Will Pope Leo Kill the Trad Movement? - with Christian Wagner
58 minAudio
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Have you noticed the seismic shift happening in Catholic media? The comfortable patterns established during the Francis papacy have been utterly disrupted by Pope Leo's different leadership style, leaving content creators scrambling to adapt. For ten years, Francis provided a steady stream of controversial statements and actions that united conservative and traditional Catholics in shared concern. As Anthony observes, "Francis made normal Novus Ordo conservative Catholics feel like they had more in common with trads than they did with the Pope." This environment spawned an entire industry of Catholic media outlets that thrived on daily papal headlines. Enter Pope Leo, who speaks in what Anthony calls "squishy platitudes that allow everyone to hear what they want." This dramatic change has exposed the unsustainable nature of outrage-driven content. We're witnessing former allies taking shots at each other not because they disagree on substance, but because they're struggling to find new approaches in this changed landscape. Christian challenges fellow Catholic content creators to examine their mission: "The call of the Catholic is to take over the world, is to say that Christ has died, Christ has risen, Christ is coming again." He argues that many talented people in Catholic media have been wasting their gifts on sensationalizing papal news rather than creating content that advances Christ's kingdom. The conversation extends beyond just traditional Catholic circles, touching on how liberal Catholic media outlets like "Where Peter Is" are similarly affected. Both hosts advocate for a return to substance over sensation, relationship-building over viral moments, and reconciliation between Catholic media figures who found temporary unity under Francis. Whether you're a content creator yourself or simply a consumer of Catholic media, this episode offers crucial insights into the changing dynamics of faith communication in the digital age. How will Catholic media evolve in the Pope Leo era? What strategies will prove sustainable? Join us as we explore these questions and more. Support the show Get 10% off an amazing Black Monk Rosary by going to https://www.blackmonkrosaries.com/?ref=AVOIDINGBABYLON and using code AVOIDINGBABYLON at checkout! Check out our sponsor, Nic Nac, at www.nicnac.com and use code "AB25%" for 25% off of your first order! Please subscribe! https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCKsxnv80ByFV4OGvt_kImjQ?sub_confirmation=1 https://www.avoidingbabylon.com Merchandise: https://avoiding-babylon-shop.fourthwall.com Locals Community: https://avoidingbabylon.locals.com Full Premium/Locals Shows on Audio Podcast: https://www.buzzsprout.com/1987412/subscribe RSS Feed for Podcast Apps: https://feeds.buzzsprout.com/1987412.rss
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
Speaker 2I'm sorry, guys. I know you all wanted your taffy intro. We're going to save the taffy intro for locals tonight.
Speaker 3Yeah, we got a big, big show tonight because I have my member stream. You guys got your local stream. Mine's going to be on members and Patreon, so we'll see who gets the signups tonight.
Speaker 1So, okay.
Speaker 2So the original game plan was Michael Lawton threatened to sue us. So Christian and I have been speaking a little bit and he's like let's just get on and we'll talk about it. And uh, something big happened behind the scenes where we're like, okay, we can't talk about that because, um, michael, michael had reached out to both of us. So we're not going to discuss it on youtube. But if you guys can reach into your pockets and scrape some pennies together and stop being cheap and come subscribe to either Christian's channel or our channel either Scholastic Answers or Avoiding Babylon at Locals, you guys will get.
Speaker 2We spill the tea over on Locals. That's what Molly says. Right, molly says that's what we spill the tea. So, yeah, we're going to discuss it over there. Christian actually had a conversation with Michael and Michael emailed me, so we'll get into it over there.
Speaker 3Anthony likes to act like a tough guy. You know me, I was. I was like carrying both my kids, getting my fishing stuff together, drinking some beer, and you know I I got the phone, you know like that doing it, and I had a whole conversation like that. Anthony's just like calls me. He's like Christian, I don't know what to do. I'm really nervous about.
Speaker 2yeah, I had to be the man here and you know, deal with business, but anthony likes to talk big game I, um, I will, I'll discuss, I'll, we'll talk about it over there, because I don't want to, I don't want to do it on youtube. But, uh, we both have some interesting perspectives on this and and we'll see how that goes. But I, I am, I have been talking to you a little bit behind the scenes about just like I feel like there's a monumental shift coming in Catholic media.
Speaker 2I kind of wrote a tweet about this the other day saying I mean you want to pull it up or I don't want to go through this whole stupid thing. But Francis one, yeah, I threw it in there. So I I'm not going to read the entire thing, but, um, I said pope francis was the lifeblood of the trad movement. He pushed normie conservative catholics into the trad column. He spawned an entire industry of new catholic media where every day there was a new headline to be outraged by. For 10, 10 years Francis called Catholics who leaned conservative names names like rigid and backwardist.
Speaker 2He made normal Novus Ordo. Conservative Catholics feel like they had more in common with trads than they did with the Pope. That era is over. Pope Leo is not that villain. Gosh, I just did the whole stupid thing. No, I just do the whole stupid thing. No, my, my, my, my final thing in there said Leo is going to kill the trad movement, not with a heavy hand, but with squishy platitudes that allow everyone to hear what they want. Entire media companies that flourished under Francis are going to collapse If they don't figure out a new strategy.
Speaker 2I want to be very clear. I didn't mean the trad movement, I'm talking about catholic media. Um, I think the trad movement, like the real trad movement, will probably look more similar to what it did under benedict and you know, when they were getting their indult and then some more of them came out, it kind of expanded a little bit. But what we experienced under francis was very unique in that it made people come together that probably would not have come together otherwise. And I'm watching guys who were friends under Francis now starting to take shots at each other and take jabs at each other, and I don't think it's actually about anybody's position on Leo.
Speaker 2I think it's like a battle, battle of strategy. They can't figure out what to do. You have all these people just kind of scrambling for how to react under leo and I'm I'm curious to see how this all plays out, because I I mean, I don't know nick cabasa I think, leaving the trad movement I think there was something, uh, because I mean we named it like the end of trad Catholicism.
