, come on.
SPEAKER_04We possess the solid doctrine that gives meaning to life. For we know that God created us for eternal life. This truth resides within the Catholic Church, but only if people only if the Catholic Church remains faithful to the entirety of the doctrine handed down from the apostles. Um he go, he gets into look how long is this thing? This is like a book.
SPEAKER_05Uh when you say hold on, hold on. Hold on. Do you see on the far right? Do you hold on? Do you see my mouse? See this right here?
SPEAKER_04No, we're not going through the whole thing, guys. I'm sorry. It's just been in over an hour already. Yeah, we're not going through this whole thing. So um he ends up going into like talking about Fernandez and stuff. What is all the fuss about Fernandez and Buenos Aires? Is that where they are? Is that where Leo is right now? Buenos Aires? Argentina.
SPEAKER_05No, no, he's he he was in uh not um he was in a uh one of them to the west of that, not Argentina.
SPEAKER_04South American countries, Paraguay, Ecuador, Peru.
SPEAKER_05I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Paraguay's in mayhem right now. I don't know. He's down there. You know what you know the political situation of Paraguay? They just had the banking system collapse. Was it Paraguay? Yeah, that was Paraguay. They're like losing their crap over there. Peru or Uruguay? I don't know, whatever. He's down somewhere. He's down somewhere down there where they speak Mexican. Um what you know.
SPEAKER_05I wish he had been in Brazil because then it would have been funny, because then it would be Portuguese, but whatever.
SPEAKER_04Uh, what is the what is all the protests about Tuco down there?
SPEAKER_05Well, so didn't some I just saw a tweet today. Uh some former, yeah, it did shock me. Some the archbishop, and maybe it was the arch uh bishop of the same archdiocese Francis has been bishop had was archbishop of, but some archbishop just just died, and some people were thinking it was in suspicious circumstances. From Tuco? Tuco pulled a hit. No, I don't know, but I don't know.
SPEAKER_04I have no idea. Are we back to like are we back to uh Borgia days? That would be awesome.
SPEAKER_03Then he says, Mexican.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, for a second, I was like, Are you sure you're at? That's like, oh yeah, no, that's definitely ant.
SPEAKER_04All right. Well, look, things are a mess. We remain in the church, we remain steadfast Catholics. We love being Catholic. This is a great time to be Catholic, guys. Look at all this fun. stuff we get to discuss so we're gonna go over the locals we got a bunch of stuff to do with locals i have the so i'm gonna play uh i'm gonna play just a normal outro here on youtube but then before we start on locals on locals i have a special intro i made that i can't play here because it will be copyrighted but i i just and yes this this is a shot at taffy taffy i want you to recognize that okay uh before we go uh we are going to be talking about the the Fred situation oh wait real quick put that put that uh I put a screenshot of the Poplio tweet up put that up real quick hold on which before we go to the other side because this is something I want to talk about like do you want up Poplio put up two tweets one to mothers and grandmothers and one to fathers and grandfathers and just look look at the sissification of how look at the kid gloves women get treated with versus how men get treated right mothers and grandmothers never tire of passing on the faith preach with your lives as well as with your words insist on prayer love and hope do so with patience without discouragement even if your loved ones seem far from God continue to place them before him there are doors that you cannot open but God can men I would like also to address the fathers and grandfathers young people need to say uh need to see that you pray receive the sacraments treat your wives with respect ask for forgiveness and live with integrity even when doing so requires sacrifice children learn a great deal by seeing their dad that their father can kneel before God without feeling he is any less of a man for doing it why aren't why doesn't he tell wives respect your husbands wives obey your husbands you know like like either one on its own oops either one on its own completely fine obviously but yeah the the the that the dichotomy there especially by putting one as a reply to the other it's like it in uh you know maybe maybe the social situation in Uruguay is is different from it is here but look you could read that charitably I'm just tired of the kid gloves for women women are not held to any account I was speaking with a friend right before the show and uh I was just saying how like women can do the most evil thing and including strangle them with exercise bands.
SPEAKER_04And we look to and we look to like normalize it. No like literally rob a man of his entire family in life and it's just like you go girl. You just did the most you're a homicidal maniac in that sense you rob the man of everything and you get a you get praise for it. It's just insane how women are just not held to any account by any of the men ever we could talk we could talk Megan Kelly on the other side trash bag um so yeah we're gonna talk about Fred on the other side uh we're gonna for those of you who don't know who Fred is you'll think maybe maybe we'll tell you on the other side no we're gonna get into Fred on the other side um but also I had other stuff too uh oh we'll talk about the St.
SPEAKER_04Nicholas relics being stolen and burned um and we could have done three hours on YouTube tonight because you also have uh in Portland Oregon Archbishop Stample is banning the Iran's position which is hilarious I love to see it the Iran's position is actually an organic development of the novice order. It is yeah I bet Fred loves it some of the charismatic ways you know he you know he does some hand raising Fred loves when the girls put their hands over him and pray over him oh man um all right we are going to go to the other side and then there's uh man that one tweet the guy wrote uh I got it we'll do it on the other side but uh yeah so uh for those of you who want to see the intro I can't play here come over to locals and even if you're not a paid supporter you'll be able to see at least that much on locals before we turn it over to money um yeah you can give again if you want to sign up for the free version of locals before we put it behind the ad wall if you want to see the if you want to see the video Rob will leave it up and we won't put the paywall up until after the video's done so if you're not a locals member go sign up for the free version and while you're there stop being cheap just throw five bucks up are you kidding me you people it's still five dollars you have one month left to get the five dollar version January 1st rate to go about you know if we're gonna be accused of grifting and have people email our sponsors we might as well up the price a little moving up listen to me I see what other people are charging and we're worth way more than them that's all I'll have to say about that.
SPEAKER_04So all right we're going to the other side take us out Rob
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! One viral clip trashes the Knights of Columbus as a boomer “wife guy”...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! You can feel it after this election: the old scripts are breaking. We sit...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! That new trailer moment where Christian TV starts to look like superhero...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A single word can flip a villain into a victim, and that’s what sent us...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A packed auditorium, a national candidate, and one question that made the...