Losing a major donor over a skipped thank-you can sink a quarterly campaign. Veteran fundraiser Patrick Feeley brings 35 years of front-line experience to help operators shift from transactional asking to strategic matchmaking. Stewardship requires more than mail-merged letters. It demands owning public oversights and navigating tight margins. Feeley outlines exact steps to save relationships after massive blunders, like omitting a top sponsor at a ribbon-cutting. We examine tactics to stop post-gala ghosting and keep attendees engaged all year. You will learn to segment event lists, assign board members gratitude calls, and execute high-touch outreach on a zero-dollar budget. For development directors facing declining retention rates, this conversation provides a framework to restructure follow-up workflows without adding overhead. Subscribe and share this episode with a peer managing a stalled campaign. What is your best low-budget stewardship tactic for surprising a donor?
Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.
Transcript
From the show. Tap a time to play from there.
SPEAKER_00Welcome back to the Ask Allison Podcast. I'm Allison McElroy, a certified fundraising executive located in Northwest Arkansas. I love helping people reach big goals with my version of strong encouragement. I mix my heart, my humor, and my experience to lift you up. Thank you for joining me today. So today's episode is going to be a fun, thoughtful, and practical conversation with my friend Patrick Feely about one of the most important and sometimes overlooked aspects of fundraising, donor stewardship.
SPEAKER_00We all talk about it all the time. We'll explore what stewardship really means, why it matters, what organizations get wrong, and how nonprofits of every size can build meaningful relationships that keep donors connected for years. So without further ado, um, well, I want to say this too. We spend so much time talking about how to get the gift, but what happens after the gift? Are we making our donors feel appreciated? Are we building relationships, or are we simply moving on to the next ask?
SPEAKER_00So, as I said, my guest today is Patrick Feely, and we're gonna dive into why stewardship is so important, what it should look like, and how we can all do it better. So, Patrick, welcome to Ask Allison. And I want you to tell our listeners a little bit about yourself because, you know, I think you're pretty special. And I want to know your background and how did you find your way into the nonprofit and fundraising world? Or as I like to say, um, how did fundraising find you?
SPEAKER_02Well, first, Allison, it's so good to be on the podcast with you. It's uh great to uh hear your voice, which by the way is incredible. We'll talk about that a little bit later. Um I'm so excited to be on this podcast with you. And uh just thank you for the invitation. Uh your listeners are uh getting a treat every time you speak and every time you interview uh anyone in our profession. So thanks for the honor of having some time with you today.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. I appreciate it so much.
SPEAKER_02You're welcome. Well, your question is uh, how did I get into this? How how do any of us get into this profession, right? And uh exactly. You know, my my my story starts back in uh college, and uh often uh when I look back, I I I realize that I had my first job right out of college in the nonprofit sector with uh junior achievement. Uh great organization, and I I I worked for junior achievement for almost 10 years, but my point in sharing is that I um I look back and I realize that what I thought I would do in college is not what actually uh I fell into.
SPEAKER_02You know, I fell into the nonprofit sector and I thought I was going to have a career in government, uh in politics, and be the next Robert Kennedy.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02But in in hindsight, now I look back and I say to myself, uh, I'm not doing what I thought I would do, but I'm doing what I felt I would do. And so a certain a career in service to the nonprofit sector uh is beyond what I could have ever imagined when I was in college. So I really lucked out with that first position, doing so many different things, including fundraising, in my first role uh with junior achievement in uh York, Pennsylvania.
SPEAKER_02Um just remember those early days so well. So that was my start, and I never looked back one position after another, and one organization after another led to uh, you know, more than 35 years of uh dedicated service to fundraising in particular, uh to the uh to the profession we like so much.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And then what happened after junior achievement years? Like what was your first true development role after junior achievement?
SPEAKER_02Uh so yeah, and so for junior achievement, it was certainly uh fundraising was an important part of every role I had. Um so that was that was from the get-go a key ingredient for uh what I was passionate about, what I loved. I just enjoyed the fundraising aspect of of the roles that I had at JA so, so much. Um my my first uh focused fundraising role uh was with uh LaSalle University. I was uh finishing up my MBA at LaSalle, and they were launching a campaign to build um, it was the shoulder-to-shoulder campaign, and it was back in 2002, and I um went into the dean's office in the school of business, and I said, I'm finishing up my MBA, and I think I need to do something else, something bigger.
SPEAKER_02And he said, Well, why don't you consider joining us when we launch our shoulder-to-shoulder campaign? And I was stunned, and and sure enough, there was a position in corporate and foundation relations for the university, and I went for it. And I I often consider that my um my my true break in the path to dedicated service to fundraising and and and and just doubling down on a career in in raising money for great causes. And so that was uh that was a nice uh you know level up.
SPEAKER_02Junior achievement was phenomenal, and then to work at LaSalle University when they were expanding their campus, building a new science center, um wow. Expanding scholarship. I mean, so many people in university fundraising can relate to of any big campaign, and it was just a a joy to be a part of it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I think when you and I met, were you in maybe a healthcare field or uh Yes.
SPEAKER_02Uh that yeah, with with uh LaSalle University, when that campaign was winding down, um, another campaign was uh getting launched at uh in Philadelphia at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia. And so that's where I um moved on from LaSalle to join uh Children's Hospital of Philadelphia during their Hope Lives Here campaign and worked um, you know, along my career, I've had incredible mentors from junior achievement to LaSalle uh to Children's Hospital, and it only continued.
SPEAKER_02But my my my fundraising career started to focus um more on healthcare. And so from the days I started at Children's Hospital of Philadelphia uh until you know just recently, uh all of those years, um, you know, almost 20 uh years of just uh a focus on healthcare, which is you know, there's just such great needs for healthcare fundraising and philanthropy. And so it was uh it was a wonderful experience. And coincidentally, um this morning, my uh niece, her uh youngest son, uh, had an operation at Children's Hospital Philadelphia.
SPEAKER_02He's doing fine. But it reminded me of wow, the days that I was there helping to expand their pediatric program and their outpatient facilities.
SPEAKER_00Well, it it's the full circle moment. And a lot of us, not the nonprofit fundraisers, we have that where we we're in something, and then it's it's almost like the planned giving thing. When you you leave and then you find out that that planned gift that you knew about or heard about, and then all of a sudden you get you hear see in the news that the organization got the gift, and it's long after you're gone.