Speaker 3Obviously, you know, we're not talking about the people who go to an SSPX mass or the people who go to whatever sort of mass or live whatever sort of lifestyle. We're mainly talking about a type of media complex, of media complex. But I think that while we named it trad Catholicism, I think it is really the any sort of environment that thrives off of sensationalism surrounding the Pope, and that wasn't only right-leaning, that was also left-leaning.
Speaker 3You had a lot of different media that was based on trying to make the Pope sounds like a communist, marxist and, you know, reach out to that sort of sector for a type of liberal who wanted to use that to dunk on Catholics. You had a type of media that was Pope-planning. You know people who were out there simply to try to reconcile the statements of Francis with tradition, sometimes attacking tradition, sometimes stretching a little bit in how to interpret Francis.
Speaker 3So I think that each one of these different groups, if that was your thing like, if you like for me, for example, that wasn't really like my thing, like I would talk about it, but I did a million other things Like that was maybe 10% of the actual content that I made. So switching over to a different form of Pope tracking, like I do with my bi-weekly Pope Leo stream or bi-monthly, I guess, pope Leo stream, that's some sort of completely different content than sensationalizing the Pope.
Speaker 3So I think on every single side you have a lot of people uh losing their footing and you're gonna see the destruction of um. Quite a few of these different media groups thrived off of that sort of um content yeah I.
Speaker 2Oh, I'm sorry. Do you want to say something?
Speaker 1I was gonna say, yeah, I think're right, it's not just the trad side. I don't think where Peter is exists without Pope Francis.
Speaker 2I haven't seen where Peter is in forever. Leo also killed the Pope Spleener. You know what I mean, and this isn't me saying Leo is this great guy. I have my opinions on leo. I think leo, I mean I'll. I think leo is a perfect embodiment of what I see happening in the church right now, which is kind of the. The church in its passion is weakened and, um, because I I mean I don't care if you agree with my stance on this is very you, you know, opinion, completely opinion.
Speaker 2I think that the church is going through her passion and I would imagine if the church is going through her passion, it's not like the church is teaching heresy, it's that it's kind of weakened and it's not boldly proclaiming the truth, it's kind of soft peddling things to not be so offensive. And I kind of see Leo as the embodiment of that, where even in that interview we just saw with, with crux, I don't know why everybody's saying crux, it's crux, right, the crux of the matter Isn't that. It's bizarre the way people are pronouncing that. But and it's not a knock to Leo, it's not anything.
Speaker 2Leo I is a product of Vatican II Catholicism and he's terrified. He's a boomer, so he's afraid to offend people, you know, and he's kind of exactly what I expected him to be. He's not like he's. I'm not surprised by any of it, and I'm watching people react like they did under Francis toward him, like this last interview. They're acting like he's a revolutionary and he's just not. He's not at all a revolutionary. You're not going to see the same outrage about him.
Speaker 2He's just he. I think he's a. I think he's a faithful Catholic that's afraid to offend people, which is a very common thing.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think that's exactly right. Um, I think more people now under Leo are willing to to. When they see those headlines of like pope leo does this, pope leo said this, I think they're more likely to roll their eyes and move on rather than actually like getting enraged about it. I think the example of the interview is really good, because there was a statement that he made in there like oh uh, I don't foresee the church's teaching changing on homosexual issues, yeah. And it's like well, yeah, I don't think any of us foresee the church's teaching changing on homosexual issues.
Speaker 3Um, that's not really the the point, right? I mean that that's something that we can all agree upon. It's just stated in such a way as to be liable to um a multitude of interpretations. It's a very softened way of stating it rather than just going out there and saying which you know, francis himself actually spoke like this to say no. It is like, for example, in the interview with 60 minutes on issues surrounding female priests, female deacons. They asked him straight up, like you know, is it ever possible for this to happen?
Speaker 3He said no. They asked him straight up, like you know, is it ever possible for this to happen? He said no, no. If he said something like that, something like Francis framed that issue, you know, people would somehow have a greater reverence for him. Even though, technically speaking, those two statements communicate the same content, they just communicate them in different ways.
Speaker 2It's interesting because I'm watching people see the same interview and pulling completely different things.
Speaker 1Yeah it's, it's such a it's like it's you're.
Speaker 2I watched gavin ashen and talk about, like, decoding him. And then I'm watching uh, I watched stephen cox's video today and I so I actually understand all of these arguments and I'm I'm looking at them and I'm saying I I get like the Uber trads who are like no, we need a Pope who's going to speak clearly and speak the truth. And then I also get the people who are like no, no, no, he's trying to be a, he's trying to be gentle and go about it this way. And then you have James Like we're still in this scenario where the James Martins and the Cardinal Burks are both claiming him to be their guy.
Speaker 2Yeah, and it's such a weird place to be in the church right now.
Speaker 3I was crashing out over this a little bit, because this is really like the stupidest People really. I think they're getting bored and they're trying to look at because with France it's like, you know, I I love them, I defended them, but it was pretty easy every day to find something to get pissed off about. Yeah, uh, and just reading, you know, daily sermons and letters and whatever, it's fine, it's easy to find something to get pissed off about if you're of the right disposition. But with leo it's kind of really boring. Um, like when I I don't mean it like that, but when I read that's how, that's all I've been saying I'm like we're gonna have a boring.
Speaker 3Boring, actually. Like when I read through a lot of his magisterium, I read through everything he's ever written, um, as pope. When I read through a lot of it, I actually like, in my streams I don't really cover a lot of things because it's like, uh, okay, he's going to, you know, speak about the Sunday gospel and he just kind of explains it like you wouldn't hear in your Sunday morning homily. Like there's nothing like special about it, except you know it's the gospel and that's awesome and it's explaining sacred scripture, but it's not, you know, exciting, you know it's not provocative, you don't really see anything like that.
Speaker 3And Pope Leo he has. So, people, what they have to do is really, in order to generate the same sort of like media stir, the same sort of controversy, what they really need to do is they need to look for stuff to get pissed off about. So they're like, ah, he met cardinal burke and then you see people just like getting pissed off about. It's like I met, you know, father james martin, and father james martin said this they get pissed off about. And really, if you're at the point that you are now scrupulously looking through all of the people that the Pope meets, you need to grow up. You should be doing better things with your life.
