Skip to content
PodSubs
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEvents
More
BlogPodCred
Menu
ShowsPeopleGuestsJobsNewsEventsBlogPodCredNetworksSign in
Join nowSign in
  • Shows
  • People
  • Jobs
  • News
  • More
    • Guests
    • Events
    • Blog
    • PodCred
    • Networks
    Join nowSign in

Amazed and Perplexed

Amazed and Perplexed artwork

A People of Repentance and Forgiveness(Matthew 18:15-17)

Sep 20, 202649 minAudio
ShareXLinkedInFacebookWhatsAppEmail

Send us Fan Mail 𝐀 𝐏𝐞𝐨𝐩𝐥𝐞 𝐨𝐟 𝐑𝐞𝐩𝐞𝐧𝐭𝐚𝐧𝐜𝐞 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐅𝐨𝐫𝐠𝐢𝐯𝐞𝐧𝐞𝐬𝐬(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟓-𝟏𝟕) This episode digs into dealing with Sin in the church. We discuss why the gentle, small first approach gets skipped in favor of shame and public callout, we wrestle with painful firsthand stories of disfellowship gone wrong, and reframe the passage's hard final line. Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

Audio and video play straight from the show's own hosting. PodSubs stores and serves no media.

Transcript

From the show. Tap a time to play from there.

SPEAKER_00So as we dive into this passage, I do want to acknowledge this is a it's a tough passage uh it in terms of how to apply. I've been part of many Christian uh churches, many Christian organizations, and this is always a challenge to apply. Now, contextually, this stems from a question uh that the disciples ask, and we're not sure if this is the 12 or a larger collection of disciples, where they ask him, who's the greatest in the kingdom of heaven? And so he talks through some specific answers, elevating a child, then warning not to cause little ones, which I assume is all of us, uh, to stumble, and then talks, gives the that parable about the wandering sheep.

SPEAKER_00And so it's interesting to me in this context why this corrective action, so that's part of my wondering right now is huh, as we read this, I'm asking God, God, how does this connect with who's the greatest in the kingdom of heaven? And so I think that's good context. Anything that comes up for you, Connor?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, just to maybe give a little dignity, uh, I think this is one of those few passages where if we didn't have this, I think it would be very complicated to think about to try to tease out what exactly this community of that Jesus building is supposed to look like. Um, the very idea that he is like, hey, so when conflict happens, when bad things h occur, this is how it's done. Like just that very act of himself of acknowledging this new reality, um, it says a lot.

SPEAKER_02Um, well, it says a lot about what Jesus expects, but then also I think it can direct us and how we um and how we can think about what Jesus was trying to communicate, what all this was for, and then also, okay, well what what's our job now as followers of Jesus, trying to, you know, carry the torch and and and be a part of his body. Um and so it's one of those areas where like I've been a I I've heard it talked about a lot, um, but I do think like outside of this, you could almost get the idea that hey, in a body of community, in a community, if there's strife, if there's a failing or whatever, um i if all if you were only going off of Jesus words, I think there could be like mass confusion about like, okay, well what is what are we supposed to do now?

SPEAKER_02What is what does this look like? Um and so this is like a pretty integral teaching. Um I don't know if we always necessarily get it right or or perfect, um, but it's one of those like uh one of those moments where like we always talk about, man God, why didn't you give us this or why didn't you give us that in the Bible? And this is one of those ones where it's like I think we'd be we could be up a creek or you know we would have found something, some way to deal with it. But like if God didn't include this or something like this, we might be in trouble.

SPEAKER_01My name is Connor, and I'm Jason, and you're listening to the Amaze and Perplex Podcast.

SPEAKER_00If your brother or sister sins, go and point out their fault just between the two of you. If they listen to you, you have won them over. But if they will not listen, take one or two others along, so that every matter may be established by the testimony of two or three witnesses. If they still refuse to listen, tell it to the church. And if they refuse to listen even to the church, treat them as you would a pagan or a tax collector. So, Connor, what about this passage amazes you?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so man, what amazes me is I think I I think it's just the reality that Jesus lays down some like some high bars for us to achieve and calls us, and I think expects us to follow his teachings, uh to not uh to not sin in the way he's called us not to sin. Um and it's pretty lofty, and I don't really think Jesus is ever like but hey, if you don't you know, there's there's no like but it's all fine, you know, if you if you if you mess up, if you you know don't follow these rules, it's all okay.

SPEAKER_02Like you Jesus like I don't mean, I'm I'm not saying anything like that grace doesn't exist and that like Jesus' death on the cross didn't save us and that we can uh ultimately earn our salvation. That's not what I'm saying. Jesus never seems to like like compromise on what he says the expectation is and what the expectation is in the kingdom of God and and and the what the bride of Christ will be. Um and so his decision here to acknowledge like hey, here's the expectation, but also I know reality that there will be sin, that like genuine disciples, like brothers and sisters, will not just have like disagreements, will not just have like misunderstandings, but like there will be legitimate sin.

SPEAKER_02Um for me, I I think it i i on the one hand you want it to be as simple as like you know, well Jesus in the or in the early church, there was just there was hardly any sin, there was hardly any failing, there was hardly any, you know, this or that that we deal with now, and that's just because you know of our failings in the modern times. But the fact that Jesus is like is like, yeah, this is going to happen. And like you need to have tools, a system, you need to even have an expectation for how you are to operate in this space, um, so that you, you know, you also don't fall fall down a sinful path.