SPEAKER_02I I was really happy to get the text that everything went well, and but I was thinking about that. I'm like, wow, I helped to build the outpatient um you know building uh back in the day and expanded different programs, and uh the teams were so great back then, and and you see the results uh today when families go and you know experience a wonderful hospital system like like CHOP. So it's uh it's it's neat to touch it, to be a part of teams that uh can see the results.
SPEAKER_00Right. And uh like you said, not only are other families, but your very own family is getting to benefit from that, some of the work that was done there while you were there. Um so um over the years you've worked with lots of donors and organizations, but what have those experiences taught you about the relationships and the generosity?
SPEAKER_02Oh my. Um, I was thinking about uh children's hospital um today for obvious reasons given my um family's uh uh experience. And and and my my um my niece's son is is is doing well, as I said, but but some um you know they they don't make it. And I'll I'll I'll always remember um a mother of a son who passed away uh very young uh from cancer. And um, you know, and I'm I'm a fundraiser. I'm not in oncology, I'm not part of the health team, I'm I'm part of the fundraising team.
SPEAKER_02But I'll never forget receiving a thank you letter from this mom who lost her son. And she sent me a thank you note thanking me for doing my part to try and raise money for research for the type of cancer that her son had. And I was I was really blown away. You know, I I think of you know, the fundraisers are playing a key role in people's lives um and their journey, and and when things don't go well, I was never expecting a thank you note like that.
SPEAKER_02And and and basically it was a reminder that, you know, don't give up, keep trying. And and for fundraisers, you're just as much a part of the team uh as a you know, a nurse or physician, but in a a different way. Um and and families count on you for for hope. Um and so we provided hope while we could. And even if the um, you know, the situation turned, um to to to get that gratitude from a family like that, from a mom was so I'll never forget that moment.
SPEAKER_02And I think it really helped to cement fundraising as a profession for me. It it made me realize this is not a joke, this is so important to people's lives. And and so for listeners out there, um, don't question your role, uh, don't minimize your role when you compare yourself to um other professionals around you that you're supporting as a fundraiser. It's uh it's it's so key to success.
SPEAKER_00That's such a good reminder because we do, we tend to simplify what we do or think of ourselves as less than. And it's it's I'm so glad you said that because um I always say that this podcast is therapy. So that was our our therapy tidbit uh number one right there is we don't need to shrink around others because of what we do, because what we're doing is way more powerful and has a lot more depth than what a lot of people do.
SPEAKER_00So that's good. That's good. Um, what's one thing you wish you'd known when you first started in the pos the profession? Is there a something you thought, man, I wish I'd have known that before I got into this?
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, I I think somewhere along the line, I don't know um exactly exactly where, but I I realized that as the years went on in fundraising, that I embrace this idea of being a matchmaker and not a fundraiser. I, you know, the the the term sounds like you are going out and you're taking something away from someone, an individual, a family, a foundation, and you're giving it to the organization that you work for.
SPEAKER_02Uh so you're just like looking at a meter going up and you're taking and giving and taking and giving. But when you take a step back and realize that you're a matchmaker between someone's heart and mind, uh, and and then the great work of an organization, the pressure is eased because as a matchmaker, you're just trying to find the right match. And if that match is not there, you're moving on because there is someone out there that is excited for your work to match them with a great cause.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02So I feel like that took the pressure off. It's never gone. You know, the fundraising numbers are always so um so real and so concrete, but at least it lowers the temperature because it's not about you, it's about uh you just matching wonderful people with wonderful causes.
SPEAKER_00I remember this consultant, you may have uh been been involved in AFP when she became one of the ones we all listened to, but her name was Terry Axelrod. And she had that Benavon method, you know, where you you, you know, she had her system or whatever that she created. But my fate, one of my favorite takeaways was she would say, not your organization is not going to be the passion of everybody. And you you do it this way so that you can ask them these questions.
SPEAKER_00And if if you say, Do you see yourself helping us in this mission? And they say, actually, no, I'm really passionate about dolphins or about, you know, puppies or whatever. And she said, then you know that's no big deal. You just bless and release them out to help the puppies, and then you you say, Do you know anyone else that would be passionate about this mission mission? And that's exactly what it is. It's a matchmaking process. Not everybody's gonna be passionate about your mission, but um that's what our job is, is to find out who is and who needs us, and uh who do who do we need that want to uh make great strides in what we're trying to do to help people and solve problems.
SPEAKER_00So when we say donor stewardship, I think a lot of people probably have a lot of ideas, but what what do you think we're talking about when we say donor stewardship?
SPEAKER_02Well, I I I was uh blessed to work at some small uh organizations and and very large organizations. And so donor stewardship can be um, you know, on the surface, uh a one-on-one relationship with a donor. And so we think of it in terms of major gifts for sure. Uh so how do you steward a relationship with a major gift donor or a family and making certain that they feel connected and on that journey to maybe even give more and give at higher levels?
SPEAKER_02But in uh but as you take a step back, donor stewardship is uh an the the thread of an important fundraising program in its totality, from everything uh from at the annual fund to a special event to a major gift campaign uh to a plan giving program where you're uh attempting to get you know people to leave you in their estate plans. So donor stewardship um must mean uh something bigger than just that.
SPEAKER_02How is your individual stewardship program for your major gift uh team? Uh that is critical, but it's it's not the end of the story of great donor stewardship. And so the Cystic Fibrosis Foundation, where I had the great honor of working um uh during their milestones three campaign, I I love to work with our chapters and our specialists in our annual fund and plan giving program and and looking at how we can ramp up stewardship at at all levels.
SPEAKER_02So I think it's key to a great fundraising program. Um a lot of people will focus on the ask and miss the opportunity to tee up for solicitation by grounding yourself at all levels with uh you know an in a solid stewardship program.
SPEAKER_00I I think it in in all my years, I think the stewardship has been my favorite part. Um, and I think that's because I love people and I I want to get to know them. And I like you said, I want to find out if they're the match that we're looking for. But um I just I just I want to know what makes them feel good or what makes you know what they're passionate about or the relationship building part to show them that it's it's so much more than a transactional moment.
