Rome Has Spoken: The Pope Who Fought Capitalism AND Communism | Rerum Novarum Part 1
1 hr 22 minAudio
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A pope under siege, with no army and no worldly leverage, writes a letter that rattles the rising powers of modern life. Rerum Novarum is Pope Leo XIII’s answer to an age that demanded a choice between two harsh gods: the factory that grinds families down for profit, or the revolution that promises paradise through blood and the abolition of ownership. We read it as a direct challenge to both, and as the clearest Catholic statement on money, work, and human dignity in centuries. We start with the world Leo is writing into: the industrial revolution’s wealth built on long shifts, child labor, dangerous factories, and slums where disease spreads fast and families break under pressure. That misery helps explain why Marxism sounds so seductive to the worker, yet Leo insists the socialist “cure” trades one master for another. Then we turn the spotlight where many modern conservatives don’t expect it: Leo’s warnings about unchecked competition, inhuman treatment of labor, and the shocking claim that even a mutually agreed wage can still be unjust. From there, we lay out the Catholic third way that doesn’t fit neatly on today’s political spectrum: private property as a natural right, property as stewardship with obligations, the dignity of labor, the just wage and family wage, unions and associations, and a limited state guided by the moral law. We also connect it to a very current question: if AI disrupts work at scale, what happens when a culture built on career as identity runs out of jobs to worship? Subscribe for the second part, share this with a friend who’s stuck in the capitalism vs socialism trap, and leave a review with the one line from Rerum Novarum you think every worker and employer needs to hear. Support the show Get 10% off an amazing Black Monk Rosary by going to https://www.blackmonkrosaries.com/?ref=AVOIDINGBABYLON and using code AVOIDINGBABYLON at checkout! Check out our sponsor, Nic Nac, at www.nicnac.com and use code "AB25%" for 25% off of your first order! Please subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKsxnv80ByFV4OGvt_kImjQ?sub_confirmation=1 https://www.avoidingbabylon.com Merchandise: https://avoiding-babylon-shop.fourthwall.com Locals Community: https://avoidingbabylon.locals.com Full Premium/Locals Shows on Audio Podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1987412/subscribe RSS Feed for Podcast Apps: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1987412.rss
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00In eighteen ninety-one, an eighty-one-year-old man who had spent the last twenty years as a prisoner inside his own city, with no army, no kingdom, no power that any government on earth was obligated to respect, sat down and wrote a letter that terrified the most powerful economic movements in human history. Not with a threat, not with an army, but with an argument. On one side of him stood the factory, the new god of the age, grinding men, women, and children through sixteen-hour days for wages that couldn't keep them alive, and calling it progress.
SPEAKER_00On the other side stood the revolution. Marx was dead, but a specter was marching across Europe, promising the worker paradise on the far side of blood, and telling him the only way to be free was to burn it all down and abolish the very idea of owning anything. Two answers the factory and the revolution. Greed on one hand and envy on the other. And the whole modern world was convinced that you had to pick one. Pope Leo XIII looked at both and said, You're both wrong.
SPEAKER_00And I'm going to show you a third way that is older than both of you. He called it Rerum Navarum of Revolutionary Change. And it is quite simply the most important thing the Catholic Church has said about money, work, and human dignity in the last 500 years.
SPEAKER_01That uh what a that was a great intro. Um this uh this is I was just telling Rob this encyclical series. Well, first off, locals is down. Let's go on a local.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm going to have to make a I'll make a new uh local, I'll make a new video uh Yeah, we we are doing locals tonight.
SPEAKER_01Um I'll make one before we go there. Yeah, before we go there, Rob will pop another one up. Um the uh because we definitely have some stuff we have to get get to over there. It was uh Michael Knowles drama and the Reese Soul's dad drama. I definitely won't want to talk about. Um, but uh this encyclical series it in some ways it's depressing um because you're reading some of the most amazing things. Like it's it's like the church at her in her glory, you know. You're this magisterium is just impeccable.
SPEAKER_01And when you compare it to what we're dealing with today, it's kind of uh, you know, you get a knot in your stomach. But I was supposed to be preparing for Rerum Navarum, and I have uh I have this book, The Church Speaks to the Modern World, which is basically a corpus of all of Leo the 13 social teachings, and I started reading the one on Christian marriage, and I'm stunned by it. So I think we're gonna have to double back and do that one after this. So the encyclical series is going to continue. I like we thought this might be the like the pinnacle of it, and maybe we'll give it a rest for a while.
SPEAKER_01But I think uh we may maybe not as steady as every week, but I definitely want to keep doing these. Yeah, agreed. Um uh uh Rob's got a pretty decently long um historical. It's not really a historical context, he was saying this, but he has a pretty long we've covered so you know the history, basically all the events up to here, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So it's gonna be less about the historical events, more about the economic changes that had happened during the 19th century, you know, Marxism, capitalism, industrialism. Um, and then I want to look at really actually the 20th century and the effects that Rarum Navarum um has on the 20th century, and we'll probably do that even more so when we do um quadruguesimo ano. Um, but we'll at least touch on it a little here.
SPEAKER_01Before we even jump into into that, what I like the few things that stood out to me like this this whole encyclical is a condemnation of socialism, right? Like it's it's essentially this huge condemnation of socialism, but then it has these warnings and these things to look out for in capitalism as well. It's not just a condemnation of socialism, and you but you can also see where people twist the things of Leo, and you you get a lot of the modern uh like like twisting of some of the things where you get social justice warriors from, and you could see even the modern hierarchy just uh is obsessed with this idea of social justice and all this stuff, and it's a very naturalist view of some of the things that Leo does point out that are actually super important, but he's always keeping your focus on the moral law and the importance of religion at the centerpiece of all of this stuff, and uh it's it's it's just kind of sad to to see how that's been twisted in our modern in our modern era, and I think we see even um American so-called conservative Catholics twist this encyclical right as only a condemnation of socialism when really it does it doesn't you know fully condemn capitalism, but um it condemns the way capitalism works in America, and there's some really dangerous things about capitalism, and the whole the whole thing is basically the relationship between labor and um and capital, right?
SPEAKER_01Like it's it's between your work and how you're paid for it. And it, I mean, it's there were so many things that even every time I read a Leo the 13th encyclical, I just see how brainwashed we are as Americans, and so many of the things that you just like you just were instilled in you as a child because you're an American and you you know you think the free market is everything, and it's just it's yeah, there's there's some really there's some tough things in this encyclical that us as Americans are gonna have there, we're gonna be challenged with.
SPEAKER_01Um, there's also something really interesting in that I think this is the first time that property was seen as a natural right.
SPEAKER_00Um like I mean, no, because because Aquinas saw it as that, and that's I don't know if you think in depth the way Leo did, though.
SPEAKER_01Like Leo really saw like private property as a natural right, like you you have a right to not just like the fruits of the soil, but the soil itself, you know. Like, I don't know. There's so there's so many things in this that are just that really stood out to me that like I don't I don't I mean I'm not an Aquinas, right? Uh you know, I don't not I never studied Aquinas like that, but I think it might be the first kind of the first time really in history where the church needed to enunciate such a right.
SPEAKER_00I think it was kind of common sense almost before that because you know, even in the like the Middle Ages, there was uh not only did you have private property, you had common property, right? That like there was whole, you know, the like um the commons, the common area of a village was literally property that everyone had you know owned together in a in a sense.
SPEAKER_01Um yeah, so but so well the uh the the the book I have gives a summary of each chapter. So here's the thing Rob's thing's gonna be pretty long tonight, so this might have to be a two-part episode. Um, and there's so much to highlight in the encyclical that we might just have to read through entire paragraphs, and like so. I don't know how much of the actual encyclical we'll get to tonight. This is going to be a two-part episode. Um, and we I know I know locals is down.
SPEAKER_01We are going to do an local stream in the future.