Speaker 3It's really such a waste of time. It's like, why are you doing this? There are genuine things to get pissed off about the um, the lgbt, uh, mass, you know, in rome, that's genuinely, if you get pissed off about it, uh, you are exactly disposed to the right sort of affections and if you're trying to explain this away, or if you're not pissed off about this, then you really need to have an examination of conscience and you need to think about some things, because that should drive you to some very righteous anger.
Speaker 3Yes, exactly, drive you to some righteous anger. And that's, I guess, all that I have to say, because if you're comparing, you know, meeting with somebody to the LGBT mass and that's, in your media presentation, the same thing, you're kind of missing the point. You're missing a point of proportionality with how you express things.
Speaker 2I think that I'm looking at it like we have 15 years of Pope Leo ahead of us and I'm very concerned with things like what Rob just had to endure because of tradition he wanted his custodos to get his child baptized. Like he has to travel four hours. We couldn't get a priest set up to actually do it. Like people's lives are chaotic right now because they want a Latin mass and we're going to have 15 years of Leo.
Speaker 2So I understand both approaches. I understand the people who are like we cannot. The truth, we need to speak the truth. And then I also understand that people are going look, we have to be a little strategic about this. Like the pope's extending an olive branch, why would you not want to give that? Like extend one back and say, okay, we're, we're like. Why would you? Why would you want to make the daily lives of your fellow Catholics a living hell just for clicks at this point? Like we're not in the Francis era anymore. I think that we all have to figure out a new strategy for all of this and how we even do social media, how we do our YouTube channels Like it was very easy to generate this outrage for years under Francis.
Speaker 2I mean, rob and I made the decision early on. We're like we're not going to do people news every day. So this show isn't actually about Leo. The show is about, like the, the media, how people respond. Yeah, it's. It's more just me seeing people that I genuinely like handling Leo the same way they handled Francis, and I'm like you guys are going to have a very big problem if you don't figure out something new, because we have to get back to just actually discussing the faith, teaching the faith, preparing the next generation, because a lot of these outlets and I'm saying this with affection to you guys, if you're watching you're not speaking to the younger generation by doing the boomer clickbait stuff, like the younger generation does not respond.
Speaker 2They're still doing the same thing they did on the Francis, and I want to know how we pass the faith onto the next generation and actually catechize them so that we do have this longer term strategy for when we can get the most baseball ever for real.
Speaker 3Yeah, yeah, I think there's um, this is, this is really good, because I think there's both a like descending and there's also like an ascending aspect to this. There's two aspects because there's obviously the aspect of the relationship of the content creator with those consuming the content, like your average layman. For me to and I get it's a little bit hypocritical because the fact that this is a show about you know this sort of thing and we're not just going in and talking about you know, the incarnation or whatever or something in the spiritual life, but having a constant sort of diet of contemporary news coming out of Rome, with who's getting appointed where, or you know whatever else is there, that really doesn't feed those people to be able to actually engage in Catholic action.
Speaker 3That's something that I want to instill in everybody is that you know you should take especially the teaching of Leo, because I think he's really really good on this. You should take all of what you hear and you should actually put it into action, whether it's, you know, in your parish or in the government or in business or whatever else. So there's that descending aspect where people are starving in the content realm for actually quality material that's just not rehashed takes of rehashed takes about whatever's going around Twitter right now. There's also an ascending thing, so us in the hierarchy, because I think a lot of content creators forget and this is something that I've been realizing more and more in the last few months that actually Rome kind of.
Speaker 3We have this image that Rome like doesn't know who Taylor Marshall is, or Rome doesn't know who Michael Lofton is, or Rome doesn't know who, like the sort of what is going on in the content sphere in the Anglo-speaking world, and I think that's actually completely wrong. I actually think that there is some sort of general awareness of what is going on through a lot of these different outlets, and I think a lot of people in Rome actually know some of these outlets by name and have a very bad taste in the mouth.
Speaker 2Oh yeah, absolutely.
Speaker 3And I think that this actually does affect the way in which we get treated. Of course it's not, you know, victim blaming, but it is a way of understanding that we need to be, as you said, we need to be prudent about. If we want to better our chances of change, then the best way of going about it is not to cry wolf all the time Like sure. If there is actually something legitimately bad and there are very strong grounds for bringing this up I mean, you're not just a logging the pope like you're there's actually a situation which people are genuinely scandalized, like the situation with the LGBT mass.
Speaker 3To freak out about that, to speak out about that, to make a stink about that, that makes sense. And if that was the only thing we freaked out about, the to, you know, make us think about that, that makes sense. And, uh, if that was the only thing we freaked out about the last six months, you know, if that's how, uh, the trad media sphere worked, that would actually probably get a much better hearing. It's kind of like, you know when, uh, when you have the woman who always complains all the time, you know the broad's always complaining she's complaining about something all the time you know she complains about something serious. You know, you just kind of filter it out.
Speaker 3That's why women are always complaining about their husbands not listening to them, because they're always complaining. They complain once every month. You're probably listening.
Speaker 2Pick your battles, ladies. Pick your battles and maybe we'll pay attention to you.
Speaker 1It's really the exact same reason why Anthony waits 30 days to hang things on the walls, Because if he did it all the time, it would just become expected of him Exactly. But if he does it once a month, then for that day he is a hero.
Speaker 2I told you out of principle I will leave a picture. My wife will ask me to hang something and out of principle I won't do it for 30 days Because if I did just hang it right away I'd come home the next day and there'd be another picture for me to hang. So I leave it there for 30 days and then, when she's not home, I will hang it without her asking and then when she comes home and sees it hung, she thinks I'm a hero. I'm telling you it's very easy to to to make yourself seem way better of a person than you are in your marriage anyway. Um, so um. What's interesting with with Leo is under Francis you had, when fiducia supplicants comes out, every news article comes out saying that Francis is allowing for gay blessings.
Speaker 2What happened with this Leo interview is the total opposite. But every news outlet going out like the mainstream news came out and they were likeo puts the kibosh on lgbt, because you know they basically took the opposite approach. So I know we, as you know, more conservative or trads are reading that and we're like man. This sounds really squishy, but a big one of the biggest problems with francis was the scandal he caused through the way he spoke and the way the media ran with everything.