SPEAKER_02I I just think um Jesus is m his his righteous like um I'm trying to think of the right word here, but like his steadfast expectations and also his um his insight into the human mind and the dynamics of a group are are just so breathtakingly uh brilliant and also just hitting me as like man, what a gift.

SPEAKER_00I totally agree, and I think I'll just I I think that coincides a lot with what amazes me in in common language uh today. He's so trauma aware, he's so both both aware of, and I'll I'll elaborate on this in a second, but both aware of trauma people have experienced, but also what they will experience, you know, because he's this thing that's really hard for us. There's really no parallel to the church, and and I mean in its purest form.

SPEAKER_00I don't necessarily mean the congregation you go to or I go to. I'm just saying it in as he is conceptualizing what this is gonna be, and when we see it play out in Acts, this is not your dad's religion. This is not Judaism, it's not anything else, even like communism, not communism, but the idea of okay, we're gonna form our own little utopia, and and it tends to function more under socialist kind of kind of mentalities and we share everything and we all share the work and nobody's better off than anybody else.

SPEAKER_00Even in those, that's different than this Christianity. I mean, Christianity doesn't require them to sell everything, they feel compelled to sell everything. And that's that's a big problem, I think, with modern-day Christianity is like we don't primarily move from compulsions that would lead us to do things that don't make sense to us. We lean on our conventional wisdom, even if it's a bit churtified, you know, and it's better than the quote world's version of it, unquote. Um, but it but it's still it's not this, I don't feel any like like obligation because of pressure.

SPEAKER_00I feel totally, man, this world isn't gonna last. I'm so convinced. And and so you need to, I'll I'll sell my stuff, you know what I mean? And so what he's suggesting here is so intimate, so so and on on the positives of great. So I can go, I can be known, I can be like, I can be me and I can show up, but it's like if you have any trauma, like any trauma, it's always caused by people, you know. The difference between a bad experience and and a traumatic experience is are you supported by the people you trust in that story, you know?

SPEAKER_00And and that's the that's the difference. If you're not supported by your by your system, by the people you trust and the people you love, that gets stuck. So you don't remember trauma, you relive trauma. And so, and so these people, even if they didn't have the word trauma, you know, and they probably didn't have the bandwidth to even consider it because they're just surviving. Like we were born into self-actualization, like we're in that that part of the hierarchy of needs that it's like, yeah, who's really worried about you know these things? We just want to become the person I was supposed to be.

SPEAKER_00Well, these Jewish people, they lived under oppression, and that wasn't really a consideration, but still they wanted those things for themselves. They knew what it was like to be mistreated. And so, as they're considering, well, I'm going to the relatively sterile um, and relatively it's a key thing there because I think Jews in in that in that time were more connected, especially Orthodox, but they were connected by law primarily, you know. So there's a limitation to how much intimacy you can have in that. So now Jesus is something connected by the heart.

SPEAKER_00Whoa, I mean, that could be really beautiful and very threatening. So, how are we going to handle our problems? And the fact that he is seeing around the corner, and and the admonition is I want you to start as small as you can get it. And I'm struck with how many people I've known that have been confronted over their sin, and it's as big as they can make it. Yeah. And it's like, no, no, this is small. And point out, and I I haven't studied the etymology of that word or the Greek meaning of the word, but it's that idea, what's at least in my version, point out the sin.

SPEAKER_00It's like, what does that feel like? Like it's not judge them. You know, it's he could have easily said, find them and demand their compliance, or he saw point out, it's like, at least in the English here, it it feels like, hey, did you notice this? Yeah, what are you thinking about that? It's so ahead of its time, you know, versus even what I grew up with.

SPEAKER_02Well, I do wonder I'd have to do some more kind of cultural work, but that feels like one of those things that we probably take for granted, as like, oh, you start small, then you kind of escalate the situation up the food chain. But I do wonder if that is actually as like um as obvious, if that would have been as obvious to Jesus' listeners as uh as it is to us because we've absorbed a lot of that. Like obviously, in terms of human conflict and dynamics, um pieces of this will have been at play in all situations uh in all times.

SPEAKER_02Uh, but like as a directive for as a follower of Jesus, that like our our call in this sort of situation is always to start small and then to expand. Um, is I I would again I I can't say this definitively, just my understanding of history would lead me to believe I don't think it's unreasonable to to wonder um if this is one of those inheritances that our society has um that comes from at least a piece of this.

SPEAKER_00I I think you're right. And this goes to what you were saying earlier in the introduction. It's like imagine a world without this teaching. Would we have come to this? Because honestly, when I see you doing something wrong in a system that we're supposed to be adhering to, think about anything. I I notice you you didn't touch the base when somebody caught the pop-up, pop-up, pop-up, yeah. And uh, and so you have to touch the base before you run to the next base. I notice that. You know what I mean? I don't usually come to you privately and say, hey, you didn't do that.

SPEAKER_00I usually make it as big as possible. Yeah what I mean? And so, and if I'm on your team, I don't make it small, I try to make it non-existent, I try to pretend it didn't happen. So you see the end of that continuum that I think a lot of humanity usually goes to. And to your point, it's like I think about the the spirit of Dave and Goliath. People refer to Dave and Goliath who would say, I don't believe there's a God, I don't believe in that. But if you didn't have David and Goliath, I think you'd still notice disparity in a battle, like this is the clear winner. But I wonder if it would have that more human face to it, you know, that you're like, well, of course everybody's reading for the underdog, but would you if you didn't have that story?