SPEAKER_00Once we're done here on YouTube, check over at locals. I'll pop up a new new episode over there that you can all click into.
SPEAKER_01So um, like the basically the the first three chapters are um just discussing the evils of socialism, and then in chapter three, I mean, right off in chapter three, he's like, We're uh workers are no longer protected by the ancient guilds or by the moral authority of the church, and the practice of usury has reduced the masses to a condition little better than that of a slave. Like, there's so much in this that we have to really get into, and then in chapter four, he really starts taking off with stuff.
SPEAKER_01So we'll we'll let Rob do the uh historical context and the implications of that historic, like the implications of the encyclical and how they play out, and we'll see where we get. Like, we might get a few chapters in tonight, and then next week we'll probably just dive into the encyclical and just spend some time going through some of the more challenging things and maybe getting some feedback from you guys and seeing what you think.
SPEAKER_00And I I think um I think this is an important encyclical, especially considering the upheavals we're seeing kind of in labor right now with AI, right? So I think I think it I think we should all kind of keep that in the back of our mind while we talk through this stuff because in a lot of ways it's very similar to the the upheavals that were happening.
SPEAKER_01And also also, like um, what I like the way Leo puts how much people wrap their worth up in material things, like yeah, we we all wrap our worth into material things and how much money we're making. And like every young guy today is like, I'll never own a home and all this stuff. And he he he just talks really uh like a really important part of what what he talks about is um I highlighted it.
SPEAKER_01Let me just see if I can find it real quick because the true, yeah, the true worth of a man lies in his virtues, not in his wealth. Like the the that's in chapter 21. Like when we get to chapter 21, I really want to dig into that because so much of so much of what our culture has done is take God out of the picture and made your career and what you do as it's like that's what is supposed to bring meaning to our lives.
SPEAKER_01And if we're moving into this age of AI where all of our jobs could be on the line and like society's about to face this huge upheaval, where are we going to find our meaning?
SPEAKER_00And I feel it doesn't just think about how society uses the word vocation, yeah. Right? Like a like uh a vocation is is is a higher calling, you know, is your your path to heaven, basically. Yeah, not what you do for a living.
SPEAKER_01We can definitely talk about the pink speed boat on the other side, okay? Because yeah, I yeah, you do not know how mortifying it is to be on a pink speed boat. I'm just telling you.
SPEAKER_00Is it still mortifying if you're going 100 miles an hour?
SPEAKER_01Listen, we'll talk on the other side. Okay. I'm not, I don't know. Family could possibly stumble upon this. We'll do it on the other side. Um that boat, man. Oh my goodness. Um, yeah, I just think uh they've done everything they can to remove religion and to remove God from from the from the public sphere. And now we're facing this thing where people have wrapped their worth and meaning up in their career and in their vocation, you know, things like that.
SPEAKER_01And now when that's going to be taken away, like we are going to be that phrase, the meaning crisis, has been thrown around a lot in the past few years. We are going to be facing a meaning crisis that is so catastrophic that if we don't find our value and worth in God and in our virtue, like that is really what makes a man and a woman. Like, I don't want to be that sexist. Like, like mankind, our worth is actually wrapped up in our virtue. Oh man, I also have um uh confession update from the last episode.
SPEAKER_01I went to confession.
SPEAKER_00You're not supposed to give us updates on that stuff. I well, I I have I'm gonna I'm gonna make another lobbyist confession. The drinking, yeah.
SPEAKER_01The drinking remember that yeah, so I have an update on that. I did yeah, yeah, because my last penance I didn't do, so I have an update on that. Uh, before we jump into it, Rob, Rob has a really amazing um uh knickknack success story. It's kind of touching. I've been I've been getting people um messaging me knickknack success stories, and they're pretty awesome. Uh a lot of them are uh young, young couples that are having uh babies, and I'm really excited about that.
SPEAKER_01But listen to this one.
SPEAKER_00So this is this is from uh someone in the the telegram group group. So if you're a locals member and or not in the telegram group yet, get in there. But so he says, I have a knick-knack uh success story. I, a knick-knack enjoyer, of course, prayed this morning with my wife for our friend's ex uh Jehovah's Witness mother, who was on her deathbed. She had been attending mass and praying with her daughter for months until this. We just got a call that the priest came, baptized her, confirmed her, and gave her holy communion.
SPEAKER_00She was miraculously in a state of mind to be able to truly say yes to every question on the right, and she will die a Catholic.
SPEAKER_01All thanks to Knick Knack. Look, Knick knack's out here saving souls. I got another one here. This is a Knick knack baby, it's a real thing, doing the full praise be Jesus Christ. I got everybody out here telling me that Knick knacks are a fertility wonder drug converting souls out here. I know we're not, we're gonna get sued one day for this.
SPEAKER_00Caleb, Caleb from Knick Knack. If you're listening, you should have a little baby knick knack onesies made for any babies born due to Knickknack.
SPEAKER_01Not a bad idea. And I saw they just they they just sent that a care package for Rob and I. I have to actually get uh Christian uh Bergsma a package. Uh he he texted me. He's like, yo, what's up with my knick knacks? So uh Knicknacks is sending uh care package to Rob and I. I see they they sent some swag in there also. I got my so go to knicknack.com, use code ab25 for 25 off your first purchase, use code ab 10 for 10 off all subsequent purchases and black monk rosaries.
SPEAKER_01Man, black monk rosaries, you were my penance this week. Thank you, boys. Sending that black monk rosary over. Got to make up for my shortcomings on the on the last one, but uh black monk rosary. Yeah, I love even hanging it in my truck. It's something that people always ask me about because it's just so big.
SPEAKER_00Uh I uh I prayed my black monk rosary at the uh the worst supposedly somewhat Catholic funeral service I've ever been to. Uh got a horror story over there.
SPEAKER_01You also visited the parish where the uh the the kid shot the Annunciation uh shooting. Yeah, I visited that parish this weekend too. Yeah, so all right. So go to blackmonkrosaries.com, use code of voting babylon at checkout, and you'll get 10% off there. We love black monk rosaries. If you don't pray your black monk rosary, you're not on the team. So all right, Rob, take us on a journey, brother. Let's go.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so uh most of you have at least watched a few of these encyclical episodes. Um, so you probably know uh Lee Pope Leo the Thirteenth pretty well so far. Um, and we've kind of been watching him build well, we've been watching him build his magisterium, basically. Um, you know, he started with Attorney Patras, where he rearms the Catholic mind by bringing back Aquinas. Then with Humanum Genus, he names the enemy, you know, basically uh Freemasonry and at least the Masonic ideals.
SPEAKER_00And then with Immortality Day, the last one, he kind of drew the blueprint and told nations that they owed a duty to God. Um, you you know, most most pontificates, uh, especially these days, if they had just one of those, it would be the best pontificate in the last 80 years. But uh so the you think with those three he would have he'd he'd say that was enough, but no. Um so he he understood something that uh he understood something that m many critics of his never really did.
SPEAKER_00He understood that you can't you can't tell um a man who's starving or struggling in his daily life that his nation owes a duty to God while you also ignore that he's being worked to death for pennies, right? No one's gonna listen. The the Catholic laity aren't gonna listen if you're ignoring the the difficulties that they go through uh uh in their daily life, and maybe people in Rome should listen to that, but um yeah, so basically, doctrine that floats above the factory floor isn't doctrine, it's just kind of decoration at that point.
SPEAKER_01So in 1891, uh I'm sorry, dude. I know this this this episode is gonna take forever just because you just that's fine, yeah. You just made me think of something. Like, you see how Leo's like in tune with what's going on, like he's in tune, and and just like what you just said, like he understands that if the church doesn't speak to this stuff, the revolutionaries are going to capture the people, right? And the situation we're in now, like you're you're seeing our culture is kind of sucked into this OnlyFans and this social media, like this mind-draining culture.
