We have merch! Find our awesome new shirts, mugs and hats at https://shop.askhavivanything.com. To support our work, please consider joining our Substack (https://havivgur.substack.com/), or Buy Me a Coffee (https://buymeacoffee.com/havivrettiggur). If you would like to sponsor an episode, please email us at haviv@askhavivanything.com. And be sure to check us out on Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/haviv.rettig.gur/) and TikTok (https://www.tiktok.com/@haviv.rettig.gur). -- Episode 160: Israel voted, and nobody won. Gadi Eisenkot gets the first shot at forming a government, and there’s no easy path to one. Micah Goodman returns to the podcast with an argument the anti-Bibi camp won’t want to hear: the only way out is a unity government with Netanyahu. Bibi gives up Ben Gvir and the Haredi parties, the opposition gives up replacing him, and Israel gets a government with enough domestic legitimacy to put down the growing chaos at home and turn its battlefield wins into regional normalization. He gives it a 40% chance. Haviv gives it zero. After “no tricks, no shticks” in 2020, what could Netanyahu promise the other side that anyone would believe? And Israel’s tradition, after all, is to crash first and rebuild after. -- This episode was sponsored by a father-daughter duo, Philip Wharton and Sophie Smith, who asked us to share: “At a time when public opinion of Israel is at all time low among young Americans, we dedicate this episode to the young people who take the time to think more critically and independently about these issues. It takes bravery to go against the popular tide, especially on college campuses, and so we tip our hats to you.” Thank you for that dedication, Philip and Sophie. -- Producer and editor: Rachel Gur Presenter and editor: Haviv Gur Operations: Nadav Singerman Musical intro: Adam Ben Amitai -- If you like what we do here, please consider joining our Substack at https://havivgur.substack.com/. You can also “Buy Me a Coffee” at https://buymeacoffee.com/havivrettiggur. It helps us keep the lights on. Patreon and Substack are also the platforms where you can ask the questions that guide the topics we cover on the podcast, join our great discussions where listeners share news and valuable resources, and take part in our monthly livestreams where Haviv answers your questions live. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit havivgur.substack.com/subscribe
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Hi everybody. Welcome to a new episode of Ask Habiv Anything. It is my pleasure to welcome back to the podcast Micha Gudman, prominent Israeli public intellectual, friend of the podcast, and as I say every time I introduce him, my teacher of Rambam, of Maimonides from back in the day at Hebrew University when we were young and the world was young. He's written seven nonfiction books on subjects ranging from Jewish philosophy, the philosophy of technology, political philosophy. And every single one, I think, was a bestseller, certainly in Hebrew, some of them also in English.
SPEAKER_00And Micha now co-hosts a Mifleget HaMachshavot. One of the truly excellent podcasts in the Hebrew language that translates to The Party of Ideas. It's a deep exploration of the ideas behind all kinds of issues, events, Israeli political life and social life, the Jewish world history, America, AI, all kinds different fascinating issues. He co -hosts the podcast with Efrat Shapira Rosenberg, and it is produced by Beit HaVichai We talked to Micha just before the elections,
SPEAKER_00about two weeks ago I guess it was, about the big ideas and the social trends and the tensions that underlie the coming elections, the elections that we had at the end of October. And now, about two weeks later, we have the results. And true to form for an Israeli election, they are profoundly inconclusive. Neither side, not the Netanyahu camp, not the Eisenkot camp, won enough seats to create a government in any easy way. And so today we're going to look at one of the enormous questions that stand
SPEAKER_00before Israeli politics. Gadi Eisenkot received the mandate from the president. He is going to get the first shot at trying to put together a government and replace Netanyahu after many, many years, with the exception of the 18 months of the Benedict government, after many, many years in power. The question is, What options are available to him? What should he go for? He could try for a minority government, a unity government with Likud. Is that even possible? What does Israel actually need? What do Israel's friends need from Israel?
SPEAKER_00What do Israelis need? All of those things are our topic today. Before we get into it, I want to tell you that this episode was sponsored by the father-daughter duo, Philip Wharton and Sophie Smith, who asked to share the following. At a time when public opinion of Israel is at an all-time low among young Americans, we dedicate this episode to the young people who take the time to think more critically and independently about these issues. It takes bravery to go against the popular tide, especially on college campuses. And so we tip our hats to you.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much to Philip and Sophie. I share that sentiment profoundly. I'm a big fan of young people being profoundly critical. That's not entirely what's happening on those campuses. Courage, knowledge, history, roots, understanding where you come from and where you're going. That's at the core of everything that our generation of Jews should be giving to the next generation. I'd also love to invite everyone who finds our work useful, join our Patreon, subscribe to our Substack. Those are communities where you get to ask the questions that guide
SPEAKER_00the topics we choose to talk about. And you get to take part in each of those communities in a monthly live stream. Where I answer your questions live. We even stagger the live streams two weeks apart so that if you join both the Patreon and the Substack, that's two live streams a month. You can join at patreon .com slash askhavivanything or havivgur .substack .com those links are in the show notes. Micha how are you? Confused, worried,
SPEAKER_01Married? Interested? Well, What was breakfast? That's a lot of things. That's a lot of things. It's a cocktail.
SPEAKER_00I think that's basically Israelis. You have been writing, it hasn't published yet, if I understand, you tell us, you have been writing an argument that you want to get into the Israeli conversation about the... Fundamental, deep, profound, serious, maybe historic need for a unity government. Yes. Of Eisenkot's camp and Netanyahu's camp. Let's start there. Walk us through, you know, what that would look like, why you think it's necessary,
SPEAKER_00and then we'll take it apart and look at it from all the different angles.