Speaker 2You're not seeing that under Leo. You're seeing actually the opposite, because I think even they can perceive the something different here. My, my thing is he's a he's a post-conciliar Pope, like he's just this is what you're going to get. So I want to bring the next generation up, not with a spirit of hatred, like I want to bring the next generation up and even even look, I kind of laughed at stephen cox. Stephen cox was like cardinal burke's, giving orders to trad inc.
Speaker 2To taylor marshall and michael matt and telling them to shut up and zip it. Now, at first I thought he was nuts, but now I'm kind of thinking about it and maybe Burke did say something to them and they're listening. Now, if you're in their position, a cardinal of the Catholic Church comes to you and asks you something, do you not like? Would you not obey a cardinal of the Catholic Church if he came to you and said something? Like I'm trying to understand people's logic in this. Yeah, if Cardinal Burke comes to me and says I'm asking this of you, I'm sorry, I'm going to obey him.
Speaker 1What if it was Koopage man? But to your point, if a Cardinal said, hey, big man with a little beard, listen up, I'd be like yes, sir, we're not allowed to go there.
Speaker 3Settle down, Rob. What was that?
Speaker 2I think everything Rob you just Come on, that was funny.
Speaker 1You are such a bad guy. Come on, that wasn't that bad, I know.
Speaker 2He had to chuckle a little at that Come on.
Speaker 3Yeah, I was thinking that we were all thinking that. But I think what's good with Leo is he actually totaled Pope's planer vindication. With Leo, it's kind of funny. Pope Leo is literally, when you look at the commentary on Fiducia Supplicans, pope Leo is literally doing the exact same thing that the the pope's planners uh were doing when the document came out. So w pope's planners, pope leo, he has, uh, he has confirmed and he's and he's really accepting francis's uh legacy in a uh spirit of continuity.
Speaker 3I think that's in in a way way of kind of toning down some of the more controversial aspects, which is exactly what I think is needed. I know that you guys would probably prefer Pius XIII to go into like start, you know, flipping tables and stuff, but I really do think that, for the health of the church, that there is not a catastrophic split and a catastrophic exodus from the church, I think that it is actually positive to boil the frog rather than throwing them in the boiling water.
Speaker 2I think you have to make a decision Are you a set of a contest or not? Like? If you are not a set of a contest, you have to rethink the way you're doing this. Papacy Like it's not. I understood the outrage under Francis. I even get, like, why people are frustrated with Leo and he's doing the same thing and he's not wording things Right. I'm just I'm not a set of a contest, Like I know everybody wants me to be. I'm just I'm not a set of a contest.
Speaker 1Like I know everybody wants me to be. I'm not and that's not you. I know he talked to three people specifically.
Speaker 2It's just, if we're not, we have to think about what we're going to do, going forward, and I don't I don't know what people's plan Like. I do see guys trying to adapt and handle things differently, and I think that's a good thing. I think that something new needs to come in the Catholic media realm and I would like to see now that we don't have a pope who's hostile towards even conservative, because that was my point in the tweet is that Francis acting hostile towards, like people who just loved reverence, and it wasn't just trads he was going after.
Speaker 2So if you have somebody who's not hostile, it should be a time for brothers to make peace, which is going to lead to the after show We'll figure that out too but it should be a time where, ok, we don't have a father who's abusing us, like a lot of us perceived francis to be doing. I know, christian, you didn't see it that way, but a lot of people did feel that way. So if we have a father who's not so abusive, it should be a time for brothers to reconcile at minimum. Whether you're thrilled with what's happening in rome or not.
Speaker 2It should be a time where we can all open up communication and start talking to one another again.
Speaker 3Yeah.
Speaker 2Wait, what? Seriously? No way. I haven't heard from Jeremiah, so nothing would surprise me, it's over, it's over.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think that you're right. I think that a lot of the mission of Catholic media should be very much sharpened. I've been thinking about this a lot with myself. We've, anthony and I, we've talked over the phone. I've talked over the phone with a few other people as well, trying to like think about how I want the future of my content to go Like. What is the sort of practical end that I'm seeking? Because a lot of the time it feels like a lot of the Catholic media is just content for the sake of content Like it's, it's following the trends of whatever's being spoken about in media.
Speaker 3You want a content. Actually, there was Kyle said a funny thing to me. He said that eventually, a lot for a lot of people that the their content creation becomes a monster that they have to feed so they can feed their family like that that's what it is for them listen and they're just thrown in whatever, whatever works basically, that's actually a really good point, right?
Speaker 2so a lot of these guys are still like this is always something that I I raised about being like a professional catholic, that that you get into the problem of like I'm dependent upon this now. So I have to do the most outrageous thing to get clicks. Rob and I are in a unique situation that we have day jobs, right? So I don't I'm working 16 hours of construction a day. Sometimes I don't actually have time to sit and read and then present you guys with like a theological topic, which I would love to do, and I hope to do it on occasion, but for the most part, I really my only option is to just discuss whatever's happening and whatever's on my mind that day.
Speaker 2I don't have time to give you guys something you know of in depth at all times. I hope to do that through interviews, things like that, but the danger in when you do this for a living is that you just need to get clicks. All right, we get it. Yeah, I know I say the same thing all the time, but you guys trying to just share with you a little bit of the difficulty in what we do is because I had my brother. My brother gave us a comment last time we did a show and he's like what don't rob and anthony get back to doing?
Speaker 2Talking about the catholic faith and stuff so, and he was just breaking our chops. But I had to actually say to him like joe, I'm, you're on my crew all day, like we work together. When do you want me to like what? Do you want me to do? Studies of sumo while I'm at work, like I can't do it.
Speaker 3I used to do that when I worked at walmart did you, yeah, did you really work at walmart?
Speaker 1is that, yeah, that's where it comes from.
Speaker 3Yeah, dude, where else was I supposed to work when I uh joined the catholic church and was completely without a, without a job, with a newborn child? I could work construction like anthony, but you know, I've want to keep my soft hands. I actually did my, my dad's a construction superintendent and I actually did work with him in, uh, one winter, so I uh I know how easy it is, it's not that hard.