SPEAKER_01And when Pope Leo the 14th is asked about this, he's like, Well, I think the church needs to talk about other things. Like, he doesn't, he doesn't look like uh to me, I think the number one thing facing our youth right now are the garbage that they're looking at on the internet, and I think the church desperately needs to see so much of the like depression and anxiety young people are facing, are because they're looking at these images online, and and the church just because they are so afraid to touch any kind of sexual ethics questions these days, like they're just losing the church, they're losing the youth, they're losing that and they're leaving it to people like you and I to discuss this stuff with people.
SPEAKER_01So I don't know, it just kind of came to my mind when you were saying that like the church.
SPEAKER_00Or when they when uh Francis especially, you know, comes out with uh what was the one on uh on nature? Oh, I forgot. What was it called? Uh not for Telly Tutti.
SPEAKER_01The uh there was uh oh well oh yeah, Morris, not a Morris. Uh no, yeah, the one of the one about the the the global warming. Like to see, there you go.
SPEAKER_00Like you for a Francis encyclical, it didn't have a ton of super crazy stuff in it, right? Yeah, but like I'm sorry, our daily lives, uh your average Catholic doesn't need to know how to be a better environmentalist. That's not what we're struggling with.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I mean the church could speak to like having a a uh an attitude of like conservation, right? Like we should care for our local environment, like that is actually super important. We are stewards of our of our of our land, right? So you should absolutely care about your local waterways and polluting and things like that. But like this idea of global warming and climate change, and like it's it was just so beyond the scope of what your average Catholic cares about, unless you're a leftist lunatic. So yeah, no point.
SPEAKER_00Um, anyway, so in 1891, Leo moves. You know, we talked he he re-rearmed the Catholic mind, he named the enemy, he talked about Catholic states, but this time he wants to talk about the worker, the actual human being with a wife and children and rent he couldn't pay. He's standing in the wreckage that the modern economy had made of his life. And um, Rare of Navarum is where Leo, who in a sense, he on one hand is the like the loftiest pope of the 19th century, right?
SPEAKER_00With with that with a lot of his doctrine, he like you said, he he was able to reach all the way down to the the lowest man on the industrial ladder and say to him that you have dignity and I'm going to prove it. And that's what he does in in Rare Navarum, you know, and it's it's it's gotta be one of the most talked about encyclicals today. It's it's 130 years later, you know. Like we talk about more, we talk about rare Navarro more than most of uh John Paul's encyclical for sure.
SPEAKER_01Maybe, maybe, um um maybe Veritata's splendor is uh is up there because it was like Veritata's Splendor was kind of like John Paul II putting his foot down on some moral questions that were being like ambiguously put out during his pontificate, and it was kind of a a monumental um and we we maybe we'll do that one day too, because there was so much nonsense in the air, and John Paul II was just kind of like no no no, there is truth in you know, so all right, yeah.
SPEAKER_00But to your point, and I mean that there's been two more encyclicals written specifically about Herm Navarum since then. So I'm sure we'll get to those.
SPEAKER_01Leo the fourteenth's encyclical is kind of like an extension of it, like yeah, kind of first when he just came out, it was kind of like an extension of it in some way.
SPEAKER_00Um So to really understand Rarum Navarum, you you have to really understand the world it's written into. Um, and I'm not talking about like we've already talked about so much of the the history, at least like geopolitically and and the the politics in Rome and stuff like that, but you know, we you have to really understand like what the way the world was for the average person at the time. So the industrial revolution had started in Britain around the 1760s, so about 130 years before this, before this period, and it had spread across Europe in America, and it it created staggering wealth.
SPEAKER_00I mean, don't get me wrong, you know, obviously it did railroads, factories, steel, mass production, you know, the like the the original billionaire class comes a little bit after this, but you know, like JP Morgan, uh Carnegie, Rockefeller, you know, um all those guys come out of the the industrial revolution, and that they had fortunes the world had never even imagined possible.
SPEAKER_01And you want to know what's interesting? Did you see um did you see Hillary White posted uh a graph today showing birth rates declining, not from the sexual revolution, but from the industrial revolution.
SPEAKER_00Industrial revolution.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I've seen the like I've seen that before, but yeah, yeah, it's not everybody thinks like uh like um artificial contraception and stuff was what led to the decline in birth rates, but the industrial revolution was catastrophic for families.
SPEAKER_00I and I think it's people were torn out of the the countryside, right? Um, the because common property, the commons that that that notion really was destroyed by like absolute you know monarchy and stuff. Um and so they they had to move to cities to to survive because they know they could no longer work the common property. So they're torn from their homes, from their villages, from from where their family had been, you know, for probably a millennia, and um forced into the cities, into squalor, into terrible jobs.
SPEAKER_00You know, not only they don't not only do they have to work, obviously, their wife has to work, their children, like little children have to work just for them to survive in the worst possible conditions imaginable. You know, like I why would you not have less kids?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, in a sense if you're not if you're yeah, and and and you also see like the the moral decline starts from back then too, right? Like it's not just it's not just in the like the sexual revolution didn't come out of nowhere, like it the moral decline starts all the way back in the 1800s, and it's just this steady decline. The 1920s are called the roaring 20s for a reason. They have all these speakeasies, everybody's like sexual promiscuity is rampant way before the sexual revolution. The sexual revolution was just the public coming out of it, but people are starting to do this stuff as soon as women are introduced into these factories, and as soon as they're leaving their home and getting pushed out into the industrial revolution, it's when you start family.
SPEAKER_00Well, and you know, like you mentioned the roaring 20s with the speakeasy speakeasies, like those speakeasies existed because of prohibition, and prohibition then comes from the temperance movement. And yeah, you know, the whole the whole Tito Taler temperance stuff seems silly to us Catholics, but like there was a reason for it, there was a reason that movement had gained so much traction. It's because a a large people were really drinking way too much, and it was because he had to dull them, they had to dull themselves because of the conditions they were living in, you know.
SPEAKER_01You go back to Cardinal Manning. Cardinal Manning, like everybody's talking about like all like that. Was like the Newman versus Manning debate. Newman was like at the universities and he's teaching all this stuff, and it's like this highbrow Catholicism, and it's the intellectual Catholicism. And Manning is on the ground, and he's like, the biggest thing facing our society right now is alcoholism. Like, he really thought alcoholism was destroying families. Men were becoming savages because of their because of their drinking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, yeah, like you said, a lot of it starts a lot earlier than we tend to think. I okay, I deleted the stream because it wasn't working. We're gonna have to watch here, and then when we're done with the public section, I will create a new one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so there is a local show tonight. Go ahead, Rob. I keep you know interrupting you, we'll never get through this. Okay, well, that's why we wanted to split it into two because that has to be, yeah, because you're gonna say stuff that I'm gonna jump in on, so we'll go.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so uh industrial revolution created a ton of wealth, but you know that that what it was built on is men, women, and well, like I said, little children working 12 to 16 hours a day in mines and in factories that maimed and killed them on a pretty regular schedule, and they were working for wages so low that entire families, once again, including the children, had to work just so they didn't starve. They had been pulled off their land, they'd been pulled out of their villages, packed into these squalid industrial cities.
SPEAKER_00I mean, you know, the move the the movies of industrial uh London um like uh like what you see in um Sherlock Holmes or uh Sweeney Todd or any movie set in London in the 1800s, like that that was reality, like it was black smoke and smog and soot all over. Um, yeah, I mean they lived in slums with no sanitation, you know. You had cholera epidemics running through London basically left and right all the time.