SPEAKER_01Okay, so I'll try to present three arguments for unity. But before I present, I just want to say, what does unity mean? Unity is a deal where everyone has to compromise. The not Bibi camp, the opposition has to tremendous compromise. That's to give up their dream to replace Bibi in the foreseeable future. Right? It's a very big compromise. Bibi has to give up his natural partners, Benville, the ultra Orthodox,
SPEAKER_01They have to give up the BB thing. BB has to give up the BB government thing. That's the deal. Now, you understand Israeli politics and tactics much better than I do. I can't assess what are the chances of this government being formed. But before we go into the arguments, so I explain why this might be in the interest of both sides. In the interest of the not BB camp, the not BB camp, the opposition, has been living in the past four years under three nightmares.
SPEAKER_01Benvir is a nightmare, the Haredim is a nightmare, and Bibi is a nightmare. This government shrinks the amount of nightmares from three to one. Much better than the current situation. But far from ideal, but much better than the current situation. Bibi... Now Bibi might calculate that it's better for him to go to elections. Nobody can go into Bibi's mind. But Bibi might also calculate that you don't want to waste Trump's last years in the White House, these critical strategic years, enrolling in elections after,
SPEAKER_01wasting this time in elections after elections after elections. So this question is, is Bibi calculating what's right for him politically, or is he seeing the historic opportunity he has? I don't know where Bibi's mind is, but I think that's where the dilemma is. Now, this is why it could happen. Maybe there's a 30, 40% chance it could happen. I want to argue why it needs to happen. And let's start with the crisis of Israel, of Israel's diplomatic crisis.
SPEAKER_01Okay, now, and we're after, I mean, because we're both, we're after a war, we're after our elections, and we're also after the midterms. And now we see things a little bit more clearly. And it's very obvious that I think me and you and Haviv agree that Israel did, the Israeli army had tremendous successes in this war. In weakening and defeating our enemies we had I think we could agree a certain level of a not an absolute victory but a good enough victory and I'm talking about a kinetic victory in the battlefield.
SPEAKER_01Against Hamas, against Hezbollah, against other proxies. Iran was also taken backwards. Tremendous, not the absolute childish fantasy of an absolute victory, but a good enough victory kinetically. But we paid a price for the kinetic victory. And the prices that we sacrificed are standing in the world. We sacrificed legitimacy in order to restore the turrets. That was the deal. Think about our situation on October 8th, 2023.
SPEAKER_01The love of the West was high and the fear of the Middle East from Israel was low. The jihadi forces on October 8th were looking at Israel, which seems like it lost its might, lost its mojo. The intelligence could already collapse. The army doesn't really exist. Our enemies lost their fear, but our friends around the world loved us on October 8th. Three years later, I think the asymmetry is now upside down. Yes, the fear is high, but the love and appreciation for Israel among its friends is very low.
SPEAKER_01That's the price we pay for the kinetic victory. And now, here's the big question. Now, after elections and after the war, We might have an opportunity to take it the next step, means to leverage the kinetic victory in order to win back the legitimacy that we sacrificed in order to achieve that victory. And I'm talking about opportunities in Lebanon. We have now real bargaining cards with the Lebanese governance.
SPEAKER_01After weakening Hezbollah dramatically, in some sense helping the Lebanese people liberate themselves from the tyranny of Iran, And the fact that we literally have territory in Lebanon, that is an opportunity. In Syria, there is an opportunity. And maybe there might even be an opportunity for some kind of an arrangement with Saudi Arabia. Now, by the way, Haviv, I see these opportunities. I don't think that we're going to have No full normalization in any of these fronts. But if we're pragmatic and smart, we might achieve partial normalization in these fronts.
SPEAKER_01And to do this, and if we manage to pull this off, some kind of partial normalization with Lebanon, a security arrangement with Syria, enough normalization with Saudi Arabia in order to promote IMAC, this would be These small steps would be a tremendous step in creating... A new story coming out of the Middle East. Suddenly, good news coming out of the Middle East. Suddenly, the world seems upside down.
SPEAKER_01Because I was born and raised in a world where Israel was very legitimate in the West and illegitimate in the Middle East. But happens if there's a process where there's a beginning of legitimization for Israel in the Middle East. What will that do to the process of DE-legitimization of Israel in the West? I think it would stop it. I think it is a turning point, which means the natural move is after Israel sacrificed legitimacy to achieve a kinetic victory, now to leverage the fruits of the kinetic victory to win back legitimacy.
SPEAKER_01That's the next move on the strategic map that we're using to navigate through history. Now, this kind of a move needs internal legitimacy and diplomatic flexibility. Now, Khabib's government... Doesn't have the flexibility. Babies, governments, can't do it. Obviously can't do it. There'll be no move, no flexibility, not in Syria, not in Lebanon, not with Saudi,
SPEAKER_01no maneuvering room under... So this government can't, Bibi's government can't pull this off. But here's a very confusing fact, Haviv, which I find it very hard to argue with. While Bibi's government can't pull this off, only Bibi can. That's why I think why. Imagine if a narrow, let's say, God the Isengard, I think the chances are extremely slim, manages to create a narrow government.
SPEAKER_01I don't know, if the Olds were Orthodox, getting to 61, let's say. Or a minority government that relies on parties that some of them are anti-Zionist. Let's say he manages to do that. They have a very narrow, fragile government that suffers from a serious deficit in legitimacy. Let's say they pull that off. Do you think that government could move Israel towards partial normalization with Syria, Lebanon, and Saudi Arabia?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely not, because just do the math. Any move of that government will be confronted with the entire opposition led by guess who, Bibi Netanyahu. That itself would activate all the right-wingers within Eisenkot's coalition, like my good friends, Achille Tropper. And Elias Peretz and Shira Shapira, it would be seen as... You see, the interesting fact about Israeli history of different diplomatic arrangements
SPEAKER_01in the Middle East is that back in the 90s, when we spoke about two-state solution like the Clinton plan, those were plans that created the division between right and left. But in 2020, when Trump offered his plan, it was 2020, right? The Kushner plan, the Trump plan, Peace to Prosperity. That was a plan that created a schism not between right and left, but between the deep ideological purest right and the pragmatic right.
