Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Ask Allison

Ask Allison artwork

Ep. 11 - Giving Circles: Multiplying Donor Impact with Alison Levin & Gay Prescott

Sep 7, 20261 hr 16 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Individual donations keep the lights on, but pooled funds build sustainable financial engines. Gay Prescott and Alison Levin break down how their foundations implemented giving circles to drive major gifts. Setting up a donor society requires heavy lifting on the front end, from establishing contribution tiers to securing board buy-in. You must align the pooled revenue directly with immediate operational needs or endowment growth. It takes administrative bandwidth to run allocation meetings and manage stewardship beyond standard acknowledgment letters. Yet, executing this model turns isolated contributors into a unified funding source for capital projects. For development directors struggling to engage mid-level donors, this conversation provides a blueprint to operationalize collective giving without exhausting staff capacity. Subscribe and share this episode with a fellow fundraiser. What is the biggest hurdle keeping your team from starting a giving society?

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00Welcome to the Ask Allison Podcast, where nonprofit professionals come to learn, laugh, and remember that none of us have to figure it out all by ourselves. No, never. That's why I'm here. I'm Allison McElroy, your friend in fundraising. And every month I sit down with people who know this work, live this work, and have learned a few things along the way that the rest of us can use and learn from. Today we're talking about a fundraising and stewardship strategy that I think is fascinating.

SPEAKER_00And that is giving circles. We've all heard of it. Sometimes you hear them at giving clubs, but uh we're gonna learn more about that today. What happens when you bring people together around a shared purpose, invite them to pool their resources, and then let them see the impact they can make together? My guests today, they know firsthand. I have Gay Prescott, CFRE with Hope Cancer Resources Foundation, and Allison Levin, CFRE with Mercy Health Foundation, and both have experience with giving circles, successful experience with giving circles.

SPEAKER_00And we're going to talk about why their organizations decided to create them, how they work, what donors love about them, what they've learned, and most importantly, how another nonprofit might create one of their own. So, Gay and Allison, welcome to the Ask Allison podcast. And you'll notice there are two Allison here today. Um, one is Allison Levin, and she has one L. And then there's me, Allison McElroy, and I have two L's.

SPEAKER_00So uh I'm really glad to have you guys with me today. And we're happy to be here. And um, before we get started in all the details, I do want the listeners to hear about each of you. So, gay, we're gonna start with you. Just tell us a little bit about yourself, your career in fundraising, and how you got into this profession. It's my favorite question because most of us have fallen into it.

SPEAKER_01You know, it found it chose us. I would agree. Um, I'm Gay Prescott. I have been in Northwest Arkansas this November, 30 years. And that is because I married Larry 30 years ago. And that's what brought me here. Um, before my journey into fundraising, I actually was in the advertising world, and um our ad agency gave back to the community. And so I got to be a part of fundraisers in that way, um, really in a different light, but toward the end, we got to where we really helped them with some of their fundraising.

SPEAKER_01So I got to be a part of the first Ronald McDonald house in Jackson, Mississippi, which was fabulous and just a great experience. And that probably put me on my best path. When I moved here, I uh went to that agency and decided it was time for me to do something different. And so I took a part-time job really to get to know Northwest Arkansas and figure out um Fayetteville, Arkansas in comparison to Jackson, Mississippi and to meet people.

SPEAKER_01And through that, I met Bill Rogers at the Washington Regional Foundation and um came to work for the foundation to lead the cancer support home there, and it changed my life, and I've been a part of fundraising ever since. It changed our lives too.

SPEAKER_04It changed the lives of our community.

SPEAKER_00That's right. Okay, tell us a little bit about Hope Cancer Resources Foundation and what you're doing there.

SPEAKER_01Okay. It the foundation actually started in 1998. Um, the history of Hope Cancer Resources is a little bit of a dog leg. Um, we were Nartai at one time. We provided the radiation therapy for patients in Northwest Arkansas. And so the foundation was started when we had the clinic. Uh, we sold our treatment services in 2008 and then we merged with another nonprofit in 2009. So I've been through a lot of transitions, all I'm glad to be a part of.

SPEAKER_01Um, none that I would want to do again. Yeah. So I'm glad to have the experience. I'm not saying I would like to do either of them again. Um, but our foundation um has changed its purpose through the years. Obviously, being a hundred percent nonprofit, um, we need the sustainability to make sure that our programs and services are vital and accessible to cancer patients and their families. And so that's really the purpose of the foundation. My role is um really, I get to to do the best part and that's visit with people individually and talk about how they can be a part of the foundation, how they can be a part of the mission.

SPEAKER_01Um, but what that really gives them is an opportunity just to make a difference in somebody's life.

SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness. Well, I'm glad you're here today. And I remember all of those ups and downs and changes. Um and I'm glad it's landed where it has been the last many years. Yes. So strong organization. Okay, Allison, it's your turn. Yes, same question. Same question. Your journey to fundraising or how it found you.

SPEAKER_04So I was born into fundraising, truly born into it. I think uh my parents um made it a point to always give back. So we did things at our church. Um, as a child, I would do in the summertime put on fairs and raise money for different organizations. Of course.

SPEAKER_00Of course, I'm not surprised by this at all.

SPEAKER_04No, but we would like to support animals, we would support healthcare organizations, we would support children's organizations. And I'm talking little amounts of money, but um, I think it started there that I realized that just small gifts can make a huge impact. So we moved here um in 1998, and I'm actually a master licensed social worker. So previous to coming here, I was a school counselor. Oh, I forgot that. And previous to that, I worked for an airlines and actually recruited um station agents, flight attendants, anybody other than the people that could fly the plane.

SPEAKER_04But moving here, I was fortunate enough to live next door to somebody who was just starting to build the race for the cure. And she invited me to come to a meeting. And I remember sitting around that table with all these incredible women, one man, Bob Shoulders. And I was so infatuated with the energy in the room in the room that eventually I started a 15-year career with Susan G. Comen.

SPEAKER_04And that's how I met her. And that's how that's how we all met. We all met while you were at Susan G. Comen. So, as I said, spent 15 years there, really passionate about cancer. My dad had had several different bouts of cancer, um, lots of cancer in my family. That I knew that what I was doing not only was helping breast cancer survivors, but really making an impact in our community. And we would raise millions of dollars that went to Hope Cancel Resort Cancer Resources, Washington Regional, so many great organizations.

SPEAKER_04Um, had an opportunity to join Mercy. Started back in I think 2012, maybe 2012. Yeah. And joined their foundation and never looked back. It has been an incredible opportunity. I work with a great group of leaders. Um, I report to Clark Ellison. Many of you know Clark, he's like the grand poo-bah of fundraising. Yes. Yes, and um, senior development officer.

