Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Amazed and Perplexed

Amazed and Perplexed artwork

Why Does Jesus Choose the Twelve?(Luke 6:12-16)

Jan 18, 202538 minAudio

Send us Fan Mail 𝐖𝐡𝐲 𝐃𝐨𝐞𝐬 𝐉𝐞𝐬𝐮𝐬 𝐂𝐡𝐨𝐨𝐬𝐞 𝐭𝐡𝐞 𝐓𝐰𝐞𝐥𝐯𝐞?(𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐞 𝟔:𝟏𝟐-𝟏𝟔) For some reason, I have not been able to fix some of the audio problems with this episode. We apologize and it should be better next week. Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_01Hello, my name is Connor, and I'm Jason, and you're listening to the Amazed and Perplex podcast.

SPEAKER_02So on our journey, uh following uh Jesus, and I just want to remind all the listeners uh that what we're doing right now with the amazed and perplexed perspective is we're trying to follow loosely chronologically, uh, as if we're right behind Jesus, looking around the room, trying to give dignity to everyone. Uh I I have been taught the Bible at times that the Pharisees, the apostles, pretty much everybody was an idiot in one way or another.

SPEAKER_02And so how how do we honor the people? Because when I honor the people, I see myself in them. So there is this part of what we're doing that we're trying to really see behind. You know, what is the emotional makeup? What's some cultural implications? And today we're going to look at the 12 apostles, specifically the choosing, and we're looking at the the how Luke recorded it. It's in Luke chapter 6, verse 12. I'm just curious, what comes to mind when we're trying to set the scene, as it were?

SPEAKER_02Is there anything contextually that you'd want to offer as we think through this passage?

SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it's just to set up, I I think um you and I both have have touched a lot on kind of making fun of the disciples and and um their neptitude at certain points and their uh immaturity and just uh the very real uh the the rawness at which they're presented in the gospels. And there's a part of that that I think is uh is valid and fair. I also think one of the cool things we can draw upon is is is thinking about well, why did Jesus choose 12 and why did Jesus choose um, like why did he have to choose 12?

SPEAKER_01Why do you have to designate? And um, and you know, if you spend some time around Bible, I'm sure like there's kind of the natural jumping connection to the 12 tribes of Israel, um, and and you know, some symmetry that maybe Jesus is playing on there. And then thinking about how um I think giving dignity to these people is then to begin to think about um them as not representatives of the 12 tribes necessarily, but thinking about the story of the Israelite people um and how they kept turning away from God and how they kept not getting it, and then remembering like, oh, that's not just the story of God's people, like that that's my story, that's repeatedly my story.

SPEAKER_01Um, and so like as we process through all these questions of why Jesus does it this way, um, why the number, why these individuals, um we can ask that question about ourselves anytime. Why Jason and Connor at this table right now? Um, why me to even begin with? Um, and yeah, I think I I think I think there's some healthy, healthy questioning along those lines.

SPEAKER_02I think that is that is a really good thing. And I I I wanted to tap into specifically the idea that every human being ever has a lot of expectations. You know, men are the joke is men aren't thinking anything. That may be true uh in terms of in in the ratio of how much women thin things women thinks. How much then women thinks women thinks. I knew anyway. Um, but but that idea of every situation you walk into, you have expectations of.

SPEAKER_02And I I think it's kind of, I don't know, it's kind of uh I've just been around a lot of people like I don't expect anything, like that's a sign of maturity not to expect anything. It's not because it's not true. And if it was true, you had no expectations, you'd have no disappointments. Because if you get out and your cars, all four tires are flat, you're like, oh, I didn't expect them to be filled. No, you did. But if you get angry at life, if you complain about stuff, that's an indication that you had expectations that were not met, and it's not bad or good.

SPEAKER_02It's like most things, it's what you do with it. And I think it's just important that these men aren't just cast, they're not they're not just role players in this thing. They had real lives, they were born into families, they were treated well, they were mistreated, they were raised, their families had I don't I don't know Jewish culture enough to know the kind of dreams they had. They're in their at least several of them are in their father's line of work, um, which I assume is the norm. Um, but but they had expectations of what everything meant, just like every human ever.