SPEAKER_01Normalization with Syria, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia has the potential not to be a schism between center-right and Sorry, center left and right, but between pragmatic right and extreme right. And if Bibi is there leading it, so here's the math, you have the pragmatic right plus the center plus the center left, together the math works. So here, this is very hard. I mean, Bibi's government doesn't have the flexibility. The opposition doesn't have the legitimacy.
SPEAKER_01Only a national unity government that is created out of these impossible compromises could lead to partial normalization which means Havivgur the only way to create A new architecture for the Middle East Is to create a new architecture for Israeli politics. To break the illusion of two blocks. Separate Bibi from his natural allies. And the opposition to join Bibi. Probably not all of them would join Bibi. That means it would be a new architecture for Israeli politics.
SPEAKER_01As a precondition for a move that would create a new architecture for the Middle East.
SPEAKER_00There are a few problems with this. Number one. The opposition would be sacrificing everything in terms of their political position. If the opposition does what you suggest, they can't afford another election. The next election they will have collapsed. And if Netanyahu goes into a coalition with the Eisenkot camp and leaves his own partners behind, and watches the Eisenkot camp collapse in the polls because they sat with him,
SPEAKER_00And then understands that the next election will do much better by him and he can bring his own people back. Is Netanyahu going to hold that coalition together and let the far right and the Haredim stew and be angry and develop, you know, a future willingness to not sit with him, to not see themselves as loyal partners? Netanyahu's own political interests very quickly, as soon as the polls collapse on the Eisenkot side, will be a second election, which Eisenkot will fear much more than Netanyahu. And so Netanyahu's leverage in that government will be absolute, essentially.
SPEAKER_00And then there's the foreign policy point, which I agree with you that in the Middle East, Ashraf doesn't care if it's Netanyahu or Eisenkot. He truly has no, it's not relevant to him. He'll test Eisenkot in a way that I don't think he needs to test Netanyahu. He kind of knows who he's working with. So if, you know, a Syrian-Israeli detente that may be even deeper than detente... That could be a very profound, serious thing going forward. This Syria probably wants it. I don't know if it wants it over the long term and thinks of it as peace, but it certainly wants a ceasefire and cooperation and to push a little bit back
SPEAKER_00on Turkish domination of the new Syria. In the Middle East, those kinds of things are certainly possible. The Middle East doesn't care if it's Netanyahu or not. You know who cares profoundly if it's Netanyahu or not? The new Senate, the new Congress. Netanyahu will have a hard time building anything internationally, rebuilding, pushing back. Britain is moving ahead with more and more sanctions on Israeli banking systems. And Britain is probably going to be the front runner and is probably going to get worse going forward.
SPEAKER_00Netanyahu is not the man who can stop that. Netanyahu is the target of it. And so we have a prime minister who internationally can't bring Israel's standing back to any kind of stability in the West. Regionally, it doesn't really matter if it's Netanyahu or Eisenhower, the only thing that matters is wise policy and good negotiating skills. And domestically, in terms of domestic politics, he will dominate that coalition and crush the opposition. And all of that tells me it'll solve a lot fewer of the problems you describe.
SPEAKER_00We're still going to be in deep water in Washington. We're still going to be deep negatives in London and Paris and Berlin, the places where these are our major trading bloc, right? And I cannot imagine the Eisenkot bloc going along with it, with Netanyahu still in the prime minister's chair, because that'll destroy them politically. So tackle those three questions, two questions, really. It doesn't help us in the West, and Eisenkot will be sacrificing everything politically.
SPEAKER_01So regarding the West, the movement from Netanyahu's government... To a new government. That's not hijacked by the extremists. And you don't have the old orthodox. That's a new government. It's a different government. And I agree. You have Netanyahu, at least for the first two years, on top as the face of this government. It is transition. It is not the ideal transition that people in the West were waiting for. But I think Israel standing in the world is dependent not only on who, but also on what.
SPEAKER_01Meaning not only who is the face, but also what we do. And A move towards normalization, changing the narrative, creating a new momentum, creating a new story, radiating good news from showing that there is legitimacy building in the Middle East to stop the delegitimization of Israel in the West. That's a move that only a Bibi, that Bibi's government can't promote, but only Bibi can. It's the only government that will have the internal legitimacy to pull this off.
SPEAKER_00Why will the opposition not have that legitimacy? Who will rob the opposition of that legitimacy, who will campaign against it, who rage against it ,who will play spoiler to anyone but him doing anything. And then he's in and so there are costs to him being in and Nobody can do anything with him out because he will make sure to take the entire machinery of right wing discourse that delegitimizes everybody and everything else. And I mean, that's, that's what we're talking about. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01If BB's not in, he will delegitimize. We're not living in a normal world and this is not an ideal situation. Haviv, I know who Bibi is. I'm an Israeli. In Israel we know how to tell when Bibi lies. He does that thing with his lips. He moves them. That's how we know when he lies. I know he is not the ideal political partner. He's probably the worst. But I'm just saying, he is ideal.
SPEAKER_00It's not like Lieberman doesn't lie. It's not like Bennett hasn't made these deep, deep lies to his own voter base. I'm not asking politicians to be honest. I'm saying it is, if Netanyahu takes on your deal, right? And then he looks around and he says, hey, I have this government with Eisenkot, but they expect me to go to these places and guess what's happening outside the coalition? The one thing Eisenkot will have to deliver if he's number two in a Netanyahu, first of all, there's a rotation with Netanyahu. It'll never happen. It's not a two-year move toward a rotation.