SPEAKER_00Like money might be involved, but it's really less about the actual transaction. And to me, the the beauty of it all is the friendship that we build along the way or the relationship that's cultivated, or and um, and then also I think I love how do we make our donors feel? And I feel like a lot of times that's the part we forget that the$10 gift from that person that made the$10 gift, that was a lot.
SPEAKER_00And they thought they were doing this monumental moment. And so I want them to feel like we got it and it's gonna change lives no matter what the amount is. I just the feeling because when you send your money, the the I think the saddest thing is when you wonder, well, I guess I I didn't matter because I never heard anything from anyone beyond the thank you note or beyond the receipt, I guess, the receipt part.
SPEAKER_00Um and so I there was uh I love that part.
SPEAKER_02There was a um uh a donor in um in Texas. I I was happened to be uh doing a chapter visit in uh Houston, Texas, and um great chapter for this uh CF Foundation. And I'll never forget uh we we were having our annual chapter meeting, and there was a uh a grandmother of a child with cystic fibrosis in the in the audience, and she raised her hand during the Q ⁇ A and she she asked me, um, you know, I I I raise uh you know just a little more than, you know, I think it was$13,000 or$15,000 in my golf outing uh here for uh CF research.
SPEAKER_02And she goes, I listening to how much we raised last year, it seems just like a just a drop in the bucket. I how how is it making any difference? And I uh first thanked her um for doing such incredible work and you know the passion and and her bringing in so many other donors for the cause. But I reminded her that her event and the events all throughout the country are creating a wave of an army of dollar bills that are marching towards our headquarters in Bethesda.
SPEAKER_02And each of those bills marching and jumping into one bucket creates the resources in order to have major breakfast breakthroughs in CF research and and to see her feel connected to something so big uh and being reminded of how important those you know that army of dollar bills is to the to the cause is quite moving for her. But it's also moving for all of us as as staff members to seize that moment and and remember the little gifts add up and and and they become so important to the overall success of the organization.
SPEAKER_00And you saw it, you saw her when you know she thought one thing, but when you sp explained all that, you saw her it click in her head that it still was a monumental thing she did. Yeah. Yeah. Um, have you been in organizations where you feel like they missed the mark on stewardship, or um you thought later, oh, we missed that opportunity right there, or we need to do better about this?
SPEAKER_02Oh gosh. Um uh not pointing fingers at anyone other than me. I remember uh being um, we had a capital campaign for junior achievement in um um right outside of Philadelphia, and we had built a new um uh it's called it was called Exchange City. It was a miniature city that kids would run and they would learn how to, you know, uh just run an economy, if you will, and learn about business and life skills, and it was a fun program.
SPEAKER_02Well, I had uh uh pulled together the remarks for the uh key opening for the center, and uh the governor of Delaware at that time was uh giving the remarks and reading from the script that I created, and I missed a major donor in the remarks, and I will never forget the donor um walking out early from that opening reception, and I could just I just felt the blood, you know, just rushing from I I I was So appalled at my own mistake, teeing up the remarks and missing uh a key donor.
SPEAKER_02And it was all on me. But uh making up for that was the next most important step. And so we went out of our way to send a letter to every single donor to the local chapter, um, highlighting the great work of this donor, the importance of their gift, um, and how we had uh grossly over, you know, our oversight in the um remarks at the uh um ribbon cutting.
SPEAKER_02And um uh we did other things too in terms of featuring them in the annual report, and I could go on and on. Um but it was uh it was how we made up for the mistake that uh was was key in in maintaining the relationship with a donor. But it was a great wake-up call for me. I I um I know others are cringing right now, thinking of times they made mistakes.
SPEAKER_00Uh-huh. We've all been in that moment for sure.
SPEAKER_02Yep. So uh so I just you know urge any listener to um you know own a mistake if you make one. Don't uh point fingers, right? And um and then back up your team. If there's a mistake on your team, make sure you are recognizing your role as a manager or leader that it's not your employees' mistake, it's your it's your team's mistake, including your yourself. And you need to back up your team 110% uh and and support them when you're communicating upwards, outwards, wherever.
SPEAKER_02Uh and and and that's the best way to fix a mistake is to um make sure the team feels supported when you're when you're powering through to to get to the other side.
SPEAKER_00Yes. And and like you said, never assume that it can't be fixed. Immediately go into how can we make this right and don't wait too long. Just immediately go into here's what we're gonna do. And don't pause too long because sometimes you can pause overthinking what we need to do when really they just need the recognition. They just they just need you just have to smooth it over and make it right. And it sounds like y'all went right into action and did that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I think that's a good thing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and identify the problem, identify the problem and uh analyze it as quickly as you can because you know the problem might be a vendor. Um, you know, it could be any number of things that are beyond your control, but yet what is in control uh that you have control over is the identification of the problem and then the communication thereafter uh and and and what you do with it. You you can't just wipe your hands if it's not your organization, if it's a third party, but you you hired them, it's still your obviously your issue to contend with.
SPEAKER_00Right, right. Um, we talk about this all the time here in Northwest Arkansas, and I have a feeling you've heard these conversations too, but the whole idea is to make someone feel appreciated, but um the personalization of that. Um everyone gets the blanket, you know, generated, whatever, but um handwritten notes, phone calls, and personal visits to me still are definitely handwritten notes, seem to still fall at the top of extra ways you can um be a good uh steward of the resources or build the relationship or cultivation.
SPEAKER_00Have you come across anything that's topped the handwritten thank you? Or um do you have thoughts on to me? We're all still saying you've got to write some handwritten notes, people. Can't just you can't just send emails anymore.
SPEAKER_02Can't just send emails. No, for sure. You can't just send emails, you can't just uh rely on the you know the merged letter that goes out from um, you know, and and of course you can't you can't do it all if you if you're a large organization with uh you know hundreds of thousands of donors, you have to develop a program that can make the um the letter feel intimate, um, but yet there is a uh a time factor, uh a resource factor in what you uh where you can invest your personal time and and the further up you go, you have to um you have to build those programs and then recognize how are you going to uh in invest the time appropriately.
SPEAKER_02You can't send 200,000 personalized uh note cards. Right. So so the program has to back up uh the you know the stewardship um and and right size it, if you will. Um but yeah, we need to be, we all need to be um more personal in our engagement. Um I I do think of uh one of one of the largest donors um for the campaign that we had just closed at uh CF. Um the stewardship between the CEO and this donor got uh so so intimate and warm in a in a relatively short period of time.