SPEAKER_00Um, disease, you know, was running through them like water, and families were just breaking apart under the sheer weight of everything, and all this all the all this change were happening, you know. Today it would maybe feel slow compared to the change we live through now, but the these changes were happening in a few decades, you know, within the course of a single generation.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, bro. You had a thousand, like if it's 17 or 1800 years of people getting around on horses, right? And then all of a sudden, this industrial revolution happens, the train gets invented, it's like the automobile is on the verge of becoming like a commonplace thing. It's just so much change is happening so rapidly. I know the car is a little later, but you know what I mean. Like there's just such rapid change happening that people are they think the future is here, yeah.
SPEAKER_00And and Leo Leo um is is able to to describe it and name it with with such precision. He he he writes, the misery and wretchedness pressing so unjustly on the majority of the working class. Uh, I mean, he said they have been left um and I quote, isolated and helpless, surrendered to the hard-heartedness of employees and the greed of unchecked competition. Um but why were they so helpless? You know, what why why were they so isolated?
SPEAKER_00It is because the one thing that used to protect them had been deliberately destroyed, you know, and for centuries, the working the working man had the guilds, you know, and which were basically we had talked about them kind of with Freemasonry, you know, Freemasonry started as Masonic Guilds. Um but they had these guilds, these trade associations um that originated during medieval times that trained them, protected them, gave them mutual aid when they were sick and unable to work, and gave them a community.
SPEAKER_00But in the late 18th and early 19th centuries, these these guilds had been destroyed in the name of you know liberal economic quote unquote freedom. They were abolished, they were seen as relics of a backward age. So when the factory ended up coming, the workers they had to face it alone. They had no guild, no association, no protection. It was just basically individual isolated men against the machine and the the men who own them, those machines.
SPEAKER_00Um, and it wasn't an accident, you know, it was basically the secular forces of the of economic liberalism that had cleared the field and torn down every other older Christian structure that stood between the individual and the market, you know, and it called that demolition progress. Um, and that's that's the world that Leo was writing Rarem Navarum into. The you know, the war it had it was a world that had broken the worker and told them that their suffering was the price of civilization, basically.
SPEAKER_01One of the things that, like, um, as a modern uh Republican, like growing up as a Republican, like you heard how much oh, unions are destroying everything, the unions, and like, yeah, unions have their definite pitfalls, right? Like, there's tons of problems, especially modern ones, of course. Yeah, but Leo is so adamant how important unions are, like, and the right for workers to associate, and he even points out that like we have a right to association within the church, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, we we have a right to association within the church, which is kind of funny. It's kind of like what traders are doing right now. And we could go to Pope Leo the Thirteenth to like point out that no, no, we have freedom of association, we're allowed to form these little groups and stuff, but just showing how like trade unions actually did lift workers from these impoverished conditions into into a better situation. It's all like in large part to this encyclical.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Um so one of the one of the answers prior to to Leo here, one of the answers to the upheavals caused by the industrial revolution, um, was of course um well was Marx. You know, so into into the suffering steps, you know, a man that thinks he has an answer, but Marx's answer was basically fire. So Marx had died eight years before Aaron Navarmi had died in 1883.
SPEAKER_00So Leo's not arguing with Mark with the man, with Karl Marx, he's arguing at the movement that Marx has set loose on the world. Um, Marx and Engels had published the Communist Manifesto in 1848. So that's the same year of the revolutions we covered back in the Quanticura episode. His uh Das Capital came out in 1867, and by 1889, just two years before Leo writes Rare Navarum, the socialists had organized the Second International, um, which is a coordinated international socialist movement.
SPEAKER_00It was growing fast, and it it was increasingly becoming completely atheistic and materialistic. And you know, their answer, the socialist answers to the misery, was at least from the outset, clean and simple, and it was really seductive. It it it told them that the problem, the problem. I sounded like your Chinese priest for a second. The problem.
SPEAKER_01Sorry guys, gotta throw under avoiding Babylon humor on a very serious subject.
SPEAKER_00Would you like some shitty chicken with your um they said that the problem the um oh I don't mind the problem is private property itself. Um, basically, that as long as some men own the factories and that and other men merely work in them, that the workers will always be a slave. Yeah, so to fix that, you have to abolish the whole concept of ownership. The community, uh, really the state will own everything that and that you'll take from each according to his ability and give to each according to his need.
SPEAKER_00That's what they're selling people on. There will be no owners, no workers, no rich, no poor. Basically, it will be paradise. Uh, you know, uh, on the other side of the revolution will be uh a worldly paradise. And uh you can imagine that to many, many of these men who are being literally ground to death in factories, that the it didn't sound like a threat, it sounded like salvation, you know. Um and that's the trap that Leo had to disarm because he agreed completely with the diagnosis of the problem.
SPEAKER_00The worker really was being crushed, the suffering really was real, the injustice was real. But he's he he saw he looked at the socialist cure and saw something that you know your average desperate worker couldn't see. He saw that abolishing private property wouldn't free the worker, it would instead enslave him to a new and far more total master, the state.
SPEAKER_01How much how much um because like we're we're looking at it from uh the 21st century, like yeah, we know how communism works out. Like, had there been um examples of how socialism plays out when he's writing this, had that or is it really just these small little movements? Like, has it had there been a social a socialist government enacted at this point?
SPEAKER_00Not you could probably point to to small little examples. Um, you know, for instance, it's like at some level you could say like the Anabaptist and Munster okay, kind of had a communistic state, but at the same time, like look how that turned out, and that even turned into that evolved into murder's rage, too, right? You don't really truly have a socialist communistic state until Lenin's Russia, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, yeah, the French Revolutionary government kinda um in a sense, but um not you know not to the not to the point they wanted what you know, wanted to yeah, they hadn't they hadn't fully they hadn't communism communism hadn't been done yet. That's how it's like just hasn't been done right yet.
SPEAKER_00So uh Leo wrote that socialism by robbing the lawful owner, by turning everything over to state control, would strike at the interest of every wage earner, that it would destroy the incentive to work, dissolve the family, and breed not justice but envy, discord, and eventually tyranny. Uh Leo saw that you wouldn't abolish the master, you would just trade the factory owner for the commissar. Uh and then the commissar, the state, owns everything, including you. Um so Leo, Sid of the Socialist, the central socialist can't claim, the community of goods, that it must be utterly rejected, not debated and not compromised with, but just utterly rejected.
SPEAKER_00Now, if we ended there, every American conservative watching would be cheering because the Pope condemns socialism, you know, case closed. Um, but that's not where we're gonna end because Leo was kind of just getting started, and then what he does next is you know isn't is not the thing that most American conservative Catholics end up quoting. Um having utterly rejected socialism, Leo then turns and aims the same weapon at kind of the other side, um, because um because is not an endorsement of capitalism.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um because capitalism in in a way just turns the worker into a a commodity as well. Like it's it's it just unrestrained capitalism is torturous, right? Like, that's why, like, and I I think I would think like America's monopoly laws and all that stuff probably is derived from this encyclical too. Like, all of these things that like uh you had that factory fire in New York that eventually gets people you have.
SPEAKER_01Dorothy Day comes out of this, you know.
SPEAKER_00This we'll talk about her a little.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, like so much is affected by this encyclical and the things that Leo's pointing to 50, 60 years before these things come to fruition.
SPEAKER_00Um, so Leo obviously does defend private property, and he defends it fiercely. You know, he says it's a natural right rooted in Aquinas and the natural law, and on that he and free market capitalists do agree. But defending a man's right to own is a universal way from blessing the system that had basically turned ownership into a weapon against the weak. Um, Leo condemns the greed of unchecked competition, he condemns employers who treat human beings as mere instruments for making money, basically, who treats men as human capital in a sense.
SPEAKER_00Um, you know, he he condemns people who look at man made in the image of God and sees them instead as a cost to be minimized. And he writes um that it is shameful and inhuman to treat men like chattel to make money by, or to look upon them merely as so much muscle or physical power. Um you know, and then um he says something that that is really kind of crazy to capitalists.