SPEAKER_00We've been in this movie before, as they say in Hebrew. Why would Netanyahu take this deal so that he's not replaced? Again. And then immediately, having forced the left to compromise, the center left to compromise on their one big promise of replacing Netanyahu, call the second election. Why wouldn't he do that?
SPEAKER_01Why wouldn't he treat them the way he treated guns? So I want to offer you a Netanyahu theory. Yeah. Now, I'm saying, I'm not saying, I'm not sure this is true, but I think it could be true. Okay. Netanyahu is always interested in two things, two L's, liberty and legacy. When I say liberty, I don't mean liberalism, John Stuart Mill, I mean not going to jail, liberty, right? And his legacy. The problem is that the government that will push him towards liberty is And play with a judicial system in order to achieve, in order to making it easier for him to achieve liberty is not the government
SPEAKER_01of legacy. There is no Saudi move with this government, with Ben-Viren's motto. There's no, and the government of legacy, there's no playing around with the liberty. Now, the only, now, if there'll be a national unity government, which Herzog is supposed to create, is supposed to design, you know what the deal is, right? The deal is, That he joined the government and then he gets his liberty, meaning President Herzog will offer some form of parting for Netanyahu,
SPEAKER_01assuming he'll leave after two years. And he gets two years under ideal conditions. President Trump's last term. And a coalition which is flexible diplomatically. Now, Bibi might see the political opportunity. I agree with you. He might see the historic opportunity. If he wants to go for his liberty and legacy, this is the move that takes him there. Again, Bibi is so sophisticated, it's hard to predict what he will do. I do think for the opposition, you're going down from three nightmares,
SPEAKER_01Ben Vicharudim Netanyahu, to one. And from Bibi, he's going for a... An opportunity to leave a legacy and arm the way while he's trying to achieve his liberty.
SPEAKER_00You just said something enormous and impossible. And that doesn't mean we shouldn't think about it. What you just said was, Isencote's going to form his government, his coalition, his policies. And he's going to need to get a majority to pull from Netanyahu's camp really just one small group, which is Netanyahu and his people. That's what you just said. And the reason Itzaniel is going to agree to come over to that government
SPEAKER_00and be stable in that government, and even though he's prime minister, do the Eisenkot policy strategy thing. It's power sharing, yes, but it's not his government anymore. There's no such thing as power sharing with Itzaniel. It's just we've done it. You know what I mean? Like, if this was March 2020, Rotation. What a great idea. We have these two camps. They can't decide. We're after that. We're after that. 2020 had no state budget that year because Netanyahu needed to dissolve parliament after having passed basic law changes, amendments to our constitutional system.
SPEAKER_00I was there. National television, just for people who don't know, Netanyahu in 2020, March, Gantz was leaving a camp, Netanyahu was leaving a camp, they neither had the majority, and Netanyahu said, let's form a rotation government, unity government, and I promise, I swear, he said this We will sit together and we will have a unity government. That is what this great COVID crisis that's hitting in March 2020, that's what it demands. And they formed this thing and they changed the basic laws in like 20 places,
SPEAKER_00The Knesset during that period of that government change the basic laws and those changes were brought about literally for the sole reason that nobody believed Netanyahu, that he would ever cycle out when his rotation is finished. And he said, no, I will do it. I swear it. And he literally, he gave a speech with the Bli Trikim Bli Shtikim speech, no tricks, no sticks. It was just about how everyone on earth knew he was lying. That was what the speech was about. That was what national discourse was about.
SPEAKER_00Gantz's coalition fell apart. Lapid took Yesh Atid out of it. Lapid said to Gantz, Gantz, buddy, you're never going to be prime minister. It doesn't matter how many constitutional changes. You don't know, baby. This is like new to you. You're like a former chief of staff of the IDF. These generals come into a non-hierarchical political system and are often lost. We don't yet know if Eisenkut is better than Gantz was, but Gantz was a child in the political system. And then, of course, Bibi had one last constitutional mechanism for avoiding rotation.
SPEAKER_00The budget never passed in 2020, and that automatically triggers, under Israeli law, the basic law of the Knesset, a dissolution of the Knesset. And so, Netanyahu has already done this, and he has already cheated, and he did it after swearing on national television, and he did it after changing our constitutional order, inventing the parity government. Wow. I'll tell you what's worse, Haviv. There's
SPEAKER_01nothing left! What could he say to me?
SPEAKER_00Okay, but no, this time for real. What's left to say to me? He's going to change the constitution to make it impossible? They'll still find a way. What is left? Let's imagine I'm a BB voter. There's no BB voter who doesn't know this. What's left for him to say that could do that? One second. Now you're saying there's one thing left. What if he gets a pardon? What if all his corruption trials go away? Now, I have to just lay it all out there. There was a podcast episode where I laid this all out.
SPEAKER_00I'm a huge fan of a pardon for Netanyahu. I hate Netanyahu's cases. I hate the corruption trial. I think it's borderline encompassing And probably and a right winger who says it's an attempt through the legal system to bring down somebody they couldn't bring down at the ballot box is it has a case they have a case because the argument that he was bribed. That's positive media coverage, which is case 4000. The major case the more important case of the cases is an innovative argument
SPEAKER_00that has never been made in Israeli law it has never That a bribe, the quid pro quo for a bribee in a corruption trial with, you know, that could send you to prison—the quad pro quo is positive media That's the argument in case 4 ,000. That has never been made in any Israeli corruption trial in the history of Israel. It's nowhere on the books. It's not in the law. There's no precedent. And then it turns out there's no precedent of that in any democracy ever. It is in total legal innovation and it is targeting a sitting prime minister.
