How do you spot a false teacher when they look impressive, viral, and spiritual When an Instagram poll asked what episode to do next, one name came up about four times more than anything else. Looking her up raised a stack of red flags - claims about apostleship, healing, money, and “Spirit” manifestations that don’t sit well with Scripture or the fruit of self-control. This episode isn’t about hunting one influencer. It’s a filter you can run on whoever shows up next - because false teachers seem to emerge every 42 seconds online, using God’s name and the Bible for selfish gain. You’ll get a clear checklist for what to throw out, what merely misguides, and the tension Paul names: even bad teachers can still put Christ’s name in someone’s ear - without that making discernment optional. Visit sethtroutt.com for more insights on authentic masculinity that tests every spirit and holds fast to what is true.
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00All right, how do you spot false teachers? Who are the false teachers that are out there? What do we do? And uh how do we interact with these false teachers? Uh when I did a little Instagram poll, uh, what should we do? A podcast episode about, and this lady named Katherine Crick came up uh about four times more than any other single topic, which was surprising because I had no idea who she was and never heard of her. So I had to look her up and figure out what the deal was. But she's a part of this new apostolic reformation thing, uh, kind of the word of faith healing, prosperity, gospel type thing.
SPEAKER_00And so uh out of no intention to just single her out, but she's just the one that came up. And so we're gonna get after it. Here's one of the problems with when you start naming false teachers is you don't have time to name them all. And so it can be selective in naming them, but apparently she's popular and viral and doing a new thing, so it's worth speaking out against. But map the thinking I'm gonna give you on her onto whatever you else you see in the future, because false teachers emerge, it seems like every 42 seconds on the internet saying nonsense stuff, uh, manipulating people, taking the Lord's name in vain, uh, using the Bible for selfish gain.
SPEAKER_00They look like the uh shepherds that are hacks out of Ezekiel 34, who are in it for the money, not necessarily in it for the ministry. Uh, even some of the demonic language we see about what demons do, they disguise themselves as angels of light. And so I do think false teachers are inherently demonic. Uh, and there's uh various ways that this plays out. But in particular, I want to talk you through just my filter on what I'm thinking through. So I look up this person and I'm trying to check the boxes on what are the red flags I see. The first thing is uh Catherine Crick calls herself an apostle.
SPEAKER_00So apostle Catherine Crick. Generally speaking, if someone's calling themselves an apostle, red flag, stop listening, ignore it. Uh, you can throw it out. Uh that's number one, that's just, I think, unbiblical. So Ephesians chapter two talks about uh the the church was built on the foundation of the prophets and the apostles, meaning the foundation was laid, and now the church is being built upon what happened. I don't think there are any more people inhabiting the office of prophet or apostle. Likewise in uh Revelation 21, it talks about how there is this these 12 foundations of the that were the apostles, meaning there's this presumption in the New Testament, a logic within the New Testament, that there were 12 apostles, period, not more apostles, that the apostles laid the foundation, and then the rest of the work was a shepherds, teachers, evangelists, building upon that foundation.
SPEAKER_00We see that logic in Acts uh chapter, the beginning of Acts, Acts chapter one and two, when Judas, who was supposed to be apostle, uh uh flames out and betrays Jesus, and they have to find another person to take his seat after he died. After all the other apostles died, no one in the book of Acts is like, we gotta replace that apostle, because there is this presumption that the 12 apostles corresponded with the 12 tribes of Israel, and there are 12 apostles that were laying the foundation. No apostles are replaced after Judas, revealing the early church did not see it necessary to replace the apostles.
SPEAKER_00Likewise, the apostle Paul in 1 Corinthians 15 uh gives a criterion for an apostle. It's one who bore witness to the physically risen Christ. So not like a vision in a dream, but they with their eyes, their eyewitnesses to the physically risen Christ. Paul called himself one untimely born, the last of the apostles, and also the least of the apostles. So the apostle Paul has this presumption that he's also gonna be the last. And so I do think the apostles and their giftings were laid as a foundation for the church to be built upon.
SPEAKER_00Uh so she says, apostle, I'm immediately like red flag. Uh number two, she's a lead pastor of a church. Uh, the pattern established in the New Testament is that uh uh men as elders were appointed to lead congregations in every city and town. That's the pattern. Uh the priesthood is all male in the Old Testament. Uh, 1 Timothy 2, 1 Corinthians 14, lots of verses that could be there. Uh, someone, a female who's calling herself a pastor, lead pastor, second, uh red flag. Um, I think there are female pastors who are not necessarily false teachers.