SPEAKER_02And I think that's important to keep in mind, not just for this this choosing experience, but all the way through the gospels.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's that's so good. And this in itself, and maybe this is it's a sneak, maybe this is stealing an extra amazement, you know. Um you were double dipping, double dipping here. But I I I think there's there's a sense in which we can think about it's so it's so easy to think about what Jesus comes to do in these broad, uh, broad strokes of history, broad theological strokes of of solving the problem of sin and death. And then like all those things are true in in reality. Um, but they're also like if if we get caught up and lose sight that there was a flesh and blood human god man named Jesus who had a beating heart and who walked and lived and performed miracles and loved, um, then like all of those high-minded concepts and broad historical strokes that we love to pontificate about are ultimately meaningless.

SPEAKER_01In the same way you think about the the reconstitution of what Israel was supposed to be and um and the fulfillment of God's promises to those people, well, you can talk about the kingdom of Israel being the way it was always supposed to be, but like if it's just like an amorphous kingdom or it's an ideal kingdom, or if it's an ideal, like it's some ideal, like blurry vision of a person when you when you picture that, then like that's not real life. But it but if you can if you can point to somebody and you can point to Peter or you can point to you know point to John and be like, I know what John looks like, and and God, our God man, Jesus, says that he is a part of the kingdom of God and that when he loves and he lives, um, and he is he's sharing and helping bring about the kingdom of God.

SPEAKER_01Like I I know it it it drags it drags the the broad strokes of history down into the depths of like of dirt and soil. And that's what Jesus does is he descends from the mountaintop. As we're about to read here, as he goes to the mountaintop to pray, God Jesus descends from the mountaintop into the into the blood and soil of our lives. And um, yeah, I just think I think it's I it's incredible and amazing to me, and it's just really important to to like to remind ourselves um that there is symbolism here, but it's also like it's important to be able to point at somebody and be like, yeah, Jesus chose Jason and Jesus chose you know Bartholomew and be able to point and be able to look at them and say that.

SPEAKER_02Right. And and I'm I'm about to jump into reading, but the thing that that I want to remind us, and we kind of assume this, um, but especially if you're new to the amazed and perplexed journey, it's that concept of Jesus wants you to notice his humanity and he wants you to notice their humanity, or else he wouldn't tell us about their humanity. He could easily have skipped over those parts. He could easily have said, here's the only, here's the social media presentation of them, you know. But he chooses to show these weaknesses and the misunderstandings and ineptitude, like you said earlier, on purpose so that we can recognize, oh, that's me in this story.

SPEAKER_02And so that's that's really, really important to how he wrote, uh, especially the gospels. Yeah.

SPEAKER_01So I'll read and direct to you since I already kind of you know jumped ahead and started my amazement. We'll uh we'll we'll we'll reverse how we usually do it a little bit. So starting in verse 13 of Luke chapter 6. One of those days, Jesus went out to a mountainside to pray and spent the night praying to God. When morning came, he called his disciples to him and chose twelve of them, whom he also designated apostles. Simon, who he named Peter, his brother Andrew, James, John, Philip, Bartholomew, Matthew, Thomas, James, son of Alpheus, Simon, who was called the zealot, Judas, son of James, and Judas Iscariot, who became a traitor.

SPEAKER_01So, Jason, what amazes you?

SPEAKER_02The thing that that really catches my attention with this is how it's just a normal Tuesday or Thursday or Saturday. One of the one of those days. It's just one of it's just a normal day to them. I don't even know how much time they spent with him up to this point, how much time they spent with Jesus. And so, and there was a larger group of disciples at one point later, well, after Jesus resurrected, it says he he visited with like 500. So we don't know where the ministry is at right now. We don't know how many people are are with him all the time.