SPEAKER_00And not just that, because Because positive media coverage is being defined by the prosecution in this corruption trial as the bribe he received, because that's the bribe, police have been scouring media coverage of him to try and figure out if they can find it to be overly optimistic, overly positive, overly beneficial to him. My journalistic work has now legally become, as a collateral damage of this trial, Something that prosecutors can read to find out if I'm too positive or too negative
SPEAKER_00toward politicians and figure out if maybe that's a benefit or not a benefit. And all the journalists are going to notice this in about 10 years and say, what the heck happened is becoming a criminalization, a legalization. Of media coverage, of the press. This is a disaster, Netanyahu's corruption trial. It changed him. It changed the right. It gave the far right leverage over him because he needs to get out of this legal problem. And it's the weakest imaginable case you could possibly have. I want that pardon.
SPEAKER_00Is that pardon going to be what actually creates actual rotation slash actual unity slash a fundamental policy shift away from the far right toward what Bibi has always been, which is a kind of center right hawk butt, very worried about the economy, very invested in diplomatic relations. You think that's enough?
SPEAKER_01I give it 40%. The combination of his liberty, pardon, no more court case, plus the historic opportunity of Trump in the White House for the last two years, and a coalition that Bibi gives the legitimacy and they give him the flexibility to go on the move with Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, or Syria. You see, I always think about there's two Bibi's. There's Bibi that's the son of his father.
SPEAKER_01And there is a baby that's the father of his son. And these are two different BBs. There's the BB that has the more historic understanding, the long-term historic understanding and understanding where we are in the large arc of history. That's one BB. And there is the other BB. Explain that. Explain that to people who don't know the characters involved. His father was a famous historian. He's a great historian, a great thinker, a great historian. I read a lot of his writings. He's a great historian and a very deep analyzer and thinker.
SPEAKER_01And interpreter of Jewish history. And Bibi is his son. And then there's the Bibi, the father of his son. Now, I don't know his son, but his son is considered an Israel. Like, directs Bibi to thinking only about the immediate political win or loss. And Bibi's father represents the Bibi that thinks about the long-term threats. Where are we in the long historical? And if we map out history, where are we now in history? And will BB see that, okay, if I get my liberty,
SPEAKER_01there's a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity for a legacy move. Trump's last two years with a coalition that will give me the legitimacy and the flexibility to do this. How will BB calculate this? I get this 40%, Haviv.
SPEAKER_00Micha, there is zero chance. That is not why Eisenkot got elected. Oh, so now... It's not just that. First of all, I don't believe... No, first of all, I don't... Again, if we had been having this conversation five years ago, six years ago, I would have said, there are two BBs, and one is this very predatory, break-everything, stay-in-power kind of guy... And the other one really is that great historic figure who thinks of himself
SPEAKER_00in historic terms and thinks of policy in historic terms, thinks of Israel in historic terms. And yes, the man behind those figures, those two figures, will choose the historic figure always. We've gone so far down that road. Why would Eisenkot give everything up to give Netanyahu one more chance? You're saying to Eisenkot, hey, you know, if you actually take power, Netanyahu's going to try and spoil everything. To prevent him from being that spoiler of all the great policy needs that this country has, in your opinion, you have to let him keep running the country.
SPEAKER_01That's a weak argument to Eisenkot. But Khabib, you're saying let's not pretend that Netanyahu is someone that he's nuts. And I'm with you on this. But let's also not pretend that there is any other options, any real options. What other options do the godly eyes think would have? 61 with the ultra-orthodox? Is that the option that he has? A minority government that depends on parties that some of them are not only post-Zionist but anti-Zionist and thinks that our army committed genocide.
SPEAKER_01Like what other options does he, real options does he have? Now I must say, Haviv, I'm not against what Gadi is doing now. Because I think the only way in the end to negotiate with Netanyahu is to have real leverage. If he's bluffing, I'm not against what he's doing now. But the thought that he really has these options out there is going to... Now once one of these options... Oh, and finally, another election cycle, that's a viable option for Gadi Eisenkot?
SPEAKER_01To go to election after he violated his promise and sat with the Haredim and promised them to guarantee their exemption from the army? It's not that you have many, so while we can't lie to ourselves about who Bibi is, let's also not lie to ourselves that Gadi Eisenkot has other options, opportunities.
SPEAKER_00And the situation is extremely complicated. If you establish a 61 with the ultra-Orthodox and you compromise painfully on the question of the draft, and then you have a 61 that's very vulnerable. Why is it vulnerable? Two people leave. Two of the right-wing edges under Bennett or under Lieberman are pulled by Likud with the promise of being defense minister. That's what we had in the Bennett-Lapid government.
SPEAKER_00Then the whole thing collapses. But that weakens if you can still rely on Ra'am. But Ra'am is very weakened if you already have 61 without them. Why wouldn't Haredi and relying on Ra'am from the outside, while giving Ra'am the one thing it wants, which is crime fighting and Segalovitch and dealing with crime in the Arab community, both of them together... Might be pretty stable. No single group can leave.
SPEAKER_01I gave 40% for the possibility of unity. Yeah. That Shas will join a center-left government. And you'll bring all Aguda. Aguda is not seven MKs. It's five different parties. Yes, this guy belongs to Vishnu, to this guy, to Gur. The thought that you could put all this together without losing, and you have to do two things, to bring 13 Haredi MKs to a partnership with a coalition of Yair Gorbachev. I would give that 5%, probably he could bring all of them.