SPEAKER_04So, as as like gay, my role is really to go out and have conversations. It's the best part of my job. Go out and have conversations, talk about what's going on in the community. We all know there's a lot going on in healthcare in our state, um, in our world. And this is a great opportunity to share the mission of what Mercy is doing.

SPEAKER_00And it's a continuation of how you got started. I mean, it's it's hand in hand with what you did at Susan G. Comen. Yes, you know.

SPEAKER_04When I left Coleman, I thought I knew everything about healthcare. And I got to Mercy, and I was like, oh my gosh, I don't even know what that affromand means. What does that mean? And what is this? So it's been a great learning opportunity. It has its own language. It does have its own language.

SPEAKER_00Um, I want to note that all three of us have our CFREs. And for those of you that don't know, that is certified fundraising executive. And that is a credential that we've all earned. And we need to come back for another episode because that's too much to cover today. But we need to come back and talk about that credential and how if you've had five years of experience, you need to be thinking about sitting for your CFRE. And you could contact any of us about that. So that's an aside, and I just want to throw that in there, get that said, but we need to have a follow-up conversation about certified fundraising uh executive credential.

SPEAKER_00It's something that's important and it's benefited all of us in different ways. And we all helped each other get through the trenches of getting that CFRE.

SPEAKER_01That's the last, and they helped me a lot.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. And honestly, I think one of the favorite things about having our CFRE is mentoring others. Me too. Yes. Are looking to follow in everybody's footsteps. I would agree.

SPEAKER_00Because if they get the fundraising bug or the fundraising jolt or whatever we want to call it, it is what you want to, you want to have that credential to show that you are full, you're all in. You're all in. Um, okay, let's start with some of the basics because some of our listeners may have heard the term, but may have never actually worked with a giving circle. Or so let's start with what is a giving circle? That's the basic, like what in y'all in we'll start with gay again. What in your words, what do you think a giving circle?

SPEAKER_00What's the definition of that?

SPEAKER_01Or what's well, I think um probably the easiest way to think of it is a giving circle is bringing a group of people together for a common purpose. Um, they do give financially, but I think they give in other ways also. And so it's a commitment to the mission through a giving circle.

SPEAKER_00Okay, Allison, let's start with you telling us about your giving circle, um, which is women with a mission. And uh, we've been in this podcast studio before to talk about women with a mission. And I am a member of it, but um, tell us what women with a mission looks like with Mercy Health Foundation.

SPEAKER_04So I agree with your definition, Gay. It really is a group of like for us, a group of like-minded women who come together to support a mission. And obviously, the mission is our hospital, providing good health care within our community. So um, our giving circle started in 2009, and we fashioned ours after our foundation down in Fort Smith. So the baseline of Women with a Mission was actually based upon Catherine Macaulay, who is the foundress of the Mercy House in Belplin, Ireland, who was called the Walking Sisters.

SPEAKER_04So beautiful. Yes. So it was really to honor her legacy and to continue that legacy to grow. So in 2009, we had an anonymous donor make a very generous gift in honor of Susan Barrett, who at the time was the president of Mercy Hospital. And so ours is called the Susan Barrett Women with a Mission Giving Society. And so from 2009 and fast forward to today, we have between 125 and 130 women.

SPEAKER_04It ebbs and flows that give a financial gift. Our minimum is$1,000 every year. And that those funds go specifically to provide care within our hospital or fund programs within our hospital. So we meet in February of every month. We call it our give back, give heart allocation meeting. And as a group, we learn about the needs that are there within Mercy. Allison, you've been there.

SPEAKER_04It's like going to college. It's like a poster presentation. We have that committee person share what they need and why this piece is so important. And then the women vote. And so we tally up whatever amount of funds that we have, and we take the top probably five or six items. And those are the items that we're able to fund for the for the next year. Huge impact. You know, as we all know, healthcare is expensive. So um this kind of fills in some of the gaps that otherwise wouldn't be filled in.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And and that meeting is is such a uh big heart, I mean, full heart meeting. Because we're thinking, oh my goodness, my donation is doing something immediate and right now.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. Right. So I know that my thousand dollars can't go very far at all. But together with 125 other people, we can make a huge impact. And normally, you know, everybody's membership comes in at different times during the year. But generally we have about$105,000 to$110,000 every year that we can put towards projects. So the benefit that you get about being part of Wing with Mission is obviously that heartfelt benefit.

SPEAKER_04But we also do um educational programs throughout the year. So we do four educational programs. We do a fall social, kind of just like a little networking fun event. Um, and then we do pop-ups throughout the year.

SPEAKER_00So yes. Okay, gay, tell us, tell us about your giving circle and what it looks like.

SPEAKER_01Okay. Ours is still new, I'm gonna say. That's why that's why I invited you today because it's fresh. It's fresh. We launched our giving circle last year in 2005, in March of 2005. We had one. 2025. I'm sorry. Yes, 2025 was last year. Let's not go back to 2000.

SPEAKER_00No, let's still go back to 2005, but 2025.

SPEAKER_01Back to the future around the world. I'm sorry. Um, and we have had the idea um looking at really different ways for people to get involved at a in a different way, like um bringing also new donors to Hope Cancer Resources that may or may not have been involved with us before. Um, and I think a lot of that comes um through personal invitation.

SPEAKER_01And so we did, we looked at, we had a goal of launching with 12 founders. Um these women, their commitment was there was a financial commitment, but a commitment to be with us year after year, but then to help us grow the circle, inviting other women into the circle. Um we ended up with 27 founders. That's wonderful. That is wonderful. And it was such, um, I think that in itself was so inspiring because we would be talking to somebody and she would say, I have somebody that has to do this with me.

SPEAKER_01And so um that in itself kind of gave them just the inspiration that you know what, people want to be a part of something that um collectively you can do in a really big way. And so that's where we started. We had our first imitation event last November and we added uh 30 more members. And so for our members to join the circle, we have three different levels.

SPEAKER_01Um we have um$240 level, a$1,200 level, and a$5,000 level. Um, our$5,000 are our sustainers, and so we've invited them to actually join us in some of our founder events. Um, it matched our founder's gift. And then um the others, we we wanted to make it where people could do it monthly if they wanted to, but make it very affordable for people to make it a little more accessible, and I think that that's been the right thing for hope cancer resources.

SPEAKER_01Um before we did anything, we visited with a lot of people, and both of y'all were part of that. Like um, the university has a big giving circle, Mercy has a wonderful giving circle. There's some others throughout the community, and it's like, what what is what is it for hope cancer resources? And and thinking like, what is the right um giving point? Um I'm very sensitive to we don't want to put something that excludes people from giving, um but we certainly don't want to limit someone's giving either.

SPEAKER_01Um, and so one of the things we did add as part of our giving options is we went ahead and put in an endowment gift. Um and it's$25,000. But that would be a hundred percent endowed and um really fits within the purpose of our foundation and the giving circle is a part of our foundation.