SPEAKER_02That this was uh it was fun to see how they developed a relationship where the donor's favorite college basketball team was um doing well in uh you know last uh season. And uh there was a key game in March Madness, and and our CEO, we're not you know, in athletics and university, we're we're a research organization, but they're texting about the game. That and so the intimacy to see that uh where uh the donor was like, This is so cool. The CEO is texting me and saying, I you're your your team's doing well, you know, and so that's a an example of it.
SPEAKER_02Doesn't always have to be stewardship about the gift. Uh sometimes the stewardship is about knowing what the donor's interests are and um and acknowledging that. And that's just an example of a a light moment, but it's yeah, it's stewardship. It's just uh it just came naturally for both of them at the time.
SPEAKER_00So and that that's the key right there, Patrick. It's naturally like what feels natural and normal. If if it if you type something out in a text or an email or whatever, and you have a a gut feeling of, oh, I don't know, then that's it's probably not natural. That's right. But if you can like text and say, Oh my goodness, I'm watching the game. I see that your team is, you know, and it's just you don't even think twice about it, it tickles people.
SPEAKER_00People love to hear, you know, hear from people they didn't think that would even be watching the game, you know. So I love, I love that idea. And and it's it leans right into the next thing I was gonna ask is how do we make our donors feel more a partner in the mission than just a source of money? And and that's it. When we we help them realize that it's it's on a different, it's not on just the level of us talking about work or the mission, it's can be so much more.
SPEAKER_00But like an example, I always tell people um we we've always heard this all our lives in fundraising. Um if you want uh advice, you ask someone for money. And if you want money, you ask someone for advice. Yeah. Have you heard that all your life? Oh, sure. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we've we've heard that for a while, right? Where you know, are we listening to our are we listening to our uh our our our donors uh or are we speaking at them?
SPEAKER_00Um Right. Well, when you we take that a step further on honestly, really just keeping them in the loop and keep, you know, letting them know about things and saying, I'd love to get your take on this. We were we were thinking this and you are so close to us, we want to run it by you first. It's always it's more than just the, oh, I'm just trying to ask for advice, but it really, we do really want to know because it makes them feel more like a partner with us.
SPEAKER_00You know, we're in this together, we're in the trenches, you know, working for the same goal, instead of, oh, it's time for your annual gift and it's gonna do these great things or whatever.
SPEAKER_02So um a simple, yeah, a simple uh, you know, what what are some burning questions that you that your organization has for uh for for for itself that you're you know uh you're you're heading into a new strategic plan and you've got a lot, you have more questions than answers. Well, take some of those questions and go out on the road. A great fundraiser can have a a field day with uh any number of questions to just go and canvas uh families and and donors and just really enjoy getting uh feedback to build up your own awareness uh so that you show up at the table with more information that's you know relevant with your constituents.
SPEAKER_02It's a great, uh, great to just stay in that mode of always asking questions, be a journalist, if you will, instead of always thinking you have to be the solicitor of the moment.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we could just call ourselves fundraising journalists. That's a great idea. Um, one thing we talk about, uh, I recently started a new job. Uh, and so uh the development team, we're constantly talking about stewardship, comes up all the time. But um one thing that we really talk about is after a special event. There is a stewardship that's missed a lot. And our biggest, I told them, you know, I know I've just been here a couple of minutes, but my biggest fear is that we invite everybody to the thing and we have that moment with them, and then they don't hear from us again until the sponsorship packets ready next year.
SPEAKER_00I don't, I don't want that. So I have been saying, like when we start making our stewardship plans and like you said, procedures and um the choreography of it, who's gonna do this to these people and who's gonna do that to that. But I want the special event guests, the attendees that come to the party or come to the corporate food drive challenge, or um, I want them to hear from us all year long. As a seg, like they're a segmented group, they came to the party, and they I want them to be a part of the conversation all year long.
SPEAKER_00So we are currently working through that, and it's one of my biggest pet peeves that I was guilty of because I was a small shop in the in my previous role, and we would spend all this time planning the event, and then when it was over, I had good intentions of staying connected to all the people that really love that event. And then here it would be time to say, Oh, it's time to get your table again. And I would think, you didn't even reach out to them in the summer, or you know, make sure they got that 4th of July, you know, sparkler, you know, what whatever, something to hear from.
SPEAKER_00And so we right before I left that organization, and that's been over 10 years ago, we did a thing where uh in at 4th of July, we would go buy those 50 cent sparklers and we would drop them off at their door and it it or the office, and it would say we would tie a little tag on it with our logo, and it would just say, You're the spark that keeps us going. Um happy, hope you have a great Fourth of July.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's funny.
SPEAKER_00And because we we didn't have a budget to, you know, we weren't a large organ, we didn't have a budget to do anything, you know, branded or fancy or anything. So that's what we did, and it went over so well. I mean, it just the cutest little gesture. But um, so we're we're in the process of trying to think, you know, what are what are ways that we can keep coming back to this group of people? We had that wonderful night. There was a a moment where there was a matching gift, and then we raised more than we'd ever raised, and and then we just want to keep that feeling alive all year long instead of waiting until the next.
SPEAKER_00I don't know if you have any experience or any great ideas uh for people in our area.
SPEAKER_02Um, you know, how we uh yeah, and I I agree with you on the uh, you know, you come off of an event and then boy, the year flies by and then you're in solicitation mode and you feel guilty. Uh so you know, to take your, let's say it's your top 100 donors to your special event, put it in order of largest to smallest, and then say, track that you are actually going to do something meaningful with that donor and work through that list and make sure you do it within the first six months coming off of your event.
SPEAKER_02If you can achieve that, you've teed yourself up for uh the the following year. Um, we had a lot of third-party events in healthcare, so from Children's Hospital in Philadelphia to the CF Foundation to care and treatment centers, where I worked uh for many years there as well. And uh there was a family that had an event in New York every year, and they would bring their friends and family and um donors and any anyway. Uh I'll never forget the um the family asked me, what advice do you have to help us grow our event?