SPEAKER_00And I don't know, we don't have a parallel universe, but in that same spirit, how powerful is it that Jesus points out when you see a problem, don't pretend it doesn't exist and don't make it bigger than what it is. I'm saying be very gentle with the person that you're like, hey, I want to point this out. This is a fault you have. Matter of fact, what's interesting is it's called a sin, objectively, if your brother or sister sins, but then when it gets to how do you have that conversation, it literally uses words that are gentler, point out their fault.

SPEAKER_00And again, I'd have to go into the the wording here, what what why this choice of words, but it seems to be in the English here a gentler dynamic to say we want to start at the gentlest step we can. Now, if they refuse, you're not stuck. You're like, well, I guess it's just different opinion. No, it's important. And and what you said is really you said expectations. I was taught in a parenting class the standards do not change, but your grace will. Yeah. But as soon as you say, well, we just won't count that as important, and you change the standard, you're off your values.

SPEAKER_00Whatever values you had that brought you to those standards, you'll be off it, and then you'll count the cost in a way you do not want. So don't lower the standard. Say it's still right we treat people with respect. But I do understand you really struggle with doing this. I notice this in parenting now where a kid will be very disrespectful, a little kid will be very disrespectful, and the parent will just be like, well, it's just how they are. And I don't want that kid to be pulled aside and you know anything. I just think you need to talk to that child and say, hey, I get it.

SPEAKER_00You're nervous, you're scared, you're whatever. But I want you to start practicing toward being respectful to people because the standard doesn't change, even though we have grace all day long for that. And I think that is the challenge that I think we feel compelled. Once something isn't meant, we just get rid of the standard. Not just, no, we have to add more grace and forgiveness and teaching and those kind of things.

SPEAKER_02That's really good. And it also makes me think about like Jesus never compromises on the severity of sin and how it needs to be addressed, but also never shies away from the fact that like this is all personal, this is all intimate, this is all extremely can be extremely uh fragile. Um, and so like that Jesus can walk that line um and obviously model it, do it and then model it for us, it is just miraculous and incredible.

SPEAKER_02I think sometimes I read scripture and there's almost like unless you're really like in the book of Acts, it can almost feel stilted in terms of like who Jesus is speaking to, in terms of like, well, there's a group of the uh usually it's like there's a group of Pharisees, or he's speaking to the disciples, or there's a crowd of some sort. And you could be like, okay, well the crowd should hear this, or the crowd should not do this, or the whoever is perceived as the Pharisees in my life really could use this lesson. But Jesus is like, no, no, no, this is gonna play out person to person.

SPEAKER_02Like the way my kingdom works um is not top down, but it's bottom up. That's the nature of the upside-down kingdom. Um, and so even in this teaching where that's not exactly what what he's getting at, he there's so much dignity, um, both for the severity of sin on the individual person and the world, but also the dignity of every soul made in the image of God.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I think that is so very important, and I think recognizing how counter-cultural that was for them and for us. Now, there is a contendency in our culture that really uh honors the dignity of the individual, the autonomy, and things like that. And that is good, but like everything, it just gets blown out of proportion. And I want us, it's just like deconstruction. I don't think Christians need to be afraid of deconstruction. I think we need to claim it with passion and say yes, because there's all kinds of stuff in my faith that needs to be deconstructed.

SPEAKER_00And I think it's the same. We need to honor the autonomy of the individual. And I think there's so much good in that. And I don't want, especially older Christians, to say, well, I experience a child being rude, and then I'm like, no, this autonomy stuff is all evil. It's like, no, it may need different teaching, but that honoring the dignity of the person, honoring the dignity of the relationship, uh, honoring the dignity of the free will of the person to make a bad choice for themselves and not assume they're a bad person because of it.

SPEAKER_00All of that, boy, you're talking that gets really nuanced really fast.

SPEAKER_02Well, even you give the example of parents saying, and this is something uh Hanna and I are just in the thick of things. And Indigo, if you're listening 20 years from now, well, cool, good for you to be listening to someone episodes in.

SPEAKER_00Your dad needs a really good guy. Just let me see. I assume you're alive. Wait.

SPEAKER_02Sorry, sorry. I mean, it is it is a bet. It is a bet. Uh hopefully, hopefully, I'm still here and you can come ask me about it. But we're in the thick of it. Like, uh, you know, obviously her she is she's five years old, she's testing her boundaries, doing everything normal that a kid does. And so uh making sure you you have the standard you have we have for our daughter and sticking to it, um, and the standard always being the standard, but then allowing for grace when we feel that it's necessary, when we feel like the spirit is leading us in that way, and and when it makes sense for our family, um, is an art more than it is like a science.

SPEAKER_02Um, and one of the things that I know in my own life is there have been times where I have done the exact same thing with my daughter in terms of holding her to a standard. Um, like even to like giving the same amount of grace and holding the exact same standard in the exact same situation. And I have done it one time because I was offended because I set the standard and I was wronged, and I um I felt little because what I had been what I had said was going need to be done did not happen, and I was righteously angry for myself, and then I applied the standard in a way that I wish I could have back, because I don't think I did it well.

SPEAKER_02On the other hand, there have been times where like we set that same standard for her and it was for her betterment, and then she vi she did not meet that standard, and we held her to it. Um, and I did it because I knew what was I knew holding her to that standard, what was best for her, for her long-term growth, um, for her to be more like Jesus, to be the to to grow into the human that God wants her to. Um, and the exact same outcome, and yet done from a completely different heart posture. And I know the difference, like I truly do. And so this is how I think about my own parenting and I think about other people's parenting, um, because like I know like you know, that it's a it's a very live debate in our in our day and age, um, as my generation swings more to the uh to probably to the to the autonomy side than maybe the previous generation does.