SPEAKER_00So most of and unlike women with a mission, y'all don't meet each year and decide what what the money's gonna do. The money is literally for the foundation.

SPEAKER_01Well, the money actually the give all of the giving is for financial assistance for patients. Okay. That's pretty purpose. Very specific. It may change over the years. We just had our founder's brunch. It was our second one. Uh, we meet in August, much like y'all meet in February to really give um an impact report. Like this is what's happened since you started this circle. Um, and even looking at our financial assistance for patients in Northwest Arkansas, what we are able to help patients with, it's small, um, but it's really designed to be like a bridge to help them.

SPEAKER_01So it may be a mortgage payment, it may be a car payment, it may be something toward a prescription. Things have become a barrier to a patient. And um Allison mentioned, you know, health care is costly. And even um when we are insured, um to be diagnosed with cancer can be very costly. And there's a lot of tests that lead up to just a definitive of a diagnosis. Right. And um so a lot of times you buy you're meeting your deductible, and then you have a 20% of a high value test.

SPEAKER_01It's sometimes it just puts us behind a little bit. And so for us to help people in that way, and that's really been the focus. We talked about it at our meeting last week, and um, they felt very confident of staying in that. Um we feel like if we can help people financially, then they actually can have access to our other services that are also free to them. Um, the counseling, we have a wellness center, we have transportation and a great group of uh case managers who work with patients to help them evaluate what they really need.

SPEAKER_01And so um the money doesn't just sit at the foundation, it's just while it's at the foundation, it is invested and so it is growing. And then we utilize it to help patients day to day.

SPEAKER_00And it sounds like one of the differences the founders, the founders' circle, they're the ones invited to the meeting to analyze. But the other members are invited to other events and like like Allison, y'all have programs and other perks throughout the year of ways to gather and visit, but the founders meet every August to decide to make sure we're still going to do this. And then it's twofold it's immediate needs, but also the foundation endowment. Right. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_01And one of the things we've tried to do, we don't do a lot of engagement events, but we try to make sure that our engagement events are connected to our patient programs. And so we've offered yoga just for our circle and meditation. Those are things that um we can help people understand what it's like to be in our patient space, not necessarily with the patients themselves. We do that after hours, but just to help them understand how some of our services and get them into the atmosphere and how safe it feels and how welcoming it is, because we want to make sure that every patient has access to what is offered.

SPEAKER_00And one thing that I noticed that both of you said is you found your membership tiers or your membership, you know, payment, whatever the donation is. It you took time to figure out what fit your organizations and what fit the people, your donors that you were talking to. And that's always good because every organization is different. Yes. Every organization has a different major gift and a different small gift and a different um, you know, campaign pledge.

SPEAKER_00They're all different shapes and sizes. So that's a real important thing for our listeners to remember is that it if you're gonna do this at your organization, you don't have to copy, you know, what everybody else is doing. You sit down and look at what is a major gift to us, right? Or what would a joining our circle be to us and you make it your own. Um, I was gonna say, so those of you that listening, we're gonna ask, if we were to join your giving circle tomorrow, and I'm a member of both of these circles.

SPEAKER_00So thank you. Thank you. So I I wanna want them to hear what what would what would their walk us through what their experience would be the minute they decided to join. What's the first thing that happens? I know we celebrate. I mean, we celebrate because we love when someone has the aha moment and decides to join. So there's celebration going on in your honor.

SPEAKER_04Yes. Yeah. Um, well, we always meet, obviously, face to face and talk about what the commitment is and thank them for joining. I know that at our first meetings, when a new person joins, we always make it a point to introduce them to the group, make sure that the other members have an opportunity to go say thank you. Glad to have you. Let's learn more about you. Um, I think um I know gay does a really nice gift. We do certain things at various times of the year.

SPEAKER_04Um, this past year we gave everybody a nice woman with a mission notebook. So when they came to meetings, they could take some notes. Um, years passed, we've done cool little makeup bags just as a little thank you for joining. Um, one year we did prayer books, and it was just a lovely opportunity to again share our mission through prayer. Um, we are a very social unit group of women. It's really hard to quiet the group down for the presentation, um, which is great because that's exactly what we want.

SPEAKER_04We want these women to feel like they're loved and part of a great organization. So um I think stewardship. There's a lot of stewardship involved in not only welcoming that member, but also remembering throughout the year, we do birthday cards every month to those that are celebrating a birthday, just those little small touch points to let them know how grateful we are for their gift. It means a lot.

SPEAKER_00One thing that I notice also is with healthcare being healthcare, it's in the news a lot. It is, isn't it? Uh-huh. Every day. Yes. And so what I also love about being a member of Women with a Mission is it seems that y'all try to keep us abreast if there's going to be some news breaking, or if you can't share it ahead of time, you share it the same day so that we're all on the same page and we know. And as a member of a circle, that's the that's a nice benefit when you're out on the street and someone says, Oh, mercy did this.

SPEAKER_00And you can say, Well, I got the information this morning, and actually, this is what it is. You know, let's just clarify that make that clear. Yeah, yeah. Yeah. Um, so I think I don't know if we said this or not. If we did, let's say it again. Like, why what made each of your organizations decide to start one? You know, I I think in the past, when I've worked with organizations, there comes a time when you need another way to connect. And that might be a reason.

SPEAKER_00If you've been, you know, your organization's been around a while, like both of yours, and you feel like there's a group of people that's not being reached, you know, that might be a reason to start one. But do you remember like what the reason was? Is it because you saw that Fort Smith was successful with their initiative?

SPEAKER_04Or um, well, Fort Smith and Northwest Arkansas were pretty much all part of the same team. We Clark oversees both foundations. Um, I think they saw the value in that when that first started. But I think more than that, they saw how we could continue the legacy of Catherine McCauley and how this her legacy walks so closely to our women with a mission meeting, meaning and vision.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, and so does. Yeah. And you touched on a little bit, but what made uh what made y'all decide to start the chapter? Really launch it. Uh to launch it.

SPEAKER_01You know, we had talked about it for a long time. And I think the idea behind it is um just that individual giving and bringing people together for for that very purpose. Um, I we all love Northwest Arkansas and our fundraising in Northwest Arkansas, and um this probably may be the most unpopular statement, but I I feel like we have led people to believe that fundraising is a certain thing and not everything.

SPEAKER_01Um I think there's a lot of different ways to bring people into your mission. Um, I think the most sustainable um is individual giving. And I think we see this in our hospitals for sure. You have legacy giving of um generations that they've seen their grandparents very involved in a hospital system. And so they go there and before they know it, they're invited to something.

SPEAKER_01And before you know it, they're giving. And then their children see that. And so I think we've seen like three generations, maybe four generations of that happening, but it's the individual giving. And even when we say, let's have an event and let's let's do a fundraising event, I think sometimes we forget. It's like, yes, it is an event. It's individuals who come and become connected to make that happen. Um, I feel like a giving circle goes a little bit, a little bit deeper.

