Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Authentic Masculinity

Authentic Masculinity artwork

How to Pick a Church: The A, B, C, D Filter

Oct 20, 20266 minAudio

Maybe you've got one foot in the church and one foot out. Maybe you're sitting in a pew every Sunday wondering if it's the right one. Either way, picking a church has never been harder. You choose between churches the way you choose between brands of shoes: which one fits how you see yourself? That consumer approach turns church into a personal brand, and it's unhealthy. But underneath it is a real question. Where should you actually go? The Reformers named marks of a true church, and they're a great place to start. This episode gives you a simple A, B, C, D filter for finding a church today. It starts with one question most people never think to ask: who can fire the lead pastor? Good luck finding a church. The Holy Spirit will lead you, and that place will form you into His image. Visit sethtroutt.com for more insights on authentic masculinity that looks for a church that forms you instead of one that just fits your brand.

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00How do you pick what church to go to? How do you find a church? Maybe you're one foot, one foot out of the church. Maybe you're going to church, but questioning is it the right one for me? I do think there is a consumer culture that makes this actually way more difficult than it's been in world history in the past. We choose between brands of shoes and we choose between types of churches, similarly, which church makes me which like is congruent with how I understand myself to be. And so there is like a consumer culture approach to church that I think is unhealthy, that's all about making the church brand bleed off onto you as a brand.

SPEAKER_00I'm the type of person who goes to that church. Now I would never go to that type of church because my personal brand is this type of thing. And so there's a consumer culture part of it. But there's also, I think, a real question about faithful. Like what should I go to? What church should I find? And uh, you know, historically speaking, in the Reformation, they talked about two or three marks of the true church. Uh, and so it's number one where the word was rightly preached, number two, uh, where the sacraments were rightly administered, baptism in the Lord's Supper, and then kind of two B or three was that where church discipline was rightly practiced.

SPEAKER_00Sometimes they saw communion uh as connected to excommunication, which is church discipline, meaning, are there people within the church that if they sin high-handedly and cease to believe, that the church says you can't be here anymore because you're no longer doing what this community is committed to doing. So this isn't about petty sin management of other people, but it's about when people develop hard-heartedness to God, are they allowed to continue to pretend like they're Christians when in fact they've abandoned their faith? And so those are the three marks in the Reformation. I think they're a great place to start. But I want to give you my A B C D's on how to find a church, especially in this modern era.

SPEAKER_00So A is accountability. Ask yourself the question: who can fire the lead pastor? Who can fire the other pastor? Who is responsible for keeping of the doctrine? And so, what's the accountability structure? So at our church, we have a requirement that the board of directors or the board of elders be majority uh independent or lay, meaning unpaid, because we think that creates sobriety and better judgment, where there's no skin in the game vocationally to be ruling over the congregation. And so ask accountability. There's a lot of like churches out there where the lead pastor just does whatever he wants.

SPEAKER_00And not, it's not just like there is accountability and he doesn't submit to it, but there's just literally no governance structure where someone could be held accountable. And so is there accountability? Uh B, is it biblical? Does it teach the Bible? Do they use the Bible? Are they trying to help you understand God's word? Are they trying to just tell you their words about life or are they trying to help you understand God's word? Are they teaching, rebuking, upholding, confessing, and modeling, so not just in stated values, but in actual values, is there reverence for the scriptures?

SPEAKER_00Is the are the pastors or the pastor or the staff really submitting themselves to the scriptures and then leading out of that? Or are they kind of using the Bible to do what they want? Or are they placing themselves underneath the Bible? So is it biblical? And if it's biblical, it's gonna be Christ-centered. It's gonna be focused that everything in the Old Testament is pointing to Christ, everything in the New Testament's pointing back to Christ in his second coming, that a real cruciform, Christ-centered, cross-centered, Jesus, death, resurrection-centered gospel, that is biblical. And so it's not good enough just to do Bible, but has to be a Bible rightly understood that points to us to Christ and helps us know the person of Christ by the Holy Spirit.