SPEAKER_02We talked, I don't know, a couple months ago now about the women that were with him. And so there's there's a collection of people that are already with him, more than 12. And so um, it's just fascinating to recognize that they don't know their life is about to be totally changed. They they know he's something special. They know that they were, if you know anything about the rabbinical culture and how they would choose their disciples very young. Uh, they're most likely these men are at an age where they're beyond being chosen by a rabbi and they've they've accepted their role in the society is to be fishermen or tax collectors or whatever they were.

SPEAKER_02I don't think zealot is an official job title, but but you see what I'm saying is they were they were these were not old men, by the way. They were most likely what we would consider young, 18, 19. But I would say they probably entered adulthood at 13, you know what I mean? So they've been adults for a while in their cultural understanding. Um, but they have no idea that when Jesus comes back, I don't know if he's like, hey, everybody, let's meet at sunup or you know, at 9:30 or whatever, but he takes this completely normal moment and it's dynamically life-changing.

SPEAKER_02Where would we be? Even for those that don't believe in Jesus, we know Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John. You know, most people have some awareness of Peter the apostle or Paul the apostle, you know, who will be another apostle that's brought in. But this idea of him choosing how he makes this completely commonplace, normal moment so incredibly powerful. He changes the whole of history. And so where that leaves my brain is what is he doing today that is changing history that I don't pay attention to and I won't know for 10 years that oh, that conversation was what shifted.

SPEAKER_02And that to me taps into the mystery and the wonder and the awe that God's creativity and cleverness and brilliance could bring to our life all the time. That we're like, I wonder what he'll do with this. I wonder what he'll do with this conversation right now, the very common words coming out of my mouth and how he, yeah, it just amazes.

SPEAKER_01You think you you would think, you would think the even if so if you're somebody um like within the sound of my voice who like doesn't even believe, like doesn't believe um that Jesus is who he says he is, it's undoubted, undoubtedly true that um these 12 men are some of the most impactful people in the history of humanity. Um Jesus certainly is, and then these 12 men and and how um and how their mission and their lives uh change the course of history is is undoubted.

SPEAKER_01You would think um there's a grand like if you if you study history, um, you'll have these moments where like Julius Caesar is getting ready to like cross the Rubicon and he has these these epic words to give of like you know as as he declares basically his his intention to march on Rome. Um you think about Alexander the Great and you think about um uh the the famous quotes he has as like as as he realizes his full um as he realizes his his full dream of conquering the world, you know, everyone knows that the famous quote of you know he wept because there was no more nations to conquer.

SPEAKER_01Um, you would think that this grand moment, um, these men, as long as humans have language, these men will be known. Um you would think that there would be some grand um that like there'd be some grand thing that was like some grand um uh I'm trying to think of the right word. Um what's what's what what's the word I'm searching for? Uh like not like a graduation, but there'd be some ceremony, some grand ceremony of, you know, I dub thee, you know, whatever.

SPEAKER_01Um and it's not that. And that just leads credence to what you're talking about here, um of giving dignity. Um, like if God is in every moment and God is with me always, recognizing that when I assume that he can't do grand, incredible things in this small mutton moment that I would consider nothing, like that, like when you say it out loud, you go, Oh, that that's silly, but it's like we always assume that we will know in the moment when um when something is grand and epic, and and that's just that's not true.

SPEAKER_01And that's not what God calls for us. Luckily, that's not like God's not like, hey, have the foreknowledge and and be in the moment, but also like I yeah, I just I echo in your rejoicing of knowing of like, okay, like all of the ingredients for the epicness of this moment for Jesus and the disciples, those those ingredients are are there in my daily life.

SPEAKER_02That's exactly right. And I think I really that that really explores it a little bit more for me. I I think in general, there's something about the way we tick as humans, and we're all different, but I do think there are lots of common threads. We may live it out differently, but we have some of these same dynamics where we're like, if I don't have some mystery that I'm working to solve, and again, it's gonna look different, you solving the mystery versus me solving the mystery, and what mysteries interest me.

SPEAKER_02But but that kind of idea that what will happen next, and that excitement that's up around the corner, I I think it's tied to hope. I think it's tied to faith, I think it's needed. And and I think when we feel our lives, in particular our lives with God, are stale, I think it's an important question is how much do I experience wonder? How much do I experience awe in my life? And if I'm not experiencing it, why? Does that mean God is not a God of imagination and creativity and suspense and surprise?