SPEAKER_01It's not um more intimate. It's more personal. It's more personal. And it's like I said, it's that personal invitation to come and be a part. Um, and for some, they may be introduced and it's like it's just not for me or not for me right now. Um, but I think it is a great way to have people join you, but also, like you said, like to become an advocate in the community. Um, help us share our mission.

SPEAKER_01We just can't do it all where you're going to miss people. And this is a way to really be the multiplier of the mission within the community.

SPEAKER_04And I think we look at women with a mission as an educational tool. Um, this past year we actually did behind the scenes tours of our CAP lab and EP labs, which was really to me, I was like, oh my gosh, I don't know what goes on behind the walls here. I know they work miracles, but I don't know what happens. And it was just fascinating to watch how these groups of caregivers work together and how they dance together. When I say dance, I mean you have to do it.

SPEAKER_04You roll from one lab to another lab, the physician is ready to roll, his team is all set up, the patient is there. And I will just say it just made me feel so proud to be a part of Mercy because I could see the love that was going on. Even these people don't know that patient sitting on the table, but you could feel the love as they're watching the procedure. You can't, you can't.

SPEAKER_00I came to one and I was, I had been on the other side where I was out in the waiting room waiting on my mom. And so to get to see the procedure that she had and see how kind and care, the care that was given and the love, yeah, but the choreography, oh my word, like no one messed up their dance step. They took it. Everybody moved. And as the doctor went, like we were all in one window watching one thing, and then we got to the next one, and here he came to that lab.

SPEAKER_00And it was like, yeah, okay, now he's gonna switch gears and do this now. You know, yeah. Fascinating. It was fascinating. And and once again, it's another part of welcoming in a group that um is dedicated to the mission, welcoming them in to see how their gifts are being stewarded and used to support our community. Yes.

SPEAKER_01And it's all about people.

SPEAKER_00And that's true. It's just all about people. It is, and yours, your events are helping them see what y'all offer to people walking the journey of a cancer diagnosis and um all the things that you offer to give them support as they go through that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. And I will say, um when we were planning and trying to really do a lot of research to what was what was right for home cancer resources, what was right for our donors. Um, Jamie Dietrich met with some people and I met with some people. And um everyone when asked the question, like, do you think we should do a getting a circle?

SPEAKER_01And every one of them said yes. Yes. And I would be a part of it. And it was just um, you know, you think you really check yourself sometimes. Like, I have this idea. To me, that's always um a danger, but it sometimes is like the biggest blessing. Like, I just have an idea. And um, but to have some confirmation, and then it was like, okay, we've had enough confirmation to say, let's let's put a true plan to it, again, what fits our mission and the people who are in our community, and then go from there.

SPEAKER_01And so it worked.

SPEAKER_00If we if we go back to 2009, yes, when you started, knowing everything that you know today, would you create it in the same way, like and follow the same steps? Was there any time that you thought, oh, you know what, we should have gone right when we went left, or we should have gone left when we went right?

SPEAKER_04So I was not with Mercy when they started it. Um, but I know that we had 15 founders. Okay. That that was their mission to meet. We had three tri-chairs. We had Martha Burgeon, uh, Casey Oakley, and Leslie Zanoff. Those were our three pillars. Um, and they took that program and just began piecing it together. So it when I came on board, it was really small.

SPEAKER_04It was, it was probably, I would say, maybe 35, 40 members. And I think between everybody on our team, we have really worked diligently to make sure that that message and that opportunity to be a part of Women with a Mission is being shared. And and also, as you say, gay, when somebody that's a member invites somebody else to join, that has also helped. So I think we I think we did pivot.

SPEAKER_04I think we did a pivot from how it first started to what it looks like today. I think you have to do that to stay real.

SPEAKER_03Uh-huh.

SPEAKER_04Um, I think now we're using a lot more of our physicians to come in and do really amazing programs on sharing what their specialty is and educating our members on things you should or should not do. What tests do you need? What should you be eating? We just did an incredible partnership with Brightwater, the culinary school, where they actually prepared us a brain healthy meal and then shared about why that's important.

SPEAKER_04And it was delicious. Black bean brownies. Who would have thought?

SPEAKER_00Who knew? Who knew?

SPEAKER_01They tasted very annum brownies.

SPEAKER_00And these had black beans in them, and they were still delicious.

SPEAKER_04But I do think you have to pivot. I do think as you grow and the members, our age group is anywhere from 23 to 91. So when you look at that age group, you have to find the common denominator.

SPEAKER_01Right. Right. Yeah. And healthcare has changed so much. Truly it has. Oh goodness, yes. Healthcare in Northwest Arkansas has changed a lot. Um, thankfully, I feel like for the better. I'm always so proud of the health care that we have here. And um, can we do better? Yes. Do we have teams committed to do better? Yes. Yes. You know, and then our giving circles help us in um, you know, sometimes we can get tunnel vision. And it's like, what do you see?

SPEAKER_01What do you hear? What would you what was your experience in an oncology clinic in the hospital? And we learn from that. Um, and that that just helps to make us all better.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay, this is where our nonprofit friends are probably going to need to get their pencils out, or if you're driving, just know you can listen later. Rewind, rewind, and re-listen and share. Thank you. Um, but so for all of our friends out there, and they're listening right now, and they're thinking, we need one of these. Where should they even start? Um, I know that's a loaded question, but it's broken down into several, several little questions.

SPEAKER_00But um, what needs to be decided before you even launch a giving circle? Y'all covered some of it, but it sounds like uh you've you both did the same thing, which was gather some founders.

SPEAKER_01And you need a committed you need a committed team. Yes. Um, I think your your staff needs to understand the importance of it. Your board. Your board definitely needs to understand the importance. They need to understand that that's part of um the strategy to um increase your number of donors and to build, I think every um board will say, I met so and so and they didn't know that we did this or they didn't know about us.

SPEAKER_01And it's like giving circles give you again, like an opportunity for that to be shared more. Um, but I do think it's important for the board to understand like it is part of all of your fundraising strategy that just really and and the whole purpose of the fundraising strategy is just to to feed into the mission. You know, um, money is money. What gives money value is how it changes the lives in people.

SPEAKER_01That's the real value of it.

SPEAKER_04And also, you know what, focus on what you do best. You don't have to make yours look like mercy or make it look like hope or make it look like the University of Arkansas. Make it yours. Make it unique to your organization.

SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. I I mean I so I think just for to reiterate, we're saying one of the first things that has to happen is your board has to be on board with it and have the buy-in to be committed to helping share it and understanding it. And then probably the next is finding that that group of volunteers that want to be the leaders or the founders, which is so good about our stewardship and our information that we share with our donors.