SPEAKER_00He says a wage contract can be unjust even when both parties agree to it, yeah. You know, even when a worker freely signs. Because if an employer pays a man a wage too small to live on in dignity, a wage he only accepts because of the that the alternative is literal starvation. Yeah, then Leo says the emplo the employer is guilty of a grave injustice, no matter what the contract is. The market agreeing to a starvation wage does not make that wage anything more than just a starvation wage, it doesn't make it just.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we have we have to remember, like, because we all know sodomy is a sin that cries out to heaven, but so is depriving a worker of his wages, right? Like that's a sin that cries out to heaven. Like slavery is something God is not uh happy about, you know.
SPEAKER_00You know, and it's something that um I think even myself 10 years ago would have been really uncomfortable with this part of the encyclical, you know, because a lot obviously a lot of us are are conservatives in the true sense, but even prior to that we were conservatives in the American sense, you know, and spent you know years fighting socialism, you know, and and and in leftism and and things of that nature. Um, so there's there, I think there is a temptation there for a lot of us to read Rare Navarum kind of almost as like a Cold War pamphlet against socialism, right?
SPEAKER_00When it is so much it is so much more than that.
SPEAKER_01Um it's getting at the heart of the human person, like it's getting at like the the value of the human person and what their you know what their what their time and and and what yeah, it's it's a it's a it's a much deeper encyclical than you. It's not just a condemnation of uh the way Rabbo slaves did.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no, no, no, not 10 years ago. No, but we would have defended I do now. I have four children.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I always say like children are slaves, it's great. Have as many as you can. Yeah, labor.
SPEAKER_00Um, so Leo, Leo, you know, he looks at at like raw capitalism, and he's and he sees such a an unchristian system, you know. He's to to the to the like the raw essential capitalist, money is the only measure, workers are disposable inputs, and the market is basically a god that answers to no moral law. And he but he calls it he he basically calls it what it is. He says it's just another way of building the city of man, basically, with God left out of it.
SPEAKER_00Socialism builds the city of man by abolishing property, but liberal capitalism builds it by worshiping profit, different tools, but they're both building the city of man. Yeah. Um so then, so if if not socialism and not capitalism, then what does what does Leo what does Leo give out as the alternative? And that's you know, that's what a lot of rareum is about. And it's not a compromise between the two, right?
SPEAKER_00Because he sees them both as errors. Um, but it it it's so it's not a compromise, it's something that is older than both. And he draws it straight out of scripture, out of the fathers, out of Aquinas, um, out of the Middle Ages, and drops it into the industrial age. And you know, um, the pillars of it uh one private property being a natural right, you know, it being root rooted in the teachings of Aquinas, that when a man mixes his labor with the world and provides for his family, what he earns is his by nature, not by permission of the state.
SPEAKER_00So that's kind of the wall against socialism. The you know, the answer to the poverty is not to abolish property, it's to help more men become owners. Um, the second pillar is that property carries social obligations. Ownership is a right, but it's not an idol. What and I I think you were kind of talking, you kind of mentioned this earlier about you know being being black pilled and not about not being able to own everything you want to be able to own in in our day and age. Um we have to recognize that what we own, we hold under God, and we and with those that ownership comes duties to our neighbor.
SPEAKER_00Um
SPEAKER_01So, like this past Sunday was the unjust steward uh uh in the traditional uh uh calendar, and the whole homily was basically about how you steward the things in your care for God. Like that was the it was kind of kind of it's kind of like so. Rob texted me Sunday and he was like, Are we doing rare? And it was after I heard that homily, I was like, Yeah, let's do rare, let's go. Because I I had a lot of conviction in the homily this week just about like some of the frivolous spending I I do.
SPEAKER_01And you know, like we're all going to have to give an account for how we stewarded our money. Like, this isn't just about owners and how they pay their workers, it's about how you, as a worker, handle the the gifts God has given you and how you steward the things God has given you. You know, it's it shouldn't just be some condemnation of a system or of the owners. It should be something that all of us have to look inside ourselves and say, okay, where am I wasteful? Uh am I am I, you know, uh giving alms the way I should be?
SPEAKER_01Am I saving for the future? Am I doing like am I a good steward of my income? It's not, you know, there's there's a lot of a lot of things that were pricking my conscience this Sunday.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. So so Leo basically is saying that we're not free to do whatever we want with our wealth, with our property. You know, this is especially true of the rich. The rich are not free to do whatever they please with their wealth. Generosity and justice are not optional, right? So this he this is kind of the wall against um capitalistic greed in a sense. Um, his third pillar is that labor has dignity, inherent dignity. Work is not just servile, the working man is not a beast of burden or or line on a ledger.
SPEAKER_00You know, uh the worker is a son of God and his labor shares in the dignity of the God who worked, who made the world, and then redeems the world as a carpenter. And to degrade the worker is to insult the creator.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, he makes such a big point of like how how God didn't just become man and humble himself, like he became a worker, he became a carpenter. And you know, he quotes scripture is this not uh Jesus, the uh Joseph's son, the carpenter, and like it, yeah. Well, I can't wait to get into the encyclical of some of those parts because they're they're beautiful. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, his fourth pillar, the just wage and the family wage. A wage must be enough for a man to live in reasonable comfort and support his family without sending his wife and children into the factory to survive. Note that Leo ties the wage to the family, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And to the man being able to provide for that family and not needing a two-income household to survive.
SPEAKER_00Right. Leo says that a just economy is one that lets a father provide, a mother raise her children, and a home stay intact. The economy is to serve the family, not the other way around.
SPEAKER_01That's what made me jump back to the uh on Christian marriage encyclical. Like when I when I read that, that's what made me flip back to the Christian marriage encyclical because what's so cool about the Christian marriage encyclical, though, is there's this whole section on the depravity of pagan marriage and Jewish marriage before Christian marriage. And it we're gonna have to go back and do it because you see those things happening again. Like you see, he's he's talking about how Moses allowed for divorce because of their hardness of heart, and you see our own hierarchy is allowing for annulment because of our hardness of heart, and you're seeing some of those same patterns being repeated, you know.
SPEAKER_01But it all does kind of come down to this husband is not able to provide for the family on his own, so he sends his wife out into the workforce, and now the wife is caught up in this co-ed environment. And man, I just I I today I was thanking God that I don't work in an industry where women are around, like I just am in an all-male industry, and I really am grateful that God put me there. As hard as my job is, and as hard as the commute is and all that stuff. I'm just glad I'm not in a co-ed environment because I don't want to ever deal with that.
SPEAKER_00So uh, so the fifth pillar is the right to organize. So Leo defends the workers' right to form associations and unions, ideally, of course, Catholic ones to protect you know, to protect themselves. Um you know, basically, so if you think about the guilds that liberalism destroyed, Leo is saying that the worker must never again face the machine, you know, the economic machine alone, that he has a natural right to band together with his brothers.
SPEAKER_00Um, the sixth pillar is the role of the state. Um, the state may and must step in to protect the vulnerable, you know, so to like to limit the working day, to guard the safety of workers, to protect women and children, to defend the weak against exploitation, but the state must not absorb everything, it must not swallow the family, you know, in the association, in the church into itself. It's there to help the smaller bodies, but it doesn't replace them.
SPEAKER_00Um and not in this encyclical, um, it's actually in quadric uh quadriguesimo, I don't know, 40 years after this, but that principle ends up getting a name, you know, subsidiarity. Um, so Leo plants a seed of that principle here, um, but it gets its name um 40 years after this. So if you put all those together, you end up having kind of the Catholic third way, you know, between the the capitalist factory and the the bloody Marxist revolution, you know.
SPEAKER_00So it should be a society of owners, not not just serfs, where property is widespread, labor's honored, wages are just, families are intact, workers are organized, the state protects without devouring, and over all of it stands um not the market, not the state, but instead the moral law of God. So, like I said, it's an honest compromise between capitalism and socialism. It's really a rebu a rebuke of both.