SPEAKER_02Or does it mean I've shut that part out because your free will can shut out the work of God? That is one of that's the main unique features of humanity, is we can say, no, I don't want any of a God. And when we exert ourselves to block out God, and in particular, I'm talking about Christians, I'm not talking about atheists. Ironically, atheists may have a greater sense of wonder and all, you know, because they know they don't know necessarily what's gonna happen.

SPEAKER_02Where a lot of times we're taught Christianity means you know what's gonna happen. Well, God's not gonna work that way. And I'm like, you couldn't live in the Bible and say God's not gonna work that way and participate in what God actually does because you would never know. There's none of the stuff that happens in the Bible. You're like, well, of course he's gonna part to see here. It's like, no, you wouldn't be thinking that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, and it's if Moses walked uh walked on on what became holy ground for decades of his life, not knowing that one day God, Yahweh would appear to him in in the form of a burning bush. And yet, like there has to be a realization of like that God was not more in that, like in the in that space in that moment than he was two weeks before that moment. Absolutely right. So, yeah, getting onto my so this helps kind of transition to my my second uh my double dipping of amazement, if you will.

SPEAKER_01Life is so unfair. I know, it is what it is. I I think it would be so easy with that mindset of that realization of like God is here in this moment just as much as He is in the moment that I got saved and He was, you know, I could like He like it's easy it's easy to get caught up in that and to assume, like, okay, well that invalidates some of those other mountaintop experiences or that um lessons or that or or like um or that those are moments that we should not even seek to have because like if we're really following God, then we'll know that like you know, those are just all the time all around us, no matter what.

SPEAKER_01Um and what I love here is that like Jesus, who has more access, this seems like a bold theological claim, but I think it's true, more access to the Father than than we do, has or a clear access, I don't know how however you'd phrase that, seems to have has a deeper relationship with the Father than than than you and I do, um, still needs to find space, um, still needs to make space um and be intentional about um about that connection. Um and and I think this is one of those things where um it helps me see the humanity of Jesus.

SPEAKER_01If Jesus, if if I assume pre-creation, Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, they're not having to Jesus is not having to go onto the non-created mountaintop to commune with the Father. Um I assume that the that it's in it's instantaneous, it's outside of time, it's it's the the beautiful dance that we can't even begin to comprehend of what the what the Trinity is. Um But for me, what what is amazing about this is um it's the taking on of humanity.

SPEAKER_01It's um recognizing about what this must be like for Jesus, um, and just thinking about how um thinking about what it must be like for him to think about like, oh, I've got this decision coming up about who I'm gonna make my disciples, and thinking about like, is he is he is he long? Is he anxious about getting time to go on a mountaintop to pray to God? Is he excited for it? Is he um is he is he yearning? Is he like I just I would love to know what what what headspace he was at?

SPEAKER_01But I I I think it the conversation we had right before this part, I think it's just it's helpful to remember, uh it's just helpful for me that God is everywhere, God is in everything, um, God is through everything. But then also even Jesus, um, even Jesus, it's helpful for Jesus to make space and time um to to talk with his God, to talk with his father.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, I think so. I I have a story that I go back to uh I feel like enough that people would know it if you've been listening. Uh but I I was part of a missions group and we would do all night prayer sessions, and I think that's fine. I think it's fine. Uh but they would always cite this passage, and I'm like, Jesus didn't have an all-night prayer session. Jesus went out to pray, and he prayed so much, he prayed all night.

SPEAKER_00Yeah.

SPEAKER_02And there's a big difference because when you do an all-night prayer session to get through the night, there'd be maybe 20, 30 of us that would do it, you you have structure to keep you engaged, and we're gonna pray together, and then in small groups, and then individually, and then we'll come back, you know what I mean? It wasn't like that, it was very much for Jesus just this pouring out. And I think that is just a really important signal is this was not a spiritual discipline in the sense, man, I better get my prayer time in because I gotta turn in my schedule to whoever, you know.