Speaker 2He's crying for nothing especially like the past week. I've been sick for the past week. I've been barely sleeping. I have all these ideas going through my head and I watch pretty much everybody's stuff when I'm driving and I try to keep an eye on what everybody's doing. I would like to see people come together. I'm tired of the infighting, I'm tired of the warring factions and stuff like that. I would like to see them come together. I know there's going to be some people who are just like I'll know.
Speaker 2You know I can't. I can't associate with these people, but it'd be nice to see everybody helping each other out and doing stuff together. Can't we all just get along?
Speaker 1sing kumbaya if anthony's uncle is watching. Anthony meant to say he listens while he drives yes, yeah, I don't watch I agree.
Speaker 3I think that we need the, the broad coalition, because there's this weird thing that happens on the internet. I don't know exactly what it is or why it is. I I jokingly tweeted out I, Rob, you actually tweeted something similar to this is basically like I need to stop crashing out on everybody who I agree with on 99% of things. Yes.
Speaker 1That's like a real thing, literally no reason.
Speaker 3Somebody will make a snarky comment in response to something I say. So I just have to give a nuclear-level crash out in the replies and, like you know, post their, post, their docs and you know, send, uh, send a division of wagnerites, you know, to their house and you know I just have to go like full-on, um, you know, uh, scorched earth with this person. But really I think that a lot of the collaboration and having a broader idea of, like what we're doing here, because a lot of times and this was kind of my point mentioning the content for're doing here, because a lot of times and this was kind of my point, mentioning the content for the sake of content a lot of people don't actually have like a very missional idea of what they're doing on the internet.
Speaker 3They're kind of like, oh, it's not that serious. You know we're just doing live streams or we're just doing videos, but this idea of like just doing x or just doing y, I don't think that's really appropriate. When it comes to catholic media, there really should be a broader and wider vision. Like the call of the catholic is to take over the world, is to say that christ has died, christ has risen christ. He's coming again. Christ is, uh, redeemed, all of creation, not merely our souls and bodies, but all of creation, and therefore anything we're doing is meant to further this kingship.
Speaker 3And having a broad idea of 10, 15, 20 years down the line, how am I going to further the kingship of Christ within whatever sphere that I'm given a spot in like, however small or however large it is? I think that's very important. So, doing content for the sake of content rather than for the sake of furthering the kingship of Christ, I think that's something that a lot of us need to think about, and I think that a lot of the sensationalizing that had to or did happen under Francis was very unfortunate, because I've been a public opponent to a lot of the trad inc people like I, I will admit it.
Speaker 3You know we've disagreed on a lot of things, we've had public falling outs, fights, whatever, but a lot of them are very talented people, a lot of them are very bright people, very smart people, people who, if they put their minds to more productive contents, uh, they could change a lot of hearts. They could lead. They could lead to a domino effect wider than they could change a lot of hearts. They could lead to a domino effect wider than they could ever imagine. And the fact that they're out there doing news reports, basically, and sensationalizing content on whatever Pope Francis did yesterday, it's very unfortunate.
Speaker 3It's a waste of talents.
Speaker 2They are burying their talent by doing content like that yeah, I think um, like the, the, the, the place where I might be able to offer assistance is I have a lot of conversations with um people in in the world, like I'm much more in the world than I think most people are. Um, and it even comes to like this weekend I was away and there's somebody that was away with us had just gotten in trouble with the law.
Speaker 2And this person, because they got in trouble, they, they were talking to me and my friend, Bobby, was there. Bobby came, Bobby watches the show and he came. They were actually said they were reflecting on their sins because they had gotten in trouble with the law. They got caught stealing and they were like, when this happened, I finally just had to do a little bit of thinking about my life and and I started thinking about all my sense.
Speaker 2So now this person is opened up to reflecting on their, their life a little bit. They're, they started going back to mass but they have absolutely no catechesis whatsoever and we just sat and we started talking and just going through some stuff and there's a lot of, even from people who are raised Catholic. There's a lot of Protestant cultural stuff that drips in and you know, you think because this person was raised in a Catholic home and all this stuff, the amount of Protestant stuff you have to deprogram out of even your, your cradle Catholics, who should know better it's.
Speaker 2It's really important how you go about those conversations, because I very easily could have scared this person off, you know, by by over and and going. I'm being very careful because I'm on YouTube and my family watches, but you know it's those. Those conversations are what I try to share with people so that if they come across a situation like that in their lives, they might have some success in the areas where I've had success in sharing the gospel without going. Have you accepted Jesus as your personal Lord and Savior?
Speaker 3Have you accepted Mary as your personal mother and intercessor?
Speaker 2That's absolutely how I went about it.
Speaker 1And that shirt is available for purchase, guys. Link down below.
Speaker 3Yeah, don't buy that. Spend the money on the YouTube membership so you don't have to be a local Right, get out of the locals.
Speaker 1I've never done it to a guest before.
Speaker 3Have you heard about the owner of Locals, the owner of Rumble, that's all I'll say. Oh yes, I will not be further commenting on that, because I want to keep our YouTube channels up.
Speaker 2Man, some interesting things have been happening on YouTube with just even live concurrent viewers and the way YouTube counts the stuff. One thing I will ask you guys is, if you're watching this, leave comments, not in the live chat, leave comments in the video, because when they see a lot of interaction, that's when they like. They said yeah, you know, they like to see if our videos cause conversations and stuff.
Speaker 3So, yeah, guys out there, if you, if you've seen your favorite content creator like doing weirdly, like more clickbaity stuff over the last two ish months, like more clickbaity stuff over the last two-ish months. The reason for that is because of the weird counting changing and the notifications changing and the algorithms shift so they've been getting lesser viewership than normal. So a lot of people thought that it was because their content was more boring than normal so people stopped watching it. So they had to like ramp up that. I've seen that with a lot of people, but I just took the month off.
Speaker 2Yeah, but what's interesting is our interactions and all our other metrics are the same, but our view counts are down. It's like a weird thing. Our view counts are down, but all other metrics are the same. It's like I don't know what's going on with it.