SPEAKER_01Um, mad dog, if you had been a longtime listener, you would know I am a descendant of Lucky Luciano. Where any of his ancestors were from ancestors, any of his current uncles like cousins. I don't know what you mean. Um, yeah, good.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so uh so Ray Ronvarum really is in a sense the most fought over document in Catholic social teaching, right? Not because it's unclear, it's pretty clear. Um matter of fact, it's kind of too clear because it indicts everyone, so everyone can use it to attack everyone else, in a sense, you know. So in the 130 years since then, everyone's read it, and everyone steals the half that flatters them, basically. You know, the left reads in prayer of the borough, and they quote the just wage, the right of workers, the duties of the rich, the role of the state, right?
SPEAKER_00The preferential solicitude for the poor. And and the left says, see, the church is basically on our side, you know, social justice, redistribution. The Pope's the Pope was a progressive, basically.
SPEAKER_01Like the the church is all Protestants when it comes to this encyclical, everybody's cherry-picking, cherry-picking their verses to make it fit their own their own version.
SPEAKER_00Right, you know, but the left skips the part where Leo says socialism must be utterly rejected, and that private property is a natural right. Whereas the the the the right, at least the American right, that the modern right, reads the same document and they quote the defense of private property and the rejection of socialism and see and says, See, the church blesses the free market. The the Pope's capitalist, yeah. But they skip, you know, the starvation wage combination, they con condemnation, they skip the greed of unchecked competition, the shameful and inhuman treatment of men as muscle, and the natural right to unionize.
SPEAKER_00Um, so yeah, like you said, but everyone's cherry-picking. Yeah, um, everyone's taking the you know this document who's written by someone I believe is probably a saint, you know. Um, and in Leo writes it to transcend the the political economic and economic fight, and they take it and they drag it back down into that fight and use it as a weapon against each other. Um, and it's it's it's it's really quite shameful. Um, you know, and anyone who tries to fit this into the American political spectrum doesn't understand it because it was it's it's not supposed to fit into any political spectrum.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you really should feel politically homeless as a Catholic, especially now. Like like there was a time maybe you could kind of maybe because of the propaganda we receive, think that like like there are a lot of older people like my dad who's just convinced that being Christian entails just voting Republican, you know. Like there is there are lots of people that think like that, you know. But there is the more time goes on and the more we study this stuff, the more I realize how politically homeless we really are, man.
SPEAKER_01Like we're just we're in uh a time of debauchery. Where's the cold and show? We'll do one of those soon.
SPEAKER_00Um but one thing that um that is uh a little different about Rarum Navarum is that it's not just answering what was happening in in 1891, it basically founds a whole tradition, right? And we call it we call Catholic social teaching, but it's kind of the foundational document, not so much the principles, because a lot of those principles were there, obviously, under Aquinas and such, but it's like the foundational document of it, and every every major Catholic social document since then has been written in its shadow, and a couple of them have literally date, you know, are named after the date of the anniversary in a sense.
SPEAKER_00So 40 years after in 1931, Pius XI writes quadruguesimo anno in the 40th year, um, explicitly to mark Rahim Novarm's anniversary and extend and extend it into the age of Mussolini, the depression, uh the rising uh totalitarianism of like the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany, uh, although Nazi Germany didn't exist quite yet, but um and quadrugues animo is the document that finally gives um the name subsidiarity to the Leo's sixth pillar.
SPEAKER_00Um let's see here.
SPEAKER_01That's interesting. Like that so subsidiarity is in in principle in Rerum Navarum, but it doesn't get its name until then quadruguesima ano, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and what what uh so call uh quadruguesima ano takes the principles laid on rare navarum, but it it actually sketches out like an actual structure uh of what what uh what a state should be, you know, what what the side is.
SPEAKER_01Those principles are in um Aquinas, like they start in Aquinas, they're more built out under Leo, and then they finally like get their body under yep.
SPEAKER_00So uh so the the structure that that Pius XI um kind of develops out of Rare Navarum is a society a society that's organized not into um warring classes uh like like the socialists and Marxists would have, or not into an uh an all-powerful state like like the Nazis would end up doing, but he he wants it structured into vocational groups, into um corporations, not corporations like in the American sense, but corporations, yeah, yeah, where owners and workers in the same trade would cooperate under the moral law.
SPEAKER_00Um, and when when he puts that on paper in 1931, it it something happens that Leo never got to see. There are statesmen who pick it up and actually develop nations uh along these principles. So in the 30s, you have three um, I suppose you could call them strongmen, three Catholic strongmen in three nations that that look at Rerum Navarum and then at Quadriguesoma Anno and actually build states out of that that third way that Leo starts, you know, kind of starts to create.
SPEAKER_00Um the first one you have is Austria under Engelbert Dolphus. And of the three we're gonna talk about, he's the most explicit about creating a state after Rerum Navarum and after Quadrigues Maano. So in 1934, he's the Austrian chancellor and he declares that Quadrigues Maano will be Austria's Magna Carta. Like he actually explicitly declares so he writes a new constitution deliberately framed um as that as that papal encyclical turned into government, and he calls it the the Standestadt, the corporate state.
SPEAKER_00So he abolishes political parties and instead organizes society into vocational uh estates, vocational corporations, just as Pius XI had sketched out. So private property, family, the public role of the church, he defends all of these, and he rejects both Marxism and National Socialism by name. Um, but unfortunately, the reason why a lot of people don't know anything about Eggman Bird Dolphus is in July of 1934, just months after he proclaims this new Catholic corporate straight state, he's assassinated, isn't he?
SPEAKER_00Oh man, I know that he's assassinated by the Nazis. Oh, come on, so one shot. You know, and we'll probably get to this when we bring up uh mid I can never pronounce this one. Uh the the encyclical against not uh national socialism. But uh I don't know, like for all the kid for all the supposed Catholics who pretend like Nazism is base, like you do have Nazis literally assassinate the most Catholic leader probably in the last 100 years, you know, 100 years.
SPEAKER_01I even saw American Reform have to backtrack some of his stuff, man. He took some he took back some of his stuff and he started looking into this stuff and he started looking into the encyclical on national socialism. So yeah, you guys gotta stop LARPing with that crap.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, yeah, so he's assassinated, and then four years later, Hitler's Hitler annexes Austria entirely. So the most doctrinally Catholic state in Europe is was crushed between you know, was crushed by by totalitarianism, you know, the basically by by a state that had become too powerful, just like Leo had warned about. So it didn't survive very long, obviously. The second one is Portugal under uh Antonio uh Salazar.
SPEAKER_00Um, and Salazar is kind of different for a strong man. Strongman, if you want to use that word, he wasn't a soldier, he was actually an economics professor. Um, and he he's almost he's gosh. I'm sorry. Oh wow, that's a good one, though.
SPEAKER_01I need to know who runs this account because he really does drop some gems here and there. For the people who are listening on audio only, Father James Martin said, Anthony, I like working in an all-male work environment too. Sorry, Rob.
SPEAKER_00But Salazar is uh a Catholic, very devout Catholic economics professor who's basically begged uh to take over the reins of Portugal, and he has to be continued. They like they continually beg him for the remainder of his life to remain in leadership, and he he really doesn't really want to, but because he is just an he's a he's he's an economics professor, but he he he he answers the call in a sense. Um, so he he he built the most durable uh regime based on these principles, um, and he so he calls it the estado nova novo, the new state, and it lasted from 1933 all the way to 1974.
SPEAKER_00Um, so just over 40 years. And the motto of the Estado Novo was Deus Patria Familia, God, Fatherland, and family. He organizes the economy, he organized the economy into corporations and trade associations, um, called the the Grimios, maybe. Um, he ends up signing a con uh concordat with the church in 1940, and he explicitly grounds the whole project of the Estado Novo and uh in papal social doctrine.