SPEAKER_00It's another way for us to reach out to them, to ask them if they think it's a good idea, to ask for their advice. Yep. To ask, you know, you know, have you heard of a giving circle? It gives you a whole reason to talk to them and tell them you're thinking of launching it. Would you be interested?

SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's right.

SPEAKER_00You know, that's right. Um, I know it uh takes a lot of staff time, but uh I'm sure you're able to balance that because it is part of your stewardship strategy and donor relations and asking. So it fits in with everything you're already doing anyway. Yes. Um Gay has a success story about how you communicate the concept to prospective members. And I know you do too. Y'all both have great, great stories about how we get the word out and how we, you know, uh get more members to join.

SPEAKER_00And there's probably some ebbs and flows. Some years it's probably like, great guns, we got tons of people joining. And then there's some years is nobody seems to be answering my email. Nobody calls me back. What else would that do? Yeah, nobody seems to be excited as they were last year. But yeah, what are some of those uh ways that you can get the word out to to gain members or get, you know, get traction?

SPEAKER_01Um one of the things I remind our founders especially is that's part of our commitment is to um invite people to be part of our circle. Um, but even in our we had a um event in April and it was open to all of our members. And and at the end we just talked about like who's missing in this room? Like where in where in this hour were you thinking, oh, I should have invited so it's so to be here.

SPEAKER_01She would have loved it. You know, and so those are things that just naturally kind of come to our mind. Um, but getting people involved. Um, and I think when we feel like we're like something is we're making a difference, we want people to join us. And we know people, it's like they would so love this to be a part of this. Um after I leave here, I'm actually going to an event that one of our founders has put together, um, Melissa Fleman.

SPEAKER_01I'm gonna give a big shout out to her. Um she we have our regular invitation event in November. Um people can join at any time during the year, but it's kind of our focus. And so she asked if she could do um a personal invitation event. And so she is hosting it at one of our local or uh places in here in Rogers. And um, she invited 36. Well, and 33 women will be gathering in a couple of hours to hear our mission and to be invited to join our circle.

SPEAKER_01Very nice. She is doing the whole thing, and she asked me to come and speak on behalf of Ho Cancer Resources and really more so on behalf of the patients that we serve. And um and again, she's a part in it.

SPEAKER_04She is such a champion for cancer. I mean, cancer is part of her fabric. So yes.

SPEAKER_01They got a lot of cancer in their family, and she is one personally who is like, there's gotta be a way we can help. And so this is her using her network and people that um again, it's not just people on a list. These are women that she really feels like this can be important to them. And so she's invited them very personally to be involved.

SPEAKER_01So I'm thrilled. That's how uh circles should work. You know.

SPEAKER_04We um so we make sure that women with a mission is part of everything we publish. Um, it's in our corporate um um opportunities to give brochure. It's talked about at our charity ball. It is always front and center. It's just another piece of Mercy Health Foundation. Um, we report to our board, every board meeting. There is an update on what we have done and what's the future look like for Women with the Mission.

SPEAKER_04Um, we have a new champion that has joined Mercy, and she came from our Joplin um hospital. And she says, I am gonna find every every female leader that is in Mercy needs to be a part of. She said it is just what we should do. Since our mission is to carry on the legacy of Catherine Macaulay, we need to continue that mission.

SPEAKER_00So this is a physician or a person that works at Mercy. She is a senior vice president. Okay. So she's in administration. She's in administration. She is a Mercy employee. She is a Mercy employee. And she's made it her when her mission.

SPEAKER_04When I met with her, I said, this is great. I'm going to let you carry the torch. We have a lot of employees that are part of Limited Mission. You can do your payroll deduct through your paycheck monthly, quarterly, or in one lump sum. But we do, and we're starting to get more and more employees that want to be a part of it. But keeping that mess message about our giving circle front and center. I mean, it is it's annual giving.

SPEAKER_04Right. You know, it's to build upon future gifts.

SPEAKER_00And I know both of you have like a brochure or materials that you give each member so that if we're somewhere and it pops in our head, we can say, Oh, I've got a brochure right here and and share it with someone. Yes. But um we need to think like these two ladies that we need to be thinking like them and how we could share anything, any day, about something we're passionate about. Right. That's all it takes is to share it with somebody else.

SPEAKER_01Now we'll say this. Um, it doesn't have to be a women's giving circle.

SPEAKER_00No, no, I was gonna say, you know, circle of life is is expanding theirs to have men want to be involved.

SPEAKER_01It's anybody can be involved. There are some that are just men's getting circles. Um, Colin had a men's giving circle. We did have a we had um a great group of men, not a big group, but they were they were passionate. They were passionate, but it was what they wanted is the thing, and um they could direct how they used their gifts, which was really nice. Um they did it very much in the background, only if honestly, only if I think we only had you know, um, but like um Saint Joe, Saint Joseph's Catholic Church, they have a men's giving circle.

SPEAKER_01And so it it can be what you need it to be.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. And and cre just be like Allison said earlier, take your own situation and make it grow from what you already do and use the basics to set it up, but you don't have to copy or make it just like make it fit your your organization. And that brings me to one of the questions we have to answer is does it take a lot of seed money or do you does an organization need to spend a lot to start or maintain it?

SPEAKER_00Um I have a gut reaction to that question, but I haven't started a giving circle this year.

SPEAKER_04So you know what? I think, and I'll go back to one of my first um women of the mission programs that I went to when I first started at at Mercy. It was a cup of tea. It was a cup of tea and some cookies, and it was a program. So not a huge expense by any means.

SPEAKER_00And and I think we touched on this earlier. If you're a small nonprofit with limited staff, um it might not be realistic to do this right now. Um, if you've been a one-person development office for several years and it is you know it's time to start something like this, you probably could do it. If you in your gut, you know it's time, then that means you probably can do it and you're probably ready. But if if you're just starting out and the development department isn't strong yet, you don't have a signature special event yet, it's not the first thing you hop into.

SPEAKER_00No. It it comes after you've built your development department on the other basics, like a an annual mailer and uh an event and um ask face-to-face asks and that it's more of a it's something you do on down the road when you have something to offer.

SPEAKER_04Right. Right. Yeah. And I think you know, you will find a champion. You will find a champion that is either on your organizational board, hospital board, hope cancer foundation boards. That that champion can help you get your program going.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I've noticed it works for um operations. Like, like just a reminder, with women with a mission, it's it's we're giving to operational equipment, stuff that's happening right that second. With gays, uh foundate founders' circle or uh hope circle. What's the official name? Circle of heads, circle of hope. They are able to, they're giving towards the endowment, but they're also giving to an immediate need. It you can come up with, it could be an annual giving circle, a monthly donor giving circle.