SPEAKER_01And to do that without losing Eliasaf Peretz and Shira Shapira and Chidi Troper and devoted people that joined Eisenkot and Bennett under the promise that this is the government that will put an end to the Haredi autonomy. To put this all together, I think the chances are Very slim. Close to... Unity has a much, much higher... The chances for unity are much higher.
SPEAKER_00Dan Eisenkot has no options. Unity will mean he can't afford another election because he will be crushed. There's a huge percent of his vote, of his constituency, that I want the day after Bibi now. That's a huge part of who voted for those parties. Lieberman, for example. And there is a smaller, but still exists, part of his vote that can't sit with Ram and the Joint List.
SPEAKER_00And there is a smaller still, but still significant part of his vote that is very deeply troubled with the idea of sitting with the ultra-Orthodox parties and giving to them the whole question of the draft.
SPEAKER_01And maintaining the Haredi growing autonomy that Israel can't economically carry on its shoulders. And once a central left gives that to them, it's legitimized forever.
SPEAKER_00So you know what? So there's any move he makes to establish a coalition with any of those edges, loses him some piece of the electorate in the second round and forms a coalition that would be unbelievably weak. And therefore easily toppleable by a Netanyahu who will do nothing between now and then, but campaign and rage against it. And so he needs a second election. And there's two options for what happens in a second election, either in a second election, Netanyahu is, you know, he had one four year term,
SPEAKER_00but four indecisive elections before that, and then an indecisive election after that. Maybe Netanyahu is the problem, and maybe he continues to sink. Netanyahu's loss of hundreds of thousands of voters on election day is why Netanyahu is in this position, okay? Maybe that continues. On the other side, maybe the Arabs can replicate what they achieved. Maybe... Right. I mean, and the Shin Bet, the Zini who now says hundreds of millions of dollars came.
SPEAKER_00Well, now Zini knows that his one job, if by the way, the head of the Shabbat oversaw an election in which hundreds of millions of dollars in voter fraud came into the country from overseas and he's in charge. Why isn't he fired? I mean, if Netanyahu genuinely believes that that's what happened and the head of the Shabak is now publicly saying it in service to Netanyahu's attempt to discredit the election. That's a good question. Why is it the guy fired? That's his one job. That's a good question. He's the guy in charge of it. So he's not fired because... Because nobody in the system believes it actually happened,
SPEAKER_00his job is to run Netanyahu's campaign for him, is the fear. And I am starting to share that fear simply because he's not fired. Likud are not angry at him for this having happened. And that tells me it didn't happen. His one job will be to make sure it doesn't happen this time. What if the Arabs replicate 19 seats or even 16 seats?
SPEAKER_01If I make a prediction about next elections... The chances are Bibi won't have a government, a majority, and we'll replicate this deadlock all over again, right? And then you'll see growing voices of people for national unity. So I'm saying if we're going to that compromise sometime in the next elections or the elections after that, let's already do it now. And while we're trying to escape the immediate tactical calculations,
SPEAKER_01I want to offer another argument for unity. Besides the geopolitical arguments. And rescuing Israel from isolation through movement of legitimization in the Middle East. Another serious challenge that Israel has, besides isolation, is growing chaos from within. That is actually... The real, this combination is the existential threat that we have chaos growing up, growing from within, and isolation from without.
SPEAKER_01And the chaos has many faces. One face is violent, radical, sellers, in different hilltops, People don't understand this radical settlers. And they're organized. Organized using violence. I don't think people locate this within the right category. It's in the category now of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. It's not in the category of the war. It's in the category of glowing chaos.
SPEAKER_01If you have a shop in Be'er Sheva, the chances are that you're paying protection. You're paying the protection to organize Bedouin crime in the South. But if you have a shop in Be'er Sheva, you're probably paying them protection. Where is the law? You have gangs in the North. Yes, and you have within the Arab minority, you have growing rates of crime that are just growing and nothing's putting them down. Oh, and by the way, when the Olds were Orthodox, Protests.
SPEAKER_01Because we'd rather die than join the military. So they block roads and they burn them up. The chaos, what's happening in the hilltops is only a part of a large, more troubling phenomenon. And that's the growth of chaos. Now, and the growth of chaos in Israel is also a part of a growing phenomenon. Look at France. Look at Belgium.
SPEAKER_01Look at different places in the United States of America. We see there is a global, there is a geopolitical El Nino going on in the world. Chaos is growing all over. Now, in order to put chaos down, what you need is a government that enjoys critical mass of legitimacy. Imagine, because what happens when a government... That has a deficit in internal legitimacy tries to put down chaos. It looks like the French government. The attempt to put chaos down rings it up.
SPEAKER_01Increases it. Imagine an Izemkot narrow government relying on anti-Zionists from Balad and Kadesh. Imagine that government trying to put down the chaos of the hilltop radicals. So, people from all over the right would go join them. It would turn into a protest against the government. The attempt to put chaos down would increase it and amplify it. Only a government where the Likud is a part of the government will have
SPEAKER_01the legitimacy to crush chaos. We need a national unity government not only to liberate ourselves from international isolation, but also to bring down chaos within Israel. I know it's hard to achieve a national unity government, but you need critical mass of legitimacy both for moves with normalization diplomatically and to put down chaos internally. That's a very deep idea. Bibi's government doesn't want to. Bibi's government doesn't want to.
SPEAKER_01Enough. But Eisenhower's government can't. We need the will and the capability. And to marry them both, you need a national unity government. Now, a narrow government will only enable chaos. It won't have critical mass of legitimacy to put it down.
SPEAKER_00Micha, you took it to a very deep place and a very important place. A lot of these trends, you know, it's easy to blame Netanyahu for a lot of them. But if they're also happening in France, Netanyahu is riding a wave that he finds himself in rather than literally masterminding the breakdown of systems and trust and all of this. But also Netanyahu is doing it.