Speaker 3That would be hilarious if it was literally just a counting change and everybody thought that their audiences were getting nuked.
Speaker 1That does thought that their audiences were like getting nuked, that that does seem to be what it is. People are saying, like they've been looking at their like to view ratio and like that you know it used to be, say they would get 50 of their number of views and likes. Now it's like 80 or 90. Their number of likes has stayed the same but the views has dropped, so it seems to be youtube's just changing the way how they count views.
Speaker 2Can I live stream your local stream after this he?
Speaker 1did pay us five bucks right there. That is true.
Speaker 3You can live stream my member stream. I will give you the permission.
Speaker 2Alright, so before we do because we're going to keep this one short we do have some live chats Before we even get to the live chats. We will get to those before we do, because we're going to keep this one short we do have some live chats Before we even get to the live chats. We will get to those before we wrap up here. But my point to the trats I think it's time to like. You guys have to come together and figure something out.
Speaker 1And being entertaining does help.
Speaker 2Sorry Very much, something out because I'm watching does help very much, very much. Um, the a lot, of, a lot of what I'm seeing out there is just this this I don't, I don't like what I'm seeing. That's all I'm saying. You know, I I'm seeing guys sniping at each other who, I know, agree in substance and are just it's, it's a difference in approach, and they're they're they're fighting about an approach, and I think there should be some kind of a conversation to be had, cause I think that we we blow it on as conservatives and trads.
Speaker 2We blow it every time by not having a long-term strategy for things Like there needs to be some long-term strategy for things like there needs to be some long-term planning, some ways that we can maybe like turn the turn the ship around down the road. We want everything now, now, now, now, and it's not going to work. So we do have to. We have to figure some things out. We might have to have some conversations with people, bring them on and get people talking. Hopefully we could pull that off.
Speaker 3Yeah, I think another I guess my closing thought somebody actually a former A teacher of mine reached out to me recently and he was asking about content creation stuff, how he goes about it. He's just starting out. What are the tips and stuff like that? And I think one of the things that I wanted to emphasize the most, because I've seen people not do this and then completely destroy their entire channel. Basically, you want to focus on building an actual audience, and that's very important, because when you have like an actual relationship between content creator and an audience, there's actually something that happens with that, that stabilizes.
Speaker 3So for a lot of the people out there who kind of want, want to, you know, monkey around and uh, mess around with trying to just like get the view count up on as many videos as they can, you know, and get a, get this viral video here and get that viral video video here and there, and that's going to like create a sustainable sort of channel that just doesn't work. So really you're you're shooting yourself in the foot by doing the sensational stuff when, if you just kind of were a, you know, a more, a more boring, stable, honest broker, you know, just creating quality content over time you're going to get an audience and that audience is going to they're going to be dedicated to what you have to say.
Speaker 3They're going to. They're going to like what you have to say. They're going to like what you have to say. They're going to follow what you have to say. They're going to actually not just watch for entertainment but actually to get out something from what you say. So I think that the sort of like long-term strategy of the stratosphere of a lot of very talented and skilled people who could really help with the furthering of the gospel skilled people who could really help with the the furthering of the gospel I think that that would be a much, uh, more healthy way of looking about it rather than trying to like seek those short-term gains that end up in a long-term and that's exactly what will happen out there, like you, if you okay.
Speaker 2So, and a lot of this will come back to our conversation on locals because, like, how often built his channel was by like going after Taylor Marshall and going, and you will build an audience doing that, like you will, but there's not really like a long-term sustainability in that and we're starting to see that I'm I don't mean to bring Lofton up, I really don't. I'm saying because we, we've done that too. Everybody can do that. If you go and pick, you know, a group and start attacking that group and picking people in that group, you will make a name for yourself but you're gonna, you're gonna destroy relationships and you're not going to build beyond this tiny little bubble that you create for yourself and then, and then you're going to constantly be trying to chase that.
Speaker 2You're going to see that the only time you get those views is when you're criticizing somebody. Like it isn't easy to do an entertaining show regularly, it's very difficult. And like our show is like I'm not trying to be some trad icon at all, really just two guys having a conversation about catholicism, from whether it's from within the news that day or something deep spiritual experience that one of us had at some point, or raising our children and what's helped in, you know, catechizing our kids in this secular world, things like that.
Speaker 2But I'm telling you, it's easy to go for the, for the low-hanging fruit, and take shots at somebody by name and you will build a channel. You could do a video saying has Anthony left Trad Inc? Has Anthony left Trad? I thought, like Nick Cavazos did today, you'll get a couple clicks, nick, but I don't know if it's a good long-term strategy. I love Nick Cavazos.
Speaker 3You got cuffed in that video by the way, I was totally cheering you when I was listening to it. I'm sorry, but if you guys watch it, I'm so sorry to point this out, nick, but it's like one of his lips was super chapped.
Speaker 2Oh, leave me alone, stop it. It was driving me nuts. I was like watching it. His lip was super chapped and he kept licking it and I was saying I think some people misunderstood my tweet. They thought I was saying like the trad movement is going to die. And I don't think the trad movement is going to die, I just think it's going to go back down to a size more like it was under Benedict and it's going to be more faithful people. And that might be a good thing, because I think it was overinflated and there were these entire media conglomerates that were built and blew up, especially during COVID.
Speaker 2Like COVID happened and everybody's channels blew up because everybody was sitting home and then they thought they were going to sustain that. And to keep people's attention is so difficult these days. There's so much competition out there. There's 80 billion podcasts for people to listen to. Competition out there, there's 80 billion podcasts for people to listen to. It's just you have to. You do have to build an audience that actually likes you and not just clicks because of what topic you're covering or who you're interviewing, and that's a really tricky thing to do. We're just teasing you, nick. We love you, bud. Sorry my lips.
Speaker 2Sorry my lips. Bother you, christian. I will try. Yeah, why you gotta be mean christian?
Speaker 3that's not nice, it's just the the altism struck at the wrong moment time.
Speaker 2Too much tylenol nick, we love you, you'll be. You'll be on the next one we do a christian, but we're uh, all right, let's read the super chats before we, before we head out okay, um, why do you so?