SPEAKER_00Um, so of all all the three, Portugal is the clearest and most sustained attempt to institutionalize Catholic social principles in the 20th century. And then the third is Spain under Franco. Um Spain is a little bit more syncret uh syncretic. Um, it's not as explicitly just based on Rarum Navarum and stuff, um, probably largely because of the coalition that had to be built to fight in the Spanish Civil War against the the so-called Republicans.
SPEAKER_00Um, but Franco, Franco, Spain, you know, lasts from the end of the Civil War, basically in 1939, to when to his death in 1975. And he um he ends up calling his former government National Catholicism.
SPEAKER_01Can we do an episode on Franco one night? Because I don't know any really anything about him. And like I see all the Franco Friday posts and stuff, and I'd like to actually know a little bit about the Spanish Civil War and who Franco was.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I the the Spanish Civil War itself, especially the first year or two, is uh it's amazing how how much of a crusade it really was, um, as it kind of devolves. It it I mean, I'm not gonna I'm not gonna say the nationalist side didn't do anything wrong because there were instances in which uh some nationalist generals definitely did commit some atrocities, but uh compared to the explicit and outright um satanic Marxism of the Republican side, like uh yeah, yeah, we should we definitely should do an episode on the Spanish Civil War and on Franco.
SPEAKER_01How much uh how much do we have left in the we're we have uh we're probably two-thirds of the way done.
SPEAKER_00We're three quarters.
SPEAKER_01All right, let's I'll try not to interrupt anymore and we'll try to get through it.
SPEAKER_00But so so Franco uh fused in a sense genuine Spanish so uh like social catholic ideas um with the military. He was he was obviously a military general. He also had to fuse it with the Falange, which is kind of like the Spanish version of the of Fascism in a sense. Um and he also had to fuse it with the old uh Spanish traditionalism under the uh under the Carlos.
SPEAKER_00Um so it wasn't as strictly just uh like Catholic social teaching as say Salazar or Dolfus. Um, but like I said, that's probably because he he was he had to build a coalition to win the war. Um, so he he kind of fuses these all together under his own personal rule as the Cadillo. Um, he created vertical syndicates, vertical corporations for labor. Um, he had a church-state alliance sealed by Concordat with the Vatican. Um, you know, he rebuilt Catholic education in the country and Catholic morality as kind of the public spine of the nation.
SPEAKER_00So um, but once again, that only lasted until his his death. And really, all in all three of these, these these attempts to build a Catholic nation really did only last until until these these men died, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and now the church has no desire to see a Catholic state anymore.
SPEAKER_00So well, in in the I think that's one of the I don't even have this in the document, but I think what that's one of the things that we should maybe explore further as we go through this, like like these men they they they try to build what Rareum Navarum and Quadragas Mano and stuff taught, but Rare Navarum and Quadragasumano taught that these should you know they they taught the principle of subsidiarity that a lot of this stuff should be done from the ground up, right?
SPEAKER_00From the smallest units possible, you know, whereas these men built it from the top down. Now, did they do that because they basically had to? Because they were you know, because the Catholic nations had been destroyed by this point, and there was no way for it for them to be built from the ground up, right? So I I I can see why why these men did did things the way they did, um, but because of that, they really didn't get a lot of support from the church, at least initially in their movements.
SPEAKER_00You know, uh Franco and the and the nationalists are like I said, they're they're in the first couple of years, they're they're fighting a literal crusade against demons, you know, in a sense. And um, and you know, priests are being murdered, uh, nuns are being murdered, you know, actual bishops and cardinals are being murdered by the the the Republicans in Spain, and the Vatican, it kind of just keeps it at hand's, you know, at arm's length, doesn't want to get involved. And eventually, of course, they they the Vatican publicly supports them, but um, you know, I I think as we've re read through these and looked at the history, you know, we see how amazing these encyclicals are, but we also see behind the scenes, that it's messy behind the scenes, and and uh in a sense, none of these worked.
SPEAKER_00We the world is the way it is even after these encyclicals, you know, and why is that? Well, I I think I think a lot is because the church had lost a lot of temporal power, yeah.
SPEAKER_01The pope can put out an encyclical, but but none of the none of the nations of Europe were Catholic anymore, they didn't have any any nation to support support them and promote them in the world, and um yeah, you see the collapse of Christendom happened long before Vatican II, guys.
SPEAKER_00Like, yeah, but but then when you have these men who who do try to build Catholic nations, the then the Vatican's like that's a little too messy for us, you know. You it's so frustrating.
SPEAKER_01I have so many things like okay, so uh, I'm sorry, guys. I know you want to go to locals. We'll go to locals, just give me a second here, because you see from the Reformation right up through the council, these popes are all seeing, like, oh my goodness, Christendom's falling apart, and everything's happening, and there are prophets of doom, they're all predicting the collapse of civilization, they're all predicting like the demise of of of everything, and you kind of almost can see why there were some men who were like, All right, enough of this prophets of doom stuff, let's get to some happy stuff because they were just done fighting with the revolutions and all this crap, and they were just like, let's just get along and let's talk happy things.
SPEAKER_01It's kind of what happened. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00It's uh I think in a in a sense, maybe maybe this is way more charitable to these people than what they deserve, but I I think the people uh leaders in the church saw that if they were going to have any influence, they had to have some sort of influence in governments again, right? And they were only ever going to do that if they compromised in a sense.
SPEAKER_00And and I mean, obviously that hasn't worked either. And you know, I I both you and I agree, like to most of our problems in the world, there's no political solution in the sense of at least working in the politics we have now. But at the same time, I think the more I I read these things and look into them, I don't think it I don't think it matters much if you have suddenly a Pius the Thirteenth that that puts out another syllabus of errors.
SPEAKER_00I mean, obviously that would be better than what we're getting, yeah. But I I think in a sense the only way to really restore a lot of this is politically, not not not within the the liberal political system we have, but uh you I think you need both someone like a Franco, someone like a Salazar, but also then what would be more important than a Pope who puts out a Silva Severos would be a Pope who actually throws the full support of the Catholic laity behind a leader like that. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00Like uh I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a kind of look, that's a whole episode. It is, it is a whole episode because I want to go on a tangent right now, but I'm holding back because we'll be here for three hours tonight. So that isn't that is an episode in itself.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I um so just to sum up uh the this section on on on Salazar Franco Dolfus. Um you know the the these men at least well the you know they're not saints. Dolfus, you can maybe argue he was maybe potentially martyred, but um, you know, they're they're not canonized saints, but they kept their their nations out of the Marxist furnace when half of Europe fell in.
SPEAKER_00You know, they kept their their nations out of um out of uh you know, Hitler, you know, like it Italy under Mussolini, you know, uh Italy's fascism had some aspects of Rare Novarum and a little bit of Catholic social teaching, but not not like these other three. And you see Italy get involved with Hitler and and that whole issue with World War II, obviously, but like these men kept their their their nations out of both sides, uh you know, out of the totalitarian fascism, uh, and out of out of um out of Marxism.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, and they and they really did defend real goods, they really did try to defend family, property, faith. You know, at a moment when everything all those things were under open assault from all sides.
SPEAKER_01Um what an oddly what an odd amount to donate. 2567. It's an odd amount to donate. Um, we do a very good job of promoting knickknacks, and if you haven't had a girlfriend, go back and look at our Bobby story. Bobby went from incel loser to engaged in under four months because of knickknacks. So I would get on that. Um, all right.
SPEAKER_00Um, but besides besides uh Portugal and Spain and Austria, Rare Novarum, um, you know, it inspired a lot of other things. It inspired a lot of Catholic labor unions across Europe and America. Um, it inspired a lot of the uh kind of completely failed Christian democratic parties that tried to rebuild Europe after World War II. Um it launched distribu distributism, you know, kind of under Chesterton and Bellock.