SPEAKER_00I want to say it's not literally him. It's social media algorithms. It's a change in culture. It's happening everywhere to everybody because of how information works now and algorithms. It's also him. The judicial reform could have happened one way, and it was a choice to have it happen a completely different way. Trust destroying way. This is an argument made many times on this podcast that if you're going to have a complicated negotiation where you're compromising on multiple different places and across time, you need a lot of trust.
SPEAKER_00And the only way to do that is you must, you can never take the strategy of a maximalist opening position that you can take with a simple negotiation over the price of something. You can't take that in a complex negotiation where there's many moving parts. And in order to give here, I have to know that I will receive over there a month later, right? So we need trust. I can't open with a maximalist position that destroys trust. This government back in 2023, January 2023,
SPEAKER_00opened with a judicial reform so radical that Yeriv Yerive Levine, the Justice Minister's own people and Netanyahu's own people, and I think Netanyahu personally in public, I think later in March of 2023, declared that obviously it was a maximalist opening position for people to then come to negotiate. They break and then they don't understand why everything's broken. Netanyahu is not unaware of what's happening.
SPEAKER_00Um, with the hundreds of people involved in the violence that we're talking about. He's not unaware of what's happening with the Arab criminal networks and organizations. He has ceded it to Ben Gvir, and he's sitting back and watching it.
SPEAKER_01But you can't learn from the policies of Netanyahu's government and attach that to a national unity government, because it's not Netanyahu's government. It's not hijacked by Ben Gvir anymore.
SPEAKER_00Miche, there will have to be so much work. Do you know what it will take to reign in? Never mind the Arab crime families. They're going to bring in the Shabak to ride shotgun with the police, and they're going to crack down, and there's going to be... We have the courts, we have the police that can do that. It'll take years, it'll take... Take money, but it's doable. Benville explicitly doesn't want to do it.
SPEAKER_01He wants them to suffer. And that's why a government without Benville is essential. Great. Without Benville, it has the will, but with Bibi, it has the legitimacy.
SPEAKER_00Who's going to crack down? Who's going to crack down in the hilltops? Who's going to crack down in the West Bank? Judea and Samaria, just for the emails. Who's going to crack down? Who's actually gonna do that? And when it turns violent between Jews, What's the opposition going to do whether or not Netanyahu? And can Netanyahu do that crackdown knowing that he's creating a breach with the future partners that he's still planning?
SPEAKER_01There's only a UNI government if Bibi gives up his natural alliance with the far right. That's the deal. The left gives up replacing it. The central left gives up replacing Netanyahu. Netanyahu gives up his partners. That's the deal. That's the deal. We have, I think, a 30-40% chance to make it there. That's the deal. There is no other deal. It's not that Eisenkot joining the current Netanyahu government and then all your critique is right, it's true. This is a different government, a different architecture of Israeli power.
SPEAKER_01And it's the only government that could put down chaos from within and make a move in the Middle East. Now, and Haviv, I want to make, I want to sound even more naive than I sound. Okay, I want to make a third argument if we have time. We're looking at this El Nino, this geopolitical El Nino. We're looking at France, we're looking at Germany, the AfD is getting strong, the alternative for Deutschland, the radical right, and the Linke, the radical left.
SPEAKER_01Which has players in it that support Hamas. We're seeing that. We're seeing Melanchon getting strong and LaPen getting strong in France. We're seeing a whole generation of right-wingers being hypnotized by Tucker Carlson on the right. And then we see the rise of Abdullah al-Sayed and Zohar al-Mamdani. We're seeing a global phenomenon. And where power is always attracted to the, power is relocating and is being attracted to the extremes. A national unity government separates power from the extremes.
SPEAKER_01It would, Israel would be now, if we do that, if we pull that off, Israel will be on the other side of the flow of history, against the flow of history. And the national unity government won't bring us unity. I'm not that naive. Because I believe in today's political climates, just like in physics there's the law of preservation of energy, in politics there's the law of preservation of polarization. You can't cancel polarization, but you can relocate it.
SPEAKER_01And that's what a national unity government does. Right now, Israel is divided, central left versus right. Once you have a national unity government, so now the polarization is relocated. It's the mainstream Israelis versus the extremists. Imagine a government, Haviv, that in Haaretz, they criticize it, that it's a fascist government, and the Benghils criticize that it's a left-wing government. And polarization in a new form, When the mainstream is attacked from the extremes,
SPEAKER_01that new form polarization, I think makes polarization bearable. Right now, polarization is a part of, is an existential risk. So by reorganizing polarization, I think you're saving Israel from polarization and saving Israel from this geopolitical storm that is shaking Western civilization.
SPEAKER_00That's not bringing peace, it's just relocating the war. This was extremely helpful to me as an exercise in figuring out exactly what the options are for Eisenkot, for Netanyahu, what the obstacles are in the system, what prevents the system from moving forward. I would say my fundamental question would be, and this is a question that I know that Eisenkot will be asking, and I know how Eisenkot will answer it, and that's why none of this could possibly work.
SPEAKER_00Would anything be enough for Netanyahu? Would anything actually make Netanyahu trustworthy? Can you give him something now when you're going to receive from him the quid pro quo In a year, in two years, in three months, not going to an election after I broke my, all my promises. And the answer is no. And now we're at a point where because there's zero, now if Netanyahu came forward for the first time after having given Gantz his rotation for two years, and by the way, then won the next election.