SPEAKER_00I think they're just misguided on that. Uh, but the apostle plus female pastor, red flag, red flag. Uh, number three, she's doing this like sow your seed of faith to be forgiven. So anytime someone's talking about sowing and reaping and financial leading to spiritual returns, I'm skeptical of it. It looks like financial manipulation, it looks like preying upon desperate people. It just doesn't really vibe for me. And so sow your seed of faith and you may be healed physically feels uh really, it just gives me the ick.
SPEAKER_00It there's a there's a vibe check there that's not good. Nowhere in the Bible is giving associated with healing. Uh, faith and prayer is associated with healing, but giving is not associated with healing. Similar on the healing thing, this idea that there are certain people who have gifts of healing and certain people who don't have gifts of healing. So the apostles in the New Testament, like Peter, his shadow falls on someone and they get healed. Nobody who even claims to have the authority of the apostles or gift of healing now heals like that. They're all praying for healing. I'm a big fan of praying for healing.
SPEAKER_00We should pray for healing. The Spirit heals today like he did, but not the same way he did in the first century, because we don't see this absolute apostolic authority where people are commanding healings and healings are happening. I think you see people uh who have prayers of faith, and you say people get healed. Uh, another big part to me that is a question mark when it comes to these things is kind of the slain in the spirit shaking about, uh, like the shaking thing. It just feels like um one, that type of movement is typically associated with demonic behavior for virtually all of church history, not angelic or spirit-filled behavior.
SPEAKER_00And so the slain in the spirit, shaking about, rolling of eyes, being uh not understandable, that to me codes more demonic than angelic when I understand the sweep of church history and the way the New Testament talks about. When Paul's policing congregational behavior in the book of 1 Corinthians, he's talking about how God's not a god of confusion, but of order and kind of loss of self-control flies in the face of the fruit of the spirit, which is self-control. And so, why would you lose yourself or lose your control when the spirit comes upon you? To me, it feels like the spirit, the fruit of it is self-control.
SPEAKER_00And the function of the foot of the spirit is to lead you into Christ-likeness, not to cause you to lose control of your faculties. And so it all to me feels demonic. It feels money hungry. Uh, there's a bunch of flags that it raises for me. And so, whether it's someone on TBN or someone on Instagram or someone you're just noticing, uh, you want to be discerning on these false teachers, uh, these angels of light who are designed to uh leverage God's name and take it in vain. Now, one of the other tension points I feel uh that I want to recognize here is Paul himself says of these false teachers, so long as Christ's name is proclaimed, I can celebrate.
SPEAKER_00So Paul is able to even look at false teachers and see this like shred of light and say, well, they're proclaiming the name of Christ, even it's for selfish motive. And I want to have that space in my heart as well. I know some people who are members of my church who uh started hearing and following Jesus by first listening to false teachers, then they started reading the Bible because the false teachers use the Bible, then they came to the knowledge of the truth, and they came to our church. And so there's no telling how God will use these false teachers. But discerning Christians, even if they maybe are first introduced to Christianity through the false teachers, should sober up, read the Bible, check out, and go find a church that teaches the gospel, Christ's death and resurrection for sin, and is promote something that's congruent with what the New Testament's saying the church ought to be doing.
The cultural lie is that work should be effortless. The biblical truth is that sweat is a feature, not a bug. Men are experiencing what feels like malaise - that halfway commitment to work where you're present but not...
The real problem with "work-life balance" is that it's a lie. You've internalized the split: work is over here, life is over there, and if you're smart you'll keep them separate. But God didn't design you that way. He...
Your body is either a tool or an idol. Most men don't realize which one they're treating it as until they're standing in front of the mirror hating what they see. A generation ago, body image was a women's issue. Now...
Maybe you've got one foot in the church and one foot out. Maybe you're sitting in a pew every Sunday wondering if it's the right one. Either way, picking a church has never been harder. You choose between churches the...
She married a man. Act like one. There's a version of vulnerability that sounds good in theory but feels terrible in practice: coming home emotionally unfiltered, asking your wife to help you sort through your feelings,...