SPEAKER_02Um and obviously we're always primed to see the shortcomings of the other side of the pendulum swing. Absolutely. Um and and so even as I as I find myself where I find I am, even when I feel like I do things the exact right way, the heart position that I have in them is it can be uh so far off of where I think God wants me to be. So, Jason, what a what uh what perplexes you about this passage?

SPEAKER_00So it what jumps off the page at me is why don't people practice this? I'm just like I have been in a couple conversations over the last few months where uh we've run into something like more of a collective problem at our congregation, uh, or in a group of people that I'm I'm minister with or two, and I'm like, man, this could have, oh, it could have gone so much better if at the first time you noticed it, or first time I had noticed it, I just went to the person and said, Hey, I'm noticing something.

SPEAKER_00Uh tell me what, am I seeing that right? Is that happening? You know, and just let them talk it over with me, then to pretend it's not happening, pretend it's not happening, and then it just comes out wrong for any number of reasons. So that's it. But really, the question for the text uh is what does it mean? And and there are some times I will say what perplexes me, and I feel like we got a decent answer, but I think it's a it's a based on all my conversations with humanity over the years, I'm like, this is something that really perplexes us, and I feel like it's been misapplied.

SPEAKER_00This one I think I have a sense of what it might be, but I, you know, I don't know. But that idea of treating them as you would a pagan or a tax collector, because I heard that early on, and that's where we're like disfellowship them, put them out, because you combine this with what happens in the Corinth, in the Church of Corinth, and what's expressed in First Corinthians, and you're like, this is disfellowshipping. And so uh Church of Christ didn't start with excommunication, that's more of a Catholic teaching and maybe high church teaching in general. I don't know enough about it, but I did experience churches where we would disfellowship people, and there was painstaking um application of this passage.

SPEAKER_00Like I remember this pastor being read, and typically it's like the preacher found out from somebody and he went and checked it out, and they didn't, you know, weren't won over, but they wouldn't use that. Basically, they didn't do what we said, and so and so then you get into this. So we brought an elder, if you had elders in the church or a leader in the church, and then that and now we're bringing it to the church. Now, what's interesting is if they still were Refuse to listen, tell it to the church, and if they refuse to listen even to church, well, that means they're there with the church.

SPEAKER_00You know, and now you there's so many terms to define, like what is sin and what is church, and what is pagan, you know, and in this context, uh, that if we had a bunch of time would be useful, or we researched these verses before we talked about them. Um, but it it is that idea I'm recognizing that's that's very operative here. Like if you don't, if you have a misunderstanding or a different understanding than somebody else about a word, this could really throw you. But the way I saw it experienced was a person went to her, and the sense was they they weren't pointing it out.

SPEAKER_00They were saying, This is the sense I got, hey guys, you're doing this wrong. You need to do it right. We heard this about you, you need to stop it. You know what I mean? I don't know how the conversation went, but that's the way I was presenting it. Then we took one other person, and now we're bringing it in front of the church with the person not present, and we're letting you know that it's fellowship. So to me, there's a skip already in this step that we're not honoring it. But the thought of how do you treat a pagan or a tax collector? And I'm like, okay, hold, hold, hold. Because I was told have nothing to do with them, and there is another place, have nothing to do with them, you know, in a different context than this one.

SPEAKER_00But just based on this verse, how did Jesus treat pagans and tax collectors? Well, he ate with them, he loved them, he was patient with them, he invited them in. Now, here's the interesting thing: it's not because Jesus didn't do a good job with tax collectors, it makes it confusing. What makes this confusing is our churches aren't intimately connected. And so then it simply becomes have no contact with them, which is not what this verse is teaching. Now, I'm not talking about another verse, I'm just talking about this verse.

SPEAKER_00This verse is saying you treat them as a non-believer. What does that mean? You love them, you appeal to them on behalf of Christ to come to God, not you shut them out. Can I read you uh Eugene Peterson's paraphrase of this?

SPEAKER_02Which I think we're way off track for now. I'm just kidding. Absolutely. That'd be Connor, I need you to pause so we can I can speak to you uh one-on-one real quick. So uh he says, if you won't listen to the church, you'll have to start over from scratch. Confront him with the need for repentance and offer again God's forgiving love.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think that is a brilliant translation and really honors the spirit of it. Um what the what the listener doesn't know, we took an hour and a half between the cuts and Connor had to correct me, but I I'm back to the ways he won me over.

SPEAKER_02Well, first first I called one of your elders in.

SPEAKER_00And then we have an elder just constantly ready to fulfill this verse. Um but but no, I think that is a really good translation. It really reflects it. Now, I can't think of an example where Jesus specifically articulates I'm now with a pagan, but certainly we we understand with with Zacchaeus, with Matthew, he doesn't simply not ignore the tax collector, he is drawn at times to the tax collector to express what Eugene Peterson had his the spirit of that verse is saying, and I think that's very clarifying.

SPEAKER_00That idea of going back and starting from scratch and saying, oh, because here's the truth. If you if you play this out in ideal, and I do this a lot of times in my interpretation of scripture, I'm like, what was Jesus wanting to happen here with the rich young ruler, with the men in the boat when there's a storm, with these situations, like what would have been the ideal? And and I think this dynamic is the ideal is if a person comes to me and I care about the things of God and they say, Hey, I needed to point out this thing that I perceive as a fault, I should be eager to receive that.