SPEAKER_00Now we would be talking about how that's the solution to all our problems. And of course, Bibi can go first. He's best. He's closest to Trump, but that's not the conversation we're having. The trust is gone. And so with Netanyahu, I really truly think on the domestic stuff, on the chaos stuff you were talking about, on Benvir running all these systems, on our relationship with the new democratic Washington, I really think we crash. And after crashing, we have to pick up the pieces.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know that Netanyahu can or wants to do anything other than lead us into that crash because it holds him in power one year, two years, three more years. And to ask Eisenco to dismantle everything that he's built, a second election is much more comfortable for him. This is by the way, the awful dynamic right now, because a second election is a possibility. It becomes extremely likely because nobody can make the compromises that would compromise them in that second election. And so that lack of compromise is probably true politically.
SPEAKER_01But if we try to think about this in this moment in Jewish history, which is a scary moment, dark moment, paralysis and chaos from within Israel and isolation from without. It's not a healthy cocktail. It's a very dangerous cocktail. Isolation plus chaos. And I think, and the only way out is almost impossible politically, a national unity government. But I think it's worth a shot.
SPEAKER_01And I've wound up this conversation that enabled me to just present the argument for national unity government, a multi-layered argument for national unity government, because it's not relevant now. Right now, I think the Isencots and the Bents of the world, they're trying to show Bibi that they have an alternative to unity with him. And that's probably the only way to gain leverage towards the moment where they'll have to make a very tough decision and to sacrifice and make a very...
SPEAKER_01See, it might even be political suicide for them. It might even be political suicide for them. Again, it would be political suicide again. And it might not. It might not. It's hard. It's hard to understand. It might not. It depends where the public is. But I don't think we're having a serious enough conversation in Israel and outside of Israel about unity and about the need for national unity government at this moment in history.
SPEAKER_00I wish that was the kind of politics we're in. We are so far down a very different road. You know, we're Zionists and the fate of Zionists at the beginning of Zionism was to know what's coming and to have to sit and watch it all happen and to lay the groundwork for the day after. And this is not that. This is the strongest Jews who ever lived with a lot of options. There's a long way for us to fall before we fall into what the best situation
SPEAKER_00for Jews ever was other than our generation. This is really a blessed generation with almost infinite gifts and benefits and safety and strength. Our task, I think, is to lay the groundwork for what comes after this political system drives the country into a brick wall. And that's, by the way, how it happened with the, you know, the Israeli economy crashed in the 80s, triple digit inflation for eight years. And then a unity government came, but it came after the currency was canceled twice. Then a unity government, or the second
SPEAKER_00time was already the unity government. It came after everyone's life savings were already wiped out. An honest unity government didn't come at the beginning of the crisis to solve the crisis. It came after the crash to rebuild. We crashed, then we rebuild. That's the Israeli tradition.
SPEAKER_01You remind us something very important about the Israeli tradition. Is that national unity governments in the past were very successful. It was a national unity government, people don't know this, that led to the victory in the Six-Day War. It was a national unity government that got us out of Lebanon and shrunk inflation in the 80s. It was a national unity government of Shimon Peres. And Arik Sharon, the titan of the right and the titan of the left that broke the second intifada in Operation Defensive Shield. Oh, and narrow governments have a tendency to fail.
SPEAKER_01It was the Oslo government that was narrow. It was the first Lebanon war that was a narrow government. And this government, narrow governments have a tendency to fail. I mean, that's what Israeli political history teaches us. After the crash. Maybe we could be smarter this time.
SPEAKER_00No, we can't. You've not met this, people. We're on our fourth currency, I think. They canceled the currency early on in the 40s and early 50s, I think. No, this is a beautifully run, incredibly competent country that's on its fourth currency. No, we crash, then we rebuild. That's the tradition. Yes, Eisenkot is trapped. Yes, Netanyahu is the problem. By the way, his trial really is part of the problem for him because he can only be prime minister. He can't be a minister in a government because there's a tradition established
SPEAKER_00by the Supreme Court, not by law, that a sitting minister can't be under indictment and investigation. So he can't be deputy prime minister. He can only be prime minister, which is also why there's never going to be a rotation no matter what he agrees to. All of these different things are obstacles standing in the way of anything useful in any way out of...
SPEAKER_01And yet, liberty and legacy might be a real temptation for Netanyahu. 40%.
SPEAKER_00Look, if everything you ever wanted for Israel happened, it would be a very happy place. But... 40%. Yeah. Well, thank you so much for coming on. I... I had a lot of fun talking about just how awful this political moment really, really is. And when you've wasted all the trust and you built out a politics of polarization for so many years, suddenly you have a hard time getting things done. Who would have thought? Who would have thought? And yeah, Eisenkot is in a trap.
SPEAKER_00I don't know how he gets out of. And things will get worse. And then the Jews will fix it somehow. Alright, maybe we could fix it before. Thanks, Micha. Thank you, Haviv.
We have merch! Find our awesome new shirts, mugs and hats at https://shop.askhavivanything.com. To support our work, please consider joining our Substack (https://havivgur.substack.com/), or Buy Me a Coffee...
We have merch! Find our awesome new shirts, mugs and hats at https://shop.askhavivanything.com. To support our work, please consider joining our Substack (https://havivgur.substack.com/), or Buy Me a Coffee...
A note from Haviv to our viewers: Please excuse the video troubles. Elizabeth’s connectivity was limited for the first half hour or so of the conversation. But the audio came through perfectly and we didn’t want to...
To support our work, please consider joining our Substack (https://havivgur.substack.com/), or Buy Me a Coffee (https://buymeacoffee.com/havivrettiggur). We have merch! Find our awesome new shirts, mugs and hats at...
To support our work, please consider joining our Patreon community (https://www.patreon.com/c/AskHavivAnything), Substack (https://havivgur.substack.com/), or Buy Me a Coffee (https://buymeacoffee.com/havivrettiggur)....