Speaker 1why do you think trads embrace Kirk? I would assume Charlie or Eric. Armature and the Trent Horn types don't. Is it a feminism thing? I think they'd be all for the ecumenism.
Speaker 3What in the world is that? I don't know.
Speaker 2I don't know what he means by that. Why, like Trent Horn and those guys, didn't embrace Charlie. I don't know. Is it Charlie, or why, like Trent Horn and those guys, didn't embrace Charlie? I don't know.
Speaker 1I don't know if that's a Charlie or Erica. The feminism comment makes me think Erica. The trend, maybe Charlie too, cause right, cause Charlie was anti-feminist.
Speaker 2Maybe we could discuss on locals also what you guys thought of the Charlie Kirk Memorial, because I have kind of mixed feelings about it and I don't want to. I don't want to just jump on and I've very strong feelings, very strong. All right, well, we'll hear those over there. All right, well, I didn't watch it, so I saw clips. That's the thing. I didn't watch it. I saw clips and, um, yeah, so, like fed, fed's a protestant and he watches our show regularly. He says we're fun. It doesn't always have to be.
Speaker 2I know I'm very adversarial to Protestants on Twitter, but a lot of it's just sarcasm, crazy humanism going on right now.
Speaker 3I can't handle it.
Speaker 1Let's see here. So this is not so much for Anthony, because he doesn't really know, but Taffy wants to know if we think we'll a 30 odd six, have an exit, a body at 150 yards.
Speaker 3Look all I'm going to say, rob. All I'm going to say I don't know whether we'll disagree on this I have not a hell of a lot of deer. I've skinned and gutted a hell of a lot of deer who've been shot with a .30-06. If I shot somebody in the neck with that, there's gonna be an exit hole, I can guarantee you it's, yeah, it's unlikely to not have an exit wound, but bullets do do crazy things.
Speaker 1But it's, I don't know man, the only thing I could think um some ranges, indoor ranges, especially made for rifles, make you use frangible ammo right because they don't want the rifle rounds penetrating into like a backstop. You wanted to break up, so maybe the maybe the idiot was, you know went to his range and just used whatever range and when they made him buy and it was frangible and it just shattered, maybe on a spine or something, I don't know it.
Speaker 2It is unlikely oh, you got guns and rosaries for this stop, I don't care.
Speaker 3He paid us 20, you care for 20 yeah, some guy, uh, mores ultra, shout out the mores ultra. He gave me 50 memberships. So I I appreciate it.
Speaker 2So everybody can watch the after show on.
Speaker 3Lofton.
Speaker 2I want to see somebody give 50 locals memberships. Guys, let's go. Can you gift locals?
Speaker 3memberships I don't know you can give coins or something, yeah, coins Oy vey. So JD says Oy vey, give me 50 locals coins. Yes, I know.
Speaker 1We're still on YouTube. So, yeah, give, or you beg, give me 50 locals coins.
Speaker 2Yes, I know it is. We're still on youtube, um so, um yeah. Bishop paprocki said honoring a public figure who has actively worked to expand and entrench the right to end an innocent human life in the womb undermines the very concept of human dignity and solidarity that the award purports to uphold, which he's talking about. Supich giving an award to a Democrat politician. And then Archbishop Cordelione said I stand in solidarity with solidarity with Bishop Paprocki in Springfield, illinois, in urging Cardinal Supich to reconsider giving Senator Durbin a lifetime achievement award through the Archdiocese of Chicago's Office of Human Dignity and Solidarity, given his long record of supporting legal abortion.
Speaker 2Bishop Paprocki, who is Senator Durbin's bishop, has expressed shock that the Archdiocese plans to honor Senator Durbin who, although a self-professed Catholic, supports access to abortion so radically that he has even opposed legislation to protect babies born after an attempted abortion. Bishop Paprocki is correct that both clarity and unity are at risk. I hope this will be a clarion call to all members of the body of Christ to speak out to make clear the grave evil that is taking of innocent human life. I'm sorry, but this statement does not happen under Francis.
Speaker 2This does not. People were terrified they would get strickland. I'm telling you, there's something happening where our bishops are like okay, new pope, I'm going to start speaking out and they're going bishop against bishop, publicly. So it's a unique moment um so house.
Speaker 1music for 50 has a so house music is my little Patrick.
Speaker 2Little Patrick came to Italy with me.
Speaker 1Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Speaker 2Little Patrick who was supposed to come to Pennsylvania and we called him, like you, coming to PA. He's like no, I'm in Japan. I don't know how the heck he's in Japan.
Speaker 3Well, he asked a question of me and he sent a super chat on your channel. I told him he that I might super chat tonight, okay he said I might super chat tonight.
Speaker 2I go, you better super chat on my channel and not wagner's channel, because I'll kill you next time I see you that's fair enough.
Speaker 1Wow, someone's like okay, does prayer aid the development of moral virtues? I know that it depends on action, but if I'm praying for courage or magnanimity, magnanimity magnanimity even, even if it depends on my action. I can't imagine the God wouldn't help us in that situation.
Speaker 3Yeah, I mean, when it comes to the natural moral virtues, there are the virtues which are somehow essentially supernatural. So faith, hope, charity, the gifts of the Holy Ghost are also habits, et cetera, et cetera. Charity, the gifts of the Holy Ghost are also habits, et cetera, et cetera. And there are those which are naturally. They are essentially natural, but they are modally supernatural. So by modally supernatural basically means that it is something that comes to us in a supernatural way.
Speaker 3So all of the moral virtues and natural intellective virtues, they come to us by sanctifying grace. And when it comes to the exercise of these virtues, we can think about the increase of their adhesion in us. We can think about the different obstacles in our faculties, like we might have, you know, in our faculties, like we might have a superfluous amount of concupiscence or irascible behavior, or we may have various different vices that order us in different ways.
Speaker 3When we're asking God to increase in us these different virtues, he's aiding us in removing all of those contrary habits, aiding us in strengthening the adhesion of those virtues within us, to aid us and give us those good inspirations so we can consider the goodness of the exercising of those virtues, to actually elect to carry them out. So there's many different ways, like if you want to scientifically break it out, break it down in moral theology and look at the various different aspects of the exercise of a virtue, like we can talk about all those things, but the short answer is just yes, like God can aid you in the exercise of even natural virtues.