SPEAKER_00Oh, oh, I don't want to be right, I want to be Jesus. Like, like, yeah, what do you what are you seeing? You know, and it's taken me a long time, a long time, even to entertain that thought that when somebody comes to me, I'm like, I'm eager to hear. Like, not just tamping down my defensiveness, which is progress for me and the way I was raised, but I'm eager. I'm like, man, even if you're wrong, me listening to God and somebody cares enough about me to say, hey, I'm taking the risk to say I don't want you separated from God. Man, that should be a beautiful experience.

SPEAKER_00And it's like, oh, if it doesn't make sense to me, why doesn't it? Is it because I'm just defensive, or it's because I don't understand? So you bring in another person that theoretically, at the very, very least, has another way of expressing that opinion, which a lot of times that's all I need, or I'm like, well, this guy, I don't know if I trust this guy, but now that two of them are like, oh, it really is something showing up. There's a blind spot I have. And so, but if even then I'm like, oh, the whole church is here, but what's the posture of the church? Is my name on a on a chalkboard? That's how I experienced this when I was a kid.

SPEAKER_00Is the name on a chalkboard of a lady I loved, and then all of a sudden she'd had an affair and she's out. I mean, we don't talk to her anymore. But it but it's like, and that was very defining, and I have to own that's what's that's that's what I'm seeing through when I see this passage. Um, and I think the group that was there was trying to do right, and I think they just weren't taught well. But it's like, is the church looking at the person in sin with an appointing finger? Because this is also what happened to my dad when he had an affair. It's like they're all all these men are there pointing at him, or is it like we love you, we think this is really gonna hurt you?

SPEAKER_00Or is it we're judging you and you need to, I don't even know what would satisfy us, like crying, bowing down, like like signing a contract, like what would satisfy us? And the spirit here, as based on what you just read from Eugene Peterson, and I think he's Matthew's expressing this in the NIV. Absolutely, but I but I still think that's what Jesus intended. He's like, notice how I treat tax collectors. The issue here isn't the condemnation, the issue here is you have to go back to square one with saying, Okay, I don't know that you got the point of what it's what it is to follow God.

SPEAKER_02Of repentance, of forgiveness, of yes, of to be a to be a part, to be like an active part of this community is to be a person of repentance and forgiveness. Exactly. Always, really.

SPEAKER_00And then that goes to, like I said in a sermon recently, I was like, man, I've taken on the discipline of more actively being in repentance and apologizing. And I'm like, okay, so today I realized last sermon I said this, I probably shouldn't have said that, you know what I mean? Just trying to be very active, and it was funny, but it was also really trying to normalize this is who we are as a people.

SPEAKER_02Yeah. And I think that that that's a really important shift. And when you get that perspective on that last part of what Jesus is speaking about with the tax collectors and the pagans, like it does r I think reframe what he is what he said before. Um, and there is a part, I do share your kind of initial perplexion at why we don't do this, but I think it's because there is this like there's this underlying thing in all of us that like we can acknowledge when we came to save saving faith, or you know, however, however you want to phrase it in in Jesus, that of course, of course we have to repent.

SPEAKER_02Of course there I needed forgiveness. Um and we can say, yeah, I'm all I'm in always in need of of of God's forgiveness. Um, but I can say that. I can say I'm in need of God's forgiveness. Right. But please, dear God, you don't get to say that about me. That's exactly right. And this is one of those things that it's like it is so um I've been on the I wouldn't say the opposite end of this where somebody was saying that I was in sinner and error, but like in a in a way I was. Um and you know, it it is so incredibly um it's it's so incredibly difficult to know like when are you going to a person because like you see that they are in sin and like you are brokenhearted for the way for their sin for their sake.

SPEAKER_02Not because you're afraid, what does this mean for the group? What does this mean for me? What does this mean for um you know, for the outsider and what they say about us, but but stri strictly for I love this person and I'm afraid that their unrepentant sin is going to be disastrous for them. And I think this this is this this becomes the rub of like for me, how I think about, okay, if I'm on the side where I'm noticing sin, how how what what is the posture that I want to be in? What what's the place I want to be in?

SPEAKER_02And and ultimately it I want to be in the place of grief because somebody a brother or sister that I love is refusing to be a part of the act of forgiveness that God offers us. And like if if you can get to that place, you realize how heartbreaking it is to refuse um the offer to repent or refuse the offer of forgiveness. And this is not to say I don't know historically at the church, when this has been, when this practice has happened, I don't know what percentage of the time it's been done right. I know many times it has not been done well, and even sometimes the bare facts of the situation were wrong.

SPEAKER_02Um and so, listener, if if that was you, you were on the wrong side and you were justified. I I don't want to, I'm not saying anything about that. But in an ideal world, well, not an ideal world, in the world that we have now, um, where you have found your play, found yourself surrounded by brothers and sisters that are all genuinely attempting to follow Jesus as much as they can. Um, what what is the posture we want to assume?

SPEAKER_00That that is so good. And yeah, I'm thinking about all the different people and how you've experienced this, what side you've been on it. A lot of churches in recent past don't do it. There was a church not far from here from where we are that got sued for the process of just fellowshipping, and it was national news. Like I'm in Wilmington, North Carolina, and Collinsville, Oklahoma. Like we are raising money to help them pay in Wilmington, North Carolina.

SPEAKER_02That's crazy. That that's that that was a church, right? That my father-in-law ended up working at eventually way down the road, right? That's crazy.

SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Well, one of the members of our congregation was one of the lawyers on the church's side trying to figure out how to clean this up. Yeah, so it's like living in Tulsa is like so weird because I'm like, we raise money for you in our scandal.

SPEAKER_02Well, and you've mentioned in the past, like it's like Tulsa, where all the scandals happen. Where Oral Roberts, who I've been taught is is the you know, devil incarnate is why God's calling me to Nineveh, I guess.

SPEAKER_00Yeah. There's a lot of anyway, yes, yes, yes, yes. So I another experience that I want to know what perplexes you, but another experience I had with disfellowshipping, which is was, I mean, one of the worst from one of the sweetest people I knew, honestly. But I was new in a Spanish-speaking country as an AIME student, and we spoke a little bit of Spanish, but we were each, we were broken up, not by our coordinator, but by another missionary. He gave us each an envelope to take to a family. We had no idea. I don't know if he told us in Spanish, we didn't pick up, or he didn't tell us at all.

SPEAKER_00But we go and we we're just going out to visit people. We're there to encourage people, and we traveled. It was the kind of thing where they didn't have addresses. You had to go to the local, they'd give you a neighborhood, and you go to a bodega, and you'd ask them, Where does this family live? And you're walking and walking. These families were so happy to see us, and we go in and they open the letter. We don't even we can't even read the letter, and they start crying or they're getting angry, and like, what's the letter saying? It says you're disfelling because I'm like, nice to meet you. So that was like worst case scenario where it was so awful. So I'm not a fan of it until I think through the way we're talking about I'm like, I need this.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, I need people in my life that are like, and I asked for it uh to try to condition my heart and inoculate me from from just having a knee-jerk fear response. But it is totally that idea of I need this dynamic.

SPEAKER_02Man, I'm so glad you brought that up because oh my word, that just makes me it both makes me like laugh in the the absurdity of doing that to them, and then having you like that. I'm imagining basically children doing this. The absurdity is is is hysterical, but then also it's like it makes me want to crawl out of my skin in terms of just like how much that must have grieved God.

SPEAKER_00Um okay Well, and how did that person ever go to church again? Because we were so happy to meet them, like genuinely. Oh my worst. And it's like now we're the car salesman, we're like, by the way, we're not talking to you ever again.

SPEAKER_02Well, and it's so funny. I think about my story in terms of when when Hannah got fired, this was it was not directly that language, but it was basically the same sort of thing, um, where the idea was considered like we although the this practice certainly was not followed, um, that we were um unrepentant or uh not uh accepting of of uh of what they said and wasn't this language, um but it was very much that feel. Um and I you know I often think about how disorienting that experience was, and if I hadn't had, you know, at the time of Morial, and then when we ended up at jinx, like just people, men and women of God just love us and surround us.

SPEAKER_02Um like I there's n I think I sometimes underestimate like if I had been if if Hanna and I had gotten that job and it'd been seven hours away and then we had to figure out everything else while we're pregnant and and discompopulated, I think it very easily could have I I don't think I would ever stopped loving God, but I think I very very easily would become jaded against the church. Um but it was the and this it was the it was the love and and attention um that we received from Memorial and Jinx that kept us uh kept us gave us faith to to keep um to keep trusting and going forward.

SPEAKER_02Um but like I think sometimes like man, I got not lucky because God was it was part of God's plan. Um but if I hadn't had that, um I probably would have felt similar to some of those people that got those letters and been like, I love God, but obviously those people are have no connection.

SPEAKER_00Yeah, you know, with how how will you ever trust anybody you know feels away. So absolutely what perplexes you?

SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I think um I I want Jesus to speak about like I and again maybe there's uh in the Greek there's a more sp uh some more insight we could get into terms of sin and fault. Um but uh you you kind of get this picture of like, man, I wonder ten to fifteen years after Jesus like after Jesus ascends and the disciples as they've taught people in the church and are trying to apply this. Um I just feel like there there's a sense in which um this is always a problem that we have with Jesus, his just trust in people.

SPEAKER_02Like his his his trust is just absurd. The fact that he says like, hey, if you see a brother or sister sinning, it doesn't say, hey, go talk to you know, go talk to one of the apostles, or go talk to a deacon, or go in our language talk to a pastor or preacher, but like you yourself go and talk to that person. I mean, it's just uh on the one hand, I'm like, oh that's great when I think about like you know, there are a lot of great people I know who I would trust with that responsibility, but then there are other people who are like, oh my word, geez, no qualifications on this.

SPEAKER_02No like, well, if you sin, if there's if you see a sin and it's like a really, really bad sin, here's our here's our other protocols for the uh the super duper secret bad uh sin list that I that I have. Um that we all you know, we all have our our our tier rankings in terms of how we view them. Um and so yeah, I I think for me, um there is both like the the things that amazed me before about the acknowledgement of the ness necessity of intimacy and the realities of how this is gonna work, but then it's also like um the the perplexing thing is Jesus, I feel like you need to spell it out more, you know.

SPEAKER_02I've been in situations I've seen this, I've seen this not as intensely from you on the on the church side of things, and even when it wasn't done right, man, it was done with a lot of care and a lot of thought. It was done with like, okay, hey, what do you think about this email? I'm gonna send you this. What do you think about this? And people really negotiating and thinking through and even praying. Okay, like are we are we really doing this the right way? Is this sounds the best? And the fact that G is like, there's no like, okay, go tell the church and have the church form a committee, and also make sure you review the language, study it against the the the Bible.