SPEAKER_00Um, C is connections. Where do you already have connections? I think some people want to kind of parachute in straight away. But I do think, like I talked to a guy on the phone recently who's having a bit of a crisis in his life, and he's going to this church that was closer to him. But I he had this other church that was maybe 20 minutes away, but he had four or five really meaningful connections already. And I said, hey, if you want to go to that church, you have to form connections. Or you could drive 20 minutes to this church and go to the place where you already have connections. And I do think that if you're on this type of spiritual journey, trying to find a church, trying to find Christ, a good place to start is to reach out to the people that you know that go to church and say, Where do you go?

SPEAKER_00Could I come with you? Because all us being equal, going somewhere where you have pre-existing relationships is important. So go where you have connections. Okay, part two to the connections piece is go somewhere where you could have a connection with a pastor on staff. Now, some churches that are larger, it might be 20 pastors. You don't need to have be friends with all 20 pastors or all 40 staff people. But you want to go somewhere where you can have a connection with someone in leadership, whether it's an elder, a pastor, a director, someone who is on the inside.

SPEAKER_00And so maybe have a connection there. But if a church has no emails available on the website, if the staff is too busy as a whole to connect, there may be some staff members that are busier than others based on travel or whatever, or burden of work, but you should be able to connect with someone on staff relatively easily and have your name known and connected with. And so if that's totally unavailable, um, I'm skeptical on it. So connections, pre-existing connections and the capacity to connect with the staff. And then D, I want to talk about this hospitality, warmth, delightful connection.

SPEAKER_00Like, is the church really have this delightful spirit where you want to be there? They want you to be there. You walk in and they're skeptical of new people. What is that? Because a church that has a delightful or warm, uh, delicate approach to bringing people in, uh, I think that hospitality is what grace looks like with skin on. That's we're glad you're here. Welcome. Thanks for coming. Is there a clear step for new people, how to get connected? Is it on, is it, is it clear for uh how you can get more information about the church?

SPEAKER_00And so this kind of delightful, hospitable connection piece is, I think, a big part on church culture. And so this is like, do the people seem to generally speaking enjoy each other, or do they seem to generally speaking be tolerating each other? And so is there mutual delight? You know, and so I delight in my kids because I like them and appreciate them and what they're doing. And it warms my heart when they delight in me. And so a church culture where there's mutual delight, both in the people that are there and the people that are coming, that's a culture that really values the image bearer and values the grace of God and is willing to engage with people on a really human way because of the grace of Jesus Christ.

SPEAKER_00So A, B, C, D, accountability, biblical connections, and delight. Good luck finding a church. The Holy Spirit will lead you, and that place will form you into his image.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. The Forgotten Virtue: Why Hard Work Is the Antidote to Modern Malaise (2025)

    Nov 10, 20265 minAudio

    The cultural lie is that work should be effortless. The biblical truth is that sweat is a feature, not a bug. Men are experiencing what feels like malaise - that halfway commitment to work where you're present but not...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Myth of Work-Life Balance: Why Your Search for It Is Destroying Both (2025)

    Nov 3, 20265 minAudio

    The real problem with "work-life balance" is that it's a lie. You've internalized the split: work is over here, life is over there, and if you're smart you'll keep them separate. But God didn't design you that way. He...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Beyond the Mirror: Finding Freedom from Male Body Obsession (2025)

    Oct 27, 20266 minAudio

    Your body is either a tool or an idol. Most men don't realize which one they're treating it as until they're standing in front of the mirror hating what they see. A generation ago, body image was a women's issue. Now...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Your Wife Isn't Your Mother: Dump On the Lord, Connect with Your Wife

    Oct 13, 20266 minAudio

    She married a man. Act like one. There's a version of vulnerability that sounds good in theory but feels terrible in practice: coming home emotionally unfiltered, asking your wife to help you sort through your feelings,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Dumbest Guy in the Room: Using Incompetence to Produce Endurance and Long-Suffering

    Oct 6, 20266 minAudio

    The older you get, the better you become at the things you already do. When was the last time you did something you were genuinely bad at? Years of reps at work, at home, and in your routines build real confidence. They...

    Credit the people on this episode