SPEAKER_02This was him wanting to commune and longing to commune, and he had some sense he needed to choose people, which kind of leads into my perplexion, but it but it is that idea that I mean, when you think about what this becomes, it's like this is not a mild choice. I mean, Judas alone would be such a complicated choice. And we don't know when Jesus learned the things about Judas, you know, that that he does, but it is that dynamic that it's just important. This is a really important decision because these guys will be carrying on um in his his work, they're his plan A of how to carry out this message once he leaves.

SPEAKER_02And to some degree he knew that, you know. I I think there is this learning process that Jesus himself is going through. Like at this point, like in the text, it said Judas Iscariot, who became a traitor. That doesn't mean he's he knows that he's gonna be a traitor. It's simply because this is written afterwards, of course. You know, Luke writes he's things on after Jesus has died and resurrected and these kind of things. And so, anyway, uh so we don't know, but anyway, the point there is Jesus knows it's a complicated decision. Now, here's the here's the rub for me, and we alluded to this, I think you even said this in the introduction.

SPEAKER_02Why choose? Why, why choose? You know, and then, and this is where the perplexing stuff always gets me, is what do I do with it? Like, okay, so I'm a minister, I'm a I I get paid, that's my full time job, to be a minister. Am I discipling people? Because if Jesus only chose 12 as his inner circle, now he had more disciples than this, maybe 500, but what does that mean? Do I need to have a group inside the congregation I'm working with? It it did he only choose 12 just simply be like he could have.

SPEAKER_02Chose another number from the Bible. 40 is a good number from the Bible. If 12 is good, 40 is better, you know. Um, 70 is a number that shows up, you know, why not 70? You know, and so he chooses 12. And I I agree, it goes back to the 12 tribes, but again, we only see that as, oh, yeah, it needed to be 12 because it was 12. If he had chosen 79, we're like, okay, eventually he sends out 72 disciples. Is that the magic? You see what I'm saying? It's like, it's like, what, why 12? Why the difference between disciple learner and apostle is one who is sent.

SPEAKER_02It's like, why do this at all? What and and what do we learn from that? Do I need to have a sense of I have a group that I have an impact on? And so let's say I'm not a professional minister. I have six people that I see have an impact on, my my spouse and my kids and my whatever, you know, my friends. So do I need to choose one of them to be the inner apostle? You see what I'm saying? Like, what's the implication here of this choosing? Because it's important to remember, and I mean, it seems like a kickball dynamic. He's like, guys, I'm gonna be doing some choosing.

SPEAKER_02See, I would love that narrative to know how did he do it? He's like, everybody up against the wall and uh face me, don't put your hands on the wall. Like, I'm not arresting you, but but it's that idea of it's like saying, I choose um, let's go with with Peter and with John and with Thaddeus. We know at least two guys are there, named Matthews and Barsabbas. We don't learn that until Acts chapter one, because they choose one of them to replace Judas, which that's another thing. Why not just do both? You know, eventually they had Paul, so now you have 13 apostles. It's already a baker's dozen, like you're off already.

SPEAKER_02So it's just this weird. To me, it's it's it's kind of arbitrary. And I'm not a numerologist, so I do get that there's some significance, but I'm like, why is he feel the freedom to send out 72? Why not just choose 72? You know, and and again, uh the reason things perplex me most of the time is because I don't know what to do with it. Because ministers are responsible for everybody that crosses their path. So if you got three or four hundred people in your congregation or a thousand, to some degree you're part of the discipling process for all of them.

SPEAKER_02So so it is, I don't know what this teaches me.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't I I echo a lot of a lot of what you have to say. I I do think, you know, I wonder I don't think Jesus is doing just one thing. I don't think he's just like I don't think he's praying to God and being like, you know, we gotta get 12 because it, you know, we uh we really only have good strong 10, so let's stretch it out. And like, you know, God uh Judas, Judas, yeah, I mean we could we he we could fudge the number, we'll we'll get to that, you know. We'll like we'll we'll fill out our team with some scrubs at the end of the bench.