SPEAKER_00Like you can come up with all different shapes and sizes of your circle. Um, but the pooled gift is the ultimate greatest thing about this circle. And um, so uh we talked about it earlier. You may feel like your small donation or your donation that's big to you is not making a dent in anything. But when you see it come to fruition when it's pooled with everybody else's, um have you seen members who are a part of the circle increase their giving because of their experience in the circle?

SPEAKER_00I know yours. Yes. Yes. And yours is brand new.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. We have seen it in different ways. Okay. Not necessarily an additional gift. Well, I'll take that back.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, take it right back.

SPEAKER_04I'm gonna take it right back. Because we did, when we did our allocation meeting last February, there was um a program that really spoke to one of our members, and she had already paid her annual dues, and she took out her checkbook and wrote a check right there and said, I can pay for that. Let me buy that. So I think yes, but the other ways we see it is their involvement in other activities. You see, they may come to our charity ball, they may play in our golf tournament.

SPEAKER_04They'll call they'll come to cornhole. Right. Um, they'll they may come to corporate roundtable to hear what's going on in the hospital. So I think once they're engaged with your mission, they crave more information. Right. They want to know more and how they can help do more.

SPEAKER_01And I think in do in thinking of that, like being willing to be transparent and open to their questions. I had a um one member before she joined, she said, Would you share your financials with me? I said, Absolutely. Yeah, and so I did that. I gave a lot of information, but I'm like, if we we want to sit down and visit, I was like, I'm good. Thank you for being willing to share.

SPEAKER_01Um anything mission, I would say share um through a e-newsletter. Sometimes it's picking up the phone and saying, I gotta tell you what happened today. You know, um, but it it helps people again, it's like it's so personal and it's like I just wanted you to know. And I think the stewardship of a circle um is very, very important. It's important with any donor. Um, but because it's a little bit tighter, I think the stewardship um needs to be a little bit stronger.

SPEAKER_00And what you said about the choices, you know, at that at our meeting, that annual meeting, um, that happened to me one year. Because you list, you don't just list the thing, like some of that equipment, you see the zeros on that, and you're like, oh my word. But then you think we're able to help with that because of our all of our pooled resources, but then always down at the the bottom, there's like, you know, breast bags for the mammogram patients. Or and yeah, I went home that day, and I thought, I mean, that is less than$2,000.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we I could just ask you 10 friends or something. And I five friends, yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_04And she raised the money.

SPEAKER_00And we all support so that they could this one did we can just get this one taken care of.

SPEAKER_01Scratch that scratch that off the desk. That's when you put a little heart diet.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, we give we provide these these blessing bags or these uh breast bags because it was just like a uh whatever comes.

SPEAKER_04It was a book, it was a book, educational materials. I think there was a blanket that might have been in there.

SPEAKER_00I think the blanket's what got me.

SPEAKER_04Yeah, blanket.

SPEAKER_00I thought I know people that would want to give to that. And if we just split it up, we get it all. And that that was it gives an opportunity that's um for us to go ahead and tackle that stuff at the top with all the zeros, but it's always good keep listing those because the people like me and like the lady that said, I can just do that. You know, that's the best. Um, and gay brought up stewardship, which is totally my language. Because it's not about just getting the membership and the gift, it's everything that happens after.

SPEAKER_00And that's that's where I think um this donor stewardship relationship building, all of it comes in, is after they join. And how has that helped with your donor stewardship? Like how has it helped you be more mindful, more thoughtful? Um, you probably think of the circle as, oh, need to let them know the news is about to break that we won the five-star. Yes, yes, you know, right, leap front, yeah, gold standard.

SPEAKER_00And we want them to know and explain what that is out when they're out on the street. Or um, it just gives you all those reasons to continue to communicate. But tell us about stewardship and how has the circle helped you with your stewardship goals? And I say that because even though we all know stewardship is so important, a life in a nonprofit has all these burning flames. Just they're all it's like chicken dinner, tablecloth color, um, you know, balls that are dropped, you know, flames are just happening all around us.

SPEAKER_00And so the the things that aren't so urgent, like saying thank you a billion times, get put on the back burner.

SPEAKER_04And is this a way that helps get that back to the front burner of this is just as urgent as this fire that's on, you know, that's happening right here on my desk, or I think we do a really great job in thanking our our our donors, or whether um annual giving, major gift, regardless, donors. Um, I think that is the key to building that relationship is to continue to be in touch with them.

SPEAKER_04You know about them, you know about their kids, you know about their spouse, you know about where they like to vacation. You're a part of their family. That's how I feel.

SPEAKER_00It has it deepens the relationship. It does.

SPEAKER_04Yeah. It does. Um, I will remember, and I'm sure gay, you do. If I know somebody's taken a nice trip, just a quick little note. Hey, enjoy your trip. Right. It it stewardship should not be, oh my gosh, I'm gonna have to write a letter or something. Kids don't write letters anymore. I do write letters. I still write. Yeah. But um, stewardship should be the fun part of receiving a gift because you're, like I said, continuing to build that relationship with that person.

SPEAKER_01And really a a thank you. It is not hard. It's not hard to thank someone. And the stamp and the handwritten note are still the best way. I write a lot of notes, um, I make a lot of phone calls. You know, Northwest Arkansas is really big, but we all laugh because we're like, and yet it's really small. We rub elbows a lot, and so we run into each other, and so it it's great when you run into uh someone who's part of your circle, who is one of your donors, or their friends, and you still can have this meaningful conversation.

SPEAKER_01And we're not asking them for money every time we see them, but we we do remind them that we care about their life. Um kids going off to college, um, starting first grade, you know, um, empty nesting, all the things that are pivotal moments in our lives. Well, they happen in our donors' lives too. Yes. And so um the more I think the one of the big things that we can do um in the fundraising field is give people our time.

SPEAKER_01And um sometimes people see that as like, oh, you have a meeting. And it's like, well, actually, we're just we're connecting. Yeah. And I learned something every time I sit down. We did um with our founders just this summer, just to kind of break up the group a little bit. We had some smaller coffees, and so we just call them circle connections, and we met in coffee shops in different places in northwest Arkansas. And who could come.

SPEAKER_01And but I will say um we talked um a little bit about the services of hope cancer resources because there was usually a question. But what really that time was about was tell me about your summer, tell me what's going on with your family, um tell me about your friend, you know, everybody has so much in their life. And so, um, but to see other members connect, um, one coffee specifically, one had a really good friend who had just been diagnosed with breast cancer, um, and very she was very concerned about her and how can I help?

SPEAKER_01And another person that was at the coffee is like, I'm actually a six-year breast cancer survivor. Um, and so if she has questions that she wants to ask someone who's actually had this surgery, had this treatment, I'm happy to visit with her. And I was like, this is what it is, this is what connections are, and this is how we help each other. And so it was really a beautiful way to bring um a group of women closer together that maybe would not have done that just in our regular brunch meeting.

unknownRight.