SPEAKER_02It was um, you know, what but what can we do to expand it? It was just an annual uh moment for them in New York. And I just I said exactly that. I said, take your top 100 donors, put them in order of largest to smallest, and make sure you go and visit with them in the next six months to thank them and ask them for you know what what could have gone better with the event, what did they like the most? Just go out there and and get their their thoughts. Um, and so anyway, I I stick by that. You just said those key ingredients to success.
SPEAKER_02But one of my my funniest moments in my career, this is really bold and I would never do it again. When I was with Junior Achievement in Reading, Pennsylvania, um, there were a three-person team, myself as the director of the chapter and and two others uh that uh worked with me, um Joanne and Heather at the time, uh, we dress we dressed up, I dressed up as Santa Claus, they were elves, and we went around to all of the major donors that supported the organization right before the holidays, unannounced, asking for the CEO if we could go in and give them a gift because they were so good to kids in the in the uh community.
SPEAKER_02And the number of the number of organizations that let us go into the CEO's office to deliver this present because they were supportive of youth in in Berks County was really remarkable. I don't know if we can pull it off today given security and everything, right? But it was still one of the most um it was a fun moment. We had a great time, and boy, did we put a brand uh the the junior achievement uh chapter at the time.
SPEAKER_02Um people thought it was a pretty bold, but also fun. It was a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_00Fun and and it stood out, it stood out from all the rest. And there they said probably said, Oh, you know, do you remember the year junior achievement came and they brought Santa and the elves to bring the gift? And like it's priceless. It's priceless, and it sounds like something I would have absolutely loved to do.
SPEAKER_02I could see you, I could absolutely see you pulling that off.
SPEAKER_00So that makes me think we have to stop just for a second and me tell y'all when Patrick came to Northwest Arkansas, he was a speaker at one of our our we our AFP local chapter had like a one-day summit, and Patrick was the keynote and came into town for it. And I got to take him to the airport. And this was before podcasts had taken off, but I was trying to start something. I don't know what I thought I was gonna do. And I said, We're all the way back to the airport.
SPEAKER_00Um, we're gonna do, will you do a video with me? And it and we I called it Ask Allison. I did, and we we uh had turned the car phone, like my phone turned it on and videoed us going back to the airport. But we got so tickled that we could not talk because it was five in the morning and there was it was dark. Yes, and so my favorite line of that whole interview was when uh I said, So how are you doing this morning, Patrick?
SPEAKER_00And he says, Well, it's dark, like it's dark, we couldn't see anything. So, like the video meant nothing because you couldn't see us at all. But that was before podcasts had really taken off.
SPEAKER_01And look at how far you've come now. You're in a studio.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean studio, and and it's all it's all come full circle, and now I'm talking in a dark room with a bunch of lights. You know that's oh, it was so funny. But um, so bold has always been I want to do something fun and I want to do something bold, and I always want to do something that makes the donor feel how how grateful we are. And a lot of times fun and bold relays that message when you go and go kind of out of a comfort zone, or you think outside the box, or you you do something really creative and crafty that goes along with them.
SPEAKER_00And then they know that you spent time thinking about their gift and what it meant to the organization and how it what it means to you personally. And so I I love that idea. There's probably going to be some people here that'll steal that and do it. I hope they do. Um, now this is one that's easy to talk about because I just brought up one example of not having a budget. But if a nonprofit has small staff and no stewardship budget, you know, how do they start?
SPEAKER_00I mean, the handwritten card is one thing, and dressing up as Santa is another thing, but like we we didn't have any budget. So we thought of those little sparklers. I think they were a dollar 50 cents at the time, I think. So you could get a pack of two sparklers for a dollar, and they were just a little box of those, you know, and um well, I think I think being intentional uh is key.
SPEAKER_02You know, I I you know I'm I'm kidding around uh as far as that moment in in Reading, but we also had a very uh limited budget. And so I I you know I'm laughing about the uh running around town as elves and and Santa, but in being you know intentional, uh we had a we had a newsletter, we had uh uh a website that we were developing, we had uh our annual meeting, um, we had a a gala um or a business uh uh dinner, I should say, and very intentional about how we recognized donors within that limited menu.
SPEAKER_02Uh so when you have a newsletter, are you recognizing a bank that doesn't contribute to your cause? But uh and and and there's some real basics that sometimes fundraisers are not able to see the low-hanging fruit right in front of them. And so I would just urge for those small organizations um don't miss opportunities that are right in front of you. The newsletter can be a key, should be a key ingredient for your uh stewardship program.
SPEAKER_02Your social media program, what what do your postings look like? Um is is someone who is a key donor of yours receiving an award from the Chamber of Commerce? Are you highlighting that? Uh that's that doesn't cost much for you to um put on your platform something that one of your donors is being honored by another organization. Uh so I I I just think we often miss um very inexpensive ways to leverage what we have right in front of us to amplify our donor stewardship program.
SPEAKER_02Um and it's easy to do. You have a deadline for uh a newsletter and you're like, oh, I should have put uh this donor uh you know at the top of the list for this upcoming newsletter. But it it's never too late. You can always play catch up uh if you have social media uh opportunities coming up, but there are just so many ways, inexpensive ways, to uh amplify the relationship that donors have with your organization.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Do you think there's um there's a way to overshare or over like how frequently should we talk to our donors between between asks or between, you know, is there is there a a rule of thumb or is it kind of how you feel or what the relationship's like between certain asks or um when we're not asking for money, should we email so many times?
SPEAKER_00Is there a formula like I've always told people, you really just know what feels right? And I know that's not a scientific uh formula to use, but if I go to email somebody and I think, yeah, it seems like I just sent that email, even though it seems like yesterday, it was two weeks ago, it seems a little too soon right now. So I'm gonna wait and put this off for another week or so. Do you know if there's a certain rule of thumb on that? Or do you just
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you you do have to go with your gut because if if you if you start to become a nag, you're you're you're not gonna be uh you're not gonna be a lot of fun. Uh so you want to you want to make sure you're not uh uh becoming a nag. You you you want it to feel natural. You so I I think you're you're you're spot on there. And I think people can feel that in terms of the cadence of communication, whether that's email or direct mail or social media posts, uh, to a major gift officer trying to determine how often do you reach out to uh a donor.