SPEAKER_01I don't get the sense that that's what's happening, although maybe I don't know. Um what I what I wonder um if one of the small aspects of what Jesus is doing is he chooses 12 because um he knows that it means something, it'll mean something to them. Um to think about where they are at, what they're going through, what their emotions are. Um again, they're people who are steeped in in Jewish religion, in tr in tradition, and history.

SPEAKER_01Um, and to have this rabbi who's outside of the traditional rabbinical system come by, choose you, pick you. Um, and you're also, but you're not don't have esteem, but you're picking up a lot of followers and doing crazy things and and like you're caught in this whirlwind, and and then all of a sudden, um like and then you as some as soon you're gonna have a lot of Pharisees coming against you um and Jesus to be like, no, no, no, no, no. Like you know how it, you know how the uh you view you view Jacob and you view his children and the tribes, and how big of an impact and how important that is in every person that you talk to.

SPEAKER_01Like, I'm giving like the significance of what we're doing here is even more so. And giving like you is there a piece of confidence that he's giving them, is there a piece of um responsibility? Like I don't I can't say that that's the case at all, but I I do wonder um if one of the reasons he's doing it is is for them.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, I do. I I that resonates with me, and I think too, we know there's gonna be a lot of self-questioning, there's gonna be a lot of questioning about uh their role and are they valid, and so any encouragement he gives them.

SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, and thinking about like thinking about your example of like what do I do with this? I I think about if I I think about when you when when somebody's a pastor, um I've had this I've when I when I was a pastor and had the situation where I'd meet with somebody, there are some people who come in with the with the armor on of like, well, this is just what you do. You meet with people, you get coffee, and you know, like I'm just another, I'm just another number to you. Um I'm just another, you know, like you have you you're getting paid to be here, so you you have to be here.

SPEAKER_01And there's a sense in which that's you know, something to deal with to do with uh something to deal with. Um but what I what I what I do wonder is like I I think when we view what our like our biggest impact can be, like if we are trying to be um like there's a sense I think if we are trying, if if we have six or seven or eight or twelve people in our life that like we have deep, deep impact on, um, that we have an incredibly close relationship.

SPEAKER_01If we are trying, um I I I do think if we're if we tend to be the kind of people that want to try and fill that with 20, 30, 40, 50, 100, 200 people, um, there's a sense in which as we attempt to go um wide, our depth maybe our de I don't know. This I'm just talking out. I don't know if this is even true or not. I do wonder if there's a the small message for us can be like the truth can be the truth is the human bandwidth only has so much room to go so deep with so many people.

SPEAKER_02I think that's reasonable. I have sat in rooms with ministers who felt safe, so maybe there's 30, 40 ministers in the space, and they're you know, most of them are full-time. If they feel any space to be honest, they're like, it's overwhelming carrying all these burdens. It's overwhelming just hearing the stories and then being and then being yeah, you know, carrying the expectation that I'll remember the stories, and they may not talk to me for six months, but when they do, they assume I remember all these details, you know.

SPEAKER_02And so it would be so relieving if Jesus came along and said, Look, preach your sermons or do your ministry, whatever. But choose, you know, Jesus had 12. We're gonna go ahead and say you qualify for two, you know, and so it's like pick two, pick one, you know, pick one person that you're gonna invest in. I think ministers, number one, I think that last a lot longer, uh, because they're just worn out most of them. And and honestly, that's probably the least of their concerns, the complete disrespect, the combative nature oftentimes of other leaders in the church, the territorialism, blah, blah, blah.

SPEAKER_02This goes on and on. Um, but I do think that would offer such relief. And if I do feel overwhelmed to step back and say, okay, who has God given me right now that I have influence over and they have influence over me, and we're discipling together, that's actually clarifying. So that that does represent a peace-bringing discipline for me.