SPEAKER_00Um distributism's uh very heavily influenced by Ram Navarum. Um it influenced Dorothy Day, like you said, and the Catholic Wor Worker movement. And obviously there are some issues there with both Dorothy Day and the Catholic worker movement, but um but at least initially, you know, they really did they you know they they did serve the poor to the poor, you know, in the name of the same dignity that Leo defends in Rarum Navarum.
SPEAKER_00Um but you know you can even say um um May 1st. So uh for instance the communists, of course, have claimed May 1st as International Workers' Day, May Day. Um, and they you know they they did that trying to claim the worker as belonging to the the Marxist revolution. So in 1955, you have Pius XII who goes and establishes the feast of St. Joseph the Worker on May 1st. You know, in in a sense that's kind of directly from Raranovarum.
SPEAKER_00You know, the communists were saying the worker belongs to us, but then you have Rome coming on and saying, no, the worker belongs to Christ. And the worker's patron is the carpenter who raised the son of God. Um, you know, not the worker of the state, not the worker of the party, but the worker of the the work branch being free, dignified, and holy. Um, so in a sense, you know, the May 1st, the the feast of St. Joseph, the workers almost rare mabarum turned into a feast day. So you have all so much of this stuff all comes right back to rareum.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's kind of the headwaters of the of Catholic social teaching, and yeah, it really is pretty amazing.
SPEAKER_00So that's basically what I have.
SPEAKER_01That's pretty cool. Um, uh uh, what's his name? Uh Richard, I hope you didn't think we skipped this. I highlighted it before. I don't know much about Franco. That's what made me actually say I want to do an episode on him. So Franco's Franco's the best leader we've had in the last two centuries. Only problem is he trusted America and the modernist satanic Western Allies post-World War II. Like, I I kind of don't know anything about that history. So it would might be interesting to do to jump into that one episode. So we're not going to get into the meat of the encyclical tonight, obviously, because we'll be here for hours upon hours.
SPEAKER_01So, next episode, um, Rob and I will kind of just go through it. I have so much highlighted in this encyclical, man. Maybe we'll go through the summary at the beginning of the episode and give you guys a quick layout of what the whole thing has because that we could get through pretty quickly. And then Rob and I'll jump into the weeds and then jump into some of the more difficult things. And I want to not just tackle socialism because all of us are against that. I want to get into some of the things that'll challenge us personally and challenge our modern American propagandized views.
SPEAKER_01So, uh, a couple of things. Please smash the like button, please share this show. Uh, Rob's going to set up locals now while I'm talking. Yeah, I'm working on it right now. Rob's setting up locals now. So we're going to go over to locals. If you're a locals member, there will be a new stream set up. Um yeah, this this uh over on locals tonight, we're gonna talk Michael Knowles because I think if John Deloney is able to come up with financial uh infidelity as a term, like I want to come up with my own term where attractive young male podcaster sits down one-on-one with an attractive female podcast, and they have cocktails together and he makes her laugh and he's flirt.
SPEAKER_01Like, there's so yeah, somebody called it uh influenity, like influencer infidelity. But I'm just like, I like come on, what are we doing here, guys? Like, this is just I it's something I would never do to my wife, so I want to get into that. Also, I want to talk about Brie Sol's dad and her obnoxious tweet. Even though I like agree with her in principle, I just think there's something so insane about going around and ridiculing somebody for eating meat on a Friday, especially like in the way she did it.
SPEAKER_00Well, I'll talk about it on the Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's definitely we're gonna get into that. Like the spec detectors out there, man. I don't know. And we'll get into TLM Ryan throwing throwing a couple of bombs at us. TLM Ryan, like, like he thinks it won't get back to me that he started a war with us, supposed to be a friend of the show, and he thinks he's just gonna start problems. Where now there's chat is chat. What are they saying? What one of his one of his uh one of the people in his chat said uh avoiding Babylon is an appendage of Taylor Marshall.
SPEAKER_01He basically set them up and gave them the platform they have. They by their own admission. What he's been on the show twice. He set us up, he set us up and gave us our platform. So for those of you who've been around for a long time, in my opinion, the one we owe like our jump in like subscribers and attention would be Father Isaac. Like that was Isaac mod Father Modsley. There Father Modsley for sure. But I mean like that initial, that initial big one.
SPEAKER_01Like we were we were doing like a couple hundred views, maybe eight fifteen views.
SPEAKER_00That was like the first one to break 10,000 views, right? Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01It was our first show to break 10,000 views, and uh it led to me having Father Isaac at my home for dinner one night. Yeah, it's like to say it was Taylor. I just have given credit to Taylor for inspiring me to want to do a podcast. Like the TNT shows, those episodes made me want to get into podcasts. I just thought they were fun. And it like once TNT broke up, it kind of seemed like everybody was kind of doing the monologue thing, and I was like, I kind of want to have like uh you know, more of a hangout kind of thing, and that you know, I'll I'll give credit where credit's due.
SPEAKER_01So that's what that was. But um, yeah, I don't think we owe our we're not an appendage of Taylor Marshall.
SPEAKER_00I don't consult first off, I think Taylor Marshall would be offended by that more than we are. Yeah, right. They're an appendage of me. No, no.
SPEAKER_01Uh I don't consult Taylor at all. Uh, somebody said we should have Tim back on the show. Tim had uh asked me to go on his show tonight, but we were doing our show, so I couldn't. Uh, and he asked me to go on his show tomorrow. So I'm going to jump on with Tim tomorrow to discuss the apocalypse apocalypticism of Benedict the 16th. Uh, I want to go, I want to talk to Tim about the Jewish question because I've watched him cover that and I feel like he's missing some of the meat of it. So I'm probably, for those of you who are longtime listeners, you're going to hear me go through the whole older brother, younger brother scenario.
SPEAKER_01We're going to go through the uh the the uh northern kingdom and southern kingdom breaking out. I'm gonna try and take Tim on a journey. So that's what I'm gonna do tomorrow with him. Um, how are we doing with the stream we set up?
SPEAKER_00Um, I have it ready. I'm gonna put the link in the live chat, and Taffy just taffy just sent me a video I can use as an intro video to it. I haven't watched it, Taff. Do not screw me over.
SPEAKER_01So uh, you know who does yield to our schedule? Is Eric Salmons. Eric Sammons texted me the other day and he goes, Look, I wanted to do an evening stream, but I don't want to go on at the same time as you guys. What time do you go on? I said we go on at eight, but we're done with YouTube at nine, so we'll go and we go behind the paywall at nine. So today he announced he's doing a show at 9 p.m. tonight. And I said, I hope grandpa can stay awake that late.
SPEAKER_00So we'll see. Remember, remember when we uh when Tim Flanders was basically falling asleep during a trivia episode? I do. Is TLM Ryan looking for a spiritual father?
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, I think so. TLM Ryan.
SPEAKER_00TLM Ryan. I wonder if I wouldn't be surprised if this is T L M Ryan, to be honest.
SPEAKER_01Oh, look, here he is, here he is taking shots, taking shots at us on your show today, telling everybody we're no longer friends, telling everybody I'm a paler marshall stooge. All right, we'll see.
SPEAKER_00We'll discuss who are you? Who do you think you are? Yeah, who are you? Who do you think you can do? Is the stream set up, Rob? Yeah, it's all set up.
SPEAKER_01All right, Molly, we're going now. All right, guys, we will see you on Thursday. I do not know what we are going to discuss Thursday yet, but I will let you guys know Thursday morning because that's usually when I figure it out. See you guys on the other side. Rob, hit your post this time.
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! One viral clip trashes the Knights of Columbus as a boomer “wife guy”...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Somebody tried to get our sponsors to drop us, and it accidentally became...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! You can feel it after this election: the old scripts are breaking. We sit...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! That new trailer moment where Christian TV starts to look like superhero...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A single word can flip a villain into a victim, and that’s what sent us...