SPEAKER_04So uh women with a mission, our little members um have become my new book club. Nice. I get better recommendations from this group of women on what should I be reading? And it's just a wonderful opportunity for them to share what they liked, what they didn't like. And um, I have read three great books that have been recommended. Nice. Yeah, yeah.

SPEAKER_00Y'all, y'all have done so well that half of the questions on that that one page, y'all answered them in your other answers. So sorry I'm gonna no, no, it's great. It's great. It's it's exactly what I love about this because it all just bubbles up. Yeah. And it's not it, we don't have to be structured. We're literally just talking. But okay, now we have to talk about have there been any mistakes? Has there been anything that you did along the way and everybody thought, uh oh, we shouldn't have done that?

SPEAKER_04I'm sure that I'm sure I've made money.

SPEAKER_00Let me think. I think y'all would know. I think you would know. You'd say, well, uh-huh. The day we gave away the blue thing and it got blue all over everybody's, you know, dress or whatever, you know.

SPEAKER_01I would say we all need to be reminded that we're not perfect, but also perfection is not expected. And so there will be things that we don't do as well. I can't say, like, oh, that was an absolute mistake. Um but there are probably things that are like I may would have done that differently. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. And it's the thing, you gotta do it. You gotta push yourself and do it so that you find that out. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. That's right. That's right.

SPEAKER_04I'm trying to think. We definitely I don't want to admit that.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Do not, you don't have to either. Um, okay, we're we're to the portion we're gonna do this rapid fire advice. Oh gosh, okay. Like I'm gonna ask something, and then y'all can give quick, quick advice to the nonprofit uh professional that's listening. Okay, so small situation. So small nonprofit, one development person, giving circle, yes or no?

SPEAKER_04Not yet.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Brand new development program. Start now or wait.

SPEAKER_01Wait. Wait.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01That you can plan in your waiting. Yes. Okay. Like you can have your idea list. Yes. And and kind of like maybe, maybe now, still wait.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh can't decide on your minimum gift for the circle. What should they consider?

SPEAKER_04Again, it's based upon your organization and your mission. And I mean, there's so many factors involved in that. Um, again, don't follow some other program just because that's what they ask for. But you know your board is gonna say, well, if they can get that, then we should ask for that.

SPEAKER_00But we have to say to the board, but here's why we need to do our own thing.

SPEAKER_01It's gonna say evaluate your own data. Yeah. Like what's your largest gift? What's your average gift, annual gift, and look at where your donors are, meet them where they are, make it accessible. It may still be a stretch goal, which is okay, but it still needs to be accessible to you and attainable to your donors. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Say you have 10 donors interested. Is that enough to start? It could be.

SPEAKER_01I think so too. It's a good starting point. That's right.

SPEAKER_00Okay, your board is not excited about it. What do you do?

SPEAKER_04I think you show them a story. I think you show the value to them on how this could really change somebody's life, um, benefits to the hospital, benefits to our patient. Share a story. I think storytelling is so valuable. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Okay. What if your giving circle was launched, but lately it something, you know, there's been change and now that it's been stale for a couple of years. What do you do? How do you revive it? I think you pick up the phone. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01You know, I think there's it I think it depends on why it went stale. You know, there might like evaluate really what's going on. And back to like asking them, talk to some of them, either on the phone, in person, like help me identify this. Help us get this, help us get this fire feeling to do to survive it, to bring it back. Like we're down to an ember. We need this to be a glow. Help us get to that. And I think in again, like asking people to join you, um, it will it will flourish unless there's a a really horrible reason, which that's probably not gonna be the case.

SPEAKER_01No, sometimes it's busyness. Um, and so, or we may realize like we've dropped our communication, right? Like, so we have to be willing to self-evaluate also.

SPEAKER_00Now remember we had that episode with Teresa Mills, and it was about what do you do when the blank hits the fan? And she said the blank hit the fan, she became executive director and realized the fan was blowing the blank all over. Blanket it blank blank.

SPEAKER_01And she said, I saw the books.

SPEAKER_00She said the first thing she did was she just got on the phone with every board member and then every donor to tell them personally, here is what's happening. So it's it's literally a a way to just communicate, ask for advice, which always leads to a commitment and a partner partnership.

SPEAKER_01And I think it gives us perspective when we ask people, because what we may feel like, oh, this has kind of gotten they're like, no, no, I don't feel that way at all. Yeah. And I was just talking to somebody about this yesterday, or this just happened, and I'm looking forward to this. And so, but sometimes we just need to hear that to be like, okay, yeah, that's that's good. Yeah, you know.

SPEAKER_00Okay, members. Love the social part more than the fundraising part. Is that a problem or an opportunity?

SPEAKER_04I don't see that as a problem. I don't either.

SPEAKER_00No, I don't make it fun.

SPEAKER_04So they want to be a part of it.

SPEAKER_00Yes. And that's what they said today in that one session we were in. You know, you don't have to spend a lot of money to have fun. Right. That's right. So they encourage us, you know, just make something fun. People want to have fun. Yes. And they want good lemonade. That was also sick.

SPEAKER_01Well, and people are drawn to where there's energy. You know, and so and fun creates energy. Yes.

SPEAKER_00Okay. One thing every successful giving circle must have.

SPEAKER_01You have to have a strong commitment from the very beginning.

SPEAKER_00That board commitment. And the founder leadership. And a founder leadership.

SPEAKER_04And we do have a steering committee. So the commitment from them to give ideas on things they want to see. So that commitment.

SPEAKER_00Okay. Good. Okay. We're running out of time. So we're going to the um towards the end. And I thank you both so much for being here and doing this because this is just one of those things in the fundraising toolkit that we can add to all of the things we do, you know, at the right appropriate time when we have, you know, when we're ready to go with it. But your experiences, your ideas, the lessons you've learned along the way, this is what I hope my listeners get to hear about all the aspects of nonprofit life and fundraising.

SPEAKER_00And I hope they all walk away, remembering that a giving circle isn't just about pooling money. It's about pooling the people, the passion, ideas, relationships, and generosity around something they care about. And so we have done that today. And I know that if you have any questions or want a follow-up, you can always email me at askallison at allisonmackelroy.org. And I can get you to Allison Levin and Gay Prescott.

SPEAKER_00I can get you their information if you want to talk. They would talk to anybody about we love to talk. They love to talk. We love to talk. We all love to mentor. So you can always reach out to us. Okay, so now you guys get to ask me anything you want because it's the Ask Allison podcast. Y'all get to ask me anything you want about anything. It doesn't even have to be about fundraising.

SPEAKER_04What's your favorite vacation place?

SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness.

SPEAKER_04There have been so you were going to ask about a book.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, we were just talking about this the other night. We've my Dwayne is our vacation planner, and he goes overboard on the special. Um, it seems to be every other year now on the big one. We call it the big one.

SPEAKER_04Okay.