SPEAKER_01So this is uh this kind of transitions to a a what perplexes me. Um, and it's not, it doesn't perplex me because it perplexes me because it goes against so often what we end up taking away from scripture. Um when we I I get caught up a lot with Judas and get caught up a lot with how much Jesus knew, how much the other disciples knew, what was going on, um, and when they knew it, and and and all that's that's at play there. But when you think about like the preachers that you know, if you said, hey, you've got 12 core guys that are just like they're your men, they're they're your guys who will go to bat for you, and you're like, 11 of them, like one's gonna stab you in the back, but 11 of them are gonna be like, you know, they you know, they might fail you every now and then, but they're gonna be there for you in the end.

SPEAKER_01You'd be like, I don't know a single person that wouldn't take that and wouldn't, you know, take it running, screaming away, thinking they got the best deal ever. Um, because um, yeah, that like that that that feel that betray, and again, like we know we know Peter does have some betrayal or whatever, but again, ultimately stands firm in the faith and um is is there for Jesus. I I think what is what is is perplexing to me is um this is outrageously successful. Like just like even again, we don't measure these things this way because it doesn't seem to be, but just numerically, for him to pick 11 out of 12 random uh blue-collar, white collar, where like just r a random survey of of Jewish guys like 2,000 years ago who had no special religion, like really religious training, um, to be and and for him to be like, yeah, to get it right, you're like, oh, that can only be because he spent the night with God in prayer.

SPEAKER_01That can only be because of the power of God at work. Um, and so yeah, I I'm I'm perplexed because there is certain parts where we read scripture where I would think like if I was reading up to this, I'd be like, oh yeah, this is the part where we find out that uh we call them knuckleheads all the time. But actually, fit Jesus only bats 50% here, but hey, 50%'s a lot better than I've ever batted. So you know what? Good job, Jesus. But it's like, yeah, this is this is a miracle how how well how well it works out.

SPEAKER_02I I think so. I I did the math, uh, meaning I asked, I asked Google. 91, his success rate is 91.666667 uh percent. And so it's that's great, you know, a 90, 92 percent success rate. That's a solid A. And uh yeah, I mean that that's good. You're right. I I don't know that I'd thought about it. There is another thing I'd throw in here is why tell us you chose them and only give us character development for four of them, five of them, you know.

SPEAKER_02It's it's interesting. We know more about Judas than we do Bartholomew, and it's because he acted out. You know, it's like it's like a parent has 12 children, okay? Poor them. Uh I mean, God bless them. That's what I meant to say. Treasured blessings, but they have 12 children. And the one that acts out, because I've had this, I mean, the people that have had trouble in my life, I typically know them better than the people that it always goes smoothly, because I'm invited into their life more in my role. Um, but it is interesting. It's like, why name them if only five of them we hardly know anything about, you know?

SPEAKER_02And that's just another part of it that's perplexing. I mean, I think it'd be beneficial from a personality perspective to find the apostle you're most like. Like, I think it would have been a good assignment. Matter of fact, I think this is how you disciple a person. Like, I I don't know, we've done discipling together, we still do, but I never stop, you never stop and say, hey, Jason, present a paper. But it would be reasonable to say, um, hey, what has your experience been in this? And I'm like, it'd be fantastic to have 12 books, you know, that are the, you know, here's the gospel according to, and we've got Mark who wasn't an apostle, and Luke who wasn't an apostle.

SPEAKER_02So you got two apostles and two non-apostles writing it. And it's like, why not have 12? That'd be fascinating, you know? And so I do think it's just it's it's all interesting to me. And I don't think any of this blows the faith. This would just be things that would add color, as it were, add, add nuance to this, to be like, man, the way, the way, you know, uh Simon the Lesser, what's that? Wow, that's awful. But Simon the Lesser thinks about his relationship with Jesus, that that relates to me, you know. I I I think we have this similar personality.

SPEAKER_02So it is interesting how you name the twelve, but only really explore a few of them. Yeah, no, that that's my double dipping on the perplexion. So there's that.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, that that is that is incredibly fascinating to think about um the king of the universe coming down, going up to a mountain to pray to his father, coming back with a list of names, and then and then just no further explanation. Like the the writing there, it's almost it's funny to me because I think it's like it's one of those small things where like it helps me, it helps me uh trust maybe the Bible even more. Because you would think like, oh, a good writer here is like where you break down into like you know, and and we have there's church history for pretty much every one of the disciples.