SPEAKER_02If you guys have collected the Sermon on Mount at that point, you know, measure that against exactly what so the thing that amazed me before is now perplexing me a little bit now because like I I don't want more rules around this, I don't want more rigidity, but also it's just so free-flowing, and it's like it's almost uh it almost feels like an invitation to some sort of like crazy anarchy of like the church does get involved, but it's only basically at the end of things. Um and it's like just this radical trust in the average brother or sister disciple, um, which is beautiful when it works really well, and it's good when the person has the heart like that you've been talking about, trying to cultivate.

SPEAKER_02But then other times I'm like, oh my word, the responsibility. Yeah, like have you met people, Jesus? Have you met people? Yeah, because there's a sense in which he's like, Man, he gee you can read this and be like, man, Jesus gets people, he understands the dynamic of what happens when people are confronted with their sin. But that's also like, but you haven't, but but but Jesus, like come on.

SPEAKER_00Have you ever been betrayed? Yeah, you're like, would you have agreed to this after the crucifixion?

SPEAKER_02And so there's so much of here that like the many times we've talked about when Jesus, when somebody comes to Jesus and gets a healing, and she's like, okay, go and sin no more, or like, you know, go don't tell anybody about this, but go on. And there's no like, oh, by the way, here's the gospel message, or hey, here are the three most important, you know, notes on my Sermon on the Mount that you should probably get down, or here's the catechism that I I want you to have. Um just radical trust and the movement of the Spirit and God and it the fact that Jesus isn't I am so not a micromanager.

SPEAKER_02I am such a loosey-goosey go-with-the-flow kind of guy. And yet there's part of me that's like, how is like that still thinks, even to this day. Well, Jesus probably should be more of a micromanager, you know? And the fact that he could, I guess in theory, he he had the capabilities. Like, I don't like the reason micromanaging doesn't work is because we're limited humans that aren't capable of analyzing all of the inputs and putting out the most efficient response uh to any given stimuli.

SPEAKER_02And so the fact that Jesus was capable of that and doesn't, I don't know. I don't know, man.

SPEAKER_00I I do think I always go to create a new role. You and I are Jesus' best high school friends, like we ran track together or whatever it was, you know, and and uh for the record, for people that are new to the Bible, that didn't happen. Like we don't have any record of him going to school at all.

SPEAKER_02We don't have any record of no track, so yeah.

SPEAKER_00So I'm gonna assume he was a pole bar guy, pole vault guy. Anyway, um, so and we're just standing around with him and we're just thinking from admittedly, all I have is my understanding right now, but we're like, oh, you're you're so doing this wrong. Like, no, no, no, no, no. You need to add like 75 steps to this because I've just I know humans. But it is, it's a radical trust in the Holy Spirit. It's radical, and so and and it refines like all the time I am held responsible for decisions I've made specifically of empowering people to take on roles, and then they do it in a way that the congregation doesn't appreciate for whatever reason.

SPEAKER_00I feel I feel like I field at least one question every two weeks, and sometimes it's like I'm fielding the same question from different people 20 times, you know, and I'm like, okay, I'm like, I get it. What world do you want to live in? Do you want to live in a world where I control all this stuff and I only let people that are the most vetted, like we allow people to teach things that I don't agree with, or I don't think are necessarily that important, but for whatever reason other people do, and I'm in there listening and I'm asking and I'm having conversations with the people that are teaching, and I know the motivation, but still it's like, how much control do you want?

SPEAKER_00Because I most people, when they're thinking of themselves, I want to be free to walk with the Spirit of God and allow him to lead me as he's created me. I'm like, I'm for it. But in a community, that takes a lot more trust in God than it does if you're just on a deserted island.

SPEAKER_02Yeah, this is one of those things I as I grow my faith, um, and I I especially just take in more teaching and information from like outside of my tradition. I mean, I so honor like so much of like of the of the reading and and the people that I've I honor so much um of like of the work of like my Catholic brothers and sisters and even Orthodox brothers and sisters and um you know uh just so many of the high church uh disciples that I I have really benefited from.

SPEAKER_02And sometimes the reasoning they give for a lot of the structures that are organized like are deeply compelling to me. And again, I I think there's probably some pieces that are absolutely correct, and there is some history that's like ways that God has moved that has informed how they've set up certain hierarchies or certain structures that are wise and good and and we should emulate or um should praise in their context. Um, but there are so many things where like I'll hear about different structures that they will have erected, and I'm like, man, that just oh, that feels safe.

SPEAKER_02That feels good, that feels fantastic. And maybe at a time and a place that's good and that's right, or it's good for certain people, certain disciples and not other disciples. Uh and yet for me, the thing that I become compelled by about Jesus is just like there's just there's no safety but him, you know? And it's like that's what I want, but it's also like it's not what's easy and I want I want the pure uncut Jesus. Experience.

SPEAKER_02Um, but it's not easy and it's not safe. And again, I grew up hearing about how Aslan is not a safe lion, and I was like, Yeah, that's cool. I like the sound of that. But when it comes to this radical vulnerability and this absurd trust in the Holy Spirit working in every follower of Jesus, then I'm like, that's like real unsafe.

SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, oh yeah. I I fielded a question from an elder that was such a good question a couple days ago about a specific teaching. And is this it had the feel, it would not that it was Gnosticism, what was being taught, but it had the feel of is there something that the devil can use against us and how do we how do we work? Just such a healthy question, such a great uh discussion that I'm I'm still part of. Um, but I but my response is this is where legalism would help us so much. I mean, if we were legalistic, this would make this so much easier.