SPEAKER_02Uh so the your your gut does come into play here. Um, I also think coming back earlier, you mentioned Terry Axelrod and that whole idea of letting people go. Uh if you have a top 100 list and you're a major gift officer, uh, it's okay that 25 names that are on that 100 list drop off at the end of the year because you have basically um cultivated, stewarded, and realized you need to you need to drop them and leave room in your calendar in your day for a new 25 so that you can be successful long term and not just short term working with the same donors.
SPEAKER_02Um so that there's an art form to that art form to that as well in terms of managing your own prospect pool.
SPEAKER_00Right. Oh, that's such a great reminder because I think we feel like we failed, or some, you know, but if we have been trying to steward those people and we're not hearing from them, then that's the hint that they can take we can take a break from that 25 and move them to a new list, move them over somewhere else.
SPEAKER_02And and if you know you might you might notice a pattern too. Uh uh some uh some miss the spouse or another key relationship, maybe an older son or daughter that was actually more important to engage with. So there's also a little dynamic there too, where um, you know, that bottom 25, you might realize I've been, you know, I've been beating my head on a wall here, and I was actually missing an opportunity to engage others in the family in order to achieve success, and I was just focused on one individual.
SPEAKER_02Um, that often happens too, where people will drop a family when maybe it was the other spouse that you should have been focused on. Um so uh donor stewardship is really complex. It's a game of chess, not a game of checkers. And uh Yeah, so just you know, checking yourself uh on that to make sure that you're um you know, trying, trying uh as best you can and um and seeing different angles to the to the outcome.
SPEAKER_00Um one my next question, and and I hope you're still gonna be my friend after this when you see that I skipped around and didn't go straight down the list. But um what role can board members? We talk about this a lot where I work now at the Northwest Arkansas Food Bank. What role can board members take in the stewardship? Um, because we know our board members sometimes don't want to, they don't want to go around and ask people for money. We've always got two or three that are rock stars and want to or want to make the connections.
SPEAKER_00Um, and I always do this training at how to be a rock star board member. There's five easy ways, and most of the time it's not about asking for the gift, it's about all the things that help us do good stewardship. But I I have been trying to think of easy things board members can do to help us with stewardship.
SPEAKER_02Well, what I would suggest is to uh get in the habit of asking board members to thank donors. Start there. You have a gala, you have a dinner, you have a ribbon cutting ceremony, have a board member teed up the following day or the following week to reach out to a donor and say, I want I wanted to thank you as well since I'm on the board. Easy, easy activity for them. And they love it. You know, they they they find that wow, that was that was an exciting thing for me to do as a board member.
SPEAKER_02Well, you've just you've just pulled them into the fundraising program. And so you've teed them up with a profile, with information on the donor, and they have engaged in an activity that is so simple, but yet you're then coaching up to the board member to get them engaged to a point where if you get enough board members in that habit, it's going to be easier for them to start to do a little bit more in volunteer engagement for future campaigns.
SPEAKER_02So if you feel that your board member board members are not engaged in your fundraising program, start with stewardship and don't have another goal in mind. If they think that you're trying to be passive aggressive to get them to solicit their network, just get them to thank your existing donors and get them in that muscle memory, if you will, or that habit of working with you on that side of the aisle, they'll develop a relationship with you as a staff member. And then that board will be far more engaged in fundraising simply because you started with donor stewardship.
unknownRight. Right.
SPEAKER_00And stewardship, like I said before, is the easiest, funnest thing to do anyway. So if we can get them get their toe wet with some stewardship, you're absolutely right. It makes them realize, oh, this is not, it's not as creepy as I thought it was. This is all fun. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And it's easy to like I roll it off my tongue right now, but I also recognize time constraints. And I I look back and I'm like, oh, I miss so many opportunities for this board member to thank that donor. And so I speak, I speak from the standpoint of I knowing what I should have done or should do. Um, but it it's a it's a great reminder for for all of us. Um, it can be a it can be a real easy task for a board member and they'll love it.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and and you saying that, uh, ladies and gentlemen listening, Patrick and I, we are, we have done this a long, long, long time. But most of the time, the stuff that we're saying, we know how time gets away. There's time constraints, there's schedules, there's all the things, and juggling it all is hard. But man, if you can figure out how to get it in your calendar for the stewardship part, it's it's going to cause most of the people that already are donors probably to give more with sometimes without even being asked for more because of the way you they are made, you make them feel as a as a partner.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um so um let's talk about donor retention. Um, how to can good stewardship influence whether a donor gives again?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, if you can if you can retain donors and add new ones, you're expanding your your donor pool for sure, right? Um so so retention, uh stewardship can be the uh program that leads to a higher level of retention. We we all we all know that. And so if your retention rate is going down, um it's important to take another look at your donor stewardship program and see if there's anything uh missing or anything that could be um ramped up.
SPEAKER_02Uh so so I I would just highly encourage recognizing well, what is the reason for retention going down, or what is what is the what is the reason for donor stewardship to help build retention up to a whole new level. Um it's it's key. There are some things that are out of our control. Sometimes there is a transition in leadership, right? Where that's when some donors say, you know what, I've been supporting the CEO of a university for 10 years, and now's my time to let others uh step in.
SPEAKER_02Um that's a hard that's hard. So you have to work, uh you have to work uh diligently, intentionally to try and retain that donor when there is a leadership transition. Um so that's just one example. There's so many other moments. A big gift can sometimes disrupt retention. Um, you can get a one of the largest gifts in your organization's history, and people may say, you know what, I this is my time to step back because they're already getting large gifts from you know this family.
SPEAKER_02Uh so it's important to communicate the why in in those moments, whether it's a transition, a big gift, or unfortunately, you you you'll you'll have some sort of dramatic uh ethical problem that the organization is facing, uh financial challenges. Um how do you communicate with donors through those tough, tough moments? Um the best way is to engage even if it is really difficult.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, you know, lying low and being quiet is not the right thing to do.
SPEAKER_00It really isn't. And transparency and honesty really goes further when you're talking to a donor, and if they've been a partner and a true trailblazer for years, they don't want to see that on the news first. They want to hear from us first and hear what's going on. And we had a one of my guests is a CEO of a nonprofit. And when she came into the into the and took over, took the reins, um, she looked, that was the first time she had noticed the bank account and the all the accounting and how in dire straits they were.