SPEAKER_01I'm like, you know, church history that you can lean on, and and some I some some you can more historical proof than others. Um you can do without whatever you will. Um but yeah, I there there has to be a reason that that that's not the case. And I have some ideas, but I also can't know for sure. And you know, that's the brakes.

SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, I I see that. And and I think in the in the grand scheme, you know, I I I I think we have what we need for sure. I just think it's a very interesting, it's funny because you're like, well, of course Jesus told chose 12, you know, apostles. Not of course, first of all. And second of all, okay, if you're gonna choose them, this is kind of like Peter going, well, if you're gonna wash my feet, wash my whole body, that's functionally what I'm asking for. Well, if you're gonna give me a little, give me a lot, you know, tell me more, you know. And you are right, in traditions they have it.

SPEAKER_02So I'm speci I'm speak speaking specifically of the canonical uh, you know, gospels, obviously the gospel of Thomas and there are other gospels out there. Um, and and I think, you know, weigh those however you will, listener. Um, but just that general dynamic of if I'm gonna name people, like like the only reason we know that Bartholomew, Bartholomew was an apostle and important to the mission is because of this passage.

SPEAKER_01Well, and what's funny as we as we finish up here, I think throughout church history, and there's other things beyond like apocryphal gospel uh uh collections, um, just general church history and and things that like the church fathers will um will pass down and say, Bartholomew went to do this or whatever. The only through line through all their lives is that they all die a pretty brutal death.

SPEAKER_02Um and so that's why they're named here. These are all the guys that died, except the guy, you know, some drawn in exile.

SPEAKER_01Yeah, and so um I I think that there's something we can take away from that. And um, but also it but also just I I I love wanting to come back and center myself and recognizing um this was an of course. And um it's easy to assume when we look at other people's lives and the way that God's moves, oh, of course it happened, or like, of course, God has to work in my life in this way. Um, and there is no of course. And that is scary for us because that means God won't fit in our box, but it also means that God doesn't fit in our box because and that's good news because our box isn't good.

SPEAKER_02And I like that reflection because it's like even in the choosing of 12, which we might think of as relatively straightforward, it's not. And so that reminds me, today is a day that's not, and of course, I and that's that's that's what it's like living with a living God, and I think that's a good idea.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How We Think About Marriage(Matthew 19:1-12)

    Nov 8, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐖𝐞 𝐓𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐀𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐌𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐚𝐠𝐞(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟗:𝟏-𝟏𝟐) Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Unmerciful Servant(Matthew 18:21-35)

    Oct 4, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐔𝐧𝐦𝐞𝐫𝐜𝐢𝐟𝐮𝐥 𝐒𝐞𝐫𝐯𝐚𝐧𝐭(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟐𝟏-𝟑𝟓) This episode sits with Jesus' parable of the unmerciful servant, unpacking the ancient debtor's world behind the story and the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hearing as a Community(Matthew 18:18-20)

    Sep 27, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐚𝐬 𝐚 𝐂𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟖-𝟐𝟎) Jesus makes a bold, almost startling promise: where two or three gather in his name, he's there, and whatever they agree on will...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. A People of Repentance and Forgiveness(Matthew 18:15-17)

    Sep 20, 202649 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐀 𝐏𝐞𝐨𝐩𝐥𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐑𝐞𝐩𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐅𝐨𝐫𝐠𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟓-𝟏𝟕) This episode digs into dealing with Sin in the church. We discuss why the gentle, small first...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. The Rich Man and Lazarus(Luke 16:19-31)

    Sep 13, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐢𝐜𝐡 𝐌𝐚𝐧 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐋𝐚𝐳𝐚𝐫𝐮𝐬(𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐞 𝟏𝟔:𝟏𝟗-𝟑𝟏) This episode dives into the strikingly detailed story of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16. The discussion explores what it means...

    Credit the people on this episode