SPEAKER_00And we were talking the other night, and we we we feel guilty against it's nothing against the other vacations because they were all wonderful too. But we were talking about the the vacation to Italy and Greece, and how I never thought I would see those places in my life and getting to see the things I'd seen pictures of all my life. And it was a breathtaking trip. And then that led us to talk about some other trips and the great things about those trips. But I think we both keep going back to, and I think I do too, is getting to see Venice.

SPEAKER_00And we both were born in 1970. He was born in January, I was born in December, and we had a children's book, both of us, called um, oh goodness, what was it called? Dad Gum. It just went right out of my head. It was about the little kid who visited all these places, and we both remembered the Venice section of that book, and it shows him in the gondola. Yes. And while I can't, I think of the name of that book.

SPEAKER_00I'll think of it before this is over. I have to. And we both, when we both realized we both had that book, uh, we we neither one had it anymore. Come over to my house. That's what it's called. Anyway, uh, so that was something close to Venice, yeah, was because we remembered the Venice part of that book and wanting to see it someday. And he had already seen it, I think at 15, uh, which is a whole nother story. He got to go on a trip all by himself with a group.

SPEAKER_00Um, but for me to finally get to go, you know, at 53 years old and see it with my own eyes and experience it, yeah. That's a good question. Yeah. So and then Santorini. Oh seeing Santorini, yes, you know, and the glow and of those white just the beauty. Yeah. Do you have a good question?

SPEAKER_01I have a question.

SPEAKER_00Okay.

SPEAKER_01So what what has been your favorite ask donor experience that has just kind of stayed with you and inspires you when you think about it?

SPEAKER_00I think it would go back to our when Brenda and I were doing our capital campaign at Open Avenues and things just kept at first it seemed like nothing was gonna happen ever. And, you know, why can't we be popular like Mercy? Or why can't we, you know, no one gets us, you know. And then things just started happening. Yeah. And I remember we kept meeting with this gentleman named Arthur. And um, Arthur wasn't the a big philanthropist, it wasn't something that he did all the time.

SPEAKER_00And when we found out that he finally decided to make a gift to the campaign that was substantial and would help us, you know, inch toward yeah, yep. It it was huge. It was huge for me. You know, I remember being at lunch. I remember uh going to the bathroom while we were at lunch because the lunch was we kept talking and talking. And Leanne, my very best friend, was pregnant and she went into labor while we were at the lunch with Arthur. And so I'll never forget it. It was February. Um but that that was very monumental because we honestly did not know if he was a true candidate or if we were just barking up a tree of but for him to do that was huge.

SPEAKER_00And then and then there was the other one was um a planned gift that was made during the campaign. And um it was a parent of a participant in the program, and we thought one thing it was decided he was going to leave the organization in his plans and uh for when he passed away. And that was going to that also counted in the campaign.

SPEAKER_00So it helped us, you know, reach next goal. But when he passed, lo and behold, he had changed it. And but we weren't upset about it because it was to the participant, uh his daughter, still uh needed that. Yes, and so it was to her. Yes, um, and so we understood that everyone would understand that, but but then she passed away uh two years ago. And Brenda and I are no longer at Open Avenue. Brenda's retired, you know. I left in 2015 and he had left it all after she passed away.

SPEAKER_00Oh Open Avenue received this beautiful planned gift after years and years, and we had decided that maybe it could still be possible, but we weren't sure. Yeah. And to know that it came to fruition and it's a a big reminder of planned giving. That's right. You just never know. Never know. You never know. The ones that are yeses could be no's by the time something happens, and the ones you think are absolutely never gonna happen can happen just not in mid time you thought it was.

SPEAKER_01So but how deeply meaningful our programs are in Northwest Arkansas helping people and it shows. Yeah. Yeah.

SPEAKER_00Well, nice. Thank you all again. And to all my nonprofit friends listening, you don't have to do everything or have everything figured out all by yourself. You can start somewhere, build relationships, take care of your donors, and keep moving your mission forward. And remember, when you don't know what to do next, you can always ask Allison. Of course she can. So I'll see you next time. And oh my goodness, there's some big news coming out tomorrow. By the time this airs, I will be starting a new position.

SPEAKER_00Um, and I am thrilled to say that I am, I've totally forgot this. I am going to be the chief development officer at the Northwest Arkansas Food Bank.

SPEAKER_03Yay!

SPEAKER_00So when you hear this, the news has gotten out, and the Ask Allison podcast will still be here. Um, but I will be coming with uh some new perspectives as getting back into the uh trenches. I guess I missed them. I'm wanting to get back in there and roll my sleeves up even more. So, anyway, that's just a little aside that we threw in at that last. And and now remember, all you have to do is ask Allison.

SPEAKER_04Well, and you are gonna make a major, major change to that fabulous organization. I love the food bank. Yeah, I have volunteered there.

SPEAKER_00I love it too. Yeah, it's it's a jewel in our Northwest Arkansas or uh organization lineup. So beautiful. Um, we'll see how I sound next month at the Ask Allison podcast. If I'm have all my hair pulled out or, you know, we'll see. But I know it's gonna be rewarding and I am tickled to death to be a part of it. So, but thank you both. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, ask Allison, share with your friends.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. Ep. 13 - Donor Stewardship – The Art of Making Donors Feel Valued, Connected and Inspired with Patrick Feeley

    Nov 7, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    Losing a major donor over a skipped thank-you can sink a quarterly campaign. Veteran fundraiser Patrick Feeley brings 35 years of front-line experience to help operators shift from transactional asking to strategic...

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. Ep. 12 - DAF Rules: Navigating Galas, Pledges, and Perks with Jody Dilday

    Oct 7, 20261 hr 20 minAudio

    Over $320 billion currently sits in donor-advised funds waiting to be distributed. Jody Dilday from the Arkansas Community Foundation explains exactly how nonprofits can position themselves to receive these resources....

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Ep. 10 - A Lifetime in Fundraising: Lessons from a Fundraising Pioneer with Andrea Kihlstedt

    Aug 7, 20261 hr 12 minAudio

    Artificial personalization is quietly destroying donor trust across the nonprofit sector. Fundraisers are moving so fast with automated outreach that they are actively alienating the people funding their missions,...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. Ep. 9 - 10+ Things I’ve Learned After 31 Years in Fundraising

    Jul 7, 202659 minAudio

    Treating donors like ATMs is a direct resource leak for nonprofits. With grant guidelines constantly shifting and donor retention requiring deeper attention, leaning into authentic human connection is a practical...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Ep . 8 - Capital Campaign Triumphs: Beating the Deadline with Frankie Rankin

    Jun 7, 20261 hr 11 minAudio

    With shifting economic landscapes and looming federal budget cuts, fundraising leaders must learn how to strategically leverage big opportunities before time runs out. In this episode, Allison McElroy sits down with...

    Credit the people on this episode