SPEAKER_00No one knew. Board members did not know. And so the first thing she did was talk to the board. And then the second thing she just started calling donors and telling them she needed to talk to them. And she said, I just it was the hardest thing I've ever done, but I just went and said, I I've just started as the, you know, the executive director, and I just need to tell you what's been going on and explain where we are and what my plan is. And and and she said every single donor was so um thankful that she came straight to them to talk to them about it so that they understood what was going on.
SPEAKER_00Instead of hearing that leaked news story that's like, you know, details at 10, you know, the players are gonna shut their doors or whatever. They she had contacted all of the the players to say, this is what's happened, and and none of us knew, none of us knew until the exit of the previous person. Um, so it's it's just transparency always is better. Um if you could tell a nonprofit three stewardship practices to start doing immediately, what would they be?
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's a uh great question. Um So I I I would say um number one, uh do you have a do you have a stewardship plan that is written out, literally? Uh so do you have a document that provides you with a um a strategy, objectives, timeline, uh backed up by by best practices and other organizations that you can point to and say, this is our stewardship program.
SPEAKER_02Uh so if you don't have a manual, if you will, of sorts, um I I would I would take seriously the the goal of putting it all down on paper because it's so easy for us in this conversation in the last hour to say you should do this, you should do that, but you can't do it all. And so you have to come up with a a game plan. Uh you have to come up with uh something that's gonna say this is what we're going to do when. You know, we know the why.
SPEAKER_02The why is to engage donors, uh steward them in such a meaningful way that it increases revenue for your organization. But how are you going to do it with the limited resources that you have? That's the rule book. So I would say that's number one. Uh, and then number two, we're for your listeners, wherever they are at in the in the organization, whether a director of grants or the chief development officer of the organization, what is your personal list of donors to thank this year?
SPEAKER_02What is your individual top 100? And so if everyone on the team, but most importantly, yourself, the listener, regardless of their role, um, if they have their list, that that can be quite meaningful. Imagine the impact of everybody taking quite seriously their role in one-on-one engagement with uh with with donors. Um and then and then the the third would be to have um uh an attitude, if you will, a a um an approach, if you will, that is always transparent, honest, uh, and and and open so that anything from direct mail to a phone call to email to what you put on your website, if you're always standing behind transparency and and truth, um you're you're gonna be more successful with your donors.
SPEAKER_02So that's more about your um your approach, uh, your style, if you will. Um that that's that's that's a key ingredient to the overall success. So there's my my my quick top, you know, one, two, three list for your listeners.
SPEAKER_00I love it. And I know, I know we're we're running close out of time, so I'm gonna ask this one. I know this is gonna be a hard one to answer quick, but I think you can and you'll know what I mean. You know, when you said that about a written plan with the strategy, the the timeline, the outcomes, and all that, and then who's doing what on the team, you know, who's doing what with which donors and how many weeks or whatever. But when when somebody goes to write this plan, I know they can they can Google anything to get ideas, but like it's not rocket science.
SPEAKER_00It I mean, if I'm I was gonna ask you, like in my mind, it's like you decide the levels of giving and then you decide what each of those touch points are gonna be for each of those groups of people. Is that kind of how you look like if somebody's listening today and they're like, yeah, I I'd love to write a stewardship plan, but I don't even know what y'all are talking about. I don't, you know, what what's a basic stewardship plan look like? Just a basic.
SPEAKER_02Uh, you know, just uh when when I think about um you you could take any program from corporate and foundation relations to um plan giving to the annual fund to the major gifts, uh each of them have um different, you know, different approaches. You know, so for for plan giving, do you have uh do you have a society? You know, some don't uh have a plan giving society. That may be uh an example of what you write down as a director of plan giving.
SPEAKER_02Um, you know, is there uh a way that you can integrate your plan giving program into the events program by making sure that all of the gallas throughout the country have a page that recognizes the donors that included the organization in their estate at their um at that uh in that local community? I mean, there's just there's so many ways that uh any director could create uh a program for their uh area that when rolled up creates kind of a master um uh guidebook.
SPEAKER_02Uh so I I kind of like that approach too. Um I I I love the uh at the CF Foundation, they have the National Corporate Champions Program. And so recognizing companies that give cumulatively more than$100,000 uh in in all ways to the to the organization. And so it created a program that is you know well thought out, written down, and then there are touch points throughout the year for uh for those national corporate champions. So if every program is writing their stewardship um objectives and their timeline and what they're going to do, you're rolling that up into um basically a master plan.
SPEAKER_02And then for the small shop, you're doing the same thing, but you're just gonna have to do it all uh and find ways to recognize those different buckets in your small organization. Um, but it can be done, it doesn't have to be overthought. And I encourage Chat GPT in this stuff. It's okay to go in and say, create a solid stewardship program for a small organization with this budget in these areas, and you rattle them off and see what comes back, and then and then start uh you know really editing it and and fine-tuning it and making it your own.
SPEAKER_02Um it can be done.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, thank you. Okay, now we get to the fun part where you get to ask me a question. You get to ask me anything you want that has nothing to do with anything, or it has all to do with everything, whatever.
SPEAKER_02It uh it goes with the start of this of this podcast. I mentioned your voice. People love to hear your voice, but I'm uh not only talking about your your voice on a podcast like this, but your voice as a singer. You are such a fabulous singer, and I've always enjoyed, especially um, you know, it's been over the last several years where I'm every once in a while I'll be on social media and I'll see you pop up singing a song. And I I wanted to ask you what what was the origin of your passion for singing?
SPEAKER_02And you know, what what what are you doing about that, about that part of your life that the listeners might find intriguing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Ooh, good question. Thank you, by the way, because yes, I've been singing since I was like two years old. My parents would bribe me with Coca-Cola. If if you sing that song for Aunt So-and-so, we'll buy you a Coke. So I'm currently addicted to Coca-Cola because of that. Um, so uh it came from my dad's side of the family. They were all very musically inclined. He was a singer-performer, and um his his talent he ended up being having a salon in St.
SPEAKER_00Louis, Missouri, and he was a very talented hair designer. And so uh I miss him so much because uh I I luckily I got another really good hair designer for my hair now. But when he first uh got sick or had a stroke, um I didn't know what I was gonna do because he's the only person that ever done my hair. But um I digress. I I so I I was raised singing and around instruments, but I never learned to play an instrument.