Speaker 2I'm glad to see our audience finally super chatting a bit, because Christian's audience super chats like crazy on his show. I've caught your live streams. Your audience is very generous.
Speaker 3I'm like, you guys are awesome. Well, somebody on my side said sorry, but trad larpers who don't chant the hours in latin every day but screech about vatican 2 are the actual enemy. Just my opinion. So real, you guys are so cucked right now I learned.
Speaker 2I learned that I don't know the angelus in latin. Last week we were away with a bunch of guys and they know the Angelus in Latin. Last week we were away with a bunch of guys and they said the Angelus in Latin.
Speaker 3I was like I only know the Hail Mary.
Speaker 2Yeah, I only know the Hail Mary and the Glory of God.
Speaker 3Trad.
Speaker 2LARPer, trad LARPer. I am a Trad LARPer. That's it. We got a couple more.
Speaker 1Andy paid us $30. I don't know what he means, but what?
Speaker 2about.
Speaker 1Cavazos, though, Sorry.
Speaker 2Andy, if you're asking, we love Nick.
Speaker 1Someone said that they're broke, but they really wanted us to answer this. So sorry, anthony, but do you think there's a connection with an Augustinian pope and a president that talks a lot about peace? Because St Augustine talks a lot about peace as a supreme good of life.
Speaker 3Oh yeah, he asked me that question on mine too, but I accidentally skipped over it.
Speaker 2I think there's more of a connection between the fact that we have the first American Pope and we have an American president who acts like an emperor, and I'm more, I'm more interested in that connection, you know, because I see, I see america as like the new roman empire and we have the first american pope. I think that's a connection. But what do you think about saint augustine?
Speaker 3I think there's an interesting connection with leo the 13th, because when you read immortality day, what you see is that basically the, the political program of the catholic church is based on saint augustine and specifically um, on the city of god, in response to the claims against christianity and the good of the state. Like this is leo the 13th, like he completely, uh, explains political Catholic political philosophy in light of this. So I think that when it comes to Leo XIII, he also had a very sharp understanding of the American situation, the different virtues that the American people have, the hope that we have for the American people in the future, if, when she accepts the Catholic faith, and he, I think it was very clear that Leo XIII thought that America would eventually accept the Catholic religion in its fullness, not only in a truncated way, like a lot of Americans viewed the effects of Catholicism on in the civil sphere.
Speaker 2Somebody's asking if I know the Our Father. Father, yes, I know the whole rosary. I know all the responses at mass, because I'm not that bad.
Speaker 1Uh, jd, I would say so, my wife was so jd asked what is your advice to get your spouse into tlm?
Speaker 2thank you, rob. I'm terrible about actually reading the questions and I know people get driven nuts by that. Um, I can only share my experience. My wife was very resistant early on and it was because I kept pressing it. Um, but eventually I just asked her to go and I and I didn't argue with her about veiling, I just brought her and she fell in love with the music and the aesthetics of it at first. And after bringing her several times, without like arguing about why it's this and that, I just kind of left it to god.
Speaker 2And now my wife, she just she just likes the novus order more than I do. Um advice for a diocesan seminarians who are traditional don't be an idiot.
Speaker 3Do not be an idiot. If you try to be a hero, you will get screwed over. Okay, your bishop will bury you. If you try to be a hero and you act like an idiot, okay, be smart. Do not spurg out. Okay, I'm telling, I've seen it before all these off to tylenol seminaries they spurg out. You know, I think they're going to be a hero and change their bishop's mind and they get hammered into the dust.
Speaker 1Yeah, then they have to go to an old Roman Catholic bishop to get ordained and it's just not pretty.
Speaker 2I'm not sure if I'm going to promote Mass of the Ages until I get a call from Cameron. That's all I'm going to say.
Speaker 1Cameron's still you know, still still stealing her idea A call asking you to come on or a call apologizing for stealing the film series. You're the one that brought that up. I dropped a little hint at something.
Speaker 2here you just. What am I going to do about this guy?
Speaker 3You're yapping about him on the phone for like an hour all right.
Speaker 2So what we are going to do now, we are going to go over to locals and christians um members only and we're going to discuss what happened behind the scenes. Michael often reached out um and we'll we'll get into that, and then I think we're going to discuss the Charlie Kirk Memorial.
Speaker 3I'm thanking all my people for the super chats Come over to Locals.
Speaker 2Guys Like, where else are you getting a show? Come on, like I'm so tired of you guys watching the YouTube-only portion.
Speaker 3Okay, well, I'm switching over to my member stream, or, if you're a patron, I posted a link there as well, so I'm switching my stream over. All right, rob. Thank you everybody, god bless. Remember to like subscribe, yeah.
Speaker 2If you're subscribed to uh, avoiding Babylon and not scholastic answers, go throw him a sub. If you're subscribed to scholastic answers and not avoiding Babylon, throw us a sub. Uh, it's five bucks a month. You could get like a single episode for four bucks and then you can get the year for 50. People are asking how much. It is, um, very much worth the the money. We we do a locals episode pretty much every show we do, and that's where we can get a little little more spicy and we don't have to worry about, you know, the general public watching what we say.
Speaker 2So, all right, we're heading over take it out family.
Speaker 1Yeah, okay, I'm just so, because the video you want to play on locals, i'm'm going to just remove all the public.
Speaker 2Yeah, remove YouTube and then we'll have an intro video. We have an intro video coming that only locals gets, so if you're still watching on X get over there quick.
Speaker 3I already stopped mine and started my member stream, so I started before you, which means that everyone's going to flood.
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! One viral clip trashes the Knights of Columbus as a boomer “wife guy”...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! Somebody tried to get our sponsors to drop us, and it accidentally became...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! You can feel it after this election: the old scripts are breaking. We sit...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! That new trailer moment where Christian TV starts to look like superhero...
Want to reach out to us? Want to leave a comment or review? Want to give us a suggestion or berate Anthony? Send us a text by clicking this link! A single word can flip a villain into a victim, and that’s what sent us...