SPEAKER_00We just say stop it. We just don't do it. Yeah, it's like we I feel uncomfortable, we stop doing it. And and man, there are times I'm like in 30 years, well, I look back and I'm like, oh, I sewed some bad teeth there. I didn't mean to, but I sewed some bad teeth. But at the end of the day, I'm like, I know for a fact I'm forcing myself all the time to say, okay, God, convict me if this is wrong. Convict me if I need to confront this. Is there what's the gentlest way I can say this? Do I need to say it? You know, whatever it is, you know. And that is as hard work as anything. So when people say, What do you do as a minister?

SPEAKER_00I can certainly tell you the things that you would appreciate. But honestly, some of the hardest work is this. It's like praying through what is radical trust in Christ, and what is me somehow, because of blind spots or fear or whatever, shirking my responsibility or not being strong enough on something. And I'm it is a constant thought. Um, and and I I don't deal with it well sometimes in terms of I will judge myself so heartlessly about man, you just should have said, You should have done it, and they would have, you know, the old days, da da da da.

SPEAKER_00And I'm like, okay, I don't think that's the world I want to live in, but I also don't want to be just the relatively speaking young guy, and I'm talking about to the hundred-year-old guys, I'm the young guy that are that I'm like, well, I I just don't want to be them so bad, I'm not gonna recognize their wisdom, you know, and yet I want to be open to whatever's new because of the whole wineskin discussion, you know, it's like, okay, and so I the reason I'm sane is because I'm like, no, no, no. My work is to trust the one, is to believe in the one who God sent.

SPEAKER_00That's it. That's it. Everything else out of that is learning and submission and growth and challenge and all that. And so one thing I do want to say, my final thought is man, I'm convicted about this passage in a way I wasn't an hour ago, because I'm like, okay, well, instead of me focusing on well, what it doesn't mean, or you know, like, I don't know, or just referencing loosely, it's like, okay, as a church, we need to have a conversation of what would this look like? What like when is it when is it won over? You know, when is it like, okay, they're in the front of the whole church?

SPEAKER_00What do they need to do to prove it to us? It's even proving uh, you know what I mean? So there is so many more questions I have because I want to know, like, I'm hungrier for this passage than I was an hour ago for sure, because I'm like, okay, God, what's the beauty in this? Like, how can I promote this the way it's beautiful? So I'm left with more questions than answers, but love the experience.

SPEAKER_02I was gonna sign off and say something to the effect of, man, I I just pray that this man, that we would, we would be, we would be a people of repentance and forgiveness. And I realize, man, I need to go smaller than that. Man, God, would I be a person of repentance and forgiveness? Um, and if, listener, you want to take up that call for a prayer, you know, I'll let you make that call. But like for me, I need to start at the small and just say, man, um, this vision for the he the this vision for humanity that Jesus casts, um, man, I want to be a part of it.

SPEAKER_02Um, and I need I need to start at the beginning. Grace, peace, and love, and then you're gonna be a good idea.

Open the transcript file

Hosts and Guests

Nobody is credited on this episode yet.

Credit the people on this episode

Be the first to rate this episode

More episodes

All episodes
  1. How We Think About Marriage(Matthew 19:1-12)

    Nov 8, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐨𝐰 𝐖𝐞 𝐓𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐤 𝐀𝐛𝐨𝐮𝐭 𝐌𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐚𝐠𝐞(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟗:𝟏-𝟏𝟐) Contact: amazedandperplexed@gmail.com Music by: Heavensense https://soundcloud.com/hvnsen

    Credit the people on this episode

  2. The Unmerciful Servant(Matthew 18:21-35)

    Oct 4, 202632 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐔𝐧𝐦𝐞𝐫𝐜𝐢𝐟𝐮𝐥 𝐒𝐞𝐫𝐯𝐚𝐧𝐭(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟐𝟏-𝟑𝟓) This episode sits with Jesus' parable of the unmerciful servant, unpacking the ancient debtor's world behind the story and the...

    Credit the people on this episode

  3. Hearing as a Community(Matthew 18:18-20)

    Sep 27, 202627 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐇𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐚𝐬 𝐚 𝐂𝐨𝐦𝐦𝐮𝐧𝐢𝐭𝐲(𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰 𝟏𝟖:𝟏𝟖-𝟐𝟎) Jesus makes a bold, almost startling promise: where two or three gather in his name, he's there, and whatever they agree on will...

    Credit the people on this episode

  4. The Rich Man and Lazarus(Luke 16:19-31)

    Sep 13, 202634 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐑𝐢𝐜𝐡 𝐌𝐚𝐧 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐋𝐚𝐳𝐚𝐫𝐮𝐬(𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐞 𝟏𝟔:𝟏𝟗-𝟑𝟏) This episode dives into the strikingly detailed story of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16. The discussion explores what it means...

    Credit the people on this episode

  5. Marriage, Divorce, and Patriarchy(Luke 16:18)

    Sep 6, 202631 minAudio

    Send us Fan Mail 𝐌𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐢𝐚𝐠𝐞, 𝐃𝐢𝐯𝐨𝐫𝐜𝐞, 𝐚𝐧𝐝 𝐏𝐚𝐭𝐫𝐢𝐚𝐫𝐜𝐡𝐲(𝐋𝐮𝐤𝐞 𝟏𝟔:𝟏𝟖) Jesus' words on divorce in Luke 16:18 are short, sharp, and easy to skim past, but they land differently once you...

    Credit the people on this episode