SPEAKER_00And I honestly am not um an avid music reader. Like I don't know how to read the music. So I pretty much just kind of sing by ear. Um, and it's just always been in me. And I guess um what started during COVID was the singing on social media because my my mom and my in-laws were, you know, everyone was going star crazy.
SPEAKER_00And so I started singing and just sending them to them because we couldn't see anybody, no one could visit. And so they said, You should post this. There are other people that will want to hear this. Your friends that haven't heard you sing in years, they're gonna want to hear it. Just it's gonna brighten somebody's day. So that's how that got started. And I did that for four years every Sunday night. And then um, two years ago, two and a half years ago, we had a tornado here in Rogers.
SPEAKER_00And for some reason, that that Sunday after the tornado, I just couldn't figure out what we needed to hear. It was, we were all just kind of shell-shocked. Rogers had had tornadoes before, but nothing, nothing like the damage this one did. And so I thought, I'll just pause this week. And then the next week, I think I might have sung something. And then the next week, I just it's just like it just kind of derailed everything. I think the first week we didn't have any power.
SPEAKER_00There was no way to, no way to record a song. And so um, I I got I let it slide. I got out of the habit. And so you're the fourth person in the last three weeks to say, when are those songs gonna come back on Sunday nights? And, you know, I just thought maybe everybody was kind of tired of seeing it or hearing it. But uh, from what I've heard, no, they're they're wanting to see, you know, we I missed the Sunday night song. And so I may have to, I may have to come out of retirement to do that.
SPEAKER_02Or at least at least one it's it's like the once a year, maybe it's a holiday special with Alice and Matthew.
SPEAKER_00That's right. That's right. And then and so I do a lot of community theater. Um I had a I went I've gone through a health journey and uh had you know quite a bit of weight loss, and it brought back the old me. And so I started trying out for shows again, and I've had several really fun, awesome roles, and most of them are musicals. And so I feel like I'm just back to my old self. And um, and that also started during COVID.
SPEAKER_00I had the the weight loss journey had started right before COVID, and I was getting my just getting me back, and so I think that gave me the confidence to even put them on social media because um I really cringe sometimes when I hear them and think, what was I thinking? But um, but getting back on stage has just been a dream. And we have some we have several local community theater groups, and so there's lots of opportunities around here to try out for different shows.
SPEAKER_00And um, and most of them are my friends because guess what? Theater is nonprofit. So like we've all been, we're all in the trenches together, and and so I'm on the stage, but then help you know, saying, Here's what we need to do to raise more money for this group and and that group. But um that's fine. Wait, that's that's the answer. But I need to make a note that we've got to figure out the Sunday night song, whether it's quarterly or monthly or something, maybe not weekly, yeah. But but we need to have a a special or something, or maybe greatest hits.
SPEAKER_00I don't know.
SPEAKER_02Well, you have a beautiful voice.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. I know you know the first time you heard me sing, I think we might have sang a duet at the AFP After Dark party. So many great memories of AFP conferences, and and I'll never forget I hadn't seen you in a couple of years. And um the one, I I don't know if it was New Orleans or something, I was literally acting like a crazy person, getting my picture made. I was laid out in front of the display, and all of a sudden I hear Addison.
SPEAKER_00And I was like, oh, and I was just so excited to see you. So I'm probably just gonna have to come visit you sometime, or uh y'all are gonna have to come visit us down here again in Northwest Arkansas.
SPEAKER_02Come up with an excuse. We'll find a way.
SPEAKER_00We can there's Chris, there's so much to do here. There's crystal bridges and the Walmart brand new campus. You can see that. I mean, there's lots to do, plus just some great scenery too.
SPEAKER_02So well, it's such a treat to see you, and uh yes, to see you in person would be uh even better. So I'm sure uh we will do that. A conference will be here before we know it, I'm sure.
SPEAKER_00That's right, that's right. Well, I'm gonna stay in touch with you better this time. I'm gonna give pro I'm gonna do proper stewardship and make sure we stay in touch. Um, well, I I just appreciate you so much for doing this and sharing your expertise and your wisdom and your experience and and just your passion for uh fundraising, because I know we have that in common. Um, and I'll just tell you all the first time I met Patrick was at an AFP conference, and not just me, but the rest of our AFP chapter friends, I mean, we felt like we had known him for you know the whole our whole lives.
SPEAKER_00And we literally just met at karaoke at an after dark party. Um, I think it was the year you were president. Either that or you were president-elect.
SPEAKER_02It was yeah, it was right around then, back in 2015, 16, somewhere in there.
SPEAKER_00And and I mean, it was like you are our long-lost brother that we just hadn't seen in a while, and um, he's just the greatest. And I know I'm gonna say this, I know that if you have questions for Patrick or want to just ask him one more thing about something, I know that he would answer that question. You can always email me. But uh, to all of you that have been listening, I hope today's conversation reminds you that fundraising isn't just about raising money, it's about people, relationships, trust, and gratitude.
SPEAKER_00And don't just thank your donors, know your donors. Um and just thanks for listening. And remember, you know, it always comes out on the seventh of the month at 7 a.m. because I like sevens. That's just a weird thing that I do. Um, so share it with others and um remember that if you just don't know what to do, you can always ask Allison. That's why we call it the Ask Allison Podcast. So we'll see you next month. Thank you guys.
Over $320 billion currently sits in donor-advised funds waiting to be distributed. Jody Dilday from the Arkansas Community Foundation explains exactly how nonprofits can position themselves to receive these resources....
Individual donations keep the lights on, but pooled funds build sustainable financial engines. Gay Prescott and Alison Levin break down how their foundations implemented giving circles to drive major gifts. Setting up a...
Artificial personalization is quietly destroying donor trust across the nonprofit sector. Fundraisers are moving so fast with automated outreach that they are actively alienating the people funding their missions,...
Treating donors like ATMs is a direct resource leak for nonprofits. With grant guidelines constantly shifting and donor retention requiring deeper attention, leaning into authentic human connection is a practical...
With shifting economic landscapes and looming federal budget cuts, fundraising leaders must learn how to strategically leverage big opportunities before time runs out. In this episode, Allison McElroy sits down with...